Citigroup Inc. (C) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

October 15, 2024

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Banks earnings 90 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Jen Landis

executive
#1

Thanks, operator. Good morning, everyone, and I appreciate you all being on the line for our earnings call covering the third quarter of 2024. With me today are Jane Fraser, who serves as our Chief Executive Officer, and Mark Mason, our Chief Financial Officer. I want to note that the presentation we're using today, which you can download from our site, citigroup.com, might include forward-looking statements. Those statements reflect what management currently expects and are subject to uncertainty as well as changes in circumstances. A number of factors, including the ones laid out in our earnings materials and in our SEC filings, could cause actual results to differ materially from what those statements suggest. So with that said, I'll hand things over to Jane.

Jane Fraser

executive
#2

Thanks, Jen, and good morning, everyone. Well, these are certainly interesting times we're living in. Normally I'd kick off our calls by sharing our take on the global macro picture, but we're especially proud of what we accomplished this quarter, so I'll begin there. In what is a pivotal year, this quarter gave us several proof points showing we're headed the right way and that our strategy is producing tangible results. We achieved revenue growth along with positive operating leverage for the company and in each of our 5 businesses. Our businesses did well as the rate cutting cycle got underway, with fee-based revenues rising by a double-digit amount, which speaks to the increasingly diverse mix of our earnings. We keep gaining share in Services and Banking. Over in Wealth, we recorded a sizable rise in client investment and flows. We reduced expenses while still investing in our transformation and in our businesses; and we keep drawing the industry's top leaders and successfully pairing them with our own teams in banking and wealth. So although we aren't yet where we'd like to be, the effect of the changes we're making shows up clearly in our momentum and in our improving performance. Now to the macro picture. While growth this year isn't slower than last year, the global economy keeps proving surprisingly resilient. Whatever label you attach to the U.S. landing, sentiment surrounding it has turned more optimistic, helped by the recent positive payrolls report, and we observe a healthy yet more discerning U.S. consumer along with a U.S. corporate sector that's on its front foot. Weakness in manufacturing is holding back a modest rebound in Europe, which keeps wrestling with deeper structural challenges regarding its competitiveness, as Draghi's Report pointed out; and in China, consumer sentiment and the property market stay a worry, with markets waiting for details on the anticipated fiscal stimulus. India, ASEAN, Japan, the Middle East, Mexico and Brazil all stand out as bright spots around the world. Today, we posted net income of $3.2 billion and earnings per share of $1.51, with an RoTCE of 7%. On the whole, revenues rose 3% ex divestitures, with every one of our core businesses delivering growth and positive operating leverage, while we kept making substantial investments in our transformation, and the efficiencies gained from our simplification and other efforts produced a 2% decrease in overall expenses. Now to the 5 businesses. Services had a record quarter, with revenues climbing 8%. Fee growth, the best indicator of underlying momentum, was significant. And that, together with growth in loan and deposit volume, powered this quarter's excellent performance. Treasury and Trade Solutions rose 4% year-over-year, reflecting good underlying momentum in the core drivers, and Security Services rose 24%, reflecting the benefit of new mandates and an increase in assets under custody. Both TTS and Security Services reached over 10% wallet share in our target markets through the first half of the year. Earlier this month, we shared that we've become the first bank anywhere in the world to finish linking our cross-border offerings with Mastercard Move; ultimately, that allows nearly instant, secure payments across the huge Mastercard debit network, beginning in 14 markets, with additional ones arriving early next year. That stands as yet another strong illustration of how we keep putting money into innovations that lead the market. Over in Markets, revenues rose modestly, helped by a September that beat expectations. Equities climbed 32%, with solid results in every product. Our ongoing standout results in equities confirm both the plan we've set and how well we're executing to expand prime and cash. Fixed income, on the other hand, fell 6%. Our rate compliances business couldn't repeat the exceptional showing it had a year ago. Banking had a really gratifying quarter. Even with the IPO market subdued, investment banking fees rose 44%, powered by investment-grade debt issuance as clients moved activity forward before the U.S. election. Corporate sentiment is still constructive as Boards chase strategic deals, like the $36 billion Mars acquisition of Kellanova, where we serve as the sole adviser and the lead financier. Our banking strategy keeps building momentum. We're steadily expanding our share in key target sectors including health care and tech, with a solid pipeline in front of us, and the considerable upside of our franchise keeps drawing top talent to Citi. During the quarter, we unveiled an innovative $25 billion private credit partnership with longtime client Apollo, which gives us the capacity to originate new transactions without drawing on our balance sheet. This partnership gives us one more debt financing solution for clients, and it lets us take part in private credit with the same depth and expertise we already bring to syndicated debt markets; we're also beginning to witness the positive effect of the major changes we've made in our wealth franchise, with revenues rising 9%. It's a clear instance of the traction I mentioned earlier. As Andy and the team sharpen their focus on our investment business, we lifted client investment assets by 24%, and we were especially happy with how we did in Asia and in Citigold. The opportunities and the pure potential of our franchise continue to excite me. During the quarter, we signed an agreement to exit trust administration and fiduciary services as we keep sharpening where our Wealth business focuses. We still have work ahead to hit our medium-term margin and return targets. But this quarter is a solid sign that we're getting there. U.S. Personal Banking revenues rose 3%. We increased branded cards revenues by 8%, with account acquisitions, spend and payment rates all pushing interest-earning balances higher. Softer discretionary spending is weighing on our retail services portfolio. Still, we keep seeing lower payment rates add to interest-earning balances. In Retail Banking, we're expanding our mortgage portfolio as the rate environment changes, along with growing loans overall. U.S. consumer dynamics remain remarkably consistent with earlier quarters. When it comes to our customers, they're in good shape, though they've grown more selective about what they spend, and any strain we're seeing is confined to the lower FICOs. We've kept our credit standards tight, and the performance of our card portfolios is tracking right where we expected it to be. On the capital side, even with the uncertainty surrounding Basel III end game, our position stays quite strong, and we finished the quarter with a CET1 ratio of 13.7%. Over that quarter, we gave back $2.1 billion in capital, which included buying back $1 billion of common shares. We'll keep repurchasing stock while assessing the appropriate amount each quarter. As everyone knows, our transformation ranks as our top priority. This quarter brought the closing of yet another long-standing consent order, this one tied to how effective our anti-money laundering systems are. We've stepped up our investments in places where progress has fallen short, like data quality management. Both I and the management team stay unwavering and resolved to get this transformation right and see it through; we'll finish this pivotal year carrying momentum and a determination to keep lifting performance in every business and across the firm as a whole. We're dedicated to hitting our revenue and expense targets for the year, along with our medium-term return target. I take great pride in our senior leadership and the whole organization as we show what our distinctive global franchise can achieve. Leading this firm is a privilege. With that, I'd like to hand things to Mark, and after that we'll be happy, as always, to field your questions.

