Tencent Holdings Limited (700) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

May 18, 2022

Hong Kong Stock Exchange HK Communication Services Interactive Media and Services earnings 69 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Hello, and thanks for holding. You're welcome to the Tencent Holdings Limited conference call announcing our 2022 first quarter results. Right now, everyone is in listen-only mode. Following the speakers' presentations, we'll hold a question and answer session. If you'd like to ask something during that session, press star one on your phone. Please note that this conference is being recorded today. Should you need any additional help, press star zero. I'll now hand the conference to Ms. Wendy Huang of Tencent's IR team. Thank you. Over to you.

Wendy Huang

executive
#2

Thanks, operator. Good evening, and welcome to the conference call for our first quarter 2022 results. Before the presentation begins, we'd like to remind everyone that it contains forward-looking statements, which a number of risks and uncertainties underpin, and for various reasons those statements may not be realized in the future. Information regarding general market conditions comes from a variety of sources outside of Tencent. This pre-presentation also contains some unaudited non-IFRS financial measures, which should be considered in addition to, but not as a substitute for, measures of the group's financial performance prepared in accordance with IFRS. For a detailed discussion of risk factors and IFRS measures, please refer to our disclosure documents on the IR section of our website. Let me introduce the management team on the call tonight. Our chairman and CEO, Pony Ma, will kick off with a short overview. President Martin Lau and Chief Strategy Officer James Mitchell will provide a business review. Chief Financial Officer John Lo will conclude with a financial discussion before we open the floor for questions. I will now turn the call over to Pony.

Pony Ma

executive
#3

Thank you, Wendy. Good evening, and thanks to everyone for joining us. In a tough first quarter of 2022, we carried out initiatives to control costs and rationalized some non-core businesses, and that will let us reach a more optimized cost structure as we move ahead. We used tools like mini programs, Tencent Meeting, and WeCom to help enterprises and consumers get through the resurgence of COVID-19 in China, and we kept investing in strategic growth areas, including enterprise software, Video Accounts, and international games. Going forward, we will sharpen our focus and keep innovating through challenges and cycles, and we will continue creating value for our users, partners, and society. Now let me walk through the headline financial numbers for the quarter. Total revenue came to CNY 135 billion, largely stable year-on-year, or down 6% quarter-on-quarter. Gross profit was CNY 57 billion, down 9% year-on-year, and 1% quarter-on-quarter. Non-IFRS operating profit reached CNY 37 billion, down 15% year-on-year, or up 10% quarter-on-quarter. Non-IFRS net profit attributable to equity holders was CNY 26 billion, down 23% year-on-year, or up 3% quarter-on-quarter. For our key services, we generally hold our certain place positions in activities including social games, long form video, news, music, literature, payment, and mobile browser. Combined MAU of Weixin and QQ was 1.29 billion.

Pony Ma

executive
#4

QQ's mobile MAU came in at 564 million. At this point, I'll pass things along to Martin and James for the business review.

Martin Lau

analyst
#5

Thanks, Pony, and a good evening and good morning to everyone. Total revenue for the first quarter of 2022 was broadly flat compared with a year earlier. VAS accounted for 54% of total revenue, and inside that, the social network sub-segment made up 22%, the domestic games sub-segment 24%, and the international games sub-segment 8%. Online advertising contributed 13%, while fintech and business services represented 32% of total revenue. Within value-added services, segment revenue for the quarter came to CNY 73 billion, roughly unchanged from a year earlier. Social networks revenue rose 1% year-on-year to CNY 29 billion, driven by higher revenue from the Video Accounts live streaming service, an increase largely offset by lower revenue from music and games related live streaming services. Total VAS subscriptions climbed 6% year-on-year to 239 million. At Tencent Video, we strengthened our long video market leadership with 124 million subscribers. Popular content including the drama series Sword Snow Stride and the animated series Perfect World Season two showed our strength in adapting comics and novels into IP. Music subscriptions rose 32% year-on-year to 80 million, supported by high quality content and greater consumer willingness to pay for music services. Domestic games revenue fell 1% year-on-year to CNY 33 billion, as the direct and indirect effects of minor protection measures weighed on active user and paying user accounts.

Martin Lau

analyst
#6

On the recent game launches side, League of Legends: Wild Rift and Battle of the Golden Spatula both brought in incremental revenue, whereas Moonlight Blade Mobile and Call of Duty: Mobile saw their revenue go down. International games revenue climbed 4% year-on-year, reaching CNY 11 billion. That year-on-year growth came in slower than what we saw in recent quarters, which reflects lower PUBG MOBILE revenue as user spending normalized to post-COVID industry-wide, plus the timing of content upgrades in League of Legends and Clash of Clans. Sequentially, revenue fell from a high base in fourth quarter last year, when there was a trued-up adjustment to Supercell's revenue and more consumption over the year-end holidays. Turning to Weixin, Video Accounts kept up strong growth momentum, posting a significant year-on-year rise in daily viewers and time spent. That was supported by expansion in news, knowledge-based, and entertaining content, along with better recommendation technologies. We also improved enterprise messaging and shopping features within Video Accounts to make user engagement and monetization easier for creators, which is driving a more vibrant content ecosystem. Mini programs surpassed 500 million DAUs and maintained rapid year-on-year GMV growth, with especially notable gains in retail and restaurant categories as we strengthened functionalities for customer services and operational analysis. As more public service such as health and municipal services become available through mini programs, we're able to cultivate user habits around accessing essential services through mini programs.

Martin Lau

analyst
#7

When it comes to QQ, we're adding features for younger users so they can create, share, and connect more easily. We offer avatar tools that let users make fun short videos starring their own customized Super QQ Show characters. With status updates, users can share the videos and music they're enjoying, and their friends can then access and stream that same content through mini programs without ever leaving the QQ app, which boosts both social interaction and content consumption. Moving to domestic games, we built on our long-standing leadership among the highest DAU games while also breaking into new Gen Z game genres that are new to Tencent. In battle arena games, Honor of Kings saw grossing receipts fall year-on-year over the Chinese New Year holidays because fewer items were commercially successful. Even so, the game's adult user base held steady, and grossing receipts returned to year-on-year growth in March on more commercially successful items. Peacekeeper Elite, the number one shooter game in China, lifted its user engagement by adding new combat items and battlefield design in its third anniversary content update in April. Within new genres, in auto battler games, Battle of the Golden Spatula introduced new champions and game mechanics that made players' competitive experience richer. The game ranked number one in the genre and number six in all mobile games by DAU in the first quarter.

