Citigroup Inc. (C) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

July 12, 2024

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Banks earnings 91 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Jenn Landis

executive
#1

Thanks, operator. Hello everyone, and I appreciate all of you being here for our call covering results from the second quarter of 2024. With me this morning are Jane Fraser, our Chief Executive Officer, and Mark Mason, our Chief Financial Officer. Please keep in mind that the presentation we're discussing today can be downloaded from citigroup.com, our website, and it might include forward-looking statements. Those statements reflect what management currently expects and are open to uncertainty as well as shifts in circumstances. A range of factors, among them the ones outlined in our earnings materials and in our SEC filings, could cause actual results to differ materially from what those statements suggest. So, I'll now hand things over to Jane.

Jane Fraser

executive
#2

Thank you, Jenn, and good morning to all of you. Ahead of discussing the quarter's results, I'd like to begin by addressing the regulatory actions announced on Wednesday by the Federal Reserve and the Office of the Controller of the Currency. These actions pertain to the consent orders we and both agencies entered into during 2020. Four primary domains were covered by those orders: risk management, data governance, controls, and compliance. Our transformation effort is focused above all on those domains — this is our number one priority — and it represents a multiyear initiative to upgrade our infrastructure, unify previously distinct technology platforms, and bring automation to our processes and controls. Most of what was released this week had to do with managing the quality of our data. We've acknowledged openly over the course of this year that we fell behind in that particular area, and that we answered by increasing what we spend on it. The regulatory actions consisted of two civil money penalties, plus — under the revised consent order we have with the OCC — a newly established procedure intended to guarantee we allocate sufficient resources toward completing our remediation milestones on time. That procedure goes by the name Resource Review Plan. At this moment, we are drafting a plan that will be sent to the OCC. For context: Citigroup, which is our bank holding company, has the Federal Reserve as its primary regulator, whereas Citibank, N.A. has the OCC as its primary regulator. We call it CBNA, and it's our largest banking entity, accounting for about 70% of the assets we hold. The amended consent order we have with the OCC allows CBNA to continue making payments to Citigroup — at minimum, the dividends needed to cover debt service, preferred dividends, and other obligations that aren't discretionary. While we work on our Resource Review Plan and look for the OCC to sign off on it, anything above those amounts would require the OCC to raise no objection. These are intercompany dividends — money moving from CBNA up the chain, ultimately reaching the parent company, Citigroup. They're not the same thing as the common dividends Citigroup pays out to its shareholders. Actually, there's no restriction at all on Citigroup's capacity to pay common dividends to shareholders, and no restriction on repurchasing shares either. I want to be completely straightforward here: Citigroup's resources are ample enough that, despite the funding our transformation demands, we can still put money into our businesses and hand shareholders the capital returns we've planned. Our dividend will go up to $0.56 per share, an increase from $0.53, matching what we told everyone back in late June, and during this quarter we will restart buybacks at a modest level. These steps didn't catch us off guard entirely, but there's no question they leave our investors and our people feeling let down. That reaction makes complete sense to us. Even so, we remain sure we can bring these particular areas up to standard, just as we've managed to do elsewhere within the transformation. We're glad that on Wednesday, people recognized the real strides we've taken in carrying out our transformation and making our company simpler. A multiyear undertaking such as this was never going to move in a perfectly straight path, but I can assure you that the funds we've committed are starting to deliver benefits—reducing risk, tightening controls, and generating very tangible outcomes. Our investments in technology are producing returns; we've shortened loan booking times, installed automated controls for our traders to reduce mistakes, moved risk analytics to cloud-based infrastructure, and improved our platforms' resilience to reduce downtime. The changes we've made to how we're structured and how we work together are producing real results. We've taken out management layers and bureaucratic structures, and at the same time we've given our leaders greater authority. To serve our people better on workforce matters, we introduced new tools. Because we've put so much focus on culture, people are more accountable, and we've brought in outstanding talent — Vis Raghavan, Tim Ryan, and Andy Sieg among them. I give you my commitment, and the entire leadership team joins me in it: any area of the consent order where we're behind, we will devote whatever resources and focus it takes. We'll get this effort to the standard it needs to reach, exactly as we've already done in executing our strategy and streamlining the company. Turning to a quarter that was again quite strong, the results show how firmly we're sticking to our strategy and how hard we're working to reach the medium-term return target we've set. Net income came in at $3.2 billion, and that works out to $1.52 per share, while RoTCE was 7.2%. Revenue was up 4% on the whole, and it also grew across all five of our core businesses, with positive operating leverage in every one of them except a single business. Year-over-year, expenses were down 2%. The actions we're taking to simplify how the organization is structured, to get businesses like Markets and Wealth to the right size, and to remove stranded costs are beginning to show results, and we're doing this while increasing what we spend on our transformation. Looking ahead over the medium term, we believe these actions around simplification and stranded costs will deliver annual run rate savings of $2 billion to $2.5 billion. A 3% increase came through in Services, driven by strong fee growth, an area we've made a priority. In TTS, we saw more activity in cross-border payments as well as commercial cards. Security services rose 10%, with new client onboarding, deeper relationships with existing clients and market valuations contributing to a preliminary 9% increase in our assets under custody. During our recent Services Investor Day, we truly appreciated the chance to speak with you in depth about how we'll keep growing this high-returning business. And we're delighted that people are beginning to understand why we call it our crown jewel. To wrap up the quarter, Markets performed really well—better than we had expected. Fixed income came in a bit lower compared to the same period last year, mostly because of declines in FX and rates. That said, we saw solid issuance activity and growth in loans within financing and securitization, which is a business that delivers attractive returns. Equities climbed 37%, helped by a strong showing in derivatives, and that figure includes a gain from the Visa B exchange offer. In banking, we posted a 38% gain as wallet recovery gained traction and we picked up more share again. Our clients continued to have access to debt capital markets, with investment-grade issuance near all-time highs. Equity issuance also increased, particularly in convertibles, though companies are still waiting for the IPO window to reopen more fully. Fees from investment banking rose 63% compared with the previous year, and we have observed solid volumes tied to announced deals so far this year, notably in natural resources and technology. Alongside the robust pipeline, advisory activity appears encouraging when we consider the remainder of the year <<inaudible>>. Wealth is beginning to show improvement. Higher client investment assets produced stronger investment revenue, particularly in Citigold, which rose a preliminary 15%. Our effort to rationalize the cost base is likewise beginning to deliver results, with expenses falling 4%. Andy and his team keep drawing top talent from the industry as they concentrate on our investments business and on improving the client experience. US Personal Banking posted 6% revenue growth, with all three businesses once again adding to the top line. Revolving balances and loans grew nicely in both branded cards and retail services, and we still notice divergence in the credit segment, where lower-income customers face pressure. Retail banking gained from increased mortgage loans and better deposit spreads, while providing strong referrals to Wealth.

