Valley National Bancorp (VLY) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
July 25, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Travis Lan
executiveGood morning, everyone, and thanks for joining Valley's conference call covering second quarter 2024 results. On the call from Valley today are CEO Ira Robbins, President Tom Iadanza, and Chief Financial Officer Mike Hagedorn. Before we get started, I want to point out that the quarterly earnings release and the supporting documents are available on our company website at valley.com. In discussing our results, we reference non-GAAP measures, which leave out certain items from reported results. Reconciliations of these non-GAAP measures can be found in today's earnings release. I'd also like to draw your attention to Slide 2 of our earnings presentation and remind everyone that remarks on this call may include forward-looking statements about Valley National Bancorp and the banking industry. Valley encourages all participants to review our SEC filings, including those on Forms 8-K, 10-Q and 10-K, for a complete discussion of forward-looking statements and the factors that could cause actual results to differ from those statements. With that, I'll hand the call over to Ira Robbins.
Ira Robbins
executiveThank you, Travis. In the second quarter of 2024, Valley posted $70 million in net income and $0.13 in diluted earnings per share. The drop in net income from the prior quarter came about because pre-tax pre-provision net revenue held steady—helped by net interest income turning positive—while the loan loss provision stayed elevated. Although that provision sits above our typical range, we think this quarter will mark the relative peak in provisioning. Last quarter, I laid out the planned acceleration of our strategic initiatives designed to bring certain balance sheet metrics that stand out versus peers back to normal. I am very pleased with how much progress we have made so quickly on each of the balance sheet goals we set out. Importantly, we have started executing these initiatives without reducing our capacity to earn in the future. In fact, we believe further strengthening of our balance sheet will bring stability to our performance and relative value in the market. Slide 4 shows our progress in detail. By the close of the second quarter, both our CRE concentration and allowance coverage ratios had already hit the year-end expectations we presented only three months earlier. By capping investor CRE and multi rate origination and by re-classifying certain healthcare loans into the owner occupied bucket, we managed to bring our commercial real estate concentration ratio down to our full year 2024 target of around 440%. Against a backdrop of strong credit performance and stable past due and non-accrual loan metrics during the quarter, our reserve coverage grew to our near-term targeted level of above 1%; we now expect to reach our intermediate term expectation of around 1.10% by the end of 2024. To be clear, our view is unchanged that a coverage ratio of about 1.10% suits our risk profile, given our analysis of the portfolio and the current backdrop; this quarter's elevated provision, set against strong credit performance, resulted from our conservative choice to place less value on personal guarantees as a mitigating factor in our internal loan risk ratings. That shift pushed additional loan downgrades into our criticized and classified buckets, which each carry higher reserve requirements under our methodology. Our criticized and classified loans keep performing and remain current on payment activity. While this conservative treatment of personal guarantees is reasonable given the current market environment, we still believe personal guarantees help influence borrower behavior and matter in cases of stress. Throughout our history, these guarantees have proven very useful in limiting charge offs and enhancing recoveries. For this reason, we expect that in practice, personal guarantees will remain valuable in minimizing the loss content of our portfolio going forward. Turning to capital, our risk based ratios improved meaningfully during the quarter despite strong non-CRE balance sheet growth and only modest retained earnings. This growth came primarily from a synthetic risk transfer, which we executed during the quarter. The deal lowered the risk weighted assets tied to our indirect auto loan business by roughly $1 billion. We still feel quite good about where our regulatory capital stands and about the substantial growth we have delivered on both a quarter-over-quarter and year-over-year basis. On Slide 6, you can see what we expect for the rest of 2024; we are looking for annualized loan growth in the low single digits through the remainder of the year. In line with the strong results this quarter, coming loan growth will probably lean toward C&I and owner-occupied CRE, since new investor CRE originations are staying well controlled. We expect that this growth, along with continued repricing of existing assets, to support as much as 3% growth in net interest income each quarter for the rest of the year. Non-interest income ought to rebound from where it sits now as capital markets activity improves and we keep expanding our treasury management capabilities. Non-interest expense is staying well controlled, although we will absorb a full quarter's worth of the premium expense tied to our risk trade in the third and fourth quarters. Our tax rate will probably land between 25% and 26% for the remainder of the year. On credit, net charge-offs will likely stay near present levels through the rest of the year; even so, I will repeat that we are confident our provision has peaked, and that a figure between the first and second quarter's provision is a more sensible quarterly expectation going forward. Those