Wayfair Inc. (W) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 4, 2026
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Ryan Barney
executiveGood morning, and thanks for being with us. On today's agenda is a look at how we performed in the third quarter of 2026. Joining me are Niraj Shah, our Co-Founder, Chief Executive Officer and Co-Chairman; Steve Conine, Co-Founder and Co-Chairman; and Kate Gulliver, Chief Financial Officer and Chief Administrative Officer; all of them will be on hand for Q&A once today's prepared remarks wrap up. A quick reminder that this call today will include forward-looking statements, among them, though not limited to, statements about our future prospects, business strategies, industry trends, and our financial performance, including guidance for the fourth quarter of 2026. Anything predictive we discuss during this call is based only on what we know right now. While we feel our assumptions and expectations have been sensible, there's no way to promise that these statements will prove correct. Specific risks that might make actual outcomes diverge significantly from what we forecast today are spelled out in our 2025 10-K, the 10-Q for this quarter, and the other SEC filings we make afterward. We’re not obligated—unless the law requires it—to publicly update or revise any of these statements, whether because of new information, future events, or anything else. Also, please be aware that on this call, while reviewing the company’s performance, we’ll discuss some non-GAAP financial measures, including contribution profit, contribution margin, adjusted EBITDA, adjusted EBITDA margin, and free cash flow. These non-GAAP financial measures shouldn’t be viewed as substitutes for GAAP results and should be read alongside them. For a copy of our earnings release and investor presentation—which include explanations of our non-GAAP financial measures and reconciliations to the closest comparable GAAP measures—please visit the Investor Relations section of our website. This call is being recorded, and a webcast replay will be available on our IR website. I'll now hand the call over to Niraj.
Niraj Shah
executiveThanks, Ryan, and good morning, everyone. We're glad to be with you today to go over the results for our third quarter. Q3 delivered the biggest growth we've posted since the pandemic, as total net revenue rose 9.7% versus a year ago and our US business expanded by more than 11%. That growth carried through well to the bottom line, producing an adjusted EBITDA margin of 6.9% — our strongest Q3 showing since 2020. When this year began, we told you we intended to gain share in the US at a rate we hadn't achieved in a number of years. We came into 2025 with US share spread in the mid-single digits, broadened it to high-single digits by year-end, and committed to driving it to the double digits in 2026; with US revenue up double digits against a category that was roughly flat here in Q3, that is precisely what we've accomplished. Orders fueled that growth, rising 12% versus a year ago. That showed up as strength in customer growth, with active customers increasing more than 4% and new customer orders climbing over 14% — yet another post-pandemic record. The momentum in orders and customers makes us confident our share gains are structural, since order growth compounds over time whereas AOV growth does not. We're thrilled about the trajectory we're on, and we remain in the early innings. Earlier this year, I walked through the many pistons powering our growth engine, and you're watching them succeed in real time as they operate in tandem. People often ask us which of these is the largest driver of our share success. The answer is that no single one is. Initiatives such as Wayfair Rewards, Wayfair Verified, Delivery Plus, and our stores, together with long-standing businesses like Perigold, our specialty retail brands, and Wayfair Professional, all rest on a core recipe of assortment, availability, speed, and price that is the strongest in our history. Most of these initiatives remain early in their maturity, and they build on that core and on each other to generate outcomes like the ones we just delivered in the third quarter. Let me illustrate how that works in practice. A shopper walks into one of our stores and discovers the depth of our catalog, including categories such as bedding and tabletop she may never have imagined buying from Wayfair. She signs up for Wayfair Rewards at checkout, giving her one more reason to return. Her kitchen table arrives in days rather than weeks, because stores sit close to our CastleGate fulfillment centers. The next time she shops online, the Verified badge helps her choose with confidence. She returns more often, she benefits from low prices thanks to rewards, and for Wayfair, our ad costs have fallen, improving her customer lifetime value. As she helps our volume grow, suppliers invest more in our platform and sharpen their pricing, which makes the offer even better for the next customer. That’s why we’re genuinely confident our US share gains can keep compounding through 2027 and beyond. You’ve heard this from us repeatedly, but our success hasn’t depended on the macro, and once the category returns to growth, those gains will be applied to a far bigger base. We’re now running the same playbook internationally, though we’re earlier there, with more to roll out over the next several quarters. Our approach hasn’t changed: outgrow the market, let that growth flow through to maximize adjusted EBITDA dollars, and continue reinvesting in what earns customer loyalty. Loyalty is a crucial concept for our flywheel. We opened this year discussing loyalty within the scope of our rewards program, and now I’d like to close out the year by coming back to loyalty and explaining how we view it across our marketing investments. During the last two years, we’ve increased orders at a faster rate while spending a smaller share of revenue on advertising, which came in below 10% this quarter for the first time since 2021—even as we put more into our brand and channels that are newer to the mix. Today I want to spend some time on what has produced that progress, why we think it will endure, and where we’re going next. Driver one is that more customers are reaching us directly. Rewards, Verified, our stores, and a better, faster site and app all give customers additional reasons to begin their shopping at Wayfair. In Q3, revenue from direct visits rose more than 15% versus a year earlier. That coincides with solid improvements in our core channels; for instance, our text message audience has grown by over 40% in the past year, with revenue from those texts increasing by more than 30%. Driver two is measurement, which has always been central to how we operate Wayfair. Since our earliest days, we’ve built in-house tools of our own to understand what each marketing dollar returns, and that discipline plays a big role in keeping us efficient. During the last few years, several things changed at once: privacy changes at the major platforms made traditional attribution less dependable, and customer behavior shifted in the post-pandemic environment, altering where and how people shop for their homes; in response, we’ve substantially raised how frequently we test, relying more heavily on controlled experiments that isolate the true incremental impact of our spend. Not surprisingly, that combination has revealed opportunities to reallocate spend. Where spend was mostly reaching shoppers already headed to Wayfair, we’ve reduced it. Where it reliably generates incremental sales, as with influencers, we’re leaning in. This is one of several factors that helped our conversion rate rise by more than 30 basis points since early 2025. We've been directing a bigger portion of our spending toward establishing the Wayfair brand. Television now makes up a bigger piece of our marketing blend, and that includes the fall campaign that launched in September alongside the NFL season, plus newer channels such as creators and video. Those investments create familiarity and trust around the Wayfair name, and it shows in the way shoppers locate us. Branded search visits — meaning a customer types something like Wayfair sofa into a search engine — climbed over 17% in Q3. Anyone who arrives at our site directly is someone we won't have to pay for a second time, and that releases dollars we can keep putting into growth. Creators represent the most obvious case of where we increased our investment. The home category is built for creator content. When a product is styled inside a real home, it responds to the question on every shopper's mind, namely how it will appear in her own space. We designed our program around what creators said they required, and we deal with them the same way we deal with our suppliers: their success is our success. That effort is delivering results. Sales generated through creator content rose over 70% during the most recent Way Day compared with our event last fall.
