Tencent Holdings Limited (700) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

August 16, 2023

Hong Kong Stock Exchange HK Communication Services Interactive Media and Services earnings 74 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Wendy Huang

executive
#1

Hello and good afternoon or good evening, everyone. Thanks for being with us. This is the webcast for Tencent Holdings Limited's announcement of results for the second quarter of 2023, and we're glad you could join. Wendy Huang here, from Tencent's IR team. <<operator_script>> Please note that this session is being recorded today. Before the presentation begins, we'd like to remind everyone that it contains forward-looking statements. Those statements are subject to a number of risks and uncertainties and might not come to pass in the future for various reasons. Information on general market conditions is drawn from a variety of sources outside of Tencent. This presentation also includes some unaudited non-IFRS financial measures, which should be considered alongside, but not as a replacement for, measures of the group's financial performance prepared in accordance with IFRS. For a detailed discussion of risk factors and non-IFRS measures, please see our disclosure documents in the IR section of our website. Let me introduce the management team joining us tonight. Our Chairman and CEO, Pony Ma, will begin with a brief overview. President Martin Lau and Chief Strategy Officer James Mitchell will then provide a business review and an update on our progress with some strategic growth drivers. Chief Financial Officer John Lo will wrap up with a financial discussion before we open the floor for questions.

Wendy Huang

executive
#2

I'll hand things over to Pony now.

Huateng Ma

executive
#3

All right. Thanks, Wendy. Good evening, and thank you all for being with us. In Q2 2023, we maintained a healthy pace of revenue expansion while shifting toward revenue of higher quality with improved margins. That shift, together with prudent cost control built up over prior years, meant profit grew faster than revenue, and we saw especially swift expansion in advertising revenue, helped by applying machine learning across our ad platform and by monetizing Video Accounts. Now I'll walk through the headline financial figures for the quarter. Total revenue came to RMB 149 billion, an increase of 11% year-on-year, or a decline of 1% quarter-on-quarter. Gross profit reached RMB 71 billion, rising 22% year-on-year and 4% quarter-on-quarter. Non-IFRS operating profit stood at RMB 50 billion, up 37% year-on-year and 4% quarter-on-quarter. Non-IFRS net profit attributable to equity holders was RMB 38 billion, climbing 33% year-on-year and 15% quarter-on-quarter. Moving to our key services. In communications and social networks, the combined MAU of Weixin and WeChat grew both year-on-year and quarter-on-quarter to CNY 1.3 billion, with stronger synergies across Video Accounts, Mini Programs and Moments. On games, we launched 2 high-quality PC titles in China — our most significant PC game releases since 2015. In generative AI, we are testing our own proprietary foundation model internally across various use cases, and we offer Tencent Cloud Model-as-a-Service solutions that support efficient deployment of open-source foundation models across multiple industry verticals.

Huateng Ma

executive
#4

Now I'll turn things over to Martin and James for the business review.

Chi Ping Lau

executive
#5

Thanks, Pony, and hello everyone, whether you're joining us in the evening or the morning. Total revenue for the second quarter of 2023 rose 11% compared with a year earlier. Value-added services accounted for 50% of overall revenue, and inside that, the social networks subsegment made up 20%. The domestic games subsegment came in at 21%, while international games contributed 9%. Online advertising was 17% of the total, and FinTech and Business Services represented 32%. Within value-added services, segment revenue reached RMB 74 billion, a 4% increase year-on-year. Social networks revenue climbed 2% year-on-year to RMB 30 billion, powered by higher revenue from Mini Games and music subscriptions, though that gain was partly offset by weaker revenue from music and games related live streaming services. Long-form video subscription revenue fell 2% year-on-year. Video subscriptions dropped 5% year-on-year, yet rose 2% quarter-on-quarter to CNY 115 million, helped by our original animated series and drama series. We keep improving how we produce content. As an example, we now use Unreal Engine to produce animated content, including our series the Land of Warriors, so as to streamline the workflow and boost production capacity and efficiency. Music subscription revenue grew 37% year-on-year, with both ARPU and subscriptions rising at double-digit rates year-on-year. TME has expanded its subscription offerings when it comes to membership privileges and content.

Chi Ping Lau

executive
#6

Also, in June our music subscription count hit an all-time peak of 100 million. For Domestic Games, revenue held steady compared with a year earlier at RMB 32 billion, which was partly because we scheduled less commercial content for our largest games following a particularly strong first quarter. Revenue rose for our newer competitive eSports titles that are still growing, namely Arena Breakout and Fight of the Golden Spatula. International games revenue climbed 19% versus a year ago, or 12% when measured in constant currency, reaching RMB 13 billion, helped by the strong showing from VALORANT, NIKKE and Triple Match 3D. Turning now to communications and social networks. Weixin's total user time spent grew at a healthy pace during the second quarter, helped by deeper engagement across Video Accounts, Mini Programs and Moments. Video Accounts grew its user base and deepened how engaged users are. Overall time spent nearly doubled compared with a year earlier in the second quarter, powered by double-digit DAU growth and considerably quicker growth in per-user time spent. At the same time, we saw robust gains in user interactions including likes and comments. We are reinforcing our content ecosystem by enabling a flourishing creator community, as daily active creators and daily video uploads maintained strong year-on-year growth in the second quarter. We offer tools that assist creators in expanding their presence on Video Accounts and that also add to growth in our ad revenue.

