Public Service Enterprise Group Incorporated (PEG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 30, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Carlotta Chan
executiveAppreciate that, Sylvia. Hello everyone, and thanks for joining us on this earnings call. You can find PSEG's third quarter 2020 earnings release attachments along with slides that break down operating results by company posted on our website at investor.pseg.com, and we'll be filing our 10-Q shortly. Forward-looking statements and estimates that carry various risks and uncertainties appear in the earnings release as well as in other matters we'll be discussing on today's call. Our discussion will cover non-GAAP operating earnings and non-GAAP Adjusted EBITDA, both of which differ from net income as reported under generally accepted accounting principles in the United States; reconciliations of our non-GAAP financial measures, plus a disclaimer regarding forward-looking statements, are included on our IR website and in today's earnings material. At this point I'll hand the call over to Ralph Izzo, Chairman, President, and Chief Executive Officer of PSEG. Dan Cregg, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, is joining Ralph on today's call. Once their remarks conclude, we'll open things up for your questions. Ralph?
Ralph Izzo
executiveThanks, Carlotta, and good morning to all of you for being with us. For the third quarter of 2020, PSEG posted non-GAAP operating earnings of $0.96 per share, compared with $0.98 per share during the same quarter a year ago. On a GAAP basis, PSEG's third-quarter results came in at $1.14 per share, versus $0.79 per share for the third quarter of 2019. With these third-quarter results, non-GAAP operating earnings for the year-to-date now stand at $2.78 per share, a 5.3% increase over the $2.64 per share recorded in the opening months of 2019; that showing is driven by robust performance from our regulated operations at PSE&G, cost discipline at both the utility and PSEG Power, reduced pension expense, and the beneficial resolution of tax audits we discussed last quarter. At both PSE&G and PSEG Power, we turned in a strong quarter. We are revising PSEG's 2020 non-GAAP operating earnings guidance to a range of $3.35-$3.50 per share, which takes $0.05 per share off the bottom end of the range we originally provided. Last month, the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities — the BPU, as I'll call them — gave approval to the settlement covering the energy efficiency portion of our Clean Energy Future filing. As you're aware, back in October of 2018 we put forward a comprehensive filing spanning energy efficiency, Energy Cloud, and electric vehicles and storage, aimed at advancing the objectives of New Jersey's Clean Energy Act. Thanks to the BPU's landmark ruling on energy efficiency, PSE&G will be able to put $1 billion to work over three years toward bringing universal access to energy efficiency for every New Jersey customer; these programs will reduce customer bills, cut their carbon footprint, and provide them with more control over how they use energy. PSE&G's Clean Energy Future energy efficiency program will additionally set up a clean energy jobs training program, generate over 3,200 direct jobs, and allow all New Jersey residents to share in avoiding 8 million metric tons of carbon emissions through 2050. The remaining $1 billion of CEF programs we have proposed to carry out — namely Energy Cloud, also referred to as advanced metering infrastructure, plus expansion of electric vehicle infrastructure and energy storage — move into hearing stages later this year. We anticipate those concluding in the first quarter of 2021. During the first half of the summer, our service territory saw notably warmer weather, which, together with the ongoing reopening of the New Jersey economy, helped temper the 7% load loss experienced earlier in the year as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. Since the spring, New Jersey has aggressively managed its positivity rate, with some recent resurgence, yet it continues a phased reopening of businesses, schools, and activities, and that will shape the pace of economic recovery ahead. Acknowledging the severe economic strain the pandemic has inflicted on many of our customers, PSE&G, working alongside Governor Murphy and the BPU, pushed the non-safety-related shutoff moratorium out to March of 2021 for residential electric and gas service. For commercial and industrial customers, the shutoff moratoriums will remain in place through November 15th. When it comes to keeping essential services running, PSEG will, just as it always has, arrange alternative payment plans with customers who need them, and we'll make sure people know about the assistance programs out there, including LIHEAP. All of our employees keep receiving the most current health and safety guidance and protocols. A new mobile app went live not long ago, and it features a health questionnaire for both employees and contractors who are physically showing up at a PSEG site. A large share of our workforce is still getting the job done remotely, effectively so. Our careful planning for re-entry is still underway. As we head into these crucial winter months, our cross-functional executive crisis management team keeps watching how COVID-19 is affecting the business; back in early August, Tropical Storm Isaias tore through the New York-New Jersey region, bringing strong winds and heavy rain in a storm that moved quickly and knocked out power for roughly 1 million of our customers across New Jersey and Long Island. Of all the storms we've dealt with since Superstorm Sandy hit in 2012, this one caused by far the most damage. COVID-19 restrictions compounded the storm's effects on multiple fronts. Nearly 3,000 mutual aid workers in New Jersey and more than 5,000 on Long Island joined PSEG and PSEG Long Island around the clock to get service back. Here in New Jersey, 90% of our customers had power restored inside 72 hours. Wind was the main driver of this storm, and it did serious physical damage to poles and wires. Throughout the storm, PSEG's transmission system stayed online with no outages at all, which highlights how our transmission investment programs deliver reliability and resiliency benefits. Things were tougher on the PSEG Long Island side. Within 72 hours, we managed to restore 80% of the customers who had lost service. That said, our communications with customers and our restoration time estimates fell short of what we expect of ourselves, and we're correcting that. Over the last six years, we've made dramatic customer service improvements on Long Island, and J.D. Power just named PSEG Long Island the most improved utility in the country on customer service metrics across that span. We remain committed to getting better all the time. What we took away from Tropical Storm Isaias will be put to use to drive customer satisfaction even higher. Turning to regulation, confidential settlement talks are ongoing with the BPU and other parties regarding the return on equity tied to PSEG's Federal Energy Regulatory Commission formula rates for transmission. On the state side, the energy efficiency ruling that greenlights a $1 billion investment across 3 years works out to an annual run rate of roughly $350 million, which is close to a tenfold jump over what we used to spend each year on energy efficiency. Through a clause mechanism, these investments will get recovery of and on capital at the currently authorized return on equity of 9.6%, and they'll be amortized over 10 years, with no incentives or penalties in the first five years after the program begins. The 10-year energy efficiency programs the BPU approved will help New Jersey reach its preliminary energy savings targets — 2.15% for electricity and 1.1% for gas — within five years. Also, under the energy efficiency settlement, a conservation incentive program got the BPU's approval, designed to give us a lost revenue recovery mechanism tied to sales fluctuations caused by energy efficiency, weather, and other variables. Electric revenues under this conservation incentive program start in June 2021, while gas revenues begin in October 2021. Turning to the power side, lower loads from COVID-19, cheap natural gas, and plentiful generation keep shaping current market conditions. Because those conditions persist, PJM day-ahead around-the-clock prices stayed in the mid-teens to low $20 per MW hour on most days in the third quarter, even though a few weather-driven spikes pushed above $30 per MW hour during the summer. With PJM day-ahead power prices stuck at low levels, the economic strain on our base load carbon-free nuclear units grows even tougher. PSEG Power just filed its application to extend the Zero Emission Certificate program, which I'll call ZEC, through 2025, as the 2018 ZEC law requires. We expect a final BPU decision in April of 2021.
