AMCIL Limited (AMH) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

January 24, 2025

Australian Securities Exchange AU Financials Capital Markets earnings 51 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good day, everyone, and thanks for joining us for the AMCIL Half Year Financial Results Briefing. <<operator_script>> At this point I'll pass things over to the Managing Director of AMCIL, Mr. Mark Freeman. Thanks very much. Over to you.

Robert Freeman

executive
#2

Thank you, and good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to this half year result briefing. I'd like to begin by acknowledging the traditional owners and custodians from the lands we are gathered on today and pay my respects to their leaders, past, present and emerging.

Andrew J. Porter

executive
#3

Thanks, Mark, and good afternoon, everyone. Half-year profit came in at $3.6 million, down from $4.1 million. Income from dividends and interest on the portfolio actually rose, while trading and options income fell. That's what drove the decline you see there, to $3.6 million from $4.1 million. Even so, the interim dividend stayed at $0.01. The management expense ratio was 0.53%, compared with 0.46% in 2023. That works out to $0.53 per $100. We flagged this at the AGM. We noted then that costs would probably climb because of a smaller refund from AICS, and that's pretty much how it played out. The portfolio stood at $423 million, versus $370 million a year earlier, and we'll cover some performance numbers a bit later. The following slide addresses something I think most shareholders know — that we trade at a meaningful discount to the NTA. At December's end, NTA was $1.33 and the share price was $1.175. Discounts like this exist across most LICs in the sector right now. In our view, several factors explain it. Higher interest rates have drawn people back toward fixed interest.

Andrew J. Porter

executive
#4

So we observe certain asset allocators arguing that investors should exit equities — where folks had gone seeking any kind of yield — and return to fixed interest for their risk allocation. I believe there has also been a shift in which people head offshore and gravitate more toward U.S. shares, meaning they pull money out of Australian equities and send it abroad. ETFs clearly exist in this space. I genuinely think people are sometimes perhaps unaware of certain pitfalls connected with ETFs, and maybe we could discuss that down the track. AMCIL typically trades at a modest discount, which you're able to see on that graph. Our view is that this is probably attributable to what historically has been a shortage of liquidity. And if you look at '21 and '22, it traded at a premium, and many of the LICs you'll see — AFIC, for example — traded at a considerably bigger premium during that stretch. So that has since come out, and AMCIL bears the brunt of it. But what I can tell shareholders is that both the Board and management are acutely conscious of this. Considerable marketing is underway toward planners and brokers, highlighting the advantages of an LIC and what putting money into them can achieve, and whether right now is a favourable moment for investing in LICs or otherwise.

Andrew J. Porter

executive
#5

We’re aware of that, as I mentioned, and we’re trying to close the gap. With that said, I’ll turn things back over to Mark.

Robert Freeman

executive
#6

Alright, thank you Andrew. We'll turn to Slide 7, I believe that's the one, and really just examine how performance has gone. As you'll notice, across 6 months we beat the benchmark. And crucially, over 1, 5 and 10 years, on a grossed-up basis, we sit ahead of the benchmark. So we gross up the index to account for franking. Our portfolio gets the same treatment. But for our portfolio, we've only applied it to the extent that franking has actually been distributed. There's still franking held within the company. What that means, essentially, is that AMCIL's numbers here are a touch understated, since were we to distribute that surplus franking, those performance figures would rise. Moving on to the following slide, which covers a few of AMCIL's benefits, one being a more concentrated portfolio. Our focus is heavily on quality companies. Index weightings don't dictate our position sizes. Interests are aligned, in that directors and staff hold a substantial equity stake in AMCIL. No performance fees apply, and the expense ratio is comparatively low versus other managed funds available in the market. Being tax effective matters to us, so we aim to keep turnover down and invest with a longer-term horizon.

Robert Freeman

executive
#7

If you turn your attention a little more toward how we invest, we keep showing this slide as a reminder of our objectives. Our aim is to remain invested in the higher-quality businesses out there. That means firms possessing unique assets that are extremely difficult to copy — put another way, businesses building a leadership position within the markets where they compete, and ones whose competitive advantage, in our view, can be sustained over time. We are cautious about businesses exposed to external risk factors. Balance sheets matter a great deal. We avoid companies carrying excessive debt. Too much debt invariably lands companies in trouble. Our preference is for businesses whose earnings streams are more consistent. And people matter enormously. So we seek out management teams that are effective and passionate, with strong alignment of ownership. All of these form a really important part of how we work. These factors exist for a purpose, since what we have observed over time is that when such company characteristics come together, it means we will be investing in businesses enjoying a better competitive advantage. That produces a higher return on capital. We observe this in the stocks we invest in.

