Ninety One Group (N91) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

May 17, 2023

London Stock Exchange GB Financials Capital Markets earnings 69 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#1

Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. Welcome to the presentation of Ninety One's results for the 2023 financial year. Thank you to our clients, shareholders, regulators and the people of Ninety One for your support and commitment over the last year. This was not an easy year. I will start with the business review. And including a summary of the results, then Kim, our Finance Director, will present the financial review. I will then cover growth opportunities and provide an outlook for the business before taking questions. <<operator_script>> Here are the key messages. This was a solid financial support -- performance supported by cost discipline. Globally, we faced headwinds from interest rates rising at the fastest pace in 40 years, compounded by geopolitical upheaval. The result was obviously a risk-off environment. In the U.K., we experienced indiscriminate sell-off of risk assets because of the stress in the LDI market. In the final quarter, to top it all, we saw a range of bank failures in the U.S. And for Ninety One, this has been a period of extensive client engagement. While risk aversion among asset owners over the reporting period muted demand the quality of engagement gives me confidence for the future.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#2

Investment performance is what truly drives our value over the long term, and on that front we've delivered. The approach we follow hasn't changed, and it fits with the structural opportunities over the long run that we identify in today's market. Our staff are dedicated and driven, and the share of the company held collectively by our people keeps rising. Creating value over the long term through investments that succeed and client relationships that last is the business we're in. As always, I'll remind you about our long-term track record. Through the years, we've demonstrated that we can invest well, satisfy what clients want and need, bring in assets and expand revenues. Ninety One is a resilient business, with a product offering that's relevant for the future. Reminding you of the business model also matters. First, we are a specialist active investment manager. Ours is a capital-light, cash-generative operation. Capital isn't what sits at our center — people are. What we run is an organic, client-focused, results-driven business. In the world of today, we must be technology-enabled as well. During the last year, we concluded that this needed to be stated explicitly in how we describe our business model, since tech is evolving more quickly than at any point before. The scope for efficiencies in our business is enormous. That doesn't mean overambitious tech budgets. What we intend is simply to deploy, in the most disciplined and coordinated manner, the tools that are most relevant and most readily available.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#3

Ninety One stands apart clearly from rivals in its field. This is a company that expanded organically, moving from an emerging market base into the mainstream of global investment management. Our 32-year history gives us confidence — a record marked by resilience, originality and growth, all powered by an owner culture. Our emerging market heritage makes us proud, since it reflects not just where we came from but also what the world's future holds. Lastly, we think our client reach beats that of other midsized active specialist managers, thanks to sustained investment in our regional client group presence. This is a purpose-led organization — something you already know. By becoming a better firm, investing better and building a better world, we can fulfill our purpose of investing for a better tomorrow. Now, on to the numbers. Assets under management were GBP 129.3 billion as of 31 March 2023, a 10% decline versus the prior year. Average assets under management across the financial year came to GBP 134.9 billion, down 3% on the prior year. Net outflows picked up speed in the second half of the financial year, producing a full year figure of GBP 10.6 billion. That outcome disappoints us. In our view, the pickup in the final quarter was client specific, driven by risk aversion stemming from the volatility of the preceding period.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#4

Client dissatisfaction with Ninety One played no part in this — market conditions were responsible. Investment performance improved relative to the prior year and the trend kept getting better: firm-wide outperformance came in at 57% on a 1-year basis and at 71% over 3 years. Adjusted operating profit dropped 10%, landing at GBP 206.7 billion. Even so, through cost control we achieved an adjusted operating profit margin of 32.7%. Basic earnings per share came in 19% lower. Much of that decrease is down to the prior year's gain on the silica sale plus the share scheme net credit. Kim will go through the financial results in greater depth, but I'll simply note a 10% decline in adjusted earnings per share, which mirrors how the business performed underneath. Conditions in both the market and the business were exceptionally tough. Sentiment was firmly risk off throughout the period, and the flow takers were money markets, developed market fixed income, alternatives and solutions. None of those are areas where we operate. To put this result in context, we can't overlook how dramatically interest rates rose in reaction to a steep jump in the inflation rate. There are many reasons behind that inflation.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#5

Interest rates climbing away from their historic lows has brought to the surface weaknesses in the system that accumulated during the period of inexpensive money we saw following the 2008 financial crisis. In the U.K., the LDI squeeze hit our flows directly, since clients rushed to obtain liquidity—frequently selling risk assets with little discrimination—in order to satisfy margin requirements. Long-term interest rates jumping sharply additionally generated fresh demand for liability matching, which contracted the risk pool even more. The U.S. bank failures that began in the year's final quarter stemmed from business models that could not withstand interest rates rising so quickly. Disruptive geopolitics, among them Russia's war in the Ukraine, has pushed risk appetite for emerging markets down further. The regulatory burden has kept growing. It would be reasonable not to anticipate a straightforward extrapolation of these factors into the year ahead and the years beyond. Though still challenging, we will be addressing the specific effect of higher interest rates on each investee company or issuer we hold. Bottom-up analysis will truly be what counts. This ought to be a stronger market for active managers. Our belief persists in the resilience of our business and in how sound our business model is over the long term.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#6

Following several years of asset growth, we saw a first-half decline, caused by GBP 3.2 billion in outflows along with a market drawdown of GBP 8.4 billion. During the second half, net outflows sped up even as asset prices recovered modestly, which brought the year-end figure to GBP 129.3 billion. Thus, most of the full-year outflows came in that second half. Our exposure to client concentration is limited, since no single client accounts for over 5% of assets under management or over 4% of revenues. Even so, 3 clients were responsible for over half of the net outflows reported this year. Their wish to derisk or reallocate drove this. It matters to note that those clients are still with us. We have likewise observed significant currency and market shifts. If we had presented this picture in U.S. dollars over the last year, you would have seen assets under management rise by over $20 billion in the second half and finish above where they stood at half year-end. Obviously, we do not report in dollars, which sets us apart from many peers. The point is simply to show how foreign exchange affects our business. We are working hard to reverse the accelerating outflow trend recorded here and, indeed, to turn it into inflows.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#7