Niraj Shah
executiveThe program now encompasses tens of thousands of creators who, alongside our partner networks, have generated hundreds of thousands of fresh content pieces during this year — well beyond what we turned out in 2025. Sales from the creator program have already exceeded their full-year 2025 figure, and LTK, our biggest creator network partner, honored Wayfair this year for leading what comes next in creator commerce. We're excited about plenty ahead, including creator storefronts on the site and app, which is slated for a full rollout in 2027. Creators illustrate one way we're extending our reach to ensure we're visible everywhere a customer might begin her home shopping journey; those journeys can kick off in many spots: a store, a social feed, a search interface, or an AI assistant. Wherever her journey starts, we want Wayfair present and to make it simple for her to continue shopping with us. When it comes to AI applications and agents, our aim is straightforward and consistent with how we view other surfaces: Wayfair's catalog ought to be accessible wherever shoppers are and tailored for the channel. With that in mind, we're engaging across the major AI platforms and agent applications instead of wagering on any one of them. We feel good about Wayfair's competitive position here, because we've built up strengths across twenty-plus years: the widest assortment available in this space, detailed and reliable product details, shopper reviews, prices that compete, and delivery that's quick and dependable. Tens of millions of products are shared by us with these platforms, and we're using our own AI to enrich that catalog information at scale. Even though AI assistants represent a new entry point for customers, what we're seeing is that the endpoint is usually the same. The majority of shoppers who find us via these tools continue their journey on Wayfair's own site and app, and even if a customer completes a purchase inside an AI assistant, Wayfair remains the retailer. The order sits in her Wayfair account, yet the delivery and service commitment remains ours. In either case, the customer's relationship is with us; it's still early days, but this traffic is climbing fast. During the third quarter, visits referred by AI more than doubled quarter over quarter, reaching approximately 1% of our overall traffic. A good deal of what we've achieved here comes from collaborating closely with the platforms themselves and from alliances involving Google, OpenAI, and Meta, and these illustrate what this looks like. Google has been a key partner across almost the whole of our history. When Google began work on an open standard for agentic commerce together with the industry, Wayfair served as a foundational partner in co-developing the Universal Commerce Protocol. Right now, shoppers are able to locate our items and even finish buying them from Wayfair within Google's AI experiences. We're likewise observing a lot of customers who come across products through Google's AI features and afterward keep shopping on Wayfair's website, and that helps us establish durable relationships with those customers. As for OpenAI, we ranked among the first advertisers on ChatGPT, and we were also an early company to launch a Wayfair-branded shopping agent that customers can converse with directly within the platform. Many customer interactions with our agent span several turns, and the most common request involves assistance with decorating or coordinating a room — exactly the kind of inspiration-driven shopping where Wayfair's assortment and design expertise really stand out. When she's ready to buy, she completes her purchase on wayfair.com, where her orders, rewards, and saved looks all live together. Thus a conversation that starts in ChatGPT becomes the beginning of a direct relationship with Wayfair; we were also among the first partners announced for Meta's Muse. Our entire AI-optimized catalog is now live in Muse, and alongside Meta we're exploring richer, agent-led experiences. A lot of home inspiration starts on social platforms these days, so an assistant that guides a shopper in converting that inspiration into a home she can genuinely purchase suits the wide range of what we offer. As AI agents get better at assisting customers through a huge, unbranded, and intricate category such as home, our scale, our data, and our logistics strengths stand out more. No matter how a customer first finds us — via a creator, a search engine, or an AI assistant — the objective remains unchanged: converting that initial encounter into a durable relationship, so when she shops for her home next time, she heads straight to Wayfair. That loyalty is precisely what has been pushing our direct traffic upward, as shoppers opt to return to our website and app for an experience built specifically around the home category — and increasingly, around that individual customer. That is where a substantial portion of our customer experience spending as we move toward 2027 is directed: engineering our site to function more like a personal design partner, offering room concepts matched to her taste and full looks assembled from whatever she is viewing, all tied to inventory we are able to deliver. That's the self-reinforcing cycle we're constructing. Each shopper we win—no matter where she initially discovers us—turns into someone who returns to us straight, more frequently, and more cheaply, and we think that's what will keep driving both our share expansion and our adjusted EBITDA growth through 2027 and past it. With that said, I'll hand things over to Kate to take us through our financials.