Martin Lau

analyst
#8

As of now, it stands as the industry's top new game launch since 2021. Within real-time strategy, we released TiMi Studio Group's Return to Empire at the end of March. Through our collaboration with Xbox Game Studios, this title delivers premium visuals and content to players. By grossing receipts in April, it ranked second among all games in the genre for revenue. Turning to international games: outside China, the mobile gaming sector largely saw slower growth or shrinkage in early 2022 compared with the COVID-19-affected stretch of early 2021. Consequently, PUBG MOBILE posted a year-on-year decline in grossing receipts during the first quarter. Still, we remain confident about the game's longer-term trajectory now that it has moved past the COVID comparisons. A Spider-Man themed mode for PUBG launched in January and succeeded in boosting user engagement, and Lamborghini tie-ins from March became the game's best-selling crossover skins to date. Valorant, our PC title, kept up its strong performance. A growing user base, willingness to pay, and appealing content pushed gross receipts up substantially year-on-year. By MAU across all genres, Valorant now ranks as the sixth most popular PC game and stands as the highest-ranked new PC title launched in the past four years. Beyond our current titles, we're bringing out compelling new games through partnerships with globally renowned IPs.

Martin Lau

analyst
#9

Take Dune: Spice Wars as one illustration — a real-time strategy title for PC built around the sci-fi property Dune. Released by Funcom, our subsidiary studio, it has seen early success from the moment it hit early access on April 26th. Funcom holds game rights to well-known properties including Dune and Conan the Barbarian, and it is at work as well on an open-world survival game set in the Dune universe. A second illustration would be Apex Legends Mobile, a hero shooter battle royale that our LightSpeed & Quantum Studio built together with EA's Respawn Entertainment and that went live worldwide yesterday. This mobile title draws on one of the biggest new PC console properties of recent years. Going forward, our goal is to keep expanding the titles we already have and to bring out several large-budget new games, particularly starting in 2023. That said, I'll hand things over to James, who will cover our other businesses.

James Mitchell

executive
#10

Thanks, Martin. Now for online advertising: first-quarter revenue came in at CNY 18 billion, which is a decline of 18% from a year earlier and 16% versus the prior quarter, since softer bidding density pushed eCPMs lower. Social and other advertising brought in CNY 16 billion, 15% lower year-on-year and 15% lower quarter-on-quarter; inside that, mobile ad network revenue fell sharply from a year ago because of weak demand and regulatory shifts like limits on flash screen ads. Weixin Moments ad revenue slipped a little year-on-year, as softness in education and real estate spending more than canceled out gains from FMCG and games. Official Accounts ad revenue rose notably compared with a year ago, helped by letting advertisers target young users more effectively through notification feeds ads and place their ads in a setting of high-quality, relevant content. More than 20% of official accounts ad revenue is generated by click-to-purchase and click-to-message ads, which run on mini programs and WeChat, respectively. Media advertising revenue stands at CNY 2 billion, 30% lower year-on-year and 27% lower quarter-on-quarter, and within it video ad revenue dropped double digits from a year earlier. The Winter Olympics and hit drama series like The Oath of Love added incremental video ad revenue, yet that was more than outweighed by fewer top-tier variety show releases relative to the first quarter of last year.

James Mitchell

executive
#11

During the second quarter so far, advertisers across sectors including FMCG, e-commerce, and travel have reduced their spending because of the COVID situation and the supply chain disruptions that came with it. We keep putting money into our advertising system and are upgrading our machine learning infrastructure so data can be processed more efficiently. That upgrade should eventually let us sharpen our targeting and, in turn, improve conversion rates for advertisers. Turning to Fintech and business services, segment revenue came in at CNY 43 billion, which is up 10% year-on-year and down 11% quarter-on-quarter. Within Fintech, revenue growth year-on-year slowed because commercial payment volume grew more slowly, a reflection of multiple cities adopting measures to fight the COVID-19 resurgence in March, which led to less consumption of everyday items like food and beverage as well as big-ticket items like travel booking. Our payment volume slowed in tandem, particularly in categories including transportation, dining services, and apparel. On the business services side, our revenue declined slightly year-on-year as we moved our focus away from prioritizing revenue growth and toward customer value creation and quality of growth. We proactively pulled back on certain loss-making activities, for example projects that bring substantial headline revenue but also substantial costs that we had to pay to subcontractors, along with deeply discounted infrastructure-only contracts for basic services such as cloud computing content delivery network.

James Mitchell

executive
#12

But we have grown our PaaS revenue at healthier margins, particularly in video cloud and cybersecurity. In video cloud, drawing on the experience we have built up delivering in-house interactive entertainment and video chat services, plus our low-latency network infrastructure, we are moving more and more of our clients away from the basic content delivery network toward more advanced video on-demand, live streaming, and real-time communication solutions. Our real-time communication service is meeting rising demand for interactive video offerings in scenarios like online meetings, customer service, and live streaming e-commerce. Gartner put Tencent in first place among all vendors for communication PaaS revenues in China for 2021. In cybersecurity, we broadened our client base across network endpoint and business operation security solutions, meeting enterprises' needs for protection against cyberattacks as well as for cybersecurity compliance. To position ourselves for the fast-growing demand for next generation enterprise security, we are strengthening our zero trust security solutions that support remote working. These zero trust security solutions draw on the internal experience we have accumulated in network security management. I will now hand over to John Lo.

