Citigroup Inc. (C) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 14, 2025
What were the key takeaways from Citigroup Inc.'s October 14, 2025 earnings call?
In the third quarter of 2025, Citigroup Inc. reported a net income of $3.8 billion and earnings per share (EPS) of $1.86, reflecting a solid performance despite a goodwill impairment from the Banamex transaction. Revenues increased by 9% year-over-year, driven by strong growth across all business segments. Management raised full-year revenue guidance to exceed $84 billion, indicating confidence in continued momentum, although they expect a sequential decline in market revenues in Q4. Adjusted EPS, excluding the impairment, was reported at $2.24, with an adjusted return on tangible common equity (ROTCE) of 9.7%.
What topics did Citigroup Inc. cover?
- Revenue Growth Across All Segments: Citigroup experienced a 9% increase in revenues, with all business segments achieving record third-quarter revenues. Management noted, "every business had record third quarter revenue and improved returns."
- Banamex Transaction Progress: The agreement to purchase a 25% equity stake in Banamex is a significant step towards deconsolidation. CEO Jane Fraser stated, "this transaction and subsequent IPO is going to maximize value for our shareholders."
- Capital Return Commitment: Citigroup returned over $6 billion to shareholders, including $5 billion in share repurchases, exceeding prior guidance. Management emphasized their commitment to returning capital, stating, "we are disciplined stewards of our shareholders' capital."
- Investment in Technology and AI: Management highlighted ongoing investments in technology and AI, which are expected to drive efficiencies and enhance client service. Fraser mentioned, "we are committed to embedding AI into how we work."
- Forward Guidance Adjustments: Management raised revenue guidance for the full year to exceed $84 billion, reflecting strong year-to-date performance. However, they cautioned about a potential sequential decline in market revenues, indicating a more cautious outlook for Q4.
What were Citigroup Inc.'s October 14, 2025 results?
- Net Income: $3.8B (vs $3.5B est, +10% YoY)
- Earnings Per Share (EPS): $1.86 (vs $1.74 est, +7% YoY)
- Adjusted EPS: $2.24 (excludes goodwill impairment, +12% YoY)
- Total Revenues: $22.1B (vs $20.2B est, +9% YoY)
- Return on Tangible Common Equity (ROTCE): 9.7% (adjusted basis, +0.5% YoY)
- Capital Returned to Shareholders: $6B (includes $5B in share repurchases, exceeding guidance)
Citigroup's strong performance in Q3 2025 positions it well for continued growth, but analysts are cautious about external economic factors that could impact credit quality and revenue sustainability. Key catalysts to watch include the successful execution of the Banamex divestiture and ongoing investments in technology and AI to drive future efficiencies.
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jen Landis
executiveThanks, operator. Morning, everyone, and I appreciate all of you being on this Third Quarter 2025 Earnings Call. With me here are Jane Fraser, our Chief Executive Officer, and Mark Mason, our Chief Financial Officer. Please note that the presentation today, downloadable from our site, citigroup.com, could include forward-looking statements grounded in what management currently anticipates, and those are exposed to uncertainty plus shifts in circumstances. A range of factors, among them the ones outlined in our earnings materials and in our SEC filings, could cause actual results to vary materially from those statements. So, Jane, over to you.
Jane Fraser
executiveThanks, Jen, and good morning, everyone. Today we announced yet another strong quarter, featuring net income of $3.8 billion along with earnings per share of $1.86, and an ROTCE of 8%. If you set aside the goodwill impairment tied to the Banamex transaction, adjusted EPS came to $2.24, while adjusted ROTC stood at 9.7%. Revenue climbed 9%, and each of our businesses posted a record third quarter for revenue as well as better returns. We keep producing positive operating leverage for the whole firm and across all 5 of our businesses. These steady, strong results stem from the way we have fundamentally reshaped the bank over recent years. We operate the businesses differently and seize the synergies among them. We've brought in new senior leaders to supplement the outstanding talent already on hand. As disciplined stewards of shareholder capital, we invest it where appropriate and return whatever we don't deploy. Best of all, plenty more upside lies ahead. Now to the businesses. Services delivered a record quarter, with revenues rising 7%. Growth in cross-border transactions and U.S. dollar clearing was easy, reflecting the intense focus we've placed on boosting fee revenue. AUCA rose 13%, hitting almost $30 trillion. Fresh client wins and share gains show how much confidence our clients place in our capacity to guide them through a highly dynamic global environment and to lead via innovation. Even with low volatility, markets had a record third quarter. Revenues increased 15% as we keep building momentum and traction with clients. Rates activity was especially strong, and equities expanded nicely, with ongoing progress in prime, where balances rose more than 40%, adding to our long-standing strength in derivatives. Within Banking, greater clarity on tariffs plus record equity prices fueled CEO confidence. We took advantage of that, with investment banking fees climbing 17% and continued growth across every product. Thanks to our investment in talent, we strengthened our position in tech, health care, consumer and responses. We keep bringing talent onto the team, which will help us deepen or establish relationships that should bear fruit over the next 2 to 3 years. Wealth had another solid quarter, with revenue up 8%, powered by Citigold and the Private Bank. Our focus on growing investment assets produced record net new investment assets of $18.6 billion, while client investment assets rose 14%. We unveiled a new partnership with BlackRock, under which they will manage $80 billion of our client assets, fully aligning with an open architecture strategy. USPB