Citigroup Inc. (C) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 13, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jen Landis
executiveThanks, operator. Morning, everyone, and I appreciate all of you being on the call for our results in the third quarter. Let me note that the presentation we have today, which you can download from our site, citigroup.com, might include forward-looking statements. Those statements rest on what management currently expects and are subject to uncertainty and shifts in circumstances. A variety of factors, including the ones laid out in our earnings materials and in our SEC filings, could cause actual results to differ materially from those statements. With me this morning are Jane Fraser, our Chief Executive Officer, and Mark Mason, our Chief Financial Officer. I'll now hand things over to Jane.
Jane Fraser
executiveThank you, Jen, and hello everyone on this call. Before I walk through the quarter and the organizational news we shared last month, I want to spend a moment on the macro picture. Desynchronization continues to define the global backdrop; here in the U.S., the latest figures point to a soft landing, though the historical record argues against that, and we're noticing certain cracks among lower FICO consumers. Over in the euro area along with the U.K., conditions have clearly deteriorated. What began as summer softness across industrial economies is now broadening quickly, and because labor and energy costs are structurally elevated, that region likely faces a longer-lasting competitiveness problem. As for China, its economy could be sitting at a cyclical trough thanks to modest stimulus from the government, yet it must still digest poor sentiment, joblessness among the young, and distress in property markets. Client sentiment has plainly been shaped by all these macro forces. September is invariably a hectic month for meeting clients, and what strikes me is how uniformly CEOs express less optimism about 2024 than they did just a few months back. As the rates debate moved from how high to how long, client activity has picked up. Even so, corporates no longer wait for rates to fall and have started tapping debt capital markets worldwide. The geopolitical environment is changing, and our clients who operate across multiple countries are adjusting how they run things—building in extra capacity and making their operations more resilient. That plays right into what we do well and how we've planned our approach, particularly the worldwide network we've built, which is incredibly valuable. Because we have a portfolio of high-quality assets, solid reserves, plenty of liquidity, and earnings coming from many different sources, we're showing clients that we really can perform in any kind of market. Turning to the quarter now: net income came in at $3.5 billion, EPS was $1.63, and RoTCE stood at 7.7%. Outside of divestitures, revenues were up 10%, and every one of our five core interconnected businesses saw revenue growth. Relative to the revenue and expense guidance we provided for the year, we remain on track. Let's start with services, which is our fastest-growing business. On a year-over-year basis, TTS was up 12%. That represents our best revenue quarter in more than ten years, and it continues to run ahead of the goal we laid out at Investor Day. Half of the increase came from business drivers, while rates supplied the remaining half. Even with the Argentine devaluation, which we had long anticipated, we produced fee growth once again — the clearest evidence of what our globally leading franchise is capable of, and we never stop innovating for our clients. Among the launches we made this quarter was the announcement of Citi Token Services, which will harness distributed ledger and smart contract technologies to provide a digital asset solution for TTS clients. And this is the first for the industry as it allows us to seamlessly integrate a permission tokenized bank deposit network with traditional cash services such as 24/7 dollar clearing. Security Services had revenue growth of 16% with some good underlying fee growth. We gained share once more, and over the past twelve months we increased our AUC and AUA by more than $2 trillion. There's a lot of momentum in this business, along with a solid pipeline of clients who are reaping the benefits of the cloud and data investments we are making. Markets rose 10% compared to a year earlier, driven by rates and currencies, which delivered their strongest quarter in a decade, and by commodities, which also posted nice growth. Equities partly offset that, declining a bit. Even so, momentum in cash stayed solid and our prime balances have increased since the start of the year. Banking enjoyed a solid quarter, with revenues climbing 17%, as activity aligned with our mix. Now, corporate lending came in basically flat, since we stay quite disciplined regarding use of our balance sheet, while DCM was healthier. And the IPO market displayed a few hints of life too. That helped drive a 34% increase in investment banking revenue, even though it came off a low base and a small wallet. Looking at where things stand right now, it's still hard to say when deal activity will come back in a lasting way, but I'm proud of the work we've done advising on several of the biggest deals anywhere in the world this year. As you know, growing our banking franchise is a priority for us. We brought the investment bank, the corporate bank and the commercial bank under one leadership structure, and that setup will allow us to drive key synergies across all three more effectively. We've been bringing in new talent in sectors that matter. And in the right situations, we've begun providing more leverage finance to key clients. U.S. Personal Banking likewise posted a double-digit gain, coming in at 13%. In cards, we saw strong results across both the branded portfolio and retail services. Spending is decelerating, and buyers are being more deliberate about their purchases. Affluent clients, in particular, continue to sit on savings above what they need, and they drove the increase in spending, with a persistent preference for travel and entertainment. This quarter we introduced Simplified Banking, aimed at improving how our retail banking customers experience us. Our thinking is that combining products and making our fee schedule less complicated will lead clients to expand how much they do with us, and the initial response from clients along these lines has been pretty positive. Wealth revenues have flattened out and moved up just a little. The standout item was that investment revenue got better in each region, and the franchise's key growth engines — referrals, bringing in new clients, and net new inflows — were strong everywhere. We also landed significant new mandates for Wealth at Work, a solution we'd showcased at Investor Day. Andy Sieg is officially on board with us now. We're in a time of tremendous wealth generation globally, and our franchise holds a distinctive edge for capturing it. Andy will ensure we stay ahead of developments worldwide. Regarding the balance sheet, sticking to our practice of expanding operating deposits has let us keep a steady deposit foundation across the last 5 years; loans increased this quarter, and credit quality is still exceptionally robust, helped by how carefully we pick clients. Our CET1 ratio climbed to 13.5%, putting us $14 billion above the regulatory minimum, and that figure still factors in a 100 bps internal management buffer. Over the quarter, we gave back $1.5 billion to shareholders via common dividends along with stock buybacks; buybacks get reassessed every quarter; I anticipate we'll keep doing a modest amount in Q4, assuming our Board approves. While the ultimate impact of potentially hefty capital requirements remains unclear until Basel III end game is finalized, we've been actively working on ways to lessen that burden. Slide 3 illustrates just how relentlessly we chase our strategy; during this quarter, we completed the divestiture of our Taiwan consumer business, which ranks as the second biggest among the Asia consumer sales. At the start of this week, we also revealed an agreement to sell our China consumer wealth portfolio to HSBC. That transaction involves approximately $2.6 billion in assets under management along with $1 billion in deposits; in Q4, we expect to finalize the sale of our Indonesia consumer business. Regarding the International consumer operations, we are in the process of exiting them.
