Citigroup Inc. (C) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 12, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jennifer Landis
executiveThanks, operator. Good afternoon, everyone, and thank you for being with us on our fourth quarter 2023 earnings call. Today I'm joined by Jane Fraser, our Chief Executive Officer, and Mark Mason, our Chief Financial Officer. I want to remind everyone that today's presentation, which you can download from our website, citigroup.com, may include forward-looking statements. Those statements rest on management's current expectations and are subject to uncertainty and changes in circumstances. A variety of factors could cause actual results to differ materially from these statements, including the factors described in our earnings materials and in our SEC filings. With that, I'll hand things over to Jane.
Jane Fraser
executiveThanks, Jenn, and happy New Year, everyone — hope you all had a nice break. Here at Citi we're back to work, and with the notable items plus our new financial reporting structure, there's plenty to get through today, so I'll dive straight in. 2023 was a foundational year in which we made substantial progress, simplifying Citi and executing the strategy we laid out at Investor Day. That said, the fourth quarter was clearly very disappointing. Today I'll give a high-level view of our progress in 2023, discuss our Q4 results and finish with our priorities for '24. We recognize how important 2024 is as we get ready to move into the next stage of our journey, and our attention is fully on hitting our medium-term targets and completing our transformation. Now, regarding what we achieved in carrying out our strategy. On slide five you can see that 2023 was a record-setting year for services, and we held onto our top position among large institutions in TTS, with client wins rising 27% and a win-loss rate that stayed above 80%. Since 2021 we have picked up more than 100 basis points of share in security services; in wealth, we brought in an estimated $21 billion of net new assets over the year. During the sixth straight quarter of expansion in USPB, early payoffs from putting money into key banking personnel started becoming visible. September marked the beginning of the biggest set of organizational and operational shifts at our company since the period following the financial crisis; we reorganized into five interconnected core businesses so that our structure would match our business strategy and give clearer visibility into how each performs. Our financials now show full-year returns and P&L broken out by business. Although investments and transformation expense affect every one of them, the areas needing improvement are evident. Our organizational simplification wraps up at the close of Q1 and will generate more than $1 billion in run-rate savings, stemming mostly from cutting roughly 5,000 roles, predominantly managers. Mark will walk through how this helps bring our '24 expenses down. Looking to the medium term, combining simplification, transformation benefits, stranded costs and other productivity work, we anticipate removing 20,000 positions outside Mexico, which yields over $2 billion in run-rate savings. Simplification also lets Citi operate with greater client focus and less bureaucracy. Capturing synergies across our five businesses stands as a major lever for hitting our medium-term revenue goal. Under this new setup, I'm making my business leaders answerable for improving connectivity between clients and products. Beyond that, a Chief Client Officer role exists to keep us disciplined about delivering the full strength of our franchise to clients. To date, we have completed divestitures of nine of the 14 international consumer franchises we had, and we have wound down nearly 70% of our retail loans and deposits in aggregate across Russia, Korea and China. Poland's sales process has been relaunched, and for the Mexico IPO next year, we are far along the execution path. We are exiting some smaller-scale operations, including munis and certain distressed debt trading, to focus on what we do best and allocate capital carefully. And there's no question that these changes are hard, even when they're needed. Meanwhile, we continue putting money into our transformation efforts, our risk and control framework, and our data architecture. We were also glad to have finalized the FX consent order with the Federal Reserve. Given the distinctive part we play in the worldwide financial system, we remain dedicated to satisfying our regulators' expectations. Upgrading our technology infrastructure is progressing quickly, which enables us to bring new capabilities to clients. Over the course of the year, we merged our trading and reporting systems and, for a second consecutive year, eliminated 6% of our older applications. Such improvements align with major spending in our operations—for instance, bringing on commercial bankers to gain market share, enhancing the digital payment features available across our worldwide network, and streamlining workflows for clients of our security services. This was likewise a period when we strengthened our talent base via important internal promotions, along with targeted outside recruitment, among them Andy Sieg. The streamlined reporting framework has been well received by colleagues. With this new setup, we believe we are better equipped to serve clients and generate shareholder value. Mark will walk everyone through the specifics, but before I recap the full year, I want to set the baseline on a fourth quarter we found disappointing. We announced earlier this week some added outside pressures, a portion of which hit during the latter half of December — among them a $1.3 billion reserve build tied to transfer risk arising from our exposures in Argentina and Russia. A devaluation of the Argentine currency that came in larger than expected also produced a negative revenue impact of almost $900 million. Those factors, along with the $1.7 billion FDIC assessment, pushed this quarter to negative EPS of $1.16; painful as these items clearly are, they are highly idiosyncratic and won't alter the course we have charted. Looking at how the five businesses performed, services took the biggest hit from the Argentine devaluation. Even so, the underlying growth is still quite robust, powered by share gains and client wins. All told, services revenues rose 16% for the full year even with the Argentine devaluation weighing on results. Over in TTS, cross-border transactions climbed 15%, and in Security Services, AUC and AUA each grew by nearly $3 trillion during the year. In markets, our fixed income results fell short of expectations, with a notable slowdown in December, especially in rates and FX. Markets likewise felt the effects of the Argentine devaluation. Our franchise is in a solid spot when it comes to corporate clients, and we continue to take actions aimed at improving returns—either by directing capital toward products that generate high returns or by pulling out of those that aren't a strategic fit. We delivered a decent quarter in equities, particularly in derivatives, and we recorded growth in prime balances, which is an area we've been focusing on. Well activity picked up speed in the fourth quarter, with revenues up 22%. On the whole, banking revenue stayed under pressure because of a weak wallet globally. Investment banking came up a bit for the year, and we finished 2023 as the number five franchise. We certainly want to do better. CEO confidence is on the rise, and our pipeline looks good to us, although the timing of a strong rebound is naturally still unclear. The market share we've picked up in segments like health care puts us in a strong position for the moment this business turns more decisively. At the same time, investment activity in Asia bounced back, with quarterly revenues climbing 21%, and Wealth at Work rising 18% for the year. On the whole, wealth revenues fell in 2023, and we completely acknowledge that this business is not where it should be. Andy has gotten off to a quick start. Along with resetting the expense base and making sure our balance sheet is used properly, he is honing our emphasis on developing fee-based revenue streams and investment AUM.
Jane Fraser
executiveLooking forward, by 2030 there will be $100 trillion in new wells created, mostly across North America and Asia, and since our clients keep $5.4 trillion with others rather than with us, we see a meaningful affinity here that can drive growth and bring us back to where we ought to be. USPB was a clear bright spot, with each product rising double-digits this quarter compared with a year ago, retail banking included, which gained from a rebound in mortgage origination; newly launched and updated offerings have lifted customer engagement now that the benefits of our investments are showing, and within Cards, IB and ANR kept growing, reflecting a lend versus spend mix that is more balanced and payment rates that are falling. Loss rates, as expected, have returned to where they stood before the pandemic, with customers in lower FICO bands driving that trend. Looking at the full year 2023, revenues ex-divestures rose 4%, but the Argentine devaluation largely prevented us from hitting the $78 billion revenue figure; we came in on our full year expense guidance, and our CET1 ratio climbed to 13.3% over the year; tangible book value per share increased 6% to $86.19, and we returned $6 billion of capital to shareholders via common dividends and share buybacks. We stay committed to returning capital to investors through both of those channels going forward. Looking back over the year, I'd like to point out that during a turbulent stretch for banking and geopolitics, we served as a pillar of support for both the system and our clients, and I take great pride in how our teams across the globe delivered in difficult circumstances. In terms of the macro backdrop, 2024 appears comparable to 2023, with rates and inflation easing. We anticipate a global growth slowdown, and should an ordinary recession occur, the US is in good shape to weather it. Thanks to a robust balance sheet, plentiful liquidity and careful risk management, we are positioned to assist our clients through any conditions that may arise. Also, we believe conditions such as these suit us well, since we have progressed so far with simplifying our operations and completing divestitures. Next year, 2024, marks a turning point, because we'll be in a position to devote our full attention to how our five businesses perform and to our transformation. I understand how significant this year is, and I have strong confidence that the benefits of the steps we've taken will show up through the momentum in our businesses. With support from investments in key products, we think we're able to keep raising revenues ex-divestitures by 4% to 5% across the medium term. Broadly speaking, our confidence is unchanged in our capacity to adjust to the shifting capital and macroeconomic landscape so that we can hit our medium-term return goals and give capital back to shareholders, all while carrying on with the investments our information requires. On that note, I'll hand things over to Mark, and after that we'll be glad, as we always are, to field your questions.
