Tencent Holdings Limited (700) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 12, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Wendy Huang
executiveGood evening, and welcome to the conference call for our third quarter 2020 results. This is Wendy Huang from Tencent's IR team. Before we begin the presentation, we'd like to remind everyone that it contains forward-looking statements, which are subject to a number of risks and uncertainties and may not be realized in the future for various reasons. Information regarding general market conditions comes from a variety of sources outside of Tencent. This presentation also includes some unaudited, non-IFRS financial measures, which should be considered in addition to, but not as a substitute for, measures of the company's financial performance prepared in accordance with IFRS. Non-IFRS measures are meant to reflect our core earnings by excluding certain one-time and/or non-cash items. For a detailed discussion of risk factors and non-IFRS measures, please refer to our disclosure documents on the IR section of our website. Let me introduce the management team joining us on the call tonight. Our Chairman and CEO, Pony Ma, will kick off with a short overview. President Martin Lau and Chief Strategy Officer James Mitchell will provide a business review. Chief Financial Officer John Lo will conclude with a financial review before we open the floor for questions. I will now turn the call over to Pony.
Pony Ma
executiveThanks, Wendy. Good evening, everyone, and thanks for being with us today. This quarter is the second anniversary of our strategic organization upgrade, which was meant to strengthen us in consumer internet and expand our footprint into industrial internet. Although that upgrade was built to deliver results over the long run, we are already seeing early gains in areas like consolidating our advertising services, rejuvenating our product and content platforms, growing our cloud and SaaS businesses, and building an internal open-source code base. Given the challenges in public health, the macroeconomy, and geopolitics, we will look to sharpen our focus, innovate, and work with our partners so we can better serve our users, customers, and society at large. I'll walk through the results we delivered in the third quarter of 2020. Total revenue came to RMB 125 billion, up 29% year-on-year and 9% quarter-on-quarter. Gross profit was RMB 57 billion, up 33% year-on-year and 6% quarter-on-quarter. Our non-IFRS operating profit reached RMB 38 billion, up 34% year-on-year and 1% quarter-on-quarter. Non-IFRS net profit attributable to equity holders was RMB 32 billion, up 32% year-on-year and 7% quarter-on-quarter. Turning to our online platforms. In social, combined MAU of Weixin and WeChat was 1.2 billion.
Pony Ma
executiveOn smart devices, QQ’s MAU came in at 617 million. Within games, we’re extending our lead through the broad popularity of established franchises and through new releases that have done well both in China and internationally. In media, video and music subscriptions rose as we put out top-tier content and added songs to the paid library. In fintech, commercial payment transactions kept growing strongly, and our wealth management platforms grew their aggregated customer assets. In public cloud, demand for PaaS solutions is climbing, and we upgraded our SaaS enterprise productivity toolkit to seize opportunities in emerging sectors. In utilities, we hold our industry leadership in mobile security and mobile browser in China. I’ll now ask Martin and James to walk through the business review.
Martin Lau
analystThanks, Pony. Good evening, and good morning as well. In Q3 2020, total revenue rose 29% compared with a year earlier. VAS accounted for 56% of overall revenue, with social networks at 23% and online games at 33% within that. Online advertising made up 17% of total revenue. Fintech and business services contributed 26% of overall revenue. Within value-added services, segment revenue reached RMB 70 billion in Q3, a 38% year-on-year rise and 7% growth quarter-on-quarter. Social networks revenue came to RMB 28 billion, up 29% year-on-year and 6% quarter-on-quarter, largely fueled by in-game item sales and live streaming services. Total VAS subscriptions climbed 25% year-on-year to 213 million, helped by digital content subscriptions. Total video subscriptions rose 20% year-on-year to 120 million, mainly thanks to hit drama and animated series including "Nothing But Thirty" and "The Land of Warriors Season Three." We converted trial users gained during summer promotions into regular video subscribers successfully. Total music subscriptions increased 46% year-on-year to 52 million, supported by an expanded paid library and improved retention. Online games revenue climbed 45% year-on-year and 8% quarter-on-quarter to RMB 41 billion, powered by growth in paying users and ARPU. Total smartphone games revenue rose 61% year-on-year to RMB 39 billion, aided by strong growth of existing titles and recognition of deferred revenue from the stay-at-home period.
Martin Lau
analystRevenue rose 9% in sequence, while cash receipts dipped a bit as people went back to their offices and in-game activity returned to normal levels. PC client games revenue held steady year-over-year at RMB 12 billion, since higher revenue from League of Legends worldwide and from Valorant, a new game, in Western markets made up for lower revenue from Dungeon & Fighter in China. Revenue was up 7% quarter-over-quarter, driven by CrossFire and by a full quarter of contribution from Valorant. Now let me say more about our social networks. With Weixin, our focus is on giving users convenience and efficiency. To make high-frequency services easier to reach inside the Weixin Pay interface, we sorted the service list into four key verticals: financial services, daily services, transportation and travel, and shopping and entertainment. In the travel and transportation vertical, we broadened the geographic coverage of mobility services to 10 provinces and municipalities in China. Mobility services link auto owners with car services like car washes and car insurance, and link general users with public transportation services, including transit codes and bus schedule checking. To make content and service delivery more efficient, we allow more cross-referencing within Weixin properties. For instance, in the chat box, users can press to search words and phrases that show up in messages, and Weixin will then offer related content and services from Mini Programs, official accounts, Moments, and other sources.