expectations, taken together with our loan growth outlook, suggest we will finish the year at an ACL to loan ratio of about 1.10%. Before I hand the call to Tom, I wanted to point out the underlying franchise value we keep building at Valley. Since the close of 2017, reportable tangible book value has risen 47% for us versus 36% for our regional banking peers. Once distributed dividends are included, that becomes 93% growth versus 70%, respectively; the gap shows our capacity to strengthen franchise value without materially diluting tangible book value through overpriced acquisitions or through other means of maximizing near-term results. Customer account growth is another important gauge of how well we build and optimize franchise value. Commercial deposit account growth stayed strong this quarter, and our stable deposit levels on a quarterly average balance point to considerable stability despite some late-quarter movement that briefly affected spot balances at quarter end. Average balances have rebounded in July, which reinforces our confidence that net interest income growth will carry on. We also see real value in the geographic diversity we have built across both the asset and liability sides of the balance sheet. At the end of 2017, almost 80% of our commercial loans sat in New York and New Jersey; that number has fallen to 50% today thanks to our focus in Florida and other dynamic commercial markets. We keep building strong service-focused banking teams nationwide, and those teams are aimed at creating and growing the valuable commercial relationships we've been targeting. At the same time, 78% of our deposits sat in northeast branches at the close of 2017. By the end of the second quarter, that figure had fallen to just 43%; we have a mix of niche funding businesses and a solid branch network spanning Florida and Alabama. That diversity helps shield our funding base and offers distinctive, differentiated chances to lessen our dependence on wholesale funding as time goes on. To wrap up, I'm very happy with how far we've already come toward the balance sheet goals we set out. We keep working diligently to further ready ourselves for growth and strong performance as conditions return to normal. Based on what we know, I'm confident our provision has already topped out. With ongoing net interest income momentum, denormalization and expense discipline, we anticipate our earnings will grow through the remainder of the year and put us in position for further gains in 2025; with that, I'll hand the call to Tom and Mike to cover this quarter's growth and financial results. Once Mike finishes his remarks, Tom, Mike, Mark Sagaer, our Chief Credit Officer, and I will be here to take your questions.
Tom Iadanza
executiveThanks, Ira. On slide 9, you can see how deposits moved during the quarter. Compared with the first quarter, total deposits rose by $1 billion, and that was mostly because indirect deposits came in at higher levels. At the same time, customer balances—including those on the non-interest bearing side—stayed broadly steady across the quarter, and that steadiness let us, from a pricing standpoint, mostly hold the line for a third quarter in a row. The following slide gives more detail on how our deposit portfolio breaks down by delivery channel and by business line. Our specialty commercial verticals and our private banking business both posted strong growth in the quarter, which partly offset runoff in branch deposits that came late in the quarter. Average deposit balances in July are running above second quarter levels, as customer activity has bounced back after a brief dip at quarter end. We don't usually call out deposit team additions as they happen, but we recently got approval to open a new branch office in Beverly Hills, California. That location will be overseen by experienced in-market leadership and will add to how we deliver our financial products and services to our existing customer base. We're also planning to open a new branch in Staten Island, which sits contiguous to our existing Metro New York footprint. We already have over 2,000 customers in this market, and we're extremely excited about the market leadership we've attracted to speed up our business development efforts. Both initiatives will strengthen our name recognition in our markets and should contribute to deposit growth in the future. Beyond growing deposits through our specialty commercial vertical, which I mentioned earlier, we believe selective branch expansion backed by experienced end market leaders is an attractive way to grow core deposits at a reasonable all in cost, and we expect a few more opportunities to come to provision. Slide 11 shows what drove loan growth in the quarter. Total loans grew by almost $400 million, powered by roughly 16% annualized C&I growth. Focusing on C&I has been a strategic imperative for us as we work to diversify our balance sheet further; this quarter's growth came from multiple business lines and geographies. And while growth in the future may be lumpy, this asset class holds significant opportunities for longer term growth. On the commercial real estate side, we saw a meaningful shift during the quarter from investor real estate to owner occupied real estate. While most of that transition came from reclassifying approximately $1 billion of healthcare loans, we continue to benefit from this strategic de-emphasis of investor real estate originations. This focus will keep lowering our real estate concentration going forward. Slide 12 gives more detail on how our commercial real estate portfolio is composed by property type and geography. Overall, commercial real estate markets and borrower performance across our footprint remain healthy. With that, I'll hand the call to Mike Hagedorn for additional insight into the quarter's financials.
