Citigroup Inc. (C) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

April 14, 2023

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Banks earnings 88 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Jen Landis

executive
#1

Thanks, operator. Hello, everyone, and I appreciate all of you being here this morning. Let me note that the deck for today, which you can pull down from our site, citigroup.com, might include forward-looking statements. Those statements rest on what management currently anticipates and carry risk as well as shifts in conditions. Because of numerous elements, among them the ones laid out in our SEC filings, actual outcomes could vary significantly from what those statements suggest. Having said that, I'll hand things over to Jane.

Jane Fraser

executive
#2

Appreciate that, Jen, and welcome to everybody on the line with us today. So, 2023 is looking like yet another intriguing year. With all the turbulent developments over the past few weeks, I'll offer a few observations, and after that we'll get into what was a solid quarter. To start, the banking system overall is quite robust. Although a modest number of institutions continue to face hurdles they need to clear, the financial system here in the U.S. has no equal anywhere in the world; and I can say that with confidence, having spent time working within numerous systems across the globe. The American system is made up of a sound blend of community banks, regional banks and bigger global banks, Citi among them. Each of us plays a vital yet distinct role, serving various clients with varying requirements and at varying scale. I'd also highlight how quickly state, federal and international regulators responded, which helped bolster faith in the system at an extremely pivotal moment. It makes me glad that Citi has served as a pillar of stability for the financial system and a wellspring of strength for our clients. None of that happened by chance. We're able to fill this role because our strategy is producing a simpler, more focused bank. We gain from a diversified earnings base and a resilient business model. Our strong balance sheet management, liquidity position and solid risk management frameworks further underpin this. From client selection through capital planning, we take a disciplined approach to running the firm. And credit also goes to our people, and I want to say how proud I am of our colleagues worldwide who put in tireless effort last month serving clients as they looked to Citi as a safe harbor amid the storm. What's happened recently demonstrates that careful asset and liability management is truly essential. Mark will take you through how we approach this along with our emphasis on interest rate risk, liquidity and capital, but I'd like to touch on a few points personally. On the asset side, our loans carry high quality and short duration; we hold highly liquid investment securities along with a substantial cash amount; our available liquidity resources exceed $1 trillion, encompassing $584 billion of HQLA and an LCR of 120%. Plus we keep a varied set of funding sources, among them more than $1.3 trillion of deposits spanning corporates, consumers, industries and regions, a great many of which are operational by nature. Truly, the foundation is our institutional deposit base, making up roughly 60% of our deposits. A large share of these deposits proves especially sticky, since they reside in operating accounts fully woven into how our multinational clients conduct business globally, from payroll to supply chains to cash and liquidity management. Among these deposits, 80% belong to clients who rely on all 3 of our integrated services: payments and collections, liquidity management and working capital solutions. The information we gather from these deposits and the flows tied to them is essential to how our clients handle their efficiency, risk and compliance. This makes our deposit base much more loyal, and it also explains why close to 80% of those deposits come from client relationships that have lasted at least 15 years. On top of that, we run a robust risk framework that examines concentrations in both assets and liabilities, looking across client segments, industries and regions. Given how thorough our stress testing is, we feel good about the scale and character of our exposures. We likewise stay disciplined about counterparty risk, which matters a great deal because financial institutions are so interconnected. Whatever conditions come our way, we're well positioned to handle them — something especially important considering how much uncertainty exists right now. The Fed keeps wielding rate policy in its fight against inflation, and while we're seeing signs of cooling in labor and manufacturing, inflation has proven quite stubborn in services. Our expectation is that the recent event will prove disinflationary and that credit will shrink. Our view is that a shallow recession in the U.S. later this year has now become more probable. In a more severe credit crunch, that could grow worse in both depth and duration. At present, though, what remains most unknown is how terminal short-term U.S. interest rates will be affected and, naturally, how the debt ceiling situation resolves; over in Europe, the ECB is pursuing a comparable yet harder mission to bring inflation under control. Lower-than-expected energy prices have given them some relief, and the outlook remains somewhat more encouraging. Still, the war in Ukraine, sadly, appears nowhere near finished, and Europe confronts deeper structural issues — including the need for more defense spending, elevated energy costs and fiscal burdens — all of which will complicate attempts to curb inflation and boost growth; in Asia, China's reopening is fueling greater momentum across the region, even though the Chinese consumer has rebounded more slowly than anticipated. During my various trips to India, Japan and Hong Kong this year, I witnessed plenty of green shoots myself while speaking with our clients and our bankers. Geopolitics demands our close attention, since the U.S.-China relationship is growing more strained and economic blocs are fragmenting; we observe this showing up as a shift in flows and greater cross-border volume throughout TTS and our global network. Now let me turn to our results for the quarter. Net income came in at $4.6 billion, with an EPS of $2.19. Revenue grew a healthy 6% ex divestitures, and both revenue and expenses landed in line with our guidance. Our RoTCE of almost 11% got a boost from completing the sales of our consumer businesses in India and Vietnam, and absent those gains it would have exceeded 9%. Allow me to walk through how each of our 5 core businesses performed. Within Services, TTS keeps going from strength to strength, with revenues rising 31%. Noninterest revenue climbed 11% quarter-on-quarter, driven by higher cross-border activity and solid results in commercial cards thanks to the rebound in corporate travel. Securities Services had a pretty solid quarter too — a 23% increase, driven by us delivering on new mandates, bringing new AUC on board, and getting a lift from higher rates. On the market side, fixed income revenues rose 4% versus the same period last year, helped by outstanding rates performance and ongoing involvement from our corporate clients. As you probably remember, the first quarter of 2022 was strong as well, yet this quarter ranked as our third best in a decade. Equities, on the other hand, came in far softer, falling sharply in both derivatives and cash, even though revenues still exceeded $1 billion. Banking declined once more, though we saw early signals of a recovery, among them more activity in the investment-grade market. Turning to U.S. Personal Banking, momentum built in our cards businesses as every driver kept normalizing toward pre-COVID levels and past them. Branded cards and retail services posted revenue gains of 18% and 24%. Retail banking grew somewhat, with us still seeing solid momentum in mortgages and installment lending, plus a substantial rise in digital deposits. Over the quarter, we did observe a marked softening in consumer spending growth. Travel and entertainment kept expanding in March, but essentials held flat, and nearly every other spend category declined. Savings rates sit under historic averages.