Ralph Izzo
executiveThe application we submitted on October 1st shows that the financial justification for the zero carbon attribute payment has grown over the past two years, since energy prices have fallen further and keep squeezing whether our New Jersey nuclear units can remain economically viable. Adding evidentiary hearings to the second ZEC proceeding will make things more transparent, and in our view the application backs the case for an attribute payment above $10 per megawatt for Salem and Hope Creek. According to a new Brattle report, keeping our New Jersey nuclear units running by extending the $10 per MWh attribute payment would save customers roughly $175 million annually in lower energy costs across the next 10 years. The New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection also commented, in a report released not long ago that assessed how far the state has come in cutting greenhouse gas emissions, targeting 80% by the year 2050. Among the recommendations in the DEP's 80x50 report is holding onto carbon-free resources that already exist, which includes the state's 3 nuclear power plants. That is a direct quote; they described it as a key path to reducing emissions from the electric power generation sector. As our state and region increasingly shift toward carbon-free energy, keeping existing nuclear generation — today the reliability backbone of New Jersey's zero carbon energy mix — will only become more important. On the ESG side, I'm happy to report that we have built equity into our diversity and inclusion programs, broadening our commitment via new and ongoing initiatives aimed at making sure every employee can access the benefits and opportunities the company provides, while also promoting equity in our lower-income communities. When it comes to governance, we keep earning first-tier scores for our contributions disclosure and transparency, as cited in the 2020 update of the Corporate Political Disclosure and Accountability Index, also known as the CPA-Zicklin Index, where a score of 85.7 puts us above both the S&P 500 company average and the utility average score of 77.2. Moving to earnings guidance, as I said, we are narrowing PSEG's non-GAAP operating earnings guidance for full-year 2020 by taking $0.05 per share off the lower end. That brings our guidance range to $3.35-$3.50 per share, reflecting solid results through the first nine months of the year and our continued confidence that we can manage costs effectively at both businesses, keep executing on PSE&G's investment programs, and give New Jersey safe, reliable sources of efficient and zero carbon electricity. We still expect regulated operations to deliver nearly 80% of total non-GAAP operating earnings for the year, which reflects the benefits of PSE&G's ongoing investment in New Jersey's energy infrastructure; we also remain on track to execute on the PSEG five-year $13 billion-$15.7 billion capital plan without needing to issue new equity, and our liquidity position at September 30th stood at nearly $5 billion. PSEG is still carrying out due diligence and holding talks with Ørsted as it gets ready to bring a final recommendation to our board of directors about whether to put money into an equity stake of as much as 25% in the Ocean Wind project. Our decision should be made public later this year. Also, before I get into the financial review, I want to note that after our announcement in late July that PSEG was looking at strategic alternatives for Power's non-nuclear generating fleet, feedback from investors and regulators has been positive. Our plan to speed up PSEG's transformation into a mainly regulated electric and gas utility plus contracted zero-carbon generation is moving forward as expected. This process remains at an early stage, and by the end of this year we expect to start marketing a potential transaction in one or a series of steps. Should that succeed, we ought to finish the process at some point during 2021. At this point I'll hand the call to Dan so he can give you more detail on our operating results, and once he finishes speaking I'll be here for your questions.
