Ategrity Specialty Insurance Company Holdings (ASIC) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 21, 2026
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Justin Cohen
executiveGood evening, everyone, and thank you for being on Ategrity's Q3 earnings call. I'm Justin Cohen, and with me today are Chris Schenk, our President and Chief Underwriting Officer, and Neil Adler, our Chief Financial Officer. Ategrity posted an outstanding underwriting quarter, with our lowest combined ratio ever at 84.7% and underwriting income up 83.7% compared with a year ago. These numbers show how strong our underwriting strategy is and how the benefits of our productionized platform keep compounding. Our disciplined technical underwriting and centralized operating model are pushing loss and expense ratios lower, and our differentiated products and solutions are creating solid business momentum along with market share gains. Submissions rose 30% this quarter, which reflects tremendous demand for what we offer and gives our distribution partners a competitive edge. Gross written premiums were up about 15% from a year earlier, well ahead of a fairly flat E&S market. We had expected to beat the market by an even wider margin this quarter, but we made 2 deliberate decisions to put long-term growth and profitability first. First, we put through meaningful rate increases on new Casualty business to reflect the cost of broader coverage and to reinforce underwriting margins. Second, we launched our next-generation underwriting technology, which cut productivity for the time being in return for much greater underwriting throughput and efficiency down the road. Chris will go into these decisions and our new growth initiatives in more detail later on the call. We came into the fourth quarter with 4 new specialty products, a larger underwriting team and distribution network, and a more powerful underwriting system. Taken together, these capabilities increase our capacity to meet rising demand, win additional market share, and compound growth profitably. With that, I'll hand things to Neil Adler to walk through our financial results.
Neil Adler
executiveThank you, Justin. Adjusted net income came in at $14.7 million, versus $22.8 million a (sic) $22.7million in the prior-year period. Underwriting income rose 83.7%, and net investment income climbed 19.1%, though realized and unrealized investment losses offset those gains. Gross written premiums increased 14.7%, with property premiums rising 25% and casualty premiums up 10%. Net written premiums grew 25.8%, reflecting better retention year-over-year, while net earned premiums rose 35.7%. Fee income reached $2.6 million, up from $2.2 million a year ago, driven by standard policy fees rolled out during 2025. Underwriting income for the quarter totaled $19.5 million, yielding a combined ratio of 84.7% versus 88.7% last year, mainly because both our loss ratio and expense ratio came down. Our loss ratio was 57.5%, a decline of 2.5 points year-over-year, reflecting favorable underwriting performance across both property and casualty, including 1.6 points of favorable development. Catastrophe losses represented 4.2% of net earned premiums, up from 4% last year; on the expense side, the overall expense ratio improved 1.5 points to 27.2%. Our operating expense ratio fell 0.8 points year-over-year to 10% of net earned premiums. That improvement reflected earned premiums growing faster than operating expenses, along with higher fee income. Policy acquisition costs as a percentage of net earned premiums also decreased in the third quarter, to 17.2% from 17.9%. The ongoing shift in our business mix toward the brokerage channel lowered policy acquisition costs and helped underwriting margins. Now to investment results. Net investment income was $13.1 million, up from $11 million last year, reflecting a larger investment portfolio and higher interest rates. Realized and unrealized losses were $17.2 million, or $13.7 million net of noncontrolling interest, primarily reflecting a normalization of the substantial gains recorded earlier this year in our utility and infrastructure investments, which have been running well ahead of long-term Street expectations of 5.5% annually. As of the end of the third quarter, year-to-date returns remained above that annual expectation. Our effective tax rate was 24%, bringing net income to stockholders to $14.6 million. Adjusted net income was $14.7 million, or $0.29 per diluted share. Turning briefly to the balance sheet. Cash and investments increased by $33.5 million from the second quarter to $1.24 billion, reflecting strong operating cash flow. Book value decreased by $6.7 million from the second quarter as an increase in retained earnings was offset by a decline in AOCI, due to the material move in U.S. Treasury yields in the third quarter. We did not repurchase any shares during the quarter. Our book value per share ended the quarter at $13.72, up 30% since our IPO. With that, I'll turn it over to Chris to discuss underwriting and operating performance.
