Ninety One Group (N91) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 15, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Hendrik du Toit
executiveGood morning, and welcome to the presentation of Ninety One's interim results for the Six Months to 30 September 2022. We appreciate you joining us, whether you're here in person or virtually. I'll begin with an update on the business, and then Kim McFarland, our Finance Director, will present the financial review. After that, I'll cover the outlook before we move to questions. If you're participating through the webcast, you can submit questions during the presentation via the chat function at the bottom of your screen. Before I move on to the first half performance, let me remind you of the key characteristics of our business model. At Ninety One, clients always come first in good times and in bad times. We have, and we continue to build longstanding relationships with our professionally intermediated clients, which we, whom we serve locally or through our various offices across the world. Ninety One's origins are in the emerging markets, from which we have grown into a global investment manager. Stability and Owner Culture are key foundations for Ninety One, and we have no intentions of undermining those foundations because of temporary market headwinds. Ninety One has a people-centric, capital-light, technology-enabled business model, which is highly cash generative.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveFrom the time we started, roughly GBP 1.6 billion in dividends has been distributed to shareholders. What we're creating is an intergenerational company capable of delivering competitive returns for clients across the cycle. We hold the conviction that serving clients well means shareholders will be well-served too. The foundation for all of it is our purpose: investing for a better tomorrow. That happens through building a Better Firm, committing to Better Investing, and contributing to a Better world. This slide, which you've seen before, shows how resilient our business has been across many cycles. Over more than three decades, Ninety One has been built organically and built sustainably, with a record of navigating various market conditions successfully. Many stories come through in this chart, and it highlights the phases our business has passed through. The most recent phase began in March 2020, when we became independently listed. During this brief span, two fully-fledged bear markets have hit us. Different from the recovery seen after COVID, we anticipate the current difficult conditions will last into the foreseeable future. Now let me turn to my key messages. Back in May, when we presented record full-year results, we signaled caution. Ninety One is a risk-on business currently operating in a risk-off environment.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveOur business is mainly long-only, so by nature it is exposed to price swings in the financial assets where we put client capital. Clients have grown warier and are spending longer before committing to investment choices, or they are reducing portfolio risk regardless of how investments have performed. Given that environment, revenues came in broadly flat while costs rose moderately. We recorded net outflows during the period, since new business volumes were lower while outflows held broadly steady. Our investment performance relative to peers stays competitive, and we keep concentrating on lifting our short-term performance. Despite these difficult market conditions, our strategy is unchanged. We will keep using our well-tested investment processes, with attention right now on our clients and what they need, making sure our people have solid support for the work ahead. Meaningful staff ownership in Ninety One aligns the interests of our people with those of our shareholders and encourages our long-term orientation. These are the key figures for the first half. We will go through the financials in greater detail afterward. Assets under management fell by 8% to GBP 132 billion, reflecting net outflows of GBP 3.2 billion and weaker markets. Average assets under management rose by 1% compared with the same period last year.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveWhen it comes to how our investments have performed, we continue to stack up well, with firmwide outperformance over three years sitting at 66%. Adjusted operating profit fell 7%. At GBP 0.065 per share, the interim dividend works out to a payout of 71%, consistent with both the prior period and the dividend policy we have stated. Some very challenging markets have been with us during the last six months. Interest rates have climbed more quickly than expected, coming off historically low levels. Add central bank tightening along with growing geopolitical uncertainty, and equities and fixed income have both faced additional headwinds. Active managers have contended with a tough operating environment, made worse by heightened volatility and higher cross-asset correlations. Clients have been de-risking their portfolios and putting off investment decisions, which has limited the sales opportunities available to us. We launched intensive engagement with clients, making sure we stay close to them and are ready to act when opportunities arise. Back in 1831, 1941, and 1969, Treasuries and equities were likewise highly correlated on the downside. For a long-only investment manager, there was not much place to hide. As I have said many times before, short-term market events do not cause us to change our approach. Let me remind you that net outflows have occurred in 25% of the half-yearly periods since 2002. Over the last 20 years we delivered significant growth, and under half of that came through net inflows, with the other half due to markets.