Mark Mason

executive
#3

Appreciate that, Jane, and good morning to everybody. I'll begin with the financial results for the whole firm, concentrating on third-quarter year-over-year comparisons, unless I say otherwise, and afterward I'll take a bit more time on the businesses. Turning to Slide 5, the financial results for the entire firm are shown; for the quarter, net income came in at roughly $3.2 billion, EPS was $1.51, and RoTCE was 7% on revenue of $20.3 billion. On a reported basis, total revenues rose 1%. Once divestiture-related impacts are excluded, revenues climbed 3%, powered by growth in every one of our businesses. Looking at the bottom left of the page, you'll see net interest income, excluding markets, fell 1% from a year earlier, mostly because of lower interest rates in Argentina, while noninterest revenue, excluding markets, rose 9%, as strong fee momentum continues across Services, Banking and Wealth. Revenues year-to-date rose 1% on a reported basis and are up 3% once divestiture-related impacts are excluded. Expenses came to $13.3 billion, a decline of 2%, mostly from savings tied to our organizational simplification and stranded cost reductions, partly offset by volume-related expenses along with ongoing investments in the transformation and other risk and control initiatives. Year-to-date, expenses rose 1%, mainly because of the FDIC special assessment and civil money penalties. Cost of credit was $2.7 billion, mostly from net credit losses in card and ACL builds across the businesses, primarily for portfolio growth and mix. We ended the quarter with total reserves above $22 billion and a reserve to funded loan ratio of about 2.7%, and year-to-date, excluding divestiture-related impacts, we delivered positive operating leverage for the firm and an RoTCE of 7.2%; Slide 6 shows how expenses have trended across the past 5 quarters; this quarter, expenses were $13.3 billion, down 2% and 1% sequentially. As we've previously stated, we'll keep raising our investments to tackle data governance and data quality tied to regulatory reporting, and we're committed to spending whatever is necessary to address these areas and the transformation more broadly. Though plenty of work is still ahead, benefits from our prior investments have begun to come through. We've kept simplifying our technology infrastructure, retiring more than 450 applications year-to-date and now over 1,250 since our 2022 Investor Day; we've upgraded 100% on of our more than 2,300 ATMs in North America and Asia Pacific to next-gen software for better customer security and monitoring, and we've streamlined our cloud onboarding process, cutting time to onboard applications to the public cloud from over 7 weeks to 2 weeks. Every one of these initiatives will deliver both improvement of our operating efficiency and our safety and soundness. Regarding our expenses for the entire year, our expectation remains that we'll land at the upper portion of the $53.5 billion to $53.8 billion guidance range, not counting the FDIC special assessment and civil money penalty. As previously stated, we will naturally keep seeking ways to absorb the civil money penalty. Slide 7 presents net interest income along with loans and deposits, and I'll discuss the quarter-over-quarter changes. Net interest income fell 1% during the third quarter. When markets are excluded, net interest income rose 4%, primarily from volume growth in USPB plus improved deposit spreads in Services and Wealth. NIM came down 8 basis points, which was caused by a decrease in Markets stemming from seasonally higher dividends during the second quarter. Average loans grew 1%, powered by gains in Services and USPB, partly counterbalanced by modest reductions in Banking and legacy franchise. Average deposits stayed about level, since Services growth was mostly canceled out by a drop in legacy franchise. When you consider guidance for fourth quarter NII ex-markets, with short-end rates still declining, we anticipate a headwind affecting floating rate assets, which disciplined deposit pricing will partially counterbalance. An additional offset will come from the ongoing advantage of securities being reinvested at greater yields. Also, keep in mind that we anticipate a continuing NII headwind as legacy franchises loans and deposits keep decreasing. Bringing all these factors together, we anticipate NII ex-market will be approximately flat quarter-over-quarter during the fourth quarter, and slightly lower for the entire year, which is an improvement over our earlier guidance. Slide 8 displays important consumer and corporate credit metrics, showing how our disciplined risk appetite framework works in practice. Within our cards portfolio, about 85% of loans go to consumers whose FICO scores are 660 or above. According to what we observe, the U.S. consumer is still healthy and resilient. Spend and payment rates keep normalizing, and underlying credit performance stays broadly consistent with what we expected. NCLs rose compared with a year ago as card loan vintages originated during the past few years keep maturing simultaneously. Quarter-over-quarter, NCLs decreased while delinquencies rose, with both matching typical third quarter seasonality. Without that seasonal pattern, we still observe stabilization in early-stage delinquencies. We continue to be well reserved, with a reserve to funded loan ratio of roughly 8.2% for our U.S. cards portfolio. Our corporate portfolio is mostly investment grade, and corporate nonaccrual loans stayed low at 31 basis points. Consequently, we are quite comfortable with the more than $22 billion in total reserves we hold given current conditions. Moving to Slide 9, we give specifics about our balance sheet, capital and liquidity, all of which mirror our risk appetite, strategy and business model. Our $1.3 trillion deposit base is thoroughly diversified across regions, industries, customers and account type. $840 billion of that is corporate money spread across 90 countries, and it's essential to how our customers finance their everyday operations globally. The bulk of what's left in deposits — around $400 billion — is nicely spread among the private bank, Citigold, retail, and wealth and work offerings. Looking at all our deposits together, about 70% are denominated in U.S. dollars, while the rest covers more than 60 currencies. Our asset mix similarly shows the strength of our risk appetite framework. Our loan book of $689 billion is properly diversified between consumer and corporate lending. During the quarter, deposits grew faster than loans, which left us with larger cash balances and helped push available liquidity resources to roughly $960 billion; we still feel quite confident about our balance sheet's strength and the quality of our assets and liabilities, and that puts us in a good spot to serve clients and carry out our growth strategy; turning to Slide 10, we lay out the sequential CET1 walk to give you more granularity on this quarter's drivers. To start, we brought in $3 billion of net income to common shareholders, adding 27 basis points. Next, we gave back $2.1 billion through common dividends and share repurchases, which cut 18 basis points. Then, unrealized AFS gains produced 12 basis points. Lastly, the other 9 basis points of decline came from a rise in RWA as we keep putting money into accretive growth opportunities; we closed the third quarter with a preliminary CET1 capital ratio of 13.7%, against our 13.3% target.