Mark Mason
executiveThanks, Jane, and good morning, everyone. There's plenty to get through on today's call. I'll begin with the firm-wide financial results for the fourth quarter and the full year, concentrating on year-over-year comparisons unless I say otherwise. I'll also cover our guidance for 2024 and finish up with the path toward our medium-term return target. The way we present our results reflects the changes we've made alongside our organizational simplification, including reporting legacy franchises and corporate other within all other. But before diving into the results, let me take you through some of the notable items that hit the quarter and were included in the 8-K we filed recently. On slide seven, upper right corner, those items appear before taxes. Roughly $1.7 billion in FDIC special assessment charges related to the regional bank failures back in March — that hit expenses within all other. About $780 million in restructuring charges tied to steps we took as part of simplifying the organization, which will bring headcount down and generate savings down the road over the medium term — that also landed in expenses within all other. And the Argentina currency devaluation cost us approximately $880 million, booked in noninterest revenue across services, markets and banking, with the breakdown by business available in the appendix of the presentation. Although Argentina's currency devaluation hurt us this quarter, we also gained from elevated interest rates—bringing in roughly $250 million of NII on the net investment for the period, reflecting the hyperinflationary conditions—along with a $1.3 billion reserve build tied to heightened transfer risk on our Russia and Argentina exposures, as outlined in the 8-K. That effect lands largely within other provisions and cost of credit, and because of how global these businesses are, it stretches across several of them. Taken together, these factors reduced diluted EPS by about $2 and RoTCE by roughly 920 basis points. Moving to the left side of the slide, which covers our financial results for the entire firm: for the fourth quarter, we reported a net loss of $1.8 billion and a net loss per share of $1.16 on $17.4 billion of revenue. Excluding the notable items, diluted EPS would have been $0.84 with an RoTCE of 4.1% for the quarter. Total revenues for the quarter decreased by 3% on a reported basis. Excluding divestiture-related impacts and the impact of the Argentina devaluation, revenues increased 2%, driven by strength across services, USPB and investment banking, partially offset by lower revenues in markets and wealth and the revenue reduction from the closed exits and wind down. Now looking at expenses, we recorded $16 billion, a figure that includes the FDIC special assessment plus some modest costs tied to divestitures. Once you strip those out, expenses rose 10% to $14.2 billion, mostly because of the restructuring charge I referenced earlier. On cost of credit, the number came in at about $3.5 billion. Leaving aside the reserve build connected to transfer risk, net credit losses on cards — now back at pre-COVID levels — were the primary factor, together with ACL builds associated with new card volume. At quarter end, total reserves stood at nearly $22 billion, with the reserves-to-funded-loans ratio at approximately 2.7%. For the full year, we generated $9.2 billion in net income and an RoTCE of 4.9%; once you adjust for the notable items, net income was about $13.1 billion, with an RoTCE of 7.3%. Slide eight lays out full-year revenue trends by business covering 2021 through 2023. One thing worth flagging: when we changed to align with the new financial reporting structure, we shifted most of the financing and securitization business out of banking and into markets; we also put in place a revenue-sharing arrangement inside banking and among banking, services and markets so that the benefits businesses receive from our relationship-based lending are reflected. The impact of those adjustments is now visible in our results as well as our historical financials; moving on to the full-year numbers. In Services, we had a record year with revenues reaching $18.1 billion, a 16% increase, driven by both rates and business actions, new client wins, and deeper relationships with existing clients, though partly offset by the Argentina devaluation. Markets revenues declined 6% to $18.9 billion, largely due to lower volatility and a significant slowdown in December. The Argentina devaluation also weighed on the markets business. Banking revenues were down 15% to $4.6 billion, primarily as a result of the mark-to-market on loan hedges and a decrease in corporate lending. Investment banking revenues were roughly flat for the year, as we gained share amidst the declining wallet. On the corporate lending side, revenues fell 4% once you set aside mark-to-market effects on loan hedges. Wealth revenues dropped 5%, landing at $7.1 billion, and the main driver was a deposit mix that moved toward products with higher yields, which pushed deposit spreads lower. USPB revenues climbed 14% to $19.2 billion, driven largely by card balance growth as the benefits of what we've put into digital acquisition and customer engagement keep showing up. All in, revenues excluding divestitures were $77.1 billion, under our full-year guidance range of $78 billion to $79 billion, and the biggest reasons were the Argentina devaluation's impact, weaker markets performance, especially in December, and loan hedge losses; even so, NIIX ex-markets reached $47.6 billion, which matches our guidance. Even with a tough backdrop and the Argentina devaluation weighing on us, revenues across the firm rose about 4% excluding divestitures, matching the target we set at Investor Day — evidence of what our diversified model and ongoing investments deliver. Slide nine lays out how expenses moved over the full year from 2021 through 2023; once you set aside the FDIC special assessment and divestiture-related effects, 2023 expenses came to $54.3 billion, consistent with the guidance we gave. That number, as I mentioned, includes approximately $780 million of restructuring charges connected to simplifying the organization, along with about $730 million of additional severance costs, which addressed stranded costs and let us start right-sizing the businesses. Relative to last year, the rise in expenses continued to be driven by transformation and business-led investments, costs tied to volume, and further spending on risk and controls and technology, which was partly offset by productivity savings and lower expenses and legacy franchises in all other. Over the past few years, we have been directing money into these themes, and that has influenced both how the firm performed and the businesses themselves. Slide 10 sets out the components of our transformation and technology spend from 2021 to 2023. Over the last three years, we have invested substantially in our infrastructure, platforms, applications, processes and data. Looking at the chart at the top of the slide, roughly 30% of what we put into transformation over those three years was allocated to technology, and the rest covered non-tech staff and consultants. During 2023, as our transformation work has matured, we've shifted spending away from consulting toward technology and compensation. That trend should continue. In total, our technology investment in 2023 came to over $12 billion. Beyond transformation, these technology dollars also go toward digital innovation, developing new products, improving the client experience, and foundational infrastructure areas like cloud and cyber.