A lot of that came from equities. Some of it was LDI, some involved tactical reallocation by clients, and some tied to falling demand for U.K. equities, which is structural. This outweighed the inflows recorded during the year in global quality, sustainable and natural resources equity strategies. Emerging market fixed income was classified as a risk asset, and net outflows came mostly from sovereign strategies. Just as in the prior year, net inflows at our South African platform business stayed positive. We kept inflows positive in South Africa through the first half. Yet by the end of the financial year, every one of our client groups was negative. To sum up, Asia Pacific net outflows stemmed from a small number of one-offs caused by client reallocations. Europe and the Americas Client Group told a similar story. Risk exposure was reduced, though there were no client terminations. U.K. net outflow resulted mainly from the fallout in LDI, where risk assets were sold off to meet margin calls, along with further derisking of defined benefit plans. In the Africa Client Group, inflows into the fund platform were more than offset by larger net outflows from fixed income strategies.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#8

The outflows I’ve been describing were largely concentrated in the institutional segment. During the year, institutional clients made significant withdrawals, and every one of them was drawing on liquid investments to raise cash, given their substantial exposure to less liquid asset classes like real estate, private equity, and private credit. The adviser market, by contrast, has held up much more steadily. Clients in that channel generally stay put when volatility hits. Long-term performance continues to be strong and competitive. Investment performance came in better over the year. That puts us in a fairly good position to win new business once markets recover. Over the course of the year, we also bolstered our CIO office along with the technology and quantitative resources available to our investment teams. Mutual fund investment performance turned around, and that shift deserves a mention. At Ninety One, our guiding principle in this area is sustainability with substance. We have been making the case for a transition that is inclusive and fair. And at this year’s IMF and World Bank Spring meetings in Washington, the tone shifted. There is now considerable momentum behind the idea of transition finance. We are working on developing frameworks that support decarbonization, and we are helping heavy emitting companies make the transition.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#9

We're broadening the set of sustainable strategies we offer, anticipating that demand will grow for structural reasons. In the end, we also need to put our own transition plan into practice and concentrate on how we operate the business and our scope 1, 2 and 3 emissions. It isn't only portfolio companies that we expect to do this. We ourselves must do it. At this point, let us remind you of the targets in our transition plan and of the progress we've made. This is a process, not an event. And progress is being made. By 2030, a greater number of our investee companies are developing science-based transition pathways. Our scope 1, 2 and 3 emissions continue to come down. In the last 15 months, two new sustainability strategies have been launched, with more in the pipeline. And finally, engagement continues with multiple stakeholders on a transition that is fair and inclusive. We are on track to meet our targets of 50% to finance emissions with SBTi aligned transition pathways, a 46% reduction in scope 1, 2 and 3, Category B of Scope 3 reported emissions by 2030, while remaining active advocates for better disclosure and more ambitious climate finance solutions. What matters most is the culture and, of course, the mindset of our people.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#10

This is fundamentally a people-focused business. Our staff are dedicated and driven, and they've put in tremendous effort throughout the past year. We've kept a firm grip on managing headcount. That said, clients want more while paying the same fee, and that keeps pushing headcount figures upward. What we demonstrated this year is that our variable costs genuinely do vary. Kim will walk through those figures shortly. We're intentionally constructing a business that spans generations, and we keep standing behind our people during these difficult times. Last, we've lifted employee ownership once more — it now stands at 28% and is aligned with what's in the interest of both our staff and our shareholders. I'll pass it to Kim now for the financial review, and afterward I'll address our growth opportunities and outlook. Kim?

Kim McFarland

executive
#11

Thank you, Hendrik, and good morning, everyone. Following a difficult year, I'm glad to share a strong set of financial results for the year ended 31 March 2023, and here are the key points: adjusted operating revenue fell 5% to GBP 633 million; adjusted operating expenses were down 2% to GBP 426.1 million. That gave us an adjusted operating profit of GBP 206.9 million, which is a 10% decline. I'll cover these numbers in greater detail over the coming slides. Then, taking into account adjusted net interest income for the share scheme, last year's net expense or credit, and the one-off gain on the disposal of silica in FY '22, Ninety One profit before tax dropped 20% to GBP 212.6 million. The effective tax rate for the period came in at 23%, slightly lower than the prior year's 23.1%. Those factors meant profit after tax fell 20% to GBP 163.8 million. So there are a couple of points I want to flag for you. Interest expense on our lease liabilities for office premises was GBP 3.6 million for FY '23, as reported within adjusted operating expenses. The share scheme net credit from the prior year has reversed our share scheme expense.

Kim McFarland

executive
#12

That comes from lower variable remuneration and, as a result, fewer deferred bonuses being granted in shares during the current year. Our adjusted operating profit margin went from 34.7% down to 32.7%. Adjusted EPS is down 10%, matching the decline in adjusted operating profit. This slide gives more detail on adjusted operating revenue, which fell to GBP 633 million. Management fees were down 4% at GBP 607.7 million, mainly because average AUM dropped from GBP 138.6 billion to GBP 134.9 billion, a 3% decline. That fall in average AUM, together with the average fee rate slipping to 45 bps from 45.7 bps, drives the lower management fees. At the midyear the rate stood at 45.2 bps, which shows a slower rate of decline. Once again, the cause is a shift in the mix of strategies our clients hold. Even so, fee pressure does persist, and as the client mix shifts, our guidance for the year ahead is cautious, pointing to a marginal decline. Performance fees keep coming down from the high levels of FY '21 and '22, though they remain a positive contribution at GBP 19.4 million.

