Tencent Holdings Limited (700) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

March 20, 2024

Hong Kong Stock Exchange HK Communication Services Interactive Media and Services earnings 79 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Hello and good evening, everyone. Thanks for being with us today. You're listening to the webcast for Tencent Holdings Limited's announcement of results for the fourth quarter and full year of 2023. I'm Wendy Huang, with Tencent's IR team. Right now, everyone joining is in a listen-only mode. Once management finishes its presentation, we'll open things up for questions and answers. Those of you who joined via telephone: should you want to pose a question, just hit 5 on your keypad to raise your hand. If you're joining through the Tencent meeting or WeMeet app, go ahead and tap the Raise Hand button in the bottom left corner. Please also note that today's webcast is being recorded. Before the presentation gets underway, we'd like to remind everyone that it contains forward-looking statements, which are subject to a range of risks and uncertainties and might not come to pass in the future for a variety of reasons. Details on general market conditions come from multiple sources beyond Tencent. This presentation also includes certain unaudited non-IFRS financial measures, which ought to be viewed alongside, and not as a replacement for, the group's financial performance measures prepared under IFRS. For a thorough discussion of risk factors and non-IFRS measures, please see our disclosure documents in the IR section of our website.

Operator

operator
#2

So now I’d like to introduce the management team joining us on tonight’s webinar. Pony Ma, our Chairman and CEO, will begin with a brief overview. After that, President Martin Lau will go through the strategy review, Chief Strategy Officer James Mitchell will give a business review, and Chief Financial Officer John Lo will wrap up with a financial discussion before we take questions from the floor. At this point I’ll hand things over to Pony.

Pony Ma

executive
#3

Thank you, Wendy. Good evening, and thanks to all of you for being here. During 2023, we honed our strategic focus and made considerable headway on our key products, guided by our high quality revenue growth model. In particular, time spent by users on video accounts more than doubled, as we broadened the ecosystem of short video content. Gross receipts on our mini-cams platform climbed by more than 50% compared with a year earlier. The count of our major hit games in China that combine high DAU with meaningful monetization grew from six in 2022 to eight in 2023, and games connected with that effort posted double digit revenue growth and climbed to 30% of games revenue. Tencent Video and Tencent Music widened their lead, with 117 million and 107 million paid subscribers respectively. WeCom and Tencent meeting reinforced their leadership in enterprise software and lifted monetization, and we also delivered significant breakthroughs in technology. Tencent Hunyuan, our foundation model, now ranks among the top tier of large language models in China, with notable strength in advanced logical reasoning. Our upgraded advertising AI model lets us achieve better ad targeting and higher revenue. We put further investment into sustainable social value initiatives. Our digital philanthropy platform helped raise RMB 3.8 billion in public donations during the 99 Giving Day campaign in 2023.

Pony Ma

executive
#4

The cornerstone investigator initiative we launched recently backed 104 researchers working on fundamental science. Turning to the financial results for the quarter, we posted total revenue of RMB 155 billion, which represents 7% growth year-on-year and was stable quarter-on-quarter. Gross profit came in at RMB 78 billion, an increase of 25% year-on-year and 1% quarter-on-quarter. Non-IFRS operating profit reached RMB 49 billion, up 35% year-on-year, or 5% lower quarter-on-quarter. Non-IFRS net profit attributable to equity holders stood at RMB 43 billion, up 44% year-on-year, or down 5% quarter-on-quarter. With that, I'll pass it to Martin for the strategy review.

Martin Lau

analyst
#5

Thanks, Pony, and good evening and good morning, everyone. Over the course of 2023, we've built a high-quality revenue growth model that will support our continued creation of economic value. That, along with our sharper focus on discipline in capital allocation, will further boost shareholder value. Beginning with our financial performance, we've recorded a healthy rise in revenue since the first quarter of 2023 by growing high-quality revenue streams and cutting back on low-quality ones. Importantly, growth in gross profit has consistently outpaced revenue growth, because the margins on our incremental revenue are significantly higher than the 50% overall gross margins for the entire company. That incremental revenue comes predominantly from our leading social and payment platforms, which are already built and have had their costs covered. Given this shift in the revenue mix, we now see gross profit growth as a key proxy — and frankly a better proxy than revenue growth — for our organic growth. We further enhanced operating profit growth over gross profit growth through operating leverage. First, we streamlined operations and prudently cut aggressive marketing expenditures. We view these measures as a less recurring strategy. Second, and more importantly, we're committed to operational efficiency and disciplined resource allocation, which includes thoughtful staff distribution and effective management of marketing expense.

Martin Lau

analyst
#6

By doing this, we keep the organization focused and our cost structure lean as we move ahead. Over the next few slides, I'll go into more detail about what's driving our earnings growth going forward. Weixin offers the first set of examples showing how we cultivated high-quality revenue streams. On the Weixin platform, both DAU and daily time spent per user are growing steadily. New services inside Weixin — video accounts, mini-games and Weixin Search — add to engagement and overall platform health, while also bringing in extra revenue at very high margins, since they sit on top of a fairly stable platform cost base. Taking each one in turn: first, video accounts — total user time spent more than doubled in 2023, driven by strong growth in DAU and time spent per user. Video accounts advertising revenue has risen substantially thanks to higher traffic and better ad targeting, even though ad load was kept at a much lower level than industry peers, which in turn gives a better user experience overall. Second, mini-games saw a 50% increase in gross receipts in 2023, benefiting from more DAU and high revenue per user. That growth in gross receipts drove an increase in high-margin platform fees for us.

Martin Lau

analyst
#7

Weixin mini-games are plainly the industry frontrunner, with retention rates and time spent per user for mini-games markedly above what peer services see — that comes from Weixin's platform stickiness, a well-built ecosystem including social sharing and notifications, plus our game expertise and know-how. Third, Weixin Search has now reached more than 100 million DAU, rising over 20% year-on-year, while Weixin Search content QV climbed over 30% year-on-year. Search revenue for us multiplied year-on-year during 2023 as we stepped up monetization of this asset that had been under-monetized. Beyond that, fintech offers a second set of illustrations of high-quality revenue streams. For many years we have laid a solid foundation for fintech services through our widely used payment offerings, with strict adherence to regulatory requirements and careful risk management. During recent months, we finished a comprehensive self-inspection along with a corresponding ratification process, lifting our operational compliance capability. We further reinforced our payment ecosystem by improving security use, refining transaction tools built on mini programs, and enhancing the cross-border payment experience. Building on that solid base, we offer additional products and services together with licensed financial institutions, and these produced high incremental margins since such revenues are recorded on a net fee basis.