Mark Mason
executiveTurning to slide 11, we present the main credit metrics for both consumer and corporate portfolios. Roughly 80% of card loans across our branded cards and retail services businesses go to consumers whose FICO scores are 680 or above. NCL rates in both portfolios are now at pre-COVID levels, yet our reserves remain solid, with a reserve to funded loan ratio of 7.7%. Within the corporate portfolio, most of our exposure is investment grade, and that shows up in the low level of nonaccrual loans, which stand at 63 basis points of total corporate loans. We're pleased with the quality and mix of the portfolio and feel adequately reserved for today's conditions. Regarding Argentina, the appendix contains a slide laying out the value Argentina contributes to the global network, the broader institutional client relationships we hold there, and the strength of our financial profile in that country. Regarding Russia, we've also put a slide in the appendix. There you'll see that the transfer risk reserves we've taken have substantially cut our net investment, and with it our risk of loss tied to Russia. Slide 12 presents our summary balance sheet along with key capital and liquidity metrics. We hold a very strong $2.4 trillion balance sheet, funded partly through a well-diversified $1.3 trillion deposit base that is deployed into high-quality diversified assets. The bulk of our deposits — $801 billion — are institutional and operational, spread over 90 countries, and they're supplemented by $426 billion in US personal banking and wealth deposits. We hold about $561 billion of HQLA together with roughly $690 billion of loans, and our total liquidity resources stood at $965 billion. Our LCR slipped slightly to 116%, while tangible book value per share reached $86.19, a 6% increase. Down in the bottom left corner of the slide, a full CET1 walk lays out the 2023 drivers in more detail. To start, we brought in $8 billion of net income to common, contributing 70 basis points. Next, common dividends plus share buybacks gave back $6.1 billion to shareholders, and that accounted for roughly a 53-basis-point decline. Then lower rates across our AFS investment portfolio helped us, adding 20 basis points. The last three basis points came mostly from increased RWA, partly offset by capital freed up when we left certain markets. We ended the quarter at a CET1 capital ratio of 13.3%, which is about 100 basis points higher than the 12.3% regulatory requirement. So as you can see, our CET1 ratio has risen by roughly 30 basis points during the year, even as we returned more than $6 billion to shareholders via common dividends and repurchases. As Jane said earlier, we're not happy with how our businesses are performing or the returns they're delivering. So we're sharply focused on carrying out our strategy, making the organization simpler and getting the expense base to the right size. Just as a reminder, the investments we've made have touched every single one of our businesses, and you'll see that on the slides that follow. Moving to slide 13, which covers how services did in the fourth quarter and across the full year. Revenue was up 6% for the quarter, driven mainly by NII in TTS and security services, and partly offset by NIR, which mirrored the Argentina devaluation. Once you strip out the Argentina devaluation impact, services noninterest revenues were up 20%. We saw a 9% rise in expenses, driven largely by continued spending on technology, product innovation, and the client experience. The cost of credit reached $646 million, which included a reserve build of about $652 million, primarily related to transfer risk in Russia and Argentina. Net income dropped to $776 million, as higher revenues were more than offset by an increased cost of credit and elevated expenses. Average loans were up 6%, largely due to robust demand for working capital loans in TTS, both across North America and internationally. Average deposits fell 3%, since quantitative tightening more than outweighed new client acquisition and deepening with existing clients; however, on a sequential basis, deposits increased 1%. Services delivered an RoTCE of 13.4% for the quarter. Across the entire year, services produced a return on tangible common equity of 20%, bringing in $18.1 billion of revenue; the fourth-quarter and full-year markets figures appear on slide 14. Markets revenues declined 19% compared with a robust quarter the prior year, driven by a drop in fixed income plus the devaluation effect, partially countered by equities growth. Fixed income revenues fell 25%, chiefly from rates and currencies given reduced volatility and a notable December slowdown, together with the devaluation impact. Even so, underlying momentum in equities remained healthy, with revenues climbing 9% as every product posted gains, and we keep expanding prime balances while achieving meaningful headway toward our revenue-to-RWA objectives. Expenses climbed 8%, with the increase coming from spending on transformation and risk and controls, along with costs tied to volume, which were partially offset by savings from productivity. The cost of credit came in at $209 million, which included a reserve build of about $179 million, mainly related to transfer risk in Russia and Argentina. Markets posted a net loss of $134 million, since higher expenses and a higher cost of credit outweighed revenues. Average loans grew 4% to $115 billion, with stronger client demand for credit fueling growth in warehouse lending. Average trading assets were up 18% to $391 billion, mostly from treasuries and mortgage-backed securities, reflecting strong client activity in fixed income through much of the year. Although the quarter proved difficult, markets delivered reasonably solid results across the entire year, posting $18.9 billion in revenue and a 7.4% RoTCE, set against exceptionally strong performance during the previous year, and our attention is on enhancing returns as time goes on via a mix of revenue growth, expense discipline and capital optimization; slide 15 presents the banking results for both the fourth quarter and the full year. Banking revenues rose 22%, fueled by expansion in investment banking fees and smaller losses on loan hedges, partly offset by reduced corporate lending revenue. Investment banking revenues climbed 27% year-over-year, propelled by DCM and advisory amid better market sentiment. In advisory, we observed indications of strength spanning technology, health care and energy, and we feel good about how strong our pipeline is. Corporate lending revenues, excluding mark-to-market on loan hedges, fell 26%, mainly because of a smaller revenue share from investment banking services and markets. Expenses rose 37%, chiefly because no operational loss reserve release occurred in the prior year. Apart from that reserve release, expenses stayed roughly flat. Cost of credit came to $185 million, caused by a reserve build tied to transfer risk in Russia and Argentina. The NCL rate equaled 32 basis points of average loans, and we closed the quarter with a reserve to funded loan ratio of 1.6%. Banking posted a net loss of $322 million, since higher expenses and cost of credit outweighed the revenue increase. RoTCE was negative 6% for the quarter.
Mark Mason
executiveNow looking at the full year, banking delivered a return on tangible common equity of negative 0.2% while generating $4.6 billion in revenue. It's evident, then, that we still have more work to do on returns; and while predicting exactly when activity levels will normalize is difficult, we're positioning the business to capitalize on a market wallet recovery, which means ongoing investment in key growth areas, bringing in stronger talent within traditional sectors, and continuing to right-size the business. On Slide 16 you can see wealth results for both the fourth quarter and the full year. Wealth revenues dropped 3%, primarily due to lower deposit spreads, which was partly offset by reduced mortgage funding costs and increased investment fee revenues. Noninterest revenue is showing solid momentum—up 13% in the fourth quarter—supported by growth in investment assets, more client activity, and market performance. Expenses increased 4%, largely from spending on risk and controls and on technology, partially offset by swapping out strategic investments and by tighter cost discipline as we start to right-size the expense base in the business. Wealth posted net income of $5 million, with revenues largely offset by higher expenses. Client balances climbed 6%, mostly on higher client investment assets, partly offset by a decline in deposit balances. Average loans held steady as we keep optimizing capital usage. Average deposits dropped 2%, which reflects the ongoing shift of deposits into higher-yielding investments on Citi's platform. Client investment assets climbed 12%, helped by acquisitions and gains from higher market valuations, and net new assets are showing strong momentum—they more than doubled to $16 billion this quarter. Across the full year, we brought in an estimated $21 billion in net new assets. RoTCE came in at 0.1% for the quarter, and for the full year it was 2.6% on $7.1 billion of revenue. Going forward, we'll lift returns in the business by investing in talent to carry out our refocused strategy aimed at growing investment revenue, while working to right-size the expense base. We'll wind down non-core initiatives, part ways with less productive performers, and bring greater discipline to every expense line. On slide 17, you can see how US Personal Banking performed in Q4 and across the whole year. Revenues there climbed 12%. For branded cards, revenues were up 10%, which came from a better net interest margin and a 13% increase in interest-earning balances; new account acquisition also keeps growing at a healthy pace, rising 8%, with spend volumes up 3%. Retail services revenues gained 15%, again helped by a higher net interest margin and 11% growth in interest-earning balances, along with lower partner payments stemming from higher net credit losses. Retail banking revenues also rose 15%, supported by wider deposit spreads, loan growth, and better mortgage margins. Operating costs decreased by 1%, since increased spending on lending program support, client engagement, and the simplified banking launch was balanced out by reduced non-volume-related costs. Credit costs reached $2.1 billion, a 20% increase, primarily due to higher NCLs, partially offset by a smaller ACL build. Net income climbed to $201 million, fueled by greater revenues that were partly counteracted by an elevated cost of credit. Average deposits declined 5%, a result of moving relationships and their associated deposits into our