Dan Cregg
executiveOkay, thanks, Ralph, and good morning to everyone. As Ralph mentioned, for Q3 2020, PSEG's non-GAAP operating earnings came in at $0.96 per share, compared to $0.98 per share during the same quarter last year. On slide nine, we've given you details about how each business contributed to non-GAAP operating earnings for the quarter. Slide 10 has a waterfall chart walking you through the quarter-over-quarter net changes in non-GAAP operating earnings by major business. Now I'll go through each company more closely, beginning with PSE&G. PSE&G posted net income of $0.61 per share for Q3 2020, versus net income of $0.68 per share for Q3 2019, as you can see on slide 14. The utility's third-quarter results showed continued growth from our investment programs, which was offset by certain items—mainly tax adjustments that are timing-related. Looking at the year-to-date period, PSE&G's results remain on track to meet our full-year guidance, thanks to revenue growth from ongoing capital investment programs, lower pension expense, and cost control. Transmission investment contributed $0.04 per share to third-quarter net income. Electric margin came in $0.01 per share favorable versus the year-earlier quarter, driven by higher weather-normalized residential volumes, which were mostly offset by lower commercial and industrial demand. Summer 2020 weather was $0.01 per share better than the weather in Q3 2019. O&M expense was $0.03 unfavorable compared to Q3 2019, mainly due to our internal labor costs from Tropical Storm Isaias and the timing of certain maintenance activities, partially offset by reversing certain COVID-19-related costs that had been recognized in prior quarters. In July, the BPU gave PSE&G authorization to defer certain expenses incurred as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. To reflect that order, PSE&G deferred certain COVID-19-related O&M and gas bad debt expense that had been recorded previously, and set up a corresponding regulatory asset of roughly $0.05 per share for future recovery. Partially offsetting this timing item, PSE&G reversed a $0.04 accrual of revenue under the weather normalization clause for collection of lower gas margins resulting from a warmer than normal winter earlier in the year, due to recovery limitations under that clause's earnings test. Distribution-related depreciation reduced net income by $0.01 per share, while non-operating pension expense was $0.01 per share favorable compared with last year's third quarter. Flow-through taxes and other items cut net income by $0.07 per share versus Q3 2019, primarily driven by timing of taxes and taxes tied to bad debt expense. Most of these tax items should reverse about half in the fourth quarter, with taxes related to bad debts reversing in the future based on when actual write-offs occur. Summer weather in the third quarter, as measured by the temperature-humidity index, was nearly 18% warmer than normal and 7% warmer than Q3 2019. On a weather-normalized basis, electric sales dropped roughly 1% in the quarter compared with a year earlier, which once again mirrors the gains in residential volumes that only partly make up for weaker commercial and industrial sales. Residential weather-normalized sales rose 7%, driven by the work-from-home effects of COVID-19. Meanwhile, C&I sales fell about 6%, since numerous segments of the New Jersey economy have still not completely reopened. Even so, on a net margin basis, residential margins — powered by volumes that are 5% year-to-date weather normalized — have made up for the margin hit from reduced C&I demand. PSEG's capital program is still on track. During the third quarter, PSEG put about $700 million to work, and $1.9 billion through September 30th, as part of a 2020 capital investment program totaling roughly $2.7 billion for infrastructure upgrades at its transmission and distribution facilities, aimed at maintaining reliability, boosting resiliency, and replacing aging energy infrastructure. The Clean Energy Future energy efficiency investment gets underway later this year and will climb to about $125 million in 2021, then reach a full annual run rate of approximately $350 million in 2022. Our forecast still calls for more than 90% of PSEG's planned capital investment to go to the utility across the 2020 to 2024 timeframe. Earlier this month, PSEG submitted its annual transmission formula rate update to FERC, reflecting net plant additions among other updates. PJM cost reallocations will more than cover the higher revenue requirements of roughly $119 million, producing a net decrease in costs for PSEG customers once implemented in January of 2021. PSEG's full-year net income forecast has been revised to $1.325 billion-$1.355 billion, up from $1.310 billion-$1.370 billion. Now let's turn to PSEG Power. PSEG Power posted third quarter non-GAAP operating earnings of $0.33 per share and non-GAAP Adjusted EBITDA of $349 million. That's against non-GAAP operating earnings of $0.29 per share and non-GAAP Adjusted EBITDA of $322 million in the third quarter of 2019. Non-GAAP Adjusted EBITDA leaves out the same items as our non-GAAP operating earnings measure, plus income tax expense, interest expense, depreciation, and amortization expense. The earnings release and Slide 20 give you a detailed analysis of the items affecting PSEG Power's non-GAAP operating earnings relative to net income quarter-over-quarter. We've also given you more detail on generation for the quarter and for year-to-date 2020 on Slides 21 and 22. Several items positively affected PSEG Power's third quarter non-GAAP operating earnings, improving results by $0.04 per share compared to the year-ago quarter. The scheduled increase in PJM's capacity revenue on June 1st lifted non-GAAP operating earnings comparisons by $0.03 per share against the third quarter of 2019. Lower generation volumes cut results by $0.02 per share versus the third quarter of 2019, reflecting last year's sale of the Keystone and Conemaugh coal units, along with somewhat weaker market demand. Recontracting and market impacts trimmed results by $0.02 per share versus the year-ago quarter. Results from gas operations came in $0.02 per share higher. A reduction in O&M expense contributed $0.03 per share favorably relative to the third quarter a year earlier, driven by decreased fossil maintenance costs, which included not having a major outage at Linden that had taken place during the third quarter of 2019. Interest and depreciation expenses both being lower together contributed an additional $0.01 per share compared with the same quarter last year; additionally, in that quarter, New Jersey passed a rise in the corporate surtax to 2.5% within its fiscal year 2021 budget, and that pulled comparisons down by $0.01 per share against the third quarter of 2019. Gross margin during the third quarter reached $33 per MWh, which was $2 per MWh better than the third quarter of 2019, primarily driven by the planned capacity price increase tied to the new energy year that started on June 1st. Throughout the summer, power prices along with natural gas prices remained low, since diminished commercial activity spanning PJM, New York, and Maryland led to weaker loads and offset the bulk of demand spikes caused by weather. Now looking at power's operations, total generating output fell 9% to 14.9 terawatt-hours in the third quarter, a result of divesting Keystone and Conemaugh. Output from PSEG Power's combined cycle fleet totaled 6.7 terawatt-hours, a decline of 7%, due to weaker market demand stemming from continuing COVID-19-related effects on economic activity within the state.