Jane Fraser

executive
#3

And although households in the top income quintiles still hold about $1 trillion in extra savings, those in the lower quintiles have seen their savings substantially depleted; as a result, we are watching the lower FICO bands closely while economic growth and services spending decelerate. Last, even though revenues declined once more, our confidence in the Wealth business's prospects is unchanged. Notwithstanding the difficult headwinds, Citigold account growth, client acquisition, and client advisers all performed well, and we anticipate those drivers will feed into revenues later in the year and afterward; we also observed the first indications of a long-awaited recovery in Asia. We added to credit reserves this quarter because revolving balances in cards grew and the macro outlook worsened. NCLs kept normalizing in consumer, while the strength of our corporate base showed in yet another quarter of unusually low NCLs. Last, we keep generating capital via our earnings; our CET1 ratio stands at 13.4% now, so we can absorb the temporary upfront impact if we sign a deal for Mexico. As you're aware, we are still pursuing a dual-path approach here, and we are dedicated to raising how much capital we return to shareholders over time. As Slide 3 shows, on top of solid operating performance from our businesses and despite all the other things happening in the industry, we accomplished a great deal this quarter as we carry out the strategy we presented to you at Investor Day. We completed the sales of our consumer operations in India and Vietnam. Indonesia and Taiwan are the next to close later in the year. Once that happens, our Asian consumer sales will be finished, and we are stepping up efforts to remove stranded costs and streamline our organizational structure; we made several important leadership announcements. It's a pleasure that Andy Sieg will join Citi at my table as the new Head of Wealth Management. Andy is a highly regarded leader in this field and arrives after running an $18 billion business with $2.8 trillion in client balances. He is the newest and most prominent illustration of the outstanding talent we've brought in over the past couple of years; since Karen Peetz is retiring, we named Anand Selva as our Chief Operating Officer and asked him to take charge of running our enterprise-wide Transformation program, on top of his existing duties. Anand has spent more than 3 decades at Citi and has a solid record of producing results. When it comes to our transformation, we are entirely focused on carrying out our plan to address the consent orders and enhance our risk and control environment. Mark will take you through particular examples of how we are modernizing our infrastructure, simplifying processes, and improving data quality. Crucially, these efforts are enhancing the client experience and helping us bring Citi's full capabilities to them. As we close, it has been 1 year since our Investor Day, and I take pride in how far we've come and in the unwavering commitment we bring to execution. The path we've chosen is well defined. Our approach to business is both sturdy and varied. Our balance sheet stands on solid ground; execution is advancing nicely. Even with a great deal of upheaval around us, we are meeting both our guidance and the promises we made. Everyone on this team is set on keeping up outstanding delivery. So, I'd now like to hand things to Mark, and after that we'll be happy, just as we always are, to answer any questions you may have.

Mark Mason

executive
#4

Thank you, Jane, and good morning to all of you. I'll begin with the company-wide financial results, and unless I say otherwise, my focus will be on how the first quarter compared with the same period a year earlier; I'll also devote a bit more time to expenses, our balance sheet and capital; after that, I'll go through what each segment delivered. On Slide 4, you can see the financial results for the entire firm; during the first quarter, net income came in at roughly $4.6 billion, EPS was $2.19, and RoTCE reached almost 11%, on revenues of $21.4 billion. Within those numbers are pretax divestiture-related impacts of about $950 million, mostly from the gain on the sale of the India consumer business. Once you set those items aside, EPS was $1.86, and RoTCE was above 9%. During the quarter, total revenues rose 12% as reported, and were up 6% when divestiture-related impacts are excluded, since strength in Services, Fixed Income and U.S. Personal Banking was partly offset by declines in Investment Banking, Equity Markets and Wealth, along with the revenue reduction from the closed exits and wind downs. Our expenses came to $13.3 billion, which is 1% higher than the prior year. If you exclude divestiture-related costs from the prior year, expenses were up 5%, mostly because of the transformation, other risk and control investments and inflation, partly offset by productivity savings and the expense reductions from the exits and wind downs. Cost of credit was about $2 billion, mainly reflecting the continued normalization in card net credit losses and ACL and other provision builds of roughly $700 million, largely tied to a deterioration in macroeconomic assumptions and growth in card revolving balance. At quarter-end, total reserves stood at nearly $20 billion, with a reserve-to-funded loan ratio of about 2.7%; on Slide 5, we lay out an expense walk for the first quarter along with the main underlying drivers. Transformation investments accounted for 1% of the growth, mostly in the data, finance and risk and control programs. And 4% of the increase came from structural items, largely compensation and benefits, including the full year impact of the people we hired last year as well as those we hired in the first quarter. A few key items sit inside this structural bucket. First, other risk and control investments that are enterprise-wide and in the businesses, which represent about 2% of the total expense increase. Second, the impact of additional front and back-office hires. Third, inflation and severance costs. Productivity savings, along with the benefit from foreign exchange translation and the expense reduction from the exits, partly offset all of this. And across the firm, technology-related expenses grew 12%; we recognize these investments have driven a significant increase in expenses, but they are crucial to modernize the firm, address the consent orders and position Citi for success in the years to come; now turning to Slide 6. I want to take a few minutes to walk you through some concrete illustrations of where our investments are going and what we'll get out of them as time goes on. Often, these outlays allow us to make our processes and platforms simpler. To give you one instance, 20 cash equities platforms are being retired and brought together into 1 modern platform, which takes out costs as time passes. We've also merged 11 platforms into 1 global sanctions-screening platform, which cuts down on false alerts, makes things better for clients, and removes costs. Beyond that, we're updating our infrastructure along with the safety of our data and information by strengthening cybersecurity with AI and making our infrastructure and devices more secure, which means fewer operating losses. We're also using cloud-based solutions that lead the industry to update and streamline how our front-office systems connect with the general ledger, which removes manual work and operating costs as time goes on. Our strategy is powered by putting money into the client experience, covering both our technology interface and new innovative products. In TTS, we rolled out our cloud-based instant payments platform for e-commerce clients. We're also rolling out CitiDirect Commercial Banking, our mobile and digital interface for commercial clients, so they can open accounts and reach all products and services across ICG just as our large corporate clients do. Last, we're putting money into data to build advanced decision-making, client-targeting and risk management capabilities, which has let us improve our returns via greater RWA efficiency; and we anticipate that many of these investments will produce efficiencies that let us self-fund future investments as time goes on; on Slide 7, we lay out net interest income, deposits and loans, and there I'll address sequential variances. Net interest income rose by roughly $80 million in the first quarter, mostly because of interest-earning balances in cards. Average loans edged up as growth in PBWM was mostly canceled out by a decline in ICG. Average deposits likewise edged up, thanks to growth in both PBWM and ICG, and our net interest margin went up 2 basis points. On Slide 8, we lay out key consumer and corporate credit metrics; we hold solid reserves for the current environment, at nearly $20 billion. Our reserves-to-funded loan ratio came in at approximately 2.7%. Within that figure, U.S. cards sits at 8.1%; in PBWM, 44% of our lending exposures are in U.S. cards; and of that exposure, nearly 80% goes to customers whose FICO scores are 680 or higher. And NCL rates, though they show some typical seasonality this quarter, remain under pre-COVID levels and are normalizing as we expected. The other 56% of our PBWM lending exposure is mostly in wealth and predominantly mortgages and margin lending. In our ICG portfolio, roughly 85% of our total exposure is investment grade. Of the international exposure, approximately 90% is investment grade or exposure to multinational clients or their subsidiary. And corporate nonaccrual loans are still low, at about 40 basis points of total loans. On this page, you can see that our commercial real estate lending exposures are split between ICG and PBWM, adding up to $66 billion, and 90% of that is investment grade. So even though the macro backdrop and geopolitical situation stay unpredictable, we have strong confidence in our asset quality, our exposures and our reserve levels, and we're constantly examining and stress testing the portfolio across multiple scenarios; Slide 9 gives you our summary balance sheet along with the key capital and liquidity metrics. We've put a few extra metrics on this page so there's more transparency around the way we manage the balance sheet; we keep a very strong balance sheet of $2.5 trillion, funded partly by a well-diversified deposit base of $1.3 trillion spanning regions, industries, customers and account types, which gets deployed into high-quality diversified assets. Our balance sheet mirrors our strategy and our well-diversified business model. We use our unique assets and capabilities to serve corporates, financial institutions, investors and individuals with global needs. First, the bulk of our deposits, $819 billion, are institutional and cover 90 countries; and most of these institutional deposits are typically sensitive to interest rates. So as rates rise, we reprice those deposits, but that repricing considers the overall client relationship along with the level of rates.