Martin Lau
analystWithin Moments, users can make hashtags on their posts. When people reading a post click those hashtags, they’re able to view related material from official accounts, video feeds, and H5 pages. Now on to QQ. We continue building fresh experiences that reinforce how tightly the youth community sticks to the QQ platform. We give young users more ways to share experiences together. For instance, they can watch Tencent Video together while on a video chat, compete against friends in battle mode mini games, and jointly edit classwork through Tencent Docs. Since April, we’ve been testing Mini World, a video and image feed service inside QQ. Contributors in Mini World can produce images and videos that are shared beyond their existing friend circle, and users can discover content via recommendation. Mini World connects strongly with a young audience and has grown steadily in popularity. These efforts, together with rising adoption of real-time video chatting, pushed daily time spent per user within QQ up by a teens% year-over-year. Now shifting to our gaming business. For smartphone games, we draw on our industry expertise, user insight, and execution to bring engaging experiences to large-scale audiences, boosting the vitality and longevity of our existing titles, including blockbusters as well as the lesser-known games.
Martin Lau
analystWe marked the fifth anniversary of Honor of Kings not long ago; during the first 10 months of 2020, that title surpassed 100 million average DAU. By continually innovating, running operations with users at the center, and maintaining strong technology infrastructure, we have broadened Honor of Kings' player base. We are unlocking the value of its IP through new games, animated series, and a live-action drama series. Titles like Honor of Kings and Peacekeeper Elite are well known to investors, yet we bring comparable strengths to smaller, vertically focused titles too. Take Naruto Mobile, our self-developed game: although it came out four years ago, it has just hit record highs in DAU and revenue, thanks to operational improvements made over the years, including a better PVP mode. Naruto Mobile now ranks among China's most popular and highest-grossing fighting-genre games. As for PC games, we remain fairly positive on that segment. Revenue growth in the PC game market has not matched that of the mobile game market, but PC games carry substantial influence. The PC platform offers ample scope for IP and product innovation that can generate direct revenue or wider platform benefits. For instance, League of Legends ran a big thematic event, Spirit Blossom Festival, during the quarter, aligning the launch of new champions, skins, and an event pass, which proved popular with users and generated revenue.
Martin Lau
analystThe latest League of Legends World Championship, held in Shanghai, also drew a big, sizable audience around the world. We turned CrossFire into a drama series that earned strong ratings, and we put out a tie-in new game mode plus skins, which brought the game's popularity and monetization back. On top of that, Valorant, a new title, has turned into a breakout hit within the tactical shooter category in Western markets, with a broad audience on Twitch. Alongside maintaining and building on the success of existing games, we keep launching impactful new titles. Moonlight Blade Mobile, a self-developed game built on the well-known novel, by iOS grossing became the most successful MMORPG launch in China this year. League of Legends: Wild Rift, a mobile battle arena title drawing on the LOL IP, currently ranks among the most downloaded mobile games in every market in Asia where it's available. With that, I'll hand things over to James, who will cover the remainder of the business review.
James Mitchell
executiveThanks, Martin. Now turning to advertising: revenue was up 16% from a year earlier and 15% versus the prior quarter, reaching RMB 21 billion. In our view, China's ad market has by now mostly bounced back from the COVID-19 hit. Verticals enjoying strong long-term structural expansion — education, internet services, and e-commerce among them — kept posting fast year-on-year gains on our platform in the third quarter. Spending from certain cyclical advertiser groups, including automobiles and real estate, improved compared with a year ago. A few sectors whose ad budgets had fallen because of COVID, financial services and consumer staples for instance, were roughly flat year-on-year during the quarter. On the internal side, we carried out efforts that included enhancing our algorithmic ad-buying tools, which produced better conversion for advertisers and drew a larger share of budgets toward our offerings. In addition, we made extra ad inventory available across casual game apps, esports events, and live streaming platforms. Within social and other advertising, our properties posted healthy year-on-year revenue gains, powered by impressions rising faster than eCPM. Revenue from our mobile ad network climbed sharply year-on-year, as advertisers took favorably to video formats like our rewarded video ads. As for media advertising, following four quarters of sharp year-on-year revenue drops, the pace of decline eased to -1% year-on-year. We secured sponsorship demand through self-commissioned variety shows, including "The Coming One," season four, and drama series like "Nothing But Thirty." We also revamped the splash screen ads on Tencent Video, lifting eCPMs and delivering sequential revenue growth for our video advertising service.
James Mitchell
executiveTurning to Fintech and business services, revenue for that segment came in at RMB 33 billion — a 24% increase from a year earlier and 11% higher than the prior quarter. Within that, Fintech services posted healthy gains both year-on-year and quarter-on-quarter, driven by the ongoing strong growth of our commercial payments and wealth management operations, whereas social payments and micro-lending grew more modestly. On the payments side, momentum carried through the quarter, with total payment volume rising more than 30% compared with a year ago. Daily active users of commercial payment and spending per user each climbed quickly. Online transactions got a boost from the pandemic's acceleration of the shift away from offline purchases toward online ones, and from heavier use of Mini Programs to transact in categories like groceries and apparel. Payment operating margins held steady. In wealth management, active customers rose more than 50% year-on-year, which drove a comparable increase in aggregated customer assets. As for business services, revenue growth year-on-year decelerated, reflecting the pandemic's continuing drag on project deployments and new contract sign-ups, together with non-recurring adjustments to certain Infrastructure as a Service contracts. Still, demand picked up for Platform as a Service, especially security PaaS among clients in financial, healthcare, and internet service sectors.
James Mitchell
executiveOver the course of this period, we enhanced our Software as a Service enterprise productivity toolkit, made up of three signature products: WeCom, Tencent Meeting, and Tencent Docs. WeCom, formerly called Enterprise Weixin, is seeing growing adoption among customers for workplace communication and management. Even though most people have gone back to their workplaces, WeCom's DAU rose more than 100% year-on-year in the quarter. Tencent Meeting has now surpassed 100 million registered users. In September, we launched an enterprise version of Tencent Meeting in response to rising demand for customization. We connected Tencent Docs, our cloud-based document processing tool, with other Tencent products — among them QQ Browser — as well as our customer relationship management SaaS, to broaden its use cases further. With that, I'll hand things over to John to walk through the financials.
