Valley National Bancorp (VLY) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 25, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Travis Lan
executiveHello everyone, and thanks for joining Valley's conference call covering our first-quarter 2024 earnings. With us today from Valley are Ira Robbins, our CEO; Tom Iadanza, our President; and Mike Hagedorn, our Chief Financial Officer. Ahead of getting started, I want to let all of you know that you can locate our quarterly earnings release along with supporting documents on our company website, valley.com. In our discussion of results, we use non-GAAP measures, and those leave out certain items from reported results. For reconciliations of these non-GAAP measures, please look at today's earnings release. I'd also like to point out Slide 2 of our earnings presentation and remind everyone that remarks given on this call might include forward-looking statements concerning Valley National Bancorp and the banking industry. Valley urges all participants to consult our SEC filings, among them those on Forms 8-K, 10-Q and 10-K, for a full discussion of forward-looking statements and the factors that could cause actual results to differ from those statements. With that said, I'll hand the call over to Ira Robbins.
Ira Robbins
executiveThanks, Travis. For Q4 of 2024, Valley posted net income of $96 million, along with earnings per share of $0.18. If you set aside noncore items, adjusted net income came to $99 million, and adjusted earnings per share were $0.19. An unusually large provision for loan losses weighed on the quarter's results, and I'll get into that shortly; looking at things on a pretax pre-provision basis, though, we turned a positive corner this quarter. Net interest income's sequential decline eased considerably even with fewer days in the period. That speaks to the advantage from asset pricing plus what we're doing to keep a tighter grip on funding costs. Fee income came in strong, helped by some distinctive businesses, tax credit advisory among them. And noninterest expenses stayed under excellent control even with the usual seasonal drag from higher payroll taxes. Even as the inverted yield curve persists and other environmental hurdles remain, I'm happy to see stronger pretax pre-provision earnings this quarter. I'm likewise pleased with how the balance sheet and credit quality held up this quarter; Slide 4 lays out some of the steps we took to rein in loan growth, build up reserve coverage where the portfolio needed it, and fine-tune our funding base bit by bit. Total loans fell close to $300 million across the quarter, reflecting deliberate moves to participate out part of certain commercial real estate and construction loans, plus the divestiture of our commercial premium finance business. Every one of those sales closed at or above par, and they each give a modest boost to our commercial real estate concentration, capital ratios and reserve levels. Our allowance for credit losses on loans, measured against total loans, rose 5 basis points to 0.98% over the quarter. At the same time, both past due loans and nonaccrual loans came down relative to December 31, 2023. The bigger provision and the reserve coverage tied to it stem from internal risk rating migrations, which came out of our ongoing monitoring and rigorous stress testing of the commercial loan portfolio. Over the quarter, another 1% of loans moved into either the criticized or classified buckets. We're still at ease with the sponsorship, collateral, support and potential loss content on these loans, but under CECL, criticized loans call for elevated reserve coverage; the present level of reserve coverage sits fine with us, though we expect the allowance might drift somewhat higher across the coming few quarters. Our emphasis on, and know-how in, commercial real estate lending has produced robust and steady risk-adjusted financial results all through our history. The caliber of our commercial real estate underwriting, together with the consistently low loss content in our portfolio, has driven considerable shareholder value creation via above average tangible book value growth. Our solid borrower network has banked with Valley for decades and has held up quite well during other stretches of rising interest rates; we stay highly confident in our capital allocation and in how our commercial real estate portfolio will perform on credit going forward. That said, I recognize that how our concentration in commercial real estate is perceived has lately magnified the swings in our company's valuation. What we're seeing in terms of volatility is entirely perception-driven. It doesn't mirror our financial results, nor does it say anything about how solid our credit quality and balance sheet really are. That said, our purpose is to serve the stakeholders who matter most to us. I take pride in how we've been able to surpass what our clients, communities, and employees expect from us, but I also recognize that the level of volatility our shareholders have been dealing with simply can't continue. Commercial real estate is a fantastic asset class, and our distinct approach to it keeps generating tremendous value. We're not stepping away from the space — we'll just handle our concentration in a smarter, more efficient way from here on. Our C&I diversification efforts are going to keep picking up speed, and we'll build even more financial flexibility. All of this fits within the strategic plan we've already laid out, and my belief is that pushing forward faster on these fronts will help bring down the volatility in how we're valued. With that in mind, Slide 5 lays out what you can expect from us over the near and intermediate term on certain balance sheet metrics. By year-end 2024, our expectation is to reach roughly 9.8% Tier 1 common equity, 440% commercial real estate or risk-based capital, an allowance coverage ratio exceeding 1%, and a loan-to-deposit ratio near 100%. Those figures align with the strategy we've talked about before, along with our continued work to reinforce the balance sheet and improve financial flexibility. The next slide brings our earlier guidance up to date. The cut to our net interest income projection comes from slower loan growth and a modest shift in funding mix tied to lower noninterest-bearing deposit balances in the first quarter. We expect that the reduced net interest income figure for the year will be mostly offset by noninterest expenses coming in below what we previously guided. Holding everything else steady, that puts pretax pre-provision income roughly in line with where consensus currently sits. Slide 7 gives you more detail on our base case net interest income scenario, plus a few things to consider regarding our sensitivity to interest rate changes. As we've explained in the past, our balance sheet is broadly neutral when short-term rates move; what we're more exposed to is movement in longer rates, which affected the repricing of about 60% of our loans. Before I hand things over to Tom, I'd like to call attention to the underlying franchise value we keep building, even with all this volatility in our valuation. Starting from the close of 2017, our reported tangible book value has risen 47%, compared with only 38% for our regional banking peers. Once you factor in dividends paid out, those figures climb to 91% and 70%, respectively. That favorable gap speaks to our capacity to strengthen the franchise without significantly diluting tangible book value or overpaying for acquisitions, and without resorting to other tactics aimed at maximizing short-term results. Growth in customer accounts is another important measure of how well we build and refine our franchise. From year-end 2017 onward, we've more than doubled the count of our commercial deposit accounts, which lines up directly with our strategic goals. Bringing in fresh deposit customers all the time matters greatly, since that underpins what we can earn down the road and keeps our financial performance steady. Gains have come from many different regions and across our various business segments, and we keep pushing to hold onto that forward motion; beyond that, we see real worth in the geographic spread we've built on both sides of the balance sheet — assets and liabilities alike. When 2017 wrapped up, close to 80% of commercial loans sat in New York and New Jersey; that share is now down to roughly 50%, which reflects where we've been directing attention, namely Florida along with other vibrant commercial markets. All over the country, we keep building out banking teams that excel at service and concentrate on creating and deepening the valuable commercial ties we've been pursuing. The funding arm of our bank has gained from this too; back in 2017, 78% of deposits sat in Northeast branches. By the close of the first quarter, that share had fallen to 45%. Across Florida and Alabama we run a range of specialized funding operations plus a strong branch footprint; such variety helps shield our funding sources and opens distinctive, differentiated chances to lessen how much we lean on wholesale funding as time goes on; during the prior quarter's call, I set out 3 strategic imperatives for the year ahead. What we've seen so far shows encouraging movement on strengthening our low-cost core deposit funding, pulling back from commercial real estate, and broadening revenue streams. As I noted, we'll keep speeding up the diversification of our loan book, and I'm fully confident we'll keep delivering strong outcomes. Having said that, I'll hand things over to Tom and Mike so they can walk through the quarter's growth and financial results. Once Mike finishes, Tom, Mike, Mark Saeger — our Chief Credit Officer — and I will be here to take your questions.
