Valley National Bancorp (VLY) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

January 25, 2024

NASDAQ US Financials Banks earnings 69 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Travis Lan

executive
#1

Hello everyone, and thanks for joining us for Valley's conference call about our earnings for the fourth quarter of 2023. Here with me from Valley today are our Chief Executive Officer, Ira Robbins; our President, Tom Iadanza; and our Chief Financial Officer, Mike Hagedorn. Prior to starting, I want to let all of you know that you can find our quarterly earnings release along with supporting documents on the company's website, which is valley.com. In our discussion of results, we use non-GAAP measures, and those leave out specific items from what we reported. For reconciliations of those non-GAAP measures, please look at today's earnings release. Also, I want to draw your attention to Slide 2 in our earnings presentation, and to remind everyone that anything said on this call might include forward-looking statements about Valley National Bancorp and the banking industry. Valley asks that all participants review our SEC filings, such as those on Forms 8-K, 10-Q, and 10-K, for a full discussion of forward-looking statements and the factors that could make actual results differ from those statements. With that said, I'll hand things over to Ira Robbins.

Ira Robbins

executive
#2

Thank you, Travis. Valley's net income for Q4 2023 came in at $72 million, with earnings per share of $0.13. Once you strip out noncore items — among them the one-time special FDIC assessment connected to that year's bank failures — adjusted net income stood at $116 million and adjusted EPS at $0.22. I'm happy with how the balance sheet trended this quarter, but the earnings and profitability metrics leave me dissatisfied, and I'll get into that shortly. Turning to the positives: we advanced on building C&I growth while pulling back on commercial real estate originations. That let us do two things at once — accrete organic capital and shrink our funding needs. On deposits, we brought in an impressive 14,000 net new consumer households over the year, plus 8,000 net new commercial deposit relationships. Measured against the same period a year earlier, that's 4.5% growth in consumer households and 10.5% growth in commercial relationships. Continuing to bring on new deposit clients matters enormously, since it ties directly to Valley's franchise value and to what we can earn down the road. Our new customer growth showed up broadly across every geography we serve, and I'd note it happened while the external environment remained tough, with midsized banks such as Valley appearing far too often in front-page headlines. New relationships during the quarter drove strong customer deposit inflows, and that let us cut our reliance on broker deposits by a significant margin. Those customer deposit inflows were outstanding, yet the organization-wide focus on pulling off a successful core conversion in October probably caused us to take our eyes off the ball when it came to deposit pricing. Without question, that hurt net interest income this quarter. In a few minutes, Mike will walk through some of the follow-up steps we've taken to manage those deposit costs going forward. Strategically, we're shifting back toward holistic customer profitability, and we'll once again price deposits by weighing balance and return together rather than balance alone. A few other items also affected the quarter and deserve mention. First, waste service charges and the proactive steps we took to supplement customer support — both tied to our core conversion — dragged quarterly earnings down by an estimated amount equal to roughly $0.01 per share. We enacted those efforts out of an abundance of caution so our customers' experience would transition smoothly onto the new system. The customer response to our core conversion pleases me, though I'll acknowledge that some portion of those excess support costs will carry into the first quarter too. Second, our provision came in somewhat elevated because of a loan charge-off in our commercial premium finance business. The after-tax impact of that provision was about $0.01 per share as well. That business line holds roughly $275 million in outstanding balances, and we have an agreement in place to sell the business, with a portion of the outstanding loans expected to fetch a modest premium during the first quarter of 2024. Although the current quarter's results fall short of what we'd like, my conviction remains strong that the strategic strides we've taken across recent years leave us favorably situated within a transforming banking sector. The steadiness in financial outcomes that we've delivered while pursuing that strategic transformation shows up clearly in how our tangible book value has grown. Since 2018, our reported tangible book value is up 52%, a figure exceeding twice the 25% recorded by our proxy peers. When we look at value creation through tangible book value combined with dividends distributed, the total comes to 90% since 2018 — over 1.7x the 53% median for our proxy peers. Turning to the balance sheet, we've effectively reshaped and broadened where our funding comes from. Back at the close of 2017, roughly 92% of deposits sat within our branch network. Through deploying technology to widen our delivery channels and building fresh deposit verticals oriented toward growth, reliance on branch-based deposits has fallen to merely 65% as of today. Geographically speaking, Northeast branches accounted for 78% of all deposits in 2017. As of today, that figure has dropped to only 45% of total deposits. Our emphasis on spreading across geographies and cultivating holistic relationship banking has paid off on the asset side too; during 2017, 78% of the entire loan portfolio was concentrated in New Jersey and New York. Today that mix has fallen to only 55%. We first set foot in Florida back in 2014 by acquiring First United Bank, which held slightly more than $1 billion in loans. Via further strategic acquisitions and focused organic initiatives within that vibrant, growth-focused market, our Florida loan book now exceeds $12 billion. Ample and varied commercial growth possibilities remain open to us in Florida and throughout our full footprint. Proactively evolving our technology infrastructure represents a less visible yet just as important accomplishment for the company. We've brought in and cultivated a robust bench of tech talent, enabling us to update our infrastructure and putting us in position to lead on future breakthroughs within banking. Thanks to our technology adoption, we've been able to grow this franchise while keeping net headcount growth limited. Since 2018, assets have nearly doubled, climbing from $32 billion to $61 billion, accompanied by an almost 17% rise in headcount. Our latest core conversion brought technology into alignment across the entire company and delivers added capabilities that we're eager to put to work for our clients. Once we're beyond the conversion, we expect additional efficiencies to surface as well; we've likewise concentrated on building out a more consistent data infrastructure, enabling swift, deliberate responses to shifting market conditions. An internal AI working group has been formed to assist us in identifying suitable potential use cases and to start pursuing associated opportunities. Now I'd like to shift to our strategic imperatives for the year ahead. Though none of them represent new initiatives for Valley, our belief persists that they will generate shareholder value across a long horizon. To start, we must keep pushing core deposits into the bank; we have an amazing branch network focused on service, spanning our vibrant geographic footprint. In 2024, we'll produce additional consumer and commercial activity from those locations. As the curve normalizes more and more, we'll further take advantage of the specialty niches we've already set up, and we'll build on the momentum from the second half of 2023. Second, we'll keep pulling back from investor commercial real estate lending, favoring C&I and owner-occupied CRE instead. We've reorganized our commercial banking group so that expertise and experience line up better with opportunities in our markets and business lines. Our improved treasury management capabilities and product offerings will back expanded wallet share within our customer base and assist us in bringing in new customers on the commercial side. We've also tweaked our incentive programs to support our goals for gathering deposits and lending, which will push greater strategic alignment throughout the whole organization. Last, we'll keep expanding our differentiated noninterest income businesses so our revenue base becomes more diverse. By organic and acquisitive means, we've built a strong suite of fee-income products and service offerings for our growing customer base. The recent upgrades to our treasury management offering will assist in offsetting certain capital market headwinds tied to lower swap-related revenues in 2024. The industry difficulties of the past year showed me that we've pursued the correct long-term strategy, and I'm happy with how we've managed this hard year. 2024 will be focused on speeding up our progress toward hitting our strategic initiatives and lifting our performance as we keep maturing. As we carry out these initiatives, I want to restate that tangible book value growth remains our priority. We think steady growth in tangible book value would create shareholder value over time, and we still anticipate beating our peers on this metric. With that, I'll hand the call to Tom and Mike so they can go over the quarter's growth and financial results.