wealth business; progress on our digital strategy continues, with digital deposits up 14% and active digital users 6% higher. RoTCE for the quarter was 3.6%. For the full year, US Personal Banking posted an RoTCE of 8.3%, or $19.2 billion of revenue. Once again, our focus is on lifting the return profile of the business. Steering through this phase of the credit cycle and keeping up our progress in retail banking will be essential. Slide 18 shows results for all other on a managed basis, covering corporate other and legacy franchises while excluding divestiture-related items. Revenue fell 17%, which reflected a 29% drop in NII stemming from the closed exits and the wind down, partially offset by greater noninterest revenue, while expenses rose to $4.5 billion, pushed up by the FDIC special assessment and restructuring costs, partly offset by reduced expenses in both the wind down and the exit markets. Turning to slide 20, as 2024 gets underway, conditions remain somewhat unclear and the markets continue to be difficult to forecast; nonetheless, judging by what we observe at present, we anticipate revenue of approximately $80 billion to $81 billion, as the left side of the slide illustrates. Key drivers are shown on the right-hand side of the slide. For TTS, we see revenue growth coming from winning new clients, strengthening relationships with our current clients, and sustained momentum among commercial clients as we continue to capitalize on our global footprint and product innovation. Within Security Services, our pipeline is quite healthy, and we will continue bringing on assets under custody from new mandates, securing new clients, and deepening ties with existing clients. In Investment Banking, we expect activity to rebound and plan to maintain our position as the wallet recovers. Down the road, we anticipate that what we've put into key growth areas—health care and technology among them—will enable us to pick up share. We likewise look for a modest rebound in wealth as we carry out our refocused strategy aimed at growing investment fees, especially among clients we already serve. Within USPB, we anticipate card balances will continue rising on the strength of the investments we've been making, while lower partner payments in retail services keep fueling revenue growth. We also expect continued improvement in how our retail brand performs. On NII, if we set markets aside, net interest income should come down a little, because the volume growth we're expecting in loans and deposits gets more than outweighed by lower US rates and the decrease from the closed exits and the wind-down. Turning to slide 21, our expense projection is about $53.5 billion to $53.8 billion, below $54.3 billion, although volume-related expenses might shift that. The reduction will be driven by gains from our organizational simplification, continued cuts resulting from market exits and wind-downs, and productivity savings — partially offset by risk and controls spending as well as volume-related expenses. This outlook accounts for greater severance expenses plus other potential charges tied to simplifying the organization — roughly $700 million to $1 billion in total. Those moves will help reduce headcount between now and the end of 2024 and across the medium term, and the following slide walks through the details. On Slide 22, we show the factors behind lower headcount and spending over the medium term. Three forces, as noted previously, will drive our expenses down: simplifying the organization, including removing layers of management; getting rid of stranded costs as we do more to cut unneeded overhead following the market exits; and realizing productivity gains from the transformation and technology investments we've made. Combined, those three factors should reduce our workforce by a net 20,000 people — Mexico not included — and deliver net run-rate savings between $2 billion and $2.5 billion across the medium term.
Mark Mason
executiveThat's the piece that underpins our path to somewhere between $51 billion and $53 billion of expenses, with the final figure hinging on costs tied to volume. By trimming both headcount and spending, we'll be able to right-size the company and its businesses, which should sharpen performance and returns. Our 2024 outlook for US Cards appears on Slide 23. Turning to credit performance, based on the trends we're seeing, we expect NCL rates to rise above pre-COVID levels in both the branded cards and retail services portfolios and to peak in 2024; for the full year 2024, we're projecting branded card NCL rates of 3.5% to 4% and a retail services NCL rate of 5.75% to 6.25%. Regarding reserves, we have set aside funds based on a weighted eight-quarter average unemployment rate of nearly 5%, and that figure accounts for a downside case of roughly 6.8%. How much we add to the ACL in 2024 will hinge primarily on the volume growth we achieve, as well as shifts in the macro scenarios and the likelihoods we assign to them, and we anticipate cards will keep up their momentum, although closer to mid-single-digit loan growth. Our medium-term targets appear on Slide 24. As for revenue, we continue to project a 4% to 5% CAGR across the medium term, and that includes the steady decline in revenue caused by the completed exits and the wind down. On the expense side, we are now positioned to begin reducing our expenses in 2024. Regarding credit, the cost of it will hinge on the mix of our portfolio, our volumes, and macro assumptions. We're dedicated to giving capital back to shareholders, and in fact we anticipate a modest amount of buybacks during Q1 of 2024. To sum up, even though the world has shifted considerably and the components have changed since Investor Day, our strategy remains the same, and we're confident we're on the correct path toward delivering our 11% to 12% RoTCE over the medium term. With that, Jane and I would be glad to take your questions.
Mike Mayo
analystHello. I went through the earnings presentation closely, particularly slide four. And I believe this question is on a lot of people's minds. I tally 12 restructurings at Citigroup. And I tally 12 restructurings at Citigroup that have failed. You may disagree with that number 12. It might be five, it might be eight, it might be 12; it could be higher, but I have not talked to a single investor of any kind who would claim Citi has succeeded on its earlier restructuring. So the question is, why is this time different? First, who is this new and improved Citigroup? Second, why have expenses fallen even more, particularly when almost nobody I talk to thinks you will hit your revenue goal? And third, Jane, how confident are you about reaching that 11% to 12% RoTCE in '25 or '26? Thanks.
Jane Fraser
executiveThank you so much, Mike. I'll start with the question of who Citi is. Citi, I'm happy to say, is at last simple. At Investor Day, I described a vision of becoming the preeminent banking partner for clients' cross-border needs. That vision was built on five core, interconnected businesses. We embarked on a deliberate path to reach it. And over the past three years, we have done exactly that. Page four shows who we are at present: five interconnected businesses, nothing more and nothing less. Our organization is now structured around those five businesses, which lets us concentrate on two priorities. The first is enhancing the performance and returns of those five core businesses so we can hit the medium-term RoTCE target we set out; the second is tackling our regulatory issues through the transformation. I should also note that I completely understand 2024 is an inflection year, Mike. Both I and the management team are accountable for delivering, and you and our investors have the transparency required to hold us accountable. Why would things turn out differently now? I realize full well that people have tried to reshape this firm many times before. Both I and the management team are completely dedicated to remaking this company over the long haul, and we're tackling the problems that previously slowed us down. The past three years give you concrete evidence: we made plenty of hard calls and drove through an enormous amount of change to arrive at the simple Citi we have today. Our strategy was entirely reset, which leaves us with a far more focused business and operating model, and we've announced the most far-reaching changes to how our organization is structured. From where I sit, what matters even more is the way we operate this bank—something we've focused on since the financial crisis, with the goals of making it simpler and strengthening accountability. You've seen how quickly we've moved; we're on track with this effort, and by the end of Q1 it will generate over $1 billion in run-rate savings, all of it stemming from the organizational actions we described to you in September. We've accomplished this while continuing to invest, which I believe is another distinguishing factor. We've committed significant capital to our transformation. And although our consent orders capitalized that, these investments will in the end pay off through automation, through well governed data, through consolidated platforms; we've also made considerable investments in our business to support the 4% to 5% revenue growth and to ensure client momentum; and those investments have helped us broaden our product suite, put money into digital capabilities, automate our processes, and capture synergies through a client organization. We've also recruited some remarkable external talent in key strategic areas, including Andy to lead wealth, and we now have a good balance between experienced Citi people and external talent with fresh perspectives through multiple layers of the organization; so we are doing things the right way. Our focus is on the long haul, and we're acting with speed. We'll require the funds—and we're already spending them—to meet our regulatory obligations, but that spending is already factored into our medium-term path to an 11% to 12% RoTCE. This already feels like a different bank. There's more work ahead. I know '24 is a pivotal year; and as I mentioned, the picture is much clearer now, letting us concentrate on two priorities: lifting our business performance and delivering the transformation. As we've seen over the past three years, neither of those follows an entirely straight line. We're all aware of that; we have to earn our credibility. We are dedicated to that goal, and we're giving much greater visibility into how the business is performing, which lets investors understand our progress more clearly. On your last question, my management team and I bear full responsibility for completing all of this, and we will. Mark, what about expenses?
