Citigroup Inc. (C) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

January 14, 2020

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Banks earnings 81 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Elizabeth Lynn

executive
#1

Thanks, operator. Hello, everyone, and we appreciate your presence on this call. Our Chief Executive Officer, Mike Corbat, is going to start us off. After that, our Chief Financial Officer, Mark Mason, will guide you through the earnings presentation, which you can download from our site, citigroup.com. Once that's done, we'll gladly take your questions. Before we begin, please note that this presentation could include forward-looking statements, which rest on management's present expectations and are vulnerable to uncertainty and shifts in circumstances. Actual results, capital, and other financial conditions might differ significantly from those statements because of numerous factors, such as the precautionary statements mentioned in our discussion today and those contained in our SEC filings, including, without limitation, the Risk Factors section of our 2018 Form 10-K. Having said that, I'll hand things over to Mike.

Mike Corbat

executive
#2

Thanks, Liz. We started the day by telling everyone that 2019 ended on a high note for us. Fourth-quarter earnings came in at $5 billion, which took our net income for the entire year to $19.4 billion — the best figure we've seen since 2006. Earnings per share were $2.15, more than 30% above the prior-year level, while the $8.04 we posted for the full year came in over 20% higher than 2018. We closed out the year with a return on tangible common equity of 12.1%, slightly above the 12% goal we set for the year, and that figure sits 120 basis points above our 2018 return on tangible common equity of 10.9%. On a constant-dollar basis, underlying revenues for 2019 rose 4% in Global Consumer Banking and also 4% in our Institutional Clients Group. Solid revenue gains, combined with tight control over expenses, let us generate positive operating leverage, all while we kept pouring significant investment into the franchise. Pretax earnings climbed 5%. We also grew both loans and deposits over the year, marking the 16th quarter in a row of such growth. Return on assets improved to 98 basis points for the year. The strong way we finished 2019 came from balanced performance across both products and geographies. North America consumer banking and international consumer banking each delivered 4% revenue growth versus a year earlier. In the U.S., Branded Cards revenues kept expanding at a healthy pace, up 10% for the quarter, which brought the full-year gain to 8%. We kept drawing digital deposits from customers both existing and new, pushing the total to $6 billion for the year. Improved sentiment lifted our wealth management revenues in Asia, and growth in Mexico was helped along by our cards business. Institutional results in the fourth quarter also got a boost from investor sentiment. Fixed Income jumped almost 50%, coming off a difficult final quarter in 2018. Equities fell short of that, largely because derivatives were weak. We kept picking up share in Investment Banking, and the Private Bank turned in solid revenue growth of 6%. Treasury and Trade Solutions kept expanding as well, even with rates lower, as we strive to keep our global network essential for our multinational clients. We finished the year with a strong capital position, posting a common equity Tier 1 ratio of 11.7%, and we remain on track to meet the commitment from Investor Day to give back more than $60 billion of capital to shareholders across three CCAR cycles, having already returned over $22 billion in 2019 by itself. Our dividend gives common shareholders a very respectable yield, and we cut shares outstanding by 11% over the year. Tangible book value per share climbed to more than $70, a 10% gain for the year. I take a lot of pride in how our firm performed. Just like in 2018, we reached our return target for the year even with an uncertain backdrop featuring trade disputes, growing geopolitical tensions, and Brexit still lacking any finality. Like we mentioned when the year began, we had plans in place for a range of outcomes and pulled several different levers to steer the company through that ambiguity and still produce a strong result for our owners. We came into 2020 positioned well competitively — from capital and liquidity through to talent and technology. We keep putting money into places where we spot chances for growth driven by clients, as well as into our infrastructure, given the lasting imperative of being a bank that is unquestionably strong and stable; we can't wait to show you how we'll move our firm ahead across the coming several years. With that in mind, our next Investor Day will take place on May 13. A great deal has shifted since our 2017 Investor Day, and we'll set out our ambitions for this year and past it. So now, I'll hand things to Mark, and after that we'll be glad to take your questions. Mark?