Tom Iadanza

executive
#3

Thanks, Ira. If you look at Slide 6, the deposit trends for the quarter are laid out. Direct customer deposits rose by roughly $1.6 billion, which mostly counterbalanced a substantial $2.3 billion decline in indirect deposits. A key highlight for the quarter was the meaningful decrease in how much we depend on wholesale deposits. We saw robust growth in interest-bearing transaction accounts, and the easing of noninterest deposit runoff is encouraging; even so, we recognize that a competitive interest rate is among the levers we used to support our generation efforts in the quarter. Even so, deposit cost increases decelerated, and shortly, Michael described the steps we have taken to manage interest expense going forward. More information about how our deposit portfolio is composed by delivery channel and business line appears on the following slide. Traditional branch deposits grew by about $600 million in the quarter. That growth was distributed throughout our geographic footprint. Our specialty niches also grew by roughly $1 billion, with important contributions from our online delivery channel and technology deposit team. Moving to the next slide. The ongoing diversity and granularity of our deposit base is visible there. No single commercial industry makes up over 7% of our deposits. Our government portfolio stays diversified across our footprint and is fully collateralized with respect to state collateral requirements. Slide 9 gives an overview of our loan growth and portfolio composition. In the top left, the proactive growth slowdown that took place throughout 2023 is visible. In the end, we hit the low end of the 7% to 9% growth target we had set out at the beginning of the year. Annualized loan growth decelerated steadily as the year went on, demonstrating our capacity to respond to shifting market dynamics. The slide that follows breaks down our commercial real estate portfolio by collateral type and geography. As a reminder, our loan portfolio is extremely granular, well diversified by collateral type and geography. Our debt service coverage and loan-to-value metrics are still very attractive; we keep monitoring pools of maturing and resetting loans closely and believe our borrowers are well-positioned to absorb the pass-through of higher rates. This reflects consistent underwriting discipline at conservative cap rates and significant stress testing efforts at origination. The next 2 slides offer additional details about our multifamily and office portfolios. From a multifamily perspective, our $8.8 billion portfolio includes $2 billion of co-op loans with an extremely low loan-to-value. Excluding our co-op portfolio, our Manhattan multifamily exposure is close to $600 million, which appears in the last column of the table. The rest of the portfolio is well diversified across our footprint with low average loan sizes and attractive loan-to-value and debt service coverage ratio metrics. With that, I will hand the call over to Mike Hagedorn to provide additional insight into the quarter's financials.

Mike Hagedorn

executive
#4

Thanks, Tom. On slide 13, we show how Valley's net interest income and margin have moved over recent quarters. Although noninterest-bearing deposits held steady at period end, the drop in those noninterest deposits measured on an average basis subtracted roughly $4 million from quarterly net interest income. During those 3 months, we swapped out maturing direct and indirect CDs for higher-yielding interest-bearing transaction accounts and promotional retail CDs, and that was the price of the substantial deposit growth we saw from customers that quarter. The right-hand portion of this page describes what we've been doing to manage funding costs more carefully going forward. In our online channel, we lowered the high-yield savings rate, though we're still competitive. We've also brought down our 1-year CD rate considerably, which should help ease the repricing pressure we ran into last quarter. And lastly, we're collaborating with our relationship bankers to make sure deposit rates make sense when viewed against overall customer profitability. A few quarters back, after the industry turmoil in March, we set deposit product pricing with an eye toward making sure direct customer balances had recovered. As we put those difficulties further behind us, our product pricing will weigh balances and profitability more evenly. Moving to the next slide, noninterest income adjusted for certain items was broadly flat versus the third quarter of 2023. Deposit service charges fell quarter over quarter because we waived some transactional fees around the time of our core conversion. Apart from that, growth trends held up fairly well this quarter even with swap revenues acting as a headwind. On the slide after that, noninterest expenses came in at roughly $340 million for the quarter. If you adjust for the $50 million FDIC special assessment plus certain other nonrecurring litigation and merger charges, noninterest expenses were about $273 million on an adjusted basis. Compensation costs remain very tightly managed. The quarter-over-quarter rise in expenses was mostly driven by higher traditional FDIC assessment costs, consulting costs, occupancy and advertising expenses, and the usual seasonal increase in other business development expenses. Part of the expense increase this quarter related to certain consulting and customer support initiatives tied to our core system conversion in October. The customer experience around that conversion has been very positive, but some of these costs will carry a tail into the first quarter. As you're aware, the first quarter also brings the customary seasonal headwinds from payroll taxes; we're quite pleased that we could proactively manage headcount and the related compensation expenses all through 2023. Our expectation is that 2024 will be a more typical year for expense trajectory; and as you'll see in a moment, we're anticipating mid-single-digit expense growth next year. Slide 16 shows our asset quality trends over the last 5 quarters. Nonaccrual loans rose a bit this quarter, but they were roughly unchanged compared with a year earlier. During the quarter, net charge-offs came to $17 million, and roughly $5 million of that related to our commercial premium finance business, which we have an agreement to sell in the first quarter of the year. Because of the higher provision we recorded, our allowance for credit losses on loans rose 1 basis point over the quarter, reaching 0.93% of total loans. On the next slide, you can see how our tangible book value and capital ratios grew sequentially. Tangible book value was up almost 2% versus the third quarter of 2023, helped by a smaller OCI impact tied to our available-for-sale securities portfolio; we're glad that over the course of the year we could both fund our robust loan growth and build regulatory capital organically. Given the loan growth we expect in 2024, we believe this pattern should persist. Slide 18 sets out what we're looking for in the year ahead. In 2024, we expect to deliver mid-single-digit loan growth, centered on C&I and noninvestor commercial real estate. Taking consensus interest rate expectations for 2024 as our basis, we would look for net interest income to grow somewhere between 3% and 5%. On an annual basis, noninterest income ought to rise between 5% and 7%, since pressures in our swap business are more than outweighed by ongoing scale in our wealth, insurance, and tax advisory operations, along with our recently strengthened treasury management offerings. Noninterest expenses should increase roughly in step with revenue, as higher FDIC costs and inflationary pressure are offset by savings from our core conversion and the ongoing advantages of the expense initiatives we announced earlier. Putting all of this guidance together, we expect 2024 EPS to land just a touch below the current 2024 consensus estimate of $1.08. With that, I'll hand the call back to the operator so we can start Q&A. Thank you.