Martin Lau

analyst
#8

When it comes to wealth management, our take rates are low, yet we earn fee income at higher margins from a big and expanding pool of aggregated customer assets, because we give customers top-quality products along with outstanding convenience. Those products consist mainly of low-risk money market funds and, to a smaller degree, fixed income mutual funds. On the consumer loans side, our partners at WeBank and other licensed banks help us distribute small-sized cash loans and installment payment services, and we have held the default rate down through strict, technology-driven risk management procedures. In both wealth management and consumer loans, we provide considerably better economics for consumers, for partners and for ourselves than standalone fintech businesses do, since we lower customer acquisition costs and credit charges. Turning now to games: revenue from our domestic game business was soft throughout 2023, though we expect improvement starting in the second quarter of 2024. The slow growth in 2023 came about because our two biggest games, Honour of Kings and Peacekeeper Elite, held onto their leading positions on DAU, but monetization stalled for the time being, which led us to take remedial actions. With Peacekeeper Elite, we saw the need for more creative monetization strategies and have overhauled the leadership of the team responsible for monetization.

Martin Lau

analyst
#9

We expect the game to keep delivering more innovative and engaging experiences, which should also support monetization. We're optimistic that our new monetization team can deliver here, since its sister product, PUBG Mobile, has already achieved a notable rebound in monetization internationally. As for Honour of Kings, our monetization efforts had been too heavily concentrated around the Chinese New Year period in 2023. In 2024, we're rolling out a monetization strategy that is distributed more evenly, and we'd expect that to help revenue generation throughout the year. Beyond these two titles, a number of our recent releases have done well on DAU and are now turning that DAU success into monetization. Major hit games in China went from six in '22 to eight in '23. Our definition of major hit games is titles exceeding average quarterly DAU of 5 million on mobile and 2 million on PC, while also generating more than RMB 4 billion in annual gross receipts. We see these thresholds as indicative of a major and enduring hit, and games that surpass such DAU and revenue thresholds will contribute to the long-term stability and growth of our game portfolio. A large and expanding portfolio of major hits shows our ability both to keep developing new major hits and to operate highly popular games at the same time.

Martin Lau

analyst
#10

Over the course of this year, we've got several new major titles. First is Fight of the Golden Spatula, which has gone from being a niche auto chess game to becoming one of the most popular mobile games in the domestic market — it's now ranked in the top five by DAU and total time spent. Second, LOL Wild Rift also now sits among the top five mobile games in China by total time spent and gross receipts. We expect to keep adding major hits through our portfolio as this year unfolds. We're looking forward to releasing several major new games that should also help improve revenue trends through 2024. DnF mobile is a key title for us, given the success and longevity of DnF PC and given a general scarcity of successful action games on mobile. DnF mobile has just successfully completed a major closed beta test, and given the positive results, we intend to launch the game in the second quarter of this year. Other high potential games in our portfolio for 2024 include Honour of Fight, Need for Speed mobile, and One Piece mobile. In 2023, we also made notable progress in core technologies, especially those involving AI, which will serve as our growth multiplier going forward.

Martin Lau

analyst
#11

So after we rolled out cutting-edge technologies like mixture of experts, or MoE architecture, our foundation model Tencent Hunyuan now delivers top-tier Chinese language performance among large language models both in China and globally. The upgraded Hunyuan stands out especially in multi-turn conversations, logical inference, and numerical reasoning — areas that have proven difficult for large language models. We've scaled the model up to the trillion parameter mark, using the MoE architecture to boost performance and cut <<inaudible>> costs, and we're moving quickly to improve the model's text-to-picture and text-to-video capabilities. More and more, we're integrating Hunyuan to offer copilot services across our enterprise SaaS products, such as Tencent Meeting and Tencent Docs, and we're also building new gen-AI tools internally for efficient content production. Broader still, putting AI technology to work across our existing businesses has started to bring meaningful revenue benefits. That shows up most clearly in advertising, where our AI-powered ad tech platform helps deliver more precise ad targeting and higher ad click-through rates, and therefore faster advertising revenue growth rates. We're also seeing earlier-stage business opportunities from offering AI services to Tencent Cloud customers. Lastly, with this high-quality revenue growth model, we have the resources to continue investing in our businesses while also returning more capital to our shareholders.

Martin Lau

analyst
#12

Our practice has long been to return cash to shareholders through regular dividends, and from time to time we have bought back stock when we felt the market was pricing our shares below their worth — and that is especially the case right now. Given our record and rising profit along with cash flow, we are proposing a 42% year-on-year raise in the next cash dividend, taking it to HKD 3.4 per share, and we plan to grow buybacks year-on-year by no less than 2x, from HKD 49 billion in 2023 to a minimum of HKD 100 billion in ’24. We believe our free cash flow — US $24 billion for the full year of ’23 — together with a gross cash position of US $57 billion and an investment portfolio of US $126 billion, comfortably supports this commitment to return no less than HKD 132 billion, or US $16.9 billion, to shareholders over the year. With that said, I’ll hand things over to James for the business review.

James Mitchell

executive
#13

Thanks, Martin. Total revenue for Q4 2023 rose 7% compared with a year earlier. EAS accounted for 45% of revenue, and inside that, the social network sub-segment made up 18%, domestic games 18%, and international games 9%. Online advertising contributed 19% of revenue, while fintech and business services made up 35%. Value-added services segment revenue came to RMB 69 billion in Q4, a 3% decline year-on-year. Social network revenue was RMB 28 billion, also down 3% year-on-year. Music-related and game-related livestreaming services brought in less revenue, while video accounts streaming service, music subscriptions and mini-games brought in more. Long form video subscription revenue grew 1% year-on-year, helped by higher ARPU, while video subscriptions slipped slightly to RMB 117 million. Our self-commissioned drama series Blossoms Shanghai ranks first by video views across all online platforms in China year-to-date, extending Tencent Video’s audience lead within the online video industry. Music subscription revenue climbed 45% year-on-year on 21% growth in subscription count and 20% growth in ARPU. Domestic games revenue fell 3% year-on-year to RMB 27 billion. Recently released PC games Valorant and Lost Ark helped lift PC game revenue, but that was offset by lower revenue from Honour of Kings and Peacekeeper Elite.

