The Home Depot, Inc. (HD) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 14, 2023

New York Stock Exchange US Consumer Discretionary Specialty Retail earnings 60 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Isabel Janci

executive
#1

Appreciate that, Christine, and good morning to all of you. It's a pleasure to welcome everyone to The Home Depot's earnings call for the third quarter of 2023. On today's call with us are Ted Decker, our Chair, President, and CEO; Ann-Marie Campbell, Senior Executive Vice President; Billy Bastek, Executive Vice President of Merchandising; and Richard McPhail, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. Once our prepared remarks conclude, we'll open the lines for questions. Only analysts and investors may ask questions, and please remember to keep to a single question plus one follow-up. Should we run out of time before reaching your question, you can reach our Investor Relations Department by dialing 770 to 384 to 2387. Before handing things over to Ted, I want to note that the press release issued today, along with the presentations our executives will make, contain forward-looking statements as defined in the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such statements carry risks and uncertainties that might cause actual results to differ materially from what we expect and project. Those risks and uncertainties include, but are not limited to, the factors laid out in the release and in our filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Certain non-GAAP measures will also appear in today's presentations. You can find a reconciliation of those measures on our website. With that, I'll hand the call to Ted.

Ted Decker

executive
#2

Thanks, Isabel, and good morning, everyone. Our third-quarter sales reached $37.7 billion, which represents a 3% decrease compared with the same quarter last year. Comp sales dropped 3.1% year over year, while comps at U.S. stores came in at negative 3.5%. Diluted earnings per share in Q3 were $3.81, compared with $4.24 in the third quarter of last year. The third quarter's results were in line with our expectations. Just like in the second quarter, we kept seeing customer engagement with smaller projects, along with pressure in some big-ticket discretionary categories; in addition, deflation in lumber and copper and wire, as well as storm-related overlaps, put a drag on results for the quarter. Billy is going to go over those and some other business patterns shortly. During Q3, results from our professional customers outpaced what we saw from do-it-yourself buyers. Even though surveys both inside and outside the company show pro backlogs are lower than they were twelve months back, those backlogs are still solid and above where they typically sit historically. Since only one quarter is left in the year, we now think the two ends of our earlier guidance range won't be the actual results. That's why, as stated in this morning's press release, we've tightened the range for fiscal 2023. Richard will explain the specifics in a bit. As we've mentioned before, this year is one of moderation. Even so, we believe we can navigate these unusual conditions. Our strategic efforts continue to generate real enthusiasm for us, and we're dedicated to funding the business so that we can provide the finest interconnected shopping experience, win more of the pro's wallet share, and expand our store footprint. During our June investor conference, we discussed how we keep directing investment and attention toward giving customers a seamless, interconnected buying experience. The strides we're taking make us happy. Among retail websites in the United States, HomeDepot.com stands as one of the biggest, and within the entire retail sector, our digital app holds some of the highest ratings. That said, we see room to make things less frustrating for customers from start to finish when they shop. Our teams are identifying where we can do better — for example, clearer communication at every stage of the buying experience, a simpler way to send items back, and letting people adjust an order after it's been submitted in a way that feels smooth and natural. When it comes to our pros, we're putting money into many different efforts; our attention stays on expanding the distinctive ecosystem of goods and services we offer. As a result, we're changing how our company is organized and just promoted Ann-Marie Campbell to Senior Executive Vice President, which does a better job of aligning our outside sales and service business within the global stores organization. Pro represents a major area where we can expand, and this shift in how we're structured will let us support those customers more effectively by drawing on everything we offer — our knowledge, the range of goods we carry, how we get orders to people, and how we run things day to day. Throughout the quarter, the people running our merchant operations, the MET teams in our stores, the partners who supply us, and the groups handling our supply chain all did remarkable work bringing value and service to the people who shop with us, and before I finish, I want to express my appreciation for their commitment and effort. Beyond that, The Home Depot feels proud that so many veterans, active service members, and military spouses — tens of thousands of them — wear its orange aprons. Earlier this week, we shared news that The Home Depot Foundation had exceeded its goal of $500 million dedicated to veterans' initiatives, while also increasing its total pledge to $750 million through 2030. Having said that, I'll now pass the call to Ann.

