Public Service Enterprise Group Incorporated (PEG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 5, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Carlotta Chan
executiveAppreciate that, Christy. Morning, everyone. PSEG put out its results for the first quarter of 2021 earlier today. You can find the attachments to the earnings release along with today's slides on the PSEG Investor Relations site, and we'll be filing our 10-Q soon. The earnings release, plus other items we'll cover on this call, include forward-looking statements and estimates that carry various risks and uncertainties. We also talk about non-GAAP operating earnings and non-GAAP adjusted EBITDA, both of which differ from net income as reported under generally accepted accounting principles in the United States. Reconciliations for our non-GAAP financial measures, along with a disclaimer about forward-looking statements, are available on our IR website and are part of today's earnings materials. Now I'll hand things over to Ralph Izzo, who serves as Chairman, President, and Chief Executive Officer of Public Service Enterprise Group. Dan Cregg, our Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, is with Ralph on today's call. Once they finish their remarks, we'll open things up for your questions. Ralph.
Ralph Izzo
executiveThanks, Carlotta, and I appreciate everyone being on the call today. It's a pleasure to share that PSEG has hit a number of significant milestones as we work toward our goal of operating mainly as a regulated utility, complemented by a generating fleet that is both substantially under contract and carbon-free. Solid results came out this morning, with non-GAAP operating earnings for Q1 2021 landing at $1.28 per share, compared with $1.03 per share during the same quarter a year ago. On a GAAP basis, our first-quarter figure was likewise $1.28 per share, against $0.88 per share in Q1 2020. Favorable year-over-year comparisons at both businesses were driven by ongoing regulated investments at PSEG as well as cold weather's impact on PSEG Power. You can find the quarter's details laid out on slide five of the earnings presentation. With such an eventful quarter behind us, we're well-positioned to deliver on our financial and strategic objectives for the rest of the year. Starting with our Clean Energy Future programs, which total close to $2 billion and have now shifted from approval into execution, PSEG is contributing to New Jersey's decarbonization in a meaningful and equitable manner. Alongside our Clean Energy Future investments, we've paired a jobs training initiative that creates opportunities for low and middle-income communities across New Jersey. Last week, the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities cast a unanimous vote to grant a continuation of the full $10 per megawatt hour Zero Emission Certificates — I'll refer to them simply as ZECs going forward — for all three of New Jersey's nuclear units, namely Hope Creek, Salem Unit 1, and Salem Unit 2, extending through May of 2025; that represented the maximum award the BPU had the authority to grant; we're grateful for the backing we received from the numerous community, labor, business, environmental, and employee organizations that took part in this tremendously important proceeding. Every one of those groups understands what our nuclear plants deliver: a dependable, around-the-clock, carbon-free electricity supply. Our nuclear team has handled operations at the units throughout this process with the highest professionalism and commitment to safety. I want to congratulate PSEG Nuclear on being acknowledged by INPO as an industry leader in operational reliability — one of just two nuclear fleets industry-wide that recorded no scrams across the past 365 days. By extending the ZEC program, the BPU's decision will push climate action forward in New Jersey, helping preserve the state's biggest carbon-free generating resource, and it aligns with mounting federal interest in keeping existing nuclear alive as a vital component of a clean energy mix; we applaud the BPU's ruling, which serves the best interests of the State of New Jersey and its capacity to meet long-term clean energy targets without sacrificing reliability or reversing environmental progress achieved so far. Going forward, we'll shortly engage with stakeholders to align state and federal climate objectives as we look for ways to lengthen the duration of support for carbon-free nuclear power. This quarter, the BPU gave the green light to PSEG taking a 25% equity stake in Ørsted's Ocean Wind project. On top of that, Ocean Wind got a notice of intent from the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management, known as BOEM, to get an environmental impact statement ready; that same agency is going to look over the construction and operations plan for the project too. Back in April, PJM, working hand in hand with the BPU, kicked off a four-month window for solicitation aimed at finding transmission solutions that would back New Jersey's target for offshore wind generation. This marks PJM's inaugural public policy transmission solicitation, and our company intends to take part in that proceeding. The proposal put forward recently by the Biden administration that centers on climate action plainly backs offshore wind, nuclear generation that already exists, and electrification of transportation — every one of which lines up with PSEG's business plan and its sustainability strategy. PSEG strongly urges and champions a national strategy to speed up net zero emissions across the whole economy, reaching it even before 2050, done in a way that's constructive and grows green jobs through putting money into clean energy infrastructure. My optimism that momentum behind genuine climate action is gaining ground has never been stronger. PSEG keeps pushing forward with our Powering Progress Vision, which folds energy efficiency into electrification of transportation so our customers can use less energy; alongside that, we're working to make the energy our customers consume cleaner, which fits with our push to keep our existing nuclear units running and to explore strategic alternatives for our fossil fleet. We aim to deliver with strong reliability and resiliency, and that connects to what we invest in energy infrastructure and the Energy Cloud. Today, we're also sharing news of progress in our exploration of strategic alternatives: an agreement to sell our Solar Source portfolio to an affiliate of LS Power. A robust marketing process produced this sale, and we're happy with how it turned out. We've concluded the transaction is modestly accretive on a sum of the parts basis and on an operating earnings basis going forward. We anticipate the Solar Source portfolio deal will close in the second or third quarter of 2021, assuming customary, regulatory, and other closing conditions are met. PSEG Power is still exploring strategic alternatives for its fossil generating fleet and right now expects to reach an agreement around mid-year. These anticipated transactions, together with more than a decade of capital allocation aimed mainly at PSEG, leave the remaining company positioned as a primarily regulated electric and gas utility, complemented by a carbon-free nuclear fleet and offshore wind investments that will be highly contracted. The COVID-19 pandemic and the economic fallout from it keep weighing on the New Jersey economy. Because transmission and residential electric and gas make up such a large share of our overall sales mix, that has stabilized margins in our utility business, as has a supportive regulatory order permitting deferral of certain COVID-19 related costs for recovery later on. Governor Murphy said not long ago that a notable loosening of COVID-19 limits affecting businesses, venues, and gatherings across the state would start on May 19th, after gains in getting more than half the state's residents vaccinated along with a continued drop in positivity and hospitalization figures. PSEG has started rolling out the Clean Energy Future energy efficiency offerings by kicking off customer engagement and outreach, while also moving forward on the clean energy jobs training initiative I brought up earlier, plus the associated IT system build-out work. After the BPU gave the green light to our $700 million AMI proposal in January, implementation of the four-year program has gotten underway. Right now we are concentrating on designing the AMI communications network, reaching out to customers, and putting together the installation timeline for the new meters. When it comes to regulatory and policy matters, a number of developments are coming up at the FERC, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, the BPU, and PJM that may shape future results. Last month, FERC issued a new proposed rule that would cap the 50 basis point RTO return on equity incentive at a three-year span. In light of the Biden administration's desire for a major transmission build-out to broaden how much clean energy gets integrated into the country's power grid, this move was a letdown. We have consistently backed the case for stronger incentives for transmission investment compared with distribution returns, given the greater complexity and risk these projects carry. Going through the RTO together brings advantages, yet countless risks and complications have to be weighed too.