Robert Freeman

executive
#8

Generally speaking, their returns on capital are far greater than what the market delivers. High returns let you produce solid cash, and that cash can go back into the business, letting you keep taking market share, strengthen your leadership position, and in the end generate profit growth. And ultimately, profit growth is what pushes share prices and dividends higher, and that is what delivers long-term returns to shareholders. So we go out looking to purchase such companies whenever we spot long-term value, and we'll trim or sell out when a company fails to display those traits. But really, the key thing in investing isn't merely spotting them — it's spotting them early and being ready to take a position, which is essential for beating benchmarks. So every day we're in the market searching for opportunities, striving to be early on them and bring them into the portfolio. So if you turn to the next slide. If you review some of that activity across the half year, we have sold out of CBA. In our view CBA is a wonderful business, but the share price, as it stands right now, is something we're really finding difficult, and in fact we sold at prices a little below where it sits today.

Robert Freeman

executive
#9

Its P/E sits around 26x, with a yield just shy of 3%. Great company though it is, we simply couldn't defend a valuation stretched to that degree. That's why we sold out of CBA. We held a bit of Mineral Resources, and once the problems surrounding the CEO surfaced, we were out almost immediately. Being invested in businesses whose management carries that kind of baggage isn't something we want. PEXA is another one we've exited. Its standing in the Australian market is genuinely strong. Still, at the level where it trades, our hope, I suppose, is that more emerges from the U.K. Hope, though, is the operative word here, and investing on hope isn't what we do. Observation is our basis for investing, and we simply couldn't observe the outcomes we'd want to see that would suggest the U.K. could work. Domino's has had its troubles too. The bigger question there is where that business sits. On top of that, it has picked up some debt across the last few years and is finding things a bit tough, so we got out. PSC was a smaller holding, but it was recognized as the thing moving the stock.

Robert Freeman

executive
#10

That takeover ended up being a profitable investment for us. As you may recall, we acquired PWR not very long ago, though we had real worries that the company could face a tough stretch lasting a couple of years. They're pouring substantial capital into growing their operations and footprint in Australia, and especially in the U.S., and we felt the shares were pretty pricey. So we largely backed off from the modest stake we held, yet we continue to monitor it rather closely, since this business retains many of the traits we're looking for. Still, we'd want to see what I'd describe as additional turning points, to confirm that after they move beyond this CapEx-heavy period, we become persuaded the U.S. will deliver the kind of growth the company anticipates — then we'd definitely be interested in re-entering. We've also cut back several other positions that we felt had hit full valuation, for example Wesfarmers, which is at record-high PEs, and Westpac too. Goodman is a large holding, but we've shaved a little off the top, and the same goes for Netwealth, Breville, REA and Reece. Our positions in those remain substantial, we've simply trimmed them slightly.

Robert Freeman

executive
#11

Conversely, we increased our position in WiseTech. That stock dipped somewhat after the CEO appeared on the front page of the newspapers. We viewed that situation as a buying opportunity, since in our view this is a well-established company with an incredible market position, solid growth prospects, and a capable management team. So we took advantage of the weakness to add shares. We added to our holdings in ARB, Block, Redox, and NEXTDC. NEXTDC has been rather weak in the market, so we've increased our position there. I'll return to a few of those shortly, though we have discussed some of those names in earlier presentations. Among the new stocks is Region. We actually mentioned that one at the AGM, but I'm glad to revisit it if there are questions. Amcor and EVT — there's a slide coming up on those. We'll walk through the reasoning behind them. Sigma — this is the Chemist Warehouse business being backed into Sigma, and it suits our process very well, as a founder-led company that dominates its market. ReadyTech is a small position. It's a technology company. It's a founder-led business. We're only taking a smaller position at this stage. We don't have an actual slide on this one, but they generate solid annuity income streams.

Robert Freeman

executive
#12

They supply software primarily to the <<inaudible>> to help those businesses operate, and we’re still seeing decent growth in that area. And we believe the price is quite reasonable. Life360, which we mentioned earlier. And Cuscal was an IPO. It’s a payments business. So they provide payment services to smaller banks in the market. So there’s a variety of banks they serve that way. It holds a very strong market position. We felt it was very fairly priced in the market. And so, we took a small position in that one. Happy to take questions on those at the end. So just in terms of performance, I think it’s worth highlighting on the next slide, and again, we discussed these throughout the year at our July webinar and also at the AGM. But just the importance of continuing to capture opportunities and stocks that fit our frameworks, because that’s what drives ongoing performance. And with the — I mentioned the Chemist Warehouse deal, we took <<inaudible>> like to take a position in that and the stock is really pretty hard since that deal was approved. It’s a good position. It’s one we could have more of going forward, but it fits that category killer, big market opportunity, well-run company.