Jane Fraser
executiveBeyond those three markets we're exiting, we've kicked off the sale process again in Poland, and we're still on schedule to spin off Mexico in the coming year, with an IPO to follow in 2025. Our top priority continues to be the transformation. We're deeply engaged in a massive amount of work around automating manual controls and processes, bringing together scattered technology platforms, and improving our data architecture. We're determined to do this properly, recognizing that meeting our regulators' expectations and delivering a modern, more efficient infrastructure won't happen overnight. Last month, we rolled out significant changes that bring our organizational structure in line with our strategy and alter the way we operate the bank. As I mentioned at the Investor Day, simplifying the organization would come after the divestitures. These changes will remove layers, duplication, and complexity, which lets us run the bank with more agility and gives our people room to concentrate on clients and execution. By raising the five core businesses up to my leadership team, I'll be able to push for stronger accountability and lasting results — so let me make that concrete. The steps we've taken over the past few weeks will cut more than 15% of the regional and functional positions across the company's top two layers. They also remove 60 committees, which frees up over tens of thousands of employee hours each year; we've pinpointed roughly 1,000 — or 50% — of our internal financial management reports that are no longer necessary. And we've done away with co-heads and dual reporting lines so decisions can be made faster. We're pushing these changes down through the organization quickly. We announced the first two layers in September, and the following round of changes will be put in place by mid-November, with the goal of wrapping up the whole process by early next year. When we speak in January, Mark and I will be able to give you an update on the financial and other metrics, sharing what the simplification has meant among other things. Now, even though expenses aren't the main reason behind the organizational changes, they will help us begin bending the expense curve in the fourth quarter of next year. And once this work is done, we'll have a simpler company that can move faster, serve our clients better, and unlock value for our shareholders. We've made some hard calls here, and I want to say how pleased I've been watching the leaders of the firm, particularly the next generation, embrace these changes and step up to carry them out. They completely grasp that we have to change how we run Citi if we're going to genuinely transform it once and for all. Before I wrap up, I'd like to speak about our people in Israel. We are a significant bank in the country. And many of our people have lost friends and loved ones. Others are being called up to serve. Despite all they are dealing with, they are keeping our bank running in the country; and I'm frankly in all of their commitment to our clients and each other. On a wider level, the toll this crisis is exacting on ordinary people who have done nothing wrong is truly heartbreaking to see. With that said, I'd like to hand things over to Mark. After that, we'll be glad, as always, to answer whatever questions you have.
Mark Mason
executiveAppreciate that, Jane, and hello everyone. I'll kick things off with our results across the whole company, zeroing in on how the third quarter compared with the same period a year earlier, unless I note otherwise, and afterward I'll spend a little extra time walking through the businesses; turning to Slide 4, you'll see the financial figures for the entire firm. In Q3, we recorded net income of about $3.5 billion, earnings per share of $1.63, and a return on tangible common equity of 7.7%, all on revenues of $20.1 billion. Those results factor in roughly $214 million of after-tax impacts tied to divestitures, which came mostly from the sale of our Taiwan consumer business. Leaving those items out, earnings per share would have been $1.52, and return on tangible common equity would have been 7.2%. During this quarter, overall revenue increased 9% as reported, and 10% when you strip out the effects tied to divestitures. That was driven by strong performance in services, cards and markets, plus modest gains in banking, though it was partially offset by lower revenue resulting from the completed exits and wind-downs. Within our results, expenses came to $13.5 billion, which is 6% higher as reported, or $13.4 billion once divestiture-related costs are excluded — also a 6% increase. Cost of credit stood at roughly $1.8 billion, a 35% rise, largely because card net credit losses kept normalizing and volumes grew. When the quarter ended, total reserves exceeded $20 billion, and our ratio of reserves to funded loans was about 2.7%. Through the first nine months of the year, our return on tangible common equity came in at 8.3%. Turning to Slide 5, you'll see what drove expenses during the third quarter, along with the main themes behind our investing. We saw a 6% increase in expenses, and the level we're at keeps being shaped by several things: money we're putting into transformation, spending on risk and controls, investments led by both the businesses and the enterprise, broader macro forces like inflation and foreign exchange, and severance costs — about $190 million for the quarter and close to $640 million so far this year, reflecting actions taken across banking, markets, wealth, and the functions. Productivity savings, along with cost cuts tied to the exits and wind-downs we've closed, helped offset some of that. During the quarter, we spent $3 billion on technology throughout the company — an 8% increase. The main drivers were funding for product development, improvements to our platforms, and efforts to make the client experience better. Another factor behind the rise is our ongoing tech investment tied to the transformation, as we work through the consent orders and bring the firm up to date. Last quarter we noted that our spending on transformation and technology covers these areas: simplifying platforms and processes, modernizing security and infrastructure, enhancing how clients interact with us, and upgrading data. We're still tracking toward our full-year target of about $54 billion, leaving out the effects of divestitures and the FDIC special assessment. Turning to Slide 6, we present net interest income, deposits, and loans, and I'll discuss the quarter-over-quarter changes. During Q3, net interest income came down $72 million. Excluding markets, that figure climbed $332 million. Growth in PBWM was the primary factor, as loan balances keep rising and the spreads on those loans keep getting wider. Services also contributed, with deposit spreads expanding due to elevated rates and proactive beta management. Offsetting some of those improvements were declines connected to closed exits and wind-downs. Loans averaged 1% higher, driven largely by U.S. Personal Banking — both Cards and retail banking — along with TTS. Deposits averaged 2% lower, primarily from Services, where non-operational deposit outflows occurred, matching our expectations in light of quantitative tightening. Net interest margin came in 1 basis point higher. Turning to Slide 7, we lay out the key consumer and corporate credit metrics. Our reserves are solid for the environment we're in, totaling more than $20 billion. The ratio of reserves to funded loans came to just about 2.7%, and for U.S. cards within that, it's 7.8%. In PBWM, U.S. cards make up 45% of our loans, and within that exposure, 80% goes to customers whose FICO scores are 680 or above. NCL rates at both Branded Cards and Retail Services remain under where they were before COVID, but they're normalizing as we anticipated. The other 55% of PBWM loans sit mostly in wealth, primarily mortgages and margin lending. If we turn to the ICG portfolio, investment-grade assets make up around 85% of what we hold overall. Internationally, close to 90% falls into investment grade or relates to multinational customers and their subsidiaries. Our corporate non-accrual loans increased by $490 million, though they remain modest at 68 basis points of all corporate loans. At quarter's end, the reserve to funded loan ratio stood near 1%. This page lays out our commercial real estate lending exposures split between ICG and PBWM — together totaling about $65 billion — and 86% of that amount is investment grade, with a reserve to funded loan ratio of 1.4% overall. Let me give you a sense of the broader economic picture that sits behind the over $20 billion we hold in reserves. In the scenario we're currently using, the average jobless rate comes in around 5%, and within that we've built in a more adverse case where unemployment averages approximately 7%. So while there's still plenty of uncertainty in both the economic and geopolitical environment, our view on asset quality, our exposures, and the level of reserves we've set aside remains pretty favorable, and we continue to examine and stress test the portfolio against a variety of different scenarios. Turning to Slide 8, you'll see our summary balance sheet, together with the main capital and liquidity figures. Our balance sheet is quite robust at $2.4 trillion. Funding comes in part from a deposit base of $1.3 trillion that's well diversified — different regions, industries, customers, and account types — and that money gets put to work in high-quality diversified assets. The way our balance sheet looks reflects both our strategy and a business model that's well diversified. Through our distinctive assets and capabilities, we serve corporates, financial institutions, investors, and individuals who have needs around the world. Institutional and operational deposits make up the bulk of what we hold — $782 billion — and they're spread over 90 countries. On top of those institutional deposits, there's $416 billion of U.S. Now moving to personal banking and deposits within our global wealth division. Our high-quality liquid assets stand at roughly $569 billion, alongside approximately $666 billion in loans, and we kept total liquidity resources at $937 billion. The LCR came in at 117%. We closed out the quarter with a CET1 ratio of 13.5% under standardized RWA, which serves as our binding constraint. Even though it isn't binding, our advanced RWA did rise during this quarter, mostly because of business activity. Tangible book value per share reached $86.90, which is 8% higher than a year ago. Slide 9 gives a sequential CET1 walk so you can see more detail on what drove things this quarter. Beginning at the close of the second quarter: first, net income to common of $3.2 billion contributed 28 basis points; second, returning $1.5 billion through common dividends and share repurchases cut roughly 13 basis points; and finally, the other 2 basis points of increase came mainly from lower DTA deductions and a net decrease in RWA; we finished the quarter at a 13.5% CET1 capital ratio, which is about 120 basis points, or $14 billion, above the regulatory capital requirement of 12.3% that applies to us as of October 1st. Before moving ahead, let me take a moment on capital. We keep optimizing our RWA and capital, and we expect that to be a tailwind over-time.