Chi Ping Lau

executive
#7

With deeper user engagement and a stronger content ecosystem as our foundation, we're achieving meaningful progress when it comes to broadening monetization opportunities in Video Accounts. On the advertising side, we're at an early phase of building a substantial revenue stream that carries high incremental margins. We think considerable revenue potential remains to be captured down the road. Live streaming e-commerce, which remains in an early stage of development, delivered 150% year-on-year GMV growth in the second quarter, giving us a chance to establish a new commission-based revenue stream with high margins. In the course of the quarter, we enhanced the consumer shopping experience and lifted repeat sales for merchants by sourcing additional branded products, rolling out shipping return insurance and upgrading customer service functionalities. Moving on to Mini Programs. We now serve over 1.1 billion users each month, and their engagement rose significantly, with time spent per DAU growing double digit year-on-year in the second quarter. 4 million developers took part in our Mini Program ecosystem, providing a wide range of Mini Programs, from public services and productivity tools to AI-powered photo editors. Today, I'd like to take you through our recent success in Mini Games as an example of a vertical use case. Mini Games drew over 400 million MAU, and 300,000 game developers built upon the Mini Program framework.

Chi Ping Lau

executive
#8

Mini games—covering casual titles, card games, and plenty of other categories—are actively built and run by both the major game publishers and smaller studios. During Q2, over 100 mini games each brought in quarterly gross receipts above RMB 10 million. This robust expansion shows developers a compelling value proposition on our side. First, for those with fresh game ideas, we lower the barriers to entry and the costs of launching. Via social sharing plus the existing login and instant-play infrastructure that the Weixin ecosystem provides, they can grow a user base. Second, for developers whose app games are already successful, porting to mini games lets them reach a new audience of non-app users. Third, advances in mini games infrastructure benefit developers, who can draw on our know-how and game technology. Our infrastructure, for instance, now handles sophisticated genres like shooters, with quick loading and smooth gameplay. Mini Games carry major strategic value for Tencent as well. First, via Mini Games we host China's biggest casual game community, with hundreds of millions of MAU—substantially more than the MAU of the market's largest app-based casual games. Second, Mini Games let us broaden our audience base and cultivate new gamers.

Chi Ping Lau

executive
#9

More than half of Mini Games MAU don't play games on Tencent apps, and 50% of Mini Games MAU are women. And lastly, from Mini Games we get game distribution plus ad revenues that come with high margins and platform economics rather than hit-driven dynamics. On the reporting side, what we book as revenue is net platform fees paid to Tencent, not gross user spend, and those fees land in the social networks subsegment rather than the games subsegment. So when third-party Mini Games grow, our game segment revenue doesn't gain from it — instead it comes through to our VAS segment as high-margin revenues. Developers are also able to purchase advertising, which adds to our advertising revenue. With that, I'll pass it to James now for the other business updates.

James Mitchell

executive
#10

I appreciate that, Martin. When it comes to domestic games, both MAU and DAU for our mobile and PC titles rose year-on-year during the second quarter. Having rolled out a heavy slate of highly commercial content in the first quarter, we scaled back those releases in the second quarter. Looking at quarter-to-date trends, that pullback proved temporary, and we expect Domestic Game revenue to return to year-on-year growth in the third quarter. Over a longer horizon, 3 of the new games we launched during the past 2 years — Fight of the Golden Spatula, Arena Breakout and Wild Rift — have been steadily growing their user bases, and by total time spent in the second quarter, each ranked among the top 10 mobile games across all developers in China. Although different new titles from various developers appear on the top download and top grossing charts from one month to the next, our attention is more on cultivating evergreen successes, where the total time spent trend serves as a stronger leading indicator of longevity and of long-term revenue generation. As an example, Fight of the Golden Spatula hit a new milestone of 15 million daily active users in June and placed fourth by total time spent across all mobile games in China during the quarter.

James Mitchell

executive
#11

Arena Breakout also set a record for DAU in Q2 and came in eighth among all mobile games for time spent. We think Arena Breakout is the first high production value extraction shooter of its kind on mobile anywhere in the world, and we rolled the game out to international markets through July. At the same time, our existing long-life titles showed they remain vital. Naruto Mobile, launched in 2016, hit all-time highs in gross receipts and average DAUs in Q2, thanks to engaging gameplay, added stories and appealing new characters with distinctive combat techniques. Even with several competitive launches over the years, Naruto Mobile remains the clear leader in China's fighting genre. Dungeon & Fighter shipped its 15th anniversary content update in June, featuring a more contemporary anime type art style and better combat visuals. As a result, DnF's average DAU rose by a double-digit percentage year-on-year in June. Q2 was a quiet period for our new mobile game launches, but we have recently launched 2 big PC games in China, which will start contributing to revenue in Q3. VALORANT, a top tactical shooter in international markets, was our most successful PC game release ever in China, measured by the number of active users on launch day.

James Mitchell

executive
#12

Looking at all the titles that have come out since 2019, VALORANT ranks as the most watched game across the major live streaming platforms. As for Lost Ark, it's presently the top-played MMO action RPG on Steam, thanks to a training combat system, a gripping narrative, and wide-ranging exploration of its game world. Ever since we brought Lost Ark to China in July, it has turned into the most popular MMO on live streaming platforms there. Moving on to International Games: we observed continued expansion in PC games, indications that the post-pandemic slowdown in activity is receding for mobile games, and favorable contributions from a few titles launched recently. VALORANT kept up its robust results, with DAU and gross receipts both up year-on-year, powered by the arrival of Gekko, a popular new agent, plus appealing items such as weapons and skins, along with Premier, a new game mode delivering a professional tournament experience. Following an extended post-pandemic period of consolidation, PUBG MOBILE went back to year-on-year gains in DAU and gross receipts in June, propelled by an upgraded Royale Pass system, a fresh dinosaur-themed game mode, and fruitful brand collaborations with Bearbrick and Ducati. NIKKE, since launching in November last year, has boosted user engagement via popular content updates, among them new premium characters, additional story lines featuring fully voiced scenes, and successful thematic events.

