Public Service Enterprise Group Incorporated (PEG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 26, 2020

New York Stock Exchange US Utilities Multi-Utilities earnings 66 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Carlotta Chan

executive
#1

Thanks, Tiffany. Good morning, everybody. PSEG released its fourth-quarter and full-year 2019 results earlier on Wednesday, February 26, 2020. The earnings release attachments and the slides that break down results by company are available on the IR website, and the 10-K will be filed shortly. The earnings release and the other items we'll be covering on this call include forward-looking statements and estimates that carry various risks and uncertainties. We also discuss non-GAAP operating earnings and non-GAAP Adjusted EBITDA, and those differ from net income as reported under generally accepted accounting principles in the United States. Reconciliations for our non-GAAP financial measures, along with a disclaimer about forward-looking statements, can be found on our IR website and in today's earnings materials. Now I'll hand things over to Ralph Izzo, who serves as Chairman, President, and Chief Executive Officer of Public Service Enterprise Group. Dan Cregg, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, is with Ralph on today's call. Once they finish their remarks, your questions will be taken.

Ralph Izzo

executive
#2

Thanks, Carlotta, and good morning to all of you, and I appreciate you joining today's call. PSEG's non-GAAP operating earnings came in at $0.64 per share for the fourth quarter. Compared with non-GAAP results of $0.56 per share in the fourth quarter of 2018, that represents a 14% increase. For the full year, non-GAAP operating earnings reached $3.28 per share, which is 5% above 2018's non-GAAP results of $3.12 per share; 2019 brought us solid operating and financial results, and it was the 15th consecutive year in which PSEG produced results within or above our original earnings guidance. Our GAAP results for 2019 came to $3.33 per share, versus net income of $2.83 per share for 2018, and reflected higher earnings driven by several factors. Among these were the completion of PSE&G's 2018 distribution rate review. Pardon me. A partial year of Zero Emission Credits, or ZECs, as I'll call them going forward, mark-to-market gains, and nuclear decommissioning trust fund gains rather than the losses seen in 2018, plus higher pension credits stemming from benefit plan changes in 2019. Net income for 2019 also reflected a loss booked on the sale of PSEG Power's ownership stake in the coal-fired Keystone and Conemaugh units in Pennsylvania, a transaction that closed in the third quarter. You can find details on the quarter and the full year on slides six and seven. At PSE&G, net income rose 17% to $2.46 per share in 2019, while rate base at year-end climbed to over $20 billion, an increase of 6%. We put more than $2.7 billion to work at PSE&G in 2019, aimed at boosting the reliability and resiliency of our transmission and distribution system, and at the same time cutting methane emissions via the second phase of our Gas System Modernization Program, or GSMP, as I'll also call it later. PSE&G wrapped up its Energy Strong resilience work for almost $200 million below the authorized amount. We closed the second Energy Strong agreement to spend an additional $842 million on system hardening so we can better adapt to a climate-challenged world. In 2019, PSE&G again earned top quartile OSHA scores for safety and recorded our best-ever J.D. Power scores for electric and gas customer satisfaction; we beat the average industry improvement on metrics covering total monthly cost, bill clarity, fairness of pricing and options, and ability to manage monthly usage; we were also pleased to receive, for the 18th year in a row, PA Consulting's ReliabilityOne Award as the most reliable electric utility in the Mid-Atlantic region. We continue to strongly back New Jersey Governor Murphy's goals of achieving reductions in electric usage of 2% and gas usage of 0.75% within five years of programmatic energy efficiency implementation. During the prior week, we reached an agreement to push back the procedural timeline for our Clean Energy Future energy efficiency filing, moving it from March until the close of September 2020, so that regulators would have more time to finish examining our $2.5 billion submission, which New Jersey needs in order to hit its carbon neutral energy target by 2050. The New Jersey Board of Public Utilities, or BPU, gave its approval to this agreement during their meeting on February 19th. Simultaneously, our current programs received authorization to put an extra $111 million to work. Notably, the BPU removed a moratorium that had applied statewide to advanced metering infrastructure, AMI, and instructed the electric distribution companies to submit fresh proposals — or for us, to revise proposals already on file — for installing AMI throughout the state; this represents a major step forward for customers, since it will assist them in managing their energy consumption more effectively and shorten outage restoration times. AMI will additionally facilitate the integration of EE programs, which can constrain increases in the customer bill. We are eager to apply the best practices gained from our experience of installing roughly 1 million smart meters at PSEG Long Island across the past three years. Regarding the remaining $1 billion of proposed Clean Energy Future investments in AMI, electric vehicles, and energy storage, BPU staff have distributed draft procedural schedules. Those draft schedules set out wrapping up these cases through BPU decisions during the first quarter of 2021, or potentially later in 2020, should the parties in the cases reach settlements. Since PSE&G filed its four-part Clean Energy Future program in January of 2019, a great deal has occurred on the clean energy front across New Jersey and neighboring states. Last April, the BPU granted three years of ZEC to every one of our New Jersey nuclear units, which sustains their ongoing operation as the largest source of base load carbon-free generation in the state. In June, the BPU selected the 1,100-megawatt Ocean Wind project in the state's inaugural offshore wind solicitation. As 2020 began, New Jersey rejoined the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative, or RGGI. Pennsylvania and Virginia are weighing whether to join RGGI too, which might tackle a portion of the price disadvantage, or leakage, that lower carbon states encounter when surrounded by participants outside RGGI. The BPU completed the state's Energy Master Plan last month, which broadly backs decarbonizing and modernizing New Jersey's energy system so that its objective of 100% clean energy by 2050 can be met. A cornerstone of achieving that objective is keeping nuclear generation in place through 2050, maximizing energy efficiency, deploying offshore wind and other renewable generation, and electrifying the transportation and building sectors. The finalized Energy Master Plan also brought up the BPU's intent to take a more proactive stance on matters concerning transmission siting, cost allocation, and financial returns set by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, or FERC. The FERC's November 2019 order brought this matter squarely to the forefront, since it tightened the approaches employed when setting the return on equity for a set of Midwest transmission owners. We are restating the transmission return earnings sensitivity we've shared previously: for every 10 basis point shift in ROE away from our 11.18% base, annual utility earnings would move by $0.01 per share. I have to say, the market seems to have priced in a drop in PSEG's transmission ROE stemming from the Midwest ROE order — and then gone further. Keep in mind that the Midwest ROE order looks anything but settled. Given how complicated and costly this is, plus the lack of clarity around when FERC will finally settle on which calculation methodologies to use, the result of any complaint that might be brought is hard to call. I'd also like to speak to the Energy Master Plan's aim of preserving the reliability and safety of the existing gas pipeline system even as it anticipates future declines in natural gas usage linked to energy efficiency. Our view is that siting new natural gas infrastructure in New Jersey — pipelines and power plants alike — could grow more challenging; even so, regulators have voiced public backing for keeping existing gas infrastructure in good shape and upgrading it, so that safety is assured and harmful methane emissions are kept to a minimum. Our Gas System Modernization Program delivers both of those advantages. Practically speaking, natural gas already heats the homes or fuels the cooking of 80% of New Jersey households. Indeed, a large number of our customers switched over to natural gas after previously relying on oil or electricity for those needs.

