WHSP Holdings Limited (SOL) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
March 20, 2025
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Tanny Mangos
executiveGood afternoon, everyone, and welcome to the Soul Patts presentation of financial results for the first half that ended on 31st of January 2025. I'm Tanny Mangos, and I handle Investor Relations here at Soul Patts. As the majority of you are aware, Soul Patts is a diversified investment house unlike any other in the Australian market. Our goal is to grow shareholder wealth via a diversified range of investments capable of performing across market cycles. Our team actively manages a portfolio of more than 200 investments, and we can shift the investment mix in order to extract the highest quality risk-adjusted returns. I'm pleased to introduce today's presenters: Todd Barlow, Managing Director and CEO, will take you through the group performance highlights; David Grbin, Chief Financial Officer, will cover the group financial results; and Brendan O'Dea, Chief Investment Officer, will give an update on how each investment portfolio has performed. Todd will then wrap up the presentation with the outlook before we move to Q&A. <<operator_script>> With that, I'll now hand things over to Todd Barlow.
Todd Barlow
executiveThanks, Tanny, and hello everyone, and welcome to our first half 2025 financial results. Our dedication to creating value over the long term, our decisive approach to investment, and an open mandate to pursue the highest quality returns keep benefiting our shareholders. Since we listed in 1903, our purpose has not changed: to deliver enduring success for our shareholders. We achieve this through our long-term commitment to building value rather than being distracted by short-term events; through our strength and conviction when we make investment decisions; and through our unconstrained opportunity to invest wherever we can extract the highest quality returns. As I hope we can show you today in this presentation, overall, our first half results were very strong, and we performed well against our 3 key investment measures of success, increasing cash generation, growing the portfolio and managing investment risk. The first of our objectives is generating strong cash flows from our portfolio. The cash from our portfolio is an important indicator of the health of our operations as well as allowing us to keep paying higher dividends to our shareholders. Net cash flow from investments, or NCFI, is the dividend and interest income across the portfolio. NCFI was $289.5 million for the first half of FY '25, representing an increase of 8.2% on a per share basis compared to the previous corresponding period.
Todd Barlow
executiveFor the last 3 years, NCFI has expanded at 16% annually. That has allowed us to pay larger dividends, which have risen 15.1% per annum over that same 3-year stretch. Given how sluggish dividend growth has been throughout the market lately, this really represents an exceptional rate of growth. As the graph on the right shows, Soul Pattinson's dividends have climbed a cumulative 68% across the last 5 years, which works out to more than 10x the growth of the all ordinaries group of companies. Growing the portfolio's capital value is the second objective. Our net asset value, or NAV, rose to $12.1 billion, producing a 2.4% return in the first half of 2025. Although that trails the market, the market delivered strong growth relative to what we had expected. Looking at performance across the last 3 years, the NAV has compounded at 12.8% per annum, almost 2% above market. That outperformance during the 3-year period has contributed nearly $650 million in shareholder wealth beyond market returns. The graph on the right illustrates the benefits of that compounding outperformance, showing total NAV growth for Soul Patts across 5 years running 54% above market growth.
Todd Barlow
executiveThe third goal is handling investment risk. Through the first half of '25, we kept managing risk by rebalancing the portfolio and holding a solid cash position. In that half, total transaction activity came to $1.9 billion, and $1 billion of that went into public and private investments. Just 3 years ago, private investments were only 13% of the total portfolio. At present, close to 1/3 of our portfolio sits in private assets. Net cash rose by $502 million over this half. That takes our cash to $716 million, helped by the capital raising we completed successfully in August 2024, giving us substantial funds and flexibility for investments ahead. To show how the portfolio defends capital and has done so in earlier stretches of volatility, you can see that over the last 25 years, in months when the market fell, it averaged a 3.3% loss. In each of those months, Soul Patts did 2.4% better than the market. That has been a big driver of our outperformance. Thanks to the strong cash generation I mentioned earlier, the Board has declared a fully franked interim dividend of $0.44 per share. That is 10% higher than last year's interim dividend.