John Lo
executiveThanks, James. For Q3, total revenue came to RMB 125.4 billion, which is up 29% year-on-year, or 9% quarter-on-quarter. Gross profit reached RMB 56.6 billion, rising 33% year-on-year, or 6% quarter-on-quarter. Net other gains stood at RMB 11.6 billion. That was mainly driven by non-IFRS adjustment items — namely higher valuations of some investees in verticals including electric vehicle, online games, and local services — plus net gains on deemed disposal of certain investees. Operating profit was RMB 44 billion, up 17% year-on-year, or 12% quarter-on-quarter. Net finance costs were RMB 1.9 billion, up 11% year-on-year, or down 3% quarter-on-quarter. The year-on-year increase reflected recognition of a foreign exchange loss this quarter versus the foreign exchange gain a year earlier. QoQ was broadly stable. Share profit of associates and joint venture was RMB 2.6 billion. Both year-on-year and quarter-on-quarter gained from better performance of some investees in verticals such as e-commerce and online games. Year-on-year growth also reflected non-IFRS adjustment items of certain associates. On a non-IFRS basis, we recorded a share profit of RMB 3.2 billion for the quarter. Income tax expense was RMB 5.7 billion for quarter three 2020. The effective tax rate was 12.9%. IFRS net profit attributable to equity holders was RMB 38.5 billion, up 89% year-on-year, or 16% quarter-on-quarter.
John Lo
executiveDiluted earnings per share came to RMB 3.964, which is an 86% rise compared with the same period last year and a 15% increase from the prior quarter. Let me now walk through some of our non-IFRS financial measures. In the third quarter, operating profit reached RMB 38.1 billion, up 34% versus a year ago and up 1% sequentially. Net profit after non-controlling interests was RMB 32.3 billion, an increase of 32% year-on-year and 7% from the second quarter. Diluted EPS was RMB 3.314, rising 30% relative to last year and 6% quarter-on-quarter. Turning to gross margin by segment. VAS gross margin was 52.6%, edging up 0.8 percentage point from a year earlier while declining 1.1 percentage points sequentially. Compared with last year, we keep seeing a benefit from the shift in mix toward higher-margin self-developed platform gains. On a quarter-over-quarter basis, the VAS margin fell because content costs tied to our online video operations were higher. Gross margin for online advertising stood at 50.9%, an improvement of 2.1 percentage points year-on-year and roughly unchanged from the prior quarter. The year-over-year gain was driven mainly by the industry-wide exemption from the cultural construction fee that applied this year. Fintech and business services gross margin was 27.9%, essentially flat from a year ago and down one percentage point from the previous quarter. The sequential decline primarily reflected higher channel costs for payment-related services as offline merchants resumed activity during the pandemic. On the topic of operating expenses, selling and marketing expenses totaled RMB 8.9 billion, up 56% compared with last year and up 15% from the prior quarter.
John Lo
executiveLooking year over year, marketing spend went up, especially for online games, Weixin, and business services. The quarter-on-quarter rise came mostly from online games and business services. Selling and marketing expense came to 7.1% of revenues in the quarter. G&A costs were RMB 17.2 billion, 27% higher year on year, or 4% up quarter on quarter, largely because of higher R&D and staff costs. Inside G&A, R&D expenses reached RMB 9.9 billion, up 25% year on year and flat quarter on quarter. G&A and R&D accounted for 13.7% and 7.9% of revenues, respectively. At the close of the quarter, headcount stood at roughly 77,600 employees, 27% more than a year earlier, or 10% higher quarter on quarter. Gross margin for the third quarter of 2020 was 45.2%, 1.5 percentage points above the prior-year period and 1.1 percentage points below the previous quarter. Year over year, better segment gross margins lifted the blended gross margin, notably from value-added services. In sequential terms, the margin decline chiefly reflected a lower VAS gross margin than in the last quarter. Non-IFRS operating margin came in at 30.4%, 1 percentage point higher year on year and 2.4 percentage points lower quarter on quarter. Non-IFRS net margin was 26.6%, 0.8 percentage point above a year ago and 0.6 percentage point below the prior quarter. Last, I'd like to walk you through a few key financial metrics before we wrap up our remarks.
John Lo
executiveCapEx came in at 8.7 billion RMB altogether, which is a 31% rise from a year earlier but an 8% decline versus the prior quarter. Operating CapEx rose 34% year-on-year, reaching 7.8 billion RMB, and that reflects higher spending on servers and network equipment meant to support growth in our business. Non-operating CapEx was up 12% year-on-year to 901 million RMB, driven by outlays on data centers constructions. In the quarter just reported, free cash flow totaled 28.1 billion RMB, roughly flat on both a year-on-year and a quarter-on-quarter basis. Our net cash position stood at RMB 6.4 billion, lower sequentially because of payments tied to M&A initiatives, partly offset by cash flow generated from operations. The fair value of our shareholdings and listed investees, excluding subsidiaries, came to approximately RMB 891 billion, or $131 billion, as of the end of the quarter, versus RMB 726 billion, or $103 billion, in the previous quarter. Thank you.
Wendy Huang
executiveThanks, John. Operator, we’re ready to take questions from the floor now.
Operator
operatorWe’re going to start the question-and-answer part now. If you’d like to ask a question, press star one on your phone and wait until your name is called. To cancel your request, press the pound or hash key. Each participant may ask one main question and one follow-up question each time. Our first question is from Kenneth Fong at Credit Suisse. Please go ahead.
Kenneth Fong
analystThank you. Nice work on the very strong results, and I appreciate management taking my question. I have two questions about the game, please. Regarding the game, we saw that recent new titles such as Genshin Impact and Rise of Kingdoms are launching via game community platforms like Bilibili and TapTap in order to reach a broader target user base and steer clear of Android's high revenue sharing. I recall that last year we said we had been negotiating with the Android platform to reduce the channel fee on a game-by-game basis. Do you believe the successful launch of these recent titles, along with more mobile cloud platforms like Huya and Yowa, would open us up to additional game distribution channels, and that this would shift the negotiating power toward us as a major game developer? Put another way, we will see more room for margin improvement by lowering the channel fee over time. Thank you.
