Snap-on Incorporated (SNA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 22, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Sara Verbsky
executiveThanks, Emma. Good morning, everybody. We appreciate you being here as we go over Snap-on's results for the third quarter, and you can find all the specifics in the press release we put out earlier today. Joining us on this call are Nick Pinchuk, who serves as Snap-on's Chief Executive Officer, and Aldo Pagliari, Snap-on's Chief Financial Officer. Nick is going to get us started this morning by sharing how he sees our performance. After that, Aldo will walk through our financial results in greater detail. Once Nick offers a few final remarks, we will open things up for your questions. As we normally do, slides are available to go along with what we discuss. You can reach these slides through the Downloads tab inside the webcast viewer, and they are also posted on our site, snapon.com, in the Investor section. Those slides, together with a transcript of today's call, will be kept on our website. If anything said on this call relates to management's expectations, estimates or beliefs, or otherwise expresses management's or the company's outlook, plans or projections, that constitutes a forward-looking statement, and actual results could differ materially from what those statements indicate. You can find additional information, along with the factors that might cause our results to differ materially from those in the forward-looking statements, in our SEC filings. Lastly, this presentation contains non-GAAP measures of financial performance, and those should not be viewed on their own or as a replacement for the comparable GAAP figures. Additional information, including a reconciliation of non-GAAP measures, appears in our earnings release and on pages 14 through 16 of our conference call slides. You can locate both on our website. With all of that covered, I would now like to hand the call over to Nick Pinchuk. Nick.
Nick Pinchuk
executiveAppreciate that, Sara. Morning, everyone. I'll begin today by covering the key points from our third quarter. I want to give you a view of how the virus situation is unfolding and the trends we're seeing now and looking ahead. I'll also discuss where we stand physically and financially; and Aldo will walk through a more thorough review of the financials. We look at the third quarter as yet another encouraging stretch, and the metrics plainly affirm Snap-on's resilience, demonstrating our capacity to keep up a track record of positive results, shifting from the early hit of the virus and the related disruption of activity toward a blend of creating safe and effective methods to back the essential character of our business, and in certain segments it's beginning to resemble psychological recovery, where customers start regaining confidence in what's ahead, and return to full buying engagement. The quarter's results confirm all of that, showing substantial elements of progress, with sales and profitability improving sequentially throughout our operations despite the virus, and the Snap-on team kept advancing by growing our ability to adapt to the threat and safely pursue our essential commercial opportunity, moving along upward paths in line with our overall view of how the days of the virus are unfolding. When it comes to geography, COVID's effects remain uneven across the regions where we operate. Asia Pacific is still virus challenged. Southeast Asia and India remain in deep turbulence. Meanwhile, Europe displayed some indications of recovery. Regarding business segments, particular areas — education, oil and gas, aviation — faced greater and more prolonged difficulties, which you might anticipate; in fact, how quickly our customers adapt to the environment does differ by segment, but leading the upward charge are our vehicle repair technicians, who support the essential mobility of our society, and our direct selling vans, with our franchisees delivering extraordinary face to face value — both are seizing the full opportunities and the numbers prove it. And looking forward, we see considerable additional opportunities as society pivots toward suburban locations and more individual transportation. I'll tell you, that's music to the ears of the vehicle repair operation. We believe we truly have abundant opportunities on the road ahead. And for that reason, we're keeping our focus on Snap-On value creation — safety, quality, customer connection, innovation, and Rapid Continuous Improvement, or RCI. And in this area, that emphasis — in this era, that emphasis is especially important in customer connection and innovation; we're pursuing that focus to generate a continuing stream of great new products, positioning our operation — operations — to monetize the accommodation and the psychological recovery that outlines the path to the future; and then in the third quarter, Snap-On value creation, customer connection and innovations drove growth amid the uncertainty and led to significant additions to our long line of product and innovation awards. Snap-On was prominently represented with three Motor Magazine Top Tool awards. Additionally, we received five honors from professional tool and equipment news, or peak 10 innovation awards, yet the most notable recognition was 18 P10 people's choice awards, in which technicians—the real users—do the choosing. Eighteen is a substantial figure. It matches the record we set only a few years back. You can see a key catalyst for our expansion, whether or not the pandemic exists: inventive products that simplify work. That has always been our forte, and these hard-earned honors demonstrate that outstanding Snap-On products continue to arrive, keeping pace with tasks of rising complexity and sustaining our momentum even amid turmoil. That covers the big picture. Let's turn to the results. Third quarter reported sales came to 941.6 million, an increase of 39.8 million, or 4.4%, over 2019, which includes a 34.6 million, or 3.8%, organic gain, 4.2 million of positive foreign currency translation, and 1 million from acquisition related sales. On the earnings side, OpCo OI for the quarter was 185.7 million, which includes 1.5 million in direct virus-related costs and a $4.5 million negative impact from unfavorable currency, versus 167.7 million a year ago. The OpCo operating margin reached 19.7%, a rise of 110 basis points. For financial services, operating income was 65.6 million, an improvement over 2019's 61 million, even as 60 day delinquencies got better year over year, over year, and that outcome, combined with OpCo, produced a consolidated operating margin of 24.5%, a 130 basis point gain. Overall EPS came in at $3.28, compared with $2.96 a year earlier, which is a 10.8% rise in a rather difficult environment. Those are the headline figures; now the groups. In CNI, third quarter volume was 308.4 million, including 2.2 million of favorable foreign currency, and declined 8% as reported and 8.6% organically. That reflects the reductions in—we're discussing—lower sales to our customers in critical industries. I mentioned a few, and in Asia Pacific. Meanwhile, our European based hand tool business was basically flat versus last year. That's a positive outcome, considering the dual headwinds of COVID-19 and the economic turbulence now present in that region. On earnings, C&I operating income was $43.1 million, a drop of $5.2 million, including $1.4 million of unfavorable foreign currency effects and eight-tenths of COVID related expenses. C&I sales fell 8.6%. OI declined 10.8%, a sensible ratio, showing that RCI and cost containment did much to counterbalance the effect of reduced volume at C&I. Furthermore, the group demonstrated meaningful sequential improvement. Both the sales and OI declines shrank substantially relative to the second quarter, confirming the positive upward trajectory that began after April. As for critical industries, military and international aviation once again kept growing, while activity in education, oil and gas, and U.S. aviation was hit especially hard. That's probably what you'd anticipate, considering how those specific industries are doing. Still, we stay confident in, and dedicated to, expanding within the critical industries. Looking ahead, we’re seeing more chances open up, and the main route to making that possible comes through connecting with customers and innovating, which together produce strong new offerings. Yes, our European hand tools operation proved resilient during the quarter. A solid share of innovation helped it along, including items such as our brand-new Bahco ERGO line and insulated cutting and holding pliers. We rethought the steel mill and improved our heat treat process, creating a new metallurgy that achieves the ideal balance of strength and reliability; because of those particular material benefits, the edges were redesigned and enhanced, progressive blades that cut soft cables at the tip as well as hardwires near the joint, enormous versability — versatility. The new players have longer jaws and are aligned with greater precision, better access and more accurate work. The insulation satisfies the IEC 60900 international standard for working with live systems up to 1,500 volts DC, considerable protection, safety in the — in vehicle repair or in industrial environment. Strength, reliability, flexibility, accessibility and safety, the ERGO plier is a strong addition to the Bahco lineup of insulated tools, now totaling 250 strong, all focused on electrical work. The new pliers were launched just this quarter, and I’ll tell you, the recession was quite enthusiastic.
