Northern Technologies International Corporation (NTIC) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 12, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
G. Lynch
executiveGood morning. Patrick Lynch here, CEO of NTIC, and with me is Matt Wolsfeld, our CFO. I want to note that the press release issued earlier this morning contains the financial results for our fourth quarter and full year fiscal 2020, and you can find a copy at ntic.com. During this call, we'll discuss several key aspects of those results and provide a brief business update, then finish with a question-and-answer session. For a substantial part of fiscal 2020, COVID-19 dealt our business a heavy blow. Since the beginning of this crisis, we've concentrated on providing customers worldwide with uninterrupted service in a safe manner, and I feel proud of what our team has accomplished during this challenging period. Viewed overall, the fourth quarter and full year numbers demonstrate how we have navigated the difficult market conditions brought about by COVID-19. Our experienced management team, which has led NTIC through many market cycles, including the Great Recession of 2008, 2009, has played a vital role in our ability to operate under today's market conditions. The flexibility NTIC needs to handle today's macroeconomic difficulties comes from lessons learned during previous periods of disruption, along with our wider diversification across end markets and a solid balance sheet. Naturally, we have continued funding research and development efforts that underpin our product strategies and longer-term growth. For the near term, however, the pace of our recovery remains unclear, because successive waves of the COVID-19 pandemic continue to hit the world economy, and this month several key European markets have brought back lockdowns. On today's call, NTIC together with every one of its subsidiaries, joint ventures, suppliers and customers is designated an essential business and continues to operate. In addition, we have not observed any negative effect on our recent sales trends so far from the recent rise in COVID-19 cases or new pandemic countermeasures, and the sequential quarterly sales improvement we saw in the fourth quarter of fiscal 2020, along with the start of fiscal 2021, gives me encouragement. We're keeping a close watch on all our end markets, working closely with our customers and backing our joint venture partners. We feel we're well positioned to come out ahead in the current macroeconomic environment. With that overview in mind, let's look at what drove the fourth quarter. For the quarter ended August 31, 2020, total consolidated net sales fell 25.4% to $10 million compared with the quarter ended August 31, 2019. By business unit, that figure included a 58.5% decline in Natur-Tec net sales and a 13.1% decline in ZERUST Industrial net sales, partly offset by a 53.5% rise in ZERUST oil & gas net sales and a slight gain in net sales from NTIC to its ZERUST joint ventures. Net sales from our joint ventures—which aren't consolidated in our financial statements—came to $18.5 million in the fiscal 2020 fourth quarter, versus $28.6 million in the same period a year earlier. That 35.4% drop in joint venture net sales stemmed mainly from the global COVID-19 pandemic. During fiscal 2020, our wholly owned NTIC China subsidiary saw net sales climb 2.9% to a record $13.4 million, despite having to weather COVID-19 shutdowns that fiscal year. In the fourth quarter of fiscal 2020, NTIC China's sales increased 2.7% versus the same period a year earlier, reaching $3.4 million, and were up 11.2% from the fiscal 2020 third quarter. We see this encouraging quarter-over-quarter gain in NTIC China sales as a reflection of new customer development efforts and our successful push into nonautomotive markets, and we remain optimistic about our long-term potential in this large and growing market. ZERUST oil & gas net sales for fiscal 2020 increased 2% compared with the prior fiscal year. For Q4, ZERUST oil & gas net sales came to $770,000 — that's 53.5% higher than the same period a year earlier and 81.4% above the fiscal 2020 third quarter. Oil & gas sales in the fourth quarter of fiscal 2020 got a lift from a notable easing of travel restrictions, which let us get our solutions delivered and installed at customer job sites. We've also managed to grow sales of our ZERUST oil & gas pipeline and storage tank solutions among both new and existing customers, and we feel we're well positioned to capture further opportunities in the oil & gas market during fiscal 2021 and beyond. Let me now turn to our Natur-Tec bioplastics business. The COVID pandemic went on dealing a significant blow to colleges, stadiums, arenas, eateries and corporate office parks, all of which had been heavy consumers of bioplastics. Such venues are likewise projected to be among the last to resume operations, and a number of these organizations have yet to disclose any reopening timelines. On top of that, output throughout the apparel sector fell steeply, which cut demand further for our Natur-Tec bioplastic bags — items that had grown into a key component of many sustainability programs in that sector. Consequently, Natur-Tec sales for the fourth quarter of fiscal 2020 came in at $1.9 million, down 58.5% versus the prior-year period and 21.4% lower than the fiscal 2020 third quarter. Near-term conditions in the marketplace for our bioplastic solutions are anticipated to stay weak. Even so, with the global economy emerging from the COVID-19 pandemic, we anticipate a recovery in the bioplastics market over the next several quarters, and the longer-range trends in this market look highly promising. Turning now to fiscal 2021, our present view is that although first-quarter financial results will show a marked gain over fourth-quarter levels, net sales and earnings will probably remain lower than they were in the corresponding period of the prior fiscal year. Also, because our product and end market diversification strategies kept paying off for us in the fourth quarter, we plan to keep partly countering softness in the market through winning new customers, creating new uses for our corrosion prevention solutions, and moving into additional market segments. Although the timing and speed of the worldwide economic rebound are still unclear, we remain committed to our long-term operating strategy, keep a strong balance sheet, and put investment into our technologies, our people, and our global platform. Last, on behalf of the whole leadership team, I want to take this chance to thank every one of our employees around the world and our joint venture partners for the hard work and dedication they have shown throughout this crisis. With that overview, I will now hand the call over to Matt Wolsfeld, who will summarize our financial results for the fourth quarter and full year fiscal 2020.