James Mitchell

executive
#14

International games revenue rose 1% year-on-year when measured in RMB, but fell 1% on a constant currency basis to RMB 14 billion, since Superstar was in the process of repositioning several of its titles. PUBG mobile continued to recover revenue and Valorant kept up solid growth. Taken together, reported revenue for our domestic-plus international game sub-segment declined 2% year-on-year, even though game gross receipts were up slightly year-on-year. We anticipate that reported revenue for our domestic and international games will improve starting in the second quarter of 2024, as rebounds in existing titles like Brawl Stars and Peacekeeper Elite begin to produce results and as we release new games, among them Dungeon Fighter mobile. Turning to communications and social networks: on the content consumption side for Weixin video accounts, time spent climbed over 80% year-on-year during the fourth quarter, driven partly by DAU and mostly by time spent per user, thanks to our improved content recommendation engine. On the content creation side, daily video uploads expanded rapidly year-on-year. We gave targeted traffic support to creators in key categories including knowledge base content, lifestyle and music, which helped drive a sharp rise in the count of creators with over 10,000 followers, and with more followers plus better livestreaming tools, the count of creators earning revenue directly from their video accounts grew more than threefold year-on-year.

James Mitchell

executive
#15

On QQ, active QQ channels rose by a double-digit percentage quarter over quarter, and we introduced a fresh QQ release with a redesigned interface and richer features. Turning to a few domestic game highlights: with Set 10 out, Fight of the Golden Spatula more than doubled its average DAU year-on-year during the fourth quarter, reaching a new peak. Arena Breakout lifted both gross receipts and average DAU by more than 30% year-on-year apiece, helped by a new competitive PVE mode, an improved battle pass and more attractive virtual items — and by total time spent, Arena Breakout now ranks as China's seventh largest mobile game. Naruto mobile, an eight-year-old title from our More Fun Studio, posted record gross receipts and average DAU in January thanks to wide-ranging content updates. We see Naruto's success as a favorable early signal for our forthcoming One Piece game, which also comes from More Fun. Our party game Dream Stars arrived in December. Party games bring together many kinds of game modes, and we are continuing to expand how many Dream Stars modes exist and how varied they are so as to compete with the modes offered by established party games, while also putting out tools that let players build modes of their own.

James Mitchell

executive
#16

We see party games as a category that’s going to take consistent work over a long stretch, but we’re encouraged that Dream Stars was among China’s top 10 mobile games by DAU over Chinese New Year, and we think Dream Stars already leads the industry in party games as measured by DAU in certain game modes, including social deduction and tower defense. On the international side, PUBG Mobile posted year-on-year gains in both DAU and gross receipts during the fourth quarter, helped by the Frozen Kingdom theme mode and an innovative top tier outfit with upgradable weapons. Nikke launched a new storyline and new characters, and encouragingly Nikke’s average DAU hit a 2023 year high level in the fourth quarter. Supercell’s five-year-old game Brawl Stars set record high gross receipts and DAU in February 2024, thanks to improvements to its friend invitation system, a new 5v5 game mode, and a complete redesign of its battle pass. Brawl Stars’ resurgence shows the latent franchise value of our evergreen titles and their potential to unlock new growth. Turning to online advertising, our ad revenue was RMB 30 billion in the fourth quarter, up 21% year-on-year, driven by upgrades to our ad tech platform and more advertising revenue and video accounts.

James Mitchell

executive
#17

Ad revenue rose across every major category apart from automotive, with particularly sharp gains coming from internet services, healthcare, and consumer goods. We sharpened our ad targeting by feeding more real-time data into the AI that drives our ad tech, which let us pair target users with more relevant ads and do so more promptly on both our owned properties and our ad network. Revenue from our video accounts more than doubled compared with a year earlier, even though we kept ad load very low, thanks to more video views and better ad targeting. Weixin Search posted revenue growth of several-fold versus a year ago during the quarter, driven by gains in commercial queries and RPM. Turning to fintech and business services, segment revenue reached RMB 54 billion in the fourth quarter, a rise of 15% year-on-year. Fintech services revenue kept up a teens year-on-year growth rate, lifted by higher commercial payment volume along with wealth management fees and consumer loan fees. Gross profit climbed faster than revenue, reflecting a shift from social to commercial payments. Inside commercial payments, both daily active users and transactions per user went up. We improved mini program-based QR code and palm payment solutions, which helped offline merchants boost repeat sales. On business services, revenue was up around 20% year-on-year in the fourth quarter, helped by greater cloud spending from industries including retail and finance, plus higher technology service fees tied to ecommerce transactions on video accounts.

James Mitchell

executive
#18

Business services gross profit rose by more than four times compared with a year earlier, driven by those technology service fees along with initiatives to optimize the supply chain. Within our enterprise software-as-a-service lineup, we brought AI to Tencent Meeting for understanding content in real time, introduced AI in Tencent Docs for generating documents from prompts, and launched a paid tool for customer acquisition for WeCom. We increased penetration of our enterprise SaaS offerings among domestic firms like Vivo and among multinationals such as Novo Nordisk. Consequently, enterprise software revenue across WeCom, Tencent Meetings and Tencent Docs combined grew by over twofold versus a year ago. I'll hand things over now to John.

John Lo

executive
#19

Thank you, James. Hello, everyone. For the fourth quarter of 2023 and the full year 2023, we have reclassified interest income, moving it from above the operating profit line to below it. In addition, investment-related gains and losses, along with donations — both of which were previously included in other gains or losses net above the operating line — are now combined as net gains or losses from investments and others and presented below the operating profit line. This reclassification is intended to better reflect the results of day-to-day operations. Comparative figures have been restated as well. For the fourth quarter of 2023, total revenue came in at RMB 155.2 million, up 7% year-on-year. Gross profit was RMB 77.6 billion, up 25% year-on-year. Operating profit reached RMB 41.4 billion, up 42% year-on-year. Net losses from investments and others were RMB 6.7 billion, mainly reflecting payment provisions against certain investees. Interest income was RMB 3.9 billion, up 52% year-on-year, driven by growth in cash reserves and improved yield on term deposits. Finance costs were RMB 3.5 billion, down 3% year-on-year due to reduced forex losses, partially offset by higher interest expenses. Share of profit of associates and JVs was RMB 2.4 billion, versus a loss of RMB 1.6 billion in the same period last year. On a non-IFRS basis, share of profit increased to RMB 4.5 billion, up from profit of RMB 3.1 billion last year, driven by better profitability at certain domestic associates and a successful game release by an overseas video investee.