Frank Schiraldi

analyst
#5

Regarding your net interest income outlook, I get that you’re tracking the market, or the forward curve, and that the majority of those assumed rate reductions are weighted toward later in the year. On an annualized basis, what kind of lift—annualized—would you see in either NII or NIM from a specific 25 basis point cut? What is the underlying assumption?

Ira Robbins

executive
#6

Let me make sure I’ve got your question right. What you’re asking is simply what the effect would be from one 25 basis point rise, correct?

Frank Schiraldi

analyst
#7

Right. So essentially, when you — assuming we see 3 or 4 cuts, I'm simply attempting to estimate or understand what effect, on average, 25 basis points has on the NIM or NII according to your modeling.

Ira Robbins

executive
#8

Let me point you back to the guidance we've given of about 3% to 5%. What we currently anticipate for 2024 is approximately 175 basis points that are going to impact the shorter portion of the curve as inversion there diminishes. That initial rise actually begins at the close of March. During the first quarter, there isn't much. Yet you're right that they're weighted more toward later periods, with the cuts coming in the fourth quarter of 2024. So answering precisely what a 25 basis point reduction does isn't something I'm ready to do, since it will hinge on how the funding sources are mixed at that moment. Across the entire year, we anticipate NII rising 3% to 5%; and that ought to push the NIM modestly higher compared with the prior year.

Tom Iadanza

executive
#9

So Frank, in terms of how we're set up conceptually, we're fairly neutral when it comes to the short end of the curve. So if those cuts don't happen, there isn't a big swing for us. Where we have a lot more exposure is on the longer end, because that affects the gain we'll see when our fixed rate loans come up for maturity and reprice.

Frank Schiraldi

analyst
#10

All right. So I take it that across the entire curve, you remain liability sensitive, though closer to neutral when it comes to the front end.

Tom Iadanza

executive
#11

Yes. That is right.

Frank Schiraldi

analyst
#12

All right. And this is maybe somewhat of a hypothetical one, given how the mix of the business has shifted somewhat in recent years — with a niche deposit chance, plus the C&I opportunity that all of you keep expecting during 2024 — assuming a yield curve with a more typical slope, what would you consider a typical margin, a normalized NIM, to be for Valley given how the balance sheet has been constructed?

Ira Robbins

executive
#13

Yeah, that's me, Ira. My view is that it's considerably greater. Clearly, with an inverted curve lasting 3 years, and managing the balance sheet the way we do, attempting to stay as neutral as possible, this is a very tough backdrop for us. Even so, when the curve does move toward something more normalized, we expect meaningful margin growth once we return to a suitable setting. We've been quite successful in changing where commercial growth happens inside the company. For a long stretch, we've delivered a 10% CAGR in C&I expansion. And as you pointed out, having a more varied funding base will genuinely benefit us once that curve becomes somewhat more ordinary, allowing us to return to a suitable method of pricing deposits throughout the organization.

Frank Schiraldi

analyst
#14

All right, that's great. Then, if I may squeeze in a final question along those same lines. Regarding the specialized deposits that arrived during the quarter, and the growth in that area. And when I think about the betas across your deposit book — the specialized ones compared with the branch deposits — are those betas widening, now that you have the national businesses, and would that, obviously, perhaps substantially assist you in a falling rate environment?

Ira Robbins

executive
#15

What I'd say is that some of those national businesses carry a somewhat elevated beta. And I believe that ties back to Travis's point that things will be somewhat more neutral once part of that curve gets hit immediately. I think the shift in mix away from noninterest-bearing hurt us over the course of the year. So the asset-liability picture has shifted somewhat, correct? That means we now have greater downside sensitivity in deposit cost, since we used to run 28% to 29% noninterest-bearing deposits, and those now sit in interest-bearing deposits; so that will work in our favor. But as you pointed out, what really excites us is the diversity and granularity inside that deposit book, along with the opportunity it presents. As we said earlier on this call, deposit pricing clearly drifted somewhat away from us while our attention was more on the core conversion; even so, I do think it's a simple fix. We'll concentrate on it and ensure that 2024 returns to the results you'd expect from us.

Steve Moss

analyst
#16

I just want to continue the discussion about the liability side of the company. I'm simply wondering how much of your securities and fixed rate loans will reprice during 2024.

Tom Iadanza

executive
#17

Sure. Steve, as we've mentioned before, we hold $20 billion in fixed-rate loans. The pattern isn't exactly linear; we actually have more — a greater portion of our contain loans repricing during the latter six months of the year compared to the first six months. However, altogether, the amount repricing in 2024 falls somewhere between $3 billion and $4 billion. Yet once more, that figure is fairly weighted toward the end of the year.