Mark Mason

executive
#3

Thanks, Mike. Morning, everybody. If we begin on Slide 3, we posted net income of $5 billion for Q4, up 18% versus a year ago, since operating margin expansion was partly countered by increased credit costs, and we also gained from a much lower tax rate. Earnings per share rose 34%, and that figure includes the effect of average diluted shares outstanding coming down 10% as we kept repurchasing stock all year long, in line with our capital plan. Revenue came in at $18.4 billion, 7% above the previous year, powered by greater noninterest revenue and showing ongoing strong performance in consumer plus our accrual businesses within ICG, together with a recovery in markets. Expenses were 6% higher than a year earlier, which mirrors increased compensation and volume-driven costs, plus ongoing franchise investments, partly countered by efficiency savings and the runoff of legacy assets. Meanwhile, cost of credit rose because of volume growth and seasoning in consumer, as well as volume growth and several episodic downgrades in ICG, though credit quality overall stayed steady. Our effective tax rate for the quarter came to 12%, which beat our outlook thanks to discrete tax items. Those discrete tax items amount to a $0.25 per share benefit in the quarter. Without that benefit, our tax rate would have come to about 22%. In constant dollars, end-of-period loans were up 2% year-over-year, reaching $699 billion, as 3% growth in our core businesses was partly countered by the runoff of legacy assets, while deposits rose 6%, helped by both our consumer and institutional franchises. Over on Slide 4, we lay out our results for the full year. If we look at 2019, our progress spanned the board, with revenue growth, positive operating leverage, and operating margin expansion in both our consumer and institutional businesses. Revenue rose 4% on an underlying basis, leaving out the FX impact plus the $150 million gain from selling the Hilton portfolio and the $250 million gain from the asset management business in Mexico during 2018. Within Global Consumer Banking, we delivered 4% revenue growth in all three regions. At ICG, revenue likewise increased 4%, with ongoing momentum in our accrual businesses and growth in our market-sensitive businesses. And even while we kept making critical investments in our franchise, we held onto expense discipline and produced roughly flat expenses for the year, matching our outlook. Credit quality stayed broadly stable throughout the franchise, and underlying pretax earnings climbed 5%. EPS increased 21%, and we delivered an RoTCE of 12.1%, surpassing our target for the full year. Now let's move to the businesses. Slide 5 presents Global Consumer Banking results in constant dollars. The consumer business carried on its momentum in the fourth quarter. During the quarter, revenue increased 4%, with every region contributing, while expenses fell 1%, which fueled further growth in operating margin and earnings. Now, when we look at the consumer full year numbers and leave out the two gains from 2018, we still delivered revenue growth of 4%, and with expenses staying about level, that led to a 9% increase in operating margin and 13% growth in pretax earnings. On slide six, you can see more detail on North America Consumer Banking results. Q4 revenues came to $5.3 billion, which was 4% higher than a year earlier. We've kept making solid progress on our strategy of building a more integrated, client-centric relationship model, rolling out new value propositions in cards and Retail Banking and further strengthening our digital capabilities. During 2019, we rolled out the rewards plus cards, the digital lending offerings Flex Loan and Flex Pay, new digital checking and savings accounts, and relationship offers spanning both cards and deposits. On the digital side, we improved account opening and servicing capabilities—for instance, by simplifying the digital account opening journey, which has about doubled our application submission rate. These moves are landing well with clients, producing deeper relationships and stronger growth in deposits, AUMs and loans. And although most of the new offerings launched in 2019 have drawn on our proprietary products and reward programs, in the year ahead we'll broaden our reach and the breadth of our customer base through both existing and new partners—for example, we're widening our American Airlines partnership to add deposit products. We also recently unveiled a new partnership with Google aimed at attracting clients digitally. Importantly, we're developing these capabilities so they scale, with the ability to extend efficiently to other partners. Now to the results of the individual businesses. Branded Cards revenues reached $2.4 billion, a 10% increase year-over-year. Client engagement stayed strong, with purchase sales rising 7%; average loan growth improved to 4%, while net interest revenue as a percentage of loans widened to 921 basis points this quarter. In Retail Banking, deposit momentum kept improving, with average deposits rising 7%, supported strongly by both traditional and digital channels. Our AUMs rose 20%, or 8% once market movements are excluded, reflecting robust engagement from our Citigold clients. We saw ongoing momentum in digital deposit sales, taking our full year total to about $6 billion, compared with the $1 billion raised in 2018. And what we've experienced so far gives us confidence in our ability to move toward national scale in retail, as we deepen relationships over time. That said, Retail Banking revenues of $1.1 billion declined 4% year-over-year, since the benefit of stronger deposit volumes was more than offset by lower deposit spreads. Lastly, Retail Services revenues of $1.7 billion rose 1% year-over-year, with continued growth in loans and purchase sales across the majority of the portfolio. Total expenses for North America consumer declined 4% year-over-year, as efficiency savings more than offset investment spending and higher volume related expenses. Turning to credit. Net credit losses increased 10% year-over-year, reflecting loan growth and seasoning in both cards portfolios. Our full year NCL rate in U.S. For Branded Cards, the figure was 319 basis points, while Retail Services came in at 513 basis points. As we look forward, our expectation for 2020 NCL rates is that they will land at or just above the top of our outlook range — 300 to 325 basis points for Branded Cards, and 500 to 525 basis points for Retail Services. I should also point out that the first half typically brings us higher NCL rates than the second half, which reflects normal seasonality. On slide seven, we present International Consumer Banking results in constant dollars. Revenues for the fourth quarter reached $3.2 billion, up 4%. Within Latin America, consumer revenues rose 6%, helped by a few small episodic gains. Loan and deposit growth in Mexico was muted once again this quarter, since we're observing lower client demand amid decelerating GDP growth and a slowdown in overall industry volumes. Yet importantly, EBIT growth year over year was strong once again this quarter. Moving to Asia, consumer revenues increased 4% in the fourth quarter. We kept seeing robust growth in our wealth management drivers across Asia, with Citigold clients up 10% and net new money up 9% compared with last year.

Mark Mason

executive
#4

All told, fourth-quarter operating expenses in International Consumer Banking rose 3%, since investment outlays and growth tied to volume were partly counterbalanced by savings from efficiency efforts, while cost of credit fell 6%, mostly because of Mexico. On slide eight, we lay out worldwide consumer credit trends in greater depth. A quick note: during this quarter we reorganized our Commercial Banking operations so that every commercial banking activity — among them those formerly disclosed under GCB — is now reported within ICG. The consumer credit trends shown on slide eight incorporate that adjustment. Across North America and Asia, the change produced just a modest bump in the NCL rates we report. Its effect on reported NCL rates in Latin America was bigger, though, because of how large the commercial business is in that region — it carries structurally lower NCL rates and made up about one-third of the GCB loan book. On the whole, credit trends stayed favorable once more this quarter. Let's move to the Institutional Clients Group, on slide nine. Fourth-quarter revenues came to $9.4 billion, a rise of 10%, which mirrors ongoing momentum across the accrual businesses plus robust results in both Investment Banking and Fixed Income markets, partly held back by weakness in equity markets. Total banking revenues reached $5.5 billion, climbing 3%. Treasury and Trade Solutions posted revenues of $2.6 billion, an increase of 2% as reported and 3% in constant dollars, as we generated strong client engagement and solid expansion in deposits and transaction volumes, partly countered by lower interest rates. Within TTS, underlying business drivers stayed robust, reflecting growth from new clients along with deeper relationships with clients we already serve, including 10% growth in average deposits and double-digit growth in our cross-border payment flows for the quarter. Investment Banking revenues hit $1.4 billion, up 6% versus last year and ahead of the market wallet, reflecting strong results in equity and debt underwriting — investment-grade underwriting especially — as we drew on our global capabilities to help clients optimize their funding needs. Private Bank revenues totaled $847 million, up 6%, fueled by more lending and greater investment activity among both new and existing clients, partly offset by spread compression, while corporate lending revenues of $732 million were roughly flat, since growth in the commercial book was canceled out by lower volumes elsewhere in the portfolio. Total Markets and Securities Services revenues came in at $3.9 billion, up 28% from last year. Fixed Income revenues climbed 49%, largely a rebound from the fourth quarter of 2018 combined with strong performance, especially in rates and spread products. Equities revenues dropped 23%, chiefly a reflection of a tougher environment in equity derivatives. Lastly, in security services, revenues declined 1% on a reported basis yet were largely unchanged in constant dollars, as higher volumes from new and existing clients were offset by lower spreads. Total operating expenses of $5.4 billion rose 8% year-over-year, pushed up by higher compensation-related expenses and legal costs. Additionally, credit costs rose to $246 million, driven by growth in overall volume along with a handful of one-off downgrades, though portfolio quality on the whole stays solid; meanwhile, on a full year basis, $563 million in credit costs matched our annual expectations, taking into account both the size and the quality of our portfolio; during full year 2019, net income rose 3%, fueled by a mix of revenue growth, positive operating leverage, sustained credit discipline, and a reduced tax rate; measured in constant dollars, full year revenue growth came to 4%. Looking at clients, our revenue growth was mostly powered by ongoing strong engagement with corporate clients throughout TTS and Investment Banking, plus both Fixed Income and equity markets. Turning to our results by product, more than half our revenues came from banking, which rose 3% as reported and 5% in constant dollars amid continued momentum in TTS, Investment Banking and the Private Bank. Security Services revenues were essentially flat on a reported basis, yet climbed 4% in constant dollars as we keep bringing on new clients and deepening relationships with existing ones. And within Fixed Income, revenues rose 10%, with strong contributions from rates and currencies alike, plus spread products. The combined solid performance across these businesses helped more than offset softness in equities and produced positive operating leverage for the year; and lastly, although our cost of credit came in higher, it matched our 2019 outlook, reflecting normalization in credit trends, and credit quality stays strong with about 10 basis points of losses for the year. Slide 10 presents results for Corporate/Other. Revenues of $542 million rose 8% versus last year, driven by gains on investments partly offset by the wind down of legacy assets. Expenses rose 34%, driven by higher infrastructure costs partly offset by the wind down of legacy assets. And the pre-tax loss came to $80 million this quarter, roughly consistent with our prior outlook. Turning to 2020, we would anticipate a quarterly pre-tax loss of approximately $250 million in Corporate/Other as we keep investing in infrastructure and controls and experience some impact from lower rates, along with a reduced level of gains. Slide 11 presents our net interest revenue, divided between our markets business and the contribution from the rest of the franchise excluding markets at the top of the slide. As you can see, we achieved 3% growth in net interest revenue, or approximately $1.4 billion year-over-year in constant dollars in 2019, matching the high end of our latest outlook, mainly reflecting strength in North America Branded Cards and TTS. Turning to results for the quarter, we saw a rebound in markets, net interest revenues, both year-over-year and sequentially, while growth in the rest of the franchise was more than offset by the headwinds of lower rates. And net interest margin rose by 7 basis points sequentially, also driven by the higher markets net interest revenue. Now, regarding noninterest revenue across Citigroup overall, during this quarter we achieved robust growth compared to the prior year, amounting to about $1.2 billion. That solid conclusion to the year enabled us to produce close to $650 million in noninterest revenue expansion for the entire year, which is 2%, surpassing what we had initially projected as approximately flat. Thus, when examining our overall revenues for the whole of 2019, we saw a 2% increase as reported and 4% on an underlying level, with even input from both NIR and non-NIR sources. As we look forward to 2020, we anticipate achieving certain growth in net interest revenues this year, even with the shift in rate direction, since loan growth and mix are becoming the main factors, and we stay at ease with our capacity to produce ongoing expansion in noninterest revenues this year, fueled by persistent fee increases in both our consumer and institutional divisions. Therefore, taken together for Citigroup as a whole, we look for modest revenue growth compared to last year in 2020 on a reported basis. Turning to slide 12, we present our essential capital measures.