Ralph Izzo
executiveGiven the brief period allowed for remarks, the suggested regulation might be adopted by the third quarter at the earliest. We plan to submit feedback acknowledging the benefits of keeping the RTO adder in place; however, this appears to be a difficult struggle because the chair backs the supplemental rule. As we wait for the outcome of PJM's first capacity auction in 3 years, set to be revealed by PJM on June 2nd, PSEG keeps pushing for a minimum offer price rule—I'll refer to it simply as MOPR from here on—that would prevent duplicate compensation for assets like offshore wind and nuclear, or other zero-carbon sources required to meet state targets. FERC Commissioner Danly has put forward a state option to choose resources proposal, or SOCR, aimed at fulfilling the key objectives of granting states the right to select their favored capacity resources to meet their energy policy goals and removing double payments by states for the capacity they select; this idea might also help preserve a great deal of FERC's capacity market reform rules while tackling state concerns. This month, New Jersey is anticipated to release its consultant's report and recommendation on resource adequacy. Whether a fixed resource requirement, or FRR, will be picked to fulfill the state's upcoming capacity obligations past the 2022 and 2023 energy year could hinge on this report. We still think the state might adopt an FRR without needing legislation, and we'll propose ways to reduce the cost effect of the first capacity ruling on New Jersey ratepayers. In April, the BPU issued its draft plan to tackle the design of the Solar Successor Program. Stakeholder gatherings are taking place to evaluate a solar financial incentive scheme that would permanently supplant the Solar Renewable Energy Certificate, or SREC program, along with the temporary Transitional Renewable Energy Certificate, or TREC program, which began in 2020 when the state reached 5.1% of kilowatt-hour sold from solar generation facilities. Because of the significant rise in New Jersey solar targets, the steep expense of solar, and the solar cost caps within the Clean Energy Act of 2018, we regard it as essential to craft a cost-efficient method to spur future solar generation. Without question, the most efficient and economical means for New Jersey to make the most of what solar can contribute toward reaching its clean energy objectives is to optimize grid-connected utility-scale projects by engaging the state's electric distribution company. To conclude my comments, we are restating non-GAAP operating earnings guidance for the entire year of 2021 at $3.35 to $3.55 per share. We base our outlook on typical weather conditions and standard plant functioning for the rest of the year, and we factor in the conservation incentive programs starting in June for electricity and October for natural gas, which address swings in revenue caused by energy efficiency along with other effects. Also, as we stated during our year-end call, our 2021 guidance presumes a forward-looking resolution of our transmission return on equity at a reduced rate, plus the full-year inclusion of fossils results. We remain on schedule to carry out PSEG's five-year $14 billion-$16 billion capital plan through 2025, and we possess the financial capacity to support it without issuing new equity. More than 90% of the present capital plan goes toward PSE&G, which should deliver 6.5%-8% compound annual growth in rate base across the 2021 to 2025 timeframe, beginning with PSEG's year-end 2020 rate base of $22 billion. As we have said before, PSE&G's substantial ability to generate cash is underpinned by more than 90% of its capital expenditures still receiving formula rate, clause-based, or current rate recovery of and on capital. Last, I thank our staff for their outstanding work on a strong PSEG narrative this quarter. From nuclear operations achieving a second breaker-to-breaker continuous run at Hope Creek, to a cross-functional regulatory legal finance and government affairs team juggling Clean Energy Future, ZEC, and numerous other regulatory cases, to our field crews across New Jersey and Long Island who demonstrate a safety-focused approach. I have never been more proud of the whole PSEG team; now I'll hand the call to Dan for further specifics on our financial and operating results, and I'll be ready for your questions once he finishes. Dan?