generated record quarterly revenue of $5.3 billion, marking 12 straight quarters of positive operating leverage and delivering an ROTCE above 14%. We built momentum in branded cards with the well-received launch of our Citi Strata Elite card. And this quarter, we'll roll out a new mid-tier product to complete the Citi Advantage portfolio. It will reinvent the travel experience for American Airlines' customers and open access to premium benefits. Within our retail banking division, we keep pushing forward with new offerings, such as rolling out Instant Payments via FedNow and making digital issuance available for Citibank debit cards. The retail bank also keeps getting stronger as a feeder into our wealth operation, with $4 billion in deposits moved over during the quarter. Wealth is making the most of those transfers, and we keep witnessing better investment penetration along with much greater revenue tied to investments from those clients; we gave back more than $6 billion in capital to our common shareholders in the third quarter, consisting of $5 billion in share buybacks, which was $1 billion above what we had guided, and that shows how dedicated we are to returning capital. So far this year, we have bought back $8.75 billion of shares under our $20 billion repurchase program. We closed the quarter with a common equity Tier 1 capital ratio of 13.2%, which is more than 100 bps above the regulatory requirement we faced at quarter end. The deal with Fernando Chico Pardo to acquire a 25% equity stake marks a highly important move toward divesting Banamex and moves the broader timeline forward toward deconsolidation and past it. We feel certain this route serves the best interests of our stakeholders when it comes to certainty and value, and we are extremely happy to have Fernando as our partner, given his proven track record for investors. As we streamline, we keep putting money into technology to drive our transformation and turn into a more nimble, modern bank. Our execution has been tireless, and it is producing results. More than 2/3 of our transformation programs have reached or are near our target stage, and we are seeing really solid progress in the other areas. I am especially happy about how our controls have improved this year by standardizing, automating and digitizing them; we remain a leader in digital payments innovation, allowing payments, clearing and settlement capabilities to run on an always-on basis across numerous borders and currencies. As networks move toward an always-on future, we are taking the next step by connecting Citi Token Services with our 24/7 clearing platform. This integration will let Citi clients send funds seamlessly to third-party banks in real time within our U.S. dollar tiering network, and that delivers genuine interoperability across more than 250 institutions. We are dedicated to embedding AI into the way we operate. Almost 180,000 colleagues across 83 countries now can access our proprietary AI tools and have used them close to 7 million times this year. These tools save hours every day by automating routine work, analyzing data and producing materials in minutes rather than hours. Our services and USPB teams are leveraging AI to answer client inquiries more quickly; in Wealth, advisers are getting real-time insights that assist them in offering more personalized advice. And AI-driven automated code reviews have surpassed 1 million so far this year and are greatly boosting our developers' productivity. This innovation by itself saves substantial time and generates roughly 100,000 hours of weekly capacity as a very meaningful productivity gain. Back in September, we began a pilot program putting Agentic AI in the hands of 5,000 colleagues. With just one prompt, it lets people finish complicated tasks that involve multiple steps, and what we've seen so far is quite encouraging, so access will be broadened over the coming months. And lastly, we kicked off an initiative across the entire firm to weave AI into our processes from start to finish in a systematic way, which should generate additional efficiencies, lower risk, and make things better for clients. If you zoom out for a moment, what we're seeing in the macro picture is a world economy that has held up better than a lot of people expected. The U.S. remains the one setting the pace, powered by steady consumer spending plus investments in technology, specifically AI and data centers. That being said, some corners of the market showed signs of valuation frothiness; so my hope is that discipline holds; but on balance, even though growth has cooled a bit, and we're watching the labor market closely, America's economic engine is indeed still coming. Over in Asia, domestic spending in China has decelerated; yet the scale of their technology investments is staggering, and the world should take notice. In India, the fundamentals of a young, tech-savvy labor force and strong domestic consumption kept driving high growth. In Europe, though, structural challenges remain to be tackled if the continent is going to break out of this low growth cycle. One thing that's certain amid all of this is our dedication and our capacity to serve clients with excellence regardless of what difficulty they're up against. As you can see, carrying out our strategy in a steady, disciplined way is producing stronger business performance each quarter and lifting our returns. What we've accomplished across the past years, taken together — our transformation, our refresh strategy, our simplification — has left Citi in a substantially different position when it comes to our capacity to compete. We recognize that success doesn't move in a straight line, but I take real pride in the progress our people have delivered and in how everything is coalescing. Our plan is to finish the year carrying momentum into 2026 as we get closer to our medium-term return target. As for what lies ahead, we're eager to share that with you at our next Investor Day, set for May 7 of next year. There's still a great deal of upside remaining for us to capture, and we can't wait to lay out how we intend to do it. With that, I'll hand things over to Mark, and after that we'll gladly take your questions.