Ralph Izzo

executive
#3

The cost to convert each customer would exceed $10,000, or even more; that represents a hefty financial hit for every household, and it goes against what most customers personally want. Customers of PSEG benefit from the region's cheapest natural gas rates. If electrification of homes were mandated, it would erode the price advantage that shale gas has delivered to New Jersey across a decade. Beyond that, it would harm the environment until zero carbon generation became the dominant part of the fuel mix. It is our firm conviction, and the BPU agrees, that natural gas alongside nuclear power is vital to New Jersey's energy mix and will stay vital for the foreseeable future; given this context of clean energy progress, the urgency of needed climate action, and major elements of the 2018 Clean Energy Act still awaiting implementation, completing PSE&G's $3.5 billion Clean Energy Future filing matters as much as ever. Through our proposed energy efficiency programs, every customer gets a chance to cut their energy bills while emissions come down. Under the BPU-approved extension of the energy efficiency filing, PSE&G will boost investment across several existing programs by $111 million. The earlier extension, authorized last fall, sold out rapidly, which highlights how much demand exists for our energy efficiency offerings. Universal access to energy efficiency is just one of many ways we show our dedication to keeping the customer bill as low as possible, since we have always understood this to be a critically important factor in our capacity to make system investments affordably. Beyond the bill comparisons we've pointed to before, and I'll say it again here, combined customer bills sit 30% below their level 10 years ago and are 40% lower in real terms. Note that across the 2018 to 2023 period, PSE&G will reduce bills by nearly $3 billion of tax reform-related benefits, with roughly $650 million coming in 2019 alone. More than half of that, $380 million, went toward lowering transmission bills. These savings can, in certain cases, be passed through on an accelerated basis. During 2019, PSE&G returned all eligible excess deferred tax balances at transmission, offsetting a scheduled formula rate increase and producing a $52 million rate reduction. We remain mindful that the strength of PSE&G's balance sheet lets us pass these savings through on an accelerated basis, which in turn helps make investing in large infrastructure projects that benefit customers affordable. Let me now focus on PSEG Power. Power's non-GAAP operating earnings for the full year came to $409 million, or $0.81 per share, which was 19% under 2018, reflecting recontracting at lower market prices and reduced capacity revenues, partly offset by ZECs beginning in April. With Bridgeport Harbor 5 placed into service, we finished Power's 1,800-megawatt combined cycle construction program. We also achieved meaningful progress replacing reactor vessel bolts at Salem 1. Power keeps applying strict cost discipline so it stays competitive in a difficult market. During 2019, PSEG Power moved forward in lowering the carbon footprint of its 11-gigawatt fleet, which was already small, and its output profile is now more than 50% baseload zero carbon nuclear generation. With the sale of close to 800 megawatts of coal interest in Keystone and Conemaugh now complete, Power anticipates that it will remove coal-fired generation entirely from its fuel mix by the middle of 2021, when Bridgeport Harbor 3 is retired early as scheduled. Turning to the power market and policy side, the capacity auction that ISO New England recently ran yielded a weak clearing price for capacity, which mirrored a demand forecast that was significantly lower. Our biggest New England asset, though, is the new Bridgeport Harbor 5 combined-cycle gas turbine, which, as you are aware, cleared the 2019 to 2020 auction and secured a capacity payment of $231 per megawatt day for seven years, which limits how much we are exposed to this most recent auction outcome. The long-awaited FERC capacity order expanding application of the Minimum Offer Price Rule — from here on I'll simply call it MOPR — warns PJM states that wish to support clean energy resources that they must look for an alternative to the capacity market auction so they can procure the resources they prefer and steer clear of the risk of expensive double payments in order to meet their capacity obligation. PJM is expected to soon update its price floors for every PJM nuclear unit and to submit those default avoidable cost rates, or ACRs, to FERC in its compliance filing on March 18th. The price floor for subsidized nuclear units will be the ACR, and it will probably decide whether our New Jersey nuclear units are able to clear the PJM capacity auction for the 2022 to 2023 energy year. Keep in mind that our capacity revenues are locked in through May 2022. Under the FERC order as it stands at present, the MOPR will also apply to new renewable generation supported by states, including offshore wind, whose price floor will be the net cost of new entry; that price floor makes clearing the capacity auction extremely unlikely, which has led several PJM states to weigh a fixed resource requirement, or FRR, self-supply option. We will cooperate with the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities and PJM to determine the best path forward, whether that means bidding and clearing the capacity auction under business as usual or pursuing the FRR alternative together with New Jersey in order to preserve its preferred zero carbon resources. Let's keep in mind that FERC's action was fundamentally intended to remove price suppression brought about by units that were getting out-of-market payments. At Power, we have agreed to sell our stake in the Yards Creek Pumped Storage Generating Station, which we co-own with FirstEnergy. This sale shows our continued commitment to maximizing the value of the generating fleet. These proceeds will contribute to improved cash flow at Power, now that the combined cycle construction program is finished and Power's capital needs are declining. We're still on course with PSEG's long-range plan of shifting the company toward being largely regulated, which brings cash flows you can count on. Financially we're in solid shape — our balance sheet is healthy, and that gives us room to fund the capital plans covering 5 years while also raising the common dividend, all without selling equity. Across the 2020 through 2024 stretch, the capital program now totals $12 billion-$16 billion, and more than 90% of it goes toward regulated utility expansion that makes our operations more reliable and efficient and backs New Jersey's energy policy objectives. At PSE&G, the capital spending blueprint for 2020 to 2024 comes to $11.5 billion-$15 billion, and we expect it to deliver 6.5%-8% compound annual growth in rate base, beginning at the 2019 year-end base of a bit more than $20 billion; that denominator in the CAGR keeps growing. Looking at 2020, our forecast for consolidated non-GAAP operating earnings is $3.30-$3.50 per share, and the midpoint works out to roughly a 4% gain — 3.6% to be exact — compared with 2019 results.