Ann-Marie Campbell

executive
#3

Thank you, Ted, and hello everybody on this call. First off, I want to share how thrilled I am about this new position and the way it will bring the outside sales and services operation into closer step with the global store organization. During our investor conference back in June, you heard that grabbing a bigger portion of the pros wallet stands as one of our biggest chances to grow; it accounts for about $475 billion in addressable market, and right now our share is fairly small. What makes The Home Depot special is that we hold distinctive competitive edges: handy locations, top brands, committed associates, and wide-ranging fulfillment choices that appear on maps and can be put to work for our customers' benefit. That is precisely what we intend to accomplish. To get there, our refreshed organizational design will generate greater momentum among our teams to win with the Pro. Hector Padilla will concentrate on making things better for pros who shop in our stores. His 29-year tenure and familiarity with our store operations and new pro capabilities will prove essential to reaching our objectives. Chip Devine, who leads Outside Sales, comes with almost 30 years of distribution experience. He will concentrate on developing capabilities to serve more complex product needs more effectively. In the end, we need to zero in on eliminating friction in our operations so that customers enjoy a terrific experience each and every time, however they decide to buy from us, whether that's in our store aisles, selecting an item at the store, getting product at their job site, working with a sales associate, or online. We recognize that the majority of our pros take advantage of numerous such capabilities throughout our ecosystem when they shop with us. On our side, we are fostering trust and a partnership that endures for decades and spans generations; that requires us to strive hard to provide a wonderful experience whatever point of interaction they use. As you're aware, we have pinpointed further growth possibilities with the Pro, and those demand that we put money into new capabilities and functionalities throughout the business. Consider the initiative we are pursuing with the Complex Pro. This kind of customer behaves differently. They are used to dealing with their suppliers in a manner unlike our traditional business model. Pros handling complex projects wish to hold product, tap trade credit, and get products brought to their job site in stages. Although such capabilities are available in the market right now, we are folding them into our entire ecosystem to serve Pro customers in a way nobody else can. I could not feel more enthusiastic about what lies ahead. Turning to the in-store experience, we have spoken over the past several years about how much in-stock matters and, in the end, on-shelf availability, or OSA. Keeping the right products in stock, in the right quantity, and sitting on the shelf ready to buy is essential, and we have rolled out a number of initiatives to help us accomplish this more effectively and efficiently. Earlier, we discussed GSR, or Get Stores Right. By applying our proprietary space allocation model alongside experienced field merchandising teams, GSR boosts productivity and identifies which categories warrant investment at each individual store. More recently, we've updated you on our deployment of Sidekick and Computer Vision. Leveraging machine learning, Computer Vision enables our associates to locate depalletized products in the overhead swiftly, while Sidekick guides associates toward critical bays where OSA is low or out-of-stocks occur. As of today, these tools are live in every U.S. store, and though it remains early, they've produced substantial gains in our on-shelf availability. What makes these efforts so powerful is that they simultaneously enhance productivity. They simplify restocking for associates, provide greater depth of high velocity product, and keep us in stock with more items on the shelf ready for purchase. Consequently, we free up our associates to concentrate on the highest-priority tasks and devote more time to delivering an improved shopping experience; these represent only a handful of examples among the many initiative types capable of generating considerable value for our customers, our associates, and our shareholders. Even through a difficult year, our incredible associates have stayed engaged and prepared to serve our customers, and I wish to thank them for everything they do; with that, I'll hand the call over to Billy.

Billy Bastek

executive
#4

Thank you, Ann, and good morning to all of you. I'd like to begin by expressing gratitude as well to each of our associates and supplier partners for their continued dedication to supporting our customers and communities. As Ted mentioned, sales during Q3 came in as we had anticipated. That said, we did encounter certain unfavorable effects related to core commodity deflation as well as overlaps from storms. A trend we've been watching all year long persisted, with weakness appearing in particular big ticket, discretionary kinds of purchases. Rather than taking on larger projects, customers kept pursuing smaller ones. Now, looking at how our departments performed on a comp basis in Q3, our building materials department delivered a positive comp, and 7 of our other 13 merchandising departments generated comps exceeding the company average, among them plumbing, appliances, hardware, outdoor garden, millwork, tools, and paint. In Q3, our comp transactions fell 2.7%, while comp average ticket slipped 0.3%. Once deflation from core commodities is excluded, comp average ticket grew, mainly fueled by demand for new and innovative products. Deflation across core commodity categories dragged down our average ticket growth by roughly 60 basis points in Q3, with lumber and copper behind that deflation. In Q3, we kept seeing lumber prices drop versus the prior year. To illustrate, framing lumber averaged about $420 per 1,000 board feet, against roughly $545 in Q3 of 2022, which works out to a reduction exceeding 20%. Big ticket comp transactions, meaning those exceeding $1,000, declined 5.2% versus Q3 of last year. We're still seeing weaker engagement in big ticket discretionary categories such as flooring, countertops, and cabinets; even so, big ticket strength showed up in pro heavy categories including roofing, insulation, and portable power. Now for total company online sales, sales using our digital platforms rose roughly 5% versus Q3 of last year. We kept investing in the digital experience across our website and app, rolling out a range of enhancements in Q3. These go from straightforward improvements that help customers track orders to more intricate items such as updating our search and recommendation algorithms. Among customers who transacted with us online in Q3, almost half of our online orders got fulfilled through our stores. In Q3, we held our annual Labor Day Appliance and Halloween events, and the results pleased us. In appliances, we felt encouraged by how customers engaged during the event. 2023 marked another record sales year for our Halloween program, both in-store and online, since our customers kept adding to their collection with our unique and exclusive product assortment. As our focus shifts toward Q4, we plan to carry that momentum forward with our annual holiday, Black Friday, and Gift Center events. When it comes to our Gift Center, we keep emphasizing the brands that are most important to our shoppers, featuring our lineup of Milwaukee, Ryobi, Makita, DeWalt, RIDGID, Husky, and others. There will be an option for everybody, whether that means our broad selection of cordless Ryobi tools, DeWalt Atomic drill and impact kits, or our latest Milwaukee M18 FORGE batteries. For our pro customer, these new M18 FORGE batteries are going to change everything, delivering the strongest, quickest-charging, and longest-lasting performance of any battery across the Milwaukee M18 platform; this quarter, I am also thrilled to share that WAGO is joining our powerhouse lineup of pro brands, such as Milwaukee, USG, Custom Building Products, Leviton, and QEP, to name a few. Those strategic vendor relationships are what make us the product authority in home improvement, and bringing in WAGO will help us extend that position. Among the wire connector segment's most requested and most innovative pro brands is WAGO, which offers a releasable lever lock wire connector that accelerates installation and conserves space in tight applications. A number of SKUs have recently launched in our stores, and they are exclusive to The Home Depot within the national big box retail channel. Being our customer's advocate for value stays the focus of our merchandising organization. That means we keep offering a broad assortment of best-in-class products that are in stock and ready for our customers whenever they need them. We will also keep leaning into products that make the project simpler, saving time and money for our customers. That is why the innovation we keep bringing to the market excites me so much. Having said that, I would like to hand the call over to Richard.