Kate Gulliver
executiveThanks, Niraj, and good morning to all of you. Let's turn to the numbers from our third quarter. Q3 revenue rose 9.7% compared with a year earlier — the US segment climbed 11.4%, while International fell 2.3%. As we noted last quarter, our international markets are still earlier in capturing share than the US business, and the home furnishings category in Canada and the UK keeps trailing the US market. Orders increased 12.2% relative to last year's third quarter, while AOV shrank by about 2%. Much of that drop came from several aspects of mix shift, since the gap between the wayfair.com business and our other higher-AOV business lines got narrower. I'll keep moving down the income statement. While I do that, keep in mind that the rest of these financial figures account for depreciation and amortization but leave out equity-based compensation, the associated taxes, and other adjustments. That same approach will apply when I talk about our outlook. For Q3, gross margin came in at 29.6% of net revenue, reflecting the ongoing investments we're making in loyalty and in the broader customer experience. Customer service and merchant fees represented 3.7% of net revenue, and advertising was 9.9% of net revenue — which, as Niraj mentioned, marks our first single-digit outcome on that line since 2021. Putting that together, contribution margin was 16.1%. The advertising gains you're seeing are the result of years of effort spent reworking how we test and broadening the mix of channels we use. I'll cover guidance shortly, but part of the better-than-expected advertising cost in Q3 came down to timing, and we'd anticipate that figure rising again in Q4 as we invest more going into the holiday period. Third-quarter selling, operations, technology, general and administrative expenses totaled $378 million. That was a bit above the range we had guided, since a handful of one-time costs landed during the quarter, among them the Competition and Markets Authority settlement in the UK. Given that this was a one-off, we fully anticipate getting back to the $360 million to $370 million range in the coming quarter. Even so, we still posted one of the strongest profit performances in our company's history, recording adjusted EBITDA of $236 million, which works out to a 6.9% margin on net revenue. Moving further down the P&L, Q3 brought us $62 million in net income — an improvement of more than $160 million versus the third quarter a year ago. During our previous call, we walked through a detailed explanation of the bridge from positive adjusted EBITDA to positive net income, and it was gratifying to see that unfold in Q3. We closed Q3 with $1.1 billion in cash and equivalents sitting on the balance sheet, and when you factor in our revolver, total liquidity stands at $1.5 billion. Operating cash flow was $198 million, capex totaled $62 million, and that left us with $136 million in free cash flow for the quarter — more than 40% higher than the figure we posted in Q3 2025. Capital markets were somewhat quieter this quarter, though I should note the double upgrades we received from S&P and Moody's, which line up with the one Fitch handed us earlier in the spring. On the last call we spent some time on our capital structure priorities, and that included shifting from buying back convertible bonds to buying back equity directly. Q3 was the start of that; we bought back $60 million in shares, fully offsetting the stock-based compensation we paid during the quarter. The upshot is a share count that's roughly flat quarter-over-quarter. As we've said, we plan to make this offset a recurring piece of our capital allocation strategy, while staying opportunistic about adjusting it when we think that's appropriate. Let me now move to fourth quarter guidance. On the top line, we'd point you to a high-single-digit growth range for Q4. We're pleased with the early-quarter momentum, and last week's Way Day has set up the holiday events later this month nicely. Regarding gross margin, I'd continue to point you toward 29.5% to 30.5% of net revenue, with the aim again being the low end of that range. Customer service and merchant fees, measured as a share of net revenue, ought to come in line with our Q3 results, and advertising should fall within a 10.5% to 11.5% of net revenue range. For Q4, we do anticipate that advertising will represent a higher percentage of revenue than it did in Q3. To repeat what I mentioned earlier, seasonality plays a part because our spending is heavier around the holidays, yet compared with what we reported in Q4 2025, we would still anticipate solid year-over-year leverage on advertising. SOTG&A ought to stay within a $360 to $370 million range. Further down the P&L, for the fourth quarter we would anticipate an adjusted EBITDA margin between 6% and 7% of net revenue; now for a few housekeeping items. We anticipate equity-based compensation and related taxes of approximately $60 to $70 million. Depreciation and amortization ought to come in at roughly $59 million to $65 million. Net interest expense of approximately $42 million. Weighted average shares outstanding of approximately 138 million. CapEx within a $70 million to $80 million range. You can see this line item increasing as we put more money into stores, and that trend is going to carry on through 2027. Naturally, everything here rests on the foundation of solid store results, which allows us to fund that expansion ourselves while continuing to generate strong free cash flow that keeps climbing. As the holidays draw near and we keep our eyes on 2027, let me take a moment to look back. A year ago, we made a commitment to invest wisely so the business could grow rapidly, with adjusted EBITDA climbing at a quicker rate than revenue — and what we're seeing this quarter shows exactly that. Our US share spread has now hit the double digits. Orders and customers are what's fueling that growth. Bringing in every one of those customers runs us less, and more of each added dollar reaches the bottom line: adjusted EBITDA, net income, and free cash flow. Because our balance sheet is stronger and we hold our share count tightly controlled, that expansion is being turned into more value for each share. Nearly all of the initiatives Niraj described are still in their early days, and in our view the best stretch of this compounding is still to come. Thank you. Niraj, Steve, and I are now open to your questions.