Ralph Izzo

executive
#4

For the entire year of 2020, our consolidated guidance is staying within a steady $0.20 range, just as we've given in prior years, though the guidance ranges for our subsidiaries are a bit broader to account for differences across the businesses that tend to even out when we report on a consolidated basis. The growth in 2020 comes primarily from a larger contribution of regulated earnings at PSE&G, which is nearing 80% of consolidated results, and that's partly offset by an anticipated drop in Power's results reflecting lower expected market prices for energy and capacity. Included in this guidance is the advantage of a full year of ZEC for each of the three nuclear plants we operate in New Jersey. Our board of directors recently chose to raise the company's common dividend to an indicative annual amount of $1.96 per share, marking the 16th time in 17 years we've done so, and this shows our dedication to giving capital back to shareholders while also keeping the financial flexibility needed to chase growth; we wrapped up 2019 in a strong position to carry out our policy and regulatory goals, along with our environmental, social, and governance goals. Not long ago, PSEG embraced the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board, also known as SASB, disclosure practice and included the UN Sustainable Development Goals in the sustainability report we published for 2019. In July, PSEG Power set a net zero by 2050 target, on the assumption of progress in technology, public policy, and customer behavior; this April coming up, we anticipate releasing our initial climate report based on the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures framework. In 2019, PSEG earned a spot on the Dow Jones Sustainability Index for North America once more, making it 12 years straight. More recently, Forbes and JUST Capital honored PSEG as one of America's Most Just Companies for 2020. For a third consecutive year, Forbes placed PSEG on its 2020 list of America's Best Employers for Diversity. Given all this, I'd like to express gratitude to every one of our employees for the commitment and dedication to customers they show daily, which is what allows these results to happen. At this point I'll hand the call to Dan so he can walk you through our operating results in greater detail, and I'll be around to take your questions once he's finished.

Dan Cregg

executive
#5

Okay, thank you, Ralph. Good morning, everybody. As Ralph said, just to go back over it, PSEG's non-GAAP operating earnings for Q4 2019 were $0.64 per share, versus $0.56 per share during the same three months of 2018. Because of what we earned this quarter, full-year non-GAAP operating earnings hit $3.28 per share, a 5% increase over 2018's $3.12 per share. On slide six, you'll find a reconciliation of non-GAAP operating earnings to net income for the quarter; slide 12 lays out how each business contributed to non-GAAP operating earnings in the quarter. The waterfall charts on slides 13 and 15 take you through net changes in non-GAAP operating earnings by major business, both quarter over quarter and year over year. Now I'll walk through each company in detail, starting with PSE&G. PSE&G's Q4 2019 net income was $0.54 per share, compared with $0.47 per share in Q4 2018. For all of 2019, net income came to $1.25 billion, or $2.46 per share, over 17% higher than the $1.067 billion, or $2.10 per share, posted in 2018. Slide 17 indicates that PSE&G's fourth-quarter net income increased due to larger investment in transmission and distribution infrastructure, along with a full quarter of distribution rate relief, as new rates went into effect on November 1st of 2018. Higher transmission investment at PSE&G boosted quarter-over-quarter net income comparisons by $0.04 per share. Gas margin picked up $0.02 per share from rate relief and recovery of gas distribution investment carried out through the Gas System Modernization Program. Electric margin was flat this quarter, as one extra month of rate relief versus Q4 2018 was offset by softer weather-normalized volume and demand. O&M expense was $0.02 per share better than the prior quarter, helped by lower tree trimming and preventative maintenance work. In addition, retiree medical plan benefit changes made in 2019 contributed $0.03 per share to net income compared with the year-earlier quarter; those gains were partly offset by $0.01 per share of higher depreciation expense from larger plant balances, $0.01 of greater interest expense from more debt outstanding, and taxes and other items that came in $0.02 unfavorable against the year-earlier quarter. For the full year, weather-normalized residential electric sales declined 0.2%, while weather-normalized residential gas sales decreased 1.8%. Total electric and gas customers rose 0.9% and 0.6%, respectively, for the full year. In October, PSE&G updated its transmission formula rate filing for 2020 so it could implement a rate increase, now that the return of excess deferred tax benefits finished in 2019. During 2019, PSE&G's formula rate filing included returning to customers the tax benefits tied to accumulated deferred income taxes on a faster schedule within one year, and that lowered the annual revenue requirements and transmission revenue for 2019 once system investments were factored in. With more than $2.7 billion invested by PSE&G in transmission and distribution infrastructure during 2019, rate base grew 6%, exceeding $20 billion. Looking ahead, PSE&G's net income for 2020 is projected at $1.310 billion to $1.370 billion. Transmission investment by PSE&G makes up 45% of that number — a bit more than $9 billion of the company's consolidated rate base at the end of 2019. For 2020, PSE&G's net income is projected to land between $1,310 million and $1,370 million. Now let's move on to Power. In the fourth quarter, PSEG Power's non-GAAP operating earnings were $0.10 per share, compared with $0.11 per share on the same basis a year earlier. With the help of the quarter's results, Power's non-GAAP operating earnings for the full year came to $409 million, or $0.81 per share, against 2018's non-GAAP operating earnings of $502 million, or $0.99 per share. Power's non-GAAP Adjusted EBITDA for the quarter and the year were $198 million and $1,035 million, respectively. That compares with non-GAAP Adjusted EBITDA of $176 million in the fourth quarter of 2018 and $1,059 million for that full year. Detailed analysis of Power's operating earnings on a quarter-over-quarter and year-over-year basis, driven by revenue and cost changes, is available in the earnings release along with slides 13 and 15. As slide 23 shows, Power's reported net income climbed by $0.39 per share while non-GAAP operating earnings dropped by $0.01 per share versus the fourth quarter of 2018. Capacity prices in PJM and ISO New England fell on schedule in the second half of 2019, which reduced fourth quarter non-GAAP operating earning comparisons by $0.11 per share. Generation output was also lower for the quarter, taking $0.02 per share off comparisons. Partly offsetting those factors were the benefits of a full quarter of ZEC revenues at $0.06 per share and a lower cost to serve of $0.05 per share, though recontracting at weaker market prices lowered results by $0.03 per share. Gas operations were flat, since lower commodity prices squeezed margins and constrained off-system sales. A drop in our O&M expense lifted comparisons by $0.03 per share, as savings from the Keystone Conemaugh sale and reduced fall 2019 fossil outage expense outweighed higher costs tied to the Hope Creek refueling outage and Bridgeport Harbor 5's in-service as of mid-year 2019. Lower taxes boosted non-GAAP operating earnings by $0.01 compared with the prior year's fourth quarter. For the fourth quarter, gross margin held steady at $31 per megawatt hour, matching the figure from Q4 of 2018. The reason: a planned drop in capacity prices that kicked in on June 1st across PJM and ISO New England was mostly balanced out by the ZECs granted in April. On a full-year basis, gross margin slipped to $32 per megawatt hour from $33 per megawatt hour, which mirrors roughly a $3 per megawatt hour average decrease in 2019 hedge prices for energy. Moving on now to how Power's operations performed—slides 24 and 25 lay out the generation details for both the quarter and the year. At Power's generating facilities, fourth-quarter output dropped 6.2% compared with the same period a year earlier. The main factors were the divestiture of the Keystone Conemaugh coal-fired generating units, which closed at the end of the third quarter, and a refueling outage at Hope Creek that ran longer than usual. For the full year 2019, output reached 57 terawatt-hours, putting us at the low end of the 57 to 59 terawatt-hour guidance range. Nuclear generation averaged an 81.9% capacity factor in the quarter, lifting the full-year capacity factor to 88.7% and total production to about 30 terawatt-hours. Turning to the combined cycle fleet, its quarterly average capacity factor was roughly 54.8%, yielding a 52.2% capacity factor for the year and annual output of approximately 23 terawatt-hours. That represents an increase exceeding 20% from the prior year, reflecting the addition of Bridgeport Harbor 5 as well as solid capacity factors at Keys and Sewaren, the other two new combined cycle units. Coal-fired generation declined considerably for both the quarter and the year as a result of the Keystone Conemaugh sale. On Slide 27, you'll find an update on Power's hedge position following the BGS auction that took place in early February. For PSE&G, net income for 2020 is projected to land between $1.310 billion and $1.370 billion.