Nick Pinchuk
executiveOur 14.4 volt compact cordless power tool lineup keeps gaining attractive options. Two strong new products arrived this quarter, built for repair shop work and production line tasks. First, the new CGRS861 and CGRR861 incline and right angle grinder, which deliver high torque, longer run time, and extended motor life, all in a compact, lightweight body that's easy to maneuver. A dual collet system comes on both new units, accepting both eighth-inch and quarter-inch bits, which opens up a wide range of accessories, and that feature, paired with our built in spindle lock, delivers very quick changeover. That's a time saver customers like. Another feature of these new devices is adjustable speed operation, something that matters a great deal when tackling a wide range of service tasks. August was our launch month. It's obvious technicians have responded, and two of these grinders now rank among our million-dollar hit products. C&I continues to show positive movement quarter over quarter while supporting the essential. Every one of the businesses keeps delivering steady gains and leaves the quarter in better shape than it started, with product investment responsible for a substantial share of that momentum. Turning now to the Tools Group. Per our report, revenue rose 16.8% to $449.8 million, a figure that includes $1.8 million in favorable foreign currency, and organic same-store sales climbed $62.8 million, or 16% — 16.2% — with the U.S. and international operations both posting double-digit growth. Earnings from operations came in at $87.1 million. That figure includes $400,000 in costs tied to the virus, plus $2.9 million from unfavorable foreign currency. For comparison, last year's number was $53 million. How the Tools Group performed operationally made it plain that our read on COVID-19's path was right, that the vehicle repair sector can hold up, and that our direct, face-to-face band model is strong. When the quarter began, franchisees were looking for better and better methods of dealing with the pandemic; toward that end, they went after help from the essential side, and we backed that push by providing time-saving tools such as added automation for collecting from customers, renewals of remote diagnostic software, and data bundling across multiple franchisees. We've introduced new tech tools designed to simplify working amid the pandemic and to free up limited time for franchisees no matter the circumstances. And, as most of you probably know, our yearly Snap-On Franchisee Conference, or SFC, typically takes place in the third quarter. Not surprisingly, this one looked nothing like any prior version. We scrapped the face-to-face get-together, and pushed our 100th anniversary festivities planned for that gathering into 2021. Rather than the standard affair, we gathered on the weekend that would normally have been set aside for the SFC, but did so as a virtual event, broadcast live from the Forge. Over 3,800 van drivers took part remotely — that's just about 98% of the North American network — and it made for what I'd call an energetic Friday night start. The agenda included presentations about major offerings, training sessions covering what makes certain products stand out, and seminars on how to sell effectively. Once that Friday show wrapped, 180 separate videos went up on demand, each one spotlighting products, programs, and training. Across the weekend, franchisees generated over 43,000 views of that material. Sunday afternoon marked the finish of the live from the Forge activities, and I have to say, the whole thing was plainly a win. This kept up what the SFC has always been about — putting fresh offerings in the spotlight, strengthening what our franchise can do by way of top-notch training, and building up the brand through an upbeat message along with lots of enjoyment. During live from the Forge, nobody could miss how much excitement among franchisees gets generated by new product. Our confidence in the strength of what we offer is very high, and good reasons support that. The product awards came up in what you heard. Beyond those, though, as franchisees saw for themselves, there's an ongoing flow of other terrific new items — possible honorees for next year, things that draw attention, make fixing vehicles less difficult, and truly assist technicians in handling the growing complexity of cars as each model year arrives. To give you one illustration: at the conference we pulled the wraps off our New Steel Titan Roll Cab, which comes in a fresh color scheme. It's eye catching, with dark titanium paint and brushed blue trim, plus special accents in bright blue, the Snap-On nameplate, the S-ranch logo sitting on the cap face, and a unique S-ranch imprint inside every liner. The Titan certainly turns heads, I can tell you, yet it also makes work easier: three extra wide drawers that give you easy access to the tools you reach for most, the speed door, better organization for all sorts of small items such as drill bits, and a power drawer so you can charge power tools thanks to an exclusive power Snap-On, an exclusive power strip design featuring five offset AC outlets along with 2 USB ports. Fixing vehicles has become a matter of getting back to mental well-being, building up trust, and beginning to put money into things that take longer to pay off — and a steel tighten fits that need perfectly. Even during the pandemic, this product generated real enthusiasm, and it has kept doing so ever since; customers are fans of it. This quarter also brought the launch of the new 8 piece, power steering and alternator polymaster set a handle, which lets technicians remove and install presson pullies on most GM, Ford and Chrysler engines with greater ease. This handle's one-of-a-kind reversible dual design comes with multiple adapters, so switching between models happens quickly and productivity goes up — something that matters quite a bit in the garage. For getting power steering pump, alternator, and vacuum pump pulleys on and off without trouble across a wide variety of vehicles, that master set is really essential. We build it at our plant in Elkmont, Alabama — made right here in the United States. I visited that facility just last week, and I have to say, the team there is outstanding. So it comes as no surprise that the master set got such a strong initial reaction. Within its very first month, it earned a spot on our list of hit million dollar products. That covers the Tools Group — meeting the challenges of the pandemic, capitalizing on the psychological recovery, pushing innovation forward, and building strength for what lies ahead. Let's turn now to RS&I. The RS&I segment, meanwhile, showed a notable gain over Q2, cutting the gap down to 1.6%. You'll recall that in Q2, revenue fell 29.8%. That's quite a change. Volume during that period — and for Q3 too — totaled 317.5 million, a figure that factors in 800,000 from favorable foreign exchange and $1 million from recent acquisitions. This somewhat softer level of activity mirrored ongoing expansion in sales of diagnostic and repair information offerings to independent repair shops, alongside unchanged capital expenditure on undercar equipment, all offset by better yet still reduced activity across vehicle OEM projects. RS&I operating earnings reached $80.1 million, a drop of $3.2 million, which mirrors the reduced volume. The OI margin stood at 25.2%, a decline of 60 basis points, with a 10-point impact stemming from currency. Thus, although the group overall experienced some effect, diagnostics and information-focused operations keep expanding; and yet again, newly introduced products paved the path. One of the fresh offerings brought to market during the quarter was our newest intelligent diagnostic device, the Apollo D9, built with ergonomics in mind, this new handheld — it is a new handheld and it comes with ultrafast, 2-second startup capability, a bigger 9-inch touch display and multiple preloaded training videos loaded straight onto the tool for immediate access.
