Citigroup Inc. (C) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 15, 2025
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jenn Landis
executiveThanks, operator. Good morning, everyone, and I appreciate all of you being on this call for our fourth quarter 2024 earnings discussion. Here with me today are Jane Fraser, our Chief Executive Officer, and Mark Mason, our Chief Financial Officer. I want to remind everyone that today's presentation — which you can download from our website, citigroup.com — might include forward-looking statements. Those are based on what management currently expects and are subject to uncertainty and shifts in circumstances. Actual results could differ materially from those statements because of a range of factors, including the ones laid out in our earnings materials and in our SEC filings. With that said, I'll hand things over to Jane.
Jane Fraser
executiveThanks, Jenn, and good morning, everyone. I'll begin with the broader environment, then take you through how we performed for the entire year. I want to offer a few reflections on how our strategy execution is coming along, and I'll wrap up by explaining the reason we chose to revise our 2026 return objective. We came into 2025 with a clear strategic direction and solid momentum in every one of our businesses. Looking at the worldwide macro situation, economies have managed to absorb central bank rate increases quite well, and inflation has plainly been cooling. Although policy decisions, whether through tariffs or taxes, will undoubtedly affect economic activity, 2025 appears quite similar to 24. The U.S. still sits at the center of the macro story. Higher-end consumers aren't the only growth engine — a robust, innovative corporate sector is contributing as well. China has grown more slowly than anticipated, yet additional stimulus remains a possibility. Europe keeps falling short of potential, and a number of emerging markets have come back as standout performers — a development that clearly works in our favor, thanks to our worldwide network and deep footprint in places like India and across the Middle East and ASEAN. As I mentioned, 2024 was a pivotal year, and I take pride in what we achieved and in how our businesses delivered. We closed out with an exceptionally robust fourth quarter, which Mark will walk through in a moment. Across the entire year, net income rose almost 40%, reaching $12.7 billion. We beat our revenue goal for the year, with revenues climbing 5% excluding divestitures. Fee revenue increased 17%, and the hit from Argentina's currency devaluation turned out smaller. We kept expenses inside our guidance range and lifted our efficiency ratio by 340 bps while also boosting investment in our transformation. Our RoTCE improved by more than 200 bps, even though it started from a low base. All five of our core businesses produced positive operating leverage for the year, and we hit that mark at the firm level too. Despite rates staying low, our Services segment grew 9% and delivered another record-breaking year, powered by fresh mandates and a push toward fee-based growth. We gained ground in both TTS and security services, helped along by our best fourth quarter in ten years; the market itself was up 6%. The way this franchise delivered during a stretch of subdued volatility shows what our diversified product mix is worth. Equities held up throughout, climbing 26% in what turned out to be a record-setting year for us. Banking was up 32% as we captured share in all three investment banking products, and we unveiled a groundbreaking $25 billion private credit partnership with Apollo, a longtime client of ours. Thanks to our business leadership, we expect to keep closing the gap on rivals throughout 2025 and afterward. Turning to wealth: 2024 was a pivotal year, since we concentrated more sharply on investments, adjusted the expense base to the right size, and enhanced how clients experience us. For the full year, revenue climbed 7%, which included an 18% increase in fees. Citigold and Asia performed particularly well, and net new investment asset flows grew 40%, which was very gratifying. Throughout the year we recruited outstanding talent into wealth, and most recently we added Kate Moore as our CIO and Anne McCosker as our Head of Lending. This business holds tremendous potential, with both new and existing clients, and we are dedicating genuine focus to it. USPB revenues were up 6%, driven by card borrowing in both portfolios as well as fee growth. We shared news of a 10-year extension to our cobranded partnership with American Airlines, ensuring this valuable relationship makes it into its fifth decade. With the Barclays portfolio acquisition, we will become American Airlines' exclusive partner in 2026, and as a result, we anticipate delivering greater value for our cardholders along with strong returns for our shareholders. Tangible book value per share was up 4%, and we closed out 2024 with a CET1 ratio of 13.6%, about 150 bps higher than our regulatory capital requirement. After buying back $1 billion in common shares during the fourth quarter, we returned nearly $7 billion in capital to our common shareholders in 2024. While our dedication to giving capital back remains strong, I'm particularly pleased to share that a $20 billion share repurchase program has been approved by our board. The strategy we presented at Investor Day three years back is clearly producing concrete results, as you can observe. Our company has undergone significant simplification since that time. Operations serving consumers in nine nations were divested, closures in three are almost finished, and we expect to complete departures from the remaining two; among these is Banamex, which we officially split off from our institutional operations in December. At this point, our entire attention is directed toward preparations for an IPO, though when that happens largely hinges on regulatory clearances and market circumstances, naturally. As part of matching how we're set up to what we're trying to accomplish, we carried out a major streamlining of the company — cutting out layers of management as well as the regional setup. The result is faster decisions and a stronger partnership with our clients. Our culture has gotten stronger too, because we tied pay more closely to shareholder interests and upgraded our scorecards so we make sure clients are getting what they need. Across the company we brought in some of the best people in the industry, and that includes new leaders at my table overseeing banking, wealth, and technology; we've set higher expectations for one another and for what our clients should receive from us. We keep finding new ways to make things better for clients and to work more efficiently. Citi Payments Express is now up and running in 18 countries, and 4 million retail bank customers in the U.S. have moved onto our simplified banking platform. Our adoption of AI has sped up: 30,000 developers now have coding tools at their disposal, and we rolled out two AI platforms so that our 143,000 colleagues can do their jobs with less friction. Thanks to the money we're putting into upgrading infrastructure, smoothing out processes, and automating controls, the way we operate the bank is different — balance sheet reporting, for instance, now sits on a single unified ledger. For valuing trading assets more accurately, we brought in a cloud-based risk analytics solution. And three consent orders that had been open for a long time are now closed out. We have strong capital, liquidity, and reserves. Thanks to our focused strategy, our infrastructure, and being selective about clients, we've cut our risk profile substantially. Considerable headway has been made on our transformation. Some areas are further along than others, and plenty of work remains — especially when it comes to data and regulatory reporting, which last summer's regulatory actions made clear. We went through the whole data program, changed how it's governed and structured, and put more money into it. As CEO, my aim is to position this company for long-term success and make sure we have sufficient capacity to invest toward that goal; so when it comes to expense guidance, the bulk of the savings from the org simplification and stranded costs will go toward funding the extra investments required this year in both transformation and technology. Consequently, we anticipate total expenses for 2025 landing a bit under the 2024 figure, along with delivering yet another year of positive operating leverage. We view our elevated expense level as temporary and expect it to continue declining past 2025; but once we factor in the necessary investments, our 2026 RoTCE expectation is now somewhere between 10% and 11%. That 2026 RoTCE is a waypoint, not a destination. We intend to keep pushing returns well beyond that level, and we hold ourselves accountable for it; we won't let up in our drive to run the bank more efficiently, realize Citi's potential, and satisfy our shareholders' expectations. Before handing things to Mark, I want to recognize the catastrophic wildfires in Los Angeles. A number of our clients and multiple colleagues have lost their homes, and we'll do everything we can to assist them in recovering from this devastating event; they and their loved ones remain in all our thoughts at Citi. Now, over to Mark.