Daniel Cregg
executiveAll right. Thanks, Ralph, and good morning to everybody. Like Ralph said, for the first quarter of 2021, PSEG's non-GAAP operating earnings came in at $1.28 per share, compared with $1.03 per share during last year's first quarter. On slide 12, we've given you details about how each business contributed to non-GAAP operating earnings this quarter. A waterfall chart on slide 13 walks you through the quarter-over-quarter net changes in non-GAAP operating earnings by major business. Now I'll go through each company more closely. PSE&G, as slide 15 shows, posted net income of $0.94 per share for the first quarter of 2021, versus $0.87 per share in the first quarter of 2020 — an 8% increase over last year. Earnings per share came in $0.07 higher. That improvement stemmed from revenue gains tied to continuing capital investment programs, along with favorable pension OPEB results. Relative to the first quarter of 2020, transmission capital spending added $0.02 per share to first quarter net income. Turning to distribution, gas margin beat last year's first quarter by $0.03 per share, which came from the scheduled recovery of investments made under phase two of the Gas System Modernization Program. Compared with the first quarter of 2020, electric margin was favorable by $0.01 per share, helped by higher weather-normalized residential volume. Versus the first quarter of 2020, O&M expense was unfavorable by $0.02 per share, reflecting higher costs from several February snowstorms. Depreciation expense rose by $0.01 per share, reflecting higher plant and service. Pension expense was favorable by $0.02 per share versus the first quarter of 2020. Flow-through taxes and other were favorable by $0.02 per share versus the first quarter of 2020; this tax benefit stems from the use of an annual effective tax rate that will reverse over the remainder of the year and was partly offset by the timing of taxes related to bad debt expense. When we look at winter conditions through heating degree days, the season came in 4% warmer than typical, yet it was 18% chillier than the gentle winter we had in Q1 2020. Over the twelve months finishing March 31st, sales after weather normalization showed the pattern we anticipated—more residential demand alongside reduced commercial and industrial activity, both stemming from COVID-19's economic effects during 2020. Electric sales overall fell 2%, whereas gas sales rose roughly 1%. Throughout this stretch, we kept adding residential customers on both the electric and gas sides. PSE&G put about $600 million to work in the first quarter, and we remain positioned to carry out our full 2021 capital investment plan totaling $2.7 billion. For the 2021 capital spending plan, we'll be funding improvements to our transmission and distribution infrastructure, plus moving forward with the Clean Energy Future initiatives — that covers energy efficiency, Energy Cloud, which involves smart meters, and EV charging infrastructure. PSE&G keeps postponing the financial effect of extra costs we took on to safeguard our workers and customers during the COVID-19 pandemic. Over at PSE&G, we've experienced a significant increase in accounts receivable and bad debt, and we're collecting less cash from customers, which stems from the residential shutoff moratorium that began last March and continues through June of this year. To address this, we rolled out a broader customer outreach effort aimed at letting everyone know about payment help options and tools for managing bills. Just a reminder — PSE&G keeps submitting quarterly filings to the BPU that lay out the COVID-19 pandemic-related deferrals. Through March 31st, PSE&G has booked a regulatory asset of roughly $60 million tied to net incremental costs, and that figure includes $35 million in added gas bad debt expense. Electric bad debt expense gets recovered via the societal benefits charge and is trued up on a periodic basis. Turning to subsidiary guidance for PSE&G, our 2021 net income projection remains the same, between $1.41 billion and $1.47 billion. Now let's shift to Power. During 2021's first quarter, PSEG Power posted net income of $161 million, equal to $0.32 per share. Non-GAAP operating earnings came in at $163 million, or $0.32 per share, while non-GAAP adjusted EBITDA was $321 million. Compare that with the first quarter of 2020, when net income was $13 million, non-GAAP operating earnings were $85 million, and non-GAAP adjusted EBITDA was $201 million. The earnings release, along with slide 21, gives you a thorough breakdown of the factors affecting Power's non-GAAP operating earnings versus net income on a quarter-over-quarter basis. Slide 22 offers additional detail on generation for the quarter. During the first quarter, PSEG Power benefited from a scheduled increase in capacity pricing that took effect in the opening half of 2021, along with more favorable weather than the gentle winter experienced in the same period of 2020, as well as additional factors — many of which we expect to unwind during subsequent quarters. Compared with the prior year's first quarter, the projected increase in PJM capacity revenue improved non-GAAP operating earnings by $0.03 per share. The absence of the unplanned Salem-1 outage that occurred in 2020's first quarter meant greater generation this time around, adding $0.01 per share. Colder-than-normal temperatures in February created beneficial market dynamics that contributed an extra $0.03 per share compared with Q1 of the prior year. Our full-year outlook still includes an average recontracting decrease of $2 per megawatt-hour, and we recognize that the pattern of that yearly average shift is weighted toward the winter months in the first quarter. Results got a $0.04 per share boost from higher total gas sendout to commercial and industrial customers, which was weather-related. We expect some of this gas ops improvement to give back later in 2021, which would reflect the fact that a one-time pipeline refund benefit was recorded in Q3 of 2020 and won't repeat. For the quarter, O&M expense was favorable by $0.03 per share, aided by there being no outages at Bergen 2 and Salem-1 like there were in the first quarter of 2020. Things got $0.01 per share better versus the same quarter last year thanks to reduced depreciation along with lower interest expense. Generation output increased a little, by just under 1%, to 13.3 TWh total, versus the first quarter a year earlier, when Salem Unit 1 experienced an unplanned outage that lasted a month. At PSEG Power, the combined cycle fleet produced 4.7 TWh, down 8%, reflecting weaker market demand in the quarter. During Q1, nuclear generation totaled 8.2 TWh — a 3% rise — with a 98.8% capacity factor, representing 62% of total output. Per Ralph, Hope Creek completed a continuous stretch of operation between refueling shutdowns, and its 23rd such outage got underway just this April. Looking at the last three quarters of 2021, PSEG Power expects between 36 and 38 TWh of output, and about 95%-100% of that electricity has been sold forward at an average of $30 per megawatt-hour. Gross margin for Q1 rose to roughly $34 per megawatt-hour, up from $30 per megawatt-hour in the same quarter of 2020 — a stretch that featured one of the gentlest winters in memory. During the first quarter of 2021, power prices were stronger throughout PJM, New York, and New England relative to the same period a year earlier, and temperatures this winter averaged 12% cooler, producing better market conditions than in the first quarter of 2020.