Mark Mason

executive
#5

Yet even with that sensitivity to rates, the balances in these accounts are generally steady because they're linked to the operational services we deliver. Alongside these institutional deposits, we also have $437 billion in U.S. retail consumer and global wealth deposits, which you can see in the bottom right corner of the page. Those deposits are broadly spread across the Private Bank, Citigold, Retail and Wealth at Work, and also across geographies and offerings, with 75% of U.S. Citigold clients and approximately 50% of ultra-high net worth clients having stayed with Citi for more than 10 years. Our Wealth deposits also tend to react to interest rates, though that typically means customers shift into higher-yielding deposits and investment products; now moving to the asset side. Broadly speaking, you can view our deposits as mostly put to work in 3 asset buckets: loans, investment securities and cash, which offset the rate sensitivity and add liquidity value to our liabilities; and this allocation also ties into our strategy. We deploy our resources to lend and transact with clients in ways that strengthen the relationship and generate returns for our shareholders while keeping liquidity and capital strong. Our $652 billion loan portfolio is broadly spread across consumer and corporate loans, and the total portfolio's duration is approximately 1.3 years since most of these loans carry variable rates. Roughly 35% of our balance sheet sits in cash and investment securities, which feed into our $1 trillion of available liquidity resources. And at quarter-end, our LCR stood at 120%, meaning we hold about $100 billion of HQLA above what the rule requires to cover stressed outflows. You can find the specifics on Page 27 in the appendix; but the makeup and duration of that liquidity matter just as much as its quantity; and our $513 billion investment portfolio is made up mostly of highly liquid U.S. Treasury, agency and other sovereign bonds and is divided evenly between available for sale and held to maturity, where we've kept a short duration of less than 3 years, so we could gain from higher interest rates. And we manage our assets and liabilities actively and prudently, weighing a range of possible stress scenarios and how they might affect interest rate risks, liquidity and capital. So to sum up, our assets and liabilities line up across interest rate sensitivity, liquidity value and duration and mirror a diversified business model and execution of our strategy. On Slide 10, we present a sequential CET1 walk to give more detail on this quarter's drivers. Starting from where the fourth quarter left off: first, net income to common came in at $4.3 billion, which contributed 38 basis points; second, we paid out $1 billion as common dividends, and that produced a decrease of roughly 9 basis points; third, the effect on AOCI from our AFS investment portfolio produced a 7 basis point gain; and last, the other 4 basis point gain came mostly from the RWA benefit tied to completing our consumer exits; we closed the quarter at a 13.4% CET1 capital ratio, about 40 basis points above the prior quarter, and that figure incorporates a 100-basis point internal management buffer. Turning to buybacks, no stock was repurchased during this quarter, and that call will keep being made one quarter at a time. Slide 11 presents how our Institutional Clients Group performed in the first quarter. This quarter's revenues rose 1%, mainly on services and fixed income, with investment banking and equities offsetting most of that. Expenses were 4% higher, owing to transformation, other risk and control investments and volume-related expenses, partly offset by FX translation and productivity savings. Credit cost was a $72 million benefit, since an ACL release exceeded net credit losses. That produced net income of roughly $3.3 billion, a 23% rise, on the lower credit cost and greater revenues, partly offset by larger expenses. For the quarter, ICG generated a 13.8% RoTCE. Average loans declined 2%, which speaks to discipline around our strategy and returns. Average deposits climbed 3% as we keep bringing in new clients and deepening ties with existing ones. Sequentially, average deposits rose 1%. Measured at end-of-period, ICG deposits fell 3% quarter over quarter, reflecting seasonality since clients typically make tax payments during the first quarter; Slide 12 lays out revenue performance by business along with the key drivers we described at Investor Day; in Treasury and Trade Solutions, revenues climbed 31%, on 41% growth in net interest income and 13% in NIR, with gains across every client segment. Underlying drivers in TTS remain healthy, pointing to consistently strong client activity: U.S. dollar clearing volumes rose 6%, reflecting continued swift share gains; cross-border flows increased 10%, outpacing global GDP growth; and commercial card volumes grew roughly 40%, led by travel spend. So although the rate environment accounted for about 60% of this quarter's growth, business actions accounted for the other 40% as we kept deepening relationships with existing clients and winning new ones. In fact, client wins are up approximately 50% across all segments. These include marquee transactions in which we act as the client's primary operating bank. Over in Securities Services, top-line results climbed 23%, with net interest income surging 94%, fueled by rising rates across currencies, though that was partly counterbalanced by a 6% drop in noninterest revenue stemming from market valuation effects; execution in this segment has us encouraged, since we keep bringing on board assets under custody and administration tied to major client wins, and our outlook on the pipeline of fresh mandates is quite positive. Keep in mind that the services businesses sit at the heart of our strategy and represent 2 of our higher-returning operations, with tight connections throughout the firm. Markets revenues fell 4%, since gains in fixed income were outweighed by equities. Fixed income revenues rose 4% against a particularly robust quarter a year ago, as a strong rates franchise was partly offset by softer FX and commodities. Equities revenues dropped 25%, again versus a strong quarter a year ago, mainly because of lower client activity in cash and equity derivatives. Corporate client flows stay robust and steady, and our revenue to RWA target keeps seeing solid advancement; last, banking revenues, once gains and losses on loan hedges are excluded, declined 21%, pulled down by investment banking as elevated macro uncertainty and volatility went on weighing on client activity. That said, we are seeing revenues improve quarter over quarter, mostly thanks to the investment-grade market reopening. So on the whole, even with a difficult market backdrop, the strides we're making in ICG leave us feeling positive. Moving now to Slide 13, we present the results for our Personal Banking and Wealth Management business. Revenues rose 9%, powered by a 10% increase in net interest income, partly offset by a 1% dip in noninterest revenue caused by weaker investment product revenues in Wealth.