James Mitchell

executive
#13

On the online advertising side, revenue rose 34% compared with a year earlier, reaching RMB 25 billion. Now, our growth rate definitely got a lift from the comparison with a pandemic-depressed period 12 months back, but we think we outperformed the industry overall, and we put that down to improvements in the machine learning systems that power our ad platform, along with strong demand for Video Accounts ads. Ad spend rose at a double-digit year-on-year pace across every major advertiser category apart from transportation. On Weixin, Video Accounts ad revenue came in above RMB 3 billion in the second quarter. More broadly, rolling out e-commerce tools — things like discovery of live streaming e-commerce and digital shops inside Video Accounts — helped make Weixin's wider e-commerce ecosystem more vibrant, drawing merchants and brands to put bigger ad budgets into multiple Weixin properties. As a result, during the quarter, ad revenue was up year-on-year not just for Video Accounts but also for Moments, Mini Programs and official accounts. On the content platform side, our music ad revenue posted notable year-on-year growth, fueled by the ad-supported music service and by brand sponsorship of offline music events, including TME's Wave Maker event. Revenue from our mobile ad network climbed significantly year-on-year, helped by partnerships with apps that hold high commercial value inventory. We upgraded the infrastructure of our mobile ad networks, improving efficiency and matching advertiser demand with traffic supply, which delivers higher ROIs for advertisers.

James Mitchell

executive
#14

Turning to FinTech and Business Services. Revenue for the segment came in at RMB 49 billion, which is 15% higher than a year earlier. To begin with FinTech services for commercial payments: both daily active users and transactions per use rose compared with last year, and payment volumes, online as well as off-line, expanded year-on-year at rates similar to those seen for consumption spending generally as it picked up. In our Wealth Management business, the second quarter brought healthy growth, since we stepped up investor education and services, and both users and AUM went up year-on-year. Regarding regulation, our self-inspection and the corresponding rectification for Tenpay are now complete, and we have upgraded the compliance capability of our payment business. We are eager to move our business forward and deliver innovative services within the supportive regulatory framework. As for Business Services, revenue growth year-on-year got back to a low double-digit rate during the quarter, powered by fees collected on Video Accounts live streaming commerce transactions along with modest growth of cloud services. Cloud services revenue gained from higher spending by industries such as finance and automotive. Gross margin for business services rose notably year-on-year, thanks to cost optimization and also the new fee-based revenue streams. Inside Cloud Services, we introduced Model-as-a-Service solutions, drawing on our proprietary vector database in high-performance computing clusters, which are letting enterprises across multiple industries, tourism and public services among them, build customized large models with greater efficiency and lower costs.

James Mitchell

executive
#15

And at this point I'll hand things over to John.

Shek Hon Lo

executive
#16

Thanks, James. Hi, everyone. In Q2 2023, our total revenue came to RMB 149.2 billion, which is an 11% increase compared with the same quarter a year earlier. Gross profit reached RMB 70.8 billion, rising 22% year-on-year. Net other losses stood at RMB 0.2 billion, primarily due to costs tied to compliance, partly offset by net gains from deemed disposals and from disposing of certain investee companies. Operating profit was RMB 40.3 billion, a 34% year-on-year rise. Net finance costs amounted to RMB 3.4 billion, up 82% year-on-year. That rise reflected ForEx losses this quarter versus gains in the same period last year, plus higher interest expenses. Our share of profit from associates and JVs was RMB 1.2 billion, compared with a share of loss of RMB 4.5 billion in Q2 2022. On a non-IFRS basis, the share of profit was RMB 3.9 billion, an improvement from a share of loss of RMB 100 billion last year. This reflected stronger profitability at certain domestic associates, driven by revenue growth and better cost efficiency. Income tax expense rose 144% year-on-year to RMB 11.1 billion, owing to pretax profit growth, a higher withholding tax provision, and a tune up of a deferred tax adjustment tied to an overseas subsidiary.

Shek Hon Lo

executive
#17

On an IFRS basis, net profit attributable to equity holders came in at RMB 26.2 billion, an increase of 41% year-on-year. Diluted EPS reached RMB 2.695, also up 41% year-on-year. Next, let me walk you through our non-IFRS figures. Operating profit was RMB 50.1 billion, 37% higher year-on-year. Net profit attributable to equity holders stood at RMB 37.5 billion, up 33% year-on-year. Diluted EPS was RMB 3.875, representing 34% growth year-on-year. Turning to gross margins. The overall gross margin came to 47.5%, an increase of 4.3 percentage points year-on-year. Looking at it by segment, VAS gross margin was 54%, up 3.4 percentage points year-on-year, which was driven by high-margin game-related revenue, including revenue from Mini Games, along with a higher music subscription margin stemming from subscriber growth and ARPU expansion, as well as cost efficiency gains across our digital content services. Online advertising gross margin reached 48.9%, 8.3 percentage points higher year-on-year, thanks to a greater mix of high-margin Video Accounts at fair revenue and better cost efficiencies. FinTech and Business Services gross margin was 38.4%, up 5.1 percentage points year-on-year, reflecting cost optimization in cloud services and high-margin revenue from Video Accounts livestreaming e-commerce transactions. Now on to operating expenses. Selling and marketing expenses totaled RMB 8.3 billion, up 5% year-on-year and equal to 5.6% of revenues. R&D expenses amounted to RMB 16 billion, up 7% year-on-year.

Shek Hon Lo

executive
#18

General and administrative costs, not counting R&D, came to RMB 9.4 billion, a 16% decline versus a year earlier, largely driven by a smaller workforce along with share-based compensation expenses. At the close of the quarter, our headcount stood at roughly 105,000 employees, which represents a 6% decrease year-on-year, or 2% lower quarter-on-quarter. Now let's turn to our operating and net margin ratios. In the second quarter of 2023, the non-IFRS operating margin reached 33.6%, an increase of 6.2 percentage points compared with the same period last year. Non-IFRS net margin came in at 25.9%, 4.3 percentage points higher year-on-year. In closing, I'd like to point out several key metrics on cash flow and the balance sheet. Total CapEx amounted to RMB 4 billion, rising 31% year-on-year. Of that total CapEx, operating CapEx was RMB 3 billion, climbing 43% year-on-year, fueled by greater investment in GPUs and servers. Nonoperating CapEx grew 6% year-on-year, reaching RMB 1 billion. Free cash flow during the quarter totaled RMB 29.9 billion, an increase of 34% year-on-year, thanks to higher operating cash flow and lower CapEx payments. Our net cash position was RMB 17.7 billion, a 44% drop quarter-on-quarter. That sequential movement stemmed primarily from dividend payments and share repurchases made during the quarter. Thank you.