Nick Pinchuk
executiveOur platform runs on intelligent diagnostics software, more than 1 billion repair records, and in excess of 100 billion unique diagnostic events — all arranged so technicians can repair vehicles far more quickly. We have discussed reducing how long it takes to sell our complex diagnostics and boosting how much our franchisees can sell. So, live from the Forge includes an in-depth seminar about running and selling the new Apollo, and to give that remote selling even more force, every franchisee got a fresh demo unit so they could follow along live, hands on with the program. Beyond that dedicated training, the unit could be put to use right away the following week to show off the new Apollo's strong benefits out in the field, and that appears to be paying off. Even though it launched near the close of the quarter, what we hear on the street is that our new handheld will do a great deal to push forward our strategic thrust into intelligent diagnostics. We have faith in RS&I's strength, and we keep working to grow its standing among repair shop owners and managers, easing their work through excellent new products even during the days of the virus. So that was our third quarter: taking in a shock after the accommodation, then shifting toward psychological recovery, protecting our people as we serve the essential, carrying on with sequential gains on a positive trend, a successful SFC at a distance, proving how powerful our direct selling van model is, and results ahead of last year. Sales rose 4.4%, OI margin reached 19.7%, 110 basis points greater. Financial services steered through the virus era with strike, and EPS came to $3.28. All of this while sustaining and putting money into our strengths of products, brands and people. It was a heartening quarter. Now I'll hand the call over to Aldo. Aldo?
Aldo Pagliari
executiveThanks, Nick. On slide 6, you'll find an overview of how we performed on a consolidated basis. Net sales for the quarter reached $941.6 million, up from $901.8 million during the same period last year. That reflects organic growth of 3.8%, a $4.2 million benefit from favorable foreign currency translation, and $1 million in sales tied to acquisitions. The organic improvement was driven by better year-over-year results sequentially across each of our three operating segments, and the Tools Group led the pack, posting a double-digit sales increase in the third quarter versus a year ago. While the Commercial & Industrial and Repair Systems & Information segments both finished below where they stood in the third quarter of 2019, each improved considerably over their 2020 second quarter levels. During the quarter, COVID-19 continued to act as a drag in some regions and sectors; on the whole, however, the forward motion we experienced in June persisted across the entire third quarter throughout every one of our businesses. Just like we did a year ago, during the prior quarter we pinpointed $1.5 million in direct expenses tied to COVID-19. That figure encompasses direct labor, under absorption stemming from temporary plant shutdowns, pay for associates in quarantine, event cancellation charges, plus additional costs required to support today's heightened health and safety conditions. Gross margin on a consolidated basis came to 49.9%, compared with 49.7% a year earlier. That 20 basis point gain is mostly due to increased sales volumes and advantages from RCI initiatives, though it was partly offset by 50 basis points of negative foreign currency impacts. Our operating expense margin came in at 30.2%, which is a 90 basis point improvement over last year's 31.1%, primarily driven by the effect of stronger sales and savings from cost containment measures, while also accounting for how COVID-19 has affected the broader business environment. In financial services, operating earnings reached $185.7 million, a figure that includes $1.5 million in direct COVID-19-related costs and $4.5 million in adverse foreign currency effects, compared to $167.7 million in 2019 — a 10.7% increase year-over-year. When you look at operating margin before financial services as a share of net sales, it came in at 19.7%. That figure includes 20 basis points tied directly to COVID-19 costs and 60 basis points from negative currency movements. Compared with 18.6% a year earlier, that's a gain of 110 basis points. Turning to Financial Services, revenue reached $85.8 million during the third quarter of 2020, up from $84.1 million the prior year. Operating earnings there were $65.6 million versus $61 million in 2019, driven mainly by expansion of the Financial Services portfolio and reduced provisions for credit losses. On a consolidated basis, operating earnings totaled $251.3 million, a figure that factors in $1.5 million in direct pandemic-related expenses and $4.3 million in adverse foreign exchange impacts, compared with $228.7 million the year before. When you look at it relative to revenue, our operating earnings margin came in at 24.5%, up from 23.2% back in 2019. For the third quarter, the effective income tax rate was 23.4%, versus 23.5% a year ago. And then net earnings landed at $179.7 million, which is $3.28 per diluted share — that's up $15.1 million, or $0.32 a share, over where we were in 2019, and it works out to a 10.8% rise in diluted earnings per share. Let's move on now to how the segments performed. Starting with the C&I Group — that's on Slide 7. Sales there were $308.4 million, down from $335.3 million the prior year, which breaks down as an 8.6% drop in organic sales, partly offset by $2.2 million of favorable foreign currency translation. The main reason for that organic decline was a drop in the low teens for both sales to critical-industries customers and our Asia Pacific business, while the segment's Europe-based hand tools operation was basically flat. If you break out critical industries, increases in international aviation and U.S. military sales were outweighed by lower natural resources results — oil and gas among them — plus technical education sales that kept falling. In Asia, customer sales in India and Southeast Asia remain behind the rebound that other parts of the region have started to show. Our gross margin landed at 37.3%, which is a 60 basis point decline compared to a year ago. The main drivers were lower volume and 50 basis points of negative currency headwinds, though those pressures were partially offset by savings on materials and gains from the company's RCI programs. On the operating expense side, the margin was 23.3%, an improvement of 20 basis points over last year. For the C&I segment, operating earnings hit $23.1 million, and that figure includes $1.4 million in unfavorable foreign currency effects, versus $48.3 million in the prior year. Operating margin stood at 14%, compared with 14.4% a year-ago. Let's turn now to Slide 8. During the quarter, the Snap-on Tools Group generated $449.8 million in sales. That compares with $385.2 million back in 2019. The improvement came from a 16.2% organic sales gain along with $1.8 million in favorable foreign currency translation. Within that organic growth, our U.S. franchise operations posted a mid-teen increase, while the segment's international operations rose roughly 20%. Gross margin for the quarter reached 45.5%, which was 210 basis points higher. The main drivers were the greater sales volumes and benefits from RCI initiatives, though 70 basis points of unfavorable foreign currency effects partly offset those gains. On the operating expense side, the margin came in at 26.1%, which is an improvement over the 29.6% recorded a year earlier. The main drivers were the effect of selling more volume and the money we saved through cost containment measures, such as reduced spending on travel and meetings. At the Snap-on Tools Group, operating earnings reached $87.1 million, a figure that includes $2.9 million in negative foreign currency impacts, up against $53 million in the prior year. Operating margin stood at 19.4%, versus 13.8% twelve months ago. Moving on now to the RS&I Group, which you can see on slide 9. Sales totaled $317.5 million, down from $322.7 million the year before. That reflects a 2.2% decline in organic sales, partly offset by $800,000 in positive foreign currency translation and $1 million in sales from acquisitions. Within that organic drop, there was a high single-digit falloff in revenue from OEM dealerships, which was partly counterbalanced by a low single-digit gain in sales of diagnostic and repair information products to owners and managers of independent repair shops. At 47.3%, gross margin was down 40 basis points year over year, and that figure reflects 10 basis points of negative foreign currency impact. Operating expense margin came to 22.1%, which is 20 basis points above the 21.9% recorded a year ago. Turning to the RS&I Group, operating earnings reached $80.1 million compared with $83.3 million in the prior year, while operating margin stood at 25.2% versus 25.8% a year earlier; those results include 20 basis points of unfavorable currency movement along with 10 basis points tied to direct COVID-19 costs. Next, let's look at slide 10. In Financial Services, we brought in $85.8 million in revenue, compared to $84.1 million during the same period last year. Operating earnings for Financial Services came to $65.6 million, while in 2019 they were $61 million. Our expenses in Financial Services totaled $20.2 million, which is $2.9 million less than the previous year, largely because we set aside less for credit losses, reflecting a year-over-year decrease in net charge offs. If you look at expenses as a percentage of the average portfolio, they were 0.9% in the third quarter of 2020 and 1.1% in the third quarter of 2019. For the third quarter, finance receivables had an average yield of 17.8% in 2020 and 17.7% in 2019. Contract receivables had an average yield of 8.4% and 9.2%, respectively. The 2020 figure for contract receivables yield reflects the effect of lower interest business operation support loans extended to our franchisees. Those loans were made available in the second quarter to help franchisees manage their operations and cope with the COVID-19 situation. At the close of the third quarter, roughly $16 million of those business operating support loans were still outstanding.
