Snap-on Incorporated (SNA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 6, 2020

New York Stock Exchange US Industrials Machinery earnings 66 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Sara Verbsky

executive
#1

Thanks, Abby, and hello everybody on this morning's call. We appreciate you being with us as we go through Snap-on's results for the fourth quarter, and you can find all the details in the press release we put out earlier today; joining us on this call are Nick Pinchuk, who serves as Snap-on's Chief Executive Officer, and Aldo Pagliari, Snap-on's Chief Financial Officer. Nick is going to get us started this morning by sharing how he views our performance. After that, Aldo will walk through a more thorough look at our financial results. Once Nick offers a few closing remarks, we'll open things up for your questions. As we always do, slides have been made available to go along with what we discuss. You can reach those slides through the Downloads tab inside the webcast viewer, and they're also posted on our site, snapon.com, in the Investors area. Those slides are going to be kept on our website, together with a transcript of this call. When statements are made on this call about management's expectations, estimates or beliefs, or that otherwise describe management's or the company's outlook, plans or projections, they are forward-looking statements, and what actually happens may differ materially from what those statements suggest. You can find additional information, along with the factors that might cause our results to come in materially different from what the forward-looking statements indicate, in our SEC filings. One more thing: this presentation contains non-GAAP measures of financial performance, and those shouldn't be viewed by themselves or treated as a replacement for the comparable GAAP figures. You can find additional information, which includes a reconciliation of non-GAAP measures, in our earnings release and on Pages 14 through 17 of our conference call slides, and both of those are available on our website. Having said all that, I'd like to hand the call over now to Nick Pinchuk. Nick?

Nick Pinchuk

executive
#2

Appreciate that, Sara. Morning, everyone. I'll begin today the way I normally do, walking through our quarter — the fourth — updating you on conditions and the patterns we're observing, plus covering a few of the disruptions we ran into along with the strides we've taken. After that, Aldo will walk through the financial details more thoroughly. Both the quarter and the full year comparatives contain special nonrecurring items that shaped our as-reported figures, so for better clarity, just as we've done before, we'll treat the amounts without those onetime effects as as-adjusted numbers so everything lines up comparably. Looking at the whole picture, much like the third quarter, Snap-on did face outside headwinds across several areas; even so, we rose to those challenges and kept moving ahead. Sure, we saw variation between segments and inside each segment. Still, on balance, we feel good about where we stand and what's possible. Elements of progress showed up in the fourth quarter, though economic turbulence in difficult geographies and the hit from unfavorable foreign currency dampened them somewhat. Just like recently, we're showing improvement in the U.S., with gains across the majority of our operations there, so U.S. volume kept climbing. Meanwhile, our European operations displayed offsetting softness in a number of major countries; and as I mentioned, currency translation and transaction also took a meaningful toll, so the headwinds were significant. Yet again, though, I believe our strengths won out. Organic sales rose 0.6%. We saw sales increases in critical industries and repair information in independent — plus equipment for independent repair shop owners and managers and in continued growth at the — and continued growth in the — at the U.S. van channel; we made advances in power tools, in tool storage, and in customized tool sets. Together, all of that got us around the variations and pushed us forward on the whole. Opco operating income before financial services came to $171.4 million, which included unfavorable foreign currency, versus $182.1 million in 2018, a figure that included a $4.3 million onetime gain from settling an employee-related litigation matter. Leaving out that legal matter, fourth quarter as-adjusted OI was $177.8 million. Now, RCI showed up in the quarter, but it couldn't fully counter the negative foreign currency and Europe's economic softness. Over in financial services, operating income reached $62.2 million, up from $56.1 million a year earlier. Combined with opco, that gave us a consolidated overall operating margin of 22.5%, against 23% last year — or 22.6% — 22.5% this year versus the 22.6% as adjusted, which excludes last year's legal benefit. Our quarterly EPS came in at $3.08, above the 2018 as-adjusted EPS of $3.03. As-reported Q4 2018 EPS, which included a onetime legal matter, was $3.09. So those are broadly the numbers. Let's talk markets. We believe — what we believe is that the automotive repair environment remains generally favorable. That said, when it comes to the parts of our business that serve vehicle OEMs and dealerships, there has been a bit of a stall. Fewer new cars sold over those years did shape the way dealers purchase, and while the total number of projects carried on, the count commissioned by the vehicle OEMs went down; independent repair shops, on the other hand, present a different picture. Drawing on what we've been told — what franchisees, technicians, and shop owners are telling us — there's a lot of optimism among independent repair shops, and new car sales haven't touched it, and our U.S. sales in that sector have been positive and remain that way; so vehicle repair, in our view, is still a good business to be in. Over in critical industries, we're making headway. There's robust activity across U.S. aerospace, military, and heavy-duty, partly canceled out by weakness abroad, chiefly in general industry and international aerospace. Even so, the overall trend in our activity still looks quite encouraging, and the direction of critical industry — of our critical industry business — is unmistakably upward. The opportunities in critical industries were on display in our industrial division. It pushed past the headwinds of Brexit and the broad softness in Europe, posting gains powered by its customized product kits, fitting the product to the job. We genuinely think we're set up well to meet the challenges of this moment, advancing along our runways for growth in spite of the turbulence. We're also confident that our runways for improvement still hold promise. Safety, quality, customer connection, innovation, and Rapid Continuous Improvement — the Snap-on Value Creation processes — are a steady source of fuel for our progress, above all customer connection, grasping the work professional technicians do, and innovation, pairing that understanding with technology. Our product lineup, we believe, improves daily, and we continue to put money behind making that happen. Vehicles, as you can see, grow more complex. Technicians require help, so our offerings grow more advanced to meet the climbing demands; and Snap-on products are keeping up. And our franchisees are — along with our direct sales force, meeting technicians face-to-face, they're ideally placed to show off our strong new offerings and to demonstrate how they're used right at the workplace. In today's shifting environment, that's a terrific opportunity, and we're putting in the effort to seize it fully. So, taking the corporation as a whole, I'd describe our markets as mixed, positive, with considerable potential, yet turbulent from one period to the next and one place to another. Turning now to the full year, sales came to $3.73 billion, which was an organic increase of 1.2%, much the same story as the quarter. Growth in the U.S., knocked about by Europe. The U.S. franchise is climbing, with particular turbulence in the U.K. van channel, critical industries expanding against the wind, and strength among independent repair shop owners and managers offsetting the shortfall in OEM dealerships. As-reported opco OI margin for the year was 19.2%, versus last year's 19.4%. If we leave out the one-time gains from each year, then for the whole year our as-adjusted opco OI margin came to 18.9%, and that figure includes a 20 basis point hit from foreign currency, versus the as-adjusted 19.3% we posted in 2018. Then, once you add in the $245.9 million of operating income from financial services, an increase of $15.8 million, the corporation's consolidated operating overall margin works out to 23.7%, or 23.4% as-adjusted, which matches the as-adjusted level from last year. As a result, reported earnings per share for the year came in at $12.41, a rise of 4.5%. And if you set aside the nonrecurring events, EPS reached $12.26, which is up $0.45, or 3.8%, against last year's as-adjusted figure. Those are the numbers. Now let's discuss each of the operating groups, beginning with C&I. For the group, fourth quarter reported sales, which include $900,000 of acquisition-related volume and $3.5 million of unfavorable foreign currency, were up $9.2 million, or 2.7%. Organic sales for the group were higher by $11.8 million, or 3.5%. During the period, our power tools division turned in a strong performance, rising double digits, which confirms that our innovative new product tools are connecting with automotive technicians. In addition, the industrial division posted low single-digit growth, with results varying across the industries and the geographies. As I mentioned, military was strong, and U.S. and aerospace, heavy-duty also climbed, offsetting a decline in the international sector.