Tom Iadanza
executiveThanks, Ira. On Slide 9, you can see how deposits moved during the quarter. Overall deposits were down a bit, and that was deliberate — we let higher-cost time deposits run off as they came due. Looking at it from the customer deposit side, that runoff was largely made up for by increases in interest-bearing nonmatured deposits in our specialty deposit niches. Being able to cut deposit pricing selectively across certain products and categories helped us slow the rise in deposit costs considerably during the quarter. Even though roughly $200 million in noninterest deposits rotated into interest-bearing deposits, our total cost of deposits was up only 3 basis points. The next slide gives you a closer look at how our deposit portfolio breaks down by delivery channel and business line. Traditional branch deposits were down modestly, reflecting the runoff of certain higher-cost time deposits. That said, deposit trends in our Southeast franchise held steady. Our specialty niches grew a little during the quarter, with our online deposits and technology business continuing to expand. Slide 11 shows the management actions that brought loans down during the quarter. Total loans fell close to $300 million, mostly from commercial real estate and construction participations leaving the bank. Importantly, those participations were done without any negative effect on equity. We keep watching for chances to participate out additional loans and to let certain maturing loans refinance away from Valley. The quarter-over-quarter drop in C&I loans came entirely from selling our commercial premium finance business and the maturities that followed in what remained of that portfolio. Our origination focus stays on traditional C&I, owner-occupied real estate and health care. On Slide 12, I'd point out that our loan to values rely on the most recent appraisal we've received for a property. These appraisals have an average life of about 2.5 years. Our debt service coverage ratios are figured using the latest borrower financial information available to us, which we generally get at least once a year. The next 2 slides offer more detail on our multifamily and office portfolios. Our exposure to New York multifamily loans remains modest, and we'd note that close to $531 million — about 20% of that sub portfolio — is more than 50% rent-controlled units. Our office portfolio is still diverse by geography and backed by generally diverse cash flows, with almost 65% of our loans to multi-tenant properties. With that, I'll hand the call to Mike Hagedorn, who will give you more insight into the quarter's financials.
Mike Hagedorn
executiveAppreciate that, Tom. I'll keep my remarks on CRE short. Slide 15 lays out the contractual maturity schedule for our commercial real estate portfolio. To make things easier, each maturity bucket also includes its LTV, DSCR, and rate. What this schedule shows is that the loans maturing over the next several quarters carry only a modest level of repricing risk. Turning to Slide 16, you'll see how Valley's net interest income and margin have trended over the last few quarters. The modest quarter-over-quarter declines in net interest income and net interest margin were largely attributable to one less day in the quarter. We deliberately reduced deposit costs by about 40 basis points across nearly $10 billion of deposits, and that helped net interest income steady as the quarter went on. It also helped counter the pressure from lower average noninterest-bearing deposits in the quarter. After we shortened liability duration in the first quarter, we locked in a modest amount of long-term funding at fairly attractive costs, which should provide an additional lift to net interest income in the second quarter, assuming nothing else changes. Let’s move to the next slide. Noninterest income on an adjusted basis, as you can see, rose significantly versus the fourth quarter of 2023. Part of that improvement was driven by a rebound in fees we charge for deposit services, because certain charges had been waived when we went through our conversion during 2023's fourth quarter. We also offset pressure on swap income tied to commercial lending deals by generating higher wealth-related revenue and enjoying an especially strong three months in tax credit advisory. Related to that, Dudley Ventures completed some tax credit transactions in the quarter that had been delayed beyond the close of 2023. While appetite for our tax credit advisory offerings continues to grow, we anticipate that dead lease revenues will likely moderate a bit relative to the elevated figure posted this quarter. Turning to the following slide, noninterest expenses totaled about $280 million for the quarter. Once you factor in the $7.5 million FDIC special assessment along with some other noncore charges, our noninterest expenses came to roughly $267 million on an adjusted basis. Compared with the adjusted fourth quarter of 2023, that's down 2%, and it's up just under 1% from the same period a year ago. Higher compensation costs this quarter were driven largely by seasonal payroll tax effects, though overall head count has stayed under solid control. We also saw sizable reductions in technology and consulting expenses, since costs associated with our core conversion in the fourth quarter of 2023 kept winding down. While revenue challenges have recently weighed on how efficiently we operate, our cost structure has held steady when measured against the size of our balance sheet, and it sits well below where peers stand on that same measure. The core elements shown on Slide 19 underpin both the disciplined approach we take to underwriting and our solid credit results, as well as our ability to limit losses when conditions become stressed. I'll expand on that in a moment. Slide 20 offers a wide view of our lending approach as a relationship-driven regional bank, set against institutions that focus more on transactional deals; we possess deep knowledge of our markets and serve recognized, engaged investors who have strong incentives to safeguard and expand the worth of their properties as time goes on. The people who borrow from us usually show greater discipline and prioritize value when they pick which projects to pursue. As for how we underwrite, we typically concentrate on cash flows that already exist instead of ones that are only forecasted, and that provides added protection should NOI growth never materialize. We hope what you've seen on these pages offers more background on the credit outcomes presented on Slides 21 and 22. Looking at 21, our nonaccrual and past due loan buckets remain stable, as you can see. The bottom charts display our allowance for credit loss coverage as measured against loans and past due loans. To build on what Ira said, the bump in our allowance this quarter largely came from quantitative reserves linked to loans shifting into criticized and classified buckets. Our confidence in how these loans will perform and their potential loss content remains intact. We're comfortable with the allowance level as it stands right now, though we acknowledge that additional real estate pressure along with high interest rates might nudge our allowance coverage a bit above 1% through the