WHSP Holdings Limited (SOL) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
September 26, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Tanny Mangos
executiveThis is Soul Patt's presentation of financial results covering the year that ended on 31 July 2024. I'm Tanny Mangos, and I look after Investor Relations at Soul Patts. It's my pleasure to welcome today's presenters. Todd Barlow, our Managing Director and CEO, will take everyone through the highlights of group performance. Todd will also present the group's financial results, since our CFO, David Grbin, was unable to attend owing to surgery. Happily, his recovery is going well. Here with us in the room are Steve Jones, who handles finance, and Phil Neal, who handles treasury; both are available to answer any financial questions. Brendan O'Dea, Chief Investment Officer, will give an update on how each investment portfolio has performed, along with an overview of capital management. After that, Todd will wrap up the presentation with the outlook, and then we'll move to Q&A. <<operator_script>>. On that note, I'll pass things over to Todd Barlow.
Todd Barlow
executiveThanks, Tanny, and hello everyone joining the call. Soul Patts, as the majority of you are already aware, is a diversified investment house unlike any other in the Australian market. Growing shareholder wealth is our goal, achieved through a diversified range of investments capable of performing across market cycles. Our team actively manages a portfolio of over 200 investments, and we're able to adjust the investment mix so as to extract the highest quality risk-adjusted returns. As at 31 July, the value of our portfolio stood at $11.8 billion. We delivered a strong performance this year and continued our track record of generating enduring returns for our shareholders. In this presentation, the financial performance for our shareholders will be covered in more detail. But I'd also like to emphasize some of the work we do with all of our stakeholders. Our people are critical to the success of the business. This year, we completed our second culture and engagement survey, which showed engagement scores 11% higher than the top quartile of finance organizations in Australia. Thank you to all of the Soul Patts' team and the staff of our many investee companies for their dedicated service throughout the year. Equally, our commitment to communities is important to us.
Todd Barlow
executiveOur partnership with the Royal Flying Doctor Service goes back a long way. This year, thanks to our shareholders, we raised and donated $735,000. To every shareholder who gave to this worthy cause, thank you. Now, turning to how we performed against our strategy. There are 3 key objectives, and we did well on each of them in FY '24. First, we increased cash generation. Net cash flows generated by our investments rose 10.3%. That strong cash generation has allowed the Board to declare a fully franked final dividend of $0.55, taking total dividends for the year to $0.95 fully franked. That is up 9.2% on the prior year. Second, we grew the portfolio. The net asset value per share increased 12% after adding back dividends. That was 1.4% below market in a year when the market performed above average in terms of historical returns. But 12% is a very pleasing overall return. The net asset value as at 31 July was $11.8 billion, which is about $900 million higher than the previous year. And lastly, we also managed investment risk. We do this in a variety of ways, but primarily by investing in a diversified portfolio of high-quality, resilient and growing businesses.
Todd Barlow
executiveTo show how strong the team’s deal flow and execution capabilities are, we put $2.8 billion into public and private equities over the course of the year. Brendan will go into more detail on that activity a little later in the presentation. The $4.7 billion of total transaction activity across the portfolio covers both acquisitions and sales. That level of activity reflects how we continue rebalancing the portfolio and a constantly shifting environment that meant we had to be somewhat more active than normal. On a net basis, we deployed more than $800 million of cash, and that left our cash balances low at year-end. In August this year, we bolstered our cash position through an equity and bond raising, and Brendan will give a bit more detail on that later. It has now been almost 3 years since we closed the Milton acquisition in October 2021. I thought it was worth reviewing how we have performed over that 3-year period against each of our objectives. From a cash flow perspective, the cash flow per share we received from our investments grew at an impressive 20% per annum. That has allowed us to pay increasing dividends, which rose at 15.3% per annum during this period.
Todd Barlow
executiveTo give that accomplishment some context, dividends across the entire market have risen by just 0.9% annually on average. Then, when it comes to expanding the portfolio, net assets have compounded at an average of 13.5% each year. That works out 6.4% above the benchmark in each of those 3 years. Put in dollar terms, the portfolio is $2 billion larger than it would have been had it merely tracked the market across the last 3 years. Alongside delivering these results, we've lowered the portfolio's risk by shifting into asset classes that are uncorrelated and more diverse. Over 3 years, total transaction activity — covering both acquisitions and disposals — came to $10.7 billion. Through this, our exposure to credit has risen 4.4x and our Private Equity Portfolio has grown 2.4x. This graph illustrates an extraordinary unbroken streak of dividend increases that no other ASX-listed company can equal. As I noted in the highlights, the final dividend of $0.55 per share takes total dividends for the year to $0.95. That's 9.2% higher than the prior year. Ordinary dividends have risen annually since 2000.