James Mitchell
executiveThanks for asking that. In the past we've said that we didn't think the economics of the game industry were ideal for game studios, and that in many cases the channels were taking a larger portion of the profits than the studios did. We're large enough as a company to withstand that, but plenty of smaller companies couldn't withstand it. We've been pushing for the revenue share with the channels to be reset to more reasonable levels. As you noted, a number of mid-size game studios in China have lately gone around some of the traditional channels entirely, and still made their games highly popular, which is impressive and deserves praise. On our side, as you know, we've been negotiating the channel revenue shares toward levels we consider more sustainable. That has flowed through, and will keep flowing through over time, into our game margins. We think there's room for many different participants to succeed, including small studios, large studios, and both traditional channels and new channels. The fact that these different players are experimenting with different channels is healthy for the industry.
James Mitchell
executiveWhen it comes to our own situation, the relationships we have with the large traditional channels are solid. After certain adjustments were made in how we work with those major channels, we believe we're positioned in a healthy and sustainable way.
Martin Lau
analystI do want to make one additional point: I don't think this comes down to a single figure, like the revenue share. What really matters, I believe, is setting things up so the relationship is fair. At the same time, the channel actually gets an incentive to deliver value. That, I'd say, is the more significant and somewhat more intricate piece of the negotiation. Take an example: if you genuinely can bring in a promotion of new users, that's worth a lot. If another party is kind of signing up users via other channels, but they were simply coming through an app store, then the value would be lower, I think. We're heading into an industry where the value contributed by different parties will be divided in a more delicate way. Overall, then, I think the economics will be fairer, and it will be healthier for everybody.
Kenneth Fong
analystThanks. I have a follow-up about the overseas game. At this point, what percentage of revenue comes from it? Apart from the U.S. and Japan, where our Chinese operator has been concentrating, which market do you think holds the greatest potential going forward? And what obstacles have we encountered so far that keep us from reproducing our success in those countries? Thank you.
James Mitchell
executiveOkay. That percentage isn't something we report each quarter, though I think the most recent quarter when we provided a specific figure was Q4 of last year, at which point we said 23% of game segment revenue came from international. The reason is that, on one hand, our international games have done very well over the past nine months, while on the other hand, our domestic game business has also grown at a nice clip. The ratio for Q3 was quite close to what it was in Q4 of last year. On geographies, the game business globally really is global, and our portfolio certainly reflects that. What that means is that beyond the U.S., Japan, and China — the ones you mentioned — there are quite large game markets in other regions, and some of our games clearly perform disproportionately well in particular markets. To illustrate, the Supercell and Miniclip titles tend to over-perform in Continental Europe. League of Legends and Brawl Stars, for instance, have over-performed in Korea, which is a major Asian market. PUBG Mobile has over-performed in parts of the Middle East and in emerging markets. Call of Duty: Mobile has over-performed in South America. We're actually rather lucky that, given the breadth of games in and around our portfolio, we now have experience with successful publishing or partnerships across many different geographies.
Kenneth Fong
analystUnderstood, that's very clear. Thanks, and congratulations once more.
James Mitchell
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our next question is from Alex Yao at JPMorgan. Go ahead, please.
Alex Yao
analystThanks for taking my question, management, and congrats on a strong quarter. I'd like to ask about how the operating environment has shifted because of the policy introduced over the past 1 to 2 weeks, covering both online micro-lenders and the anti-trust guideline. In light of those policy introductions, what operational changes are you likely to bring in? And as a follow-up, could you update us on the fintech growth strategy given this change in the regulatory environment? Thank you.
Martin Lau
analystThank you for the question. Regarding fintech at this moment, my answer would be that our strategy won't shift much, correct? Steadily advancing our fintech operations is what we've been doing, and that approach will carry on. When you consider the principles we've stuck to in fintech, the first one is genuinely regulatory compliance, and we've carried that out very systematically in the past. Looking at the micro-loan regulation, it actually doesn't really affect our flagship micro-loan service, Weilidai, since Weilidai is in fact provided by WeBank, which is a bank holding a full license. It has complied completely with banking rules, which constitute the regulated portion of the whole industry. We hold risk management in high regard, and we manage risk prudently. That covers deliberately reining in the scale of certain financial products of ours, loans, wealth management products, and insurance included, so that we optimize for quality instead of merely pursuing scale. We concentrate on working together with industry partners inside the financial sector. For instance, in the micro-loan business, we actually partner with over 60 banks, which lets us actually contribute our loan-origination expertise.
Martin Lau
analystAnd at the same time, we actually collaborate with them so their expertise gets brought into the business, and jointly we end up with a win-win result. I think we also place a great deal of emphasis on having diversified revenue sources. If you look at our revenue, it's actually fairly diversified across payment and the lending business, plus wealth management, and the emerging piece on the insurance side. Lastly, I'd say we concentrate heavily on creating unique value for users and for our industry partners too. We bring in technology solutions so that we can lower the frictional cost. We boosted engagement for our industry partners with the users. Because of that, we've been growing our fintech business at a measured pace. We also control the size while at the same time building our capabilities and enhancing our value proposition for both our users and industry partners. If you look at this whole strategy, I think it actually aligns very well with the regulatory environment as it stands today. I think we will keep steadily driving our fintech business forward.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our next question is from Gary Yu at Morgan Stanley. Go ahead.
Gary Yu
analystHello, and thanks for giving me the chance to ask a question. Congratulations on the strong results. My question is about the gaming business. Since we're in a COVID-19 normalization phase starting in the first half, momentum could slow somewhat. Meanwhile, the pipeline of new games looks quite strong. How should we view whether gaming revenue growth can be sustained going forward, especially as we head into 2021? Thank you.