Nick Pinchuk

executive
#3

After quite some time—really, an extended stretch—our European hand tool operation, SNA Europe, saw a decline in volume this quarter. That drop came from softness across a number of key markets, among them Germany, the Nordic countries, and France. At C&I, operating margin landed at $45 million, a decrease of $5.8 million, which includes $0.6 million from unfavorable currency. The main reason was that industrial gains carried more weight toward the lower military sector, which pulled the group's operating income down to 12.8%, versus the 14.8% posted a year ago, when customer mix was more typical. Earlier I noted that our power tools operation had a strong quarter. Sales rose by double digits. That gain was driven by our fresh cordless lineup, including the new 14.4-volt CTR762 3/8-inch ratchet. We call it The Brute. As the name implies, it was designed for automotive tasks that demand real muscle—jobs like pulling exhaust manifolds, swapping brake calipers, and doing general suspension work. The 762 Ratchet provides power similar to pneumatic tools, putting out 70 pound feet of torque, plus all the ease of a cordless platform. And the ratchet mechanism—both the head and the neck—is tough, sturdy enough to take on even greater force: 158 pound feet of manual torque. It's a brute, and technicians know it. There's also a variable speed trigger on the new ratchet, which gives you improved control, and free speed tops out at 175 RPM. So you can take fasteners off quickly. October was when we brought it to market, and the reception has been strong — it's without question among our million-dollar hits. And within C&I, as we anticipated, our torque lineup is advancing significantly, partly because we keep expanding the range of new options available to customers in critical industries — for example the new high-powered 18-volt cordless EvoTorque line, built for railroads, wind turbines, natural resources, and other critical industries in which repair and maintenance work is typically done remotely. When it comes to torque, EvoTorque handles everything from 150 pound feet all the way up to 4,000 pound feet. There are 6 basic models available: 3 single speed and 3 auto 2-speed. And here's something significant — this product exists because of the synergies that became possible after Norbar recently joined the Snap-on family. What gives the Evo its power is an innovative design that brings together a robust, powerful Norbar gearbox, a Norbar beam transducer, an ergonomic handle, and an 18-volt battery platform from our Snap-on power tools division. What you get is a torque wrench that's compact, portable and accurate to plus or minus 3%, whereas similar tools are far less precise — typically within plus or minus 5%. The response from the industry has been very favorable, and sales are moving at a good pace. Now, shifting our attention to the industrial segment, which concentrates on vital sectors beyond automotive repair. We've now achieved gains for 13 consecutive quarters, even with softening conditions in Europe. This positive momentum stems from our customer relationships, which enhance our understanding of key applications, and you can measure that progress by tracking the number of new tool solutions we launch each year. So, over the past year, we introduced roughly 5,700 new items. It's a crucial — it's our — it's vital for our industry — a vital industry lineup; that's a significant quantity of products, 5,700. Certainly it poses design and logistics hurdles, yet it delivers a significant edge with essential industry buyers. We're expanding the Snap-on brand beyond the garage with growing momentum. Essential industries represent a tremendous chance, and we're tackling those prospects through new items designed to handle the high-stakes jobs found within that essential space; moving along now to the Tools Group. Organic sales rose 1.3%, helped by ongoing expansion in the U.S. business, which climbed by a low single-digit percentage, a gain that once more, during this quarter, was cancelled out by a drop in overseas business, mainly within the U.K. Operating income for the quarter reached $54.3 million, compared with $57 million during 2018. The OI margin came in at 13.2%, which is a decline of 80 basis points, encompassing 40 basis points of adverse foreign exchange, the instability in the U.K., plus the spending we're directing toward training and field support so franchisee selling capacity can grow to keep pace with what our increasingly advanced items require and to seize the chance presented by the shifting repair landscape. During the quarter and across the full year, the Tools Group indeed affirmed the foundational market-leading standing of our van network. We think franchisees are becoming more robust; that's evident from the franchisee health metrics we track every period. Those metrics keep moving in a good direction, and such favorable results were noted by several publications, all of which named Snap-on as a franchisee — a franchise worth choosing. This quarter, Snap-on once again earned a place among the leading franchise organizations, in the U.S. as well as overseas. We were, once more, acknowledged by the Franchise Business Review, which, in its most recent franchisee satisfaction ranking, placed Snap-on among the top 50 franchises, which represents the 13th straight year we've earned that honor; additionally we were placed #2 across all franchises on Entrepreneur Magazine's 2019 roster of Top Franchises for Veterans. And overseas, Snap-on took the #1 spot in Elite Franchise Magazine's ranking of top U.K. franchises, climbing 3 places versus the prior year and ending up ahead of numerous recognizable global brands in the magazine's biggest competition to date. Thus, in spite of the challenges facing the U.K. economy, our franchise continues to be held in high regard. From my perspective, that bodes well going forward. Now recognition of this kind mirrors the core resilience of our franchisees and of our van operation overall, and it could not have happened, it would not have been accomplished absent a steady flow of inventive new items created via our robust customer connection, producing a customer connection, producing a number — producing numerous new innovations stemming from our insight and expertise amid the evolving vehicle repair landscape. A recent product we've brought into the range illustrates this point well: a GM head bolt socket made in Milwaukee, which came about thanks to a relationship with a dedicated Snap-on technician. With its 0.5-inch drive and 13-millimeter size, this socket lets you take out and put in head bolts efficiently on General Motors' light truck gen 5 V8 engines. Because of how the socket's drive geometry is uniquely shaped, it provides the twisting force required to break free head bolts that are badly rusted, and since the socket stands 4 inches tall, technicians gain room to work around the rocker arms found in the GM engine design, which means fixes turn out to be easy, even when you're dealing with the tight quarters of a GM V8 engine bay — and honestly, that's one more great example of connecting with customers. Now, if you'll trust me, moving on to something else, and truly, we're working hard to strengthen what we offer in tool storage. Those efforts are delivering results. Tool storage was up for the quarter as well as for the year. Our mobile tool solutions lineup now includes the KRSC430A professional-grade shop cart, which we brought out not long ago. With this new 40-inch cart, moving even really heavy tools from one bay to another becomes simple, and it features a sliding split top — a split lid — so the tools you reach for constantly are quickly accessible. The heavy-duty cart body is built at our facility in Algona, Iowa, right in the heartland, and it's fully welded with a double-wall design that delivers lasting strength. Beyond that, the doors can be swapped out, so you can customize it for whatever job comes up. That initial launch did quite well.