Todd Barlow
executiveAcross those 24 years, the compound annual growth rate came to 9.6%. In recent times, that growth has actually picked up. And as I mentioned, over the last 3 years, dividends have risen by an average of 15.3% per annum. Should Soul Patts manage another dividend increase in this financial year, we would become Australia's first dividend aristocrat — a label reserved for a small group of companies around the world that have raised dividends annually for 25 years straight. Over the past 20 years, Soul Patts has produced a total shareholder return — covering both share price growth and dividends — of 11.7% per annum. That works out 3% above the market each year. Compounded across 20 years, that performance means an investment in Soul Patts has grown by 820%, versus a total increase of 434% in the All Ordinaries Accumulation Index. Although the 1-year TSR fell short of the benchmark, all the other periods show solid outperformance. Turning to our financial results in more detail. It's worth remembering that statutory accounting earnings and balance sheets aren't our main focus when we judge our performance and financial position. We measure ourselves by what drives value for our shareholders. First, the growing value of the portfolio as measured by net asset value.
Todd Barlow
executiveAnd number two, the cash income that the portfolio produces, as measured by net cash flow from investments, is what lets us consistently pay a growing dividend. I'll return to those points shortly. Turning to our statutory results, net profit after tax came in at $499 million, which is 28% below the prior year. The main factors were weaker results from Brickworks and New Hope. At Brickworks, the decline stemmed from property devaluations and noncash impairment charges within its Building Products division. New Hope delivered a strong year — its third highest result on record — yet it was down versus the previous year as record coal prices were treated. As I said earlier, we saw very strong growth in net cash flow from investments, which rose 10.3% for the year to $468 million. This chart lays out the $44 million increase, supported by strong growth in interest income and fees from our growing credit book, together with realized gains from our trading portfolio. Those gains were partly offset by lower large cap dividends following our rebalancing and by lower dividends from New Hope. The pretax net asset value of our portfolio ended at $11.8 billion. Once dividends paid to shareholders are added back, the total return for the year was 12%.
Todd Barlow
executiveWe were pleased to see strong results in every area. The Strategic Portfolio returned 11% in total, large caps contributed 14.1%, and private equity produced an IRR of 15.9%. Emerging companies had a very strong year, growing 16%. Credit came in at 14.9%, and property rose 20.1% for the year. Brendan will now walk through each of these portfolio performances in a bit more detail.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveThanks, Todd, and good afternoon everyone. It's a real pleasure to bring you up to speed on how our portfolio has performed, following a year in which returns were strong right across the board. Over the past 3 years, your investment team has concentrated on lifting the quality of the portfolio, drawing on the flexibility that permanent capital gives us, along with available cash, and what we like to call our unconstrained mandate. That lets us keep building investments we believe will deliver for shareholders. Over the long term, this comes through strong cash and capital growth, which leads to increased fully franked dividends. These efforts paid off in 2024, with a total portfolio return of 12% and growth of 10.3% in the cash received from our investments. We believe our portfolio, which will stay actively managed, is well positioned to withstand volatility and disruption, which is a feature of the markets we now operate in. It is also capable of delivering strong returns in a rising market like we saw this year. At the end of the year, the portfolio was valued at $11.8 billion, an increase of $900 million on the previous year. We actively deployed cash during the period, investing $800 million, with a continued focus on adding to our Private Equity and Private Credit portfolios.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveWe're increasing our positions in these portfolios because of the possibility of returns above the market with a risk level we find acceptable, and Soul Patts has a lengthy track record of achievement in these asset classes. During the year, we put $196 million more into our private equity investments and a net $460 million into our Private Credit Portfolio, and I'll discuss that in greater detail shortly. Our direct property holdings delivered solid results, though at present they aren't material. It's worth pointing out that we hold exposure to high-quality industrial assets via our stakes in Brickworks. As we kept investing this year, our cash reserves fell from $911 million at the end of 2023 to $214 million at year-end, which leaves us in a net debt position of $160 million. A series of capital initiatives after year-end have strengthened this, giving us added flexibility — I'll cover that in more detail later — but it leaves us very strongly placed to keep investing in our exciting pipeline of opportunities and to respond to market volatility. Turning first to the Strategic Portfolio. The Strategic Portfolio is still the heart of our cash generation, with Brickworks, New Hope and TPG accounting for 52% of our net cash from investments.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveTypically, our strategic investments carry significant ownership stakes, tend to be defensive and produce cash, and have delivered solid results for Soul Patts over the long run. In a lot of instances, we hold Board seats so that our interests are safeguarded. As the rest of our portfolio expands, we anticipate that the Strategic Portfolio's share will keep shrinking with time. Cash generation fell 9.1% compared with a year earlier, since dividends from New Hope were lower because of weaker coal prices. The portfolio delivered an 11% return in 2024, with Tuas and Brickworks driving that growth. Although this fell short of the All Ordinaries Accumulation Index, which gained 13.4% over the period, we are highly satisfied with the result, considering how defensive the portfolio is and how the market delivered above-trend returns. Turning to individual companies, Tuas is still going strong, posting a total return of 127% across the 12 months as it keeps expanding its rollout in Singapore. Brickworks also did well, delivering a total return of 14% despite a tough cyclical environment in construction markets, helped along by its investment portfolio. Aeris and TPG were the biggest drags on performance, with Aeris struggling with operational problems and TPG swinging about during the year as various initiatives to broaden network coverage and unlock value from infrastructure assets played out.