Dan Cregg
executiveDuring the quarter, the nuclear fleet ran at an average capacity factor of 95.7%, generating 8.2 TWh — a 5% increase compared with the third quarter of 2019 — and that accounted for 55% of total generation. PSEG Power still expects its 2020 total output to come in at 50 to 52 TWh. Looking at what's left of 2020, Power has hedged somewhere around 95%-100% of production at an average price of $36 per MWh; for 2021, Power has hedged 75%-80% of forecast production of 48 to 50 TWh at an average price of $35 per MWh. PSEG Power is also projecting output of 48 to 50 TWh for 2022, and roughly 35%-40% of PSEG Power's output in 2022 is hedged at an average price of $34 per MWh. We're revising our forecast of PSEG Power's non-GAAP operating earnings for 2020 to a range of $385 million-$430 million, down from $345 million-$435 million. Our estimate for non-GAAP operating EBITDA moves to a range of $980 million-$1.045 billion, from $950 million-$1.050 billion. Let me touch briefly on operating results from Enterprise and Other, which reported net income of $8 million, or $0.02 per share, for the third quarter of 2020, versus net income of $6 million, or $0.10 per share, in the third quarter of 2019. Net income for the quarter reflects continuing contributions from PSEG Long Island and lower taxes, partly offset by a small loss on the sale of the Powerton and Joliet investments at Energy Holdings. The 2020 forecast for PSEG Enterprise and Other has been revised to a net loss of $10 million from a net loss of $5 million. PSEG closed the third quarter with more than $4.9 billion of available liquidity, including roughly $966 million of cash on hand, and debt made up 52% of our consolidated capital; in August, PSEG issued $550 million of five-year senior notes at 80 basis points, along with $550 million of 10-year senior notes at 1.6%, and paid off $500 million of the 364-day term loan agreements issued in the spring. PSEG also holds $700 million of floating rate term loans maturing in November of 2020. Also in August, PSE&G issued $375 million of 30-year secured medium-term notes at a coupon rate of 2.05% and retired $250 million of MTNs at maturity. After PSEG announced it would explore strategic alternatives for Power's non-nuclear fleet, S&P cut PSEG Power's credit ratings to BBB with a stable outlook from BBB+ with a stable outlook, noting its view that PSEG Power was no longer seen as core to PSEG. S&P's rationale reflects its family rating methodology, which had previously given Power a one-notch uplift because of that core designation. Moody's also published updated issuer comments after the announcement and kept Power's credit ratings unchanged at Baa1, with a stable outlook. Power's debt as a percentage of capital fell to 28% at September 30th, and we still expect to fully fund PSEG's five-year $13 billion-$15.7 billion capital investment program over the 2020 to 2024 period without issuing new equity. Ralph already touched on this, but to add to it: for the entire year, our non-GAAP operating earnings guidance has been tightened. We took $0.05 per share off the bottom of what we'd originally projected, and the range now stands at $3.35 to $3.50 per share. That wraps up what I wanted to say. Sylvia, let's open it up for questions.
Jeremy Tonet
analystHi, good morning.
Dan Cregg
executiveMorning, Jeremy.
Jeremy Tonet
analystI'd like to begin with offshore wind, if that works. I'm curious whether Ørsted's recent comments about delays affecting certain onshore projects in the U.S. have any bearing on how you're thinking and what you're doing here, and do you have any reaction to some of what Ørsted has heard in New Jersey, some criticism that came up lately?
Ralph Izzo
executiveJeremy, I'd put it this way: because this sector is still so young, honestly, every one of us anticipated that regulators would take time. What I believe you're pointing to in New Jersey had to do with how much offshore wind would contribute to economic growth. When something is this new, what people expect in terms of jobs created versus the jobs actually delivered, and how quickly that unfolds, don't line up perfectly, yet the trajectory is fully in sync. The state is still dedicated to expanding this industry. Ørsted is still dedicated to backing its project through the hiring commitments it offered in its solicitation, and I believe this simply comes down to people needing to communicate with one another more frequently regarding how much and how soon. Nobody is arguing about which way this is headed.
Jeremy Tonet
analystUnderstood. That's clear to me. From what you're saying, it seems this wouldn't change how willing you are to take part in upcoming bidding rounds for offshore wind, such as the one anticipated shortly.
Ralph Izzo
executiveRight, that's accurate; our position has stayed the same — if we were to take on that 25% equity stake, we'd do it only anticipating involvement in a future solicitation. A single, standalone project wouldn't hold much appeal for us.
Jeremy Tonet
analystUnderstood, got it. Let me shift topics—any perspective on the BPU's FRR evaluation slipping? What might be causing that delay, in your view? And do you have a sense of how that FRR study might affect the ZEC application you filed?
Ralph Izzo
executiveYeah, well, I want this to land clearly with everyone, and I'd ask that I be quoted so it reaches the BPU. Credit where it's due: the BPU has stuck to a schedule amid a genuinely ambitious set of priorities. Consider everything they've gotten done—wrapping up the first offshore wind solicitation, issuing the second, and kicking off the FRR analysis. The pivotal window for New Jersey arrives when offshore wind projects reach commercial operation in 2024, and that won't be the full 1,000 megawatts—only a portion of it—so we must avoid paying for capacity two times over. The PJM capacity auction most likely won't happen until late in 2021 at the earliest, and quite possibly in 2022. As far as I know, the BPU process is tracking the timeline its staff set forth: toward the close of this year or the start of next, their consultants' report should come out, after which they'll weigh whether legislation is needed; our view is that it isn't, though the design will determine that. Jeremy, I'd put it this way—at this stage, they're well positioned to sidestep that double capacity payment by the time of the 2024 auction.