Mark Mason
executiveThanks, Jane, and good morning, everyone. I'll begin with the financial results for the entire firm, concentrating on comparisons against the prior year, unless I say otherwise, and after that I'll go through how our businesses performed in more detail. Slide 6 presents financial results for the whole firm. In this quarter, net income came in at $3.8 billion, EPS was $1.86, and ROTCE was 8%, on revenues of $22.1 billion, which produced positive operating leverage for the firm and for each of our 5 businesses; on an adjusted basis, leaving out the effect of a notable item — the goodwill impairment Jane mentioned earlier — net income was $4.5 billion, EPS was $2.24, and ROTCE was 9.7%. Total revenues rose 9%, helped by growth across each of our businesses and legacy franchises, partly offset by a decrease in Corporate/Other. Net interest income, excluding markets, which appears on the bottom left side of the slide, rose 6%, helped by USPB, services, wealth, legacy franchises and banking, partly offset by a decrease in Corporate/Other. Noninterest revenues, excluding markets, rose 12%, as stronger results in banking, wealth and legacy franchises were partly offset by decreases in Corporate/Other, services and USPB. And total markets revenues rose 15%. Expenses of $14.3 billion rose 9%, mostly because of the goodwill impairment I just mentioned. On an adjusted basis, expenses of $13.6 billion rose 3%. Cost of credit was $2.5 billion, mainly made up of net credit losses in U.S. card along with a firm-wide net ACL build. Looking at the firm on a year-to-date basis, total revenues rose 7%, helped by growth in each of our 5 businesses, together with the benefit of foreign exchange translation, partly offset by a decrease in all other. Expenses, which have also been affected by foreign exchange translation, rose 2% and were flat on an adjusted basis; we've produced positive operating leverage for the full firm and for each of our 5 businesses and reported an ROTCE of 8.6% and 9.2% on an adjusted basis. Slide 7 shows the expense and efficiency trend across the past 5 quarters. On an adjusted basis, in this quarter, we improved our efficiency ratio by roughly 360 basis points. The rise in adjusted expenses came from higher compensation and benefits along with the effect of foreign exchange translation. As you can see on the bottom right side of the slide, the rise in compensation and benefits came from performance-related compensation, higher severance and investment in transformation and technology, productivity and stranded cost reduction, partly offsetting continued growth in the businesses. Year-to-date, we have incurred roughly $650 million of severance, a bit above our original expectation for the full year. As we've said before, we are very focused on managing our expense base in a disciplined manner, reducing stranded costs and generating productivity savings to largely self-fund investments in transformation, technology and the businesses. That kind of rigor, paired with momentum on the top line, is going to keep pushing our operating efficiency upward. Slide 8 is where we lay out the credit metrics for consumer and corporate. The cost of credit for the firm came to $2.5 billion, as I noted earlier, and it was mostly made up of net credit losses in U.S. card plus a net ACL build across the whole firm. An 8-quarter weighted average unemployment rate of 5.2% is still baked into our reserves, and that figure includes an average unemployment rate of almost 7% under a downside scenario. We finished the quarter with close to $24 billion in total reserves, and the ratio of reserves to funded loans stood at 2.7%. Our card portfolio keeps its high credit quality, with roughly 85% of consumers carrying FICO scores of 660 or above, and the reserve to funded loan ratio within that card portfolio is 8%. Also worth pointing out, delinquency and NCL rate across our U.S. cards portfolios keep tracking right where we expected them to. Over on the right-hand side of the slide, it's clear our corporate exposure sits mostly in investment grade. Corporate nonaccrual loans did rise during the quarter because of an idiosyncratic downgrade, yet they stay low, and so do corporate net credit losses. The high-quality character of our portfolios gives us confidence, and that reflects our risk appetite framework along with our emphasis on deploying the balance sheet within the overall client relationship. Moving to capital and the balance sheet, Slide 9, where I'll cover sequential variance. Our $2.6 trillion balance sheet grew 1%, lifted by increases in cash and loans. End-of-period loans were up 1%, with markets and service driving that. Our $1.4 trillion deposit base stays well diversified and rose 2%, powered by services and wealth. We posted a 115% average LCR and kept more than $1 trillion of available liquidity resources; the quarter closed with a preliminary 13.2% CET1 capital ratio, which sits 110 basis points above the 12.1% regulatory capital requirement we had during the third quarter. Starting October 1, our new standardized CET1 capital ratio requirement is 11.6%, reflecting the drop in our SCB from 4.1% to 3.6%. That being said, we still need clarity from the Federal Reserve about whether averaging SCB results from the previous 2 consecutive years will take effect within the next few months. With that uncertainty in mind, we'll aim for a standardized CET1 ratio nearer to 12.8%, which factors in a 2-year average SCB of 3.8% plus a 100-basis-point management buffer. As we've noted before, we stay highly focused on using both standardized and advanced RWA efficiently, while giving the businesses the capital they need to chase accretive growth opportunities; and we'll keep prioritizing capital return to shareholders via buybacks, as shown by the $5 billion of buybacks in the third quarter and almost $9 billion year-to-date. Now to the businesses, Slide 10. We present the third quarter results for Services. We saw a 7% rise in revenues, with growth in both TTS and security services fueling that. NII climbed 11%, mostly because average deposit balances went up and deposit spreads were higher. NIR fell 3% from the effect of a larger lending revenue share, but total fee revenue rose 6%. Activity and engagement with corporate clients look really strong, and we have momentum across the underlying fee drivers: cross-border transactions rose 10%, U.S. dollar clearing volume rose 5%, and assets under custody and administration rose 13%, as we keep bringing innovative products and services with digital capabilities into new markets. Expenses rose 5%, mainly from higher compensation and benefits, including severance, plus higher volume and other revenue-related expenses. Average loans rose 8%, lifted by sustained demand for trade loans as we keep supporting clients while they plan for possible shifts in trade corridors. Average deposits rose 8% as well, with growth in both North America and International, largely from an increase in operating deposits. Services produced positive operating leverage for a fifth straight quarter and delivered net income of $1.8 billion, with an ROTCE of 28.9% in the quarter and 26.1% year-to-date. Now to markets on Slide 11. Revenues rose 15%, driven by growth in both fixed income and equity.