Richard McPhail

executive
#5

Thanks, Billy, and good morning to all of you. For the third quarter, overall revenue came in at $37.7 billion, which is a decline of roughly $1.2 billion, or 3%, versus the prior year. In Q3, company-wide comps landed at -3.1%, breaking down as -2.1% for August, -3.4% for September, and -3.7% for October. U.S. comps for the quarter stood at -3.5%, with monthly figures of -2.5% in August, -3.8% in September, and -4.1% in October. Measured in local currency, both Mexico and Canada recorded comps that beat the company average. Worth noting is that once you account for storm-related overlaps and a bit of seasonal shifting, monthly comps held fairly steady throughout the quarter; gross margin for Q3 was 33.8%, roughly 20 basis points lower than the same period a year ago, which matched what we had anticipated. In Q3, operating expense measured as a percentage of sales rose about 120 basis points to 19.4%, versus the third quarter of 2022. This operating expense result for Q3 mirrors the compensation raises for hourly associates that we put through earlier, along with deleverage stemming from our top line results... Operating margin in Q3 came to 14.3%, against 15.8% during the third quarter of 2022. Interest and other expense for Q3 grew by about $30 million, reaching $438 million. Our effective tax rate for Q3 was 23.3%, lower than the 24.4% recorded in the third quarter of fiscal 2022. Diluted earnings per share in Q3 totaled $3.81, which is a 10.1% drop relative to the third quarter of 2022. We opened 7 new stores during Q3, which lifted our total store count to 2,333. Retail selling square footage came to roughly 242 million sq ft. Merchandise inventories finished the quarter at $22.8 billion, a reduction of $2.9 billion, or 11%, from the third quarter of 2022, while inventory turns were 4.3 times, unchanged from a year ago. Moving to capital allocation. Once we've invested in the business and paid our dividend, our intention is to give excess cash back to shareholders through share repurchases. In the quarter, we put approximately $670 million into our business as capital expenditures. We also paid out roughly $2.1 billion in dividends to shareholders during the quarter, and we returned about $1.5 billion to shareholders via share repurchases. Calculated using the average of beginning and ending long-term debt and equity over the trailing twelve months, return on invested capital was approximately 38.7%, down from 43.3% in the third quarter of fiscal 2022. I'll now share some thoughts on our guidance for fiscal 2023. As Ted mentioned, with one quarter left in fiscal 2023, the endpoints of our prior guidance range are no longer viewed as probable outcomes, so we are tightening our outlook for 2023. We anticipate fiscal 2023 sales and comp sales falling 3%-4%. For the year, we are aiming for an operating margin of 14.2%-14.1%. We're aiming for an effective tax rate of about 24.5%. Interest expense should come in around $1.8 billion, and versus fiscal 2022 we're looking at diluted earnings per share declining somewhere between 9% and 11%; beyond that, as Ann mentioned, driving productivity across the business stays a priority for us. A series of steps have been put in place that will assist us in achieving the $500 million in annualized cost savings we previously announced for 2024, and we have complete confidence in fulfilling that pledge. Our attention also stays on serving customer needs through our leading product authority in home improvement, solid in-stock levels, and well-informed associates. We'll keep investing prudently to bolster our competitive standing and to use our scale along with our low-cost position to beat the market and produce shareholder value. Thanks for joining today's call, and Christine, let's begin taking questions.

Simeon Gutman

analyst
#6

Hi there, morning everybody. As we consider turning points and when one could arrive, examining the gap perhaps between DIY and pro, does this quarter's narrative suggest DIY has maybe leveled off, while pro is deteriorating somewhat? And if so — and please correct me if I've got that wrong — would that imply it might take somewhat longer for pro to finish normalizing, and in fact the total comp might decline a bit more prior to improving?

Richard McPhail

executive
#7

Good morning, Simeon. Appreciate the question. What I'd say is pro and consumer — that gap in performance was the tightest it's been in quite a while, so both did fairly well. If you zoom out and examine the quarter, we're feeling quite positive about Q3, and as a result we tightened our comp outlook for the full year. Actually, when you look at how the business performed in total this year, considering the seasonal pattern of Q1 and Q2, we're fairly steady at a -3% comp across the first three quarters of this year, and that's adjusted for weather, storms, and commodity price deflation; beyond that, our regional operations are quite steady too; regional variability has been at its lowest, and like I mentioned, the pro versus consumer gap is at its tightest. Seasonal sell-through was quite strong, and with prices having stabilized as deflation eased, we're feeling fairly confident about that.