Wendy Huang

executive
#19

Thanks, John. At this point we’ll open it up for questions.

Wendy Huang

executive
#20

<<operator_script>> We’ll now go to our first question, from Ronald Keung at Goldman Sachs.

Ronald Keung

analyst
#21

And nice work on the impressive numbers. First thing I'd like to ask about is advertising, which came in really robust at 34%, helped by Video Accounts as you just referenced, and that's above RMB 3 billion, so we're back to positive growth on a 2-year CAGR basis, more or less. So with several different drivers behind Video Accounts monetization, how does management view the second half outlook? You also brought up the algo upgrades involving machine learning on the back end, plus live streaming — those are the positives. So when we factor in the macro as well, how should we frame the second half advertising growth outlook following such a strong second quarter?

James Mitchell

executive
#22

Yes, thanks for asking, Ronald. The second quarter came in strong. April gave us an unusually easy comparison base for advertising, since that month was really the toughest point of last year's lockdowns. After that, growth in May and June was still fast, though less so, and that pattern is carrying into July. Across recent weeks, every ad category other than automotive has continued to post double-digit year-on-year gains. Looking ahead to the remainder of the year, advertising obviously does hinge somewhat on domestic consumption patterns. Still, it's worth remembering a few things: first, domestic consumption patterns weren't particularly strong in the second quarter, and even so we delivered 34% year-on-year growth. Second, we have our own internal drivers, especially the ad tech improvements and the monetization of Video Accounts. And third, should domestic consumption turn substantially weaker later in the year, advertisers would naturally respond by first cutting back on the lower ROI inventories they've been buying, and we believe the ad tech platform enhancements we've implemented, which draw on large neural network models, have considerably raised the ROI of advertising on our platform.

James Mitchell

executive
#23

So if weakness were to show up, we'd likely spot it after others do. Broadly speaking, we're definitely keeping a close eye on the macro risks, but macro risk has been present throughout the year, and we're optimistic that we'll keep growing faster than the industry for the remainder of the year.

Ronald Keung

analyst
#24

To build on that point about generative AI, which is the leading theme here — beyond the business segment, I'd like to hear more about our consumer-facing side. Is there anything we're considering around chatbot or anything else inside our Tencent ecosystem, and connecting that to the advertising question, do you expect any forms of monetization to emerge from generative AI usage scenarios?

Chi Ping Lau

executive
#25

Yeah. So when it comes to general AI — and, more broadly, the foundation model — I'd say we view both the opportunity and the technology in a much wider way than simply a chatbot or a question-and-answer kind of experience. That is, of course, a product form factor that could be added over time to our large DAU products such as Weixin and QQ. But to look at it in a broader sense, right, AI is — the more closely we examine it, the more excited we get about that asset growth multiplier across our many businesses. It would help enhance efficiency and the quality of our user-to-user services, and at the same time, you enable improvement in our ad targeting, data targeting, and also the cost-efficient production of a lot of our content. So there really are multiple ways in which we can benefit from the continued development of generative AI. And as for the development itself, I'd say there are multiple initiatives underway at the company. The first one, obviously, is building our own proprietary foundation model, and that is actually going very well. The training is on track and making very good progress.

Chi Ping Lau

executive
#26

We've begun internal testing across our various businesses — games, ads cloud, and FinTech — so they can start trialing the model and begin work on integration. Regarding how the model has performed up to now, I'd say, based on our own testing, it ranks among the top leading foundation models built in China. And we're working very relentlessly on upgrades and iteration, right, to get it ready for launch at some point later this year. On the additional efforts front, we're also on the cloud side, offering a MaaS solution for enterprises, right? Essentially we provide a marketplace so that various enterprise clients can pick different kinds of open source large models to customize with their own data for their own use. And we have a full set of technology infrastructure plus tools to help them make that choice as well as handle the training and the deployment. We believe this will be a pretty high value added and high margin product for enterprise clients. At the same time, our various products have already been deploying different types of AIGC tools to boost their efficiency or sharpen their product competitiveness.

Chi Ping Lau

executive
#27

Take Tencent Meeting, for instance — it's already been using a model built by one of the companies we've invested in, and that model generates summaries of meeting notes. The user experience it delivers is genuinely solid, and customers are seeing real productivity gains from it. So on several fronts, I'd say we're actively embracing generative AI, and each of those efforts is moving forward quite well. Looking toward the medium and longer term, we see this as a strongly favorable force for our business.

Wendy Huang

executive
#28

Kenneth Fong from Credit Suisse has the next question.

Kenneth Fong

analyst
#29

And congratulations on another strong set of results. My first question concerns games. I understand that a shortage of major title releases explains why domestic game revenue has been rather flat. Yet setting the new games to one side, since monetization of our legacy games remains at a very low level, how should we view the longevity of existing titles and the potential for growth ahead? And then on the VAS GT margin. In the second quarter it was flat quarter over quarter, whereas historically it is usually down 2 percentage points. So how should we think about whether that margin can be sustained going forward? And I have a follow-up.

James Mitchell

executive
#30

Kenneth, regarding your second question: the gross margin gain in the Value-added Service business is structural, and it stems from several favorable mix shifts. One mix shift is the very rapid growth in Mini Game activity. And as Martin discussed, we record Mini Games on a net revenue basis rather than a gross revenue basis. So the flow-through from Mini Game reported revenue to gross profit is substantially higher than for the traditional game business. Another factor that has affected us more recently is the reduction in live streaming entertainment revenue at our subsidiaries, Tencent Music and HUYA and as you're probably aware, that revenue is unusually low margin. So those are 2 examples of structural shifts away from lower-margin revenue streams toward higher-margin revenue streams, which we view as ongoing, and therefore, we believe the higher levels of Value-added Service gross margin is sustainable. On the game question, then we believe that the primary driver of the flat domestic game revenue in the second quarter was not lack of new titles. We did launch some PC game titles. We didn't launch many mobile game titles, but even if we had, revenue from life cycle contribute more later in the year than during the second quarter.

