Mutares SE & Co. KGaA (MUX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 7, 2024

Deutsche Boerse Xetra DE Financials Capital Markets earnings 36 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

This call is being recorded at this time. Hello, everyone, and thank you for joining us for the Mutares Earnings Call covering Q3 2024. Joining us today are the CIO, Johannes Laumann, and the CFO, Mark Friedrich, who will walk you through the results and the key events from Q3 2024. Once the presentation wraps up, they will take your questions. The deck you are seeing will be posted on the Mutares website following this call. Before we begin, please be aware that forward-looking statements appear in this presentation, including projections that might not turn out as we currently anticipate. So I would ask you to review the cautionary note regarding forward-looking statements contained in the materials available on the website. With that, I will turn things over to Johannes Laumann.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#2

Thanks a lot, and a really warm welcome to our Q3 2024 earnings call. These are rather interesting times — a new president in the U.S. as of last night, the government here in the country stepping down, and something we in Munich like a great deal, a Bayern win in the Champions League. So let's quickly walk through a reminder of what we do, how we do it, and how we've developed. Then I'll move to the Q3 highlights and take a small peek into Q4 already, since we're in November now. Before handing things to Mark for the Q3 financials, I'll wrap up with the outlook once more. Our business model hasn't changed. We operate in 13 countries through 14 offices, with Europe as the main focus, having added international footprints in Chicago, Shanghai, and Mumbai, where I'll be next week, to further stabilize and also further accelerate growth. We run four segments: automotive, engineering technology, goods and service, and retail and food. Okay, back on track. Sorry, we lost the stability of the presentation here, I think, and then those three segments represent two things for us: first, risk mitigation within the portfolio, and second, the chance to buy at any time and the chance to sell at any time.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#3

The businesses we're focused on are typically sized above 100 million. When it comes to platform investment, EUR 2 to 400 million is our sweet spot, since we're looking at absolute value — the absolute euros at holding level — and that's much simpler at a larger scale, then converting to Euro. People ask us frequently what kinds of transactions we pursue. The primary kind we do — and the sole kind we do — is one where operational improvement potential exists and where our own consultants, the ones on our payroll, can see that potential. Our life cycle is split into four phases. The acquisition part is where we purchase the companies, and we've refilled the pipeline once more. We've done a significant amount of transacting in Q3 both on the buy side and on the sell side, and we'll keep doing so. As recently as today, we announced one more transaction for us in the Polish market — a market we newly developed just over a year ago — and we're very pleased that today, or last night, we completed the signing of Natura, a retailer that is very well known in Poland.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#4

When it comes to acquisitions, we need to put money in, and across the lifecycle we've put money into our portfolio companies. Essentially, our investments fall into three categories. First, there's the very, very initial kind of investment, which comes by contract from the seller. We're compelled and obligated to have skin in the game — to put money into the business we're acquiring, or to put money into a purchase price when we make a strategic add-on acquisition. By contract, we invest into our company. Second, there's investment aimed at building up the groups — building up groups such as Amaneos, building up groups such as FerrAl United, building up groups such as NEM Energy — so that ultimately this leads to a larger exit. Deliberately, we put money in there into the existing portfolio through purchase price, or we put money in through manpower, through our consultants, or we invest directly. The third type of investment, which is decided case by case, is when things aren't going as planned: we take the liberty to divest — to invest, sorry — before divesting, into a portfolio in order to reduce or eliminate the impact on the rest. To give a simple example, we invest so that a company survives when it isn't going according to plan or when things are happening on the geopolitical side, so as not to harm the rest of the portfolios, so as not to harm any stakeholders who pay us back for the bad things on the other portfolio.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#5

So it's decided on a case-by-case basis. On the acquisition side, we make three kinds of investments. Realignment — that's where my Mutares career began. This is hardcore restructuring. This is taking a -EUR 30 million business to break-even. This is where you go to the customer base, you go to the supplier base, and you truly transform the company. That's the spirit. That's our core USP. Day to day, we put our heart and soul on the line to make it happen. Then the optimization phase is about creating the new setup, creating and stabilizing the business we have. At the end of the day, the harvesting phase is where we prepare for divestment. I'll come to that in the outlook later on. Last but not least, divest as well. We've started investing a lot in the business. Our typical holding period is three to six years, and we've already seen in the last year and this year that it kicks in on our growth path. It kicks in when we've divested SMP. It kicks in when we've divested Frigoscandia, and the growth strategy kicks in when we've completed the listing of Steyr Motors.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#6