Kim McFarland

executive
#13

A big part of that came from relative benchmark investment strategies beating expectations during the period. Once again, we don't expect any material change on that front over the coming year. Profit from associates shares rose versus the prior year and contributed a little to adjusted operating revenues. Same with the addition of other income of GBP 4.5 million, a blend of FX gains on earnings recognition plus operating interest. On the next slide you'll see how adjusted operating expenses build up year-on-year, and I want to actually spend a bit of time on this one. Back at the half year, we were alert to the uptick in operating expenses. And as was mentioned in November, we went through costs to identify where cuts could be achieved. Beginning with remuneration, down by $18.9 million, or 6%. That now represents 65% of our cost base. Fixed remuneration, we show, is up by $11.2 million, with just under half of that tied to inflation-based increases. The remainder reflects ongoing investment in our teams, including headcount growth averaging 2%. But importantly, variable remuneration declined in line with the drop in operating profit, by GBP 30.1 million.

Kim McFarland

executive
#14

We have consistently been transparent, both inside the company and outside, and it is now demonstrated here that this element is variable and will move in line with how the business performs. More than 50% of employee remuneration continues to be variable, and as a result the compensation ratio fell to 43.5%. Turning now to business expenses. These rose by GBP 11.5 million, or 8%. That figure is above the level we would have liked, yet it is below where we stood at the half year. Business costs had gone up by 13%. However, every category of our costs has risen apart from promotional. We have examined this at -- and at a high level, the increase can be broken down as follows: an inflation-linked effect of GBP 5.8 million, covering those costs genuinely affected by inflation; an FX-linked effect of GBP 3.5 million, which is chiefly expenses denominated in USD; one-off costs during the year of GBP 3.5 million; travel costs returning to normal after the COVID impact of GBP 3.1 million; and lastly, what we would consider cost management or reductions of GBP 4.4 million. The year-on-year breakdown of these expenses stayed fairly similar to the year -- to last year, apart from travel, which clearly went up, and promotion, which went down. The biggest expense item here continues to be client and retail fund administration.

Kim McFarland

executive
#15

Going forward, we anticipate that business expenses will rise due to inflationary pressure, and I’d note that nothing material is planned for the year ahead. So the slide presents business expenses and total expenses as a percentage of average AUM in basis points across a 7-year period, covering both before and after the March 2020 listing. And the one key point here is how consistent total expenses have been in basis points of AUM as the business has grown and developed. We’ve tried to keep cost discipline and achieve some operating leverage, but that has been challenged, as shown on the previous slide. While fixing the rebar remuneration, total expenses have risen only marginally relative to AUM, but importantly they show a downward trend from the high seen back in 2017. However, business expenses in basis points of average AUM have returned to levels last seen around 2020 because of the impact of inflation and FX on the GBP cost base. So to summarize here. This is an analysis of the absolute movement in adjusted operating profit from FY '22 to '23. Adjusted operating profit for FY '22 was GBP 230.4 million. Management fees have decreased by GBP 25.1 million.

Kim McFarland

executive
#16

Performance fees went down by GBP 11.7 million. Other income items, including FX gains and operating interest, rose by GBP 5.9 million. Of particular note, employee remuneration fell by GBP 18.9 million. And as we covered earlier, business expenses were up by GBP 11.5 million, which brought adjusted operating profit to GBP 206.9 million for FY '23. My last slide then gives a summary of the Ninety One capital position as at the close of the financial year. At the end of the financial year, Ninety One's qualifying capital stood at GBP 314.6 million. Consistent with our dividend policy, the Board has recommended a final dividend of 6.7p, which brings the full year dividend to 13.2p per share — a decline of 10%, matching the fall in adjusted earnings per share. Once this dividend is paid, the estimated capital surplus will be GBP 137.2 million, and that produces capital coverage of 219%, a slight increase on the prior year and consistent with our conservative approach to retaining capital while distributing less than 100% of after-tax profits. That is still above the 200% coverage we have been targeting, and given the current market environment, we are comfortable holding this position. Any intention to extend our dividend payout ratio in future years will be discussed further with the Board.

Kim McFarland

executive
#17

Consistent with these proposals and the capital buffer, our commitment to the capital-light model is as strong as it has ever been. In addition, as of right now, we have no intention of raising the share count in H2, and we won't burden the balance sheet with debt of any kind. Thank you. I'll hand things back to Hendrik now.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#18

Thank you, Kim. <<operator_script>> Even with the climate we're in right now, we see meaningful opportunities for growth over the long term in global and international equities, emerging market equities, emerging market fixed income, specialist credit and sustainability-related strategies. So with those in mind, let's turn to how they can drive growth. Emerging market equities, then, have been lagging for a while now. And believe me, at some point that is going to change. Emerging market credit is a growing asset class that is underappreciated. Substantially -- sorry, and naturally, emerging market credit has in fact performed excellently, something that has gone unnoticed. Sustainability and impact investing will continue to grow. This is structural and will stay with us over the long term. As part of how we continually assess opportunities, we have in fact carried out detailed work on the addressable market. Our true opportunity comfortably exceeds 15% of the entire global market for professionally managed assets, which Mackenzie has estimated at roughly USD 120 trillion. But to prove the point, we have pinpointed specific categories in which we are already active, to demonstrate that we have genuine plans and not merely dreams for growth. We conservatively estimate an immediately addressable market of approximately GBP 7 trillion for the investment competencies summarized on the previous slide.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#19

These capabilities have grown organically within our firm over a long stretch of years. Across them, our market share varies widely — anywhere from negligible to roughly 2.5%, slightly above 2.5%. There's plenty of room for expansion. In each of these segments, we hold credible track records and market positions that are well recognized. To sum up, provided we remain focused, communicate our differentiation effectively and produce competitive long-term results, substantial growth is achievable. For instance, within the global large-cap equity universe, our global franchise strategy ranked third for attracting net flows. That figure comes from investment. During recent years, we've demonstrated that growth is possible in particular categories when opportunity exists. Given proper application, track record and time in the market, we can build several scalable global leadership positions across large categories. That could contribute substantially to shareholder value in the years ahead. Strategy launches and closures in recent years have numbered in the single digits, which reflects a careful balance of innovation against product discipline. Even this year, our newest strategies once again brought in positive net inflows. That validates continued innovation. In summary, the year has been tough. Market conditions have offered little support.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#20