Mark Mason
executiveThank you, Jane, and good morning, everybody. My plan is to begin by covering the Q4 and full-year financial results, and I'll be concentrating on how they compare year over year, except where I note otherwise. I'll also walk through what we currently expect for 2025 and 2026. Turning to Slide 7, the figures there cover the entire firm and demonstrate better performance in both the quarter and the year. Just to remind you, revenues in last year's fourth quarter took a big hit from the Argentina currency devaluation. Adjusted revenues along with non-interest revenues for the whole firm and for services appear in the earnings presentation appendix on Slide 36; for this quarter, net income came in at $2.9 billion, EPS was $1.34, and RoTCE stood at 6.1%, or $19.6 billion of revenues, which produced positive operating leverage for the firm and across each of our businesses. Total revenues rose 12%, fueled by gains in every one of our businesses plus a reduced effect from the Argentina currency devaluation. Net interest income excluding markets was about flat, as growth in USPB and wealth was offset by decreases in corporate other and banking. Non-interest revenues excluding markets climbed 40%, fueled by sustained strong fee momentum across services, banking and wealth, together with lower partner payments in USPB and a reduced effect from the Argentina currency devaluation. And total markets revenues rose 36%. Expenses came to $13.2 billion, a decline of 18%, mainly because the prior year included the FDIC special assessment and restructuring charge, which are absent now. If you set aside the FDIC special assessment and divestiture related impacts, expenses fell 7%, as the prior year's restructuring charge was absent and our organizational simplification produced savings, partly offset by higher volume related expenses. Cost of credit was $2.6 billion, mostly made up of cards, net credit losses and ACL build. When the quarter closed, our total reserves exceeded $22 billion, with a reserve to funded loan ratio of 2.7%. And for the full year, we generated $12.7 billion of net income with an RoTCE of 7%. On Slide 8, we lay out full year revenue trends by business spanning 2021 to 2024. This year we brought in $81.1 billion of revenue, which is up 5% on an ex-divestiture basis, fueled by gains in every one of our businesses and a reduced effect from the Argentina currency devaluation. Services revenues grew 9% to $19.6 billion, helped by a reduced effect from the Argentina currency devaluation, fee growth and higher deposit volumes. Markets revenues grew 6% to $19.8 billion, mostly fueled by growth in equity, which posted its highest annual revenue in a decade, and spread products. Banking revenues grew 32% to $6.2 billion, mostly fueled by growth in Investment Banking with fees up 42%, as we picked up roughly 50 basis points of share on an increased wallet. Wealth revenues grew 7% to $7.5 billion, mostly fueled by a 15% increase in non-interest revenue, as we keep growing client investment assets. USPB's top line rose 6%, reaching $20.4 billion, powered by cards growth, since we keep witnessing robust customer engagement plus a rise in interest earning balances along with reduced partner payments. Broadly speaking, this year proves to be yet another showing of results in line with our medium-term objective of 4% to 5% yearly expansion and the worth of our diversified business model. Slide 9 presents the full year expense trend spanning 2021 to 2024. If you set aside the FDIC special assessment's effect, our full year expenses came to $53.8 billion, matching our target. The decrease in expenses stemmed from savings tied to our organizational simplification and stranded cost reduction, plus reduced restructuring and repositioning charges. Organizational simplification, stranded cost reduction, and efforts to generate efficiencies throughout the businesses all contributed to a net drop of roughly 10,000 direct staff; these savings were largely canceled out by higher volume related expenses, along with investments in the transformation and other risk and controls and the civil money penalties. As the bottom of the page shows, we allocated $2.9 billion toward transformation this year, encompassing investments in our infrastructure, platforms, applications and data. Transformation investments rose 1%, fueled by growth in certain programs including data that was mostly offset by a decrease in the transformation bonus award. We also directed $11.8 billion toward technology, concentrating on digital innovation, new product development, client experience and other areas such as cybersecurity. Moving to Slide 10, we give specifics on our $2.4 trillion balance sheet, which fell 3% sequentially, mainly because of foreign exchange translation's impact. During the fourth quarter, we put some of our excess liquidity to work in loans while keeping 116% LCR and $933 billion of available liquidity resources. Our $1.3 trillion deposit base stays well diversified across regions, industries, customers and account types; we preserved strong capital, finishing the year with a preliminary 13.6% CET1 capital ratio, about 150 basis points above our regulatory capital requirement of 12.1%; throughout the year, we gave back nearly $7 billion to our shareholders through common dividends and repurchases. Now to the businesses on Slide 11. We present the results for services for the fourth quarter and full year. Services revenues climbed 15%, owing to a diminished impact of Argentina currency devaluation and reflecting ongoing momentum across security services and TTS, both of which picked up share this year. NIR grew 61%, due to a smaller impact of Argentina currency devaluation as well as sustained strength in underlying fee drivers such as U.S. dollar clearing, commercial card spend, cross border transactions, and assets under custody and administration. NII stayed roughly flat since the benefit of higher deposit volumes was offset by the impact of lower interest rates in Argentina. Expenses rose 1%, driven by ongoing investment in technology and platform modernization, partially offset by productivity savings. Cost of credit was $112 million, with a net ACL build of $84 million and net credit losses of $28 million. We saw average loans rise 5%, mostly because demand kept up for export and agency finance, along with working capital loans. Average deposits grew 4%, since growth in operating deposits is still showing up. Services produced positive operating leverage and brought in net income of $1.9 billion, plus $6.5 billion for the year, and it keeps posting a high RoTCE, landing at 29.9% and 26% for the year. Slide 12 lays out how markets performed in the fourth quarter and the full year. Markets recorded its best fourth quarter revenue in a decade, climbing 36%, with broad-based gains across every product. Fixed income revenues rose 37%, helped by rates in currencies, which were up 39%, and spread products and other fixed income, up 30%, both reflecting more client activity. Rates and currencies also gained from a favorable trading environment versus a tough prior year quarter. Credit and mortgage trading, plus higher securitization volume, drove spread products and other fixed income. Equities revenues climbed 34%, partly from strong execution of strategic client transactions in cash equities, while momentum carried on in prime, with balances up roughly 23%. Expenses fell 8%, mainly because of lower legal expenses and productivity savings.