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveRegarding Perpetual, we're monitoring that process closely, as it's aimed at delivering value for every shareholder. We still need further tax clarification before we can fully gauge what shareholders will net from the divestment of the Wealth Management and Corporate Trust businesses. Turning to large caps: our Large Caps Portfolio, at $2.3 billion, turned in a robust 2024 — a year in which beating the index proved extremely difficult for managers in that space. The portfolio delivered 14.1%, producing $313 million of returns and surpassing the index by 60 basis points. Although the portfolio's size is broadly unchanged versus a year earlier, that stems from us harvesting growth within it to free up cash for investment in fresh private markets opportunities. It's especially gratifying to post strong results while also selling into market strength. Those sales mirror our ongoing belief that equity valuations look elevated at present, given the threats looming for earnings and economies. They also mirror the calibre of opportunities we're currently finding elsewhere in our portfolio. Cash generated came in 25% lower, at $88.8 million, owing to net selling during 2023. That selling skewed toward the closing months of the year, which set up a difficult comparison base.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveThere are 35 holdings in the portfolio. Across the year, we've generally trimmed our consumer exposure while adding to resources. Our investments in retail banks have increased, though they remain significantly underweight relative to the index. We continue to hold a positive view on new energy growth, which we're expressing via an investment in Macquarie, and on the data center and artificial intelligence theme through our holding in Goodman. The Large Caps Portfolio is run on an active basis. As a result, our holdings will shift regularly, yet our focus will stay firmly on delivering strong returns over the long term. Moving on to Private Equity. For our Private Equity Portfolio, 2024 was a year of consolidation, as we brought together a set of strategic acquisitions completed in 2023 and early 2024. We're drawn to opportunities offering not just robust organic growth but also the capacity to add growth via acquisitions. Happily, every one of our major portfolio investments is performing well and helped drive a 15.9% return for the Private Equity Portfolio in 2024. The portfolio now stands at $1.6 billion, which is 13% of our total investment portfolio, and it grew by 32.2% this year thanks to a mix of new investments and valuation uplift.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveOur view of private equity differs from how a lot of others in this area operate, we think. Flexibility is central to how we work, and our aim is to partner with businesses for the long haul. Whether we hold all of a company or just a stake, that suits us, and we prefer to leave owners and managers to focus on what they do best, which is growing their company. Such investments can compound steadily as time passes, and we are glad to stay invested across a long horizon, at times spanning decades. Ironbark, Ampcontrol, Aquatic Achievers and our Agriculture portfolio sit in strong positions to thrive in sectors with obvious tailwinds and opportunities ahead. Net cash flow rose 97.9% during the period as investments matured, and we stay confident that cash generation will keep growing going forward. Moving on to Emerging. The Emerging Companies Portfolio holds listed and unlisted investments, generally in fast-growing companies exposed to structural shifts or strong growth themes. During 2024, the portfolio delivered a very strong result, returning 16% and beating the Small All Ordinaries Accumulation Index by 6.7%. That strong performance is especially pleasing given a challenging market for small-cap equities caused by higher interest rates, which affect longer dated valuations.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveDuring the year, the portfolio expanded 68.2%, partly because of fresh investments in energy — in particular, a sizable uranium position taken through NexGen Energy, which is based in Canada. That NexGen holding consists of listed shares along with convertible notes, which shows the adaptable method we can use to extract maximum value from our investment ideas. We continue to feel highly confident about energy, given the requirement to supply more electricity worldwide to support, among other things, electric vehicles and artificial intelligence. Net cash from investments rose 192.3%, since we booked larger trading gains across the period. How gains land in any given year can vary. Our Emerging Companies Portfolio had another robust year, and it carries a history of outperformance over the long term. Now to credit. Through the course of 2024, our rapidly expanding Credit Portfolio shifted from pure growth to 2-way flow, as repayments on loans started coming in. A loan in our portfolio has an average life of 2 to 3 years. That means a meaningful share of the portfolio gets repaid annually as loans come due. During 2024, we put $644 million of new capital to work, and $184 million of loans were repaid.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveWe're continuing to put meaningful amounts of capital into the portfolio as a whole, and over the year the portfolio's size increased by 65.1%. As of 31 July 2024, we have $269.1 million in facilities that are committed but still undrawn. Risk-adjusted returns in the credit market remain excellent. And as in many other areas, Soul's brings its own differentiated approach to the market. We possess a strong set of capabilities, and our reputation as a trusted partner lets us access high-quality deal flow. The portfolio is well diversified by size and spans a range of sectors. It is also predominantly senior secured. The portfolio holds 28 loans, ranging from $1 million to $123 million. Returns in 2024 have been excellent, with the portfolio delivering a 14.9% total return. Cash received from the portfolio rose by 161.3% to $108.4 million, as the portfolio has grown rapidly over the year. And finally, our capital position. During 2024, we have actively grown investments in private assets and used a substantial amount of our available cash reserves to do so. These investments have delivered as expected, and we believe they will continue to deliver strong cash returns and capital growth for shareholders.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveWhen 2024 began, our cash at bank stood at $911 million, and across the year we drew down $697 million of it. Equity finance facilities are available to us, and our listed portfolios carry embedded liquidity that we could tap if needed. Both management and the Board stay committed to keeping a conservative balance sheet, which includes holding enough cash to move quickly on an investment opportunity should one arise. With that in mind, and following the close of the financial year, we carried out a set of capital management initiatives: a $225 million equity raise at 0 discount sold to select Aussie institutional investors, repayment of our existing convertible bond, and the issue of a new, larger replacement convertible bond carrying a higher conversion price. As a result of these transactions, cash at bank rose by $450 million, and the potential conversion of the original bond was reset higher. That gives us ample financial flexibility to respond to new opportunities. All in all, 2024 proved a very successful year for Soul Patts when it comes to financial returns, and also when it comes to our capabilities and future resilience. I want to thank the investment team and everyone who supported them for their efforts, and I will now hand it back to Todd.