That said, over the long term we possess a relevant skill set. We're competitive, and our investment performance is solid. Our client relationships run deep, and thanks to our scale we have superior client reach. Our team is motivated and committed. So our foundations are solid; our multi-decade track record, along with our culture, team spirit and will to win, give us confidence for the future. Looking ahead in the current financial year, conditions have stabilized. We haven't yet seen a decisive change in risk appetite among clients, though among certain asset owners we've seen signs of that. Our working assumption is that market conditions will remain challenging. We'll focus on execution and avoid distractions. We're confident in our ability to deliver in the long term and give our shareholders the results they deserve. Let me end with a quote from Marcus Aurelius. "you have the power over your mind not outside events. Realize this, and you will find strength." Thank you for listening, and now we can -- we are open for questions. Lots of hands. Right. Kim, let's go stand here. Where are our pens? To make sure we can take that. So we're starting with Hubert in front.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#21

Hubert, I've got 3 questions for you, I believe — 3.

Hubert Lam

analyst
#22

Yeah, 3.

Kim McFarland

executive
#23

I’ll make a note of that this time.

Hubert Lam

analyst
#24

This is Hubert Lam from Bank of America, and I have 3 questions. First, I found that slide about the growth opportunities you mentioned quite interesting. It sounds like you believe the capabilities you have today are still enough to grow in those areas. So how would you weigh that against diversifying into other areas, particularly given that you saw outflows during the last 6 months? How are you thinking about staying the course versus diversification? That's my first question. My second question also concerns flows over the -- how do you expect flows to look over the next, I suppose, 6 to 12 months? Do you feel the worst has passed, given that you had some one-off impacts in LDI during the last quarter and concentration around 3 clients? Would you say things will improve relative to prior quarters? And the third question is for Kim, if there's a chance. On the operating margin, it came in at 32.7%. Given that last year was a tough market, would you view that as the floor we should expect going forward?

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#25

Thank you, Hubert. I believe that first question of yours really is the question. So there's this enormous depression hanging over active investment management. And we've been through a risk-on period in investment management. Why? Because flows were absent or extremely limited, and clients — asset owners — have been diversifying very heavily into illiquid spaces, correct? As a result, liquid assets served as the banker — we were the bankers for the remainder of the industry, for private equity and others. That's already baked in, because you're going to witness some accidents as leverage begins to bite and people come to realize that you actually have to mark to true market, and people come to realize they need liquidity from time to time. So a shift is coming. I think that structural shift is beginning. It won't happen this year, because the money is tied up, and new flows have to be generated, and jobs have to be created. So I think a rebalancing in thinking is coming. Our view as a firm is that we will not chase the markets that captured the flows yesterday and the year — decades before now at great expense. What are we doing?

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#26

In public equities and emerging market debt, we're building out sustainability and broadening our lineup of sustainability-related offerings, and we're developing our credit platforms, since we already have quite strong emerging market credit platforms that will extend into private as well as public markets. There's also an overlap among sustainability, emerging markets and infrastructure financing, and that is going to be a sweet spot in the global economy for a long time. We're positioning ourselves for that. But within our mainstream categories, we think the bar keeps rising. With a long track record, with longevity and with performance, you'll capture the flows, because the market will grow more discriminatory. That's what we're aiming for. So the trade-off for a capital-light business is that you must be capital-light and nonvolatile, and we're a bit more volatile. Yet if we deliver, and if we have the human potential and the technology to deliver and to write, the gains are substantial. So I'd say our strategy carries a huge amount of option value. If we don't execute well enough, we won't realize that option value, and the bet a shareholder makes is whether they believe this team, with its 30-year track record, its culture and its human component, has the ability to capture it.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#27

But we're keeping our attention on our lane, since we believe that focus is actually — and really, we're working to point the business more toward clear growth opportunities. Even though other parts of our business exist, which might make money in the near term, like multi-asset and others. But we aren't leaning into the solution business or into the winners of the last decade or 2, because we think you'll just get whiplashed. If you head there now, unless you have very deep pockets, suspend. So that's question one. And I think it's a really important question, because that identifies and defines as dialogue. Let me just — I see David McCann looking at me. Let me just say the difference between us and a small single product boutique. Now that's another great position to be in. I sit there with a single product is that we have reached to large asset owners wherever they are. And what we're really in the business with is building 100-year relationships with 100 large asset openers and asset platforms. And over time, making their life easier, not all the time, sometimes having low allocations for them, sometimes higher allocation. So that's the strategic essence.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#28

Regarding the flow in the coming year, Hubert, you know we never make predictions. But what I can tell you is I think the one offs, the sort of extreme — unless, of course, the U.S. default, okay? I can't guarantee. I think no one in the room can even imagine what that will do to the world. But unless that happens and unless there's a nuclear war, I guess we've reached the stage where extreme behavior and risk adjustment or risk reshaping of risk in portfolio has happened and normal allocations will resume, which will be better for us. The experience we've had since the beginning of the year was that of a more stable market. Although, very importantly, clients take longer to make decisions. They postpone them. They've also had — because of the impact of last year on their financials, there are also some management changes in our clients and asset owners, which slows down decision-making process. So I'm not predicting back to Goldilocks world in 3 months, understand that. But I do feel there's a much more stable and sort of sensible allocation process as opposed to a reaction to extreme market events. Interest rates went up 10x last year in the U.S.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#29

Consider the scale of that effect — it's huge. It will flow through, yet that shock has already been absorbed at this point. So my take is, if conditions turn out as poor as they did this year, then next year I'll end up looking foolish, and I won't even bother appearing here. But I honestly lack certainty, though what we're seeing points toward a steadier, normal market. Kim, would you take the final question?