Daniel Cregg
executiveDuring Q1 2021, Power's average capacity prices in PJM came in above their Q1 2020 level, and they're going to stay flat at $168 per megawatt day through May 2022. When it comes to New England, our average realized capacity price is set to dip a bit, to $192 per megawatt day, starting June 1st. At the same time, though, Power's cleared capacity is going to fall by 383 MW because of the planned retirement of Bridgeport Harbor Unit 3, which gets us to our objective of a Power fleet that is entirely free of coal. More than 75% of PSEG Power's expected gross margin for 2021 is locked in thanks to our fully hedged position of energy output, capacity revenue set in previous auctions, and the chance to earn a full year of ZEC revenues, and certain ancillary service payments such as reactive power. Our forecast for PSEG Power's non-GAAP operating earnings and non-GAAP adjusted EBITDA for 2021 stays the same, at $280 million-$370 million and $850 million-$950 million respectively. Let me now turn briefly to results from PSEG Enterprise and Other. For the first three months of 2021, Enterprise and Other reported net income of $10 million, which works out to $0.02 per share. In the same period of 2020, the figure was a net loss of $5 million, or $0.01 per share. A couple of factors drove the improvement this quarter: tax benefits that were higher in the first quarter of 2021 because an annual effective tax rate was applied and will unwind across the rest of the year, plus interest income tied to a prior IRS audit settlement. Looking ahead to 2021, our projection for PSEG Enterprise and Other stays the same — a net loss of $15 million. Now on the balance sheet: PSEG ended the quarter holding $803 million in cash. In Q1, PSEG brought $450 million in five-year secured medium-term notes to market at 95 basis points, along with another $450 million in 30-year secured medium-term notes priced at 3%. We also paid off a $300 million medium-term note at PSE&G carrying a 1.9% rate that came due in March. Back in March 2021, PSEG finalized a $500 million variable rate term loan agreement running 364 days, after prepaying in January a $300 million term loan that had been started in March 2020. Looking at the rest of 2021, PSEG Power has roughly $950 million in debt coming due across June and September. Then at the parent level, $300 million matures in November, while PSE&G has $134 million coming due in June. Thanks to our strong balance sheet and credit metrics, we can fund the 2021 to 2025 capital investment program without issuing any new equity. Ralph noted earlier that we're reaffirming our full-year 2021 non-GAAP operating earnings guidance of $3.35 to $3.55 per share, and that wraps up what I wanted to cover. Christy, let's open it up for questions.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystMorning, and thanks for the invitation. Hello there, and thank you as well, everyone. To start, if it's alright with you, I noticed a piece earlier today in Reuters, as I recall, concerning federal backing for production tax credits. Naturally, all of you recently obtained your own support at the state level regarding ZECs. Could you explain how those two things could fit together, given that it's clearly quite early on any federal initiative? And on a connected note, regarding nuclear, when you consider the work to lower costs and counterbalance the dyssynergies, how ought we to view the cost structure positioned above the nuclear plants, more or less after everything is finished following this year, if you also take that into account?
Ralph Izzo
executiveHello, Julien, and thank you for asking. Within the New Jersey statute, the one from 2018, an explicit offset exists that would lower the ZEC payment in the event of a federal payment for the carbon-free attributes of the plants; our consistent position has been that whether the source is nuclear, wind, or solar, cutting the country's carbon emissions ought to be managed through a program covering the entire nation. We are vigorously chasing those federal remedies. Indeed, as I mentioned just a moment ago, they would offset the ZEC. I'm not certain I completely grasp what you're asking regarding the cost structure sitting on top of the plants. Dan, were you-
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystIf you all don't mind, let me put that a different way. Thanks, Ralph. When you're thinking about the old SG&A — the corporate expenses, roughly — and you're thinking about spinning off these other packages here, could you explain how you're looking at what the run rate for that business is, without asking what the nuclear plants actually earn? How are you thinking about the cost structure in that case, particularly as we try to refine ourselves on a 2022 and beyond basis?
Ralph Izzo
executiveYeah. No, we've established a target for ourselves that no stranded costs would be left once assets are divested. The approach we've taken is this: we want to be very aggressive about removing positions, yet very accommodating when it comes to helping individuals get reassigned, as long as their abilities fit what the company needs, right? I mean, 7% of our employee population turns over annually. We're constantly in search of talent. The single exception there, naturally, is that when we have people such as myself whose pay was distributed across a larger asset base, that's something we'll need to address through other means. Clearly we have some roles where that will apply. No, we're very focused and determined not to leave any residual stranded support or overhead costs behind after the SAM.
Daniel Cregg
executiveYeah. Be them direct or indirect, as Ralph pointed out.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystAlright. Great work, everyone. I just want to confirm — aside from the fact that you're not booking a write-down, I assume there's nothing more you can tell us about the price the portfolio sold for today.