Jane Fraser

executive
#3

So on the whole, although operating margin did go up, weak returns came under strain from credit seasonality combined with the normalizing of specific vintages. We do anticipate that USPB returns will get better going forward. The stress tests done lately once more demonstrated how solid our balance sheet is. At present our CET1 ratio is 13.6%, and given the lowered stress capital buffer, we anticipate that as of October 1 our regulatory capital requirement will fall to 12.1%. Tangible book value per share rose to $87.53. Over the quarter, we gave back $1 billion of capital to holders of our common stock, and we are raising our dividend 6%. This quarter we expect to repurchase $1 billion of common shares, and we'll keep evaluating the buyback level each quarter, especially in light of uncertainty surrounding the Basel III endgame. Turning to the macro picture as we head into the year's second half, the US remains the economy with the strongest structural footing worldwide. Following a pause in progress, inflation looks to be moving downward once more. Spending on services has kept trending higher, even though there are obvious indications of a labor market that is softening and consumer budgets that are tightening. And naturally, you may have heard that November brings an election; over in Europe, rate cuts have started, yet the area's weak competitiveness keeps weighing on growth. In Asia, China's growth is moderate, though propped up by government stimulus, and its shift toward high-tech manufacturing faces pressure from tariffs on EVs and semiconductors. Even with such uncertainty, as was evident at our Services Investor Day when we reviewed how we performed across the prior two years, our business model is capable of delivering solid outcomes in a broad range of macro conditions, and there is substantial upside throughout our five businesses; we've achieved a tremendous amount on simplification, in strategy as well as in organization. Nearly all of our exits from international consumer markets are finished. We simplified our organization to spark agility and quicker decisions; we're updating our infrastructure so client service gets better, and we're automating processes so controls get stronger. Ours is a deliberate path. We'll keep carrying out our transformation and strategy, enabling us to hit our medium-term targets and afterward keep enhancing our returns as time goes on; having said that, I'll hand things to Mark, and then we'll be happy, as always, to field your questions.

Mark Mason

executive
#4

Appreciate that, Jane, and good morning to all of you. I'll begin with the company-wide financial results, and unless I say otherwise, my focus will be on how the second quarter compares with the same period a year ago, after which I'll devote a bit more time to the business; turning to Slide 6, you'll see the financial results for the entire firm. During the quarter, net income came in at roughly $3.2 billion, alongside EPS of $1.52 and RoTCE of 7.2%, all on $20.1 billion of revenue. We saw total revenues rise 4%, powered by gains in every business plus an approximately $400 million gain tied to the Visa B exchange offer. A large share of that gain shows up in equity markets, with the rest appearing in all other. Expenses totaled $13.4 billion, which is down 2% and 6% on a sequential basis. Because revenue grew while expenses fell, we generated positive operating leverage for the firm and for most of our businesses. Cost of credit reached $2.5 billion, mainly due to higher card net credit losses, which were partly offset by ACL releases and by all businesses except USPB, where we built reserves for loan growth. When the quarter closed, we held nearly $22 billion in total reserves, with a reserve-to-funded loan ratio of approximately 2.7%. Slide 7 lays out how expenses have trended across the past five quarters. For the quarter, costs totaled $13.4 billion, representing a 2% decline from the prior quarter and a 6% drop versus the same period a year ago. That number takes in the $136 million in civil money penalties handed down by the Fed and OCC earlier this week. Most of the expense reduction came from savings related to simplifying our organization, cutting stranded costs, and lower repositioning expenses, though these were partially counterbalanced by continued spending on transformation and the penalty from the Fed and the OCC. As we've noted over the past several months, we will continue putting money into transformation and technology so that our operations and our risk and control infrastructure can be modernized. Looking ahead, we anticipate that those investments will cancel out a portion of the reductions we're making in sales and headcount. Even so, given our current understanding, it's probable we'll land near the upper boundary of the expense guidance range, once you set aside the FDIC special assessment and civil money penalties. That being said, we'll naturally keep seeking ways to offset the civil money penalties. Before turning to the balance sheet and this quarter's business results, I want to provide additional detail on the transformation and speak to what the Fed and OCC made public on Wednesday. In several areas over recent years, our transformation has advanced well, and I'd like to call out a few of those areas prior to getting into the announcement. Starting with our wholesale credit and loan operations: we rolled out one unified operating model that spans the entire process and brought several systems together under improved technology. The result has been lower risk along with better operational efficiency and a stronger client experience. Progress on risk and compliance has been significant as well — we improved our methods for evaluating risk and upgraded our technology, allowing more monitoring to run automatically. Regarding data, there is still substantial work ahead, but we put a data governance process in place and streamlined our data architecture, aiming ultimately to make straight-through processing possible. More generally, we have reinforced risk management and combined and updated our systems and platforms to strengthen resiliency. These examples show concretely the progress we are achieving against our transformation milestones. Even so, we haven't done well enough on overseeing how good our data is, particularly for reports we must file with regulators—a point we've acknowledged openly from the beginning of this year. As a result, we've begun steering additional funding and personnel toward addressing data quality management for regulatory reporting and data governance, and beyond that, toward capabilities for stress testing, including DFAST along with Resolution and Recovery. We've also shifted our priorities so that we're concentrating first on the data that feeds into these reports; we take our regulators' feedback extremely seriously and we're dedicated to putting whatever resources are needed behind meeting their expectations; now let me return to the quarter's results; on Slide 9, net interest income, deposits, and loans are shown, and I'll walk through the sequential changes; net interest income came in about level in the second quarter. If you set aside Markets, net interest income declined 3%, mostly because of foreign exchange translation effects, revolving card balances that are seasonally lower, and reduced interest rates in Argentina, partly made up for by better deposit spreads in Wealth. Average loans were about unchanged, since growth in cards and Mexico consumer was mostly canceled out by modest decreases across businesses. And average deposits fell 1%, mainly from seasonal outflows and transfers into investments within Wealth, along with non-operational outflows in TTS; Slide 10 lays out key consumer and corporate credit metrics, which mirror our disciplined risk appetite framework. Within our card portfolios, about 86% of card loans go to consumers whose FICO scores are 660 or above. And though the overall US consumer still looks resilient to us, we keep observing a split in performance and behavior when it comes to FICO and income bands. If you look at our consumer customers overall, the only group holding more in savings than they did when 2019 began is the top quartile by income. Meanwhile, the spending expansion and elevated payment rates are being driven by people whose FICO scores are 740 or higher. For those in lower FICO ranges, payment rates are falling more sharply and debt is rising, because inflation and interest rates have squeezed them harder. With that said, and we'll cover this in more detail later, we are seeing signs that delinquency trends are leveling off across our cards portfolio. All of these factors have gone into how we set reserves, and our reserve position remains strong: an 8.1% ratio of reserves to funded loans across the entire card portfolio. As of the second quarter, roughly 82% of our corporate portfolio is investment-grade, and corporate non-accrual loans dropped almost $500 million from the prior quarter, mostly because of upgrades and repayments. On top of that, this quarter brought better macro assumptions, thanks to HPI, oil prices, and equity market valuations. Our credit loss reserves still factor in a scenario weighted-average unemployment rate of almost 5%, plus a downside unemployment rate of almost 7%. So with close to $22 billion of reserves in today's environment, we feel quite comfortable. Turning to Slide 11, I want to take a moment to highlight just how solid our balance sheet, capital position, and liquidity really are. That strength is precisely what allows us to support clients when times are uncertain and markets are volatile. The way our balance sheet is structured reflects our risk appetite, our strategy, and the diversified nature of our business model. We hold $1.3 trillion in deposits, spread broadly across different regions, industries, customers, and types of accounts. The largest portion comes from corporate deposits, which total $807 billion and reach across 90 countries. As was shared during the Services Investor Day, the bulk of these deposits are held in operating accounts that are vital to how clients fund their daily operations around the world — giving them an operational character and making them very stable. The rest of it, which comes to about $404 billion, is spread out pretty broadly among the Private Bank, Citigold, Retail, and Wealth at Work offerings, and it's diversified across geographies and products too.