Kim McFarland

executive
#30

On that final question—obviously, operating margin gets shaped by both the top line and the bottom line. Hendrik addressed the top line, meaning your flows, and holding on the fee rates, which, as I noted, is not showing the kind of drop off we saw previously, and that has been a full bit. On the cost side, a big chunk of those costs remains fixed. Yes, we've demonstrated we can fix that variable piece. We talked about it last year, and we've done it. We haven't had any mass exiters walk out. There hasn't been some kind of natural reaction in the business as a result. We basically processed at internally very early on, both internally, as I said, and we mentioned externally. So we will still be challenged from an operating margin point of view with a fixed cost base. If we're going to hit the game with inflationary pressure, we're looking—we've analyzed that quite closely. We know where these figures are. And again, with the sort of the USD base, but we're not seeing any material. We have some one-offs. We had the last of the COVID sort of travel costs coming through, which hit us.

Kim McFarland

executive
#31

We don't set a specific goal for it. Our preference is to hold it roughly in the 30% to 35% range. Right now we're right in the middle at 32.7%, and that's a level we feel comfortable with.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#32

Could I add a point here? In a market this negative, we intend to be on the front foot. So we're not optimizing toward margins and earnings targets — there are opportunities out there in the world. At this moment, there is loose talent at a number of organizations. There are regions generating a lot of money right now. For us to be entirely conservative and pass that up, and not build growth for the next 5 years, would be a mistake. So we will take bets, we will put money into our business, and we will in fact invest as if we own 100% of the business. I know we own only 1/3, and a lot of people own the rest. But we think like owners of 100% of the business. And that means from time to time, you don't actually play to the next quarter's dividend. Just yesterday, I had a lengthy conversation with the Board about this, laying out for them what they can expect. And so we'll be opportunistic, but only in the areas we've identified as growth opportunities. Not — you won't see us tomorrow starting, say, a life sciences business out of nothing, where we have no credibility — that you won't see.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#33

So there isn’t a lot we can promise. Who’s up next? We’ve got these folks over here, and David is on the right.

Paul Bryant

analyst
#34

Hendrik, this is Paul Bryant from Equity Development. I have two questions about the sustainability investing opportunity. The first: transition finance plays a fairly notable role in the opportunity you describe. Discussion of it appears to be more prominent in South Africa and the U.S. than in Europe. I'm curious whether that carries over to your client base — is there a difference in interest in that area across geographies?

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#35

That's a very sharp observation, and a very good question, because I've hinted at it there without saying too much. And in — unlike banking, when you launch a new idea, you go to clients and they respond quickly. If you're an investment banker, you can get it done, go to a corporate, you do a deal. In the asset management world, where we have a heavily intermediated channel — consultants, boards of trustees, advisers — it takes a long time for new categories to take off. Now we know how successful Brookfield and Macquarie have been on the transition equity side. But much of that involved dealing with existing asset owners who were already in that space and wanting to go. In the more traditional end of the market, there's been a long conversation, which initially started with decarbonize all portfolios and then pretend the world is going to be better. Well, we now realize we've actually got to take the businesses we have and make them decarbonize. That would need finance, both equity and debt. That is the opportunity we're talking about. That GBP 4 trillion a year, of which some has to go to the emerging markets. Those are massive, massive numbers.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#36

When it comes to returns at the end, if you do it, there's massive destruction if you don't. That transition finance space is something you'll be hearing more about as we head toward COP — you'll hear it turn into a normal, mainstream talking point. The banks have already made their move. You'll notice they say large chunks of their balance sheet are part of that, but their balance sheet isn't big enough. It's the $120 trillion I showed you that has to take part. That's the unquantified growth opportunity we've been chasing for, I'd say, the last 5 years without revealing much detail. We're hoping to begin showing you some real results, but the investment in education has been enormous. The meeting, the potential regulatory and market risks that come with being linked to green washing — those are enormous. You have to be extremely careful. So we've truly been laying deep foundations for something I'm quite excited about, but I have no proof points to say it's beginning to happen. Sensis transition finance is going to become a very important part of finance. Ninety One will be a player in that at scale, but you have to wait.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#37

I can't make any guarantees, and I can't promise anything over the short term. What I do know is that it's going to happen. The question is who will capture it, and how? I think we're putting our existing skills in place where they matter so we can contribute to that. That's all I can say at this point. But I think there'll be more news around the interim stage and at the year-end stage. Keep in mind, though, that everything we do is organic. So it takes time. We begin laying these foundations — global quality equities, which we discussed, the global franchise strategy, which is now a very substantial flagship strategy. That was 15 years ago — 0 15 years ago. It was 15 to 20 years ago. It's kind of a dream. These things take a while. But I'm very excited about that opportunity as an addition to the traditional betas on which we add alpha. And we don't believe those traditional betas are disappearing, as I showed you with the $7 trillion — which I could easily have shown in pounds, which is almost $10 trillion, which I could usually have made $20 trillion, if I wanted to impress you. But I was — we were really focused on what is there now and today to capture.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#38

Of that $7 trillion, transition finance gets 0. Okay. Rahim, then David. David, you're last since you handed us a report card today, but...

Kim McFarland

executive
#39

I believe that on that line, we have the question first.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#40

David, you’re up first. Rahim doesn’t have the speaker. I’ll hand it over to David now.

David McCann

analyst
#41

David McCann from Numis here. I'd like to briefly address the new growth channels you described for the product. You've clearly already fielded a few questions on this front. I'm simply trying to understand what share of your current business those 4 areas would actually account for, so we can gauge how much of your present book those bids could grow — what proportion is it? And regarding the remainder, which is clearly the more mature or perhaps even shrinking portion, just so we can confirm how that stays balanced?