Mark Mason
executiveFoster credit came in at $134 million, with the main driver being a net ACL build tied mostly to spread products. Loans on average rose 6%, with the primary push coming from asset-backed lending within spread products, along with margin loans in equities. Average trading account assets climbed 15%, mostly because clients wanted U.S. treasuries and foreign government securities. Markets posted yet another quarter of positive operating leverage, producing net income of $1 billion, and $4.9 billion across the year, while generating an RoTCE of 7.4% and 9.1% for the year. Turning to Slide 13, we lay out banking's results for both the fourth quarter and the full year. Banking revenues rose 27%, with investment banking as the main force, as fees climbed 35% amid growth in every product. ECM's performance came from sustained investment grade issuance momentum plus more leverage finance activity. ECM recorded strong issuance activity, notably in follow on and convertible instruments; within M&A, growth came from ongoing strong client engagement and the closing of previously announced acquisitions, helped by a more conducive macro environment; across the year, we picked up share in regions, products, and multiple sectors, among them healthcare and technology. Corporate lending revenues, excluding mark-to-market on loan hedges, fell 24%, pulled down by lower revenue share and volumes, partly offset by a smaller hit from Argentina currency devaluation. Our expenses were down 9%, largely driven by benefits we realized from reducing staff as we adjusted the size of both our workforce and our expense base, which were partially offset by costs that rose alongside higher volumes. On the cost of credit side, we saw a $240 million benefit, which came from a net ACL release of $247 million, primarily as a result of better macroeconomic conditions. In banking, we achieved positive operating leverage for a fourth quarter in a row, with net income of $356 million, and $1.5 billion across the full year, together with an RoTCE of 6.5% and 7% for the year. Turning to Slide 14, we show wealth's results for both the fourth quarter and the full year. The performance we delivered this quarter demonstrates that our strategy is generating solid progress, and we expect that momentum to continue. On the top line, we saw a 20% increase in revenues. That was supported by NIR coming in 22% higher, with investment fees up and client investment assets rising 18%, which included $16 billion of net new investment assets. NII was up 20%, helped by better average deposit spreads and higher volumes. Expenses were down 3%, reflecting the continued payoff from reducing headcount as we resized both the workforce and the expense base. Client balances at period end grew 8%, lifted by stronger client investment asset flows and market valuation. Average deposits increased 3% as relationships and related deposits moved over from USPB, though that was partly offset by deposits shifting into higher yielding investments on Citi's platform. Average loans were 1% lower, consistent with our ongoing effort to optimize capital usage. In Wealth, we posted a 21% pretax margin along with yet another quarter of positive operating leverage, producing net income of $334 million, and $1 billion across the year, while RoTCE came in at 10.1% and 7.6% for the year; Slide 15 lays out what U.S. Personal Banking achieved in the fourth quarter and for the full year. Revenues at U.S. Personal Banking climbed 6%, helped by a 5% rise in NII and reduced partner payments. Branded cards revenues rose 7%, with interest earning balances growing 7%, since payment rates keep normalizing and we keep seeing spend growth, which rose 5%. Retail services revenues grew 7%, helped by reduced partner payments and a 3% increase in interest earning balances. And retail banking revenues came in roughly flat, since the effect of higher deposit spreads was offset by the effect of moving relationships and the deposits tied to them into our wealth business. Expenses fell 2%, helped by ongoing productivity savings, partly offset by higher volume related expenses. Cost of credit reached $2.2 billion, mostly from net credit losses, plus a build largely tied to volume growth. Average deposits fell 18%, mostly from moving relationships and the deposits tied to them into our wealth business. USPB produced yet another quarter of positive operating leverage and posted net income of $392 million, and $1.4 billion across the year, while RoTCE came in at 6.2% and 5.5% for the year. On slide 16, you'll see the results for everything else — that's corporate other plus legacy franchises, and it excludes items tied to divestitures. Revenue was down 34%, driven largely by losses on net investment securities as we reposition the portfolio, along with higher funding costs and our closes, exits, and wind downs. Expenses dropped 51%, mainly because last year's FDIC special assessment and restructuring charge are no longer in the picture, and also thanks to reduced costs from the closed exits and wind down. Cost of credit came in at $397 million, consisting of $257 million in net credit losses and a $140 million net ACL build, which was mostly related to Mexico. Now let's turn to slide 18, where I'll walk you through our current expectations for 2025. Just to remind everyone, our present outlook takes into account several possible situations involving varying conditions in the broader economy and capital markets. Given what we currently understand, we're projecting revenue somewhere between about $83.5 billion and $84.5 billion, which works out to growth of approximately 3% to 4% compared with last year. We anticipate that the NIR ex-markets momentum we've observed during this year will carry forward, powered by investment banking as we continue taking market share in strategically targeted sectors including healthcare and technology, along with leverage finance and sponsors, provided the industry wallet remains favorable. Wealth, driven by an ongoing emphasis on expanding client investment assets and improving banker productivity, which will fuel investment revenue services as we carry out the plan we presented at our Investor Day in June, extending our leading position with large institutions and increasing our market share among commercial clients in TTS. And in security services, we keep gaining share by investing in our digital and data capabilities while going deeper with asset managers and asset owners. Moving to Slide 19, we anticipate NII ex-market will rise modestly this year. That said, a number of tailwinds and headwinds exist that I will take you through. Looking at the left side of the page, we expect most of that gain to be generated by growth in volume and mix, mainly from increased loan volumes in USPB — cards especially — along with deposit volumes in services. We should continue gaining from lower yielding investment securities running off and getting repriced into assets with higher yields, like cash, loans and securities. Working partly against those tailwinds are a number of headwinds, among them multiple scenarios involving lower rates in both U.S. and non-U.S. markets, which we anticipate will be largely offset through repricing actions throughout the franchise, plus the possible effect of card late fee reduction and FX. Turning to Slide 20, for 2025 we expect costs to come in just under $53.8 billion. What's behind that outlook: we keep seeing gains from simplifying how we're organized, from cutting stranded costs, and from productivity wins tied to investments we've already made. Still, those gains get mostly canceled out by more spending on the transformation, on technology, and on the businesses, plus expenses that rise along with volume.