Mark Mason

executive
#5

When it comes to our overall deposit base, 68% is held in US dollars, while the rest is spread across more than 60 currencies. Our approach to assets likewise mirrors the robust framework we use for risk appetite. Our loan book of $688 billion is nicely diversified between consumer and corporate lending, and roughly a third of our balance sheet sits in cash along with high-quality, short-duration investment securities, which feed into our available liquidity resources of about $900 billion. We keep feeling really good about how solid our balance sheet is and about the quality of both our assets and our liabilities, and that puts us in a position to serve as a source of strength for the industry and, importantly, for our clients. Turning to Slide 12, we lay out a sequential walk that gives more detail on what drove our CET1 ratio during this quarter. We closed the quarter with a preliminary CET1 capital ratio of 13.6%, which is roughly 130 basis points, or about $15 billion, higher than the current regulatory capital requirement of 12.3% that applies to us. We anticipate that our regulatory capital requirement will drop to 12.1% as of October 1, which factors in the decrease in our stress capital buffer from 4.3% down to the indicative SCB of 4.1% that we announced a couple of weeks ago. It was gratifying to see our DFAST results improve and the corresponding drop in our SCB. That being said, even after that reduction, our capital requirement still doesn't completely capture our simplification efforts, the benefits of our transformation, or the full execution of our strategy — all of which, we believe, will bring our capital requirements down over time. And to remind everyone, after the SCB result we announced a raise in our common dividend, taking it from $0.53 per share to $0.56 per share. And as Jane said earlier, we intend to do $1 billion of buybacks during this quarter; so let's now move to Slide 13. Before I dive into the businesses, just a reminder that in last year's fourth quarter we put in place a revenue-sharing arrangement within Banking and between Banking, Services and Markets to reflect the benefit these businesses receive from our relationship-based lending. The effect of revenue sharing shows up in the all other line for each business in our financial supplement. Over in Services, revenues rose 3% this quarter, which reflects continued underlying momentum across both TTS and security services. Net interest income fell 1%, mostly because of lower earnings on our net investment in Argentina, partly offset by the benefit of higher US and non-US interest rates compared with the prior-year period. Non-interest revenue grew to 11%, driven by continued strength across underlying fee drivers as well as a smaller impact from currency devaluation in Argentina. The underlying growth in both businesses comes from our continued investment in product innovation, client experience, and platform modernization, which we highlighted during our Services Investor Day last month. Expenses were up 9%, largely because of an Argentina-related transaction tax expense, a legal settlement expense, and continued investments in product innovation and technology. Cost of credit came in as a benefit of $27 million, driven by an ACL release in the quarter. Loans on average rose 3%, mostly because demand kept up for export and agency finance, especially across Asia, along with working capital lending to corporate clients within commercial banking in Latin America and Asia. Deposits on average fell 1%, a result of outflows in non-operating deposits. Meanwhile, we keep seeing solid inflows into operating deposits. Net income came to roughly $1.5 billion, and Services keeps posting a strong RoTCE, reaching 23.8% this quarter. Slide 14 lays out how Markets performed in the second quarter. Market revenues climbed 6%. Fixed income revenues dropped 3%, pulled down by rates and currencies, which fell 11% amid reduced volatility and narrower spreads. That decline was partly offset by gains in spread products and other fixed income, which rose 20%, mainly on continued loan growth and higher securitization in underwriting fees; along with a boost from the Visa B exchange offer, we keep witnessing solid underlying momentum in equity, chiefly from equity derivatives, and we keep advancing in prime, where balances grew about 18%. Expenses fell 1%, thanks to productivity savings, partly offset by expenses tied to higher volumes. Cost of credit was a benefit of $11 million, since an ACL release outweighed net credit loss. Average loans grew to 11%, mostly on asset-backed lending and spread products. Average trading assets rose 12%, mostly on client demand for treasuries and mortgage-backed securities. Markets produced positive operating leverage and posted net income of about $1.4 billion, with an RoTCE of 10.7% this quarter. Slide 15 lays out how Banking performed in the second quarter. Banking revenues grew 38%, on growth in investment banking and corporate lending. Investment banking revenues rose 60%, on strength throughout capital markets and advisory, given favorable market conditions. DCM kept gaining from robust issuance activity, mainly in investment grade, as issuers kept reducing funding risk ahead of what may be a more turbulent second half amid numerous important global elections plus the macro environment. In ECM, leaving out China A shares, we're witnessing more IPO activity, led by the US, plus continued convertible issuance as issuers capitalize on strong equity market performance and expectations that rates stay higher for longer. And in advisory, we're seeing revenues from the relatively low announced activity in 2023 materialize as those transactions close. Both year-to-date and in the quarter, we picked up share throughout DCM, ECM, and advisory, especially in technology, where we've been investing. Corporate lending revenues, excluding mark-to-market on loan hedges, rose 7%, mostly on a higher revenue share; we produced positive operating leverage once again this quarter as expenses fell 10%, primarily from actions taken to right-size the expense base. Credit costs came in as a $32 million benefit, thanks to an ACL release tied to a better macroeconomic outlook, though net credit loss partly offset that. Loans on average fell 4% while we keep tight discipline on returns and face softer overall appetite for credit. We posted $406 million in net income, with RoTCE at 7.5% for the quarter. Turning to Slide 16, those are the Wealth results for Q2. Wealth revenues rose 2%, helped by a 13% jump in NIR on stronger investment fee revenues, partly offset by a 4% drop in NII due to higher mortgage funding costs. Momentum in non-interest revenue remains solid, as we gained from double-digit growth in client investment assets across North America and internationally, fueled by net new client investment assets and market valuation. Expenses declined 4%, reflecting the early benefit of cost reductions from right-sizing both the workforce and the expense base. Credit cost was a $9 million benefit since an ACL release outweighed net credit loss. Preliminary end-of-period client balances grew 9% on higher client investment assets and higher deposits. Average loans stayed flat as we keep optimizing capital usage.

Mark Mason

executive
#6

Deposits on average rose 2%, mostly because relationships and their related deposits came over from USPB, though that was partly offset by money moving into higher-yielding investments on Citi's platform. Client investment assets climbed 15%, fueled by net new investment asset flows along with the gain from higher market valuation. In wealth, we produced positive operating leverage for the quarter and posted net income of $210 million, with an RoTCE of 6.4% for the quarter. Turning to Slide 17, we lay out the second quarter results for US Personal Banking. Revenues there were 6% higher, helped by 5% growth in NII and reduced partner payments. Branded cards revenues rose 8%, helped by a 9% increase in interest-earning balances as payment rates keep moderating, and we keep seeing spend volumes grow 3%, mainly from customers whose FICO scores are 740 or above. Retail services revenues were up 6%, mostly because Citi made lower payments to our partners given higher net credit losses, while interest-earning balances grew 8%. Retail banking revenues rose 3%, helped by better deposit spreads along with growth in mortgage and installment loans. USPB likewise delivered positive operating leverage this quarter, with expenses falling 2%, helped by reduced technology and compensation costs, though higher volume-related expenses partly offset that. Cost of credit rose to $2.3 billion, mostly because of higher NCLs of $1.9 billion plus an ACL build of roughly $400 million, reflecting volume growth in the quarter. Still, let me walk you through the three factors behind our NCLs this quarter. First, card loan vintages originated across the past few years are all reaching maturity simultaneously; those vintages had their maturation delayed because of the unprecedented government stimulus during the pandemic. Second, we keep seeing seasonally higher NCLs in the second quarter. Third, some pockets of customers remain affected by persistent inflation and higher interest rates, which leads to greater losses. That said, in both portfolios we see signs that delinquency performance is stabilizing, though we'll keep monitoring how persistent inflation and high interest rates play out as the year goes on. Even with these factors, we still expect branded cards to land in the 3.5% to 4% NCL range for the full year, and retail services to come in at the high end of the range of 5.75% to 6.25%. Average deposits fell 18%, since the transfer of relationships and the associated deposits into our Wealth business more than outweighed underlying growth. Net income came to $121 million, and RoTCE for the quarter was 1.9%. As we've said previously, we'll keep taking actions to manage through the regulatory headwind, lap the credit cycle, and grow revenue while improving the overall operating efficiency of the business, so we ultimately reach a high-teens return over the medium-term. On Slide 18, we show results for all other on a managed basis, which includes corporate/other and legacy franchises, and excludes divestiture-related items. Our top line came in down 22%. The main factors there were the exit we completed along with the winddowns, plus increased costs for funding. Those pressures were partly balanced out by expansion in Mexico and by what the Visa B exchange offer contributed. On the expense side, we saw a 7% decline, largely because of that closed exit and the winddowns. Turning to slide 19, you'll see our outlook for the whole of 2024 together with our medium-term guidance — neither has been revised. We stay intensely focused on carrying out our transformation and lifting how the business performs. We know there is considerably more work ahead on transformation, yet we're encouraged by how far we've come against our 2024 and medium-term targets, and we hold firm to hitting them. With that said, Jane and I are ready to take your questions.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#7