John Lo

executive
#13

Thanks, James. For Q1 2022, our total revenue came to CNY 135.5 billion, flat versus a year earlier, or a 6% decline quarter-on-quarter. Gross profit reached CNY 57.1 billion, 9% lower year-on-year, or 1% lower quarter-on-quarter. Net other gains stood at CNY 13.1 billion, a 33% drop year-on-year and an 85% drop quarter-on-quarter, and these were mainly non-IFRS adjustment items — among them an CNY 18.5 billion gain from our partial divestment of Sea Limited, partly offset by impairment provisions against investee companies in verticals including transportation services and online media. Operating profit was CNY 37.2 billion, a 34% decrease year-on-year and a 66% decrease quarter-on-quarter. Net finance costs came in at CNY 1.9 billion, 42% higher year-on-year, or 4% higher quarter-on-quarter, reflecting larger interest expenses from greater indebtedness as well as smaller foreign exchange gains both year-on-year and quarter-on-quarter. Our share of losses of associates and JVs was CNY 6.3 billion, versus a share of profits of CNY 1.3 billion last year. The non-IFRS share of losses was CNY 2.2 billion, compared with a non-IFRS share of profits of CNY 0.5 billion a year ago, reflecting revenue decline at certain overseas game associates due to post-COVID user spending normalization, losses recognized from associates in the transportation services verticals, and the impact from JD.com ceasing to be an associate.

John Lo

executive
#14

For the first quarter of 2022, income tax expense fell 27% to CNY 5.3 billion compared with a year earlier. The effective tax rate came in at 18.2%. Net profit attributable to equity holders reached CNY 23.4 billion, a decline of 51% year-on-year, or 75% quarter-on-quarter. Diluted EPS stood at CNY 2.404, down 51% year-on-year, or 75% quarter-on-quarter. Next, I'll walk you through our non-IFRS figures. Operating profit was CNY 36.5 billion, 15% lower year-on-year but 10% higher quarter-on-quarter, which mirrors reduced marketing expenses stemming from our cost optimization measures. Net profit attributable to equity holders came to CNY 25.5 billion, down 23% year-on-year, or up 3% quarter-on-quarter. Diluted EPS was CNY 2.62, down 23% year-on-year, or up 3% quarter-on-quarter. Turning to gross margin: overall gross margin was 42.1%, a drop of 4.2 percentage points year-on-year, or a rise of two percentage points quarter-on-quarter. The year-on-year decline mirrored stable revenue combined with higher operating costs, a mix shift toward lower margin products, and our ongoing investments in key strategic initiatives. The quarter-on-quarter increase stemmed from a seasonal revenue mix shift toward high margin businesses such as games. Looking at segments, gross margin for VAS was 50.4%, down 4.7 percentage points year-on-year, or up 1.7 percentage points quarter-on-quarter.

John Lo

executive
#15

On a year-over-year basis, the decline came from steady segment revenue paired with higher costs — among them content costs for games, server and bandwidth expenses — plus what we put into strategic initiatives, Video Accounts especially. The sequential rise came from a seasonal shift in revenue mix within the segment toward higher-margin businesses. Online advertising gross margin stood at 36.7%, which is 8.4 percentage points lower year-on-year, or six percentage points lower quarter-on-quarter. The year-on-year drop stemmed from falling revenue and rising operating costs, including costs tied to our Video Accounts and content costs for the Beijing Winter Olympics, together with the fact that the full exemption from the cultural construction fee was no longer available this year — that was also the primary driver of the quarter-on-quarter decline. Fintech and business services gross margin came in at 31.6%, roughly flat year-on-year, or up 4.5 percentage points quarter-on-quarter. That sequential gain was driven by a revenue mix shift within the segment toward higher-margin Fintech businesses, along with our recent move to cut loss-making cloud service contracts. Turning to operating expenses: selling and marketing expenses were CNY 8.1 billion, a decrease of 6% year-on-year, or 31% quarter-on-quarter. If you exclude stock-based compensation, selling and marketing expenses fell 7% year-on-year and 32% quarter-on-quarter. The year-on-year reduction reflected the marketing expense optimization measures we have taken.

John Lo

executive
#16

The sequential decline came from reduced marketing outlays on games and business services, driven by both seasonal patterns and cost-optimization efforts. Selling and marketing costs represented 5.9% of revenues, essentially flat versus a year ago. R&D spending totaled RMB 15.4 billion, rising 36% year-on-year, or 10% quarter-on-quarter. If you strip out share-based compensation, R&D costs grew 27% year-on-year, or 6% quarter-on-quarter. Those year-on-year and sequential gains stemmed largely from higher staff costs tied to our continued investment in key strategic initiatives, plus the effect of subsidiaries acquired recently. R&D accounted for 11.4% of revenues. G&A costs excluding R&D came to RMB 11.3 billion, climbing 47% year-on-year, or 9% quarter-on-quarter. Strip out share-based compensation, and G&A excluding R&D rose 25% year-on-year, or fell 7% quarter-on-quarter. The year-on-year rise mirrored higher staff costs from headcount growth supporting our ongoing investment in key strategic areas, crypto expenses run up by overseas subsidiaries, and costs from subsidiaries acquired recently. We finished the quarter with roughly 116,000 employees, 30% more than a year earlier, or 3% higher quarter-on-quarter. Now let's look at operating and net margin ratios. For the combined reasons I cited earlier, non-IFRS operating margin stood at 27%, a drop of 4.6 percentage points year-on-year, or a gain of four percentage points quarter-on-quarter.

John Lo

executive
#17

Our non-IFRS net margin came in at 19.4%, which is 6.1 percentage points lower than a year earlier, reflecting a reduced operating margin and the swing from profit to losses in our share of associates overall. Sequentially, non-IFRS net margin rose 1.5 percentage points, helped by the seasonal shift in revenue mix toward higher-margin businesses and by steps to optimize marketing expenses. Last, let me go through a few key financial metrics covering cash flow and the balance sheet for the quarter. Total CapEx reached CNY 7 billion, a 10% decline year-on-year, or 40% lower quarter-on-quarter. Of that total CapEx, operating CapEx was CNY 5.2 billion, 21% below the prior year. Non-operating CapEx rose 54% year-on-year to CNY 1.8 billion. Operating cash flow in the quarter was CNY 33.8 billion, falling 34% versus both the prior year and the previous quarter. The year-on-year drop, after adjusting for normal working capital changes, stemmed partly from reduced cash receipts from games and online advertising, while R&D and staff costs kept rising. The quarter-on-quarter decrease was mainly because our annual bonus payment is recorded in the first quarter of each year. Free cash flow for the quarter was CNY 15.2 billion, down 54% year-on-year and 55% quarter-on-quarter. We ended with a net debt position of CNY 11 billion, versus CNY 20.2 billion in the last quarter.

James Mitchell

executive
#18

At quarter's end, the fair value of the stakes we hold in listed investee companies, leaving out subsidiaries, came to roughly CNY 606 billion, which is $95 billion. During the quarter, we bought back around 8.9 million shares, spending approximately CNY 3 billion. Thank you.