Steve Moss

analyst
#18

All right. Then regarding security-related matters, my guess is that for the year ahead there will likely be only very small cash flows, correct?

Tom Iadanza

executive
#19

That's right. The duration of our securities portfolio has stretched out to roughly 7 years. We do receive — correct, the amount is truly negligible. That portfolio totals $5 billion. During the year, it amounts to a couple of hundred million dollars.

Steve Moss

analyst
#20

All right, and regarding credit, I'd like a bit more detail about the rise in C&I and CRE NKs. It seems a portion of that came from premium finance you wrote off during this quarter. I'm just wondering what kinds of loans are involved and whether you can add anything further.

Tom Iadanza

executive
#21

Sure. Steve, this is Tom. That nonaccrual increase was mostly within the CRE business, $20 million, and $10 million of it has been repaid since. If you look at our performing past dues, there's a decrease on the commercial side and almost nothing, if anything at all, in the 90-day bucket. The accruing past due increase is happening on the residential side. As for detail there, it's our jumbo on-balance sheet portfolio, with an average loan-to-value of 58%; we don't anticipate any loss. Looking back across a 15-year period, our real estate portfolio typically experienced roughly 35% of charge-offs relative to our peer banks. That pattern should keep going. We're actually witnessing improvement in every area. Our metrics are still solid, particularly on the commercial side.

Steve Moss

analyst
#22

All right. And I'm just wondering — I realize your written remarks mentioned a rise in classified assets. So I'm a bit curious: what were criticized and classified assets during this quarter?

Tom Iadanza

executive
#23

That figure is something you'll have. Regarding the increase, we conduct that forward-looking examination of every loan we hold, or the portfolio as a whole, particularly early in the year focusing on those that are repricing or resetting. During the third quarter there was a shift involving those loans, mostly into the special mention bucket, where they may have dropped under or landed right at a 1x debt service coverage. I'd like to remind everybody that the loan we repriced across 2023, along with our assessment of 2024 repricing, produced no changes to any contractual repayment terms. But Travis, is there another figure I'm leaving out?

Travis Lan

executive
#24

Right, I don't have that figure right here with me, though I'd say during Q3, the stress testing effort Tom brought up produced a fairly notable rise in loans categorized as criticized and classified. Once more, it isn't a sense that we'd encounter further losses — it's simply how debt service coverage ratios come out; when it came to Q4, the uptick was far more typical, meaning it wasn't significant.

Mike Hagedorn

executive
#25

And Mike here. That rise would largely have shown up in special mention credits rather than the more severe ratings.

Steve Moss

analyst
#26

All right, understood. And perhaps to build on that. Since some borrowers are approaching their debt service coverage ratio limits, I'm wondering what insight you might offer regarding whether this becomes a workout situation, or whether the borrower might be able to reduce the loan balance. Basically, what are you observing, and what NPA formations might emerge during 2024?

Mike Hagedorn

executive
#27

Once more, for those borrowers we were repricing over the last 12 months to 18 months, no terms have needed modification. Generally speaking, our underwriting standards — which begin with a cap level higher than what our peers likely apply; we base it on present cash flow rather than projected cash flow. Our leverage is usually lower at the outset, and the average loan-to-value across that real estate portfolio sits at roughly 60%. That covers every one of our asset classes. Consequently, there's room to maneuver; a great deal of our business comes from customers we already have. They possess the means. When things get tight, we'll obtain extra collateral, or arrange a paydown, or set up reserves, in order to keep any funding beneath at a suitable level. Yes; and one more thing worth mentioning — refinance activity, particularly among multifamily properties, increased during the fourth quarter; that let us get out of those nonrelationship, noncore loans.

Michael Perito

analyst
#28

I realize you don't typically provide guidance on this, but I'm attempting to get a sense of the rhythm of profitability as it relates to NIM, along with certain expense objectives and the rationalization effort, which I believe will begin delivering a more meaningful advantage partway through the year. Are you folks willing or capable of speaking in a qualitative way about what your current budget assumes regarding the return ROE profile as you finish out '24? What I mean is, it seems as though the opening half of the year could stay somewhat weak. Still, I'm curious whether you might offer any signals about that rhythm compared with the guidance you gave.

Travis Lan

executive
#29

Yes. I'd say your view there, Mike, is fairly on point. So during the initial quarter, whether we're talking about expenses — with the payroll tax acting as a drag — or net interest income, where day count and similar items matter, plus the absence of meaningful movement in the projected industry backdrop; we expect a margin that's broadly steady, I would say, during quarter one, then somewhat better in quarter two, before seeing greater expansion across the third and fourth quarters. That's roughly how the budget has been constructed right now, using the implied forward curve. On the expense front, if you go back to the prior year, there was a $7 million increase during quarter one tied to payroll taxes. So something comparable is what you should expect. As we sit here in December, on an annualized basis, we've realized $20 million in expense savings stemming from the headcount reduction put in place in June. We believe roughly another $8 million, more or less, on an annualized basis will come from additional steps taken here during quarter one on the personnel side. Then, once we move into quarter two and afterward, there ought to be savings tied to the core conversion, along with some of those elevated costs we've discussed involving customer support efforts and similar items; so I think quarter one will carry a seasonal expense drag, but after that you're looking at broad stability across the 3 quarters that follow. Thus we do expect profitability to strengthen as the year progresses. Blending everything together, once more, at the midpoint of our range, you arrive at $1.04, $1.05, which places you at an ROA level I would describe as comparable to what we delivered this year, though it does get better as the year moves along.

Michael Perito

analyst
#30

Right. What I'm saying is that ought to land you somewhere around 90 on the ROA at exit. I suppose the real question is this: if revenue and expense move up by the same dollar amount, that won't deliver much of an improvement, correct, and that's basically the shape of the outlook for '24. But what I'd like to know is why you're confident that in '25 and after, you folks can return to a stretch of better operating leverage and keep seeing those gains roll forward into '25. Is margin the whole story? Are there other unit economics inside a few of the specialty businesses you're expanding that scale will help? Some extra detail would be great.