James Mitchell
executiveThanks for the congrats and for asking. In the prepared remarks we noted that although our reported games revenue rose from one quarter to the next, that partly mirrored how conservative we are in deferring and amortizing cash receipts. In Q3, we enjoyed the complete advantage of the jump in cash receipts we had seen during the first half of 2020. Even so, our cash receipts fell a bit quarter-on-quarter. As for the third quarter, we have already seen some normalization in cash receipts. We expect that to persist as we move ahead, which carries consequences for the growth rate of reported revenue over time as well. Speaking more broadly, I'd say we stay optimistic regarding the games business across the short, medium, and long term, because first, we keep improving our live operations. As discussed in the prepared remarks, I believe many investors now know about certain live operations initiatives we have introduced into our truly flagship, highest-profile titles such as Honor of Kings, yet they might be less aware of how far we are also applying these to more vertically niche or genre-focused games like Naruto. That covers live operations for games already in market.
James Mitchell
executiveWhen it comes to new games, the pipeline holds quite a few very prominent, widely talked-about titles. Some of these are already developed and already possess their Bǎn Hào along with a pending launch, like DNF Mobile and Call of Duty: Mobile. Others have been developed and released in other markets yet await a Bǎn Hào and launch in China, like Wild Rift and Valorant. There are a large number of games — both our own IP and licensed IP from our big internal studios, including TiMi, Quantum, Morefun, and Aurora — that would generally draw less external attention until they launch. As the success of Moonlight Blade over the last few weeks shows, those games can be very impactful and successful as well. That's our view on the game business looking forward.
Gary Yu
analystAlright, thanks — that's quite clear. As a follow-up, I'd like to ask about your online video businesses. We've noticed that a few industry players have announced they're raising the monthly fee. How should we think about the possibility of additional price increases from outside going forward? And more generally, how ought we to view competition? Thank you.
James Mitchell
executiveWell, I recall this was probably seven or eight years back, when we introduced what we called at that point our Hollywood VIP video subscription service. The name Hollywood VIP came about since 100% of the paid content consisted of Hollywood movies. Every single piece of content was literally either Warner Bros., Viacom, or Disney. In my view it was among the finest products we had ever brought to market, yet the broader user base didn't appear to share my opinion. We priced it at RMB 20 each month, and we reached a particular subscriber base, but we came to see that growing that subscriber base required us to add more content. That is what we have been doing progressively. At first we added drama series that were also shown on terrestrial television, then we layered on domestic films, and after that we began creating our own drama series. More recently, we started creating our own variety shows and our own animated TV program, which have had a very strong impact. In any case, the net result is that what we now invest in content for our subscription video service is many magnitudes larger than it was when we set that 20 RMB price point. The range of high-quality content available — and in many cases uniquely available — is infinitely bigger than it was when we set that 20 RMB price point.
James Mitchell
executiveNaturally, as time passes, inflation in Chinese consumer prices has meant that the 20 RMB price point has grown increasingly affordable. Our firm view is that subscription video services in China are, in a sense, priced too low. Given the right conditions, we would be glad to explore the chance to make pricing adjustments in a manner that is fair both to consumers and to the content industry.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our next question is from John Choi at Daiwa. Please go ahead.
John Choi
analystGood evening, and thanks for taking my question. Congratulations on a really strong set of results this quarter. I wanted to ask about your online advertising. During your prepared remarks, management did mention that spending is gradually normalizing. You also said there's some increasing adoption of certain algorithm and buying solutions. I was wondering how much this has actually helped us when it comes to capturing more ad dollars spent on our platform? Is that the main reason we're seeing such strong growth, or is it also a combination of higher impressions on eCPM from the other inventories that you have? A quick follow-up on your cloud. We noticed that your cloud revenue growth was a little softer than expected. You mentioned IaaS has been delayed or postponed. If you look at the industry-wide situation right now, we're seeing growth that's still relatively healthy. I was wondering what challenges we're facing and what kind of growth we should expect going forward? Thank you.
James Mitchell
executiveLet me take the advertising question, and Dowson will cover cloud. I think in advertising, looking at it worldwide, there's a massive change in the way advertisers spend their money online. Broadly, spending is moving to video format, and it's moving to retargeting. Take Google's third-quarter results, for instance: their search revenue, I believe, was up one point something billion year-on-year, which is great. Their YouTube revenue was also up one point something billion year-on-year, which is amazing when you consider YouTube starts from a far smaller base than search. That reflects both of those trends — YouTube is a natural home for video advertising. Over the last two years, Google has let advertisers retarget from earlier search queries and other intent-based activities into advertising on YouTube. When you think about it and look at our platforms, I believe we're well positioned to gain from video advertising. That's very clear in a few of our feed products. It's very clear in Tencent Video itself. It's especially clear in recent quarters in our ad network, where the shift to video has been big.
James Mitchell
executiveAnd then I believe we're in a strong position to gain from retargeting as well. Historically, a huge gap existed between what people call intent-based advertising, eCPMs, and every other eCPM. Retargeting's rise has genuinely brought those price points together. We haven't gained much from that, since structurally we were short on intent-based advertising, on intent-based opportunities, while some of our peers were structurally long on aggregate traffic. Naturally, we aren't the sole company benefiting from those trends. ByteDance, I think, has quite clearly benefited too. ByteDance and we are likely the two that gain most naturally from the move toward video and the move toward retargeting.
Dowson Tong
executiveYeah. Regarding the cloud business at the moment, I’d point to several factors behind the softer quarter, particularly when you compare us with peers. One factor is actually more tied to a handful of projects and contracts. That will disappear next quarter. It’s more of a one-time, non-recurring event involving delays on some projects and the restructuring of some contracts. The second factor, I’d say, is that when we are catching up, we actually depend more on new projects. During the pandemic, some of those new projects were delayed, and because of that, the catch-up effort got disrupted somewhat. Another factor is that, if you examine the growth fueling the cloud business, particularly through the pandemic and afterward, a fair amount of it comes from short video as well as games. In games, I’d say, since much of the games revenue actually comes from our own games, right. Even though we provide cloud service to our own games, that isn’t recorded as revenue. On the short video side, there is a competitive factor there. Those are all the reasons why I believe growth is softer than peers. I think that one-time adjustment will basically come to an end after this quarter.
