Monte Carlo Fashions Limited (MONTECARLO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 4, 2026

National Stock Exchange of India IN Consumer Discretionary Textiles, Apparel and Luxury Goods earnings 59 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good day, everyone, and welcome to the Q2 FY '27 earnings conference call for Monte Carlo Fashion Limited, hosted by Emkay Global Financial Services Limited. <<operator_script>> Kindly be aware that this conference is being recorded. At this point, I hand the conference over to Mr. Sunny Bhadra of Emkay Global Financial Services Limited. Thank you, and the floor is yours, Mr. Bhadra.

Sunny Bhadra

analyst
#2

Absolutely. Prasant, thanks. Morning, everybody. On behalf of the team, I'd like to welcome the management and express our appreciation for the chance to hold this call. Joining us on the line today are Mr. Rishabh Oswal, Executive Director; Mr. Sandeep Jain, Executive Director; Mr. Dinesh Gogna, Director; Mr. R. K. Sharma, Chief Financial Officer; and Mr. Ankur Gauba, Company Secretary. At this point I'll pass the call along to the management so they can deliver their opening remarks. Gentlemen, the floor is yours.

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#3

Good morning, everyone, and thanks for being with us on the quarter 2 and H1 FY '27 earnings call for Monte Carlo Fashions Limited. Before Sandeep Ji walks through our performance and priorities, I'd like to take a few minutes to talk about how we view Monte Carlo today and, more importantly, where we're taking the business from here. The opportunity for us isn't about altering what Monte Carlo represents. It's about making the brand relevant to more consumers, across more categories, and across a bigger portion of the year. Monte Carlo has developed a strong franchise in winterwear over the years, but the business is already far broader today. Cotton apparel, kids wear, and home textiles are well-established parts of our portfolio, and our focus now is on scaling these categories in a meaningful way. That shifts the opportunity for Monte Carlo, because it lets us engage with consumers past the winter season, grow our presence in markets where penetration remains relatively low, and extract more from the distribution network and brand we've built over several decades. This evolution is already starting to reflect in our sales mix. Cotton has been our biggest reported product category since FY '22 and accounted for roughly 63% of gross product sales in H1 FY '27.

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#4

Monte Carlo's business today relies heavily on this segment. Even so, winter still matters a great deal to how we perform across the year—whether through jackets in cotton apparel or blankets and quilts in home textiles. So we see 2 areas of opportunity. The first is growing the established business. Our brand, our long-standing retailer relationships, our distribution network, and our sourcing and textile capabilities give us a strong base. There is scope to grow our established categories and to improve productivity across the existing businesses. The second is selectively developing newer businesses, markets and channels. Footwear and our newer brands remain relatively small. West and South are still markets for further expansion, alongside digital and modern retail channels. We will pursue these opportunities with discipline. Growth backed by consumer demand, profitability and cash generation is our priority. We will measure progress by the quality of the business we build, not by expansion alone. As we enter the second half, execution through the festive and winter selling season is the immediate priority. The first half includes inventory build and preparation across our distribution network, with quarter 3 particularly important to full year performance. Our longer-term focus remains on growing the product portfolio and improving business and productivity. With that, I will now hand over to Sandeep Ji to share his perspective on our priorities and discuss our Q2 and H1 FY '27 performance.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#5

Yes, thank you, Rishabh, and good morning to all of you. As the business expands, we need to keep expansion in step with the economics of every category and channel. The upcoming selling season matters a great deal — for sales, and for turning the inventory we built in the first half into collections. Against that backdrop, we are reviewing how we have performed and looking at the season for the rest of the year. Let me walk you through our Q2 and H1 results now. In Q2, revenue from operations came in at INR 262 crore, versus INR 248 crore last year, which works out to growth of 5.5%. Operating EBITDA was INR 28.35 crore, giving an operating EBITDA margin of 10.80%. Profit after tax came to INR 1.17 crore. Turning to H1, revenue from operations reached INR 411 crore, against INR 387 crore in H1 '26, a rise of 6.25%. Operating EBITDA was INR 15.42 crore, a margin of 3.7%, and the loss after tax was INR 22.25 crore. Although revenue grew, profitability came in slightly lower, driven by higher material cost, lower other income and increased employee cost. So 2 points matter when we look at how H1 played out. Monte Carlo continued to have a meaningful seasonal cycle.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#6

Q3 accounted for roughly 48% of financial '26 revenue. The September half takes in production, inventory build and dispatch activity ahead of the key winter selling period. This year, the later festive season moved a meaningful portion of consumer demand and winter sell-through into Q3. H1 should therefore be read alongside a seasonally important second half, not on its own; actual consumer sell-through and collections will decide the outcome. Second, as we discussed on our Q1 call, retailer returns were processed earlier in Q1, and we expect that timing effect to reverse over the next 2 quarters. Gross dispatches thus need to be read together with returns, rebates and provision to understand reported net revenue. For Q2, the return ratio came in at 16.17% versus 23.18% last year. On an H1 basis, returns were 30.70 against 29.47 in H1 '26. So portfolio H1 gross sales rose across cotton, home textiles, kids wear and footwear. And these are gross category sales before returns and other adjustments, not reported net revenue. Cotton sales climbed from INR 326 crore in H1 to INR 390 crore in H1 financial '27. Home textile sales rose from INR 83 crore to INR 91.6 crore. Kids wear sales grew from INR 30 crore to INR 34.5 crore.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#7