Mark Mason
executivePart of the reason for that comes down to the way we're executing our plan — for example, we keep broadening what our business is made up of and simplifying how our business model works, and that means stepping away from the 14 consumer markets we operate in internationally. The funds we're directing into the transformation will go on bolstering our capabilities in data analytics and stress testing, which lets us keep optimizing capital; and of course, with the regulatory landscape shifting as it is, we're likewise looking at additional mitigating steps; even so, those will for the most part depend on how the final capital rules end up being written. Steps of that kind could include getting out of or reorganizing particular products, shedding certain equity investments, and revisiting both the way we deploy capital and our management buffer. No matter what the broader economic conditions looked like or how regulations shifted over time, our track record shows we can keep RWA and capital levels under control — and we'll keep doing that. Moving on to Slide 10, the numbers there reflect how the Institutional Clients Group performed in Q3. Revenue for the segment climbed 12% this quarter, with services, markets and banking all posting growth in the double digits. Currency translation of the ordinary sort created a headwind that pulled down net revenue within ICG during those three months. Strip out FX effects, and ICG revenue would have shown a 15% gain. Beyond that, Argentina's currency devaluation hit us for roughly $180 million against our net investment in that country, concentrated mostly in TTS, markets and security services. Our expenses increased by 10%, largely because we kept putting money into risk and controls and because of costs tied to volume, though productivity savings helped counter some of that. The cost of credit reached $196 million, which included $51 million in net credit loss. From that, we generated net income of about $2.4 billion, a 12% increase, thanks to higher revenues, though that was partly counterbalanced by greater expenses and a higher cost of credit. Average loans dropped 4%, reflecting how carefully we chose where to allocate resources across the businesses, among them a decrease in subscription credit facilities. Average deposits stayed level, since gains from acquiring new clients and expanding ties with existing ones were canceled out by outflows of non-operational deposits. For the quarter, ICG posted an RoTCE of 10%, and 11% on a year-to-date basis. Turning to Slide 11, you can see how each business performed on revenue and what drove those results, which ties back to the framework we presented at Investor Day. Within Treasury and Trade Solutions, we posted our strongest revenue quarter of the past ten years. Revenue climbed 12%, with net interest income growing 17% accounting for that increase. Non-interest revenue was up 1%, and if you strip out FX effects, it would have risen 8%. The underlying drivers in TTS remain solid, pointing to steady, robust client activity — cross-border flows increased 16%, exceeding global GDP growth, and on a year-to-date basis, cross-border flows were 12% higher. U.S. In the quarter, dollar clearing volumes increased 6% compared with last year, and they're also up 6% for the year to date. Commercial card volumes climbed 8% versus a year earlier, with business-to-business payments along with travel and entertainment spending fueling that gain. For the year to date, commercial card volumes have grown 20%. As has been the case across the last few quarters, client wins have increased roughly 40% in each client segment. Those include flagship assignments where we serve as the client's primary operating bank. Our commercial client strategy continues to progress nicely, with wins this year having more than doubled, helped by moves into new markets and by expansion in multiproduct mandates from clients with cross-border needs. Over in Securities Services, revenues climbed 16%, powered by greater net interest income across currencies. Non-interest revenues gained 3%. We're quite happy with the strides we're making in Security Services as we keep bringing on board assets under custody and administration, which have grown roughly 10%, or $2.1 trillion. Markets revenues rose 10%, powered by fixed income. Fixed income revenues climbed 14%, mostly powered by the strength of our rates and currency franchise. Although volatility is still subdued compared with a year ago, we did observe overall volatility edging up relative to how the quarter began. Equities revenues fell 3%, powered by a drop in equity derivatives, partly offset by gains in cash and prime. And we keep making steady headway on our revenue to RWA target; and lastly, banking revenues, excluding gains and losses on loan hedges, climbed 17%, powered by investment banking, which rose 34% on a reported basis and 12% excluding marks. Here as well, we noticed activity picking up during the final couple of weeks of the quarter, especially in DCM, but in M&A too, as we closed a few deals ahead of schedule. So on the whole, though the market environment is still difficult, and more work lies ahead, we're making steady headway on our strategy in these businesses. Now moving to Slide 12, we present the results for our Personal Banking and Wealth Management business. Top-line results increased by 10%, driven by a 9% gain in net interest income alongside a 20% increase in non-interest revenue—largely attributable to reduced partner payments within retail services and higher investment product revenues in wealth. On the expense side, costs were up 5%, primarily due to investments in risk and control as well as severance, which was partially offset by savings from productivity initiatives. The cost of credit reached $1.5 billion, reflecting higher net credit losses as normalization continues across our card portfolios. Average loans were up 7%, supported by cards, mortgages and installment lending. Deposits were down 2% on average, which mostly came from clients moving cash into investments through our platform. In PBWM, we posted an RoTCE of 8.8%, and 6.6% on a year-to-date basis. Turning to Slide 13, we break out PBWM revenues by product, together with the main business drivers and metrics. For Personal Banking, this was our fifth quarter in a row of double-digit growth, driven by cards. Branded cards revenues climbed 12%, mainly on higher net interest income. Underlying drivers remain solid: new account acquisitions gained 5%, card spend volumes increased 4%, and average loans were up 12%. Retail services revenue grew 21%, lifted by higher net interest income as well as lower partner payments after net credit losses increased. Within the card portfolios, the investments we've kept making, plus lower payment rates, are still fueling growth in interest-earning balances — 15% for Branded Cards and 12% for retail services. Retail banking revenue fell 3%, which came from moving relationships and their related deposits into our wealth business, though higher deposit spreads partly made up for it. Wealth revenue climbed 2%, supported by bigger investment fees across every region and segment, the boost from relationships shifted over from retail banking, and greater lending revenue. We also recorded robust net new inflows in every region. And on a year-to-date basis, new client acquisitions jumped nearly 30% at the private bank and more than 60% at wealth at work. Overall, we feel good about the direction these businesses are heading. On slide 14, you'll see what happened with Legacy Franchises results. There was a 13% decline in revenue, and the main driver was the impact of differing one-time gains on sales in the Asia consumer businesses, plus reductions tied to consumer exits that have closed and wind-downs, though Mexico's stronger revenue provided some offset. It's worth noting that Mexico's revenue was up 32%, driven largely by the Mexican peso appreciating, higher interest rates, and growth in volume. If you strip out FX, Mexico revenue rose 16%. Expenses were down 3%, primarily due to closed consumer exits and wind-downs, with separation costs in Mexico and the Mexican peso's appreciation partially offsetting that.