Mark Mason
executiveOur guidance for the year includes about $600 million tied to repositioning, and that figure is still high, since we keep working to cut stranded costs, generate efficiencies throughout the businesses, and because the payoff from our transformation and technology investments lets us remove manual processes. As Jane mentioned, we know our expense base is still elevated, and we stay very focused on lowering our expenses annually, while making sure we retain sufficient capacity to put money into the company; moving now to Slide 21, I'll walk you through what we expect ahead. As we move into 2025 and look toward 2026, a clear path to better returns remains in place for us. After completing another strong planning cycle and having set revenue and expense targets for 2025, we'd like to bring you up to date on our 2026 RoTCE target range. During 2026, we anticipate that revenue will keep growing from both NII and NIR, with the drivers mostly in line with what we've seen lately; we anticipate that expenses will fall relative to 2025, and we are aiming for an expense level under $53 billion. Lower legacy and stranded costs, a more normalized amount of severance, and greater productivity savings from investments we made previously will drive the decline in our expense base. We'll keep strict discipline across the whole expense base, seeking additional chances to generate still more efficiencies, as we head into 2026. We're also staying intensely focused on further optimizing RWA, though as you're aware, what lies ahead for capital rules — and thus for requirements — is still unclear. Given all of that, we now aim for an RoTCE between 10% and 11% in 2026. We're dedicated to generating positive operating leverage and enhancing our returns annually, for the firm as well as the businesses, and we'll accomplish that in a sustainable manner, which will position this company for long-term success. With that in mind, under the $20 billion share repurchase program, our plan is to buy back $1.5 billion of common stock during the first quarter. Stepping back, 2024 marks yet another year of solid progress and a series of proof points toward better firm-wide and business performance, along with continued execution against our transformation. And as we enter 2025, those priorities stay critical, as we keep making progress on improving our returns. With that, Jane and I would be glad to take your questions.
Jim Mitchell
analystMorning, everyone. I think, as Jane mentioned, expenses appear to be a significant factor behind the lower OCC target for '26. You seem to have stepped back from the bottom end of that because of increased spending on the transformation, yet you also described it as being somewhat temporary. So, while we're grateful for the below 53 for '26, how much further is there to go when it comes to removing parallel running systems, cutting consultant costs, and all of that? Does a path still exist to an efficiency ratio of 60% or less?
Jane Fraser
executiveWell, Happy New Year, Jim. I realize you'd like to discuss the guidance, so allow me to frame it properly. During the past year, you've heard me state very plainly what our two priorities are. The first is driving business performance, and the second is executing the transformation. You've watched this quarter, the prior quarter, and the entire year — our businesses are producing the progress we intended. The strategy is succeeding. We altered the business mix, and we're bringing in more fee based revenues. You can see that in services, where NIR rose 37% this year, wealth NIR climbed 15%, and IBCs increased 35% — a key element of the mix regarding the quality of our earnings. We described services as a crown jewel. It has produced growth and high returns, and it has gained share; it is a crown jewel. We put together a solid strategic plan, and you've observed us steadily demonstrate why we can be a force globally, with a clear route to delivering the financial performance we promised. We've reliably met our revenue and expense targets; and I perceive far more opportunity and additional upside to reinforce our business performance; we're pursuing it in very tangible ways. It excites us quite a bit. The second priority is transformation. I have to say, I'm generally satisfied with the headway we've achieved in risk and compliance and accountability. I'm enthusiastic about the work currently underway in controls for the business too. We've been extremely transparent. Data was an area where more work remains for us. Last year, as you're aware, and then during the annual planning process, we paused significantly to re-evaluate our plan; and together with Mark and the management team, I concluded that we needed to broaden the scope and speed up certain work to meet our regulators' expectations. I'm certain that choosing to do so was the correct call; it's the right call for our transformation efforts; it is definitely the right call for the firm as a whole. I could have made a short term choice to trim other investments that matter for our long term investment and competitiveness. I'm simply not going to do that. You shouldn't want me to do that. As I mentioned at the start, hitting that ’26 goal marks a stop along the route, not where we ultimately intend to end up.
Mark Mason
executiveAnd I might be able to add something there.
Jim Mitchell
analystGo ahead, Mark.
Mark Mason
executiveAll right, thank you. Jim, I'd like to speak to the latter portion of what you asked, specifically the route toward getting below 60%. Jane, I believe, described it rather well: what we're constructing is a franchise with top line revenue momentum that continues and is sustainable; our attention is on eliminating inefficiencies, stranded cost, and legacy franchise expenses throughout the organization, and the gains from the investments we've made in transformation are going to produce a reduced cost structure as time goes on; putting all of that together should bring us to that operating efficiency target as we exit 2026, at below 60%; so indeed, a path remains, and our attention is fixed on it.
Jim Mitchell
analystAll right, excellent. That's quite useful. So now perhaps shifting over to the pace of repurchases and that $20 billion authorization. Clearly, one has to inquire about what comes after 1Q. Should we perhaps gain greater clarity, possibly no bump in capital requirements, would that begin to assist you in maybe at least for a period reducing the buffer so you can capitalize on shares trading beneath tangible book, capturing the accretion and speeding up the buyback? Alternatively, how are you viewing the remainder of the year regarding repurchases?
Mark Mason
executiveWell, I'll offer a few remarks. First, announcing the $20 billion buyback program brings us a great deal of satisfaction. In numerous respects, that serves as evidence, so to speak, of our ongoing assurance regarding earnings production and the momentum surrounding it, along with acknowledging that our shares trade under book value and that isn't the position we wish to occupy. Both Jane and I have spoken about how vital it is to expand and do additional buybacks. That figure now stands at $1.5 billion. I believe that reinforces the very same level of assurance we hold concerning the momentum. Each year, through our annual planning cycle, we continually examine the management buffer of 100 basis points that we maintain. Even though the past few quarters saw us operating above 13.1%, our objective remains 13.1%. Thus, as we progress — as we move through the remainder of the year and obtain clarity on regulatory rules and such, you'll observe us staying on course toward 13.1%. Naturally, two key elements or drivers we always bear in mind are the chance to put more money into the business at returns that are accretive, along with where our shares are trading, plus the necessity of conducting additional buybacks so as to mirror the fundamental value. So the goal is 13.1%, we keep watching that management buffer as the regulatory landscape shifts, and we'll keep pursuing further capital actions whenever that is sensible.
John McDonald
analystThanks. Mark, I just wanted to build on what you told Jim there; so regarding that 10% to 11% RoTCE goal for 2026, does it kind of presume you'll be near the target, or is it more like you're treating 13.1% as the target and then over a longer horizon you're hoping to lower that target as the rules become clearer and the franchise gets simpler?
Mark Mason
executiveJohn, good to hear from you. In fact, yes, that 10% to 11% RoTCE goal we've set for '26 does presume that we are running and using a 13.1% CET1 ratio. Obviously, there will be an SCB that comes out sometime later this year. The rules are continuing to evolve and what have you and we'll factor those in, as we know more about them. But yes, it does presume the 13.1% which is our management target, if you will, for CET1.