Mark Mason

executive
#4

Just to remind everyone, starting October 1, our requirement for the new CET1 capital ratio stands at 12.1%, and for the time being we continue to intend to keep a management buffer of 100 basis points on top of it. When we look ahead to upcoming quarters, several factors will keep factoring into how we handle our capital levels, such as demand from clients and the way the macro picture and Basel III end game play out. All of these will be weighed when it comes to capital levels and how much share repurchasing we do, evaluated quarter by quarter. Moving to the businesses on Slide 11; over in Services, revenues rose 8%, which speaks to ongoing momentum in both Security Services and TTS, each of which kept picking up share during the first half of this year. Net interest income came in roughly unchanged, since the gain from higher deposit volume was mostly canceled out by falling interest rates in Argentina. Looking sequentially, net interest income climbed 7%, helped by volume growth as we keep bringing on high-quality operating deposits along with the advantage of better deposit spreads. Noninterest revenue rose 33%, thanks to a reduced effect from currency devaluation in Argentina plus sustained strength in the underlying fee drivers within TTS and Security Services. Excluding the effect of the Argentine peso's devaluation, NIR climbed 11%, driven by higher cross-border activity, U.S. dollar clearing volume, and commercial card volume. A 3% increase in expenses came primarily from technology investments, other risk and controls, and product innovation, including bringing the CitiDirect commercial banking platform to additional markets. Credit cost came to $127 million, chiefly due to something involving remittable corporate dividends held on behalf of clients. Loans averaged 5% higher, largely on sustained demand for export and agency finance plus working capital loans. Deposits averaged 4% higher, with operating deposit growth continuing. The Services segment delivered positive operating leverage, with net income coming in at roughly $1.7 billion. It also continues to turn in a strong RoTCE — 26.4% for the quarter and 24.7% on a year-to-date basis. Turning to Slide 12, we lay out how Markets performed in the third quarter. Revenues there were up 1%, as gains in equities more than made up for a pullback in fixed income. Equities revenues jumped 32%, driven by prime momentum, where balances grew about 22%, along with expansion in derivatives and heavier cash volume. Meanwhile, fixed income revenues slipped 6%, weighed down by rates and currencies, which were off 10%, though spread products and other fixed income offered some cushion with a 5% increase. Although rates and currencies declined compared with the same period a year earlier—a quarter that ranked as our best third quarter in 10 years—we still saw solid FX momentum driven by increased activity among corporate clients. Results in spread products and other fixed income improved, supported by securitization financing volumes and underwriting fees, though this was partially offset by weaker commodities amid reduced gas volatility. Expenses increased 1%, largely attributable to costs tied to higher volumes. Our credit-related expense reached $141 million, primarily reflecting an ACL build that resulted mostly from portfolio mix as well as spread products. Average loans grew 10%, driven chiefly by asset-backed lending and spread products, along with margin loans in equity. On average, trading account assets were up 18%, driven largely by what clients wanted: U.S. treasuries, foreign government securities, and mortgage-backed securities. Markets delivered another quarter with positive operating leverage, reporting net income of about $1.1 billion, an RoTCE of 7.9% for the quarter and 9.7% year-to-date. If you go to Slide 13, we show how Banking performed in the third quarter. Banking revenues increased 16%, mostly because investment banking grew. Investment banking revenues were up 31%, and fees rose 44%, with gains in debt capital markets, advisory, and equity capital markets. DCM benefited from investment-grade issuance that stayed strong. Advisory benefited from a high level of announced deal volume earlier in the year. Turning to ECM, we had more follow-on deals, though that gain got partly canceled out by a lower number of IPOs because of choppy markets in August. Wallet share improvements have been achieved by us both for the year so far and during the quarter, and that includes the healthcare and technology verticals where we've been putting money to work. When you strip out mark-to-market on loan hedges, corporate lending revenues were up 5%, mostly because currency devaluation in Argentina had a smaller effect. A 9% drop in expenses came largely from the advantages of having fewer employees, since we keep right-sizing both the workforce and the expense base. Cost of credit came to $177 million, caused by an ACL build tied mainly to shifts in portfolio mix. Average loans declined 1%, reflecting the strict discipline we keep around returns. For a third straight quarter, Banking produced positive operating leverage. Net income came in at $238 million, with an RoTCE of 4.3% for the quarter and 7.2% year-to-date. Turning to Slide 14, you'll find our Wealth results for the third quarter. Our performance this quarter shows we're making solid headway on our strategy, and we anticipate that momentum carrying forward. Revenue was up 9%, helped by a 15% gain in NIR, as investment fee revenues grew on the strength of client investment assets, which rose 24%. NII increased 6%, lifted by higher deposit volumes and spreads. Expenses dropped 4%, reflecting the ongoing benefit of headcount reductions as we rightsize both the workforce and the expense base. Credit expenses came to $33 million, mostly from $27 million in net credit losses. Client balances at period end climbed 14%, fueled by growth in client investment assets and deposits across both North America and international markets. Deposits on average increased 4%, which reflects relationships and their related deposits moving over from USPB, though this was partly offset by deposits shifting into higher-yielding investments on Citi's platform. Average loans declined 1% as we keep optimizing how we use capital. Wealth produced yet another quarter of positive operating leverage, posting $283 million in net income along with an RoTCE of 8.5% for the quarter and 6.8% year-to-date. Slide 15 lays out the results for U.S. Personal Banking in the third quarter. U.S. In Personal Banking, we saw revenues climb 3%, which came from a 2% rise in NII along with a reduction in partner payment. Over at Branded Cards, revenues moved up 8%, with interest-earning balances also growing 8% as payment rates keep returning to normal levels, and spend volume continues to expand, rising 3%. Retail Services revenues slipped 1% because interest-earning balance growth has been slowing down. For Retail Banking, revenues fell 8%, and that was due to moving relationships and their related deposits over to our Wealth business. Expenses came down 1%, which reflects our ongoing productivity efforts, though this was partly offset by expenses tied to higher volume. On the credit side, we saw $1.9 billion in costs, driven largely by net credit losses along with a modest reserve increase tied to higher volumes. Looking at the full year, our expectation for Branded Cards remains an NCL range of 3.5% to 4%. For Retail Services, we continue to anticipate finishing the year near the upper end of the 5.75% to 6.25% range. That reflects the ongoing effects of inflation, interest rates that remain elevated, and softer sales from our partners. Deposits, on average, were down 23%, with the primary driver being the transfer of relationships and their associated deposits into our Wealth business.

Mark Mason

executive
#5

USPB turned in yet another quarter with positive operating leverage, posting net income of $522 million and an RoTCE of 8.2% for the quarter, along with 5.2% year-to-date. As we've noted previously, this segment delivers substantial value to the firm. We understood going into 2024 that it would be a challenging year given the credit cost comparison, yet a route exists toward stronger returns; we'll keep pushing revenue growth via product innovation while also enhancing how efficiently the business operates; and simultaneously, we anticipate the credit environment will normalize, and all of that should ultimately lift USPB to a high-teens return over the medium term. Turning to Slide 16, we present results for all other on a managed basis, which encompasses corporate other and legacy franchises while excluding divestiture-related items. Revenues fell 18%, mainly due to closed exits and wind-downs, plus margin compression on mortgage securities that have extended. Expenses declined 5% since the reduction from closed exits and wind-downs was partly offset by a legal reserve. Cost of credit came in at $289 million, primarily from net credit losses and an ACL build in Mexico. On Slide 17, you'll see our full year 2024 outlook along with medium-term guidance; we produced $61.6 billion of revenue year-to-date, powered by NIR ex-markets growth of 12%, and we're on track to hit our $80 billion to $81 billion full year guidance. As I noted earlier, we now anticipate NII ex-markets will be slightly down for the full year; and given year-to-date expenses of $40.4 billion, excluding the FDIC special assessment and civil money penalties, we still expect to land at the higher end of our full year guidance range. Stepping back, the third quarter marks another period of solid progress and a series of proof points pointing toward better firm-wide and business performance. We stay focused on further improving our performance and delivering on our transformation. These priorities remain essential to bolstering our operations and turning into a more efficient, agile and client-centric company as we keep advancing toward our medium-term targets. With that, Jane and I are glad to take your questions.

Glenn Schorr

analyst
#6

That's helpful guidance — thank you. I'd like to dig into card losses within Retail Services. It appears the exit rate for 2024 will land above the full-year guide of 6.25%. Could you walk us through how that's trending, plus those very large reserves you've accumulated there? And whatever you can share about the portfolio would help us keep our expectations properly calibrated.

Mark Mason

executive
#7

Yes, absolutely. Glenn, let me handle that one. A few points, then. First, with Retail Services, a couple of dynamics are at work. For one, spend volumes are drifting lower. Payment rates are declining too. That, clearly, is driving the growth in average interest-earning balances we're recording. And on top of that, as spend volume falls, a denominator effect kicks in, which naturally lifts the loss rates we're observing. Within the quarter, that remains consistent with our guidance. Still, given what we witnessed earlier in the year along with normal seasonality, we'd anticipate that figure landing at the upper end of the range and probably climbing in Q4 — though how much it climbs in Q4 hinges on traffic patterns and how the holiday spending season shapes up through year-end. As for reserves, I'd describe the levels we hold as quite healthy for this portfolio. In the back of the deck, I believe we disclose a reserve-to-loan ratio of roughly 11.7; so the Retail Services portfolio is well reserved given the conditions we face. In a similar vein, delinquency trends are stabilizing across both portfolios; so all told, we're managing this actively. Retail partner activity matters greatly here, and it will shape Q4 activity or levels — yet we do believe we'll finish at the upper end of the range.