Chris Schenk
executiveThanks, Neil. The results for our third quarter show how well our productionized underwriting strategy is working. We posted the strongest combined ratio in the company's history of almost a decade, and submissions rose by 30%. Both our property and casualty businesses expanded at rates we believe were faster than their respective markets. That happened while we keep gaining market share. On top of that, indications for the current policy year loss ratio keep trending favorably, and prior year results developed better than expected. Our property business grew strongly, which runs counter to the prevailing market trends. During the quarter, we kept widening our distribution network, created value through our regional strategies and brought 4 new specialty products to market in record time. We also built and rolled out the next generation of our underwriting platform across our established brokerage businesses, while improving our unit economics. I want to highlight 4 areas that show how we are expanding our business while strengthening underwriting performance. First, coverage certainty is turning into a key differentiator in the casualty market and a major consideration for brokers and insurers; we have studied our clients' businesses and the emerging insurance requirements they face from customers, lenders, regulators and their contractual counterparties. During the quarter, we redesigned several of our core casualty offerings to meet this demand for expanded coverage. At the same time, we launched a marketing campaign, called We Cover What Matters, to drive home the guiding principle of our product strategy. Consistent with our technical approach to pricing, we effectively implemented rate increases on new casualty business to cover the higher cost of product, resulting from this expanded coverage; this enables continued price adequacy as casualty loss trends evolve. Second, we launched 4 new specialty products: Life Sciences, Energy, Environmental and Sports & Entertainment. These offerings were already on our product road map, but we used AI to accelerate their launch in order to meet growing demand from our partners. All in, total development was 4 weeks, down from our originally budgeted 12 weeks, which included technology, product design, form development and pricing. These launches demonstrate the productivity gains, AI is delivering across our business, both in development costs and speed to market. What is most exciting about these new growth opportunities is that we are bringing to the market predictability, speed and simplicity in lines of business that others have deemed to be highly complex and bespoke. Using our micro-segmentation and risk modeling methodologies, we have built a repeatable process for underwriting this business. Third, we deployed our next-generation underwriting platform during the quarter. This adds to the analytical depth of our underwriting. It enhances the value of our micro-segmentation and risk selection, while reducing the work time per quote. Productivity temporarily declined this quarter as our underwriting teams adopted the system. As we enter the fourth quarter, this implementation is starting to produce greater throughput, faster response times and more competitive quotes. Finally, our loss ratio performance continued to validate our underwriting approach. This quarter's results, which include favorable development from the prior year, show how dedicated we are to technical underwriting—covering strategic deployment of coverage, careful risk selection, and pricing that anticipates a higher product cost. All told, we think our product strategy, technology, operational capabilities, and differentiated distribution strategies put us in position to grow profitably in today's environment. Our priority is turning those advantages into additional loss ratio improvements and sustainable underwriting income. With that, I'll hand it back to Justin.
Justin Cohen
executiveThanks, Chris. We believe there are meaningful chances to capture additional market share while also generating robust underwriting profitability. Turning to guidance for the fourth quarter, we anticipate gross written premium growth that surpasses E&S market growth by 15 to 20 percentage points, which keeps our strong business momentum going while preserving the flexibility needed to push underwriting margin improvement further. As a result, we expect our combined ratio to come in under 87% once again in Q4. On the investment side, year-to-date realized and unrealized gains, net of noncontrolling interests, have reached $8.9 million. Consistent with Street assumptions, we apply a long-term annualized return assumption of 5.5% to our utility and infrastructure investments. We think our differentiated access to these strategies delivers meaningful value for shareholders, backed by a track record spanning nearly 3 decades of strong annualized returns with no calendar year loss. At the same time, in light of the higher interest rate environment, we intend to raise our allocation to fixed income investments toward 90% of our total investment portfolio, up from the current level of approximately 80%. Last, on our share repurchase program: although we managed to make stock purchases in the high teens during the second quarter, the stock rose meaningfully in the third quarter, which made open market purchases more difficult to execute; we will endeavor to buy more shares in Q4 in the open market using the $47 million outstanding in our buyback program; and we note that our excess capital far exceeds our remaining buyback capacity. To sum it up, we believe Ategrity is just getting started. Our new products, expanded coverage, next-generation technology and implementation of AI are creating an expanding opportunity set and a runway for further profitable market share gains. With that, we thank you for your time. And operator, please open the line for questions.