Hello. Could you go into further detail regarding the revised consent order? Jane, you described receiving it this week as disappointing. We're nearly 4 years into that consent order. And a bit about why it remains unresolved? And what's on the — that's the loss side, and perhaps a bit more on the win side as well. I mean, you've got, what, 12,000 people assigned to this issue, billions of dollars. Is the headcount insufficient? Is the funding insufficient? Is it — do you need to examine it from a different angle? Are you not speaking the same language? I mean, John Dugan serves as your Lead Independent Director, coming out of the OCC, and it appears you received your report card, I suppose you passed on the whole, they made a point of saying some positive things, yet it seems you received failing marks in data and regulatory management; so, your confidence is that it's going to be resolved, but 4 years have already passed and it still hasn't been resolved. So, what will it take going forward? And how are you able to address the regulatory concerns while still serving shareholders better? And then, on the win side, since this back-office is so nebulous, what are you accomplishing? You listed a few items, but could you add more substance to those? Thanks.

Jane Fraser

executive
#8

Yes. Thank you, Mike. That covers a few distinct parts; so, let's begin by taking a step back. What we're doing through our transformation is addressing decades of insufficient investment across large portions of Citi's infrastructure and within our risk and control environment. And when you break that down, those areas where we lacked enforced enterprise-wide standards and governance, we've had a siloed organization that's blocked scale, a culture where many groups are permitted to solve problems — the identical problem in varying ways, fragmented tech platforms, manual processes and controls and a weak first-line of defense, too few subject matter experts; so, this is an enormous body of work that extends well past the consent order. And this isn't old Citi applying a band-aid. This is Citi confronting the root issues directly. It's a multi-year undertaking as we've discussed and you saw the statement from one of our regulators this week, we have achieved meaningful progress on our transformation — excuse me, and on our simplification. Mark, do you want to...

Mark Mason

executive
#9

Right. So, as Jane mentioned, the headway we've achieved covers several areas of both the transformation efforts and the consent order. Keep in mind, that transformation work and consent order take in risk, take in controls, take in compliance, take in data, plus data tied to regulatory reporting. And against each one of those areas, we have proof points and evidence showing advancement.

Jane Fraser

executive
#10

Thank you, Mark.

Mark Mason

executive
#11

Yes.

Jane Fraser

executive
#12

So, in terms of transforming — to address what you asked regarding how we both repair things and serve our investors, transforming Citi is going to deliver gains for shareholders, clients, and regulators alike. These goals aren’t in conflict. Early in the year, we settled on 2 priorities: the transformation and lifting our business performance. And we can manage that because we’ve mostly cleared the decks. Our strategy is clear and focused. The divestitures are done. Our organization is far simpler, which lets us concentrate on those 2 priorities, and we can handle both. You can see it in our results once more this quarter — several strong proof points showing the strategy is being executed — and we understand what’s required on both fronts; plans exist for the transformation and for the strategy, and we’re carrying them out. When problems arise, we have been transparent about them and how we’re tackling them, and we will continue to be.

Mark Mason

executive
#13

And to throw in a few more figures on that point, Mike — you've probably caught us bringing up some of these in the past — but we've shut down platforms. We've cut back on how many data centers we operate. Roughly 300 platforms are gone. Where we once had 39 corporate loan platforms, we're now below 20. Our 20 cash equities execution platforms have been consolidated into a single one. The six reporting ledgers have been brought down to one, and 11 sanctioned platforms have become one. So over the last couple of years, the progress we've made is substantial; that being said, a great deal of additional effort remains when it comes to the data regulatory reporting work. Consider Citi — altogether, we have 11,000 global reg reports, correct? So we need to ensure the data feeding those reports is of the quality we expect it to be, and even more crucially, that we're doing this efficiently, without requiring thousands of employees to reconcile that information. And so, our approach treats this as an end-to-end process. Take the 2052a liquidity report we have as one illustration; it contains 750,000 lines of data, and once again, what matters is that we collect that data efficiently from numerous systems, with standards and governance guaranteeing it meets the quality we're after, without again depending on manual activity to support it.

Glenn Schorr

analyst
#14

Hello, and thanks. Mark, I picked up on what you said regarding credit this year — specifically, US Personal Banking. I caught your remarks about credit for the remainder of this year, and it seems you're sitting in a spot where reserves are quite conservative. Yet at this moment, you're delivering a 3% margin, and credit costs represent nearly 50% of the revenues generated in that space. So what I'm asking is this: moving ahead, with the economy slowing and probably some modest rate reductions coming, what's the trajectory for the P&L? In what way does it get better from this point? Is it reasonable to anticipate credit cost arriving in a decelerating economy? I'm simply attempting to map out where this goes, since USPB clearly moves toward the level you require it to reach, and that could matter a great deal.

Mark Mason

executive
#15

Yes. As I stated, we genuinely believe USPB has meaningful upside; that upside is what we're targeting within the medium-term objectives we've established for ourselves. Keep in mind, when you examine the quarter and, honestly, when you examine the half, we remain in a stretch where the normalization of credit cost is still occurring. And like I said during the prepared remarks, you've got a sort of compounding <<inaudible>> now maturing simultaneously that is flowing through the P&L — and that applies not only to us but to others too; therefore, we would anticipate, and indeed we do think we're observing a few indications of a peak when you look at delinquencies at present; consequently, we'd anticipate those losses beginning to normalize and loss rates beginning to decline as we move toward the medium-term. Simultaneously, we're putting money into the business and seeking to see ongoing volume growth along with top-line expansion. The mix of those factors, as we push toward the medium-term, will assist us in producing both top-line growth and, without question, better returns compared to where we stand now, consistent with the guidance we've provided; so it comes down to top-line results driven by volume — and clearly the environment factors into that — yet we believe we hold a sensible assumption regarding top-line growth there, credit cost normalizing, and sustained expense discipline, which lets us achieve enhanced returns throughout that USPB business.

Glenn Schorr

analyst
#16

All right, that's helpful. Just a brief follow-up regarding DCM. Your results there were incredibly strong. A lot of people have been discussing how much activity got pulled forward into this year, with refinancing alone accounting for roughly three-quarters of it. Can you walk us through how to think about the back half, specifically for DCM, so we don't end up assuming this pace lasts forever?

Jane Fraser

executive
#17

Sure. As I see it, looking at the latter portion of '24, the activity mix within Banking will look different. Demand should remain pretty robust across our capital market products, since a substantial amount of maturing debt securities is set to come due during the second half and that will persist for a couple of years. That said, certain clients moved their issuances up into the first half to avoid possible market volatility. Taking everything into account, we anticipate that the rate environment and financing markets will stay accommodative, and that deal-making will keep going, with M&A taking up somewhat more of the overall mix, even though certain regulatory factors have restrained a portion of it.

