Citigroup Inc. (C) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
July 15, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jen Landis
executiveAppreciate it, operator. Morning, everyone, and thanks for being here. Just a quick note — the deck for today's call can be grabbed from our site, citigroup.com, and it might include forward-looking statements. Those reflect what management currently expects and are subject to uncertainty and shifts in circumstances. Because of a range of factors, among them the ones laid out in our SEC filings, actual results could differ materially from what those statements suggest. On that note, I'll hand things to Jane.
Jane Fraser
executiveThanks, Jen, and thanks to all of you for being here today. The last time we talked, we described the macro and geopolitical picture as complicated and uncertain. In a way, not much has shifted since then. That said, the headwinds have definitely taken clearer shape. And against that background, I take pride in what our team achieved this quarter as we carry out our strategy and transformation. The string of supply shocks we've been through keeps generating rising costs; and now there's another S in ESG that demands our attention, which is security. Beyond energy and cybersecurity, food security has moved into sharper focus too, with the risk that the humanitarian toll of the war spreads far past Europe. For governments and businesses, resilience is now the top concern. This is adding to inflation, and the Fed and other central banks are responding with more hawkish policies. As a result, U.S. consumer confidence is dropping sharply. Elevated volatility will persist because of higher rates and QT. Still, despite the shift in sentiment, nearly all the data I review indicates the U.S. is not on the verge of a recession. Household savings provide a buffer against future strain, and consumer spending remains far above pre-COVID levels. Also, as any employer can tell you, the labor market remains extremely tight. Similarly, demand among our business customers remains robust and their financial positions are solid, with the softness in revenue thus far attributable to limitations in the supply chain. Therefore, while it's quite possible that a recession will hit the U.S. within the next two years, a downturn more severe than others we've seen recently is highly improbable. I recently came back from Europe, where the situation looks quite different. A very tough winter lies ahead in our view, driven by disruptions to energy supplies. There's also mounting worry regarding secondary impacts on manufacturing and how those might influence economic conditions across the continent. And of course, the overall sentiment grows even gloomier given the widespread belief that the conflict in Ukraine will not conclude anytime soon. Turning to Asia: China's rebound faces real limits, since further lockdowns could hit, the economy carries heavy leverage, and the property sector remains under strain. Against that backdrop of uncertainty, our overall results leave me pleased. Net income came in at $4.5 billion, EPS was $2.19, and RoTCE reached 11.2%. Year-over-year revenues rose 11%, and we remain on pace to meet the expense guidance we set for this year. Services continued its excellent momentum, posting a 28% year-over-year revenue increase. Some of that gain reflects the rate environment, but we also delivered double-digit fee growth, consistent with the strategy we presented to you back in March. TTS especially fired on all cylinders as clients made the most of our global network, producing the best quarter this business has seen in a decade. The market turbulence we experienced in Q1 carried over into Q2, which pushed corporate clients especially to engage more heavily in managing risk, and that helped produce a 25% revenue increase in markets. The swings we witnessed across foreign exchange, rates, commodities and equity derivatives played to the strengths of our mix, and our capital usage became more efficient. And although this activity level reflects where we currently sit in the cycle rather than representing some new baseline for markets, I think we are doing a solid job of steering our clients through these conditions. It also demonstrates that our focus on corporate clients around the world, with their steady trading requirements, sets us apart in market. On the other hand, that same backdrop keeps placing significant strain on the Investment Banking wallet, with our revenues falling 46%. That said, we are observing more lending activity since clients have shown less willingness to secure financing via debt markets amid the recent turbulence. In U.S. personal banking, the favorable trends across our 2 credit card businesses from recent quarters translated into strong revenue growth this quarter, highlighted by 10% growth in Branded Cards. And the elevated payment rates along with the low level of credit losses show you just how resilient the U.S. consumer is. They have, on the other hand, redirected their spending much more toward travel and entertainment, which has now surpassed 2019 levels. While turbulence can create opportunity for our trading desks, weaker asset prices present a headwind for wealth management. Asia once again was affected more severely than other regions, resulting in flat year-over-year wealth management revenues overall. All the same, our wealth strategy is still being executed across several fronts. We're adding to the ranks of client advisers, expanding the physical presence of our Private Bank so that it reaches 20 countries through the addition of Germany and France, and increasing referrals coming from the U.S. branch network. As a result, the core strategic forces driving long-term growth for this business continue to advance. Broadly speaking, we did see a modest increase in reserves because a recession looks increasingly possible, yet the position we're operating from is one of strength. Our capital, liquidity, credit quality and reserve levels are all still solid, and the diversified mix of our businesses leaves us well placed for the choppy waters that lie ahead. Okay, so even though the global landscape looks different now compared to when we shared our Investor Day presentation back in March, the approach we're taking remains the same. We've continued to carry it out consistently and swiftly. On Slide 3, you'll find our quarterly report card, which is meant to give you a way to measure how we're doing; we're intensely committed to those long-term objectives we laid out in March, and to me, the results from this quarter confirm that we're definitely heading in the correct direction. Streamlining the company ranks very high on our list, and we've made solid headway on our divestitures, including finalizing the Australia sale this quarter. We're quite far along in the sales process in Mexico, dealing with the regulatory and legal factors that you'd anticipate in a deal like this; when it comes to Russia, we keep reducing the scale of our operations and taking actions to lower our financial exposure. Because of the complicated situation, we're looking at every option available to exit our Consumer & Commercial Banking businesses, portfolio sales included. As divestitures like Australia move forward, we're starting to remove stranded costs and make our model simpler; this discipline matters greatly if we're to have the resources to put into the businesses where we aim to gain or keep a competitive edge and to guarantee our transformation succeeds. On that note, we were especially happy that the OCC lifted our AML consent order in April. We're dedicated to making sure our technology, controls and processes meet the standards our regulators expect from us and that we expect from ourselves. Let me finish with capital. This quarter we raised our CET1 ratio to 11.9% while giving back $1.3 billion in capital, which included a fairly small amount of buybacks. Our tangible book value per share is now above $80. Despite how solid our reserves and balance sheet are, this year's stress test scenario means our stress capital buffer is going to increase to 4% during the fourth quarter. As a result, over the near term, we plan to build up to a CET1 ratio of about 13%, which factors in the 100 basis point management buffer we maintain. Looking at the medium term, our CET1 target remains 11.5% to 12%. While we build capital, our priority is the dividend, and we're pausing buybacks of our shares. To help keep the journey toward our required levels steady, we have a management buffer available to draw on, and in a few minutes Mark will walk through how we plan to do this. Thanks to the money we're earning and the divestitures we expect to finish, we'll generate a lot of capital. We get how important buybacks are for building shareholder value — particularly with us trading where we are right now — and we're dedicated to resuming them the moment it makes sense. We'll do whatever it takes to make the most of our capital, especially in areas such as Markets, so that we strike the right balance among what clients, investors and regulators require. Taking everything together, through a tough macro and geopolitical backdrop, our team delivered solid results, and this bank sits in a very strong spot to weather uncertain periods while making the most of our strengths. Looking forward, I'm confident, and the early progress we've achieved pleases me. Now I'd like to hand things over to Mark, and then we'd be glad, as always, to take your questions.