Aldo Pagliari
executiveIn the third quarter of 2020, we had total loan originations of $252.8 million, versus $253.5 million a year ago. Both finance receivables and contract receivables originations came in basically level with where they stood last year. Let's move on to slide 11. At quarter end, our balance sheet shows roughly $2.2 billion in gross financing receivables, and $1.9 billion of that comes from our U.S. operation. Our worldwide gross financial services portfolio was up $25 million during the third quarter. Collections on finance receivables for the quarter reached $185.2 million, against $181.6 million in collections during the third quarter of 2019. As we said last quarter, because of the COVID-19 pandemic, we did extend short term payment relief, or forbearance, to certain franchisees who qualified as customers. By the end of September, those accounts with forbearance terms had returned to more normal levels and accounted for under 1% of the finance receivable portfolio, versus roughly 2.5% at the close of the second quarter. Trailing 12-month net losses on extending credit, or finance receivables, came to $46.7 million, which was 2.7% of outstandings at quarter end, a decrease of 23 basis points sequentially. For U.S. extended credit, the 60-day plus delinquency rate was 1.5%, against 1.7% a year ago. Sequentially, that rate rose 50 basis points, largely reflecting the usual seasonal bump of 20 to 30 basis points we see between the second and third quarters, plus the 20 or 30 basis point benefits to this rate that showed up in the second quarter of 2020 tied to the deferred payment programs offered through June; now let's turn to slide 12. Cash provided by operating activities during the quarter was $224 million, an increase of $92.9 million over comparable 2019 levels, mainly reflecting higher net earnings and net changes in operating assets and liabilities, including a $57 million decrease in working capital, driven largely by lower year-over-year changes in inventories. Net cash used by investing activities totaled $18.8 million, which included net additions to finance receivables of $11.7 million and capital expenditures of $10.1 million. Net cash used by financing activities was $105.1 million, which included cash dividends of $58.8 million and the repurchase of 300,000 shares of common stock for $45.1 million under our existing share repurchase programs. At the end of September, we still had availability to buy back up to an additional $294.5 million of common stock under existing authorizations. Moving to slide 13, trade and other accounts receivables fell $75.7 million from 2019 year end; days sales outstanding came in at 64 days versus 67 days at 2019 year end; inventories rose $4 million from 2019 year end; on a trailing 12-month basis, inventory turns were 2.4, though that's a slight improvement from 2.3 times at the end of the second quarter, compared to 2.6 at year end 2019. Our cash position at quarter end was $787.5 million, against $184.5 million at year end 2019. Our net debt to capital ratio stood at 15.5%, compared to 22.1% at year-end 2019. Beyond cash plus the operational cash flow we expect, we also hold over $800 million worth of credit facilities we can draw on. When the quarter closed, nothing had been drawn against that credit facility, and no commercial paper borrowings remained unpaid. That wraps up what I wanted to say regarding how we did in the third quarter. At this point I'll hand things back over to Nick so he can share his closing thoughts. Nick?
Nick Pinchuk
executiveThanks, Aldo. This quarter gives us reason for optimism. Across our operations—every group, C&I, RS&I, and Tools—things are getting better step by step, and we're struck by how much of a psychological rebound is taking hold, which traces a distinct and ongoing upward path. There's a notable increase in the Tools Group, which came in at 16.2% organic same-store sales growth, which validates the possibilities that exist in vehicle repair and demonstrates what our manned network can do. Financial service is doing nicely amid the turbulence, plainly showing how sturdy its processes and its portfolio are, along with the favorable results overall. Sales rose 4.4%, 3.8% on an organic basis, OI margin was a solid 19.7%, which amounts to an improvement of 110 basis points. EPS came to $3.28, a gain of 10.8% versus last year, meaningful advances in the face of the turbulence. All of this was accomplished while we deliberately kept building up our strength and edge in product, with a variety of new offerings, in brand, with a successful SSC in spite of the distance, and in people. Our team is staying whole. You can see that we hold a confident belief that near-term momentum will keep carrying us upward, and we acknowledge that our opportunity has grown in the context of shifting technologies and, over the long-term, with more people using personal vehicles. And we're preserving our advantages throughout the virus, so that Snap-On will stand at full strength, seizing these plentiful opportunities, propelling steady improvement through this challenging stretch, and far past it. Now, I want to address our franchisees and associates directly—I'm aware that many of you are on the line—this quarter was encouraging. And a bright future is indeed ahead of us. And I know that none of it could happen without your energy, your capability and your dedication; for the essential efforts you make in supporting our society, you have my admiration; for your remarkable achievement and for driving us forward, you have my congratulations. And for the commitment you continue to show our team, you have my thanks; at this point I'll hand the call to the operator. Operator?
Christopher Glynn
analystMorning, and nice work on a solid quarter.
Nick Pinchuk
executiveAppreciate it, Chris.
Christopher Glynn
analystAt Tools Group, I'm just wondering how we should frame that growth — it truly came without any warning or prior example over the past several years, unless perhaps the way to view it is 2Q to 3Q together on a year-over-year basis, or in terms of…
Nick Pinchuk
executiveWell, here's how I see it: I believe we mentioned this as we entered the first quarter; during the first quarter, we noted that March hit us hard, yet before that point business looked fairly strong. So I think we'd put money into products and processes that let us support the franchisees' capability better, and we began noticing that late in last year's fourth quarter and in the first quarter. And then, KT Bar <<inaudible>>, the one who acts on the virus, and so activity declines. But we began to observe recovery among people, which is why we describe it as shock accommodation. They began to accommodate, and we noted that June was rebounding, following an upward path. So as you examine the third quarter, I think you frame it this way: fine, some makeup exists, I presume, when activity fell so severely, especially in April. Some of that is catch-up, yet here's what strikes us as sensible when you examine the sales off the van — those sales off the van have remained robust for quite a while. They outperformed our sales during the second quarter. And during the third quarter, they were equally robust far into — clear weak, well into double digits each month. And then, reviewing it afterward once the third quarter ended. The sales off the van rose year-over-year by a clear amount. And so they're play it by clear amount, so I believe that's the data point. It appears to me we're returning to something like that upward path, though what comes next is difficult to predict. I suppose that's the $64,000 question. What pleases me about what I observe in this sort of circumstance is that Tool Group appears to be firing on every cylinder; the wildcard might be Europe, and during the quarter one of the great things about that quarter was the UK, which rebounded rather nicely. I'm not sure whether you noticed the international operations up double digits, and that hadn't been the case; and so plenty of fluctuations exist there, and that might be an uncertainty ahead across those geographies and so forth, but let me tell you, plenty of momentum exists and plenty of solid reason — we see plenty of solid reasons behind this, and the franchisees growing more capable in the manner we understood how to overcome this, since, you know, this wasn't our first rodeo tied to the downward trend. And we understood how to guide our franchisees through it, and we guided them through it and it paid off. So I guess, you sort of take a look at that, right, 16.2% on an organic basis, that's a sizable figure, but we truly extracted the profits; and — and if you consider things away from the van side, it demonstrates there's demand out there and vehicle repair has come back; it's nearing, it's nearing what we describe in our own setting and our own framework as psychological recovery, and the vans are capitalizing on that. What pleases us about this is, we've shifted to something arithmetic. It demonstrates how resilient vehicle repair is amid turbulence, plus the optimism and the strength of the face to face bad model. As we empower them with these technologies, we've been assisting them.