Mark Mason

executive
#18

Sure. The one point I would tack on is that, clearly, what happens with the wallet across the year hinges on several variables. First, whether the IPO market comes back to something more like normal; second, which way interest rate volatility moves; third, the continuing conflicts around the world that all of us are sort of watching unfold; and last, as Jane brought up when she spoke, the elections and how those results shake out, and not only here in the US but internationally too. So a handful of elements are going to shape the wallet, but like we've said, we think our position is strong when it comes to being there for our clients and doing it in a manner that is economically sound.

Jim Mitchell

analyst
#19

Hi there, good morning. Mark, regarding NII being lower by nearly 4% compared to the same time last year, that appears somewhat larger than what was guided, yet it's a slight decline across the year; could you walk through the pluses and minuses for this quarter and share your thoughts on how each quarter might trend for the remaining portion of the year?

Mark Mason

executive
#20

Sure. Let me mention a few points. First, as I noted earlier, during this quarter — and you can find this on Slide 9 — excluding Markets, the figure fell roughly 3%. The main reasons are foreign exchange translation effects that came through, plus revolving card balances that are lower due to seasonal patterns, and additionally, reduced interest rates over in Argentina. Regarding Argentina specifically, we hold capital in that country, the policy rate got lowered, and when that occurs, we clearly generate reduced earnings on those capital holdings, which shows up in the NII line. When I consider the latter six months of the year along with our guidance calling for a slight decline, several pluses and minuses should be remembered. First involves rates, correct? When I consider the greater yield available from reinvestment, that becomes a favorable factor affecting NII. Next comes growth in volume, especially within our portfolio of card loans. We anticipate ongoing volume expansion throughout the — most certainly the branded portfolio, which serves as an additional favorable factor for NII. On the unfavorable side, there's reduced NII generated in Argentina because of rates, and that will keep affecting results; we've also assumed greater average betas during 2024, particularly outside the US. Our projection still includes the CFPB late fee effect. If we assume that takes effect during this year, it will create an impact, and it's factored into the forecast; plus there's the effect of NII lost due to the exits we've made. Taken together, these factors likely indicate NII during the latter six months will be marginally above the first six months, yet still aligned with the modest decline guidance we provided.

Jim Mitchell

analyst
#21

That's useful. And perhaps briefly, a comparable question regarding costs, which beat expectations this quarter, yet no restructuring or repositioning charges appeared. To reach the top end of your range, I believe you'd need a slight increase in the back half versus the 2Q run rate — is that due to anticipating additional repositioning/restructuring in the second half, or could you just walk through the expense trajectory going forward?

Mark Mason

executive
#22

Yeah. So that's correct. When I spoke during the first quarter, I described a downward trend for each quarter following Q1. The second quarter landed somewhat below what we had anticipated. I'm maintaining the guidance, and that does imply the back half of the year will likely land — will land above the second quarter. That reflects a mix of several factors, among them the pace of hiring and investment we'll undertake in the transformation work that must be done; it also encompasses repositioning charges we might incur or need to incur as we keep working through our businesses across the firm and the franchise. And then, the second quarter did — yes, the second quarter did contain a one-time or so in certain delayed spending that will ramp up in the third and fourth quarter around advertising and marketing and some of the other line items. So, yes, the second quarter will — the third and fourth quarter, the back half will exceed the second quarter, but in line with the guidance that I've provided.

Erika Najarian

analyst
#23

Hello there. I have a couple of inquiries, and I'll start with the one about costs because it flows nicely from what was just discussed. Mark, to make sure we're on the same page, let's suppose we use the top figure from the year-end guidance, which is $53.8 billion — I'm just attempting to anticipate how consensus estimates might shift. So we begin with that $53.8 billion, then we add the $285 million in FDIC expenses incurred year-to-date thus far, plus the civil money penalties totaling $136 million, which brings us to $54.2 billion for the full year — and would any additional repositioning charges during the second half of the year already be captured within that $53.8 billion?

Mark Mason

executive
#24

Right, so the final portion of what you asked — the response there is affirmative. Within that guidance I provided, $53.5 billion up to $53.8 billion, we've factored in what we expect for the entire year tied to repositioning as well as any restructuring charges. That guidance leaves out the FDIC special assessment that came up earlier in the year, and it also leaves out the CMP totaling $136 million.

Erika Najarian

analyst
#25

Understood. My follow-up is for Jane. I realize this capital return topic must be wearing on you by now. So, you intend to repurchase $1 billion during this quarter; it appears no shares were bought back by you in the second quarter; and the reason I'm raising this now is that consensus models roughly $1 billion of buybacks in the fourth quarter, with that level continuing through the first half of next year before climbing. So, I suppose my question is whether that $1 billion figure represents a catch-up rate, given that nothing was repurchased in the second quarter? And I completely understand there's also the Banamex IPO ahead, which sets you apart from peers who are likewise awaiting Basel clarification, but I'm simply asking, must we wait for that Banamex IPO before the company is comfortable stepping away from quarter-to-quarter guidance? And naturally, I'd also like to revisit how I opened my question, when I asked pointedly about the pace.

Jane Fraser

executive
#26

All right. So when it comes to our buybacks, we won't be providing guidance from here on out. Instead, we'll keep issuing it each quarter — and the amount will be decided on that quarterly basis. A big reason for that relates to the ambiguity surrounding the regulatory changes that are coming. I'd say we felt very pleased to observe a modest decrease in our stress capital buffer, which speaks to the financial strength and resiliency of our business model, and it was also nice to see our strategy's benefits coming through, but given that the regulatory changes remain uncertain, that's one of the key factors behind our decision to stick with quarterly guidance.

Mark Mason

executive
#27

Yes, that's correct. Regarding the first portion of what you asked, Erika, I would say this: we had been speaking with those who regulate us, and we arrived at a cautious decision when it came to repurchasing shares during the quarter, for Q2 <<inaudible>> Q3, which, as we previously discussed, would come to $1 billion, and that figure really shouldn't be taken as a steady-state pace. As Jane noted, from this point forward we'll evaluate things one quarter at a time.

Gerard Cassidy

analyst
#28

Thank you. Hi, Jane. Hi, Mark.

Mark Mason

executive
#29

Good morning.

Gerard Cassidy

analyst
#30

Mark, about what you said regarding the greater credit losses and the three items you listed, could you also address whether this played any role at all for your company? Did FICO score inflation occur during the pandemic that could be contributing to these sorts of credit losses? And on the credit card topic, you brought up the CFPB and the fees you've accounted for, the reduced fees, you include that in your outlook — what's the current status there? Do you have any insight on that too?

Mark Mason

executive
#31

Yeah; so, concerning the first portion of the question, look, we've all discussed previously the possibility of FICO inflation during the COVID timeframe. We've remained extremely, extremely concentrated on making sure that the acquisitions we've completed were properly evaluated within the underwriting process to become comfortable with the standard of new customers we've been adding. Given the environment, we have examined shifting toward elevated FICO scores for new account acquisitions. But when I consider what we're observing today, there's that dichotomy I referenced, where we have the higher FICO score customers who are fueling the spend growth and who honestly still maintain robust balances in savings, and it's truly the lower FICO band customers among whom we're seeing the steeper decline in payment rates and increased borrowing. And so, the FICO inflation has essentially faded away when we examine the mix and dynamic of the customer portfolio we currently hold. And regarding the CFPB, late fees, well, I don't have any update on that. As I stated, we've incorporated an assumption into the — into our forecast, but concerning the timing, I don't have an official update on its certainty.