Mark Mason
executiveMexico's costs rose 27%, though excluding foreign exchange effects they climbed 11%. Slide 15 presents our Corporate/Other results. Revenue went up, mainly because the prior year included mark-to-market effects on certain derivative transactions that didn't recur. Costs came down, mostly from reduced consulting fees; turning to Slide 16, I'll give a quick look at our outlook for the whole of 2023. With a single quarter left, our expectation for total-year revenue remains $78 billion to $79 billion, leaving out 2023 divestiture-related impacts. That said, given how U.S. and non-U.S. rates along with lagging non-U.S. betas have played out so far this year, we now anticipate net interest income for the full year, excluding markets, coming in a bit above $47.5 billion. Our expense guidance stays at approximately $54 billion, excluding the 2023 divestiture-related impact and the FDIC special assessment. Card net credit losses ought to keep normalizing, with both portfolios getting to pre-COVID levels by year-end. As for buybacks, we anticipate a modest amount during the fourth quarter. Prior to Q&A, let me close with a handful of points. Our strategy is being executed, and we're delivering 5% year-to-date topline revenue growth. We're continuing to put money to work over the long haul in a disciplined manner, and we're still positioned to meet the expense guidance we've set. Our attention is directed at making our organizational and management structure less complex, and that should give additional support to how quickly we execute. Given the regulatory challenges we face, we're handling our capital carefully, and at the same time we keep optimizing it and giving capital back to shareholders. Also, we have confidence that we can reach our RoTCE goal of 11% to 12% over the medium term. As before, we're eager to hold a fourth quarter earnings call that's more expansive, at which we intend to provide further specifics about the organizational simplification, such as the severance and expense savings we expect from it, along with what we foresee for 2024. Having said that, Jane and I are ready to answer whatever questions you may have.
Mike Mayo
analystHi, Jane. You went into more detail about the restructuring that you had brought up not long ago. So the real question is this: since Citi took its current shape 25 years ago — I think that was only about a week back — you've seen maybe 5, 10, or 15 restructurings. What sets this one apart from all of those? We keep hearing about cascading downward, about simplification, about cutting dual heads and committees, but we've heard all of that so many times that — why is this time different?
Jane Fraser
executiveYes. That's a really important question, Mike, and thank you for raising it. Like I mentioned, we see these as the biggest changes we've implemented in roughly twenty years — not only to how our company is structured, but also to the way we operate the bank. The first part is straightforward: our organizational structure was built for a financial supermarket, and that just isn't the kind of bank we are now. So we're bringing the org model into line with a simpler business mix and strategy. What's genuinely different, though, is that we're altering how we run the bank — and these changes are permanent, and they'll be pushed all the way down through the organization. Let me walk through a few examples to make this concrete. We discussed removing layers from the bank's top two or three tiers. That effort is going to keep moving down through the company as we look at spans and layers, especially eliminating aggregator positions. Here's an illustration: in HR, we had people aligned to a region. There was the region head, the institutional client group head, and the banking head — plus, on top of that, a North Asia head and a South Asia head. Now we'll have only the North Asia head and the South Asia head, and every one of those other roles has been folded into those two. We're cutting out work in certain parts of the world that we simply don't need to do anymore, since we've stopped operating local consumer franchises in those places. Consider the financial reporting — actually, the management reporting that Mark and I brought up earlier. We're able to cut our management reports roughly in half. That comes to 1,000 reports. What's the impact of that? Country-level shadow P&Ls, quarterly outlooks, monthly performance updates, plus all the related tracking and reconciliations — things that exist essentially for a shadow P&L instead of the one our shareholders actually care about. So this creates a lot more clarity. Beyond that, this allows us to do away with certain workflows as part of our transformation. We're examining ways to automate those workflows and the associated controls. When a workflow is redundant, we remove it entirely, meaning it no longer has to be performed, and that speeds up transformation efforts. We're pulling certain activities out of individual businesses and bringing them together centrally. Much of the client-facing work will end up embedded inside a business, and we've raised that up into shared centralized utilities that the whole firm can benefit from, and those will deliver economies of scale. Across these strategy and marketing groups, plus all those tiny niche operations that pile up as a company grows, we see a chance to speed up how choices get made by cutting back on committee tiers. Our plan is to shrink the number of layers, pushing down from thirteen to eight wherever that's feasible. We're making decision authority clear, and moving it away from shared ownership by two or more individuals into the hands of a single person — creating far more instances of one person being answerable. This ties in better with what shareholders want, since those accountable roles live closer to the products themselves. When it comes to tracking our progress, we look at a range of indicators: spans, layers, revenues, whether someone is a producer or non-producer, grade mixes, the synergies we're capturing, and voice of the client. That said, what we're really trying to accomplish here also comes down to our expectations and how we carry out the business strategy. Our global network is where our strength lies. I don't want our geographies spending their energy on the full monty of management processes that just replicate what the product organization is already doing. What I want them focused on is serving our clients, connecting with our clients, and handling their legal entity responsibilities. Similarly, within our banking group, combining the investment bank with the corporate bank and the commercial bank is going to significantly help us capture the synergies that exist among those three. When a mid-market commercial client grows into a corporate lending and corporate banking relationship, that transition becomes far smoother if everything sits inside one company — or when we pitch our full banking product lineup to that commercial banking customer, along with other cases. What we're really doing is reshaping how choices get made, giving employees room to concentrate on customers and on transformation, creating far more visibility, altering who decides what and what authority they hold, and generating synergies. Throughout the summer we invested an enormous amount of effort in designing exactly how we want this organization to operate. Right now, that work is being pushed further into the detailed, deep design stage. These kinds of efforts are currently sitting at the second and third layers, and they'll move into the fourth layer, continuing until we wrap up at the close of the first quarter. So this is quite different. You'll hear more about it during the fourth quarter earnings call. Still, I hope that gives you a feel for why this is genuinely different. This is the way we're operating the company. It isn't merely an organizational restructuring—both things are needed.