James Mitchell

executive
#31

The main reason was that we chose to hold back some content that doesn't drive as much commercial activity for a while. In Q1, we put out a big batch of commercially impactful content, and that made our game grossing receipts go up quite a lot — considerably more than our game domestic revenue. Then in Q2, we sort of took a pause. And by Q3, we had gone back to releasing that commercially impactful content. On the longevity question for our evergreen games, we pointed to several data points covering both larger and smaller titles, plus some of the newer games we're hoping to build into evergreen status, such as Fight of the Golden Spatula, Arena Breakout, and Wild Rift. Broadly speaking, when you stack our competitive eSports-style evergreen titles against the more content-driven ones, the gap in retention is enormous, and for a lot of our competitive eSports titles there are actually stretches — and Fight of the Golden Spatula has been in that situation over recent months — when net churn turns negative, which means new content, in this case Set 9, brought back more returning users or more lapsed users than the number we actually churned out of the game, and that's something you don't really see in content-driven games.

James Mitchell

executive
#32

We’ve got a lot of years of experience running evergreen games. A few of our older evergreen titles, such as League of Legends and Honor of Kings, remain very healthy today when it comes to users and monetization. One part of running those games across decades instead of years or quarters is switching between quarters with heavier commercialization and quarters with lighter commercialization. The upside, though, is that those games stay popular and endure for decades. And that’s what we’re now hoping to accomplish as well with the new games that would be evergreen, like Fight for the Golden Spatula, Arena Breakout, and Wild Rift.

Chi Ping Lau

executive
#33

Another thing I want to bring up is that I believe our game revenue doesn't truly reflect the full picture of how our game franchise is developing. The reason is that it doesn't really capture how quickly our presence has grown in the casual games segment, which has come through building out our Mini Games platform, right? That Mini Games platform is now, by a wide margin, the biggest mini — casual game platform in China, and compared with any casual game title or platform in China, I think it has several times the user base and several times the gross receipts. Yet the financial benefit doesn't actually appear in game revenue. In fact, what shows up is only a commission rather than the full gross receipts. And that actually appears in VAS revenue instead of games revenue. So a very significant development and growth in our casual games segment was in fact not reflected in game revenue.

Kenneth Fong

analyst
#34

Understood. For my second question, I want to focus on the advertising side. We've observed that we have many initiatives underway, and internally we're upgrading our ad system, which raises ROI across the board and helps us beat peers. On the external side, we've also seen some cross-platform partnerships—for example, during 618 we had a major e-commerce platform plus some Mini Game ads running inside other short-form video platforms. So given the near-term macro picture, which remains uncertain, how many more of these operational initiatives or opportunities are available for us to capture in order to drive growth and keep outperforming peers going forward?

James Mitchell

executive
#35

I think there are quite a few opportunities here, both over the longer term and more immediately — and some are immediate while others will keep developing. Then, when you look at Video Accounts, the ad load is only a tiny fraction of what our peers already run, so as we move forward we'll steadily raise our ad load, and mechanically that means more revenue. On top of that, roughly half of our peers' advertising revenue comes from endemic, or kind of native, advertisers who are doing e-commerce inside their short video services. So as e-commerce grows within Video Accounts, drawing on our existing Mini Program and Tenpay infrastructure, we're well positioned to cultivate that opportunity of roughly doubling advertising revenue. And then, as Martin discussed, time spent — which is the ultimate raw material for advertising revenue in Video Accounts — nearly doubled year-on-year as well. So there's a very long runway for Video Accounts, driven by higher time spent, driven by normalizing ad flow, driven by cultivating endemic advertisers. Then on advertising technology: if you look at the big ad tech-driven companies in the West, such as Meta, that's a never-ending journey — just continuing to invest more in CPU and then GPU-driven machine learning infrastructure, continuing to enhance the neural network models doing the ad targeting, continuing to shrink the rate at which you update the models, from weekly, daily, hourly to minute-by-minute to real-time, and that's a gift that appears to never stop giving.

James Mitchell

executive
#36

Whether we like it or not, when it comes to certain parts of that ad tech rollout, we still haven't reached parity with Meta. Still, we think there's a longer path ahead for us, both because we're less far along that path and because we hold so many distinct types of inventory and so many distinct types of data that neither our global peers nor our local peers can access. On top of that, we have fresh advertising inventories, for example the search inventory inside Weixin. All in all, we think there's plenty of runway for growth. And sure, the broader economy is uncertain, but it has been uncertain for the last couple of years, it was uncertain during the first half of this year, and we've managed to grow through all of that. And we think we'll continue growing down the line as we improve the return on investment for advertisers and, in turn, improve what advertisers are prepared to spend with us.

Wendy Huang

executive
#37

Alicia Yap from Citi will be our next questioner.

Alicis a Yap

analyst
#38

Let me start with the Tencent Cloud Model-as-a-Service offering. Does management expect this to be taken up first by bigger companies in the sector that handle huge amounts of data? Beyond tourism and public services, which you brought up, which other verticals do you intend to move into? Do you think mid-sized and smaller firms could likewise gain from it and roll out the service? And finally, does this Model-as-a-Service product bring in strong recurring revenue and carry a better margin compared with the business services you currently offer? On my second question, I'd like to follow up regarding advertising. Could management go into a bit more detail on precisely which machine learning integrations on your ad platform are helping ad revenue — it really seems this is only the very start, and we may see a greater positive effect from this AI on ad revenue growth going forward. Any color you can provide would be appreciated.