Ralph Izzo
executiveCorrect. What I can give you is a range, and it's a wide one: somewhere from $500 million to $600 million. The accretion in value comes from averaging our EBITDA estimates across the coming three years. The accretion to earnings assumes those proceeds go straight toward paying down debt. We aren't assuming anything overly optimistic. Like I mentioned earlier, the process was competitive. The bidders were credible. The offers that came in were very credible, and in our view it went very smoothly. You're probably sick of me repeating this, but up to now, the sole unexpected thing since July is that nothing unexpected has happened. I'd like to keep being able to say that, and I'm confident I will.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystAbsolutely. And once more, nice work on how far things have come. We'll talk before long.
Jeremy Tonet
analystHello there, good morning.
Ralph Izzo
executiveGood morning, Jeremy.
Jeremy Tonet
analystI'd like to zoom out a little and talk about the Biden plan. Of course, it's still quite early, and nothing is locked in yet, but I'm curious what you expect from it, and what kind of effect it might have on PEG — whether that's in offshore wind, building out transmission, or even areas like nuclear paired with green hydrogen down the road. Any perspective you can offer on the potential outcomes or what you're watching for?
Ralph Izzo
executiveAbsolutely, Jeremy. Frankly, we belonged to a very small set of firms in this sector that sent a letter to the President backing his goal of an 80% cut for the power sector by 2030. We're collaborating with lawmakers on Capitol Hill to ensure nuclear gets folded into any clean energy standard in a way that doesn't favor one technology over another. Honestly, we've been discussing with people the idea that should tax credits be broadened to cover carbon-free power, nuclear ought to qualify too. And that if an incentive structure gets designed to hit these goals, it shouldn't single out particular technologies — instead, to say it again, it should treat them all the same provided you deliver the intended result, namely lower carbon emissions. We recognize there's considerable merit in pursuing every option available, nuclear, solar, wind, carbon capture, and storage included. It's encouraging to hear what the President has stated regarding the outlook for offshore wind. New Jersey is currently running a second solicitation round, targeting another 2.4 GW. Maryland is pursuing an extra few hundred megawatts. My sense is that this momentum is genuine, and with excitement coming from Washington plus enthusiasm from governors across the region where we do business, I'm led to conclude there will be substantial chances to put money into both the transmission buildout required to reach carbon-free resources and the ongoing expansion of those resources, along with keeping the ones we already have in place. Keep in mind — I'm sure you're aware — that across the country, the current nuclear fleet accounts for slightly more than 50% of carbon-free energy, despite providing only 20% of all electricity. In New Jersey, those figures stand out even more. Nuclear plants make up more than 90% of our state's carbon-free energy. What you have is a wonderful alignment of political leaders in the nation's capital and in the states, all pulling in the same direction.
Jeremy Tonet
analystUnderstood. That helps a lot. Thank you. Of course, like you mentioned, federal backing might take precedence over whatever occurs at the state level. It's good to see that you just secured those extensions for three years. I'm just curious, when you look ahead, do you foresee any possibility of adjustments to the ZEC program in New Jersey — whether that's increased amounts, a longer time frame, or I'm simply trying to get a sense of what you believe could be feasible there?
Ralph Izzo
executiveOur message has been steady: we view this as a multi-phase effort to ensure the long-term viability of our nuclear plants, and securing round two of ZECs marked the successful conclusion of phase one. For phase two, three pathways will be explored by us. The first is a federal pathway, whether that's a clean energy standard or a production tax credit. We discussed that a moment ago; we will work hard to pursue it, since this is global climate change, not New Jersey climate change. The second path involves acting as an honest broker and advisor to the state as it pursues an FRR. That, as I noted in my remarks, is underway, and we expect a summary, a report from the state's consultant at some point this month. It's only slightly behind schedule, though not by much, and the state has time to do that thoughtfully and well; in the unlikely event that none of that achieves the long-term economic viability of the nuclear plants, we would then speak with state policymakers about modifying the ZEC program to accomplish that. It's fairly clear that a three-year process is untenable for such a capital-intensive asset. As we stated throughout the ZEC proceeding, the $10 per megawatt hour did not match the cost of capital associated on a risk-adjusted basis for not bringing those plants. Given the chance to pursue these three other remedy paths, we would accept the $10 per megawatt hour. I do believe there's a fair amount of opportunity to change the economic support for the nuclear plants.
Jeremy Tonet
analystExcellent. That's useful. I won't ask anything more. Appreciate it.
Shar Pourreza
analystHi, everyone. Morning to you.
Daniel Cregg
executiveHi, Shar.
Shar Pourreza
analystI have a few things to ask. To start, I'm just wondering what your view is on possibly allocating capital from the fossil divestiture — the one that's still pending — particularly now that you're nearing completion. Given that this deal lowers risk, do you actually require those cash proceeds to reduce leverage further, or do you expect it will strengthen credit? And as a related point, how quickly do you believe you could put that money back to work through organic avenues? We've noticed some fairly robust asset-level deals involving PE. I'm interested in that.
Daniel Cregg
executiveYes, that's a wonderful question, Shar; throughout this year and even prior to it, we've stated that when you examine the capital program ahead of us for the 2021 to 2025 period, we could finance it without requiring any additional equity. Accept that as given and begin considering the divestiture of the business and the proceeds that will arrive. There will be proceeds above what's needed. Your inquiry is the correct one: how do you view the utilization of those proceeds? Debt exists at the Power level. If you consider navigating through certain provisions of that debt, you'll notice that a few of the requirements within it depend on certain assets that are being divested. In my view, reducing debt at the Power level is clearly the initial application of proceeds. We would expect proceeds above that amount, and at that stage you begin to examine how we have characterized the business. Our characterization of the business is that it keeps expanding the utility. That utility has a rather insatiable hunger. The current capital plan is achievable without any extra equity. As time progresses, as we have consistently stated, when you examine the five-year capital plan, there are further items that ultimately emerge across those four- or five-year stretches and then near the conclusion of that plan which are unknown at the outset. There definitely will be chances at the utility. We've engaged in considerable conversation regarding offshore wind. We've discussed putting money into Ocean Wind. Our intention is not to pursue Ocean Wind as a singular endeavor. Either we would participate in that sector or we would not. Prospects will arise there, and they have a tendency to arrive unevenly, depending on the different solicitations. I believe there's an additional chance to invest capital in that area. There is consistently the chance to give some capital back to shareholders. As you noted, we have frequently stated that when we evaluate certain deals taking place where parties are paying above one times rate base to obtain the capacity to earn on a $1 of rate base, that represents a difficult economic circumstance for us. We have reviewed and will keep reviewing those prospects, but up to now, they have generally ranked beneath the best options available for our capital.