John Lo

executive
#20

Income tax expense increased 111% compared with a year earlier, reaching RMB 9.7 billion, which reflected growth in operating profit as well as a higher reporting tax position. IFRS net profit attributable to equity holders came to RMB 27 billion, a decline of 75% year-on-year, mainly because the same quarter last year included the RMB 106.6 billion gain from the disposal of Meituan. Diluted EPS stood at RMB 2.807, down 74% year-on-year. I'll now walk you through our non-IFRS figures. In quarter four, operating profit reached RMB 49.1 billion, up 35% year-on-year. Net profit attributable to equity holders was RMB 42.7 billion, 44% higher year-on-year. Diluted EPS came in at RMB 4.443, up 46% year-on-year. Turning to gross margins, the overall gross margin for quarter four was 50%, an increase of 7.4 percentage points year-on-year. Looking at segments, value-added services posted a gross margin of 53.7%, up 3.9 percentage points year-on-year. That reflected a larger mix of high margin mini-games, platform service fee, and a smaller contribution from low margin music and games-related livestreaming revenue, together with our cost control measures. Online advertising gross margin climbed to 56.8%, 12.6 percentage points higher year-on-year. As Martin pointed out, our high quality revenue streams — especially video accounts ad revenue generated from our own traffic, where platform costs have already been paid for — helped drive our incremental margins.

John Lo

executive
#21

We also achieved better margins thanks to our efficiency work. Fintech and business services posted a gross margin of 43.9%, which is 10.3 percentage points higher than a year earlier. The gains came from margin improvements after our business restructuring, new high-quality revenue streams such as video accounts, ecommerce and technology service fees, a shift in mix toward higher-margin products within fintech services, and our efficiency programs. Turning to quarter four operating expenses: selling and marketing came to RMB 11 billion, a 79% year-on-year increase from a low base last year, as we spent more on promotion advertising to support new content releases. That equaled 7.1% of revenues. R&D expenses reached RMB 16.4 billion, up 3% year-on-year. G&A expenses, excluding R&D, were RMB 10.8 billion, 6% lower year-on-year, reflecting reduced <<inaudible>> and optimized operating lease costs. We finished the quarter with roughly 105,000 employees, a 3% decline year-on-year and flat quarter-on-quarter. Now let's review our operating and net margin ratios. For fourth quarter 2023, the non-IFRS operating margin stood at 31.7%, 6.6 percentage points above a year ago. Non-IFRS net margin came in at 28.2%, up 7.1 percentage points year-on-year. Next, I'll cover a few key cash flow and balance sheet metrics. In quarter four, total capex was RMB 7.5 billion, 33% higher year-on-year. Of that total, operating capex accounted for RMB 6.7 billion, more than triple the prior year, driven by greater investment in GPUs and servers.

John Lo

executive
#22

Non-operating capex came in at RMB 0.8 billion, which is a 78% drop compared with a year earlier. In quarter four, free cash flow reached RMB 34.2 billion, marking a 42% rise year-on-year. For the whole of full year 2032, as Martin pointed out, free cash flow stood at US $24 billion, or RMB 167 billion, which represents an 89% increase year-on-year. Our net cash position was RMB 54.7 billion, 15% higher quarter-on-quarter, driven by robust free cash flow generation that was partly offset by outflows tied to share repurchases and strategic investments. To wrap up, I'll go over our share repurchase activity and the annual dividend. During the full year of 2023, we bought back 152 million shares, with total consideration amounting to HKD 49 billion. Consequently, after accounting for employee share options and one issuance, our total issued shares as at the end of 2023 fell 0.9% year-on-year. The weighted average share count used to calculate our 2023 diluted EPS likewise declined 0.9% year-on-year. Pending shareholders' approval at the upcoming 2024 AGM, we are proposing an annual dividend of HKD 3.4 per share, which reflects a 42% increase from the prior year. Shareholders will receive this dividend on 31 May 2024. Thank you.

Wendy Huang

executive
#23

Thanks, John. At this point we’ll begin the Q&A portion of the call. Those of you joining by phone should press five if you’d like to ask something, and then press six so your line is un-muted. For anyone on Tencent Meeting or the WeMeet app, just hit the Raise Hand button located at the bottom of the screen. Each time, we’ll take one primary question along with a single follow-up. Our first question comes from Kenneth Fong at UBS.

Kenneth Fong

analyst
#24

Good evening, management, and thanks for taking my question. My first question concerns online games. In the strategy we outlined for online games, we'll focus on strengthening the flagship titles, developing emerging franchise games, and launching new titles. Could management share the timing, and when should we expect this to start contributing to growth across our online games overall? Looking at the industry from the top down, we're also seeing some gradual easing in the number of banhou <<inaudible>> getting approved, along with games that carry high commercial value, yet at the same time there are some industry headwinds, such as lower player spending amid greater competition, so how should we think about medium-term growth for online games going forward? I have a follow-up on livestreaming ecommerce. We made very meaningful progress last year and have stepped up hiring and team building for livestreaming ecommerce. Could management give us some updates, such as our current scale, the road map ahead, and how we're differentiating from peers? Thank you.

James Mitchell

executive
#25

Hi Kenneth. I might take the online game question. You listed several possible factors that might impact our growth, such as banhou issuance, reduced player spending, and, I believe, increased competition. In fact, none of those, in our view, is the core problem we’ve been dealing with. We’ve gotten a reasonable quantity of banhou—definitely enough for what we’re aiming for. Our games typically have much lower ARPU than the industry, so we haven’t observed, and we wouldn’t anticipate, reduced player spending as an outside macro factor. And ongoing competition is more or less unavoidable in a sector that remains one of high growth and high returns, so our view is that the main difficulty for us is simply getting our own house in order. We currently have three strategies in progress to get our own house in order. The first is overhauling and changing the leadership of our existing games, and we did that with Brawl Stars, and we’ve seen a very sharp upturn in Brawl Stars revenue reaching new records and becoming the biggest super sell game. We’ve done that—we’ve made changes with PUBG mobile, and that’s seen a big upturn, and more recently we’ve made changes with Peacekeeper Elite, so where changes are needed, we are now making those changes.