Chi Ping Lau

executive
#39

Yes. Regarding the AI and Model-as-a-Service offering, we believe many industries stand to gain from it, correct? At first, it would certainly be larger companies. As for sectors beyond tourism and public services, we think areas like financial institutions, retail enterprises—particularly the big ones—industrial firms, and even some midsized Internet companies, right? These are the businesses that possess data and user engagement, and I believe they could train their own models and genuinely help with how they interact with customers. Over time, as the sector matures, obviously, medium-sized and smaller enterprises will likely see benefits too. But I don't believe they'll gain from training their own model, right? Instead, they'd likely gain by using models that are already trained directly via APIs. So that's roughly how I think the industry will probably develop over time. On the business model side, obviously, the revenue model is still taking shape, but I'd say, in theory, the high margin and high recurring revenue you mentioned will hold true, because we're adding more value for customers.

Chi Ping Lau

executive
#40

And once customers begin using these services, right, they'll be baked into how they interact with their own customers, and that's going to be far stickier than having it sit in their back-end systems. So I'd say that's probably true. And when it comes to the ad platform, I'd say — I think James covered a good deal of that, right? If you look at the key changes, or the key things we've done regarding machine learning on the ad platform, I think the traditional challenge for us is that we have many different platforms. We have many different types of inventories. We have a very large coverage of user base and a lot of data, right? And all these things make it actually very complicated for us to target customers based on just rule-based or CPU-based targeting system, which was actually what we have been deploying. And a key change is that we have deployed a lot of GPUs, so moving from CPUs to GPUs and we have built a very large neural network to basically accept all these different complexities and be able to come up with the optimal solution. And as a result, our ad targeting becomes much more effective and much higher speed and more accurate in terms of targeting.

Chi Ping Lau

executive
#41

So because of that, at this moment it genuinely gives a really powerful lift to how well we can target, and also to the ROI our ad systems are able to deliver. And as James mentioned, this is kind of an early phase of this rollout and of the ongoing enhancement of our technology, and I believe this trend is going to keep going.

Wendy Huang

executive
#42

Moving on, our next question comes from Robin Zhu at Bernstein.

Robin Zhu

analyst
#43

Okay, a couple of questions if I may. First, on games specifically: could you discuss the upcoming launch slate? Given everyone wants visibility there, what are you especially excited about on the new games side? And could you update us on how AAA game development is progressing? I know the company made a pivot, what, 2 or 3 years ago now — I'd just like an update on how you think that's going. Then a housekeeping item on Mini Games. Management is clearly very enthusiastic about it. Why not share some financials about it and what it's contributing? There used to be a line for smartphone games that you stopped disclosing at the end of last year, so thoughts on bringing that back. Second question on e-commerce — another important growth driver. I'm wondering whether management can share some thoughts on the size of total e-commerce across WeChat, how much it's growing, and how much of that is live streaming at the moment, and whether management has plans or targets for reaching peer levels of scale on the e-commerce front. Thank you.

James Mitchell

executive
#44

Robin, regarding the games, there are quite a few titles—domestic and international—that we're eager to launch over the next several months, in no specific order and without suggesting any preference. On the domestic side, we have the high ability heroes game. We have an Honor of Kings tie-in. We have a Need for Speed game. Internationally, just within the past 2 weeks, I believe, Riot showcased their new fighting game at the major fighting tournaments in Las Vegas, and it got an excellent reception; Grinding Gear Games has displayed Path of Exile 2, which has drawn a very positive reception. And then there are several games being developed in China and distributed globally that matter and are interesting too. As for the Mini Game disclosures, we assess what ought to be disclosed on an ongoing basis, and we'll keep your counsel in mind.

Chi Ping Lau

executive
#45

When it comes to e-commerce, I'd say that prior to Video Accounts going live along with live streaming e-commerce — right — there were already plenty of commerce activities taking place on our Mini programs. Those sit in the trillions on an annualized GMV basis. And a meaningful share of that, I believe, actually relates to physical products, to e-commerce. So if you look at physical product e-commerce GMV, it exceeds RMB 1 trillion on an annualized GMV basis. Then when you look at live streaming — right — that represents a new revenue source and a new set of e-commerce activities. Its size so far runs in the tens of billions of RMB on an annualized run rate. That's why we feel it's really at a very early stage of development. The key difference, though, is that these are e-commerce revenues on which we can charge a take rate. And at the same time, it genuinely helps many merchants acquire new customers. With the Mini Programs e-commerce activities, merchants are basically using their own channels to serve existing customers and to try to drive repeat purchases from those existing customers, whereas with live streaming e-commerce activity, they're actually leveraging this platform to market their products and services to a new set of customers — right?

Chi Ping Lau

executive
#46

So it really reflects a different dynamic, and at the same time — without — over time it complements the Mini Program and e-commerce activities too. So I'd say live streaming e-commerce is a really nice addition to the e-commerce activities across the whole ecosystem, and it would actually generate considerably more revenue for us too, since it brings in commission revenue. It also drives more advertising within Video Accounts, because all those merchants will be spending ad dollars to bring new customers into their live streaming e-commerce sessions.

Wendy Huang

executive
#47

Our next question comes from William Packer at BNP.

William Packer

analyst
#48

To start, there have been a fair number of shifting pieces when it comes to regulation since our previous earnings call—among them a sizable fine, though we've also heard encouraging remarks about the platform economy from several state institutions. First, as with the prior quarter, could you bring us up to date on what's happened in recent months on the domestic gaming, short-form video, and FinTech regulatory fronts? Then, as a follow-up: the Cyberspace Administration of China has put forward new rules aimed at protecting minors online. Could you tell us about any possible effect those new rules might have on your business? Setting aside video games, which you've already covered, do you have an estimate of the revenue exposure to those aged 18 and below?