Pablo Singzon
analystCould you break down what extra coverages you're offering on the casualty side? And also, how does your offering stack up against what's broadly available in the market?
Chris Schenk
executiveFor competitive reasons, we aren't revealing on this call the additional coverages and new product designs that we've rolled out. What I can tell you is that because of a number of changes at the municipal level, items like residential real estate habitability coverage now fall within scope. A new market norm is taking shape. There are also obscure coverages, human trafficking among them, that are likewise evolving as a market requirement. As for what we've done with our specific products, our new We Cover What Matters campaign is making those clear to the market. Part of the push for more coverage stems from fear about what could be happening at the municipal level, fear about how entanglement with immigration and ICE raids and the like might affect landlords. Part of it is a genuine need for coverage adequacy, which might come from a lender or from the insured clients themselves; but part of it has to do with responsiveness to political trends. So the line we're drawing is being made clear to our trading partners through our new campaign, but for competitive reasons we're not disclosing it on this call.
Pablo Singzon
analystGot it. And on that second question, should we expect productivity to get back to normal in 4Q, simply because the new underwriting system is now rolling out? Or might there be some disruption that carries on into the following quarter?
Chris Schenk
executiveYes. Our technology rollout has actually done better when it comes to stabilization with our employees, training, and all of that. Through this rollout we managed meaningful improvements versus the last time — compared with our prior technology rollout — and much of that comes down to how training was delivered; so on adoption, we have moved faster than expected. One thing we did anticipate as we entered the quarter was the need for extra capacity, underwriting capacity, to absorb some of the inefficiencies that typically follow any rollout — there will always be inefficiency; we planned for that. Some timing delays around hiring and start dates and such carried into the quarter. And that — so effectively, where we stand, we are past a very meaningful change for the organization. And effectively we have some additional capacity to cushion, because we are an organization that, we are doing, I believe we're doing interesting things; we are on the leading edge and what we have planned for that, because over my career and I think it's just widely known in the industry, any technology change will have a lag in terms of productivity. But where this — what this sets us up for is breakthrough productivity, as we go into this quarter and we have some cushion in terms of capacity.
Elyse Greenspan
analystMy first question probably also relates to a few of those new products you mentioned on the casualty side. You said you raised rates. So can you give us a sense of the price gap, I suppose, between the new products and the older ones you're writing?
Chris Schenk
executiveYes; to be clear, we've rolled out a set of new products, and for our current casualty verticals — micro-segments, rather — we've designed a new offering. As you may know, our product strategy involves predesigning coverage. We examine insureds' needs before they actually walk in the door; that lets us be explicit with the market about what we will and won't cover. Alongside that is a technical pricing method where we charge for optional coverage in a very explicit, very mathematical and economically sound manner. So the rate increases you referred to involve adding coverages to our base product across several casualty lines. We won't disclose those specifics here, either, for competitive reasons. But it's — what it lets us do is deliver what the market needs while charging adequate rates; this is the same method we've applied consistently over the last 5 years, as we became solidly committed to technical underwriting. We've used that same method whenever we've made product adjustments, and we charge for the additional coverage. Now, that differs greatly from what many in the industry do. They'll add a lot of trickier, potentially high-volatility types of coverages and not charge for them. And in my view, if you consider the pitfalls of our casualty performance and go back to pre-2020, if you consider what caused that, it was this kind of — erratic kind of talk, improve the product, but don't raise the rates kind of approach; we've been disciplined about it continuously from day 1. When we began engaging with you all as a public company, we talked about technical pricing being sacred to us. That's exactly what we've done here. We — so where we stand right now is, we're delivering what the market needs and we're charging for it. Where the rest of the market stands is, they're either struggling to work out what the market needs or they're delivering it and not charging for it. If they're delivering it and not charging for it, the natural evolution of that will be a deterioration in results; and what we've learned over multiple cycles of doing this again is that we tend to benefit from that. Being an early mover on rates did lead to a reduced conversion ratio, which we had anticipated, and we had a plan in place to bring on more people because, honestly, when conversion comes down, our response is simply to generate a greater number of quotes. We're able to do that quite efficiently and at very low cost. That's been our steady strategy, and it's exactly what we carried out in this instance. We held strong conviction regarding the rates. We aimed to serve what the market needed, and we therefore assembled a plan to accomplish that, all while keeping production at a level that would drive the growth.