Taking a brief look at the portfolio — and Mark will get into much greater detail — I wanted to touch on the automotive side, Amaneos and FerrAl United, where we've invested heavily so they'd be too big to fail, so they'd be a significant player in the automotive supplier market, and what we're seeing today is that the market recognizes us as such a significant player. The most recent transactions we did, for instance, the one that went into the Amaneos Group, which was SMR, was that we provided a solution for a very, very large German OEM who came to us in order to take over the business and said, "Please provide me a solution. I'm going to pay for it." And in the end, it's a win-win scenario, so Amaneos and FerrAl United, I'm absolutely convinced, will pay off in the years to come. We have created two large groups over EUR 1 billion of turnover, global footprint, and all the OEMs perceive us as significant players in the plastic market for Amaneos and in the metal and aluminum market for FerrAl United. Engineering technology — a quick word on Buderus Edelstahl, a very well-known brand here in the country, an acquisition we have lately conducted with voestalpine.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#7

This facility brings in roughly slightly over EUR 300 million. It's a classic Mutares situation. Here we grasp the business, we grasp the market, and we know exactly what our plans for it are. We'll confirm all of that once closing has taken place, which we expect by the beginning of Q1 at the latest — and there's still a solid possibility we get the deal closed even this year. But this marks a very substantial step, and it also moves the engineering technology ahead. The next one — and I'll touch on it briefly later too — but I want to confirm what's already circulating in the market regarding the merchant market. It has already been mentioned. So Conexus is a transaction we completed previously in Italy. We built up that business. We turned it profitable, and now we're taking it to market for sale. And last but not least, the Natura transaction we signed last night together with the Polish team in Warsaw. So a great, great accomplishment to be in the market and to have carried out this deal in the retail cosmetics business, a EUR 100 million, a very, very well-known brand in Poland.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#8

Moving right along to the main points from Q3 and Q4. Buy-side acquisitions were carried out both at signing and at closing of the deals. On the left-hand side you can see the closing of the transaction — that was two add-ons for the FerrAl United Group, one add-on for the Terranor Group, and MatiKon, which is the former Fischer Automotive. Strategic add-ons were made for the FerrAl Group and the Terranor Group so that more value gets created down the road when we exit the business. You can see purchase revenue of roughly EUR 300 million, and EUR 17 million has been invested. Now the signed transactions. Our belief now is that we have built these groups as large as we want them, and as significant as we want them. The newly signed transactions were mostly platform transactions, apart from the one at the bottom, which was the case where a German OEM asked us to provide a solution for him. But Magirus was Seneca, Altura, Buderus was in Natura are platform acquisitions. And what stands out clearly is that the ratio between the turnover we acquired and the investments we made on the deal side drops significantly.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#9

So that's the plan we're pursuing moving ahead. The groups have been developed to the point we intended. Money has gone into the business, and we're strongly convinced it will deliver returns. What you're seeing now is more exits, and fewer investments right at the outset of a deal. Regarding exits, we've divested 2 businesses in Q3 and Q4. The first was Repartim, sold to a big French strategic buyer, and the second was Mobilitas, also sold to a local strategic — that one came as part of the Arriva acquisition we made from Deutsche Bahn AG. Two further highlights on the capital markets front. In September 2024 we successfully placed a bond of EUR 135 million, a Nordic bond alongside the existing instrument, and on several occasions — and we stand fully behind it and are repeating it right now — we have confirmed the guidance for 2024. The most recent capital market transaction and event we've completed is the listing of Steyr Motors. As for the Steyr Motors listing, we chose to list here despite a difficult market environment since we have faith in the company. We've achieved a great turnaround in a very short span of time — a carve-out situation from Thales in France — and we've set the company on a stable path for growth and a stable path for profitability.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#10

Clearly, the market also gave us a push to move even faster here. Then last week, it was successfully placed at a share price of EUR 14, which amounts to a successful placement of roughly 30% of the shares. We continue to hold 71% of the shares since we believe in Steyr Motors' future success. We intend to keep it, and we intend to sell it at a later stage. A full sell down will happen, but definitely not right away. Revenues and profitability have a growth path of 50%, but we at Mutares want to benefit. We believe that is the greatest and the maximization of shareholder value creation that we could achieve with Steyr Motors. Let me make this my final remark on this Steyr Motors IPO to thank the Steyr Motors team, to thank the transaction team, you know, led by Julian Cassutti, the CEO of the business. They did a fantastic job in making Steyr Motors successful, but also in IPOing the business. Very well done. We are very proud that we remain the majority owner of this business. With that, I would like to hand over to Mark for the financials of the year.