Todd Barlow
executiveThis marks the continuation of a remarkable 25-year stretch of dividend increases, during which ordinary dividends have compounded at an average annual rate of 9.8%. And note that figure covers only ordinary dividends — it leaves out the $1.05 in total special dividends distributed over that span. As I noted before, the 15.1% per annum growth achieved across the last 3 years came in an environment where market dividends have been flat. Our long-term shareholder returns, which reflect growth in both capital and dividends, have been outstanding. Across a 25-year period, we have produced a TSR of 13% per annum, beating the market by 4.5% per annum. A $10,000 investment made in Soul Patts in the year 2000 would now be worth over $200,000 with all dividends reinvested. That works out to triple what an equivalent investment in the index would have returned. We keep performing well against every one of our objectives, and over the longer term that shows up in these phenomenal total shareholder returns. I'll now hand over to our CFO, David Grbin, who will walk us through the financial results in a bit more detail.
David Grbin
executiveThanks, Todd, and good afternoon, everyone. As CFO, it's a real pleasure once again to walk you through another strong set of financial results from Soul Patts for the first half of the 2025 financial year. Over the last 5 years, we've grown our portfolio, the net cash flow from our investments and our dividend faster than the broader market on a consistent basis. Statutory net profit after tax came in at $326.9 million, which is up $24.4 million or 8.1% for the half, driven in part by a solid 18% rise in regular or underlying net profit from our investments to $284.8 million, along with an additional nonregular profit contribution of $42.1 million, largely from investment sales. The growth in regular net profit came from improved operating contributions from New Hope, Brickworks and our credit portfolio. Nonregular gains of $42.1 million resulted from a sell-down of our Tuas stake, which realized a gain of around $85 million, partly offset by an impairment on Brickworks North American business and a write-down of our investment in Aeris. It's worth remembering that statutory accounting earnings and balance sheets aren't our preferred measure of performance or our primary focus when we assess our performance and financial position. Our focus is on growing the value of our portfolio as measured by net asset value and the cash income the portfolio generates as measured by net cash flow from investments.
David Grbin
executiveLet me take each of these one by one. Net cash flow from investments rose almost 10% versus the same period a year earlier, reaching $289.5 million. After adjusting for the larger capital base, the increase came to 8.2% over the prior corresponding period. The bulk of our first-half growth was driven by greater interest income and fees from our credit book, along with a stronger contribution from our private equity portfolio. Crucially, this expansion in net cash flow from investments has been steady. Measured per share, net cash flow from investments has compounded at 13.3% per annum across the last 5 years. That sustained growth in net cash flows has supported a 10% lift in the interim dividend, taking it to $0.44 per share. As at the end of January 2025, the pretax net asset value of our portfolio was $11.1 billion, versus $11.5 billion at the end of January 2024 — a rise of 4.7%, or roughly $600 million. Counting dividends of $347 million paid to our shareholders over the last 12 months, the portfolio's total return is 5.8%. Our NAV growth over the last 12 months stemmed from capital growth in our private equity portfolio, the August '24 equity raise, and retained net cash flow from investments.
David Grbin
executiveOne thing worth noting is that in August 2024, we seized the chance to secure extra long-term borrowing at an attractive rate through a fresh $450 million convertible bond, which the market welcomed warmly. By the close of January 2025, our cash balances came to almost $716 million, and we still hold considerable liquidity that lets us pursue investment opportunities. At this point I'll pass things to Brendan, who will walk us through our portfolios.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveThanks, David, and good afternoon. It's a pleasure to bring you another update on how our investment portfolio is doing. Through expanding uncorrelated, high-performing private credit and equity assets, we've kept taking steps to strengthen the portfolio's resilience. During the half, markets kept climbing, supported by fresh economic optimism and the prospect of interest rate cuts made possible by inflation that is moderating. Valuations are still elevated. As always, our attention has stayed fixed on a disciplined investment process that stresses what price we pay for investments, producing growing cash returns across the long term, generating capital growth alongside risk management, and safeguarding capital. That approach has worked well for us across the last 120 years and has produced excellent returns over the long term. Now to portfolio composition. As you can see, our listed portfolios shrank over the prior year while we put priority on growing private equity and private credit. Private assets now account for 28% of our portfolio. This carries forward a deliberate strategy that has been underway for the last 3 years to diversify our portfolio and open up the chance for above-market capital and income growth over the long term.