Mark Mason
executiveYes. Thank you, Jane, and why are expenses lower to a greater degree? I believe, addressing your question, Jane, we have been putting money into the franchise, on the front end and, importantly, into transformation as well as risk and controls. What I would note is that during 2023, we reported expenses of $54.3 billion, excluding the FDIC charge. That matches the guidance we provided. But I would also point out that we additionally included $780 million tied to the restructuring charge, which exceeds what I had laid out in terms of guidance. So the capacity we generated through our work over the year, we deployed that wisely; we used it to cover the org simplification costs so that we can capture the savings later on, and we will keep managing our expenses in a disciplined and smart manner. That means spending what is needed on transformation and risk and controls, while driving better efficiencies and productivities along the way to make sure we reach that 11% to 12%. And regarding your point that revenues are to decline or land below expectations, we will adjust the expenses accordingly.
Glenn Schorr
analystHi. Thanks a lot. So, you're obviously making a great deal of progress, and I hate to ask this question so early, but I think it matters. Your guidance on expenses and revenue both look solid, and you clearly have the cost side under control. So my question is this: how do you weigh the near-term profitability gains that everyone badly wants against making sure the right investments get made? Because looking around the world, there are lots of opportunities to grow — your branch network, the wealth management ambitions, the digital investments. So how do you — how can we be confident that all the right future investments are being made while you keep taking costs out in all the good ways you have been?
Mark Mason
executiveYeah, thanks, Glenn. I suppose I'll kick things off, and Jane, please chime in whenever you like. The way we see it, this is a matter of striking the right balance, and we examine every one of our five core businesses individually. Our strategy is certainly well defined, yet we ask where the growth sits, which return opportunities come with each business, and how we make sure resources are put behind them so we can serve the client and achieve those returns over the long run. We need to balance that against what modernization of our operations will cost, and those trade-offs get made continually; but the key point is that whenever we put money in to seize growth opportunities, we stay nimble — we try to be nimble about it — which means that if those opportunities fail to develop as we expect, since the cycle simply doesn't mature or take shape that way, we must be disciplined enough to scale them back. That is exactly what you have witnessed over the last year or more: where we invested in the business and didn't get the upside we had anticipated, we cut that spending, correct — and that is the sort of iterative process, so to speak, Glenn, that we are instituting so that once we're through this, we remain in position to capture growth. In investment banking, for instance, we've put money into healthcare and technology, expanding our capabilities so we're ready for a market recovery. That leaves us feeling positive. We've taken comparable steps in our wealth business; we're putting substantial investment into our TTS franchise so that we stay competitive in that area. That's the kind of discipline called for. At times it means making a trade-off, though we've concentrated hard on handling it wisely.
Glenn Schorr
analystThanks for that. Perhaps just a quick question on Services — clearly it rose 16% and set a record, which is excellent. I’m not sure whether you’ve broken out how much of that came from rate versus new business, but you do have solid momentum in the core business and a pipeline of one, though not yet funded; so I suppose what I’m asking is, where can Services land over, say, the coming two years in terms of growth, while rates decline yet your business keeps winning new wins?
Mark Mason
executiveYes, absolutely. Would you like me to? Certainly.
Jane Fraser
executiveAbsolutely, I’ll handle that question. Let’s start by looking at TTS. As we noted, TTS growth this year—19% excluding Argentina—was driven both by rates and by the strong business actions we’ve taken, and that shows up across the various drivers. Cross-border rose 23%, while commercial cards increased 8%. Regarding growth prospects, from ’21 through ’23 we delivered average revenue growth of 22%, far exceeding the high single-digit guidance we gave at Investor Day. That result wasn’t purely because of the rate cycle. Rates clearly contributed, and as we now lap the prior periods that benefited from those rate increases, we certainly expect revenue growth at mid-single digit. This will stem from several distinct areas. To start, our attention on fee strategy—we're leveraging robust client involvement, top-tier client solutions, and executing on numerous growth efforts we've invested in throughout every client segment. We'll keep refining our deposit portfolio and attracting superior-quality deposits; plus, when rates are lower, GDP tends to rise, so you'd anticipate somewhat stronger expansion in our capital-efficient payment volumes. You'll observe us persistently bringing on new clients and strengthening ties with those we already serve. And I'd highlight what's driving our confidence — new client acquisition is up 27% this year, and we've maintained an 82% win-loss ratio on new deals. That held true across various client segments. Revenue from these clients keeps ramping up as we broaden our footprint across geographies and product suites with them. You'll also keep seeing us put money into the infrastructure and platforms we've been building, rolling out new innovative products, and we're picking up momentum from recent launches like Citi Token Services, Payment Express, 24/7 Clearing, and so on; so I think the main takeaway on TTS is that we'll keep investing in it. We anticipate robust momentum with clients; feedback on what we can do has been consistently favorable. As a result, we look for solid worldwide expansion, which should definitely be beneficial once the interest-rate cycle turns downward. There's a reason it's considered a prized asset. Turning briefly to security services: as noted, we've secured quite a few high-profile mandates spanning every client segment. That pipeline covers both investors and issuers, and growing our share among US-based asset managers was among the central strategies Open implemented. Our share stood at just 2.6% back in 2020 — quite low. The figure now stands at 4.3%. Much of the pipeline expansion has come from our global network names, as well as from prominent firms in the US asset manager arena. I believe that reflects how we link our capabilities together, which delivers major efficiencies for these players' clients. Mark, did I miss anything? You know this industry is one I understand well.
Mark Mason
executiveLike you correctly pointed out, there's a lot of returning business and strong growth potential. To address one of your questions, Glenn, roughly half of the NII growth could be tied to interest rates, and approximately half, I would say, comes from business action—meaning our work alongside clients to build that momentum. Then, when you look at noninterest revenue for services: it rose around 20% during the quarter compared with a year earlier if you strip out the Argentina devaluation effect, and it was up 7% on a full-year basis. So there's solid momentum in noninterest revenue growth too.
John McDonald
analystMorning — hi there. Mark, I'd like to hear your take on how fast capital is building. Basel III proposals are obviously on the table, though naturally they might shift — and even if they remain unchanged, you've got a couple of years to phase them in and maybe locate some mitigation chances. Given all those moving parts, along with being able to buy back some stock down the road as you mentioned earlier, what's the right way for us to think about your capital build?
Mark Mason
executiveYeah, absolutely. So look, John, the Basel III proposal is clearly still out there and being discussed. We've spoken up quite a bit about what it could potentially do. We've been pretty disciplined about capital management too, and we picked up more than 30 basis points over the course of the year. You've watched us manage that actively throughout the year. That's going to continue; naturally, the earnings we generate feed into it. We want to keep pushing growth throughout the business. With our stock trading at 0.5 times book, wherever possible we want to repurchase as many shares as we can, and over the last couple of quarters we've aimed to stay disciplined by doing so at a modest level. You heard me say it — we'll do the same thing this quarter, again at a modest level. Even so, we need to think carefully about how those challenges could play out, and we're already figuring out which steps we'd take to offset them if things end up resembling the proposal as it stands now. That means continuous, hands-on management to keep the right balance in serving our clients while, of course, keeping an appropriate level of capital given the uncertainty in the environment, and looking at buybacks whenever we're in a position to pursue them.
John McDonald
analystOkay. To follow up about expenses, I'm not sure I grasped it. In your view, has the transformation spending reached its peak, comparing what you'll spend on transformation this year with last year? And are those transformation benefits starting to appear yet?
Mark Mason
executiveYeah. To be clear, whatever is needed on transformation and on risk and controls, we're going to keep spending. And so this year we did see a tick up. For 2024 we've got a plan. And if we've got to spend a bit more than what we spent this year, we're going to spend more. That's what the plan calls for. That is exactly what we intend to do. It falls within the guidance figure I provided, correct? So that is—that matters to us. Clearly, I believe it will produce operational gains and future savings. It is included in the $2 billion to $2.5 billion, though that represents the initial phase, so to speak, of the transformation spending generating returns. As we discussed at Investor Day, frankly, we will keep realizing expense benefits past the medium term from some of this transformation investment we have been making. So I'd view the medium term as when the payoff from our transformation, risk, and control investments really begins to show.