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#42

That's a great question. I wouldn't characterize the balance as declining. I'd say just over half — half to 60% — is facing those spaces. Then the other half to 40%, a bit less than half, would sit in low-growth base. So 1/4 of the business is in generally lower-growth spaces — and you don't need to be a genius to figure out which ones those are — but lower growth. 1/4 is a version of, though not in the sweet spot where we believe it will grow that much. So 1/4 has good beta that could attract positive flow, like, for instance, in areas such as — in our case, we have to compete very hard for multi-asset mandates since we don't run a solutions business. We have a very good multi-asset team. They will win. But winning at the same scale as those growth areas is going to be a challenge for them, yet we want them as part of our business because they're a strategic part — they inform us about the entire asset spectrum. They understand how our clients think, because they think like our clients, and they grow.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#43

But they simply aren't sitting in a sweet spot for growth the way solutions are — I mean the low-margin solutions — since we're actually taking on responsibility for the alpha too. Given how things stand right now in the South African economy, I think we can't expect that portion of money to expand at the pace it once did, though it remains a decent part that's growing. That's a great business for us. And in our view it won't fall into decline, yet it also won't expand at the rate of the areas I've walked you through. On top of that, there are always particular styles of products you run that fall out of fashion — even if you yourself consider them the least fashionable, clients may think so — which is why I keep that quarter open for what I'd call, well, not run down, but less gross. What's fascinating in this business is that some of those older strategical offerings that might not be in heavy demand — value hasn't been in demand for 10 years — could return. So you hold onto them since they're profitable, they cost you nothing, but at that point they don't necessarily grow. So within a focused asset manager, you end up with a few extra things.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#44

At Ninety One, our aim is to avoid having an excessive number of these, since that would give you an <<inaudible>> proposition. Then when you speak with a client, that client has no idea what you represent. So here's what we state very plainly: we represent a handful of areas. That's our opening game, yet that is how clients recognize us. Still, if they know us sufficiently well, they might ask, "Could you do that on our behalf?" And we answer yes. What we don't do, though, is take the conventional broad waterfront approach — not only that. Our view is that won't succeed unless you happen to be a retail or mutual fund or ETF manager in a large market, and we are one. We speak with people who on any given day can choose among 20 or 30 suppliers for whatever they require. So they work with the suppliers they trust, the ones who have performed well for them previously and who are plainly expert in their field. That is what Ninety One aims to represent. Now, had we begun in the U.S. 30 years ago in a scale market, we would have been known for 2 or 3 things, and we would have bothered with the rest.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#45

We began in a small emerging market, where we had to contend with the waterfront, and we also had to figure things out; then we came to the U.K. at precisely the moment when risk-taking in the institutional market was collapsing. Interestingly, we got there when the market was, in a sense, finished. We had a broader base from which to start, and gradually, step by step, you narrow it down, and gradually, step by step, you become known for something, and you put out your long track record. That's the process we've gone through. I think we're quite clear now. And we offer large clients a very clear proposition, which is why most of our assets sit in the growth space, but some parts will inevitably see lower growth, or fashion would dictate, or customer client demand would dictate that there wouldn't be much there, yet we run those profitably. We don't run anything at a loss or less. We believe they hold growth prospects. So where are we investing right now? Specialist credit sustainability — we're investing heavily there. We're investing heavily in the technology that supports our investment teams to ensure they can be more efficient.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#46

We aren't putting money into quick new ideas that might or might not work out.

David McCann

analyst
#47

And then a quick follow-up on that — for the newer areas, how did flows look over the last year, say? Maybe if you'd want to strip out any one-off you also mentioned. And then also, looking ahead, what would good look like? Would that be sort of a talk range of like 5%, 10% in those areas on their own? Is that the kind of number we should be thinking about?

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#48

Well, I think the new areas held up quite nicely — not every one of the new ones, but the growth areas, emerging markets among them, which are obviously labeled a growth area, did quite nicely this year, right? So even this year they've remained strong, apart from places where clients pulled back in a big way; you saw a big equity risk at scale that simply removed all of it — they didn't want it. Those weren't good or bad, the risk was simply taken off. I'd look at sustainability growth. You can go and look at impact, these results, and that there's demand. We have an equity-centric offering, and we're adding data-centric products into the equity centers, and it was somewhat dampened toward the end but did okay. On the global equity side, I think, particularly around the quality style, there's a major opportunity for us, especially coming out of the U.S. We saw in the last quarter of the financial year, when people had been hit by so many risks and then the U.S. banking thing arrived. Liquidity was on hold and allocations were on hold. I think at half year we'll be able to tell you whether those allocations are structural.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#49

And then, naturally, we are reimagining certain platforms we already have that have solid histories, to ensure they face clients and address what clients need. So I think at the half-year mark, I can offer you some sense of it. But my — the newer segments, along with those I have named, have plainly delivered the stronger client experience, bearing in mind that equity risk was cut back considerably and there was notable prudence around emerging market fixed income, and Ashmore's numbers, which you have seen, convey that identical narrative, Yes. Rahim?

Kim McFarland

executive
#50

Hendrik, a few questions have come in offline.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#51

Yes. Yes. Eva, let these folks ask their questions first, and after that we’ll take it offline.

Kim McFarland

executive
#52

Five minutes.

Rahim Karim

analyst
#53

Rahim Karim here, from Investec. I have two questions, if that's all right. Hendrik, you brought up the structural decline in U.K. equities. I was just wondering whether you could maybe go into a bit more detail on that — specifically, what you might be doing internally to rightsize that business? Is that needed? Or was it just a — was that comment more relative than absolute?