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveBecause we're unconstrained, we can aim at what we see as the finest opportunities, no matter what kind of investment they are. A lot of this activity happened during the latter six months of the 2024 financial year. Yet momentum has carried on through the first half of the 2025 year. When the half closed, the portfolio's value stood at $12.1 billion, which is $600 million more than a year earlier. Over the first half of 2025, the portfolio gave back a return of 2.4%. That falls short of the All Ords, whose return over that 6-month stretch was 7.5%, including a striking 4.4% in January by itself. Still, we've said consistently that following indices or reacting to short-term noise isn't our aim. We take pleasure in the portfolio's ongoing growth, better cash generation and the steady risk management that Soul Patts is known for. Beginning with strategic. Over the long term, the strategic portfolio has produced superb returns for us. It sits at the core of our long-term outperformance and dividend growth. Strategic, though it makes up 47% of our overall portfolio, provided 58% of our net cash flow from investments during the half. Generally, our strategic investments are material when it comes to ownership levels.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveTypically, we have representation on the Board, which helps support growth and safeguard our interests. During the half, strategic generated a total return of 1.9%, with Tuas producing a very strong return that could not offset softness at Brickworks and TPG. Tuas posted a total return of 47% for the period and stood out as our biggest performance contributor. That business keeps expanding quickly in Singapore's telecommunication market. We used the opportunity during the period to trim some of our stake and stay enthusiastic about Tuas' growth prospects. Brickworks faced a tough half, since the cyclical downturn in building activity weighed on its domestic business, while the U.S. business also contended with difficult conditions. TPG had a very busy half on the corporate front, with the new roaming agreement with Optus now Live expanding its addressable market. That new roaming agreement is already producing gains in market share. In addition, I note today's approval for the sale of network infrastructure, which could permit balance sheet improvement. Turning to Perpetual, they recently turned down a bid from KKR because net proceeds to shareholders were insufficient. That was a disappointing yet logical result, given the inefficient tax treatment of the proposal.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveWe are still Perpetual's biggest shareholder and we see obvious upside in that business. New Hope gave us a solid return over the half and keeps paying out our strong dividends. New Hope is a high-quality, low-cost producer, and because of that it holds up well even with thermal coal prices having fallen lately. Turning to large caps. Our large caps portfolio of $2.2 billion was, narrowly, the best performer among our listed portfolios for the half, though it lagged the wider market. That largely comes from our underweight positions in banks, gold and tech. That same underweight stance runs right across the whole Soul Patts portfolio. The chart on this slide makes that plain. Just 2.3% of the market's 7.5% return came from sectors other than banks, tech and gold. With 30 investments and a firm dedication to valuation discipline, the portfolio isn't run with short-term market tracking in mind and doesn't try to chase market momentum. The portfolio is smaller than in the prior period because of investment sales, and most of those sales were booked in the second half of financial year 2024. We were worried that market valuations had gotten elevated and we keep leaning toward trimming the portfolio.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveWe should note that while we were putting these remarks together, there was a lot of volatility during February and March. Cash generated came in 23.9% below the prior half, which reflected a smaller portfolio as well as certain compositional items. Turning to PE. Private equity remains a part of the portfolio we focus on in particular, and it keeps producing strong results. We don't revalue the entire portfolio at the half year. So on this slide we've included some revenue data to give you a sense of how these businesses are performing. You can see how strong revenue growth is at each of these high-quality businesses. Strategic acquisitions are still an opportunity for us across our Private Equity businesses, and that is somewhere Soul Patts can help the companies we invest in succeed, given our access to capital and our transaction expertise. During the half we put an additional $84 million into acquisitions. The portfolio now stands at $1.7 billion in size, and cash generated was $27.7 million in the half, which is an increase of 107.9% against the previous year. We keep finding a niche to operate in within the market by taking a partnership approach to private equity and seeking to grow alongside companies and their founders over the long term.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveFor founders needing growth capital, or those navigating ownership transitions or liquidity requirements, Soul Patts makes sense as a partner. We think plenty of companies matching that description are drawn to the distinctive way we operate. Now on to credit. Our credit portfolio turned in excellent results during the half, with net cash flow from investments up 81.4% to $94.1 million. Credit complements the wider portfolio strongly, producing robust cash growth while serving as a diversifier of risk. Compared with the prior year, the portfolio's size has grown by $500 million. Worldwide, the private credit market keeps getting bigger. And we stayed busy, completing $266 million of fresh credit investments during the half. We favor situations in which our structuring skills let us earn suitable returns for the risk involved. Having multiple products and a flexible portfolio gives us an edge in a market where numerous players pursue a narrowly defined strategy. This slide highlights the EOS transaction as an illustration of how our adaptable, innovative method can deliver excellent results for both Soul Patts and the counterparties we invest with. EOS was grappling with working capital and debt maturity problems. We could put forward a flexible solution enabling the business to navigate its difficulties.