Nick Pinchuk

executive
#4

And it's obvious that this new cart is going to become yet another one of the hits we've produced. So that covers the Tools Group — growing what's working in America, keeping overseas operations in balance, rolling out inventive products on an ongoing basis, and strengthening the foundation. Moving on to RS&I. Q4 volume came to $335 million. Organically that's a decline of 1.5%, as higher sales of undercar equipment plus diagnostics and repair information products were outweighed by lower results in the business serving vehicle OEMs and dealerships. That lumpy, project-driven OEM segment had yet another unsettled stretch. Operating earnings at RS&I for the quarter totaled $87.2 million, which is $200,000 below a year ago, and that figure includes $200,000 from unfavorable foreign currency. The group's OI margin reached a robust 26%, a gain of 30 basis points versus last year's level, and it was — essentially the information products business growing, information products growing, that cleared the path to that 26%. On that note, when it comes to innovative offerings, our Mitchell 1 division, the one supplying software to independent shops, keeps winning, chasing customer connection and innovation, delivering excellent new products that boost shop efficiency; we've just rolled out — or rather Mitchell 1 just rolled out our fresh online appointment scheduling capability on top of the already extensive repair shop management software we have. Now a vehicle owner can request an appointment with only a few clicks on the shop's website, which automatically alerts garage schedulers about their request. As part of our Mitchell 1 shop management offering for independent garages, it's a terrific efficiency tool, and it shows once more how Snap-on Value Creation is writing the ongoing upward story at Mitchell 1. While we're on Mitchell 1, we've just opened a new facility for that information business, an improved operating and design environment. We're putting money into Mitchell 1 and we anticipate further success. RS&I also introduced during the quarter our new PRO-LINK Edge heavy-duty — it's a heavy-duty diagnostic handheld. A larger screen, a more user-friendly interface, quicker vehicle connection times, refreshed software and broader vehicle coverage. Snap-on already leads in heavy-duty diagnostics. That edge gets extended by the PRO-LINK Edge. It only came out at the close of the year and, so far, results look favorable. We continue pushing to grow RS&I's standing with repair shop owners and managers, providing additional new products to sell, created through Value Creation processes or brought in via our strategic and coherent acquisitions, and we're confident that formula wins. So that wraps up our fourth quarter. Arenas — areas of both challenge and of advancement; we believe we leave the year stronger than when we entered. And in the end, an EPS for the quarter of $3.08, up from the as-adjusted $3.03 from last year; and for the full year, as-adjusted EPS of $12.26, rising from the as-adjusted $11.81. Overall progress hard won against turbulence. Now I'll turn the call over to Aldo. Aldo?