Elyse Greenspan
analystAnd my second question, I suppose, right? So you folks are mentioning roughly 15% growth for the fourth quarter, right, which is 15% to 20% above the E&S market. And it sounds like you entered that quarter having rolled out the new next-gen offering. So going into '27, would you expect that new run rate range to be something like 15% to 20% versus the market?
Justin Cohen
executiveElyse, we haven't — disclosing our 2027 view isn't something we're going to do, but what we'd say is the trajectory remains the same. A piece of that guidance of 15% to 20% comes from the fact that we relied on stamping data, adjusted stamping data, as the source for defining the market. And we observed that market ourselves as being down 0% to 5% this quarter. But the stamping data, as you know well, came in at negative 2%, then 19%, then negative 5% during the quarter month by month. And so that adjustment is really meant to reflect greater variability in those numbers and to allow room for that dynamic.
Andrew Kligerman
analystSo I want to follow up on gross written premium growth, and Justin, your guidance has been very clear at 15% to 20%. But when I hear you and Chris discussing coverage certainty, which involves higher rate, it's kind of a mixed bag, correct? People do want coverage certainty, yet they don't like the higher rate. But then you've rolled out 4 new specialty products. You mentioned a little bit about some pressure as you rolled out the technology, but that's all finished now. You've got a couple of big time pluses. And so I know your guidance is 15% to 20%, but it would strike me that you might feel extra good about that 15% to 20%, given everything you accomplished during the quarter, meaning maybe the higher end, maybe better, but it feels like there's some real momentum there. And I want to get your read on that?
Justin Cohen
executiveAndrew, the momentum in the business is outstanding. With the 30% submission growth, this business is really resonating in the market; and even on the coverage point, we had, our soft market playbook is to quote more in a soft market; so we had this temporary hiring gap, that was filled by the end of the quarter, which Chris alluded to. So we feel very strong about where the business is going.
Chris Schenk
executiveSo every box you could tick is what drove the growth figures we posted last quarter. You can tick those off, and honestly you could give a few of them bonus points, since they're still heading the same way; in other words, if you treat them as the leading or consistent indicators behind our growth, nothing there has changed; so let me walk you through a few of them. First, the regional strategies. They keep delivering more than 50% of our growth. Second, our distribution strategy and the reach of that distribution. It keeps expanding exponentially, with higher clicks than earlier quarters, as we've brought on new partners to complement the New England strategy and the Texas strategy that we launched, along with continuing to appoint partners in the Midwest; we've also put money in to entrench ourselves in the Midwest strategy, which is now producing a fresh wave of growth; so we ran marketing campaigns and sponsored events throughout the Midwest during the summer. That has genuinely solidified our commitment to that region, and it's resonating really well with our partners. So we're seeing submission growth take off there once more. So all of those raw materials through to production are in place; on top of that, we can turn out quotes more quickly with less strain on our partners, thanks to the current system. That ranks among the biggest improvements here. So beyond having a submission funnel that keeps growing and more engagement with our partners, we can raise our service level as well as the rigor surrounding the quotes we provide; so that's all extremely encouraging. Now on the new products, we take particular pride in this, because we see ourselves as a company that is very execution-oriented. We think the way to win is to hunt for opportunities in the market, move fast to build solutions around them, and move intelligently. That is precisely what we did with these 4 new products. So they are in market. We are not — we haven't modeled too much into our plans for these. So there is — the reception has been tremendous. I will — we just got back from one of the big industry conferences; this was — that was our key focus in conversations with partners, and the reception for those 4 new lines has been tremendous. There's a lot of dislocation in those lines in the current market, and we saw an opportunity. And in 4 weeks, which is I — nobody on our team who has been in insurance has ever done that. Frankly, we — until these products, we had never done that. Insurance simply does not move that fast. And we managed to do it, and we managed to do it with a high level of sophistication. What we're doing with these products is not just — we're not merely entering as a participant in Life Sciences, for example. We're rolling out a completely new approach to underwriting Life Sciences, and it will eliminate all the back and forth and the hassle that tends to come with that line. Everyone assumes that simply because it has science in the name, it must be complex or there's some mystique surrounding it, right? We've demystified it. We've applied our segmentation approach, our pricing approach, our form design approach — all of that is in place. And when someone looks at our appetite guide, it's a digital appetite guide, where they can literally open up their phone and describe what they're trying to write and see exactly what we're trying to put up. So when I say we did something in 4 weeks, that's a giant leap. And in our numbers right now, we are not even accounting for any upside from that. So yes, to put a finer point on it and agree with you effectively, we have a lot of positives here and a lot of momentum in the business. The fundamentals are strong. And yes, so I'd say that is a comfortable number.