Dan Cregg

executive
#6

PSEG Power expects lower output in both 2020 and 2021, projecting 50 to 52 terawatt hours — a drop of two terawatt hours from what was given in the third quarter 2019 update — mostly because of soft prices and reduced market demand. Once the recent Basic Generation Service, or BGS auction in New Jersey wrapped up, roughly 85%-90% of 2020 production is hedged at an average price of $37 per megawatt hour, while base load production is hedged at about $1 below the 2019 average hedge price. Looking at 2021, Power has hedged 45%-50% of its forecast output of 50 to 52 terawatt hours at an average price of $36 per megawatt hour. As for 2022, Power has hedged 20%-25% of forecast output of 50 to 52 terawatt hours at an average price of $36 per megawatt hour. The 2020 to 2022 volume forecast completely incorporates the sale of Keystone and Conemaugh, which in earlier years had generated about five terawatt hours annually. It also reflects generation from the three new CCGTs, roughly three terawatt hours of reduced generation in each year, in line with present market conditions, along with the planned retirement of 383 megawatts of coal-fired generation at the Bridgeport Harbor 3 station in June of 2021. Power's 2020 non-GAAP operating earnings forecast and non-GAAP Adjusted EBITDA forecast are expected to come in at $345 million-$435 million and $950 million-$1,050 million respectively. Turning to Enterprise and Other, in the fourth quarter of 2019, Enterprise and Other reported net income up $0.01 per share and non-GAAP operating earnings up $0.02 per share versus the fourth quarter of 2018. Net income came to $2 million in the fourth quarter of 2019, against a net loss of $5 million or $0.01 per share in the fourth quarter of 2018; across the full year of 2019, PSEG Enterprise & Other posted a net loss of $25 million or $0.06 per share, versus net income of $6 million or $0.01 per share for all of 2018. Enterprise & Other reported non-GAAP operating earnings of $2 million for the fourth quarter 2019, lifting full year results to $7 million or $0.01 per share, which compares to a non-GAAP operating loss of $12 million or $0.02 per share in the fourth quarter of 2018. That brought results to $13 million or $0.03 per share for full year 2018. For 2020, Enterprise & Other is expected to generate a non-GAAP operating loss of $5 million. This guidance reflects continued PSEG Long Island results that are more than offset by a higher parent interest expense. PSEG ended 2019 with $147 million of cash on hand and debt representing 52% of our consolidated capital position. Power's debt was 33% of its total capital base, and its year-end debt position stood at just over 2.7x 2019 non-GAAP Adjusted EBITDA. Our internal cash generation should cover the $12 billion-$16 billion capital plan we have in place for 2020 to 2024, plus let us make additional investments in the opportunities we've already flagged, all without selling equity, and still give us room to raise the dividend. As a quick recap, our 2020 non-GAAP operating earnings guidance sits at $3.30-$3.50 per share, roughly a 4% gain versus 2019, with PSE&G's regulated operations accounting for close to 80% of consolidated earnings; we also boosted PSEG's common dividend by $0.08, bringing the indicative annual figure to $1.96 per share, which is a 4.3% increase over 2018. That amount still works out to roughly a 58% payout of consolidated earnings at the midpoint of the 2020 guidance, is well covered by utility-only earnings, and has helped drive a 4.7% yearly growth rate in the dividend across the past five years. With that, Tiffany, we're ready to open it up for questions.