Footwear rose from INR 4.9 crore to INR 9.3 crore. Woolen gross sales fell from roughly INR 106 crore to INR 94 crore. Our distribution network is changing as well. As of September '26, we reported 506 EBOs, versus 497 a year earlier. Our shop-in-shop network grew to 632 from 578. MBOs dropped to 1,413 from 1,615, and national chain stores fell to 846 from 891. We keep evaluating expansion based on store profitability and returns potential, rather than looking at the actual outlet count alone. So geographically, North is still our largest market. West and South combined made up about 9.7% of <<inaudible>> gross sales and remain key medium-term expansion opportunities. At the same time, reported geography should be read with care, since online and certain other sales are not attributed to individual states in the available classification. Working capital discipline continues to be a priority. Reported and working capital days improved from 176 in financial '25 to 146 in financial '26. The seasonal funding requirement needs to be viewed alongside capital expenditure and other investment commitments. For the rest of financial '27, our priorities are consumer sell-through, productive retail expansion and cash conversion. We continue to maintain our guidance for low double-digit revenue growth, 20% home capital growth and 40 to 45 new EBOs focused on West and South as well.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#8

So, to wrap things up, we’re heading into the key second half with a wider portfolio, a solid distribution base, and several paths for growth. Our strategy stays the same: profitable growth, disciplined inventory, and sensible deployment of capital. With that, we can now open the floor for questions. Thank you.

Operator

operator
#9

<<operator_script>> Our first question is from Yuvraj Kunwar of Emkay Global.

Yuvraj Kunwar

analyst
#10

Sir, my first question concerns RM inflation. How are you viewing it — is it putting pressure on your margins? If you could quantify it, what has the inflation trend looked like? And during Q3, what was the trend with regard to inflation?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#11

Inflation is certainly driving material costs higher, and you can see that reflected in this quarter's results. That said, we're properly shielded going into Q3, since that increase has already been implemented. Still, on a broader economic level, inflation is in fact cutting into discretionary spending. Even so, we remain confident about the company's long-term outlook.

Yuvraj Kunwar

analyst
#12

Are there any price increases you're implementing? Is there a figure you'd like to put a number on, or any qualitative result you want to share?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#13

We implemented a price increase of roughly 8% to 9% this winter. And I believe that should be enough to cover whatever rise in raw material costs we see in the winterwear category.

Yuvraj Kunwar

analyst
#14

All right. And could that possibly influence demand and volumes? <<inaudible>> regarding that?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#15

No, I wouldn’t say that, because the Indian economy is expanding at 7%. That demonstrates we have an economy that can withstand shocks even with oil prices higher or inflation elevated, and we feel very confident as we head into quarter 3.

Yuvraj Kunwar

analyst
#16

The other thing I wanted to ask about, sir, is that in India the winter rental market for retail is gaining momentum as the winter window gets shorter. That means plenty of models are coming up, and they're what's driving this trend along. I just wanted to check whether you could offer some insight into that emerging trend.

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#17

Thanks, Yuvraj. That's a fair point. Yuvraj, the rental market for these apparels is expanding. However, as you can see, the product value isn't high enough for us to move into that kind of business model. So at this time, we have no plans to enter the rental model.

Operator

operator
#18

<<operator_script>> Our following question is from Keshav Garg of Counter Cyclical PMS.

Keshav Garg

analyst
#19

Mr. Oswal, I have real concerns about the company's numbers. If you look at our stock price, it's below where it stood in 2014. Essentially, 12 years ago the stock was at INR 570, and today it sits at INR 490. Sir, I just can't understand what's happening, because until 2 years back we were a net debt-free company. Now, though, we're carrying a fairly sizable net debt on our balance sheet. We keep opening EBOs, yet revenue isn't growing. My sense is that SSG has been negative for a long time. Sir, so what's the point of opening new stores when our SSG alone isn't growing?

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#20

Let me start with SSG. On like-to-like growth, I should set the record straight. In the prior year, our like-to-like growth came in at roughly 10%. During the first 6 months of this year, we achieved 9% like-to-like growth. So it isn't the case that like-to-like growth hasn't been occurring. It was present last year as well, and we feel confident we should deliver about 9% to 10% like-to-like growth in this financial year too. Turning to how the company has performed, I think it's not — if you look at 2014, when the price was INR 570, our revenue stood at INR 375 crore. And profit, if my memory serves, was approximately around INR 40 crore. So today the company has moved from INR 375 crore to what will be, as per the double-digit growth guidance we've provided, an ending figure in the vicinity of about INR 1,400 crore. That means revenue has grown 4x from the INR 375 crore level at the time we came out with the IPO. As for the share price, that's something we have no control over.

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#21

That said, we are certainly putting in a lot of effort to enhance how our company performs. During the prior year, growth came in at approximately 15%. That was the commitment management made at the time, and EBITDA, when other income is included, stood at about 20% as well. So for this year, we are guiding toward yet another double-digit expansion. True, the second quarter proved somewhat difficult owing to material costs, which rose. That certainly caused us damage, yet it will not hold us back regarding our long-term view of the company. We remain committed to double-digit growth in this financial year. And as we move ahead, you will also observe the company performing better than it does in this financial year.