Aldo Pagliari

executive
#5

Thanks, Nick. Slide 6 lays out our consolidated operating results. Quarterly net sales came to $955.2 million, a 0.3% increase, which came from a 0.6% organic sales gain, $3.5 million in sales from acquisitions, and $6.3 million of negative foreign currency translation. This quarter's organic sales gain came from low single-digit growth in both the Snap-on tools segment and the commercial and industrial segment, partly offset by a low single-digit decrease in the Repair Systems & Information Group. Much like what we saw in Q3 of 2019 overall, looking at it year over year, sales to United States customers rose while European sales kept showing weakness. Consolidated gross margin was 47.2%, versus 48% a year ago. That 80 basis point decline mainly comes from higher sales in lower gross margin businesses and 10 basis points of negative foreign currency effects, partly offset by savings from RCI initiatives. The operating expense margin was 29.3%, up 40 basis points from 28.9% a year ago. Q4 of 2018 had a $4.3 million, or 40 basis point, benefit tied to the legal settlement Nick mentioned earlier. Operating earnings before financial services were $171.4 million, which includes $2.5 million of negative foreign currency effects, versus $182.1 million in 2018, or $177.8 million as adjusted for the legal settlement. As a percentage of net sales, operating margin before financial services was 17.9% of sales, versus 19.1% a year ago, or 18.7% as adjusted. Financial services revenue was $83.9 million and operating earnings were $62.2 million, up 1.5% and 10.9%, respectively, from 2018, mainly because of year-over-year growth in our financial services portfolio and better portfolio performance, which produced lower provisions for credit losses. Consolidated operating earnings were $233.6 million, which includes $2.6 million of negative foreign currency effects, versus $238.2 million a year ago, or $233.9 million as adjusted. As a percentage of revenues, operating earnings were 22.5%, versus 23% a year ago. Against last year's fourth quarter as-adjusted operating earnings margin of 22.6%, which had a 40 basis point benefit from the legal settlement, this year's operating margin was 10 basis points lower. Our fourth quarter effective income tax rate was 22.3%, versus 22% a year ago. Lastly, net earnings were $170.6 million, or $3.08 per share, which includes a $0.04 negative impact tied to foreign currency, versus $175 million, or $3.09 per share, a year ago. In 2018, excluding a $0.06 per share benefit from the legal settlement, adjusted earnings were $3.03. For the full year 2019, fully diluted earnings per share were $12.41, up 4.5% over the $11.87 per share reported last year. Now let's move to our segment results. Beginning with the C&I group on Slide 7. Quarterly sales were $352.9 million, up 2.7%, which came from a 3.5% organic sales gain and $0.9 million in sales from acquisitions, partly offset by $3.5 million of negative foreign currency translation. Within that organic growth, we saw a double-digit improvement in Power Tools, a mid-single-digit rise in our Asia Pacific operations, and a low single-digit uptick in sales to customers in critical industries—especially sales to the U.S. military. Those gains were partly offset by a low single-digit drop in our European-based hand tools business. Gross margin came in at 35.5%, down 300 basis points compared with a year earlier, mainly because of higher sales in lower gross margin businesses, including sales to the military. Fourth quarter sales to the military rose substantially both versus last year and versus the prior quarter. The operating expense margin was 22.7%, an improvement of 100 basis points from 23.7% last year, largely driven by higher volumes in lower expense businesses. Operating earnings for the C&I segment were $45 million, a decrease of $5.8 million from last year, and the operating margin was 12.8% versus 14.8% in 2018. Moving on now to Slide 8. Sales in the Snap-on Tools Group reached $411.7 million, up 1.1%, which reflected a 1.3% organic sales gain, partly offset by $1 million of unfavorable foreign currency translation. That organic sales increase includes a low single-digit gain in our U.S. franchise operations, partly offset by a low single-digit decline internationally. Gross margin was 40.2%, including 40 basis points of unfavorable foreign currency effects, and it remained unchanged from last year. The operating expense margin was 27%, up from 26.2% last year, mainly because of higher field support investments. Operating earnings for the Snap-on Tools Group were $54.3 million, including $1.7 million of unfavorable foreign currency effects, a decrease of $2.7 million from last year. And the operating margin was 13.2%, including 40 basis points of unfavorable foreign currency effects, versus 14% in 2018. Turning to the RS&I Group shown on Slide 9. Sales were $335 million, down 1.4%, which reflected a 1.5% organic sales decline and $2.3 million of unfavorable foreign currency translation, partly offset by $2.6 million of acquisition-related sales. That organic sales decrease includes a high single-digit decline in sales to OEM dealerships through our equipment solutions business, partly offset by low single-digit gains in both sales of undercar equipment and sales of diagnostics and repair information products to independent repair shop owners and managers. Gross margin was 47.7%, up 20 basis points from 47.5% last year, while the operating expense margin was 21.7%, an improvement of 10 basis points from 21.8% in 2018. Operating earnings for the RS&I Group were $87.2 million versus $87.4 million a year ago, and the operating margin was 26%, up 30 basis points from 25.7% last year; now turning to Slide 10. Operating earnings from financial services were $62.2 million, an increase of 10.9% versus the fourth quarter of 2018. Revenue was $83.9 million, up 1.5% from a year ago. Financial services expenses were $21.7 million, a decrease of $4.9 million from last year's levels, mainly because of decreases in the provision for credit losses, reflecting improved portfolio performance as well as lower variable compensation and other costs. In terms of the average portfolio, financial services expenses came in at 1% and 1.3% during the fourth quarters of 2019 and 2018, respectively. Finance receivables yielded an average of 17.5% in Q4 2019, versus 17.7% a year earlier, mostly a reflection of the credit quality of customers who originated loans across the last several months. Contract receivables averaged a yield of 9.2% in each of those periods. Total loan originations reached $262.4 million, a decline of $4.7 million, or 1.8%, driven mainly by a 3.7% drop in finance receivables originations, partly offset by greater originations of contract receivables, largely franchise finance. Let's move to Slide 11. Our year-over-year — at year-end our balance sheet holds roughly $2.1 billion in gross financing receivables, with $1.86 billion of that coming from our U.S. operation. During the fourth quarter, our worldwide gross financial services portfolio expanded by $24.3 million. For U.S. extended credit, the 60-day-plus delinquency rate sits at 1.8%, holding steady and reflecting the seasonal uptick we normally see in the fourth quarter. When it comes to extended credit, or finance receivables, which make up the biggest share of the portfolio, trailing 12-month net losses totaled $49.4 million, equal to 2.91% of outstandings at year-end, a decline of 6 basis points sequentially, which supports continuing stabilization in how the portfolio's credit metrics are performing. Now let's turn to Slide 12. Cash provided by operating activities came to $196.7 million for the quarter, down $19.2 million versus comparable 2018 levels, mainly because of increases in working investment and cash paid for taxes. Net cash used by investing activities was $41.4 million, which included net additions to finance receivables of $24.6 million and capital expenditures of $21.6 million. Net cash used by financing activities totaled $139.2 million, which included $59 million of cash dividends and the repurchase of 435,000 shares of common stock for $71.2 million under our existing share repurchase programs. For full year 2019, share repurchases came to 1,495,000 shares for $238.4 million. At year-end, we still had availability to buy back as much as an additional $359.6 million of common stock under existing authorizations. Let's turn to Slide 13. Trade and other accounts receivable rose $2 million from 2018 year-end. Days sales outstanding stood at 67 days, unchanged from 2018 year-end. Inventories climbed $86.6 million from 2018 year-end, mainly to support the introduction of new products, higher levels of demand across critical industries, including demand for U.S. manufactured hand tools, as well as to improve service levels to our customers. On a trailing 12-month basis, inventory turns were 2.6, compared to 2.9 at year-end 2018. Our year-end cash position of $184.5 million rose $43.6 million from 2018 year-end levels. Our net debt-to-capital ratio fell to 22.1% from 24.2% at year-end 2018. Beyond cash and expected cash flow from operations, we have over $800 million in available credit facilities. At year-end, we had $193.6 million of commercial paper borrowings outstanding. That wraps up my remarks on our fourth quarter performance. I'll take a brief look at a few outlook items for 2020. We expect capital spending to come in somewhere between $90 million and $100 million, and at this point we're looking for our effective income tax rate for the full year 2020 to land in the 23% to 24% range. At this point I'll hand the call back over to Nick so he can share his closing thoughts. Nick?