Praful Mehta

analyst
#7

Thanks so much. Hi, guys.

Ralph Izzo

executive
#8

Hi, Praful.

Praful Mehta

analyst
#9

Hello, Ralph. Regarding the PJM capacity auction, I'm certain you figured this question was coming. Regrettably, given how FERC has structured things, it's hard to envision a path for states to remain in it should they genuinely wish to advance renewable mandates, particularly as you mentioned, offshore wind, and we'll find out how the net ACR turns out for nuclear. What's your perspective on that? If states were to split off or at minimum establish their own FRR, as you mentioned, what are the implications for New Jersey? How long would the process take and what would the timeline look like, and what would that mean specifically for your portfolio?

Ralph Izzo

executive
#10

Thank you, Praful. That question is extremely complex. A great deal of it essentially boils down to a couple of words: it depends. My sense is New Jersey doesn't wish to pay twice for capacity derived from carbon-free sources, and especially from offshore wind. Under the existing construct, which as you're aware, many parties have submitted filings for rehearing, but under the existing construct, New Jersey would need to have either a zonal or statewide FRR, which in my view is suboptimal, correct? Now you'd be addressing a minor issue using a fairly massive instrument. If your goals involve 7,000 megawatts of offshore wind, then withdrawing 15,000 megawatts from the capacity market appears somewhat excessive; it also hinges on how the FRR is designed. Are you removing what the engineering assessment determines is the reserve margin you require, 15%, 16%? If that's the case, you're left with a residual market that is absurdly oversupplied and driving capacity prices down in that market. How does price get determined? There are simply countless questions. What gives me confidence is, first, we have an Energy Master Plan stating nuclear matters through 2050, so it must receive economic support. Second, we have fossil assets situated near load centers with deliverability benefits that will render them significant components in whatever capacity, reliability, construct gets established. Honestly, we've already submitted comments, and based on those comments, I believe it's fair for me to state that we've indicated FERC didn't get this quite right, and it appears the likeliest result is that parties not near load centers and located in other regions might encounter a residual market that does see some price suppression, which is precisely the reverse of what FERC claimed it intended to accomplish. Everything I've said following those first two words, "It depends," you should receive with a somewhat very cloudy crystal ball regarding its capacity to be precise, and I'll conclude where I began, which is, it depends.

Dan Cregg

executive
#11

Praful, perhaps I could just add one point. In the prepared remarks, we noted that on March 18th we'll learn somewhat more from PJM regarding the ACRs, which ties into what you asked about too. That also remains contingent, though we will gain somewhat greater insight, and we expect that to be released on March 18th.

Ralph Izzo

executive
#12

Sure, Praful — I believe you're already aware that, based on what the IMM figures indicate, our nuclear plant would definitely be competitive if we were to decide to take part.

Praful Mehta

analyst
#13

Right. No.

Ralph Izzo

executive
#14

For capacity price.

Praful Mehta

analyst
#15

Yeah. No, I appreciate you laying all that out, and it's clear that nuclear should, at least going by IMM numbers. I suppose with all these caveats and unknowns, thinking about timing, if FERC moved forward, do you figure New Jersey could move quickly enough to secure the FRR should that be the route taken? As you put it, a hefty instrument for a modest issue, but if that were the sole option, how long do you think it would take for New Jersey to pull together and resolve things on the FRR front?

Ralph Izzo

executive
#16

Keep in mind, capacity prices are locked in through 2022, so there's some breathing room. Whether or not FERC acts swiftly on the March 18th filing Dan mentioned, it's possible the following auction happens late in Q4 of this year. New Jersey won't see offshore wind receiving payments until sometime in 2024; the double payments don't kick in until the second auction from now, correct? We're still dealing with the 2019 auction. The 2024 energy year corresponds to a 2021 auction. New Jersey has some time, and from talks with staff, we think, and staff has indicated to us, that they share the view that legislation might not be required to proceed with an FRR; of course, that's not entirely guaranteed. I do believe there will be enough time for New Jersey to steer clear of double paying for capacity in 2024. It won't be easy.

Praful Mehta

analyst
#17

Understood. That's reasonable. I'll rejoin the line, everyone. There's still plenty more to ask. Appreciate it.

Julien Dumoulin-Smith

analyst
#18

Thanks. Hello, everyone.

Dan Cregg

executive
#19

Good morning, Julien.

Ralph Izzo

executive
#20

Good morning.

Julien Dumoulin-Smith

analyst
#21

Hi, great. Let's shift to something a bit different, more utility-focused. During the EMP, there was at least some discussion of transmission returns. I'm interested in hearing your most recent perspective on the dynamics specific to New Jersey. Clearly, you mentioned the MISO circumstances in your prepared remarks. Within New Jersey in particular, do you see any possibility of submitting a 205 to move ahead of whatever process might unfold in New Jersey, or how do you expect this to unfold, if it does at all? I'm curious about your thoughts on that.

Ralph Izzo

executive
#22

Julien, I can't predict whether a 205 will happen at all. A 206 has come up many times in our discussions, and filing a 206 carries a high threshold. Honestly, I think we need to improve at reminding people just how enormous the value of our transmission investments has been over the years, correct? Consider August of 2003, when the grid's structure was quite different and it has become far more improved today in terms of reliability — we've cut transmission outages by 300%, as I recall, during that span. There was a time when generators in the West had low-cost fuel, and New Jersey encountered prices with a $20 basis uplift in the East. Today, that low-cost fuel in the West has shifted in nature from coal to gas, yet it remains lower-cost fuel in the West. New Jersey has no natural gas at all, and basis differentials today, rather than being +20 or -3. Transmission has brought plenty of advantages, and we still have no shortage of 90-year-old transmission assets that must be replaced. That said, we probably won't file a 205 to alter our ROE, since we truly don't know what the FERC rules will end up being; to me it seems quite clear that FERC has, as professionally as anyone possibly could, essentially said, "Oops." Perhaps we should reconsider what we did here. The chairman himself, I believe, has stated that they are open to potentially rehearing this case. A 206 filing is incredibly complicated. It consumes many years. Just look at what occurred in New England. Look at what occurred in the Midwest. That was when people understood what the methodology would be. Now, without a known methodology amid that complexity, I think it's not especially beneficial for our customers or for us to go in and begin guessing what those rules might be through a 205 filing. Every dollar allocated to transmission is something I stand behind, along with the advantages our customers have gained, and once FERC clarifies its regulations, perhaps we'll be able to hold a sensible discussion with both our regulators and the people we serve regarding what constitutes a reasonable return. At present, it appears the market has already priced in all of that and more.