Mark Mason

executive
#6

There was also a 9% rise in expenses, mostly from spending on transformation plus various risk and control programs. Our cost of credit came to $1.6 billion, pushed higher by increased net credit losses amid ongoing normalization across our card portfolios, together with roughly $500 million of reserve build that stemmed largely from worsening macroeconomic assumptions and expansion in card revolving balances. Average loans climbed 7%, with cards, mortgages and installment lending fueling that gain. Average deposits fell 3%, mostly because Wealth clients moved cash into fixed income investments available on our platform. PBWM posted an RoTCE of 5.5%, mainly as a result of elevated credit costs. Turning to Slide 14, we break out PBWM revenues by product along with the key business drivers and metrics. Branded cards revenues rose 18% on the back of higher net interest income. Underlying drivers remain solid, with new account acquisitions rising 17%, card spend volumes rising 9%, and average loans rising 15%. Retail services revenues rose 24%, again helped by higher net interest income. Across both card portfolios, payment rates keep declining. That trend, together with the investments we have been making, helped push interest-earning balances up 18% in branded cards and 11% in retail services. Retail banking revenues rose 3%, mainly from higher mortgage revenue and robust growth in personal installment lending, partly offset by the effect of moving relationships and their associated deposits into our Wealth business; indeed, in line with the strategy, we keep using our retail network to generate more than 13,000 wealth referrals during the first quarter. Wealth revenues fell 9%, hurt by a continuing investment fee headwind and rising deposit costs, especially at the Private Bank. That said, we saw meaningful revenue improvement in Asia, up about 20% sequentially. Client advisers rose 3%, and we are observing net new investment inflows along with strong new client acquisitions throughout our Wealth business, with new clients at the Private Bank and Wealth at Work up 62% and 81%, respectively. Although conditions remain difficult for Wealth, underlying business drivers look strong as we carry out our strategy; Slide 15 presents results for legacy franchise. Revenues rose 48%, helped by a gain on the sale of our Consumer business in India, partly offset by the wind downs and closed consumer exits. Expenses fell 24%, mainly because the prior year included a goodwill impairment, as well as due to the wind downs and closed consumer exits. Slide 16 presents Corporate/Other results for the first quarter. Revenues were higher, mainly from greater net revenue in the investment portfolio. Expenses were higher, driven by transformation and other risk and control investments, partly offset by lower consulting fees. Before we go to Q&A, I want to close with several key points. Even with everything that's happened lately and the economic uncertainty still with us, we're not changing our outlook for the full year on either revenue or expenses. Our balance sheet is very strong, with assets and funding sources that are diversified, plus plenty of capital and liquidity. That puts us in a good position to serve clients and handle any number of scenarios. Across most of our businesses, we're seeing solid momentum in the underlying drivers, and we keep executing on our strategy. The financial path won't be linear, but we're confident we can hit our medium-term targets. And finally, I couldn't be more proud of how our firm and our employees have kept helping our clients navigate the recent environment and support the health of the overall banking system. With that, Jane and I would be happy to take your questions.

Glenn Schorr

analyst
#7

Just a quick one. I really do appreciate how many moving pieces there are, but your NII and revenue production in the first quarter were excellent. And if you simply annualized that, you'd be comfortably above your full-year guide. So I'm just wondering how you're reconciling keeping the guide where it is while running ahead of schedule.

Mark Mason

executive
#8

Yeah. Thank you, Glenn. I'm glad you asked. Look, the first quarter really was very solid for us. Even so, as Jane mentioned when she gave her prepared comments, there's still a fair amount of ambiguity and murkiness in the worldwide macro picture. Honestly, that includes figuring out where interest rates will go and what it will take to bring inflation under control, plus the instability we saw this quarter in certain parts of the sector. Given all of that, and given how betas have shifted — honestly — along with the odds of a downturn later this year, which we factored into our forecast, I still feel good about the guidance we've laid out. And if you look at what's driving that, it's the strength in TTS and in Securities Services, both of which got a lift from last year's rate increases while also growing ties with clients new and old; it's the momentum in cards, which mostly reflects more revolving balances as payment rates begin to ease; and it's the fact that the rebound in Investment Banking and Wealth isn't coming along as quickly as we'd hoped. We'll need to watch how that situation develops as well. Taking all of those factors into account, there are definitely some positives and negatives, which reflects how varied our business model is, yet I still feel at ease with the outlook we've provided. Should anything shift, we'll definitely let you know, but that's our current position.

Glenn Schorr

analyst
#9

Well, I'm grateful for that. Perhaps I could build on what you said, plus the earlier remarks regarding TTS and Securities Services. I attempt to gain wisdom from every error I've made, and I've made plenty. Back in '08, our belief was that housing prices couldn't decline significantly, yet they fell substantially, and every one of us adjusted. Same situation in March — we figured deposits couldn't exit a bank that fast, but they did. So I'd say Slides 25 and 26 deserve people's attention since they're excellent, and they demonstrate how stable your deposit franchise is. Still, I wonder whether history might shift at all — what I mean is, at this moment those are cash and operating deposits that clients maintain with you, they depend on you, and you're completely integrated. Yet are there client concentrations we ought to be aware of? Alternatively, how are you contemplating any major shifts in client behavior compared with earlier times, regarding what they hold at a particular bank? I realize that's a difficult question.

Jane Fraser

executive
#10

Yes. Glenn, let me begin and then hand things to Mark. I'm quite at ease with how thoroughly diversified our deposit base is spanning various countries, industries, clients and currencies. In that regard, it's exceptionally robust. And as you noted, most institutional deposits are woven into operating accounts worldwide, letting clients handle their everyday operations — payroll, working capital, supplier financing, and so forth. What I believe has shifted in this more digital era is that, honestly, these have grown even stickier, because the volume of data, the depth of integration into clients' technology platforms and systems, and the value we draw out and deliver back to clients through combining our FX trade, cash, and other flows is enormously significant for them — in powering their efficiency, their risk management and their financial results too. So both how far that diversification reaches and the growing stickiness relative to the past are things we definitely aren't complacent about, but I think that's why you're seeing certain pages we included in the deck, even toward the end, concerning just how consistent this area is. Mark, anything you'd like to add?

Mark Mason

executive
#11

I'd say you've got that right, Jane. And Glenn, thanks for bringing up Pages 25 and 26 — they make the diversification clear, and they also show how big those deposits are and how steady they've been over a long stretch. The one thing I'd tack on is that, plainly, we're operating in a setting with quantitative tightening happening, and that will affect the industry broadly, as we've already begun to observe. At the same time, we're in a setting where rates are climbing. How that shakes out for the rest of the year remains to be seen. Betas get affected by that, yet price sensitivity, or sensitivity to interest rates, shouldn't be confused with how sticky the deposits are. So we've certainly discussed betas going up, especially within our TTS portfolio, and more so in the U.S. Outside the U.S. they'll clearly keep rising too, but we'll lean on the relationship we hold with those clients and the range of services we provide to sway and shape pricing; and even more crucially, given how operational they are, we regard them as quite stable.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#12

Jane, a few calls back I pushed you on how complicated it gets when you operate in that many countries. Your response was that TTS was the crown jewel. And now here it is, up nearly 1/3 compared with a year ago. So since your Investor Day, things look good so far. Could you walk us through the fee growth a bit? The NII growth is something we more or less follow, but fees are also growing at a double-digit pace. I take that to be money in motion. And I believe your description of it was the world's largest wholesale global payment system. What is driving the double-digit top line growth there?

Jane Fraser

executive
#13

Thanks, Mike, and that's a terrific question. One figure I might be even happier about than the outstanding revenue growth is the fee growth we saw quarter-over-quarter. Clearly, TTS has gotten a lift from the rates environment, but we've also gotten a lift from what drives the franchise; and the fee revenues arrive from several products and several offerings that we have. Our typical approach, and one we've stuck with, is to grow fee revenue as a percentage of the underlying growth in TTS; that got somewhat obscured while the rates environment was climbing so much, but the various areas around the world are contributing significantly to both how strong our earnings are and how high their quality is in these areas.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#14

All right. Then when it comes to rates in general — what is it, roughly more than 90% of your rate sensitivity sits outside the U.S.? So given a few of these rate increases, shouldn't the benefit you're getting be bigger than what you first assumed? And, I suppose, Mark, is it possible you're holding back just a little? I understand there's uncertainty in IB, with backlogs pushed out. And no, what I mean is, we'd like you to have a sensible hurdle to clear. I'm simply questioning whether the bar you've set for yourself this year is high enough.