Chi Ping Lau

executive
#49

Alright, so I think we've covered industry regulation before. In earlier discussions, we noted the trend was moving in the direction of normalization. This time, beyond that continuing shift toward normalization, there's actually a somewhat more supportive posture, and that comes from several new developments. First, as you can see, top leadership has lately on multiple occasions restated how prominent a role the private sector plays, as well as the platform economy, and has restated its intent to nurture healthy and sustainable growth among platform companies. So that's point one. When it comes to the various vertical ministries, right, I think there are several different examples. On FinTech, the financial regulators in early July basically said they've wrapped up the disciplinary action against the FinTech sector. And going forward, their focus will be on normalized regulation, plus supporting and encouraging platform economies to keep up their work on financial inclusion. On the investment side, the NDRC on July 12 put out a statement acknowledging Internet platforms' investments in start-ups, and those start-ups have added to technology innovation, and Tencent was named specifically with regard to 2 investments.

Chi Ping Lau

executive
#50

On the games side, we’re seeing Banhao issuance continue at a normalized pace. So I’d say that across all the various segments where we have a meaningful business, the regulatory environment has been moving toward normalization and has become more supportive overall. Now, regarding the CAC consultation paper on minors protection, our view is, first, that we fully support and embrace the policy, because this is something we have already been doing across many of our different products. For instance, in games, we have already put the mandatory protection measures in place. And that measure is in fact much more stringent than what the consultation proposed. And within Video Accounts, the time spent limit in teenage mode for us is 40 minutes per day, which is at the low end of the consultation time spend of 40 to 120 minutes per day. So overall, we expect no material impact to our business, because minimal revenue is actually generated from minors. And we will continue to be very committed to minor protection and full compliance of relevant regulations and work very constructively with the regulatory authorities on this consultation and the subsequent implementation.

Wendy Huang

executive
#51

Charlene Liu from HSBC has our next question.

Charlene Liu

analyst
#52

Thanks, Wendy. My first question concerns profit growth. Clearly, both GPM and the bottom line exceeded consensus estimates. Monetization of Video Accounts, which carries high margins, clearly contributed to those results. I'd like to ask how we should view the profit growth trend for the second half of this year, or even for 2024, especially given further monetization of Video Accounts and a possible recovery in domestic games growth. Can these factors — is it possible for them to sustain somewhat stronger profit growth relative to top line? I have a follow-up later.

James Mitchell

executive
#53

We think three factors are helping our margins. The first is the mix shift toward higher-margin revenue, and you specifically called out Video Accounts. I would add that deploying ad tech in general lets us start selling inventory that previously went unsold. That makes it a very high incremental margin business for us. It also means more competitive bidding on inventory we were selling before, which again means a higher price and therefore higher margins. So ad tech broadly lifts our margins. In Mini Games, as we've discussed at considerable length, there's a very substantial GMV revenue stream, but only a minority percentage of it gets booked into reported revenue, and the flow-through on reported revenue is much higher margin than for our mainstream game business. The e-commerce fees are also disproportionately high margin, because they leverage the very substantial fixed investments in the Mini Program video account infrastructure. So that's one bucket. The second bucket is that we have scaled back certain lower-margin revenue streams, including some of the resale businesses within cloud, including the live streaming entertainment I mentioned earlier, at Tencent Music and Huya. And thirdly, we simply have a different culture now, one of being very focused on cost discipline and efficiency, and that culture is here to stay.

James Mitchell

executive
#54

So for those 3 reasons, we think that past the second half of this year and on into the future, we'll keep growing profits at a quicker pace than revenue.

Charlene Liu

analyst
#55

Understood, that's very clear. Could I also get some sense of what share of social network revenue comes from Mini Games, and what portion of ad revenue is contributed by Mini Games ads? And how should we view the synergies as opposed to the competition between Mini Games and our online game business, please?

James Mitchell

executive
#56

Okay, let me address synergies in relation to competition. And maybe John can share a few thoughts on the first part of what you asked. On the overall dynamic, we generally identify 3 broad types of games in China at present. First, there are competitive eSports-style titles that, when managed well, tend to be fairly evergreen. We hold a very strong position in that segment across all the leading games. And with Wild Rift, Arena Breakout and Fight of the Golden Spatula, we think we are cultivating 3 additional titles of that kind. Those are evergreen by nature, and in our view they will produce cash flow for us across decades, not merely years ahead. Second, there are the more story-driven or content-driven games, which have historically been a weaker area for us. Our competitors have had a number of quite strong launches over the past few months, including in video. We believe that points, to some degree, to a renaissance in that category, and over time we would like to take part in that renaissance. So we have some large narrative-driven, content-rich games under development, and time will tell how well they do. But from our standpoint, it is essentially greenfield and mostly upside.

James Mitchell

executive
#57

And then thirdly, casual games. If you look at the Western world, every year or 2 there's a new app-based casual game, and among us sort of 4 guys that generates great attention, especially among younger users, and then typically reaches a certain point and then declines through that point. But the really big development in the past 5 years, which we've been following extremely closely, has been the emergence of platforms, in particular, the roadblocks platform. And while the individual app-based games come and go in the casual category, in the platforms the individual experiences also come and go, but the platforms appear to in extra be growing in terms of both users and revenue. So we believe that the right way to address the casual game opportunity is primarily -- not entirely, but primarily through the platform model. We have a platform that is over 5x bigger than any single app-based casual game in terms of users and also in terms of revenue, and it's growing at an extremely rapid rate year-on-year as new casual game experiences appear on that platform. In terms of the cannibalization, there's 3 sort of broad buckets of users of roughly similar size.

James Mitchell

executive
#58

One group is people who’ve always played games on apps and clients, and they keep at it — they don’t touch Mini Games. A second group had never played any Tencent games before and now only play Tencent Mini Games. Then there’s a third group that does both. And we see no sign of cannibalization, because even among those doing both, the games tend to differ in type, and the dayparts differ too — Mini Games versus what they play on apps or clients. So from where we sit, the Mini Game platform is mostly additive rather than cannibalistic to our app-based games. It opens up this large, emerging casual-gaming opportunity for us, and it does so in what we believe is the best possible way — as a roadblock-style platform, not as a stand-alone app with a stand-alone game experience that thrives for a while and then yields to the next hit.