Simeon Gutman
analystGood morning, everyone, and thank you for taking my question. First off, I'd like to ask about loyalty. Could you share how happy you are with the growth you're seeing and with the growth in gross profit dollars, so to speak? Niraj, is there any way for you to tell us what inning you're in on this? Does this fully change how you're able to engage with consumers? It feels like we're only a couple of quarters in, and I'd want to ask how much the share spread has gone, I guess — are we early in that share spread equation? Could it grow even further than that? Thanks.
Niraj Shah
executiveHey, Simeon. Appreciate the questions. Let me start with loyalty. Regarding loyalty, I'd say we feel pretty good about it; we introduced it about two years back, and what we've seen is healthy growth. As for your question on innings and the growth still ahead, here's how to think about it: there's a lot still in front of us, since typically you get the people paying the most attention, or your most engaged customers, early on. A big part of what we think lies ahead is that the program offers really meaningful benefits, and when we discuss it with customers, they get quite enthusiastic. Even now, a customer could fairly easily remain unaware that the program exists. Consider all the spots throughout our services where we could help current members discover the full range of benefits available to them — the extra benefits they hold — and as you asked, we generate more dollars per year from them along with more gross profit dollars per year. Or consider the much bigger group of people who have not yet enrolled, who could then find out what the program is and what advantages it offers, and then join; once they join, their behavior shifts, since they want to make the most of the program they have just signed up for. All of that is still in front of us. My take is that when you frame it in baseball terms, we aren't at the opening frame, though we're still early in the contest — maybe the second or third inning, something like that; the game is young. Our view is that this has room to grow into a far larger share of revenue than where it stands now. The program's central principle is delivering genuinely meaningful value to customers, which makes them think of us far more readily as their first choice for everything home-related. That gets them purchasing in additional categories, so annual spend rises along with our yearly profit dollars—since the advertising load tied to the revenue from that customer falls considerably. Despite the benefits we hand them, we come out ahead overall. Regarding your question about share gains and where our heads are on that: for two years we've been saying that entering 2025, growth compared with a year earlier was 0%, which, given the category was shrinking, indicated we were picking up share even though the growth was modest. We described the progression: 0 to 5, 5 to 10, 10 to 15, 15 to 20, and then beyond 20. We said recipe, price, selection, speed, and availability had been the foundation of those share gains since 2022, but that by 2025 we'd gotten to a place where additional initiatives could build on that, because we'd come far enough along with the tech replatforming to put resources there. Rewards, loyalty, Verified, and Delivery Plus are a few examples. Those initiatives have performed well and helped speed up our growth; and with the replatforming now further along plus a major merchandising and catalog change, product-led growth as a whole concept can get additional cycles, and clearly agentic coding might speed things up even more. Our framing is that we're essentially at 10, correct? We began discussing this at 0—0 to 5, 5 to 10, 10 to 15, 15 to 20, 20-plus; we're essentially at 10, and we're essentially just continuing down this path. You'll see that carry on. From a share spread perspective, we don't anticipate the categories growing at those rates—stepping up at those rates, that is. The share spread—really the gap—you're going to see it keep widening.
Simeon Gutman
analystSo now we're discussing EBITDA growth, and we said the outlook for this year is for that to outpace revenue growth. Is that a reframing for going forward — a permanent reframing? Should we no longer be thinking about margin, and instead be thinking about dollar growth? And how does physical retail influence that growth rate, in either direction?
Niraj Shah
executiveI think at the end of the day, what we're optimizing for is definitely EBITDA dollar growth. When EBITDA dollar growth rises faster than revenue growth, the margin does expand over time. I think our focus should be on EBITDA dollar growth, because there are two ways EBITDA dollars can go up. One is the margin rate expanding, but the other is revenue dollars expanding. I think the way to actually get the furthest over any meaningful period of time is to think about both of those, and not over-optimize for the margin rate. The margin rate will keep rising, but you're going to see EBITDA dollars grow faster, because on a relative basis between margin rate and revenue dollar growth, you're going to see the contribution from revenue dollar growth be quite high.
Kate Gulliver
executiveSimeon, I would add one point — and I believe you brought this up — is that really a change or a shift? I think it's actually quite consistent with the way we've described it for a while now, and with how you've watched it unfold over several consecutive quarters. You also, I believe, raised the question of how physical stores are affecting this EBITDA dollar growth rate, and I think it's worth noting that when we think about the stores, our focus is very much on what those stores contribute. As we've discussed, we're seeing some really strong performance coming out of the Chicago market, which is driving substantial revenue growth there. We're seeing really strong performance from the two additional stores. When we think about how that moves through the P&L, our focus is on that continuing, over the long run, to still deliver that improved EBITDA dollar growth and improved EBITDA margin growth. As for the stores themselves, we've talked for a long time about them being self-funding, so when we think about investment in stores from a capital standpoint, we want to do that in a self-funding manner as well.
Simeon Gutman
analystHave a great fourth quarter. Thanks.
Kate Gulliver
executiveThank you.