Ken Usdin

analyst
#32

Hi there, thanks, and good morning. Mark, I wanted to ask about the NII outlook. There's now a bit of a gap opening up between US rates — perhaps elevated for a longer stretch — and the early signs that some non-US curves are at least starting to signal their first cut. I know the Qs include that helpful chart showing the relative contributions. Could you walk us through, in general terms, how you're approaching that gap and how it shapes the split between NII tied to the US and NII tied to non-US as we move ahead?

Mark Mason

executive
#33

Yes, thank you. So here's how I'd put it: looking out over the — certainly over the medium-term, we anticipate continued NII growth, clearly at a modest level, and certainly below what we've delivered historically. That's largely driven by — or partly driven, I should say, by the way we've been running the balance sheet, which has let us reinvest as securities have rolled off and pick up a higher yield on them than what we'd been earning; for some of those investments, the terms ran five years; so we still see some upside from a reinvestment standpoint. On your point about non-US dollar rates or US rates coming off, that will feed through somewhat when we consider the beta increases we expect outside the US. So we've built in assumptions of higher betas outside the US. Should rates come off more substantially, then we might see somewhat less NII pressure than what we're projecting there. But on balance, when I consider the combination of volume growth we expect between loans and deposits over that medium-term, the higher yield we can earn on our assets, combined with the pricing capabilities we have across the portfolio, offsetting some of that beta, we believe continued NII growth will follow. When I think about what I often highlight regarding the IRE analysis, you have to keep in mind that it's a shock to the current balance sheet and it assumes the full curve moves at the same time across currencies. In that scenario, the 100 basis point parallel shift downward would be a negative $1.6 billion, with roughly $1.3 billion of that originating from non-US dollar; but again, that assumes all of those currencies decline simultaneously and doesn't factor in the rebalancing of the balance sheet and items I mentioned such as the reinvestment higher yields we'd be able to earn.

Ken Usdin

analyst
#34

Understood. Alright, then a single additional question regarding the OCC amendment, specifically tied to the resource review plan. Can you see clearly how much time it will require for your team to complete, since it appears — and is that the thing we ought to focus on, simply grasping which aspect of what must be accomplished concerning the remaining wording contained in the order?

Jane Fraser

executive
#35

Well, Ken, here's the thing — the Resource Review Plan amounts to precisely that: a blueprint meant to guarantee we've directed enough resources toward obtaining prompt and lasting adherence to the order. Basically, should some area fall behind or appear likely to, we'll figure out whatever extra resourcing, if any, is needed to return it to schedule, after which we'll provide that to the OCC in a manner more formalized than our current practice. Naturally, we examine this quite continuously on our own. Following finalization alongside the OCC, work on the plan is already underway. Consequently, it will constitute confidential supervisory information that disclosure isn't possible for; therefore, telling you the plan is — whether the plan — what the plan's character will be isn't something we can do, yet it won't prove significantly more intricate than what we've described; and obtaining it is what we anticipate — we don't anticipate this requiring much time.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#36

Hi, good afternoon.

Mark Mason

executive
#37

Hello.

Jane Fraser

executive
#38

Hey, Betsy.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#39

All right. So, I'm aware we've spent considerable time discussing costs. I've got just one big-picture question, and it's about how we ought to view the trajectory of expenses from now through the medium term, given that we've traveled pretty far down the road on simplification, so perhaps you could help us understand where we stand regarding how much simplification has affected expenses so far? And when that overlaps with the regulatory demands, do those two offset each other, or are we tilted somewhat more toward the regulatory demands carrying more weight than whatever simplification work remains from this point? Thanks.

Mark Mason

executive
#40

Thank you, Betsy. I suppose there are a few points I'd make. So, I believe we've mentioned this previously, so for the medium term, with 2026 as the target, expenses land at roughly $51 billion to $53 billion. As we've stated, roughly $1.5 billion of savings will come from the restructuring we've completed, plus an additional $500 million to $1 billion tied to net expense reductions from removing the stranded costs along with extra productivity across that medium-term window. And so we've achieved, in my view, quite solid progress, as Jane referenced regarding the organizational simplification and the restructuring charges tied to it; those savings will — some of those savings have begun to materialize early in that period, which means this year will probably be offset by ongoing investment we're directing into business areas such as transformation, and also into growth that's business-led or driven. And regarding the trend, you ought to anticipate a declining trend heading toward 2026 and reaching that range.

Jane Fraser

executive
#41

Let me say again that our confidence hasn't changed when it comes to hitting an RoTCE goal of 11% to 12% across the medium-term. What's more, we possess the capacity to handle the various pieces discussed earlier today — ensuring enough resources go into the transformation effort so we stay on track with it, while also supporting our businesses and returning capital to shareholders. So our confidence around this holds, and we feel good that this is something we can manage.

Mark Mason

executive
#42

Yes, I believe that's a really good observation, Jane. Look, the truth is, as someone noted before, we spent roughly $3 billion in the prior year, slightly under that amount, on work tied to the transformation. And our plan has us spending somewhat more than that during this year. And honestly, during the first six months, as we move through the transformation effort and some of the items that Jane and I discussed earlier in the year that we've been concentrating on, such as data and data connected to regulatory reporting, we ended up spending beyond what we had budgeted for in that first half, correct? And we've completed that and we've paid for it; we've managed to locate productivity opportunities that let us remain inside the guidance we've provided for the entire year. So, we are overseeing this whole expense base, correct? Okay, so with regard to that entire amount of more than $53 billion, we're monitoring it closely as we assess what a transformation effort requires—how to keep things moving forward, accelerate the parts where we've fallen short, and strengthen the parts where we're on pace with what the order calls for. We're also asking where other inefficiencies exist that could help us unlock savings in the cost structure. Things like the effort Andy Sieg has led alongside the finance organization to examine that cost base and identify efficiencies—those are chances we've been able to pull out of the business. In certain areas of USPB, we've taken actions, and we've kept pushing forward on that in certain parts of Banking—that's what shows up in the 10% decline for this quarter. Those are places we've really zeroed in on: where do we have overlapping positions, where are processes that waste effort and that we can squeeze more efficiency from? So, to put it in a roundabout way, we get the expense guidance we provided. We also recognize—and want to emphasize—how vital it is to pay for the transformation with whatever it takes, and we're accomplishing both at once.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#43

All right, excellent. Many thanks. I appreciate it.

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#44

Hello. All right, allow me to get this straight, Mark and Jane, simply so everyone is clear on it. That figure of $53.5 billion to $53.8 billion leaves out whatever you anticipate possibly having to lay out for the Resource Review Plan up to now — in other words, the extra resources you'd need to deploy to resolve the consent order — is that accurate?

Jane Fraser

executive
#45

No, that's not accurate. So, Vivek, I believe — as you've heard from us for some time, we were aware of the parts of our transformation program where we had fallen behind, and we started tackling those and putting the investments in. A portion of that is in people, a portion is in what we spend on technology, and it involves deploying different tools and capabilities so those areas get handled sooner, and we kicked that off earlier in the year. Our regulators recognized this too, noting that we had already started dealing with the areas where we lagged. Mark?

Mark Mason

executive
#46

Correct, Jane. What's been conveyed to you is that even though we've had to lay out additional funds — roughly $250 million extra — our guidance remains unchanged. So, as Jane pointed out, we've already addressed the areas requiring attention, and we've sought methods to offset that amount, which we're accomplishing while staying inside our guidance.

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#47

Alright. So from here on out, despite the fact that this plan is still being assembled and needs the regulators' sign-off, there shouldn't be any adjustment to that expense?