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveOur emphasis is on securing strong results for clients over the long term, and that is what we will keep doing. Our assets under management stay well diversified by asset class, client region, and client type. Now let's examine flows by asset class. We recorded net inflows in our South African fund platform and marginal net inflows in alternatives, which are mostly credit. Regrettably, the other asset classes offset those, chiefly Equities and Multi-Asset. Net outflows in equities came largely from certain global equity strategies. Most of those outflows stemmed from two clients de-risking their portfolios for reasons unrelated to investment performance. As I've said before, our clients include very large, sophisticated institutional investors. Consequently, our flows can be lumpy, as we saw in this period. Just the Africa client group recorded net inflows over the last six months, mostly into fixed income strategies and our fund platform business. The Asia Pacific client group posted the largest net outflows in the period, driven by global equity strategies. Net inflows in the advisor channel were more than offset by outflows in the institutional channel. The advisor channel drew net inflows from the Africa and UK client groups.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveInstitutional outflows were driven by a mix of de-risking and LDI-related liquidation near the close of the period. Turning to investment performance: our firmwide aggregate asset-weighted results stay competitive, with 66% of our strategies beating benchmarks across the three-year period. At the end of September, over five and 10 years, our outperformance came in at 75% and 83% respectively, which leaves us well placed to compete. We recognize that short-term performance, though somewhat improved versus six months ago, still requires work. Mutual fund investment performance has picked up markedly since year-end. That's a decent, if imperfect, proxy for how we stack up against peers. We're in a better spot now, but we're not complacent. As always, our focus stays on delivering competitive long-term investment performance for our clients. For the past two years, our sustainability efforts have centered on climate change. Given how urgent the issue is, this will stay our priority for some time ahead. We've devoted considerable time to how we can contribute to our clients' thinking while achieving real world change. Decarbonizing portfolios does not guarantee real world decarbonization. Through our Sustainability Mandates, we've been encouraging asset owners to put money into climate solution providers and to support the transition of companies and countries that currently emit heavily.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveA lot of our work has happened through the Sustainable Markets Initiative and the Glasgow Financial Alliance for Net Zero, and Ninety One has been an active contributor to the transition finance framework that is now in place. These things are going to matter a great deal in the years ahead, and we've been vocal across our industry in pushing for measurement approaches that encourage allocations into these areas without leaving emerging markets behind. The targets we submitted to the Net Zero Asset Managers Initiative were accepted in July by the Institutional Investors Group on Climate Change. That lends credibility to our transition plan — the same kind of delivery we expect from the companies we invest in. Unless there is substantial investment in the transition that's required, the world won't improve. Ninety One is committed to aligning its business with that imperative. Our range of sustainable strategies has drawn positive net inflows, and we launched one additional strategy during this reporting period. In these testing times, we take confidence from the strong, deeply ingrained Owner Culture at Ninety One. A stable and experienced staff complement gives us that confidence. Talent density and diversity are key objectives for us. We are direct and honest with our people about the challenges we face and about the high expectations we have of them.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveAt Ninety One, staff now own more than 28%, and that aligns with what we set out to do in creating a business that lasts across generations. Kim will now take over and walk you through the financial review. Thank you.
Kim McFarland
executiveThanks, Hendrik, and good morning, everyone. The interim results I'm presenting capture the environment just as Hendrik described a moment ago. Here's what stands out. Adjusted operating revenue rose 1% to GBP 330.9 million. Adjusted operating expenses were up 5%, reaching GBP 223 million. That gave us an adjusted operating profit of GBP 107.9 million, which is a 7% decline. When you add the rise in adjusted net interest income and last year's gain from selling Silica, profit before tax fell 16% to GBP 110.6 million. The effective tax rate came in at 23.4% for the period, essentially matching the earlier period. Those items together bring profit after tax down 16% to GBP 84.7 million, while adjusted EPS drops 7% to 9%, mirroring the adjusted operating profit decline I just walked through. As usual, my adjusted operating profit figures adjust for lease interest and subletting income, and they strip out the contra effect from revaluing the deferred employee benefit schemes. Adjusted operating profit margin moved from 35.2% down to 32.6%, driven by fixed expenses growing faster than revenues.