Christopher Glynn
analystThank you; and only as a follow-up, I got curious about how far you folks would consider moving the payout ratio upward, since organic reinvestment, bolt-ons, and share repurchases, you know, are pretty well handled by your sort of pay-as-you-go levels there. I believe, you know, that some field makes a compelling argument for a payout ratio of 50% to 60%, and I'm curious what you think about that?
Nick Pinchuk
executiveWell, Chris, you likely realize that in the recent past, we typically take another look at the dividend rate during the fourth quarter, which is nearly here. And as with each meeting we hold with the Board of Directors, we'll have that conversation and we'll attempt to move ahead by whatever amount we judge to be within reach. Understanding that Snap-On handles the dividend increase, sort of like a perpetuity. Once more, that's the pattern we've followed historically and I'll sort of stop there.
Aldo Pagliari
executiveYes. I mean, when it comes to how we govern our policy and dividends, that's forever. We see it as a foundation and a mark of how sturdy and strong our model is. So that's something we firmly believe in.
Luke Junk
analystHello, everyone. Thank you for taking the question. I have two questions about the ToolsGroup. First, I'm curious whether you could share something about how each product line is growing. From what I can tell, diagnostic revenue probably rose at a modest pace, judging by what you said regarding RS&I. Second, on storage — if we simply consider originations, things appear quite steady. Should we interpret that as handle sales being the primary source of the momentum, or is there another factor we ought to weigh?
Nick Pinchuk
executiveI suppose the answer is partly affirmative, though with some caveats attached to what you asked — I'm not entirely sure. Let me put it this way: before anything else, I want to offer this as a disclaimer. Examining just one quarter's byproduct figures isn't going to reveal a whole lot, since the outcome hinges greatly on which items get brought in — which products and programs land with the franchisees and then reach the technicians during that period — and that has a big impact. So a single quarter can't really tell you anything meaningful here, though it does beat poking around blindly with a sharp stick, which is sometimes what these situations amount to. Anyway, here's the key point: on big ticket items, we saw growth this quarter. During the quarter, our franchisees' sales increased — yes, they went up. Tool storage, in fact, had a strong quarter. There's a lag between originations and sales — specifically, our sales into the vans. Keep in mind that what you observe from us is sales to the vans, and afterward they need to, well, first off, they have to arrive; once delivered, the people then set them up, locate a purchaser, secure credit, and so forth. Because of that, some disconnect in timing can occur. Overall, yeah, that's accurate. Hand tools had a really strong quarter for us—extremely strong—and they were out front, though power tools also posted a solid gain. So there were quite a few products that came in higher. Hand tools, obviously, and a lot hinges on what you promote and which new items you roll out, which is the reason I brought up the master set, since hand tools was a standout this quarter, but not in a way that shut out, for example, total storage and the rest.
Luke Junk
analystAll right. That’s…
Nick Pinchuk
executiveAnother thing, I believe, that you’d take away from this — when you look at originations, effectively, what are they at, 0.3% or so, or perhaps somewhat larger here in the U.S., and you hear me say that tool storage decisions sit with the franchisees and big ticket purchases also rest with the franchisees — you’d say it isn’t the product’s model; rather, the fact that things are flat, and even flat we’re slightly up versus a year ago, means a psychological recovery is coming. Put differently, the garages and the franchise, and then the technicians along with the franchisees themselves, are beginning to have faith in what’s ahead and the confidence to put money into items with longer payback periods. In terms of the mindset across the whole industry, this is something of a watershed for vans. Among the setbacks — and if you consider it, wow, you simply step back and you take in the general news regarding the auto industry, but you also sort of glance around — you know, vehicle repair is actually quite robust; in fact, technician wages rose in August, according to — the rollings roll up, so I view that as a positive. And when I head out, when I visited the factory in Alabama — you know, in Elkmont, Alabama — I also visited franchisees; I spoke with a number of franchises nationwide, and every one of them describes robust garages. When I stopped by a garage recently near where I am, you couldn’t even enter the parking lot because there were so many cars. So I’d say this is going quite well.
Luke Junk
analystAll right. My second question is really just for clarification. Could you tell me where things stand with those deferred payment sales plan programs you described to us in April? Did those initiatives affect the quarter at all when it comes to sales in the Tools Group? And on the credit side, even though you referenced roughly a 20 to 30 basis point sequential effect on U.S. extended credit delinquency rates, should we treat that as completely washing out in the third quarter relative to what you might call the noise in 2Q?
Nick Pinchuk
executiveDuring Q3, no portion of sales came out of the deferred programs, simply because no deferred programs existed. Now, I'd point out that our Elite franchisees — the folks enrolled in the Platinum program known as Elite — have always enjoyed the right, as part of ordinary operations, to provide a 60 day deferred program; so I wouldn't label that anything but routine activity; so nothing distinctive happened in Q2 or in Q3 that gave the sales line a boost. As for how this touches delinquency rates, collections, and charge-offs, we take all of it into account drawing on our track record, which is substantial, since although our COVID-19 experience is limited given that this is our first time facing it, we nonetheless have extensive experience with catastrophic events, which tend to be more localized. And within our provisioning, we do account for the losses you'd expect when customers make use of deferred programs rather than non-deferred ones. So with all of that said, I suppose I'd rather not say 'it washes out,' but the fact is it's essentially already baked into our results. As for what lies ahead, whether we roll out additional deferred programs is still to be determined. We'll examine the opportunities, and if they arise, we'll consider it, and see whether it gives a reason to buy now. What strikes us as interesting is that absent COVID, nobody would be sitting on the edge of their seat over this. I understand that everyone is eager to know whether the credit company will run into trouble with collections, delinquencies, and so forth, all because of COVID. Yet the truth is, deferral is simply an ordinary part of how we operate. We offer it every so often; it occurs on a regular — not regular, not periodic basis, but it occurs fairly frequently. We just vary it so that, for instance, our customers get a reason to buy now, and a franchisee gets a reason to switch up a sales pitch and have something to discuss with those customers.
Luke Junk
analystThat's helpful on both of those, so I won't push any further. Appreciate it, everyone.
Bret Jordan
analystMorning, folks.
Nick Pinchuk
executiveMorning. How's it going?
Bret Jordan
analystGood. Hey, when you consider the effect of — I suppose — the mix, it sounded like hand tools were really strong. Do you figure stimulus had a part in that? I mean, clearly garages are getting business since folks are putting their own cars back on the road, have you used...