Jeremy Tonet
analystUnderstood. That's really useful. I'll stop here. Thank you.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystHey, good morning, everyone. Thanks for making the time. I appreciate it.
Ralph Izzo
executiveHi, Julien.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystHi there, good morning, and I appreciate the clarification you gave a moment ago. That was crystal clear. Still, I'd like to revisit something. What's your current thinking when it comes to strategic choices regarding the nuclear business as things stand right now? And I'd be interested to know whether a sale or a spin might be something you'd be open to, and I'm certain all of you have seen some of the press coverage circulating out there. I just want to get out in front of that and find out whether that figures into your deliberations in any way.
Ralph Izzo
executiveJulien, we chose to concentrate solely on our non-nuclear assets for two reasons. The first was to reinforce further what we consider a robust ESG position. The second, as you're aware, is that Dan and I just spoke about how we're currently in the midst of applying for round two of the ZEC process. We felt it wouldn't be fair to New Jersey or the BPU to carry out a ZEC process while remaining ignorant of who nuclear's ultimate owners could be. We'd be delighted to own and run nuclear plants provided they satisfy the state's energy requirements, provided they move the state toward its carbon goals. There's a crucial third condition: they have to be economically viable. Absent the ZECs, those plants aren't economically viable; actually, I can't share specifics since the financials we filed are confidential, but they genuinely require in excess of $10 per MWh. We were prepared to run them at $10 a MWh since we do believe the trajectory of public policy, in New Jersey and across the country, points toward growing acknowledgment of how vital carbon-free energy is for mitigating climate change, and that value will ultimately be recognized more completely. Without such payment, we'd have no ability to run those plants. That's a familiar tale, isn't it? Since that's been the situation for no fewer than three or four years at this point. I don't know of any press coverage that you're alluding to, so I won't be able to address that. I'm confident there will be persistent scrutiny of this regulatory process.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystUnderstood. All right, that's sufficiently clear. Regarding what you're disclosing to the BPU — clearly, transparency has been discussed a great deal, along with the necessity of nuclear backing in numerous states. I'm certain you know this. Could you discuss how this particular instance may vary from the prior initial ZEC request, particularly when it comes to disclosure? I realize it might not all be public, necessarily. I'm simply wondering whether you might expand on that somewhat.
Ralph Izzo
executiveAs you're aware, round two has two primary distinctions compared with round one, and then I'll hand things to Dan momentarily; during round two, a far more transparent public proceeding exists, which in our view benefits everybody. December brings a preliminary decision, then evidentiary hearings, a response to that preliminary decision, and April brings the final decision. My view is that this is excellent since, well, those plants are essential. As we noted, they spare customers close to $200 million annually, $175 million annually across 10 years. They remove 13 million tons of carbon each year; they supply jobs for 1,600 PSEG employees, 5,000 employees overall. The truth is, given the present benefits that natural gas enjoys absent any carbon price and given subsidized renewable levels that sit far above nuclear's cost, these plants face enormous economic drawbacks. No particularly sophisticated analysis is required. NEI released the typical expense of running a nuclear facility, roughly $30 per MWh. Indeed, when you examine what round-the-clock prices do in net capacity, it's approximately $30 a MWh. Unless your belief is that firms ought to put over $1 billion annually in for no return, those plants aren't dependable. Naturally, the final characteristic beyond their carbon-free power is that they serve as base load workhorses. For all our eagerness about wind and solar, mother nature doesn't obey us. The dispatch ability of those resources, as we all recognize, demands battery storage or another storage method. That merely piles extra economic suffering onto customers beyond what they already endure. Nuclear wins handily, and I'm confident the regulatory process will confirm it.
Dan Cregg
executiveJulien, regarding this and basically how the whole process works, I believe Ralph already covered whatever I might have contributed. The sole additional point I'd make is that as this process gets underway, the pricing conditions we face have grown tougher. Looking at things from the perspective of the surroundings these facilities operate within, from a market standpoint, you've got forward prices that keep falling and additional zero cost energy entering the grid; from an economic angle, that's harder than what we saw previously. Over roughly the coming six months, we'll work through the process Ralph laid out.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystFantastic. That's great. Appreciate it, everyone.
Constantine Lednev
analystHello there. Morning to you all. This is Constantine speaking — I'm filling in for Shar. Thank you for such a thorough briefing. I was hoping to dig a little deeper into what you're thinking regarding the infrastructure initiatives and the Clean Energy Future efforts. When it comes to sustaining those CapEx levels over the long haul, in what ways would initiatives like these move New Jersey toward its wider policy objectives? Along those same lines, what sort of runway exists — if you will — for infrastructure efforts such as GSMP and Energy Strong, among others?