remainder of 2024. Turning to Slide 22. Net charge-offs increased this quarter, driven by a $9.5 million charge-off on taxi medallion loans. Commercial real estate charge-offs were minimal. At the bottom of this slide, we present two key analyses. On the lower left, we look at how our loss given default ratios for commercial real estate and construction loans stack up against those of peers over various time periods. We calculate loss given default by taking charge-offs and dividing them by nonaccrual loans. What this analysis shows is that, over time, our nonaccrual loans were far less likely to end up charged off compared with peers, which we attribute to our loss mitigation techniques. When stress hits, the most important loss mitigation tool we typically have is the deep resources and liquidity of our wealthy borrower base. On the lower right, we show our reserve relative to implied years of coverage, based on certain loss rates. Even though our allowance coverage sits below that of our competitors when you look at the raw numbers, we think that when you measure it against the losses we could actually incur, we're consistently reserved better than they are. Take our present reserve: it would be enough to absorb 6 years of implied loan losses, using the average net charge-off rate from 2001 through 2023. Compared with our peers, that's twice their relative reserve coverage. So we continue to feel confident that we're well positioned should credit quality deteriorate across the industry. Slide 23 shows how our loss rates stack up against peers relative to total loans, and to CRE loans in particular — we're lower on both. As we've noted in the past, our loss rates generally run at about 40% of what peers experience over the course of a cycle. Moving to the next slide, you can see how tangible book value and capital ratios grew in sequence. Versus the fourth quarter of 2023, tangible book value edged higher, despite a modest headwind from the OCI impact on our available-for-sale securities portfolio. Regulatory capital ratios continue to climb, and as Ira mentioned earlier, we anticipate further increases for the rest of 2024 and beyond. With that, I'll turn it back to the operator so we can begin the Q&A. Thank you.
Steven Alexopoulos
analystI'd like to kick things off. So, Ira, to begin with the CRE concentration, which has declined to 440% — could you walk us through the $32 billion of CRE loans you had this quarter, construction included? What direction should we anticipate those moving for the remainder of the year? Also, do you believe you can keep doing what you managed this quarter and exit at par?
Ira Robbins
executiveSure. When we examine that CRE concentration, the exclusion of owner-occupied loans is essentially what drives it. On one of our slides, where we lay out the balance sheet breakout, that likely offers a somewhat clearer picture of what that opening figure looks like. I'd say we enjoyed a very successful quarter collaborating with <<inaudible>> and certain other partners we've worked alongside for years, exploring greater participations. Looking at the loan yield maturities scheduled to come due, there's genuinely no meaningful difference between where our existing portfolio stands and where market signals or rates sit right now; therefore a rate problem doesn't truly exist that would limit our capacity to offset certain loans we hold from a participation standpoint. And as you've witnessed throughout the years, credit quality here has been truly exceptional; and when people have reviewed the loans, they generally share that same view.
Steven Alexopoulos
analystAll right, that's useful. I'm interested, Ira — the stock is down. My sense is it's a bit more than 30% for the year. And you brought up perception, I believe, regarding the real estate portfolio. When you stack yourselves up against others, I mean, this is what unfolded after New York Community — how would you compare your pre-portfolio with peer banks, and what do you figure the market isn't seeing?
Ira Robbins
executiveTo say there's no problem in commercial real estate from a macro standpoint, I think, would mean burying my head in the sand. That being said, if you truly dig into the pockets that are most stressed right now, office strikes me as the obvious one, correct? And that isn't simply a result of where rates are or because behaviors have genuinely shifted. Rent regulated in New York City is a second pocket of stress. And then a third angle, I'd say, is the repricing risk that's out there; so if you truly separate out those 3 particular pockets and then dig into the underlying specifics of where Valley stands on those 3 items; on the office portfolio, it's roughly $3.3 billion. But when you examine the particular underlying metrics of those loans, they're quite small in size; beyond that, what we attempted to do is provide an update even on what those revised debt service coverage ratios look like. So we're at 168 for a debt service coverage ratio on the office portfolio, which I believe is highly differentiated. I'd argue the bigger differentiation on the office is in fact the size. Our office is just $3 million on average. I mean there genuinely isn't a lot of stress among those kinds of offices that we're lending against. So I think that's probably somewhat differentiated. And on the rent regulated side, it's clearly somewhat differentiated too. As Tom said during his prepared comments, we're only at about $500 million of rent and regulated; that's equal to 50% of what that composition looks like. So again, I think it's a really small portfolio and very manageable when we consider what the risk of that portfolio looks like. Everything is current today within that portfolio. And then the third one I referenced was really the rate reset risk. And we tried to provide a bit more granularity on the earnings call as well as in the presentation. The rate reset risk isn't like what it is at many of our peers here; that said, look, I recognize the CRE concentration is fairly significant; and at a macro level, we examine the concentration; and people simply have a view of what that is at Valley; so I'm aware of that. I recognize it. I think as an organization, we need to start bringing down what that macro CRE concentration is. Yet here at Valley, having a lot of commercial real estate exposure isn't the same as taking an outright loss; during this particular quarter, we moved certain loans into classified and criticized categories. Like we've said previously, our track record of losses looks quite different from others in this region, since a loan here can be tagged as criticized without that meaning a loss will follow. We've demonstrated this on a year-over-year basis. In the third quarter, I believe, our classified loans also rose considerably. And when you examine what happened this quarter, nonaccrual hasn't gone up. Delinquency hasn't gone up either, while classified loans did climb a few quarters back. So I think it's simply a matter of becoming acquainted with how granular our portfolio really is, which for certain people requires time and effort too. With that said, we have patience here, and over the long run we're quite confident we'll wind up in a very strong position.