Keshav Garg

analyst
#22

Okay sir, turning to Page #28 of the investor presentation — close to 8% of revenue comes from brands other than Monte Carlo. Sir, given all these decades, why keep running so many brands when they bring in roughly 8% of our revenue? It would be best to focus only on the Monte Carlo brand, since it anyway delivers 92% of revenue. And sir, the second point: even though our non-woolen category keeps expanding, why bother when 3 quarters out of 4 we still post losses, and Q3 is the only quarter that really earns? So then why get into all that cotton wear, summer wear?

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#23

First, let me address your first question about why we need so many brands. Look, if a category is completely distinct, you can’t fold it into the parent brand. Rocket is one category operating in athleisure. Athleisure simply can’t be merged into Monte Carlo, since it’s entirely different — a separate category all its own. Then, turning to Cloak & Decker, which sits in the economy segment, again it can’t be merged into Monte Carlo, because Monte Carlo is a premium brand. That said, both of these brands, if you look at the last 2, 3 years, have grown impressively. And they’ll deliver substantial revenue going forward. So in the early years sometimes, when you’re trying to establish things, growth is a bit slow. But once people know the brand, growth begins to come. And you’ll see that starting this year. Even in this year, you’ll see these brands growing faster than the parent brand. As for Monte Carlo Home, it’s a completely separate category. This category is also expanding at roughly 20% CAGR, and I’d say it’s growing — outgrowing even the Monte Carlo garment section as well.

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#24

I believe that covers what you asked about the brands.

Keshav Garg

analyst
#25

Sir, to revisit this sales return matter—it's been persisting for 2 years now and it just keeps happening, so why, I mean, how long will this pattern continue where we book the sales in 1 quarter and then in the following quarter, the sales return comes in?

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#26

My view is that this stems from the business model we currently operate. Our dispatches occur in quarter 3, and returns come back to us in the quarters that follow. And this -- let's say the step -- we will continue to follow that chronology, since our dispatches take place during the third quarter, and we have to allow some time before those returns reach us. Still, since the volume of dispatches in quarter 3 is very high, that is the reason this imbalance shows up. So as the other quarters contribute more to overall sales, you will see this balance out.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#27

I'd like to build on what Rishabh correctly pointed out. Look, please don't evaluate us based on only 1 quarter. Evaluate us on how we perform annually. There were quarterly variations last year as well. Even so, we remain committed to whatever guidance we've provided. We hit our guidance last year too, and this year as well on margins, we foresee there could be a 100 basis point drop at the EBITDA level. Apart from that, every piece of guidance still holds.

Raj Sharma

executive
#28

I'm Raj Sharma, and I'd like to clear up a few things regarding the results. Every quarter, we set aside sufficient provision for anticipated returns. However, occasionally extra returns come in, and those are merely marginal, which impacts the quarterly figures. So it isn't the case that we record the entire amount up front and then later quarters reveal the returns. As per Ind AS requirements, we have disclosed the return provisions in the PPT for each quarter. Thus, in every quarter, we make sufficient provision for returns. I just wanted to clarify that returns are properly and sufficiently covered for each quarter's performance.

Keshav Garg

analyst
#29

Now, sir, looking at our PAT for FY '23, the company had no net debt at that time, and we posted a net profit of INR 133 crore. Then over the last 12 years, net profit stands at INR 90 crore while the company carries INR 300 crore of net debt. Sir, so I mean — and at this point we're moving into solar for returns that are basically in the low teens. So essentially, this amounts to a kind of implicit admission that our core business isn't going anywhere. So we're just trying to earn a bit of money on the side through solar.

Raj Sharma

executive
#30

Regarding the debt, this is simply a working capital need tied to our accumulation. All that inventory has to be built up. That's why the working capital requirement as of 30th September is consistently elevated. So you should really look at our debt position only as of 31st March, which for this year will come to roughly INR 200 crores — that represents our permanent working capital requirement.

Keshav Garg

analyst
#31

What I'm getting at is that as of March '23, the company had a net cash surplus. And now we're going to have INR 200 crore of net debt, while PAT is declining. So net debt is rising, profit is falling. And at this point we're talking about a 20% EBITDA margin plus other income. So, I mean, what sort of figure is that? Why would anyone add other income, which is nonoperating income...

Operator

operator
#32

Apologies for cutting in, Mr. Garg. Kindly get back in the queue if you have further questions. <<operator_script>> Our next question is from Aman Kumar, an individual investor. Sorry to cut you off, Mr. Kumar — you sound a bit far from the mic. Please move closer to it and repeat what you were saying.

Speaker

unknown
#33

I've only got my cell phone here. Are you able to hear me at this point?

Operator

operator
#34

Yes, you're coming through more clearly than earlier.

Speaker

unknown
#35

So just one thing on my mind. Given the festival season shift—and I'm not sure how you'd work this out—but could you give some kind of estimate of roughly how much business you'd have lost in this particular quarter because of that shift?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#36

Aman, you see, the thing is that whenever festivals come a bit later — like last year Diwali fell in October, and this year it's moved into November — some dispatches typically get pushed into the following quarter. So that's a shift we usually see, depending on where the festivals land each year.