Ralph Izzo
executiveThose are solid questions. You get two answers that connect to each other yet differ somewhat, correct? When you look at those conventional infrastructure initiatives, keep in mind that our objective isn't constructing additional infrastructure to serve rising demand — that used to be the core rationale for utilities across many decades, through most of the 1900s. What we're dealing with instead is the need to swap out infrastructure that has grown old, and the reason isn't demand growth. It stems from several different causes, among them our society's growing dependence on electricity and weather patterns that have become more severe, which we attribute to climate change. Other people are free to hold different views. The effort to replace old infrastructure doesn't really have an endpoint, because you can't possibly replace every bit of that aging infrastructure in just a few years. The cost would simply be too high. So you end up in a situation like what happened with our Gas System Modernization Program: even spending the $400 million annually that we do right now, we'd still have 20 more years of work ahead of us. By the time we mark 10 years since launching that program, our newest pipe will already be 30 years old. Certain pipes that are 50 years old today will have reached 70 years old at that stage. Our transmission system and our substations are in the same situation. You're likely aware that the final segment of our electrical network remains completely unaddressed, correct? Within our regulated utility, we've seen expansion reach double-digit levels or come quite near that mark, with the primary focus being cast iron gas main transmission along with electric substations. Since homeowners today place greater emphasis on dependability—a trend we anticipate will continue beyond Covid—we foresee that enhancing reliability all the way to the residence, that concluding portion, will become increasingly essential. In New Jersey, there is enthusiasm for helping the state bounce back from its current economic downturn by accelerating a portion of that infrastructure replacement work and broadening stimulus-oriented initiatives, as this counts as vital labor. So that might push us, at least for a little while, to stray from the single binding constraint on how much investment is needed. And that constraint is what happens to the customer's bill. As you likely know, we've always tried to hold a consistent cadence, so that the money we recover through clauses, together with the formula rate mechanism at FERC—state-level clause recovery plus the FERC formula rate approach—allows us to keep swapping out infrastructure while still letting the bill go up about in step with CPI. By the way, that bill is 30% below where it stood ten years ago in nominal dollars, and 40% beneath its level from a decade ago once you adjust for inflation. Stimulus could permit us to bend that guideline somewhat, simply acknowledging that moving utility bills from 3% of disposable income to 3.06% of disposable income represents a worthwhile trade-off to get folks working and accomplish significant infrastructure upgrades. Beyond that, however, lies the matter you raised regarding Clean Energy Future. Those are distinct conditions, correct? For us, our emphasis is placed on energy efficiency, something I refer to as the quadruple winner. It means 8 million fewer tons of carbon released into the air, so the environment benefits. Participating customers see reduced bills, and actually, the entire customer base enjoys net savings totaling $1 billion. Customers are pleased. We believe we can generate over 4,000 jobs, so the economy is pleased. Our shareholders receive a 9.6% ROE along with a contemporaneous return on the investment. This is simply an extraordinary investment prospect and unlocks an entirely new rate base definition for us. One that I'm absolutely certain the state will want to extend past the program's three years. Indeed, considering the $1 billion three-year grant approval we got, that reflects a quicker run rate during the initial phase compared to the $2.5 billion six-year program we'd initially put forward. Regarding the state's ambitions for alternative clean technologies like offshore wind and solar, the situation differs. Those are considerably pricier, and they'll need to depend on the price curve descending and technology driving that price lower, with the state moderating its appetite for them so as not to overload consumers. As for the sectors we're engaged in, I hold a great deal of confidence that support for carrying on with them is quite robust. Apologies for the lengthy response.
Constantine Lednev
analystNo, that's certainly very much appreciated. Going back once more to build a bit further on the fossil asset sale process and a few of the ideas surrounding it. Clearly, a fairly strong collection of assets is on the market, and the equity portion of the price tag is certainly going to be substantial, simply because there isn't a lot of leverage on the business. I'm curious to hear some of your thinking on capital recycling and what would take priority for reinvestment, buybacks, and how to keep everything efficient.
Dan Cregg
executiveYeah; that's a terrific question. You're correct, if you look at PSEG Power, it isn't very heavily levered. At the moment, about $2.4 billion in debt remains unpaid. When a potential deal wraps up, you'd see approximately $1 billion getting retired at that point. That leaves roughly $1.4 billion. What you just said, I'm on board with. Given how strong the assets are that we're talking about, that should provide plenty of capital—more than enough, you'd think—to take care of that debt. Right, you'd be looking at paying off that debt, which means, more than anything, you'd be looking at having surplus capital. Typically what gets communicated is really general corporate purposes, I'd say, and in this situation I believe that's the right thing to communicate. There's a capital program already on the books that I think we've talked about. There was talk about potentially finding additional capital. Our five-year plan has consistently included a forecast where capital needs go down. Once we get to the end of that five-year stretch, we've identified additional opportunities beyond it. It's still unclear whether some of those might come from a stimulus angle tied to the economic fallout we've experienced because of COVID. Putting more capital to work in the utility is, I believe, where we'd turn first. If we end up with more cash than we need, we'd compare using it for new investment chances against returning it to shareholders, whether through dividends or repurchases, if no such opportunities are available. That's not off the table, though it's definitely not our top priority.
Constantine Lednev
analystAll right, thanks.
Durgesh Chopra
analystHello there, good morning, everyone. I appreciate you taking my question. Ralph, may I return to something? I'd like to confirm that I've got the Conservation Incentive Program straight.
Ralph Izzo
executiveOf course.
Durgesh Chopra
analystWhat would that involve? Would it shield you moving ahead from money lost because of storms, weather, or something such as COVID-19? Could you walk us through it? Also, is this a trial effort in which a filing must be made each second year or similar, or has it essentially become a lasting arrangement now?