Mark Mason

executive
#15

Yes; so once more, I believe there's definitely additional opportunity when it comes to the way rates move and to capturing NII. As you noted, beyond the U.S., we lay out our interest rate exposure for a parallel shift; and that mix at the close of last year was the 90 to 10 you referenced for non-U.S. Sitting here in March, it's probably going to tilt somewhat less non-U.S. and somewhat more toward the U.S., and you'll see that in the Q. That said, I said before, there remains a degree of uncertainty regarding how rates keep developing here in the U.S. We'll see how betas develop. We hit terminal betas in the U.S. with our clients around the close of last year. And so we'll see what happens when it comes to pricing across the remainder of 2023. And betas aren't yet at terminal levels beyond the U.S. And so we'll see the pacing of that, once more, given how the interest rate curve might be shifting and honestly, given how we've watched the wider sector turmoil unfold. That could actually work in our favor. But we're also, once more, in a setting where there's quantitative tightening still in effect. And then the last thing I'd say, Mike, that people frequently overlook is that within that NII is legacy NII; and so as we keep going with our wind downs, our divestitures, and so on, that's going to be a headwind we'll need to handle.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#16

During your prepared remarks, you mentioned Andy Sieg joining. I'd like to get a sense of how we should view what you're planning for Wealth, both inside the U.S. and in markets outside it, and also to grasp how much capital you believe could be directed toward that business compared with what's in place now?

Jane Fraser

executive
#17

Betsy, we're clearly very happy that Andy will be coming in as our new Global Head of Wealth, sitting around my table. He's an outstanding leader whose record of generating growth is excellent. His knowledge of products and digital is deep, he's a demonstrated leader of people, and we will definitely make the most of what he knows and has done in the U.S. Our approach to Wealth isn't changing. What he's been asked to do aligns with the strategy we presented at Investment Day — Investor Day; we anticipate considerable room for expansion in Asia as we complete coverage throughout the entire Wealth spectrum there. In the U.S., we'll be expanding by developing the investment offerings and cross-selling to our current and new clients nationwide. We anticipate enormous room for expansion in our Private Bank and the family office franchise, really on a global basis. And as we highlight through the various KPIs and drivers, plenty of synergies can be captured with the other 4 core businesses when it comes to referrals and additional business we can bring in across the franchise; so the heart of the strategy won't change now that he's joining. Mark, what would you like to add?

Mark Mason

executive
#18

I'd also mention that, honestly, we're, in my view, set up nicely for when the market comes back, and that trend favors Wealth. If you look at the client advisers, as you're aware, we've put money into recruiting additional client advisers. We've also been raising the count of new clients we bring aboard; we've put funds into certain investment products we offer; so I feel we're getting ourselves ready for the point when this reverses. And regarding what you asked about capital, in a typical cycle, this is a business that returns capital quite healthily. And when the market reverses and we bounce back, we'd aim to put capital to work in a way that fits the growth and return opportunities we see ahead of us; it's also less of a business that requires heavy capital than other businesses; so I believe you need to bear both of those points in mind.

L. Erika Penala

analyst
#19

I find it quite striking that the opening 2 things you were asked amounted to suggestions that your top line is overly cautious — that's really worth noting when it comes to Citi. Let me begin with something that builds on what Betsy raised. Jane, I believe everyone was definitely impressed by the decision to bring in Andy Sieg. And it's obvious he was overseeing a far bigger operation than the one Citi runs at present. This is a somewhat delicate thing to ask. Obviously, you're continuing to push through parts of the transformation. A consent order remains in place. Yet considering how strong you are as a worldwide institution, might Citi take part in possibly non-organic possibilities available out there, arising perhaps from the liquidity crisis we witnessed, which could speed up expanding your Wealth Management presence?

Jane Fraser

executive
#20

We observe a great deal of room for growth that comes from within. And honestly, that's the area we intend to concentrate on, Erika, since I consider the Private Bank along with the family office. Wealth is being created at such a scale, and it's bolstered by the commercial banking ties we hold with numerous businesses and the people who own them, the very ones producing the emerging industry leaders across nation after nation, and our position for capturing that is exceptionally strong. I don't perceive any non-organic move that would genuinely assist us there. Another advantage we enjoy stems from lacking proprietary offerings of our own along with a sales force that promotes such in-house products — we operate on open architecture. As a result, we're a highly sought-after ally for numerous of our major partners within the institutional side of the company, enabling us to deliver compelling value propositions, investment chances and similar things to our customers globally. And lastly, we definitely notice possibilities in intriguing digital ventures, various alliances, things of that nature, which hold appeal; so I won't ever rule it out over a longer horizon. Should something highly appealing emerge, I'm certain we'd be quite keen to examine it. However, at this moment it isn't something I believe is sensible, considering our current priorities. And no consent — really almost regardless of the consent orders. What I think we're trying to do at present is to get this organic strategy right, and after that we'll take it from there.

Mark Mason

executive
#21

I think it's pretty telling that we had 13,000 referrals from our retail bank.

Jane Fraser

executive
#22

Correct.

Mark Mason

executive
#23

Turning to wealth, correct, moving on to the wealth side of our operations. So there's substantial opportunity baked in, and that genuinely reflects the integrated model we've been discussing.

Jane Fraser

executive
#24

Also, another thing I want to mention is that one advantage we have is not being held back by having a brokerage model dictate how we handle Wealth in a specific manner. So part of what Andy has been tasked with, and what we've been focused on so far, involves examining what today's Wealth Management really looks like and ensuring we're positioned strongly for that, since I genuinely believe that's going to represent more of how things unfold going forward.

Jim Mitchell

analyst
#25

Perhaps a capital-related question is all I have. I understand that selling the Mexico franchise could hurt things, yet right now you're comfortably above where you want to be. Clearly, the retained earnings growth you expect down the road ought to more than compensate; so how should we view — what's your thinking on when you'd start repurchasing again, given how inexpensive your stock is?

Mark Mason

executive
#26

Yeah. Thanks, Jim. Well, we — as you mention, our capital expanded quite a lot during this quarter, reaching 13.4% on a CET1 ratio basis, and that's a sizable jump versus 12 months earlier, roughly 200 basis points; a large share of that, a meaningful share, came from net income earnings generation, and that matters. Well, here's how we view it: at 13.4%, we're definitely sitting far above the regulatory minimum, and that figure incorporates our internal management buffer of approximately 100 basis points; however, as we've previously stated, the Mexico transaction certainly exists, and at signing it would create a temporary drag, so to speak, on CET1 — the gap between signing and closing, assuming such a sale were to happen. Beyond that, a few additional items are also in play. So consider Basel III Endgame and whatever capital requirements might emerge from it; consider CCAR and DFAST, which is current — has been submitted and is presently being reviewed, and what that could imply for stress capital buffers; and also consider simply where we stand within the wider economy and the broader global macro environment we're operating in, and the need to watch how that develops; so factoring in all of those elements, we find ourselves continuing to approach this quarter-by-quarter. Still, I'd close by noting our bias aligns with yours, meaning that given our trading level, all else held equal, we would prefer to be repurchasing shares. Yet we must act responsibly regarding that and its timing.