Speaker

unknown
#37

I'm not referring to dispatches, since in any case your wholesale business has come to represent a comparatively smaller share of total sales as time has gone on. My sense is that your EBO channel is now far and away the biggest contributor to your sales, correct? And on that retail sale line, you'll essentially be carrying the inventory on your books as well, and correspondingly, sales will only fully land in the third quarter this time, as opposed to being split between 2Q and 3Q. So my question really comes from an EBO retail angle: how much of sales — or, if you've done any kind of estimate on that front, how much of sales would you have lost on that account in 2Q?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#38

But EBOs come in 2 types. One is the outright kind, where we hold no inventory on our books—it sits on the franchise's books. And the second is company-owned, yes, definitely, where our inventory is on our books. And third is, again, a model in which we take a collection of 15%. So their inventory stays only on the franchise's books. So those are the 3 models. Yes, apart from that, when it comes to large format stores and when it comes to the online store, yes, we do hold inventory. Online, we keep inventory on our books. I think that's what you were asking.

Speaker

unknown
#39

No, no, that's fine. What I'm really getting at is this: in those channels where you essentially carry inventory on your books, given that the festive season falls entirely in the third quarter this time, versus being split between 2Q and 3Q last year — and last year some of the festive season also landed in the second quarter — how much in sales would you have lost on that? Do you have any estimate for that?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#40

We aren't able to put a number on that. But yes, definitely, since when the festival moves, sales move along with it as well. So I think a portion of those sales has moved out of quarter 2 and into quarter 3 as a result. But as for an exact quantification, I may not be in a position to do that right now.

Speaker

unknown
#41

Turning to RF, I just want to get a handle on what's happening, since most of your business, again, sits on the cotton side. When we look at cotton prices in India and the U.S., they've shifted somewhat, but raw material prices are up 10%. So that ought to, I'm saying raw cotton prices should typically mean roughly a couple of percentage point hit to you on fabric cost — basically, you'll be purchasing, you don't even make that much today, it's more garment. So a couple of percentage points on garment cost — why is an 8%, 9% rise in end product pricing actually pretty high on the cotton side? So what's going on?

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#42

Aman Ji, as you said, cotton prices — really all commodity prices — have been swinging a lot. So while we can't just look at the latest cotton prices, we do need to consider when the company actually booked its raw material. And if you check the books, our cost of goods went up by only 3%. That matches what you expected, a 2% to 3% impact on our numbers. So that's the impact.

Speaker

unknown
#43

That's precisely what I was asking about—during the third quarter, you mentioned something like an 8% to 9% price increase. Why is that necessary? That's really all I'm trying to get at...

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#44

Regarding the price increase, costs have gone up. Raw material prices are also higher than they were a year ago. We don’t view this as a one-time price increase. Also, if you look at our quarter 3 products, which supply woolen products, the raw material price for pure wool has risen by nearly 20% compared with a year earlier. This year as well, we expect the same increase in raw material prices. So if the company has no other option, it has to pass these prices on. And as a practice...

Operator

operator
#45

Mr. Kumar, apologies for cutting you off. Could you please get back in line for additional questions?

Speaker

unknown
#46

Yes, of course.

Operator

operator
#47

Ritika Pahwa of Pahwa Securities Private Limited has the next question.

Ritika Pahwa

analyst
#48

My first question concerns the full-0year performance. I just wanted some clarity—you already mentioned that prices went up 8%-9% during this quarter. So looking at the full year, what level of profitability do you anticipate? Should we expect EBITDA to stay in the 15% to 20% range, or might there be a dip? My second question relates to your subsidiary. Could you give more detail on that business—for instance, what are the timelines? Have you secured a vendor? Are you planning to enter into a PPA for it? What will the end use be? And when can we expect revenue to start coming from that subsidiary? Yes, those are the points I'd like to ask about.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#49

On the margin side, we're now in the third quarter, and this quarter matters a great deal for us. So we're looking at roughly plus or minus 100 basis points of margin versus the prior financial year, and it hinges on how the quarter turns out. Turning to solar, I'd like to note — to point out that PPAs have already been executed for all 3 of these sites. We're putting up a 35-megawatt plant in Madhya Pradesh. The land has been identified, land aggregation is done, and the projects — all 3 sites — are expected to be commissioned on 31st March '27, and we remain on track to hit that.

Ritika Pahwa

analyst
#50

So starting next year, what sort of profitability do you expect from the subsidiary from FY '28 onward? Would that be something like...

Sandeep Jain

executive
#51

17% to 20%.

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#52

Correct. However, we did send those exact details to you via email.

Operator

operator
#53

<<operator_script>> Our following question is from Diwakar Rana at Prudent Equity.

Diwakar Rana

analyst
#54

With the increases we've seen in both interest cost and depreciation, what kind of PAT margin are you expecting for this year?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#55

As we've said before, the EBITDA margin ought to land within roughly plus or minus 100 basis points, and where it falls depends on how this quarter turns out. So PAT margins should stay in that same range as well.

Diwakar Rana

analyst
#56

Identical range.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#57

Give or take 100 basis points, and that, of course, hinges on how this quarter turns out.

Diwakar Rana

analyst
#58

All right. And sir, is there any update you can share on the buyback? Have any discussions taken place? Did you—

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#59

Buybacks weren’t discussed at all within management. If and when that topic does come up, we’ll be sure to inform the exchanges.