John McDonald
analystAll right, that's helpful. Then for my follow-up, can you make clear what you anticipate for card net charge-offs during this year? I realize there's a seasonal pattern quarter to quarter, yet across the whole year you expect charge-offs to land within the guidance range you gave last year. Could you shed some light on that, and perhaps also address provision build, which was substantial in 2024, and whether it might ease as balance maturation decelerates?
Mark Mason
executiveCertainly. Regarding net credit losses and our forecast, our expectation is that net credit losses will sit at the upper end of the range we provided; for branded cards, 3.5% to 4% is the full-year range we gave. For retail services, it's 5.75% to 6.25%, pardon me. So at present, retail services sits at that upper end, 6.28% for 2024. We would anticipate it remaining at that upper end, though I apologize; then for branded cards, we're at 3.64% and we would anticipate a gradual rise to roughly the 4% mark across the year. But for the full year, the NCL rate—and we recognize seasonality exists across quarters. Thus you'll observe shifts from quarter to quarter driven by that pattern. Then concerning provision build, a few factors are at play. One clearly is volume, and we do anticipate volume growth in USPB; that will be a significant element in how CECL calculations get made. The second factor is clearly that as we run models—and these models include a base scenario plus downside and upside scenarios tied to broader macro factors, unemployment, GDP, and so on—and lean toward the likelihood of an upside or downside scenario; those elements turn into key considerations within provisioning. That's our thinking as we head into 2025. I hope that's useful.
Mike Mayo
analystHello. I just want to get one thing straight. Your guidance covers a trio of back-to-back years where costs decline, and that includes the $600 million repositioning during this year. Those costs fell in ‘24, and you're steering them downward for ‘25, then downward once more for ‘26. On top of that, based on your remarks, you're projecting a trio of back-to-back years with rising revenues. That part wasn't in the written materials, but Mark, I believe I caught you saying it. So that's a trio of years with reduced costs and a trio of years with increased revenues, extending through at least 26%. Do I have that right?
Mark Mason
executiveNo. What I'd say is that your description captures it well — momentum keeps building on the top line, and our attention stays on pushing costs lower, exactly as we managed in '24, slightly in '25, and by a larger amount in '26.
Mike Mayo
analystAlright, I think this question is for Jane. Pulling that off would be even more impressive than haggis on toast, but I keep wondering why the efficiency can't improve further. Let's say you have $5 billion in stranded costs along with transformation costs in 2024, and some of that decreases — I realize you're investing in technology, transformation, volume, and the businesses, and there's always a tension between the bottom-line results you're showing today and the growth you'll show later on. It seems like you're going to get there with the lower expenses, so why favor a little more growth? Please speak to that tension and explain where you're leaning in for growth a bit more.
Jane Fraser
executiveFirst off, Jane Fraser here — I have to say, that haggis on toast comment kind of unsettles me. Let's be clear: haggis belongs with mashed potatoes and whiskey. Robert Burns night is just around the corner, after all. Now, on the topic of expenses — Mike, and everybody — this isn't just something Mark and I care about; the entire management team is concentrated on it. We're making sure that kind of focus and discipline becomes part of Citi's DNA for good. And as you pointed out, you've seen it happen. These past two years, we've hit the expense guidance we set. We've been generating positive operating efficiency, and each of us is intensely committed to strengthening our operating expense base. When it comes to pulling our technology together, streamlining operations, bringing in automation, and having unified systems instead of scattered ones throughout the company—plus leveraging AI tools and our approach to locations—we're taking a real look at that core operating expense base. How do we become more efficient, more modern, and bring it to the right level for the revenues we bring in? Everyone wants transformation to happen fast and to happen correctly. That's the reason our costs are temporarily higher right now—to fund the investments required. This isn't all run rate. Like you mentioned, in my role as chief executive, I won't give up the proper long-term bets on expanding and staying competitive just to gain a quick advantage — what we're seeing here marks a stop along the way rather than the end point, and we understand exactly what has to get done. We have a firm grip on all of it when it comes to carrying things out.
Betsy Graseck
analystHello, and good morning. Jane, I wanted to build on what you just said. Once you actually deliver on that execution, everyone here — or at least I do — anticipates that the market is going to reward you for it, which means the multiple ought to rise. I have a handful of questions about the buyback, and I'm feeling a bit puzzled, because as we're all aware, right now, today, your stock trades below book value. Under those conditions, repurchasing shares simply has to be the most accretive way to deploy capital at this moment. So why hold off on the buyback instead of pressing harder right now while still keeping your 2026 guidance? The prior guide, after all, was 11% to 12% RoTCE, and the new one is 10% to 11%. It's a little confusing to me why you wouldn't pull that lever with more force, since buying back stock — the accretion it delivers to tangible book — has to be the simplest route to pushing that RoTCE higher, especially when you weigh it against all the difficult work you've been putting in, which will clearly matter a great deal for lifting the RoTCE. But why not press harder on that buyback? And could you give us some sense of when that $20 billion will be deployed?
Jane Fraser
executiveYes. Betsy, I appreciate the passion. I have to tell you, your voice carries real determination. I believe that's the very same determination all of us share. Look, returning capital to shareholders is something we're deeply committed to, full stop. We have a $20 billion buyback program. As Mark indicated, that program mirrors the expanding earnings power we possess and the confidence we hold about the road ahead. Over the past few quarters we've been raising the pace of capital return, and I'm also glad to see a more aggressive Basel III scenario now clearly off the table. Even so, we've included a 13.1% CET ratio in the plan, and that figure can shift with time too. Still, there isn't total certainty regarding where capital requirements will ultimately land. Our hope is for a holistic approach that reflects the bank's risk profile, which has been improving substantially across the past few years. So we do have some excellent growth opportunities. When I look across the various areas, what we're seeing in wealth excites me. We have a strong runway with clients who wish to do business with us in banking; we also have some very significant investments and an investment agenda we're undertaking to help us keep growing the bank and build competitiveness in a responsible manner. Let me finish by echoing precisely your point. The bar for those investments is set high, correct? We won't make them unless we see exceptionally attractive marginal RoTCE, and there are plenty of things we turn down in order to establish that $20 billion program. As for timing, we — like our peers — aren't locking ourselves into any specific timeframe on this, but our commitment is plain to see. Our dedication comes through loud and clear.
Ebrahim Poonawala
analystMorning, and thanks for taking the question. Jane, maybe I can dig into a couple of the business lines. I think your comment was that this year, 2024, marks a pivot point for wealth, and you've seen fairly steady gains in RoTCE in that division. Could you take us through it — a year has passed since you took on the role, you've watched things move forward, so what remains to be done? Shed some light on where the franchise stands competitively, in the U.S. as well as abroad, given that you're thinking about competing directly with certain global peers, and tell us which areas look like the likeliest sources of growth over the coming one to two years?