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveThat loan has since been paid back, and EOS is performing well — its share price has risen 137% between the date we first provided support and the repayment of our loan. On repayments, $146 million of loans were repaid during the half. We have not had any cases where repayment did not come through as expected. Every one of our credit investments is actively managed, which lets us act proactively with the companies we invest in. The portfolio's average tenor sits between 2 and 3 years. We also hold $238 million in committed but undrawn credit lines. During the period we completed a number of offshore transactions, and we expect our international exposure to keep growing over time. Turning to emerging. Our emerging companies portfolio delivered a total return of 1.8% for the half. Cash generated from the portfolio came to $25.1 million, helped by realized investment gains. Portfolio size is about flat versus the prior year, reflecting roughly $100 million of sales in the half. The portfolio trailed a Small Ords Index by 4.8% over the last 6 months, though the chart above shows the strong long-term returns the team has delivered. The portfolio is highly concentrated, with just over 30% of it invested in uranium-exposed companies.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveDuring the half, spot uranium prices softened, pulling back from higher levels. At present, spot trades under the longer-dated contract price, and that ought to provide support as time goes on. As decarbonization efforts intensify and electricity demand rises across areas ranging from AI to electric vehicles, we anticipate that our uranium-linked investments will gain from long-term expansion in the worldwide nuclear sector. In closing, on the whole, we're highly satisfied with the half, which has gone on showing the advantages of portfolio flexibility, our emphasis on cash, and a long-term, disciplined investing approach. The portfolio adjustments made across the last 3 years keep producing results. I'd like to express thanks to the investment team and the various groups supporting them for their professionalism and their efforts during the half. And now I'll return the floor to Todd for a few remarks regarding the outlook.
Todd Barlow
executiveThanks, Brendan. With our solid liquidity and modest gearing, Soul Patts is in a good place to handle the market uncertainty we're seeing right now. That financial strength means we can keep evaluating opportunities capable of delivering long-term value. Cash generation keeps rising across the portfolio. And although thermal coal prices sit below forecast at present, higher output from New Hope and the weaker Australian dollar ought to offset that to some degree. Earnings and dividend growth in the market could stay weak for a while. Even so, we'll keep pushing for stronger cash flows out of our private equity and credit portfolios. We also think these private market opportunities offer better value than public markets do, and they correlate less with equity markets. On top of that, we're strengthening our offshore investing capabilities by building partnerships with high-quality, like-minded people. When markets are uncertain, our defensive portfolio is built to perform well, delivering stability and resilience through softer conditions. A strong balance sheet and a flexible financial position give us a solid foundation for growth. Many thanks for your interest in our company. We'll now take some of the questions I can see have been coming in slowly through the portal, but please keep submitting questions, and we'll do our best to respond to them.
Tanny Mangos
executiveThanks, Todd. Before we move on to questions, a few people have asked about when the dividend gets paid. I want to remind shareholders that the date is May 14, 2025. Our first question concerns how much we're exposed to large-cap gold stocks. Would you think about raising that exposure to gold?
Todd Barlow
executiveOkay, so within the strategic portfolio, one of the companies is Aeris, and it produces both copper and gold. Unfortunately, output at that company has not come in the way we had hoped, which would have let us capture part of the upside in gold prices and copper prices alike. Still, that was definitely one route we were using to get exposure to that sector. When I look at some of the other portfolios, especially the large caps, that is not the kind of thing we would normally put money into. Our thinking on gold is somewhat more cyclical in nature. Basing a fundamental valuation on cash flows becomes harder, since you are accepting that commodity risk without necessarily having a fundamental supply and demand basis behind the view. So we have generally steered clear of those kinds of volatile commodity stocks. And as Brendan described, gold has done well in recent times, certainly, but that is an area where our exposure has not been large.
Tanny Mangos
executiveTodd, staying on the large-cap topic, someone is asking if there's been any exposure — what's your copper exposure, and what are your views on copper prices?