Robert Freeman

executive
#13

So that contributed positively during the half. Earlier, as we noted at the beginning of the first half of the year, we established a position in TechOne. In our view, it ranks among the highest-quality stocks available. It has a solid history of annuity income. The company supplies software to government and to universities. Universities represent a substantial portion of its operations. It is expanding in the U.K. Its earnings are highly consistent, return on equity exceeds 30%, and it carries no debt. It possesses every attribute we seek in a business, and we initiated a position during the first half. After we invested, the company held a major Strategy Day, and the market, I believe, truly grasped how strong this business is. So that contributed positively. We added Block, which was a newer holding. We identified value in that company, 65 million customers, with room to grow revenue from that customer base. We judged it inexpensive, and the market is now beginning to recognize that. And Redox, another founder-led business, with a 30-year record of consistent expansion, strong returns on capital, and ample opportunities for growth. So each of those holdings performed — they were newer positions, yet they did very well.

Robert Freeman

executive
#14

We got into the story early, and they have contributed a great deal of performance to the portfolio, and some of our existing companies also had strong halves, like Objective, Netwealth, founder-led businesses, Breville, Gentrack, founder-led characteristics with strong CEOs. They performed very well in the half as well. So moving to the next slide, 2 of the newer stocks, Amcor and EVT, and I'll get Gilbert and Jaye just to talk about the rationale for adding those.

Jaye Guy

executive
#15

Thanks, Mark, and good afternoon to everyone on the call. Amcor is a global packaging company with market-leading position in consumer segments such as food, beverage and health care. Their customers include the likes of Nestle, Johnson & Johnson and Coca-Cola, which are all obviously well-known brands. There's a very good chance that while you may not recognize the Amcor brand in itself, if you do walk into your kitchen and go through the pantry, a good number of those packaged items will be -- or the packaging will be manufactured by Amcor. So in November last year, Amcor announced a merger with one of their global peers known as Berry Group, which is listed in the U.S. And we think the merger has good strategic rationale. They have -- the products that they produce have complementary nature from both, I guess, products and a geographical perspective. And we also see significant cost synergies or savings once the 2 companies have combined. Historically, Amcor has undertaken 2 major transformative deals over the past 20 years, being Alcan in 2010 and Bemis in 2019. But both of these acquisitions like Berry Group offered significant synergies, which served as operational tailwinds for Amcor's EPS growth in the years following.

Jaye Guy

executive
#16

We anticipate a comparable pattern for Amcor's earnings going forward. And what our due diligence has indicated is that these synergies — which rest largely on the procurement capabilities of the combined group — are realistic. Beyond that, we think this valuation fails to reflect those benefits. Our confidence gets additional support from the track record of the Amcor team, whose history of delivering such synergies is very strong. And with that, I'll hand things over to Gilbert to speak about EVT.

Gilbert Battistella

executive
#17

Thanks, Jaye, and good afternoon to all of you. EVT holds a portfolio made up of entertainment assets. Cinemas, hotels, and EVT's Thredbo Ski Resort are the main ones. We opened a position in the stock once it had sold off, which happened because of cyclical weakness: a soft film slate that followed the Hollywood writers' strike, plus unfavorable weather conditions that produced a lighter ski season. Our view is that EVT has come through the worst of those cyclical headwinds and sits in a good position to benefit from a cyclical recovery. We also find strong latent value in EVT's property portfolio, since EVT's market cap is trading below the latest third-party valuation of that property portfolio. EVT could capture this valuation uplift, and the company has committed to a structural review, through which it has optionality to recognize shareholder value by evaluating opportunities like divesting noncore properties, selling noncore segments, and development opportunities involving their hotels. What matters a great deal to our investment process is the strong insider alignment with Chairman Alan Rydge, given his substantial shareholding. With that, I'll hand things back to Mark.

Robert Freeman

executive
#18

All right, thank you Jaye and Gilbert. Moving on to the following slide, I want to add a few more remarks regarding those 2 stocks, reflecting on what AMCIL holds and how we see the investment case for each. As I mentioned before, clearly the portfolio is dominated by what I would describe as structural compounders, most likely. These companies hold leading positions and have plenty of avenues for growth. Typically, they generate strong returns on capital. In our view, these are names you can own across very extended time horizons. We're comfortable with steady growers such as CSL, Macquarie and Wesfarmers. I'll return to CSL shortly. When timing is right, you can purchase solid income stocks. So roughly a year back, we substantially increased our bank positions while they were trading cheaply. Clearly, we've begun to move out of some of them. In fact, with the last 2 holdings, Westpac and NAB, we've kept reducing our exposure. But we've also started writing call options over those positions now, meaning we receive 2 income streams: franked dividends along with option premiums. So those gave us fairly attractive yields. And as for the 2 stocks we discussed earlier, even though there's a heavy preference for locating the great structural compounders, we're comfortable hunting for value in any place.

Robert Freeman

executive
#19

And names such as Amcor and EVT — when we genuinely grasp the opportunity and believe the price doesn't reflect it, what we term cyclical asset plays like those two, we're glad to establish positions in them if we figure we can earn some money across the coming few years. Holding them indefinitely isn't required, yet we definitely see some opportunity in that area. Moving now to the top 20 holdings, simply to show that we keep our stocks for extremely long stretches, seeking those rewards from terrific success stories. In my view this is a segment of the market that went underappreciated for quite a while. I believe it's beginning to gain more appreciation now — namely, that wonderful stocks deliver wonderful outcomes. Not across 5 years or 10; rather 15, 20, 25 years. That reinforces our approach of investing for the longer term. So as you can observe, we've enjoyed solid holdings, solid long-term holdings, among many of our top 20 stocks. Let's proceed to the following slide, with a little on markets and what we're observing right now.