Jane Fraser

executive
#27

My sense is that within a reasonably short period, we're going to gain a clearer picture regarding quite a few of these elements. As a result, we should be in a position to offer you improved visibility on the schedule before much time passes.

Jim Mitchell

analyst
#28

Understood, that all makes sense. And as a follow-up, perhaps — you brought up that reserves now incorporate higher macro assumptions. What's the current status of those macro assumptions within the reserve book?

Mark Mason

executive
#29

Regarding the reserve — keep in mind once more that when we work out the CECL reserves, there are a few distinct scenarios we use. Those 3 macroeconomic scenarios form the basis of the reserves we hold at present. On a weighted basis across 8 quarters, it points to an unemployment rate around 5.1%. So compared with the prior quarter, that's fairly level. One more thing to note: for this quarter's specific calculation, we leaned somewhat further toward the downside with the probability weighting relative to the prior quarter — again, given the macro backdrop, and that factor combined with some normalization in the portfolio, which included more revolver activity, drove the reserve increase we recorded. But to get to your question — unemployment stands at roughly 5.5% on a weighted — pardon me, 5.1% on the weighted basis across those 8 quarters.

Steven Chubak

analyst
#30

I'd like to kick things off with a question about the outlook for investment banking and trading. Where trading is concerned, in light of the macro shocks we've seen lately, has any of that volatility shown up in the numbers? And do you remain confident in your ability to hit that mid-single-digit growth target? Then, turning to investment banking, I was wondering whether any green shoots have appeared. As you pointed out, Mark, the backdrop has been a difficult one, but I was hoping you might give us some color on the various product lines — M&A, ECM, and DCM.

Mark Mason

executive
#31

Let me begin, and Jane, please chime in whenever you'd like. Look, in the quarter, our markets performance came in stronger than what I described when I spoke at the conference earlier in that same quarter. That really showed up in fixed income, where we posted a gain of roughly 4% versus the prior year, mostly on the back of strength in rates. Rate volatility emerged late in the quarter, and we were positioned well enough to capitalize on it and to serve clients, which helped bring us to a 4% decline overall in markets. For the entire year, what we've discussed is performance that's more or less flat. Based on what we're seeing right now, and depending on how the macro picture keeps developing, I continue to believe we can get there. That said, as you're aware, in plenty of cases volatility works in favor of markets businesses, so there's some uncertainty around how it will play out, but I'm confident in the guidance we've provided so far on that front. Did you want...

Jane Fraser

executive
#32

Absolutely. I want to add something before you move on to banking. One way our franchise stands apart from certain others, I believe, is that we're the bank corporate clients turn to first. That gives us a very appealing yet fairly consistent stream of business. In the turbulent markets we've witnessed lately, this volatility actually works in our favor, since we can help our clients with hedging in rates, FX, and commodities. It also means our risk flows end up far more varied than what our rivals have, especially when markets are this choppy; we aren't putting on positions. This is genuinely appealing client-flow business sitting squarely within the global network. Another element that matters in this overall picture is our partnership with TTS on cross-border payments. Those are the things that form a foundation of the FX franchise. So some of these volatile components — most people wouldn't typically characterize this as being so client-focused, yet that's precisely what sets the Citi franchise apart. Mark, over to you.

Mark Mason

executive
#33

Appreciate it. Regarding that corporate client base, I believe you've got it precisely right. Of course, within Investment Banking, the wallet has contracted — it fell substantially during the last year. We did observe some results — solid results in debt capital markets for this quarter, rising 66% compared with the previous quarter, especially given the activity we witnessed among investment-grade names, which is definitely a strong suit for us. Also, I believe a little momentum was building — somewhat greater clarity regarding where rates are headed; therefore, we'll watch how that keeps developing and unfolding. One more point I would make is that we keep enjoying really productive conversations with clients as they work through the current conditions and attempt to foresee what the remainder of the year will bring. And eventually, it's evident that clients will have to return to the markets; however, that path will mostly hinge on the geopolitical and macro backdrop and on how all of us handle and steer through that uncertainty. So heavily engaged, a robust pipeline, yet contingent on how conditions keep changing.

Steven Chubak

analyst
#34

That's excellent. For my next question, I want to focus on the fee income trends in PWM. I won't probe you on the wider Wealth strategy, though all of us here are strong supporters of Andy, so congratulations on bringing him aboard. What I'd like to understand better is this: within the sequential gain we observed in fees, how much stems simply from partner payments running higher while credit keeps normalizing? And how ought we to view the path of fees in PBWM across the rest of this year?

Mark Mason

executive
#35

A few points are worth bearing in mind regarding PBWM fees; part of this is that PBWM combines the cards operations with the Wealth operations. A sizable share of the strain we've observed on fees — which still depends on how conditions develop — sits in wealth, since fee pressure on investment activity and the revenues from it persists there. We'll need to watch how market valuations shift for certain assets we manage for clients, and what momentum that generates for additional investment activity. So I'd say that accounts for a major portion of the fee drag, whereas the favorable movement we've seen in fees plus banking and cards will likewise depend, I believe, on how activity and volume develop throughout our cards operation. Our expectation is that revolving levels keep going, yet purchase sales, though higher versus a year ago, have been — looking at the later months of the quarter — slowing in growth, and quite concentrated in travel and entertainment; so we'll need to see how that volume activity develops, and that's something to bear in mind.

Ebrahim Poonawala

analyst
#36

Let me ask a few things quickly. First, regarding the Banamex sale — Jane, I believe you said we could possibly hear something fairly soon, and you're still running a dual-track process. If you ultimately choose the IPO route, does that alter the accounting dynamics, Mark, when it comes to absorbing that hit early, given how long it could take to complete an IPO? And with the Mexican economy and the banks continuing to look strong, does that affect or shape how you think about the value you ought to receive from this deal?

Jane Fraser

executive
#37

We're currently in very active discussions in Mexico. So neither Mark nor I will go into much detail on that. As you noted, we're still pursuing a dual path — both a sale and an IPO; either way, we'll have an exit strategy. And we'll choose whichever path serves our shareholders best. There's a tremendous amount of work underway in Mexico to separate out the institutional business. I'm happy with the progress being made. When we look at how our Mexican franchise is performing, I think we're seeing that a great deal of the really strong performance is coming from our ICG business, where Mexico benefits enormously from the supply chain shifts occurring globally; and its location is clearly very advantageous given how close it is to the U.S. as well. So we're seeing much of the momentum and the major benefits here arising in the institutional franchise, which we're retaining within Citi as a core part of the business. So the present Mexican economy doesn't really influence our decision-making much right now. The principle is that we'll take whichever path serves our shareholders best.