Glenn Schorr
analystI'm interested — you said you're continuing to move toward that 11 to 12, which is welcome, since it was on everyone's mind to ask about. Mine is slightly different: given that the denominator rises 25%, put another way, plenty of efforts support the transformation, yet a surprise came in the form of that 25% bump to the denominator. So you appear set to gain from rates staying elevated for an extended period, no doubt; and you noted that mitigation work is underway right now. Could you perhaps describe the offsets that aren't visible to us which keep you confident about still targeting that figure, since the top-line items are performing?
Mark Mason
executiveYes; allow me — good morning, Glenn. Nice to hear your voice. I'll offer a few remarks on that, and then Jane, jump in if you wish. First, when I discussed this during the conference we last attended, I noted that analysts fell somewhere between 16% and 19% regarding a capital increase, and we'll probably land inside that band, presuming the Basel III proposal stays as structured as drafted; and clearly, that isn't the final version. A review period is currently underway. What I'd say is a few things, Glenn. First, we haven't completely carried out the strategy Jane just outlined. And clearly, further simplifying the business, steering through the transformation, shifting our business mix toward something more consistent and predictable and repeatable when it comes to PPNR. Those items are significant and affect the SCB. We discussed exiting our business, the international consumer operations. That will influence how our balance sheet appears and how stress losses may appear, plus reducing the expense base, which we recognize is a key input in that PPNR calculation too. And so I believe those items assist in cutting the capital that could be needed as we enter that medium-term stretch. Crucially, as you note, additional parts of the proposal will demand that we examine them closely and pinpoint mitigating steps should they survive into the final version; so consider the rise in operational risk and the reality that part of that is already captured in SCB, which is somewhat a matter for advocacy, yet that's clearly a major headwind we'll need to navigate; the FRTB and the model enhancements. Then there's a global market shock too, but once more, another advocacy point we must address, the equity investments, and now they shift from 100% risk weighting to 400% risk weighting. We'll be examining closely if those still make sense to hold given the greater capital tied to them, which will pressure the returns, which will compel us to view them with a different strategic perspective, and that's what we'll do. And beyond that, there's the credit piece affecting both companies and individuals when it comes to things like unfunded commitments, for instance. So, just as with CCAR and other regulatory shifts, we'll need to assess the implications for our product lineup, the returns tied to those, whether chances exist to use tools such as pricing, or if we must make other choices regarding them. That's what I mean when I refer to the mitigating steps we're sizing up, documenting, and working through; yet once more, we aim to be careful since the rule isn't finalized, and further conversations are needed on those key points I've already brought up.
Erika Najarian
analystGood morning.
Mark Mason
executiveGood morning.
Erika Najarian
analystYou have discussed at length what I refer to as defense — the transformation Jane laid out and the effort to bend the expense curve. What I'd like to ask Jane and Mark is whether you could speak to what I believe is the most contested piece of your target: that 5% revenue CAGR. You delivered a very strong quarter on the revenue side, in both net interest income and fees. Perhaps you can help us peer beneath the surface at that momentum and unpack what is genuinely performing well? TTS, I think, keeps exceeding expectations. Down the road — will we be sitting here 2 years from now saying, wow, TTS is still doing great? Which areas of the business do you see benefiting from strong, lasting tailwinds that the market isn't fully recognizing — and how do you balance that against where you can make cyclical plays and bring people on board for the long haul? And looking forward, what still needs to happen to reach at least the top-line portion of that RoTCE goal?
Jane Fraser
executiveErika, what a great question — honestly, I couldn't be more excited about the strategy we've built and what it can deliver. Like you said, this is about the company's revenue upside and how we continue to capture it. There are several forces that won't be stopped, and they'll propel us through what I see as a ten-year stretch. Whether it's our corporate customers or individual consumers, everyone today has to become more resilient. Our large global customers have been steadily working to become more resilient over the long haul — driven by environmental concerns, by geopolitical factors, by regulation, whatever the many different reasons happen to be — and they need to embed that resilience in their supply chains and in their own operations as they do business across the globe, and that's exactly where the bank shows up for them. You've seen this play out in TTS, I believe, since we enjoyed such powerful growth drivers in recent years, right as this trend was getting underway; so that's a key one. Anywhere clients choose to operate, we're present. We've been present for many decades. The risk is something we grasp. The client base is something we grasp. We get the possibilities that exist on that granular, neighborhood-by-neighborhood scale — the kind a person who shows up with just a suitcase simply isn't able to provide. Plus, it's tied into the whole world, so honestly, this whole thing is a real marvel. Woven into that is something I'd describe as an overlooked treasure sitting right among our finest assets: Security Services. In custody too, it holds this remarkable worldwide web, that same everywhere-connectivity; we've kept putting money into this operation. Our slice of the North American asset manager market has been expanding, a space where we'd previously held too little, and we've landed quite a few significant, headline-grabbing mandates. You can see the market share we're picking up in this segment, plus the deal pipeline we've already secured and the fresh pipelines coming down the line. Returns are very high. Our investments span cloud, data, and client experience; and in a sense, let's say, I really consider this a hidden gem, with a highly appealing return profile, fee profile, and other aspects. There's still quite a lot of runway ahead here; so it mirrors the TTS story, with a somewhat different customer base, and a competitive edge because you have both — you have pre-trade and post-trade, and linking those two delivers enormous efficiencies for clients, which will matter. Global wealth generation represents the upcoming force nobody can stop, and an enormous wave of it worldwide is on its way. Andy Sieg has settled in, locates his workspace without trouble, and is familiar with every level where staff are based—words can't capture how delighted he feels. He's preparing to set off across the globe. Our positioning for fulfilling that opportunity is exceptionally strong. You've witnessed that our results across the past two years left us dissatisfied, yet this is going to serve as a hugely significant catalyst for the company. In time, the banking wallet will bounce back—though not one of us will forecast the moment that becomes durable. That stands as yet another catalyst. Cards, I would say, continue getting stronger and stronger — especially, in my view, when you look forward, because that business fits so well with the lending-led model we run. Then there's one more area I genuinely have great affection for: our commercial bank. Around the world, we work with entrepreneurs who are going to shape plenty of industries in the years ahead. What we do for them is support that initial move across borders, plug them into worldwide supply chains and similar networks. Pretty much by definition, among mid-market companies, the quickest-growing ones are those that make use of what we're able to provide; the ties we've formed with them are excellent. After that, our private bankers reach out to them. And after that, our investment bankers reach out to them. Our capital markets groups are actively reaching out to those customers. We support their expansion and success, and over the medium term this should serve as a major driver of fresh client wins coming our way. That means stronger ties with existing clients, additional gains from newcomers who align with what we offer in a fairly distinctive way, plus several powerful megatrends we intend to capitalize on, where our position is quite unique. We're going to keep putting money in so that wherever we're lagging, we move right up to the front, and wherever we're doing amazingly well — for instance, our TTS win rate sits at 82% — we make certain that stays the case and that we keep innovating along those lines. Sorry if I come across as overly excited about this, but Mark and I truly think that 4% to 5% is very much within reach.