Glenn Schorr

analyst
#8

Alright, one brief question about the Apollo tie-up — quite intriguing and consistent with plenty of other developments we've been observing. What I'd like to know is why you decided to work with a single dedicated partner rather than several, and even more crucially, might additional segments of the franchise gain from closer connections into private markets? My mind goes particularly to the asset-backed space. Thanks.

Jane Fraser

executive
#9

We're very pleased to have teamed up with Apollo, since this combination brings together our broad banking footprint and know-how, and lets us deliver more creative, customized funding options to our customers. Other partners will be part of this too. Mubadala is also taking part. From our standpoint, this is extremely advantageous for the people we serve. We constantly examine ways to serve our clients best and provide them with the widest set of choices. The platform boosts corporate and sponsor clients' ability to tap the private lending capital pool at genuine scale, and $25 billion represents a truly substantial partnership. It also delivers funding certainty for strategic transactions. This arrangement is exclusive for LBOs in non-investment grade within the U.S. And clearly the U.S. accounts for most of the private credit market. It's essentially the BMS on a global basis; witnessing that market grow in Europe would be wonderful. And I wouldn't be shocked if we pursued additional partnerships and other components down the road.

Ebrahim Poonawala

analyst
#10

Perhaps this one's for you, Mark — if we turn to Slide 7, the NII slide, and split things between Markets and ex Markets. On the ex Markets side, NII came in at $11.96 billion for the quarter, and given your comments on the back book repricing and deposit Flex, can we safely say ex Markets NII found its floor in 2Q '24? Also, I saw the securities yield dropped 7 bps versus the prior quarter. Was there a one-time item that weighed on the yield this quarter compared with what you'd laid out before?

Mark Mason

executive
#11

Yes. On Slide 7, there are a few dynamics at work. Take your point about that low figure, the 11.46 low print in the second quarter — that's really a mix of FX translation versus the first quarter, card balances that are seasonally lower, and reduced interest payments in Argentina flowing through from 1Q into 2Q. The third quarter, as I said before, stems largely from lending volumes along with spreads, deposit spreads, and Wealth services; and I believe I've already provided the guide for the fourth quarter, which should be roughly flat. Still, it's worth reminding everyone about the headwinds and tailwinds running through this NII line. On the tailwind side, I'd look for continued loan volume, especially USPB, plus Services — and since we're discussing ex Market, that means Services. I'd also look for ongoing gains from reinvesting securities at higher yields, and we're actively handling beta with our clients. Consider what happened when rates ticked up — we manage that actively on the way down too, when it comes to our institutional clients. Another thing: let's remember our rate sensitivity leans more toward non-U.S. So much of our thinking and discussion centers on U.S. rate moves and the betas tied to them. We'll still see some beta catch-up beyond the U.S., and that's among the headwinds, along with the legacy franchise exits. So, in my long-winded fashion, I do expect flat results as we head into the fourth quarter. I won't provide guidance for 2025. What I will say is that sustaining growth momentum toward our medium-term targets — a 4% to 5% CAGR — will require a blend of NII and NIR, weighted toward NIR. I highlight that because the third quarter and year-to-date figures in our performance reflect very strong fee NIR growth across all 5 of these businesses. And I don't want that to slip out of view while all of you are working hard to grasp how we reach that medium term — right now, we're showing that move toward greater fee revenue; so I'll leave it at that, though I believe that matters. And with any luck, I've addressed what you asked about the NII forecast here.

Ebrahim Poonawala

analyst
#12

That's useful, and I'm with you on the fee momentum. One fast question about the Wealth segment: since the start of the year we've watched a lot of improvement, moving from an ROE of 0 to roughly 8.5% RoTCE, which is meaningful operating leverage. My recollection is that Jane said this momentum ought to keep going. Can we reasonably expect that RoTCE stays — that is, Wealth stays a good-news story when we consider how Citi's ROE keeps getting better from this point as we move toward the targets? Some detail on the Wealth side would be great.

Jane Fraser

executive
#13

Yes. I'm in agreement with you. All of us are quite happy to witness the headway on the strategy we presented at Investor Day. For Wealth, our medium-term goal is 15% to 20%, along with a 25% to 30% operating margin, and we are progressing steadily on that. I'd say the initial step is assembling the pieces of the Global Wealth Organization. And at present our attention is on getting positioned for growth and reshaping the business so it produces the returns all of us anticipate. A key element of that involves changing our mix through growing investment. Client investment assets grew 24% this quarter. I'd describe that as a solid beginning toward achieving the potential we hold here. Meanwhile, Andy keeps right-sizing our expense base and pushing productivity. Adviser productivity in Citigold North America rose more than 50%. So there are various areas he's concentrating on, allowing us to keep expanding the investment space, among them some significant new talent we've been recruiting that I'm certain you've seen.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#14

What guarantee is there that Citi can hit the '26 expense target of $51 billion to $53 billion, and still satisfy its regulatory goals? I'd point out that the run rate so far this year points to $54 billion. So the challenge is moving from a $54 billion run rate to $51 billion to $53 billion by 2026. Put another way, can Citi walk and chew gum simultaneously? As you're aware, on October 2, Senator Warren requested that the OCC place growth restrictions on Citi because it is "too big to manage." I'd imagine you disagree with that characterization, but many people still wonder: what assurance can you offer that an asset cap won't be placed on Citigroup?

Mark Mason

executive
#15

Thanks, Mike. Let me begin with the expense question, and then Jane will certainly add her thoughts on the rest of what you asked. We issued medium-term targets of $51 billion to $53 billion for 2026, contingent on revenue, naturally. That aligns with the target we provided of an efficiency ratio below 60%. This year, as you know, our target sits at the high end of $53.8 billion. So we need to move from $53.8 billion to $51 billion to $53 billion by 2026. I won't give guidance for '25, but you should expect that it would probably glide down toward that figure. What's behind the decrease? We've previously discussed $1.5 billion in savings, mostly tied to the restructuring and the head count reduction that comes with it. We mentioned another $500 million to $1 billion from expense reductions by eliminating stranded costs as we keep exiting — we're already out of 9 of these consumer countries. And we talk about beginning to see efficiencies and benefits from the investments in transformation and technology near the end of 2026. Those are the 3 drivers that matter for us to keep delivering between now and 2026. Will there be headwinds? Yes, there will be. Transformation takes multiple years; we're also investing in risk and controls and regulatory spend to support improving our operations. Of course, headwinds will exist. But there will also be things we move away from, and there'll be tailwinds tied to that. Jane mentioned some of the productivity efforts that both Andy and Biz are pushing on. If you look across these businesses, you see positive operating leverage across the Board. That means Andy Morton, as well as Gonzalo, are 2 people examining their cost structures for expenses they can remove or productivity they might improve. And so there will be additional cost that we have to incur. Extra expenses came up over the course of this year, yet we'll also keep finding further productivity savings as we work them out, so that we can hit those targets.