Kim McFarland
executiveAs I warned in May, this has been a tougher stretch, and we're confident that the adjusted figures cited here capture the business's actual operating position over the last six months. On this slide you'll find more detail on adjusted operating revenue, which rose to GBP 330.9 million. Management fees fell 1% to GBP 312.8 million, down from 314.8 million in the first half of 2022. That follows a 2% drop from GBP 380 million in the second half of 2022. Average AUM, though, was up 1% across the comparable six-month span, reaching GBP 138.2 billion. The average fee rate, on the other hand, went from 45.7 to 45.2 basis points. Broadly speaking, this again stems from growth in AUM coming from clients with below-average fee rates, plus a shift in the mix of strategies clients hold, mainly within our offshore fund range. Given today's market conditions, our guidance will stay cautious about downward pressure in the period ahead. As we flagged before, performance fees dropped 19% versus the prior period yet still came in at GBP 11 million. Those fees came about because of relative investment outperformance in a selection of strategies.
Kim McFarland
executiveOther income is mostly made up of a material foreign exchange gain of GBP 7.4 million, largely driven by translating U.S. dollar assets, or by the pound sterling weakening across the six-month period, moving from 1.31% to 1.11% as at the end of September 2022. On the next slide, you can see how adjusted operating expenses build up between H1 2022 and H1 2023. Every area rose versus the prior period. Adjusted operating expenses in total were up 5%, reaching GBP 223 million. Employee remuneration is a key expense once again, and it fell to 66% of the total expense base, versus 69% in the comparative period. Total remuneration expense rose marginally, by GBP 1.5 million or 1%, to GBP 147.3 million. The driver was higher fixed remuneration from annual inflation and market related adjustments, which was largely offset by a lower accrual for variable remuneration, consistent with the lower adjusted operating profit. As a reminder, over 50% of employee remuneration is variable, and overall this produced a compensation ratio of 44.5%. Turning now to business expenses, they rose 13% to GBP 75.7 million. Let me walk you through each of the business expense categories.
Kim McFarland
executiveClient and retail fund administration is the biggest cost line, and it's up 8%, or GBP 1.6 million, mostly because of the weak sterling against the U.S. dollar-based expenses we have here. Information expenses, which actually sit within other, are much the same story. Luckily, USD makes up only around 20% of our cost base, with the rest mainly in GBP and ZAR. As I said earlier, we did gain from a high share of dollar-based revenues. Travel expenses have risen substantially in absolute terms versus the prior period after COVID-19 related restrictions eased, though they are still below the pre-COVID period. Systems expenses went up because of continued investment in underlying platforms, but there's nothing notable to call out there. Overheads, which are also in other, rose mostly with inflation, plus a few one-off charges that we don't expect to repeat in the second half. The split of these expenses across the comparable period is largely unchanged. Going forward, we expect business expenses to rise through a combination of inflation and FX pressure. At the same time, the business maintains strong cost discipline, and as a result, we guide for a lower rate of increase in the second half.
Kim McFarland
executiveWe anticipate and steer that overall remuneration costs will be roughly level as we adjust the variable component. This slide just presents total and business expenses measured against average AUM, expressed in basis points, across what is now a 6.5-year span. That span takes in periods before and after the March 2020 listing. What matters most here is how steady business expenses have been while the business expanded and evolved. As I mentioned before, the modest rise seen here stems mostly from FX and inflationary pressures, though only marginally. Neither is within our control, but wherever possible, we will keep tightly managing the overall cost base in the future. To wrap up here, this is a graphical depiction of the absolute change in our adjusted operating profit before tax between H1 2022 and H1 2023. Our adjusted operating profit for H1 2022 stands at GBP 116.6 million. Management fees fell by GBP 2 million. Performance fees fell by GBP 2.6 million. Employee remuneration rose by GBP 1.5 million. It also rose by a further GBP 8.7 million. The foreign exchange loss in the prior period was reversed gains, with an impact of GBP 7.7 million. After adjusting for the small decline in other income items of GBP 0.6 million, adjusted operating profit for H1 2023 came to GBP 107.9 million, as shown earlier.