Andrew Kligerman
analystYeah, that's pretty persuasive; and perhaps let's turn to the other section of the income statement. The expense ratio going from 28.7% to 27.2% year-over-year is a good improvement, and given a 10% operating expense ratio, as you grow, and as the mix shifts somewhat further and further toward brokers, how do you expect that expense ratio to trend — not necessarily next year, but across the next 2, 3, 4 years? I mean, could there be a few points of expense ratio reduction in the cards?
Justin Cohen
executiveAndrew, this business has substantial opportunities for scale. We've built a centralized operation, with meaningful headcount and expenses ready to scale as we grow. So we see plenty of opportunity. We won't put a number on it here, but that's how we picture it unfolding, and that's part of the opportunity and how we keep getting more effective in a competitive market.
Chris Schenk
executiveRight, so we can take our efficiency — sorry, our competitiveness in this case — up to the next level. That's essentially what our new platform, or this version of it, accomplishes. As we said before, we already run a highly efficient quoting process and a very smart one; we've strengthened both of those elements. On top of that, the products we're launching at this moment come with 0 upfront investment. There's no added expense we have to recover when we bring those products to market. No fixed cost is involved. Managing fixed costs down is already something we're quite good at, correct? But here — nothing is ever genuinely 0, yet this is about as close to 0 upfront — 0 fixed cost — as it gets. The technology, the forms, the pricing — all of it sits within Ategrity's framework, though it's applied with AI's assistance. If you consider some of the expense involved in getting a product off the ground, you'll get a sense of the potential upside in years ahead as those products scale up. So, first, forms. For these products, we needed to draft more than 400 forms. Normally those would move through a month-long process in a parallel work stream involving lawyers and coverage counsel review, right? So that back and forth carries a high cost. What we've done is apply AI to produce the first draft of highly sophisticated forms, and then we just send them for a quick review by coverage counsel — eliminating the back and forth, as in going to coverage counsel with a first draft rather than attempting to explain what you want the form to be 400 times. That expense alone ought to give you an idea. And considering where legal costs stand, that compounds; so that's a small, very finely detailed illustration. But when you think about what launching a sophisticated product in market requires — it's IT development, legal cost, pricing, analytics, purchasing data. All of these things used to be difficult to absorb during a product launch's first year, and we took pride in managing that historically; but now there's nothing for us to absorb in that first-year launch.
Taylor Scott
analystThe first thing I had was about concentration of investment in digital infrastructure, and I'd be interested in possibly your fixed income portfolio and whether you hold any of that there. But also, and importantly, is there any exposure in the Zimmer Infrastructure Fund that we ought to take into account as we monitor those trends?
Justin Cohen
executiveYes. Understood. As I said during the prepared remarks, we've had roughly an 80% allocation to fixed income ever since — since we became public. And we've discussed by now how we're going to be targeting a 90% allocation. When you consider the Zimmer investments in utilities, those are liquid assets that aren't — that are market neutral, and those aren't — those kinds of loans you're referring to there. So that's a very different exposure, a market-neutral exposure, which has a significant track record of never having had a down year, and it's actively managed. So that is — those are the 2 components of our portfolio, and we don't have the — I think, the sort of exposure that you're pointing to there.