Mark Mason

executive
#38

Sure. Let me attach a few figures to that. During the quarter, revenue in Mexico rose 16% on a year-over-year basis; on a quarter-over-quarter basis, it was up 5%, with growth in cards and deposits, so I'd call that solid performance. As for the second half of what you asked, Jane is completely correct. All of our efforts are setting us up for either a private sale, an IPO, or both, and whichever route serves shareholders best is the one we'll take. Going the IPO route would require more time, and it would probably take longer because we'd want a complete set of audited financials, and so on. Regarding how this would look from an accounting standpoint, I'd note that CTA accounting differs in an IPO, meaning we wouldn't take that CTA through the P&L; under an IPO, at signing we wouldn't have that impact, which differs from the closing; therefore that wouldn't pose a problem. How big the impact is would depend on how much we IPO-ed at that moment. So there are plenty of — plenty of variables in play. If we ultimately went down that road, we'd have to work that out. Still, I hope this gives you a feel for the possible scenarios; and let me close with one last thing Jane already mentioned, which is that whichever result we select will be the best one for our shareholders, our clients and employees.

Jane Fraser

executive
#39

And that's going to be a divestiture.

Matt O'Connor

analyst
#40

You folks have mentioned bending the cost curve, I believe, during the later portion of 2024. And I was curious whether that remains true. And perhaps I could just get a bit of clarification regarding what bending the curve actually signifies. Does that mean expense growth is slowing or that it's declining in absolute terms? Some kind of clarity on that, plus on costs broadly over the medium term, would be useful.

Mark Mason

executive
#41

Thank you, Matt. To respond to you point-blank, yes, that remains true; we will bend the curve, as I said in — near the close of 2024. What it means is a reduction in expenses in absolute dollars.

Matt O'Connor

analyst
#42

All right, that's useful. And then, I suppose, previously you've sort of hinted that this could be the beginning of what we hope will be a bigger decline in expenses past that — clearly, if that point is a long way off — but any further detail on that as well would help.

Mark Mason

executive
#43

Yeah. Well — once more, well, our cost foundation is a major priority for us, correct? We understand that costs have been rising. They've risen since we've been putting money into the franchise, in terms of transformation and also growth driven by the business, to back the competitive edges we hold across many of our franchises. Yet we're handling that quite actively and quite intentionally. Which means we're aiming to make sure we're directing the funds properly, into the proper areas, and that we'll eventually realize the gains we anticipate from doing so. And all of that was included in the goals we laid out at our Investor Day for the medium term. What that calls for is that we begin bending the curve in '24, as I said, and that we finish that medium term at a point where operating efficiency stands at roughly 60%, and we're set up for returns around the 11% to 12% RoTCE mark. A few elements will help bring that expense base down. First, the divestitures we've discussed, correct? Second, the gains from transformation plus the other investments I just mentioned. And third, additional organizational and management simplification work now in progress, made possible by the fact that we're leaving 14 consumer countries. So those 3 elements, so to speak, turn out to be quite significant, both for reaching that reduced cost structure and for being able to fulfill the wider commitments we're making on returns.

Gerard Cassidy

analyst
#44

A few things I'd like to ask. Jane, perhaps we begin with you, or Mark, either of you is welcome to respond; given what — the turmoil that occurred within the banking sector during March, with the situation involving the regional banks in the U.S. and clearly, that sizable investment bank in Switzerland, do you anticipate adjustments ahead? Or which adjustments do you anticipate ahead regarding regulation, be it additional capital, additional liquidity? And it might not be aimed at an institution such as yours since you're already a global SIFI, and it could be more focused on the regional side within the United States. And as part of that, Jane, could you provide some insight regarding the deposit that you and your counterparts placed into First Republic? What was the rationale there too?

Jane Fraser

executive
#45

Yes, absolutely. I appreciate the question, Gerard. Well, I would say we are hopeful that there will be a considered and focused response to any modifications in the regulatory and capital framework, and that they tackle the underlying drivers of what truly took place here. And what took place is a mix of macro consequences from the swift steep rate hikes and some idiosyncratic circumstance, specifically insufficient proper asset and liability management at a small number of banks; we do not view these problems as widespread across the wider banking sector. But the events definitely underscore how crucial prudent asset and liability management is. We continue to believe that ample capital exists among the large banks. And if capital requirements were raised for the large banks by the regulators, it would worsen any credit tightening that could occur. And connected to that, what keeps me most awake at night is the volume and quality of activity within the shadow banking industry; it does not enjoy the same regulatory frameworks and protections for participants. And I, along with others, worry that more activity being pushed into it, should the banking capital requirements rise, will come at the expense of system strength and stability. So we are hopeful that this response will be considered and focused on where the problems truly were. As I mentioned in my opening remarks, we felt that the regulators, both at the local and the national and the international level, were very — were prompt and effective in ensuring that they address the issues that were in front, and we were absolutely pleased that the large banks served as a source of strength. And let's just pause for a moment. Amid enormous market uncertainty, 11 of the largest U.S. banks were able to unite to inject $30 billion of deposits into First Republic in just over 1 day. That says a great deal about where we stand with capital and our balance sheet; and I believe big institutions are acknowledging their duty, since we too have a meaningful part to play in settling circumstances of this kind. And we felt it mattered a lot to assist in creating some breathing room and, at the same time, to show the assurance we have in the U.S. banking system as a whole. So I trust that provides you with something of a sense of it.

Gerard Cassidy

analyst
#46

No, that was really helpful. Great stuff. And for my next question, I saw on your card — Slide 8, I believe — you told us the prime figure: 80% of the portfolio is prime, meaning FICO scores above 680. I'm not sure whether you'd share this view, but we keep hearing about some FICO score inflation. Because of the pandemic, many consumers watched their FICO scores climb. And I've come across figures reaching 70 points, which might be on the high end. But can you all — would you say that's right? And if so, would you expect that 700 FICO score customer to eventually act like a 650-score customer?

Jane Fraser

executive
#47

The short answer, I'd say, is no, but let me have Mark take that one.

Mark Mason

executive
#48

Yeah. No, I'd say the key thing to focus on here, Gerard, is really the way the portfolio has been behaving. So, once more, I've come across that view about FICO score inflation. We have a lot of confidence in the way we've evaluated our customers and in what it means that 80% of them are prime and above 680. And what matters, I think, is that payment rates are beginning to moderate. Average interest-earning balances are starting to grow. NCL rates are rising, though mainly because of the customers with lower FICO scores throughout the portfolio, and that's exactly where you'd anticipate that pressure to first show up. And the NCL rates we're currently observing remain far under what a normal cycle would produce, correct? Plus they match the performance we've been projecting. So nothing has caught us off guard in how that curve is developing. We'd anticipate it returning to those normal levels around the start of next year. It will probably run through those normal levels for a while before easing off. But what I'm getting at is that we know our customers, the portfolio, and how it responds to the environment well enough to project that. And up to now, it has been coming in consistent with that projection and those estimates. And crucially, we keep stressing it to confirm we aren't overlooking anything. And crucially, we hold a substantial reserve, as you're aware, within that $20 billion.

Jane Fraser

executive
#49

One more thing I want to mention: when it comes to evaluating the credit quality of both our customers and our portfolio, FICO scores aren't the only thing we lean on. We pull from an enormous volume of information that reaches far, far past that. And as you might expect, that is another factor giving us considerably more confidence; it isn't merely past history, and an abundance of data gets put to use.

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#50

Mark, let's turn to your revenue. I hear you saying the revenue guidance stays the same. What assumptions sit behind that revenue number? I'd like to peel that back a bit. What are your revenue assumptions regarding rates, both U.S. and internationally? And what's happening with deposit betas, especially after the inflows you've recently seen in the U.S. amid the crisis?