Mike Hagedorn
executiveThanks, Tom. I'll stay on the CRE subject for a bit longer. On Slide 15, you can see when our commercial real estate portfolio comes up for contractual maturity. For your convenience, we've shown the LTV, DSCR and rate for each maturity bucket; this maturity schedule makes clear how little near-term repricing risk our portfolio carries. Slide 16 shows the notable positive turn this quarter in both net interest income and net interest margin; that strong result came from growth in interest income together with reductions in interest expense versus the first quarter of the year. We expect net interest income to keep growing, driven by modest balance sheet growth and the continuing tailwind from expansion in asset yields. On the funding side, we've gained from targeted cuts to deposit costs made over the past few quarters. Average non-interest deposits rose modestly during the quarter, and even though there was a brief dip at quarter end, we're already seeing further growth in average non-interest balances in the third quarter. Moving to the next slide, you can see that non-interest income on an adjusted basis fell relative to the first quarter of 2024. About 75% of the net decline in fee income came from the expected normalization of tax credit advisory revenues after the first quarter's elevated level. Beyond that, we were affected by a negative valuation adjustment on certain Fintech investments, partly offset by stronger swap fees, insurance commissions and bank owned life insurance income; we keep driving growth across our capital markets, wealth management and treasury services channels; those factors should support the fee income growth we anticipate for the remainder of the year. On the following slide, you can see that non-interest expenses came to roughly $278 million for the quarter. If we adjust for our $1.4 million FDIC special assessment and certain other non-core charges, non-interest expenses were about $270 million on an adjusted basis. That's a very modest increase over both the first quarter of 2024 and the second quarter of 2023; it mainly reflected costs tied to the credit risk transfer we executed plus higher traditional FDIC assessment expense. We remain focused on headcount optimization and technology efficiencies to counter the revenue pressure we've seen. As a reminder, non-interest expense for the rest of the year will include roughly $6 million of premium costs tied to our risk transfer transaction. On Slide 19, you can see the continued notable stability in our non-accrual and pass-through loan categories. Even with higher rates and isolated stress in the office segment, our borrowers generally continue to perform well. At the bottom left, you can see the lower historical loss content of our portfolio, which holds consistently across cycles. We remain confident in our reserve coverage relative to our loss content, as the charts at the bottom right show. The next slide illustrates the trend in allowance coverage, charge offs and provisions. Our allowance coverage ratio is still climbing toward the intermediate-term target, and you heard Ira walk through what drove that expansion in the second quarter. To restate it, we anticipate the allowance to loan loss ratio reaching roughly 1.10%, given present market conditions and what we know about the portfolio. That outlook means our provision has topped out and will probably move lower across the coming few quarters. The vast bulk of our loan book is still performing very well indeed. About 85% of net charge offs this quarter came from one commercial real estate credit and one C&I credit. The C&I credit was mostly covered by a specific reserve that already existed. As Ira said, in light of today's market environment, we do expect net charge offs to stay near present levels through the rest of the year. On the next slide you can see the sequential rise in tangible book value and in our capital ratios. This quarter's elevated provision, plus a modest expansion headwind stemming from the OCI impact tied to our available for sale securities portfolio, held back tangible book value growth in the quarter. Even so, we are very pleased with how substantially our risk based capital ratios grew versus both the previous quarter and the year ago period. We take real pride in our capacity to fortify the balance sheet and boost financial flexibility in ways that are friendly to shareholders. With that, I'll hand the call back to the operator so we can start Q&A. Thank you.