Tom Iadanza

executive
#31

To my mind, plenty of opportunity exists for us. If you take a look at the net interest income piece, being positioned in an inverted curve, hopefully that isn't where we remain for a great deal longer, yet it certainly affects us. My view is that the core conversion gets far too little credit when we consider how scaling ability looks on our end. Every one of our clients was moved onto a new core platform throughout the whole organization. With that done, we layered in 261 separate APIs atop that core conversion, all with an eye toward the shape of that client experience. Walk into Valley, and you open a checking account at any of our branches. That's the very same platform used when someone opens a digital account while at Valley. So I'd say we were quite clever in the way we went about deciding how we would take advantage of the infrastructure and technology foundation. From a scalability standpoint, then, we aren't handing a per-unit payment to some core provider each time an individual account gets opened. What we actually have is a technology infrastructure here that scales, one centered on how that client experience will look, and it will unquestionably produce outsized growth. When I brought up certain commercial growth figures and consumer growth figures, those reflect household growth, not just individual accounts. All of that happened through our core conversion at a time when everybody disliked midsized banks. So I'd say we enjoy plenty of favorable tailwinds when we consider our efforts through a franchise value lens. So the opportunity on the expense side of the book is something I feel genuinely enthusiastic about, though the revenue side will most certainly start speeding up too.

Michael Perito

analyst
#32

That's useful; and finally, along those same lines of inquiry, you had set a goal of 5% to 7% for loan growth in '24, and clearly, you're still attempting to...

Tom Iadanza

executive
#33

Take a look at what we originated in the fourth quarter — it came to $2.2 billion <<inaudible>>. My apologies, Mike. We were catching your question regarding loan growth, but it cut out right when you said that...

Michael Perito

analyst
#34

Sure, no issue there. What I was really getting at is basically the same thing I asked before. Regarding loan growth — since you're putting greater emphasis on how customers are priced and on overall customer profitability and so on — would it be reasonable to believe that the additional loans you generate, along with the new customer loans you take on, will carry stronger margins than what you saw in 2023, given some of the adjustments to deposit pricing and similar factors? Or do some of those effects take time to show up? Or what's the right way for us to view that situation?

Tom Iadanza

executive
#35

What you ought to anticipate is that our spreads on those will keep getting wider and rising, and to give you some background on that: we've noticed an increase in that C&I pipeline, and that business is likely at 70% of the peak it once reached, and it makes up 65% of our overall portfolio, and this spans every business line, particularly in our health care and fund banking line, so improvement is beginning to appear and spreads are staying firm.

Mike Hagedorn

executive
#36

To build on what was just said, if you consider the pressure we've experienced on margin, it's mostly driven by the factors we discussed — certain changes in mix along with other repricing — as rates either level off, and they appear to have done so, or decline, there's genuinely going to be a meaningful gain for us. The fresh value margin we've applied ranges from $3.50 to $3.60, and that captures what we're capable of doing on the pricing side and the way we're approaching it in terms of profitability. With the new loans we've added, we've managed to secure an equivalent volume of funding tied to those from a client standpoint, so it isn't as though we've exited the broker market. Therefore, when we eventually see some stabilization, which we expect to occur regarding that mix shift, there's truly potential upside for how that margin appears given that the new originations, as Tom noted, $2 billion came in at a spread of positive 3.50 for us.

Michael Perito

analyst
#37

That's useful. Before I step back, let me just quickly confirm a couple of things. Mike, could you say that again — I want to be certain I caught it properly. What Fed funds rate assumptions are included in the NII guidance? And Travis, just so I understand clearly, you're essentially telling us that on the short end — whether there are 2 cuts, or cuts, or focus — it really doesn't make much difference for 2024. It's more about the long end, plus some of the back book and the other factors we've been talking about. I only want to confirm I got all of that right.

Travis Lan

executive
#38

Yes, that's right. And although we haven't spelled out exactly and we expect the Fed to cut this amount on this day, what I can share is that the first reduction we're expecting is 25 basis points, though they speed up as the year progresses. So during the third and fourth quarters, we see bigger cuts. And once more, the largest gain for us would come from the curve's inversion easing and short-term rates coming down. That's why we absorbed the cost this quarter to reduce the duration on our liabilities — or on our funding more broadly, as Tom mentioned — regarding the shift in our deposit mix away from FHLB, along with some of our maturing CDs, whether indirect or direct, that we held in the fourth quarter, moving instead to money market and transaction accounts. All of that was done deliberately to get the balance sheet ready for the Fed's arrival.

Jon Arfstrom

analyst
#39

To build on that, Mike, is the reduction in liabilities happening? For your team, is that mostly finished now?

Mike Hagedorn

executive
#40

Mostly finished, yes. One more sizable component remains for the first quarter. It was weighted heavily toward the beginning since we were getting ready for this while establishing those obligations, with duration stretching back to Q1 of last year; so one more component lands in the first quarter. Following that, it drops off considerably.

Jon Arfstrom

analyst
#41

All right, that's helpful. And staying on that same subject, Slide 13 — you mentioned the reductions in CD rates that happened in December, and you also noted additional ones are on the way, like maturing liabilities during Q1. How did customers respond to the CD repricing? Also, are these maturing liability items deposits too? Or something else? And where can repricing occur there?

Travis Lan

executive
#42

The effect on customers hasn't shown up yet, though I wouldn't anticipate it being severe. To put it plainly regarding that 1-year CD rate, most of the effect from it will roll. As you may recall from what we said earlier during '23, we introduced a number of CD specials, with one standing out at roughly a 13-month duration. Those are now rolling at 12. Because of that, we're lowering the roll. Typically, when we're active in the market, retention of those CDs averages somewhere between 70% and 80%. So my sense is that a fairly substantial tailwind ought to be there.

Jon Arfstrom

analyst
#43

All right, good. Then, Ira, this is somewhat of a margin-related question, though perhaps it isn't, yet it seems like the pressure on deposit pricing may have been somewhat greater than you anticipated. Still, when I examine it and consider the figures, perhaps we've hit the floor on margin — so I'm interested in that. Also, I'm interested in the trade-off choice you mentioned before, regarding growing deposits versus possibly some of the promotional rates or actions taken to acquire new accounts and attract deposits. Could you discuss a bit that trade-off choice you all made?