Operator

operator
#60

Our following question is from Nilesh Khandelwal, an individual investor.

Speaker

unknown
#61

Sir, my question concerns the rebates. Could you explain what these rebates actually are and why they've gone up by roughly 70% year-on-year? In the same quarter last year, the figure stood at about INR 213 million, and for the current quarter it now sits at INR 389 million. So if you could just offer some explanation on that.

Raj Sharma

executive
#62

What details are you requesting...

Speaker

unknown
#63

Rebates, and discounts — rebates, rebates, rebates.

Raj Sharma

executive
#64

So in fact, for the H1 position, rebates and discounts are up 4% this year. For the full year, though, we're expecting them to stay at no more than 10% of the total...

Speaker

unknown
#65

Looking at PPT Slide 18, I notice that rebates and discounts came in at INR 35 crores for the same half year previously, and that figure has now risen to INR 54 crores. So that works out to not 4% — it's closer to 40%, or I could even say 50%.

Raj Sharma

executive
#66

No. What you're after is the growth percentage...

Speaker

unknown
#67

Rebates — I mean the rebates that exist.

Raj Sharma

executive
#68

And yeah, that's fine too. But I'm not seeing a growth comparison when you measure it against revenue proportionally. Measured against revenue, it's 12%; versus last year, that figure was 9%. So every percentage has to be looked at only in relation to revenue.

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#69

I'd like to add one thing here. So please don't treat this quarter's rebate as the benchmark for the full year. The annual benchmark, as Sharma Ji correctly put it, ought to fall in the 3% to 4% range for rebates and discounting. It could rise, and...

Sandeep Jain

executive
#70

The absolute term isn't...

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#71

Since discounts went up during this quarter, I'd ask that you not treat that figure as a yearly benchmark.

Speaker

unknown
#72

Is there any particular reason it went up in the current quarter?

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#73

The reason is that end-of-season promotions kicked off sooner and ran longer, since the off-season was extended by unfavorable macroeconomic conditions. On top of that, geopolitical circumstances forced us to offer discounts ahead of schedule so we could move our product and lift sell-through. That explains why markdowns came in higher than they did a year ago. Also, as you can see, we'd accumulated some inventory over the last few years, and we're working to clear it out this year. This year we sold a considerably larger amount of older merchandise than we did last year. So part of that discount effect shows up because those sales carry deep markdowns. The goal, though, is to get the inventory cleared this time.

Operator

operator
#74

Our next question is from an individual investor, Jitesh Rupert.

Speaker

unknown
#75

Before anything else, I want to mention that I spent 8 to 10 minutes waiting when the call began, so please take that up as a suggestion. Also, with respect, I'd like management to address something: we've been attempting to justify how sales have performed since the IPO. In fact, taking the 2015 figures, sales have more than doubled up to now across 11 years. Operating profit hasn't even doubled, and net profit stands at 1.5x. So that isn't a performance that justifies anything, in my view. A brand as prominent as ours is capable of doubling within 3, 4 years. That's a suggestion. So there ought to be a proper justification. One more point: why aren't we pursuing the opportunities -- the export opportunities we talked about, I think, around 2 years ago, when some samples were being sent to European countries. So why haven't we been able to capitalize on that? Second point, and the last one: a participant raised a question about the diversification. I don't think he'll get another chance in the queue. But if he doesn't come back, I'd request that management clarify this matter at the end of the call.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#76

Sure. I'll begin with the export question. A couple of years ago, we made an attempt to secure an export order, but we came to see that exporting and doing white labeling for other brands doesn't leave enough margin. So that — and we're a branded retail player. So we don't want to get into white labeling for other players. On the other hand, we are exploring the export market, though it isn't a priority sector for us. We still believe there are plenty of opportunities in India, particularly in the West and Southern market, and we would want to focus there, since we have more experience and bandwidth there than in an export market that is relatively unknown to us. So that's the export point of view. And you rightly mentioned performance. Yes, the profitability we used to have is down compared to 2015, '16. But I think if you look at last year, there have been a lot of efforts from our side to improve our profitability, and we did that as well. But unfortunately, this year we got interruption from the material cost rise because of geopolitical tensions and all. So that has hurt us in this quarter.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#77

Even so, we feel quite encouraged and optimistic that moving ahead, we will also be placing greater emphasis on profitability as well as sales growth.

Operator

operator
#78

Our next question is from Mahendra Jain, an individual investor.

Speaker

unknown
#79

Given everything we've discussed on this call, sir, I'd ask you to lay out the plan for the next 5 years, since whatever happens, happens. As the earlier analyst asked, the move into solar must stem from having cash on the books and earning a 15% return, which is fine. But the question was why we are moving away from our core business. Can we not look for a 20% return from our core business over the next 5 years? And where are we — what are the plans for the next 5 years so that profit quality improves and the summer business, the home textile business, contributes equally over the next 3 quarters? What are the plans for this cotton business and home textile so that we can step up from this woolen business to the next level? So are we planning — can you share any road map with us for the next 5 years? Where will our top line or bottom line stand, on a projection basis, if cotton and home textile perform? Please, sir. This is all we need from your side.