Todd Barlow
executiveWhen it comes to the outlook, our focus will stay on the 3 core objectives we've set. Cash generation across the portfolio keeps benefiting from the larger share we've allocated to credit, as well as from the Private Equity Portfolio moving toward maturity. Right now, a substantial amount of that cash is being put back into the private equity companies so those businesses can grow. Even so, they're going to begin paying solid dividends. With our cash balance, we have the liquidity needed to act opportunistically and to recycle the portfolio. We must make sure we keep exploiting our competitive advantages, and that includes being flexible and having long-term capital. There is a degree of uncertainty surrounding the macroeconomic environment, but we think that continuing to invest thoughtfully in resilient businesses that carry downside protection ought to let us weather any economic shocks. Our gearing is light and our cash balances are decent. On top of that, our deal flows are excellent. As a result, we should be in a position to keep rebalancing the portfolio and to seize new and better opportunities whenever they come up. Many thanks for your interest in our company. We'll now take some of the questions that I can see beginning to arrive through the portal.
Todd Barlow
executiveYou're still welcome to send in more questions, and we'll do our best to answer as many as we can in the time we have.
Tanny Mangos
executiveSo, Todd, for our first question: I still don't get how you're achieving an average of more than 15% on private equity lending — I'd like a piece of that action.
Todd Barlow
executiveSo, look, this is a portfolio that performs very strongly. Over the course of the year, we identified an additional $500 million in opportunities. And the team running it has managed to keep a yield of close to 15% across that portfolio. Our approach differs sharply from what anyone else in the market does. What we offer are highly structured, engineered solutions for counterparties who simply need capital in some form and fall through the cracks — perhaps because of the bank, or because for whatever reason they don't want to raise equity. Those are the solutions we give them. So I'd say this is a really exciting piece of our portfolio. We've spent a number of years building it up, and it's gratifying to watch it keep growing.
Tanny Mangos
executiveThe upcoming question concerns the DRP. Several inquiries have come in regarding the DRP. First, what drove Soul to set up a DRP after going without one for such a long period? Second, will this become a lasting feature going forward? Third, would we look at a dividend substitution share plan like the ones listed investment companies provide? And fourth, tying back to an earlier question about Soul not having offered DRPs in the past, what prompted this shift?
Todd Barlow
executiveOkay, it's actually quite straightforward. We've simply received quite a few incoming requests from shareholders. Our earlier stance was that investors were free to take their dividends and purchase shares on the market. However, in light of the number of people who have asked for a DRP, the Board decided to put one in place, and we'll see how it performs. There's no reason we shouldn't keep it going. Still, judging by the demand we've observed up to now, I'd anticipate a reason to participate.
Tanny Mangos
executiveThanks, Todd. The question we have now concerns emerging companies. That portfolio has expanded a great deal—68.2%—and beat its index by 6.7%. Which particular market trends or sectors are you concentrating on inside it? And how do you see its growth prospects over the long term?
Brendan O'Dea
executiveOkay, Tanny, I'll take that question. Over the long run, our Emerging Companies Portfolio has performed very well for us, with results that have exceeded its benchmark more or less annually, and certainly across the long term for many, many years now. And we run the Emerging Companies Portfolio — we approach it with an active mindset, much as we do with our other listed portfolios. That said, the team has done a wonderful job generating returns there. Regarding what we've done in that portfolio this year, as I mentioned in my presentation, the major change is an investment in NexGen Energy, a uranium opportunity located in Canada. That isn't the only uranium investment held within that portfolio. And thematically — which is a fair question — the portfolio carries very heavy exposure to energy, thanks to that new investment along with existing ones. I'd note that this is an actively managed portfolio. So our positioning in these portfolios does change. But we found an opportunity this year to expand that portfolio into a theme and an opportunity we feel very strongly about, and one we believe will perform well over the long term.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveWe're genuinely enthusiastic about the momentum we're seeing across every one of our portfolios in a broad sense. Yet more specifically, you've watched us convey that enthusiasm during this year through emerging companies.
Tanny Mangos
executiveTodd, the following question concerns listed investments. One of our investors would like to know whether, considering its size, the Soul portfolio of listed investments is likely to expand beyond the Australian market, and whether a substantial international listed portfolio may become unavoidable.