Frank Schiraldi
analystI just wanted to ask, Ira — you brought up that 1:10 reserve to loan ratio, and basically, I suppose, you're arriving there a bit early. But when it comes to a continued mix shift toward C&I, I'd think that would still tend to place more pressure on that ratio; so it sounds like you're fairly comfortable with the 1:10, but I'm just kind of curious whether you can walk through the thinking there. Is the idea that criticized and classified start to moderate here as an offset? Just curious what your thoughts are.
Mark Sagaer
executiveHey Frank. This is Mark Sagaer. I think on the criticized classified front, if you look at our migration this quarter, it was lower than the prior quarter and very much tied to what Ira mentioned about deemphasizing a personal guarantee in our decisioning on internal risk rating. I want to be clear, though, that we believe loans carrying a guarantee will ultimately produce materially better outcomes for the organization, and they remain very important in our really relationship based model within the organization. On your point about C&I, you're right in the sense that C&I traditionally carries a higher level of provisioning than CRE, and that's going to be a portion of the build; however, in the environment we're in right now with continued higher interest rates, there is likely to be continued modest migration in our CRE portfolio into criticized categories.
Frank Schiraldi
analystBut just to make sure you remain at ease even with that — as the mix shifts toward C&I and the reserve-to-loan ratio sits at roughly 1:10, do you not foresee any need for it to rise in the near term?
Mark Sagaer
executiveNo. That 1:10 reflects an ongoing build on our part, and we're at ease with that level.
Frank Schiraldi
analystThen, to follow up on that: clearly you addressed CRE partly by way of that reclassification. And my guess is that's an area you folks have been pursuing more actively. I'm just wondering whether there are ongoing efforts here that might potentially lead to more to come; and any fresh thinking, now that you're at roughly your year-end level — I suppose regarding concentrations in CRE, your target — any updated view on where you could be by the end of things, or what you're aiming for by the end of 2025 when it comes to concentration?
Ira Robbins
executiveYes, I believe last quarter we were fairly specific about where we thought we'd be on an intermediate basis, and getting below 400 mattered quite a lot to us. Obviously, speeding that up, if we can, is something we're looking at doing; but bearing in mind, we want to be sure we bear in mind the earnings profile of the organization, and as we consider various alternatives, making certain they're in a shareholder friendly manner and that we aren't denigrating a future earnings profile. So it truly is a balance for us as we keep moving forward. We're quite excited about the ability to accelerate some of those initiatives, but we also have to bear in mind some of the economics tied to various alternatives as well.
Frank Schiraldi
analystAnd regarding the reclassification, was that something like a particular project to push that forward? Is it mostly done, or might we see another chunk of it in the next quarter?
Mark Sagaer
executiveIt was a particular project that we assembled specifically tied to the skilled nursing segment of the portfolio, and that was basically finished in the second quarter.
Steven Alexopoulos
analystIra, I'd like to begin with the net interest income outlook, that 1.5% to 3%. My assumption is that this is unannualized growth, but I want to verify that. And then I'd like to ask: if we get two rate cuts, where do you think you land within that range?
Travis Lan
executiveYes. Steven, it's Travis here. So you're right — what we're showing on a quarterly basis going forward is unannualized growth. Our forward guidance bakes in two rate cuts, in line with what the implied curve showed at 6.30; so that is included. And then within that range, I think you'd also find that static rates are captured there too, since there isn't much impact or change to our NII guidance depending on how many rate cuts occur here in the near term.
Steven Alexopoulos
analystNow, turning to Slide 15 — that commercial real estate slide really helps. You had $1.1 billion of commercial real estate that matured and stayed on the books. Can you guys walk us through it? Did you have to make any concessions? Did those loans go into an extension period, or were they full refinances where the borrower contributed more equity and these became new commercial real estate loans?
