Tencent Holdings Limited (700) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 10, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorHello everyone, and thanks for holding. You're joining the Tencent Holdings Limited conference call announcing our third quarter 2021 results. Right now, everyone is in listen-only mode. Following the speaker's presentation, we'll open things up for questions and answers. <<operator_script>> Please note that this conference is being recorded today. <<operator_script>> At this point, I'll hand the conference to Ms. Jane Yip of the Tencent IR team. Thank you. Over to you.
Jane Yip
executiveThanks a lot. Good evening, everybody. Glad to have you on our conference call covering results for the third quarter of 2021. Prior to beginning the presentation, we'd like to remind everyone that it contains forward-looking statements, and those are subject to various risks and uncertainties, so they might not come to pass in the future for a range of reasons. Data regarding general market conditions is drawn from multiple sources beyond Tencent. This presentation also includes certain non-IFRS financial measures, which are unaudited, and those ought to be viewed alongside, rather than as a replacement for, measures of the group's financial performance that are prepared in accordance with IFRS. For a thorough discussion of risk factors and non-IFRS measures, please see our disclosures document in the IR section of our website. Allow me to introduce the management team joining tonight's call. Our Chairman and CEO, Pony Ma, will begin with a brief overview. President Martin Lau and Chief Strategy Officer James Mitchell will then give a business review. Chief Financial Officer John Lo will wrap up with a financial discussion before we open the floor for questions. I'll now hand the call over to Pony.
Pony Ma
executiveThanks, Jane, and good evening, everyone. We appreciate you all being here. In Q3, the Internet sector — domestic games included — along with several advertiser categories, adjusted to fresh regulatory and macro-economic shifts. We're actively embracing this new regulatory landscape, and we think it should help set the industry on a path toward more sustainable development. In the domestic games market, our sector is taking the lead in fully complying with the new rules, which cut game time and spending considerably and are fostering a healthier environment for gameplay. We're also investing heavily in key strategic areas and in technology frontiers, while making fresh commitments to common prosperity initiatives. Looking ahead, we're dedicated to giving users superior experiences, helping businesses digitalize their operations, and contributing to society more broadly. Beginning this quarter, we're disclosing revenue from Domestic and International Games as new sub-segments under VAS, which reflects the growing scale of our international games business. Now I'll walk through the headline figures — the financial numbers for the quarter. Total revenue came in at RMB 142 billion, up 13% year-on-year and 3% quarter-on-quarter. Gross profit reached RMB 63 billion, up 11% year-on-year and flat quarter-on-quarter. Non-IFRS operating profit was RMB 41 billion, up 7% year-on-year, or down 5% quarter-on-quarter.
Pony Ma
executiveNon-IFRS net profit attributable to equity holders came in at RMB 32 billion, representing a 2% decline year-on-year and a 7% drop quarter-on-quarter. Turning to our key services: we are focused on upgrading technologies and innovating products, while holding onto first or second place market positions across key businesses, including Social, Games, Digital Content, Payment, and Public Cloud Services. Taken together, Weixin and WeChat MAU stood at RMB1.26 billion. Mobile devices MAU off QC was RMB574 million. At this point, I will pass things over to Martin and James for the Business Review.
Martin Lau
analystThanks, Pony, and good evening — or good morning, everyone. Total revenue for the third quarter of 2021 rose 13% compared with a year earlier. VAS made up 53% of that total, and inside it domestic games took 24%, international games 8%, and social networks 21%. Online advertising contributed 16% of overall revenue. FinTech and business services accounted for 30% of the total. Within value added services, segment revenue reached RMB 75 billion in the third quarter, an increase of 8% year-on-year. Social network subsegment revenue climbed 7% year-on-year to RMB 30 billion, with video and music subscriptions growing relatively quickly and live-streaming plus in-game item sales growing moderately. VAS subscriptions overall were up 10% year-on-year, reaching RMB 235 million. Video subscriptions rose 8% year-on-year to RMB 129 million, helped by hit drama series. For instance, Crime Crackdown, our self-commissioned TV drama, and You Are My Glory, the Honor of King's tie-in, took the number 1 and number 2 spots by video views among all online platforms in China during the quarter, which widened our user mix across gender and age. Those series' success showed how far we have come in content production and in extending IP across media.
Martin Lau
analystMusic subscriptions rose 838% compared with a year earlier, reaching 71 million, as TME's improved streaming experience draws in more users. Turning to games, domestic titles brought in RMB 34 billion, up 5% year-on-year, with Honor of Kings, Call of DUty Mobile, and Moonlight Blade Mobile doing most of the lifting. Seasonal events in Peacekeeper Elite and Dungeon and Fighter pushed revenue higher quarter over quarter. Internationally, games revenue climbed 20% year-on-year to RMB 11 billion, which is 28% in constant currency terms, thanks to strong showings from Valorant and Clash of Clans. On Weixin, we keep building out both the content and commerce sides. Within video accounts, we're encouraging content that is rich and varied. More and more creators from official accounts are now putting their ideas out in video form, which adds a distinctive mix of material to video accounts. Our depth in sports coverage, music, and games has likewise made what we offer richer and more varied. Video consumption posted healthy growth as we actively improved content and recommendation technology. With Mini Programs, we're pushing deeper into sectors such as restaurants, retailing, and transportation. Active Mini Programs rose by more than 40% year-on-year, which speaks to how vibrant the commerce ecosystem is. By pairing WeCom's enterprise communication tool with Mini Programs, we let individual sales people and customers interact directly inside a retailer's private domain environment.
Martin Lau
analystSo retailers can build their own customer relationships and generate sales efficiently. When it comes to QQ, in our most recent upgrade, we've been ramping up both effort and technology on the interactive front. We improved video and AI technologies to support creative, efficient content production, which drives more UGC activity on our platform. We customized AR tools around festivals and national landmarks, adding more engaging ways for users to interact with the physical world. We also delivered cross-screen interactive effects in video calls, giving people more entertaining shared experiences. With these upgrades, interaction on QQ becomes more exciting and immersive for users. Moving to games, starting with Domestic Games. We believe that cultivating a healthy game-play environment in the domestic market matters above all. Since September 1st, we have put new measures in place to fully comply with the latest regulations restricting minors' game time in China. As a result, users under 18 years old accounted for 0.7% of our Domestic Games time spent in September, a significant reduction from 6.4% in the same period last year. In addition, those users accounted for 1.1% of our Domestic Games gross receipt in September, down from 4.8% in the same period last year. We remain the industry leader in tightening minors' use of adult accounts.