Wendy Huang

executive
#19

Operator, please go ahead and open up the lines for questions at this point.

Operator

operator
#20

Thanks. The first question is from Alicia Yap of Citigroup. Your line is open now, so please go ahead.

Alicia Yap

analyst
#21

Hello there, and thank you. Good evening, management, and thanks for taking my questions. First, given the most recent developments in China, could management share your observations from the last two months regarding any shifts in consumer behavior or in how your business partners feel — specifically around digital content consumption, consumers' willingness to spend, partners' online advertising budgets, and the timing of cloud infrastructure migration, particularly in light of the recent lockdown? How will the current macro headwinds influence your outlook for gaming, payments, advertising, and even cloud into the second half? Second, could management expand a bit on the remarks in your prepared comments about video on-demand, live streaming, and the real-time communication solution? How will these event solutions eventually lead to better pricing and also assist you in optimizing operating costs, which could potentially support future growth in business revenue — business service revenue growth — as well as the margin profile for this segment? You mentioned some customer adoption rate. Is there any color you can share about this on-demand service so far?

Alicia Yap

analyst
#22

Thanks.

James Mitchell

executive
#23

Alicia, I appreciate those two questions. They contain several sub-questions, but I'll do my best to address most of the topics you brought up. Regarding what we're seeing in terms of shifting sentiment among consumers and enterprises, broadly speaking, behavior is closely linked to the COVID situation in various cities throughout China. As most of you likely know, Shanghai has gone through a very severely unfortunate COVID outbreak. On the consumer side, we've observed that commercial payment volume has stayed below trend and declined year-on-year for many weeks in Shanghai. The trend is now improving gradually, though it remains lower than it would otherwise be. Shenzhen, by contrast, offers a case study of a city that experienced a small scale COVID outbreak in March and brought it under control very quickly. Looking at consumer commercial payment volume in Shenzhen, there was a sharp drop in March with the lockdowns, followed by a fairly rapid recovery in April. By May, commercial payment volume in Shenzhen is largely back to the prior trend rate and is growing year-on-year. So when it comes to how the latest macro headwind will affect our businesses, the question really hinges primarily on how COVID behaves across different cities nationwide.

James Mitchell

executive
#24

To dig into a few of your sub-questions on the digital content side — if I were to draw a distinction between the COVID outbreaks in 2022 and those we went through back in 2020, what we observed in early 2020 was that, since the COVID outbreaks struck right after the Chinese New Year period, a lot of people were in a vacation frame of mind, a holiday frame of mind, and they stayed in that holiday frame of mind through the lockdown. Usage of entertainment-related applications picked up relatively quickly. Conversely, consumers, enterprises, teachers, and students needed several weeks before they grew comfortable with productivity-related applications. This time around, the COVID outbreaks came several weeks after the Chinese New Year holiday. People were generally back at work and back at school, and they wanted to keep working or studying, but from home. We observed a slower uptake of entertainment-related applications, yet a much faster uptake of productivity-related applications, such as Tencent Meeting. I believe that accelerated uptake of productivity applications reflects, first of all, the fact that far more enterprises, consumers, and education establishments now know how to use Tencent Meeting, along with WeCom and Tencent Docs. Secondly, it reflects the fact that a number of enterprise software services — Tencent Meeting in particular — have substantially increased their market share over the past two years.

James Mitchell

executive
#25

That's regarding digital content. As for how the macro headwind will impact particular businesses, unfortunately COVID is having a negative effect on most people in China, especially in the cities that are affected. We're not exempt from that. The negative impact is especially noticeable on advertising, partly due to overall pressure on GDP, and partly because many companies, particularly multinationals, run their marketing budgets out of Shanghai. Then there's some impact on our payment volumes, as I mentioned, though that's more differentiated city by city rather than universal nationwide. There's some negative impact on cloud project launches, and then the impact on the game business is harder to see. I hope that covers off your first question. On the second question about the video on demand opportunity, in general, our belief is that over time, customers are migrating from bare bones content delivery network toward a more sophisticated, real-time video communications and ultimately toward integrated communications platform as a service solutions. As they migrate, the competitive barriers to entry become higher, and the margins correspondingly become healthier. Starting with content delivery network, there are many companies in China that are reselling telco bandwidth for CDN.

James Mitchell

executive
#26

You know, we do hold some competitive edge because we possess quite substantial in-house infrastructure, and that includes lease lines which we own and run ourselves. Frankly, you know, this is a business that's somewhat commoditized. It's subject to price wars and to margin compression. But when you move to real-time video, only a handful of companies out there have the algorithms needed to deliver low latency video solutions. We're among them, you know, since we hold the unique advantage of having supported billions of video chats for Weixin and QQ users over many years. And as you move into communication platform as a service, I think we're somewhat uniquely advantaged because there are many enterprises whose salespeople are individually using Weixin anyway to communicate with their customers. So it's very natural for those enterprises to then aggregate those salespersons' customer relationships through the WeCom software and ultimately systematize things by providing video chat and video communication within WeCom. Regarding the customer adoption rate, you know, I think both globally and in China, we're very optimistic about the trends we see and the trends we expect to see going forward. If you think about how corporations interact with consumers online, at first, they did it just by operating a website that would include a telephone number.

James Mitchell

executive
#27

After that, they made it possible to do email inside the site, and then customers wanted to shift over to live chat. Looking ahead, I believe it's inevitable that a lot of consumers, across many products, are going to want to go from messaging to video conversations. For businesses, having the ability to offer real-time video interaction with customers at low latency is simply going to turn into an unavoidable cost of operating and an important competitive instrument. We feel positive about communication platform as a service, and about low latency real-time communications, as we look to what's ahead.

Operator

operator
#28

Thanks. Our following question is from Eddie Leung at Bank of America. Go ahead with your question.

Eddie Leung

analyst
#29

Good evening, everyone. I’d like to ask about your new cloud strategy. I’m just curious whether these changes will give any signal about how your client mix may shift going forward. Will that alter the mix of clients by vertical industries, by client size, and also by how sophisticated your clients are? Thank you.