Mark Mason
executiveI appreciate that, Jane, and hello everybody. I'll begin by covering the companywide financial outcomes, concentrating on comparisons versus a year ago for Q2, unless I say otherwise; after that I'll take a bit more time on costs, capital and Russia; and then move to how each segment performed and finish with the 2022 outlook. On Slide 4, we present the financial results for the entire company. As Jane noted before, during Q2 we posted net income of $4.5 billion along with EPS of $2.19, an RoTCE of 11.2%, or $19.6 billion of revenues. During the quarter, overall revenues rose 11%, with gains in both net interest income and noninterest revenues. Net interest income was up 14%, thanks to higher rates and strong volumes across ICG and PBWM. Noninterest revenue increased 5%, driven by fixed income and services, which offset the decline in noninterest revenue from Investment Banking and PBWM more than enough. Total expenses hit $12.4 billion, an 8% increase, largely from transformation, business-led investments and volume-related expenses. For the year-to-date period, expenses were up 12%, but excluding divestiture-related impacts, they were up 9%, again from the factors I just mentioned. Cost of credit was $1.3 billion, driven by $850 million in net credit losses and an ACL build of about $400 million. At the end of the quarter, our total reserves stood at about $18.3 billion. The ratio of reserves to funded loans came in at 2.44%, and our CET1 ratio of 11.9% leaves us well capitalized. Turning to Slide 5, we show a walk for Q2 expenses along with the main drivers behind them. Expenses, as I mentioned earlier, rose 8%. Of that figure, 3% came from transformation investments, and roughly two-thirds of those investments are connected to risk, controls, data and the finance programs. Technology accounts for around 25% of the spending in those programs, and today over 9,000 employees are working on transformation. Roughly 2% of the rise in expenses came from investments led by the business side, since we're continuing to add commercial bankers, investment bankers, and client advisers within wealth. We're also continuing to put money into the client experience, along with front-office onboarding and platforms. Revenue growth and volume-driven costs, largely in Markets and cards, made up another 2%. Compensation, together with other investments in risk and control, contributed about 1%, though productivity savings and foreign exchange translation effects offset part of that. Within each of these categories, we're still investing in technology, and that spending rose 14% for the quarter. We have one last item on the cost side. We'd like to share concrete illustrations of the transformation work underway and some of the gains we anticipate down the road. The goals of this effort are better governance and processes, stronger policies, and using technology to tighten our controls. We've been putting money into tech to boost automation and bringing on staff to build these capabilities. Along those lines, we're bolstering our risk management practices and expertise across a number of areas. Take Banking as an example: a new platform is now live, and we've begun merging 37 systems that handle loans into one platform for servicing them. At the same time, we've continued growing our infrastructure to strengthen stress testing across the entire firm, which pays off especially in a market like the current one. Given how much power and importance data holds, we're overhauling how data is governed and organized, and that ought to sharpen both the speed and the quality of our data. With those foundational changes in place, we'll be positioned to streamline and enhance client onboarding and deepening, product development, and make data analytics more incisive across every function. We're likewise making our financial planning process less complex so it can work through multiple scenarios on a more frequent basis, including capital planning that's more nimble. Beyond that, we reached an agreement with a big software company to begin a project spanning several years aimed at updating and consolidating the 16 ledger systems we operate across 121 instances down to a single ledger hosted in the cloud. While these programs remain at an early phase, we anticipate that the cost savings generated by this spending will prove essential in enabling us to fulfill the targets we set on Investor Day. Turning to Slide 6, we present net interest income along with loans and deposits. During Q2, net interest income rose roughly $1.1 billion quarter over quarter, fueled by elevated rates, additional day count, expansion in loans, plus the European dividend season's effect on our Markets business; compared with the same period last year, net interest income climbed about $1.5 billion, propelled by higher interest rates and volumes across businesses. Average loans in ICG grew around 3%, mostly in trade finance, while PBWM saw a 4% increase. Loans in legacy franchises fell, primarily because of reclassifying loans to held for sale; on a sequential basis, our loans' gross yield went up 35 basis points, and interest-bearing deposits' cost rose 20 basis points. Moving to Slide 7, you'll see a summary of our balance sheet along with the main capital and liquidity figures. Our balance sheet stayed very strong. Out of $2.4 trillion in assets, roughly 22%, or $531 billion, consists of high-quality liquid assets, or HQLA, and we held total liquidity resources of about $964 billion. Deposits at period end rose 1%, mostly from TTS and wealth. Looking sequentially, deposits fell 1%, which includes wealth seasonality effects. On the RWA side, both advanced and standardized RWA declined versus a year ago and versus the prior quarter, as we keep optimizing RWA. We closed the quarter with a standardized CET1 ratio of about 11.9%, and standardized is still the binding requirement. On a per-share basis, our tangible book value came in at $80.25, which represents a 3% increase. Turning to Slide 8, you'll see a walk of our sequential CET1 ratio that gives you a closer look at what drove results this quarter, along with what we're aiming for in the coming quarters. First, net income to common reached $4.3 billion, adding 34 basis points. Second, we returned $1.3 billion via dividends and buybacks, which reduced the ratio by about 10 basis points. Third, interest rates affected AOCI through our investment portfolio, subtracting 12 basis points. Finally, a reduction in disallowed DTA added 5 basis points. And last, what remained came from a mix of our net RWA optimization work plus the 12 basis point advantage from completing the Australia sale. We closed out the quarter at a CET1 ratio of 11.9%, which is 50 basis points above the first quarter and comfortably higher than the 10.5% regulatory requirement. We anticipate that our regulatory requirement will rise to 11.5% in October of 2022 to reflect the growth in our stress capital buffer from 3% to 4%. Come January, our regulatory requirement will climb to 12% because of a rise in our G-SIB surcharge. A blend of our earnings generation, completion of divestitures, and ongoing RWA optimization work will serve as key tools as we steer toward our CET1 requirement; and our management buffer, which was created to handle volatility for a limited time, will let us build steadily while still supporting our clients.