Nick Pinchuk

executive
#6

Appreciate that, Aldo. Turning to Snap-on's performance in Q4. We faced some near-term uncertainty, currency headwinds that worked against us, and a decline in Europe — notably the difficulties tied to Brexit over in the U.K. Even so, we made meaningful headway in spite of those challenges. The overall gains were not easily achieved given those headwinds. Organic sales at Opco rose 0.6%. Our OI margin came in at 17.9%, which is 80 basis points lower than the 2018 as-adjusted figure, and that was affected by the mix of critical industry sales carrying more weight toward the military sector, which has a lower margin, along with adverse currency movement and investments aimed at bolstering the franchise network. There were broad improvements as well, with sustained momentum in RS&I and the repair information business, which posted a 26% margin. We saw encouraging movement in the industrial business, picked up ground in the U.S. van channel, and made notable headway in reinforcing our product line throughout the organization — greater customization, greater sophistication to align with what a shifting repair landscape demands; plus a finance company that posted NOI gains, which alongside opco brought us to an OI margin of 22.5% for the quarter, versus the as-adjusted 22.6% we saw a year earlier. Earnings per share for the quarter landed at $3.08, which tops the as-adjusted $3.03 from the prior year. On the whole, we hold a firm belief that our business remains robust, and we're confident that as we move ahead, we possess the opportunity, the standing, the offerings and the personnel to take on these headwinds and stay on our upward path throughout 2020 and past it; and before I hand things to the operator, I want to address our associates and franchisees directly. I'm aware that many of you are tuned in. To everyone across the Snap-on team, we understand that the outcomes for this quarter and this year come from what each of you does individually and together. For the devotion you show to our progress and the loyalty you bring to our company, I offer my gratitude. At this point I'll pass the call along to the operator. Operator?

Curtis Nagle

analyst
#7

So I suppose, to start, Nick, I have something to ask you. In what way would you characterize the conditions we operated under in tools during this year compared with the prior one, regarding items such as how competition stacks up, the fundamentals beneath everything, and product launches on your end? Do you figure organic growth will come in larger, or more or less hold steady? And regarding that optimism you brought up during the call, would you say it's possibly greater than it was, let's say, twelve months back?

Nick Pinchuk

executive
#8

I'd say that's right. Look, my view is — I made this point at the very start. My view is that we exit 2019 in a better position than when we came in. Never has our product line been this strong. We're witnessing advancement in the — perhaps not at the pace we'd prefer in the U.S. van channel, but the direction is up. On a year-over-year comparison, this quarter came in stronger than prior ones. And because of that, our feelings are fairly upbeat. When we speak with our franchisees, we get it, and with the technicians too, we get it — our fundamental strength. Put simply, the question is whether we can equip our franchisees with sufficient efficiency to handle the complex products, the sophisticated offerings, and sell them within the circumstances they face, rather than being limited by capacity or by time? For quite a while I've discussed how the van business is constrained by time; that's the reason we put money into it, and results are beginning to show. That said, though, we observe instability in the U.K. Actually, the U.K. came in slightly worse during this quarter. Conversely, Brexit did get signed, so then, lacking any insider knowledge regarding the schedule, things ought to improve from here. So my feeling there is fine.

Curtis Nagle

analyst
#9

Great, fair enough, and I have a quick follow-up for Aldo. In C&I for 2020, how should we think about the product and customer mix balance and how it might affect gross margin? Maybe pressure continues since military appears strong, though that could be a one-off. Might that reverse — or reserve — the mix impact on gross margin?

Aldo Pagliari

executive
#10

Curt, regarding military, I'd say the quarter probably had the largest sales from one specific job in that area we've discussed previously. You refer to it as the GMTK, the general mechanic's toolkit. So it was actually up double digits both year-over-year and sequentially, as I mentioned; it'll contribute significantly in Q1, though probably not at the same level as Q4. Additionally, what was missing in Q4 was some international sales within the critical industries. Those usually are solid margin contributors, so if they return to what I'd call more typical levels, you gain a bit more coverage and a more conventional gross margin mix. So we're happy about the military sales, don't misunderstand me. And they'll progress over time, but they ought to have a smaller mix effect as you see a bit more normalized impact across the overall critical industries.

Christopher Glynn

analyst
#11

I wanted to ask about Snap-on Tools' margin and how it behaves seasonally. In the past, you'd consistently see a ramp from the third quarter into the fourth, and last year looked like an outlier at the time, yet the same pattern showed up again this year going into the seasonal volume ramp. So I'm curious what has shifted. Is this now a new pattern where SOT sees sequential gross margin pressure from 3Q to 4Q?

Nick Pinchuk

executive
#12

It's possible this is indeed a new pattern for us. It wasn't only last year — I believe we've seen this kind of downward move for 2 years now. Part of that could come from our strong Christmas promotions, which — at times — carry somewhat lower margins. Here's what you might raise: fine, it's 40%. Gross margin came in at 40%. The figure of 40.2% was unchanged versus last year, and during last year we had substantial discounting tied to the Diagnostics business. You could be wondering — well, you might wonder, why hasn't it risen? I think the explanation goes like this. A year ago, we had that discounting. Currency had some impact but not as large, and we also had a small effect — some effect from the U.K.; this year, currency gave us 40 basis points and the U.K. contributed 20 basis points of effect, so once you combine those, you land at 60 negative. That means we actually achieved margin improvement year-over-year in the quarter. The only issue is that heavier currency impacts during the quarter tied to the Tools Group transaction effect, plus the U.K. remaining a problem for us. So they managed to overcome that and keep gross margin flat.

Christopher Glynn

analyst
#13

All right, yet if we look at just this year, what was behind the sequential drop?