Ted Decker

executive
#8

Things are largely returning to the way they used to be. The supply chain is performing quite smoothly. We're in a better spot with inventory, our in-stock rates have improved considerably, and Ann walked you through everything we're doing in stores to make sure products are available on shelves. As Billy said, our value propositions look strong, product innovation has never been better, and the money we've put into wages is delivering returns. Attrition has dropped significantly, and because of that decline, our associates are spending more time on the floor, and their capacity to take care of customers has gotten better. So all of that is really what produced that steady comp across the year. That said, to address what you asked specifically, while we're sitting here feeling quite good about operations, the share shift of PCE from before COVID until now hasn't fully gone back, and we still can't say precisely where that ends up. The home improvement asset class is worth $15-odd trillion more than it was before the pandemic. And we recognize at this point that the Fed definitely maintains a higher for longer monetary stance, and that will keep weighing on durable goods when it comes to financing or the motivation for bigger home improvement projects; so like we said, we're seeing strong engagement in seasonal goods, engagement with smaller projects. It's just that larger projects are somewhat soft right now; so that's the thing we're monitoring. Obviously we're not discussing 2024 today, but there's plenty of positive news in how the business operates. Great news with a customer who remains very resilient. After all, we just came off 4.9% GDP in Q3, driven by the consumer. But as you're aware, we're looking at this year, this stretch of moderation, for home improvement spend, yet couldn't feel better about the business and about our operations overall.

Simeon Gutman

analyst
#9

I appreciate that. And perhaps as a follow-up, you brought up GDP. Since, as you know, home prices appear rather sticky, despite fairly soft turnover, and might not improve, how should we... ought we to consider GDP? Should we go back to GDP as perhaps a superior proxy for what the business might achieve?

Richard McPhail

executive
#10

Simeon, I'm Richard. As you know, we've aimed to adopt the most considered method feasible across the past several years regarding what drives the business, and the factors that signal to us, you know, how we've settled back out from the pandemic era, which is why we honed in on share of PCE. As Ted mentioned, we won't discuss 2024 today. There's a fundamental sort of stratum of economic activity underpinning the business; yet as Ted noted, first, we still haven't fully reverted to 2019 levels of PCE share, and the Fed's higher-for-longer position has exerted and could exert growing pressure on the outlook for durables and housing-related spend. So as Ted stated, that's what we're monitoring right now. We'll discuss 2024 once we reach our call next quarter.

Simeon Gutman

analyst
#11

Thanks.

Zach Fadem

analyst
#12

Hi there, good morning. Richard, when you take into account everything affecting your cost structure this year — the wage investments, that legal settlement from Q1, and then the savings coming next year — should we fairly expect operating margins to grow in 2024? Or do you need to hit some specific comparable sales level to keep that margin at 14% or above?

Richard McPhail

executive
#13

Good morning, Zach, and thanks for asking. Margin growth really comes down mostly to how the top line performs. At a certain point — low positive comp digits — your expenses shift from deleverage into leverage. We won't be offering 2024 guidance at this time. What we've done instead is implement measures, and in fact have now basically finished the actions, that give us a $500 million cost buffer as we enter 2024, so no matter what the outlook turns out to be, that gives us some cushion on margin.

Zach Fadem

analyst
#14

Understood; and then you brought up that the legal settlement gain from Q1 would be reinvested; so to start, do you have anything on what that reinvestment actually consists of, or how it might take shape? And then, is it reasonable to say the spending will mostly land in Q4, or was some of it already in Q3?

Richard McPhail

executive
#15

A portion of it, we've had a portion of it, spent across the year. I believe the assumption still holds that by the time the year ends, that favorability will be entirely offset. So honestly, I'd direct you to our guidance as the best starting point for your modeling.

Zach Fadem

analyst
#16

Got it. Thanks for the time.

Richard McPhail

executive
#17

Thanks, Zach.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#18

Morning, everybody. Across certain other retail sectors — actually, quite a few of them — what we're noticing is a shift back toward how buying happened before COVID, meaning you'd likely observe heavier purchasing activity on weekends plus during holidays and events, with, honestly, deeper quiet stretches separating them. That brings up two questions: first, does a broadly comparable trend show up for you? Second, if that's indeed what's happening, can your team capitalize on such a trend operationally to boost productivity? Thanks.

Billy Bastek

executive
#19

Yeah, appreciate that question, Scott. This is Billy. Look, when it comes to varying shifts in how customers behave and things like that, that isn't something we've observed — it's stayed quite steady across the quarter; and like Ted said during his prepared remarks, essentially all year long, once you factor in certain weather impacts along with that bathtub effect from the first half. So that's not something we've observed. Look, regarding any sort of promotional pushes, our stores hold events that we enjoy running and that create excitement among our customers, yet when it comes to promotional pushes, things truly have gone back to how they were before COVID. As you know, our pricing has definitely, per Ted's comments, leveled out across the past several months. The landscape has definitely become stable. So, as you know, we compete within a highly rational market and promotional landscape. Like I mentioned, this has gone back to roughly pre-pandemic conditions.