Mark Mason
executiveWith that in mind, we anticipate reaching a CET1 goal of around 13% by the middle of 2023, which factors in the higher regulatory ask and presumes a management buffer of 100 basis points. That said, in line with our comments at Investor Day, the medium-term objective stays at 11.5% to 12%. And although buybacks are on hold right now, as I've mentioned previously, we are still dedicated to giving excess capital back to shareholders down the road. Turning to Slide 9, there's an update on our Russia exposure; during 2Q, we cut that exposure by $3.1 billion in local currency terms, though ruble appreciation more than made up for it. Today, the composition of our exposure looks different and now includes a greater share of stronger credit names. On top of that, our net investment in the Russian entity sits at roughly $1.2 billion currently, compared with about $700 million before, thanks to the ruble's rise. Because of the steps we've taken to lower our risk, we now think that across a variety of severe stress scenarios, the estimated potential hit to capital comes to about $2 billion, versus the $2.5 billion to $3 billion figure from last quarter; Slide 10 presents the results for our Institutional Clients Group. Revenues rose 20%, mostly from TTS, Markets, Securities Services and a gain on loan hedges, with a decrease in Investment Banking revenues partly offsetting that. Expenses were up 10%, pushed by transformation, business-led investments and volume-related expenses, partly offset by productivity savings. Cost of credit came in as a benefit of $202 million, with a net ACL release of $220 million and net credit losses of just $18 million. That release mostly stemmed from lower Russia-related risk, partly offset by a build tied to greater global macro uncertainty; the outcome was net income of about $4 billion, an increase of 16%. Average loans grew 3%, mostly from TTS loans, which climbed 17%. Average deposits rose 1%, helped by deeper relationships with existing clients and new client acquisitions; and ICG posted an RoTCE of 16.6%. Slide 11 shows revenue performance by business along with the key drivers we outlined at Investor Day, which we'll walk you through every quarter; in services, the new client pipeline remains very strong and we're deepening ties with existing clients, and we expect that momentum to keep going. At Treasury and Trade Solutions, revenues climbed 33%, helped by 42% growth in net interest income and 17% growth in NIR, as we saw strong growth with both mid- and large corporate clients. And we keep seeing healthy underlying drivers in TTS that point to continued strong client activity, with U.S. dollar clearing volumes up 2%, cross-border flows up 17% and commercial card volumes up 61%. Again, these metrics reflect client activity and fees and together drive roughly 50% of total TTS fee revenue. Securities Services top line rose 16%, with net interest income climbing 41% thanks to elevated rates across various currencies, while NIR increased 8%, mostly due to heightened activity in issuer services. Revenues for markets overall climbed 25%. The macro backdrop suited our strengths, since volatility spurred greater activity among corporate clients. Fixed Income Markets top line increased 31%, powered by FX, rates and commodities, reflecting robust engagement with our corporate customers as we assist them in handling risk tied to turbulent markets. Equity markets revenues rose 8%, fueled by solid equity derivative results, partly countered by reduced client activity in cash and a net drop in prime balances, as weaker asset valuations outweighed new client balance additions. Banking revenues, leaving out gains and losses on loan hedges, declined 28%, pulled down by Investment Banking as rising geopolitical uncertainty and the wider macro picture weighed on client activity, partly offset by stronger revenue from corporate lending. So we feel quite positive about the headway we are making here as we keep strengthening ties with existing clients and bring on new ones. Moving now to Slide 12, we present the results for our Personal Banking & Wealth Management business. Revenues rose 6%, with net interest income expansion partly offset by a decrease in noninterest revenue, mostly from partner payments in retail services. Expenses climbed 12%, pushed by transformation, business-led investments and higher volume-driven costs, partly offset by productivity savings. Cost of credit came to $1.4 billion, up as we built reserves amid greater overall uncertainty in the macro environment versus a net ACL release a year earlier; and NCLs fell 19% as we keep witnessing robust credit performance across portfolios. Average loans increased 4%, lifted by strong growth in Branded Cards plus gains across Retail Services and wealth. Average deposits rose 6%, driven by growth in both retail and wealth. We continue to hold a solid reserve-to-loan ratio of 7.5% in our U.S. Cards businesses. And PBWM posted an RoTCE of 6.8%. Though that is a low return, it stemmed from the ACL build and higher expenses in the quarter; on Slide 13, we lay out PBWM revenues by product along with key business drivers and metrics. Branded Cards revenues increased 10%, driven by higher interest on larger loan balances. We see encouraging underlying drivers, with new accounts and card spend volumes each up 18% and average loans up 11%. Retail Services revenues rose 7%, again driven by higher interest on larger loan balances, partly offset by greater partner payments. So even though payment rates stay elevated, the investments we have been making have generated growth in interest-earning balances of 3% in Branded Cards and 2% in Retail Services, and we believe we will keep growing those balances in the second half of the year. Retail Banking revenues increased 6%, mainly driven by deposit spreads and volumes. In wealth, revenue stayed level, since headwinds from investment fees canceled out NII growth that came from deposits and loan volumes. If you take out Asia, revenue rose 4%; leading indicators are beginning to improve, with average deposits climbing 7% and client advisers climbing 8%. We're also seeing robust acquisition of new clients, with 800 Private Bank clients and more than 50,000 Citigold clients brought on since last year. Slide 14 covers how legacy franchises performed. Revenue fell 15%, mostly because of the completed sale of the Australia consumer business, the wind down in Korea, and weak investment activity in Asia; and as noted earlier, during this quarter we completed the sale of the Australia consumer business, which yielded a capital benefit of as much as $1.5 billion. Slide 15 covers Corporate/Other results. Revenue grew mostly on higher net revenue from the investment portfolio, while expenses declined; on Slide 16, we take a brief look at the full year 2022 outlook. Right now, our expectation remains that full year revenues will rise within the low single-digit range. Compared with Investor Day, the rate curve is clearly providing a tailwind on the NII side, and Markets revenues have risen for the first half of the year.
Mark Mason
executiveThat said, as we noted before, Investment Banking activity is coming in at significantly reduced levels, and that trend is probably going to persist through the rest of the year. On the expense side, our expectation remains growth of 7% to 8%, once you strip out what divestitures contribute. Inflation is having some effect, but in our view the efficiencies we are working to deliver, along with foreign exchange translation, ought to counter those pressures; and having said all that, Jane and I are ready to take your questions.
John McDonald
analystJohn, thanks for the question. Let me try to give you a bit more detail on the 2022 outlook. It does look like the positives outweigh the negatives in terms of keeping that guidance intact. That said, can you share a little additional insight into what you anticipate for net interest income, since the trends there appear robust, and also what you're factoring in for markets during the back half of the year?