Steven Alexopoulos
analystAll right, that's useful. Could I ask just one more thing about change direction? Regarding expenses, the revised expense guidance is now slightly under the bottom of the range. What steps do you believe you've taken — you've done quite a bit over the last several years, correct? And what's the fresh range for how you're viewing expense growth in this year?
Ira Robbins
executiveHopefully it comes in below where it stands right now. On our prior call — not the one last year, but the one before, when we first really began noticing extra strain tied to the inverted yield curve — we said we'd implement a 5% reduction in head count in June of last year. Looking at the real figures, we had 3,912 employees in June of '23. Today we're at 3,709 employees. That means we're down 5.2% in total employee head count. We believe there's additional room to keep pushing that same overall emphasis. And the larger factor, Steve, is that folks undervalue how many resources — both inside and outside — went into the core conversion we completed at the end of 2023. A considerable level of expense came with that. We're now starting to truly see some of the advantages of operating on a single platform. And we expect that to keep going through 2024 as well.
Matthew Breese
analystWhen we consider how commercial real estate might expand given this quarter's revised guidance and the steps taken, ought we to anticipate meaningful runoff from that portfolio? If that's the case, how large would it be? Alternatively, might that lending category basically stay flat while every other category, C&I in particular, increases around it?
Tom Iadanza
executiveMatt, this is Tom. You can see we adjusted our outlook for overall loans to a range of 0% to 4%, compared with the 5% to 7% annualized figure; we are deliberately steering our real estate book by concentrating on our best relationship-based customers. Roughly $750 million of real estate loans were originated by us during the first quarter, a sharp decline relative to what we accomplished over the last several years. Real estate will remain an area where we stay active and engaged, yet we will keep selling loans as well. For those loans lacking a relationship connection, we'll allow them to reach maturity and depart; during the first quarter, roughly $500 million in loans matured and moved to other banks, and I want to note that entire amount benefited the bank. Now look, our C&I expectations aren't being altered. That portfolio has expanded 10% on an annualized basis. Had it not been for the premium finance sale, we would have posted a slight increase in the first quarter. The first quarter is typically a sluggish one. We usually see paydowns on line utilization. Our owner-occupied portfolio during the first quarter rose 6% annualized. That's therefore a favorable development. Our pipelines and C&I remain quite steady, and $1 billion of C&I loans were originated by us in the first quarter, matching what we have achieved previously.
Matthew Breese
analystUnderstood. Alright. Then when it comes to CECL, it seems we were all trained to consider past losses along with forward-looking economic variables. And the allowance was meant to be tailored to every institution according to those assumptions. Yet following the emergence of newer community and now the category for bank classification, it seems a third leg has appeared on that stool, namely your peer group and their actions. Given that, is it reasonable to assume that over the longer term, past what you've described for the intermediate term, many of your ratios, commercial real estate, reserve capital needs will shift toward the levels of your category for peers regardless of what CECL indicates regarding your quarter-to-quarter change in reserving?
Mark Saeger
executiveMatthew, I'm Mark Saeger. Regarding our model specifically, one advantage is that we employ a transition matrix model, which is highly sensitive to migration within the portfolio. We maintain an elevated level of reserves against criticized and classified credits; therefore we receive an immediate bump through migration in our reserve, which demonstrates the appropriateness of that migration, not merely loss; and roughly 2/3 of the rise in our reserve for the quarter was tied to migration within the portfolio.
Ira Robbins
executiveFrom a broader perspective, Matt — regarding what you asked specifically — must we really match where our peers sit? Given the size of our company, just $60 billion, there's plenty of room ahead before we reach $100 billion. So taking those reserve ratios and assuming we automatically ought to be at that same level, based on this third-party view of how CECL appears, strikes me as a wrong conclusion. The accounts, I believe, make fairly evident what actually drives the CECL model. And like Mark said, there will be a modest uptick owing to what the transition is showing us, plus some growth in certain classified loans and criticized loans; however, I don't believe any guidance exists saying we must match whatever the banks above $100 million are doing.
Matthew Breese
analystWhat worries me more is the commercial real estate concentration, since comparable banks run at a median concentration of 100%, and the top end is M&T at roughly $180 million to $190 million, while we sit far below that. So to reach $100 million, significant adjustments would have to occur somewhere along the way. I'm wondering whether that factors into the strategy here.
Ira Robbins
executiveClearly, stating that at $100 billion we'd carry a 400% CRE concentration wouldn't make any sense at all. That said, we obviously have a very long runway, Matt. Consider that even at a 10% growth rate on the balance sheet as it stands today, more than 6 years would pass before we reached $100 billion. And plenty will unfold at Vale across the next 6-ish years. Bringing the CRE concentration down is something we've discussed for years now, and it's genuinely been the strategic focus here; we set up C&I business lines spanning the tech business, a commodities business, and all sorts of other C&I businesses many, many years ago, aiming to start diversifying the look of that portfolio. As Tom said, C&I is expanding 10% annualized. So it isn't as though we suddenly realized one morning, "Hey, the CRE concentration is too high. We need to start building some of these foundational C&I businesses." We've been at it for years. And in fact, we've witnessed plenty of positive results tied to that C&I business too. So clearly, CRE can't remain at the same level at Vale that it has historically; and we've put many solid strategic initiatives in place to truly start driving C&I business here, whose benefits we've seen for years now, and we expect that acceleration to continue.