Mark Mason

executive
#5

During Q4, our tangible book value per share rose by 10% compared to the same period last year, reaching $70.39, which came from net income along with a reduced share count, and our CET1 capital ratio went up on a sequential basis to 11.7%, thanks to a decrease in risk-weighted assets. To sum up, 2019 saw us achieve solid advancement through revenue increases across the board, positive operating leverage, growth in earnings, and a substantial capital return to shareholders; we boosted our RoTCE by more than a 100 basis points, reaching a full-year RoTCE of 12.1%, surpassing our 12% goal for that year; we generated 2% revenue growth with even contributions from our consumer and institutional segments. When it came to expenses, we managed to keep them level, even as we made major investments in the franchise, since productivity gains kept substantially exceeding our added investments and also covered costs tied to volume; we upheld our credit standards, expanding our loan portfolio while keeping loss rates in line with our medium-term projections across all businesses and regions. Regarding the tax rate, we kept striving to improve the firm's position after tax reform, and we met our objectives for capital optimization, giving back more than $22 billion in capital via share buybacks and dividends over the year. Crucially, we kept strengthening and expanding our client connections to fuel lasting, client-driven growth and consistent enhancement in returns. Our 2019 outcomes provide us with assurance for 2020, and we remain dedicated to achieving ongoing advancement in the future. Looking at 2020, we anticipate modest topline growth and approximately flat expenses, all while responsibly overseeing the franchise. We foresee cost of credit staying manageable, and we anticipate our effective tax rate will be near 22% in 2020, barring any discrete tax items. As Mike noted, the revenue landscape has shifted since we established our 2020 targets, with reduced interest rates, decelerating global growth, and the strain observed in industry wallets within markets and banking. In conditions comparable to what we face now, we aim to achieve an RoTCE between 12% and 13% for 2020. Thus, we believe we will keep enhancing our returns, and we anticipate the chance to discuss more about this year and what lies ahead at our Investor Day in May. With that, Mike and I are ready to answer any questions.

John McDonald

analyst
#6

Good morning.

Mike Corbat

executive
#7

Good morning.

John McDonald

analyst
#8

Mark, I'd like to raise the topic of deposit growth. It appeared to pick up speed over the course of the year, and by the end of it, you seem to be running at roughly $2 billion each quarter. Do you believe that rate is sustainable given the new programs aimed at growing deposits?

Mark Mason

executive
#9

Well, as you mentioned, we've recorded solid deposit growth across the year, in our consumer operation and on the institutional side too, and in many respects I view that as a meaningful validation of our consumer strategy; on the consumer side we keep concentrating on value propositions so that we expand alongside our card customers and beyond our Retail Banking markets; we've just introduced the high-yield checking account, and we'll keep building new offerings, for instance with our partner at American Airlines; through efforts of that kind, we anticipate fueling further expansion in consumer deposits. As I noted, we've likewise observed solid momentum on the institutional side. We anticipate that expansion will persist, and that stands as a key metric when we consider how we deepen our engagement with clients. So yes, we do anticipate further deposit growth.

Glenn Schorr

analyst
#10

I'm interested — Branded Cards is performing nicely, rising 10%, whereas Retail Services is only up 1%. Could you discuss what makes one grow faster than the other, comparing and contrasting the drivers? Were there any partnerships, repricings, or partners lost along the way? Thanks.

Mark Mason

executive
#11

Sure. Regarding Branded Cards, throughout the year you've heard us mention that we keep seeing solid traction with our clients in that area, purchase sales have risen 7%, and loans on the branded side have kept growing; specifically, 1% growth in quarter one, 2% growth in quarter two, 3% growth in quarter three, 4% in quarter four; so solid momentum there, a nice pace of building up the average interest earning balances, and that has been a major factor and driver behind the 10% growth you mentioned, plus considerable growth for the entire year too. Turning to Retail Services, as you're aware, several portfolios comprise Retail Services; and we've observed solid momentum across a decent number of those portfolios. Yet, obviously included in that is Sears, one of our partners, and the results we have do show the effect from Sears; even so, we achieved the 1% we discussed as guidance for revenue growth this quarter and I believe it's 2% for the entire year. We'd anticipate ongoing pressure from the Sears piece of the portfolio, especially regarding purchase sales. Having said that, it remains a highly profitable portfolio for us. We continue to be quite engaged with the customers there and roughly 80% of the spend happens outside those stores. Thus, profitable with good returns, though under some pressure because of everything happening with that partner.