Nick Pinchuk
executiveI think, I don't know. Look, I think, my take is, first off, most of our people are working. You can look at it, things dropped. I believe hours were down 5% or so in April. And then it came right back, and generally what we're seeing, what I hear from my franchisees — and I've spoken with plenty of them — garages are largely employed. So I don't figure unemployment is a major factor. I mean, the unemployment thing or the PPI. You could have made the case that whatever folks received early on, like $1,200 or so, that may have assisted. I'm reading that people deposited that, I don't know; but I think it would have ended in the second quarter; we sort of believed that might have aided us in the second quarter. That was among the questions for us, when we saw the tools group rise and reach 3%, or I guess it was 2.4% in United States and that sort of thing. We figured maybe that could have been assisting us. But I — my feeling is, it was probably either banked or spent before it. I don't think it was fueling the third quarter. I don't think. And I don't think those — I don't think our people are sitting on the edge of the seat, waiting for Congress to approve another one; now if they do…
Bret Jordan
analystRegarding the combination of people paying with cash and those using credit — it appears your tools figure was quite robust, yet the credit accounts didn't expand as much; did a meaningful move toward paying in cash actually occur during Q3?
Nick Pinchuk
executiveIndeed, a move did happen in the direction of the smaller — not exactly a move, but during that quarter we enjoyed solid hand tools performance, and those are typically RA rather than extended credit. Keep in mind, whenever you mention credit, whenever credit comes up, every item purchased by buyers using credit falls under that.
Bret Jordan
analystCorrect.
Nick Pinchuk
executiveEvery single thing. Okay? So really, all you're discussing is if it's credit over 12 to 15 weeks or credit spanning three years or four years — everything gets sold on credit, essentially. Thus I don't believe, if you state — if you toss that into a pot and claim all of it was sold, then I don't witness folks using cash that much. I haven't encountered people paying with cash; plus our RA book has risen somewhat, since hand tools performed well. Whenever hand tools do well, that's what you observe, and credit with longer terms usually is slightly reduced. Yet in truth, we believed longer term credit, considering conditions were fairly strong during the quarter; now, like I mentioned, I reckon it signals improvement in the overall perception of the repair shop; now, should some miracle occur and those folks in Washington come together and choose to give everyone $1,200, I figure that might be the cherry on top, I'm not sure. Still, I doubt we received much during the third quarter. I genuinely don't.
Bret Jordan
analystWere you discussing how the third quarter flowed? I mean, clearly the timing — there was no franchise event, so perhaps customers were opening their wallets sooner or —
Nick Pinchuk
executiveYeah, okay. I mean, the flow across the — Bret, how the third quarter flowed isn't as obvious as what happened in the second quarter, since we're climbing out of some — April was absolutely terrible. So, what I'm saying is you're emerging from that and you sort of build upward, but in general, if you examine — I mean if you want to discuss the Tools Group, if you examine revenue off the van, which barely feels any SFC effect at all. It was — every single month landed in the double-digit territory without question; therefore, I'd say the flow off the van was quite steady. Things fluctuate based on where the SFC sits, I'd argue, in this case. Occasionally, say, whenever there's a live SFC, folks usually hold back their spending since they're eager to arrive and then spend — it's nearly comparable to Disney World. We were — it's nearly comparable to an enjoyable outing once they arrive, and they dash around and purchase all these items. And so this one felt somewhat more restrained since it was added this time, hence not as thrilling, so they bought a bit sooner than they otherwise would have, and I believe that pushed things up; so, that's a reasonable take. Yet if you examine what comes off the van, it appears steady.
Bret Jordan
analystThank you. Thank you.
Nick Pinchuk
executiveSure.
Curtis Nagle
analystMorning, everyone. Really appreciate it.
Nick Pinchuk
executiveCurt, how's it going?
Curtis Nagle
analystGood. Nick and Aldo, what's up, how are you both?
Nick Pinchuk
executiveWe're doing fine.
Curtis Nagle
analystFantastic, fantastic. Good to hear that. So perhaps starting with the inventory question. It appears there was a solid reduction. Could you share a bit about which segments experienced, I suppose, the steepest drops, or I guess the most significant shift compared to last year?
Nick Pinchuk
executiveIn the Tools Group, I'd say we didn't really observe a notable decrease, though you need to view that through seasonality's prism. Inventory in the Tools Group invariably climbs during the third quarter, since we're getting ready for sales and preparing to fulfill the surge of orders that follows an SFC. So essentially, flat inventory this quarter signaled that the Tools Group's seasonal pattern looks quite favorable, actually, relative to what we — what one would anticipate had it been a typical year. The remaining groups, I believe, declined. Our total inventory, I think, dropped by a fair amount, so that's — I think it was — just as you'd likely anticipate during this sort of period.
Aldo Pagliari
executiveRight, Curt. In terms of constant dollars, our inventory declined by roughly $28 million to $29 million. Nick already pointed out that the Tools Group was fairly level when it came to the change in their inventory, while the remaining amount was split more or less evenly across the commercial and industry groups, and both of them contributed to bringing inventory down, which makes sense given that their sales weren't as strong as they had been a year earlier.
Nick Pinchuk
executiveHowever, the point I really wanted to drive home on this call — hey, let me highlight something: I'd say both of them got better in sequence. C&I, if I recall, fell 25%, then 19.7%; roughly 20% during that quarter — and in Q2 it was 8.6%, which is a solid gain. Then the one that truly surprised us was RS&I. Honestly, I'll admit it: given the mood among the OEMs, we figured RS&I and the garages themselves would struggle more to bounce back and would need more time. Yet they went from — as I mentioned in my script, down 29.8% the prior quarter — to, I believe, a 2.2% organic decline and 1.6% lower as reported, so that's quite a shift. So in those businesses, despite lacking the dazzling figures the Tools Group delivers, since their sectors remain in a phase of adjustment and aren't anywhere near a psychological rebound, you're still witnessing fairly strong momentum.
Curtis Nagle
analystGot it, that's helpful. Then perhaps a brief point of clarity regarding what I suppose you'd call the sequential pattern for sell-through on the vans, the Tools Group from 2Q into 3Q — did things get better, or how exactly did that pattern go? I wasn't quite…
Nick Pinchuk
executiveYes, it got better. Definitely better, it got better; though — how should I put this — it was — during Q2, I'd say it was running ahead on the sales to demand. The sales side was sort of — if you'd like to frame it that way Curtis, here's one way to frame it, and my sense would be that Q2 inventory was getting pushed out somewhat. Inventories were declining since sell-through from the van was somewhat stronger, not great. Still, they were stronger than — plus they began spiking up during June, which explains why we began discussing the Tools Group during June, we were able to see that, in fact, I believe we mentioned it on a call. After that, during the third quarter, roughly the same, the van, sell-through from the van was roughly the same as the, you know, close enough for government work was roughly the same as the sales to the van. That's the way it goes. So my take is simply that sales to the van sort of caught up. It doesn't appear they're accumulating inventory in the third quarter, though, it simply appears they sort of remain stable.
Curtis Nagle
analystAll right, that sounds great. Many thanks, and best of luck for the remainder of the quarter.
Nick Pinchuk
executiveOn to the next one.
Gary Prestopino
analystMorning, everybody.