Matthew Breese
analystThis will be my final question, after which I'll rejoin the queue. Tom, you brought up what sounds like a pretty thorough stress test applied to your commercial real estate portfolio. It demonstrates that across time, your loss content has been superior to that of peers. I'd like to know which kinds of assumptions got layered into those stress tests. And ultimately, what did the loss content look like? What charge-offs did that stress produce?
Tom Iadanza
executiveWe don't make public, nor do we disclose, the particular assumptions behind our stress testing, yet occupancy, rent per square foot, vacancies, the overall rate, and market conditions are all stressed by us as part of that process, and we then measure that against our total capital to confirm we stay a well-capitalized institution.
Ira Robbins
executiveMatt and I believe there's one additional point worth making here, which concerns how broad our credit review process actually reaches. On Slide 19, we set out a credit framework tied specifically to value, and that has driven much of the reduced loss given defaults that Mike brought up earlier. Our credit officers personally examined more than 60% of the commercial real estate portfolio during the most recent quarter alone. So for us, stress testing isn't merely about which assumptions get applied — it's also about how large that exercise is. It isn't simply a matter of saying, let's review a handful of loans maturing within roughly the coming 12 months. Instead, we conduct thorough examinations of every one of these portfolios individually. As a result, the migration you're observing this quarter doesn't only reflect loans due within approximately the next 12 months. It represents 60% of our whole CRE book.
Frank Schiraldi
analystTo build a bit on that final part of the question, I simply want to confirm I've got it right regarding Slide 5, the reserve. Mike, you mentioned you feel fairly at ease with the current level of reserves, and because of loss rates, your reserving has actually been stronger than peers in a number of respects. Still, I'm just trying to grasp what gets us to approximately 110 of reserve across the coming 12 to 24 months. So what would be causing that? Does it happen as the commercial real estate book ages and reprices, or is it more just that as you expand you gradually align with peers over time?
Mike Hagedorn
executiveFrom a big-picture standpoint, I'd say there are probably 2 items, correct? Clearly, the CRE reviews we perform and the migration tied to them have genuinely helped us in terms of what the loss given defaults are. So there may be somewhat more migration in terms of how that CRE appears as we move through the remaining portfolio. And I believe another factor is really over on the C&I side: as we keep originating additional C&I loans, those will carry a higher reserve ratio than the rest of the legacy CRE does; so that will by itself wind up pushing up how that coverage ratio appears.
Frank Schiraldi
analystUnderstood. Alright, so I was also curious about whether there's room to speed up part of this decrease in concentration. Clearly, you shifted certain things out of CRE at par during this quarter. And clearly, it appears there's been some chance on the commercial side; we've definitely observed commercial teams making moves, I'd say, to a larger extent, I'd say, because of some of the disruption in the marketplace, let's say. So I'm just interested, when you consider that, whether that's something where you folks see an opportunity to perhaps speed this up via a bigger mix shift in the near term.
Ira Robbins
executiveI think perhaps I'll begin, if that's alright, and then I'll hand it over to Tom; but I think one of the limitations that we've always functioned under here is what that tangible book value figure is, correct? And it's truly been a priority inside the organization not to water down shareholders via tangible book value deals, as we said before, whether that's through foolish M&A deals that have very lengthy buybacks or through balance sheet restructurings. I mean we witness that now and what's going on with certain securities books we see with what's also going on with sales. So I think that's a limitation that we examine to confirm what our options are that we have to confirm that, that tangible book value and capital truly keep expanding within the organization. Having said that, we managed to complete plenty at par today.
Tom Iadanza
executiveFrank, on the question you raised about commercial teams that are deposit-driven: in some markets we've brought teams on board when the chance arose, and that covers both the Southeast and the North.
Frank Schiraldi
analystOkay, alright. I suppose the main thing — it just appears as though there's quite a bit of activity. I'm not sure whether a few of these items wind up costing too much upfront. Clearly, you folks trimmed your expense guidance somewhat. Yes. So I was simply wondering whether there might be a notable pickup chance right here in the short run. We've clearly observed a few other press releases from other companies. And so, I was just wondering about anything near term that's sizable.
Ira Robbins
executiveYes. Perhaps I didn't catch your question at first, and I'm sorry. I believed you were leaning a bit more toward the lending side, and I ought to address that immediately. Look, I think, as we said during this call, we're witnessing substantial expansion in that Southeast market. So a portion of the disruption you're noticing up here in the Northeast with folks arriving alongside teams, they clearly arrive at a considerable cost. We've examined a few of them and the incremental expense of bringing in some of those deposits. Once you factor in what those teams cost, we're discovering far, far less expensive options in other places, and that's where we plan to direct a great deal of our resources.
Chris O'Connell
analystYeah, this is Chris. Regarding capital — Ira, the $9.8 million before the year ends, and $10 million plus across the following 12 to 24 months — how do you arrive at those figures? I'm just curious, sort of — I follow the mechanics behind getting there. But how did you reach, I suppose, what matters more, that $10 million plus, when a number of your peers sit around the mid-10s or even $11 million.
Ira Robbins
executiveYeah. I'd say, listen, Chris, we've discussed extensively how, compared with our peers, our allowance and capital ratios were justified in sitting a bit under where peers are, with the recognition they still have to climb above today's levels; so I'm not certain whether you're asking about the short term or about where we see ourselves over the long haul. Yet if you look at that near-term expectation column, every one of these metrics captures organic work or marginal items, such as what we completed this quarter by selling certain commercial real estate loans at par. So nothing major or drastic is built into the near-term expectation column. And from there, continuing those same efforts as time passes is what carries you to the right-hand column. So I don't know whether that answers it, but...
Chris O'Connell
analystRight, that's useful. One more thing on that point. Might there be a scenario in which you'd pursue something such as a credit linked note, or another form of RWA mitigation, in order to speed that up? Some competitors have done this and it's worked well for them.
Ira Robbins
executiveI'd say every chance to optimize RWA is something we're considering. Certain portfolios are better suited to it than others, but our balance sheet is quite diverse, and portfolios such as auto and residential might present strong chances for deals of that kind.