Martin Lau
analystTo give you an example, our screening systems get upgraded so that misused adult accounts can be spotted at all hours. Beyond that, we actively help the authorities as they work to crack down on transactions involving illegal accounts. Now turning to the highlights of our Games business. With Honor of Kings, we are bringing Chinese culture to life through a series of popular skins, and those skins have successfully carried provincial arts and traditions to a wider audience. We achieved significant progress when it comes to expanding a successful PC franchise onto mobile — Wild Rift successfully reactivated an enlarged League of Legends user base by extending the authentic PC experience to mobile devices. In October 2021, it ranked second by DAU among all mobile games in China. We also invigorated the auto chess genre by introducing PBE and co-op game play in Fight of the Golden Spatula. By DAU, it is the second most popular new game launch in China year-to-date, only behind Wild Rift. As for international games, we have been developing our business for more than a decade now, and its scale relative to our domestic business has been increasing over the last few years. We do expect exciting opportunities ahead in the Global Games industry, as we discussed in our investment strategy with you earlier this year. In order to further develop this high-growth business, firstly, we enhanced our upstream game development capabilities.
Martin Lau
analystWe're putting more resources into talent and into our leading studios. Our base studio groups in China — TiMi and LightSpeed in particular — are growing their headcount with fresh hires, and that's happening not just inside China but around the world too. Riot and Supercell, both of which have produced several hit games, are likewise expanding their development teams. At the same time, we're buying and supporting specialist studios that lead their genres, including Digital Extremes, Grinding Gear Games, and Fatshark, among others. And we back them with our expertise, technology, and capital. Second, we're reinforcing our worldwide IP portfolio through several approaches. On the internal side, we take IPs that are recognized globally — League of Legends, Clash of Clans, and Honor of Kings — and extend them to mobile and into other genres, which widens our addressable market. We're also building games that could turn into new global IPs, like Valorant and Brawl Stars. On the external side, we work with well-known IP owners to create mobile titles that appeal globally, for example PUBG Mobile, Call of Duty Mobile, and Pokemon Unite, and additional ones are on the way. Third, to back our growth across multiple regions, we're developing localized publishing and operational capabilities. We're also increasing our marketing work in eSports operations to build up player communities.
Martin Lau
analystWe're going to keep increasing what we put into our international games business. With that said, I'll hand things over to James to talk about the other businesses.
James Mitchell
executiveThanks, Martin. Turning now to online advertising. In the third quarter, total revenue came in at RMB 22.5 billion. Growth in revenue decelerated to 5% year-on-year, held back by softness in the education, insurance, and games sectors, even as consumer staples, Internet services, and automobile stayed resilient, and bidding density declined overall. We anticipate that industry-wide advertising pricing could stay soft across several quarters, given macro headwinds and regulations impacting some key advertising sectors. Our view is that the advertising industry ought to adjust and re-base over the course of 2022, after which growth should resume — with the secular growth drivers reasserting themselves. Revenue from Social and Others Advertising rose 7% year-on-year to RMB 19 billion, mainly on the strength of Weixin Mini Programs and Official Accounts, though it was held back by softer eCPMs at our ad network. We are letting enterprises link users with salespeople by embedding WeCom chat-to-salesperson functionality inside their advertisements, which works especially well for need-driven advertisers like automobile dealers. A growing number of transaction-driven advertisers, such as grocery and e-commerce merchants, are using Mini Programs as the landing pages for their ads, which helps them convert traffic into transactions more effectively. Our media advertising revenue fell 4% year-on-year, reflecting lower revenue from the Tencent news app. On the plus side, we streamed top-tier drama series, variety shows, and the Toyko 2020 Olympic Games, which generated sponsorship revenue previously on the Tencent video app.
James Mitchell
executiveNow turning to FinTech and Business Services: revenue for that segment came in at RMB 43 billion, which represents a 30% increase compared with a year earlier and a 3% rise from the prior quarter. Within Infintech services, the year-on-year revenue gain was primarily powered by higher commercial payment volume, with solid growth across categories including groceries, power and transportation. Both daily active users of commercial payments and transactions per user went up. Measured against the second quarter of 2021, growth in offline commercial payment volume was more moderate year-on-year, reflecting control measures aimed at COVID-19 resurgence in certain provinces. We expanded our collaboration with UnionPay to build out new scenarios for payments and service interconnection. Through the UnionPay Cloud QuickPass app, users are now able to scan Weixin Pay QR codes when making offline payments, and Cloud QuickPass additionally supports top-up purchases for QQ points, QQ music and Tencent video subscription services. Revenue from business services grew at a healthy year-on-year pace, helped by ongoing digitalization, traditional industries like financial services and transportation, and the videolization of the Internet industry. We believe China's customer relationship management market, which remains under penetrated, holds substantial potential. More than a million enterprises have used our CRM Software-as-a-Service solution, Tencent QiDian, to improve cost efficiency in customer service, and adoption by medium and large scale enterprises including Dell, SF Express, and Siemens keeps increasing.
James Mitchell
executiveUsing the virtual assistant, clients are able to automate 80% to 90% of the work involved in customer service, drawing on our AI-powered solutions spanning chat, voice, and other communications channels. More than 3,000 clients across verticals such as financial services, public services, and telecom have been served by our Tencent Database Structured Query Language Platform-as-a-Service solution with TDSQL database. In the financial vertical, demand keeps rising for database architecture upgrades that bring stronger security protection. Six out of the top 10 banks in China are served by TDSQL, and penetration within financial institution's core systems has grown because of their trust in our data security, reliability, and consistency. And now I'll hand things over to John for the financial review.