Jane Fraser

executive
#16

And Mike, I'd like to pick up on one part of — the second half of your question, about where the transformation stands. As you know, and as Mark said, this effort reverses a long stretch of insufficient spending on Citi's infrastructure, and it strengthens how we handle risk and controls. It's a strategic overhaul, as we've discussed, that goes well beyond the consent order, meant to simplify and strengthen Citi for the good of all stakeholders. Citi right now is already very different. During the past 3 years, we've changed a great deal — a far simpler business model, big organizational changes, so that our structure matches that model. Our organization is now flatter, with greater accountability; and as Mark noted, through what we've invested in our transformation, we're focused on simplifying how we operate, modernizing our infrastructure, risk and controls, and all of that lowers risk as we move forward. We're well down the road in executing the transformation plans. We've delivered meaningful progress, which one of our regulators has acknowledged publicly. It's a wide-ranging portfolio of work, and we've made significant advances in areas such as risk management, compliance and accountability. And that reaches well beyond the extensive efforts to consolidate our platforms. So as Mark said, we've retired 1,250 since 2022. Other areas of progress: our stress testing capabilities are better — faster, more frequent, more precise assessment. We've put in place a new target operating model for wholesale credit risk, enterprise risk, price risk firm-wide. A massive amount of work reducing risk and high-risk processes such as payments and markets through systemic preventative controls. We've been deploying the Zing platform. That's the strategic cloud solution for market risk analytics that values trades on demand and at scale. And we've built risk and controls into our performance management framework and tied that to compensation across the entire firm. So this is only a sample of the enormous body of work we're carrying out and finishing with risk. I was very pleased that we closed the FRB, AML/BSA consent order, particularly given the heightened risk and scrutiny in this area. That's the third consent order we've closed since 2021; and we've been very transparent wherever there are areas where our execution has slipped against our original time lines. As happens with our data work, we step back, work out what needs to change in those areas and get back on track and make the relevant tech and people investments. So I feel very confident about the strategy we've laid out for the firm, the deliberate path we're on, the huge progress we've already made and that we will keep making with determination and with clarity going forward.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#17

Just one more question from me. You now have that revised consent order, so it's no longer a recent development. But does this create difficulties in how you serve your customers? Or does it relate to supplying regulators with what they require? And once more, simply to verify, there's no asset cap on you at present. Would it be reasonable to think you aren't anticipating one in the near term? Or is it possible that one exists without us being aware of it?

Jane Fraser

executive
#18

Serving our customers isn't a problem at all. It's quite the reverse; we provide a wellspring of support to our customers when it comes to running their payments operations, their trading operations, their consumer lending operations, in every respect. So I'd describe it as quite the reverse. For them, we represent an enormous wellspring of support, and that's evident in this quarter's results, which delighted us in every respect throughout each of our business lines; and we're collaborating closely with our regulators. We take in what they tell us along with what we ourselves have learned whenever we lag in some part of the consent orders. But please recognize how extensive the consent order effort is, as I described, plus the substantial advances we're achieving in numerous areas, and when we lag somewhere. We put more investment in as required and examine whatever we've learned about our approach and fix it. So I'm quite at ease.

Mark Mason

executive
#19

Right, so once more, this isn't about anything tied to client information, client data, or client reporting. What we're discussing isn't information connected to financials either — it's regulatory reporting. And as I've said on earlier calls, we operate as a global firm. We have more than 11,000 regulatory reports. What we're focused on is making sure the data captured when a trade is entered is the data needed to eventually appear on those different regulatory reports the way we require it to. making sure proper controls exist at that front end. That way, we don't have — we don't need to spend a lot of effort on reconciliation and manual adjustments to that data just to get it into the shape we need for the report, and making sure we have standardized rules and controls surrounding that process so we can carry it out as efficiently as possible. But by and large, this is about making sure we enhance those regulatory reports we're required to produce, beginning with the underlying data needed to do so.

Jim Mitchell

analyst
#20

Mark, let's talk about consensus expectations. This is essentially another way of asking about expenses, but the consensus view is that you won't reach your revenue growth targets — and you're absolutely welcome to push back on that, which I think is reasonable. However, they also project your costs landing at the upper end of your $51 billion to $53 billion range in '26. So, does that seem right to you? Or are you confident that if revenue does somewhat fall short of your targets, you could land — you should or could land at the lower end of that range to help reach your RoTCE target.

Mark Mason

executive
#21

Yes. Let's break this down. First, I believe Jane and I have stayed very consistent in offering guidance on full year performance over the last couple of years. And we've mostly delivered on that guidance. Looking at top line growth since Investor Day, it's mostly in line with what we discussed for the medium term, and looking at the expense guidance we provided, mostly in line with that too, including this year, even when I consider the $80 million to $81 billion revenue guidance we gave for the year and you look at the $60.6 billion we've achieved year-to-date, and you consider what we need to deliver to reach that target, it is achievable, especially when you recall we had a significant Argentina devaluation last year, and the fee momentum needed in the fourth quarter is very achievable. And we believe we will clearly reach the high end of the range for 2024. Thinking about that outer year period and the guidance we provided there, look, all of you want proof points before you truly believe we can deliver on that medium-term target. I'm directing you to proof points. I'm hopeful that as you witness those proof points through 2024, full year and each quarter, you'll begin to believe in that revenue momentum needed for the medium term. The fee revenue is a strong indicator of what we delivered this year and this quarter is a strong indicator of the momentum we should see across these businesses in the next couple of years. I also hope you'll then see that as we meet the expense target, we have a path to keep delivering on the medium-term expense target, the drivers of which I mentioned earlier. Sure — if we end up bringing in less revenue than the goal we established for ourselves, it makes sense that costs tied to volume and transactions, along with compensation costs, would decline proportionally with that shortfall. And you'd likewise anticipate that we'd examine whether additional productivity chances can be identified so we can still hit the operating efficiency objective we set for ourselves.

Jim Mitchell

analyst
#22

Thanks for that. And perhaps, as a quick follow-up regarding the capital issue. I suppose one factor that has acted somewhat as a drag during the past 12 months has been the expansion in DTA deductions. Are we beginning to observe that turning into a positive force once more? In what way should we consider it building back into capital across the next 2 years?

Mark Mason

executive
#23

Yeah. Well — see, the primary catalyst for our use of DTA is going to be generating greater income within the U.S.; that is going to be the key catalyst. And when we consider — so when you consider every one of those strategies Jane outlined for our company, you will frequently hear how crucial it is to succeed in the U.S. You will hear that in connection with banking and the activity plus the robust results we witnessed this quarter and in business world. You hear that regarding the Wealth division and how vital it is for us to expand investments, especially throughout North America, you notice it in USPB, which is mostly a business centered on the U.S. Using DTA comes down to our raising net income or achieving greater net income within the U.S. And while we strive to carry out our client-driven strategy, we are seeking chances to accomplish that. We are motivating the business to sustain that momentum. And that is what will provide us with greater utilization on a quarter-by-quarter basis in the years ahead.

L. Erika Penala

analyst
#24

Jane, this first one's directed at you. When I talk with investors who hold for the long haul, a remark I hear often is that obviously the route stretching from this quarter's 7% RoTCE up to 11% to 12% will, with luck, get bridged, and to establish a position ahead of that progress being delivered, they genuinely kind of need to witness additional capital optimization; and this isn't actually the identical question I've put to you each quarter regarding buybacks, but instead perhaps an update on how things are progressing at Banamex. So chatter circulated in the market that Banamex required 4 quarters of standalone financials prior to being IPO-ed? And I'm curious whether you could share concrete progress on how that effort is going. And Mark, perhaps remind us what Banamex contributes when we consider unlocking that excess capital rather than pulling it from the P&L?