Todd Barlow
executiveNot really. The ASX’s Australian market capitalization is roughly $2 trillion, I believe, and our investment in the Australian market is around $2.2 billion. That makes us a very, very tiny slice of the market. But the question being raised, I think, is whether we will increasingly look toward global markets, and that is what we are doing. We are considering how to go about it in a thoughtful way. Right now, our focus is more on obtaining offshore exposure to private markets, private equity and credit, in particular. There is, I think, a natural move for us toward exposure to other exchanges and listed equities around the globe, but that is something we have not done a lot of yet. Still, I would say the exposure in the existing portfolio already has a considerable global complexion to it. Take our strategic investments, for example: New Hope is an export-only business. Brickworks has operating businesses in the U.S. We have Tuas, which is a Singapore and mobile business, and Apex, which is a Malaysian listed health care business. And I think we did some analysis of our listed large cap equities portfolio, and about 60% of revenues came from offshore.
Todd Barlow
executiveThe portfolio already carries a fairly substantial worldwide makeup.
Tanny Mangos
executiveMoving to our next question: the portfolio lagged the All Ords accumulation Index by 1.4% during FY '24. Which particular strategies or asset rebalancing initiatives do you have in place to boost performance and narrow that gap over the coming fiscal year?
Brendan O'Dea
executiveYes. Thanks for asking. I suppose the first thing I'd point to is that our attention is on how we do over the long term. We aren't really fixating on any single year, quarter, or half, and at Soul Patts we have an extremely lengthy track record of results — something we take real pride in — which Todd mentioned when he talked about the 3-year view. The shift you've observed us making toward private assets is highly pertinent here. You're able to see the robust results we've delivered from private equity and private credit across the year. Each of those portfolios did considerably better than the wider market. And we expect those asset classes to deliver superior returns as time goes on. So essentially what we're doing is ensuring our portfolio is built in a manner that delivers high performance, and the shift into private assets — whether private credit or private equity — forms part of that. I'd point out as well that the remaining portions of our portfolio, apart from Strategic — clearly our biggest portfolio — turned in a very strong showing. Our Listed portfolio beat the market this year. Our Emerging portfolio beat the market. And clearly, we enjoyed a strong result in Property, which makes up a smaller share of our portfolio.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveWe're quite pleased with how we did this year. The Strategic Portfolio underperformed during what turned out to be a really strong year for the market. Even so, we remain very happy with that result. It produces substantial cash for the portfolio, and these are investments we've held for a long time that have done very, very well across the very long term. That said, the rebalancing we're doing at present and our shift toward private assets are specifically intended to deliver performance for the portfolio going forward.
Todd Barlow
executiveAnd I would add to that. I mean, when the market delivers 13.4%, we're not unhappy about a 12% return. Our portfolio is reasonably defensive, built to perform throughout the cycle. From history, we know that we do better when the market is poor. And getting close to a very strong market performance makes us extremely happy. 12% is an excellent return. And if you look at what I mentioned earlier around the individual portfolios, every one of them outperformed their benchmark by some margin. The only one that was a drag was the Strategic Portfolio, which was dragged down by some poor share price performances out of, in particular, TPG and New Hope, but it still returned 11%. And if we look at that Strategic Portfolio performance over the long run, it's been outstanding.
Tanny Mangos
executiveThe following question comes from an institutional investor based abroad. Do you feel at ease carrying net debt, or would you rather hold net cash? And where do you anticipate standing in FY '25?
Todd Barlow
executiveOkay, so at present we're a touch net cash following the capital raise we completed. Before that, we were marginally net debt. The question isn't really whether we sit at net debt or net cash — it's more about evaluating what liquidity we can access. Having spent close to $800 million last year and considering where our cash balance ended up, we concluded that additional cash was needed. We raised it via two things: a convertible bond of $450 million, plus a placement of a bit over $200 million to replace the convertible bond already in place. So at the moment we feel we're lightly geared — or actually net cash — and even if we began deploying some of that cash, gearing would remain very, very light. We're comfortable going into slight net debt. Heavily geared is something we'll never be, since our inclination is to be a little more conservative. That said, I'd argue there's no reason we wouldn't consider gearing of up to 10% within the portfolio as a liquidity source for pursuing new opportunities.
Tanny Mangos
executiveMoving to the next question — I guess when you dig into the details, when deciding whether to lend or not, you have to determine if the company is worth putting some equity into.
Todd Barlow
executiveYes. I believe it's reasonable to say that regarding the Credit Portfolio, what we're really engaged in is building in protection against downside risk. So these are companies we view as fundamentally healthy, and we'd be glad to purchase the equity, but we — for one reason or another, since it suits our counterparty better or suits us better, we structure an arrangement that resembles credit. However, we don't make a practice of extending loans to those whose operations are something we dislike and wouldn't be pleased to hold the equity in or take ownership of the business if that became necessary.
Tanny Mangos
executiveThere are a few questions we have regarding our Private Equity Portfolio. Could you speak a bit about the private equity businesses? You raised your investment in this one this year. Can you give more detail on the swim schools market in Australia — does that include Aquatic Achievers? How large is your Agricultural Portfolio, and what investments does it consist of? And also, is it possible that you could potentially list and control, which you've held for a number of years?