Robert Freeman

executive
#20

Basically, this is just a chart showing the Australian market's PE over a 20-year span. And right now you can see we're trading at fairly elevated levels, and that's the reason we're somewhat cautious on markets, and why, when stocks get pushed to extremes, we're glad to take a little off the top. We have to be careful there, because trimming good companies always sounds great, but in my experience, unless you can pick the absolute extreme, it's better to simply leave them in the portfolio. So one thing we're mindful of is that when markets are strong, the first thing you should be doing is trimming, I suppose, the lower quality stocks in your portfolio. We do like the banks. We think they're good businesses, but we're not seeing a lot of profit growth. So they've been very strong. So we've had a bias toward taking some money out of those. And so, we're just cautious. We've got to keep assisting are we in good stocks. We're just doing a bit of work at the moment, saying where we see again our individual holdings against valuations to make sure that if there is some sort of downdraft at some point, we're not too exposed.

Robert Freeman

executive
#21

As we all know, this is difficult — a company can remain overpriced for extended stretches. That's simply unknowable. What we must do is ensure, first, that we hold solid stocks offering solid opportunities, and second, that we aren't carrying, I suppose, an oversized stake in any stock that's overpriced. And it isn't only about quality names with lofty P/Es, since frequently those stocks deliver strong earnings growth — it applies to any stock, really. Turning to the outlook remarks: we do believe earnings growth is getting somewhat tougher because economic conditions are more subdued. Yet the U.S. economy, and even here, continues to grind ahead despite elevated valuations, which I mentioned. Uncertainty over interest rates will keep generating volatility. The market continually wants to anticipate rate cuts. My take on that: perhaps we should accept that, really, on a long-term view, these rates are closer to normal — though there may be room to cut if things slow down, I doubt we'll return to where we were a couple of years ago, when rates were drifting toward 0.

Robert Freeman

executive
#22

That simply isn't the reality — the historical record indicates otherwise. To repeat what I said, looking back more than a century, these figures sit at or near that longer-run mean. Right now we hold a modest amount of cash so we can seize opportunities. So, to wrap up, we believe the portfolio is well placed. Should volatility arise, we hold strong businesses with strong leadership teams. In our view, those businesses can serve the purpose of generating growth. We aim to own shares capable of expanding earnings, and we intend to remain with high-quality holdings. I also think it matters that we continue working to seize opportunities, since grabbing them in strong stocks makes you less prone to wander off and hunt for value among weaker businesses. So — I believe what we've provided are several instances of us seeking to seize opportunities in the strong names and, by doing so, working to steer clear of value traps in the market. With that, we'll take questions.

Geoffrey Driver

executive
#23

Okay, thank you, Mark. I’ll pull these questions together. <<operator_script>> So, to start us off, the first one asks about the strong interest people have shown in data centers as well as in private lending. Do you have a perspective on those areas?

Robert Freeman

executive
#24

Yes, I’ll hand that over to Gilbert.

Gilbert Battistella

executive
#25

Absolutely, and thanks for asking, Graham. Data center space is an area with meaningful long-term tailwinds tied to AI-driven demand. These facilities are essentially where AI computation resides. As a result, we've observed an acceleration in the long-term demand picture. Catching up on building supply takes a multiyear process. So in the near term, demand has sped up considerably. Returns and the near-term outlook for these data centers and upgrades are quite strong. We have exposure to that via the portfolio through holdings in NEXTDC, Macquarie Technology and Goodman Group. Looking further out, we're conscious that a substantial supply response is in progress. We'll keep watching this closely, and we recognize that barriers to entry for meeting hyperscaler demand from those large U.S. customers are lower than the colocation work done more historically.

Robert Freeman

executive
#26

Yeah, so I suppose as a summary: for the next 2 or 3 years, we believe things look fairly good for those who already hold positions and are expanding data centers. We believe that demand is genuine. But I suppose we expect that we're going to enter a period of — soon, we will begin to see some contract wins over the coming couple of years. We believe that will be positive for share prices. But we are mindful that it's not a said and forget these things. And so, if we do get some strong strength, we have some good exposure at the moment, but we would then have to reassess if we see a strong response from share prices.

Geoffrey Driver

executive
#27

Thanks, Mark. So I’ve got a few questions here about the discount, the buyback, and the DRP, I suppose. Given that wide discount, why has the share buyback come to a halt? And then there’s also this idea about neutralizing the DRP by purchasing shares on market to satisfy it.