Mark Mason
executiveYes, thank you, John. As you mentioned, we've clearly benefited this quarter from the rise in rates, and all signs point to those rate hikes probably persisting for the remainder of the year. As I've mentioned previously, I do anticipate ongoing loan growth, especially in cards, and we began to see some of that emerge earlier than I had expected, since I'd previously indicated it would come in the latter half of the year. We actually saw a bit of that in the second quarter. So we still believe we'll see some improvement there; we also anticipate sustained momentum on the services front, in both TTS and probably Securities Services too. That growth stems from more than just rates, though a share of it certainly does come from rates. The area where we'll feel strain is noninterest revenue, and we definitely saw that this quarter in Investment Banking. We also saw it in certain wealth businesses, especially in Asia. That's where we'd expect some offset to that NII momentum; the truth is, I think we'll need to watch how this unfolds regarding markets. All the uncertainty present in the environment so far has actually worked in our favor, given our emphasis on corporate clients and so forth. But I'd say that looking at the full year, based on what we know today and with the uncertainty out there, I still feel good about that guidance, likely toward the upper end of that low single-digit growth I've referenced.
John McDonald
analystAll right. As a quick follow-up, could you walk us through again how things look right now on your net interest income sensitivity? My understanding is that your approach to evaluating it has shifted, both relative to how peers handle it and in relation to rates. Just bring us up to speed on your current position there, plus what kinds of deposit pricing assumptions feed into that view.
Mark Mason
executiveAbsolutely — it helps to start from a common baseline here, John. Really good question. We should remember that a few different factors matter when we think about sensitivity. For starters, there's clearly the mix. And so in our case, roughly 2/3 of our deposits are wholesale, roughly 1/3 are consumer; obviously 70% of ours are in U.S.-denominated and the rest are kind of non-U.S; and that mix matters when you consider betas, when you consider sensitivity and how they play out, particularly in a rising rate environment at the pace that we've seen, and that pace varies for both the U.S. versus the non-U.S. currencies. And so that's all going to be a factor in how we consider it. You're right; in our disclosure, we forecast our IRE disclosure based on a runoff balance sheet assumption. So, the method I've been talking about for the last few quarters is one that lines up better with what our peers do, and it works off the idea that the balance sheet stays fixed. If we apply that framework and assume rates move by 100 basis points in parallel across currencies, our estimate is that NII would rise by about $2.5 billion. For us, though, the bulk of that would lean toward currencies outside the U.S. Roughly 80% would come from non-U.S. dollar exposure, with about 20% from U.S. dollar exposure. That tilt partly reflects the fact that we've already seen a big jump in the U.S. We've also seen some pickup in non-U.S. rates, but nothing close to what happened in the U.S. So I'll leave it there. Hopefully, that addresses your question.
Glenn Schorr
analystMark, could you go into more detail about the noninterest revenue headwinds in PBWM and Retail Services? From what I'm hearing, it sounds like you renewed an agreement with a partner or something along those lines; and then, thinking more broadly about cards, you just brought up card loans increasing. Rising loans are what all of us want. But given the backdrop and the economic outlook ahead of us, how do you distinguish between a healthy increase in card loans and one that's somewhat worrying?
Mark Mason
executiveSure. Let me address the first one — I'll handle them in sequence. On the Retail Services side, this has nothing to do with renewing an agreement or anything of that nature. What I'm referring to is that within Retail Services, it's a partner business that we operate; what that means is profits tied to the business we produce get shared. So in this environment of rising rates, we've observed — and from a volume standpoint in terms of activity, we've observed growth in the net interest income we've produced. What that means is there are more profits, luckily, to share with our partners. That profit sharing flows through the noninterest revenue line. So it shows up — it shows up as a fee, a contra revenue item, when we share those with clients. That's what's driving the swing you're seeing there, or the pressure we're experiencing in PBWM when it comes to Retail Services. Regarding the cards growth, the cards growth, we feel quite good about it. There's certainly an environmental dynamic at play when it comes to consumers and corporates. But what I'd say is that you've also heard us talk about more marketing spend, more advertising spend, more acquisitions, 18% growth in acquisitions; we've been aiming to grow our customer base there while remaining within our risk appetite. The parameters we've established have been very disciplined about. And that has begun to pay off. And that's part of what I mentioned regarding the loan growth that is materializing. There's nothing we see of significance as we grow these loans that would indicate, first, that they fall outside the focus we've had so far, because they don't, nor that there's any material risk when it comes to outsized losses. If you look at our loss rates, our loss rates are — for Branded Cards, 1.5%; Retail Services, 2.6%. Those are 50% of what we would normally — what we used to describe as a normal loss rate, NCL rate, through a cycle. And so we feel quite good about the loans we're growing. There's obviously risk, but we also feel quite good about the reserves we have.
L. Erika Penala
analystSo Mark, my first question really builds on what John asked. Forecasting net interest income for Citigroup, I've always found that harder to do. And net interest income along with net interest margin definitely came in stronger than expected. Let me put the question a different way, then. The $2.5 billion for every 100 basis point parallel shift — I appreciate that. But when we look at the U.S. forward curve, what's the right way to think about where net interest income goes from that 10.58? And obviously, with a deposit base that's 2/3 wholesale, how should we think about deposit flow, deposit growth and deposit beta when we look at the second half of the year? Put differently, quarter-over-quarter, does that rate of change speed up, stay flat or slow down?
Mark Mason
executiveThat's quite a few questions. What I'd say, though, comes down to a couple of points. First, rates have clearly risen quickly. How fast rates move matters a great deal when it comes to betas. That's especially true on the wholesale corporate side. So betas there have gone up. Where they sit now is probably around slightly — a little bit better than what we'd anticipated. Given the forecast for rates to keep rising, though, we'd expect that momentum to carry on through the back half of the year. Another thing worth noting, just to give you one data point on how forecastable things are from Citi's perspective: in the first half of the year, we did roughly — I believe it was about $1.8 billion versus the prior year ex Markets. So NII ex Markets, $1.8 billion year-over-year in the first half. To give a little more guidance on our thinking, given the rate curve and given our mix, I'd say I expect roughly another $1.8 billion in the back half. So on a year-over-year basis, that's probably around 8-ish percent, or 4% for the full year, based again on our mix, our beta assumption and our current assumptions about how the curve would likely play out. I'll pause there and see whether Jane has anything to add.