Brendan O'Dea
executiveI'll begin, and then I'll likely cover parts of this along with the other items. Our Private Equity Portfolio has had an excellent year. Valuations rose throughout the portfolio, and that increase accounts for approximately half of the growth you've observed in the portfolio's size, and we made an investment of about $195 million, which happened during the first half — it was a packing facility in Shepparton that we discussed on the first half earnings call. So as far as fresh capital going into the portfolio during the year, things were fairly quiet in the second half, and I described it as a year of consolidation for that portfolio, and I believe that's accurate. But when you look at the portfolio's breadth. You can see it on the slide — we saw strong performance in the form of valuation uplift right across our portfolio. Aquatic Achievers is delivering good results, Ampcontrol is performing greatly. Ironbark keeps going from strength to strength as well. So the growth we're seeing from that portfolio overall makes us really pleased. The one section of that portfolio that has been lagging the other sections is probably our Ag Portfolio.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveThat doesn’t mean it’s a weak performer. It’s simply that the rest of the portfolio is doing extremely well. The Ag Portfolio sits at roughly $550 million to $600 million. It has several components, though I won’t get into all the specifics. It generates somewhat less cash than other areas of our portfolio. Still, when it comes to our Private Equity Portfolio overall, we’re comfortable keeping it in an investment phase right now. Cash isn’t a requirement for us. We’re glad to put it back into growing that portfolio, and that’s where our attention has been lately. So we have a number of highly exciting private equity investments that we very much hope to build on in the years ahead.
Todd Barlow
executiveSo when we discuss the Private Equity Portfolio more broadly — why do we hold it, and what's the strategy overall? First, as I think we've mentioned before, we began with a thematic approach. We chose long-term themes in the Australian market that we were after, themes where we held a global competitive advantage and which enjoyed long-term tailwinds. We've acted on quite a few of those. The second piece we're aiming to capture is the illiquidity premium — the fact that you effectively earn higher returns from private equity simply because these assets aren't listed. In our view a business isn't inherently riskier just because it's unlisted rather than listed. We're simply seeking to capture that illiquidity premium. We can do that thanks to our permanent capital. And we aren't layering much gearing onto these businesses. So they don't get progressively riskier from carrying more gearing than a listed company would. But another aspect of private equity we genuinely favor is how swiftly and simply we can supply capital for growth. So, free of the constraints of a listed environment — and there are several constraints there — really, one of them is how comparatively hard it is to raise money quickly.
Todd Barlow
executiveThe second factor is the regulatory and compliance landscape. Short-termism among investors is the third. In a private setting, then, we're able to incubate these businesses so they keep expanding without those 3 concerns getting in the way, and we can put more capital behind their growth. So only once they reach a particular scale and stop gaining from that kind of fast, easy growth capital would we think about an IPO. That said, given the growth we see coming across all of our current businesses, it will be a while before we consider an IPO for any of them.
Tanny Mangos
executiveStaying on that same point, how are you addressing the emerging macro trend of intergenerational wealth transfer within the strategic horizon — the thinking that's needed to plan for meeting the shifts in wealth management markets that future investors will demand?
Todd Barlow
executiveSo that's essentially the theme we're aiming to address with Ironbark, which is a quite substantial and expanding operation within Australia's wealth management sector. For a while now, we've held the view that as the wealth of individuals and families grows, along with the superannuation balances of essentially everyone in the Australian market, the percentage cost of wealth is in fact declining, since the balances being managed keep getting bigger and bigger. And what people in the Australian market truly require is access to sound advice and sound products, and we have a very strong conviction about that market.
Tanny Mangos
executiveSince Star is quite topical right now, could you walk us through how the private credit equity gets valued? Is that handled independently? And do you carry any exposure to Star Group? We also have one more question on that front — can you give us more detail about the exposure to Star Group? My assumption is that it has grown since the July year-end.
Todd Barlow
executiveJust within the past 24 hours, there's been an announcement that the Star Group received additional capital from the lending group. We're one of the lenders in that group to Star. So we'll be putting in a bit more capital as well. The first tranche of that capital comes to $100 million. Our view is that the asset quality at Star can support more debt. So all of the lenders carried out a thorough analysis, and we concluded that adding more debt was in the lending group's best interest. As for how we approach the valuation exercise, there's a very thorough valuation done for the private equity assets. And on the credit book, we establish expected credit losses against any portfolio position. So right now, we don't believe any of the portfolio positions would be impaired, but for accounting purposes we're required to take up an amount that you'd ordinarily expect a portfolio of this nature might encounter over a lifetime of investing. And so we did in fact increase the expected credit loss against the Star loan, but that doesn't mean we actually think that will come to fruition.
Todd Barlow
executiveThat's simply an accounting treatment—one approach that we adopted.
Tanny Mangos
executiveBrendan touched on Perpetual somewhat already. Still, could you potentially launch another takeover offer for Perpetual? What lies ahead for the strategic stake you hold in Perpetual? Right now it's trading at a 25-year low. And what do you intend to do with your stake?