Jim Mitchell
analystHi, good morning. Mark, perhaps regarding what we discussed on revenue, let's turn to NII for a moment. Your company has a highly distinctive deposit base, with a much smaller presence in low-cost consumer. Betas are already elevated. So it appears there isn't as much risk of beta catch-up for you. About 50% is non-U.S. How do you view the path of NII as we — do you believe it levels off next year ahead of rate cuts? How should we think about the positives and negatives for your NII going into next year?
Mark Mason
executiveYes. I appreciate that question. Look, guidance for 2024 isn't something I'll provide; that will come, of course, when we report fourth quarter '23 earnings; but expecting that certain trends observed thus far will persist seems reasonable; so considering what lies beneath this, higher rates across currencies should keep benefiting us. Growth in card interest-earning balances should also keep helping, I believe. Keep in mind that our U.S. dollar IRE position is fairly neutral right now. And continued card spend along with lower payment rates ought to drive interest-earning balance growth; and so the key thing to keep in mind regarding our business, I think, is that it's global, and while you're correct that on the U.S. dollar side, betas have sort of reached — especially among our corporate clients — terminal levels by the end of last year. On the non-U.S. dollar side, betas are lower, they trail, and room remains for improvement since the rate curve differs and the pace of increases differs; and so those are among the positives and negatives to consider — volumes, the rates, how quickly the curve moves, and then how betas develop, all of that will come into play. And the last point to keep in mind is that within our NII, we present it both with and without markets. On the ex-markets side, we'll feel the drag from the country exits as that unfolds. For instance, we just left Taiwan, and that will clearly affect next quarter's NII; so those are a few factors to consider. And certainly, more detail on 2024 will come during the fourth quarter earnings call.
Ryan Kenny
analystHi, good morning.
Mark Mason
executiveGood morning.
Ryan Kenny
analystRegarding capital markets, I picked up on what was said about how difficult it is to forecast the point at which deal activity will make a lasting comeback. Could you provide an update or additional detail on what CEOs are considering when it comes to launching transactions across M&A, ECM and DCM? Also, has the volatility in markets and rates during recent weeks made any notable difference to getting deals over the line or to the pipeline?
Jane Fraser
executiveSure, I think there are a few elements here. Let me begin by noting that Q3 marks the seventh quarter of this IB downturn. Going back to 2000, periods like this usually haven't lasted more than seven quarters, because that's roughly how long it takes for pricing expectations to fully align with new realities. We're starting to see that happen, particularly in the debt capital markets and the investment grade market, where the question has moved away from how high rates will go toward how long they will stay there; clients have come off the sidelines and basically decided to accept the situation and engage more substantially with the debt capital markets instead of holding back; when you talk with CEOs, our view remains that how a recovery and a return to normal wallet plays out depends mostly on the macro environment. That's really the crucial element as far as they're concerned. When it comes to ECM, interest and activity levels are climbing. You obviously noticed a number of IPOs hitting the market during September — sizable ones, and we were part of three of those major deals. Despite that, conditions in the market stayed rather delicate. We're keeping a close watch on it. There are also plenty of questions around Q4, and some things could slip into Q1. We'll simply have to wait and see how that plays out. Still, the pipeline looks solid. What I mean is, there's substantial pent-up demand here; on the debt side, DCM saw a significant uptick, and we're confident that the steady improvement in DCM, along with the early signs of that LevFin activity, will keep going. We will definitely be doing more in leveraged finance when the circumstances suit our most important clients. On the M&A side, we have a solid pipeline of sell-side mandates. Many businesses whose sectors are going through major change are eager to pursue bold strategies. Once confidence picks up even more, I believe that will start to come through. Firms are coming around to the current pricing environment, and a recovery in equity markets will make that easier. From our perspective, turning that into actual revenue clearly requires a number of quarters, simply because of how the product works. So the opportunity exists, but considering the geopolitical situation and especially the macroeconomic picture, nobody is prepared right now to predict when we'll reach that durable phase in banking.
Steven Chubak
analystHi, good morning.
Mark Mason
executiveGood morning.
Steven Chubak
analystMark and Jane, I realize you're going to give us a fuller picture on expense moves next quarter. What I'd hoped, though, is that you could put the expense opportunity in terms of where headcount has been going. Before COVID, and before the consent order too, Citi had 200,000 direct staff; today that figure sits nearer 240,000. That's a 20% jump, even after several divestitures you've completed. So how should we frame a suitable goal, or the right headcount level, for Citi compared with that 200,000 pre-COVID baseline? And would the consent order change when such headcount steps happen, or how big they are?
Mark Mason
executiveRight. Look, I won't offer headcount guidance. What I can tell you is Jane has previously discussed the heads tied to the divestitures now in motion; and clearly, as those divestitures keep advancing — and we've already made a lot of progress — we'll watch those heads decline. Another thing worth noting is that in-sourcing has been part of our effort. As a result, the extended workforce is included in the headcount we report here. Then I think the last piece is that as we keep delivering on the transformation work and as we carry out the org simplification we just announced, without question, the technology spending, the automation we're deploying, the straight-through processing that takes place, the fewer reconciliations needed, the streamlining across all those layers Jane referenced will be removing. Every one of those items will help bring headcount down too. So while we're putting money in and hiring on the front end to capture upside as markets turn, and also to position ourselves to grow with clients, we're likewise going to capture efficiencies that result from headcount reduction. One more thing: you've heard me say previously that we've booked probably around $600 million, year-to-date, in repositioning charges. Along with that, roughly 7,000 or so in headcount will come down tied to those repositioning charges. And so — and we'll keep at that, by the way. We haven't even started taking repositioning charges linked to the org simplification that's underway. Those will arrive in the fourth quarter and in the first quarter of next year. So we'll see heads keep shifting through this process. But remember that there are puts and takes tied to that as we consider where we must in-source rather than rely on external parties.
Ebrahim Poonawala
analystMorning. Mark, perhaps I could follow up on what you just said. When we consider how the curve bends by the close of next year, could you speak to the trade-offs involving investments and expense reductions? What portion of those cost savings, or that bending, will occur in legacy as opposed to PBWM and ICG? How do you split — how should we view that when thinking about bending the curve and the source of those savings?
Mark Mason
executiveWell, look, next year, we mentioned expenses declining from the third quarter to the fourth quarter. And in thinking about that, some benefits will come from costs disappearing due to the exits we would have announced. Some benefit will come from additional lowering of stranded costs, something we've been intently focused on as we've exited each of these; and then I think as we reach the medium term, you'll begin to see some benefits from the transformation spend and investments we would have made starting to play out, along with efficiencies we begin to gain in a lower structural cost base. But again, that falls in that medium-term period; so all of those items will be drivers toward getting to bending of the curve. I'm not — I haven't broken down. I won't break down here on this call how much comes from each of the pieces, but all are important factors to achieving that.