Mark Mason
executiveWithin fixed income, revenues rose 12%, as rates and currencies climbed 15%, mostly fueled by expansion in rates against a backdrop of policy uncertainty and strong client activity; meanwhile spread products and other fixed income gained 8%, chiefly on the back of more mortgage trading, greater financing activity, and reduced commodities activity. Equities revenues grew 24%, propelled by elevated client activity in derivatives and higher cash volumes, plus ongoing momentum in prime, where balances rose roughly 44%. Expenses were 5% higher, mainly from increased compensation and benefits plus the effect of FX translation. Transactional and product servicing costs declined, since efficiency measures more than outweighed growth in transaction volumes. Average loans rose 24%, primarily from financing activity and spread products. Markets produced positive operating leverage for a sixth straight quarter and posted net income of $1.6 billion, with an ROTCE of 12.3% for the quarter and 13.5% year-to-date. Moving to Banking on Slide 12. We revenues climbed 34%, lifted by expansion in corporate lending and investment banking. Investment banking fees rose 17%, with gains across every product. M&A gained 8%, with momentum in multiple sectors, continued share gains among financial sponsors, and more sell-side activity. ECM rose 35%, with increases across all products, especially convertibles amid the favorable environment. And DCM grew 19%, powered by leverage finance. Corporate lending revenues, excluding mark-to-market on loan hedges, rose 39%, driven by a larger share of lending revenue. Expenses grew 2%, from higher volume-related transactional and product servicing costs as well as compensation and benefits, which reflect recent investments we've made in the business. Cost of credit came to $157 million, including a net ACL build of $148 million, driven by shifts in portfolio composition, such as exposure growth. Banking produced positive operating leverage for a seventh straight quarter and posted net income of $638 million, with an ROTCE of 12.3% for the quarter and 10.7% year-to-date. Moving to Wealth on Slide 13. Revenues rose 8%, lifted by growth in Citigold and the Private Bank, partly offset by a decline in wealth at work. NII, shown on the bottom left of the slide, grew 8%, from higher deposit spreads, partly offset by lower mortgage spreads. NIR rose 9%, from higher investment fee revenues as client investment assets grew 14% despite a reduction of approximately $33 billion tied to the sale of our Trust business; we recorded net new investment assets of $18.6 billion in the quarter and over $52 billion in the last 12 months, representing approximately 9% organic growth. Expenses rose 4%, from investments in technology and volume-related transactional and product servicing costs, partly offset by continued productivity savings. End-of-period client balances kept growing, up 8%. Average loans rose 1%, as we remain strategic in deploying the balance sheet to support growth in client investment assets. Deposits came in about even on average, since money flowing out from operations and clients moving funds into better-returning investments on Citi's platform got balanced out by fresh deposits gained and transfers of clients coming over from USPB. Over in Wealth, the pretax margin stood at 22%, and the business produced positive operating leverage for a sixth quarter in a row, plus net income totaling $374 million, alongside an ROTCE of 12.1% for the quarter and 12.5% year-to-date. Now moving to U.S. Personal Banking, which you'll find on Slide 14. Revenues climbed 7%, helped by gains in branded cards and retail banking, though a modest drop in retail service partly held that back. Within branded cards, revenues rose 8%, lifted by wider loan spreads, bigger interest-earning balances — those grew 5% — and stronger gross interchange, with greater rewards costs providing a partial offset. Customer engagement remains solid in our view, with spend volume also rising 5%. Retail banking revenues jumped 30%, mostly because of the effect from wider deposit spreads and larger balances; meanwhile retail services revenues fell 1%, mostly due to bigger partner payment accruals. Expenses held steady, since reduced advertising and marketing costs along with lower compensation and benefits got offset by greater volume-related transactional and product servicing costs. Cost of credit reached $1.8 billion, mostly from net credit losses in card. Average deposits rose 6%, as newly gained deposits were partly offset by those client transfers into wealth I referenced before. USPB produced positive operating leverage for a 12th straight quarter and posted net income of $858 million, with an ROTCE of 14.5% for the quarter and 12.9% year-to-date. Moving to Slide 15, we lay out results for all other on a managed basis, covering Corporate/Other plus legacy franchises while leaving out divestiture-related items. Revenues dropped 16%, with a decrease in Corporate/Other partly offset by a rise in legacy franchise. That Corporate/Other decrease stemmed from lower NII, which came about because of steps we took across the past few quarters to lessen the firm's asset sensitivity amid a declining rate environment, and from lower NIR as well. Growth among legacy franchises came from Mexico, reflecting the effect of Mexican peso appreciation, partly offset by the impact of continued reduction from our exit and wind down market. Expenses rose 4%, with growth in Corporate/Other that included higher severance, largely offset by a decrease in