Mark Mason

executive
#48

Well, that plan — the Resource Review Plan, which Jane talked about — is the thing we're currently hashing out with the regulators. It's going to be a matter of proving to them that our spending and our allocation of resources are suitable for delivering on the commitments we've made. Suitable resources could mean everything from personnel to tech to sharpening our workflows and making sure execution improves. When you consider what that involves, it involves spots where we're lagging or trailing, and as we pinpoint those spots, being able to dig into why any holdup happened and make certain we've directed enough money to bring it back where it belongs. That's just me sketching out my thinking on how something like this could take shape. So what we're telling you is this: should we uncover problems in upcoming quarters that we haven't yet found, that's the approach we'll use for them. And like you've heard from us again and again, we'll shell out whatever it takes to get those things back where they belong, and just as we've been doing all year, we'll hunt for chances to soak up those headwinds. Hopefully that makes sense.

Matt O'Connor

analyst
#49

Hello. Sorry if this was covered earlier in the prepared comments, but what caused credit card revenues to fall from 1Q to 2Q? Even though average loans rose and spending increased, they appear to have dropped roughly 6% overall. What accounted for that?

Mark Mason

executive
#50

The seasonal pattern in credit card revenues...

Jane Fraser

executive
#51

Yeah. Seasonality...

Mark Mason

executive
#52

Seasonality playing through there.

Jane Fraser

executive
#53

Sequentially.

Mark Mason

executive
#54

Yeah, sequentially. Yeah.

Jane Fraser

executive
#55

When you compare things on a year-over-year basis, I believe a fairly consistent pattern becomes visible. There's some slowing happening on the consumer side when it comes to spending, which Mark mentioned to Matt, but a great deal of the spending and the areas of growth we're observing, along with the underlying numbers, is coming from the affluent customer.

Mark Mason

executive
#56

Yeah, I believe there's also the way the CRS on the reward behaves — moving through the whole set of rewards from one quarter into the next; so those elements together are flowing through into the revenue line there.

Jane Fraser

executive
#57

But nothing that's particularly worrying us, Matt.

Matt O'Connor

analyst
#58

Alright. Then, switching to a different topic — near the start of your prepared remarks, you mentioned that dividends face a cap regarding how much can be moved up from the bank to the holding company, and that's because of the OCC development released this week. Essentially, does this affect the way you operate the company or the subsidiary, or does it affect liquidity or capital? From what I gathered, you said there's no change to dividends or buybacks at the holding company, but would there be any effect from this that we'd observe externally? Thanks.

Jane Fraser

executive
#59

Well — let me be direct; this move doesn't affect our capacity to give capital back to shareholders. Those dividends being discussed are simply intercompany transfers from CBNA to the parents. So, to begin with, don't mix up what a dividend means in this context. We will — it won't affect how we operate the company, the subsidiary, capital, or liquidity in any way, and there is no cap on the dividends.

Mark Mason

executive
#60

Yes. I believe so — Jane, you're correct about that; and let's keep in mind why those orders exist in the first place. What those orders are meant to accomplish is making sure we put money and resources toward this in the right way, correct? So essentially, the regulators are after the same outcome we are, right — they want us to finish this, right? That's the main goal. The mention of dividends flowing from CBNA to the parent is indeed brought up there for the period between now and when that Resource Review Plan gets established, but as Jane said, that doesn't stop the parent from taking the actions it needs to take; and rather than — it isn't a ceiling. The way it works is that anything beyond the parent's debt service or preferred dividends and other non-discretionary obligations would need a non-objection from the OCC.

Jane Fraser

executive
#61

As long as the resource plan hasn't been finalized...

Mark Mason

executive
#62

As long as the resource plan...

Jane Fraser

executive
#63

Also, it's already clear to everyone that the resource plan has a 30-day submission deadline. And as I mentioned before, we're handling that item, and I don't expect it to cause any issues.

Saul Martinez

analyst
#64

Hello there, and good afternoon. I appreciate you taking my question. I suppose I simply want to build on that previous question. Let me put it plainly: what you're telling us is that the condition for CBNA to obtain a non-objection before it can dividend upstream to the parent — that has no bearing on the way you view your capital flexibility, the way you view — it doesn't constrain you at all, and it shouldn't affect, say, your capacity to gain from, for instance, a Basel endgame rule that gets softened, or some of those benefits, Mark, that you mentioned regarding simplification. So you don't see this having any effect on your continuing degree of capital flexibility and your capacity to buy back stock down the road if some of these things do in fact unfold?

Mark Mason

executive
#65

No. No, I don't.

Saul Martinez

analyst
#66

All right, that makes sense. It couldn't be any clearer. Great.

Mark Mason

executive
#67

I appreciate it.

Saul Martinez

analyst
#68

For my second question, I'd like to stay on USPB. Look, I understand that card losses are normalizing, but once you account for reserve builds, your RoTCE remains in the single digits. Even with these NCL levels, I'd expect the cards business to be quite profitable. You have scale on your side. Sure, you're above pre-pandemic levels, but I'm not convinced it's dramatically higher. That would suggest the retail bank is a significant drag on profitability — possibly even unprofitable, I'm not sure. So could you discuss what steps you can take to boost retail bank profitability, and share any additional detail on how you plan to reach that high-teen RoTCE you mentioned?

Jane Fraser

executive
#69

Sure, I'll start us off on that. Obviously, we're highly focused on lifting USPB returns to reach the high-teens level over the medium term. You saw us deliver healthy positive operating leverage this quarter. We've enjoyed several quarters of solid revenue growth. That said, as Mark noted, we're at the low point of the credit cycle. We anticipated that returns would face pressure this year from elevated NCLs and some of the industry headwinds we've discussed. But as NCL rates move toward steady-state levels, and the mitigating actions we've all been implementing against those industry headwinds begin to take effect, we anticipate returns will rise and back our medium — the firm-wide medium-term targets. Within the retail bank, we keep concentrating on gaining share across our six core markets, doing so by leveraging our physical and digital assets, and it plays a key part in enabling the wealth continuum and the growth we're seeing in our Wealth franchise. We keep enhancing our operating efficiency, staying very disciplined on expenses, and carefully managing branch and digital productivity across the retail bank network. That said, we're at the high point of the credit cycle, which is causing the low point for USPB, and as I mentioned in my remarks, we expect those returns to rise from here.

Steven Chubak

analyst
#70

Good afternoon. Mark, my question is somewhat technical, concerning DTA utilization—more precisely, the NOLs. That deduction remains quite substantial, sitting at $12 billion. That's approximately 10% of your market cap. The positive side, I take it, is that eventually this ought to flow back into capital, yet utilization has been minimal across the last two years, even though the company has been profitable. Therefore, I'd like to grasp better: what is holding back your capacity to draw on those DTAs? Also, do catalysts lie ahead that could genuinely speed up that drawdown past what organic earnings generation provides?

Mark Mason

executive
#71

Yeah, thanks. Let me respond to a highly complex question in a very straightforward manner. Essentially, it boils down to generating US income, correct? Thus, our attention is on everything we've referenced, plus on producing greater US income, which would let us use the disallowed DTA. A portion of that appeared during the quarter, and we anticipate additional progress as we advance through the medium-term, though that stands as the primary force behind such utilization. And...

Jane Fraser

executive
#72

Plus, a large number of our business leaders are heavily concentrated on that chance too. So succeeding in America, for instance, forms a crucial pillar of the plan that this is revitalizing. In the same way, we notice possibilities coming from the commercial bank, we notice them in Wealth, we notice them clearly in US Personal Banking and in Services. Thus, we're quite — from the standpoint of business strategy, we're centered on this, not merely regarding the financial aspect.