Jane Fraser
executiveCorrect. I would mention as well that roughly 65% of Citi's deposit base sits in our institutional deposits, though 55% of those are operational deposits. Since pre-COVID, TTS deposits are up by $134 billion, while operational deposits rose by $141 billion, and nonoperating ones declined. So as QT approaches, we would definitely anticipate a contraction in the volume of deposits across the system. Our expectation is that this would mostly hit nonoperating balances. And I believe we feel quite confident about how sticky the deposit base is, especially internationally, where these accounts are operating accounts that are, frankly, extremely sticky in every kind of environment.
Mark Mason
executiveThat's a fair question.
L. Erika Penala
analystMy follow-up is simply this — the capital you built this quarter was genuinely impressive, all the more so given that it's been a sticking point for investors ever since the SCB came out, in particular. One element I suspect we're overlooking when we think about the ongoing climb to 13% is the CET1 uplift tied to Slide 19. So along the lines of — I believe it was 12 basis points — that came in from the Australia sale, could you possibly provide a range for how the transactions closing in the Philippines, Thailand, Bahrain, and Malaysia during the second half of the year might lift your CET1 and move you nearer to that 13% target?
Mark Mason
executiveYes. If you don't mind, let me respond in a fuller manner, and then I'll definitely make sure to convey how much we anticipate divestitures will contribute on the capital side. So once more, several drivers matter to us as we work toward the eventual 13%, for as long as that figure holds given the SCB. One is clearly income generation. And on income generation, we posted a very strong quarter. Regarding the back half of the year, I'm feeling good, as I've just provided some guidance on. Another is — don't lose sight of this — from the start of the year through the end of the first quarter, we saw 160 basis points on the 2-year from rate increases, plus another 60 during the second quarter. And there will be AOCI effects stemming from that — 34 in the first quarter; and, as we note here, an additional 12 in the second. A pull to par should begin to unfold and keep unfolding across the remainder of the year; that will matter a great deal. The third, which you've heard us bring up, is that we've worked extremely hard at optimizing our RWA, and we'll keep at it. We halted the buybacks. That plays a role. And then, as you noted, the divestitures reaching roughly $1.5 billion in Australia — I've previously discussed about $4 billion for the year in capital impact. With Australia included, I'm presently expecting about $3.5 billion. So that's somewhat below what I mentioned earlier, partly due to some shifting in the timing of certain closings. I still feel good about it. It's just a tough market we're navigating. So that $3.5 billion figure overall ought to give you a sense of how it converts into the CET1 impact we anticipate, at least for the rest of this year. And clearly, as we keep finalizing and — getting signatures on and wrapping up several of those deals that are still left, there will be additional ones ahead.
Jane Fraser
executiveRight, I have a strong hunch that once we get through all this, capital is going to be more than plentiful. And honestly, I take real comfort in the fact that Citi is already sitting in a very strong spot no matter what conditions we face. Like Mark mentioned, several different forces are converging right now — a few of them short-lived — and together they're driving this fast accumulation of capital across the industry. Still, I believe our position is exceptionally solid for whatever comes next, whether you look at robust capital ratios or the overall pool of liquidity we hold. The credit quality across our portfolio is exceptionally strong, and we're well reserved against it. So, as I said, we're eager to get back to repurchasing shares once that build is complete — especially considering the level at which we're currently trading. And I want that commitment to come through to you unmistakably.
Mike Mayo
analystI'm trying to work out whether you folks are fortunate or brilliant, and the basis for my question is that during your Investor Day, essentially at the very beginning, you mentioned having 5 core interconnected businesses, with services and TTS leading the way. Then, only a few months afterward, you post your strongest quarter in a decade; it feels like such a coincidence that you point to that as a growth area and then merely a couple of quarters later, boom, here we are. So what portion of that TTS growth comes purely from one-time items? What portion stems from a higher baseline thanks to, let's say, interest rates? And what portion reflects market share gains? Also, please remind everyone what TTS and Securities Services actually is, since I believe you caught everyone's attention with this quarter.
Jane Fraser
executiveSo let me start things off, and then I'll hand it over to Mark; and Mike, there's a risk here related to how much time you have, because there's plenty to discuss. So my suggestion would be for you to relax at the beach this weekend and thoroughly enjoy reading the supplement, since we've given you plenty of solid facts, proof points, and information covering both the services businesses and the rest, along with the early progress on the strategy. As I mentioned, TTS managed to fire on all cylinders this quarter. Roughly 2/3 of the results came from business actions, while 1/3 came from rates. And as Mark noted, there was very active management of the deposit base, along with beta discipline across every region. And the NIR growth you observed came from cards, payments, receivables, and trade. When you examine the strategic drivers we set out at Investor Day this quarter, cross-border transaction value rose 17% year-over-year; clearing volume increased 2% in U.S. dollar; commercial comp spend climbed 62% as that business recovered; average trade loan balances grew 14%; average deposit balances rose 2%. So that 2/3 which wasn't tied to rates has a very broad and substantive set of drivers supporting it that, as Mark mentioned, places us in a very strong position for continued momentum here. This level of year-over-year growth is very pleasing, but over time we would expect to see it revert to the medium-term guidance we gave you at Investor Day. But this was across the board, with all elements firing. And I want to give a shout-out to Shahmir, the Head of TTS, as well as to our Securities Services team; but he has truly established a culture of intensity, of tremendous focus, of discipline in how he runs the business as well. And I think that also contributes to the confidence that you're hearing from us about this. Mark, would you like to explain what TTS and Securities Services is?
Mark Mason
executiveTo reiterate what you've already heard from us, the TTS franchise sits at the heart of our company. It clearly delivers a network for big multinational customers across more than 90 countries; we handle the entire range of their working capital and cash management requirements. On top of that, we extend trade financing to them along with their suppliers and partners. In many respects, this is fundamentally what sets our franchise apart from the competition; and beyond being inherently a core, expanding, high-returning operation, it's one of those businesses tightly linked to the remainder of the franchise when you consider the Markets business we operate and the FX we handle for clients. So — and right now is an especially pertinent moment for us to be working with those partners as they navigate supply chain challenges; and once again we're there to assist them in getting through those matters and offer them options for their production and operations, plus comparable kinds of services we deliver to our investor client base from a Securities Services standpoint. Look, the approach here didn't begin with Investor Day. That is — we clearly took time with you to discuss that. But this has been a piece of the franchise we've been putting money into continuously. And it matters that we keep doing so, investments in technology, investments in bringing on new clients and the services we offer and upgraded digital capabilities and the operations. So all of that and part of it, what you're seeing here is those investments beginning to bear fruit.