Jane Fraser

executive
#25

Yes, Erika, I'd be happy to. And before diving into Banamex, I'd also point to an intense focus on capital optimization. Within our Markets business and in Banking, it has served as a mantra for quite a while, a discipline we've pushed across the entire organization. And I'd say nobody at Citi fails to be acutely conscious of the emphasis on optimizing our capital, returning to shareholders, especially considering where we're trading, and ensuring we drive toward return. So turning to Banamex, what we're singularly focused on at present is separating the 2 banks, something we expect to finish in this year's fourth quarter; this has amounted to a tremendous body of work since we are essentially creating de novo Mexico's eighth largest bank; we've only just obtained the core regulatory authorizations required to move ahead with separation. Though a few other approvals remain pending. We're in the very final stages, working alongside our clients to get them ready for this switchover and — later in Q4. After separation wraps up, we'll direct our full attention toward the IPO itself, and successful execution of the IPO ranks as the highest priority for our Head of International, Ernesto Torres Cantú, to run Banamex, along with our incoming Banamex Executive Chairman, Ignacio Deschamps, who starts this quarter; we intend to be ready to IPO at the end of 2025 depending on the factors within our control; but as Mark and I have consistently stated, market conditions will dictate the timing so we maximize shareholder value. And we're making the investments required to keep growing share, and I was quite pleased that Banamex surpassed average market revenue growth year-to-date while maintaining good expense discipline despite the complex separation process and the environment. So I'm pleased with our position, and I hope that offers you some sense of what the road ahead looks like.

Mark Mason

executive
#26

Regarding the latter portion of what you asked, there are a few points to make. First, our consumer operation in Mexico has been expanding nicely. We've likewise been putting money into it as needed, so that we can safeguard the durability of that franchise while getting it ready for the eventual spinoff ahead of the IPO. Erika, assuming I grasped your question correctly, if you go to Page 16 in the deck, at the lower right, we lay out the P&L for Mexico consumer covering '22 and '23. That way you're able to observe what it contributes on both the revenue side and the expense side — roughly $1.5 billion during 2023. And I believe we have somewhere around $4 billion of TCE tied to this business. So that should give you a feel for what it contributes, though it keeps delivering pretty solid results as we steer it through this whole process.

L. Erika Penala

analyst
#27

Great. And to follow up on that, I'm certain it must be annoying for you to watch how the stock has moved in a period when you delivered PPNR strength and improved expectations for net interest income in Q4. So let me put it to you this way, Mark. Given all the swings we're seeing in rate expectations around the world, could you remind us whether it's reasonable to think that Citi is asset-sensitive outside the U.S. while sitting in a neutral spot at home? What's the right way to think about late fees? I recall you saying late fees would reach $8 as part of your original — your original outlook for the year; and on top of that, it seems maybe since capital markets are performing so well everywhere across every one of your competitors. Perhaps that isn't the reason you're receiving "credit" for how strong you were this quarter. So looking ahead to '25, with NIR contributing more to your revenue CAGR, could you take us through which other core fee strengths we ought to anticipate, besides FICC and banking staying robust and rebounding, that might feed into that route toward '26.

Mark Mason

executive
#28

All right. That's quite a bit, but I appreciate the question. I'd prefer to see the stock respond far more positively since this genuinely was a solid quarter for us. And actually, as you pointed out, NII, once you dig into it, we've actually nudged our NII guidance higher just a little, as we noted that the full year would be slightly down rather than modestly down, with a fourth quarter that's flat versus the third quarter. So that's a key point to take away. I brought up the headwinds and tailwinds before, and we shouldn't forget about them. Reinvesting the securities as they mature will give us a boost, we'll keep seeing volume growth, and those matter as drivers of tailwind activity for us. You correctly brought up our interest rate exposure analysis, which we run every quarter and which shows the asset sensitivity of our business. And in the prior quarter, it was roughly $1.6 billion of a negative, assuming a 100 basis point decline across the curve, assuming a static balance sheet and cross currencies. And when you look at that asset sensitivity, again, you correctly noted that we lean non-U.S. in terms of how large that NII decline would be if we saw that parallel shift. And actually, as much as $1.3 billion or so out of that $1.6 billion is tied to non-U.S. dollar across 60 currencies. So all of it would need to move together for that drag to hit. And the U.S. dollar drag comes to roughly $300 million, assuming a 100 basis point shift, and that figure has been declining. Looking back across the quarters, we've been carefully managing it lower, and it's now down to around $300 million. When we report the third quarter, I'd anticipate it'll decline somewhat further. So again, our position is asset sensitive, though it does have a bias beyond the U.S., and I appreciate your question, since I believe it's worth reminding both our investors and analysts about that characteristic, which in numerous respects might differ from what other institutions experience. Regarding late fees, we did mention that our assumptions and the outlook we provided incorporate them. I'll say what's plain, Erika: naturally, we'd like people to pay promptly, and we make every effort to help and make sure they do so. That being said, we lack a set schedule regarding late fees, and we aren't excessively dependent on them to generate revenue for our company; therefore, it appears that this decisioning will probably land nearer to some point during 2025. Consequently, there's a modest tweak in the final quarter of our revenue projection, yet it remains within the guidance we offered and doesn't meaningfully alter it at all. Then the final portion of your question, I believe, concerned NIR along with fee revenue. As I said before, I won't provide guidance for 2025, but I think what you were asking is where we're probably going to keep seeing momentum when it comes to growth in fee revenue; and I'd begin with Services, where fees rose roughly 33% compared to a year earlier; and yes, we ought to make an adjustment for the Argentine peso devaluation; yet even after doing so, it's double digit, 11% year-over-year noninterest revenue growth, and when you examine those drivers, they've remained reliably robust, cross-border transaction value climbed 8%, U.S. dollar clearing volume increased 7%, commercial card spend rose 8%, and in the supplement, you'll find it's mid- to high single-digit year-to-date growth across those KPIs too. We anticipate that this will persist with our corporate clients and as we onboard new commercial clients as well. I'll direct you to — if you look at banking, we've already covered that. So I won't dive into it too deeply, other than to point out a genuinely robust quarter in banking, in investment banking fees especially, the recovery we've been discussing, but crucially, our gaining share within that recovery and these key partnerships that leave us well positioned as sponsors begin re-engaging with the market, the investments we've made in talent and sectors requiring strengthening. Every one of those factors will contribute to ongoing fee momentum as we head into 2025. Wealth, once more, delivered truly strong results this quarter with revenues climbing 9%; but consider the client investment assets, which rose 24%. Client balances have climbed 14%, which fuels the momentum in fees, and that's something Andy and the group he's assembled are sharply focused on. It's a genuine opening for us when you consider the roughly $5 trillion in assets our clients keep elsewhere, and we're putting ourselves in a stronger spot to win that business. Then last, you can see USPB carrying on its momentum. But what I'm telling you, Erika, is that this fee momentum shows up everywhere, and it matters. It counts as a key piece as we look toward hitting those medium-term objectives within that 4% to 5% revenue range.

Gerard Cassidy

analyst
#29

Mark, during your prepared remarks you brought up pushing U.S. Personal Banking RoTCE toward higher levels, and you named two things — innovative products plus normalization of credit costs. Could you go deeper on those two, which will act as drivers, beyond the efficiency gain you also brought up?