Nick Pinchuk
executiveMorning, Gary. Nearly everything I wanted to ask has already been covered, though I do have one thing — regarding the modest currency-related boost you saw on the revenue line, how much did that affect adjusted EPS during the quarter, Aldo?
Aldo Pagliari
executiveIn fact, currency cost us $0.06 per share on EPS. Sales did get a lift, but we took transaction losses on currency. Those came mostly from selling goods made in the U.S. into Canada and the United Kingdom, and also from the commercial industrial group. This relates to movements between customers whose books are in euros and supply sources based in Sweden. That is what caused the transaction impact.
Nick Pinchuk
executiveSo what takes place, Gary, is that with the transaction, translation effects are usually present-oriented, whereas transactions have a tendency to look backward, since you establish the product's cost at the point it ships, and it may not be sold until a later time, and that is the reason for that gap, so basically the transaction lags behind the situation.
Gary Prestopino
analystAlright. So you'd anticipate a smaller hit, for sure, when it comes to work?
Nick Pinchuk
executiveCorrect. You wind up with higher sales — that's the good part — and reduced profit — that's the bad part.
Gary Prestopino
analystAll right, excellent. And then earlier in this quarter, especially, we're hearing about COVID making a comeback, and I believe the UK has imposed stricter lockdowns. Could you perhaps discuss what you're observing at this early point in Q4 across different parts of the globe?
Nick Pinchuk
executiveGuidance isn't something we actually provide. But look, my general perspective, I can share: boy, you know, if you look at the United States, I'm not sure. Vehicle repair in particular, I think, won't take another hit. You know, they're not — actually, no region will take another hit. No matter what occurs, I believe our folks will handle it better than they managed in the April and March period; so that's sort of the broader picture. I think, look, the United States sort of keeps moving toward March, you know, nobody can predict exactly what will happen; but I think our — the adjustment keeps going in the United States across all our areas. Europe has dual challenges with economics and so forth. So it's difficult to see, across all those geographies, what will unfold there. Again though, I don't believe they take another hit. So I think, you know, they handle it, though it might be slowed or it might be sped up. Asia Pacific, China obviously is fine, I think. Japan ought to be fine. I think, I have no idea what on earth is going on in India and Southeast Asia, but their capacity to cope with this situation appears to be completely flat on their back. So, so we'll see how those — that's my read on how it plays out; and I think, you know, we see an upward trend, as we mentioned, last time. I think, I believe in the shock accommodation, psychological model, but how steep that upward slope is will shift based on how conditions develop. I do think they'll report a fight against the really bad news and that's really, I'm not telling you anything we could have just as good a quarter or a better quarter next time.
Gary Prestopino
analystOkay. Thanks. I appreciate that.
Scott Stember
analystGood morning, everyone.
Nick Pinchuk
executiveScott, how are you?
Scott Stember
analystFine. You've already covered the bulk of what I wanted to ask, but let me return to the U.K. within the tools segment. I'm aware that conditions there have clearly been difficult for the last 12 months to 18 months, and they deteriorated during the second quarter, yet the improvement we witnessed in U.K. tools was really striking. Could you elaborate — was anything else at play? Were new products rolled out, and can you help me gauge whether this rebound can be sustained?
Nick Pinchuk
executiveSeveral factors are at play. In my view, we think the U.K. They've traveled a pretty long way, and actually the climb upward for them had already begun in June; it just wasn't happening at the level we were at, but looking back, April had them further down, and if you studied how the curve sloped upward during June, you'd go hold on, there's something going on there. I think one piece of it is that folks absorbed the shock and were truly shocked; after that you had the economic side of things stacked on top. Speaking just for myself, three factors played a role. One, they started to loosen up. Two, the virus sort of shifted people's attention away from Brexit, they weren't focused on it, you know, to the same degree. Thus, it wasn't creating financial pressure for folks, nor was it draining—at minimum, once the virus situation got better, they began figuring things out. And number three, we restructured our network so that getting the new product trained over there would be just as strong as it is here. It simply happens a bit afterward. Therefore, we're bringing in certain diagnostics that had already been rolled out here but weren't available there, plus additional new products. So the new product has consistency; it wasn't unlike what happened in the U.S., but what I'm saying is, we kept pushing that new product in there relentlessly. I believe, I believe those make up the three factors. At this point it has risen, and as you put it, the increase was fairly strong. We'll find out how things unfold. Still, my sense is it won't take another hit like that.
Scott Stember
analystGot it. Thank you.
Nick Pinchuk
executiveSure.
David MacGregor
analystYes, good morning to all of you. Nick, congratulations — yes, well done on a solid quarter. I suppose the thing that was raised a bit earlier regarding certain spending habits and the techs who exited those 90-day deferrals, I'm curious whether we might revisit that at the outset here, and specifically those individuals who were eligible for the program and got relief from it — once they left it, what sort of purchasing behavior did you observe from them, or had they essentially dropped out of the market, and the momentum you delivered this quarter comes from the remaining portion of the — of the base?
Aldo Pagliari
executiveDavid, my view is that folks continue to spend; we don't break things out based on whether someone simply has an easy loan. Keep in mind that two-thirds of business activity involves the franchisee on a revolving account type basis. And they stay largely active. I'm certain you'll hear every sort of example. A few might hold off purchasing for a period, even though people continue buying each and every week. You see every sort of pattern, yet the reality is there was a deferred program and I'll say it really dramatically alters the flow of activity, since, again, we've had programs of this kind more regarding Q2, certainly given how unusual it was, but fairly consistent. What you must always keep in mind — people asked Nick earlier in this call about stimulus. Keep in mind that everyone holding a job, and I believe we stated, the majority of our customer base still hasn’t come to has additional discretionary money in their pocket just because many other places to spend your money aren't open, whether that's going out to dinner, catching a movie or attending a sports game, so that people possess more money beyond merely stimulus checks arriving in the mail, and techs favor the right tools, which he's been shown over the tunnel of time.
David MacGregor
analystYou'd figure, I think, that when a person exits a furlough lasting 90 days due to tight credit, they probably won't purchase all that eagerly.
Aldo Pagliari
executiveHold on, hold on. That belief simply isn't correct.
David MacGregor
analystIs that so?
Aldo Pagliari
executiveThey aren't—they aren't hurting for credit. Here's the situation. What we did—we didn't simply extend 90-day terms to folks who lacked access to credit. We presented 90-day terms as an incentive to make a purchase right away. Think of it like financing a vehicle; so the idea is, I believe the idea is, do those individuals recognize who you are? You're about to purchase a still tight, David? Alright, am I able to receive a 90-day deferral or not? I may accept it, correct. You may accept it. It's every dollar that you possess. You may accept it.
David MacGregor
analystOkay, thanks for clarifying that — I appreciate it. I'd also like to explore the difference between the growth you've achieved in C&I and RS&I versus what's going on in the Tools Group. I understand that, directionally, both C&I and RS&I are moving in a positive direction relative to what you reported in Q2. Even so, we're still seeing high single-digit declines in C&I, high single-digit declines in the OEM dealership business, and RS&I. That appears to conflict somewhat with the mid-teens increase in the Tools Group, so I suppose my question is: what's your take on that divergence? And then, second, do we expect those other businesses to catch up in Q4?