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#54

We have clearly been cutting some expenses in that area, but we are also concentrating our efforts. There is a really exciting U.K. income offering, U.K. Helfand, and U.K. sustained. Just last night we received an award for the top U.K. sustainable strategy, yet flows have not materialized, all right? So our attention is on U.K. equities for the rest of the market, while we make certain that investment is matched to the opportunity. We believe we will be among those who survive. That, in our view, will not ultimately be what drives the entire value of the firm. It will contribute value, and we are likely near the bottom. But it is simply that — and as we have been consolidating within wealth managers, those firms are likewise constructing more international portfolios on behalf of their clients. One of the scandals, I would say, is the way U.K. Inc. effectively short sold its own equity market rather than continuing to develop it. And in a sense, everyone of us in this room is a casualty of that, because equity is needed to finance your own developments. You need your businesses, you need — you cannot keep active vision here held as a prisoner. You need plenty of new active visions brought forward by an equity market that delivers the proper kind of valuation, with enough money behind it.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#55

I think that's a challenge for the policymaker. That's above my pay grade. But I would say there's still a large pool of money here. And for that pool, we're going to complete in a measured and in a specific sense. But what we've done, we, for example, had U.K. products across some of our equity platforms. Remember, we are skills-based platforms. We're narrowly down to 1 platform and made the others focus on either global or emerging markets because there was more money flowing there. So I think we've done that. There's no reengineering to come. That's done.

Kim McFarland

executive
#56

Any other questions?

Rahim Karim

analyst
#57

For my follow-up, you mentioned what we're putting into technology. Could you help us understand the amount we've been spending there and how we ought to view the efficiencies that result? Does that help support the underlying margin? Is that essentially the modest decline in revenue margins expected ahead? In other words, how should success of that technology investment be measured?

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#58

First, Kim can speak to the spending. We haven’t exactly taken out the checkbook. It’s more about the mindset.

Kim McFarland

executive
#59

Yes. I think you gauge it through performance. It isn't a financial impact. The expense you're seeing — the system spend you're seeing is really where the investment sits. We discussed this last year. And there's always a risk, we see technology-enabled investment spend, that shouldn't be translated. I think Hendrik mentioned earlier as an increase in what you're actually seeing currently being predicted or in the figures that you see right now. So I think what we're rather seeing as an internal efficiency, and if anything, an improvement of the processes.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#60

So I think you can simply — take a look right now, for instance, at our investment managers: the screens in front of them, the cashboard they work with — does that let them get by with fewer analysts than before? Yes or no. Does it sharpen how clearly they can see what they're doing? Because keep in mind, our clients have also been — a great deal of what we spend has gone toward keeping pace with our clients. Our clients want to say, I want to know in real time what's happening. When you've got an insurance company in Germany with 20,000 people in the U.S. scrutinizing you, and you have 3 people on this side of the fence, or 30, you really then need the systems that let you handle them. So one thing we can promise you is that we have the systems and the pipes to plug these asset owners in and to satisfy their demands. That rules out a great many boutique outfits, which can't even begin to compete with them. So we're there. And that spending happens every year and keeps going. Sure, the AI benefits and their data, but we're quite wary of making the kind of promise that we'll reinvent how we do things.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#61

The benefit is slight, and it's about matching what your client is doing. Then, naturally, we've put a lot of attention on the investment front office, where over the last 3 years we've built an internal team that creates systems in a consistent manner across every one of our teams. That way we aren't stuck with a bunch of purchased packages through which our data can't be examined in an aggregate, comprehensive manner. And naturally, RFP — I mean, the AI revolution will really assist with basic RFP, basic marketing items, basic compliance checks and all of that; it's on the way. Yet that won't give us an edge over anybody else. We'll simply be there alongside the good people. And in fact we have a session with our staff right after this one to explain it and discuss what we can do. But it isn't a large outlay. I mean, Kim, it's a few million more. It's not...

Kim McFarland

executive
#62

Well, basically, we aren't seeing a pick — I'll try to put it this way: there isn't a pickup in expense when you're building a model going forward, and efficiency.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#63

We’ve taken the question from outside. 2 — Piers, you and your group first, then 2 from outside. Please go ahead.

Piers Brown

analyst
#64

Yes. This is Piers Brown at HSBC. So perhaps one question for Kim and another for you, Hendrik. Regarding — my question for Kim, it's about costs once more. Apologies for continuing to press on that cost topic, since I know you — I'm somewhat sympathetic to a view that you can't shrink the glory, but in light of the market outlook, you referenced the GBP 44 million of cost management savings last year. I mean, is that a...

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#65

GBP 4.4 million.

Kim McFarland

executive
#66

Yes, GBP 4.4 million.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#67

It's not quite as heroic, yes. <<inaudible>> 10 times.

Piers Brown

analyst
#68

If you could just kind of walk us through that process, that would help. Is it simply a continuous effort to find efficiencies within the fixed cost base? Or are there particular things you're examining in this year's pipeline that you might decide to act on?

Kim McFarland

executive
#69

It's not about waiting for some particular thing you're aiming to pull the trigger on. What it involves is going through the business, taking deep dives into where the spend sits. And crucially, seeking out places to strip out fat rather than attempting to cut into muscle — which, I think, is what Hendrik was referring to earlier when he said you can't simply halt spending across the organization. Rather, it's the continuous piece — it's a matter of discipline and a mindset that we've really driven down into the business: examining each and every spend line, whether that's travel, promotional, or anything along those lines. There isn't anything specific that you can point to. I've got to shut an office or made a particular...

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#70

Take one example, generally speaking: one of our marketing staff yesterday wanted to book the non-execs into a truly poor hotel for the strategy session. So no — that's sufficient. There's a cost-conscious culture in this place, all right? And so unfortunately, we don't — as a matter of fact, had we come in as a matter of fact, it would have been simple. That may be the difficulty we face. The other...

Kim McFarland

executive
#71

That also posed a challenge.

Piers Brown

analyst
#72

All right. So when we look at our models for this year — taking full year '23 and adding inflation — I mean, that would be a reasonable response for...

Kim McFarland

executive
#73

Right. And clearly, that applies to the whole book — which was really the main thing I wanted to get across. There's any — much of the book — the inflation effect isn't uniform across the whole book, which it ought to be. Thanks.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#74

Below inflation.