Taylor Scott
analystUnderstood — that's clear. I simply wanted to confirm things on the Zimmer piece. All right. The second question I had concerns casualty, and I just want to grasp better what you're saying there. I realize there's a new product structure, and it does call for rate increases compared with what you were selling before — but I believe it was described as one of the reasons you fell short of the 20% growth. So what exactly is it about that product switch? When I hear you describe it, it sounds as though it will be more attractive and perhaps generate more growth, yet in fact it maybe held your growth back versus what you expected; so what was it in the older casualty product that you needed to adjust, and do people — I'm simply trying to grasp why it became a growth headwind, if it's this new exciting product.
Chris Schenk
executiveYes. So picture buying a car and you wanted leather seats, and in the past you could get leather seats at no charge and — or there were enough car sellers in the market — car dealers in the market, who would hand you leather seats at no charge or whatever accessory you want, frankly; and then leather seats turned into a requirement for cars; and now one car dealer charges for it and one doesn't, right? That is — that's what the approach to coverage in this market has been. It's been the pitfall of so many carriers; we have one of the best-performing casualty books in our view in the industry. The way we have achieved that is we have been meticulous about understanding the cost of product. So whether you describe it as a true rate increase or merely a charge for the enhancement to the product, it is an additional cost to the insured. It's charging for the leather seats. And there are other dealers out there providing the leather seats at no charge. So that's the dynamic we went into this quarter adjusting for. We are willing to provide it, but we are going to charge for it, because it increases the cost of product. We have done this over and over again, and it is so fundamental to our playbook to underwrite to a cost of product that is realistic. And we do not want to have our heads in the sand and think that offering a coverage doesn't really add to the cost of product. It very literally does; and we don't want to have our head in the sand, right? So we have been explicit. And what happens is that the rest of the market, they start to feel the pain and then that business comes back to us. It has happened over and over again. Pricing is an area where we consistently stay out in front, and that matters a great deal to our plan of examining what the product costs and then making rate changes looking forward. That has been our practice all along. As you may remember, we took that approach with property in reaction to tariffs in the prior year; and when you examine the growth rate for property and the way it has moved since we put those changes in place, it follows a cycle. There is a path we follow. This pattern is something we understand. So although we acknowledge that this would have produced a reduced conversion ratio, the submissions we received were more than sufficient to make up for it. The only thing needed was a handful of extra underwriters to lift production, and that is the element where timing slipped.
Justin Cohen
executiveWhat we mean by that headwind is essentially carrying out these kinds of offerings and then experiencing a lag in staffing.
Matthew Heimermann
analystI suppose I was having some trouble, Scott, getting a handle on what's behind the rate change in casualty growth, and I think you covered most of that when you answered his question. The one thing I'd still be curious about is what triggered the decision to start charging for leather seats now. Did some new claims data come in that you're reacting to? Or was it more like — that's it, because the way you first described it, it didn't really come across as a rate change but rather a coverage form change, yet it's kind of — but either way, what triggered it?
Chris Schenk
executiveWhat it is, is a product enhancement, correct? It is not a...
Matthew Heimermann
analystWhat I'm having trouble with, though, is that you call it a product enhancement, and then in the same breath you say others will be negatively affected if this isn't done. That kind of change sounds like a reaction to something — either something you've been through or something you see coming? I'm only trying to understand the context.