James Mitchell

executive
#26

Second, we have several games that have built up really large user bases over the past two to three years, and we're now in the process of monetizing them — you can see that fairly clearly with Fight for the Golden Spatula, Wild Rift, and Arena Breakout, among others. Third, we've been focused on bringing bigger-budget games to market that iterate on prior successes, and you'll see those arrive through the remainder of this year, including Dungeon and Fighter mobile, where a very successful internal test led us to actually move the launch date up to the second quarter of this year, within the next three months. Because of all of the above, we expect our game revenue to improve starting in the second quarter of this year, and how well we do across those three strategies will determine the medium-term growth rate. Thank you.

Martin Lau

analyst
#27

When it comes to livestreaming and video accounts ecommerce, I'd say we've achieved quite strong progress during 2023, though this is really just the start of cultivating what is a very exciting opportunity. On GMV, during 2023 it increased substantially, reaching over 100 billion, yet for context that figure remains quite modest relative to video accounts' overall size. It's likewise only a portion of mini-programs ecommerce GMV. So to genuinely seize the sizable opportunity in this business, we have several strategies underway. First, we aim to truly elevate how the whole ecosystem is managed, which includes strengthening product quality control, refining the process for handling user complaints and feedback, and more broadly enhancing the shopping experience for customers. Second, we intend to do this via improved category management. We want to go through every one of the high-potential product categories and ensure we offer quality merchants along with appealing products for customers, and that demands highly meticulous effort, a meaningful addition of workforce, and rollout done one at a time.

Martin Lau

analyst
#28

We'd also like to improve the tools we offer merchants and brands, so that we can conduct business with them, review their business analytics, and assist them in making better pricing decisions. There's an entire suite of merchant tools that we plan to add. More broadly, we also want to promote this overall platform and the availability of these products to consumers on WeChat who are using video accounts, so that we can actually raise awareness of our shopping experience within video accounts. Lastly, we aim to strengthen the integration among video accounts, the shopping experience and infrastructure, and the mini programs that many merchants already operate at scale, and we believe that by combining the above, we can keep growing the GMV of our video accounts ecommerce in a healthy way. At this point in time, it's very important for us to establish a very solid foundation for this platform, so that we can actually usher in a very long and significant growth track for this business going forward.

Wendy Huang

executive
#29

Thanks. We’ll go next to William Packer at Exane BNP.

William Packer

analyst
#30

Hi management, thanks for taking my questions. First, domestic gaming growth softened through the 2021 to 2022 rectification period, and then last August, we discussed softer Q2 trends reflecting seasonality and less commercial content. Now you're again referring to weak monetization at key games for Q4 and Q1. Should we view these challenges as the new normal for evergreen domestic games? Does this indicate that these games are now ex-growth, so you therefore need to depend on new releases? Then my follow-up question concerns regulation. The market was somewhat alarmed in Q4 about new draft rules for the video games industry that could curtail in-game monetization. Could you update us on the latest developments there? When should we expect a new draft, and how should we think about the potential impact on your business? Thanks very much.

James Mitchell

executive
#31

Hi Will, so maybe I’ll begin with your first question. If you look at what we said in Q2, what we reported in Q4 is really kind of a consequence of that Q2 commentary, if you will, because as you may know, for our two biggest games we have roughly a nine — we have a nine-month amortization period from gross receipts into reported revenue, and so we saw weak monetization, therefore weak gross in receipts from Q2 onwards last year. That hits us most heavily in Q4, because in Q4 we lose the benefit of relatively strong gross in receipts from Q1, and as a result, that’s why if you look at the reported revenue for Q4, it was down year-on-year because of the lag effect of weak monetization in Q2 and Q3. But if you looked at the gross in receipts, the actual cash inflows, it was slightly up year-on-year in Q4, so what we saw in Q2 is the driver of what we saw in Q4, as opposed to being two sort of separate or contradictory phenomena. In terms of whether our big games are ex-growth, we clearly don’t think that’s the case. We are very active investors across the game industry, we can see that big games with longevity, with substantial user bases enjoy — they experience upswings and down-swings, but over the longer term they’re only becoming more powerful, whether you look at a Call of Duty or a Grand Theft Auto or a Fortnite.

James Mitchell

executive
#32

We really do think that holds true in China — longevity works as an asset instead of a liability, much like it does in luxury goods. Nobody would argue that a luxury brand with a long history is worse than one that has just appeared on the scene. You can see this in our own games. PUBG Mobile is rebounding strongly right now, and Brawl Stars, plus in fact the whole Supercell games portfolio, is rebounding strongly too. We expect several of our other titles to post substantial rebounds as well. Again, given the lag between cash coming in and revenue as reported, that will appear in our P&L starting from the second quarter, but we are already seeing better cash inflow, so that covers the first question on where we stand with games. Then perhaps on the game regulation side — ?

Martin Lau

analyst
#33

On the regulation side, we honestly don’t know when the new draft might come out, or even if it will come out at all, but that’s not something we’re worried about anymore. After the original draft came out, the market had concerns, and I think the regulators have since spoken very clearly, explaining that the draft’s purpose was to create a healthy environment for the industry to grow, not to constrain it. Second, we’ve been very encouraged by the supportive measures that came out after the market first raised concerns — including, right at the start of this year, a single batch of domestic banhou numbering more than 100, along with expedited approval of imported game licenses, and our flagship mobile game, DnF mobile, was approved in that batch. Also, if you look at what people were mainly concerned about, it’s high-ARPU games, and that really doesn’t apply to us now, because our ARPU sits at the very low end of the overall industry, so frankly, it’s no longer a concern for us.

Wendy Huang

executive
#34

Thanks, Martin. Now we’ll take a question from Alicia Yap at Citigroup.