Richard McPhail

executive
#20

Our attention will remain fixed on EDLP at all times.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#21

Thanks.

Richard McPhail

executive
#22

Scott, EDLP is what we'll keep concentrating on, always. What I'm saying is, at particular times of year we run events, and honestly, those are quite enjoyable. Our associates find them engaging, and so do our shoppers. Even so, every single day, throughout all 12 months, our goal is to operate as an EDLP retailer offering strong value daily.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#23

Understood. Thanks. And a brief follow-up here. Regarding the large, discretionary purchases, are there particular segments where you're truly noticing a favorable turn, or do all of them remain at what you'd describe as mid-single digit negative?

Billy Bastek

executive
#24

No, as I mentioned during my prepared remarks, areas such as portable power and similar ones, where engagement has been excellent. Honestly, we're delighted with the innovation we keep collaborating on alongside our supplier base, which we introduce to the market. In places where innovation persists, we keep witnessing strong engagement from the Pro as well as the consumer.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#25

Understood. Appreciate it, folks.

Chris Horvers

analyst
#26

Thank you. Morning, everyone. I've got a few follow-ups to earlier questions. First off: regarding the gross margin drop we saw in Q3, could you shed some light on what caused it? You were up against storm-driven demand, plus there was some commodity deflation, so my assumption was those factors would help; is that accurate? And what worked against it to push it down?

Richard McPhail

executive
#27

Appreciate that, Chris. I'll refer back to what Billy said, and Ted brought this up too. The key takeaway, in my view, is that inflation's toughest stretch is now behind us, and because of that, as Billy put it, retail pricing is finding its footing in the market. Certain prices are landing above where they were in 2022, while others are landing below, yet we're observing a degree of stabilization that Billy can speak to. Regarding this quarter specifically and gross margin, there are timing mismatches as certain prices settle before the expected product and transportation cost savings flow through as our inventory turns. But those are—I'd essentially treat them as timing. For the whole year, our stance on gross margin remains the same, and we anticipate modest year-over-year pressure; but Billy, perhaps you could address the settling of prices.

Billy Bastek

executive
#28

Yeah, I mean, like you said, you know, it feels like that inflationary period is now behind us. Prices have really settled down, and again, I'll repeat my point, you know, we operate in a very rational market; and one more thing I'd mention is that this really isn't any different from any other period, honestly. We use a portfolio approach for how we handle, whether it's lumber deflation that we've discussed a lot over the course of the year or other, you know, ins and outs when it comes to the P&L; so a very normalized environment, rational and really a stabilization that we've observed across the board when it comes to pricing.

Chris Horvers

analyst
#29

Understood. That's clear, makes sense. Now, regarding variable costs, you mentioned a historical leverage point in the low single digits and $500 million in cost savings for next year. Meanwhile, you've been seeing negative transactions for a while. So could you discuss where things stand in terms of how this becomes less variable over time, perhaps in relation to the percentage of stores operating at minimum staffing levels? If negative comps occur in 2024 or during the next six months, is the flexibility gained from the $500 million offset by potentially ongoing negative transactions and reduced flexibility?

Richard McPhail

executive
#30

Chris, I appreciate the question. That response contains quite a bit of speculation about 2024, I must say. When you refer to shifts in the character of our labor model, the extent of transaction changes isn't significant enough to claim it alters the nature of our labor model.

Chris Horvers

analyst
#31

Understood. That sounds fine. Many thanks.

Michael Lasser

analyst
#32

Hello, good morning, and I appreciate your time in answering my question. You mentioned that the discounting climate is quite rational. Should the home improvement cycle or slump stay drawn out and prolonged, what circumstances would lead you to anticipate discounting becoming more aggressive than it was during 2019 throughout the sector? And in that scenario, would Home Depot opt to stay faithful to everyday low pricing and the portfolio-based strategy it follows, or would it aim to defend market share and take part in some of that promotional activity?

Ted Decker

executive
#33

Good morning, Michael. Yes, we will remain dedicated to EDLP and our promotional rhythms, as we mentioned before — you know, Black Friday, you know, appliances and gift center and, you know, certain spring events for, you know, seasonal garden items to bring traffic into stores. Those have been, you know, the approach for many, many years, correct, Billy?

Richard McPhail

executive
#34

That's right.

Ted Decker

executive
#35

And we don't anticipate moving away from that approach. As a matter of fact, we've remained even more committed to cutting back on promotional activity. Consider categories such as ceiling fans, which I recall were always going on and off promotion — you know, 10% and 20% off paint, a category that was promotional where, you know, it was 5% and 10%, and later it became 10% and 20%. We've pulled back on all of that; and at the margin, our preference would be to promote even less than we do right now. If the market experienced a prolonged downturn, I mean, absolutely we're gonna be competitive, and absolutely, we are going to defend our share; but when you consider what a big home improvement project is like, especially one a pro handles, you know, labor makes up such a substantial portion of that job. I mean, take paint, for instance. You know, if you're painting your living room for, you know, $500, the paint in that job is gonna be under $100, and it's your labor bill, either your opportunity cost as a consumer or the pro doing the job for you. So, you know, being extremely aggressive to knock $10 off the $100 component of a $500 job, I don't think really moves the needle, and that's why our bias, our starting position would be, no, we wouldn't chase a lot of price in that dynamic.