Matthew Wolsfeld
executiveThanks, Patrick. Versus the same period a year earlier, NTIC's consolidated net sales fell 14.5% in fiscal 2020, and in the fiscal 2020 fourth quarter they dropped 25.4%, driven by the trends Patrick covered in his prepared remarks. Sales across our global joint ventures dropped 35.4% in the fourth quarter, which weighed on joint venture operating income, and that figure fell 37% for the fiscal 2020 fourth quarter versus the prior year period; for fiscal 2020, sales across our global joint ventures were down 31.4%, which weighed on joint venture operating income, and that figure decreased by 31.4%, or by $4.1 million, versus the prior fiscal year period. As expected, total operating expenses improved during the fourth quarter, coming in at $5.3 million versus $6.3 million in the same period last year and $5.7 million in the fiscal 2020 third quarter. The 15.3% year-over-year decrease in the fourth quarter stemmed primarily from lower selling, general and administrative expenses incurred during the quarter. We stayed focused on proactively controlling expenses, and total operating expenses declined 3.4% in fiscal 2020 versus the prior fiscal year period. In the fiscal 2020 fourth quarter, net income took a hit from a onetime $1.6 million noncash adjustment to the company's deferred tax asset, which was required to remove the net U.S. deferred tax asset from NTIC's balance sheet. Consequently, NTIC reported a net loss attributable to NTIC of $1.8 million, or a loss of $0.19 per diluted share, for the fiscal 2020 fourth quarter, versus net income of $829,000, or $0.09 per diluted share, for the fiscal 2019 fourth quarter. For the year, NTIC reported a loss of $1.3 million, or $0.15 per diluted share, versus last year's net income of $5.2 million, or $0.55 per diluted share. As of August 31, 2020, working capital stood at $27.1 million, including $6.4 million in cash and cash equivalents and $5.5 million of available-for-sale securities, versus $25.5 million, including $5.9 million in cash and cash equivalents and $3.6 million in available-for-sale securities, as of August 31, 2019. As of August 31, 2020, the company had $24.1 million of investments in joint ventures, of which nearly 59%, or $14 million, is in cash, with the remaining balance primarily invested in working capital; with that overview, Patrick and I are happy to take your questions.
Tim Clarkson
analystSolid quarter relative to where we've been. So just a few questions. The first is for Matt. Could you sort of walk through in everyday terms what triggered this write-down of the tax deferral?
Matthew Wolsfeld
executiveAbsolutely. I think it's worth noting, because absent that write-off of the 1.6 — if we hadn't recorded the $1.6 million valuation allowance, our fourth quarter would have come in very near breakeven, which would have represented close to a $0.10 gain versus the third quarter. So it definitely distorted the picture as far as letting people see the favorable trends we're experiencing as we move from the third quarter into the fourth quarter and now into the first quarter. But essentially, here's the situation — whenever we assess our deferred tax asset, we have to examine our profitability in North America in particular across the last 3 years. Since we incurred losses in North America — and bear in mind that the income we report for North America does not include equity income from joint ventures, and that's a meaningful share of our income. So essentially, when you examine that — looking back across 3 years, it reveals losses and an inability to use that deferred tax asset. It's purely accounting; it's applying accounting rules. And so when we had to go in at the — at year-end and assess whether we could utilize that deferred tax asset sitting on our books, applying the accounting rules showed that we had to establish a full valuation allowance against that $1.6 million; so it doesn't mean that any of the items comprising that $1.6 million expired — nothing did. That figure included research and development costs previously capitalized, net operating loss carryforwards, and stock-based comp, all of which had previously been components of that deferred tax asset. So what we're watching is that as we track our future North American operations along with any changes to U.S. tax law and similar matters, it's quite likely that later on, all or some of that valuation allowance will be reversed in subsequent fiscal years as conditions improve. So while we don't enjoy taking onetime charges, certainly at — in the fourth quarter right now, that sort of distorts things and then possibly several years out they get reversed. Due to the accounting rules, we're required to do that; but bear in mind, it is noncash. There are — we didn't have to pay anything; it's merely establishing a valuation allowance on our balance sheet, though obviously we had to book the expense for it in the fourth quarter. So there's certainly far more detail on that and precisely what comprises it. All the tax-related details are going to appear in the 10-K, and that filing happens tomorrow; so I'd really urge everyone to go through the tax footnote in that 10-K if you're looking for additional detail regarding the valuation allowance.