Jane Fraser
executiveThis holds just as much for Securities Services, so my response to what you asked is negative — we are simply staying quite strict.
Mark Mason
executiveYes. Nicely put.
Ken Usdin
analystI've got one more question about RWA. Regarding that $3.5 billion premium you mentioned — could you help us separate what portion hits the numerator versus what comes from an RWA effect tied to the deals already made public? And on a connected note — where do things stand right now with the RWA optimization push?
Mark Mason
executiveThanks. That $3.5 billion figure I brought up is entirely capital. So everything I'm describing lands on the numerator side. It covers both the premium — any gain or effect we realize from a sale — along with the RWA we've assigned to that business. So all of it essentially comes through on the numerator side. Take Australia as an illustration: that figure would capture the RWA we'd tied to that business plus the CTA effect flowing back into capital. Keep in mind, we absorbed a hit when we signed that deal tied to the CTA. I said repeatedly that it would offset once — at the point the deal shut. And indeed it did, and that feeds into the approximately $1.5 billion there; as for the RWA optimization push, that work never stops. We're always reviewing the balance sheet to confirm it's directed toward clients offering the greatest potential for growth and drawing on the full breadth of the franchise, and that will keep going; I believe we — the team performed really well in ICG and especially in Markets this quarter, ensuring we moved forward on the revenue to RWA metric they rely on, which serves as a stand-in for returns. They collaborated closely with clients to steer the recycling of trading inventory in the best possible manner, optimizing collateral positions that — and postings we must make to raise initial margins on derivative trading where it's warranted. So they've been actively managing the balance sheet, and that will continue; we aim to be there serving our clients, while also making certain we deliver a suitable return on the capital we deploy.
Jane Fraser
executiveThis is part of the change that we have been putting in place — with Paco and Andy in Markets, throughout ICG, and throughout the entire firm — reflecting our pledge to shareholders to focus more on returns and to run the business differently in that regard. It's a very clear instance of that, since it's multidimensional.
Ebrahim Poonawala
analystSo I suppose this is about capital, Mark, and it comes in two parts. First, did I understand correctly that buybacks won't be considered at all before reaching 13%? I take Jane's point about part of the AOCI effect being temporary. Why not act a little more opportunistically? And connected to that, how much danger is there that certain deals slip? On Slide 19, I notice you pushed back the timing on several deals. With the macro picture as it is, is that a genuine concern? Or are you fairly confident in the revised schedules?
Mark Mason
executiveYes. Certainly. So here's how I'd put it: clearly, when it comes to buybacks and from a capital standpoint, we'll handle things one quarter at a time. Again, without listing everything that mirrors the surroundings we find ourselves in, the uncertainty out there is plain to see. Clearly, under this SCB, the capital requirements facing the industry are elevated. That's regrettable. Our view is that the industry already held the appropriate level of capital. We have to operate in line with that. The requirement itself is correct. We'll comply with it; but we'll — the SCB lets us make those calls quarter by quarter. At this moment, we're hitting pause. Then next year brings another DFAST cycle, and an SCB will emerge from it; and honestly, the stronger PPNR we've been producing ought to help shape how that turns out. So we'll approach it quarter by quarter. As for the risk around divestitures, once more, we did point out that we're being extremely, extremely open with all of you and with the world. And we do acknowledge certain delays, which we flagged relative to our initial timetable shown toward the back of the presentation. Still, we're quite confident about reaching completion there, and it isn't a question of if, it's a win. And we believe we're keeping to the schedule we laid out for you.
Betsy Graseck
analystLet me ask about capital once more. On Slide 8, you provide the medium-term view — your long-term capital objectives, that 11.5 to 12. Implied in that is an assumption your requirement would drop by roughly 200 basis points. I understand the exits play into that. Can you give us a sense, as things get more simplified, of what the SCB benefit would be? I had thought it was around 25 basis points, but I'm probably wrong there.
Mark Mason
executiveYes. Look, the 11.5 to 12 lines up with what we discussed at Investor Day. And the medium term, as you know, Betsy, for us means 3 to 5 years. There are a few items we're working through, and the divestitures are certainly among them. They will definitely play a part in that, but so will certain other items I've referenced, such as utilization of the DTA, the AOCI pullback and that kind of thing. The divestitures will surely be helpful from an SCB standpoint, though I believe the stronger performance we're seeing will help there too. And importantly, the mix shift we expect from executing our strategy — a mix toward more sustainable, predictable earnings, earnings coming from some of the growth areas we showed this quarter like TTS and Securities Services, et cetera, et cetera. So there is time there. There's clearly a management buffer element to that, which I think is certainly a key factor to consider as our mix evolves. And then there's the G-SIB score. Not only will the divestitures reduce peak-to-trough losses, there are also deposits that will leave with them and balance sheet evolution that will add to the reduction in G-SIB score as well.
Jane Fraser
executiveAbsolutely. I want to emphasize a few things here. Our strategy wasn’t designed simply to deliver higher returns—it was also meant to bring down our capital requirements over time, just as Mark mentioned. You can observe how we’re carrying that out through both the change in our mix and the divestitures. Of course, the regulatory capital framework isn’t something we have control over; even so, we aren’t running the business to react to near-term movements in SCB. As you’re aware, banks saw a great deal of variation in SCB from one year to the next. It depends heavily on which scenario is selected. That’s the reason we stay committed and confident about the medium term.
Steven Chubak
analystI had a follow-up for Mark regarding NII. Given that the Fed keeps moving along with shrinking its balance sheet, I wanted to make sure I understand whether that $1.8 billion lift in NII you referenced for the back half depends on deposits staying flat or on some runoff tied to QT. And specifically within ICG, could you offer any color on what caused Markets NII to rise and how that ought to trend from here, considering the historical liability sensitivity in the Markets business?
Mark Mason
executiveRegarding your first question, as I consider the back half of the year under quantitative tightening, my expectation is that deposit growth will continue somewhat, as I said before. The strain from quantitative tightening will, I believe, definitely unfold gradually. That said, we remain focused on expanding the operating deposits we hold with clients. We believe we have solid traction and the capacity to sustain momentum with those operating deposits. Once more, those deposits position us to genuinely deepen relationships both with multinational clients and with certain commercial clients, where growth and momentum have been strong. So yes, the impact will probably be felt throughout the industry, yet we think we can maintain some momentum, especially with the operating deposits we hold with clients. Turning to Markets NII, you have the European dividend that occurs in the second quarter. That clearly is a factor in this. Also, I would remind you that when discussing Markets, I prefer to focus on total revenues, since the character of the security, the trading, and the activity we conduct there can affect NII and NIR. What truly counts is the total revenues we are producing and generating from that franchise. As you can observe, we achieved 25% growth in Markets revenue year-over-year. So it was definitely a very good quarter for the Markets team.