John Lo
executiveThanks, James. Hello, everyone. In Q3 2021, our total revenue came to RMB 142.4 billion, representing a 13% increase year-on-year, or 15% quarter-on-quarter. Gross profit reached RMB 62.7 billion, which was up 11% year-on-year and broadly flat quarter-on-quarter. Net other gains amounted to RMB23 billion, rising 99% year-on-year, or 11% quarter-on-quarter. That figure was mostly made up of non-IFRS adjustments tied to our investing companies, including, first, deemed disposal and disposal gains from our investees in areas like games, Internet utility, and local services. Second, valuation gains from certain investee companies in verticals such as e-commerce. Third, impairment provisions for investees in verticals like FinTech and social entertainment. Operating profit stood at RMB53.1 billion, up 21% year-on-year and 1% quarter-on-quarter. Net finance costs came in at RMB 1.9 billion, largely steady on both a year-on-year and quarter-on-quarter basis. Our share of losses from associates and joint ventures was affected at RMB 5.7 billion, versus a share of profit of RMB 2.6 billion a year earlier. That shift mirrored the impact on non-IFRS adjustment of certain associates, heavier investment in community grow-by initiatives by certain associates, and losses booked from certain associates in the Social Media sector, partly offset by stronger performance from certain associates in the e-commerce sector.
John Lo
executiveWhen we look at non-IFRS figures, we posted a share of losses for associates and joint ventures of RMB 282 million in this quarter, versus a share of profit of RMB 3.2 billion during the same period last year. Income tax expense came to RMB 5.5 billion for this quarter. The effective tax rate in the quarter stood at 12%. On an IFRS basis, net profit attributable to equity holders reached RMB 39.5 billion, which is 3% higher year-on-year, or 7% lower quarter-on-quarter. Diluted EPS came in at RMB 4 billion, representing a 3% increase year-on-year, or a 7% decline quarter-on-quarter. Next, let me walk you through our non-IFRS financial figures. Operating profit amounted to RMB 40.8 billion, rising 7% year-on-year, or falling 5% quarter-on-quarter. Net profit after NCI was RMB 31.8 billion, a decrease of 2% year-on-year and 7% quarter-on-quarter. Diluted EPS was RMB 3.269, down 1% year-on-year and 7% Q-on-Q. Turning to gross margin, the overall gross margin came to 44.1%, which is 1.1 percentage points lower year-on-year and 1.3 percentage points lower quarter-on-quarter. Looking at the segments, the gross margin for value-added services was 53%, up 0.4 percentage point year-on-year, or lastly, stable Q-on-Q. The gross margin for online advertising was 46.4%, down 4.5% points year-on-year or 2.4% points quarter-on-quarter. The declines in both year-on-year and quarter-on-quarter terms reflected higher bandwidth and server costs, including those tied to our Video Accounts service.
John Lo
executiveFinTech and Business Services gross margin came in at 28.5%, which is up 0.6% points from a year earlier, or down 3.5% points versus the prior quarter. That year-on-year gain came from a mix shift inside FinTech services, partly offset by a bigger revenue contribution from Business Services, which carries a lower margin. The sequential drop was mostly a reflection of our ongoing investment in Cloud computing, including talents and operations. Turning to operating expenses, selling and marketing totaled RMB10.4 billion, 17% higher year-on-year, or 4% up quarter-on-quarter. That Y-o-Y rise was finally driven by previous marketing spending on gains, as well as consolidation of Bitauto. Measured against revenues, selling and marketing expenses stood at 7% of revenues, broadly stable compared to the first quarter of 2020. R&D expenses reached RMB13.7 billion, up 39% year-on-year, or 7% Q-on-Q. R&D expenses accounted for approximately 10% of revenues. G&A expenses, including R&D, were RMB10.2 billion, up 39% year-on-year, or 3% quarter-on-quarter. Both the year-on-year and quarter-on-quarter increase reflected greater staff force. Excluding share-based compensation, G&A expenses rose by 23% year-on-year and 7% quarter-on-quarter. As the quarter end, we had approximately 107,000 employees, 38% year-on-year or 14% quarter-on-quarter, primarily due to our increased resources allocated to our strategic growth initiatives. Let's take a look at the operating and net margin ratios. For Fiscal Year 2021, non-IFRS operating margin was 20.7%, down 1.7 percentage points Y-on-Y, points Q-on-Q.
John Lo
executiveThe non-IFRS net margin came in at 22.83%, which is 3.8 percentage points higher year-on-year, or 2.6 percentage points higher quarter-on-quarter. Last, I'll walk you through a few key financial metrics for the quarter. Total CapEx reached RMB 7.1 billion, a decline of 19% year-on-year, or an increase of 2% quarter-on-quarter. Inside total Capex, operating Capex stood at RMB 5.6 billion, 28% lower year-on-year. Our operating Capex, however, rose 62% year-on-year to RMB 1.5 billion, which reflects greater spending on land use rights and building constructions. Free cash flow in the quarter amounted to RMB 24.1 billion, 14% lower year-on-year, or 40% higher quarter-on-quarter. Our net debt position was RMB 26.1 billion, versus RMB 21 billion in the prior quarter, largely reflecting cash flow for M&A activities and payment for purchase of share — repurchase of shares, partly offset by free cash flow generations and on market diversions subsidiary to securities. The share market value of our shareholdings in listed investing companies, excluding subsidiaries, came to roughly RMB1.2 trillion, or $185 billion, at quarter end. We bought back approximately 5.6 million shares at an aggregate cost of RMB2.2 billion, or $334 million, during the third quarter 2021. Thank you. We shall now open for questions.
Jane Yip
executiveOperator, please open the line for questions.
Operator
operatorThanks. Ladies and gentlemen, we’ll now start the question-and-answer session. <<operator_script>> Kindly remain on the line as we put together the list of questions for the Q&A. <<operator_script>>. Our first question is from Piyush Mubayi at Goldman Sachs. Please go ahead with your question.
Piyush Mubayi
analystGood evening, Martin, James, John, and Jane, and thanks for taking my question. First, I want to ask about that term everyone keeps mentioning these days. How do you see your position in the Metaverse, which is the next version of the Internet? Do you view it as transformational, or is it simply an extension of the business models you have now? And how would you size that opportunity against current gaming industry estimates that exceed $200 billion? If I may also add a second one about advertising. Given the pricing challenges you mentioned, where China macro, PIPL, and regulations all seem to be headwinds, how would you rank those sets of risks? And regarding your comment about a re-basement in 2022, could growth rates return to a double-digit growth rate sometime in 4Q, or would that happen sometime in 2022, in your opinion? Thank you.