Mark Friedrich

executive
#11

Thanks, Johannes. I want to discuss the Q3 financials, which span Europe—clearly the summer months, including August here—and I'll begin with an overview of the financials. It essentially makes clear that the group experienced a setback in just Adjusted EBITDA, which is fairly normal since July and August in the Nordics are somewhat weaker, and on top of that, the new acquisitions are coming in, which under our business model is quite normal. At the outset they contribute negatively. We hit nearly EUR 4 billion in revenues for the group, so fairly okay relative to what we aim to achieve step by step, at roughly EUR 1 billion a year, and we're on track here in 2024 as well. Turning to the Mutares holding, you can see revenue is somewhat lower in Q3 because in August we have approximately EUR 3 million less in revenues owing to the summer break. Profitability is fairly flat. We had some one-offs during the quarter from the bond issues, but I'll go into more detail on the next page since we've now included a few additional slides that we already presented four weeks ago on the call on the 4th of October.

Mark Friedrich

executive
#12

Let's begin with the P&L for the holding company, which we always show each quarter. We'll be putting that out very shortly. As you can see, revenue has risen somewhat, and we're well on course to end up substantially above last year's figure. This line stands out clearly here, because it shows that we booked yet another operating income of close to EUR 7 million. That EUR 7 million—or most of it—comes from releasing a provision tied to a transaction we carried out. We had a deposit sitting at a bank, and it's no longer needed. So we could release the provision and collected the cash at the start of October. Conversely, you'll notice that personnel costs are flat, and this figure covers only the holding company's personnel costs. The personnel costs, or other costs, that come with our global expansion and with our offices throughout Europe sit within what we label here as expenses for purchased services. Then there are the other operating expenses, where we see a reversal—or rather a favorable reduction, not a reversal, a favorable reduction versus last year. That applies to pretty much every category of expense, every line item.

Mark Friedrich

executive
#13

On the right-hand side, you can see M&A services, legal travel, and admin costs — all of them either held flat or came down somewhat. Combined with the higher revenue, that gives us a substantial improvement in EBITDA. We also expect this to hold going forward. It lines up precisely with what we told you four weeks ago: we have steered things in the right direction, and quarter by quarter you will see that reflected in the financial reporting as well. A few more slides now on how our risk is distributed, beginning with the one we already showed here. We have a distribution — roughly EUR 650 million that we have invested — and you see it here in equity loans and receivables. At the bottom, we have also included the breakdown across the various life cycles. Here you can see that realignment is already quite low, and it will stay low given what Johannes mentioned and what you saw in terms of investments — the initial investments in the M&A phase, which are coming down quite substantially. In optimization, you can see we currently hold the majority of investments, and that is mainly attributable to the big groups. The big groups we wanted to have at Amaneos and FerrAl, which together account for approximately EUR 200 million.

Mark Friedrich

executive
#14

We also have a few other significant assets in the mix here, particularly Lapeyre, which would add meaningfully to that middle figure. Looking at this again through a different lens, by segment: as we noted, certain portfolio companies are clearly more exit-ready at this point. Steyr is a strong illustration, and Conexus is another solid one. We'll likewise be monetizing in the automotive and mobility segment and in the engineering and technology segment, where we hold promising assets too and where we clearly aim to recover considerably more than we put in, doing so at the appropriate moment. Turning to the quarterly financials across the segments once more: notwithstanding certain closings, Q3 did not progress as strongly as some might have anticipated. You can see lower revenues in goods and services and in retail and food versus the segment or the months prior, plus a modest uptick in automotive and mobility from the MatiKon closing. Conversely, within automotive as well, this month or quarter has, well, low activity. That's why the Adjusted EBITDA here is quite negative relative to earlier quarters.

Mark Friedrich

executive
#15

Turning to the individual segments, Johannes has already highlighted a few different portfolio groups. And what you can see here is that in automotive and mobility — the largest segment — we hold just a small number of assets, with the major ones being Amaneos and FerrAl, where our clear emphasis is on optimizing the footprint and raising utilization of the facilities we already have. The transaction we're doing here for some of the — or one of the — big OEMs is a good illustration of that, and it sits within the Amaneos group, or the CSFC group, which forms part of Amaneos. On top of that, we continue to pursue opportunities to win business for the portfolio we already hold. That will keep going over the coming couple of quarters. Moving to the next segment, engineering technology is by its nature a fairly diverse segment and a fairly stable one. We have assets here that joined the group recently, specifically Sofinter and, in fact, Efacec as well, and both are progressing well. Efacec has been in the group for roughly 12 months now, so it is considerably further along than Sofinter, which came in only recently. With both entities we are moving in a good direction, yet together they contribute substantially negative to Adjusted EBITDA during their first 12 months after joining the group.