Kim McFarland
executiveOn my last slide, I'll walk through the Ninety One balance sheet and where capital stood at the close of September 2022. Qualifying capital for Ninety One fell to GBP 307.9 million. The estimated regulatory requirements likewise came down, to GBP 111.3 million. Consistent with our dividend policy, the board has declared an interim dividend of 6.5p. That represents a 6% decrease versus the 2021 interim dividend, matches the 7% drop in adjusted EPS to 9%, and works out to a payout ratio of just over 70%. Ninety One stays committed to the dividend policy it has stated. Once that dividend is paid, an estimated capital surplus of GBP 136.7 million will remain. That gives capital coverage of 223%, which the board considers prudent. In addition, at present there are still no plans to raise the count of shares in issue, and none to burden the group balance sheet with debt. Thank you. I'll hand back to Hendrik now.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveThank you, Kim. We're in difficult times, and we're staying careful about what lies ahead. Even so, Ninety One is a resilient company with a diversified set of offerings and a lengthy history of performing through both rising and falling markets. Despite today's market conditions, we see plenty of opportunities for growth over the long term. We'll keep our costs in check, yet we won't give up long-term growth and organizational stability merely to hit short-term targets. Our plan is to steer through this turbulence with confidence. Now is not the moment for distractions. More than ever, we'll concentrate on the investment work before us and strive to serve our clients' needs by remaining engaged with them and delivering what they expect from us. Execution is squarely our focus. Executing well requires a motivated, highly skilled team. The staff at Ninety One are ready to meet the challenge. Many thanks for your support. Before we take questions, I'd like to honor a colleague who passed away yesterday. André Roux, a Senior Fixed Income Portfolio Manager with us and formerly our Head of Fixed Income, died in London yesterday following 23 years with the firm.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveWe don’t know the reason, but he became ill over the weekend. I think a few moments of silence would be appropriate. Thank you very much. Questions. Hubert, you’re first out of the block. You always take a day longer than the other analysts, and then you write more. Your question’s first, so go for it.
Hubert Lam
analystThank you. Thank you, Hendrik. I have a few questions. First, regarding the operating margin: it came in at 33% for the first half. Kim, I believe you referenced certain headwinds for the second half related to costs and inflation effects. I'm just curious how we ought to land on guidance for operating margin in the second half. That would be helpful. Thanks. Hendrik, here's one for you. From my perspective, Asia saw what looked like fairly sizable outflows during the first half. That may stem from the one-off, I think, potentially the mandate losses. I'm just wondering whether you could speak to the dynamics in that region. And also whether that represents a setback to your objective of improving institutional growth in Asia. And finally, I know your remarks are rather cautious regarding the outlook. Does that apply both to the institutional side and to the advisor side? I noticed that your advisor flows were in fact fairly resilient. I'm just wondering whether you're also downbeat about that for the second half. Thanks.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveOn the operating margin question, I’ll hand that over to Kim — for us, operating margin is an outcome rather than an objective. Kim, perhaps you could share what you’re expecting at this point.