Martin Lau
analystWhen it comes to the Metaverse, my view is that it's a genuinely thrilling idea, though somewhat loosely defined. At a high level, our perspective on the Metaverse is this: we believe anything that genuinely brings greater realism to the virtual world, and enriches the physical world through virtual experiences, can be part of the Metaverse — it's a big word. So because of that, we saw it as a chance to genuinely contribute growth to industries that already exist. Take gaming, for instance — it will be additive to that industry. It will likewise be additive to social networking, and in certain situations, where you have real-world use cases such as business applications, it can serve as a growth engine for that sector as well. The explanation is that we believed there are in fact several routes by which you can access the Metaverse opportunity — for instance, highly interactive games with very high production values, and open-world style games. You can also have several games sharing one common worldview or IP. You can have a gaming platform offering the infrastructure that lets people build many different games inside that platform.
Martin Lau
analystA social network can exist that's gamified and enables far more programmable experiences. There's also the option of a real-world experience enhanced by — augmented reality and virtual reality. That's the way we look at the various routes through which Metaverse access becomes possible. When it comes to what we can do and where we sit, we believed we genuinely hold plenty of the tech and know-how components needed to explore and build toward the Metaverse opportunity. For instance, we possess many gaming experiences. We likewise have quite strong experience in social networking. Beyond that, regarding technology components, we have engine capability, we have AI capability, we have what it takes to construct large server architecture capable of serving a huge number of concurrent users. We're highly experienced at running digital content economies along with real life digital assets. So overall, we believed we hold plenty of tech and capability components that let us pursue the Metaverse opportunities via the multiple pathways we discussed. Now, turning to advertising, I'll hand over to James.
James Mitchell
executiveThank you, Piyush. You raised the question of the different difficulties the China advertising market is dealing with and how we'd order them. So I'd say that when it comes to magnitude and how soon they hit, the regulations touching sectors like education, the games, insurance, deliver the biggest and quickest effect, and beyond that the macro-environment matters too, in that — when the macro-environment is very robust, you'd expect some categories to slow their ad spending while other categories jump into that space and back-fill, seizing the chance offered by lower prices and higher ROI. I think that takes place gradually; however, when the macro environment is more challenging, it comes about more slowly than it would in a more robust macro environment. Next, regarding the customer information protection law, and also — you didn't bring it up, but others may wish to — Apple's IDFA changes. Those have a comparatively smaller impact. As for the Personal Information Protection, we did put that into effect as of November 1. It's important to keep in mind that those who decide to opt out still see ads, only the ads are less relevant to their needs. And we believe that because of this, at least up until now, the opt-out rate has stayed in the very low single digits.
James Mitchell
executiveNow regarding IDFA, you're probably aware that in the US and Western markets, essentially two shoes dropped. The first was the impact on targeting ability, and the second, more impactful issue was the impairment of attribution capability. In China, we've already dealt with the targeting challenge, and the attribution challenge seems smaller, partly because the industry has various mechanisms for deriving attribution, and partly because Apple accounts for only a teens percent of internet traffic in China, compared with a much higher share in Western markets — so that's on sizing and prioritizing the different challenges. On timing for when advertising might resume a faster growth rate than — obviously, it depends heavily on any future regulations that come out, as well as any future macro challenges that arise. Setting those aside, then a couple of observations: one is that I think our advertising comps are generally toughest in Q1 of next year. In a normal year, Q1 is seasonally a low quarter, and then you see very strong sequential advertising revenue growth in Q2 and Q3, whereas if you look at — in 2021 that actually wasn't the case.
James Mitchell
executiveSo we're up against a difficult comparison in the first quarter of '22, and after that it gets easier. And second, although quite a few categories are soft — and those are typically the ones that would respond fastest to lower pricing by picking up volume — there are others that remain quite strong, such as clothing, personal goods, healthcare, and so on. Now, my belief is that generally speaking, those categories respond more slowly. Their ad purchasing choices are driven more by people rather than by algorithms, the way a Mobile game or an online education Company would buy. But the reality is that since pricing has come down, the ROI on ad buying has gotten better. And so as time goes on, we'd expect some of those slower-moving advertising categories to come back. Thank you.
Operator
operatorThanks. Charlene Liu from HSBC is our next questioner. The floor is yours.
Charlene Liu
analystHello, management. Thanks so much for this opportunity and for taking my question. I'd like to build on what James was saying — I believe earlier you talked about a few of the verticals facing challenges, things like education, games, and insurance, and so on. I was wondering whether you could share a bit more about how much these verticals actually contribute to the advertising business. You also mentioned that we're seeing some green shoots, maybe in a segment such as healthcare. How much can those really make up for? The weaknesses that we're seeing in some of the challenged verticals that you discussed earlier. And I have a follow-up for online games. Thank you.
James Mitchell
executiveOn the compensation-for-weakness point, we did say that we expect the softness to last for several quarters. So let me stress that adjective on its own. We don't think this is going to snap back to prior trends right away. As for how much those categories contribute, directionally speaking, Games would sit in the low to mid-teens. Education has now fallen to low single-digits, and Insurance is a subset of Finance, but again at a low single-digit percentage. Turning to categories that are relatively healthier than financial services ex insurance, there's personal care products and clothing, food and beverage. Our transportation-related advertising is very strong for us, and that partly reflects the reinvigoration of Bitauto and the injection of the video content <<inaudible>> share of automobile-related advertising, and then healthcare. But as I said, these categories tend to make their decisions annually or quarterly rather than in real time. And so when advertising pricing softens, as it has done, they don't react immediately.
Charlene Liu
analystAll right, thanks. Regarding online games specifically, for expanding abroad, could you talk about the kinds of challenges you might expect as we push our overseas efforts in online games? And could you also give us some details about the pipeline? Thank you.
James Mitchell
executiveWell, when it comes to the pipeline, for both our domestic and international operations, our habit is not to discuss games until they launch—or at minimum until launch is very near. Still, if you look at the slide and consider what has been made public, TiMi and LightSpeed have each announced several titles that are global IPs, and you should expect those to come out globally. Each of them also has other titles based on their own IPs, which we likewise hope will find success worldwide—though only time will reveal whether that happens. Riot has made announcements about a number of games, among them the mobile version of Valorant. Supercell has announced three flash-based games. Grinding Gear Games has announced Path of Exile 2. Fatshark has announced Darktide, and so on and so forth. Not one of our studios is standing still. Many of them have new products in development, and some of those are announced while others remain unannounced—and thus are a bit further out. Regarding the challenges we confront, I'd say they are quite similar to those other companies in the game industry confront; just to touch on what's front of mind right now, one is the war for talent.