James Mitchell

executive
#30

I mean, cloud services in China are somewhat different from what you see in the Western world, because historically and right now, roughly 50% of industry-wide revenue comes from other internet companies. And 50% comes from all kinds of — mainly at first offline — businesses, like financial services, manufacturing, governments, and local services. Our shift isn't meant to necessarily alter that current demand reality. I think the shift is needed so we can deliver services cost effectively, and thus attractively, to those offline-first businesses that are moving online. Because right now in China — and this held true in the West a few years back — there's a tendency for companies, for cloud vendors, to deliver highly customized, very cost-heavy solutions, so really to act more as system solution providers or IT consultancy services. While that's doable in an environment of, kind of, infinite capital, it isn't scalable and it isn't sustainable. So that's not where long-term growth will come from. We've made a proactive decision to focus on scalable — and therefore sustainable and profitable — opportunities.

James Mitchell

executive
#31

You see, I think when you look at the West, it has been really difficult for firms that attempt to do both things to succeed at both. Generally speaking, if you're still in the project deployment business, well, that stays your bread and butter. By contrast, the companies that have gone all in on genuinely cloud-based solutions are the ones that have gained the most from the industry's shifting profile. A big chunk of our revenue comes from other internet companies, and that will continue. Over the long term, the greater growth will come from a whole range of other industries. Roughly half of our revenue within that segment comes from infrastructure, and the other half comes from platform software and industry solutions. We aspire to grow both, but particularly the latter.

Operator

operator
#32

Thanks. We’re moving on to Ronald Keung of Goldman Sachs. Go ahead with your question.

Ronald Keung

analyst
#33

Thanks. Thanks, Pony, Martin, James, and John. I'd like to ask about our online advertising. Given the COVID lockdowns and how consumption got worse in the second quarter, I just want to hear how management is thinking about online advertising growth and maybe the potential timing for stabilization or some kind of inflection — I think, looking at different drivers like macro across the various verticals, an easier base for some of those verticals, and any potential monetization of Video Accounts in that. Thank you.

James Mitchell

executive
#34

Right. Thanks. So, on earlier calls we mentioned that when we got into the back half of 2022, all of our sequential advertising trends ought to turn positive. The reason being, first, we'll be up against a set of discrete regulatory changes — those hit both our advertisers and our own advertising media. And second, over time we'll be adding more inventory, Video Accounts included. The new element since we last spoke is COVID breaking out in several places. How fast COVID gets brought under control will decide if what we said before still holds or if the timetable slides, since COVID is again damaging consumption, which doesn't help. It's also damaging logistics, particularly logistics moving through Shanghai, a logistics hub, which is even less helpful. Lastly, it's hitting the city in China where the majority of multinationals actually base their headquarters and where they make their marketing decisions, which is unhelpful on top of that.

Operator

operator
#35

Thank you. The next question is from William Packer at BNP Paribas. You have the floor.

William Packer

analyst
#36

Hello, management. Thanks a lot for taking my questions. First, there have been a lot of comments lately from various authorities about both the healthy development of the platform economy and, additionally, the completion of rectification in recent weeks. Could you help us understand how you view those two important objectives and what the implications are for Tencent? Second, operating cost growth slowed in Q1 compared with recent quarters, which demonstrates good cost control. Could you help us think through the trajectory of cost growth over the remainder of the year and the key puts and takes? Many thanks.

Martin Lau

analyst
#37

Sure, I'll take the first question. It's accurate that over the last 2 months, the Chinese government has indeed put out a fair number of supportive signals at the top level regarding the digital economy and the platform economy. Specifically, I'd highlight yesterday, at a CPPCC meeting, Chairman Wang Yang said clearly that a stronger, high-quality, and larger-scale digital economy should be supported. Vice Premier Liu He likewise restated the intention to firmly back the platform economy and the private economy. I think that aligns with last month — as of the end of last month, April 29th, when the Politburo meeting was held, it expressed the intention to foster healthy development of the platform economy, to complete rectification actions on the platform economy, to implement and normalize deregulation, and also to roll out specific measures supporting healthy and compliant growth of the platform economy. We can plainly see that from the very highest level, fairly clear supportive signals have been released. I think, for that to turn into a real impact on our business, there is going to be a time lag and a process. I'd say it will take time for the specific regulators and ministries to convert this direction into real actions.

Martin Lau

analyst
#38

I think, you know, when it comes to the Politburo direction, it's fairly clear how the sequence should be stated, right? You know, first there's the completion of the rectification actions, then normalized deregulation gets implemented, and after that specific measures to support come in. While we wouldn't expect these three actions to be specifically sequential, I would say the order is pretty much that way. It would take some time for the corrective measures to be turning into normalized deregulation, and then the specific supportive measures would be introduced. We would be working closely with the regulators in the hope to see this transition to happen. I think, you know, a positive development is that in April the publishing bureau started to approve ban hao the publishing licenses for games. It's definitely an encouraging sign. We felt when the transition continued to happen, then the compliance and also well-behaving companies would start to benefit.

James Mitchell

executive
#39

Hi. So regarding cost growth, I’ll split it into four buckets, roughly speaking. First, in Q1 you can observe that our sales and marketing expense growth decelerated, and that’s a positive for us. It cuts both ways somewhat, because quite a few other internet companies have likewise reduced their sales and marketing spending, and that affects our advertising revenue. Still, it’s something we can bring under control fairly fast, and we have brought it under control fairly fast. The second bucket involves our general and administrative expenses, which mostly track headcount and cost per head. During Q1, for several reasons, those G&A expenses kept rising quickly. Even so, you can see headcount growth is decelerating. The people we’re adding are, broadly speaking, frequently cheaper hires, and overall our cost per head is also slowing. As we move through this year, we should expect G&A expenses to decelerate. The third bucket concerns cost of sales and how it affects gross margin. Within that bucket, there are some steps we’re taking—for instance, managing costs inside Tencent Video that may need a few months before they show through.