Ralph Izzo
executiveDan is going to handle the part about the frequency of our filings. What I do know is that at whatever point we submit, there's no delay that hits us. I can't recall whether it's six or 12 months. No, my point — and I hope this addresses what you asked, if not, simply steer me back the right way — is this: take the city of Newark. We run dual 26KV distribution loops into that city, since we have commercial centers there with thousands of employees arriving daily who count on the lights staying on, the air conditioning running, and the computer systems functioning. Those people aren't there right now. Only four of us are in the office today. The vast majority of our employees are working from home. Now, the reliability level they get at home differs quite a bit from the reliability level we provide to this building; that's not due to this being the PSEG building; it's simply typical for businesses around Newark. If the home is now going to turn into the spot where you not only eat and sleep, but also work — you fill up your gas tank, so to speak, you energize your vehicle, you charge all your information tools, your phone, your computers — then that grid isn't ready to deliver the reliability people will demand when another Isaias strikes, or another Superstorm Sandy, or merely a standard Northeast thunderstorm. Investment in the last mile — what I mean by that is the overhead system — will have to happen if the economy isn't going to grind to a halt during pretty ordinary storm events these days. I'm not saying Sandy was ordinary, but as we've witnessed in certain regions of the country, whether it's the situation in the Gulf or what we've experienced before in the Northeast, the weather events we get are becoming more intense. You cannot tell people to simply quit working for 3 to 5 days when such a weather event occurs while they're working from home. That's my point, and I think policymakers are truly tuning into it. AMI and our capacity to pinpoint outages at each individual customer location will be a benefit to us. Sadly, New Jersey lacks that capability right now. I genuinely believe our BPU commissioners grasp how important it is, and I'm hopeful and optimistic we can settle that within just a few short months. Dan, would you like to say a bit about how we file for these things?
Dan Cregg
executiveAbsolutely. When you consider the objective New Jersey has in mind regarding an energy efficiency initiative, this represents a dramatic shift compared to our past approach. In my view, it will genuinely elevate the state into the top tier nationally when it comes to energy efficiency programs. When you contemplate an initiative of such scale, from the utility's standpoint it matters that, while pursuing it, some mechanism for recovering lost revenue exists. That is precisely what the filing contained. It has been among the subjects we have addressed throughout this process. Our final position essentially drew upon something the gas utilities had mostly utilized for years — namely the CIP, or Conservation Incentive Program. We touched on this briefly during our prepared remarks. This is a yearly submission. It would kick off in 2021. Consider allowing the initiative to become operational as we put the lost revenue recovery mechanism in place for this initiative. It would commence in June on the electric side and in October on the gas side. Given the seasonal patterns of those operations, that approach makes complete sense. This will be filed annually. It is not structured around a lag. Essentially, it will address the variances relative to the baseline year you established. The way I would frame it is that the most recent rate case, from a consumption standpoint, will effectively serve to recover any shortfalls or return any surplus, thereby restoring a more dependable revenue flow. In my opinion, it is an excellent answer to the difficulty created by revenues lost as a result of an energy efficiency initiative. I believe we landed in a very solid position.
Durgesh Chopra
analystThank you, Dan. I'd just like some clarity here — is this strictly about revenues we've lost because of efficiency programs, or does it also take in revenue losses tied to weather shifts, or possibly those caused by storms and similar occurrences?
Dan Cregg
executiveThis covers more than just energy efficiency. The scope includes lost revenues of a wider kind; actually, when you consider the weather normalization clause we have on the gas side, that would basically be paused in light of this. This mechanism would, in a sense, take precedence over it. The coverage is wider.
Durgesh Chopra
analystGreat. That's really helpful. Perhaps a brief follow-up regarding the fossil deals. I'm grateful that you kicked off the process during the previous quarter, aware that elections are coming up soon. Would a possible change in tax rate affect how you're thinking? Is it relevant to that deal, to the potential non-nuclear sale deal?
Dan Cregg
executiveYes. Well, clearly, it's going to influence the dollars coming out of whatever occurs; the fundamental purpose and character of our direction won't shift. That's probably the easiest way to put it.
Durgesh Chopra
analystAll right. Thanks, everyone. I appreciate you taking the time.
Dan Cregg
executiveOf course. Thank you.
David Arcaro
analystMorning, everyone. Appreciate you letting me ask something.
Ralph Izzo
executiveHello there, David.
David Arcaro
analystCan you provide an update — a status report — on where things stand with the transmission ROE matter being discussed with the BPU?
Ralph Izzo
executiveDavid. Sadly, beyond what we already shared during our opening comments, there isn't much I'm able to add, since these matters are confidential. My belief is that plenty of goodwill and good intent continues to exist among everyone involved. Three parties are talking: ourselves, the BPU, and the consumer advocate — that is, the ratepayer advocate. What clearly drives our counterparts at the BPU along with the ratepayer advocate is delivering relief right away to consumers in New Jersey through reduced rates, especially given the added hardships from COVID-19. As for what drives us, it's eliminating a degree of uncertainty about where matters might land were we to go to FERC. Since the time we began these conversations, we've narrowed a substantial divergence in viewpoints. A modest gap still separates us. I truly remain hopeful about whether we can close it, though I can't guarantee that we will. Communication between us continues, and I view that as encouraging. That the gap is modest is also encouraging, yet the matter isn't finished. Saying anything further would breach the confidentiality of it, so I won't.
David Arcaro
analystUnderstood, thanks for the update. What I really wanted to ask about is how you're thinking over the longer term regarding the gas utility side of the business — maybe what your vision is for it — and how you see it, both in light of the ESG move you're making by divesting some merchant assets and in light of the state pushing hard over time to reduce gas consumption.