Chris Horvers
analystThank you. Morning, everyone. I realize you don't address quarter-to-date directly, but momentum did come up. Based on the data points available to us, we've observed some other retail categories slowing; the election was heavily contested, midterm spending hit an all-time high, and gas prices have risen. Could you share what you're seeing in terms of the home furnishings market's growth rate? Did the market experience any kind of jolt in October? Is there any worry regarding the consumer, or do you believe some spending is being pushed off until after the election, particularly when we consider the double-digit share gains in 3Q against the high-single-digit guide for 4Q?
Niraj Shah
executiveI think there are sort of two questions bundled together there, correct? The first is our view on how the category is performing, and the second is how we ourselves are performing, correct? Breaking those apart, I'd say the category keeps bumping along; it's a category that has been out of favor for quite some time. It's an extremely large category, and it is cyclical, but we're likely at the low end of the cycle or at the bottom. It's essentially bumping along, and that's roughly how it has been for a while. I'd say think of it as holding the course it's been on; as for how we're doing, we feel we're doing quite well, but I think we're doing quite well for the reasons I mentioned earlier, correct? The recipe, what we're doing with product-led growth, what we're doing with programs, and we feel pretty happy with our continued performance and our continued momentum. It's not necessarily because the macro is changing at all, it's really because of the things we're doing.
Chris Horvers
analystGot it. Now, regarding the advertising rate side, particularly given the loyalty success you're seeing—if we go back to the IPO, I believe you set a target of a 6% to 8% margin rate on advertising. In the third quarter, you came in just a touch under that on an 80% repeat rate. When we consider potential advertising efficiency, how much does this rate decline over time back toward that initial target as you continue building the brand, as you referenced? And then, how much of that improvement is linked to a higher repeat rate? I'm just curious how that 80% stacks up against some of the more established home furnishings brands in the retail landscape, and how high it needs to climb to perhaps bring that advertising rate down to that original 6%
Niraj Shah
executiveto 8%? On some of the modeling questions, I'll hand things over to Kate in just a moment, but let me first address the 80%. The way I'd frame the 80% is that we aren't overly fixated on the 80% itself—meaning we want repeat to grow substantially, and we want to bring in new customers. The 80 reflects the blend of those two. If you're performing equally well on both fronts, the 80 would remain steady. Eventually, as you scale larger and larger, you could argue there are fewer new customers available, so repeat could increase. Ultimately, the repeat figure ought to be quite high, because if repeat isn't functioning, then the retail business isn't functioning. If customers aren't receiving a good experience from you, they won't return. Whether the issue surfaces near term or midterm, you'll have a problem; we prefer to examine repeat using a narrower definition—our net repeat rate, broken out by different customer cohorts, how frequently they return—so it's not among the metrics that are simple to spot when you pull back to the aggregate, since that aggregate has a great deal blended together. Essentially, we're observing repeat getting stronger and rising, whether that's a more loyal customer or a relatively new customer to the brand, whether that's an e-comm-only customer or an e-comm customer who has since experienced stores and what they do afterward. We slice it in many, many ways. We're seeing all of it moving in the right direction, which is effectively the leading indicator for your future revenue and your future revenue growth rate. As for how the guidance and the P&L take shape, let me hand it over to Kate.
Kate Gulliver
executiveChris, it's impressive that you can bring up a model from 12 years ago that, embarrassingly, I was likely part of developing. Thanks for the trip down memory lane. When it comes to AC&R leverage, we're clearly seeing some good momentum there over the past 12 months. I think several of the things Niraj mentioned are helping drive that. Loyalty is one of those things that should drive AC&R leverage and structural improvement over time. And beyond that, order volume growth and repeat growth, as you pointed out, do drive AC&R leverage. You're starting to see that show up, and repeat order growth has actually been growing quite nicely over the last several quarters. Niraj shared a stat on his call when he was discussing marketing spend, saying that revenue tied to direct traffic is up 15% year-over-year. You're seeing that momentum and that push, which does help provide more structural AC&R leverage. That said, we do see some seasonality here — I just want to remind folks that we've called out some of the improvements this quarter, which maybe landed a little better because of the seasonality we might see in the fourth quarter, and we noted that obviously in the guide, but over time, you have seen that nice engagement there.
Chris Horvers
analystMany thanks.
Oliver Wintermantel
analystGood morning, everyone, and thanks. Even with gross margins coming in lower, your contribution margin hit 16.1%, and looking ahead to 4Q and next year, how much of that gain can be sustained, and where do you feel you'll need to put money back in?
Kate Gulliver
executiveLet me begin. The first point I'd make is that for a number of quarters now we've described 15% as roughly the general level that's the right spot to — as we covered in a few questions earlier — truly land in that zone of speeding up revenue growth while growing EBITDA dollars even faster than that revenue. That 15% level appears broadly to be about the correct trade-off balance between gross margin and the AC&R. Clearly, in this quarter you did see it pick up somewhat. Again, as we just discussed with Chris, part of that stems from the seasonal pattern of marketing spend, and so in the guidance, you note it returns to approximately that 15% level in the next quarter.