James Mitchell

executive
#40

Other steps are underway too—for instance, we're pulling out of certain lower-margin business services operations where the payoff shows up faster. And it's easy to overlook, lastly, that reaching our net income figure means passing through the associate line. Associate contributions, you know, have flipped from a profit to a loss compared with a year earlier. A major cause of that is straightforward: several of our large associates, the ones where we hold meaningful stakes, ramped up community group buying initiatives over the last year. Adding it all together, investee A spent CNY X billion on community group buying, and we're actually accounting 15% of that loss, while investee B spent CNY X billion on community group buying, and we're associate accounting 12% of that loss, and so on and so on—so in a sense, our associate income line, effectively, is a community group buying business all by itself. Because, you know, you add up multiple companies, you know, 10, 15, 20% stakes, and get something that looks like, you know, our own community group buying business. As you may be aware, those companies who were investing very aggressively in community group buying in the last 12 months have now fairly sharply slowed down that investment.

James Mitchell

executive
#41

As you know, that’s going to begin moving through their P&Ls and, as a result, through ours as well—though it will come by way of the associate income line. Those are, you know, four buckets to keep in mind when considering costs. Thank you.

Operator

operator
#42

Thanks. We’ll take the next question from Charlene Liu at HSBC. The line is yours.

Charlene Liu

analyst
#43

Thanks. Thanks a lot for giving me the chance. There's something I'd like to ask about the growth margin in the advertising business. We noticed that. Sorry. My apologies. I think, when it comes to the different ad products, we were hoping to get a sense of which ones might recover more quickly or more slowly, and how that kind of shift would impact the online advertising GPM going forward. Because, you know, I think it landed somewhat below what we had expected. Sorry again about the background noise.

James Mitchell

executive
#44

Right. No, the noise isn’t a problem at all. So, regarding the quarter’s advertising results, I think it’s worth keeping in mind that the Olympics — the Winter Olympics — cost us CNY hundreds of millions, covering both broadcast rights and the operating expenses associated with it, and that is a low-margin activity, which has a negative effect on the blended advertising gross margin. As we mentioned in Q4, at the moment Video Accounts growth translates into more cost than revenue impact. For better or worse, Video Accounts kept growing video views very quickly in Q1. Some of that does flow through into costs for the advertising segment. Going forward, what happens with Video Accounts monetization will be an important driver of how incremental margins behave for the advertising business. Beyond that, within advertising, we have a mix of owned and operated properties that are inherently high margin, such as Moments and Video Accounts, owned and operated properties that are lower margin, such as our media services, and then the ad network business, which is inherently low margin.

James Mitchell

executive
#45

So depending on how growth shakes out across those three categories, that'll significantly influence the blended gross margin. That, in turn, depends on which advertiser categories bounce back quickest, since some advertiser categories — luxury goods, for instance — lean toward the high margin owned and operated properties. Other categories, like e-commerce, may lean toward the low margin ad network. It also hinges on the effect of the advertising system changes we're implementing, which may surface at different points for different inventories. Thank you.

Charlene Liu

analyst
#46

Thanks. We'll take the next question from Jerry Liu at UBS. Go ahead with your question.

Jerry Liu

executive
#47

Hello, good evening, and thanks. There are a couple of things I'd like to ask about gaming, perhaps splitting domestic from international. Starting with domestic: now that ban hao has restarted, I'm wondering whether we can be somewhat more optimistic about growth—either grossing or revenue growth—later in the year, or whether we should be a bit more patient, given that some titles may arrive later? Then on the international side, first, I was wondering whether that accounting adjustment discussed last quarter was present at all in the first quarter. Second, might we see international grossing speed up, or will the normalization from COVID, you know, take a while longer to play out? Thank you.

James Mitchell

executive
#48

Yes. Thanks for the game-related questions. So on the international games side, we did see something of a revenue catch-up in Q4 tied to one of our subsidiaries, Supercell. Then there was, you know, something of an accounting catch-down in revenue in Q1 tied to Riot, though that catch-down was smaller in magnitude than the catch-up had been. Turning to the outlook, we don't have a crystal ball, but broadly speaking, the games business outside China — especially for popular mobile games — enjoyed a very buoyant stretch from late 2020 through late 2021. Now it's up against a tough comparison with that stretch. When I say that, I mean the industry as a whole, and a number of listed companies with big mobile games have reported a similar phenomenon. I think it's reasonable to expect that for PUBG Mobile, tough comparatives will persist for another few months before year-on-year trends normalize toward the end of this year. Apart from PUBG Mobile, most of our big PC games are doing fine. They didn't necessarily benefit from COVID as much, and they aren't hurt by a COVID hangover.

James Mitchell

executive
#49

So, you know, we have mobile games with quite long lifespans, such as Clash of Clans, and those are performing well too. Revenue fluctuates somewhat from quarter to quarter based on what content comes out in any particular quarter. The user trends and the willingness to pay seem stable or growing as time goes on. When we look at 2023 and past that, that's the point where we anticipate more of these larger-budget games that we've been, you know, building up over the last two years to come out and begin having a meaningful positive effect on international game revenue. Regarding the domestic game business, I think, as Martin mentioned, the ban hao approval is, you know, a positive thing for several reasons. One is that, you know, additional games are able to be published, and another is the signaling effect, in that it seems, you know, the regulators are now much more comfortable with, you know, the state of the industry, and so it's a, you know, steadier environment in which, you know, people don't have to, you know, glance behind them and attempt to second-guess whether there are, you know, further regulatory shifts waiting on the horizon. So, you know, on the whole, we're quite pleased with the ban hao approvals.

James Mitchell

executive
#50

We didn't receive a game on that approval list this time around, and that's fine. The stretch without any ban hao approvals clearly causes the most pain for startup firms that have no games and thus no cash flow, compared with the larger, more established businesses that already have games, already bring in cash flow, and could weather that stretch more comfortably. We see it as quite rational that the ban hao process begins with the smaller game companies and will later extend to the bigger game companies, ourselves included down the road. On the outlook, then: yes, with more ban hao being issued and the industry now standing on a more stable regulatory footing, it's reasonable to expect the industry's grossing trends will start to improve as we move through the year, and in time that will feed through into reported revenue trends. It isn't an instant process, and it will take several months to play out.

Operator

operator
#51

Thanks. Our next question is from John Choi at Daiwa. Go ahead and ask.

John Choi

analyst
#52

Thanks so much for the question. There are two parts to it. First, Weixin Video Accounts, I believe, has kept building solid momentum. Could management expand a little further on what the advertising business there could become over the longer term? I realize we're still concentrating on user engagement and, you know, cautiously working to grow that business. Still, down the road, would it be reasonable for us to expect a comparable advertising business in terms of ad loads or business potential to what our peers have in this area? That's my first question. My second one: we've seen the value of investees rise quite a bit this quarter amid market volatility. Has that led us to reconsider our investment strategy going forward, and what would be the key focus? I think management said before that the approach would be more balanced, but I'm curious whether this could be more of a chance for us to play aggressive offense, or to be a bit more conservative going forward. Thank you.