Ira Robbins

executive
#44

From a broad viewpoint, I'd say there were a few factors. First, we deliberately opted to go shorter on the liability side. So we essentially extended or maintained the same duration we'd had previously; but once we began noticing some shifts in November and the expectations, perhaps even slightly sooner, regarding where the forward curve sat at that short end, we clearly shifted somewhat shorter. Consequently, that certainly hurt interest expense during the quarter. We believe there will be a beneficial effect from that, however, when we consider how 2024 turns out over the entire year. Having said that, from a wider standpoint, look, it was an extremely tough year for an institution such as ours, considering early in the year what occurred with Signature, what occurred with SCB, and the rest. We were intensely concentrated on keeping deposits. Because of that, I believe we might have been 2 accommodating toward certain clients, yielding to some of their rate demands; we had substantial funds shift into treasuries immediately. Even so, we're actively fighting that. In today's discussions with clients, I'm not certain we must keep doing that. We're returning to reconnect with our clients. Once more, we got somewhat sidetracked, I think, during the fourth quarter merely because of the core conversion, and likely during the third quarter too, even before that core conversion. For us, completing the core conversion mattered. We achieved an incredible result. I have 3 e-mail complaints. That's all from clients across our whole client base. There's essentially nothing. So there was heavy emphasis on keeping clients throughout that core conversion. Once more, now I simply believe we return to holding suitable discussions with our clients, suitable discussions regarding what pricing ought to be, and we'll bring deposits back to a suitable beta for what it ought to be. Yet I think above all, we completed an incredible core conversion. We kept every one of our clients. We actually expanded our client base via a core conversion, and that isn't something you can always count on happening. As I mentioned, we added 10.5% household growth in commercial over the course of this year. Those figures are honestly hard to believe. So even though, again, I've said I'm not especially pleased with how the fourth quarter turned out, when I look at the big picture, I'm not all that worried.

Jon Arfstrom

analyst
#45

Don't be too hard on yourself. It's not that bad. But one more item regarding net interest income. I brought this up before, though it suggests a fairly solid increase to your guidance, roughly $140 million more than the pace you saw in Q4. In your view, have we basically reached or hit the lowest point for net interest income right now?

Tom Iadanza

executive
#46

We're definitely getting near it. Let me handle it this way. Everyone should turn to Slide 6, since I realize this subject matters a great deal. If you look at how deposit costs moved from one quarter to the next, we began at 60 basis points, then spent 2 quarters in a row at 49%. By the third quarter, or the fourth, that figure was just 19 basis points. So the reason we have a better feeling about where NIM is headed comes largely from that, along with the fact that things appear to be leveling off somewhat in our noninterest-bearing accounts. As for the rotation out of noninterest-bearing, if you go back to the point when we closed on Leumi, 36% of our total funding sources sat in noninterest-bearing. Today that share is down to 23%, and summer starting to see some stabilization. Take that together with deposit costs rising more slowly, and it's the reason we expect our NIM to improve further over the course of 2024. To fully realize that potential, though, Fed rate reductions are clearly necessary.

Steven Alexopoulos

analyst
#47

To kick things off, when you stepped into the CEO role, wasn't boosting the efficiency ratio among your biggest goals? And I realize everyone had a tough 12 months given how rates behaved and the pressure on NIM, and so on. Yet looking at the strategic imperatives for 2024, I have to say I'm quite taken aback — it felt like the bar got shifted somewhat, since making improvements from where we stand isn't listed there. Does this remain a leading priority in your view? And ought we to anticipate seeing gains this year?

Ira Robbins

executive
#48

Correct. See, my sense is that the squeeze we witnessed in the efficiency ratio mostly stems from NIM alone, Stephen, correct? And once we return to stronger core funding, once we return to improved diversification inside that asset class, NIM is certainly going to widen because of it. Our headcount had fallen — I believe we stood at 3,325 or thereabouts employees when I assumed the role. Now we're at roughly 3,700, and we were a $20 billion, $21 billion company at that point versus $60 billion now. And I believe we've absolutely zeroed in on how efficiency looks. We've absolutely woven technology into this place. To me, it isn't even something listed among the strategic imperatives — it's simply at the heart of what we are now. I believe we're intensely focused, clearly, on what that efficiency amounts to. As I said before, the tech infrastructure we've installed permits scalability, and that matters greatly to us; thus technology, the burden, and its expense won't be anywhere close to what it used to be. So it's certainly not that treating it as something to highlight is a thing I'd want to remove and declare, hey, this isn't a priority for us. I believe it's simply what we handle each and every day. And I believe once NIM reaches a suitable level, back to where we feel it ought to be, you'll watch that figure fall back to a figure you'll be pleased with.

Steven Alexopoulos

analyst
#49

Okay, understood. Then I'd like to follow up on costs, which came in higher, and you attributed that to the system conversion — what did that amount to during the fourth quarter? And what figure should we expect for 1Q, and what drops off in 2Q?

Mike Hagedorn

executive
#50

Sure. Within the operating expense figure, $5 million was tied to the core conversion. For the first quarter, we expect it to come in at approximately $3 million, meaning roughly a $2 million decrease; after that point, it should be gone entirely.

Tom Iadanza

executive
#51

I'd say those fall under one-time costs, or infrequent items, whichever term you prefer. But remember, we also had duplicate operating expenses from running several platforms, plus what they contributed in the quarter. Once we reach a stronger position — and we're essentially just about there — those will be removed too. And Steve, let me return to what you said about efficiency. If you look 12 months back, our efficiency ratio stood at 50% in Q4 of '22, versus 60% this year. Yet measured against average assets, noninterest expenses went down across that same stretch. So it's clearly, directly linked to the revenue climate you just described. Still, we've discussed the reductions in headcount we've made, and how little headcount growth occurred across 5 years compared with the asset growth we generated; the efficiency ratio therefore leans more on market dynamics and such, but on the structural side, the things within our control, I believe we've performed quite well.