Mark Sagaer
executiveOn the retained side, every one of those loans was repriced at current market rates and sized appropriately to our standards. You'll notice we show $2 million in modified other. That really reflects a modified structure — a historic TDR type relationship. The $1 million one was entirely at market terms.
Frank Schiraldi
analystSo my understanding is that a few borrowers simply want what amounts to a 1-year extension rather than actually refinancing the loan. Did any of these fall into that category?
Mark Sagaer
executiveYes, Stephen, definitely. A number of these deals had terms shorter than 5-year renewals. Even so, every one of them closed at prevailing market rates and with amortization brought back to normal.
Frank Schiraldi
analystSo to get that extension, they'd basically have to put in full equity?
Mark Sager
analystSometimes that's the case, sometimes not. Yes, it depends on where the loan sits when it matures.
Ira Robbins
executiveSo the equity level would have had to be normal, but obviously given the original loan to value, a lot of borrowers didn't even need to put equity in.
Frank Schiraldi
analystThen one last thing from me regarding the RWA benefit and what you're doing with auto loans this quarter. Are you considering additional uses of synthetic instruments? Should we anticipate more of that during the second half, or is it finished?
Travis Lan
executiveYes. Stephen, it's Travis here. Look, we constantly evaluate what exists and what's accessible. I mean, I think you're seeing a greater number of these risk transfers occurring across the industry. It isn't something only Valley does necessarily. To be honest, the auto portfolio was the easiest opportunity, but we keep examining other possibilities in additional asset classes too. So I think, once again, not solely for Valley but for the remainder of the industry, you'll see these utilized to create capital efficiency going forward.
Matthew Breese
analystIra, I believe you touched on this, but I wanted to hear your perspective on possibly selling commercial real estate loans or securitizing loans to speed things up and bring down that CRE concentration. What are the odds of something like that happening? And if you were to take that path, what could you share with us regarding the earnings or tangible book value impacts you'd be prepared to accept in order to reach those goals more quickly?
Ira Robbins
executiveMatt, I think you pointed out the right guardrails. For a very long period of time, we've done a solid job of putting priority on tangible book value growth, and diminishing that tangible book value is something we care about, and really what that threshold is. And again, sustaining an earnings profile that's truly positioned to keep growing, given what we're seeing in the balance sheet as well as the net interest margin, matters to us. So how we think about the acceleration is a toggle. That being said, we do believe there remain plenty of opportunities for repositioning the balance sheet somewhat faster. We're not diminishing what that earnings profile is. So opportunities exist, we keep weighing them, and we'll act on them when we believe it makes good sense — not only from a balance sheet mix standpoint, but also from an earnings profile standpoint.
Matthew Breese
analystAnd I realize that throughout the last several quarters, all of you have adopted a far more involved stance regarding deposit cost. Quarter-over-quarter, they rose just 2 basis points. Is it possible that deposit cost declines in the coming quarter and that interest bearing liabilities have topped out for this cycle?
Mike Hagedorn
executiveYes. That's a fair question. I believe the results we posted this quarter essentially speak for themselves, and they were strong. If you look at total deposits, they grew $1billion, and if you examine the cost composition of those deposits, total deposit costs, as we said earlier, climbed only 2 basis points. Yet within that total deposits category, brokered costs stayed flat at $505 across both quarters, while customer costs in fact fell 1 basis point; and within that customer portion, we brought in $1.3 billion of customer deposits at a cost of 3.24. So I think it essentially speaks for itself that the cost reductions we carried out, together with our capacity to generate from the various sources we have built over the years, were very strong; and this quarter's numbers show that.
Matthew Breese
analystAnd you're not alone in pulling back from commercial real estate while pushing toward more C&I loan growth. So are you noticing any weakening in how commercial loans are underwritten? Are some loan covenants being conceded, or spreads getting tighter? I'd really appreciate your thoughts on that.