Chris Schenk
executiveYes, so let me answer that. I'll give you a bit of background on what we're doing here. We're examining insurance needs; we ran a campaign to support our product strategy and reinforce our philosophy; it's called, We Cover What Matters. Our approach is to study what needs insuring, which may involve a set of fears and a set of genuine requirements coming from their lenders, from regulators, from their clients. So we examine all of that, and we made a deliberate choice not to provide certain coverages that were somewhat optional or nice to have. Usually, bigger, more complex accounts would definitely want that coverage. But over the last 18 months, and I brought this up a couple of quarters ago, coverage certainty was moving into focus. The driver there was the political climate, which takes in things such as immigration and which affects the demand for human trafficking coverage, or Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, requirements imposed on real estate investment companies; they must carry assault and battery coverage. An animal exclusion on the policy is not allowed. There are a few other things they must carry as well. Now, we have steered clear of a number of high severity coverages, because while optional, the market wasn't willing to pay; so our base product took that into account. Once they became mandatory for smaller accounts, we decided that, okay, we will respond; that fits with our approach; we will supply what is mandatory. That fits with our approach, but we will charge for it. So it's not a — it's a difference; it is a shift for us in the risk profile. If you imagined not offering it and not charging for it, that would have a knock-on effect on the results. So in effect, we ran our playbook: provide coverage, charge for it. For our peers, the adverse impact they might see down the road comes from failing to charge for that. If you look back, again, if you look back through the history of casualty insurance, that pattern shows up, and usually it has to do with coverage expansion, whether it's the history on auto, or covering auto, or treating auto as an — ancillary auto as an unimportant exposure that nobody should even charge for; that was once standard practice in this industry, when auto coverage, ancillary auto, hired and non-owned auto came at no charge. And then everybody is aware of how that situation unfolded, since insurers experienced the hit on that ancillary auto and excess casualty specifically — it truly caused significant damage for many; and that's exactly what I meant when I said this kind of trend has another aspect to it, namely other carriers pulling out as those losses materialize. And when you consider how these matters could develop, these will probably arrive at the soonest, and — in terms of the new coverages being offered — these losses will likely show up at the earliest point and are likely to be extremely large.
Matthew Heimermann
analystAll right. I'd like to circle back on — I'm blanking on names this evening, apologies. But in any case, the broader issue of where the floor sits for your operating expense ratio when it comes to productivity. And perhaps — I realize you're reluctant to provide — you plainly don't want to give anything, but a directional pointer on that; still, I'd be interested whether you could walk us through an illustration using these new products you're launching, such as how many underwriters had to be brought on to back that launch. And when you consider the growth using — if you consider what — how much growth you could potentially capture in the market, how many underwriters for that market opportunity does Ategrity require compared with, say, if you were considering your prior life, your former firm or other contemporary firms, or would traditional firms need this, how many underwriters would they require to support this kind of endeavor?
Chris Schenk
executiveYeah. For these lines, if I had to estimate roughly, you need approximately one underwriter — you would require one underwriter per roughly $750,000 of new business premium at a traditional legacy carrier, and that's because you could spend 2 days working on a quote for Life Sciences. It usually entails things such as going to the FDA website to review or even phoning a consulting pharmacist, who is typically on staff, to obtain information. So a great deal of information gathering is needed. That's the reason new business production levels tend to be so low. I — once more, we aren't — we're merely in this space, but — so we won't hand you a number. I lack a benchmark figure for us; however, I can assure you we won't spend more than a few hours even on these complex quotes, as we come into the market. So you can draw a relative — sort of measure a relative gap there. But it's a — that is what we've done. And if you consider what AI's potential is and how it can assist you in aggregating this information, compiling a digital underwriting file, so that the individual can devote their brainpower to assessing the data instead of compiling the data. If you consider where we're achieving the efficiencies, I believe it depicts a highly intelligent underwriting process that is extremely fast and efficient and in fact probably will generate a much better and more competitive quote for the best risk. It's striking just how inefficiently a number of these lines have been underwritten, and that's — if you like — I think we brought this up: one of the reasons we introduced these lines is that slow turnaround time and all the back and forth so many brokers must put up with when they're trying to write business in these spaces. Everything we've offered in terms of speed, intelligence, efficiency, a hassle-free process, predictability in our pricing, a predesigned product — we are offering all of that for these complex products. And it was a direct answer to a massive gap in the market caused mainly by other carriers refusing to modernize. It is a — the opportunities are endless, we saw them and we leaned in very quickly.
Justin Cohen
executiveExcellent. Thank you so much for spending time with us today, and we’re eager to reconnect with you over the coming months. Wishing you all the best.
Operator
operatorThis concludes today's call. Thank you for attending. You may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Ategrity Specialty Insurance Company Holdings transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Ategrity Specialty Insurance Company Holdings earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Ategrity Specialty Insurance Company Holdings or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.