Jane Fraser
executiveAbsolutely — my goal is for us to be a top-tier player worldwide when it comes to wealth management. Few companies can match Citi's global footprint; we hold the necessary resources, particularly client connections spanning the entire world, that we simply hadn't leveraged for investment purposes previously. This represents a substantial opening. Existing clients have $5.3 trillion sitting with us. What I find particularly compelling is that 55% of that — nearly $3 trillion — belongs to affluent clients within our U.S. branch network. We're also in a strong position to bring in newly created wealth. Consider simply how Citi's geographic reach and what we're able to deliver genuinely underpin building wealth — whether that's through the commercial bank, on the investment banking side, or obviously with markets providing servicing as well. All of these serve as excellent channels for us to deepen the wealth connections we hold with our clients. Turning to Andy for the report. Andy has significantly concentrated our attention on the investment business. That's precisely where we identify substantial opportunity. He's been developing a distinctive value proposition centered on wealth creation. He's been drawing on numerous top-tier capital market strengths, the various ties we maintain with private equity firms and asset managers globally, putting a strong platform in place; and crucially, enhancing how our clients experience things, once more especially regarding investments and asset allocation, performance, and so on. Another thing I really appreciate is how precisely he's tackling costs and boosting efficiency — an effort happening throughout the entire company. I'm also enthusiastic about the people he's recruiting. Take market leaders such as Kate Moore and Keith Glenfield on the investment side. Plus, we've put substantial resources into training and cultivating an investment culture that previously didn't exist here. So, as you suggested, those proof points are indeed delivering results. In the fourth quarter, our revenue grew by 20%. Our operating margin stands at 21%, and we're targeting somewhere between 25% and 30%. Return on tangible common equity is currently 10%, with a goal of reaching 15% to 20%. Over these recent quarters, you've watched us progress along that path in March, and what excites me most is net new investment asset inflow totaling $42 billion, which represents a 40% increase compared to the same period last year. Our strategy is delivering results. We intend to become a leader in wealth, and the growth opportunities lie in Asia, the U.S., the Middle East — everywhere we already serve our current clients as well as the emerging wealth creators of tomorrow.
Ebrahim Poonawala
analystCould I make a comparison with the segment where RoTCE has been roughly 5% to 6% over the last few quarters — that's where you brought in a Vivek Agarwal from JPMorgan. Just help us understand whether we might see a comparable path in that business across the coming 12 months, and where the chances lie to boost their ROE?
Jane Fraser
executiveYes. Without question, our performance has been strong, and the strategy we've put in place is paying off well. Looking at revenues, investment banking fees, positive operating leverage throughout the year, plus share gains across all three products, in every geography where we operate. It makes me genuinely excited and pleased to watch healthcare and technology, the two areas where we've invested so heavily. You're also seeing us take a leading role in certain key transactions, the largest deals of last year — Mars, Kellanova, as sole advisor, a significant part in Boeing, and then only this week, the J&J acquisition of Intra-Cellular. Those are the deals that matter, where we play a leading role. So when this individual came aboard, the mandate was somewhat like Andy's: turn into a top three investment bank, and deliver the full potential of One Citi to our clients. There's plenty of upside for us there — instilling further discipline around capital allocation, client coverage, and some of the cross-firm linkages. Our people are giving us much more; we've been adding excellent new talent; we've also been trimming some of the unproductive spend. What I think you can observe is that we're simply on a course of methodically expanding our wallet. We'll be lifting our operating margin, producing greater returns — that ought to be your expectation for what you'll see from us over the next couple of years. As we move into a great environment in 2025, it should be quite favorable for plenty of client activity. I have real confidence that we've got the — that we're positioned well. The groundwork is finished, so we can capitalize on it.
Mark Mason
executiveI believe you mentioned a return on tangible common equity of 5%. For the entire year, banking actually came in at 7%, and it's progressing toward the mid-teens objective we've established for our banking segment.
Erika Najarian
analystThank you. I really don't want to raise <<inaudible>> about the repurchase program, yet given how the shares are moving today, it's obvious that buybacks matter a great deal to your investors. So my first question — and I'd like to squeeze in two if possible — is this: there's no doubt you intend to give money back to owners; there's no doubt you're sitting on surplus capital; and there's no doubt your PPNR trend is heading upward. So which exact milestones does Citi need to hit before you'd raise that quarterly figure beyond $1.5 billion toward a level that better matches the pace implied by that $20 billion authorization? I realize you've been asked this before, but is the consent order the gating item? Is it the stress test? Over the holidays we got some sector-positive news. What precisely are those milestones? After all, you're already delivering on the PPNR front, correct? What would you need to see to become even more confident — to borrow Betsy's phrasing — about going all in on the buyback?
Mark Mason
executiveYes. Thanks for asking. Let me clarify a few things. First, and I've mentioned this before, so forgive me for saying it again: our CET1 goal stands at 13.1%, correct? So across this year, you'll watch us bring that ratio down toward the target. That's point one. Point two, I want to be clear it isn't the consent order. That item does not drive the capital actions and choices we make; naturally, we project future performance. As I've noted, and as Jane has noted, we observe quite robust ongoing earnings momentum. I'm steering toward a 13.1% CET1 ratio, and the buyback path will mirror that decline toward the CET1 target. One more thing worth flagging, and you brought it up: clearly we face yet another CCAR stress-test cycle ahead. Nobody can foresee what emerges from it regarding the SCB, yet that will play a major role as we move through the first half of the year and into the second half of the year when it comes to how large our repurchases are each quarter. Hopefully that answers it. There aren't any artificial constraints, so to speak, sitting in the way; this is simply us planning and projecting how the franchise will perform, making sure we can fund high-returning growth opportunities so the franchise stays sustainable, weighing our capital requirements and the management buffer we maintain, and then directing that surplus capacity into buybacks — while keeping one eye on the regulatory landscape we operate within. Also, what does that imply for the capital requirements that result from the yearly stress testing exercise that gets conducted? So that's essentially the situation as things stand right now.
Erika Najarian
analystUnderstood. For my second question, thinking ahead to 2026 — and I really don't want to attribute opinions to you, since this clearly matters a great deal for your targets and whether you reach them. You set a goal of under $53 billion. Should we take it, similar to what Jim asked, that the range of $51 billion to $53 billion isn't the objective, but rather anything below $53 billion? With that said, stepping back for a moment, Jane, I believe you made a point of real significance — that you're aiming to achieve those returns in a way that lasts. And it's obvious your shareholders carry scars from the prior management team, when returns climbed into double digits only to come crashing back down, proving unsustainable. So should we simply frame this as: turning around a money center bank takes time, and maybe 2026 was the goal back in 2022, but we'll arrive there in '27 or '28 regardless, and we're just pursuing it sustainably, without stripping the bank of investments. I suppose I'm trying to work through the fact that everyone is intensely focused on what you previously stated, and now your targets differ — but is it really just a matter of: it simply takes longer, we'll get there, it just takes longer? And perhaps as a follow-up to that, what should we anticipate from Banamex in terms of how it affects that 10% to 11% RoTCE — both the immediate effect following the IPO and then once you put to work the excess capital you receive back?