Kim McFarland
executiveSure. As you mentioned, we've already factored in that those costs are going to be present. Inflation is with us. Clearly, we'll see what effect the FX costs have — they hit us pretty hard during the first half of the year. Our guidance is that it will be… it won't rise; it'll come down slightly in the second half, though not by much. We don't expect it to be material. Again, that's since we aren't anticipating any significant cost emerging.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveThe approach we're taking is essentially to keep cost increases in check instead of eliminating capacity. That's because in quite a few of the markets where we operate, we see structural growth opportunities that we have no intention of walking away from. Look, our North America platform has our full investment. We won't be stepping back from it. We could be ten times bigger there compared with where we stand today. So that's why we'd be making adjustments at this point. That's the balance we're working to strike, and as a result we're not prepared to commit to a specific target. Regarding Asia, I'd say those were very particular accounts, and the situation was tied to them. So my view is we remain as committed to the regions where we operate and, in essence, to the large asset owners and asset platforms in those regions. Their behavior is similar, whether they happen to be in California or in China. In fact, they follow identical decision-making processes. As for where the pools of capital sit, we're genuinely optimistic about both the opportunity in Australia and, naturally, the Middle East, where money is flowing out. A lot of economies there are expanding. We don't take a negative view on that. Obviously, some of you might raise the same question you posed at year-end: what about China?
Hendrik du Toit
executiveI made it very clear. Until travel is free and, you know, there are no COVID issues, you know, or the COVID restrictions are lifted, going there serves no purpose other than supporting your current client base. And right now they conduct business remotely, but not in big volume, and fundings are slow. You know that will be the situation for the next reporting period. I think when it comes to the outlook, we haven't seen it. Remember, we work with the upper end of the, let's say retail market or advisor market. Our clients are wealth managers, sophisticated financial advisors. Not directly with the man in the street, and definitely not with the sort of small accounts that are quite heavily exposed to crypto right now. That's not our market. They have not panicked. They've acted very much like institutional investors. We are not sure when an economy goes into recession that people will not need their money and call on their savings, even if it is to look after family members. We haven't seen that. Nor have we seen fear. With big movements in markets that may still come. We haven't had the negative from that. We've actually had a fairly disciplined experience from our clients.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveWhat we saw was more repositioning by institutions, and I explained the reasons behind that. From an investment performance standpoint, I'd say we've done well enough to retain our clients. And I think it matters — if your goal is genuinely to bring in new business, your relevant strategies need to deliver exceptional performance. Whether it turns out to be a big year will hinge on that, and only time will tell as the next few months play out. If you achieve that and rank at the top end, you're among the firms they considered. I mean, we've picked up a handful of landmark mandates, but the funding has come in much more slowly than we'd anticipated. Exactly. Because asset owners have been slow to release the cash. You know, when we pitched, those were very big mandates. The money is beginning to trickle in, or they tell you, "Look, we'll take our time. Thank you. You've been selected." Fine, we have to wait. That's simply how it works. That's the outlook. Nobody has panic sold on us — which one could read either as, "Well, actually, we have a great client base," or as, "Well, there could be a risk further out in the flow picture," depending on how you feel in the morning.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveThanks. Over to David.
David McCann
analystMorning. David McCann here from Numis. On the first point: you cited LDI as one factor behind some of the outflows. When you split it by geography, though, Asia Pacific actually appears to have been the primary region, and that isn't really where LDI sits — there we're really talking about the UK. Perhaps you could add a little more detail on what exactly you were observing. My assumption is this isn't directly tied to LDI, since you don't run LDI. More that pension funds holding LDI were selling other assets, some of which you may have held. A bit more detail on that would help. You know, obviously in light of the quarter's outlook. Second question, again given the obvious quarter's outlook, and given that you said the foreseeable future — I mean, how long is the foreseeable future? On that, I mean, you don't come across as the kind of operator who would simply sit on his hands and do nothing. If conditions do remain, you know, tough for an extended period, I mean, what would you do differently? What, you know, would you double down on particular basis points of the business? Are there still areas that are, you know, looking better than other parts?