Shar Pourreza
analystUnderstood; so I'll just ask about transmission ROE. Ralph and Dan, with several other items no longer sitting on the BPU's agenda, how engaged are your conversations about returns at this point? That question comes as FERC ALJs have made headlines with fairly harsh positions on ROEs and cap structures, and that clearly signals something to investors. Considering what's happening on the federal side, how qualitative do you believe the BPU is when it comes to target ROEs, on both the transmission side and the state-level side?
Ralph Izzo
executiveMy sense is that these discussions continue to be quite productive. The problem, Shar, as you rightly noted, stems partly from the board's workload relative to our ambitions, though that's not the whole story. What I mean is, the board right now is running a second solicitation round for offshore wind totaling 2.4 GW. They've also got an FRR proceeding underway, plus they oversee water utilities along with other electric and gas providers. COVID does bring in some degree of friction regarding how and when people can get together. Nothing in these talks has signaled that anyone's drive to reach common ground has diminished since we began. I'm aware that we kicked this off more than 12 months ago. It's tough for me to accept that so much time has passed, yet that simply reflects what I just mentioned. Once more, what drives us is securing a fair result that eliminates uncertainty for our investors, while also delivering a certain amount of rate relief to our customers. Board staff share that same goal of rate relief, except they want it achieved right away rather than becoming tied up in a FERC process that could take many years to conclude.
Shar Pourreza
analystGot it. Terrific. Thank you, Ralph and Dan. Thanks. Appreciate it. Very comprehensive.
Daniel Cregg
executiveAppreciate that, Ralph.
Durgesh Chopra
analystMorning, and thanks for fielding my question. Perhaps just a bit of clarification regarding that FERC topic the two of you were just covering. Has the company put a number on how removing those 50 basis points affects earnings for you folks?
Ralph Izzo
executiveYes, Durgesh, my feeling is that we managed to do so. On a yearly basis, the figure being mentioned comes to roughly $0.06 per share.
Durgesh Chopra
analystGreat, thanks. I suppose I'd just like to hear your thinking in broad strokes regarding PJM, and the capacity auction coming up next month. Could you just speak to it directionally? What's your outlook on where pricing is headed? And in what way does that shape how you go about divesting the fossil assets?
Daniel Cregg
executiveRight, Durgesh. Our track record shows we've consistently avoided making public forecasts about future directions. Internally, I believe we've managed reasonably well at forming our own perspectives, though as someone involved in the process, I typically don't reveal very much. What I can share is this: looking broadly at what's been established for this auction, the overall framework leans more pessimistic than optimistic when I compare it with earlier auctions. Results will be available on June 2nd, and then we'll observe how it plays out. All things considered, relative to previous auctions, the indicators emerging from this one seem slightly more negative than positive, based purely on what we've received up to this point.
Durgesh Chopra
analystNo, that's really useful. Is that simply whatever color from, like, the conversations you're having with active parties who are interested in those assets? What are you observing in that area?
Daniel Cregg
executiveMy sense is that it will have some influence. When I consider the properties we offer to customers, they perform very efficiently, have strong capacity factors, and are earning meaningful spark spreads, which is ultimately what makes them valuable. Certainly, capacity accounts for part of that worth, but because of how frequently these assets run, I believe the energy margins will be essential in making that determination; the auction in question lasts one year. Whatever people observe afterward, a single year allows them to form certain conclusions, yet as I just mentioned, when you compare past auctions with the one now underway, the parameters will differ as time moves forward. In my view, prior capacity auctions have not served as a great indicator of what future auctions might bring. Naturally, every participant will examine that and decide how to approach it when bidding. Looking at a historical capacity auction does not carry as large an effect as several other factors.
Durgesh Chopra
analystGot it. That extra detail is helpful. Thanks a lot.
Steve Fleishman
analystHello there, good morning, and thank you.
Ralph Izzo
executiveHey, Steve.
Steve Fleishman
analystI believe you've addressed the majority of what I wanted to ask. Only regarding that fossil divestiture we just talked about — given the first round of offers you received and the various possible outcomes for the auction, how sure are you that a deal will get done and that you'll land somewhere within the range you had in mind?
Daniel Cregg
executiveSteve, I'd say the process has been a strong one. A great deal of interest has come our way. The assets themselves merit that attention and have attracted plenty of it. I suppose I'd second Ralph's remarks from a few minutes back. When we consider that events have unfolded the way we anticipated, I view that as a relative positive for making further headway here, and we'd expect to reach a favorable outcome.
Steve Fleishman
analystAll right. So regarding offshore wind, covering what you've already committed to as well as any deals that might come later — when can we expect to learn more about the scale of your investment and its schedule? Yeah.