Jane Fraser
executiveYes, I think you've got it exactly right there, Mark. So we're going to keep on with the investments that are required for the transformation. As we've consistently said, this is a journey spanning multiple years, and in the end it delivers benefits to shareholders. Also, a good portion of those expense savings we've discussed sit apart from our transformation — they come out of the operating expense base of our businesses, and we want to be sure that base is as productive and effective as it can be. As for the kinds of benefits we're seeing, this marks the second consecutive year in which we've retired 6% of our legacy platform base. And you've heard me mention moving 20 of our cash equity platforms onto one, six reporting ledgers onto one, and 11 sanction platforms onto one. So we're starting to see some of those benefits arrive. On other fronts, we automated independent price verification for 90% of our prioritized fixed income and equity securities; that has cut down on manual controls. It has made valuation more consistent. It has also affected how efficiently the business runs. We've loaded 98% of our prioritized wholesale and consumer data into two authorized repositories, which will likewise start to deliver some benefits for us. So all of this compounds. It's starting to build now thanks to all the work we've done, but it will take a while before it truly kicks in — as Mark said, when you genuinely feel it, that's a few years out. Still, we'll keep handing you the proof points along the way, so it isn't merely a case of trust us, it's coming — you'll watch it build.
Jim Mitchell
analystHi there, good afternoon. Mark, I'd like to follow up on the expense item—slide 22, where you mention $2 billion to $2.5 billion in expense savings. Honestly, I'm having trouble reconciling those figures. If you consider the exits and market wind-downs, you're likely near $2 billion there, and with stranded costs, you probably can't remove all of that. Severance runs about $700 million to $1 billion in '24, so it doesn't look like there's much in the way of genuine cost reduction in that figure—though maybe I'm mistaken. Could you walk me through what's actually embedded in those numbers? And you've hinted there could be more coming beyond the intermediate term.
Mark Mason
executiveSure. A couple of things I'd highlight for you. First, clearly we're projecting revenue growth across this period. That means there will be volume-driven expenses tied to it. Second, as I said in response to the earlier question, we keep investing in risk and controls as well as in the transformation throughout this period. So what you're seeing is an uptick in costs tied to at least those two items, and that gets offset by the savings we're beginning to realize—especially from the org simplification Jane has discussed, along with the stranded cost reduction that will keep unfolding, and also from some of the business rightsizing we mentioned in the prepared remarks. So it's important to keep in mind those headwinds and tailwinds that net down to this $2 billion to $2.5 billion. Then the last point I'd offer: looking at that medium-term figure of $51 billion to $53 billion, Mexico is still included. On one of the other pages we reference expenses related to Mexico, but given where we are, we'll be in the IPO process, so that remains part of this expense base. You can't overlook that.
Jim Mitchell
analystOkay, that clarification matters a lot — the $2 billion to $2.5 billion does include some volume growth tied to revenue, so that helps. Then, on the slides about revenue targets, one of the significant figures nobody really discussed was markets. How are you viewing how volatility has come in — the macro picture is improving, which might dampen volatility. When it comes to that business in '24, how are you thinking about it relative to your guidance?
Mark Mason
executiveIt's a hard business to forecast, as you know, especially for a full year and in certain cases for a quarter. So we essentially exclude it, though we've assumed markets are flat to modestly down — we've backed it out, and it's roughly flat. Not out of the 81 — not out of the 80 to 81, but you can see the guidance for NIR ex-markets and NII ex-market. So within the 80 to 81, we've assumed it's roughly flat. 2% to 2.5%.
Jim Mitchell
analystAll right, wonderful, thanks so much.
Ebrahim Poonawala
analystHi there, good afternoon. Mark, I believe — actually good morning — good afternoon, Jane. I just wanted to pick up on a point Mark made at the close of his initial answer, which is that from where I sit it's really tough to determine if revenues will expand or contract with the macro backdrop. Based on what you've shared today, should we assume that as we head into '26 and work toward that 11% RoTCE, if revenues happen to come in below expectations for any reason, you're comfortable with the expense flexibility available to offset that pressure?
Jane Fraser
executiveHello, this is Jane. Clearly, I'd like to step in on one thing, which is that we remain dedicated and highly confident in the 4% to 5% revenue growth rate, so there's no retreating from that figure, and that holds across a range of macro conditions and so forth. And when we consider the various businesses and the forecasts we hold, we have confidence in that. Naturally, should a severely unfavorable macro backdrop arise and so on, we have additional levers at our disposal, but Mark, I'll hand it over to you.
Mark Mason
executiveI certainly wasn't implying any lack of confidence in our top-line forecast. When you consider the strategy behind those five core businesses and how strong they are, our conviction there is considerable. That being said, as you noted, Jane, in a scenario where that fails to materialize, expenses tied to volume-based incentive comp and similar items would obviously decrease on their own, and we would make certain they declined in step with any revenue drop or shortfall, after which we'd adjust other spending — investment spend unrelated to risk and control and transformation, but other investments throughout the platform we would adjust as needed.
Ebrahim Poonawala
analystGreat, that's exactly what I was after. One more quick thing. When we consider right-sizing the Markets business, there have been headlines about the muni and the distressed business that you've exited — is there a danger that the Markets business ends up too small? Could it lack the scale needed to be efficient and relevant across the breadth of, say, fixed income or equities? If you could address that, thank you.
Jane Fraser
executiveIn short, no. Consider our Markets business: it comprises four businesses, each roughly $4 billion in size. There's our Global FX network, where we're typically number one in any given year, thanks to the strength and especially the corporate client base we serve. Rates is typically top three — together those are two of the biggest macro pools within fixed. On spread products, we've placed our financing and securitization business fully inside Markets as part of our simplification, creating a unified, scaled spreads product business. And lastly, equities, where our focus is on strengthening our prime offering and building balances. Clearly we still have ground to cover there. On prime balances, we're pleased they rose nicely this year on client momentum, and we are a leading equities derivatives franchise. So those are the four core businesses, and I return to our key point of differentiation and the reason we still feel well-positioned: a very differentiated corporate client base, and a very strong partnership among our core markets franchise, TTS, and banking — and security services too — which assists us in FX and commodities and in rates around the world. So Markets matters, both for its leadership and for how it fits the strengths we gain from the simplicity of those five core interconnected businesses. We've shown solid returns previously. I believe many of the actions we've taken will help drive returns going forward, and you should gain confidence from the discipline we're applying to RWA — 5.3%, nearing that target we set at Investor Day, which we're raising to 6%. The exits from non-strategic businesses demonstrate our focus on efficiency, and we've also made some good investments in our technology, which is putting us in a good place there. So I'd say don't worry about the shrinking — we're simply ensuring it truly plays to our strengths and that we optimize the returns.
Gerard Cassidy
analystGood afternoon, Mark and Jane.
Mark Mason
executiveGood afternoon.
Jane Fraser
executiveHey there.
Gerard Cassidy
analystMark, could you walk us through the revenue guidance as it relates to net interest income? I know you said it's going to come in lower, and part of that reflects reduced interest rates. A number of your peers have issued guidance that uses the forward curve for their net interest income projections, and that curve embeds six cuts from the Fed in our country. Can you give us some color on what sort of rate environment—I know you said lower rates, but any detail around that guidance?
Mark Mason
executiveYeah, I think what I referenced is within the 81 — the 80 to 81 range; we're assuming three to six cuts, correct? There's a range there, and the reason I frame it that way, excuse me, is that if you consider our IRE, as we've laid it out in the Qs previously, we're positioned so that a 100 basis point parallel shift in rates across the curve would produce a US dollar impact of only a couple $100 million, right, and so on the negative side, obviously, but it's a couple of $100 million. And so as we think about that forecast, and as I said, NII being down a bit, that accounts for roughly three to six cuts over the course of 2024, likely back-loaded, but that's what's baked in.