Brendan O'Dea
executiveSo, look, our takeover offer for Perpetual got knocked back, and we—at this point, we're an investor in Perpetual, admittedly a big one, just like any other investor. We're watching how the process unfolds with interest, which is what I mentioned in my remarks. There's still information that has yet to come out from Perpetual. We're waiting on feedback from the ATO regarding the structure they're proposing to use, and that matters a great deal when it comes to figuring out net proceeds to shareholders, and we're one of them. Our position is comparatively well protected and comparatively well structured. So we feel confident and comfortable, even though the share price sits below what we consider to be fair value, but the market will do what the market will do. So we watch and wait when it comes to Perpetual. The likely course of events, in our view, is that the transaction probably goes ahead. And we get capital returned to us like any other shareholder, and then we'll figure out what to do from there. But it's—there's still more water to go under the Perpetual bridge, frankly, and we're watching and waiting like many other shareholders.
Tanny Mangos
executiveAlso, a further question concerns the Perpetual and KKR Asian fund transaction, and whether it will receive additional approval to take over Perpetual's private wealth and trust businesses. Doesn't each of those serve Perpetual clients' best interests? So please confirm that every option is still available to safeguard Soul's substantial long-term investment.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveLike I mentioned a moment ago, we feel pretty confident that the amount we're investing at present is something we can handle quite well. There are plenty of approaches and frameworks we've set up that give us protection. As for any regulatory approvals involving Perpetual as a company, I'd rather not say anything about that.
Tanny Mangos
executiveLet's turn now to how widely we're invested. The spread of your investments should give a pretty good picture of the Australian economy's health and how various sectors are doing. Could you share some observations on the sectors where Soul sees opportunities, and likewise, any that concern you as an investor?
Todd Barlow
executiveWell, this does come up from time to time. What I usually tell people is that we aren't a particularly good barometer of the Australian economy, since the segments of the investment universe that are more cyclical are exactly the ones we steer clear of. Businesses that are highly cyclical, driven by consumers, or centred on trends or fads are generally not what we hold. Ours lean much more heavily toward very long-term, robust defensive business models that produce cash right through the cycle. So what we're definitely picking up in our read is that the Australian consumer is finding things hard. Real incomes for them have come down. Prices for goods and services are climbing, and energy costs are climbing too. And in my view, that will unavoidably affect the way they spend. For us, though, our portfolio has very limited exposure to that. The areas of the economy we do favour are, obviously, resources and energy, and Brendan talked about a few of our energy investments, and it isn't only uranium or thermal coal. We also hold exposure to renewable energy. And we believe the growth in demand for energy across all things is going to be significant going forward, and that's something we're very excited about.
Todd Barlow
executiveBrendan, is there anything you'd like to add to that?
Brendan O'Dea
executiveNo, no. I think one big advantage of having permanent capital, of being a long-term investor, and of being conservative and income-focused the way we are, is that we can tune out some of the noise that inevitably goes on in the market. So when we build portfolios, we try to look through cycles. And to Todd's point, we try to avoid anything that's flattish or flavor of the month or, frankly, just a bit too expensive for us. So we're quite happy to tune out the noise. We're alert to the fact that economies are slowing. They're definitely slowing globally. But interest rates will probably come lower as well. So this is the push-pull that we're seeing right now in asset markets. It would seem a little perplexing that economies are slowing, but markets are at all-time highs, but the economy is not the market. So for us, we just try and tune that noise out, put the best investments that we can in the portfolio and keep investing for the long term.
Tanny Mangos
executiveThe next question we have concerns a different holding in the strategic portfolio. Given the ongoing share losses to new entrants like Aussie Broadband and Superloop, are you comfortable with the TPG investment? And does TPG worry you?
Todd Barlow
executiveNo, what I mean is that last year was tough for us when it came to the share price falling. That said, the business's fundamentals — and it has gone through a stretch of heavy CapEx spending along with somewhat more competition. I mean, once you factor NBN into the competitive picture. But they have been up to some really exciting things. They announced regional sharing with Optus' network, which genuinely places Vodafone and TPG on equal footing with the rest of the market and creates new market opportunities, and the ACCC gave that the green light roughly a week ago. Then at the half year, TPG confirmed it was still looking at a separation of the fiber network infrastructure. Again, our view has always been that this is an extremely valuable infrastructure asset that the market wasn't really valuing. I think getting some price discovery on that would be good for the business. And I think, following some speculation about it, you can see TPG's share price has caught up. So I think good news lies ahead for TPG, and we're quite excited.
Tanny Mangos
executiveMoving to energy now — the Tesla Megaton Battery in South Australia stands as a great illustration of storage that delivers strong value for the money. Given the infrastructure-type characteristics of large-scale battery solutions, has Soul considered funding them, putting investment into them, or taking ownership of them?