Tim Clarkson
analystAll right. So regarding the new applications you mentioned in the quarterly report, Patrick, could you give us a sense of where a few of those wins are originating from and...
G. Lynch
executiveAre you asking about specific market sectors or applications?
Tim Clarkson
analystYes. Well, uses in both the US and China, though I won't reveal any company secrets.
G. Lynch
executiveWell, you're making that difficult for me. What I'd say is that most of the fresh applications we're currently seeing are in China, with a few in the United States. Still, I think discussing them at this point in this setting would be a bit unwise, if you don't mind.
Tim Clarkson
analystNo, I understand; and then finally, once more regarding the compostable side, I realize it was a terrible quarter for compostable. But one of the reasons I'm invested in Northern Tech is the socially conscious investing potential here, and from a certain standpoint there's no doubt about it. I'm aware McDonald's has said they're committed to switching to compostable packaging over the next 2 to 3 years, and you already have a relationship with McDonald's. I mean, we actually have a waste basket right here at Van Clemens that holds compostable items, and we use it every day. And then finally, just one point, I know your compostable materials really are proprietary. I know you've had some — even in this COVID environment, you've had some success with, and you might want to comment about a customer using the resin in a machine and it — in <<inaudible>> plastic forks and plastic knives, and they came to Northern Tech because your compostable resins were the only ones accurate enough not to gum up the machines?
G. Lynch
executiveWell, yes, that's correct; we are currently supplying, and they've raised their orders with us for the resin compounds they use to make compostable plastic cutlery, particularly since our resin compounds let the finished products be produced faster. You can knock them out of molds more easily and they harden quicker while curing in the ovens. So we managed to help them make a product they had tried to do themselves but were unsuccessful and — after trying to do it on their own for a number of years. So we're very happy with that relationship, and it is growing over time; so we have great expectations for this going forward.
Matthew Wolsfeld
executiveI'd also like to mention, Tim, particularly regarding Natur-Tec, that while we've observed — clearly, we experienced a substantial drop following March 2020, and though sales remain more than 50 percent lower right now, we've kept bringing on board notable customers, distributors, and so forth across the country and in various regions worldwide. So the pace at which we're adding customers to the portfolio is still rising. Even though the size is smaller given what we're seeing — the volumes existing customers are ordering — we continue to see a net gain in customers, so that as we hopefully emerge from the COVID situation, I believe there will be a fairly considerable tailwind we'll experience from a Natur-Tec standpoint.
G. Lynch
executiveWe're also discovering fresh uses for the compostable plastics amid this crisis, especially across Southeast Asia. So we're seeing some quite promising opportunities that weren't available to us previously and that are now taking shape.
Jim Dowling
analystCan you walk us through what's going on in each of the segments during September and October in more detail? And what have you been seeing in November so far?
Matthew Wolsfeld
executiveWell, I can offer a comment — a rough one, without sharing sales figures. Since we're in mid-November, obviously, we're quite deep into our first quarter, and we clearly have a fairly solid picture of where revenue landed in September and October. What I can tell you is that division by division, when it comes to ZERUST Industrial, revenue has picked up significantly in September, October, and November relative to where we stood in the fourth quarter. A factor that distorts our figures somewhat is that the third quarter included an exceptionally strong March—which, strangely enough, happened to be among our best months this year, right as the pandemic was beginning. As a result, third-quarter revenue came in somewhat higher than the underlying trend from April onward would suggest. That said, we're now seeing order levels begin to recover in September, October, and November, returning to very near pre-COVID levels in North America. We're in the single digits behind where we used to be — at least the current trend shows us trailing last year's first quarter by single-digit percentages. As we've mentioned, Natur-Tec is still lagging more. Their revenue appears to be recovering compared with the fourth quarter, yet it hasn't climbed back near pre-COVID levels. Just as we noted earlier on this call, they'll rank among our slower-recovering groups. That applies to the Natur-Tec product line in North America, India and China. Rebounding will simply take longer there than what industrial markets are showing, because of how those products get used. In a similar way, oil & gas has put up a strong showing during the first couple of months of the year relative to the first quarter of last year. So overall, when you consider the growth the whole company posted from the third quarter to the fourth quarter, it came in at only about 2% higher. The expectation is that, moving ahead from the fourth quarter into the first quarter, you'll see sequential growth between quarters of closer to 20%.