Chris O'Connell
analystAll right, fantastic. And now perhaps just a couple of administrative items. Could you share — perhaps I overlooked the commercial real estate concentration figure for Q1? And beyond that, the sequential shift in criticized, classified, and special mention loans, I realize you touched on it somewhat generally, but I'd welcome any detail there.
Ira Robbins
executiveSure. That CRE ratio should come in at roughly 464%, which means a decline of approximately 10% versus December 31, as Mark noted.
Mark Saeger
executiveCorrect. Regarding that migration, we said roughly 500 accounts moved into criticized status during the quarter. Some added detail there: the concentration was disproportionately in office, which given current market conditions really shouldn't come as a surprise.
Jon Arfstrom
analystTo build on what was said in response to Chris, should we simply plan on seeing criticized and classified loans increase every quarter? It sounds as if you might be conducting a thorough examination each quarter. How should we frame what lies ahead so we can be ready for it?
Mark Saeger
executiveMark here. Referring back to points Ira raised earlier, during the first quarter we carried out a special review covering the sensitive asset classes and the portfolio as a whole, reaching slightly more than 60% of it, with attention centered on rent stabilized and office. Given the elevated rate setting, we expect some continued migration across the year, and we do think first quarter migration came in high because of where the reviews were focused and how much of the portfolio was examined.
Jon Arfstrom
analystAll right, that's useful. Mike, could you walk through what you expect for margins once more? My recollection is that you mentioned the margin has hit bottom, and we should see an improvement during Q2, but I want to confirm that I understood you right.
Mike Hagedorn
executiveYeah. To start, I appreciate you bringing that up. It's obvious I got overlooked earlier today. So that's nice. I'm not sure I used the term trough, but let me revisit Q1, and after that I'll provide the guidance. Broadly speaking, Q1 results matched what we anticipated when looking at it per day count, and the slight pressures regarding net interest income were essentially the noninterest-bearing deposits along with loan growth being slower. However, deposit cost reductions we've previously discussed also helped counter those; and we keep monitoring that. The guidance that's been nudged a bit lower reflects, once again, where we began with reduced noninterest-bearing deposits and, once more, this slower loan growth we've mentioned, particularly given the participations we brought up as occurring late in Q1; so that effect shows up in Q1 figures just as much as it will during Q2. And although we did factor in fewer Fed cuts, my guess is most folks are doing the same. Keep in mind that long-end rates are projected to be elevated compared with their starting position on 12/31. So overall, the yield curve shifting, whether at the higher or the short end, gives us a slight advantage since our exposure leans more toward the long end.
Jon Arfstrom
analystOkay, all right, I get it. Ira, if I understood you right, you mentioned that despite these revisions to guidance, you still anticipate PPNR staying fairly steady compared with what you previously indicated before those tweaks? Is that correct?
Ira Robbins
executiveYes, exactly.
Jon Arfstrom
analystAll right. So for our purposes, this comes down to attempting to determine the size of the provision. And you're merely observing a slight increase in the reserve. PPNR remains unchanged — only the placement on the income statement shifts. Is that accurate?
Ira Robbins
executiveI believe we've attempted to provide some direction regarding where those figures might land. But clearly, as Mark mentioned, it depends on the market, and we've already reviewed a substantial portion of the portfolio. With that said, we'll keep watching the portfolio and conducting credit reviews; we think that has truly been a strength for us, and being able to conduct the extensive reviews we perform has pushed down loss given default; it has formed part of the defining trait of who we are — actively managing the portfolio rather than simply waiting for something to occur. So we are examining each and every loan we hold as we continue to truly do so, and when market conditions shift, we'll make adjustments accordingly.
Manan Gosalia
analystConsidering every one of those button takes on the lending side you just went through, plus the repricing of fixed rate loans and the fact that 40% of loans are floating rate, what's the right way to think about how loan yields expand from where they are this quarter if we get a scenario with 3 rate cuts?
Ira Robbins
executiveWell, I'd say the speed at which loan yields have been climbing has decelerated now that rates have generally leveled off at the front end. So that instant pickup has more or less run its course, most likely; even so, there are clearly certain tailwinds; and I believe when we present it to you in the deck, we lay out that mature increase side, which could serve as a decent sort of guide to assist you; regarding what's rolling off and afterward where you're placing things back on. This quarter we originated loans, and loan yields were still within the high 7s. So from a CRE standpoint, our CRE origination yield came to $780 million. That means there remains some room to boost loan yields in that area.
Manan Gosalia
analystUnderstood, thanks for that. You mentioned buying certain Ginnies during this quarter. Does additional capacity exist for more of that? Also, how ought we to view the amount of on-balance sheet liquidity you aim to maintain across the coming few quarters?
Executive
executiveSure. Regarding those Ginnie Mae acquisitions, clearly they carry zero risk weighting; their average life sits at roughly 3 to 4 years, and yields on that portfolio for the purchases made lately, I should clarify, came in around 5%, a bit above the 5% mark. As for runoff within the portfolio, essentially no prepayment occurs, meaning it will simply be stated maturity payoffs totaling approximately $75 million to $90 million each quarter, and we expect we would keep adding zero risk-weighted Ginnies, likely at yields between 5% and 5.5%.
Manan Gosalia
analystUnderstood, sir. Regarding the on-balance sheet liquidity you have to keep from this point on. Could there be space for it to increase? Or do you feel you're at the appropriate level? I'm asking because — you also said the LDR ought to trend below 100% in 2025. So I just want a sense of what the proper level of liquidity is.
Executive
executiveAnd let me confirm I'm responding to what you mean, specifically FHLB or Federal Reserve availability.
Ira Robbins
executiveMy sense is that, on the whole, you'll likely witness somewhat more in the way of balance sheet liquidity — though not to any major extent. Still, a portion of bringing that loan-to-deposit ratio all the way down to 100% is certainly going to involve some core deposits arriving and then being put into securities rather than being directed toward loans. That said, I don't believe you truly need to anticipate any meaningful change in the composition of that securities book.
Manan Gosalia
analystUnderstood. Yeah, that's the point I was driving at. Thanks.