Martin Lau

analyst
#53

I'll take the first question. Regarding Video Accounts, it's true that we're quite encouraged by the strong momentum in growth—both in videos viewed and in time spent. If you want to think about the monetization potential, I'd say that eventually it should reach a level of monetization per time spent similar to comparable products in the market. Getting there will take time. As we go along, we'll keep enhancing the user experience so that we strike a better balance between monetization and user experience. One example is our Moments advertising. We would probably be releasing inventory into the market on a more gradual basis than industry peers. Along the way, we'll keep making improvements. Our ad load may or may not be the same. Most likely, I'd say our ad load probably won't be the same—we'll probably be more self-restrained when it comes to ad load. With that, we can potentially achieve a higher CPM eventually by continuously improving the technology, by leveraging the fact that both the user base and the content are high-end in nature, and by leveraging the fact that there's a better connection with the overall Weixin ecosystem—including official accounts and the social graph, as well as the social communication infrastructure and the connection to mini programs—so that conversion can actually increase.

Martin Lau

analyst
#54

I'd say the reality is that, you know, when the total amount of time someone spends on a platform is shorter rather than longer, that's when diminishing marginal returns really begin to set in. The first 20 minutes are likely going to be worth more than the final 20 minutes. You know, that's roughly the overall lens through which we approach this. Over time, we always aim to strike a better balance between monetization and user experience, but also to unleash this platform's full monetization potential.

James Mitchell

executive
#55

Regarding your second question about the investments we hold in other publicly traded companies and how their value declined from one quarter to the next: first, if you examine that decrease, a very large share of it actually came from proactive moves on our part that I believe serve investors well. Specifically, we handed out our stake in JD, valued at roughly $16 billion, directly to investors. We sold a $3 billion position in another company, and those proceeds were then partly directed toward repurchasing our own shares. We likewise sold a couple of billion dollars' worth of stakes in additional companies. Altogether, in the first quarter, when you compare the capital we more or less generated through divestments and distributions against the capital we deployed into investments in other companies, the former was approximately four times the latter. Naturally, when we carry out these divestments and distributions, it is unavoidable and indeed desirable that the remaining value of our portfolio shrinks as a result. Going forward, we will stay active on the divestment front. We are highly mindful of the many macro risks currently present, especially the fact that developed-world central banks are by and large raising interest rates very quickly.

James Mitchell

executive
#56

So, this is something that hasn't been seen in decades, and it affects how investors value some of those high growth, low margin, high duration tech companies that make up a portion of our portfolio. We think very carefully about those risks and about managing them. One way we manage those risks is by stepping up the pace of divestments, distributions and so forth. That said, we're also a company that generates very substantial free cash flow. By virtue of our position, we're a company with insight into emerging technology trends, among consumers and among enterprises. We see new opportunities, interesting opportunities emerging. Sometimes we see old opportunities that we're familiar with from previous investments reemerging as valuations decline. We're being very selective. We're being very disciplined, both in terms of investing carefully and also divesting when necessary. We continue to find opportunities, and we continue to put capital to work against those opportunities.

Operator

operator
#57

Okay, thanks. We'll take our next question from Gary Yu at Morgan Stanley. Your line is open, so go ahead and ask.

Gary Yu

analyst
#58

Hello, and good evening. Thanks for giving me the chance to ask a question. I actually have two follow-ups to the earlier questions. The first concerns advertising margin. I realize that several factors are affecting that margin. Could management help us quantify or rank the different factors by how much impact they have? Whether it's lower eCPM from our more profitable inventory, or some of the COVID impact, or some of it being Video Accounts investment. So, given these various impacts, how should we think about the margin trend going forward? The second question is about the comment on cost optimization. Is there any room for more aggressive control when it comes to headcount-related G&A or R&D expenses? I understand there is still a slight increase in headcount in first quarter. Is there any further room for more optimization, either from non-core business or any other areas where we could see more aggressive cost cutting in this area? Thank you.

James Mitchell

executive
#59

Okay, regarding advertising margins — last quarter, we attempted to prioritize, or force-rank, the different factors influencing our ad business. The biggest one was regulations affecting demand, regulations hitting categories like education and games, which lowered demand for advertising. A smaller factor involved regulations affecting supply, like flash screen ads. Those had a somewhat negative effect on our ad network business, though less so on Moments or official accounts, where the issue was more about demand. Updating that framework for this quarter, COVID is now the dominant driver. The COVID situation is tragic and it creates negative consequences for ad spend for the three reasons I mentioned earlier. For us, while the current COVID outbreaks are being brought under control, they are very — it's a major challenge for the ad industry. Again, the good news is that although it took a period of time for COVID to be brought under control in Shanghai, it was controlled very quickly in Shenzhen.

James Mitchell

executive
#60

We've seen a very recent example of getting COVID successfully under control. The less favorable part for our ad business is that Shanghai serves, in a sense, as the hub for media advertising and marketing decisions across China, especially among multinationals, whereas Shenzhen does not. Given what's happening in Shanghai, the effect on advertising nationally is disproportionate. Thank you.

Operator

operator
#61

Thanks.

Martin Lau

analyst
#62

On cost control, let me address the second question. Regarding cost items tied to the organization and staff, our principle is that optimization happens on the basis of structural changes and structural needs. We're unlikely to respond to temporary factors that will disappear over the short to medium term. Looking at where things stand now, the added negative impact is largely connected to COVID. That's why we felt we wouldn't respond by further optimizing our organization and staff. We might pursue other cost controls, like cutting marketing costs. If there's another lockdown, then there's probably not much need to do as much marketing, for instance. Those are the routes we'll be examining. Organization and staff, I think, will be much more driven by structural factors.

Operator

operator
#63

Alright. Next up, we have a question from Elinor Leung at CLSA. Go ahead with your question.