Mark Mason

executive
#51

Yeah, so a few things, I suppose. First, on the rates we've assumed, for the rest of the year, we've basically assumed rates would probably — rates would level off after this quarter, after the second quarter, and then decline somewhat toward year-end, slipping a bit to roughly 4.50% or so, 4.50% or so. So we might get 1 rate hike, then flat, then down to roughly 4.50%. That may shift. But honestly, if it shifts slightly one way or another, it probably won't meaningfully affect 2023; it's more likely to matter in 2024; so we can argue about that curve, but that's basically where our outlook stands right now. My second point concerns — and this is U.S. rates. We're assuming — I don't have the specifics before me regarding rate curves across the globe, but we are assuming continued rate hikes there, not large in magnitude, yet some assumptions there depending on the region in question. The beta assumptions we've incorporated call for betas to keep rising outside the U.S. But again, they tend to run below the U.S., generally speaking, for our multinational clients. Within the PBWM retail banking — or the PBWM client segment space, we expect clients will likely shift toward either higher-yielding deposit products or investment products. So we've factored those considerations into our thinking about the outlook. And might that change or evolve? Certainly, but that's essentially what sits behind our assumptions here.

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#52

Just to clarify, given the deposits coming in lately amid the turmoil in the U.S., are there other betas easing up slightly — by how much are those rising? Is that decelerating, or has nothing shifted thus far?

Mark Mason

executive
#53

A few points come to mind. First, during the quarter we saw money coming in tied to some of the industry disruption. Looking at deposit balances from roughly March 7th and March 8th until near the end of March, we definitely observed a rise — approximately slightly below $30 billion in inflows across that stretch — with a substantial share landing in our CCB, specifically our commercial middle market client base. Determining how betas will move is premature, though we believe a sizable chunk of those deposits are apt to remain sticky. The key thing, I'd say, is that one element of our approach involves expanding operating deposits among our large multinational clients as well as our middle market clients. That will stay a priority for us. What remains somewhat uncertain is the direction the rate backdrop takes and how that shapes the way betas ultimately move, correct? We'll simply need to monitor it. On that front, it's premature to say.

Ken Usdin

analyst
#54

I just want to ask something else about credit. You said, clearly, that a portion of your CECL adjustment was shifted somewhat in your weightings. And earlier you'd discussed moving toward "normalized" card losses, I believe you said around year-end. So, considering the shifts we're facing and the fact that some normalization clearly occurred this quarter, can you tell me — do you still expect to reach 3 to 3.5 and 5, 5.5 in the two card businesses by around year-end this year?

Mark Mason

executive
#55

Yes. Yes. Year-end, early, early next year, yes, we remain more or less on track on trend for that. Once more, I'd anticipate they tick up somewhat afterward before beginning to taper down. But to respond to your question, Ken, yes, that remains the time line, fourth quarter, early 2024, hitting those normalized levels.

Ken Usdin

analyst
#56

All right. Great. Then just one additional quick follow-up — end-of-period deposits came in 3% lower. You brought up taxes. Is it — do taxes ultimately show up throughout the whole business? When I look at that deposits page, there are plenty of ins and plenty of outs when you look at it on an end-of-period basis. I'm just trying to figure out which areas may have been hit by that tax seasonality versus where things were just some of those other items you already walked through, in terms of what came in, what went out, and everything in between.

Mark Mason

executive
#57

Yeah, that's a fair question. So again, when you look at our deposits on an average basis, you'll see on Page 26 that they edge up slightly. On an end-of-period basis, though, they're lower by roughly 3%. And basically, within the quarter — especially during March, as I said earlier — we did witness a considerable rise in flows. That said, if you recall, back in the fourth quarter we had a decent buildup in deposits; and then there's that seasonality element I brought up in my prepared remarks — sorry, in my prepared remarks — where we've got both operational payments coming from our large TTS clients and tax payments, and with our TTS clients, plus wealth clients to some degree, sort of working their way through end-of-period deposits. And once more, that's mostly routine operating payments that we would anticipate seeing at this point in the year.

Jane Fraser

executive
#58

There are no surprises in what happened.

Mark Mason

executive
#59

Yes.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#60

I just want one point of clarification regarding your previous response. You mentioned seeing movement during the quarter. Did deposit growth accelerate during March? And did that happen within the United States?

Mark Mason

executive
#61

Yes, we did. Yes. That is exactly what I meant, Mike, when referring to those movements. Most of them occurred inside the U.S. during March, and from March 8 up until roughly the close of the month, they were masked by the routine outflows I mentioned. And we did — plus we continue to observe solid engagement even as March concluded and into the first days of April.

Jane Fraser

executive
#62

This occurred in the institutional business, where we also observed inflows, and in PBWM as well.

Mark Mason

executive
#63

Mark Mason (Wealth): Yeah.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#64

If we're using that definition for deposits — and tell me if I'm making this too simple — you've got 5,000 multinational companies, and your real focus with them is payments, capital markets and banking. Those firms hold a great deal of deposits and use a great many services, and that's the stickiest part. That's where you mentioned 80% of your TTS clients have stayed with you beyond 15 years. So what do the deposits look like for those 5,000 multinationals? I realize I'm asking for the slice and dice in a somewhat different manner, but even a rough sense would help. My reason for asking is that I believe there's a disconnect when percent of uninsured deposits gets presented as a stickiness measure, and in my view that isn't valid. You also showed higher deposits despite having a large share of uninsured deposits, or perhaps that matters less than some newspaper front pages imply. So please speak to that.

Mark Mason

executive
#65

Yeah. Thank you, Mike. Here's what I'd suggest: go to Page 26 of the earnings presentation. We've laid out the deposits for each business we have, and at the bottom you'll find the TTS deposits. That's where the deposits of roughly 5,000 large multinational clients sit, and you can observe both the stability and the consistent growth of those deposits over time. As you say, these are mostly operational deposits these clients keep with us. And we shouldn't confuse rate sensitivity or betas with stickiness. These deposits do tend to be quite sticky with us, as you can see here. They are price-sensitive in that when rates rise, we frequently need to reprice them. But keep in mind that our relationships with these clients extend beyond deposits alone, and that's what allows us to adjust pricing accordingly on our deposits, both inside the U.S. and outside it. Another page you can review on your own is the one right before that, which again speaks to how diversified the portfolio is, and also to how long many of these clients have been with us and grown alongside us. Nearly 80% of our deposits come from clients whose relationship with us exceeds 15 years, and that says a lot. So those are the 2 points I'd make. I hope that answers your question about stickiness.

Jane Fraser

executive
#66

Yeah. I usually put it this way: pulling us out of our clients' operations is like getting a root canal, and that's precisely because of what we're discussing here. We notice the same thing even among mid-market clients, who now make up a growing share, since we assist them in growing abroad, and that stickiness shows up. Also, an LCR of 120% is an extremely strong LCR ratio.

Jen Landis

executive
#67

Appreciate all of you being here with us at this time. Should anything else come to mind afterward, feel free to get in touch with IR. Thanks so much.

Operator

operator
#68

That wraps up our review of Citi's results for the first quarter of 2023. Thanks to everyone for joining us. You're free to hang up whenever you like.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Citigroup Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Citigroup Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Citigroup Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.