Julien Dumoulin-Smith

analyst
#23

Absolutely. And if I could just build on that point, connecting the two discussions—one about power, the other about utility. Clearly there's pressure throughout the market, and possibly a decelerating utility growth path, even if only slightly. How do you view the power side of the business, once again, from a strategic standpoint, when you consider dividends and the cash flow that's needed back into the utility? Again, attempting to link that financing discussion to both sides of this business.

Ralph Izzo

executive
#24

Yeah. All right-

Julien Dumoulin-Smith

analyst
#25

And also considering that most recent asset sale.

Ralph Izzo

executive
#26

Yeah. No. To start with, keep in mind that due to the CEF delay, together with rate base growth of 6%, which formed part of a 17% increase in utility earnings, yeah, we are lowering the lower end of our rate base growth to 6.5%. I'd push back on the idea that utility growth is slowing. I believe we pay close attention to customer bills, the impact, and the customer value creation tied to the kinds of investments we're making, right? Our purpose here isn't simply to expand the rate base. What we're trying to do is give back to shareholders by improving what we offer customers. That 6.5%-8% range — I'd describe it as solid, and even if that sounds a little odd, it's genuine. I'll stop there instead of trying to characterize it further. The 6.5% figure accounts for programs and items we're already certain about, while the 8% depends on capturing part of CEF, and given that the BPU has asked us to submit an AMI or revise our AMI proposal, it seems reasonable to expect approval of at least some portion of CEF, covering both EE and AMI. Now, turning to the power side, which is really the core of what you're asking about. Julien, I apologize, but I need to challenge a few of the premises underlying what you asked. Progress is happening on our end. Divesting Keystone Conemaugh was a logical move, and Yards Creek is being sold for the same reason. Bethlehem, however, is not on the block right now, since our view is that its worth to us exceeds what buyers in the market would offer. This year, close to 80% of earnings will come from the utility, and across the coming five years, 90% of capital will go toward that business. Using power-generated cash to support utility operations is an appealing funding approach. For financing the equity portion of the utility, power's debt capacity is an appealing route, and that's something we'll continue with. Whenever someone steps up and claims, "That asset could be put to better use by us" — whatever that asset happens to be — we're glad to talk it over. Such discussions happen constantly. Occasionally they lead somewhere, and occasionally we figure out the other party simply wants to acquire something very valuable cheaply, which we won't permit.

Julien Dumoulin-Smith

analyst
#27

Okay. Thanks, everyone.

Dan Cregg

executive
#28

Julien, I believe the sole additional point worth making is this: consider that for quite a while now we've discussed how an expanding rate base will eventually point toward the possibility of slower growth, simply because that base gets bigger. That's roughly what the range we issued reflects. On top of that, bear in mind that certain provisions tied to GSMP and to Energy Strong carry five-year run rates lasting through 2023. The five-year plan we're discussing at present extends through 2024. Keep in mind that what we're certain is approved and proceeding is the bottom end of that range. From the perspective of what's approved, we essentially lose one year inside our five-year forecast. We've also noted that plenty of gas pipe and cast iron pipe exists, and that has a longer run rate when it comes to working through all of it so every methane leak coming from it gets eliminated. I'd say there's some consistency in the fact that it isn't approved yet for 2024. Through 2023, it is approved. For that reason, you observe a bit of a decline at the lower end of that range.

Julien Dumoulin-Smith

analyst
#29

Thanks.

Jonathan Arnold

analyst
#30

Hey there.

Ralph Izzo

executive
#31

Jonathan, hello. Glad you reached out.

Jonathan Arnold

analyst
#32

Thanks. Same to you. I had a quick question about that slide showing the updated CapEx. I was wondering — during 2023, the orange portion, which is electric distribution, clearly grows a lot. Could you go over again what falls under that? Does AMI belong there, or does it remain in the green hashed-out area?

Dan Cregg

executive
#33

No, Jonathan, from that angle I'd say there are perhaps a couple of items worth considering. First, as I just mentioned regarding Energy Strong and GSMP, typically a portion of what we refer to as stipulated base sits inside the total spend. Across the 5-year span of the clauses we hold, that spending has a tendency to trail somewhat. Should the stipulated base arrive near the conclusion of those programs, some of it might show up then. Typically there is a bit of capital — a capital adder — as we approach the rate base year, simply because capital gets gathered together in the end. Those are the 2 items that come to mind on that.

Jonathan Arnold

analyst
#34

All right. When I look at it, the orange and blue portions for 2023 especially have gone up quite a bit compared with what you showed us not long ago.

Ralph Izzo

executive
#35

Jon, AMI sits higher, within the cross-hatched area.

Jonathan Arnold

analyst
#36

Understood. That isn't the cause. Broadly speaking, when I attempt to infer the figures behind the slide—doing a bit of slide-rule work—it looks like what you're spending across 2023 is likely higher by $500 million, perhaps somewhat more. Meanwhile, the rate base winds up roughly where it was. Is that reading accurate, or am I off?

Dan Cregg

executive
#37

On that point, I'm not certain I completely grasp what you're asking.

Jonathan Arnold

analyst
#38

I'd just like to check what that slide of yours suggests regarding the rate base around the 2023 timeframe. Even with all this back-and-forth on CapEx, it appears to land in essentially the same spot. I simply want to confirm that my reading is correct.

Dan Cregg

executive
#39

In what way does 2023 land in the same spot?

Jonathan Arnold

analyst
#40

That came earlier.

Ralph Izzo

executive
#41

Ah — earlier in what sense? That's a comparison I can't make.

Dan Cregg

executive
#42

Oh, so you mean when you put it next to...

Jonathan Arnold

analyst
#43

Right, allow me to put that differently. Once you've factored in everything here, has the overall forecast for your 2023 vintage-style rate base shifted much?