Mark Mason

executive
#12

Yeah, and that partner matters a great deal, though there's plenty happening on that front.

Mike Corbat

executive
#13

Especially when it comes to the store closures, absolutely.

Steven Chubak

analyst
#14

Mark, to kick things off, I'd like to ask about the RoTCE outlook. It's definitely praiseworthy, and you achieved the 12% this year; however, my understanding is that figure incorporates roughly a 50 basis-point lift from discrete tax items; therefore, when I consider the underlying rate, it lands maybe around 11.6%, and I'm wondering, as we attempt to break down the path toward that 12% to 13% you projected, and given that provisions are probably going to climb in 2020, and presuming no additional tax-side gain, could you walk us through the main factors that would help us reach that 12% to 13%?

Mark Mason

executive
#15

Absolutely. Well, I'd say — when you reflect on our results this year and the significant forces behind our performance, you can look across a lot of the businesses and observe solid revenue expansion at the base and strong EBIT results. We anticipate that revenue expansion will persist, especially as we keep carrying out our consumer strategy and reach deeper into the card customers we serve there and create fresh value propositions we can bring to market, now that we've demonstrated those digital capabilities we've put money into, so ongoing revenue expansion on the consumer side. We also anticipate solid base metrics from our institutional clients, especially in TTS, which sits at the heart of our network, yet additionally connects with the rest of the ICG. So, solid ongoing momentum, deposit volumes, and involvement with both new and current clients on the institutional side, plus in TCS. And so, revenue expansion of a couple percentage points in a supportive capital markets backdrop with expenses held flat. And so, you — we pointed to that early in this year and steered toward it despite all the uncertainty that unfolded across the year, and we're aiming for that once more in 2020; and merging that with ongoing efforts on the cost of credit, and naturally, we'll keep monitoring the tax line, but we think that mix of focus and ongoing productivity gains covering the volume growth we foresee will bring us into the range of the 12 to 13 I mentioned.

Saul Martinez

analyst
#16

So, as a follow-up — actually, first, just to clarify something — I want to confirm I caught what you said, Mark, correctly. Regarding the pretax estimate for Corporate and Other for the coming year, I believe I heard $250 million each quarter. That can't be correct. Did I — is that — it sounds extremely high. Clearly, that's a far greater run rate than what you've had. What was — could you please say again what that forecast was for pretax Corporate and Other?

Mark Mason

executive
#17

Certainly. So, I did mention that we'd anticipate an impact of roughly $250 million per quarter for Corporate/Other; that's above the earlier guidance I had provided of $100 million to $150 million when I last gave guidance on Corporate/Other, so somewhat higher. A few factors affect that or will cause that. One is the effect of rates. We clearly had 3 rate cuts in the back half of 2019. That flows through business performance, but a portion of it also flows through the revenue that sits in Corporate/Other; we also have — we'll have fewer gains. I mentioned some gains we have from investments that flow through 2019 and through the quarter here. So, we're likely to have fewer of those. And then, we are — and I've mentioned the investments that we continue to — want to continue to make or will continue to make in infrastructure and controls. And those investments will take the form of technology and people and focused on things such as data, data governance and infrastructure. And so, those are important investments that we'll be making. And those 3 drivers will be what affects or is underneath that guidance. Not all in the expense line. As I said, we will move to keep the expenses flat.

Jim Mitchell

analyst
#18

Following up on that. I get that capital markets revenue is hard to predict — that's presumably why the RoTCE range is so wide. Still, looking back at the second half of last year, operating leverage has been pretty thin, especially in the Investment Bank — not terrible, but not much. Yet as a firm you posted 7% top line growth, helped by some investment gains, alongside 6% expense growth in the fourth quarter. So what I'm trying to figure out: the top end of that range, I think, would require fairly solid operating leverage. So was there something unusual in the back half — spending that got pulled forward and should taper off — or if revenue grows faster, does that just get eaten up by volume-driven costs, meaning you simply can't extract much operating leverage? Walk me through how expenses might track under different revenue scenarios?

Mike Corbat

executive
#19

Okay, let me — Mark, how about I kick things off and say a few words about the revenue backdrop and what could move it. Jim, looking at 2019 — Mark mentioned the back half and the rate cuts — but across the whole year, I'd characterize it as a period with plenty of factors creating uncertainty, whether that was no China trade deal, USMCA and where it was going, Brexit, Hong Kong. And I think we're now at a point where the outlook suggests some of that is getting resolved. Right? Fingers crossed we get a trade deal within the next couple of days, at minimum phase 1 of it, hopefully USMCA, which appears to be well down the road toward ratification, and it looks like a Brexit deal will come together; so some of those overhangs on the volume-linked portions of the market could clear, and we might see a bit more activity from the C-suite, not to mention some of our investors. Volumes would pick up, and as I look at the activity we're seeing — and again, a fairly solid finish to the year seems reasonable when you combine ECM, when you combine DCM and banking more broadly. M&A, clearly, is off somewhat. That said, the backlog strikes me as quite healthy. And the forward calendar in the other businesses looks strong too. So that's one thing I'd point to as a solid revenue driver.

Mark Mason

executive
#20

Yeah. I suppose I would simply tack on a few points to what was said. So, first, in the widest sense, when we look ahead to two thousand twenty, our aim is expenses that stay level. That being said, a handful of factors are at work that I believe will help the expense line in two thousand twenty and offset any growth tied to volume or the investments we intend to make. So, the first is the productivity savings we have discussed across the last two years, and those are growing faster than investments. As a result, we anticipate an additional five hundred million dollars to six hundred million dollars of productivity gains flowing through two thousand twenty, and that money will fund some of those headwinds or chances to invest. Second, you have heard us mention many times during the year the repositioning charges we have incurred, and severance adjustments as we resized capacity. Those clearly raised expenses during the year, and they will unwind or produce or create benefits in two thousand twenty, once again freeing up capacity. And then, you brought up the back half. In particular, when you examine the ICG in the final quarter, you must remember that the expense growth there reflects ten percent topline growth and eight percent expense growth, but that arrives alongside the compensation increase tied to those revenues and the volume growth tied to that activity we saw in the back half. So, you truly need to consider the full year expense base as we head into two thousand twenty, since the timing for both investments and the productivity benefits will shift across the year. And we will cover far more of this, along with the outlook past two thousand twenty, of course, at Investor Day.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#21

Hi. Could you discuss tech spending and where things stand regarding priorities and progress for both the back office and the front office? I realize that's a wide-ranging question, but perhaps for the back office, things like how many data centers you operate or what share of workload you plan to shift to the public cloud, or for the front office, a bit more detail on the Google relationship and where you see that heading, and then broadly on total tax spend and where you sit in terms of outlaying or realizing returns from prior outlays?