legacy franchise; and cost of credit was $331 million, mainly made up of net credit losses of $297 million, stemming from consumer loans in Mexico. As shown in the bottom right portion of the slide, divestiture-related expense items this quarter included the $726 million goodwill impairment, which is capital neutral and based on the fair value of 100% of the entity. On Slide 16, we give an overview of the agreement with Fernando Chico Pardo to buy a 25% equity stake in Banamex; this deal moves the overall timeline for exiting Banamex forward, though it remains subject to certain closing conditions and local regulatory approvals. Before I go through the financial effects tied to this stake when we close, I want to make sure the net capital impact at a full exit is clear to you. Two factors will drive the total capital gain Citi sees once we fully exit: first, the capital that gets freed up from the RWA reduction; and second, whatever gains and losses on sales accumulate over time. That said, getting from here to there involves a few steps along the way. This transaction is where that process begins. So if you look at the right-hand side of the page, when we close, and depending on Banamex's book value at that point, we anticipate assets rising by roughly $2.3 billion, reflecting the total consideration paid for the 25% stake, which is based on the fixed price-to-book value multiple of 0.8; and total equity will rise by a net $2.3 billion as well, though several factors will produce that result. First, stockholders' equity will see a temporary benefit from reclassifying the negative cumulative translation adjustment out of stockholders' equity and into noncontrolling interest, and the loss on sale will offset that slightly. Second, noncontrolling interest will rise by the 25% of Banamex book value that was sold, but the CTA reclassified as part of this transaction will largely offset that increase.
Mark Mason
executiveOkay, when you put it all together, that's an increase of $2.3 billion in assets, plus on the equity side, stockholders' equity grew by $1.8 billion and noncontrolling interest went up by $500 million. When deconsolidation happens, we'll see effects on both the balance sheet and the P&L. On the balance sheet side, every Banamex asset and liability gets taken off our books, and that's partly offset by whatever equity stake remains; when it comes to the P&L, the whole cumulative translation adjustment tied to Banamex — roughly $9 billion — will run through the P&L as a loss and will undo the temporary capital benefit from earlier sales. So when deconsolidation occurs, the cumulative effect of CTA is capital neutral. To sum up, even though there are various accounting complexities between now and a complete exit, the total capital effect for Citi is going to be the full release of RWA linked to Banamex plus the cumulative impact of any gains or losses on sales. Now let's look at the full year 2025 outlook on Slide 17. Before diving into that outlook, I want to express how proud I am of this company as we carry out our strategy and generate top line revenue growth, which keeps being driven by our investments throughout the businesses and in key areas like technology and data. We've achieved meaningful progress on improving returns, with an adjusted year-to-date ROTCE of 9.2%; so now on to the outlook. With such a robust year-to-date top line revenue growth of 7%, we're still confident we can surpass $84 billion in revenues for the year. We now anticipate NII ex markets rising about 5.5% for the full year, factoring in stronger performance along with the FX impact compared to what we previously expected; for NIR ex markets, we anticipate ongoing momentum in underlying fee drivers; and in markets, historically, we've observed revenues drop 15% to 20% from the third to fourth quarter. But because of the strong third quarter performance, the sequential decline might go beyond that range this year. Now let's shift to expenses. Our year-to-date expense base reflects both the level and mix of revenue we've experienced as well as the FX impact. And based on what I just said about revenues, full year expenses are going to land higher than our earlier guidance. Still, you should anticipate the efficiency ratio for the full year to align with the revenue and expense guidance we gave during the year, which is just under 64% excluding the goodwill impairment impact this quarter. On credit, our expectations for the year haven't changed, and we'll keep repurchasing shares in the fourth quarter under our $20 billion program. Stepping back, the performance this quarter and so far this year shows substantial progress toward our goal of better firm-wide and business performance. Our commitment to carrying out this transformation stays firm and unwavering, and we're on track to hit our return on tangible common equity goal of 10% to 11% in the coming year, while continuing to lift returns as time goes on. With that said, Jane and I are glad to open the floor for your questions.
Mike Mayo
analystSo I think you said a big chunk of the transformation — at least two-thirds — is done, and my guess is that's connected to the consent order. Can you bring us up to date on where you are with your consent order work, especially when it comes to risk, compliance, controls, and reg data? And go a bit further on the reg data part, since in the current regulatory environment, it's strange that so much effort goes into something that's really about process — which regulators are actually stepping back from — instead of plain financial strength.