Ralph Izzo
executiveIt comes in stages, Steve. There's positive news from BOEM that the environmental impact statement is going to be finished, and my understanding is that lands in 2022. We've mentioned that certain capital decisions would be made during this year's second half — that's what we refer to as our pre-FID decision. As I tell the national government, FID means financial investment decision, correct? After that, I believe a further significant decision arrives 1 year down the line; this process involves several steps. We're happy with the current trajectory. Some modifications to tax law are floating around that must be worked out, particularly given our initial assumption of serving as a tax equity partner. Honestly, at this moment, that team is paying more heed to execution, and somewhat greater focus is being directed toward the continuing solicitations, which could open up still more possibilities.
Daniel Cregg
executiveRight. Look, the credit landscape in Washington has been pretty dynamic, and that does have a way of moving things around. Like Ralph mentioned, when it comes to the tax equity and the Ocean Wind project, exactly how that ends up looking is still somewhat up in the air, since the ultimate tax rules will shape what the tax equity turns out to be. There have been shifts along the way — I think back to last December, when you saw a change in what you might call the equalization between PTC and ITC. And then there are all these, I guess you'd call them proposals rather than proposed legislation, since things haven't reached that point yet, regarding where some of those credits might end up. Until it actually becomes legislation, we won't have a final answer; and ultimately those things will have a bearing on some of the cash flows in the early years as well.
Steve Fleishman
analystAll right. This has come up somewhat already, though I'll put it another way. With the FERC NOPR now issued, in what way, if any, does it affect your capacity to resolve the New Jersey transmission ROE? Does it connect to that at all, or do you feel fine about it?
Ralph Izzo
executiveNaturally, it forms part of the backdrop against which our discussions are happening.
Steve Fleishman
analystAll right.
Ralph Izzo
executiveThere's a certain irony here. Half a year back, during the discussion we had then, I believe that is how you'd have put it.
Steve Fleishman
analystIn the opposite direction.
Ralph Izzo
executiveSetting up how we talked about it. Naturally, folks on our regulatory side kept telling us, "Fine, we require an additional 50 basis points. It has to come down." What we told them was, "That isn't assured." We ended up being correct; these days we're inclined to argue that once the RTO gets removed, our settlement figure ought to be larger. I suppose their point is, there's no assurance that will occur. That's simply part of the context. All along, the bargaining has centered on the base ROE, and each side understands that any RTO incentive adder stood separate and aside from that discussion.
Steve Fleishman
analystAll right, thanks.
Paul Patterson
analystHello there, good morning.
Ralph Izzo
executiveGood morning, Paul.
Paul Patterson
analystJust a quick one about the cap on market seller offers. As you know, P3 filed something that seemed to express some worry about whether a safe harbor they believe exists would carry over into this next auction. I was curious — I didn't really notice anyone besides them bringing this up, and obviously there were counter filings and so on. Do you have any read on whether this is a big deal or whether it could hit you guys in any meaningful way?
Ralph Izzo
executiveNot that I'm aware of, Paul. Dan and I are looking at each other right now and saying we haven't had any alarm bells go off about that at all.
Paul Patterson
analystAll right, that's helpful. So regarding the MOPR and the FRR — considering the current status of the MOPR, the developments unfolding at PJM, and what's going on at FERC — how likely is it that anything meaningful will happen on the FRR front before the MOPR question gets settled?
Ralph Izzo
executiveMy sense is that the state will keep pushing forward on figuring out what an FRR ought to be. If the MOPR doesn't fix the double payment issue, I'd rather not speculate about whether the state would move ahead with the FRR assuming the duplication in the capacity payment got removed. It's possible the state would decide to go ahead regardless, simply to demonstrate its autonomy and to avoid having to stress about a future FERC reversing course, correct? Since New Jersey is obviously committed to this for the long term when it comes to achieving carbon-free energy. We've seen fairly significant shifts in direction at FERC, be it the MOPR or the RTO adder. I could picture the state simply declaring, "Fine, I can't sit around waiting for that. I'll set my own path." That said, they could just as easily say, "Well, there's no need for me to set that path right now, because the offshore wind entering the picture in the 2024 energy year won't be subject to this penalty anymore."
Paul Patterson
analystAll right.
Ralph Izzo
executiveShould the MOPR be corrected, it does provide the state with a degree of optionality.
Paul Patterson
analystAll right, that's excellent. Thanks very much.
Daniel Cregg
executiveShould it be settled swiftly enough, it might be wrapped up prior to any finalization occurring regarding the FRR. In my view, that would represent the best-case scenario, since the State would then possess every piece of information needed in order to complete its finalization.
Paul Patterson
analystThat's logical. I appreciate it.
David Arcaro
analystHello there. I really appreciate you taking my question. What's your view on the odds you'll succeed in the offshore transmission solicitation, and how big could that opportunity eventually get?
Ralph Izzo
executiveSure. A switching station that belongs to us is among the landing points, and beyond the fact that we're familiar with the neighborhood, we know the right of ways, we know how transmission flows work, we grasp how to design several approaches for bringing that power ashore without triggering any additional reliability problems, that doesn't hand us a guaranteed edge. As for whether we've provided a sense of how large this opportunity could be? I don't believe so, correct? Since it's an RFP, so if we begin putting figures out publicly, we'd be handing our rivals a decent amount of insight into what we expect to bid. It's a significant figure. A sizable project and a solid deployment of capital is what this would be.
David Arcaro
analystAlright, sounds good. Yeah, I appreciate that. That's useful. I suppose I was only wondering, given the cable problems Ørsted recently encountered, whether that's something requiring another look or whether it alters the economics at all for the Ocean Wind project.