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#80

Look, when it comes to our long-term vision and long-term outlook, we said earlier as well that we plan to grow 15% to 20% each financial year, barring a year that has taken some hits like this one — there have been some interruptions due to intrusion. Other than that, if the economy holds up the way we see it, India is in a very — a shining spot and stays at 7%. And we see no way that we should not grow from 15% to 20% going forward as far as the piling business is concerned. Yes, this quarter has had interruption because of material costs. But we are very confident that as we move into third quarter, we would see the company's performance improve as we move <<inaudible>> and I'm talking about this core business, the core business of garments and also the home textiles. So as far as the solar business is concerned, we basically got the opportunity in this Madhya Pradesh. That was mainly because we have funds available and we wanted to improve our ROI on the investment part also. So that is why this opportunity has been taken. And it is a small investment.

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#81

This isn’t a business vertical for us to run, and it isn’t some new business line we’re entering. It’s a one-off investment, and that’s exactly how it should be viewed.

Speaker

unknown
#82

Sir, when it comes to cotton textile, are you also doing trading — like purchasing from other vendors and that sort of thing — or, as with all the rest, is everything manufactured in-house by us?

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#83

No, no — just 20% of the garments get made in-house. That's mostly T-shirts and thermals; all the rest is outsourced within the cotton category. As for woolen, we produce all of it ourselves.

Speaker

unknown
#84

All right, so over the coming 5 years, do we intend to produce more cotton textile and that sort of thing internally — is there any CapEx plan or vision for the cotton business across the next 5 years?

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#85

No, we don’t have plans like that. We think that when it comes to outsourcing, we need to become more efficient. So our belief is in that model alone. That CapEx — sorry?

Speaker

unknown
#86

We're looking to generate revenue from our brand through outsourcing, and we're leveraging that brand to bring in that revenue.

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#87

Right. We’ll be placing greater emphasis on the marketing side rather than on the manufacturing side.

Operator

operator
#88

<<operator_script>> Our following question is from Gunit Singh with Counter.

Gunit Singh

analyst
#89

To start off, I'd like to get a sense of how things have gone for us as the winter season gets underway. What sort of momentum are we seeing in this segment during the current quarter?

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#90

Honestly, it feels quite premature to comment on that, since winter typically gets underway in November. That means November and December are the two months that usually account for roughly 80% to 85% of this winter season's revenues. So I'll be better placed to give you an answer once this quarter has wrapped up. That said, I'm quite confident that the season has gotten going, and we should see a solid quarter ahead.

Gunit Singh

analyst
#91

Understood. So we're still looking at roughly double-digit sales growth for this year?

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#92

We’ve already provided guidance of double-digit growth, and we stand by that guidance, revenue growth.

Gunit Singh

analyst
#93

Understood. But consider the past 3 years: annual sales growth has been only 5%, while in your earlier remarks you said you anticipate 10%, 15%, 20% annual growth over the long term. So I'd like to understand what has gone wrong across these last 3 years that we haven't seen that growth. One year can be — as you said, in 1 year we can see inflation or something. But for the last 3 years, sales growth has been just 5%, which may even be below inflation. So could you shed some light? Is it some macro situation over these last 3 years? Or do you think the company's strategy needs to change for us to return to a growth phase?

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#94

That's the way I'd prefer to frame it. Take a look at the sales growth for the last year—during the previous con call we also gave guidance, and we were in the establishing phase in the year before last, when some of these steps were taken, and that led to lower sales in that financial year. So those steps were taken in the last year. That's why sales growth came in at 15% last year. Even in this year, despite so many challenges from geopolitical tensions at the macro level, we again say growth will be double digit. And once more, I'm giving a long-term vision of 15% to 20% growth. So barring—if you look at last year's growth and this year's growth, those steps taken 2 to 3 years back are actually resulting in around double-digit growth for us this financial year as well as the last financial year. And I'm very positive that, since we see the Indian economy growing at around 7%, we will outperform the economy going forward as well.

Gunit Singh

analyst
#95

So then, for EBO, what would your SSG be? You said it was roughly 10%.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#96

Last year, like-to-like growth came in at 10%. And in this first half, it stands at 9%. So we're confident that we will close out this financial year at roughly 9% to 10% like-to-like growth as well.

Gunit Singh

analyst
#97

Is that like-for-like growth basically referring to mature EBOs, the ones you're mentioning?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#98

The EBOs already in place — and the newer ones too — lift total EBO sales. So like-for-like growth refers to the EBOs that were also there last year.

Gunit Singh

analyst
#99

Understood. And regarding growth in the count of EBOs, what number are you planning to launch in FY '27 — both across the upcoming 2 quarters and next year — and what are your intentions there?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#100

We already provided guidance of 40 to 45 EBOs for this financial year, and we're standing by that guidance. And we're in the process of opening the number of EBOs.

Gunit Singh

analyst
#101

Understood. And do you have a long-term target for how many EBOs you want to reach, since the SSG for our EBOs is quite healthy? So I mean, I think we should focus more on putting investment into EBOs rather than any other projects. So I just want to understand what the long-term aspiration is in terms of the number of EBOs that you opened. And if you can also give me, I mean, the store economics of EBOs — I think the revenue per EBO is around INR 1.4 cr. So what is the store part per EBO, if you can help me understand.