Michael Lasser

analyst
#36

Understood, that's quite useful. For my second question: in the past, Home Depot has generally set expectations low and then surpassed them across nearly every dimension. When you put together that $500 million figure for net cost savings for next year, is it fair to assume you followed that same playbook, meaning there might be room for that number to go higher?

Richard McPhail

executive
#37

Honestly, that cost figure stemmed largely from the fact that we had added capacity to manage the surge in our volume during COVID, and then came the downward slope of that curve, when we scaled back capacity in numerous ways. So doing that was appropriate no matter what conditions we faced; it just so happens to give us a cushion for our operating margin as we head into 2024.

Michael Lasser

analyst
#38

All right, thanks a lot, and enjoy the holidays.

Ted Decker

executive
#39

Same to you.

Steven Zaccone

analyst
#40

Good morning to all of you, and thanks for letting me ask. Ann, congratulations on stepping into your new position. My focus is on the professional segment of the business. Regarding what was said about expanding through the complex pro, previously the emphasis was placed on flatbed distribution centers and rolling them out region by region. Does that remain the core approach over the coming couple of years? And when you step back and consider what the complex pro opportunity holds, which items rank at the top of the list during that one-to-two-year window?

Ann-Marie Campbell

executive
#41

Steven, I appreciate it — many thanks for those generous remarks. As you know, Chip is here with us, and he's been deeply familiar with this subject. So I'll hand things over to Chip, and he can share a bit about certain capabilities we keep drawing on, along with some of the functionalities and capabilities we intend to keep developing.

Ted Decker

executive
#42

Okay, thanks Steven. We're going to keep going, of course, with pushing forward on adding more outside sales teams and keep building up the complex Pro, like was brought up during the earlier comments. Linking things up with the store matters a lot for this asset build too. Every day, our pros are shopping at our locations, and tying that ecosystem into our flatbed delivery systems is, is a piece of that. So when we look at growing into other markets, as we go beyond where we sit right now, we'll keep assessing what the best chance is to grow those, distribution assets too, in order to back our growth in Pro.

Steven Zaccone

analyst
#43

All right, thank you. I'd like to go back to what Simeon asked regarding inflection, since I realize this is a hard environment to forecast. That said, when you consider the business, which main components are needed to move it from this stretch of moderation into a steadier market environment, the kind you described as low single digit market growth? I'm interested in your view on whether the PCE shift is truly the driver. Is it interest rates? Any insight you can offer would be appreciated. Thanks.

Ted Decker

executive
#44

Yes... We constantly examine the relationship between ticket and transactions; and something notable from the COVID stretch was that we had inflation, which pushed AUR higher, and ticket higher too, partly from basket size. Yet engagement ran so strong that elasticities basically weren't present. Ticket and transactions were both rising, which is how we got to that 25% comp. Once inflation eased, mainly in commodities, and those prices dropped, you've witnessed a decline in ticket, and at first the elasticity you'd normally anticipate didn't show up, because customers kept pushing ahead with projects; at this point it's a combination of how much pricing response there is, versus pull forward, versus the Fed's position and elevated interest rates. All those forces are clouding the usual ticket and transaction relationship. What's good for us, though, is a healthy comp split evenly between ticket and transactions. That's the outcome we'd want. And as we've mentioned, prices have basically flattened. Our ticket came down slightly, and excluding commodity, our ticket would have risen during the quarter. As for transactions, we're still dealing with some of that PCE shift, pull forward, whatever that force turns out to be. Still, going forward we'd want to see growth in both, in a good balance.

Billy Bastek

executive
#45

That's really useful. Thank you, everyone.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#46

Hello, and good morning. I appreciate you taking my question. What I want to ask — I believe Michael might have raised this earlier regarding pricing moves — but perhaps I can broaden it somewhat. We've been talking about this pattern, along with softness in larger purchases, for some time now. Clearly, the demand environment is quite unusual. Still, from where you sit, especially with an eye toward 2024, is there anything Home Depot could do — beyond pricing — to help spark stronger demand in big ticket items?

Ted Decker

executive
#47

The primary method we're using to generate demand centers on the complex Pro customer. That represents our core strategy, and it's where our attention sits. It's a space worth $200 billion, as we've framed it — the 950 split evenly between Pro and consumer. Out of that 475 on the Pro side, $200 billion comes from larger pros with more complex spending, and we're developing the capabilities needed to meet that demand. Brian, that's precisely what we're concentrating on very, very intently. I believe that for many years to come, it will fuel our business as we capture share within that roughly $200 billion white space.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#48

Okay, thanks Ted, understood. Now for my second question, a much faster one. As you know, we clearly—you guys tightened the outlook for the rest of the year. We discussed what happened in the fiscal third quarter, but is there anything you can say regarding sales patterns in these early days of fiscal Q4?