Shek Hon Lo

executive
#59

Yeah. As for how much Mini Games adds within Social Networks, it's in the single-digit percentage range, and online advertising is also up by single digits.

Wendy Huang

executive
#60

Natalie Wu from Haitong International will be our next questioner.

Yue Wu

analyst
#61

I've got a couple of questions. The first one has to do with gaming. I'm just curious — since domestic game license approvals have been trending toward normalization lately, do you sense that competition is heating up and that market share has become more dispersed recently? And second, we know that with China's domestic macro trending weak, I'm just curious, if we look closely at your business lines, which one would be the most vulnerable and which would be the most resilient? And what measures have you taken or do you plan to take to cope with macro headwinds? Any color would be helpful.

James Mitchell

executive
#62

Let me begin with both of those, and Martin might add to what I say. On the question of how competitive things are in games, I'll restate part of what I said replying to the previous question: we observe 3 broad groupings. The first is the more competitive eSports titles, a space where our presence is already quite strong. We're intensifying our efforts there, helped by the 3 new eSports games we've discussed doing well. The second grouping covers games that lean more on content or narrative, and in that area rivalry has grown sharper, with several companies recently launching some solid titles. That isn't hurting us, since our revenue from that category has historically been very small; instead, it's a space we look forward to moving into more actively over the coming years. Thirdly, there's casual games, where quite a few industry peers are, in a sense, trying to join us, while we're trying to stand in their way. That's all right — both are solid businesses — but we're definitely very pleased with the strategic choice we made to take the platform approach. So that covers game competition. As for how sensitive we are to the macro environment, let me briefly address each of advertising, FinTech and games.

James Mitchell

executive
#63

Turning to games: obviously this wasn’t the strongest quarter for our domestic game revenue, yet I believe that had nothing at all to do with macro. In fact, when the macro backdrop is difficult, consumers move toward lower ticket price experiences. They move from goods into services. In theory, that is fairly favorable for the game industry. As a parallel, I’d direct your attention to the movie theater industry in China, the movie ticketing side, where, as you probably know, movie ticketing has been extremely strong over the last 2 to 3 months. People seek affordable entertainment-driven experiences instead of highly priced luxuries and so forth. So I think the game business, both in China and globally, historically has not been economically cyclical, and we don’t believe it will become economically cyclical now in China. Regarding the advertising business, that could be economically cyclical. It should be economically cyclical. However, it isn’t sensitive so much to net exports or property prices; it is more directly sensitive to consumption spending. And so far, consumption spending has been recovering, albeit at a very gradual measured pace. Again, we believe that whatever happens going forward to the macro environment, and if net exports and real estate and so forth eventually impact consumers, we will outperform, because we are in the early stages of monetizing Video Accounts, because we are in the early stages of deploying ad tech, and because we deliver very high ROIs, which mean advertisers should stay with us for longer.

James Mitchell

executive
#64

Now, regarding FinTech and specifically the commercial payments piece of that segment — it does mirror economic activity, especially consumer activity, in something close to real time. So I'd say that's the business where macroeconomic factors influence our revenue swings the most. Within FinTech, we offer quite a few services beyond the commercial payments themselves. As we've mentioned, given this favorable regulatory backdrop, we're eager to expand and roll out additional services of that kind, though commercial payments are likely the area where, for better or worse, we're most directly subject to macro volatility on a month-to-month basis.

Chi Ping Lau

executive
#65

If we wanted to make an addition at this moment, I'd say that on the Banhao side we're genuinely excited about the new Banhao issuance, since innovation is what truly powers the gaming industry. The market simply won't grow without innovation. And I believe the growth we've observed across the overall market stems from the new innovations in new games that we're seeing. So as the overall market expands, I think we benefit, and we'll be bringing new titles to market. At the same time, looking at the Mini Games platform, it actually gains from the fact that innovation within the market keeps increasing. Now regarding your second question on the consumption side, I think James has provided a very good analysis of our own business. I just want to share some overall thoughts. What we've observed is that consumption is recovering from the COVID period. It may not be moving as fast as the market expects or wishes, but we also see that the focus of the top leaders, government leaders, on economic development and on supporting growth is actually very clear.

Chi Ping Lau

executive
#66

And meanwhile, the government is introducing a set of policies and measures aimed at spurring economic growth. We also think there's substantial resilience and entrepreneurship present in the China economy. So rolling out different measures, implementing them, and having them take effect would take time. But looking at our own business, right, in this waiting mode for recovery to arrive at a quicker pace, we're already posting strong, solid revenue growth and profit growth that's even faster in the current environment. That comes from the fact that our revenue streams are very high-quality, and we have very strong discipline that was built during the difficult times, so we feel very good, actually, about our overall positioning.

Wendy Huang

executive
#67

And our final question comes from Thomas Chong at Jefferies.

Thomas Chong

analyst
#68

I've got a question about the FinTech side. Could management comment on how we should think about the take rate trend, given that it's still relatively low? And on the other hand, for other FinTech segments such as online credit, wealth management and insurance, are there any priorities for these new businesses going forward?

Chi Ping Lau

executive
#69

Regarding take rate, my expectation is that it would remain mostly unchanged. That said, I believe we have quite a few Value-added Services we can genuinely make available to merchants, and for those Value-added Services we're actually in a position to charge extra fees in return for the added value we deliver to them. As for the financial products, given how the regulators' disciplinary action has concluded, and with the regulators stating plainly that they will back the healthy growth of the FinTech industry, we think more opportunities will emerge going forward.

Wendy Huang

executive
#70

Thanks, everyone, for being part of our results webinar. That brings the call to a close. Should you want to review the press release along with other financial details, head over to the IR section on our company site at www.tencent.com. A replay of this webinar is going to be posted shortly as well. Thanks again, and we'll talk to you in the next quarter.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Tencent Holdings Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Tencent Holdings Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Tencent Holdings Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.