Ralph Izzo
executiveI won't claim to know that subject deeply. My sense is the financial effect falls more on the need to return and repair rather than planning ahead to prevent it. That's a question better directed to the people at Ørsted. Naturally, we'll see all of it folded into the project financial analysis at the pre-FID stage. I can't give you anything more specific than that. What I'm aware of in the public domain involves existing projects that require some mitigation.
David Arcaro
analystAll right, understood. Thank you very much.
Michael Lapides
analystHi, everyone. I appreciate you taking the time to answer. Just quickly, when it comes to offshore wind, is your main intention to own projects, co-own them, or hold stakes in ones that mostly serve New Jersey? Or is your aim wider and more varied along the Eastern Seaboard, with additional venture partners beyond the single one you're working with on Ocean Wind?
Ralph Izzo
executiveYes. Broader opportunities are something we'd welcome. Michael, as you're likely aware, the Garden State Offshore Energy site, which we co-own alongside Ørsted, has easy access to Maryland, and it's in fact being put to use for what's known as the Skipjack Project, serving Maryland. It could extend into Delaware too, if Delaware decides to move forward with offshore wind, and it can also get to New Jersey. It sits at the southernmost point of New Jersey. That gives it reach across three states. Our partnership with Ørsted covers a specific portion of the Mid-Atlantic region, so outside that region we're free to collaborate with others. As you know well, nearly everyone involved in offshore wind pursues partnerships, when they do at all, with local utilities, for various reasons tied to regulation and transmission planning. Even though we'd be open to that, I believe it's reasonable to say that our main priority and emphasis lies with this partner in this Mid-Atlantic region.
Michael Lapides
analystUnderstood.
Daniel Cregg
executiveMichael, that region also happens to be quite full of opportunities. We've stated that we didn't anticipate heading to the Philippines to carry out any projects in that country. When you consider what sits nearer to home, it's an area with plenty of opportunities.
Michael Lapides
analystUnderstood. One final item — regarding Ocean Wind, or the other New Jersey projects, could you jog my memory: after the PPA gets signed, which party holds the construction cost risk? Would that be the project developers? Or does the customer bear it? What's the mechanism there?
Ralph Izzo
executiveNo, the project developer holds it, correct? Under the PPA or the board order, there's an energy price plus an escalator covering 20 to 25 years, I can't recall precisely. Whatever goes up, whatever costs or problems nobody expected or budgeted for, fall on the developer.
Michael Lapides
analystUnderstood. Thanks, Ralph. I really appreciate it.
Jonathan Arnold
analystYes. Morning, everyone. Just one brief item. Turning to offshore once more, Ralph, could you tell us again whether Ocean Wind 2 currently has any participation from you, or whether there might be a chance to secure a role in it?
Ralph Izzo
executiveJonathan, your audio cut out on me. It’s possible Dan caught what you said more clearly than I managed to, or perhaps you’ll have to say it once more. Go ahead and ask that again, Jonathan.
Jonathan Arnold
analystActually, what I was asking is this — could you just refresh our memory on how you might be connected, or potentially connected, to Ocean Wind 2, the project submitted as a bid into the present solicitation?
Ralph Izzo
executiveSure. That project belongs to Ørsted, essentially, and should they decide to bring in a partner, we hold the right of first refusal to step in and do so.
Jonathan Arnold
analystExcellent, I appreciate that. There's just a single housekeeping item regarding Power and the balance sheet. Dan, I caught your remarks concerning the use of proceeds. Have you specified a debt level that you'd plan to keep carrying at Power? I'm simply attempting to get a sense of how we ought to approach a few of these matters that are on the horizon, and what the balance sheet will probably resemble going forward.
Daniel Cregg
executiveNo, Jonathan, we haven't released any figure on that. What I'd say is this: power generation produces cash flows, and to the degree those flows can be financed — if, say, there's a longer-dated answer for nuclear, then you'd have a longer-dated sense of what that might look like, and it might support an added slice of debt over a longer horizon, all contingent on how things shake out. Turning to something distinct from power, though not tied to it, the offshore wind project Ralph mentioned has a 20-year escalation schedule, with the price locked in place. Sure, construction risk sits with the developer, yet from a revenue perspective what you're looking at isn't driven by the market. You receive the OREC, then hand back the market revenues generated by it. That brings a degree of steadiness too. No figure has been attached to it, but in both cases there's a cash flow stream that can be financed.
Jonathan Arnold
analystSo what you said earlier wasn't really suggesting a sort of power that carries no debt, was it?
Daniel Cregg
executiveCorrect. That's not a given. Of course, the issuances in question would likely differ, though it might hold some debt on the opposite side of that.
Jonathan Arnold
analystAll right. Along those same lines, perhaps—do you have any intention of refinancing the power debt that matures in November, or will you simply pay that one off?
Daniel Cregg
executiveThe decision will hinge on whatever else unfolds in the meantime, and that takes in how things stand on the sales side.
Jonathan Arnold
analystOkay, great. Thank you, guys.
Daniel Cregg
executiveThanks, John.
Ralph Izzo
executiveAlright, I believe it's time for us to conclude. We appreciate everyone for being here. I realize we've spent roughly 60 minutes on this call, but what I hope came through is a pretty straightforward point — we are carrying out our strategy and following through on the commitments we made to strengthen and build a utility that stands out above all in ESG leadership. Thanks once more for giving us your time, and I look forward to meeting all of you face to face before long. Take care, everyone. Thanks.
Operator
operatorEveryone, that brings today's conference call to a close. You're welcome to hang up now, and we appreciate your joining us.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Public Service Enterprise Group Incorporated transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Public Service Enterprise Group Incorporated earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Public Service Enterprise Group Incorporated or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.