Jared Shaw
analystRegarding the CRE sales completed during this quarter, managing to execute those at par is excellent. That said, I find it somewhat unexpected, considering the current rate environment, that no rate mark was applied at all. Could you share anything about the duration and yield on the kinds of loans we offloaded, and was there any credit participation we kept?
Tom Iadanza
executiveYeah. Tom speaking; by and large, these were participations. The participation rates, I believe, spanned from roughly 7.4% upward — on the fixed portion, 7.4% to 7.5%. Every one of them was participated at par. As lead bank, we held onto a share of those. On the floating portion, prime-plus construction loans made up most of them. And once again, we kept a position in those.
Mike Hagedorn
executiveThat final item strikes me as quite significant as well, since what we're doing is keeping those customer ties intact. And just as Ira mentioned during the prepared remarks, CRE is an extremely valuable asset class, and we'll stay in it. We've got a substantial reservoir of top-tier commercial real estate borrowers, yet there are approaches that let us weigh the imperative of managing the balance sheet against maintaining and expanding those customer relationships.
Jared Shaw
analystAll right. As a follow-up, what should we expect when it comes to deposit growth going forward? And when we consider certain promotional items that are reaching maturity, where do you observe them being replaced, and what does the new offering look like regarding its duration and its pricing?
Tom Iadanza
executiveWe've still had that rotation out of noninterest-bearing, but a genuinely strong area has been savings growth, and at this point that more than makes up for whatever we've shed from noninterest-bearing or shifted away from noninterest-bearing into different products. Growth across our niche businesses has also been quite robust. Perhaps a sign of, or an early signal regarding, what's ahead in terms of growth and the underlying strength is what happened just during the first quarter. Net, we brought in more than 3,000 net new deposit accounts, so our feeling was pretty positive. My message to you is that I believe growth will stem from the niche businesses along with ongoing work in our retail branches aimed at growing households. And if we were to witness the rotation out of noninterest-bearing leveling off, that would simply be beneficial for us.
Ira Robbins
executivePossibly, Jared, there are just a couple of additional points I'd make regarding that. On the prior call, I mentioned — speaking for myself in particular — some of the frustration I felt and how funding expenses had risen inside the company. So we took a very proactive approach, examining $10 billion worth of various deposit offerings throughout the organization and reducing those by 40 basis points. That didn't occur during the first period, let's say the first month, of the quarter — rather, it unfolded across the quarter. So we believe a bit of a tailwind will come from that as we keep evaluating deposit expense. Having said that, deposits from new originations arrived extremely strong during the quarter. The rate was just 3.23%, and net new originations totaled well over $1 billion. And clearly, a portion of that helped counterbalance some of the pricier time deposits that Tom encountered — or, I should say, that Mike noted had run off. So I think we've performed quite well in attracting newer deposits into the company at a considerably lower rate than the marginal cost of certain existing deposits we currently hold. And we've likewise managed to successfully reduce a portion of the deposit expense currently sitting on our books. So we feel there's substantial tailwind tied to all of this.
Steve Moss
analystI have another question regarding deposits. I'm just wondering, at what point during the quarter did you lower deposit rates by 40 basis points?
Executive
executiveWe cut rates on various tranches of deposit categories, starting on February 1 and then carrying on into portions of March.
Steve Moss
analystAll right. So I suppose, in essence, what we want to find out is how they stick, and assuming we remain in the rate environment we're in right now, are you going to keep pushing for further reductions on deposit rates?
Executive
executiveUnidentified Executive: Correct. It's handled on a weekly basis; we review where the levels sit, and among the groups where cuts were made, nothing meaningful has shifted in those levels. All right.
Steve Moss
analystAll right, that's helpful. Now, regarding credit — given the thorough review you both conducted on particular portfolios, you noted that you looked at the office portfolio and saw migration there. I'm just wondering, what's the exact reserve tied to office? And related to that, I'm also wondering whether you're evidently reviewing individual properties, or whether you're reviewing the worldwide cash flows of the borrowers? I'm simply curious how those worldwide cash flows are faring at present.
Mark Saeger
executiveNo, certainly. Let me take the latter part of the question. Yes, within our customary credit procedures, we review not just the property we lend against, but also the total worldwide cash flow of every developer we conduct business with, so we gain that comprehensive perspective and can determine whether there's stress in our property and the stress is worldwide, or the reverse — worldwide cash flow is strengthening while the property is weak. Every one of those elements feeds into the risk rating, and into the migration and portfolio; we don't disclose a distinct office reserve. Yet, as I said before, we hold a considerably greater amount of reserves for criticized assets, and within our office portfolio there is a heightened level of criticized assets.
Tom Iadanza
executiveOne more point I'd like to make on top of that: a lot of the clients we serve hold positions across several asset categories, rather than being concentrated in only one.
Steve Moss
analystOkay. So regarding the office portfolio, I believe the figure was either $150 million or $160 million. The debt service coverage ratio slips my mind at the moment. But in today's market, are many of those borrowers likely to end up at one? I'm just somewhat interested in how much equity a borrower would need to contribute these days to properly resize those loans.
Mark Saeger
executiveYeah. The portfolio's granularity is evident, I think, given the $3 million average loan size there. We do examine each migrated case individually. Stress in debt service coverage on those properties was obviously present, which made the downgrade necessary. However, our leverage on office properties historically, along with our initial coverage, was extremely robust for long-term clients with whom we have relationships, something we also feel helps that portfolio's overall performance over time.
Ira Robbins
executiveSteve, we displayed what the typical loan amount looks like. What I'm getting at is that I want to highlight how granular and varied this portfolio is. Yet honestly, regarding what you just asked, and this isn't only relevant for office properties — I'd say it holds true throughout the whole portfolio — because of the typical size of our loans, if a borrower has to inject more cash reserves or equity into a particular deal, the amounts involved are relatively small, so the absolute dollars needed to get things back in balance are lower. I view that as an advantage, and it's one piece of how we handle loss mitigation and credit management.
Steve Moss
analystAll right, and perhaps one additional question tied to office commercial real estate. In terms of the migration you're observing, does it show up in the bigger loans currently? Or does it span everything?