Dowson Tong
executiveWe're also making up ground when it comes to new projects.
Wendy Huang
executiveOperator, let's go on to the following one.
Operator
operatorOur following question is from Hyunwoo Kim at Macquarie. Please go ahead with your question.
Hyunwoo Kim
analystThanks. Great. I appreciate the chance to speak with you folks today. I’d like to ask about Wild Rift for League of Legends and how it interacts with the PC version. What sort of dynamism are you observing when it comes to monetization on each side, or user behavior, and how should we think about the eventual role, a commercial launch of it, an official commercial launch of it, moving from the current beta phase into a more commercial status and then the rollout into the other regions where it has not been released? I’ll have a follow-up question after that.
James Mitchell
executiveThanks for asking. Regarding Wild Rift and how users behave, it's a shorter, sharper experience than full League of Legends, as you'd probably expect. A complete match runs about half as long as a complete match on PC League of Legends. The experience quality is extremely high. Of course, Riot and we are biased, but both Riot and we are extremely pleased. It has taken a good amount of time to bring a mobile incarnation of League of Legends to release, yet the final product is something everyone is extremely satisfied with, at least internally. Judging by the data we see from the earlier beta tests in Philippines and Brazil, plus the more recent full launches across Southeast Asia and Japan, users appear to feel the same way. On monetization, as with League of Legends itself, and in fact, as with every Riot Games, monetization is relatively back-end loaded. That means I think there'll be a relatively lengthier period of time between Wild Rift aggregating users versus Wild Rift converting those users into monetization compared to a game such as Moonlight Blade, where the users and the monetization arrive simultaneously.
James Mitchell
executiveThat's okay. I'd say our games lineup is pretty wide-ranging, and it's a good thing that monetization works differently from title to title. From what we've seen with League of Legends over the very long haul, monetization isn't an issue for a game like that.
Hyunwoo Kim
analystThanks. Just to build on that, regarding the expansion into the other regions, how should we think about the phased introduction of the global commercial release that's happening today?
James Mitchell
executiveFrom what I understand, Riot has shared a bit about what it plans to do. Obviously, in the case of China, the timing hinges on the Bǎn Hào issuance, though in other regions Riot calls the shots. As I remember it, they believed staggering the launches mattered a lot, since this marks the first time Riot has put out a major mobile game. Considering how many people play League of Legends on PC today, how many used to play it on PC, and how many would like to play League of Legends yet lack a PC, the early and continuing flood of users for Wild Rift is fairly large, which places huge strain on bandwidth and server capacity. So it stands to reason that launching across different geographies in stages over time is sensible. After bringing the game out successfully in various parts of Asia over the past couple of weeks, Riot is now preparing to release it in Europe — a very large market for League of Legends PC — and then gradually in Korea, the Americas, and other places.
Hyunwoo Kim
analystUnderstood. On a personal level, I’m hoping Hong Kong arrives soon. My next question focuses on the fintech side. We discussed TPV growth of more than 30% and a 50% increase in loan placements. My assumption is that revenue growth is higher than that, and I’d like to have that confirmed. Given that, I’d also assume our profitability has gotten better. It would be helpful to hear some comments about the profit improvement in the fintech business. Thank you.
James Mitchell
executiveWe don’t provide much detail on that. In the prepared remarks, and I believe if you check the MD&A, we stated that revenue growth for fintech overall was very close to what it was in the prior quarter. The slowdown you observed in the segment came from business services, not from fintech services. We also said that the profit margin on the payment business itself stayed fairly steady. There wasn’t any major shift in growth rates or margins.
Martin Lau
analystRight. And as we mentioned, our fintech revenue actually comes from fairly diversified streams. Tying that fintech revenue straight to TPV probably isn't the right way to look at it. We don't break that out separately, but I'd like to point that out just as an indication.
Operator
operatorThanks. We’ll take the next question from Thomas Chong at Jefferies. Your line is open.
Thomas Chong
analystHello there, and good evening. I appreciate the management team making time for my questions, and congratulations on delivering such a strong set of results. My question concerns Mini Program. Since we witnessed GMV enjoying quite powerful growth momentum over the course of the year, and with digitization standing as the key industry trend, I'd like to know what our approaches are when it comes to digitization across various industries, including smart retail and smart catering, and in what ways our payments and cloud infrastructure could further accelerate that migration. Thank you.
Martin Lau
analystWe're genuinely pretty enthusiastic about the GMV growth we're seeing on Mini Programs, and we've actually made it one of our strategic priorities to boost the support we provide inside the Weixin ecosystem for transactions, and especially for Mini Program transactions. If you look at what we're doing, one piece is stepping up our backing within Weixin for Mini Programs. The new content discovery, along with the rearranging of our wallet entry point and the launch of things like live broadcast — all of that is really the infrastructure that lets Mini Programs do more when it comes to facilitating transactions. That's inside the Weixin ecosystem. On the other hand, I'd say the other side of the equation is really about helping industry partners, helping various businesses improve and upgrade their digitization, upgrade their tech infrastructure, so they can embrace Mini Programs on a bigger scale. On that front, we obviously have our smart retail team. We have our cloud service team and our sales team helping these industry partners. At the same time, we're also empowering plenty of ecosystem partners. Take SaaS providers, for example — they can help these industry partners embrace technology on a bigger scale.