Robert Freeman

executive
#28

Yeah, so obviously with the buyback, we can't execute it around when results are reported. That puts us into what you might call a blackout window. But once the results come out — and there's also some timing tied to the end of the month — I think we've been pretty open in saying that we'll keep the buyback going if a significant discount shows up, and the point there is exactly right. Neutralizing the DRP is a very clear strategy for us given where the discount sits. So we'd expect that would likely continue if this discount persists.

Geoffrey Driver

executive
#29

Mark, this is somewhat connected, but that discount to NTA — and I'm quoting here, these aren't my words — is described as a fantastic chance to buy. Do you think that discount might narrow once people see the value that's available?

Robert Freeman

executive
#30

Well, look, that's basically our hope right now, I suppose. And I guess we're simply working to be more visible in the market and to discuss what the advantages of LICs are and how they differ from ETFs, and especially from managed funds. Look, just a couple of years ago our LICs were trading at an absurd premium. So things can turn around really fast. And in hot markets, our LICs have historically tended to lag. This has been a hot market. And without question, some LICs that performed worse and charge high fees — performance fees — haven't done well. I think they've pulled the sector down somewhat. I think another point is that we've got to, I think, keep being proactive in saying that not all LICs are alike. We consider ourselves a traditional LIC. And then what I term the newer LICs are those that have a management business on the side that charges fees and then wants to charge performance fees on top of that. So I think when people examine the sector, you really need to distinguish between traditional LICs like ours, which is just cost recovery.

Robert Freeman

executive
#31

We have no outside manager, and there are no performance fees — unlike those charging higher fees. So we believe we're quite distinct. We want to put in considerably more effort to set ourselves apart from the remainder of the market. And as an LIC, our capital base is fixed. There's no money coming in or going out that we need to manage. The capital base is fixed. We can purchase and sell assets at any time we choose. So we consider it an excellent way to actually run a portfolio. And right now, at least, I'm somewhat of the view that there's probably more opportunity in the market, given they've suddenly fallen to this sort of discount. So we'll simply keep selling the story into the market.

Andrew J. Porter

executive
#32

That's part of why we're pursuing a buyback — we see it as a solid purchase at this price.

Robert Freeman

executive
#33

Correct.

Geoffrey Driver

executive
#34

Thanks, Mark. So I suppose, as a follow-up question — Andrew, you brought up the matter of ETFs and LICs. Mark touched on some of that, but would you mind expanding a bit more on what you were saying there?

Robert Freeman

executive
#35

Yes. Let me add just one more point. I mean, if — given how low — every one of our LICs within the group carries quite low — relatively low fee structures, then why would someone purchase an ETF when they could get one of these funds at a 10% discount? So as I review our portfolio and take each stock price times 0.9, which is basically what you're doing when you buy at a 10% discount, and ask myself what those prices look like, they look right to me. So did you have anything else...

Geoffrey Driver

executive
#36

You could potentially address the tax consequences that come with ETFs.

Andrew J. Porter

executive
#37

I was about to make the point that ETFs come in 2 kinds. You have managed funds, and those, like us, will pursue active management of the portfolio. They'll examine stocks. Frequently, as Mark mentioned, their MER is far higher. And since they're trusts too, they'll just distribute the income and capital gains they receive. The capital gains part is worth noting, because you might look at the headline return and the headline numbers. But with trusts and ETFs, there's considerably more tax. Nor do you automatically get to view an annual report, see the individuals running it, or ask questions. An LIC, with its conventional listed structure and ASX corporate governance, can offer all of those things. Even when it comes to what's called an index tracking fund, you might think all I'm doing is simply buying the shares in the market. Index tracking funds come in 2 varieties. There are synthetics, which don't really own the underlying stock. And if they do own the underlying stock, then once more you must bear in mind that tax implications will arise as people buy and sell out of those when stocks move in and out of the index.

Andrew J. Porter

executive
#38

That gets handed along to shareholders and isn't really factored into the total return numbers you see. And again, you don't get that same level of transparency either. So for both kinds of ETFs — and there is absolutely a role for them in the market. I mean, if you want in and you know what you're getting into, then of course, good luck to you. With an LIC, we're able to build reserves. So when lean times come, we can hold onto those reserves, retain profits, and still pay a dividend even if the distribution and income we receive have dropped. We saw exactly that during the GFC, and we saw it during COVID. So those, we believe, are appealing features of an LIC. So hopefully that's helpful and gives you a bit more information, and there are further details, et cetera, on the benefits available on the websites.

Geoffrey Driver

executive
#39

Thanks, Andrew. I have a question regarding Region Group. What makes us favor it over, perhaps, any other REIT available in the market?