Mike Corbat

executive
#22

Sure; let me kick things off, and Mark, feel free to jump in. Again, I don't want to take away anyone's thunder. We'll cover a good amount of this thoroughly at our Investor Day. But Mike, let me offer a few illustrations. You raised a question previously about data centers. At its peak, Citi had slightly more than 70 data centers. At Investor Day, we shared that we'd gotten down to 20, and as of today we're at 10. What I'd say is, given the need for redundancy combined with GDPR and other factors, I won't claim 10 is a fixed figure. But once you reach 10 while running a worldwide operation spanning close to 100 countries, I don't believe there's a huge opportunity left; and again, we need to watch how the regulatory and legal environment evolves regarding data and data storage. The second area beyond data storage concerns data itself, and in many respects Citi embodies big data, given all the locations where we do business. And considering how the Company was assembled via acquisitions and other bolt-ons, we see a major opportunity to truly modernize or to elevate our data to the next level in terms of delivering benefits around safety and soundness, in terms of delivering benefits around straight through processing, all of which show up as improved client experiences. So, a portion or reasonable portion of the figure Mark is mentioning here regarding spend relates to what I'd call the modernization of our data and our data approach; and so, we're enthusiastic about that. Let me give one illustration on the consumer side that we discussed previously, and I'll bring you back to page 23 once more regarding our consumer drivers. But, consider as an illustration, the work we've been doing around our technology in the call centers, and if you check the upper right-hand box regarding agent contact rates, what you've witnessed is essentially a roughly $15 million decrease in calls, inbound calls to our call centers. Also, the manner in which we now manage those incoming calls — using IVR alongside chat — has shifted things so that our specialists can focus on tougher matters instead of being stuck answering questions like what’s my balance, when is my payment due, or how do I collect my ThankYou points. Because of that, we’re bringing those contract rates down considerably, and that’s visible right there. We’re also absorbing greater volume, correct? As we expand — as your cards footprint expands, as your digital deposit base expands, clearly, engagement rises. So not only are we lowering the absolute count of inbounds, but we’re additionally handling more volume at rates that are obviously quite appealing. So, I believe that emphasizes or brings out why we feel — and I think the figures we’ve reported show it, as we’ve directed some of these technology investments — that we’ve achieved fairly solid paybacks. And we believe the paybacks available from what we currently have lined up definitely justify pursuing them.

Mark Mason

executive
#23

Yeah, that makes sense to me. And Mike, when I think about it, it's sort of like what Mike laid out in four buckets. So when we consider tech spending, these are things we're doing that tie directly to clients. Think about new offerings, new solutions, think about the work we do with our TTS clients, and when we spot pain points — whether that's handling their receivables or handling their invoices — we put money into other technologies, we put money into our own solutions to serve those client-related needs, so to speak. Think about client service from a client experience standpoint and the spending we're doing on things like making on-boarding more streamlined. I mentioned that with regard to digital customers on-boarding, but we also put a lot into how we bring our corporate clients on board in new countries as we enter markets alongside them. Those are tech investments. That's bucket number two. Bucket number three is simply how we make our own operations more streamlined, our own internal processes, how we rely more on automation, less manual reconciliation and manual work. There's an opportunity there to handle data from input all the way through output, as Mike's mentioned. And there are — and paybacks from streamlining internal processes. And then, bucket number four, and I keep it separate because of — partly because of how significant it is, which Mike has mentioned before, and that's cyber. So cyber is a really important tech investment for us, both to protect the franchise and to protect our clients. And we've been growing that over the last five years and expect to keep growing our investment in cyber. So that's just another way to think about the lens we use when looking at tech investment and the need for it as we head into 2020.

Erika Najarian

analyst
#24

Mike, when it comes to this year's 12% to 13% RoTCE, is that number really reflecting everything this franchise can do? And I assume you'll share more specifics with us at Investor Day. If the rate curve stays more or less level and nothing dramatic happens with the worldwide economy, do you believe we could see further gains from this point?

Mike Corbat

executive
#25

Yes. As I've said before, we've discussed the various milestones along the way. You used the term improvement. For how we're thinking about 2020, improvement sits at the very top. Through technology, getting clients more involved, capturing a bigger share of their wallets — many of the levers we've described on both the revenue and cost sides — we believe we can keep delivering improvement and keep moving forward against those targets.

Mark Mason

executive
#26

Absolutely, I’m on the same page. What I mean is that our attention is squarely on delivering meaningful gains as time goes by. During the last couple of years, when we previously discussed how our consumer business and the ICG were performing at their core, we saw advancement. We highlighted that consumer had room to narrow the distance from where it stood two years back to a level we believed could reach roughly 20%. That effort is moving along well, and in our view, additional gains remain possible. We’ve also mentioned before that when you look at our TCE and the way it splits across consumer, ICG, and Corporate/Other, we recognize that eventually a certain share of what sits in Corporate/Other — the TCE connected to surplus capital we hold, the DTA, and Citi Holdings — will gradually diminish, and that alone will help lift RoTCE. So we feel a genuine urgency to enhance our RoTCE in a responsible manner over time. And we plan to keep at it.

Matt O'Connor

analyst
#27

Could you discuss the initiatives underway in equities? Clearly, this has been a priority for the past few years, and you’ve shown some encouraging signs, though this quarter was difficult. I don’t want to exaggerate its importance. It represents just a small percentage of total revenue, yet you’re performing very well at capturing share in fixed income and appear to be picking up some share in banking, so from where I sit it remains the absent component. Perhaps you could outline the strategic vision there and the efforts you’re making?