Todd Barlow
executiveYes. I suppose that ties in somewhat with the point I made a moment ago regarding gold. The distinction is that we hold a somewhat more fundamental perspective on copper, since one can argue that rising electrification along with copper's supply and demand picture is quite supportive for copper prices, while gold is more of a wager on the macroeconomic backdrop. So ideally, the collection of assets Aeris owns — which are presently under development and could potentially begin operating and truly gain from stronger copper prices down the road — I believe there are ways for us to seize part of that upside via our investment in Aeris.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveOur outlook on copper is indeed a positive one, as Todd mentioned, and I want to highlight the large-cap portfolio in particular. It likely won't shock anyone that BHP currently stands as our biggest holding in that large-cap portfolio. We have a substantial position there since we find their portfolio of future-oriented commodities quite appealing, with their standing in copper being one example. So that's certainly a theme we're enthusiastic about and one we're positioning ourselves for.
Tanny Mangos
executiveMoving on, the following two questions have to do with our Perpetual holding. Investors want to know about cutting back that sizable position in Perpetual — particularly given that the KKR deal has now been turned down — and what has genuinely shifted regarding how appealing Perpetual looks? And does it still count as belonging to the strategic portfolio?
Brendan O'Dea
executiveThanks for asking that. Clearly, the Perpetual situation has been full of twists and turns throughout the life of — the life of that, not just the KKR transaction, but our involvement right from the beginning. We restructured our derivative holdings in Perpetual not long ago. The reason we did that is the votes tied to that structure were plainly no longer strategically important given what has happened with the KKR transaction and with our own transaction. So really, that was simply us effectively cleaning up our position. As for where that leaves us with our Perpetual holding, as I mentioned earlier, we remain the largest shareholder. Our economic exposure to Perpetual has been largely unchanged over time. Our view on Perpetual also has not changed. We think they have 3 very high-quality businesses there that the market underappreciates in terms of where the shares are trading right now, and we are comfortable with our shareholding and looking forward to the share price rerating on that. We are in contact with them regarding our shareholding. We know they are looking to sell off their wealth unit, which we see as a logical reaction to their balance sheet and to gaining a little more flexibility there.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveStill, in our view, the market tends to undervalue Perpetual overall. That was the thinking behind our initial move, and our opinion remains the same. The only thing we've done is adjust how our stake is set up, since the votes had become less strategic than previously. That said, I'm glad you raised it.
Tanny Mangos
executiveThe following question concerns how much we have in retained earnings compared with the annual dividend we currently pay. What does that figure come to? I'll perhaps direct that one to the CFO.
David Grbin
executiveYes. So in the filings we released today, you'll find information on the investment portfolio. That provides the balance sheet for the parent entity, the head stock. And turning to Page 14 of the half year report, you'll see retained earnings of just over $2.8 billion. In a full year, last year, we paid $347 million in dividends. So we've more than — there's plenty of coverage there when it comes to our capacity from a retained earnings standpoint. We also noted today that cash and liquid funds stand at $716 million. And importantly, there's more than $970 million of franking credit. So there's an almost unlimited supply of franking credits available to pay out on our dividend. So our position is very, very strong when it comes to funding the dividends going forward.
Todd Barlow
executiveTo restate our approach to dividend-setting, though: we don't determine it based on retained earnings. Obviously, a business as longstanding and as profitable as ours has accumulated substantial retained earnings across that stretch. Our aim is to keep a discipline under which we hand over a solid share of the cash our portfolio produces to shareholders. Over roughly the past 2 years, that figure has come in at about 70% to 80%. So we are distributing the cash we generate. And when we keep growing the cash our portfolio generates, that has made it possible for us to pay those larger dividends. And as I noted in my presentation, I take enormous pride in our record of dividend growth across recent years, which is something you simply don't see throughout the market.
Tanny Mangos
executiveThe following question we have concerns opportunities offshore. Investors want clarity on what these consist of, and how many additional ones you plan to pursue?
Todd Barlow
executiveSo which portfolio was that?
Tanny Mangos
executiveThis has to do with opportunities offshore.
Todd Barlow
executiveOffshore, right. That's a topic we've spent the past couple of years working on — figuring out ways to reach more opportunities worldwide. Australia, of course, is a wonderful place to put capital to work. We have genuinely strong opportunities here, since we're well recognised, we see plenty of deal flow, and we have extensive connections that let us originate the sorts of deals we want. So our effort has been to try to copy that model abroad. Now, we won't have staff on the ground capable of doing what we do, but we can locate partners possessing those capabilities, and we've been developing that. Right now, roughly $400 million has been allocated via partnerships into offshore funds. That's mostly credit and private equity. It keeps expanding, because those markets are quite deep and rich with opportunity. And it simply makes sense for us to achieve greater diversity across our portfolio. So you'll be seeing a bit more of that. As I mentioned, it stands at $400 million and keeps growing.