Mark Mason

executive
#30

Yes, absolutely. So clearly, USPB combines the cards businesses we run with the retail banking business. That cards portfolio includes both branded and retail services; and even inside branded, we have proprietary cards, where honestly we've been exploring how to develop new innovative offerings. One illustration of product innovation is the recent refresh of our Strata Premier card, built to drive acquisition and engagement through a new rewards offering; and because of that, acquisitions rose roughly 7% both quarter-over-quarter and year-over-year for Branded Cards. That's one illustration of product innovation. Another is Flex Pay at Costco, which we also launched a few quarters ago, and you can see solid installment loan growth resulting from it, up around 15%. So those — that sort of product creation matters for acquisitions. It matters for keeping the card top of wallet and matters for fueling some of that top line performance. Then the other item I brought up, you're right, concerned cost of credit, and that's really the continued normalization of cost of credit I've mentioned a few times now — the notion that multiple vintages are maturing simultaneously, and that sort of — that has to play through; and enough for us to sort of see a more normal level of credit; and that will matter for the returns. And once more, we are beginning to see stabilization both in the cost of credit line and in delinquencies, and that's a good indicator for us.

Gerard Cassidy

analyst
#31

Alright, great. Moving on to credit, just a follow-up there. Over in the Banking segment, you noted the cost of credit came to, I believe, $107 million, driven by an ACL build of $141 million, and that stemmed from a shift in the portfolio's mix. Could you tell us what that mix shift was that produced this provision?

Mark Mason

executive
#32

There's nothing — it's a combination of various asset classes and clients we've extended against; nothing in that figure is material or significant. If you look at nonaccrual loans, that ratio remains at 31 basis points. So it's a change in the mix of our exposures, but nothing material there.

Jane Fraser

executive
#33

Also, what we're observing is that the business community globally remains quite robust.

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#34

I've got a couple of things to ask, Jane and Mark. The first concerns costs, and the second relates to how you answered the asset cap matter earlier. Starting with the simpler one, on expenses. Earlier this year, you mentioned anticipating roughly $700 million to $1 billion in severance charges within the 53.5% to 53.8% range. Did any of that hit in Q3, and do you anticipate any in Q4? Also, do you think those will wrap up by the end of this year, or will they carry over into next year or the year after?

Mark Mason

executive
#35

Right. So that figure combined restructuring charges along with severance, or what we call repositioning, charges. We do separate out restructuring, as you know, so those are visible, and the restructuring piece was mostly tied to simplifying the organization. That portion wraps up during this year. As for the ordinary severance or repositioning costs that come up in the regular course of BAU, those show up every year, and they'll definitely be present in '25 and '26 as we move ahead. Some occurred this quarter. My expectation is that some will also occur next quarter, though I certainly don't see us landing beyond the range I provided. And to repeat, that range covered both components together.

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#36

Moving on to the question about an asset cap, Jane and Mark. We didn't get a definitive response regarding, first, whether such a cap exists for you and, second, assuming it doesn't, what practical consequence or effect the regulators' statements carry.

Jane Fraser

executive
#37

Let me state this without any ambiguity; no asset cap applies to us, and nothing beyond the measures disclosed in July is currently active, nor do we anticipate anything further. So — regarding the consequences — our approach is, as I've described, we've directed more funding toward the gaps we had, especially in data tied to our regulatory reporting processes. We're putting additional investment there, and we keep achieving progress, significant progress, on the orders that exist, among them resolving the BSA/AML order during this quarter, which marks the third order resolved since '21.

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#38

So you're not anticipating anything significant, Jane, that could affect the business — for instance, there was that recent report regarding the financial license you weren't granted approval for by the regulator. Anything else of that magnitude that might be happening, perhaps?

Jane Fraser

executive
#39

Let me state this without any ambiguity at all: there is absolutely nothing.

Matt O'Connor

analyst
#40

I just have a few things I want to clarify. First, regarding Banamex — do you still expect to complete the IPO during the fourth quarter of next year, or has it simply shifted by one quarter because the legal separation is taking somewhat more time?

Jane Fraser

executive
#41

Well, as I said when answering Erika's question, we intend to be prepared for an IPO at the close of '25, to the extent the factors are within our control. When it actually happens will depend on what best maximizes shareholder value, and that comes down to market conditions. That's our position.

Matt O'Connor

analyst
#42

All right, so my read on that is that you're pointing to 1Q '26 by the time '25 wraps up, though that's really what I was trying to nail down with my question. My understanding was that once you've legally separated it, 4 quarters have to pass before you can formally IPO it?

Jane Fraser

executive
#43

Based on where things sit right now, our view is that we'd be in a position to IPO at the end of '25. The bigger consideration is really what market conditions look like at that moment; and Mark and I are intensely focused on shareholder value and on maximizing it rather than hurrying to gain 1 quarter over another quarter.

Mark Mason

executive
#44

And there's no hard rule on — sorry, go ahead.

Jane Fraser

executive
#45

No strict requirement exists that says you must complete 4 entire quarters once you have — once you have split off.

Matt O'Connor

analyst
#46

Understood. Alright, that's genuinely helpful. We've just encountered so few of these, so this is valuable. And on a separate note, I think you mentioned during the prepared remarks a modest provision sitting inside services, connected to some unremitted corporate dividends; I'd like some clarity there, and which country does that involve? And from what I gathered, there wasn't really much of a liability on your end from it. So could you give us some color on that? I know the figure is small, but it would help. Also, just to note, the reserve-to-loan ratio stands at roughly 11.7%.

Mark Mason

executive
#47

Sure. The figure is small. And toward the back of the deck, there's a page that covers Russia exposure. That's the item in question.

Matt O'Connor

analyst
#48

All right. Yet it still seems to me that you folks face no danger from every one of those dividends that are sort of stuck? And I suppose, if the law poses no danger to you folks, why set aside a modest reserve?

Mark Mason

executive
#49

So, that's how we handle that exposure; the rules governing how exposures must be handled in a nation where we cannot distribute to clients but instead must hold them on their behalf are what we're adhering to. Consequently, a reserve tied to that has to be recorded, and that is what we do. Clearly, on the page we display what the exposure amounts to should control be lost, and the way that finally nets out is visible to you, but for reserves of that type, we are complying with the proper standards regarding what is needed.

Ryan Kenny

analyst
#50

I've got a question for Mark. You said that Services NII acts as a tailwind when rates come down. Could you break down the mechanics of that? Should we be factoring in any gains from swap roll off or floating swaps that are part of what you're describing?

Mark Mason

executive
#51

A few points are worth keeping in mind regarding the Services business. First, clearly, this is a client-facing business, not simply one that takes deposits. That means the way we approach pricing for those clients matters a great deal. There's a U.S. versus non-U.S. element at play where, for institutional clients, we've mostly maintained the higher betas we observed as rates moved up, once again keeping the relationship in mind, and we face some offsetting pressure outside the U.S. as those betas essentially converge. But importantly, you also heard me bring up reinvestment into securities at higher yields. That reinvestment, or those higher yields, eventually flows through the businesses. So that will appear within NII when we consider Services, and the other businesses too. Those are key pieces of the NII narrative for Services. When you examine — but during the quarter, NII performance declined 5%. A significant portion of that stems from Argentina, higher — lower rates movement in the quarter compared with last year; so lower rates that we're earning in Argentina flowing through that line, especially this quarter, if you made an adjustment for that on the NII line, it would be flat to slightly a little bit better. So that's essentially what it comes down to. It's management of client relationships along with the higher earnings on reinvested securities adding to that, plus a volume from operating account growth that we anticipate.