James Mitchell
executiveWe think this business is genuinely driven by talent, so we invest considerable time both within our own studios and alongside our investee and daughter studios to design the most suitable compensation packages. Every case differs somewhat, yet broadly speaking, we want our studios positioned so they can reward contributors very generously, and I believe we stay in that strong position going forward, since this is an area we devote a great deal of time and energy to. Another matter for gaming that I believe is top of mind is the reality that across the industry as a whole, in mobile games, app stores capture a larger profit pool than game developers do, and I think there are multiple pressures from a regulatory standpoint and from a legal standpoint. And with some announcements today, the Internet has a direct bearing on how that profit pool gets divided between App Stores and game developers, which should be helpful for game developers generally, and particularly for some of the smaller ones. So those are two of the challenges that the game industry outside China confronts, and that we would confront as well as a participant.
Operator
operatorOkay, thanks. Our following question is from Alex Yao at JPMorgan. Go ahead with your question.
Alex Yao
analystThanks, management, for taking my question. My first question follows up on how PIPL is being implemented. James, you said the opt-out ratio is pretty low, maybe in the low-single-digit range. So presumably the effect on your own property advertising operation ought to be considerably larger. What about the effect on your ad network business? Could you give us some color? And second, on the domestic gaming operation, how will the current suspension of game monetization approvals alter your gaming operation and your product launch strategy over the next couple of quarters? Thank you.
James Mitchell
executiveWe still haven't released anything yet. And if you look at history, we usually put out a mid-single-digit number of new titles every quarter, so you can tell we've got a backlog that will keep us occupied for plenty of quarters ahead. Naturally, it would be healthier for the whole industry if there were some mix, if Banhao approvals pick back up in terms of delivering more innovation to the market. But I believe you can see that between our major existing titles, between a few of the very high DAU new games we launched not long ago, and our several dozen games with Banhao that we haven't launched yet, we think we can steer through this temporary stretch and get up and move forward. So, I've already stressed the temporary nature there. As for the question about the ad networks. So, to be clear, pricing for our ad network was weaker in the third quarter, but that came from a combination of the demand factors we've discussed in terms of recognition for certain sectors, macro challenges. And then on the supply side, the restrictions on so-called flash screen advertising had a bigger negative impact on the ad network business than on our own operated inventories. PIPL didn't and doesn't have a substantial impact of those two factors.
Operator
operatorThanks. We’ll take our next question from Robin Zhu at Bernstein. Go ahead.
Robin Zhu
analystHello, management. Thanks for giving me the chance to ask a question. I suppose I have two questions, please. First, regarding WeChat, Mini Programs, and the e-commerce GMV growth there along with the ads growth there, you guys very helpfully shared some data over the last couple of quarters. If we could get an update on what's happening there, and how that's contributing to advertising growth, and whether you expect any of the — whether it's regulatory IPO or something else, the impact growth in the next couple of quarters? And the second question, just on the broader regulatory environment. I mean, it seems optically that the rates of new announcements have slowed somewhat. Last quarter, John — or, sorry. Last quarter, management said that, look, there's still plenty of stuff to come on the regulatory front. I wonder if that view has changed as of this quarter. Thank you.
Martin Lau
analystRegarding Mini Programs, when it comes to GMV and advertising growth, the main point we'd like to convey is that things continue to look healthy and strong. We'd rather not turn this into a standing disclosure item, and provided the trend holds, we won't be discussing the specific figures on this occasion. As for the ecosystem, this time we did try to give you some extra color on how diverse it is. You'll notice that the count of Mini Programs has risen 40%, which tells you the ecosystem is quite vibrant, spanning a growing range of industries and application types. That is precisely one of the main forces driving the robust expansion of GMB and advertising growth. So that's what we wanted to share on this occasion. Moving to the second question, perhaps James can take that one.
James Mitchell
executiveThis was — the question concerned the broader regulatory landscape. And honestly, Martin is likely the better one to address that.
Martin Lau
analystDoes that cover the whole thing?
James Mitchell
executiveYeah, the regulatory environment in general.
Martin Lau
analystRegarding the overall regulatory environment, I would say that the last time this question came up, our response was that additional regulations would be arriving. I think events have shown we were correct. Over the past few months, we've witnessed further regulatory developments, and we also believe that tighter rules represent a new normal for the whole industry — not only in China but around the world as well. Still, we want to stress that the reasoning driving this regulatory effort is, particularly in China, really the government's attempt to encourage growth that is higher-quality, sustainable, and healthier for the entire industry, with emphasis placed on protecting consumer rights and privacy. That is why we are working proactively alongside the regulators to implement all the required changes. And we expect that — once the industry has truly complied with the new rules and completed all the adjustments — then even if new regulations appear down the road in the future, which naturally, given that a great deal of regulation already exists, will be smaller on an incremental basis in percentage terms, and as the industry adapts further, the effect on the industry will become less and less as time goes on.
Martin Lau
analystThat’s how we saw it.
Operator
operatorThanks. We'll take our next question from Garret Wang at CITIC. Go ahead, please.
Garret Wang
analystHello, and thanks for taking my question. There are two things I'd like to ask about. First, regarding the accounting development strategy for the WeChat video account — as you noted, Tencent's cross-IP strategy has seen achievable success, so I think Tencent has superior data, and content is surprising in a very short time. In what way could the WeChat video account gain from TME, China Literature, or the eSports? How can this unit content advantage at Tencent empower the video account's development? And conversely, how could the Video Account distribution mechanism give feedback to Tencent's content system? Second, about the Tianjin Internet. Last week, the Tencent digital ecosystem meeting took place, and the Tianjin Internet was also mentioned a lot. What is the Tianjin Internet strategy, and what are the progress, the business model, and the time node? So I hope management could share more about the Tianjin Internet. Thank you.
Martin Lau
analystOkay, regarding video accounts, the main thing I'd like to highlight is that this is a product experiencing quite robust growth. It began from zero and is becoming a fairly substantial offering. Even so, it remains fairly young. And as a short video platform, it's actually considerably smaller than the market leaders right now. That said, at present we're encouraged by how our video concept is developing, since its content is rather distinctive. Many official accounts and content creators are now sharing their expertise through video accounts. We're especially strong when it comes to knowledge-based short video. We also have plenty of other content areas that are fairly unique, sports being one example. During the Olympics — our video accounts actually benefited in a cross way with our sports channel and managed to bring in a large number of video views from users around the Olympic Games. At the moment, we feel encouraged by how video accounts have developed thus far, and by the growth trend as well. And we feel that right now, what matters most for us is really to keep enriching the content ecosystem and to keep enhancing our recommendation technology, so that we can actually help more users encounter more content, and because of that, the amount of time people actually spend on a video account would actually go up.