Dan Cregg

executive
#44

Looking at the bottom of that range, my answer would be no. Essentially, what shows up at the upper end accounts for the CEF opportunity plus the IIP opportunity. We can gather our slide rules and sort of work through the details.

Jonathan Arnold

analyst
#45

All right.

Dan Cregg

executive
#46

Essentially, what you have here is a rise of 7%-8% compared with 2019, while the lower end shows six and a half compared with 2020, and year-over-year you're looking at a 6% gain. When you put it all together, it simply comes down to arithmetic.

Jonathan Arnold

analyst
#47

All right. The endpoint really doesn't look all that far off, does it?

Ralph Izzo

executive
#48

Yes, I'd say that's a reasonable way to put it, Jonathan. Right, my view is it isn't all that far off. There is a difference.

Jonathan Arnold

analyst
#49

All right.

Dan Cregg

executive
#50

Yes, I'd say CEF's reliance plays a role there. That element has accounted for the largest share of our range and continues to do so, since work on those filings is still underway.

Jonathan Arnold

analyst
#51

Great. There's just one more item. In the quarter, what did you record for the goodwill impairment at Power?

Dan Cregg

executive
#52

Jonathan, that stemmed from a long time back, when we bought a facility in New York that ended up being called the Bethlehem Energy Center, and we constructed it. My guess is it took 2 years to construct. It could have been around 2001 or 2002, roughly. From Niagara Mohawk, we purchased the site of the former Albany Steam Station. When we made that purchase, some goodwill showed up on the books, and it is subject to a yearly impairment test. As we moved through this year, it was impaired. The amount was relatively small, but in the end it was simply that accounting test as we proceeded.

Jonathan Arnold

analyst
#53

All right. It wasn't exactly one of your main holdings, then.

Dan Cregg

executive
#54

Correct — it's non-cash, and the sum is fairly modest.

Jonathan Arnold

analyst
#55

Thank you.

Dan Cregg

executive
#56

You're welcome.

Michael Lapides

analyst
#57

Hi everyone, a fast question about the transmission CapEx that's part of the 5-year outlook. I'm just wondering, at this moment, what level of visibility do you have regarding transmission CapEx figures for 2021 and 2022?

Dan Cregg

executive
#58

Broadly speaking, I'd say it's extremely strong. When you consider many of those efforts, they turn out to be efforts spanning multiple years. Much of that outlay isn't sitting around waiting for approval during those years; instead, it ties more to outlays on efforts that have a longer-term path forward.

Michael Lapides

analyst
#59

Alright. The sole motivation behind my asking is that, looking back historically, whenever all of you issued a 5-year projection for transmission spending, the actual amounts spent during years three through five, compared with those earlier forecasts made a couple of years prior, ended up being wildly divergent figures. I'm simply wondering whether we might be facing a situation where a meaningful increase could occur beyond what appears on slide 19 regarding anticipated transmission spend, particularly given that the rollover appears to be happening really in the coming year, 2021. Typically, it's roughly years three through five when your team has projected that out.

Ralph Izzo

executive
#60

Michael, I believe you can feel confident that what we're presenting reflects the best of our current knowledge. We've mentioned previously that certain bigger projects, which had a tendency to render the future somewhat more uneven, if you will, when new projects got approved, those sizable projects aren't included in the forecast. We don't anticipate any. I mean, you should never rule anything out, depending on what PJM chooses to do regarding the RTEP. A great deal of the transmission upgrades at present consist of end-of-life projects along with 69 kV upgrade projects. Projects resembling Susquehanna-Roseland, the Northeast Grid projects, which might take something sitting at X and turn it into far more than X once approved, aren't expected to emerge in the near term.

Michael Lapides

analyst
#61

Understood. I just need clarification on one more thing — could you go over what's happening with the AMI process at this point? Is that an approved spin, or does it belong to the CEF dockets still awaiting approval? If it's handled separately, at what point does it come into play? Or is it simply included in the Energy Cloud docket?

Ralph Izzo

executive
#62

Right. The BPU removed the moratorium, stating, "Alright, given certain work completed at Rockland Electric plus an independent consult report, this is reasonable. We ought to implement it across the state." They instructed the utilities, "Alright, go ahead and submit your filing. You're permitted to do so under the Infrastructure Improvement Program framework," which, as you might remember, was enacted in December of 2018. Because a filing from us is already in place, there's no need to draft a fresh one. What we'll do is take the AMI portion of our CEF — the Energy Cloud piece — confirm it requires no adjustments whatsoever, and submit it through the Infrastructure Improvement Clause Recovery Mechanism. My expectation, my hope, is that we'd have a really solid chance to reach a negotiated settlement on this, given that everyone acknowledges AMI's worth and given that the recovery mechanism within the IIP is quite thoroughly documented and has seen widespread use. Perhaps we can actually complete this during the current year, though we'll have to wait and see.

Michael Lapides

analyst
#63

Understood. One more thing — could you refresh my memory about what PSE&G spends on energy efficiency, and from an earnings standpoint, how does that get handled?

Ralph Izzo

executive
#64

It goes into rate base and earns a rate of return. Every one of our earlier programs included a mechanism, and that same mechanism carries over here: through an administrative fee, we get the chance to recoup the revenue we lost. That fee is structured so we can operate the programs and, provided we operate them efficiently, have the opportunity to recover that lost revenue piece.

Michael Lapides

analyst
#65

Understood. Thanks a lot. Really appreciate it, everyone.

Paul Patterson

analyst
#66

Morning. How’s it going?

Ralph Izzo

executive
#67

Hey, Paul. How are you?

Paul Patterson

analyst
#68

Just a quick one. Is there any basis for expecting a meaningful gap between PJM's ACR figures and the IMM's?

Ralph Izzo

executive
#69

Nothing stands out to us, Paul; as you're aware, the two don't always see eye to eye, whether on policy or in their analyses, but right at this moment, nothing stands out to us.

Paul Patterson

analyst
#70

All right. So if the FRR ends up being the path chosen, how ought we to think about how much capacity New Jersey would be looking to procure, I suppose, and in what way it would get picked, I guess?