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#102

Our goal is to launch somewhere in the range of 40 to 45 EBOs. That said, it all hinges on how the economy is behaving. We may also raise that figure next year. Once more, that hinges on the economic conditions of the country. And yes, on the subject of store economics, at present we are at roughly INR 5,000 per square feet, and we aim to reach INR 15,000 per square feet over the next 2 to 3 years.

Gunit Singh

analyst
#103

Sir, and what about the — I mean, the...

Operator

operator
#104

Apologies for cutting in there, Mr. Singh. Kindly get back in the queue if you have further questions. <<operator_script>> We now have the next question from Keshav Garg, who is on the line from Counter Cyclical PMS.

Keshav Garg

analyst
#105

Sir, I'd like to get some clarity on our EBITDA margin. Until FY '23, our EBITDA margins were running at 20%, and for the last 12 months they've come in at 16%. Now we're saying we'll achieve a 20% EBITDA margin, but that figure is EBITDA plus other income. Sir, in FY '23 it was pure EBITDA — in fact, even that is overstated, because there's INR 60 crore of lease rental in there, which by no stretch of the imagination belongs in EBITDA. Sir, so is our actual pre in AS EBITDA far lower?

Executive

executive
#106

If you're going to leave out the lease rental, then you should also include the factory lease when making that comparison. Prior to this, our EBITDA margin sat in the same range. So if you're comparing without the lease, you need to compare against the earlier period in the same way. Before the lease rental, our EBITDA margin was 18%. Now, including the lease, it stands at 20%. So you have to look at it accordingly — comparing both scenarios under the same situation.

Keshav Garg

analyst
#107

Sir, basically, if you look at our — I accept your point that the FY '23 EBITDA figure includes a lease rental element as well. Sir, but the thing now is that our total lease liability in FY '23 stood at INR 129 crore, and that has doubled to INR 252 crore. So I mean, if the lease liability has doubled, it's fair to say the INR 60 crore rental outgo would be roughly half of that up to FY '23. Sir, now the bigger point is that, sir, if we — sir, we are shareholders, and we want this company to succeed. The thing is that first we have to diagnose what the ailment is. I mean, unless we believe that everything is great — and the stock price isn't in our hands, so there's nothing we can do if the stock was INR 570 in FY '14, and today it is INR 490. And so something is not working out. If you look at Cantabil, if you look at Kewal Kiran and other listed players in the same space, they are posting better numbers than us. Sir, so I really believe some introspection is required, and maybe some course correction is required.

Keshav Garg

analyst
#108

Sir, why aren't we looking at opening more FOFO stores instead of COCO ones? That approach makes our balance sheet asset heavy, and fixed costs keep climbing since rentals continue to rise. Sir, have we considered moving to a FOFO model, or the FOCO <<inaudible>> model, rather than the COCO model?

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#109

That's a really good question, and here's how I'd like to respond. Financial '23's EBITDA margin was certainly the highest. We were just emerging from COVID, demand was there, prices were at that level at that time, and we also benefited from a good price increase. But we can't treat that as a benchmark for the future. We feel comfortable with a 20% EBITDA margin, including other income. And the reason I say that is the business model has also shifted since financial '23. We've moved toward opening more SIS, where we share some discounts. And in EBOs as well, when we go for more consignment stores, again there's discount sharing. So I think this trend will now stay the same at around a 20% EBITDA margin. And yes, definitely, as you mentioned earlier, it has come down from the financial '23 level. But I can comfortably say this is an EBITDA margin that can be sustainable going forward as well.

Keshav Garg

analyst
#110

Sir, just one thought, sir — why not consider a share buyback, since the stock is cheap? At least earnings per share would go up if we did a buyback, and right now the company doesn't have to pay any tax on a buyback, whereas previously that tax was 25%. So that's my humble suggestion — please give it some thought.

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#111

Absolutely, we will definitely take your feedback on board.

Operator

operator
#112

Our next question is from Shridhar Shah, an individual investor.

Speaker

unknown
#113

Sir, every one of my questions has now been answered. The frustration felt by individual shareholders comes through very clearly on this call. I would just like to urge you to put in all your efforts, whatever lies within your control, to bring glory to the company and put a smile on the faces of the shareholders who have stayed with you for so many years now. Thank you, sir.

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#114

Thanks a lot for that, Shridhar — honestly, we're putting real effort in as we head toward the third quarter and this financial year as well, and we'll do everything we can to deliver the strongest results possible from here on too.

Speaker

unknown
#115

Yeah, we’ve been hoping for the best from the company for so many years now, sir. But up to today, we’ve just been disappointed. I hope this doesn’t keep going, sir.

Operator

operator
#116

Our following question is from Amit Singh, an individual investor.

Speaker

unknown
#117

You mentioned Q3 would be good. My first question is just whether that would be better on a Y-o-Y basis or better on a quarter-on-quarter basis? That's my one -- first question. And my second question is that Q2 performance was affected by a higher discount on old inventories, which you have liquidated. So I wanted to know what value of the old inventory we are still holding, and one more thing: when we know we have been holding the inventory for the past 2 to 3 years, then why can't we provide in the earlier year when we know this is going to be liquidated in future and we can take a better discount? That is what I want to know.