Tanny Mangos
executiveThe following question concerns Star Entertainment and the consequences of the situation unfolding there, and whether Soul Patts stands to lose any money on the loans it has extended to Star Casino.
Todd Barlow
executiveThat isn't what we anticipate. When we made the loan, our thesis was that the business's assets were far larger than its total debt, and we still hold that view. There is considerable noise surrounding the operating business, the equity value, and their liquidity constraints, yet nothing has shifted our belief that there is substantial coverage—so if a default occurs or the situation carries on, we ought to be repaid. I would point out, though, that our accounts do hold a reasonable reserve against the Star investment, but that reserve does not mirror how we think matters will actually unfold.
Tanny Mangos
executiveMoving on to private markets — they’re roughly 28% of the portfolio at this point. Are you intending to raise that allocation? And what’s your actual method for evaluating liquidity risk within that portfolio? Also, with so much capital flowing into private credit during the last 12 months, what are you observing on pricing in this asset class?
Todd Barlow
executiveWe keep putting capital into private markets since we believe those private assets—be it private equity or credit—offer fundamentally superior value propositions. And it's evident that both the results from our private equity holdings and the results from our credit portfolio simply outperform what we're able to replicate in public markets. So as long as opportunities keep showing up, we'll carry on doing that. That isn't to say we'll pick some target and push toward it no matter what market conditions and opportunities look like. Everything will be led by opportunity. Still, right now we keep seeing solid opportunities. We want to grow our private equity portfolio. We're still investing side by side with our current suite of private equity investments. And we put roughly another $100 million into those names over the last 6 months. On the liquidity question, this is, I mean, one of the big competitive advantages we enjoy, since we face no liquidity constraints. The sole liquidity constraints—or liquidity needs—we have involve paying dividends to our shareholders. And as I said, those dividends get paid from the cash we generate throughout the portfolio.
Todd Barlow
executiveRedemption risk isn't something we face, and shareholders aren't able to demand their capital back — they can sell their shares instead, and they enjoy daily liquidity since buying and selling happens on the market. But funding redemptions isn't an obligation for us. As a result, liquidity constraints don't apply to us. That said, we hold ample liquidity throughout the portfolio, since we have plenty of listed investments in other places. We have debt capacity. We have cash. So no liquidity constraints exist for us, and there aren't any liquidity needs that would make me worry about taking on more private assets exposure.
Tanny Mangos
executiveThere's also something I'd like to ask about regarding what the prospects look like for coal.
Todd Barlow
executiveOur thematic view on coal remains positive. When you consider the supply/demand picture, growing energy requirements, and how our Asian trading partners are setting themselves up by building out coal-fired power capacity, the outlook appears favorable across the board. Short-term swings in thermal coal pricing have caught us somewhat off guard. Before Christmas it stood at USD 140 a tonne; right now it has fallen to roughly $100. That represents quite a substantial decline. Still, anyone who saw New Hope's results a couple of days back would note their earnings came in higher. Output is increasing, and that production profile will keep growing as Acland comes online and, eventually, Malabar produces too. On top of that, they are lifting output at Bengalla. A softer Australian dollar is also helping to partly counter the weaker thermal coal price. So every signal points toward the coal price recovering. Yet even at USD 100, New Hope generates considerable cash thanks to its low cost production.
Tanny Mangos
executiveMoving to the following question, which concerns large-cap disclosures: in prior periods, we disclosed our 20 largest shareholdings. Could management explain the reason for that change?
Brendan O'Dea
executiveI'd note that, for sure, at the close of every year, we give a limited level of disclosure regarding what the portfolio holds. But there's a quite specific reason we don't reveal the holdings in the large-cap portfolio the way we perhaps once did. Previously — and you're likely, or you may very well be, thinking back to the Milton LIC era. The key reason is turnover. A genuine benefit we've enjoyed in how that portfolio is managed, and in the setup it now operates within, is that we can be active with our portfolio in a manner we couldn't be before. And should you look at the investor presentation, you'll see we carried out $600 million of buys and sells inside the large-cap portfolio during the last 6-month period. That large-cap portfolio was a $2.2 billion portfolio. So you can see the turnover for that portfolio might reach as high as 50% for the year on a full year basis. So it wouldn't really be suitable for us to disclose stale position information, so to speak, as it pertains to the large-cap portfolio, when those positions may have shifted.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveThat's why we were hesitant to share details that could be misread. The way this portfolio is managed now differs considerably from how it operated previously. That explains why what we disclose has been revised.