Kim McFarland

executive
#75

Yes, that would be below inflation.

Piers Brown

analyst
#76

Right, and the second question ties into that somewhat. On variable comps specifically, I believe you're down 6% year-over-year. I'm not sure if you benchmark that against competitors and where you stand, or what you're seeing more broadly in the hiring market regarding pressure or things like that...

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#77

We compensate generously. In the past, we've faced criticism over a high comp ratio. That was actually intentional on our part, since we want the reputation that strong performers get strong pay—but it's tied to results, and when results aren't good, the pay isn't there. And culturally, people get that: they join us and they welcome the variability. What we won't do is, when profits soar, suddenly shortchange the team. That's the crux of the bargain. So at the moment, I don't see a problem on our end. If we clearly keep going lower and lower and lower, we'll run into that issue, but right now it isn't remotely part of our vocabulary.

Kim McFarland

executive
#78

You also have to factor in that a significant ownership stake exists within the business. So people are aligned with what the results turn out to be. And contrary to what has recently appeared in the press, we have no contractual arrangements with staff either. It's an agreement regarding how compensation and the variable pool are actually distributed. And we are very clear, and as I mentioned earlier, we do reinvest a lot back into the business. So the expectations were there.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#79

We’ve got one, Angeliki.

Angeliki Bairaktari

analyst
#80

Angeliki Bairaktari from JPMorgan here. I just have one question — I'd like to hear your thinking. In the press release, you brought up the liberalization of exchange rules in South Africa. You also noted that this hasn't only helped the domestic players. So I was wondering: with this change, have you seen any market share loss in South Africa?

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#81

Angeliki, that’s a good question. As the largest domestic player—though we’re also the one domestic firm with a larger international business—we’re probably in the strongest position in that market to handle it. But when your choice widens and all of a sudden you’ve got 45% instead of 25% or 30% or whatever the previous number was to dish out, every asset manager in the world shows up. I mean from BlackRock down, they’re all there. So your—the client’s choice is greater. Why would the client use exactly the same manager unless it’s compelling and competitive? So we—for the international, we only compete in areas where we win internationally and where we are known to be good. We can’t sort of sell them just because we grew up next to them. And therefore, there is a natural widening of choice, and therefore, a market share decline for domestics. I think we’ve done—our team has done really well at managing that, and our clients have also learned, it’s—you get more—better service out of the manager who you know and have dealt with for a long time than someone who just flies in speculatively and disappears in the first cost cut when it happens in America or somewhere else.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#82

And I think that as time passes, things will reset. It really doesn't help during the year when you're dealing with the worst markets and you've still got that on top of it. So that's the point I'm making. We're quite comfortable competing in that market and continuing to keep our market share, but it has become more competitive. Sorry, Eva, who is on the — online.

Operator

operator
#83

<<operator_script>> From Clucas Gray Asset Management, <<inaudible>> has sent us 3 questions. Please give specifics on how headcount grew over the year. The first half saw 16 additions, while 10 people joined in the second half. Which teams and roles did those hires go into? Are you able to offer guidance regarding headcount growth for next year? And as a follow-up to that, no meaningful movement has appeared in the compensation ratio. Given market outflows and fee compression, why is that so?

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#84

All right. On the — I’ll address the compensation question. Kim will cover headcount. What matters most here is that our pay is tied to revenues and profitability, correct? So our variable component moves in line with that. The fixed part stays fixed. And we didn’t raise our — apart from at the bottom end. We didn’t lift either ahead or with inflation except in cases of promotions or when we competed for new talent. So at times the rise in fixed looks bigger than it really is, because you had to bring someone in from elsewhere. And that person was paid more wherever they were, or that was simply their level, or they represented better human capital that you were acquiring. So I’d say variable is very much tied to our revenue and profitability results. And as a result, it will move with those, not with net flow performance. Naturally, over time, net flow will have an impact on it. On headcount itself, I think the main point is that we always begin the year short of headcount that should have been higher the prior year, but...

Kim McFarland

executive
#85

Yes. Well, we don’t provide specifics on where they’re located, but I’d say fairly confidently that these increases span every area. They’re in certain particular areas and teams. But if you look at the — probably the list on the client group side, there will be an uptake in operations. I’m referring to an average increase of 2%. So there are a few pieces within the operational teams, and you’ve had a few on the investment side too. We’ve really just strengthened the teams on the investment side. Going forward, our intention isn’t to grow that headcount number, and if anything, we’re trying to hold on it.

Operator

operator
#86

We have one last question from someone whose name we couldn't catch. Could you talk about how business momentum is shaping up in Asia Pacific for the second half? Are flows in that region showing signs of recovery?

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#87

Let me return to headcount, since there's another point I wanted to raise. Ours is a people-centric business. That means we don't go in for corporately announced cuts of 10% or 5% that spread fear through the organization. When people don't deliver, they're told, and in time they're asked to leave — if they haven't performed, or if their business area has simply run out of puff. But this isn't a broad top-down approach; it's managed consistently. Which is why, as Kim says, we'll probably see a roughly flat headcount year. Over time, technology should make us more efficient, but — our clients have been asking for more, as I said, at the same fee. And sometimes you simply need people to help you there. As for — what's the last question?

Operator

operator
#88

The momentum we're seeing in Asia Pacific.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#89

That involved a quite limited group of really big asset owners who chose to reduce their exposure, and we get along well with them. They'll return. As of now, they haven't returned. We have in fact observed some solid activity in that region, and I can confirm there's a reasonable pipeline coming from there. Are we finished? Thanks a lot, everyone. Hopefully, in the coming year, we...

Kim McFarland

executive
#90

Six months.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#91

Moving on to September, hopefully we’ll have better news to share.

Kim McFarland

executive
#92

Appreciate it.

Hendrik du Toit

executive
#93

Farewell. Appreciate it.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Ninety One Group transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Ninety One Group earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Ninety One Group or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.