Martin Lau
analystI'd say this is an ongoing process. In fact, it's moving along well, and the pandemic has actually accelerated it. Whether it's strengthening our own ecosystem, having our own team assist our industry partners, or enabling ecosystem partners to support those industry partners, I believe all of these will help drive continued growth in Mini Programs as a way for people to conduct transactions.
Thomas Chong
analystThanks. My second question concerns social advertising, specifically Moments and the mobile ad network. Should we anticipate additional rises in ad load for Moments over the next few quarters? And how ought we to view the rivalry with short-form video players when it comes to video advertising? Thank you.
James Mitchell
executiveOn the Moments ad load, I believe we've been raising inventory at a gradual, measured pace, and that will continue to be the case. As you likely know, the ad load percentage on WeChat Moments is dramatically lower than at many other very popular internet services in China, including the short video sites you mentioned. On the competition between short video and some of our inventory, I think we've discussed this a bit previously, but broadly speaking, I'd say that both the short video platforms and a good deal of our inventory gain from the shift toward videoization. Both gain from the trend toward retargeting. From a pricing standpoint, short video tends to aggregate around a mid-20s RMB eCPM. That is somewhat directly competitive with, for instance, Tencent video advertising. That's partly why our media advertising faced pressure for four quarters. Conversely, Weixin delivers a different, more affluent audience than short video and therefore commands a higher eCPM. Our ad network and many of our other properties offer an eCPM much lower than short video, which is disproportionately appealing to very performance-based direct response advertisers. We have a range of different products, some of which compete relatively head-on with short video from a price perspective, but most of which operate at different price points.
Thomas Chong
analystThank you.
Martin Lau
analystThere's just one thing I want to mention regarding differentiated inventory on Weixin, and I think it ties quite closely to what your first question touched on. If you look at Mini Programs and the GMV growth happening there, I'd say our Weixin inventory is differentiated in a way that really stems from the ecosystem advantages. It lifts the conversion ratio for many of the services that advertise on Weixin inventory. Second, when advertisers consider advertising on Weixin, they're thinking not only about direct conversion on transactions but also about how many users they can actually bring into their private domain user pool, and that's valuable to them as well. That's partly why eCPM for Weixin is higher than it is for other forms of performance-based advertising. As we keep growing the infrastructure to support transactions within Weixin, I believe that trend and that differentiation will keep improving.
Thomas Chong
analystThanks.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our next question is from Gregory Zhao at Barclays. Please go ahead.
Gregory Zhao
analystHello, management. Thank you for taking my question, and congratulations on a strong quarter. I just have a single question regarding your mobile gaming business. When you look at the top 10 mobile games ranking two to three years back, we can actually see that Tencent and NetEase largely dominated the top 10 games in China, holding about eight or nine games. Today, if we take a look at the top 10 games in China, several smaller studios have actually also launched some very successful games. At the same time, for Tencent and NetEase, we see their presence in the top 10 games falling to around four to five games. This trend differs somewhat from the street expectation of further market consolidation. I just want to understand how we should think about this kind of market dynamics and the market competition going forward. Thank you.
James Mitchell
executiveYes. Thanks for asking. The way we view the market dynamic is that this is a really healthy development. Domination isn't our aspiration. Although the top 10 now includes a more diverse set of studios, our results show that even so, we've managed to keep revenue and earnings trends in our game business very healthy. In our view that diversification is a good thing, since it demonstrates the market is growing more dynamic and users are growing more sophisticated, and new genres of games are gaining popularity and becoming monetizable that Tencent historically didn't focus on, but we can now focus on, and those represent fresh opportunities for us. That's at a broad level. If I try to be a bit more granular and examine individual games, then earlier in the call, someone raised the miHoYo game, the success of Genshin Impact. I believe that carries many lessons for the industry as a whole, all of them positive. One is that China games are increasingly able to expand beyond China and capture not only the wallets, but also the sort of malleable, flexible plastic the game industry still is when it comes to different models. If you look at the Western world, one of the really big trends has been games that were built around a single-player campaign mode, such as Call of Duty, shifting over time into more of a multiplayer virtual item mode, such as Call of Duty: Warzone.
James Mitchell
executiveIn China, we're actually seeing things move in the reverse direction. Take a title such as Genshin Impact — historically, a game like that would have concentrated entirely on the virtual-item-monetized end-game PVP experience. What miHoYo did was build a highly appealing single-player campaign, much closer to a classic Japanese RPG, and that has the effect of pulling players in and getting them ready for the end-game experience. As for what Tencent can learn, especially for our big four domestic game studios, we keep looking to innovate. We keep looking to develop new genres and to mix and match different genres and different business models so as to create something exciting and compelling. We keep raising our investment in games, because player expectations around game quality are climbing and, to some extent, converging around the world. It falls to us to genuinely invest in the people and invest in the tools, so we can create games that cut through the clutter by way of innovation and by way of quality. That's what we're seeking to do for China and for the international markets as well.
Gregory Zhao
analystAppreciate that — very useful.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our next question is from William Packer at Exane BNP Paribas. Your line is open.
William Packer
analystHello, management. Thanks so much for taking my question, and congratulations on the very strong numbers. There has been significant regulatory news flow in recent weeks. Could you offer any initial comments on the draft antitrust rules and on how they could affect your business? Is it right to think that your video games and digital entertainment businesses are not likely to be a focus? Thank you.
Martin Lau
analystOkay, William, thank you for that question. As you mentioned, the regulation—the consultation paper—was only released a short while ago. Naturally, we've gone through the consultation paper concerning the platform economy. We'd want to spend some time talking with the regulatory authority so we can fully grasp what they're aiming to accomplish. Let me share a few initial thoughts. First, based on our reading, the document stressed fair competition and regulatory oversight, along with encouraging innovation and industry development, making sure a balance of interests is reached for all stakeholders. That's essentially the spirit of the paper. Second, what we've observed is that this kind of regulation isn't new, and it isn't unique to China either. As tech companies grow larger and become more significant to the economy, I'd say additional regulations reflecting the new reality are necessary. That's true not only in China but around the world. Third, we think the government continues to support the internet and technology industry, particularly the innovation the industry drives. The aim is to stop misconduct and also secure long-term healthy growth for these industries. Fourth, I'd like to reflect on Tencent's business, strategy, and philosophy.