Gerard Cassidy
analystAll right, that's helpful. So then, Jane, this is more of a qualitative one than a quantitative one; but clearly there are a lot of moving pieces in the strategies you folks are carrying out. Leaving businesses, shrinking businesses, and particularly on the shrinking side, I believe you mentioned headcount of roughly 20,000 being reduced. How do you keep spirits up across the organization when you have these kinds of difficult choices that you all must make?
Jane Fraser
executiveYes, well, we also have parts that are expanding. So it does help to see — we have a diversified portfolio here. I think we're quite conscious that there is a human impact from the decisions we're making. We're attempting to be as open with our people as we are with our investors regarding what we need to do, the reasons we're doing it, what to expect, and setting that out so people grasp the logic behind the decisions and then they grasp what the decisions are as fast as they can. I think that's the most humane way to do this.
Erika Najarian
analystHello, and apologies for running the call long. I appreciate everyone's input. I have just one further question. Jane, at what point would you be at ease providing a buyback outlook extending past a single quarter at a time? I realize there's still some distance to cover, yet you do hold a 100 basis point cushion above your minimum, and I know Basel III and the game remain unresolved. And surely lowering risk isn't only about expenses, but also about watching — or being careful with — your RWA footprint; and considering where your stock trades versus book, when will you be more at ease offering something like a longer-term view that underpins your RoTCE target as it relates to the buyback?
Jane Fraser
executiveErika, that's an excellent question. It's one I pose to myself each morning upon waking, since — given the level at which we trade, the worth to our shareholders from buybacks is enormous. And Mark and I are strongly dedicated to that. We also recognize that we are establishing our credibility. And I don't wish to promise things we won't follow through on, even though we're going to have to change. I believe it's among the values we're genuinely striving to uphold firmly. And regarding the NPL, I think we'll soon have a clearer picture of this. The comment period was just extended and we want to see what it says. I think all of you have heard us at the Senate banking hearings voicing our worries about it. It's my strong hope that it is either wholly rewritten or very substantially so, so that it doesn't harm the economy and the competitiveness of the US banking system, the shift of more business toward shadow banks, which I believe has reached a point that is not healthy. So we're going to wait and see before — where that lands before we share it with you, but I would be posing precisely the same question if I were in your position.
Erika Najarian
analystThanks, Jane. I believe it was quite useful that you made that point in this public forum, where you're working to establish credibility, because when I consider what long-only investors have been eager to see from Citi regarding the prior leadership, it was that kind of awareness. And I think simply having that recognition of awareness is going to matter a great deal to investors. So, thank you.
Jane Fraser
executiveThank you.
Matt O'Connor
analystHello. I have a follow-up question regarding the Russia exposure shown on page 34. It looks as though the vet investment has cost you quite a lot, and you also note that this CTA would be capital neutral if the write-down happens. But what about the remaining exposure, and how exactly should we think about it — do you carry liability for some of those unremediable corporate dividends? I just don't — I believe a lot of us fail to grasp that sort of exposure. And is there risk ahead for you? Or are you expecting to clear the deck of the fund exposure going forward?
Jane Fraser
executiveYeah. Also, actually, before I turn things over to Mark, I'd like to respond to that in a somewhat broader way, since I'd have assumed this is something everyone is wondering about—particularly because of the company's generally weak returns and because our top-line figures this quarter largely reflect what we've been doing in Russia and Argentina. So, the bigger strategic question underlying it, and then we'll get to you on the Russia details. When you look at Citi, our global business model is differentiated, which means we remain committed over the long term to the countries where our multinational clients do business. What that means is we keep long-term capital invested in those countries, and we earn strong returns on that capital across the cycle. If we look at our leading services and FX businesses, they sit at the core of that network and, as you can see, they are producing double-digit results. That footprint does bring certain risks with it. I would frame them in terms of credit, currency, and transferability of capital; and over a long stretch of time we have demonstrated that we can manage those risks consistently. As for the currency and transfer items in Q4, the timing was not known, and we have been flagging those risks in our disclosures for a couple of years. Russia, I would characterize as quite distinctive—a wall, and for our firm, an extremely atypical liquidation. We managed it effectively. The wind down was carried out in an orderly fashion, with minimal losses incurred by our clients and minimal losses for us as well. Every one of our remaining net assets is now fully reserved against. And I think in a similar vein, if I spend a moment on Argentina, since I'm certain people have some questions about it—likewise, across the past several years, we reduced risk in our business model in that country; we don't operate a consumer bank there, so we've truly cut back our emerging market exposures to merely our institutional footprint, centered on multinational clients. You've heard us discuss that before and select high-grade local clients. Consider Argentina—it's a very good business for us over the cycle. And even after the impact of Q4, we had less than $5 million in credit losses in Argentina over a 10-year period. That's impressive—$5 million across 10 years. On currency risk, every one of us must record revenue at the official rate as opposed to the parallel market rate. We managed to hedge that exposure in part, though not completely, but we will certainly always make economic decisions about the business we run and did so with likely devaluations and capital controls in mind. That reserve is really a reserve — it depends on our capacity to convert and move capital consistent with US banking regulations. So I'd like to frame a few of this quarter's items against that backdrop: ours is a global business model. It concentrates heavily on investment-grade multinational clients. Our record in handling the many risks that come with our worldwide network has been extremely strong. And I believe what you're observing is a very conservative, reserve-oriented profile from us. Mark, anything you'd like to add?
Mark Mason
executiveOkay, just briefly on the Russia topic — as you're aware and as the slide indicates, we keep reducing our exposure in that market. It now stands at $6.5 billion, which is 13% lower than the prior year. And it's down by a third compared with 2021; we significantly cut back the consumer loans and consumer deposits there. Basically, what remains is a custody business plus corporate dividends we're holding that represent our clients' proceeds. Under law and regulation, we cannot pay those out. So we must hold them, and that's the item the slide refers to when it mentions unremitdable Russia corporate dividends. That isn't a loss risk for us, but we can't clear those given the situation in Russia at this point.
Matt O'Connor
analystAll right, that's clear. Then, on a separate note for credit card: you and many of your peers anticipate losses rising from here, but most of it seems to be things that recur this year, yourself included. So what makes you confident card losses will peak this year, since you're just getting back to a bit above a normalized level — is it some tightening you've done? What's behind that confidence as you look out over this year, because obviously there's still a step-up coming, right?
Mark Mason
executiveSure. A step-up is coming. As you point out, we provide a forecast for '23 regarding what the full-year estimate for NCLs will be, for both branded and for retail services. What I'd note is that you can actually see on the slide how loss rates dipped during the COVID period. So to some degree, what we're observing is somewhat of a catch-up on those as those portfolios mature over a longer period than you'd typically see in our cards portfolio. Beyond that, we've been originating new card, and you've noticed our acquisitions have grown, so obviously we have new card loans, and those are going through a far more normal maturation period. So as we examine the early buckets and the delinquencies that are playing out, we have a pretty solid sense of when we'd expect those to peak and at what level. And we believe they'll peak within '24, so that's reflected in that average forecast we've given. We haven't made material changes to our underwriting. However, mix evolution does occur. Transactors — we have a number of transactors that have somewhat come on to our portfolio and are in the mix of our branded portfolio as well. And so anyway, those are the drivers that give us confidence and inform the trajectory that we — that we're discussing here.
Ryan Kenny
analystHello, and thank you for the opportunity to ask. My question concerns quantitative tightening. Do you have any preliminary views on where Citi stands should the Fed wrap up Q2 ahead of schedule? Would that be a significant catalyst in your view? And might it allow you to reach your revenue goals even earlier?