Elinor Leung

analyst
#64

Thanks a lot, management, for giving me the chance to ask questions. My first question concerns the resumption of game approvals. Considering that just 45 new games were approved in the first month, do you believe there's a structural shift in the market whereby the government will approve fewer games than it did prior to the suspension? If so, how will that impact our future game growth should we receive fewer new games going forward? My second question relates to the mobile ad network. We observed a sharp decline this quarter stemming from the regulatory change, and how do you see the future of these mobile ad networks going forward? Thank you.

James Mitchell

executive
#65

When it comes to the mobile ad network, I'd say that's a sector with a global footprint. It's a sector that smaller and medium-sized apps and websites basically depend on to survive economically. In China, this sector isn't going anywhere. It has weathered, you know, plenty of earlier shocks, but we haven't discussed it much before because, during the PC internet era, Tencent was genuinely behind or simply absent from the PC ad network space. Only when mobile internet took off did we become a major player in mobile ad networks. In this cycle, the two major players in mobile ad network — us and ByteDance — differ from the major players of earlier cycles. Ad network has recovered from earlier cycles, and I'm confident it will recover from this one too, since on the supply side there's a huge volume of inventory sitting in those small and medium-sized apps that has to be monetized for those apps to keep going. On the demand side, there are always advertisers seeking incremental traffic, even when it comes from less branded media sites.

James Mitchell

executive
#66

Regarding the game ban hao, the answer is yes. Broadly speaking, our view is that game approvals going forward will be fewer than was the case before 2018. That has been our position for a couple of years now, and it is a major factor behind why, over the last two years, we have rebuilt our game business from top to bottom so that it focuses on releasing — and usually developing — a smaller number of larger-budget and, we hope, better games. We think we are genuinely the pioneer in the industry in doing this. At any given time, our pipeline is generally similar to or smaller than that of some competitors who have much larger headcount. The reason is that we assign more headcount to each game, in the belief that only a limited number of games will secure the ban hao going forward, and so we want that limited number of games to be all that they can be. I think that while we are very early in this, the results so far are quite positive. If you look at 2021, two of the games we released were the two most successful games in the industry as measured by users.

James Mitchell

executive
#67

So this year, Return to Empire now ranks second within the strategy category. It’s a genre with a modest user base but high ARPU. And more significantly, as we look ahead, we’re quite enthusiastic about how strong the content in our pipeline is. Once again, that pipeline is narrower — fewer projects, though in our view they are larger and superior titles compared with what we would have had 3 years ago, and that reflects both the regulatory climate and shifting user preferences. Even if regulation had not changed, players are getting more sophisticated and better informed regarding game quality. So concentrating more resources on a smaller number of bigger bets makes sense.

Wendy Huang

executive
#68

Operator, we have time for a final question.

Operator

operator
#69

Thanks. Our final question is from Alex Yao at J.P. Morgan. Go ahead with your question.

Alex Yao

analyst
#70

I appreciate the management team for taking my question. I have a couple of follow-up questions. First, on cloud: during this quarter, we observed the revenue impact on cloud stemming from the transition strategy. Could you share the margin trends since that transition? That's my first one. The second concerns video, specifically the long-form video business. I understand you are sharply focusing on cost optimization and margin improvement this year. Does that also apply to the video business? Is improving margin and reaching breakeven among your key priorities in this line of business? Thank you.

John Lo

executive
#71

Regarding how the cloud was affected where growth margin is concerned, it actually got somewhat better, since—as we’ve noted—we’re moving away from contracts that lose money. That genuinely benefited us during this quarter.

James Mitchell

executive
#72

On your Tencent Video question — “healthy” gets thrown around a lot, arguably too often when people talk about the Chinese internet. Our goal isn’t to push the video business into a short-lived breakeven. It’s to bring it, over time, to a position that is structurally healthy and sustainable. In fact, Tencent Video has hit breakeven in certain quarters already, but we failed to hold that level. What matters most is making it last. In video, landing a single quarter at breakeven isn’t hard. You can simply decide against commissioning costly content. Or, even if costly content has already been commissioned, you can decide not to air it during that quarter, since the reported P&L for that quarter then looks better than it really is. Alternatively, in the current quarter you can write off capitalized video content. You take a large loss this quarter, and then next quarter you air that content, and it still draws some traffic and revenue. The incremental margin looks very high on the surface, even when the true economic return isn’t attractive. All of those are moves available to anyone who wants breakeven next quarter.

James Mitchell

executive
#73

You know, that isn't the goal we're aiming for. What we're aiming for is simply getting the business into a structurally healthy position. You know, I think we've already completed what I hope was the hardest part, which is that, you know, Tencent Video was the eighth or ninth company to enter this space in China. Today it's the clear leader when it comes to subscribers, when it comes to subscription revenue, when it comes to advertising revenue. As I mentioned, it has already reached breakeven in some quarters in the past. You know, now we want to move toward a sustainably profitable position. You know, part of that involves continuing to optimize revenue through price rationalization and so forth. Another part involves being continually selective about the content that we air. You know, when we were moving from ninth place to seventh place to fifth place, we had to compete in every kind of content because we didn't know which content really mattered. Now that we're in first place, we have much greater clarity on, you know, what content counts, what content doesn't. We can be more selective about allocating our spending to the content that counts. Finally, you know, somewhat differentiated, we also have, you know, the opportunity that we're seizing to benefit from, you know, the vertical integration with, you know, upstream IP over which we already have influence, whether that's because the upstream IP is a web novel within China Literature, or it's content produced by New Classics Media, or it's a mobile game from the Tencent game portfolio.

James Mitchell

executive
#74

Look, for a long time now, the long-form video business in China has been a really tough industry — many years of that. At this point, it's about as hard as it has ever been. Costs and ARPU are two areas where the industry has shifted to a far more rational position. We're trying to keep that movement going and, in the end, turn this into a business that delivers good returns — the same way long-form video does elsewhere around the world. Thank you.

Wendy Huang

executive
#75

Thanks, James. I appreciate all of you being here on today's call. We're wrapping things up at this point. Should you want to review our press release along with other financial details, you can find them in the IR section of our corporate site at Tencent.com. A replay of this webcast is going to be posted shortly as well. Thanks again, and we'll talk to you in the next quarter.

Operator

operator
#76

Appreciate it. That brings today's conference to a close. Thanks for joining us. Everyone may now disconnect.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Tencent Holdings Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Tencent Holdings Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Tencent Holdings Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.