Martin Lau
analystI'd say it actually aligns quite well with what the regulatory framework is trying to achieve. As you can see, our platforms are open by nature. We collaborate with many partners. Our emphasis is on delivering excellent products and user value, instead of heavily calculated business operations and monetization. We also welcome competition. In fact, competition is where we thrive, and at times even internally we have products competing against one another. Lastly, I'd say we will engage very constructively with the regulators to make sure we comply with the paper. Those are my initial thoughts. Naturally, as we engage with the regulators, we'll have more to add down the road, and we'll gain more insights. Regarding the various sectors, I can't fully comment at this moment, but from the paper it appears to be more about transaction platforms. When it comes to games, which are essentially individual products rather than platforms, I think they're less of a focus. As for the digital entertainment industry, taking the video platform as an example, and as we discussed the video platform earlier, it's actually a fairly money-losing business at present. It probably doesn't really fall within the regulator's focus right now as far as the consultation paper goes.
William Packer
analystThanks a lot for that thorough response. My follow-up is on a somewhat different subject. Through Mini Program you have a sizable, robust presence in e-commerce, and through Tencent Meeting and related products in enterprise software. So far, it seems monetization has trailed international peers. How should we view the pace of monetization from here on? Thank you.
Martin Lau
analystWell, I think these are really businesses that are at the early stage of development. We're quite excited about the potential market ahead of us. So it's actually very much in line with Tencent's philosophy. When there's market potential, when there's a user need with a lot of potential, we tend to focus heavily on unlocking that potential and delivering amazing products and user value first, before moving into monetization. At this point in time, I think both through Mini Programs and for our enterprise software, the focus right now is really on delivering great products to grow the user base and to unlock the potential in the user market first, before we really think about monetization. On Mini Programs, I think we do already derive quite a bit of commercial benefit, through the fact that Mini Programs actually enable a lot of payment transactions within our system. The Mini Program owners, who want to get traffic, are also advertising in our Weixin ecosystem. That's part of the reason why our eCPM on Weixin advertising is actually higher than a lot of the industry standard.
Martin Lau
analystThe benefits are coming through, though it's happening in a somewhat indirect way.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our following question is from Zaihao He at Huatai Securities. Please go ahead.
Zaihao He
analystAppreciate it, management, for fielding my questions. I'd like to start with our Fintech business. Looking purely from a payments standpoint, since our transaction volume keeps climbing in the offline channel, I want to discuss this. Over the medium term, would that push our pure payments costs higher down the road, given that a lot of payment expenses and service expense are flowing through the offline channel? And on monetization gains in the pure payment business, considering today's competition as well as costs coming from the banking channels, could you share some color on what the pure payments business margin looks like over the medium to long term? Thanks.
Martin Lau
analystNow, regarding the offline payment side, it does bring in revenue. Banking charges make up the biggest cost piece, along with promotional spending. Looking ahead, I'd say it ought to be fairly steady, in that it does produce revenue for us. At present, the banking charges are fairly steady. Naturally, that hinges on how we work with the banks. That's an unknown, though up to now it has been fairly steady. Promotional expenses have fluctuated up and down over the years. A large share of that really comes down to how enthusiastic industry peers are about the opportunity and how much money they're pouring into the system. Quite often we follow the market when it comes to spending on promotional resources. As things stand, this year it appears to have settled to a more rational level versus earlier periods when some of the spending was very, very high.
Zaihao He
analystAlright, a follow-up question about our Fintech business. This quarter we saw 50% consumer growth in wealth management — 50% growth year-over-year. And yet our Li Cai user base penetration rate compared with our payment user base remains quite low. Could you tell us what other new features drove growth that strong in our wealth management and consumer base? And what other strategies are we putting in place to make sure they keep growing very rapidly when it comes to Li Cai consumers versus penetration rate versus our payment users?
Martin Lau
analystSo, I think our goal is to increase that penetration in a steady way, correct? Wealth management is usually a business built around the long term. You aim to build a lasting relationship with users. What we generally do is Ling Qian Tong. When someone puts a certain amount of money into money market funds, that really acts as the entry point for a relationship. As time goes on, we provide more wealth management products to those users. I think up to now we have stayed, again, aligned with our prudent and measured approach to growing our Fintech business. We have exercised a fair amount of self-restraint when it comes to offering wealth management products that carry somewhat higher risk, since we truly want to ensure that consumers and users are properly educated first, before they understand precisely what they are purchasing in terms of wealth management products. Again, this will be a longer-term effort to cultivate user education, and as time goes on, we will begin to offer more differentiated wealth management products to our users. We are not rushing to sell a large volume of wealth management products to users, because we believe that must go hand in hand with educating users and with the further development of the financial markets, so that there are good wealth management products that we would actually select and offer to our users.
Martin Lau
analystThat would require a process of growth. I think having the payment platform genuinely does help us establish that initial relationship. As we keep building expertise in product selection and in educating our users, this will grow organically as well.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the close of the question-and-answer session. I'd like to turn the conference back over to Ms. Huang for her closing remarks.
Wendy Huang
executiveThanks, operator. We’re wrapping up the call at this point. Should you want to review the press release along with other financial details, please go to the IR section on our corporate site at www.tencent.com. A replay of this webcast is going to be posted in a few hours as well. Thanks, and we’ll see you in the next quarter.
Operator
operatorThat brings today’s conference to a close. We appreciate everyone taking part. This has been the conference call for Tencent Holdings Limited’s 2020 third quarter results announcement. You’re welcome to disconnect now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Tencent Holdings Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Tencent Holdings Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Tencent Holdings Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.