Jane Fraser
executiveYes, I truly feel good about the progress we've made. As you note, over 2/3 of our programs have hit, or almost hit, Citi's target state. A number of the biggest workstreams are now just part of running and operating the bank on a BAU basis. You've heard me talk about risk and the progress we've made in compliance. Those are 2 areas where we're largely at the target state and are now working through sustainability. But we're also near the end of the working controls now; that's a big body of work this year focused on driving automation and putting in place more preventative controls; so at this point we have preventive controls for any large and anomalous payments across 85 countries. Each day, roughly $1.3 trillion in payments flows through that system, and it backs 55 payment apps. On top of that, in our institutional businesses, preventive controls cover more than 99% of manual payment flows. Firmwide, we've moved controls onto shared, standardized processes. The Aug simplification effort was a major factor in enabling that. Right now, on automation of preventative controls, we're on par with our peers. As I've said, all this work sets us up to deploy AI across our processes. When it comes to data for regulatory reporting, that will take more time. That said, during the past 12 months we've made substantial progress by running our own tests, and the accuracy we're seeing now on our most essential regulatory reports has improved a great deal — dramatically so. We want those gains to hold up as part of a business-as-usual process and on an ongoing basis. Turning to the regulatory landscape, it's clear that shifts are coming out of D.C. Like everyone else, we're pleased to see the proposals being put forward, including a recalibration that puts safety and soundness at the center. As far as we're concerned, though, everything we're doing across all the programs, data included, remains on schedule. Our attention is on crossing the finish line for the work we've got underway. We're eager to see transformation costs decrease in the coming year, since once we finish those various workstreams, the related spending drops away—not just because implementation wraps up, but also thanks to the efficiencies we're realizing. And with roughly $13 trillion in assets across the industry, the stakes for getting this right are enormous.
Mike Mayo
analystThen a quick second question—regarding that transformation cost for 2025, and perhaps this one's directed at you, Mark. You mentioned the figure would exceed $3 billion, so are we talking roughly $3.5 billion, $4 billion, $5 billion? Could you give some sort of range?
Mark Mason
executiveMike, what I'd say is that for 2025 it comes in slightly below $3.5 billion. And once more, like Jane said, plenty of effort is being made to carry that out more efficiently, and that should assist in lowering the figure during '26.
Betsy Graseck
analystJane, I just wanted to get a handle on your thinking regarding the Banamex transaction. We've heard the prepared remarks, and we get that you'd rather pursue the IPO path for the sake of ultimate shareholder value. What I'm trying to figure out is how you weigh the timing of the bids you've already gotten against the IPO schedule you intend to follow. Also, is there a target window for when that ultimate value gets determined?
Jane Fraser
executiveYes. Yes. Let me start by saying the 25% stake represents a really meaningful piece — a step along the road to deconsolidation and, in the end, a complete exit, which is the thing everybody has their eyes on; we strongly believe this deal, plus the IPO that follows, will maximize value for our shareholders and, importantly, comes with a high level of certainty. Those 2 things have served as our North Stars throughout this process. I'd add that Mexico's President and our government have spoken publicly in favor of this investment and the path we're taking; that clearly leaves us more comfortable about the certainty of close. Turning to this path forward, I'd say the investment from Fernando is a genuine vote of confidence in Banamex, and we think his partnership will prove quite valuable as we head toward an IPO deconsolidation and, ultimately, a full exit. There are a couple of major reasons behind that. First, he's a business leader with a superb reputation. He's built a 50-year track record of truly creating value through his investments. That makes him a strong partner for unlocking greater value at Banamex. On top of that, he carries a great deal of experience and credibility that other investors find very appealing, and the mere fact of his investment stands as a powerful endorsement of Banamex' relevance and potential. That will help considerably when we look at drawing in other investors, whether through the IPO or otherwise; so as far as next steps go, the 25% stake needs regulatory approval in Mexico; that usually takes 9 to 12 months. After that, for obvious reasons, it makes a lot of sense to secure Fernando's regulatory approval before the IPO. He has already filed his regulatory approval with the government. So that will work its way through the process. He is not dillydallying and hanging around on this, I'm happy to say. And once those approvals come through, we'll be ready to move. And we're not hanging around either when it comes to completing all the work needed for that.
Betsy Graseck
analystAll right. And regarding that approval window of 9 to 12 months, when does the clock begin?
Jane Fraser
executiveIt's already underway, since his filing for regulatory approval was submitted this week.
Glenn Schorr
analystThe point I'm trying to reach with this is the difference between evolution and revolution, plus steady uptake among clients. I've come across a few press releases. I noticed you've signed on with the Euro Stablecoin Banking Coalition. I also saw what you put out about Citi Payments Express. My assumption is that you're putting substantial money behind this evolution. So my aim is to gauge where you stand on how quickly Stablecoin is being adopted. What weight does it carry for your established banking and payments operations? Do you believe you're out in front, positioned to earn more rather than less as everything unfolds?