Mark Mason
executiveYes. Well, once more, when I consider our exposure to interest rates, especially for the US dollar, we disclosed it in the prior Q, and we'll disclose it in this Q: for a 100 basis point parallel shift, we'd expect roughly negative $1.6 billion. Still, it's worth noting that only a couple of hundred million dollars of that relates to the US dollar piece. Likewise, if rates shifted the opposite way, positive 100, there'd be a modest effect when it comes to US dollar exposure. So our US dollar exposure is fairly neutral once more, assuming a static balance sheet and a parallel shift in the curve. As a result, we're roughly neutral to rates moving either direction, and hence the impact there.
Ryan Kenny
analystThere's also considerable optimism and discussion about a rebound in capital markets. Are you observing that? And could you bring us up to date on the investment banking pipeline in M&A, ECM, and DCM?
Jane Fraser
executiveYes. At the close of '23, the market environment was certainly far more constructive, with interest rate spreads and volatility for most of the year, and equity prices elevated. We see this, I think, as a useful basis for activity to pick up in '24, provided those tailwinds continue. And regarding our own pipeline, its breadth, depth, and quality are very solid. It stands higher than before COVID; so in constructive markets, we expect to advance these opportunities, and we're hearing considerably more confidence from CEOs and CFOs on this; and on our own side, as you know, we've been putting investment into certain higher-growth areas. That gives us a good balance between our traditionally strong sectors and high-growth areas; and we've been seeing quite good momentum in health care and technology, along with areas of traditional strength, namely energy and industrial. And I think we feel quite confident about the recovery in DCM, with the beginnings of one in 11. So cautiously optimistic at this point. I'm not — so I wouldn't claim it will accelerate enormously and at incredible speed, but I think we're feeling much better regarding the foundation. Mark, anything you'd like to add?
Mark Mason
executiveI completely agree.
Jane Fraser
executiveYeah.
Scott Siefers
analystGood afternoon, everyone, and thank you for taking the question. Has any revenue attrition been factored in by all of you, purely tied to the reduction in force? And, I suppose, more generally, in what way could that be built into the '24 revenue guidance? And I suppose, just at a high level, perhaps just a thought or two on.
Jane Fraser
executiveScott, apologies, I didn't catch what that was. I believe the phone line dropped out. The revenue attrition?
Scott Siefers
analystSorry about that. Yeah. I'm just wondering whether you've factored in any revenue loss tied to the reduction enforce over the next year or two?
Jane Fraser
executiveOkay. No, we haven't. A lot of the steps we've taken as part of simplifying the organization — so the roughly 5,000 roles we mentioned — those are mostly managerial positions; and they've largely hit the functions and the geographies, not nearly as much the revenue coming from revenue generators. And the other thing is, with the client organization, we're actually putting far more time in our people's hands so they can drive revenue forward. So I think what we're seeing here is addressing a few pockets of bureaucracy and places where we've been too complicated, where we can drive efficiency while preserving our frontline and encouraging them to be as revenue-productive as possible and to deliver the full force of the firm to the client. So I'd actually like to see the opposite.
Scott Siefers
analystAll right. Great. Thanks. So, Mark, for a moment, could you talk about, perhaps in general terms, how expenses will move across the year? I understand they're supposed to start coming down near the end; but what takes place in between now and then? Do they stay roughly flat alongside a core rate, or would there be some growth from normal business activity?
Mark Mason
executiveWhat I'd say is this: you should expect that during the first quarter, our total expenses would probably rise compared with the fourth, partly because, as Jane mentioned, we expect more from the org simplification and, as a result, dollars tied to that in Q1; and after that, I would expect a declining pattern to emerge through the fourth quarter.
Scott Siefers
analystPerfect. All right. Thank you.
Mark Mason
executiveYeah.
Vivek Juneja
analystHi, Jane. Hi, Mark.
Jane Fraser
executiveHi, Vivek.
Vivek Juneja
analystJust a couple of quick points to clarify; regarding your NII guidance, you mentioned you're assuming three to six cuts. I presume that's US. So outside the US, since you have more sensitivity there, are you assuming rates stay flat and unchanged?
Mark Mason
executiveSlight decreases elsewhere, but yes, decreases elsewhere too, though nowhere near the scale of what we're discussing for the US.
Vivek Juneja
analystAll right. So Jane, regarding what you said about the 20,000 headcount reductions — and I heard you mention 5,000 coming from managerial positions — where do the remaining 15,000 come from?
Jane Fraser
executiveLet me be clear about the ones we've already completed and the ones we're working on through organization simplification. When I think about that effort, it will wrap up at the end of the first quarter, as we said, and we expect roughly $1 billion in run rate saves from the org simplification work by itself. That accounts for about 5,000 heads; at the end of this month we're just about to finish Phase III, which means the first four layers of the organization will have been addressed. That's been a net reduction of about 1,500 managers out of a total of 12,000 roles; so roughly 13%; and these are mainly manager roles, as I discussed earlier. Then, thinking about where other expense opportunities lie on top of this, as Mark mentioned earlier, the stranded costs — we'll be completing the elimination of stranded costs from the divestitures, we'll keep going, and you've seen that happening, exiting marginal businesses and hobbies and similar things and being very disciplined about it. We have some businesses where we believe the core expense base needs right-sizing. Andy Sieg will be kicking that off in Wealth, and you'll start to see some of the impact in the first quarter. He's off to a strong start. And then there are other areas where we'll create more utilities. We've still got different fragmented activities across the firm that organization simplification has highlighted — we'll be aggregating those, creating utilities or consolidating some of those different functions. And that's before we even begin getting benefits from the transformation, where efficiencies will come through. We'll still have areas where we're investing; these will be, as we discussed, core business investments, there's going to be expense growth still in the top — from the volume growth we have, and we will be investing in our transformation. And all of this is happening over the medium term to get us to the 11% to 12% RoTCE target we discussed. So that 20,000 is — it's the number we estimate at the headcount. I don't love thinking headcount and I'm thinking about expenses. I think that's a more meaningful number. So as Mark laid out in his presentation, we have net expense saves that we expect to achieve in the medium term, and these are the raft of different areas that we will be contributing to it, and we're working hard at it.
Steven Chubak
analystHello, and thank you for fielding my questions. I have a few rather nitpicky modeling questions regarding the revenue side. Is any decrease in credit card late fees baked into the full-year revenue guidance? And at Citigroup, how big a contributor is that to revenues overall?
Mark Mason
executiveLet me think about that. Clearly, the proposals that are out there, and we've taken into account what can be known regarding that matter. We haven't provided external guidance on what that impact amounts to, but we do believe there are offsets and mitigants that in time, we'll be able to sort of put to work. So, to put it in a roundabout way, our revenue forecast does presume some baseline level of late-fee adjustment.
Steven Chubak
analystUnderstood. Regarding what you said earlier, Mark, about services NII — I'm having trouble squaring the 50 to 50 split of NII contribution between rate and volume components, especially since average loans and deposits were basically flat year over year. With NII up $3 billion, that does suggest a far bigger contribution from rates. I realize deposit fund transfer pricing and other noise play a part. So could you perhaps break that down a bit more for us?
Mark Mason
executiveWell, many factors come into play there. Obviously there's also the mix in terms of what we hold in the US versus outside the US; so — a number of elements are involved, and it's probably too much to walk you through during this call, but we'd be glad to follow up with you off-line and take you through it.
Mike Mayo
analystYeah, just to clarify — when you referred to the medium term on this call, in relation to employee reductions, expense savings, revenue targets, and lastly that 11% to 12%, does medium term mean by 2026, or does it mean something else?
Mark Mason
executiveYes, it's —
Jane Fraser
executiveThe year 2026.
Mike Mayo
analystAll right, thanks — understood.
Jane Fraser
executiveThanks, Mike.
Jennifer Landis
executiveThanks to all of you for being on the call. Should you have any additional questions afterward, please reach out to IR. Have a wonderful day. Thanks.
Operator
operatorThis concludes the Citi Fourth Quarter 2023 Earnings Call. You may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Citigroup Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Citigroup Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Citigroup Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.