David McCann
analystJust be interested.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveDavid, you've paid close attention. You paid close attention to what was said. Now, that's where I'll begin. "The foreseeable future" was a deliberate choice. I didn't want to specify an exact timeframe, since I don't know when the Fed will be done. I don't know when politics will get better. I don't know how many countries are going to blow up between now and then. I don't know how big the crypto scam is going to be. So those are factors. When the illiquid guys begin to revalue their assets lower, I don't know what the level of selling is going to be. So all of those are, you know, variables that will have an impact on this. What we will do in this business is we're preparing the business and have been doing so. If you.. I wrote a staff note in, was it June? July. To people saying, "Look, guys, sort yourselves out. Let's get the costs under control. Otherwise, you know, we'll have to help you." We work. We're a firm of volunteers. Our people are sensible. They will look at the easily controllable costs. That's not the problem. I think we've got variable flex, as Kim has explained to you. We'll use it to the extent we have to.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveWhat becomes harder, should this drag on further, is figuring out what comes next. What comes next means putting real emphasis on the places where you can actually move the needle for the business, while pulling back from the ones that—and there aren't many of these in this business—don't matter as much. Taking a poorly run company through a downturn is quite simple, since all you have to do is slash a pile of unnecessary expenses. There isn't much of that here for us to cut. What we're able to do is concentrate our resources, get sharper about it, and in doing so narrow our spread of activities over time, saying, "We'll handle a smaller number of things more effectively, with greater focus, and then emerge with a stronger rebound afterward." That's being talked through right now. I won't get into the specifics. When the year ends, assuming conditions continue, you'll hear a clearer statement of it. There's a lot of active discussion on this. I'll return to my earlier point. Above all else, we have a client base worth GBP 132 billion that we must take care of. They pay fees. They pay good fees. Our duty to them comes first. What we won't do is simply cut to hit a short-term target.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveWe have to think about organizational viability, since if you don't, you won't draw in and retain talent. I believe there's actually a substantial opportunity here to both tighten up in certain areas and actually ramp up the aggression on some growth opportunities and make sure we capture that, while others are looking inward. That's probably what's going to happen in and throughout 2023. So the real answer, David, is that you can then write either a positive or a negative report in 2024 saying, "These guys did it, they're in really good shape," or, "Actually, they were just too passive and missed a few tricks." But the typical risk in these downturns, and we've seen that many times, is that when you pull in your horns too much, and then you don't capture the opportunity others leave on the table. Actually, there are quite a few others around us who are busy. I had a line in there, if you listen carefully, about distractions. This is no time for distractions, so investment bankers aren't going to make a huge amount of fees out of us doing all sorts of deals, particularly chasing the marginal growth opportunities that may look compelling, but will not move the dial. will eat up our capital, eat up our bandwidth, and eat up our valuable ability of resources, which should be serving clients.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveAt one point I mentioned a remark to the board recently, and they asked me, "Well, what about, you know, the things you do?" My reply was, "Well, actually, you know what? It'll be. It's quite. If you happen to be one of the Last of the Mohicans — to borrow the words of Sir Evelyn, the late Sir Evelyn de Rothschild, who actually kept a very good investment bank business going despite lots of corporate activity — you can do pretty well." That, I think, is more or less our strategy. Yeah. LDI. Okay. LDI, I just put in to. First of all, it's over the. During the latter part of the six months, LDI really turned into an issue. Over the last roughly month and a half of the reporting period, you began to feel the stresses. I can't recall when that mini budget was. It wasn't that long ago. It feels like a world ago. Quite clearly we witnessed some panic selling, and there will be additional panic selling or additional de-risking taking place. At first, it was panic to meet derivative requirements. Now, if you take the 3.2 minus the Asia number, there's still a reasonable number in there. We don't have a huge UK institutional business, but we saw some flows which, quite frankly, were driven by motivations other than asset allocation.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveAs far as I'm aware — and some of you probably have better information; I notice several major banks represented here who would know more — there are still sizable order books out there in need of rebalancing. Those institutions have satisfied their short-term liquidity needs, but they might not yet be in the condition they'd like to be. I also couldn't help including this point, because at the outset we were quite explicit: we don't enter a 10 basis point business where reputational exposure equals the worth of everything we do. We aren't the ones executing somebody else's strategy — that's a job for banks. Our role is active asset management, and on the risk management front we feel considerably more comfortable than we would being tied up in that sort of activity. Perhaps that's another reason I brought up the LDI topic. That market holds zero interest for us. Clients who've gone the LDI route will still receive service from us, but their dealings will be with the providers already in place, and I anticipate a great many court cases and disputes emerging from what happened in September. We won't be involved in any of that.