Matt O'Connor
analystCould you say more about why you described the Russia exposure as somewhat less risky, or a improved mix compared with a few months back? Also, in connection with that, could you break out how much out of the $8.4 billion goes to MNC subsidiaries, since that would appear to carry significantly, significantly lower risk?
Mark Mason
executiveAbsolutely. Well, what we have been doing quite actively from the start of the year, and definitely during the quarter too, is working — we have been working to lower our exposure in Russia, and particularly with the clients we serve in that market; therefore that direct exposure on — in local currency terms, we reduced it by roughly $900 million during the quarter. We lowered and cut the cash and deposits we hold by a further $1.7 billion or so, and then kept reducing third-party related exposure by an additional $400 million. That has come about by working with clients to repay those exposures and loans, and in certain cases, providing them incentives to do that and incentives to shift their deposits out too. So the team has engaged very actively on that front. What has resulted from that is the mix of the exposure we hold, or that is left, has tilted toward the higher-quality names and toward the global subsidiaries we have in the country. And so because of that mix shift toward better quality names and the decrease in exposure, that has enabled us to bring down the reserves we held tied to the direct exposure during the quarter. And so that has been, I believe, good — very good progress when it comes to that reduction. It gets somewhat obscured by the ruble impact, but we have made good progress and we will keep actively doing that. Roughly — Jane, would you like to jump in on that?
Jane Fraser
executiveYeah. Yeah — no, I wanted to chime in, just on the broader picture — let's make one thing very plain. We're steadily shrinking the footprint of our franchise. And like Mark said, the severe stress loss scenario is arguably the clearest gauge of that, and it now sits at roughly $2 billion, brought down substantially. And the character of our exposure has shifted entirely. Especially considering that at present, the bulk of our clients are multinationals. A lot of those exposures carry parent guarantees, which helps a great deal. So what are we doing about them? For many of them — we're assisting with their withdrawals from those countries. And that, as all of you can well understand, requires time. So for the ones who can get out quickly, that's yet another element that can assist us in cutting back our exposure footprint, and our operations as well. Yet there are others for whom it's tougher. I believe we've all witnessed how hard it is to sever the Russian economy from the West in a handful of critical sectors, especially food and especially energy; and as you might expect, given what kind of bank we are, we've found ourselves in the middle of some of those flows that are vital for the West and for the multinationals backing it. And so you wind up with — there's a somewhat mixed picture here in that — yes, we're aiding those who can leave, but we're likewise still fulfilling the role we must and have been requested to in sustaining some of those flows. We expect they'll keep shrinking over time once the energy and food security problems are resolved. But it's a complicated landscape. And at the end of the day, as you can hear from us, we're happy with the way our teams have handled this.
Gerard Cassidy
analystMark, could you tell us — the two of you both mentioned during your opening comments how market conditions affected Investment Banking, and your competitors have experienced the same thing. Should those conditions stay like this through the second half of the year and on into 2023, just for Investment Banking, leaving aside Markets, your trading operation, do you folks — at what point do you folks need to sharpen your approach to costs in that unit? Or do you simply allow it to continue?
Jane Fraser
executivePerhaps I'll start and then hand things to Mark. Strategic advice sits at the heart of our ambition to be the leading banking partner for multinational companies. We keep making deliberate investments in people and in the platform. Expect that to carry on, with special emphasis on technology, health care and financial services, since those are areas where a shift spanning ten years lies ahead in how much they matter; and I have — we have recruited some quite impressive bankers in those spaces. Building share, developing client relationships and realizing the complete payoff from those investments always requires several years. We're also concentrating on the wider chance by drawing on what we've put into Commercial Banking, which I'm certain Mark will cover too, plus Markets and the links between them; so I believe you'll see us approach this strategically with a long-term view instead of merely reacting impulsively when it comes to costs, because what we're doing is constructing this firm for the future. We will, without question, stay exceptionally disciplined regarding expenses. This quarter has shown you that; we've discussed our plans for expenses throughout the company as we get leaner by addressing leftover costs, our organizational setup, and so forth. Still, we take very seriously the investments we're making in essential talent within these fields; and you should not anticipate any major substantive moves in either direction here; we mean this sincerely. Mark?
Mark Mason
executiveJane, I believe you put that nicely. The one point I would make is that this operation requires little capital and delivers strong returns throughout the cycle, so we perceive considerable worth in it. We intend to be ready to scale up once activity resumes. And as you noted, it's quite strategic for us. Since you got me going about the Commercial Banking activity, I have to seize the moment. As you're aware, Jane, we enjoyed a very robust quarter in Commercial Banking. Looking at the revenue momentum there, simply by drawing on the franchise's breadth, revenues in that segment are likely up 25% to 30%. And I recognize that's part of our — as you know, that's part of our core growth strategy we discussed at Investor Day. So solid momentum in that segment of the franchise too.
Jane Fraser
executiveAnd obviously, they're having benefits for our Investment Banking colleagues as well.
Mark Mason
executiveThose synergies, yes.
Jane Fraser
executiveImportant synergies, yes.
Vivek Juneja
analystJane, I've got something to ask you regarding Mexico. In light of what the Mexican President has said, would that put a cap on how much a buyer would be ready to pay? Also, what would you say is the lowest price you'd be prepared to take? And suppose the bids coming in fail to clear that bar — then what's plan B?
Jane Fraser
executiveOh, Vivek, that's not something I'll be answering. That said, I will offer a handful of remarks about Mexico anyway. The interest shown in our Mexican franchise has us pleased, judging from what the buyers have been saying in discussions. And it's — the franchise is doing well. It's doing more than just holding onto its value. It's making a solid contribution to our financial results. Even so, we're still at a very early stage of this process. So once there's news to share, we'll clearly get that out to you fast; but these are early days; and as you'd expect, with a transaction of this nature, we need to work through a variety of regulatory and legal proceedings. We're actively doing so. We're working hard on separating our market-leading institutional franchise, which is a key part of our global network, taking the time necessary to do that the right way; and we have a variety of different options that we can always look at. But it's far too early in the process here to speculate. But so far, so good.
Andrew Lim
analystI suppose what I'd really appreciate is getting a clearer picture from you regarding your recession outlook. It's hard to square how investors are feeling about a downturn — clearly very pessimistic, and apparently far more so than was the case 3 months back. Yet when we examine you alongside certain competitors, the shift in your recession expectations appears merely slightly more downbeat compared with 3 months earlier. So I'm curious about your framework for thinking about recession, since a number of the investors we speak with point to the savings ratio, which sits above where it stood before the pandemic. They also point to mortgage affordability, and that looks genuinely awful. And the impression you're giving is clearly maybe at odds with how you're assessing recession. So maybe you could offer us some detail on your thought process regarding these matters.