Tanny Mangos
executiveFollowing that, the next question: is it likely that any of the private equity holdings will arrive on the ASX market as an IPO in the near term?
Todd Barlow
executiveWe don't have any immediate plans to take any of our private equity investments public. We're still at the stage where those businesses are expanding quickly, which you can see from the revenue and earnings CAGR we're seeing there. Our thinking is also that staying unlisted benefits fast-growing companies that need capital, since funding that growth is much simpler for us—we can simply write a check. Once a company goes public, you have to go through an entire process of doing capital raises and matching up that capital raise with your opportunities, and it's just a lot more challenging. So a point will come when these businesses grow to a sufficient size that they can have their own life in the public markets. But while they continue to be in this high-growth phase, we'll incubate them.
Tanny Mangos
executiveThere's another question about the NexGen Canada investment. How large is it? What exactly is it? And which portfolio area does it belong to? And how do you view the outlook for that investment?
Todd Barlow
executiveNexGen is building a uranium mine up in Canada. That company belongs to our emerging companies portfolio and carries a value of roughly $300 million. What I find interesting, I suppose, is that this single holding represents close to 30% of that emerging company portfolio — practically all in just 1 stock. The team there is tremendously optimistic about uranium and where that commodity is headed. It reflects how we approach portfolio management: any single portfolio is allowed to be quite concentrated, since we run the overall portfolio as one whole rather than as separate individual pieces. So, as I mentioned, there's a belief that the world will face a uranium shortage. And as we're seeing, especially — well, our thesis did not factor in the enormous electricity demand needed to power data centers and AI and all of that. But we are definitely noticing far more interest in nuclear power beyond our original thesis, which held that the world would be short on uranium. NexGen holds a very large deposit and will generate a substantial amount of uranium at a very low cost once it comes online in the years ahead. It is currently working through its final development approvals, and we hold a very bullish view on that stock.
Tanny Mangos
executiveThe following question concerns the gross shareholding involving Brickworks. In what way should shareholders view the worth of the Brickworks stake, and in particular the circular character of that joint shareholding?
Todd Barlow
executiveYes. I mean, this question used to come up years ago, when people were kind of tangling themselves up by trying not to think about valuations. And the simplest way to look at it is that they aren't really connected. I mean, we could sell one Brickworks share, or $100 worth of Brickworks shares, and convert that $100 asset into $100 of cash. And Brickworks would do exactly the same with its Soul shares. And it has. I mean, a number of years ago, it sold a couple of hundred million dollars of Soul shares to fund its investments in the U.S. And so those are real assets held by each of the respective companies. So really, in our minds, it's a straightforward sum of the parts valuation for each respective company, taking into account the market valuations of the stocks that they hold and could sell.
Tanny Mangos
executiveSomeone has a follow-up about NexGen. What kind of investment would that be, and is it in the form of shares or something else?
Todd Barlow
executiveWhat we have is a mix of convertible notes — those give us the option to convert into shares — and roughly one-third of it sits in convertible bonds, while the remaining two-thirds is simply ordinary equity.
Tanny Mangos
executiveThe following question concerns defense stocks—not defensive ones—and asks whether you hold any defense stocks apart from EOS.
Todd Barlow
executiveYeah. I'd say EOS is probably the standout one. In fact, from a private equity standpoint, it's one of the thematics we're putting a lot of work into. We see opportunities to help fund some emerging, fast-growing Australian businesses that have really interesting technology and global capability. Beyond that, though, I can't think of any major stocks we hold at present.
Tanny Mangos
executiveThe following question concerns Aeris, and whether we have any fresh update on that right now.
Todd Barlow
executiveWell, I mean, I think an update on Aeris can be found in Aeris' market releases. I mean, we've put roughly $40 million into Aeris, so given its size, it won't be showing up in our presentation. But it has underperformed within our strategic portfolio. As I mentioned, there have been certain production issues that I believe require fixing. Still, commodities—gold and copper in particular—are certainly looking favorable at the moment, and there are some rather exciting assets within the Aeris portfolio that I think they can exploit in the years ahead.
Tanny Mangos
executiveMoving on to agriculture, which names in that sector appeal to you right now?