Alicia Yap

analyst
#35

Hello, good evening. Is management able to hear me? Thank you for taking my questions. My main question concerns the AI power functionality. Beyond improving and powering the internal advertising targeting capability, how much do you expect the AI power functionality to bring in a decent amount of revenue from external cloud and business-to-business customers in the near term, or should we really expect any near-term benefit to reflect more the continued improvement in advertiser ROI and also ecommerce merchant conversion rate? Second, a very quick follow-up: I understand the user profile for mini-games differs quite a bit from that of the mobile APP game user, but I'm just curious whether there is any profit shift or cannibalization of time spent from the APP games toward the mini-games that would also contribute to the slower growth of domestic game over the past few quarters. Thank you.

Martin Lau

analyst
#36

Yeah, when it comes to the near-term payoff from AI, I'd say the money should be weighted much more heavily toward advertising. Take our ad business — roughly RMB 100 billion annually — and even a 10% lift would mean RMB 10 billion, and that's almost entirely profit, so that gives you a sense of the magnitude on the advertising side. That's especially true given how our ad business keeps growing, and once you factor in the video accounts ecommerce ecosystem, there's a really long runway for growth there, plus ad load in video accounts is low at the moment. On the cloud and business services side, though, you're dealing with a market that's still fairly nascent. We have to go out and sell to those customers, and we invest a lot of time with clients across different industries, working out how best to apply AI to their business, and then there's a lengthy sales cycle, and on top of that it's competitive, because rivals will show up claiming they can offer something similar, and even though we think our technology and product are superior, it's genuinely cutthroat — a competitor might come in and say they'll slash prices, even with an inferior product.

Martin Lau

analyst
#37

All of those factors—the thin margins, the intense competition, and the lengthy sales cycle that comes with the 2B business—would really be at work on that side of things. So if you put the two sides of the equation side by side, it becomes quite clear that investing more heavily in advertising will deliver considerably better profitability in the near term. Naturally, we'll keep doing both, and we believe the value we deliver to customers isn't measured only by the profit we earn from them, but also by how much we improve their businesses over time. We also believe that as China shifts toward an economy far more centered on productivity, and as costs—human costs, in particular—may rise, well, some of the dynamics seen in the U.S. market, where business services are more profitable, would come into play, though realizing that will take a considerable amount of time.

James Mitchell

executive
#38

Regarding your question about whether mini-games are eating into the time people spend or the revenue our app-based games generate, we have strong confidence that mini-games are no tribe of cannibals. They are a tribe of pioneers, explorers, and developers of new territory. I say that because, from a time-spent angle, our app-based games have been doing fine, and we can see that the added time spent on titles such as Fight for the Golden Spatula and Arena Breakout was very substantial. We have previously disclosed that fewer than half of mini-game MAU were also app-based game MAU. Looking at it from a user-spend angle, the picture is even starker, since only a teens percentage of mini-game paying users are also app-based game paying users, and only a single digit percentage of app-based game paying users are also mini-game paying users. So we do not believe cannibalization is occurring between mini-games and app-based games.

Wendy Huang

executive
#39

Thanks. The next question comes from Ronald Keung at Goldman Sachs.

Ronald Keung

analyst
#40

Thanks. Thanks to Pony, Martin, James, John, and Wendy. Two questions from me. First, we've read about the shorter return, so when you combine that with ordinary dividends and buybacks — and we used to have some distribution <<inaudible>> — how should we think about 2024, and perhaps over the medium term, regarding the potential for a total annual shorter return? Say, in dollar terms or as a percentage of market cap — which of those do you typically focus on more, and how do you plan to report to shareholders, perhaps around the investment portfolio value? My second question concerns video accounts ecommerce. Martin, you talked about video accounts ecommerce and about looking at combining it with mini-program ecommerce. Is it fair to say that eventually we're building a more open platform for transactions, rather than forcing every transaction through our own shop infrastructure, since mini-program is more like a platform? So that would look more like Meta — a Facebook-style open platform on which that ecommerce system is built — as opposed to the very closed system on the short video platform? Thank you.

James Mitchell

executive
#41

Hi Ronald. Regarding shareholder returns, we look at total return in a dynamic way. For the dividend and the buyback, we see those as more programmatic by nature, whereas the distributions tend to be somewhat more opportunistic, but overall the intent is to return a very substantial share of capital to shareholders over the course of this year. As for the role of the investment portfolio, in fact over the last 2 years, the investment portfolio has returned substantially more capital to shareholders than it has absorbed, and even if you exclude the JV and Meituan distributions, the investment portfolio has been self-funding, meaning that new investments we've made have been funded by divestments or dividends or distributions from what we already own in the investment portfolio. Looking at 2024 at this point in time, our expectation is that the investment portfolio will once again be self-funding and therefore a source of cash, rather than a use of cash.

Martin Lau

analyst
#42

On the video accounts ecommerce side, I'd say — that's a fair question, and honestly we spent a lot of time discussing it, in the sense of asking what the architecture of ecommerce activity on the platform ought to be, given that we already have mini-program ecommerce, which is in fact a very significant platform already. Our view, I think, is that going forward we'll actually have both an open platform and a closed platform, and they actually serve different purposes. The open platform follows the mini-program line, and those are actually much better suited to brands that are well recognized. Such brands actually have a very large self channel for promoting mini-programs — for example, if they run a very large chain of offline stores, they can actually ask their customers to add the mini-programs and then shop online. At the same time, they need pretty strong brand recognition for consumers to keep coming back to the mini-programs. But the shortcoming of the mini-program is that for merchants, basically it's very hard to get new customers online; they can only rely on their own channels. Yet even with that, the mini-program ecommerce platform has actually grown to a very large size.

Martin Lau

analyst
#43

Conversely, if we consider video accounts, the livestreaming platform, this new platform is in fact a closed one—meaning we genuinely intend to exercise far more active management over the ecosystem, so that shopping quality ends up being much better than what an open platform offers, particularly for merchants who aren't well known. With smaller merchants and white label merchants, we want to guarantee that products clear a specific threshold, which in turn generates a good experience for users. It also gives them access to video accounts traffic, enabling them to acquire new customers. Over time, we're going to link the open platform with the closed platform. We'll offer a curated connection, so that the open platform can genuinely gain from video accounts traffic, while simultaneously the small merchants can genuinely gain from their private domain once they begin selling on our platform. When we curate that connection linking open platform mini-programs with video account shops, then I believe we can genuinely achieve the best of both worlds and assist different types of merchants in maximizing their sales and maximizing their exposure to consumers on the platform, while simultaneously ensuring that our user genuinely enjoys a great shopping experience on our platforms, whether on the open platform or the closed platform.