Niraj Shah
executiveLet me pull back for a moment, all right? A few minutes back, we were talking about growth in EBITDA dollars, the margin rate, and the goals we're pursuing. If you examine the business, our end goal is a really big enterprise. What does that mean? It means top-line revenue combined with an enormous level of profit, right? What is that? It's EBITDA dollars, or owner's earnings, EBITDA minus cash flow, whichever way you prefer to describe it. Ultimately, that's the genuine intrinsic profit connected to that revenue, correct? So the question then turns to how you arrive there. The approach for arriving there is what we covered, right? We have faith in the recipe, in the programs, and in product-led growth. It's our belief that this strategy, if executed well, will deliver that result. Then, when you look at the lines in between on the P&L, those lines involve a number of items and trades. In the end, the way to judge whether your trades are right is by combining what the revenue growth is, along with the revenue dollars, and what the profit dollars are. When profits grow faster than revenue, your margin rate will continue ticking up. At that point, we think what you'd want is to avoid worrying about how fast the margin rate rises — essentially the velocity. The thing to keep an eye on is whether you're getting the most dollars along the way. In the end, the goal is to land on the largest dollar figure, and if you execute what I described properly, the margin rate will continue rising. Should you push too hard on optimizing margin rate, you might wind up with fewer dollars than you could have otherwise gotten, correct? You want both things working together — margin rate is going up, but that matters less than growing the dollars. You're raising the margin rate as you expand dollars to the maximum extent, and you achieve that by striking a balance between the margin rate contribution and the revenue contribution multiplied by the margin rate, right? When it comes to the lines in between, we believe trade-offs always exist, and we'll optimize them to achieve the result I just outlined.
Oliver Wintermantel
analystUnderstood. Thanks; so regarding international EBITDA, the loss grew to $25 million. Could you perhaps explain what’s causing that worsening and what has to change before the US growth initiatives can lead to improved international results?
Niraj Shah
executiveI’ll hand things to Kate in a moment, but first let me say, I attempted to cover this in the script. What I think needs to be understood is that when we discussed how, once our tech cycles were back to a point where we could concentrate on programs and on product-led growth, there is somewhat of an order to it, and we made wayfair.com the first place where we did that work. You can see that in some ways, such as when we launched rewards. For instance, rewards came to our foreign markets a year and a half or more later. Or there are still programs such as Delivery Plus or stores that we haven’t introduced in our other markets. Essentially there is a delay in how the strategy unfolds in other markets compared with how it unfolds in the US; that’s the key point I’d make, but let me hand it over
Kate Gulliver
executiveKate, Niraj already covered the revenue side. On the top line, we've said for a long time that these markets sit earlier on the maturity curve, and what Niraj described reflects our view of how that can get better over time as we roll out these initiatives. Take loyalty — it only launched in the spring across both markets, and engagement has been encouraging. On your specific question about EBITDA dollars, I noted during the call that there was a one-time charge in the SOTG&A line tied to the UK — the Competition and Markets Authority — so that clearly affects EBITDA dollars in the UK this quarter, or rather in International this quarter.
Oliver Wintermantel
analystUnderstood. Many thanks, and best of luck.
Maria Ripps
analystGreat. Good morning, and thank you for taking my questions. I'd like to return to the topic of market share gains, and I suppose how much of the outperformance stems from structural enhancements in your competitive position as opposed to, perhaps, opportunities that the current industry environment has created? And then, how should we think about incremental drivers behind any further acceleration in share from here? Then I have a quick follow-up.
Niraj Shah
executiveWhen it comes to gaining market share, the environment — whether it's weak or strong — in the end boils down to the competition between you and your rivals. So I think the real question is what you're doing and how that matches what customers want compared with what competitors are doing. I'd say it's more structural, right? To phrase it another way, we've got initiatives around marketing-driven customer outreach, around our delivery approach, around the selection we offer, and around helping shoppers feel confident in items through curation — and my view is these would be important in either a strong or weak macro environment. So in that light, I'd call it structural. The forces behind widening the share spread and extending our share gains are essentially the same ones I just mentioned, correct? That means the recipe, the programs, and product-led growth. Several points come to mind here. First, you don't really have to launch brand-new versions of these initiatives, since most of them build on themselves over time. As you keep carrying out those programs, they get more and more robust and produce a compounding effect. They also reinforce one another, with interactions among them. Picture someone signing up for rewards while at the same time downloading the app, and meanwhile you're improving that app, and meanwhile you're coming up with fresh, more engaging ideas for promotions, and you're expanding the selection within a category, correct? All of these things stack on top of one another.
Maria Ripps
analystUnderstood. That's really useful; next, you mentioned AI partnerships and a few of the main things happening in that area. As product discovery moves more toward AI agents, how do you see your approach to acquiring customers changing, and what does that mean for marketing efficiency and spend as time goes on?
Niraj Shah
executiveIn our view, AI agents and AI surfaces are simply the next step for our category, compared with properties such as Meta, Pinterest, or Google in earlier years. The way I'd put it is that customers may ultimately begin their experience in any number of places. Whether they go about it completely alone, or they do it alongside a friend, or they do it through an agent, the real question becomes: at what stage do they want to be more hands-on than that? Put differently, if they begin by engaging an agent, and the category were more of a commodity, we'd anticipate the agent could exercise considerable agency and carry that through to completion on your behalf. If the category is something like choosing a sweater or purchasing a sofa, we believe the agent can help you get going, and what that agent could make you aware of is that Wayfair offers the largest selection, it provides the most editorial content, it delivers the best price value, it has the quickest delivery, that sort of thing. It can then guide you in that direction. In the end, we think what you'll see is that the majority of customers will genuinely prefer to be the ones doing the exploring from there, and what we're able to offer on our services with the customer, I believe, amounts to richer experiences than an agent can deliver for them. Should they want the agent to transact on their behalf, we noted that we already do this with Google today, they could choose that route. We consider that a rare scenario, which mirrors what Google discovered with shopping, or what Pinterest discovered with buyable pins, and so forth, namely that customers ultimately, depending on the category, act in different ways. We simply regard that as a coming use case. What you'll see is that we will optimize ourselves across all of these places: optimize how we engage with agents, optimize how we manage how we show up on AI surfaces within organic results, optimize how we operate within AI surfaces as the ad products are developed and mature over time. You'll actually see us serving as an early partner to all of these companies and helping to effectively build this product set across all of these places, much as we've done with essentially all the other products through the years.