Steven Alexopoulos

analyst
#52

All right. You mentioned that deposit pricing slipped somewhat due to the system conversion. How do those two things relate?

Tom Iadanza

executive
#53

Well, we have many relationship clients, which a company of our size ought to have. We rely on internal models for evaluating deposit pricing, I believe. Our frontline team was mostly concentrated on contacting customers, keeping them, and on certain profitability measures regarding how we engage with clients and steer particular discussions. Client retention likely diverted our attention, as did simply explaining to customers what would change in how they interact with the various systems. Having said that, I believe some deposit rates, from an exception pricing standpoint, became somewhat uncontrolled. And there wasn't the necessary emphasis on ensuring we stayed inside our target parameters for what that pricing ought to be. Even so, I have great confidence we will reach that point quite soon.

Steven Alexopoulos

analyst
#54

So I'm trying to figure out what drives that NIM. You called it neutral near term, yet Ira has repeatedly said your NIM ought to widen. I believe you put it well — once the curve takes on a more normal shape. What kind of timeline is that? What is the lag? My instinct says it comes sooner rather than later, but if the curve turns positively sloped late in this year, does it become a 2026 story before your NIM begins to look more normal? I'm simply puzzled why Fed rate cuts, given how much you pay on deposits — you folks are among the higher payers — wouldn't be more helpful near term?

Ira Robbins

executive
#55

I think the front end of the curve is coming down. Jeff will have an impact on us, but the long end is where we have far more tied to it; that is absolutely going to be a fairly meaningful tailwind for how we think about where net interest income heads. I think the commentary was more along the lines that there are some day count matters that feed into that first quarter, and we aren't anticipating much movement within the first quarter either. So once the curve starts to normalize, we do believe there will be some positive effect on that net interest income and the margin too. That said, they really aren't asking or projecting anything to genuinely shift until the tail end of the first quarter, and that day count pressure exists right at the — right from the start too.

Nick Cucharale

analyst
#56

I just have a question regarding the outlook for noninterest income. What would you say the main factors are behind that 5% to 7% increase compared with the prior year? And do you anticipate swap activity returning to something like what we saw in the first half of '23 rather than the second half?

Tom Iadanza

executive
#57

The largest factor, as I mentioned before, would be that our noninterest-bearing deposit balances have stabilized. Though that was actually the largest factor for net interest income... Adjusted noninterest income. You meant interest income? I didn't catch that. My apologies for that. You're able to see that in our IP deck, and it also breaks out the components of it. Something to remember is that during 2023, we had certain one-time items tied to revenue recognition that will not happen again in the prior year. Still, I think if you consider the whole of our fee income, we're feeling quite confident about our position, since it produces only around 10% of our overall revenue, and at times growth in any single category can go unnoticed. That said, I do believe that with the slower loan growth we're experiencing, swap income is going to face some pressure and will be substituted by areas such as FX, wealth management; plus we have a very robust treasury management initiative underway within our company. And as we bring on additional C&I business, we would anticipate that contributing too. Okay.

Nick Cucharale

analyst
#58

Turning next to the cost structure — you brought up certain investments as well as chances to trim spending during 2023. Given that the core conversion has now wrapped up, which investments matter most to you for fueling the company's next phase of growth?

Mike Hagedorn

executive
#59

A great deal of it lines up with a few of those strategic imperatives we discussed, correct? What I mean is, when we consider expansion in the C&I space along with certain specialty entities that we hold, we've certainly made some technology investments. That said, from a foundation standpoint, much of it is already in place, so at this stage it's merely enhancements to things that were previously established — yet it's really mostly consistent with what we've said on the strategic front, with the bulk of attention on a few of the C&I items.

Manan Gosalia

analyst
#60

Could you discuss your perspective on deposit betas and the deposit mix when rates decline? Does a lag still exist in the way deposit yields fall as rates decrease, and do NIB deposits begin to recover once rates reach a particular level? So yes, please elaborate on that and share your thinking regarding deposit costs during perhaps the initial rate cut compared with the subsequent few rate cuts?

Travis Lan

executive
#61

Yes, Manan, Travis here. So I do believe some lag exists on the beta side when moving downward. Our model presumes a beta of roughly 35% on the way down. As you can observe, the cycle to date was 57% on the way up. Regarding noninterest-bearing, our budget and our forecast presume it stays relatively stable as a proportion of total deposits, at approximately 23%. But I do believe there is a terminal point at rates with rates where you keep building that backup; and clearly, as we grow C&I and treasury management, I mean, those are strategic initiatives that are in place to keep growing noninterest deposits more quickly than what we actually include in our budget. So those are some thoughts on that.

Manan Gosalia

analyst
#62

That's really useful. Regarding the guidance for loan growth between 5% and 7%, I realize that factors in the mix shift away from investor CRE, so could you discuss a few of the drivers? Also, how does the cadence of that shape up? Is it weighted more toward the back end? And do you require some assistance from the environment for that? Or is it grounded in the customer conversations you're having right now, and is there a high level of confidence that loan growth will speed up as we move through this year?

Mike Hagedorn

executive
#63

Yes; it's grounded in the confidence we have from talking with customers and observing the increase in their requests to us, and in building on the pipeline we've seen in the fourth quarter and so far into January; and again, pointing to the originations in that fourth quarter, $2.2 billion, up from $1.8 billion in the third quarter, and the rise in our pipelines and C&I's contribution to that pipeline, it now makes up the lion's share at 65% of our pipeline; so we are seeing that activity. Usually, the first quarter is a slow one as people get your financial statements in place and you begin seeing progressively more business as the quarters roll on.

Manan Gosalia

analyst
#64

Understood. As for the ratio of loans to deposits, is it expected to remain roughly in this range, somewhere from 95% to 105%?

Tom Iadanza

executive
#65

That's right.

Matthew Breese

analyst
#66

To start, regarding the NII guidance, I was hoping you could give some context — I'd really like to get a feel for how much it can shift, and what that guidance would look like, or what you'd estimate it to be, if we assume either no rate reductions or only minimal ones during the year.