Ronald Keung

analyst
#44

Understood — thanks, Martin and James.

Wendy Huang

executive
#45

Thanks. Our following question is from Robin Zhu at Bernstein.

Robin Zhu

analyst
#46

Thanks to management for taking my questions. I have a couple, if I may. First, on AI — you folks have discussed advertising, fintech and so forth at length. Gaming is often viewed as one of those fields where generative-AI might have a fairly large impact, potentially in areas like game design, function, AI and PCs and so on. Views differ on how much is hype versus how much is reality. I'm curious where you stand on how fast you want to move in some of these areas. Then a follow-up, also on gaming: I believe a couple of quarters ago you said there was a periodic slowdown in the productivity of triple-A game development. I just wanted your thoughts on where you are with that, the aspiration to do a new big title at the level of your top games every so often, every few years, and the aspiration to do console and PC beyond just the mobile ecosystem. Thank you.

James Mitchell

executive
#47

When it comes to applying AI to games, I'd say the line between hype and reality, as with so many things, depends on how far ahead you're prepared to look — and we're prepared to look very far ahead. Every area you brought up — AI-powered NPCs, AI-accelerated graphic content generation, graphical asset generation — those are areas where, over the years ahead rather than the months ahead, we'll see meaningful benefit from deploying AI. It's also fair to say the game industry has always combined two things: on one hand, innovation in gameplay techniques, and on the other, deployment of enhanced content, of renewed content, into existing gameplay. It's reasonable to believe AI will be most beneficial for that second activity, but the first opportunity — creating innovative gameplay — will still require very talented individuals and teams focused on it. Second, on productivity in triple-A game development: for our international studios, there were some bumps from COVID during the current game development cycle, and those are now largely behind us, so we believe productivity is now on a more normal footing.

James Mitchell

executive
#48

As we look ahead, we expect quite a few significant hits to come through the pipeline, in both domestic and international markets, and some of our approach stays the same while other parts are changing. On the changing side, our emphasis is on a smaller number of larger-budget titles. Generally, we aim to place our biggest bets on titles that either build on a successful IP — for instance, the Honour of Kings fighting game, built around the Honour of Kings IP — or titles that take proven gameplay success in a niche and bring it to a broader mass market. A classic illustration would be taking the Dark Souls combat and putting it into Elden Ring. In our situation, as I said before, we carry learnings from titles like Naruto, and those will be refreshed with cutting-edge graphics and technology for titles like One Piece. Also, when it comes to marketing, we now work with a variety of platforms, Douyin among them, covering both user generated content marketing and paid advertising marketing, so on the whole we believe these strengthen our position — these changes strengthen where we stand with triple-A game releases — and we’re eager to see the results. Thank you.

Robin Zhu

analyst
#49

Thanks, James.

Wendy Huang

executive
#50

Thanks. We now have a question from Charlene Liu at HSBC. Charlene, your line is open. We can hear you, so please go ahead.

Charlene Liu

analyst
#51

Thanks a lot for that. I've got two things I'd like to ask about. The first concerns fintech. Tenpay raised its registered capital not long ago, and I'd like to understand a bit more about how those funds might be deployed—whether toward consumer lending or perhaps the overseas operations—and what impact that would have on Tencent's balance sheet. I'd also like to know if management can give us an update on the fintech growth strategy for 2024. That's my first question. My second one relates to AI development. Clearly, advances in AI are generating new revenue streams and delivering cost optimization for internet platforms abroad, and management has already talked about where some of the monetization opportunities are. Could we get a better understanding of the benefits we've managed to capture on the cost side through adopting AI, how much additional upside we might expect from here, and how long it will take Tencent to realize those gains? Thank you.

Martin Lau

analyst
#52

On the fintech side, Tenpay has received approval for a substantial increase in registered capital. The funds will effectively shift from Tencent's balance sheet over to Tenpay's balance sheet. Because Tenpay is a consolidated entity, our consolidated balance sheet won't change as a result. I'd characterize this capital increase as essentially an acknowledgment of how much Tenpay's business has grown, and it also signals approval for the company's future development, so we see it in a very positive light. Turning to our fintech strategy, I'd say it revolves around the payment platform. We'll keep building out that payment platform and enhancing its core services and reliability as a platform supporting economic activity and consumption across the economy. We'll continue launching new and improved functionalities, among them strengthening the mini-programs payment ecosystem, so that beyond offering merchants a payment service right at the point of sale, we also help forge a connection linking merchants and consumers. That way, merchants and consumers can interact further down the road — perhaps consumers make repeat purchases, merchants engage with consumers in the future, and aftersales service can be provided too. So I think there's plenty we can do to enhance the overall payment experience.

Martin Lau

analyst
#53

We’re going to give SMEs additional tools so they can digitize their operations more and more and become more efficient. We’ll introduce new payment technologies — palm payment, for instance — to make paying more convenient, and we’ll also enhance how foreigners in China experience payments, which can help build an even livelier tourism sector in China. If we keep doing that, the payment platform will keep expanding alongside the economy, alongside consumption, and alongside cashless penetration in China. Beyond that, we also believe we can roll out value-added financial information services — wealth management, loan services, and installment services, which I described in the prepared remarks — and these are very high-margin, high-value-added services we can provide together with licensed financial institutions. Overall, I think our philosophy for growing the fintech business is this: first, we want to be fully compliant; second, we want to ensure we manage risk in an absolutely high-quality manner. We want to create more value than we capture for merchants with consumers, and at the same time we want to build constructive relationships with licensed financial institutions.

Martin Lau

analyst
#54

As long as we keep executing on all those fronts, the fintech business is going to keep thriving.