Matt O'Connor
analystHello. Jane, I think you made some comments publicly regarding signs of pressure among less affluent consumers. I'm grateful for the pie chart included in the deck, since it shows this isn't a large share of the card portfolio. Still, might you say more about that? And please also speak to the point you raised about payment rates recovering at a slower pace directionally. Yet when comparing spending growth with loan growth, the two seem somewhat out of proportion — I think spending is up a couple of percent year over year, while the loans carry lower FICO scores. When you consider that we might be in a later stage of the cycle, are you watching for that as a possible indicator that credit could weaken further? Thanks.
Jane Fraser
executiveYeah. Well, I'd say that the bulk of the strain we're seeing sits with borrowers who have lower FICO scores, and a substantial number of our customers fall into that lower FICO group, so that's what's showing up in the market. We have — clearly, retail services contains some of that exposure. We should also point out that we benefit from that loss sharing agreement, which genuinely matters here, since although we must hold full reserves against it, the amount comes back to us through the revenue line, as you're aware. When we examine our off-us portfolio and take into account certain market pressures, along with what we're seeing on the spending side, it's clear that borrowers with lower FICO scores are feeling some of that strain. On the other hand, the cards business is largely powered by affluent customers. In fact, virtually all of the spending growth we're observing comes from that affluent segment. This aligns with what the Fed reported regarding deposits — excess savings are now concentrated mainly in households earning more than $150,000 a year, while balances have fallen among everyone else. These are trends we're monitoring closely. Let me make this clear. For Citi, this doesn't concern me much, because our card portfolio is prime; and the remaining exposure we have in PBWM is clearly quite affluent. But looking at the broader market, when I speak with our corporate clients, that's where we usually find greater anxiety regarding consumer weakness; and, as I put it, they are far more careful about their spending, correct? So you see them trading down within a category. They are definitely focusing more on bargains; our retail partners have been telling us this. We've heard it everywhere; and so card loan growth is solid. We're putting more money out there, though the increase isn't as big as what we're seeing on the loan side. My sense is things are easing up a bit, yet I wouldn't call it a concern.
Mark Mason
executiveRight. I'd say that's exactly right. The one point I would add is that if you look at the payment rate — payment rates and branded cards — although they've begun to decline, they remain higher than where they stood before COVID. And clearly, we've put money into this business. So another factor behind this is that new account acquisitions are, of course, significant contributors to that spend volume and, in the end, to that loan growth. But once more, nothing we're seeing falls outside what we had anticipated regarding how this portfolio is normalizing.
Gerard Cassidy
analystGood morning, Jane. Good morning, Mark.
Mark Mason
executiveGood morning.
Jane Fraser
executiveHey, Gerard.
Gerard Cassidy
analystJane, like you mentioned, you're really enthusiastic about what's possible in TTS. You're picking up some new mandates over in the custody side of things. Could you share your thinking here — is it down to rivals dealing with their own problems, what's driving this — since this space has always had a strong reputation. So what's behind that extra enthusiasm that things are actually improving further?
Jane Fraser
executiveWell, I'd say a big chunk of that extra enthusiasm comes from the money we've been putting in, so we're — take Payment Express, for instance, which is now live in the U.S., it's — Thailand is on schedule for three additional markets. That's genuinely a capability that sets us apart. The traction we've got with 24/7 clearing, that's now up and running; we've processed more than $1 billion so far this year, getting our commercial bank customers onto CitiDirect so they enjoy seamless access to our entire PTS network worldwide, plus us discussing Citi token services, you can watch us building new things alongside the Fed; so honestly, on every front, that's the innovation in pioneering, first-to-market kinds of capabilities. Yet you're layering all of that onto a network that's simply without parallel when it comes to its footprint, its on-the-ground expertise, it's payroll, cash management, liquidity management, it's collections, its receivables — all on a single platform wired up across the globe. And what that delivers for a client in terms of efficiency gains, data insights, what they're able to achieve around risk management and how to genuinely sharpen their treasury operations. Honestly, this thing is a thing of beauty, and it's extremely, extremely difficult. It's very sticky to pull away from this since it's woven into how our customers operate. It's that essential and into their tech stacks; so when you consider where the world is going and what's unfolding globally, volatility, those other factors, it's tough not to spot opportunities. And there are opportunities too with our markets business tied in, and one of our truly differentiating elements that Andy Morten mentions constantly is his partnership with TTS. As a matter of fact, a major portion of our client base is corporates, and they carry a distinct profile, shall we say, compared with an asset manager or a hedge fund, and we're uniquely positioned to serve them. So that's the thing. It's that mix and the trends we're seeing.
Mark Mason
executiveI'd say that's exactly right. The one point I'd tack on is how big an opportunity the middle market commercial segment represents for us, as you mentioned before, by making use of that TTS platform; and regarding security services, the truth is that we are at last witnessing genuine momentum across North America. Correct? Strength has tended to be with us in plenty of the other regions, yet here in North America we're truly landing some significant mandates, which in my view is sufficient reason to feel genuinely enthusiastic.
Jane Fraser
executiveAnd to me, that's really the thing that shapes so much of our strategy and what we're aiming to accomplish as we work toward that high quality of earnings, an improved earnings mix, and the other elements that will help us reach that medium-term return target we're so focused on.
Vivek Juneja
analystHi, Jane. Hi, Mark.
Jane Fraser
executiveHi, Vivek.
Vivek Juneja
analystI just wanted to get a bit more clarity on the reorganization. Jane, I believe you mentioned keeping the North Asia and South Asia heads. So does that mean the Asia head role is gone, and the product heads are gone too — previously, product heads in each country reported to a regional product head; is that dotted line now removed? What exactly is happening there? And once you eliminate all the monthly management reporting, what do you intend to put in its place from a management perspective? From your MIS standpoint?
Jane Fraser
executiveLet me address the second one first. I have no plans to substitute it with anything. They aren't necessary. We're not operating consumer franchises in those countries anymore. What we have instead are global businesses running very consistently across the individual geographies. So replacing them simply isn't needed; this also allows us to maintain only the legal entity financial management that's required. And our internal reports become far more simplified, just as they become far more simplified by removing ICG and PBWM — another layer — eliminating that layer also removes a great many different reports. So the great answer is nothing, just simplicity. The first question was about helping you understand what we've done. On the geography side, we've already completed two main things. First, we've eliminated the regions and I've placed a single international head reporting to me. That makes things much simpler for me. I have one international head, and he'll help us manage the geographies collectively. The second piece is that we've really narrowed geography's mandate to delivering to our clients and covering our clients in their countries, and secondly, legal entity management. Previously, we had an enormous amount of management on shadow P&Ls and various — a very heavy committee structure. That was necessary because the business was still very local as a retail bank, a local credit card business, a local onshore wealth business; those are gone. It's just serving multinational, the subsidiaries are multinationals and in some markets, the investors and the wealth clients in some markets. And that's a much simpler business to manage. So we could remove the regional there, and we went straight down to the clusters that we have today, but they too have a smaller mandate than before, a much more focused one. And the part that I'm excited about is not just, yes, this makes it much simpler to manage but it also helps us really focus on the global network. Now our geographies and our banking organizations sit together on the same management structure, collectively accountable for serving and delivering against our core client base. And they're in one team to do it, it just makes it much easier. Does that give you a feel what else, Mark?