Richard McPhail

executive
#49

Through the initial 2 weeks, results are where they need to be for us to hit the full year 2023 outlook.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#50

Sounds great. Thanks a lot, and congratulations once more.

Richard McPhail

executive
#51

Thanks.

Peter Benedict

analyst
#52

Hey everyone, thanks for taking my question. I've got another one on average ticket. Before COVID, it was roughly $67. From what I understand, today it's running closer to $90, so that's a 35% increase. Richard, I'm curious if you could share your thoughts on the like-for-like SKU inflation component versus the mix from big ticket items. Your like-for-like inflation appears to be leveling off, from what I can tell. I realize innovation can cause items to fall outside like-for-like comparisons, but I'd just like to hear your view on the big ticket exposure and what might happen there — how significant of a factor is that? Thanks.

Richard McPhail

executive
#53

I appreciate that question. There are a few ways to respond. To start, inflation has cooled off and pretty much leveled out on a comparable basis throughout our portfolio. What's notable is that, as you're aware, big ticket has shown varying patterns over time — lumber prices rising and falling specifically have distorted those big ticket numbers. Billy, perhaps you could share a bit about what's happening in that area.

Billy Bastek

executive
#54

Okay, so, um, just to pick up on what Ted said to Brian — when you look at segments such as drywall, where we've got the capabilities, plus roofing, insulation, and portable power, where we've brought in innovation, we're still seeing a fantastic response, from both the pro and the consumer side, to the innovation itself and to what we're observing. When it comes to big ticket, well, clearly there's been some deferral and so on, like we discussed, and certainly the pull forward is, I'd say, still a factor there as we move further out from the pandemic, so we'll be keeping a close eye on that; we aren't seeing anything, as I said, with pricing stabilized and the environment rational, and nothing we're seeing differs from what's shown up over the past several months now.

Ann-Marie Campbell

executive
#55

All right. Appreciate it, everyone. So then, I suppose, shifting over to perhaps the leverage and how fast the buyback goes. What I mean is, should we remain in this kind of setting of, say, demand moderating, what's your thinking on perhaps striking a balance with your buyback strategy and leverage? I mean, you're running under 2x. Does anything stop you from sort of climbing to that 2x, or are you doing so? You know, I'm just sort of wondering about your most recent views on those subjects. Thanks.

Richard McPhail

executive
#56

Thanks. As you’re aware, we’ve kept our leverage around that 2x debt-to-EBITDA level, and we plan to stay there for the foreseeable future; we’ll also, you know, keep our approach to capital allocation consistent. First we put money into the business, then we pay our dividend, and after that, once we identify excess cash, we return it to shareholders through repurchases. To your point, up to now, we’ve bought back $6.5 billion. Our position really hasn’t changed, so I think that’s the key thing to take away.

Ann-Marie Campbell

executive
#57

All right, thank you very much. Best of luck.

Mike Baker

analyst
#58

All right, thank you. So when I look at Q4, taking the middle of the implied guidance, it points toward somewhat of a slowdown, and yet your business, you know, appears to have been steady. Is that simply because of... Am I overinterpreting that, or is a slowdown what we should expect? And then maybe as a follow-up, like you mentioned, Halloween came in very strong. Looking back historically, going into your trim a tree or holiday decorating business, I believe it's roughly 10 of the last 14 years that your Q4 comp has come in above the third quarter. What makes this year different from that pattern? Thank you.

Richard McPhail

executive
#59

Thank you for asking. You know, we, we. The range getting narrower is exactly that. The outer edges of that range grew less probable, so we thought it would be useful, for our investors, for us to make that range narrower. Throughout the year, from the start of the year, there has been an assumption that our guidance captured our PCE share reverting from the pandemic period to 2019 levels. Our earlier guidance range presumed that share would keep reverting across the year. That reversion has come gradually and steadily, and our present range still incorporates that assumption for Q4. We've mostly reverted, though not entirely back; so a bit, a bit of that idea is in our guide.

Mike Baker

analyst
#60

Alright. So it seems like, as you mentioned, it's simply a matter of reaching the midpoint of that range. Could I pose one more question? You touched briefly on storms and seasonality. I believe many retailers have mentioned it's been an unseasonably warm autumn. What kind of effect does that have on you? Do you require colder temperatures, you know, throughout Q4 in order to propel your business? What's the right way for us to look at that? Thanks.

Billy Bastek

executive
#61

It has been somewhat warmer, clearly, but, you know, not a significant effect. We began to observe the weather returning to normal. We began to observe a portion of that fall cleanup and fall business truly, truly accelerate. You know, we haven't obviously, you know, encountered snow and such; therefore, you know, it's fairly consistent with what we'd describe as a somewhat more typical year, in which the weather behaves in a more autumnal manner. You've witnessed, you know, the categories and businesses that you would anticipate moving higher, moving in that favorable direction.

Mike Baker

analyst
#62

I really appreciate it. Thank you for, thank you for finding space in your schedule.

Richard McPhail

executive
#63

Thank you. And just to give you a sense of scale, that $950 billion figure matters here.