Jane Fraser
executiveErica, we picked our phrasing deliberately when we said ‘26 is a waypoint, it's not the destination. When I look toward ‘27 and ‘28, I consider what kind of bank we want to be — across our strategy, our performance, our culture, all those various dimensions — and we simply keep pushing relentlessly along that path, though we'll make the right and responsible choices along the way; so our potential exceeds our medium-term target RoTCE. The Bank's potential, and the journey we're on, is to lift our returns past that point, without question. Then you raised a question regarding Banamex. On that topic, look, we had a single-minded focus on separating the two banks. That represented an enormous amount of work, since we had to stand up Mexico's eighth largest bank, de novo, within a very short window; it was completed December 1st; that involved over 100 regulatory approvals to accomplish. Now our full attention has shifted to the IPO; we're preparing so we can IPO as soon as possible. Yet depending on how the market looks and how approvals from regulators come through, there's a chance it slips into '26. Even so, whatever sits within our control, we're pushing on to be prepared at the earliest point we can. Holding on to the Bank isn't right for us as its owner. Our dedication to making Citi simpler stands. A responsible path is what we'll take in this matter.
Mark Mason
executiveRegarding the effects and the schedule Jane mentioned, please remember that leaving Banamex produces financial consequences in a pair of ways. The first is the gain or loss when selling, and the second is the release of risk weighted assets. At deconsolidation, the gain or loss from the sale will move through the P&L. That marks the moment we have either obtained or IPO-ed beyond 50%. And once we completely divest our stake, the RWA release will determine the eventual benefit. So, I hope that clarifies things, but only after we have deconsolidated do we observe that P&L effect, along with the CTA and similar items that sort of pass through the P&L for Banamex.
Gerard Cassidy
analystJane, I'm going to skip the — although I will accept that whiskey.
Jane Fraser
executiveJust so we're clear, I never offered to pay.
Gerard Cassidy
analystAll right, understood. That's our side's expense report. Moving on, Mark, to build on what you said regarding the Banamex IPO, could you remind everyone or jog our recollection about when that IPO process kicks off, and once it's public, what share of ownership do you anticipate holding? Also, the second thing: have you provided any indication whether this deal will produce a gain or a loss, since, as you just noted, it will run through the P&L?
Mark Mason
executiveYes. No sense of the precise timing has been provided by us. This is a process, as you're aware. So Jane just addressed the timing of that process, with the separation being the initial step, completed on December 1st. Now, clearly, we're preparing and getting ourselves ready for the IPO. Important filings will clearly come with that, since we intend to dual list. Regulatory approvals will be needed, sort of, as we progress with prospective investors through the IPO process; so a series of IPO steps will have to be taken by us across the year so we can keep getting ourselves ready. Certain things are outside our control, such as, as Jane said, the regulatory approval process and its timing, plus market conditions. So all those factors matter, and then how the IPO unfolds regarding the percentage taken in that first tranche versus follow-on tranches matters for when deconsolidation occurs. So an exact timing hasn't been given by me, but you can picture 15% sort of tranches occurring across a 12, 18-month, 24-month span. And then clearly arriving at a deconsolidation point, whereupon that currency translation adjustment begins flowing through the P&L. Capital sees no material impact, yet it does flow through the P&L and then eventually we do over time; so I apologize for not providing precise dates and percentages, and that's partly because we're clearly at the early stage of not just getting ourselves ready, but weighing alternative IPO structures and prospective investors/shareholders within that process.
Gerard Cassidy
analystAlright, I value those perspectives. Now for my next question — and truly, I'm not trying to ask a "what have you done for me lately" kind of thing, since you all have achieved a great deal with the strategic shifts you're making. That said, could you discuss U.S. Personal Banking? A lot of what's come up today concerns the consolidated RoTCE and ways to boost it. As you're both aware, this unit generates a very low RoTCE, below your cost of capital, and if you examine it structurally, looking at period-end loans of just over $220 billion alongside roughly $90 billion in deposits, that's a fairly different picture from competitors who enjoy considerably higher ROEs. So what's your strategy for this business? And once more, I realize you've been quite occupied shedding many operations that aren't core, yet from my view this looks like a massive obstacle you'll need to tackle before too long?
Jane Fraser
executiveLet me walk through this a little. So what does the route toward strong returns in U.S. Personal Banking look like? It stems from growing top line revenue, a better expense base, plus a credit environment that's more normalized; together, that brings us to mid to high-teen returns over the medium term. I believe we're quite confident and at ease with that. The evidence is there for you to see — I mentioned banking wealth before. We've posted yet another solid quarter of revenue growth; that marks our ninth straight quarter of operating leverage. So I think that ought to give you some reassurance. What will fuel that expansion? Co-brands — we recently renewed with American to remain their exclusive issuer. This will deliver thrilling advantages for American Airlines and Citi cardholders alike, and it should help both our growth and our returns; on the proprietary side, we're putting money in. Considerable investment goes into innovation to propel growth; so with the relaunch of the Premier card, we've kept upgrading the rewards we offer, and you're now frequently seeing us ranked first in recognition and awards in that space. Retail Services is laser-focused on bettering partnership economics and pushing top line growth; then in retail banking, we're focused on growing primary checking. We introduced simplified banking, giving us a far more streamlined customer proposition that encourages a relationship-driven banking model rather than a transactional one. Another key point — the retail bank has been supplying our Wealth business. You heard me mention earlier that we have close to $3 trillion in off-us investment opportunity coming from the retail banking customer base. We shifted $17 billion in deposits from USPB over to wealth. So those dynamics need to be factored in. So, I hope that's what you take away from me. I'm confident that we can reach the medium-term goals we established for the business, which are mid-to-high teens. I'm at ease with the growth path we have, given the innovations we're rolling out, the shifts we're making, solid cost control, and an improved credit climate. So as you examine how our business is composed, you'll notice that we're doing well here.
Matt O'Connor
analystHi there. I'd like to build on what was discussed regarding Page 9, where the breakdown of spending on technology and transformation investments appears. Apologies in case I overlooked it, but when you provided expense guidance for '25 and '26, did you address how quickly those two areas will ramp? Directionally, you indicated an increase, I realize, but was any magnitude given?