Mark Friedrich

executive
#16

Taken together, that's roughly 15 million of negative Adjusted EBITDA, though we're fairly confident — particularly with Efacec — that it flips positive in 25. Then again, we have businesses in there already performing quite well. Steyr Motors is now out and visible in the market. NEM is also operating quite well, and so is Guascor. We have a handful of promising assets here that are actually, or some of them are actually also on the list you'll see later in this call from Johannes, which repeats the slide we showed on the 4th of October. Turning to goods and services, the segment you see here consistently runs positive, because we have a few entities in this segment doing well. That includes Terranor, and Palmia is doing really well too. Conexus, as Johannes mentioned, is currently up for divestment. Go Collective is something delivering month by month, actually very good results, very positive results. We have the new additions to the group here with Greenview and Asteri, which are something we need to work on, especially Asteri, which is a similar business to Conexus.

Mark Friedrich

executive
#17

We're feeling pretty positive about things. Turning to the final segment, Retail and Food. Lapeyre's development still largely drives Retail and Food, and the soft consumer environment in France is weighing heavily on Lapeyre as well, which is exactly what the financials here reflect. We see the team has accomplished a tremendous amount in reshaping the organization and also in launching sales initiatives that look promising — these need some time before they deliver results and convert some orders into the pipeline and ultimately into revenue — but what we see here is that we're clearly on the right track to turning this company around into something that delivers positive results in 2025. That's our assumption, combined with a decline in interest rates in Europe and therefore some pickup in activity within the construction business. My final slide here: the current life cycle. As you can see, we haven't changed this. We simply add entities in the acquisition and realignment phase so as to show the progress quarter by quarter, and you can see that the realignment phase obviously becomes more negative. The more assets we include, we see revenue increase thanks to the closing of Maticon, Sofinter, and so on, but that obviously contributes a negative adjusted EBITDA, and then we have the substantial decrease, or negative adjusted EBITDA, in the optimization phase, so this is mainly attributable to the big ones I've already mentioned a couple of times, FerrAl United and Lapeyre, where we're in the middle of the transformation.

Mark Friedrich

executive
#18

Conversely, there are businesses doing really well in that category — Conexus, NEM, Palmia. In final segment harvesting, we've still got Steyr in there, but since we remained the owner at quarter-end, that company will also be included for the next couple of quarters thanks to our stake. You can see this is shaping up nicely, with Adjusted EBITDA of nearly EUR 10 million on steady revenue. With that, I'll turn things back to Johannes for the closing remarks.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#19

Thanks a lot, Mark. I'd like to share the plan and what the outlook looks like. I want to begin with a summary of our investments — I won't read it out — but I'd like to highlight 3 points, because growth remains our focus. It's our conviction, a strong one: if you stand still, you fall behind, and if you snooze, you lose. That's the reason we keep pursuing growth, and we keep following the successful growth path that we essentially began in 2019, 2020. We're dedicated, and we are fully on track, with a successful and proven track record, because of the following: first of all, I believe we are extremely strong at making deals. We are extremely strong at the operations of carving out businesses and at the operations of turning businesses around. And then, once again, we are extremely strong at conducting an exit at the right moment in time for the right valuation. And last but not least, we are attempting — and we will never manage it to the best and full extent expected — to be as transparent as possible. But I can assure you that we, as the management, are fully committed to this business.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#20

We aim for maximum transparency. We want to bring you along on our journey, just as we have done in prior years, and show how all of this gets achieved — the track record, the growth, and the acquisitions we have discussed. I'd like to offer a bit of insight, which was already shared on October 4th regarding the exit side. Those exits are currently in progress. Steyr, we have carried out. The exits sit at different stages. There's a stage in which we prepare it. There's a stage in which data collection has already begun. There's a stage in which we are already active in the market, like Conexus, which Mergermarket also published last week, or we are at the stage of choosing an advisor. But we intend to accomplish all of this in 2025, with exit proceeds of roughly and above EUR 200 million. So we are working hard on every front — not only to acquire companies, not only to turn around companies, but also to sell the companies. And last but not least, I'd like to confirm once more, as I said earlier, the outlook. I would like to reaffirm the guidance for 2025, 2028.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#21