Robert Freeman

executive
#40

Yes. Look, it's really <<inaudible>> we're taking for a bit of income. What drew us to that one was simply the yield. The yield sits at roughly 6.5%. We believe they have a fairly solid focus on what the assets are. And we anticipate they ought to be able to return to growing their income at around 3%. So, if you're receiving a yield of 6.5% and can grow at 3%, and it's roughly fairly valued in what is an expensive market, that looks reasonably okay to us. What I don't like is some of the other property trusts in the market that are trading on yields of -- in the 5s or even some in the 4s because you've got to produce some pretty solid EPS growth alongside it to make it into a reasonable investment. And that sort of analysis of REITs is the way I look at it because I don't look at the NTAs that the company has put out because I don't think that's the way we assess it. It's the way the industry assesses it. But I think the industry has a much lower return hurdle that they're trying to meet to produce those NTAs.

Robert Freeman

executive
#41

My view is that they're fine with returns in the 7%, 8% sort of range when they calculate the NTAs they publish. A 7% or 8% isn't what I'm after. What I'm after is 9% plus. And in my view, Region is the sole option that meets that bar. So we've built a modest position there, though the real point is simply capturing the income.

Geoffrey Driver

executive
#42

Thanks, Mark. Someone's asking about Woolworths. Do we think it's getting close to a good buying opportunity?

Robert Freeman

executive
#43

Yes. Look, probably — I think it's probably — we think it's a good business. And just to remember, we had a strong overweight position. And when it traded in the high 30s, we took a lot of stock out and made it a much smaller position. I think probably it's more come back to a fair value rather than being cheap at this point. So we're continuing to hold at this point. But I think we probably need to see it lower before we added more or a greater sense that there's going to be some stronger earnings growth from here to say, yes, buy some more.

Geoffrey Driver

executive
#44

Thanks, Mark. I have a question on this: have we at any point thought about gold as a hedge or precautionary investment in case of an unexpected market downturn?

Robert Freeman

executive
#45

Look, not really, because if you like gold, then buy gold. We're not a fund that goes out and buys gold. You could buy gold companies, but those gold companies never wind up performing as well as the gold price, because there are so many issues involved when you're trying to mine the material that, when you look at some of the gold companies, there are some -- we think Newmont is a very well-run company, but running a mine is complex. And the yield isn't that high. And if you look at the 20-year track record of earnings growth, it hasn't been great. And so, we want to invest in -- our style is to find businesses, businesses that can grow their profits over time by staying in things that they can control. So that means they've got a great product, a great service, and there's a big market potential. That's in our control. That's what we want to reinvest in rather than -- I've got no idea what the gold price is going to do, going forwards. So again, it goes back to if we can capture opportunities in TechOne and Sigma, that's really our space.

Andrew J. Porter

executive
#46

Our firm invests in equities.

Robert Freeman

executive
#47

Yes. Well, our money is going into strong businesses.

Geoffrey Driver

executive
#48

There's a question regarding Ramsay Healthcare. Does anyone have any thoughts on that?

Robert Freeman

executive
#49

Sure — the stock price isn’t something we control, obviously. And we do keep an eye on that from time to time. The share price has dropped quite a bit. But I keep coming back to — I did a brief recently, yes, and it’s simply facing a lot of difficulties right now. When we run it through our frameworks, it still doesn’t stack up especially well. And I recognize that if they sell their European assets, there’s a chance for some kind of re-rating. But again, if that doesn’t take place or they don’t receive a strong price, what are you really investing in? Our inclination is still toward finding businesses we believe can grow and develop on their own, rather than sort of fiddling around trying to choose a moment where — I mean, I’ve heard from many people that it was cheap at $60 and $50, then $40, and now it’s $33. You can burn a lot of time and energy on these kinds of things. At some point, someone will get it right and be a low point. It’s never to say never. And so, I think it’s something we have to keep looking at, as we discussed with EVT and Amcor.

Robert Freeman

executive
#50

Everything does carry a price, yet any candidate would still need to meet the standards we set for those stocks: we must be able to grasp it, and we must be able to see that conditions have improved. We feel genuinely good about the team. We have real clarity on the route for the business to return to growth and on the sources of value. A moment and a setting could arise, but I simply doubt we have reached that point right now.

Geoffrey Driver

executive
#51

Thanks, Mark. On the subject of stocks that possibly don't really belong in our universe — SPC Global Holdings — have we ever taken a look at it? I mean, the former SPC turns out fruit and vegetable juices <<inaudible>> products.

Robert Freeman

executive
#52

Yes. Look, it likely just needs to get through our frameworks regarding what we're trying to do. And that doesn't mean there can't be — there isn't a time to buy. But we have pretty strict criteria, and I don't think it's there for us.

Geoffrey Driver

executive
#53

Okay. CSL, it's common knowledge that over the past 5 years the share price has basically gone nowhere. Why do you — or what makes you believe it remains very appealing?