Tom Iadanza
executiveHi, Matt, this is Tom. Turning to our underwriting and the C&I portfolio on the origination side — I'd say it's comparable terms and credit metrics to what we've underwritten previously. We've consistently stated that we won't trade away credit quality for fast growth; and we've grown C&I over the last six years at roughly 10% annualized, and this quarter it's running at 16% annualized. And that growth is coming mainly from our specialty niches, where we have expertise and a market reputation, as well as from our Florida region, which continues to see solid growth.
Matthew Breese
analystOne final question from me. I believe you have $115 million of sub debt that hits its reset date next year. Do you have any plans there for paying it off, or should we anticipate some kind of pre-emptive raise to get in front of it?
Tom Iadanza
executiveAnd we constantly keep an eye on debt capital markets. I mean, I think we've roughly issued sub debt every 18 months. Obviously, given some of the industry dynamics last year, right? The sub debt market and debt capital markets overall have been somewhat slower, though we're seeing a bit of strengthening today. But I think on a regular basis, sub debt will remain part of the capital stack. And we're always watching for shareholder friendly ways to strengthen the balance sheet, so.
Manan Gosalia
analystI'd like to ask a bit more about reserves. What exactly led to the choice to speed up reserve building during this quarter? And more specifically, how does that affect 2025? Are there particular reserves included there that might cause a reserve bleed next year if charge-offs materialized? Or do you anticipate remaining in that 1.1% range going forward?
Mark Sagaer
executiveThere are indeed certain reserves in there, but looking ahead we expect to remain within the 1.1 ratio, and we feel quite comfortable at that level, Manan.
Manan Gosalia
analystNow, on this quarter's charge-offs, can you speak to those two credits — does anything there carry over to the remaining portfolio? And looking at the NCO guidance ahead, the midpoint of that range looks basically aligned with the second quarter. It's slightly above the prior quarter. So I just want to confirm whether that reflects planned steps to lower concentration? Is there something you're observing in the portfolio, or is it simply conservatism?
Mark Sagaer
executiveWell, as Ira mentioned in the remarks, once again, two credits were really what drove the charge-off level we're seeing this quarter. A single one of those on the commercial real estate side involved an office property. I'd highlight how granular our office book is, with the typical loan at 3.3%. This particular loan was a bigger CRE credit, a bit above $30 million. Beyond that granularity, I should mention that only a handful of our loans are on the larger side. Just six office loans exceed $50 million. Our headquarters is among them, and out of those six, only one carries a classified rating. We keep a close watch on the office portfolio routinely, refreshing the numbers for every office loan we hold above $10 million, and movement within the portfolio during this year has been skewed toward office, though during the second quarter that trend has eased within the office portfolio.
Manan Gosalia
analystAnd regarding the forward NCOs, does that — does a somewhat elevated NCO level stem from less concentration or from lowering consideration of the CRE book? Or is it simply some conservatism built into it?
Mark Sagaer
executiveIt's more about refocusing on what we see as potential charge-offs. Customers on our radar who could face rollover risk later, which might weaken debt service coverage going forward. So we keep watching those and recognize they may or may not result in future charge-offs down the road.
Steve McGrady
analystThere's been plenty of talk from some of your rivals during this quarter and the previous one regarding portfolio reviews, specifically around provisioning and the outlook for reserve builds. What I'd like to understand is what you yourselves have done—not just this quarter but over the last couple of quarters—to take a deeper look into parts of the CRE book, so as to arrive at that remark about peak provision.
Mark Sagaer
executiveIf you think back to our first quarter call, we examined the vast majority of the portfolio through the end of the first quarter, with updated information on all those customers. The migration this quarter, again, as was mentioned, stemmed from how we view the benefit of a personal guarantee within risk rating and really pulling back on that going forward. So our review was proactive and largely finished in the first quarter, and we've basically worked through the vast majority of our exposure to date.
Ira Robbins
executiveOne thing I'd add is that we aren't only evaluating this from an internal perspective. We've brought in third parties to assess the portfolio too, specifically to confirm that our perspective matches the external one as well.
Steve McGrady
analystAnd then just one more question. Could you give the criticized classified figure for the linked quarter and for this quarter as well? I don't have my thoughts in the deck.