Nick Pinchuk

executive
#14

Sure, I'd say broadly speaking, a sequential decrease has occurred. As for what took place within that decrease, and what's causing it, an increasing share of this comes from patterns at our plants — for instance, once you get into Q4, particularly when the hand tool operation has grown and turned into a larger slice of what we sell — the hand — the plants, which represent the most integrated product line in the United States, you encounter situations such as around Thanksgiving and around Christmas, you notice the impact, those enlarged hand tool plants, the impact of those carrying somewhat more weight than Q3 regarding the days off they get; as a result, absorption is worse during this quarter. At bottom, your sales are climbing, yet your absorption is falling owing to the days worked; that, in my view, is what has occurred. Look back 2 quarters, at a time when neither this discounting nor this legacy sales existed in Q4, that was truly the impact. And my expectation is that we will keep seeing this as we move forward with this sort of calendarization.

Christopher Glynn

analyst
#15

All right, and I was just curious — when I look at the rise in inventory along with the lower turns, I'm wondering whether any reserve was taken during the quarter for inventory that's excess or obsolete, or whether that could perhaps be something that emerges down the road from the higher inventory levels?

Aldo Pagliari

executive
#16

Nothing beyond the usual, Chris, this is Aldo. Given how our inventory is structured, once you apply the lower of cost or market test, we feel quite good about where our saleability stands. What I'd say is the largest growth in inventory is really new product introduction; and the pace of take-up wasn't as rigorous as we'd want for that, and we're confident as we look ahead. But as you're aware, we continue to aim for a higher level of sales growth. And when we fail to achieve it, the product exists and is available but it sits in inventory instead of in the sales line.

Christopher Glynn

analyst
#17

All right. And now my final question. The CFO declined somewhat compared to a year earlier, coming off really elevated figures the prior year amid considerable inventory strain. I'm just curious whether that sets things up nicely for fairly robust CFO expansion during 2020 that we might anticipate.

Aldo Pagliari

executive
#18

Sure — I definitely don't see any reason inventory must rise by the same amount it did in 2019. We attempt to approach that with a disciplined eye. What stood out in 2019 was that we carried more advanced kits across our critical industries clientele. As I mentioned, we experienced a significant wave of new product launches. We'll see some of those factors in 2020, yet as you're pointing out, nothing says the inventory buildup needs to reach the same scale as we witnessed in 2019.

Bret Jordan

analyst
#19

Could you share some thoughts on diagnostics within the U.S. van channel? I recall you folks were engaged in some educational efforts during the franchise event in August, and perhaps you could update us on where things stand with ZEUS and Apollo.

Nick Pinchuk

executive
#20

Sure. I can offer you some perspectives on that. We've had a solid — we have had — we keep on training our personnel, and we're collaborating with our field force, our diagnostic sales developers, the techno vans, and so forth, the field source, to attempt to, exactly as you mentioned, broaden the capabilities tied to that. Ours was — it rose by double digits and it increased quite substantially during the third quarter. Diagnostics declined in the fourth quarter when selling to franchisees, yet the flow from franchisees to the end user sort of tracked more conventional routes. Thus I would conclude that the — if you pull back and examine it and remark, alright, higher in the third quarter, somewhat lower in the fourth quarter, it's sort of maintaining the same level as previously. Consequently, we would state that additional effort is needed to help our franchisees grasp how to market this product. It has sort of advanced. And incidentally, ZEUS enjoyed a favorable quarter, which was a promising data point for us. So given ZEUS's favorable quarter, we believe there is some advancement, since that represents the toughest item to sell. So at this point we must ensure we focus on Apollo and TRITON to strengthen those. And I guess one takeaway from this is that we might have solved part of the challenge for ZEUS, but we need to put in a bit more effort regarding Apollo and TRITON.

Bret Jordan

analyst
#21

All right, excellent. Now regarding the U.K., you described conditions as turbulent, though perhaps improving because of Brexit. Has the number of vans shifted there at all, considering the difficulties those distributors are facing?

Nick Pinchuk

executive
#22

Indeed, a shift has occurred, though it's actually quite minor. It fluctuates. During the worst part of the slump, I believe it dipped slightly, yet it would rebound immediately. So I'd characterize it as nothing beyond typical fluctuation, honestly. Things haven't moved all that much. What I mean is, the U.K. has truly been a source of frustration for us, and it contributes disproportionately relative to its size when you look at the margins affecting our results. Still, we're putting in serious effort to bring it under control. We're collaborating on the products. We're attempting to educate the franchisees so they can capitalize on opportunities. Broadly speaking, what they sell consists of small, low, quick-return products; it's the larger-return products that typically decline amid uncertainty. Now that Brexit has been signed, I'm unsure. Yet I suspect once people grasp what will occur after Brexit, predictability comes back and the auto repair sector rebounds in the U.K. I'm fairly convinced that's how events will unfold. We're simply glad they ratified Brexit on January 31.

Bret Jordan

analyst
#23

Yes. And Aldo, one question, I guess, around the credit book. As credit quality improves and that's obviously reflected in lower rates, are you also seeing shorter loan terms?

Aldo Pagliari

executive
#24

No. Generally speaking, when products carry a higher price point, franchisees tend to elect terms of up to 5 years, pretty much across the board. And I don't see that — in fact, it's drifted slightly upward. The shift has been more toward — the average across the overall portfolio is a little bit north of 4 years. So I really haven't seen much of a change there.

David Leiker

analyst
#25

We'll just call that a case of user error. There are a couple of points. When it comes to what Snap-on tools spends on field support, my sense is we're likely about 2 full years into that at this point. Would you say that's accurate?

Nick Pinchuk

executive
#26

No, I wouldn't say that. My recollection is that we kicked it off perhaps during the fourth quarter of last year. Actually, I don't believe it's been 2 full years. That's — that's how I remember it, yes. And we've sort of been building it up here. So...

David Leiker

analyst
#27

So in what way do you — might you explain a bit about the way you establish, work out whether that is succeeding and generating added gains, say return on investment or a few other sorts of measurements, to gauge how well executing and delivering on that is going?