Robert Freeman

executive
#54

Yeah. Look, this has been a letdown since it's kind of been the portfolio's anchor. We held a large position in it, and it has simply moved in reverse. It's somewhat difficult to figure out — I'd probably describe it more as decent fair value right now. I wouldn't go so far as to call it cheap, but it's decent fair value in a market where everything else is genuinely pricey. They ought to have 3 or 4 years of robust earnings growth ahead of them. And should the market begin to buy into that, you could see it trade up somewhat from there. Look, a few things in the market I don't fully grasp, namely the unrelenting climb in the banks, yet there appears to be unrelenting selling in CSL. So you question whether big institutions perhaps got somewhat caught out holding too much CSL and not enough banks, and whether switching is occurring between the 2. I check — most analysts in the market carry valuations near $320. It's a solid business. So we worn underperformance. So I reckon we simply hold with it.

Robert Freeman

executive
#55

And with any luck, perhaps when the next results come out, if they're still discussing earnings growth in the double digits for the foreseeable future, then maybe — the market might at last begin to have faith in the company, and we could see somewhat improved performance.

Geoffrey Driver

executive
#56

There's a question regarding the interim and final dividend, noting that we've said we would aim to make the interim and final dividends more closely equal. I'm not entirely certain we've achieved that. But is that still something we plan to pursue?

Robert Freeman

executive
#57

Yeah. Honestly, look — and I’ll hand it over to Andrew. Look, I think that likely goes back to the first time the interim was introduced, and we definitely heard some feedback about trying to get an interim. But I think where we stand right now, we do sometimes pay some capital gain, though we don’t know the capital gains until the end of the year. So any special dividend we might pay is more likely to come through at the end of the year, but...

Andrew J. Porter

executive
#58

No, that was good to see — definitely a big one. We do aim to pay special dividends whenever it makes sense. That depends on how much in realized gains we end up with, and we won't have that figure until the year is over. So if the ordinary dividend went up, the Board could look at that. But on the whole, when it comes to total dividends, the special is more likely to come at year-end.

Geoffrey Driver

executive
#59

Andrew, you might have raised this point previously, yet it returns to what a listed investment company gains from being able to hold reserves and from the level of franking credits that we possess internally.

Andrew J. Porter

executive
#60

Sure. Right now, at year-end, for example, the company’s franking reserves stood at roughly $0.04 per share. In other words, after we paid the final, a franking dividend of $0.04 per share could be paid. If you look at those half-year figures, nobody would be surprised that it’s pretty much about the same. But we also have — we owe tax of about $0.02 — that would equate to a franking credit of $0.02 per share additional distribution if we pay the tax on the balance sheet for the realized gains made so far this year. And I’m not saying all of that will be paid out, and we won’t know what the position would be. But yes, that is why keeping those reserves, keeping that franking credit means we can normally seek to maintain the ordinary dividend.

Geoffrey Driver

executive
#61

Thanks, Andrew. I have a question regarding IDP Education, and obviously we have been quite patient with that one. Which triggers do you see them still giving us reason to hope for?

Robert Freeman

executive
#62

Yes. Look, I think the reason we've <<inaudible>> described this as a solid stock within our framework, but it has a few problems when it comes to our factors — namely outside influence, since the government holds a major say, and the nature of that annuity revenue stream, because they require new students annually. So it's a little weaker on quality, but it remains a good business. I think what — the key thing we seek is that — and our primary focus is always on market structure. And so, we're consistently quite keen on companies where, when you examine the market structure, it remains highly fragmented. But you have a single company that appears to be beginning to establish a leadership position, because that's the company prepared to invest capital and deploy technology. So IDP shows all of those traits. They have put out some strong products with technology. And through what has been a difficult period for the business, it's notable that profits haven't collapsed. And that's due to their continued gains in market share from all these mom-and-dad operators, and this is a global business, which means the — I guess, the model we seek is the top player in a segment that's still fragmented, and that is unfolding.

Robert Freeman

executive
#63

And should the student market worldwide settle down, or actually return to growth, they're better placed than competitors, and they ought to be able to expand earnings substantially from that point. So that's the trait. Therefore, provided we continue to observe them gaining share, we'll continue to hold, since that trait ought to produce growth over the long term.

Geoffrey Driver

executive
#64

Thanks, Mark. I’ve got a question about the retiree downside theme, I suppose. Is there any interest in names like Lifestyle Communities, Ingenia, and Stockland?

Robert Freeman

executive
#65

Yeah. Look, interest isn’t high. We tracked Lifestyle for a while, but ultimately it comes down to what return on capital these businesses really generate. And with Lifestyle Communities, they wind up taking on a lot of debt in order to drive growth. We have companies — for example, we acquired TechOne — that take on no debt to grow. In fact, they simply reinvest their cash and earn really high returns. We had an opportunity there. Why do we need to go into these? So yes, I just think they’re tougher businesses, they’re capital intensive, and they have to rely on debt. Property prices are a key part of the model. And we’ve simply seen better opportunities. And that’s not to say they’re bad companies. If you buy them at the right time, you can make a bit of money from them. But it’s just not high on our watch list, given the complexities those companies have.