Jane Fraser
executiveYes. I'll begin, then hand over to Mark. Look, as we've discussed, today's macro backdrop is essentially defined by the 3 Rs: Russia, rates and recession. Which one dominates depends on your location globally. Within the U.S., our attention leans more toward rates and a looming recession. Both the consumer and the corporate are in good shape. The labor market is incredibly tight. Our worry keeps growing regarding a potential downturn in the coming year. Yet I believe what comes through from us very clearly is our view that the economy stands in a pretty solid position to endure it. Europe is a different situation. The vulnerability of its energy supply to any additional shocks renders it more exposed, and it sits right at the storm's center. Thus we do think the continent is moving toward a recession under the most probable scenario, possibly beginning as soon as this fall; in Asia, there's concern, mostly centered on China and its COVID — Zero COVID policy. The economy is recovering, yet another wave could emerge that proves more troublesome there; so when you combine all these various elements, it somewhat hinges on your location globally. Regarding Citi, look, we've readied ourselves for an array of scenarios; we are fully prepared. We conduct stress tests continuously, given the distinctive mix of risks the global economy confronts at present; we possess a collection of playbooks refined across many years that can be activated when needed; and what counts for a bank approaching recession? Capital, liquidity, credit quality and reserves; and we feel really good regarding all 4 of them. Extremely robust capital ratios, as you've observed, at the close of 2Q. Total liquidity resources just under $1 trillion. More than 80% of our corporate exposures carry investment-grade status. Our consumer clients are largely prime; and let's discuss briefly the ICG NCL for this quarter. Looking at the figures, it came to just $18 million. The corporate's condition as it moves into turbulent times is incredibly robust. And we possess — our ratio of reserves to funded loans stands at 2.44, which is quite solid. That gives us considerable room to maneuver; should a deep downturn occur, I believe you'd observe specific measures being implemented, with another being a more gradual pace; however, in our capacity as a bank, we are prepared for a wide range of possible situations. Mark?
Mark Mason
executiveRight. Jane, regarding what you said about reserves, during this quarter you noticed we recorded a build in reserves. That increase came about partly because of how we see possible downside risk given all the things we're witnessing and worries about a recession. So from a CECL standpoint on reserves, we did add somewhat to the build. And like Jane pointed out, we're quite confident in our reserve levels and the $18 billion tied to our franchise.
Jane Fraser
executiveRight. The consumer, I'd say, is in a pretty uncommon spot as we head into these turbulent conditions, given that households are in solid shape and the job market remains so tight. That's the thing you keep hearing from so many of us. We're not really worried about a recession hitting the States any time soon.
Mike Mayo
analystCan you hear me?
Jane Fraser
executiveYes, we can, Mike.
Mike Mayo
analystAlright, regarding restoring investor confidence, you brought up hitting certain proof points. Could you refresh our memory on which ones have been achieved, and which ones we ought to keep you responsible for in the coming quarter and year?
Jane Fraser
executiveSure. I believe you should keep us responsible for every single proof point that we set out. We engaged in a highly deliberate effort to establish those various KPIs for our strategy. And they are openly included in the materials. We aim to make it as friendly as possible for shareholders and investors in that regard. And we — as is evident this quarter, the drivers beat expectations in certain areas. There were challenges in others. We presented them quite clearly. You saw — since we discussed services, so there's no need for me to revisit that one. Regarding Markets, we discussed enhancing RWA, pushing the business toward better capital productivity, and also expanding the Alpha trade solution business more, which you can observe. Personal Banking going back to IEB and revenue growth through customer acquisition, with purchase sales as a crucial metric. Investment Banking, it's about advancement on important hires and — that we've been doing; clearly it's been a difficult market for that, but I mean, happy with the talent we've attracted and thrilled with the talent we already possess. Wealth faced greater difficulties due to lockdowns in Asia, which is understandable, slowing some advancement on bringing in clients and certain key strategy drivers there. But synergies, more rigorous, tighter processes bolstered by extra metrics on the scorecard, you'll hear us discussing the fulfillment of those synergies increasingly. So there isn't truly any deviation from precisely what we presented on Investor Day, correct? We've set out a strategy we hold great conviction about; we've set out the various metrics to keep us responsible, and it ought to give you a feeling of advancement as we proceed. And we've also discussed our efforts to achieve this cultural shift toward accountability, urgency, intensity, and excellence. And we'll provide you with as many varied signs of where that's succeeding and where it isn't as we move forward.
Mark Mason
executiveLet me just tack one item onto what Jane said. And Mike, bear in mind, please, that for us this quarter has been exceptionally strong. We're feeling quite pleased with it, yet a single quarter is all it is.
Jane Fraser
executiveYes.
Mark Mason
executiveCorrect? During Investor Day, we discussed a long-term plan, plus we provided some insight into targets for the medium term. Those are items you'll keep us responsible for from this point until that time, correct? Therefore, this represents 1 quarter. We feel fantastic regarding it. We're definitely happy that you're noticing it, yet plenty of work remains; we're placing many investments into the franchise that we know will yield returns later on. And we anticipate discussing ongoing advancement across these KPIs. It won't consistently be linear, though we stay confident that we will reach that point.
Jane Fraser
executiveRight, and we absolutely understand how big the task in front of us is, and we are committed to completing it.
Vivek Juneja
analystMark, regarding your 8% NII growth across the entire year, was there anything in Q2 that came in unusually elevated and that we shouldn't extrapolate going forward? I'm simply attempting to square that with the guidance you provided, since carrying it forward as-is would land above 8%. So I'm trying to work out where that gap comes from.
Mark Mason
executiveLook, what I'd say is that every quarter clearly carries its own dynamics, its own rate movements, its own volume — amounts of volume growth, and so on; consequently volume levels differ between Q1 and Q2. And I laid out the way rates would shift from one quarter to the next as well. So, to keep it simple, and since there's fair interest in how we view this on an ex Markets basis, I simply handed you the annualization of the half and what that implies for the entire year. So there's nothing I'd flag past what you'd already observe, namely variances in rates and volumes throughout the businesses.
Jen Landis
executiveI appreciate everyone being here on today's call. Should you have any questions afterward, please get in touch with IR. Enjoy the rest of your day. Thanks so much.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Citigroup Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Citigroup Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Citigroup Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.