Travis Lan
executiveYes; that will come out in the Q. We had a migration of roughly $350 million this quarter, which is lower than the $600 million in the prior quarter, and the Q will contain more details on that.
Steve Moss
analystLet's turn to the liquidity build. Broker deposits and investment securities were both increased. I'm somewhat curious: how much further do you anticipate growing the investment securities portfolio, and might you keep adding broker deposits as well?
Travis Lan
executiveBroadly speaking, I'd expect a growth tailwind for the securities portfolio, though this quarter was definitely more outsized than what you've been seeing. Part of the reason, look, is that we have this extra cost tied to the risk transfer trade. So a small, modest leverage strategy to help offset that cost was on our mind; it's executed in a capital-efficient manner. What we're purchasing is Ginnie Mae securities carrying zero-risk weight; so that's rather important to what we're doing here. So over time, I think it migrates higher, but candidly I don't think there will be any rash actions on the securities portfolio.
Steve Moss
analystThen, returning to total capital — you're at 12.2% at quarter end. I'm just wondering, do you have any near- or medium-term goals for where you'd like that figure to land?
Ira Robbins
executiveOn a macro level, I'd say we're quite happy with where our regulatory capital ratios stand. We did provide some guidance on where we believe the CET1 figure has to reach, and we remain focused on ensuring that, over the longer term, we get above 10% on that figure.
Steve Moss
analystTurning to the commercial real estate that got repriced during this quarter, perhaps we could revisit that — I'm somewhat curious about your perspective on where full market rate, or fair market rate, stands for commercial real estate repricing nowadays?
Tom Iadanza
executiveSure; Steve, this is Tom. It truly varies by asset class and segment, along with metrics like loan-to-value and debt service coverage and similar measures. Within those classes, our spreads reach as high as 400 basis points, and likely sit no lower than 250 basis points. So it genuinely hinges on the asset class and the duration of the metrics.
Ira Robbins
executiveAnd on a macro level, I'd say the typical spread we placed came to roughly $350 million. So we figure that's probably a fair indication; and as we mentioned earlier, these deals were structured on market terms regarding what the loan-to-value coverage ought to be, the debt service coverage ratio too, and what those spreads ought to be.
Steve Moss
analystAnd perhaps, just to go back for a moment to the reduced emphasis on the personal guarantee—I'm simply wondering about the reasoning behind it. Did regulators push for this? Or are you instead observing that cash flows for customer borrowers are weakening? And what's driving that shift?
Mark Saeger
executiveThis is Mark. We genuinely seized that opportunity to take a conservative view of the portfolio, even though historically the performance we've had, and what we're observing so far for loans carrying the guarantee compared with those lacking it, is plainly stronger. Our risk ratings were concentrated on an unadjusted primary source of repayment; and so we've been intensely focused on debt service coverage as the main factor behind our ratings.
Jon Arfstrom
analystPerhaps this is for Mark or Tom, returning to Slide 15 and that box in the upper left — it looks like a solid result with just $2 million modified. I'm curious whether that outcome caught you off guard at all. And as you consider the cadence of what lies ahead, would you expect similar kinds of outcomes across the coming few quarters compared with what you just saw this past quarter?
Mark Saeger
executiveFor those of us who live with the portfolio and think about it forward-looking, I'd say it isn't a surprise; we'd highlight our conservative underwriting and how we size loans initially, so that by the time maturity arrives, amortization has brought the principal amount down and NOI has improved across most asset classes other than office and rent-stabilized multifamily; in our primary markets we're seeing strong metrics in retail, industrial and market rate multifamily. So NOI growth combined with prudent sizing at origination on these loans — the good results we're seeing on the refinancing side don't surprise us much.