Mike Corbat

executive
#28

Absolutely. As you may remember, a number of years back we set out on this endeavor when we stood around ninth, aiming to enter the top five. Currently, we sit at sixth. Throughout that period, we’ve steadily gained share, though probably not this year; based on certain coalition figures and similar sources, we appear roughly in line with the market. Still, that’s definitely not our target and not the conclusion of this effort. Considering the steps we’ve taken, you’ve observed us reallocating front-end resources toward this unit, especially regarding cash, while investing in Delta One derivatives and prime brokerage; however, I’d encourage you to consider more than just the trading revenues we report, approximately $3 billion for the year. You should examine the whole operation, which encompasses GCM, contributing roughly another $1 billion in revenue, plus our securities services division adding about $2.5 billion more. Thus, when we assess our equities operation, it amounts to roughly a $6.5 billion enterprise for us. In total, it’s a substantial business; nonetheless, we retain our goal of reaching the top five. Even so, we believe we can enhance profitability and returns within it. Once more, our emphasis is on the full process—from before the trade through execution and afterward—striving to optimize the total advantages for our franchise, but additional effort is needed.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#29

A few things I'd like to ask, starting with the capital aspect of RoTCE. My impression is you suggested there's additional room to hand back surplus capital. What I'm trying to get at is whether, during the latest CCAR cycle, you believe you fully used that request or instead held some back. The reason I ask is I want to know if we ought to anticipate a pickup from this point as we move toward the 2020 CCAR cycle.

Mark Mason

executive
#30

Yes, thank you; clearly, across time we have reduced a substantial portion of the surplus capital on our books. Previously our CET1 ratio stood at approximately 13, and we've been bringing it down so that we'll finish the year at about 11.7. As a result, the amount of surplus remaining will be smaller; naturally we'll proceed through CCAR just as we always have and make a responsible effort to determine the maximum we can give back to shareholders; that matters a great deal for us to keep delivering the ongoing improvement we've described. Naturally, our preference and our first step will be to examine where chances to expand the business exist. So, from the profits we can produce, the priority is funding that expansion, and afterward, whatever remains for shareholders, which includes gains tied to the lower disallowed DTA we've aimed at annually, we'd be glad to hand out through ongoing dividends plus repurchases. Consequently, a certain amount of surplus does exist. Clearly, many elements feed into that assessment, such as the scenario and similar considerations. Even so, we'll stay on the course of giving back the maximum we responsibly can when it's sensible, in light of the growth path we foresee.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#31

So when it comes to that 12% to 13% RoTCE target, the amount of capital you're thinking about giving back, my sense is that it also depends on that range, and that range is partly shaped by the capital. I know you talked about the…

Mark Mason

executive
#32

Yes. That range does factor in ongoing capital return, though not at the payout ratios we've witnessed previously, for the reasons I noted, but it definitely factors in a competitive ongoing payout within that 12 to 13 range, the 12% to 13% RoTCE range.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#33

Right. Okay. Moving on to a different topic, regarding the guidance you provided for your card business, you offered some figures for net charge-offs on both branded cards and retail partner cards. I'm curious whether that figure incorporates what you anticipate the day two CECL effect will be. Also, could you elaborate a bit on your thinking around CECL and what assumptions you're using regarding the reasonable and supportable period from an economic input standpoint?

Mark Mason

executive
#34

Sure. If I may, I'll split that into two parts. Regarding the guidance I provided on cost of credit for cards, or NCL rates, I should note that for cards, I indicated it would come in somewhat above the 300 to 325 basis points medium-term target we had established for branded. My reasoning there — and I believe I've said this before — is that we've observed a larger share converting into average interest-earning balances. So, when you have that greater volume than anticipated, which is positive, it arrives alongside profitable high-quality volume activity, yet it also brings elevated NCLs. Consequently, a substantial portion of the uptick I mentioned that could push us beyond that range stems from that. As for how we approach our forecast and certainly the range I've laid out, we have incorporated the effect of our CECL thinking. Previously I've cited a range of approximately 20% to 30% at the upper end for the day one impact; we anticipate the day one impact will raise reserves by about 29%, to be slightly more exact, or approximately $4 billion. So, that falls within the range I've previously communicated. From a regulatory capital standpoint, that translates to roughly 6 basis points of CET1 capital in 2020, with the full effect reaching about 24 basis points by the time we arrive at the first quarter of 2023. As you might expect, the bulk of the build is on the consumer side. So, regarding your mention of cards, cards are what's driving it, and that's rooted in the expanded coverage going from 14 months to roughly 23 months. So, that represents the more substantial component. It gets offset by a reduction in the corporate build, which nets out to approximately the $4 billion. You brought up day two, and I'm sure we'll discuss that further in upcoming quarters, but clearly there are numerous variables in motion that feed into that calculation, whether it's economic conditions or the business's seasonality — there are multiple factors at play affecting day two. And we take that into account when we examine our 2020 forecast. And since I provided you that range, it incorporates that consideration.

Ken Usdin

analyst
#35

Much appreciated. Morning to everyone. I wanted to ask about capital. Obviously, everyone is anticipating the completion of the SCB and the stress testing rules. And as we come out of the end of the year, my assumption is nothing shifted regarding the GSIB score where you finished up. So I suppose my real question is this: how are you preparing yourselves with respect to expectations — setting aside the schedule for the SCB — for whatever modifications the ultimate framework could bring, along with any changes you now anticipate and have to take into account?

Mark Mason

executive
#36

Certainly. Let me begin by responding straight to what you mentioned about the GSIB score. When we closed the third quarter, the figure came to roughly 628, which sits just under 629, meaning we remain in the 3% bucket. As we finish the fourth quarter, we ought to be comfortably within or inside that same 3% bucket too — that is, beneath 629, somewhere in the low 600s. That reflects certain seasonal patterns we observe and the emphasis we clearly place on making sure we run the business prudently. So by the time the year ends — or for year-end 2019 — the 3% bucket is where we anticipate being. Regarding the stress capital buffer, we have picked up — just as you have — plenty of remarks expressing a desire to see something issued ahead of the upcoming CCAR cycle. Nothing has appeared so far. My belief is it would have to be released by the middle of February. Naturally, we are proceeding with our standard preparation for the CCAR submission. As for how we take this into account or build it into our thinking, I tend to return to the CET1 ratio we run at roughly 11.5%. Within that, we hold several buffers, and one of them exists to reflect our estimate of what the stress capital buffer will do. That amounts to around 50 basis points on top of the capital conservation buffer we maintain. Beyond that, we also keep a management buffer. So my view is that once additional details and clarity about the proposal arrive, we ought to be able to absorb it within the target we already set for ourselves. One last thing I would note: we keep drawing some reassurance from what the regulator has said and indicated — namely that no matter what happens with any single one of these proposals, the SCB included, their aim is capital neutrality throughout the industry, and they intend to evaluate things holistically, accounting for how all these proposals interact together in an integrated way, all while maintaining that capital neutrality.