Todd Barlow
executiveSo, we don’t hold any ag stocks directly, since our private equity portfolio gives us pretty meaningful exposure there. I believe the private equity figure is roughly $500 million committed to direct agricultural assets. That’s how we gain our ag exposure. I’d say agriculture is a solid fundamental theme. Australia excels at efficient production, and we’ve assembled a portfolio of high-quality farms that supply export markets. That’s the approach we’re taking to agriculture.
Tanny Mangos
executiveThe following question concerns the large-caps portfolio, and it asks if a dividend-harvesting strategy is something we employ.
Brendan O'Dea
executiveNo, we don’t. There are a few reasons behind that. Clearly, whenever a stock trades ex dividend, its price falls by that amount. So we take that into account when thinking about total returns. We have no need to capture income in that manner, and we would point people toward the substantial growth in cash coming from the remainder of our portfolio. Running our large-cap portfolio for income isn’t necessary, since we generate very strong cash from strategic, very strong cash from credit, and steadily rising cash from private equity. That puts us in a highly fortunate situation where this isn’t required. It gives the team considerable freedom in how they invest. So no, we don’t take a specific approach of harvesting dividends.
Tanny Mangos
executiveThe following question concerns Brickworks, which reported its results today. Could you say something about how the share price compares with the net asset value?
Todd Barlow
executiveYes. So, as I mentioned before regarding how one should approach valuation for our companies, I believe a sum-of-the-parts approach makes sense. And when you examine what Brickworks’ assets consist of, roughly 50% is represented by its stake in Soul Patts. That portion is fairly simple to value, since a share price exists for it. Then approximately 40-odd percent of the value comes from properties, most of which are independently appraised and disclosed in their accounts. So in reality, only a modest share of its asset base gets valued using a capitalized earnings method, which pertains to the Building Products business. And so I’d say valuing that business is a fairly straightforward proposition, though it’s an unusual business given that such a large portion of its asset value sits in assets that aren’t what it’s mainly known for.
Tanny Mangos
executiveHere's another question for you. Has Soul Patts looked into creating funds that would let outside investors put money in alongside the existing portfolios?
Todd Barlow
executiveWe've certainly considered it, and it comes up frequently in questions we receive. The problem, as we see it, is that we're greedy, and we aim to keep as much of the strong deal flow we're finding for our shareholders as possible. So once you begin accepting third-party funds, you then have to share that excellent deal flow with a wider group. And second, when you bring in other people's funds, you wind up committing to quite rigid mandates regarding how those funds get invested, and you'll face redemption risk. You'll then be watching how you perform over the short term. And so I think you're beginning to erode many of the competitive advantages that come to us naturally. So should we ever pursue that, we'll proceed very carefully. But up to now, we have been pushing back against it simply so that we can concentrate on drawing maximum value for our own balance sheet.
Tanny Mangos
executiveThe following question is about whether we'll be holding shareholder roadshow meetings this year and which cities you plan to visit. Perhaps I can take that one. Absolutely — we are heading to Brisbane and Perth. Brisbane is on 2 April and Perth on 8 April, and we have some shareholder briefings lined up that we'll be announcing at a later date in Melbourne, Sydney and Adelaide. Now, just one last question. How are you managing the risk around dividend income and outcomes, particularly given this is the 25th year of consecutive dividends?
Todd Barlow
executiveWell, the most effective way for us to reduce the danger of a dividend cut is to keep growing how much cash we generate. And we're feeling quite positive about the cash generation outlook right across the portfolio. We've built the business to be far more resilient. We're not depending on only a couple of companies anymore to provide that cash to us. There are plenty of different assets performing in ways that differ from one another. And if you look just at the growth of the creditor, for instance, that's been a really solid performer for us when it comes to the cash outlook. Private equity, our companies -- we've put a lot of investment into their growth, which means there's been quite a bit of capital and investment going into those businesses, but they'll reach a point where they begin spinning off a substantial amount of cash. So I mean, even over the last 2 years, we've already seen a market that has lowered the dividends paid on average. And you can see what our portfolio has done during those last few years. So we feel very strongly about the outlook, and it's something we know matters to our shareholders, and it's a key performance indicator for us.
Tanny Mangos
executiveAlright, that brings our presentation and Q&A session to a close. Thanks once more for being with us and for your support of Soul Patts.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete WHSP Holdings Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to WHSP Holdings Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in WHSP Holdings Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.