Jane Fraser
executiveAbsolutely, Glenn. Let me widen the lens here, since honestly, for the clients we serve, the institutional ones, tokenized deposits are what deliver what those clients require, and that's where we've put the heaviest investment. What those clients want is money moving in real time with almost no friction and at minimal cost. As we discussed on the prior earnings call, we've spent many years pushing innovation in digital assets. What do our clients seek? They seek payment solutions that are interoperable, span multiple banks, work across borders, and run around the clock. They want those delivered safely and soundly, with every complexity handled on their behalf — compliance, reporting, accounting, tax, AML. Honestly, tokenized deposits handle that best. For our clients, we are the one-stop shop. We keep connecting new capabilities and emerging technologies, and we keep bringing partners in. That gives institutional clients the complete killer app. You heard on this earnings call that we're connecting our Citi tokenized services to the 24/7 dollar clearing network; that lets us enable transactions spanning 250 banks across 40-plus markets, letting clients move funds without friction at any hour to suppliers and third parties whose accounts sit inside Citi's broad 24/7 dollar clearing network. Demand and adoption are climbing, but honestly, the constraint is that our clients' treasury departments aren't yet prepared for a round-the-clock environment; right now, they simply aren't there. So where does that leave Stablecoin? Whatever our clients need, we'll be ready to back it. In the broader digital asset tool kit, we see Stablecoin as one more choice. It carries added friction from the on-off ramp. It carries added friction from tax, accounting, and AML — the very requirements our tokenized deposit capabilities sidestep; even so, we'll keep supplying on-off ramp solutions for Stablecoin exchanges; to our asset manager clients, we supply and will keep supplying custodial solutions for crypto assets. And to the Stablecoin providers, we'll supply corporate cash management services; on that front, we're on the verge of launching several new capabilities. And we're weighing whether to issue a true Citi Stablecoin of our own. But in my view, there's currently an excessive fixation on Stablecoin, even though as a significant player in payments, the bulk of this will end up being sold through tokenized deposit capabilities.
Glenn Schorr
analystThat reply was quite elegant.
Jane Fraser
executiveIt's something I care deeply about. My apologies, Glenn.
Glenn Schorr
analystThis is a really quick follow-up — you seem pretty enthusiastic about tokenized deposits and the possibilities there, and you're well ahead of the curve on it. Is there a chance that all securities could eventually be tokenized? Would that shift the way financial markets function overall? I'd just love for you to say a bit more about it, and then I'll...
Jane Fraser
executiveSure thing. I'll stick to the payments side of it; down the road, customers are going to expect offerings that bring together financing, securities issuance and settlement without friction, all within a regulated, trusted setting. Think about oil, think about equities — this is only going to get much wider, and we'll be delivering that through our toolkit; so that's certainly a factor in all of this. And it's genuinely great that regulators are allowing us to innovate responsibly now, since I believe that will support the market's growth as we and other banks take part in this area. It's really going to help it scale up.
John McDonald
analystI'd like to ask about the efficiency trajectory for the coming year. It appears there are some possible tailwinds that could push expenses down next year — perhaps reduced severance, lower transformation spending, and fewer stranded costs. So Mark, my question is: is it accurate that you foresee a path toward expenses trending downward next year even with strong revenues, and do you still believe there's potential to finish next year with an efficiency ratio under 60?
Mark Mason
executiveThank you, John. There are a couple of items I'd highlight when we look at 2026. First, let me remind you and everyone else that our target for ROTC next year is 10% to 11%. And it matters that we keep demonstrating progress in returns throughout the franchise. The second item I'd mention is that, going back briefly to where we stand year-to-date, we're showing robust top line momentum. Revenue year-to-date has grown 7%. And when you compare our expenses to that, excluding the goodwill impairment, they remained flat; so we're delivering very solid top line momentum alongside very solid discipline in how we manage our expense base. So when I look at 2026, that has to persist for us to achieve the 10% to 11%. In other words, sustained top line momentum. And I've provided — clearly, it's largely a continuation of what you've witnessed in the year-to-date results plus ongoing expense discipline. And that expense discipline will take into account at least 2 factors. First, the bigger efficiencies we've discussed previously, some of which you named — transformation expense declining, legacy/stranded costs steadily decreasing, productivity gains from BAU activity, and as I've said before, reduced severance, severance that's more normalized. But it will also call for investments to keep fueling that top line momentum. So investments, first, linked to those elevated revenue levels, but also sustained investments in areas of the franchise such as banking, in areas of the franchise such as services. You just heard Jane reference the investments we're making in token services. And so getting that balance right so that we're not just achieving 10% to 11%, but exceeding that past 2026 is truly essential. So what does all this add up to? It means, when I consider 2026, I start with the 10% to 11%. I then move to productivity and the necessity of investments. And I'm aiming for the less than 60 as I exit 2026 or during 2026, as I've stated previously.
John McDonald
analystExcellent, that's quite useful. And now a brief additional question. If we consider things over a longer horizon, where does that roughly $3.5 billion of transformation expenditure ultimately end up? Will it disappear entirely? At some stage, does it turn into something like standard business-as-usual investment outlay? And in what way does it change as time passes?
Mark Mason
executiveI've got a grin on my face, John, since the moment I gave out that figure, I was certain the immediate thing you'd ask would be what's going to happen to it, correct? And as I said, come 2026 it will decline for every reason already discussed, among them the considerable headway being made on the transformation. At Investor Day, naturally, we'll provide you with additional detail regarding where the cost foundation is expanding and where transformation costs are heading past that point. So please, I'd encourage you to remain watchful on that front. Still, I don't wish to let the chance slip to repeat that to reach better returns after 2026, we must strike the proper equilibrium between extracting the greatest possible efficiencies and reinvesting, enabling us to seize growth and opportunity while serving clients past '26.
Jane Fraser
executiveAnd I'd really suggest that everybody take a look at what we've delivered over time. What I mean is, our revenue has gone up steadily, even as we put money into the transformation and into the businesses. And all the while, we've held our cost structure down at a low level with a lot of discipline. That's a kind of discipline you should expect from us going forward.