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#118

I believe that was actually 3 questions rolled into 1, so let me address the second part first. Our second quarter results were largely held back by the increase in material costs, something we mentioned earlier as well. As for how the third quarter will go, it's too early to predict the quarterly numbers — whether they'll be Y-o-Y or quarter-on-quarter. That said, we're definitely feeling more positive about the third quarter than at any other point. And thirdly, on the last part of your question about lost sales — that's something outside our control. A sale only happens when a good buyer shows up, so it's not as though we can sell at any moment we choose. Demand arrives at a particular time, and we need to have something on hand for it. Unfortunately, that situation arose during this quarter, and the impact carried into this quarter as well. But Amit, to add to what Sandeep Ji just said, before this, as you know, we were a wholesale business. So as our modern channels expand, the returns will keep on increasing.

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#119

That said, this complaint won't come up anymore, since we've put a solid SOP in place for liquidating old inventory. Also, we won't be keeping inventory around any longer. Within a fixed timeframe, it will be cleared from our books.

Speaker

unknown
#120

So what you're saying, if I understand you correctly, is that you're not certain whether quarter 3 of this year will show a better year-on-year comparison, or whether it might actually be better...

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#121

Amit, that figure is clearly a year-on-year comparison. You can’t compare quarter 2 with quarter 3 on a quarter-on-quarter basis. So the commentary we’re providing for quarter 3 is on a year-on-year basis.

Speaker

unknown
#122

So that's going to come in above what we saw in Q3, and then Q4 of FY '26 as well, correct?

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#123

Yeah, that's our hope as we head into Q3 — yes.

Operator

operator
#124

Diwakar Rana from Prudent Equity has the next question.

Diwakar Rana

analyst
#125

Sir, how quickly will we be able to recognize revenue from that solar order?

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#126

So commissioning begins on 31st March, Diwakar Ji — that's our COD. And that means in the next financial year, we'll be able to recognize the revenue.

Diwakar Rana

analyst
#127

What revenue figure do you expect for FY '28?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#128

I don’t have that figure on hand at the moment. Roughly — 1 second. We’ll follow up with you on this. We don’t have an exact number we can provide, but we will get back to you. Since it’s a predefined PPA, the range is plus/minus 5%. We’ll send that amount over to you.

Diwakar Rana

analyst
#129

And sir, a lot of questions have come up regarding how the company is growing — sorry?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#130

My apologies, Diwakar Ji — revenue should land somewhere in the region of INR 17 crores to INR 18-odd crores, and for the solar project the EBITDA margins come in above 80%, so.

Diwakar Rana

analyst
#131

Just 17% to 18%?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#132

Right, on the revenue and EBITDA side, that's roughly 80% or higher.

Diwakar Rana

analyst
#133

And sir, there are many questions surrounding growth. So I'd like to ask what we're doing differently compared with what we were doing 10 years ago. So why should investors expect a different result now, since growth is staying around 8% to 10%? Now the same thing is happening around 11% to 12%, which we're heading toward. So why should we expect a different outcome in the share price? I mean, because there are no additional triggers.

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#134

Look, there's no way to compare where we were 10 years ago with this financial year. But, as I mentioned before as well, we grew at 15% last year. That should give you confidence that this company is capable of double-digit growth. And the company has also provided guidance of double-digit growth for this year too. So we're not backing away by saying we won't grow. We've already established our — what we told you, we also delivered in the last financial year. So this year as well, we will definitely deliver as we guided you. But yes, certainly, this quarter was below our expectation too, yet that doesn't alter the long-term vision for this company. So you should take this point positively.

Diwakar Rana

analyst
#135

Yes, sir. However, the past growth doesn’t actually benefit investors, correct? You might grow 13%, 14% this year, but there’s no additional trigger in the company. I mean, we, as an investor, look at the company, and we’ll see what the growth triggers are. So the growth triggers have stayed the same over the last 10 to 12 years. There’s no additional thing we’ve done—just that you diversified into the solar thing, and that was another issue, because as soon as we announced that order, our share price fell, right? Because I haven’t seen any textile—I won’t say textile, you’re the best branded clothing brand—going into the solar thing. You can see you said there’s no margin in the export, right? That’s why you didn’t pursue that. But there are many white labeling companies in India that are doing very well. You’re right there is—margins are less, they’re going down to 12%. But look at the profitability, look at the market they’re getting, because they benefit from China Plus One and a lot of things. But we haven’t capitalized any of those things, right?

Diwakar Rana

analyst
#136

And last year you made the decision to get into the solar business, and that is the reason you aren't getting the valuation — because we aren't doing anything that benefits the shareholders. We're simply doing exactly what we were doing 10 years ago.

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#137

Yeah, we've heard that point, and thanks a lot.

Operator

operator
#138

Ladies and gentlemen, since no additional questions remain, that brings us to the close of the question-and-answer session. I'll now turn the conference back over to management for some closing remarks.

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#139

Yes. Thank you very much for joining this call. And should you have any questions, please consult our investment <<inaudible>> and fill in the e-mail ID exactly as listed on the Monte Carlo corporate website. Thank you very much.

Operator

operator
#140

Appreciate it. That brings this conference to a close on behalf of Emkay Global Financial Services Limited. Many thanks for being with us, and you can go ahead and disconnect your lines now.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Monte Carlo Fashions Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Monte Carlo Fashions Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Monte Carlo Fashions Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.