Jim Dowling
analystJust a single follow-up. Can you project whether oil & gas will get less lumpy for you?
Matthew Wolsfeld
executiveI'd sure like to be able to predict that it gets less lumpy. What we bump up against is that the projects we handle in oil & gas are far larger than the typical order sizes we get for Natur-Tec or ZERUST. So orders tend to arrive where — one comes in at $80,000. Then another arrives at $125,000. That naturally makes it lumpier. My sense is — what I believe you'll ultimately see is that as the oil & gas business expands, that is 18 to 24 months out, once we've built a base of business with customers plus repeat orders, that's the point when it becomes less lumpy. So I think from an oil & gas perspective everyone cares more about when we'll see a meaningful jump in contribution coming from oil & gas. It isn't about when you go from total sales of $3 million to $4 million, it's more about when we'll see some meaningful contribution to overall total company sales. So I think once we see that, and once oil & gas turns into a significant contributor, that's the point when it becomes less lumpy.
Auguste Richard
analystRegarding Natur-Tec, could you briefly discuss the drops in garment bags as opposed to cutlery? And which of those has had a bigger effect on the revenue line?
G. Lynch
executiveWell, these are separate markets we're discussing. Cutlery matters more for our North American sales, whereas garment-industry packaging is entirely in Southeast Asia. And of course, ever since the pandemic hit and shopping malls closed, among other things, consumption of new apparel has fallen considerably. Naturally, when the markets bounce back or our economies reopen, we anticipate those sales rising substantially once more. Same story with the cutlery and the waste liners. As I said earlier in my prepared remarks, the main sales there went to sports arenas, stadiums, big college cafeterias, large corporate cafeterias, and foodservice centers. And because many of these arenas and sporting venues and college campuses shut down — some still remain shut — that is what is restraining our rebound in those specific sales. Meanwhile, as I noted, we're also discovering new applications that are — during this pandemic, which look very promising, but developing them, ramping up, and expanding considerably into those new applications is going to take us some time.
Auguste Richard
analystUnderstood; and is there any chance when it comes to, let's say, e-commerce and making that — those packages more eco-friendly?
G. Lynch
executiveMaking — oh, do you mean something like the...
Auguste Richard
analystAmazon.
G. Lynch
executiveLike Amazon?
Auguste Richard
analystYes.
G. Lynch
executiveYes. We are holding discussions with packaging companies that are exploring doing something along those lines, though it is a little early in terms of — regulation in particular is a problem for us there. Because in that industry, at least, they have not quite reached agreement on what they want when it comes to sustainable packaging. If you — I mean if you have experience with Amazon, for example, the packaging is different every day when your package arrives. And so they have not arrived at a — I am searching for the word, a standard of any sort. Yes.
Auguste Richard
analystUnderstood. So, is there any competition you're noticing coming from PHA as opposed to PLA?
Matthew Wolsfeld
executiveRight now, no. What I mean is, as things stand today, the base resins NTIC uses haven't involved PHA. Natur-Tec isn't tied to any particular base resin. Down the road, it's possible we could use PHA, and that's a possibility we're looking at. However, as of now, we aren't seeing competition from it either, and we aren't using it at present.
Auguste Richard
analystIs that essentially a matter of cost, or is it about product quality?
Matthew Wolsfeld
executiveI think, at least from what I've heard, since PHA is relatively new — and I know we've been using PLA for a long time — switching resins would probably require a certain amount of research and a certain amount of development to get there. I also believe that right now the price points for PHA are higher than those for PLA.
Joe Vidich
analystI was just curious — you had increased your spending in India, and I wanted to ask where things stand with your operations over there?
Matthew Wolsfeld
executiveOn the question of spending more in India, a big part of what we're doing there is working to turn it into more of a hub for Asia so we can supply goods to that region. So over the last year, we put money into some equipment, some extrusion equipment, and some general expenses to establish it as a key operating base — particularly in light of the problems we were encountering with the Chinese tariffs and so forth. So we have a — we view that Southeast Asia market, be it India, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, China, as quite central to Natur-Tec's growth overall. I mean, I can tell you that when I look at the higher revenues we're seeing at Natur-Tec in China, it's quite evident that the broader markets and the fit of our products for tackling some of these bigger sustainability initiatives — and on top of that, what these companies are doing — that's a really large market for us. That's the reason we're putting money into India and into that region.
G. Lynch
executiveThanks to all of you for joining us today and for the interest you've shown in NTIC. Have a great day. Many thanks.
Operator
operatorThat wraps up today’s program, ladies and gentlemen. You’re welcome to disconnect now. Have a great day, everyone.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Northern Technologies International Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Northern Technologies International Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Northern Technologies International Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.