The screen isn't functioning at the moment. We're staying on our growth trajectory. We're continuing to become the company with EUR 10 billion in group turnover and EUR 200 million in holding profit. That will keep going, and you'll notice that the investments — the original investment per case — will come down. You'll also keep seeing exits become bigger and more numerous, because we've now been through that three-to-six year holding period since we began a growth journey in 2020. As the earlier slide showed, a great deal of this will materialize in 2025 and in the years ahead. And finally, I want to reaffirm that management remains dedicated to the plan. Management is dedicated to what we do. Management is dedicated to the growth we've laid out, which means we'll keep working at it. We'll keep delivering what we promised. We'll keep walking the talk. And that also means you'll see Mark and me again at the Q1 results in 2025. So before we wrap up and move to Q&A — this is the first time this year I've said that.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#22

To wrap up, I'd like to wish each of you a wonderful Christmas and a happy, successful Rockstar Year 2025. So, on behalf of Mark, myself, and the whole management team, many thanks for joining this Q3 2024 call for Mutares. It was a pleasure having you with us throughout the year. We're now ready for your questions. Thank you so much. I'll hand things back to the moderator.

Operator

operator
#23

Thank you very much. Dear ladies and gentlemen, should you be connected to the conference call and wish to pose a question, kindly press nine followed by the star key on your telephone keypad at this time to join the queue. Should you wish to withdraw your question, please press nine, star once more. One moment, please, for the first question. Asking questions is only possible during the conference call, so please dial in if you would like to state a question. The combination for raising a question is nine, star. The first question comes from Stefan Augustin, Warburg Research. Over to you, Stefan.

Stefan Augustin

analyst
#24

Yes, thanks, and hello. My question is really about a technical point: how will Steyr Motors be valued going forward? Is the full difference shown in the financial result, or would you say it's valued market by market — and does that valuation then fluctuate quarter to quarter, or does it stay somewhere stable?

Mark Friedrich

executive
#25

Hi, Stefan. So at the close of Q3, that's clearly not in there. Also, the partial investment wasn't included either. And moving forward, we haven't made a decision on your question — on your outcome question. This is one where we genuinely want to deliver on that slide you saw, with a couple of exits that Johannes said we intend to deliver in 2025. But we've said the whole time that this runs until the end of 2025. So we're continuously working on these exits in 2024 as well, and we want to hit the target — our target — reach one signing by the end of the year, and then want to see where we stand at that point, right? That's why we've also repeated here that we're sticking with our guidance, because we believe we're able to deliver one of these exits. And then as an alternative, we can consider revaluing Steyr in the way you just mentioned, getting closer to the market price. It's a listed asset that carries a price tag at all times, and so everybody can see what we would do.

Stefan Augustin

analyst
#26

Alright, thank you. I've got it completely.

Operator

operator
#27

Many thanks, Stefan. Ladies and gentlemen, to put a question forward the combination is nine, star. So should you wish to ask our host something, kindly press nine, star at this point. Our next question comes from Marie-Thérèse Grübner. The floor is yours. Yes, good afternoon. I have a couple of questions on my end. Could we possibly obtain a range of potential figures regarding the exits — the potential exits you referred to, namely Repartim, Mobilitas, and Conexus? Perhaps for all three, if you — and I do understand that you would prefer not to provide the specifics for each one in terms of expected holding and net income contribution.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#28

Marie, the line is pretty poor, honestly. So we’re doing a bit of guessing about what you asked. Oh, I apologize. If I’ve got it right, you mean the exits we plan for this year, and the one that already took place in Q3 — is that right? Yes, sorry. Hopefully that’s clearer for you. The point is basically to understand the net holding, net income effect from the three acquisitions — sorry, the three divestitures you flagged on the slide: Repartim, Mobilitas, and Conexus. How large could that impact be? I mean, Repartim and Mobilitas are finished. So that isn’t the plan. Conexus is currently out in the market. There’s no certainty it gets signed and closed this year. Quite the opposite, so there’s another one that still has to be signed. But the proceeds from the three — and of course that’s part of the negotiation, and we’d rather not disclose the precise amounts — sit somewhere between EUR 50 million and EUR 100 million across the three. So Repartim, Mobilitas, and the one still to come. Oh, okay. Many thanks. The one still to come remains under negotiation. So even if I wanted to give you the exact figures, I can’t.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#29

All right. Still, that's above what I'd have expected. So a net income hit of EUR 50 to 100 million. Yeah. Perhaps that's another reason I'm heading to India next week. Got it. Okay. Fine. Thanks a lot.

Operator

operator
#30

Thanks a lot, and I’d like to add my thanks as well.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Mutares SE & Co. KGaA transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Mutares SE & Co. KGaA earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Mutares SE & Co. KGaA or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.