Maria Ripps
analystUnderstood. That is quite useful. Many thanks.
Michael Lasser
analystGood morning, and I appreciate you taking my question. Given the growth you've shown across the past several quarters, has the type of customer changed, or the makeup of the basket, compared with what Wayfair saw in earlier cycles or with what you had anticipated? What I'm trying to get at is how far customers are leaning toward buying more decor-type items, and whether they'll return once the furniture side of the category genuinely begins to bounce back. Thanks very much.
Niraj Shah
executiveYes. I'd say the response to that is both yes and no. Our customer base is extremely wide, and they all engage in somewhat different ways. One development that has us quite enthusiastic, taking stores as an example, is that it makes us far more visible and a powerful destination for all those recurring items you mentioned — decor, bedding, housewares. That has been exciting. Relative to the earlier question on AOV, that would, for instance, push AOV down, yet as you suggest, we'd be more front of mind, we're capturing their purchases whether large or small, revenue per customer per year is rising, and the more front of mind you are, the better placed you'll be for that big purchase when they finally get to it, since they'll think of you as the place to go explore for it, correct? That's there, though I don't want to overstate it. What we're doing is pursuing things across every dimension. As I mentioned before, take large appliances: we're expanding the large appliances business, where precious few players offer selection from LG and Samsung and GE and Electrolux and the majors, and we're among just a handful, and I believe we're especially well-positioned to grow that business; that's a category where we must build awareness, and it's one we're actively growing very rapidly, though it remains comparatively small. That doesn't fit the thesis of concentrating on decor. We're doing both, I suppose that's my only point. I don't know, Kate...
Kate Gulliver
executiveMichael, I want to jump in here, since I enjoyed what you wrote about the broader cycle and the replacement cycle within the category. What I'd say is that at this point, we aren't yet seeing the category show that, correct? Again, what we are observing is share gains on our side. Those gains are broad-based, as Niraj noted, spanning a number of different categories — something like stores is driving frequency, while something like our own initiatives may drive larger, bulkier items — but it isn't as though we're seeing pronounced outperformance in any one sector versus another. That's why we return to the idea that AOV is an output, not an input, since we aren't attempting to drive pronounced outperformance in one sector or another; instead, we're really trying to drive share gain on a wholesale basis, and I believe we are seeing that.
Michael Lasser
analystGot it. Thanks so much for that. For my follow-up, when you look at what drove the gross margin in the third quarter, how much of the shift came from what you might call reactive factors — for instance, consumers receiving a discount through the loyalty program — versus more proactive factors, such as taking some of that outperformance and working with your vendors to bring prices down? The point of my question is clearly that your message seems to suggest, as you move into next year, your gross margin could drop below the 29.5% low end of the range you're guiding to this year. Just help frame whether that's a realistic expectation, the different pieces that would drive it — more proactive, which will help future quarters, versus reactive, which is a function of how the model's going to work. Thank you so much.
Niraj Shah
executiveSure, Michael. I'm going to hand it over to Kate to answer that, but the one thing I want to remind you of is what we mentioned earlier, right, which is that we intend to grow profit dollars faster than we grow the revenue dollars. If you think about that, it means margin rate is holding in there, right? Again, there are these lines in between, but there are a lot of puts and takes, as you're saying, but I think chaining together a bunch of negative things wouldn't get you the outcome we're talking about.
Kate Gulliver
executiveMichael, thanks for that question, since I think it gets at a crucial issue—one Niraj basically just underscored—namely how we view the interaction among the different items. Our attention is squarely on contribution margin, and as we've noted over the past few quarters, we currently think the appropriate level to run at is roughly that 15% contribution margin, and that should support the objective of speeding up EBITDA dollar growth on that multi-quarter view more quickly than top-line growth, while also expanding the business overall. What does that mean when it comes to GM, when it comes to gross margin? We've noted there are a handful of distinct avenues where we've identified solid investment opportunities within gross margin. You did see that reflected. I'd actually describe loyalty as a proactive investment on our side, because we've concluded that this initiative is genuinely beneficial for the whole business and makes our overall growth more efficient and more profitable, since we know the marketing spend needed to bring those customers back is considerably lower; they arrive more directly, they're more engaged, they purchase across categories, in fact, as you just referenced in the first question, and so they have a somewhat broader-based experience with us. We believe that's going quite well; we'd characterize it as a deliberate strategy intended to broadly propel the flywheel that generates that EBITDA dollar growth, but then it does, yes, have some effect on gross margin. The net result of all that is a contribution margin of roughly 15%.
Michael Lasser
analystThat’s really useful. I hope you all enjoy a wonderful holiday. Thanks a lot.
Kate Gulliver
executiveThanks. Same to you, Michael.
Peter Keith
analystHi there, thanks. Morning to you. Strong quarter, folks. Kate, in your final remark you brought up loyalty and how it's helping your company run leaner and earn more. Could you give us an update on where things stand with the loyalty member count? My recollection is you began the year at just above a million, with perhaps an aim of doubling that figure. How's that effort progressing? Do you believe you're on pace to at least double it in 2026?