Mark Mason
executiveNo, I didn't provide that. Clearly, when it comes to both technology and transformation, these are spaces where investment will keep happening, for every reason we've already laid out; they certainly play into the figure for '25 coming in a bit below 53.8%; yet they likewise reflect, as I noted, what we think is necessary in order to accomplish the work that must be accomplished. So those figures are going to rise. As you're aware, an annual expense forecast involves plenty of puts-and-takes, among them, as you'd anticipate, volume — we have revenue growth coming that will bring volume growth along with it. Volume incentive comp, plus merit increases tied to that, and beyond that we have a set of productivity measures working through to counterbalance those headwinds, be it the extra carryover from org simplification and its full year effect, or a portion of the legacy stranded costs declining. So puts-and-takes exist, yet with transformation and technology in particular, our investment continues so we can deliver what must be delivered here and also make sure the businesses possess what they require to fuel sustainable growth down the road.
Matt O'Connor
analystSo, how can you tell that the latest bump you're factoring into your internal models for these areas is right? What makes you certain you're putting in enough money, and doing it the right way, to hit your transformation targets and also meet what regulators require?
Jane Fraser
executiveLet me take that one. I have a lot of confidence that we understand exactly what has to be done, and we understand exactly where the money has to go, thanks to the yearly planning cycle that wrapped up a month ago; it was obvious that more investment was necessary. On the data side, we widened the scope of certain pieces of the work. We pulled some other work ahead. We examined what was required on the technology side, along with some of the key investments. This is quite detailed, almost forensic. And when we look at transformation, when we look at technology, we understand what our target states have to look like, we understand the steps required to reach them, and the outcomes those steps have to produce; so we have a handle on all of it, and I believe what you're picking up from us is that confidence — that we understand what has to be done, we understand which investments have to be made, and we understand what the outcomes and the benefits must be, both for shareholders and on the regulatory front.
Saul Martinez
analystHi there, and thanks for fielding my questions. Mark, regarding that NII ex-markets guidance, annualizing the fourth quarter alone lands us at roughly $47.4 billion to $47.5 billion, if I'm doing the math right — that's actually higher than where we ended up for the full year '24. When you say "up modestly," I'm not certain whether that translates to 1%, 3%, or 4%, so please set me straight if I've got this wrong, but it feels like there might be some conservatism baked in there. That said, could you weigh in on how we ought to be modeling the quarterly path for NII ex-market? Clearly day count plays a role in 1Q, but how would you suggest we think about how that NII progresses as the year unfolds?
Mark Mason
executiveYeah, let me just get right to the point on that, Saul — when I say up modestly, think roughly a couple of percentage points, somewhere in the 2 to 3 percentage point range, that's how I frame it. I believe I already walked everyone through both the tailwinds and the headwinds, so I won't repeat all of that, but the key thing to take away is this: we'll keep seeing momentum build across the franchise, powered by loan growth within the branded card business and ongoing deposit momentum, especially in operating deposits and services. On top of that, we'll keep doing all the things we always do when it comes to pricing management, and we'll pick up a benefit from how we've been handling our investment portfolio as those positions mature. Together, those efforts will more than offset the headwinds you'd anticipate in an environment of declining rates — and when I say modestly, let's call it 2% to 3%.
Saul Martinez
analystAlright, that's reasonable. Then regarding the expense outlook reaching under 53% by 2026 — I realize this matches your prior guidance, yet it suggests quite a significant drop in '26, particularly given that revenue keeps growing. That's substantial operating leverage. So how much relief comes from severance returning to a more typical level? Put differently, by how much do we expect severance to decline? How should we think about the effect of legacy stranded costs shrinking? Could you give us a bit more detail on how much these items will help '26 compared with '25?
Mark Mason
executiveSure. Well, several points. When I examine our severance expenses, which as I noted have stayed elevated at 700, we're projecting 600 for 2025. I'd say a normal level across the cycle is roughly 300 or thereabouts. That should give you an idea. Another point: on the other page — and again, there were multiple drivers or levers we plan to use to lower that figure — but on the all other page, looking to the right, we display wind downs and what's left of legacy franchise. Adding those figures yields about $1.9 billion in expenses, and a portion of that can be considered stranded. We'll keep concentrating on reducing stranded cost over the coming couple of years. So those represent two key factors or contributors behind the decrease from just under 53.8% to 53%. There are also further productivity savings from investments we made previously, and those matter too. Then, regarding transformation spend, that will keep contributing or begin delivering returns, or help lower cost as well. So really, those four variables drive us toward bringing that number down. And as Jane said, even beyond '26 we'll keep generating or eliminating additional inefficiencies throughout the organization to fund necessary investments for business growth, all while maintaining our focus on reaching under 60% — as we exit 2026, under 60% operating efficiency.
Mike Mayo
analystHi. So this is the first complete year with the five-line-of-business setup. Mark, are those same line-of-business goals from a year ago still in place? And Jane, given everything — it had to have been somewhat of a nightmare to arrange things this way, removing your two intercompany holding companies, cutting five management layers, widening the span of control. You all endured quite a bit last year. I'm curious whether the worst is behind you regarding that internal reorganization, plus the culture, the sentiment, and how you expect that to carry forward. But first, a specific question about the targets, please.
Mark Mason
executiveI suppose I'll go first. On the targets, look, we established goals for each line of business over the medium term. We've clearly reduced the 2026 figure to 10% to 11%. So you'd figure there's at least some shift for 2026 when it comes to those goals. Banking will probably come in somewhat below the mid-15% if I consider 2026 as that medium-term target date. Yet eventually, I expect that the goals I've set are the ones we will hit and even surpass, since as Jane noted, 10% to 11%, while that's our 2026 target, is not our longer-term target, when we think about RoTCE and the strength of these businesses across the aggregate franchise. Hopefully, that addresses your question.
Jane Fraser
executiveRegarding organizational streamlining and culture, the finest days are definitely still to come. The organization has been through quite a lot. I feel a great deal of pride in the way people reacted, and I believe we take real pride in how every one of the lines of business is pushing business performance ahead. The bank has become less complex. For me, there is enormous transparency. There is far closer proximity to the businesses at this point, and you can observe the advantages we are beginning to capture from the strategy as we move nearer and nearer to the RoTCE targets and past them for each of the businesses. So having '24 behind us is something I'm glad about. What we accomplished in 2024 makes me proud. Every bit of attention is directed at what lies ahead.
Jenn Landis
executiveWe appreciate you all. Should anything else come to mind afterward, feel free to reach out by phone or send an email. Enjoy the rest of your day. Thanks so much.
Operator
operatorThis concludes the Citi's fourth quarter 2024 earnings call. You may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Citigroup Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Citigroup Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Citigroup Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.