Steven Forbes

analyst
#64

Morning. Ted, or perhaps this is for Ann — I just want to follow up regarding pro sales, with the main focus being the Dallas market compared with the chain average. Could you give us an update on how that market is doing? After that, maybe you could weigh in on any behavioral differences you're observing among pro markets, depending on how mature your strategic initiatives aimed at the complex pro happen to be. In other words, are you noticing changes in behavior that are quite predictable, and are you able to analyze them?

Ann-Marie Campbell

executive
#65

Yeah, I'll begin by simply stating that the capabilities and functionalities that Hector and Chip have, you know, been developing across the past several years are definitely, you know, going to assist us in generating a great deal of momentum and success with the pro. And, you know, Chip, you know, I'll hand things back to you again, since your knowledge of that is so intimate. But what we're focused on now is the pro ecosystem, and not the in-store side, or not just the in-store side, but the complex pro. And as we continue building out these capabilities and observe how effective they are, we're gonna keep leveraging them. And, Chip, you know, I'll hand things over to you so you can provide a bit more detail regarding Dallas.

Richard McPhail

executive
#66

Right. Appreciate it, Ann. And Steven, without a doubt — in the places where we have developed capabilities that include assets, distribution assets, and the places where we have grown our sales force, the impact and growth have been significant. Among all of our pros, the outside sales team delivers the strongest results of any group. So, as I said earlier, we will keep putting money into that, and then bring in assets where they're needed in the right markets.

Steven Forbes

analyst
#67

Thanks. Perhaps a brief follow-up for Richard or Billy. Regarding all the discussions about tickets, is there any way to summarize how the big ticket category did this quarter compared to what was anticipated? It seems like results were stronger than forecasted. There's a kind of settling in multi-year, big ticket comparable trends. My guess is that wasn't what was expected, but can you help us frame how the quarter unfolded for big ticket against the internal plan?

Billy Bastek

executive
#68

Yes, I think, you know, look, it went mostly as we had scheduled. We, you know, I mentioned, you know, some excellent engagement from our customers when it comes to appliances. That said, our inventory situation was improved there, so we benefited from simply having a stronger inventory stance in that regard. But it went pretty much just as we had anticipated. And truly, again, returning to what was said earlier, it was a quite even year overall when you factor in certain weather changes early on and then, you know, what we were up against with the hurricane. Quite even overall and throughout the regions.

Richard McPhail

executive
#69

Thematically speaking, I believe it's worth restating this: the Fed's position of higher for longer is, you know, showing up in survey data. Larger projects are being put off. So if you want to pull all the way back to the real macro picture and the pressures on ticket that we're monitoring, that's likely the biggest macro force.

Billy Bastek

executive
#70

Exactly.

Steven Forbes

analyst
#71

Appreciate it.

Isabel Janci

executive
#72

Christine, there's room for one final question.

Dean Rosen

analyst
#73

Hi, everyone. I really appreciate you letting me join. What I'd like to ask about is pro, specifically how it performed compared with the overall comp, and then how that breaks down between pro sales made in stores and pro sales from complex projects. Just so I'm clear on what you're saying: you reported a comp of about -3, with DIY and pro very close to each other, and the US a bit weaker than Canada and Mexico. So my guess is US pro was roughly down 2, 2.5. Can you either confirm that or set me straight? And then could you describe how pro purchases inside the store compare with pro purchases made outside the store, through the outside sales force and the FDCs? Thank you.

Richard McPhail

executive
#74

Let me start with your second point. As Ann put it, this is an ecosystem. We actually don't set goals or targets for how store sales and delivered sales split apart. What matters is raising sales overall, and that's been consistent everywhere we've introduced these capabilities. In the beginning, we were concerned that delivered sales might start taking business away from the store. What happened was the reverse; so we're making progress in a way that satisfies us. As for your earlier question, the facts are that pro did beat consumer in Q3, though by the smallest gap we've seen in a long while. Once you adjust for the effect of commodities, pro was basically even for the quarter.

Dean Rosen

analyst
#75

All right, that's helpful, thank you. And then for my second question, I suppose: regarding how you distinguish a large project from a small one, could you explain the criteria you use to make that call? Is it something like a transaction amount above $1,000? And if you wouldn't mind spelling that out, we'd appreciate it.

Richard McPhail

executive
#76

Our approach is to draw inferences from both category sales and class sales. As you're aware, for categories that tend to move in greater volumes and bigger projects — kitchens, flooring, and to some degree millwork — we're making certain inferences. Beyond that, we ask customers about what they're observing and the types of projects they have underway; we also rely on third-party survey information indicating that projects are somewhat transitioning away from larger and toward smaller, so we're essentially triangulating.

Dean Rosen

analyst
#77

That’s excellent; that’s really useful. I appreciate it very much, everyone. Best of luck during Q4.

Richard McPhail

executive
#78

Thanks.

Isabel Janci

executive
#79

Appreciate that, Christine, and thanks to all of you for being here with us today. We're looking forward to talking with you during our Q4 earnings call, which takes place in February.

Operator

operator
#80

Everyone, that brings today's teleconference to a close. You're welcome to disconnect your lines now. We appreciate you joining us, and enjoy the rest of your day.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete The Home Depot, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to The Home Depot, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in The Home Depot, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.