James Mitchell

executive
#55

Regarding the AI question and the cost benefit, as you'd expect, we're going to be deploying AI more and more, generative-AI included, in areas like speeding up the creation of animated content — which is big business for Tencent Video and a profitable business for Tencent Video — in terms of new game content, as we discussed earlier, and potentially in terms of creating code in general. But the benefit won't show up in substantial cost reductions; it will show up in faster content creation and therefore faster monetization and revenue generation. Not to repeat the same point too many times, but the immediate benefit and the biggest benefit is really around the advertising revenue uplift. Martin gave the example that if we can improve click-through rates by 10%, then that's RMB 10 billion in incremental revenue, probably RMB 8 billion in incremental gross and operating profit. In reality, you should view 10% as being in the nature of a floor, not a ceiling. Facebook has seen a substantially bigger improvement in click-through rates, and for some of our most important inventories, we've actually seen our click-through rates increase by 100% in the past 18 months, so when we're thinking about where the financial benefits of AI are, then it's advertising click-through rate, and therefore advertising revenue first and foremost, and that's a very high flow through business for us.

James Mitchell

executive
#56

I appreciate that.

Charlene Liu

analyst
#57

I appreciate that.

Wendy Huang

executive
#58

Thanks. We’ll go to the next question, and that comes from Alex Yao at JP Morgan.

Alex Yao

analyst
#59

I appreciate the management team for taking my question. First off, I'd like to ask about the recent collaboration with Douyin, which we think created a fairly significant ripple effect across the entire game livestreaming and gaming sector. What kinds of changes have you observed that this partnership has delivered for us? That's the first one. The second one concerns the monetization path for video accounts. Obviously, I believe the industry incumbent has shown short video monetization capability spanning advertising, ecommerce, and local services. What's your thinking and strategy when it comes to video accounts pushing into local services? Thank you.

James Mitchell

executive
#60

Alex, I’ll take the first question about promoting our titles via extra channels, Douyin included. As I said in response to Robin’s question, that’s underway. We’re putting out additional content that users subsequently spread virally across short video platforms—video accounts <<inaudible>>, Douyin, and similar services—and we’re likewise spending more on advertising our games actively on short video services; that covers the game marketing side.

Martin Lau

analyst
#61

When it comes to livestreaming ecommerce, I believe we've already covered that thoroughly. It's extremely synergistic, in my view, with video accounts and livestreaming, and also with the advertising inside video accounts. If we're able to create a closed loop — knowing which merchants are involved, which products got sold, and how users feel after the purchase — then our capacity to boost conversion rate across the entire chain becomes much stronger. That's precisely why building out the ecommerce infrastructure and ecosystem matters so much to us: we're anticipating it will support very long and significant growth in our video accounts advertising business. On the other hand, local services isn't really a focus for us right now. From where we sit, local services is much more about providing content, so in that vein we'd consider teaming up with partners — other partners, such as Meituan, our close partner for a long time — to have them produce the content while we help promote the local services.

Wendy Huang

executive
#62

Thanks. So we don't run over, the final question comes from James Lee at Mizuho.

James Lee

analyst
#63

I appreciate you taking my question. Am I coming through clearly?

Wendy Huang

executive
#64

Yes, we’ve got you.

James Lee

analyst
#65

All right, thanks for the chance to ask. I've got a question about cloud and AI. Where cloud is concerned, I believe a rival just came out with a fairly big price cut on its cloud product. I'm just wondering what you're observing regarding enterprise demand and, likely most significantly, price elasticity. Turning to AI, how should we view your positioning when it comes to large language models? I'm just curious what stage you're at right now, whether the model can deal with several modalities of data input and output, and just curious about that position as things stand. Thanks.

James Mitchell

executive
#66

Let me begin with cloud. Whether we like it or not, this is an industry in which the prices of inputs keep declining, so it follows that cloud service providers keep lowering the costs they hand on to customers. Price cuts have therefore always been present and will remain the pattern in cloud services for as long as Moore's law keeps pushing down what compute costs. We are not seeing any dramatic shift in the competitive landscape, just as we saw no dramatic shift when a round of price cuts arrived a year ago that were high profile yet low impact for SMBs. What counts is, first, staying cost competitive, and to stay cost competitive you need scale — several companies in China, ourselves included, sit at similar scale — and you need supply chain optimization, and over the last several quarters we have been very active on that front. As we optimize the supply chain, our input costs come down faster, and as a result we can reduce our output costs further. The second factor that counts is the ability to up-sell from infrastructure into platforms — our security platform, our real-time communications platform, our database platform — and also to up-sell into software as a service, including Tencent Meeting and WeCom and the other enterprise SaaS products we've spoken about, so that is really where our focus lies.

James Mitchell

executive
#67

Our focus is on giving cloud customers more value — by constantly optimizing the supply chain and by constantly upgrading how deep and how complex the services we offer can be.

Martin Lau

analyst
#68

On the Hunyuan model side, I believe — well, I actually covered this fairly extensively during our prepared remarks. Our view is that Hunyuan is currently delivering top-tier performance in the Chinese language among LLMs both within China and globally, and this conviction rests on the extensive internal testing we've carried out. Technologically speaking, the model employs a mixture of experts architecture that has already been scaled to the trillion parameter level, and it also shows strong results in multi-turn conversations, logical inference, and numerical reasoning — several of the hardest domains to master in large language models. Right now, our emphasis is squarely on text technology, since that really forms the foundation of the model. Starting from text, we've extended into text-to-picture and into text-to-video, and the next major step forward is really what we've witnessed with SORA, correct? SORA has accomplished something remarkable with text to long video, and that's — well, it's something we would be building out in the coming phase. We'll keep enhancing Hunyuan's core text capability.

Martin Lau

analyst
#69

Alongside that, we are going to build out text-to-video capability, since we genuinely believe it is highly relevant to our core business — a content-driven operation spanning short video, long video and games. That is the space where we will be advancing and steering our Hunyuan. Looking ahead, we believe Hunyuan will keep getting stronger in fundamental model capability, and at the same time it will begin developing increasingly better text-to-multimedia capability.

Wendy Huang

executive
#70

Thanks. That brings us to the close of this webinar. We appreciate everyone taking part in today's results call. Should you want to review our press release along with additional financial details, kindly head to the IR section on our corporate site, www.tencent.com. A recording of this webinar is going to be posted before long as well. Thanks again, and we'll talk to you in the next quarter.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Tencent Holdings Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Tencent Holdings Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Tencent Holdings Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.