Steven Chubak

analyst
#73

Yes, thanks to you both for providing that context, and perhaps a brief additional question. Regarding the retail services segment, there appears to be some indication that rivals of yours in this area have taken a more aggressive stance by competing primarily on pricing as a way to secure additional mandates. Could you share your perspective on what you're observing among the competitive landscape, as well as your interest or readiness to possibly extend more favorable terms given heightened rivalry from certain competitors?

Jane Fraser

executive
#74

Well, I believe you'll be happy to learn that our emphasis is squarely on returns instead of merely on revenues. Therefore, whenever we engage in conversations with a partner who might be issuing a fresh RFP for their portfolio or evaluating new opportunities like the one we recently finalized with Dillard's, everything revolves around returns and the characteristics of the business, not the revenue aspect; and this likely represents a departure from certain approaches used previously, but I'm quite satisfied with the level of discipline the team is demonstrating regarding this, and we are already experiencing the positive results.

Mark Mason

executive
#75

That might not match the picture you're getting from other companies operating here. Yet, like Jane said, our priority is making certain that while the partnership stays strong, the returns we get are suitable. Achieving our medium-term goals depends on that. Also, as you're aware, since retail cards came up, consider how CECL affects the reserves required for such partnerships. We set aside reserves covering the full lifetime, recorded on the balance sheet, and eventually those get divided according to the partner sharing economics. So when we look at growing, adding these relationships, and renegotiating partnerships, that's one more key factor in confirming the returns are sensible for us.

Jane Fraser

executive
#76

Mark and I are perfectly comfortable turning down business that fails to deliver the returns we need, and we stay extremely disciplined about that.

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#77

Hello. Apologies, I just want to ask something more about all of this consent order business, Jane. How do you see this affecting the schedule? How much additional time will it take for you to put this behind you? Are we discussing a pair of years? Has it now been pushed out by 12 months? Do you have any idea about that? Anything that could help us reason through it?

Jane Fraser

executive
#78

Well, regarding the consent order and the parts where we've experienced holdups, the consent order covers 4 parts; those are risk management, data governance, compliance, and control. Like we've stated, we were lagging in specific areas tied to data, and we've been putting money in to tackle the areas where we were trailing. We likewise observed a growth in the scope connected to regulatory reporting. Therefore, we introduced additional workstreams there, and we are making solid progress. So, we do not anticipate this will go beyond the initial projections we hold regarding the moment we'll finish the work involved in the consent order. For each of its different parts, we have a target state. To reach those target states, we have the plan; we will make whatever investments are required to guarantee we succeed. We'll attempt to finish this as fast, yet as soundly, as we can; and rather than what I'd term the old city approach—a bunch of band-aids that patch things up but fail to truly resolve the root problem—we're doing this through strategic fixes and investments. And in that manner, we are producing results for our shareholders, our regulators, and our clients, since we're implementing strategic solutions that will help everyone, but I don't anticipate this will alter the timeframes.

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#79

Thanks.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#80

Hello. I just have a couple of things to clear up. So this amendment to the consent order is drawing a lot of attention. And I believe I understand your point, but please confirm: your risk, compliance, and controls are being rated as passing. The real issue is the data. And when it comes to that data, you mention 11,000 regulatory reports, and some of them contain 750,000 lines of data. Is that genuinely the full scope of what has to be fixed? Because from the outside, people look at this and say, you're coming up short on overall controls and resiliency, yet I think your message is that it's actually mostly about the data and regulatory reporting, which matters, but represents a portion of a larger picture. Am I right about that?

Jane Fraser

executive
#81

Yes. Mike, perhaps I should — that's a great question and an important one. So let me try to walk through what we — the data elements, since Mark and I have both flagged this area. So, to start with, data gets used throughout the entire firm. It's how we produce 72 million customer statements each month. Our corporate clients, whom you heard about at our Service Investor Day, pull account data in real time across many countries on CitiDirect, and for those clients worldwide we're moving roughly $5 trillion per day; on our trading platforms we trade billions of dollars in a millisecond. We can view our liquidity positions in real time globally. None of that is possible unless you have fairly pristine data and deeply automated ecosystems. So — but what does the transformation accomplish? What it does is make the way data travels through the firm simpler, and it involves improving the management and governance of those flows. And we — as I've mentioned, we're carrying out a strategic overhaul of big chunks of our infrastructure. So, what are we doing? We're ensuring data is captured accurately through smart tools and automation. We frequently discuss this smart system, making certain there are no errors when a trade is booked. As a result, we've watched our error rate fall 85%. We're keeping our upstream data in two standardized repositories. Those are the golden sources, Olympus and Data Hub, which you've heard me mention a number of times. And for all downstream data use, they're now the golden source, feeding the thousands of regulatory reports Mark discussed along with other areas. And what having a single repository means is that the data models, the data quality rules, the controls put in place to govern and manage that data, all of them reside in one location instead of being spread across the whole firm the way they historically were. Mark has been putting money into building a standardized reporting infrastructure. You've heard us discuss having one full-suite reporting ledger rather than the roughly 6 reporting ledgers we used to maintain; and we're delivering that through consolidated systems, through automating and streamlining how data moves. So rather than sitting in multiple pipes, those flows travel through single pipes. So it's a — apologies for sounding like a plumber for a second, but I think it matters to grasp what this actually is, since it involves a great deal of work. It's a strategic overhaul; it isn't a set of tactical fixes. Where we lag, as we perform the work on data, we spot particular problems that must be corrected while we carry out the plan we already have in place. There are additional areas still to tackle, and we understood that when we created the plan. So we've — and we've also sped up efforts to boost the accuracy of our regulatory reports, and we widened the scope of that effort too. It's broader than what we initially planned; so what are we doing? We're bringing in more resources and data experts; we're taking lessons from best practices. And we're leveraging some excellent AI and other data tools that assist in spotting anomalies in data and data flows far more quickly; we're also — on the culture side, we're drawing on pilots to learn how to speed up wider deployment at scale throughout the firm in a consistent enterprise-wide way. So all of these efforts on the data side will let us leapfrog competitors, create more revenue opportunities, improve client service, reduce buffers, drive greater efficiencies, and hopefully in the end — the ultimate objective here is that it turns into a competitive advantage for the firm. That's the data plan. Obviously, there's a highly important piece of it tied to the consent orders. We lag in a few areas. We're investing; that investment has already started, as Mark and I have mentioned, to complete it, and we will complete it.

Mark Mason

executive
#82

Just one more point I want to make...

Mike Mayo

analyst
#83

A very brief additional question...

Mark Mason

executive
#84

Pardon me. Could you repeat that, Mike?

Mike Mayo

analyst
#85

Yeah, just a quick follow-up on that. You're accomplishing all these impressive things, yet you still came up short. In, say, a single sentence — even with all those impressive things you laid out, the regulators still concluded you hadn't finished the job. Why, after all of that, did they not see it as done, and why will it be resolved now? If you have it, just a one-sentence reason?

Jane Fraser

executive
#86

I've consistently said that a transformation of this size, spanning several years, would not follow a straight line. There are plenty of steps ahead. There are setbacks, we make adjustments, we take lessons from them, we keep moving, and we return to course.

Mark Mason

executive
#87

And Mike, let me just frame a single figure for you, since you brought up that 11,000 — the count of regulatory reports worldwide in this landscape. Roughly 15 to 30 of them are the key US reports that matter most to our US regulators. Much of what we're talking about here concerns making sure we put the data affecting those 15 to 30 reports first as we work through this.

Jenn Landis

executive
#88

Appreciate everyone for being here. If anything else comes to mind afterward, feel free to reach out. Thanks so much.

Operator

operator
#89

This concludes Citi's second quarter 2024 earnings call. You may now disconnect.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Citigroup Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Citigroup Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Citigroup Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.