Mark Mason
executiveOne more point, Vivek, that I believe matters a lot here: we genuinely intend to put somewhat greater funding and hours toward viewing things through the client lens when it comes to financial reporting, correct? Since, as Jane mentioned, we discussed the synergies throughout the franchise — our capacity to take advantage of what we provide to those distinct client segments; therefore, examining that P&L, examining those returns, examining that growth opportunity, by way of that client lens is something where we would like to improve the metrics we already maintain on that front, so that we can seize that upside.
Jane Fraser
executiveAlso, there's another element here that I believe deserves emphasis. The nature of globalization itself is shifting. Every one of these corridors is in flux—whether we're talking about food, trade, or financial flows, among others. Because we now have one worldwide organization alongside distinct clusters—North and South Asia, Europe, the U.K., LATAM, the Middle East, and Africa—the linkages connecting those clusters are genuinely transforming right now. That's why we can deliver through the global network with far greater agility, since this setup aligns much better with the way the world actually functions these days.
Saul Martinez
analystHello there. I'd like to pick up where we left off regarding the danger of credit losses returning to normal levels. From what I gather, your guidance suggests that branded cards and retail services will reach more typical levels by the time the year wraps up, and that represents a fairly significant increase compared with where things stood in Q3. So I'm curious about what's behind that expectation. Even more crucially, what does it mean looking ahead? Does it point to losses that run hotter than the usual trend? My thinking is that we've still got some maturing left to work through from the 2021 and 2022 vintages. On top of that, we're having this conversation while the labor market remains quite remarkable. So if you could share a bit more detail about your outlook for credit losses, and whether there might be additional risk beyond what we're anticipating — specifically, losses drifting toward a level somewhat above what we'd consider more normal — that would help.
Mark Mason
executiveSure. Let me kick things off, and Jane, feel free to jump in if you'd like. What I'd direct you to is Page 24 of the deck we've provided, since it offers a clear picture of how loss rates have moved, as well as the trajectory of delinquencies; you'll notice delinquencies climbing, which tells us a lot about where loss rates are probably headed over the coming quarter or so. So with 2.72 for unbranded cards and 4.53 for retail services, it looks like we'll land near that normalized level as the year closes out, reaching the 3% to 3.25% and 5% to 5.5% pre-COVID normalized NCL rates. Our view is that heading into '24, as you pointed out, depending on how the macro environment plays out, we'll probably see this rise beyond those pre-COVID normalized rates. As the economy slows — again, contingent on what the macro looks like before then — it should eventually level off at some point further down the road. So yes, we do anticipate that increase. This is, as we said it would be, so to speak, in line with what we expected. And we hold reserves, substantial ones, for both portfolios to cover those loss expectations; in branded cards, our ACL to loan reserve stands at 6.3%, while in retail services it's 11%, and Jane noted earlier that retail services losses are ultimately shared with partners. So although we anticipate this normalizing and maturing, so to speak, we believe we're very well reserved for whatever that turns out to be.
Jane Fraser
executiveWhen it comes to our consumer credit exposure, the portfolio now looks quite different from the old Citi. What I believe you're picking up from us is that all of this ought to be entirely manageable. At Citi, no warning signals are sounding over this; we're simply exercising prudence. On certain pieces we're taking a conservative approach and handling things responsibly. Still, no bell is ringing. I suspect there could be something of a gap between a number of the questions coming our way and how we actually feel. The data simply isn't showing us anything that worries us excessively. It's manageable. All of this is entirely manageable, and we're exercising prudence on it just as you would expect from us.
Mike Mayo
analystHello, and thanks for taking the follow-up. Jane, based on what you said in your first response, I'm hearing about the restructuring — breaking the company down from city-level to global lines, flattening layers of management, and simplifying how you report things — and once all of that comes together, we'll see some figures in January. However, regarding the return goals and efficiency goals you've set for 2025 and 2026, the consensus sits roughly one-third under what you're aiming for; and honestly, I haven't talked to a single investor who believes you'll reach those goals, and perhaps you'd want to lower them somewhat, or maybe they'd be left to be determined? Or how much conviction do you have about reaching those goals, or at minimum exceeding your cost of capital? Thank you.
Jane Fraser
executiveYes. Look, we stay confident in our capacity to reach these goals. We have — you heard me discuss earlier the revenue growth and some of the tailwinds sitting behind us, along with the core strategy and the drivers within our control that we've been putting investment behind in order to achieve. So our strategy hasn't changed. We're confident it will generate revenue growth of 4% to 5%; it isn't the main objective, but the organizational simplification is the third driver behind the expense cuts we've mentioned. And I'd add that, when you examine revenue, expenses, and the goals we set out at Investor Day, we've definitely faced plenty of headwinds — macro, regulatory, geopolitical — over the last couple of years, and we have delivered; and we — on what we committed to doing regarding revenue and expense guidance tied to the strategy. We've made adjustments along the way whenever we needed to. But I think that's the element we're also genuinely trying to instill across the firm as a culture: we will do what we say we will do, and we'll adapt accordingly in different areas. Mark discussed adapting to capital requirements, whatever they turn out to be. We have other levers available to pull — capital allocation, management buffer DTA. But my message to our investors is that we're simply accumulating a proof point. This is relentless execution. Take a look at that strategy scorecard page near the start of the deck. We've accomplished a great deal and there's a great deal happening, and we're getting a great deal finished. We don't claim we're at the end of the road there yet; but we're completing what we said we'd do and accumulating those proof points so you can watch us reach those return goals. Anything to add, Mark?
Mark Mason
executiveAs you said, building credibility and being transparent, right?
Jane Fraser
executiveYes.
Mark Mason
executiveSo we intend to keep coming through with those proof points, and we'll be open regarding the way, the timing, and the method by which we'll get there.
Gerard Cassidy
analystThank you. Mark, when you covered the credit section, you pointed out that delinquencies are on the rise, even if they're still pretty small relative to total loans. My question is about corporate loans in North America, because that area saw growth. Again, I understand that compared with the entire portfolio, it's not a huge piece. Still, could you share anything particular about it?
Mark Mason
executiveOn the corporate loan side, we had a loss. The losses totaled $51 million for the quarter, in my view, which isn't a meaningful amount. As you mentioned, we did see reserves move higher. That was largely driven by some adjustments to country ratings. We also had NALs — that is, nonaccrual loans — rise. It truly came down to only one or two names, with one in North America and one in EMEA. Both remain current, but they produced the uptick we saw in the quarter, and that movement came to 4.53%.
Jen Landis
executiveThanks, everyone, for being here. Should anything else come up that you'd like to ask about, our IR team is the best point of contact. Appreciate it.
Operator
operatorThis concludes the Citi third quarter 2023 earnings call. You may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Citigroup Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Citigroup Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Citigroup Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.