Martin Lau
analystAnd after that’s fully accomplished, once it’s scaled up even more, I think many of those cross-benefits you mentioned would really start to show. Music, animation, comics, eSports, for instance—those would come into play to a greater degree. Right now, what matters most for us is continuing to grow our video accounts in a way that’s sustainable and healthy. Then, regarding trends and the Internet, I believe part of it involves using our technology so that real-world experience gets enriched by virtual experience. And also drawing on virtual technology to help with real-life simulations. So—I think much of the underlying logic is quite similar to what we said about the Metaverse, so I’d point you to the answers we gave there.
Operator
operatorThanks. The next person to ask a question is William Packer of Exane BNP Paribas, on that line. Go right ahead.
William Packer
analystHello, management. Thanks very much for fielding my questions. First, regarding the regulatory situation for domestic gaming, the main areas of attention up to now have been caps on how much time minors can spend playing games and the approvals process for games. As the rules continue to develop, do you believe we ought to anticipate limits on the time or spending of adults on video games? And then, as a quick follow-up, we are observing the opening up of the different platform ecosystems, Tencent's included, with greater interoperability. Could you walk us through the main positives and negatives financially from these changes, for instance, more opportunities for ad or payment revenue, or more competition when it comes to engagement? Thank you,
James Mitchell
executiveWilliam, to address your first question: we think that, so far, public anxiety regarding the game industry has focused very heavily on the matter of whether kids are putting too much time into games, and the recent rules tackle that directly and, in our view, quite effectively — so the brief response is no. We do not anticipate the situation you describe. The fuller response is that we actually see it as highly advantageous for any country to have a strong gaming sector, both from a technology standpoint and from a cultural one. On the technology side, games sit right at the leading edge — they truly drive the forefront of some of the most fascinating hardware innovation. Take, for instance, the fact that games are the reason computers contain dedicated graphics processing units distinct from the CPU, and those GPUs are what get used today for training and inference in artificial intelligence. On the software side, games pioneered the use of services such as Unreal Engine, which now spread throughout enterprise and, naturally, underpin the immersive Internet too. Then, at the talent level, a few of the most prominent and accomplished figures in the global technology sector — people like Elon Musk or Mark Zuckerberg — have talked about how much they enjoyed games in their youth and how that put them on the road into the technology industry and the success they have today.
James Mitchell
executiveLooking at it through a technology lens, that's one angle. Culturally speaking, the U.S. enjoys a really favorable situation: thanks to Hollywood, America can send its culture out across the world via appealing films. Korea now finds itself in a comparable spot with television series. Japan occupies a similar place with manga and anime. Games, then, stand as one of the few chances for a nation that historically hasn't taken part globally in cultural exchange to achieve that. You can observe this right now — among the top 100 games in Japan, I believe 30 of the mobile titles originate from China. Among the top 100 mobile games in the United States, 20-something come from Chinese companies. So in any case, we believe a flourishing, robust game industry benefits society on several levels, provided the game industry can manage neighboring concerns, like children spending too much time gaming, something we think the China game industry is currently handling.
Martin Lau
analystOn the question of interoperability across platforms, I believe we gave quite an extensive response previously about how we view the ecosystem, but let me make a few points. First, as you mentioned, greater interoperability and openness among the various platforms is something we believed could benefit our business, especially when it comes to payments and advertising. Why? Because we're the company with, arguably, the greatest engagement but the weakest monetization of that engagement. If additional platforms are directing more commercial activity our way, that could translate into financial upside. That said, I think this issue should be viewed through several key lenses: first, user protection; second, compliance around information and content; and third, the effect on the ecosystem. On user protection, when a very large platform with many users has a commercial incentive to reach users on another platform, spamming becomes a real possibility, and that's something we've worked hard to guard against. When people are messaging another set of people, you need to weigh the sender's interests against the receiver's — particularly when a single sender reaches many receivers at once, which is typically what we call spamming and which can do considerable harm to user experience.
Martin Lau
analystThat covers one aspect. The second aspect really concerns compliance of information and content. When a platform manages millions of suppliers on the other side, and a message or piece of content is sent across, whose responsibility is it to make sure that content and information complies with laws and regulations? It could involve news and fake news, it could involve counterfeit products — these are very difficult issues. With a single merchant, policing is much easier, but for a platform with millions and tens of millions of merchants on the other side, policing becomes much harder. And finally, there's the ecosystem. We have said repeatedly that our ecosystem is fundamentally open, and we do prioritize providing support so that SMEs and brands succeed. That is why, when another platform with different platform regulations and economic models comes in, it may damage the ecosystem of many of the small and medium enterprises within our platform, and that is something we pay a lot of attention to. So I would say we will continue to proactively explore cooperation with other platforms, but it has to be in a manner that addresses the use of protection point — that information and content compliance point — and it also has to benefit the ecosystem, especially for the small and medium enterprises in our ecosystem.
Operator
operatorThanks. We’ll take the next question from Gary Yu at Morgan Stanley. Go ahead with your question.
Gary Yu
analystHello, and thanks to the management team for giving me the chance to ask questions. There are two things I'd like to cover. First, about that strategic investment you brought up during the first quarter earnings — how should we think about what it does to SG&A trends as we head into next year? Do we keep seeing investment levels rise, or after this year of stepped-up investment, will we be able to begin seeing margin trends that are more normalized going forward? Second, a follow-up on Metaverse. To start, you talked about the opportunities, and perhaps Tencent's position in that space. How should we think about some of the main hurdles over the next couple of years? One of them sits on the technology side. On hardware, is there anything you're looking at putting money into — investing toward hardware development? The secondary goal concerns the regulatory front. Given the heavy emphasis on the addiction issue on the games side of the world, how should we think about the regulatory stance when it comes to Metaverse? Thank you.