Nick Pinchuk
executiveHere's my take on it. Catching up is something I believe could happen. Let me put it this way — you can treat what I'm about to say as an ironclad rule for your short positions on this. Generally, when something like this hits on the macroeconomic side, what we tend to see is that smaller companies — assuming they remain in operation, and vehicle repair has remained in operation, though they might not see it that way — appear to be profitable, and they're spending in that ongoing kind of way. My sense is that the larger a company gets, the more likely it is to focus on future conditions? I can't say for certain. They become somewhat more hesitant in that regard. There's a somewhat greater forward-looking concern that bothers them during the day and influences the choices they make daily. I believe this has been the case for as long as I've been here; we've witnessed it as macroeconomic expectations rise and fall; so, when you examine C&I, you notice certain other segments facing particular difficulty, particular difficulty. Other segments, such as military and international aviation, are up, and you notice heavy truck doing somewhat better. So that's something you can observe. In the end, though, what we observe is them bouncing back—that's the key distinction. The reasons are really the sector itself, the broader conditions, plus the reality that these garages operate on a smaller scale, which puts them nearer to where the money is being made and where things are actually happening, so they feel more sure as they watch it keep going. My view is that it comes down to mindset. Turning to RS&I, what you've got there is an effort with two sides. On one hand, the independents, who generally show some improvement, and on the other, the dealers, who took quite a hit emotionally early on. They were on a roll—entering the pandemic period, as I'm sure you're aware. Starting from a likely bearish stance — okay, SAAR will decline in the coming year, does that seem favorable? What might occur is this: they entered this period feeling rather downbeat, maybe even sitting on too much inventory; once they clear that out, a rebound begins; even so, I get the impression those people grow a bit more cautious regarding putting money into future projects. Don't forget, our C&I and RS&I segments tend to track capital-oriented activity more closely, right? Those are strong businesses, but they demand greater capital, and you'd see them acting more, I'd say, diluted. Even so, I think they'll pull through. During this quarter, we're genuinely pleased with how RS&I is performing.
David MacGregor
analystSince we've reached the top of the hour, let me pose one more question, and I'm sure we'd all like to bring this to a close; even so, it appears that software sales could have played a bigger role in this quarter too. You mentioned the Apollo D9, though additional launches happened as well.
Nick Pinchuk
executiveRight; indeed they were — see, software accounts for roughly one-third of RS&I, the Mitchell 1 Software operation, which involves repair shop information and managing those shops across both cars and trucks...
David MacGregor
analystThat falls under the Tools Group.
Nick Pinchuk
executiveThe Tools Group is what you mean?
David MacGregor
analystYes.
Nick Pinchuk
executiveI'm referring to RS&I. I had thought — you were discussing the Tools Group.
David MacGregor
analystWhat I'm asking about is the Tools Group.
Nick Pinchuk
executiveMy apologies. Regarding the Tools Group, the software operation performed fairly well, yet I wouldn't describe it as having delivered an exceptional contribution or one that was disproportionately large. This quarter, it truly didn't jump out at us in any particular respect. It was acceptable, though it wasn't something you'd have labeled a driver of variance.
David MacGregor
analystRight. Then here's my final question. If franchisees are going after big-ticket items once more, your storage operation sounds solid, and diagnostics sounds like it was fine. We ought to witness some fairly strong origination figures in Q4, isn't that so? So what might it be — ?
Nick Pinchuk
executiveWell, all right. That's assuming, correct —
David MacGregor
analystRight.
Nick Pinchuk
executiveRight, right.
David MacGregor
analystIt kind of seems like you're getting a kick out of this, I suppose, right? If —
Nick Pinchuk
executiveThings look fine, I'd say. Yeah, that's a fair thing to assume.
David MacGregor
analystAll right. So should we observe —
Aldo Pagliari
executiveOnce more, David, making that choice is always open to them. Keep in mind that Snap-On gains an advantage from residual values that I'd describe as the strongest in this industry. Consequently, whenever trade-ins come in — and in diagnostics especially that turns into a real consideration — that's precisely why the penetration rate for diagnostics is, for one reason, on the lower side. Odds are decent the financing can be taken care of via the RA account. Suppose, for instance, you bring in a $2,000 trading unit against a $3,000 item — those don't necessarily need to be financed. That's the reason you end up with somewhat of a different blend. And my sense is that with interest rates this low, a number of franchisees believe they possess the wherewithal to stretch somewhat, or to borrow in their local market rather than through Snap-On Credit. Given this low interest rate environment, I also think they enjoy a certain versatility. So that explains why predictability isn't the same regarding what lands on the easy program. And once more, keep in mind: that call belongs to the franchisee. The decision isn't Snap-On's to make.
David MacGregor
analystNo, no. But I'd imagine right now a franchisee might say to themselves, my exposure on the RA is a full 100%, whereas on the EC it's only 25%, so I'm probably better off.
Nick Pinchuk
executiveThat isn't always the case.
Aldo Pagliari
executiveWell, yes, David, but if you pull back a bit and consider the lengthy span of history, the rates at which we default, and the franchisees observe this. Keep in mind, our franchisees tend to stick around for quite a while as well; on average, they bring 14 years of experience. They recognize that while defaults are never a certainty, they are fairly foreseeable to a degree, and across both favorable and unfavorable periods, they remain somewhat consistent. So they aren't quick to jump ship, though naturally, at the edges, you'll find a mix of behaviors. But they don't hurry into a panic and think, okay, let's offer the Snap-On credit since they've got just 25% at risk compared to 100%. Sure, a few might think about that. Yet the vast majority won't.
Nick Pinchuk
executiveRight. So David, inside the franchisee community there's a kind of mental math going on — they want to keep some short-term RA on hand alongside a portion of longer-horizon items, and they manage things to hold that balance. That means if something comes up in a sale that sits right on the edge, it could nudge them in one direction or the other. I'd say that's largely accurate. So here's the situation: sure, it's 100%, but the duration is shorter. Their feeling is that this individual is good for the money, they're comfortable with it, so they'll take it, get him liquidated, and move him along to the next thing.
Aldo Pagliari
executiveOkay, so, David, there are folks who rely on a metric — RA flips — and our view isn't that way at all, though some will say, oh, when RA flips are up, that has to mean trouble is ahead, when in fact RA flips have actually declined relative to storage levels. No, once more, we don't read much into that, but fine. It doesn't look like franchisees are making any dramatic attempt to unload credit readiness.
Nick Pinchuk
executiveLike I said, the franchisees appear to have plenty of cash. What I mean is, their levels of on hold are fairly modest. So from a network standpoint, I'd say the franchisees are likely in a stronger position than they have been for quite a while.
David MacGregor
analystWell, I appreciate you taking my questions. Congratulations on the results, and best of luck this quarter.
Nick Pinchuk
executiveAll right. Thank you.
Sara Verbsky
executiveWe appreciate everyone being here with us at this time. Soon, a recording of today's session can be accessed on snapon.com. As we always do, we value the attention you show toward Snap-On, and have a good day.
Operator
operatorThank you, ladies and gentlemen. This concludes today's teleconference. You may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Snap-on Incorporated transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Snap-on Incorporated earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Snap-on Incorporated or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.