Ken Usdin

analyst
#37

Understood, got it; and apart from the seasonal pattern, is there anything else — considering the conditions and a few of the complexities of balance sheet swings? The seasonal effect put you within that GSIB, appreciate the clarification on that. Is there anything else shifting when it comes to flows you're seeing from the business beyond the usual course, whether that's through repo markets, the Fed's balance sheet expansion, or is it really just — seasonal?

Mark Mason

executive
#38

The seasonal pattern was it, and clearly we strive to make sure of that. We were serving client needs while managing to stay within that bucket, but nothing beyond that, nothing tied to the sort of repo activity, as you brought up, in the market.

Brian Kleinhanzl

analyst
#39

Yeah. I've got one quick thing about the net interest revenue outlook. Can you take us through the various positives and negatives that give you confidence about achieving growth in 2020? And what macroeconomic presumptions sit behind that?

Mark Mason

executive
#40

Yeah. So like I said, for 2020 we're looking for overall revenue expansion, with contributions from both net interest revenue and areas outside of it. Our expectation is that loan expansion, along with shifts in mix, would fuel the net interest revenue increase we're anticipating. There will likely be — or rather, there will be — a degree of quarter-to-quarter variability, simply because net interest revenue includes market-related business that also runs through it. I went over that pattern during the prior quarter; even so, we anticipate loan expansion and mix serving as the main engines here, counterbalancing clearly a portion of the squeeze coming from the effect of interest rates; and one thing about how we view the outlook ahead. In our 2020 planning, much like what the forward curve shows, we've built in a single extra rate reduction of roughly 25 basis points near the latter part of 2020. So 2020 is going to reflect the entire effect of the three reductions that occurred in the second half of '19, plus one more assumed rate reduction in the second half of 2020.

Marty Mosby

analyst
#41

I appreciate you taking my question. It looks like the net interest margin keeps swinging around, and it's not really parked at or heading toward where the rest of the peer group is. So I wanted to ask — the nice lift you got this quarter doesn't seem to have come out of the balance sheet; it struck me as a real favorable contribution to earnings, given that NII landed higher. Does that hold up better over time, or how do you — what factors cause that to move as we go forward?

Mark Mason

executive
#42

NIM went up about 7 basis points quarter over quarter. As I mentioned before, a big chunk of that came from markets revenue. So we saw a sizable increase relative to the prior year as the fourth quarter recovered; and those things together lifted the NIM up to 263, which works out to 2.63%. Going forward, I actually haven't — I haven't given any guidance about where NIM is headed from here. I have talked about, as I just said, NIR and non-NIR. But obviously, all the things you can imagine, such as loan growth and the mix and every one of those pieces, will matter in terms of how NIM plays out over the rest of 2020.

Marty Mosby

analyst
#43

Then, Mike, I’d like to ask you something. At that most recent Investor Day Citigroup hosted, capital was really the focus. You also discussed the need to put money into the business. The revenue outlook overall was fairly uncertain. So it seems we’re now in a completely different situation, where revenues are beginning to gain a bit of momentum, and the investment that was needed over the past couple of years, you’ve gotten that done, so perhaps less is required going forward. So the dynamic has shifted somewhat—away from capital alone being the thing that drives it, toward the fundamentals of the business starting to improve a little as we head into the next Investor Day.

Mike Corbat

executive
#44

Marty, I wish I could say it’s a simple environment, but as we look ahead, one point is that our client engagement levels, and what you’ve observed since Investor Day—we discussed revenue improvement resulting from possible wallet expansion, yet especially from market share gains. And I think when you examine every one of our businesses—or at least the vast majority of them, that’s what we’ve seen. And I’d anticipate that at Investor Day, we’ll say more on that, since the things we do, I believe, keep connecting with clients, since the investments we’ve put into our products, the investments we’ve put into service, I believe keep producing solid returns. You’ll hear us discuss ongoing expense discipline again, yet you’ll also hear us discuss spending on technology and technology infrastructure and those elements, which we believe deliver a multiple benefit to safety and soundness, deliver a benefit to customer experience and clearly deliver a benefit on the cost side. So, once more, I think, as you point out, the big outsized periods of capital return relative to net income are likely nearing their end. But, I think simultaneously, momentum within the franchise speeds up.

Gerard Cassidy

analyst
#45

Thanks. Good afternoon to you, Mike and Mark.

Mike Corbat

executive
#46

Hi there, Gerard.

Mark Mason

executive
#47

Hi, Gerard.

Gerard Cassidy

analyst
#48

Mark, I realize you’ve already shared a few of the macro assumptions you’re using when thinking about where revenue will go in 2020. Suppose we’re having this conversation twelve months from now and your total revenue growth has come in above the modest level you expect — what indicators should we be watching over the course of the year that would signal stronger top-line performance?

Mark Mason

executive
#49

Absolutely. Looking at 2020, a handful of factors strike me as especially significant. First, staying the course with our North America consumer strategy. During 2019 we built solid momentum there. Our capabilities for reaching customers at a deeper level have advanced considerably. Engagement with clients across that portfolio looks healthy. If that momentum carries into 2020 and accelerates further, you should see it show up as we reach more customers, expand volumes with them, and as they make greater use of what we offer — through purchase sales, other measures, Citigold households, and so on. Second, consider our global corporate clients within the Institutional Clients Group, and the strong engagement we continue to see with them — not only in TTS worldwide, and not only among clients we already have, but also among new ones we’ve brought aboard and scaled with very quickly, across cash management products as well as capital markets offerings such as our FX capabilities. Those clients are gaining real advantages as we put money into technologies that unite those product capabilities, producing solutions that let them operate more efficiently. Greater traction on that front would be another thing to watch, I believe. Third, there’s a point Mike has brought up repeatedly during this call — the discipline of investing throughout the franchise, not only in growth, though certainly in growth around those key capabilities, but also in sharpening how we go to market, how we operate our businesses, and the efficiency surrounding all of that. Taken together, along with return of capital, those are the items you’ll be able to examine at the close of 2020 and understand more clearly why we landed where we did — or above that range. Mike, anything you’d like to add?

Gerard Cassidy

analyst
#50

No. Thanks for that; and to build on what you said, Mark, and pull it together. Mike, clearly credit cards on the consumer side are a textbook case of economies of scale, and banks in the states that are community-based, plus a number of the regionals, genuinely can't go head-to-head with you and your peers at a profit level that the majority of investors would consider acceptable. Now if we turn to the capital markets operation, and I realize you enjoy those same economies of scale along with treasury and trade solutions. In something like 3 or 4 years, do you see the capital markets possibly doing what credit cards did, where the 5 dominant banks essentially control everything, as happens with credit cards, say?