Todd Barlow
executiveOver the years, we've examined a handful of things. Broadly speaking, infrastructure investing isn't really what we do, since infrastructure investors accept a lower cost of capital or lower target returns than our hurdles. Nor do we typically sit at the cutting edge of technology and accept development or technology risk. We lean toward businesses whose models have already been proven. That said, this industry is still developing. And as I mentioned, energy in general excites us a great deal. I believe that as the mix of energy feeding the grid shifts, storage solutions will be needed in a significant way, and that's an area we will watch closely.
Tanny Mangos
executiveThe following question ties into that and is likely of greater interest to our international investors: does Soul perceive any advantage in repurchasing shares? And at what level might they contemplate doing so?
Todd Barlow
executiveTo be honest, share repurchases aren't something we've done. And I think if we ever reached a situation where our stock was trading at a meaningful discount to net asset value, at that point buying our own shares would turn into an attractive investment opportunity. But the way we've handled it previously, whenever we've been trading at somewhat of a discount, has been to inform the market about that discount and let the market have a chance to fix it on its own. That said, should such an opportunity ever come up, it's something we'd consider. Still, our thinking is that we'd rather keep concentrating on expanding the investment portfolio instead of trading in our own stock.
Tanny Mangos
executiveMoving to the next question: in what way do you weigh raising the dividend against keeping earnings, especially given that opportunities appear to exist for putting more capital to work?
Todd Barlow
executiveOur aim is to pass along as much of the income generated by our portfolio as we can to shareholders, while doing so in a manner that reduces volatility and keeps the dividend growing. Paying dividends matters, in my view, because franking credits hold real value for our shareholders. That's why we distribute a fairly high proportion of the cash we bring in. Over the past 12 months, the figure sits at roughly 71% to 74%. In other years it has come in above that. So there's no need for us to hold back or strip dividends away from shareholders just to keep liquidity on hand for new opportunities. We have ample liquidity available from other sources inside the portfolio. And continuing to pay those dividends to our shareholders genuinely matters to us.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveI also believe it matters a great deal that we keep scrutinizing how capital gets deployed across our portfolio. So simply withholding dividends in order to keep earnings around for investments whose completion we can't be sure of—that doesn't strike us as sound discipline. What matters greatly to us, then, is holding the strongest investments available to us at any moment in our portfolio. And so the notion of shifting out of one investment and into another whenever a superior option appears is, for us, quite a valuable discipline when it comes to managing the portfolio.
Tanny Mangos
executiveThanks for that. With supply falling over the long term and demand rising around the world, would Soul consider raising its investments in thermal and met coal?
Todd Barlow
executiveWell, I mean, I think through New Hope, obviously, we've already got a fairly solid position in coal. And what New Hope is showing us is a portfolio that keeps expanding organically. So in '23, last year, they produced a bit more than 7 million tonnes. And just a few days back, they released their full year results, and they signalled that by FY '28, that figure will be nearer to 14 million tonnes of production each year. So there's a -- and part of that additional output coming through is going to be in met coal. So we're already seeing more coal supply, or more coal exposure, showing up in our portfolio. And I'd agree with the question that supply around the world is shrinking, and our view is that demand is holding up better than many people would expect.
Tanny Mangos
executiveAnd how do you view the possibilities in health care, especially for newer companies that have secured regulatory clearance to back intellectual property commercialization at scale?
Todd Barlow
executiveActually, health care—specifically health and aging—was among the themes we pinpointed as something we wanted exposure to and didn't have within our Private Equity Portfolio. That said, we've examined plenty of opportunities in that sector. As I mentioned, our preference is for businesses with demonstrated models instead of those at a pre-commercialization phase or centered on generating technology. Even so, we genuinely review everything. Our investments span a variety of assets and asset classes, and we're continually evaluating opportunities.
Tanny Mangos
executiveAppreciate that. I'd also like to mention that several investors have praised our dollar matching, and one investor raised the topic of closed captions—we will certainly look into that for next time. We also expect a recording to be made available soon after this presentation.
Todd Barlow
executiveThere's a question about why Soul Patts isn't regarded as an LIC, and about why we don't report NTA on a regular basis. Those two questions are linked, in the sense that reporting monthly — or at least monthly — on NTAs is something LICs are required to do. By definition, we aren't an LIC, and there are both tax and ASX definitions that govern that. In our approach there are plenty of similarities, since we're a closed-end listed vehicle with access to a range of investments. But quite a few things we do differ substantially from the LIC universe. Most LICs tend to focus on a single asset class — be that large cap, small caps or international equities — while our aim is to offer a one-stop solution, where someone can buy shares in Soul's and gain exposure to a diverse portfolio of assets spanning not only large cap and small caps but property, private equity and credit too, invested really in the way a family office would typically invest. That style of investing doesn't fit the classic LIC structure or definition.
Todd Barlow
executiveThat said, a few other parallels exist in that our MER is low, yet we lack a separate vehicle for fund management. As a result, nothing leaks out through funds management fees or performance fees. Our shareholders capture all of it, and our shareholders own all of it. So we believe our business model and proposition for shareholders are genuinely interesting and unique, and that they can't be found anywhere else.
Tanny Mangos
executiveThanks, Todd. That brings our presentation of the 2024 full year financial results to a close.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete WHSP Holdings Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to WHSP Holdings Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in WHSP Holdings Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.