Mark Saeger
executiveI'd put it this way — geography plays the biggest role; the biggest share of our office book sits in Florida and Alabama, and migration there has been at a far lower level, while most of the migration is happening in the Northeast along with the New Jersey and New York market, though it's worth noting that our Manhattan exposure is pretty granular and pretty small.
Steve Moss
analystAll right, I appreciate that. And stepping back a bit from all this, I was just wondering — with the plan to bring down commercial real estate concentrations, doing a deal right now might not be simple, but I'm curious how this shift is affecting the way you think about M&A?
Ira Robbins
executiveLook, I'd say this is the strategic initiatives and plan we've laid out over the past couple of years. So I think we're simply trying to speed up certain things we're already doing. If an M&A opportunity comes along that helps move some strategic initiatives ahead faster, that's absolutely something we'd consider. That being said, the guardrails around tangible book value matter a lot to me. So clearly, where valuations stand in the current market constrain what you're able to do there. But M&A that genuinely speeds up strategic initiatives is definitely something we, as an organization, are open to.
David Chiaverini
analystI'd like to ask a bit more about costs. It seems a fairly solid decrease might be coming. Can you describe which parts you're scaling back? Also, are there any programs being moved down the priority list?
Ira Robbins
executiveFrom a big-picture standpoint, sure, activity levels will drop when it comes to volume across particular lending categories; therefore, further trimming in those places is likely. Still, a big chunk of this traces back to the subject we raised during the prior quarter. Moving to our core system demanded considerable internal and external resources. As we keep realizing gains from shifting everything onto a single core platform, we're confident some sales will result. Certainly not at the level of the momentum we experienced between last year and today; even so, we see room to improve on the cost side of things.
Tom Iadanza
executiveTo give you an illustration that might make this concrete: before the conversion — the core conversion — we operated with 3 separate GL systems, plus we had 2 different core systems. This quarter, we closed the books faster than at any point since I joined Valley. That serves as a solid illustration of the efficiency gained from the core conversion, and of how it produces ancillary benefits that sort of ripple across the entire organization.
David Chiaverini
analystI'd like to add something regarding the liquidity question, to be more precise about it. The proportion of assets held as cash plus securities came to 11%. Is it reasonable for us to anticipate that this 11% figure will gradually move upward as time goes on?
Ira Robbins
executiveYeah, I believe that over time, in a directional sense, that's logical, though I don't see any large-scale move happening at any particular moment. What I mean is that it's simply an overall trajectory — we have been moving higher. If you examine the past 2 years, and we'll keep doing that. Our deposit base is extremely steady and highly granular. So we feel we're in a strong position as things stand right now. But purely in terms of direction, as we expand, we'll keep holding a greater amount of cash and securities.
Ben Gerlinger
analystSlides 12 and 13 — those debt service coverage ratios were genuinely useful. Some slight movement is to be anticipated. Would it be accurate to state that every one of those now incorporates 2023 manuals? Or are we still waiting on a bit more? I'm simply attempting to find the freshest possible version of that ratio.
Mark Saeger
executiveFor a substantial share of what we hold, we do possess current, updated rent roll data. I don't think it covers all of them, however; we had definitely factored in 2023 figures; and our view is that across every asset class apart from office, we've observed NOI growth that is strong.
Ben Gerlinger
analystUnderstood. Then I saw a multifamily property down in the Southeast. The Florida Alabama figure dropped a fair bit from one quarter to the next. Do you have anything to say about that?
Ira Robbins
executiveBen, we are going to revisit that figure and check it. Are you referring to the debt service coverage ratio declining?
Ben Gerlinger
analystYeah. It started out at essentially...
Ira Robbins
executiveThat figure, as it turns out, is identical as well. I'm going to revisit it and examine it, since coincidentally it matches the same value shown for all of them up above. So I'll review that and follow up with everybody.
Ben Gerlinger
analystYes. Alright. And finally, I realize this has been a lengthy call, and I'm sorry if you end up saying the same thing again, but did you provide a monthly figure or an exit spot rate regarding deposit costs?
Mike Hagedorn
executiveA spot rate wasn't provided by us. In the IP, it's visible that total deposit costs rose from 3.1% to 3.16%, which means an increase of 3 basis points.
Matthew Breese
analystI only had a couple of quick follow-ups. The first one concerned the taxi medallion charge off. What took place there? Was that included in the credit review? It just appears to be a rather large charge considering how distant we are from the kind of the peak of the tax medallion days? What's the remaining balance on that portfolio?
Mark Saeger
executiveThe remaining balance, we have $52 million left in portfolio that's fully reserved down to current market prices. For the charge-off that we experienced this quarter, that was also fully reserved for. It was one relationship of a customer who had been paying; we were in a long-term negotiation and kind of hit a standstill. Subsequent to the charge-off we have entered into a forbearance agreement and that loan has continued to pay.
Matthew Breese
analystAll right. So given that loan growth may not be as strong going forward, could you lay out for us how you'd rank your priorities when it comes to deploying capital? And what I'd really like to know is whether buying back stock might factor into that plan at all, perhaps even modestly. Beyond that, Ira, I want to follow up on what you said regarding M&A — if FDIC-assisted transactions came up, would those be something you'd consider? That covers everything from me. Thanks.
Ira Robbins
executiveWell, when I think about deploying capital, directing money toward expanding the CRE portfolio likely isn't in the cards right now. We have plenty of room on the inside simply to support the CRE customers we already have, so my guess is that's where the greater emphasis will ultimately land. That said, we're currently experiencing C&I growth that's stronger than anything we've seen over the past 2 years. So putting capital into those particular areas looks like a far superior return for us at present. As for M&A, again, should an opportunity be strategic and make sense, we'd evaluate it; though I have to say, the limits tied to tangible book value are something I take quite seriously.
Ira Robbins
executiveAppreciate it. I simply want to express gratitude to all of you for spending part of your day listening to us. And I'm eager to talk with you again when the next quarter comes around. Enjoy the rest of your day.
Operator
operatorWe appreciate everyone joining us on this call today. That brings the program to a close. You're free to leave the line now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Valley National Bancorp transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Valley National Bancorp earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Valley National Bancorp or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.