Mike Corbat

executive
#51

Gerard, I'd say you're already witnessing a portion of that. There are various cases we could point to. But take Europe — the reality that in Europe, the 5 biggest banks in that market space are every one of them U.S. banks, correct? And given how these businesses work, those banks are mostly all — we certainly are running with scale in the businesses we compete in. So scale is important; and we gauge scale in many different ways, obviously in the consumer business, but in the institutional business as well. A piece of scale is whether you can invest, control and build your tech stack, your technology infrastructure, to ensure you're at or ahead when it comes to how the business evolves. So, I believe you'll keep seeing consolidation in the capital market space.

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#52

Thank you. A few things I'd like to ask. Mark, to begin with, regarding your 2020 outlook and the revenue growth guidance. If I take how much revenue grew in 2019 as the baseline, there was roughly a $1 billion increase <<inaudible>> which, as I see it, came to around 2%. So what I'm really asking is, looking ahead to 2020, should we expect those security gains <<inaudible>> to keep going, do you have any <<inaudible>> and beyond that, what assumptions are you making?

Mark Mason

executive
#53

Vivek, I'm sorry. I've been having trouble making out what you asked. My sincere apologies. Would you mind saying that again?

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#54

Sure. Regarding top-line growth. If you examine that top-line expansion, on an underlying basis — once you strip out the trade web gain plus a $1 billion bump in security gains — it came in at roughly 2% for the full year 2019. Turning to 2020, Mark, when you consider your guidance, do you anticipate additional security gains, or for these deals to keep going, or any gains from more divestitures of businesses or portfolios? And what are you assuming about rates outside the U.S., Mark?

Mark Mason

executive
#55

Sure. So, that contains a couple of questions. When I think about our forward view and our estimate for top-line growth, we anticipate that revenue growth will come from every one of the buckets I've described. So, underlying core revenue performance is what will drive what we see as we head into 2020. I'd be cautious about viewing 2019 solely through the items you just listed. Other factors exist that don't necessarily reflect the franchise's underlying strength. There are some — so in any case, just be cautious about kind of reducing it to only those two items. But the response to your question is in fact — is in fact that we see solid underlying growth across our businesses. As for the forward view on rates, I suppose what I'd direct you to is this: if you examine kind of our interest rate exposure that's in our Q and will eventually be in our K, we frequently discuss the effect of a 25 basis-point move, and there's an analysis there covering both U.S. dollar and non-U.S. dollar. And you'll see that the non-U.S. dollar impact — to address your question about non-U.S. rates — is not a material impact on a quarter-to-quarter basis, it's a little bit under $30 million a quarter for a 25 basis-point shift in the non-U.S. dollar rates; and clearly, a number of different countries make up that. But it's under $30 million.

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#56

Thank you. A question now for Mike. Mike, if we return to the equities unit — I realize it's a fairly modest operation — but I recall you held substantial ambitions for it, with a $1 billion revenue gain a couple of years back when you discussed it. Lately, there have been some reductions in headcount. I understand you've already allocated additional capital toward prime finance. So what are you doing — what concrete action can you take at this point to truly restart that revenue expansion, since full year '19 was — you're sitting at the bottom end of your range from the last five years?

Mike Corbat

executive
#57

Yes. Before 2019 — and we'll see how the coalition data and other data come through — but it appears we're landing roughly flat relative to the market wallet, whereas over the past several years we'd been gaining share. So first, we need to resume that trajectory of gaining share. The second element, I believe, is that we must keep evaluating the capacity of our front end and keep leveraging technology to power portions of our lower-touch or low-touch operations. I think our sentiment on the derivatives area is fairly positive. I think we're positive on Delta One, positive on prime broker, positive on our security services businesses, and clearly all of those generate higher returns, meaning in certain instances they require less capital. And once more, I think, given the character of the clients we serve, the consolidation of assets, not only within the U.S. but globally, we believe we possess the capability to stand against those and keep gaining share. And again, as we bring the business together to generate the returns it has, that's sensible.

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#58

If I could, just one brief thing, Mark — on CECL day one, you moved to the upper end, from 20% to 30%. Since the economy has proven fairly resilient, can you shed any light on what pushed you to that upper end? Does it reflect a change in your card business, which likewise contributed to that modest rise in charge-offs, or is it something different?

Mark Mason

executive
#59

Once more, it was simply a — nothing in particular shifted as we worked through it. Clearly, we built our model there incorporating changes in balances, but many different elements feed into that. And I believe I've been steering guidance toward the upper end, not only on this call where I discussed the actual figure, but on the last couple of calls; so, no significant shifts that I would call out.

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#60

Thanks.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#61

Hello. I didn't have a chance to raise this before now. When you examine efficiency, your guidance obviously points to improvement going forward, and it has gotten better over the past several years. Yet, if we break the figures down in various ways, it doesn't appear to be as efficient as it might be. Take cards, for instance; so, in what areas — to what extent does technology assist in holding expenses steady, and where do you see efficiency heading in the near term and over the longer term? And I also wanted to add the earlier question about the Google relationship, if I may squeeze that in as well.

Mike Corbat

executive
#62

Let me begin with Google, and Mark, feel free to add your thoughts too. So, the announcement is out. Naturally, from Q1 to Q2, we'll be rolling out certain products with them here in the U.S. And so, the precise design of that isn't available yet, but there's more to share before long.

Mark Mason

executive
#63

Right. And regarding operating efficiency, we show a chart on page 18 of the earnings deck — it’s just the LTM efficiency ratio — and there you can see a continued downward trend: 56.5 for the year, which is 89 basis points of improvement. What I’d say, Mike, is that we set a target — we set one not only on returns but also on flat expenses again this year. We’re getting ready for Investor Day; we’ll make sure we can speak to how we view the future, and also how we view technology and the part it plays today and ahead. We’ve provided you with some descriptions of the benefits the firm gains from investments already made. I think we’ve shown proof points of those consistently producing productivity savings, and we expect that to keep going. But as for far more detail about technology benefits or about how we’re thinking past 2020, I’d request that you wait until we reach Investor Day, where we can discuss it more holistically.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#64

So, I suppose I’ll pencil in May 13th on my schedule. Many thanks.

Mike Corbat

executive
#65

Thanks.

Mark Mason

executive
#66

Thanks.

Elizabeth Lynn

executive
#67

I appreciate everyone being here today; and naturally, should any additional questions come up, don't hesitate to get in touch with our Investor Relations team. Thanks, and enjoy the rest of your day.

Operator

operator
#68

Thanks for joining us on today’s call, everyone. At this point, you’re free to hang up.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Citigroup Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Citigroup Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Citigroup Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.