Saul Martinez

analyst
#52

Two fast ones from me. To start, I want to pick up where we left off on Banamex. Jane, as everyone knows, people are worried about judicial reform down in Mexico, plus what that means for the rule of law, and because of that, prices on Mexican assets have taken a hit. My understanding is that the biggest bank in Mexico is trading somewhere around 7x earnings. Suppose the market doesn't get better, Mexican asset prices stay beaten down, and those worries don't go away — then what? Do you simply sit tight and hope things turn around? Or in a situation where Mexico's macro picture looks like it's getting worse, how are you approaching this whole process?

Jane Fraser

executive
#53

Right. We have to hold off and observe how the market plays out. Still, the NorthStar for Mark and for me could not be clearer: getting the most value possible for shareholders is the goal. So should things not be right at that moment, we'll hold off until they are. Meanwhile, the business keeps delivering solid results. It adds to our returns. It isn't weighing us down at all. So there's simply no reason to hurry toward a poor outcome; we will IPO, and we will exit Banamex — just not in some careless way; discipline will guide us. That's what you'd expect from us. And I believe we're showing that across many different areas.

Saul Martinez

analyst
#54

All right, that's reasonable. Then I suppose a follow-up question regarding the RoTCE gain in U.S. Personal Banking. Normalizing the cost of credit appears to be a major piece of that. But Mark, could you remind us where things stand on cost of credit relative to what you'd consider a more typical level for Branded Cards and Retail Services? I mean, how big a tailwind would a credit environment that's more normalized bring in terms of credit cost?

Mark Mason

executive
#55

Once more, I'd rather not discuss 2025 at this point. I can promise you we'll provide additional detail and remarks on that when we reach the fourth quarter earnings in January. What I can say, once more, when you consider these businesses, we are seeing ongoing top line. We anticipate ongoing top line momentum — across USPB we've now had 8 straight quarters of positive operating leverage, 49% in this quarter; so the expense base is being managed effectively. In our view there's additional upside on the top line. Growth throughout the portfolios is really where our focus is. And I genuinely believe that cost of credit, once more, if only because of the compounding impact from those vintages maturing, plus inflation beginning to ease, rates drifting lower, that ought to benefit the consumer and ought to begin showing up both in the macroeconomic scenarios we run for CECL purposes and eventually in delinquencies and NCLs, and we are already starting to observe that improvement in delinquencies along with some stabilization; so guidance isn't something I want to get into, but that's roughly how I view the drivers or contributors to better returns over the medium term.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#56

I appreciate you clearing up the point about the asset cap that came up from me before. And I realize there's only so much you're able to share regarding regulators. Still, to make sure it's clear, since there's been a lot of email back-and-forth, you did state that no asset cap exists, that you aren't anticipating one, and that you aren't anticipating any other extra measures right now. .

Jane Fraser

executive
#57

Correct.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#58

Alright. I appreciate you clearing that up. And listen, I hold regulators in high regard — having been one myself, Paul Volcker was someone I looked up to. I have respect for regulators. And no one expects you to take shortcuts in order to reach that $51 billion to $53 billion in expenses; but I'm just asking — and you've already merged systems, apps, layers, and bureaucracy, plus you're shedding a lot of activities. So it's just — even that amended consent order caught people off guard given how much effort you've put in. And if an amended consent or other measures were warranted, they likely should have come 1, 5, 10, or even 20 years back. So from the outside, that's simply puzzling. That being said, is the issue about deploying additional funds or about carrying out these tasks more cleverly. Put differently, you're adding more fuel to the tank, yet the car isn't accelerating; so is it the quantity of resources or simply being smarter when it comes to settling some of these regulatory matters?

Jane Fraser

executive
#59

Let me separate this into a few components. First, I want to remind everybody that the consent orders are extremely, extremely wide-ranging. And the step that was taken came about since we've fallen behind in a more limited area, specifically data, especially when it comes to our regulatory reporting, and that's where we're lagging — that's the primary focus. We acted quickly to fix it. We've been quite open about it since early in the year, that we were slipping on this. And on the whole, I'm happy with how far we've come; and like you mentioned, Mike, I went through quite a few areas where we've made headway and tried to keep it as concrete as possible, considering what we're able and unable to discuss since this is supervisory. I'm glad that our businesses keep enhancing their results, even as the transformation proceeds. . Those are the 2 priorities for us this year. So in effect, yes, we're able to walk and chew gum simultaneously, and the enormous upside of all that simplification across the business, the organization, and the other initiatives is that it lets us execute more easily and stay sharply focused; and well, perhaps Mark, I'll hand it over to you.

Mark Mason

executive
#60

I believe what you're asking is useful, because you framed it as whether this represents some sort of rethinking of how we're going about things, or whether it's simply about needing to spend additional funds. And Mike, one thing we've done is step back and examine the way we've been handling data, as an illustration. So this is — and we're going to make — we've already implemented certain adjustments to how we operate, and those adjustments have to do with the manner in which we pursue fixing data problems once they've been flagged, making sure the front-end business gets involved, along with the functions that matter most, and making sure there's thought given to what reg reporting demands so that we can get that process running smoothly and accurately. And so there is — certain elements of this call for a shift in how we do things, and we've been adopting that shift, or rather implementing that change, and further changes will follow as we continue with that step back. And then the other — and certain elements of it call for, at a minimum, examining what's driving either the holdup or our failure to move at the speed we'd prefer, that our regulators would prefer. And that is, in fact, precisely what the resource review plan contained within the amended consent order amounted to. It was essentially a declaration that you must make certain you've got adequate resources and that those resources are directed at attaining timely and sustainable compliance; and so a piece of our process is, in fact, that, conducting a routine assessment of what's on track regarding our milestones and deliverables, and wherever we find items that are slipping or turning red, what's the root cause behind it. Is it a matter of resources, where additional dollars need to go toward people or technology? Is it a matter of process, where our approach needs rethinking. And on the flip side of that root cause, taking steps to remedy it; and so your question hits the mark. The response is that often, it'll be somewhat of both. But crucially, our processes incorporate that kind of analysis and evaluation so we can pursue execution on this effectively. I hope that's useful.

Jane Fraser

executive
#61

This also boosts productivity along with additional gains for those who hold stock in our company, while simultaneously ensuring that our institution becomes more robust when viewed through a regulatory lens.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#62

And now for my final question. If there's a gap between how you're performing and where the stock trades, that looks like a bigger chance to purchase shares at $64 while tangible book value sits at $90. So my hope is — I've made this comparison before, but ideally, you're selling off the chairs, the desk, the silverware, and the executive dining room so you can go buy back stock, as much as possible.

Jane Fraser

executive
#63

Yes. Given where we're trading, it's clear; we're highly focused on the chances to repurchase shares and aware of how much that matters. And at the same time, yes, we take pride in how the franchise performed this quarter. It was a very strong quarter and an important set of proof points for our investors that we're on a deliberate path, we're making the progress that we need to, and actually pretty excited about the path ahead of us and the potential that we see.

Jen Landis

executive
#64

Thanks to all of you for being on this call. Should you have any further questions, please reach out to IR. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#65

This concludes Citi's Third Quarter 2024 Earnings Call. You may now disconnect.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Citigroup Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Citigroup Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Citigroup Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.