Ralph Izzo
executiveYeah, that's a question that comes up pretty regularly. I'd say I understand why people raise it, and I respect their right to do so, but when I think about the 10 things that keep me up at night, this one ranks around 100. New Jersey, led by one of America's most environmentally progressive governors, wants us to put additional funding into the gas distribution network, mainly to get rid of the methane that escapes from an old system. Methane's impact over a 100-year horizon is roughly 28 times greater than that of carbon dioxide, as you're aware. So carbon dioxide is 28 times less potent than methane. There's certainly a dedication to maintaining the natural gas infrastructure that's already in place. I'd also mention that natural gas is used for cooking and heating in more than 90% of New Jersey households. Switching those homes to something else would run about $10,000 on average. This applies to numerous residences that, not so long ago, switched away from oil due to worries about energy security as well as pollution. That isn't really a problem anybody will take on anytime soon. Beyond that, I strongly hold the view — being someone who insists our country must act much more boldly on climate change — that the benefit consumers gain from a comparatively clean fuel such as natural gas genuinely pushes the nation toward taking action on carbon capture and storage. Abandoning this resource—one free of SO2, mercury, and fine particulates, with NOx and ozone-related effects already fairly well managed—practically demands a carbon capture and storage fix. In my view, major new pipeline projects are unlikely. Nor do I expect many additional gas plants to go up. What I do anticipate is that households will keep using natural gas to warm their homes and prepare meals for a great many years ahead. Finally, consider this: across the country, our electric grid still runs mostly on fossil fuels—roughly 75%—and here in New Jersey, which belongs to PJM, fossil fuels make up a big share too. So when you take those fossil fuels, lose two-thirds of their energy content as what's called waste heat, turn the remaining one-third into electricity, and then rely on that one-third to warm a home and prepare meals, you're getting a terribly poor return on the environmental dollar. If, on the other hand, you didn't convert it to power at all and simply burned it directly to heat the water or air in a house, the amount of usable energy you'd capture would be much greater. Doing otherwise simply makes no sense, at least for now, and my guess is the same holds over the longer run as carbon capture and storage improves.
David Arcaro
analystAll right, excellent. Thank you very much.
Michael Lapides
analystHi, everyone. To start, congratulations on a solid quarter. I have two questions. The first one concerns New Jersey in particular. When we consider what would need to occur for a bigger build-out of batteries or storage in that state, is the issue one of price, meaning cost? Or is it about market design, regulatory design, and how things are structured? I'd really like to hear your perspective, Ralph.
Ralph Izzo
executiveMike, I simply see it as a matter of how much is already on the plate at this moment. The state, through its Clean Energy Act — passed in May of 2018, signed into law in May of 2018 — set a goal of 600 MW for battery storage by next year. I believe that's by the end of the year. Obviously, we are far from reaching it. When you're paying $98.10 for offshore wind, when your solar renewable energy credit sits at $220, and your transition program for solar renewable energy is at, I think, 150 or 175 per MWh, there's only so much you're willing to place on the customer's plate, correct? Battery storage has been given a somewhat lower priority. I don't believe the state has given up on it, but the state still has a great deal more work to do on some of the core items where you'd expect us to be further along. I've brought up one of them previously: AMI is something that is simply crying out to be implemented, not just because of the operational advantages it delivers, but also because of the consumer advantages it delivers by helping the customer understand where they stand with their bills during a month, rather than waiting until the month is over. What it could mean for us in terms of more granular data and being able to pursue energy efficiency in ways we never did previously. I simply think that battery storage is falling victim to some other priorities.
Michael Lapides
analystUnderstood. And Ralph, one more thing—since the election is coming up next week, clearly one of the candidates has spoken quite candidly about raising corporate income tax rates. What's your take on what that would mean, not only for PSEG, particularly as you're paying less attention to the non-regulated side of things, but also what it would mean for customers, their bills, and how quickly those bills would change?
Ralph Izzo
executiveWell, the regulated side of the business, as you're aware, has historically been in a position to pass taxes along. To be certain, larger taxes are going to create a bigger impact on bills. In that respect, I believe we're getting somewhat ahead of ourselves. I definitely don't want to be someone predicting what could or couldn't take place on Tuesday. If anybody has thoughts about that. Our people here are giving me all kinds of hand signals that our allotted time has run out. Other folks might have commitments they also need to get to. Dan, would you like to proceed?
Dan Cregg
executiveRight, Mike, what I’d say is this: the initial step is that it has to be passed into law, and that process won’t be quick. Once that occurs, like Ralph mentioned, the statutory rate will indeed flow through in the usual way. Also, at present, what you’re observing is excess deferreds flowing back. For some of those excess deferred taxes, there are limitations on what’s possible, while for others there’s more room to maneuver. That, I think, is the second piece of it. Another point I’d make: it’s tempting to view a shift in the tax system as simply the corporate rate moving by X%. But beneath that, typically there are numerous other modifications, and from a cash standpoint those can create quite significant effects, whether favorable or unfavorable, for both the company and the customer. The specifics matter enormously, and often many details exist beyond just the headline rate that can drive impacts upward or downward for both sides of the equation.
Michael Lapides
analystUnderstood. Thanks a lot. Really appreciate it, everyone.
Dan Cregg
executiveThank you, Michael.
Ralph Izzo
executiveAlright, let's wrap things up at this point. It would feel wrong if I didn't take a moment to express our appreciation to each of you for being here, and to share my heartfelt wish that every one of you remains safe, along with your loved ones and friends staying healthy and untouched by this terrible virus and everything it brings. I also want to acknowledge anyone here who knows somebody, or has any connection at all to somebody serving on the front lines as a healthcare provider helping out during what is clearly a second wave and surge of this virus — we want to pass along our gratitude as a company to those people doing that work, whether they're located in the areas where we operate or anywhere else. I know we express our thanks to our team members daily for delivering the services that let those frontline workers carry out their duties. My guess is we'll be seeing a lot of you in 2 weeks at EEI, virtually. Stay safe on Halloween. Keep your kids protected. Put on your mask, scrub your hands, maintain physical distance, and thank you once more. Talk to you soon, everyone.
Dan Cregg
executiveThanks, everybody.
Carlotta Chan
executiveThank you.
Operator
operatorEveryone, that brings today's call to a close. We appreciate your joining us. You can go ahead and hang up now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Public Service Enterprise Group Incorporated transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Public Service Enterprise Group Incorporated earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Public Service Enterprise Group Incorporated or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.