Nick Pinchuk

executive
#28

Well, I'd say there are two dimensions here, David. One, I'd say, is the broader — naturally, our attention is really on the U.S. And I believe we were clear about that. A distinct initiative is underway to fix things in the U.K. Our top priority, I'd say, is what occurs with sales in the U.S. van channel, and it has been trending up; thus this quarter came in stronger than the prior one on a year-over-year basis; so we can sense it trending up, perhaps not as quickly as anyone might want and perhaps not as quickly as we might want, yet that signals we're pushing the boulder upward. We're growing the capacity to sell; that's one matter; then come the local matters, much like a question asked lately, if our attention is on diagnostics, what occurs with each diagnostic platform? Since ultimately, this training is delivered platform by platform by platform by platform, and customer type by customer type and customer types; so we sort of break it down that way, platforms by customer. And so how well those nodules do is what we use to assess it; and it isn't only training. It's also items such as we're introducing a fresh set of vans we call the Total Shop Solutions; we've been growing them, we had 9 last quarter and 15 this quarter, not tied to diagnostics, but this is tied to other sales with longer payback such as hand-spin tire balancers and diagnostic workstations, which include tool storage box and so on. So we assess how those items are happening in every one of the territories. So I think I've long said that one of the limits of the tools — the van business is the time, and so what we're doing is attempting to make that time more effective. The finest thing is the sales. You reckon that occurs. If the sales rises, that's the finest thing to do. But we also have a sub-analysis. So that's our method. And we think it's working. I'd certainly prefer to see it work quicker, but we believe it's a way forward because we — go ahead, sorry.

David Leiker

analyst
#29

So, as I mentioned, when you consider the absolute amount spent compared with how revenues flow through, is there a threshold—at what stage do revenues begin increasing more quickly than that spending? Also, is there any moment when that spending could actually be reduced in some way? What's your expectation for how this unfolds?

Nick Pinchuk

executive
#30

Look, here's how I expect it to unfold. Once we begin approaching our goal, we start testing reductions. The way things operate for us, and it has always operated like this, is that we invest in order to secure sales growth. Then, as we solidify our position at that level of sales growth—and that level is set by capacity, meaning the franchisees' ability to sell—when we reach it, we aim to get better and more efficient at supporting things after that wave of securing. So when we arrive at, say, x percent growth, we tell ourselves, "All right, we've reached it. That's our level." We then attempt to determine how to accomplish it with greater efficiency. So we want to be in a position where we're confident that this growth is acceptable and matches the market and the opportunities. After we achieve that, we scale it back.

David Leiker

analyst
#31

David, if that’s expanding at a low single-digit rate in the U.S., then you’re nearing that growth target, right?

Nick Pinchuk

executive
#32

Yeah, though I wish we were nearer. Right, nearer, getting nearer. Yeah, yeah, yeah. That’s right. Yeah, it isn’t easy — yet that’s how we operate, David; we take ground and afterward we run it more efficiently.

David Leiker

analyst
#33

Then there's just one more thing for you, Aldo. You never brought it up, and we've discussed this before, but do you have anything new on the bad debt provision, that accounting change? Can you give us any kind of framework so we understand what it will mean once you adopt it in Q1?

Aldo Pagliari

executive
#34

Here's what I can tell you: the formal, final reporting on that is going to come in our K, and that isn't very far off. In fact, our plan is to put out the K at the — before next week is over, actually. So I'll just put that out there as a statement. That said, here's my take: the workaround has been pretty intense and handled well; and I'm happy with the effort we've devoted to it so far. And what you're referring to is CECL. For everybody else listening, that's a mention of the adoption of CECL, which takes effect for the corporation in January of 2020. So basically, the actual reporting of it happens when the quarter ends, really. But here's what I'll say: as of right now, David, my expectation is that our total adjustment comes in at under $10 million, around that magnitude. The final figure, though, won't be locked in until roughly a week from now.

Scott Stember

analyst
#35

Could you provide additional detail about a few of the other tool categories when it comes to growth, such as power tools and hand tools?

Nick Pinchuk

executive
#36

Absolutely, absolutely. During this quarter, hand tools declined somewhat, while power tools rose by double digits. So as I mentioned, power tools delivered an excellent quarter; and mainly, tool storage increased, diagnostics decreased somewhat. So incidentally, I'd urge everyone not to become overly excited regarding these quarterly figures, since they fluctuate, based on what occurred during the prior quarter and what — when new products arrive; for instance, power tools is performing well this quarter since we have an excellent new product and everyone has been anticipating it. And so it gets introduced. And so that's among the reasons it's performing well. Now, since keep in mind, our perspective on things is that franchisees face capacity constraints. We're expanding. That's the reason the franchise operation in the U.S. is once more growing. But it's somewhat of a — when you get a new product, it has a tendency to push aside certain other products. But that's the introduction. Hand tools declined this quarter after rising throughout the year, yet power tools increased rather strongly. Tool storage rose once more, diagnostics fell. That's roughly the narrative this quarter. Last quarter told a different story.

Scott Stember

analyst
#37

Understood. Turning now to RS&I — I realize we've enjoyed several strong quarters when it comes to sales comps. The OEM business recovering accounted for part of that, yet we're seeing choppiness return in that area. So how did RS&I perform across the entire year, once more, on an organic basis? And considering what you said about certain dealerships holding back given softer car sales, do you anticipate returning to positive comps come 2020?

Nick Pinchuk

executive
#38

Well, look, regarding what happens with the OEM dealership business, we aren't certain. That's the piece we describe as, well, a lumpy business. And having been employed by Ford myself, I can tell you they — cash flow in this business shifts monthly across 5 years. So what I mean is, their attitudes shift monthly; so we aren't certain. When I look out and check the IHS forecast, next year they're projecting a decline of 1% to 2%. My sense is we'd likely witness similar conditions for a little while. Now RS&I finished the year up low single digits. What I find interesting, though, is that 26% for RS&I, I believe, stands as the highest-ever gross OI margin, so from that angle they had an okay quarter. Sales were simply down due to that OEM business. But the information business — where independent repair shops rose once more, which is what propelled that 26% since it's high-margin business — and Mitchell 1 is a — has grown consistently for us. So if you examine the RS&I businesses, and I'll step back and discuss them, Mitchell 1 appears to grow consistently. We just put money into a new building. We didn't make that move without thought; and therefore, we believe it's got a great future. Diagnostics tends to fluctuate but we're training the franchisees to become more comfortable with the new groundbreaking product of intelligent diagnostics. We expect that to move forward. The OEM businesses, which represent about 1/3 of the businesses, are hard to predict, it can be lumpy. And significantly, what's lost in the sway here is the equipment business posted a positive this quarter for RS&I, and it hadn't been positive for a while. So we regard that as a fairly — even amid a turbulent quarter, we regard that as one sign of good news. So going forward, I think — we think the OEM business, uncertain. Perhaps it will match this quarter for a while. But the remaining businesses have good opportunity.