Ira Robbins
executiveAnd John, maybe just one more point I'd like to tack onto that. I believe if you look down at the bottom of the chart, we discussed the contractual rate paid by the borrower. And I realize that has been a major concern for a lot of people in the industry — there's been a meaningful rise in that rate for many of these borrowers when they readjust. In our case, you're seeing a rate, obviously, for loans maturing in the third quarter of '24, of 7.63%. So for many borrowers, there really isn't much of an adjustment. And you can see how that plays out as we keep moving forward. So I think a common issue for many of our peers, as they must reset these borrowers to higher rates, and the effect that has on the underlying debt service coverage ratio, really isn't as significant in our case.
Jon Arfstrom
analystPossibly this is for Mike or Travis, and perhaps the answer is obvious, but regarding the upper end and the lower end of quarterly NII growth, is there anything you'd flag for us to consider in terms of how one reaches the higher end or the lower end of that guidance?
Travis Lan
executiveRight now we simply recognize that opinions differ, perhaps, on where interest rates will land, and ultimately that has had only a minor effect on our NII, but nothing material is involved. I mean, obviously the other element would be that we provided ourselves a range of growth—we gave you guidance of low single-digits. So that could mean a couple of different things, and that would be taken into account there as well.
Jon Arfstrom
analystAnd then just one last thing. Earlier you guys discussed C&I growth possibly being more erratic or lumpy. Could you speak a bit about the pipeline in that area? And what — it seems like commercial lending will drive loan growth within that CRE. So just help us get a sense of what that pipeline looks like.
Tom Iadanza
executiveJon, this is Tom. The pipeline in fact rose 30% from one quarter to the next. And that pipeline is growing quite steadily. A lot of it we're seeing come out of those relationships, the specialty national businesses as well as our Florida region, steady up in the Northeast, but a higher percent growth both on what we originated during the past quarter and on what our pipeline is looking at going forward. So we expect to keep the guidance we issued of low single-digits for the second half of the year, driven mainly by C&I.
Jared Shaw
analystGoing back to the criticized and classified, what was the — absent the personal guarantee reclassification, what would growth have been?
Mark Saeger
executiveJared, Mark here. I don’t have that breakout specifically, but most of the migration this quarter stemmed from how we handled personal guarantees.
Jared Shaw
analystAnd picking up where Chris left off, was there — did you notice — has performance come in weaker than anticipated on certain loans that went non-performing and carry personal guarantees? Did that factor into what drove that shift?
Mark Saeger
executiveNo, not at all. Once again, this simply reflects a cautious stance on risk rating and specific provisioning. What we have observed so far matches our historical experience that guaranteed loans tend to produce better outcomes, and it remains a key element of our credit structure and will keep being so going forward.
Jared Shaw
analystNow moving over to deposits. I believe Tom mentioned that the July averages were running higher. Is that higher than the second quarter average, the end-of-period second quarter figure, or possibly both on the deposit side?
Travis Lan
executiveYeah, it's a relative comparison; we framed that remark against the second quarter average. And looking at it from a customer standpoint, that would apply to the end of period too. So on an average basis, customer deposits in July are a bit above where they stood at quarter-end.
Jared Shaw
analystAnd then one last thing from me: when you consider the gap and the rates you're earning on customer deposits compared with brokered deposits — I was just looking at what your specials sit at, around 450. Why not offer a bit more on the customer side? Because it feels — I'm not sure, it seems you'd still be able to get something cheaper than on the brokerage side. Is there some reason you're leaning more heavily toward brokerage here rather than paying up somewhat more on core customer accounts?
Ira Robbins
executiveThat's clearly something we discuss frequently internally in our deposit pricing committees. A great deal of it comes down to what potential migration might look like from a relationship client standpoint. Bear in mind, a lot of these clients have been with us for a very long time. They hold sizable deposits with us. And when they spot a higher rate, many of them want that higher rate too. I think the other element is that the broker has a shorter-term duration, and the ability to consider where perhaps market interest rates are headed and to stay short on the curve is probably a plus for us.
Ira Robbins
executiveI'd like to express my appreciation to all of you for being with us today and for the interest you've shown in Valley, and we're looking forward to speaking with you again next quarter. Thank you.
Operator
operatorThank you all for joining today's conference. You may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Valley National Bancorp transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Valley National Bancorp earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Valley National Bancorp or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.