Kate Gulliver
executiveOnce in a while we do provide updates on initiatives such as loyalty. We feel positive about the momentum and, broadly speaking, the engagement around it. There are two elements we're concentrating on. The first is the members, which you brought up; we believe we're on pace, and that's progressing nicely. The second concerns how engaged those members are—getting them to boost that incremental spending—and that too is progressing nicely.
Peter Keith
analystOkay. All right, so let's switch our focus to stores. It might be somewhat early, but the Atlanta and Columbus locations are now open. Are they performing in a comparable way to the Chicago store during its first few months? And tied to that, I'm curious whether success in these stores leads to further success. Put another way, are landlords beginning to recognize that you bring in traffic and could be a major tenant? Are you getting additional inquiries and more favorable real estate terms as you work to grow that pipeline?
Niraj Shah
executiveThanks. I'll offer a couple of thoughts, and then Kate can also chime in with anything she'd like to add. Landlords are noticing that our stores attract substantial traffic, and we've found them quite eager to bring us into their properties. We've remained very disciplined and selective regarding which centers we believe match what we're after, and we keep gaining insight into the appropriate square footage, the appropriate format, the appropriate trade area, the appropriate spot within that trade area, and the appropriate co-tenancy. Since landlords are quite eager to have us, we can pair getting what we require with the right economics to achieve the financial results we're targeting. That's been a fairly clear indicator. With more stores open and the ability to replicate those strong results, that's another thing I believe landlords have picked up on, because they'll stop by several locations and remark, 'Okay, oh, jeez, I have a very clear sense of what I'm going to get here.' Few concepts are expanding that can generate this kind of draw. That's all progressing quite nicely.
Kate Gulliver
executivePeter, on your specific question about how Atlanta and Columbus are performing: what we're seeing in those two markets closely mirrors the results out of Chicago, so the state-level lift is holding up well. That's obviously a blunt-force metric, right? We conduct a lot of detailed analysis beneath it to understand where the lift comes from, but we feel really good about the trajectory there. It's quite exciting. As Niraj mentioned, having some stores in the ground certainly helps us in ongoing landlord discussions; we've already announced additional leases, and as you can tell if you go back and look through the leases, we have five stores opening next year, and we're quite excited about those.
Peter Keith
analystVery —
Chuck Grom
analystHey, thanks so much. Solid quarter. I'd like to dig into the AOV decline, and not negatively, more positively, since you said the spread of the business is narrowing — I assume the core Wayfair business actually improved in the quarter. Maybe just speak to that, and then more recently, you talked about how successful Way Day was. What do you figure you did differently, and what does that signal for the holiday season ahead? Thank you.
Niraj Shah
executiveThanks, Chuck. Look, in the end, our total company result can only diverge so much from what wayfair.com delivers, given how large wayfair.com is. It's not the entirety of the company — those other segments do count — but when you look at it purely in percentage terms, it's a genuinely massive business, correct? If that piece underperforms, then we as a company are unable to perform. What you're witnessing, however, is Wayfair delivering. You're likewise seeing the rest of our businesses delivering. And once you add them together, that's how we progress from 0 to 5, 5 to 10, 10 to 15, 15 to 20, and 20 to 20-plus. Every one of those contributes, right? That's basically the route we're traveling. It's functioning nicely, and that's the reason we're quite confident we'll continue moving forward on that path. Regarding Way Day, like I mentioned, Way Day came off successfully. A lesson that keeps coming up for us in the current year is that our event ran for less time than it did the year before. We continue to fine-tune the schedule. I wouldn't claim we have additional sales or additional event days, but we're still working out the best way to structure that schedule. On top of that, we're layering in capabilities that get more compelling all the time. For a long while, our approach to drawing people in has been to sign them up for our email list or have them get the app. The text messaging roster is substantial at this point. We've introduced elements into promotional events — items such as flash deals and other promotional-type levers that suppliers can use, which simply make these events more exciting. It also means that during a three-day event, not everything is identical on each of the three days. There are reasons to come back perhaps multiple times during it. I'd say we keep learning how to shape it. And because our focus is solely on home goods—though we cover a wide range of home subcategories—we're discovering various approaches to blending items across those segments, which keeps making our offering increasingly compelling as a destination for shoppers to explore. I really believe there's genuine innovation in our efforts, beyond the fact that the fundamental formula—pricing, assortment, speed, and in-stock availability—remains extremely solid.
Chuck Grom
analystGreat. I really appreciate it — thank you very much.
Niraj Shah
executiveLook, it's kind of early to say anything for sure, but the way to think about it is the same way we've watched rewards launches in other geographies, we watched how the Perigold program launched for Perigold, and it launched very strong; we know in the first few days what type of revenue penetration we'd like to see, what number of sign-ups we would like to see, and that's off to a really good start. As you mentioned, it's very early, extrapolating is dangerous, but the early trajectory is actually very strong. Great. Thank you.
Niraj Shah
executiveHello, everyone, and thanks so much for staying interested in Wayfair and for being here. We hope all of you enjoy a wonderful holiday season. A quick reminder from us: whether you're shopping Perigold or Wayfair, please make sure to buy with us. We also have the specialty retail brands, and we appreciate your interest.
Operator
operatorThis concludes today's call. Thank you for attending. You may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Wayfair Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Wayfair Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Wayfair Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.