Scott Stember

analyst
#39

All right. And just one final question. When you look at the business over a longer horizon, do you still expect that, over that longer term, the company could grow at a mid-single-digit rate on an organic sales basis?

Nick Pinchuk

executive
#40

Yes, yes. I believe the market exists. I believe we have the product and the stake. I believe our constraint is capacity. I've said this — if you've been listening to us, for years, we've stated that one of the limits tied to the van channel, space and time, is that we're facing a time constraint. It's obvious. You can observe it, in the way the world operates. And so we need to break through that, just as we did in earlier years. We need to find ways to help those franchisees make better use of their time, and we think we can do that. And then in the C&I business, if you have 13 straight quarters for industrial and with 5,700 new products, well, that becomes more and more complicated and it pushes inventory, but the dogs are buying the dog food there. The one thing is, in this particular quarter, one of the big businesses was low margin. That won't last forever.

David MacGregor

analyst
#41

A few things I'd like to ask. To start, since we've devoted so much discussion to field support, could you at minimum quantify how much margins were affected, Aldo?

Aldo Pagliari

executive
#42

I wouldn't single out field support by name. Clearly, that spending is something we undertake, alongside various other internal measures we track, David; however, the pressure it puts on the OE portion of the Snap-on Tools Group's financials is visible. Even so, we won't size it precisely.

David MacGregor

analyst
#43

So there's no way for you to provide us with a rough scale or any sort of figure on that?

Aldo Pagliari

executive
#44

No, I don't believe I can.

David MacGregor

analyst
#45

All right. I suppose I’d like to know, among your franchisees, what share saw an increase compared with the same period a year earlier during the fourth quarter?

Aldo Pagliari

executive
#46

I’m sorry, our what?

David MacGregor

analyst
#47

In Q4, what share of your franchisees would have posted growth?

Aldo Pagliari

executive
#48

Well...

Nick Pinchuk

executive
#49

I don't think we know that necessarily directly.

Aldo Pagliari

executive
#50

Right. In the U.S., we're seeing a rise in the low single digits, as we mentioned, and inside that portfolio you'll find a range. Naturally, certain ones will come in above that level, and certain ones will come in below it. That said, we won't break things down by how many franchisees have gone up as opposed to how many have gone down.

Nick Pinchuk

executive
#51

Usually, what we do is break them into quintiles. When the business is up, that trend typically shows up pretty evenly across them; so what you end up seeing is that about 60% of the — 60% to 65%, possibly 2/3 of the franchisees are moving in the same direction as the overall business. That's typically what you get in any given quarter; and those figures rotate in and out; it really doesn't shift all that much from one quarter to the next.

David MacGregor

analyst
#52

All right, and it feels as though we have reached a stage in this industry where consumers purchase over the internet, and I am certain technicians follow the same pattern. Tools are being sold by you through your site. Could you discuss whether — and perhaps this connects to the entire concept of that time limit you brought up when replying to the previous person's inquiry. Yet how big is the chance to build up internet-based sales in this case? Perhaps figure out how to return the credit to whichever franchisees the customer signed up under. Still, say a few words regarding the potential for expanding through online channels as...

Nick Pinchuk

executive
#53

In my view, folks — in my view, those we serve do not — we do make it available to them on the web. Yet on the whole, those we serve appreciate the visibility, the in-person visibility of the franchisees. That is — in my view, that is the key. Delivering close-up, individualized advice and direction regarding how — walking through the tool, which are becoming, I suppose, increasingly intricate, increasingly advanced, plus direction regarding its operation, followed by the notion of extending credit in that same close-up, individualized manner, and then the notion of having a substitute available immediately is what our franchisees and those we serve appear to favor; they might go on the web yet they do not always take advantage of it; now if we believed we were being forced in that direction, we would examine it somewhat further, yet hand tools have risen and one would assume that would be the #1 product line purchased over the internet given that it is simpler and folks generally are familiar with hand tools. Nevertheless, hand tools have risen this year. As a matter of fact, they have proven stronger across the last 2 years. So that is roughly how we see it. We attempt to leverage the web-based tools to improve. It is among the efforts we make to improve the franchisees' productivity when it comes to their collections, when it comes to how they engage with those they serve regarding specials and matters of that nature. Those are the chances we identify; we identify the link whether via social media or conventional web channels, whether Twitter, whether Facebook or Twitter or actually, sending texts or simply email, though not many folks bother with email these days. And for our franchisees to engage and keep those we serve informed about matters, that is part of how we view the web and helping the franchisees become more productive.

David MacGregor

analyst
#54

So what would the picture for online growth be for you at this point?

Nick Pinchuk

executive
#55

Well, I'd say it isn't...

David MacGregor

analyst
#56

Off a small base, obviously.

Nick Pinchuk

executive
#57

Pardon me?

David MacGregor

analyst
#58

Starting from a modest foundation, clearly. Still, I'm merely attempting to grasp what...

Nick Pinchuk

executive
#59

Likely it has risen somewhat, yet not in any major way; the increase isn't substantial since, when it comes to our online business, buyers are considering the assistance they receive from franchisees; therefore, our aim is to maintain that franchisee assistance, as it forms part of what gives us an edge, and next, to leverage any form of electronic media so franchisees are better equipped, exactly as I mentioned.

David MacGregor

analyst
#60

Alright, perhaps I can continue this discussion with you after the call, since it's an interesting subject.

Sara Verbsky

executive
#61

Thank you everyone for being with us today. A recording of this session should be accessible soon at snapon.com. As we always do, we value your interest in Snap-on. Have a good day.

Operator

operator
#62

That wraps up today’s call, everyone, and we appreciate your joining us. At this point, you’re welcome to disconnect.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Snap-on Incorporated transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Snap-on Incorporated earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Snap-on Incorporated or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.