Rahim Karim
analystMorning. This is Rahim Karim at Investec. I have three questions, if I can. First, some guidance on performance fees, perhaps, since I think they held up fairly well in the half. A question about the Africa business. Flows, as you pointed out, were especially robust. Could you give us a sense of what drove that? And obviously there are some exchange-related regulatory changes under way. Could you help us understand how that unfolds and whether it had an impact during the period?
Hendrik du Toit
executiveRegarding the JSE changes?
Rahim Karim
analystYeah. And the third thing was really just to get a feel for whether competitors are behaving irrationally as they try to defend flows on the pricing side, and what you might be seeing there.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveI'll take that. Since we don't really have the answer, I'll have Kim respond to the performance fee question, but we can address it.
Kim McFarland
executiveSure. So on the performance fees, I think the main takeaway is that they came in above what a lot of consensus was expecting. If you recall, back in May we said performance fees would only come from relative performance and not absolute, since there wasn't any absolute. It's a bit higher. Those numbers included a one-off performance fee. So our guidance is: don't take that figure, multiply it by two, and assume that's what the performance fee will be for the year. It'll actually — there will be performance fees in the second half, but they'll be lower than what you saw in the first half.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveIt's worth pointing out that when a fee crystallizes, your alpha can look strong at that moment, and then a month or two down the road, the alpha in hindsight doesn't look quite as strong. This instance came in as a modest positive surprise. But I want you to be aware that on the absolute side, even in a flat market, we might pick up some of the absolute or cash plus benchmarks beginning to deliver again. Keep in mind, all of those were off the table. That's part of the reason why.
Kim McFarland
executiveWe’d lean toward the cautious end on that.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveWhy Kim warned — no, no, what I'm saying is that there are two sides to this. During this period, it remains low, but what hasn't kicked in yet is the absolute part. You know, sooner or later, those are going to return. The performance fee is nowhere near large enough. That's the first point. Regarding the Africa business, the reason it has performed well, especially in South Africa, is that the central bank there was ahead of the curve. They have long been accustomed to the sort of inflation that has us panicking in the U.K. For years, they've lived with it. There wasn't this worldwide panic. They're familiar with real interest rates. They've had them the whole time. Assets were priced to reflect that, and so in the savings market there wasn't the type of panic — I wouldn't call it panic — but the type of shock we witnessed in the developed world. Nor was it a frontier market where you faced major problems with the balance of payments or the capital account. It was simply that commodities were performing quite well. I mean, if you compare the South African budget with, say, the U.K. budget, you'll notice the difference, despite other issues in that society that might obscure your view.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveThe financial ecosystem is robust, healthy and stable. That's the reason we're a leader in that space, and so this is definitely not a bull market. It's a marginal positive flow. The JSE has been through major business changes, you know, especially when it comes to listed companies. Our conversation with them is still ongoing. We hope we can align with the rest of the world rather than adding small differences. For instance, one of our big asks is that we all simply go to the ISSB, you know, and that we don't make our sustainability reporting complicated. Right now, exchanges and regulators are all thinking individually, you know. Perhaps we should begin thinking together. Maybe it's something for the G20. Currently, one of the cost areas in our industry is that the world is becoming multipolar. It's not only Brexit. It's everywhere around the globe, where regional regulators do their own thing. I mean, even in the U.S., you now have to understand the state you operate in, not just the federal system, to know exactly what to do. There's a burden on cross-border businesses such as ours, and it's probably underestimated.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveI believe that likely gets at what was behind your question, Rahim. Even so, our ties with the Johannesburg Stock Exchange are very solid, and our engagement there is good. You know, we are a major participant in that market. We feel fairly confident about however matters develop. What we are not seeing is a booming expansion in the savings market compared with the rest of the world. In fact, we likely see — we likely look toward growth in the Americas or Asia. That covered all your questions, right?