Ira Robbins

executive
#67

That's essentially what the 3% to 5% range we gave you reflects. Should rates remain unchanged, we'd still expect there to be room for improvement in both NII and margin compared with where we sit now. Once more, our biggest vulnerability would come from a substantial drop in longer-term rates. So aside from that, nearly every other rate environment would land within roughly the guidance we offered.

Matthew Breese

analyst
#68

Understood. Alright. I believe you also hinted that the NIM has begun showing a bit of stabilization — ideally, stabilization during the first quarter. Could you give some specifics on how the NIM performed month by month across the fourth quarter, and whether that stabilization has already begun to appear?

Ira Robbins

executive
#69

Yes, we did. On a monthly basis, I'd say November marked the low point. During our prior call, we reviewed 6 straight months of NII and margin that were broadly steady. Certain items we've previously discussed, such as shortening up the liabilities and other matters, created a bit of pressure during the fourth quarter. Still, I'd say the margin, once again, hit its low point in November. Looking at the yields on what we originated — loan origination yields likewise reached bottom in November and recovered in December, while deposit — the costs of new deposit origination actually fell across the quarter; so October was the peak, November came in lower, and in December it was even lower than that. Another point I'd mention, too: we obviously show in the deck what our loan origination yields are, and those declined 8 basis points during the quarter, but new deposit origination costs fell 11 basis points during the quarter, which somewhat ties into the commentary we've given on spreads; so November, again, was a low point for the margin. December was a bit better, if that helps.

Matthew Breese

analyst
#70

Yeah, is there any kind of benchmark for how far apart the low and high figures were?

Ira Robbins

executive
#71

Honestly, the gap wasn't all that big. My sense is that November came in at 4 or 5 basis points below December.

Matthew Breese

analyst
#72

Understood. All right, a few more quick items. I saw that service charges on deposit accounts dropped fairly significantly from one quarter to the next, roughly 15%. Did the conversion cause that? And ought we to anticipate that line item returning to around its typical $10.5 million mark?

Travis Lan

executive
#73

Yeah. Around the conversion, for roughly a month, certain transactional fees would have applied. So when you examine that decrease, it came to somewhere around $1.5 million, $2 million — that is precisely what it represented. Otherwise, it would have stayed flat. Clearly, we brought in a substantial amount of deposits during the fourth quarter, customer deposits. So that ought to keep fueling deposit service charges moving forward. That will additionally be bolstered by the treasury management items we mentioned. That produces deposit revenue too within the noninterest income category.

Matthew Breese

analyst
#74

Alright. Then regarding the average balance sheet, something seemed strange to me — cash balances, or interest tied to bank deposits, fell roughly 90 basis points from one quarter to the next, landing at 4.6%. Typically I treat that figure as a sort of proxy for Fed funds. What caused that? Why did yields in the cash categories drop so dramatically?

Ira Robbins

executive
#75

I'd say your general thinking is correct; we use an accrual approach to figure out the cash payments we get from the SEDAR. Those actual payments do tend to fluctuate somewhat. Some credits come in and go out of the mix, so a yield can emerge that might not line up directly with what you'd get on overnight reserves.

Matthew Breese

analyst
#76

All right. That said, in broad terms, what we ought to be looking at is a model that returns to setons.

Ira Robbins

executive
#77

Yeah, I'd say that's broadly accurate.

Matthew Breese

analyst
#78

Alright. You laid out the multifamily portfolio with quite a bit of granularity on Page 11 of the presentation. One thing that caught my attention is that several of those markets have a weighted average debt service coverage ratio below 1.4x. Given how repricing is playing out, should we be feeling somewhat uneasy? So first, I'm wondering whether those debt service coverage ratios reflect where things stood at origination, or have they been refreshed? And second, would you by any chance know what the current loan yield on this book looks like compared to an updated figure?

Ira Robbins

executive
#79

Yes. Those weighted average coverage figures are up to date. They come from recent rent rolls. On a regular basis, we refresh both that and the loan to values. I don't have the loan yield with me right now. That said, I can tell you that when we examine that repricing, none of the terms have needed modification, and in our forward look, where we evaluate every loan repricing within the next 12 months, we anticipate the same outcome. But we'll need to check on that. Travis, I'm not sure whether you have it.

Travis Lan

executive
#80

Yeah. I don't actually have the entire portfolio sitting here with me, but let me attempt to offer a few details that might be useful. As that page illustrates, Matt, we held $420 million in loans that are fully rent-controlled; those represent the lowest-yielding portion, and the yield there is 4.6%. Then there's roughly another $1.5 billion, I'd call it, tied to properties where some degree of rent control applies, and on that portfolio the yield comes to 5.45%. So when you take a broad look at multifamily, in aggregate you'll likely land nearer to that $545 deal, more or less.

Matthew Breese

analyst
#81

And regarding those categories — the $420 million that's entirely rent-regulated, plus the $1.8 billion that's partly rent — did they also come through the stress testing we performed?

Ira Robbins

executive
#82

Correct. Correct. The $420 million is entirely rent-regulated, and it's 1.4, which is partial, with 20% being less rent-regulated.

Matthew Breese

analyst
#83

All right, and I realize I'm rambling here, but that's my final question. Ira, you brought up some dissatisfaction regarding the bank's general profitability. Could you clarify what level of profitability would actually satisfy you, whether that's gauged through ROA or ROTC? And when we consider the model going forward, at what point do you believe we could return to what we'd call a 1% ROA for the bank?

Ira Robbins

executive
#84

I'm not going to contradict the guidance Chad has given, okay? That said, I feel quite positive about where things are headed in 2024. At the close of last year, we were producing 60% return on tangible common; I believe that represents a suitable level we ought to start aiming for, and we should return to it.

Ira Robbins

executive
#85

I simply want to express our appreciation for joining us on this call, and we're eager to speak with you again in the coming quarter.

Operator

operator
#86

Thanks. That wraps up the call for today, everyone. We appreciate all of you joining us. You're free to hang up now. Enjoy the rest of your day.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Valley National Bancorp transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Valley National Bancorp earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Valley National Bancorp or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.