Ralph Izzo

executive
#71

That genuinely has yet to be settled. Our desire would be to collaborate with the state so that reliability needs are satisfied, while also ensuring the state doesn't give itself too much supply and in doing so compensate more people than necessary. All of that remains to be figured out.

Ralph Izzo

executive
#72

Question from Paul Patterson, followed by Dan Cregg's response: The state would supply PJM with data so that it can confirm those obligations have in fact been fulfilled. I believe you could frame the idea of satisfying reliability in a way that aligns with PJM regarding the sort of credit assigned to specific unit categories — for instance, a solar unit wouldn't receive credit on a megawatt for megawatt basis, since it can't be dispatched. As I see it, the specifics still need to be worked out.

Paul Patterson

analyst
#73

Typically, you'd assume that PJM's capacity regulations and such, along with what PJM aims for regarding reserve margin, would be the framework here. Should we be thinking about it that way, or?

Ralph Izzo

executive
#74

Paul, that's exactly how I view it, since obviously you'd want to prevent the free rider scenario—New Jersey isn't going to cut off its ties to the remainder of PJM. You're not implying this, but suppose New Jersey crafted an FRR that opened up more chances for reliability issues in New Jersey to be covered by the rest of PJM, yet New Jersey doesn't cover the costs; that strikes me as unfair. Right, I believe we're all aware that at present PJM's reserve margins are above what it officially mandates. Likely, if New Jersey merely adhered to PJM's FRR stipulations, that would align more with what they've historically cited around 16%, rather than above 20%; this is why I believe there should be worries regarding the residual market.

Paul Patterson

analyst
#75

Certainly. All right, thank you very much.

Carlotta Chan

executive
#76

Tiffany, let's have one last question.

Constantine Lednev

analyst
#77

Good morning to everyone; Shah is not on the line, so this is Constantine speaking on his behalf.

Ralph Izzo

executive
#78

Hello there, Constantine.

Constantine Lednev

analyst
#79

Just a fast question. We seem to keep switching between distribution, transmission, and generation quite often. At a high level, when we consider the Clean Energy Future programs plus advanced metering energy efficiency possibilities alongside this update you might be contemplating, how does that convert into opportunity? I'm simply considering in total that you serve roughly 2.3 million customers, and what would be an efficient pace at which you believe you'd roll out AMI, and how should we think about the overall trajectory?

Ralph Izzo

executive
#80

The yearly pace, Constantine, I don't have memorized, the $25 billion for energy efficiency spanned 6 years, and we are convinced we can deploy it. Currently we hold authority to commit $111 million across the coming 6 months. Not all of it will be spent within 6 months, if we could commit it according to demand for our programs, I'm fairly confident. I'm extremely confident about that. Our AMI estimate comes to roughly a $500 million-$600 million investment, covering all 2 million electric customers. Our gas system possesses a rather extensive amount of drive-by reading capability. Regarding electric vehicles and storage, that's the area where it truly is merely a matter of what regulatory appetite and enthusiasm exist. The state has a 600 MW battery storage goal for 2021, which it obviously will not achieve. We're only proposing $100 million for 30 MW. Should the state wish to pursue that 2021 target truly aggressively, we could do considerably more. Electric vehicles raises a comparable question of what appetite exists; we propose a $300 million program for a range of different charging station infrastructure deployments. In total, if you sum those figures, it's $3.5 billion across 6 years, with EE being the single largest component and AMI likely being somewhat more of the back-end loaded portion in terms of once approval arrives and then deployment begins.

Dan Cregg

executive
#81

So look, by the time you actually get that deployed across the whole customer base, you're probably looking at several years. One thing I'd point to with AMI that stands out is that it really comes across as an all-or-nothing kind of deal. It's not like you'd install AMI at every third home. Either you deploy AMI or you don't — there's more of a binary quality to it. Getting that complete rollout done, I'm not sure, probably 3 or 4 years or so, it depends on how fast you go; working through the whole thing is going to take some time.

Constantine Lednev

analyst
#82

All right, that's quite useful. One brief follow-up regarding offshore wind, the schedule, and the sorts of chances ahead. Have you committed, or is there a date by which you plan to commit with Ørsted? In what way are you preparing for potential RFPs in New Jersey or elsewhere?

Ralph Izzo

executive
#83

No commitment has been made as of yet. We must settle that before the end of the third quarter of this year. I believe Ørsted and we alike would prefer to have it happen sooner rather than later, yet we're unwilling to proceed while lacking full confidence that our due diligence has been finished. We've kept ownership of a different site left over from our earlier partnership with Deepwater Wind, which Ørsted purchased. That location, I'd say, truly offers access to three states — Maryland, Delaware, and New Jersey — when it comes to upcoming solicitation.

Constantine Lednev

analyst
#84

Alright, that's quite useful. Is there any thinking on your end regarding partnerships and structures as you move ahead, or is it still too soon to say?

Ralph Izzo

executive
#85

Yes, those talks are already happening with Ørsted, and I would prefer not to engage in an extended public discussion on the matter until we've settled it together with our future partner.

Constantine Lednev

analyst
#86

Okay, that's very helpful.

Ralph Izzo

executive
#87

Thanks.

Constantine Lednev

analyst
#88

Thanks so much.

Ralph Izzo

executive
#89

We appreciate you being with us today, and for the rest of next week plus a handful of dates beyond that, we'll be traveling. It would be our pleasure to get together with people and continue the discussion. There's obviously quite a bit on the table regarding the FERC MOPR and where regulatory rulings are headed. I have to say, some recent developments in New Jersey have left us feeling upbeat. You might remember the white paper about the utility's part in energy efficiency that was released at the close of last year. The Energy Master Plan is now out. Procedural schedules are appearing for every piece of our CEF filing, and we've secured an extension worth $111 million covering only the coming six months. Naturally, we're never happy with how fast things move, but when it comes to the conversation itself and the substance of our utility's ongoing expansion in ways that serve the customer, we're satisfied with the direction. Looking forward to meeting all of you on the road, and thanks for being with us today.

Operator

operator
#90

Everyone, this brings today’s conference call to an end. You’re welcome to hang up now. Thanks for joining us.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Public Service Enterprise Group Incorporated transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Public Service Enterprise Group Incorporated earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Public Service Enterprise Group Incorporated or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.