Rahim Karim
analystRegarding pricing relative to competitors.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveOh, pricing. Kim, you're part of the pricing forum. What did you want to ask?
Rahim Karim
analystJust to check whether competitors had been acting in any irrational way.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveSome irrational players exist in the market. You’ve got folks out there saying it’s all about pricing to win business.
Kim McFarland
executiveRight.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveWe've witnessed that. If it comes to that, we step away. What we do, though, is make adjustments to keep things consistent. Put differently, genuinely strong relationships that endure and don't just rent your capacity for 3 years merit a superior price compared with those who merely rent your capacity for a limit. It isn't only about price; it's about the quality of price. We've observed folks prepared to genuinely work at extremely low fees. Our response is to walk away, and typically, the sort of clients we serve — and I've made that point repeatedly. I've stated it before. Since the shift toward passive has been so large, they actually have larger fee budgets, not smaller ones. Most of them leave the room having just dealt with private markets operators whose fees are multiples above ours, so our prices don't shock them much. Things really have moved on. They examine the quality. They want to grasp what you'll deliver for that price. Without question, everyone in the investment management business is doing more for the same fee. That's likely the larger erosion rather than the fee level itself. You must do more. You must be better. Yeah.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveRight. Right. That’s the reason our costs are less elastic, or less flexible on the downside—excluding variable remuneration—than you might expect. Because the technology requirements our clients have, and how immediately they want to look into our portfolios, are much higher than in years gone by. Yeah. Great. Any more disagreements? Eva? Any questions from outside? Where are the questions coming from? There are none. Are they going to give us hard questions in one-on-one meetings, then? If anyone wants to ask questions, those on the webcast, please type it into the chat function. Or phone us on our mobile if the chat function doesn’t work. We’ve got that here. I think just one last point to the sell-side guys here in London. A lot of our leading sell-side people. I think it’s really important you understand this bet we have in our business. We think at our scale, the long only business is a large market for us and to an extent related and ancillary alternatives business, which in our case is credit. Okay? We want to build a proper positioning in credit in a world where duration is not necessarily gonna be your friend. Okay? We think at our scale of $150 billion or GBP 130 billion, we have ample opportunities if we’re good enough.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveIf you don't put capital to work, accept somewhat higher volatility in the revenue stream or the earnings stream, stay the course, and build scale — as Kim demonstrated with her chart of cost basis points over time — that is a rational and sensible approach, and it makes you a magnet for talent. I didn't bring this up earlier, but if you're in London you'll be aware that we brought in two very significant, very, very well-known investors, and they came because they wanted to be here, not because we went out with, you know, crazy recruitment pitches. If we build that base carefully and solidly, and we return to the good times, this business will perform as well as it ever has. We aren't part of this very negative narrative about the industry. This has always been an industry where the losers were taken out. It has always been an industry where the winners won. You simply have to give it a go. The optionality, or the odds, are stacked so heavily toward trying that we believe it's worth the attempt, rather than becoming capital heavy by purchasing all kinds of businesses in ancillary areas hoping we can run them better than others.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveThat, I believe, is the model's crucial element. What? What makes us feel at ease with it? Since we have incorporated that underlying diversity across our revenue streams, we are able to weather Regional Hiccups, exactly as we have recently witnessed in the UK, or in certain regions where your mandate might fail to compete and perform well. That is the message I want to leave you with at this half year stage. We will discuss the details at the full year, and I am certain you will send plenty of questions our way. Please do. Thank you very much.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Ninety One Group transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Ninety One Group earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Ninety One Group or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.