James Mitchell
executiveI'll also cover strategic investment. Martin already addressed that — the follow-up Meta question. So, my view is that we're a company that invests aggressively for the future. And because we're optimistic about the future, we're investing optimistically and aggressively, and that shows up in our rapid headcount growth, and it also shows up in our rapid SG&A expense growth. Within that SG&A expense growth, it's worth separating the headline number, which includes stock-based compensation, from the cash number. Now, as for how this trend would evolve going forward, I think — time will tell, but I think the opportunities with them will get bigger and brighter in the future, and so we'll continue to invest in the future, and so the variable isn't a slow rate of investment; it's rather how quickly our various investments translate into revenue and margin. And going through the three specific strategic areas that we talked about at the first quarter results, I think our investments in business services, for example, and enterprise software translate into revenue on a measured basis, but there are some products we have, typically the smaller ones, that are already monetized, but because they are sub-scaled and low margin — there are other products we have, such as WeCom, such as Tencent Meeting, such as Tencent Documents, which were at very substantial scale, and we're not yet monetizing, but we're confident that when we do, they'll generate attractive margins.
James Mitchell
executiveThat covers business services. Turning to games, the quantity of titles launching annually keeps rising. Between 2022 and 2023, there's a notable jump in AAA titles in particular, which mirrors how we sized headcount at several key studios over the past two years, along with the development cycle those AAA or high production value games require. So how well those AAA budget games perform as we go through '22 and into '23 will, to some degree, shape the margins for the game industry. Third, on short video, our bandwidth costs have climbed fairly rapidly this year. A driver behind that has been a step-up in short video consumption, especially of Shiping Hao. Right now, we monetize short video Shiping Hao at a moderate rate via the interactive features. Once we insert advertising into Shiping Hao, I think that will affect the margins and the profile of that investment cycle.
Martin Lau
analystWhen it comes to the Metaverse, I'd say we're still in the early stages, so plenty of challenges lie ahead. There's a great deal of uncertainty. The future will be very exciting, but the path by which it gets realized will likely take longer than expected and probably require several iterations. I'd say the key challenge really is this — since we talk about the multiple pathways to reach the Metaverse, what matters is which one delivers the most attractive user experience? That's the most important question to answer. If you don't answer it and simply try to take the word, then it's hard to come up with the product and crystallize a product that attracts people. The other one is really, to realize such a distinguishing and engaging user experience, what technology is actually needed. But we do believe the driving force will still be software-driven, and the technology that truly helps us deliver the user experience — be it engine technology, be it the ability to provide a better real experience, a high-fidelity experience across many — a large number of concurrent users.
Martin Lau
analystTake AI technology, for instance, when it comes to tailoring a distinct experience for each individual. A great many of these technologies are truly software-driven. So Heartware will likely serve as a supporting condition rather than an essential one. We believed that even in today's mobile devices, it would be fairly adequate to begin with. Naturally, though, if at some point VR and other hardware become plainly indispensable, I believe the industry stands ready to adopt it, and we do possess the technology for that. So in a sense, it will resemble the situation when people ask what precisely will unfold with the Mobile Internet. Hardware developers will be building mobile phones, yet the real engine will be the apps that genuinely leverage those phones, and I think that is what occurred with hardware in this instance too. On the regulatory side, I would say that — regarding any service, you simply need to comply within the various territories where you operate. Thus, for the global market, one set of regulations will apply. For the China market, a different set of regulations will apply, but we believed it is not fundamentally detrimental to the growth of the Metaverse.
Martin Lau
analystThe metaverse is going to be driven by technology. As James mentioned, many technologies tie into game development and also into the metaverse. So because of that, the Chinese government is going to support the advancement of these kinds of technologies — provided that what users actually experience stays within the regulatory framework.
Operator
operatorThanks. We move to our next question, which is from John Choi of Daiwa Capital Markets. Go ahead with your question.
John Choi
analystThanks for taking my questions. I have two quick ones. First, on Cloud Computing, I understand growth has been pretty healthy, but with the overall macro slowing down right now, we've been seeing some slight delay in the deployment of so-called Capex or IT budgets. Are we likely to see any of that? Or, as we look into 2022, is the growth trend still intact? Second, a quick follow-up on your International Games strategy. Clearly, you've been doing a great job, but still mostly from the mobile standpoint. If we extend our platform, particularly in console or more on the PC side, and beyond the casual, what is our strategy there? And should we expect more strategic investments or M&A, and a decision to acquire more IP? Thank you.
James Mitchell
executiveNow, regarding the cloud question, what we believe is that the main trend is that businesses in China are adopting infrastructure in the cloud, platform in the cloud, and software in the cloud more and more, and our view is that this trend carries on whether the macroeconomic environment speeds up or slows down. To be specific, on the matter of Capex fluctuating, I believe that is accurate, and I think it mirrors the fact that during 2020, there was a great deal of uncertainty across China's technology industry regarding whether companies could keep buying servers and GPUs and smart NIC cards and so on. And that pushed some — the stockpiling pattern is now being reversed, and the global supply chain appears to be shifting onto a more normal footing, at least when viewed from a regulatory standpoint with respect to the United States. So, I would say right now, we believe our business services will be impacted less by regulation and macro fluctuation, and then advertising. And then your question about console and PC, I wasn't certain I grasped the nuance. Of course, we've been making PC games for many years, and more recently, as the X86 architecture of PC and console converge, we started putting out games on console too, including Pokemon Unite most recently.
James Mitchell
executiveNow, when you consider the group we’ve described as genre-leading specialist studios that sit outside China, most of those are really centered on console and PC. Through that, they built both a reputation and a track record for making especially strong games in a given genre on console and PC, and at this point we’re backing them to do so at a larger scale than previously. On the IP side, broadly speaking, IP carries more weight in mobile and maybe somewhat less in PC. Beyond China, the PC gaming audience in non-China markets is fairly engaged and sophisticated—they check reviews on Steam and Epic Games Store and gather input from fellow players. As a result, you’ll frequently see cases where a development team of ours that has worked very successfully on a specific IP actually leaves that IP behind and builds something different—an entirely new IP—yet it winds up larger and stronger. A textbook example, stereotypically, is Epic Games: for 10 years they were tied exclusively to the Gears of War IP, but later they sold Gears of War and concentrated on building the Fortnite IP, which is even larger and stronger than Gears of War.
Operator
operatorThank you. We’ll take the next question from Alicia Yap at Citigroup. Go ahead with your question.