Geoffrey Driver

executive
#66

Appreciate that, Mark. On the next one, I can't quite tell whether this is a statement or a question, but Goodman Group and NEXTDC still look like stronger choices than DiGiCo — and even HMC — for riding the AI wave.

Robert Freeman

executive
#67

Yes. Well, look, I think — I mean, what bothered us about DiGiCo and that whole situation was all the fee leakage going to HMSC (sic) HMC and so on. So when those kinds of companies show up in the market, it's not — we'd probably rather hold NEXTDC, since that's their bread and butter. They've been at it for a while. They have — what draws us to NEXTDC is that network effect. Around Australia, they've got the best network of centers, it's their passion, and their CEO is very connected into the U.S. tech sector. And we like that Macquarie Telco — Technology — sorry, Macquarie Technology is founder-led. And then obviously, Goodman Group, it's actually more about how good the land banks they hold around major cities are, and that's what makes them so attractive. That's really the strategic advantage they've got, and that's their bread and butter. So we prefer to stay with companies where that's their core business, and we don't really need to go into other things.

Geoffrey Driver

executive
#68

There's a question about the factors that make Australia appealing as an investment destination, and also whether you anticipate bringing in companies from outside Australia, as well as Australian ones, into the portfolio at some future point?

Robert Freeman

executive
#69

That's a fair question. When you ask whether Australia is an appealing destination for investment, the way I see it is that what we invest in is companies. So any market can be appealing — where there are strong businesses, you can locate strong businesses capable of growing, and it's a secure market. So if we continue to identify strong businesses in Australia, that's excellent. But we have in fact been discussing — and we've brought this up several times during the presentation — that a moment and situation could arise in which we add international stocks. For anyone who tracks our group, we have an international team running a modest portfolio inside AFIC. And if we can locate — it's far simpler for us these days to purchase international stocks within AMCIL; you just call a broker and instruct them to buy it. So what we're — our view is this would create value for AMCIL provided we can uncover some solid opportunities, though it must be extremely specific. And it must be stocks that truly align with the frameworks we've discussed for 2 years now, in terms of the kinds of screens we apply to stocks. If you uncover something that aligns really well, I'm more than happy to purchase an overseas stock, or a handful of them.

Robert Freeman

executive
#70

We haven't—would it be 10—no more than 10% or 20% of the portfolio consisting of items we could talk about. But definitely, since I've been here—since the investment team has been in place—there have been a handful of stocks that the international investment team bought that I just said, "Wow, that would fit perfectly in AMCIL against our frameworks," and those stocks have performed really well. And it will be another thing that sets us apart. So yes, so that is definitely on the table.

Geoffrey Driver

executive
#71

I guess the other thing, Mark, is that many of the businesses in your portfolio have substantial — well, they're all mature and profitable operations.

Robert Freeman

executive
#72

Well, all of those are international stocks in any case. What I mean is simply that where they may be — and a few of them have dual listings that we already hold. So Amcor, really, now has its primary listing in the U.S., and so does ResMed. But if you look through every one of our stocks, they are global international businesses. And even Mainfreight, which we own — we purchase that on the New Zealand exchange, and that is already an international stock. So in that respect, there is nothing new here. It's about — but we have to stay consistent with the frameworks that we know work. And when we spot an opportunity, we are glad to take a look at it.

Andrew J. Porter

executive
#73

There's one quick point I want to make about Australia, and we really shouldn't overlook it — and it doesn't necessarily outweigh everything else — which is that the franking regime matters a great deal when it comes to investing, since it ensures you aren't taxed twice on your income. So no shareholders ought to forget how valuable that is.

Geoffrey Driver

executive
#74

On the Treasury Wine question — is that something we view as an appealing asset?

Robert Freeman

executive
#75

Sure, we review that periodically. In my view, it's a well-operated company. The management teams there strike me as solid. Granted, there could be an opportunity — I recall a dislocation, when China was dumping and the tariffs affected us and the share price dropped; that presented a favorable entry point. The industry is a difficult one because — they do have a solid product portfolio, yet the market remains highly competitive, and that's likely where we come up a bit short relative to our frameworks, since achieving genuine leadership in what they do is really hard. So from that angle, quite a few factors in the business lie beyond your control. Thus I wouldn't — I'd never rule it out, but for us it's probably not a top priority.

Geoffrey Driver

executive
#76

Mark, that's all from me. Viewer count is dipping a bit, so perhaps we should wrap up the call here. So if you...

Robert Freeman

executive
#77

All right, and thanks to all of you for joining. I’d just like to remind everybody that during March, we hold a shareholder information meeting. So that’s when the — most of the investment team will travel around to most of the major cities across Australia. That gives you a great chance to meet us and put questions to us if you’d like. Details about that can be found on our website. But of course, the next webinar we’ll be running will be around the full year results in July. So once again, thank you for taking part.

Operator

operator
#78

That brings today’s webinar to a close. Thanks for taking part. You can disconnect your lines now.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete AMCIL Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to AMCIL Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in AMCIL Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.