Alicia Yap
analystHello, and good evening, management. Thank you for taking my questions. There are two things I’d like to ask. First, about the new versions of the CRM, SaaS, and CDN. It looks as though a new version will be launched by the end of this year, offering deeper integration between Tencent Meeting and WeCom as well. So how should we think about those upcoming online advertising opportunities within WeChat that could further expand and penetrate into other traditional industry verticals? Then, for my second question — there are a lot of Metaverse questions tonight. I’d just like to follow up a little on that as it relates to your international game’s development and expansion. I’m wondering whether management could share the opportunity you see in the global context of this Metaverse opportunity. What do we need to be prepared for in terms of capturing these evolving trends, especially regarding whether we need to prepare a separate global infrastructure or some social network infrastructure to capture this opportunity in the global context? Thank you.
Martin Lau
analystWith CDN, that's a fair point — we're really beginning to bring our various enterprise-facing SaaS offerings together more closely. You'll see additional integration among WeCom, Tencent Meeting, Tencent Docs, CDN, and potentially other SaaS down the road. WeCom also gives users a connection into the WeChat — Weixin ecosystem. So I'd say there are fundamental advantages when these separate SaaS apps can communicate with one another, and that gives a more unified experience to any enterprise customer who wants to use one or two, or many, of our SaaS applications. Then, being able to link these SaaS to consumers in ways that are controlled and secured is genuinely valuable for both the enterprise and the consumers, so that different businesses can serve them in a well-protected manner. When that happens — and we mention this in our prepared comment as well — if an enterprise can use this to build a selling or serving relationship with its customers, then it can contribute additional GMV to our Mini Programs. For instance, it can also give them a reason to advertise more within Weixin.
Martin Lau
analystRight, so, Metaverse — I think that covers it. James, perhaps you'd like to give that a try.
James Mitchell
executiveI mean, I actually hadn't had Martin's tag line about making such a world more real than making the physical world richer before, but it's very good, so I repeated it. I think that's the destination. Now, regarding the pathways to the destination, it's not necessarily in our interest to talk at great length about specific plans, whether inside or outside China, but maybe just to elaborate a little on what Martin was saying and what the different pathways are, what capabilities they need to aggregate, and I think that the pathway that most closely resembles the Metaverse today is games — virtual-world, open-world games. And for games, many of the components are already in place. I think the challenge is aggregating more and more virtual experiences — virtual game experiences — together. So, it's Fortnite together with Rocket League in the Epic example, or multiple different so-called game experiences within the Roblox sample. And also providing more and more powerful tools so that other amateur but also professional content creators can create experiences, including non-game experiences, within these virtual worlds. The second path, which is less well understood, is taking user-operated communities that already have a high degree of functionality-technology-bots, and then moving them from a text and image basis to more of an immersive video basis.
James Mitchell
executiveThat's an area where businesses such as Discord have a chance. And the third one is — I mean, when you take an existing social network, with that network you have to deliver the 3D graphics capabilities that <<inaudible>> alongside the server-based community, and you also need to supply the UGC and PGC tools that gaming companies require in order to do it. So although social networks like <<inaudible>> and Snap hold the largest capital resources, they likewise have a considerable amount of work ahead of them. In any case, I believe that doesn't directly answer your question, but I hope it clarifies how we think about the pathways and the future, and why we're doing some of the things we're doing.
Jane Yip
executiveThanks. And so we have time for just one more question, we’ll take the final one now.
Operator
operatorThanks. We’ll take our last question from Eddie Leung at Bank of America. Eddie, please go ahead.
Eddie Leung
analystHow’s it going, everyone? This is probably a little more dull. So, I have two questions. First, on DAU: I’d be interested to know whether the growth we’re currently seeing comes mainly from new clients or from existing clients spending more, since we know that could have some implications for margins. Second, a follow-up on headcount. I understand James has a topic about that. But if we look at the rise in headcount this year, we’re looking at — even counting the additions from some of the acquisitions or companies, Bitauto and Sogou, we’re still looking at 20,000, 30,000 or more people, right? So, looking into next year, what areas can we think about that still require more headcount? Thanks.
Martin Lau
analystWhen it comes to Cloud, I'd say both of those indicators really matter, right? As for existing clients, I'd characterize it as simply volume growth in low margin products, and that's less valuable — but if we're able to cross-sell our SaaS and PaaS products to those existing customers, that would be far better for our overall margin. And when it comes to the number of clients, it's mostly happening in the long tail, right? The medium and small — particularly small companies are going to be the key driver of client count, and typically they don't drive sales and revenue all that much. Even with a high percentage growth, the impact is actually that it lowers customer ARPU but doesn't really drive overall business volume. But the important thing is that these smaller companies will grow over time, and as they grow over time, they grow along with our Cloud, and it will be very profitable for us over time, across their lifetime. So that's why our Cloud Business really focuses on both ends, basically — growing the number of customers we have in the long tail while at the same time supporting our existing customers so they can grow their business volume.
Martin Lau
analystParticularly when it comes to cross-selling those offerings as customers move from IaaS to PaaS and then to SaaS. Now, what about the second question?
Pony Ma
executiveWhen it comes to headcount growth, as you pointed out earlier, part of it comes from the newly acquired subsidiaries, which bring in roughly 9,000 people, and beyond that we do hire fresh graduates from time to time, and those hires come in at under 5,000, 6,000 on an annual basis. As for where we'll be spending more, we've increased spending mainly in areas that include business-facing services, cloud, maps, and quite a few different businesses within CSIG. We also see some organic growth in our online gaming division, as James mentioned earlier. <<inaudible>> for talent, particularly in the online games area. So we'll put further investment into the online games side. Another thing is that we'll be investing in content. Previously, a lot of that manpower had been subcontracted out, but now we're working on building up our own team in this area, so that we can control the content and also do some content creation and similar work, in order to control the overall quality of the content. Looking ahead, I don't think we're talking about 30% and 40% headcount growth on an annual basis, but in 2022 we'll be more moderate, at least.
Jane Yip
executiveAll right, thanks. We're wrapping up the call at this point, so if you'd like to review our press release along with other financial details, head over to the IR section on our Company website. A replay of this webcast will be up shortly as well. Thanks, and we'll see you next quarter.
Operator
operatorAppreciate it, everyone. That brings today's conference to a close. Thanks for joining us. You're all free to disconnect now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Tencent Holdings Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Tencent Holdings Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Tencent Holdings Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.