Jim Mitchell
analystMark, I want to ask about NII. Given this year's guidance, it looks as though you'll be flat to up during Q4, since, as you've noted in your Qs, your exposure to U.S. dollars is limited. So is 4Q a reasonable launching point for the coming year? Is growth possible from there? How should we frame the positives and negatives related to asset repricing, expansion of the balance sheet, and rate-driven headwinds?
Mark Mason
executiveSure. Let me mention a few items. First, at this stage, I do anticipate NII will keep growing as we move into 2026. Naturally, our operating budgets are being assembled right now, but continued growth is what I anticipate. I believe several drivers are at work, and many have already shown themselves across much of this year. First, I expect deposits to keep growing — operating deposits, and deposits within our retail banking business — and both appeared quite strongly during the quarter. That should carry on. I expect loan momentum to keep building, especially for branded cards, and also in trade lending activity, which likewise came through very well this quarter. Beyond that, the investment portfolio I've mentioned to you previously should keep running off and maturing, and throughout 2026 we can put those funds to work at still-elevated rates in cash and other securities. The last element is that I would obviously also anticipate additional rate cuts, plus pricing discipline, and it matters that we keep reminding clients our offering amounts to far more than simply holding their deposits — that will help offset some of the pressure. Pulling all of that together, I do see NII continuing to grow — maybe not at the same rate, but growth nonetheless, excluding markets, as I head into 2026. Hopefully that gives you some help.
Jim Mitchell
analystNo, that helps a lot. And perhaps regarding that 12.8% capital goal and the increased buybacks we saw this quarter, should we anticipate this rate continuing until you reach 12.8%? I'm just kind of wondering what your thinking is on how soon you'll hit 12.8%.
Mark Mason
executiveI'm grinning once more, Jim, since during the prior quarter I stated we would not provide quarterly guidance when it comes to repurchases; and I intend to remain consistent with that; however, let me remind you that a $20 billion buyback program does exist. We've made solid headway on it; we will keep making headway on it. From a CET1 ratio standpoint, 12.8% is our target. And I believe you'll watch that decline — or rather 13.2% decline toward it across the coming couple of quarters. And we will find the proper equilibrium between putting capital back into the business at accretive returns so we can keep generating growth that enhances returns and giving capital back to shareholders, especially considering where we're trading, correct? And so even though the stock has performed well throughout the year, we remain at and near roughly 1x tangible book value, and I believe the stock has further upside. And so we aim to find that proper equilibrium between return on and return off.
L. Erika Penala
analystFor my first question, Mark, I simply want to confirm that I have grasped every one of the technical details you presented on Slide 16. So basically, the CTA effect at deconsolidation is neither positive nor negative. Beyond that, we ought to receive the capital release resulting from the RWA reduction — I believe that figure was $27 billion, taken from the Mexican financial statements — along with whatever gains and losses arise on sales. Thus the CTA on its own is capital neutral, yet the final capital benefit is going to hinge on that capital release plus the eventual valuation of Banamex. And assuming — I had to work that in — that my read is right, how much TCE is allocated to Banamex?
Mark Mason
executiveSure. Let me clarify a single point. I think you basically have it, and that is: there's a key difference between deconsolidation and a full exit. Deconsolidation, as you noted, would cause that CTA to flow through the P&L, and in the end that will be capital neutral, correct? So that part is entirely right; and then at the full exit, what we'd anticipate for the capital impact would be the capital tied to the risk-weighted assets plus the gain or loss — the cumulative gain or loss on sale. The capital tied to the risk-weighted assets — the risk-weighted asset is roughly $37 billion, okay? So you can more or less do the calculation of 13.2% against the $37 billion and arrive at a proxy for how much capital we've allocated in that spot.
L. Erika Penala
analystGreat. My follow-up goes to Jane. Jane, the recognition you received for the progress delivered reflects a raised standard, as I understand it, and everyone here is eager for the Investor Day this May. This really has two parts. As you move toward that 10% to 11% return on tangible common equity objective for next year, and considering the transformation is 2/3 complete, is May the moment to speak to potential end-state capital targets, similar to how JPMorgan has done and Wells shared an update on today? And should we gain further regulatory certainty — clearly you've absorbed plenty of swings historically from stress test outcomes — and particularly when we consider deconsolidating and completely exiting Banamex along with the regulatory momentum, does 100 basis points remain the appropriate buffer for this company going forward?
Jane Fraser
executiveWell, that covers quite a bit. Let me attempt to pull out a few elements of it. So we have consistently stated that the 10% to 11% ROTCE target serves as a waypoint, not a destination. And so in May, we — as I mentioned before, we identify numerous areas of upside. Mark discussed several of those areas earlier on this call regarding the revenue growth dimension. So we'll present what we foresee for the individual businesses, what the path forward looks like, and consequently, what longer-term targets we anticipate. Regarding the regulatory environment, I believe we're quite pleased to witness many of the proposals gaining greater clarity. We saw ESLR come through. We would anticipate G-SIB, Basel III, and CCAR with considerably more clarity during the first quarter. So that timing works well for being able to set out what that means for the May Investor Day, assuming that stays on pace — obviously not within our control, the timing around it. And so I believe you'll wind up with far greater clarity regarding what that — what the end state is, if an end state ever exists. Mark, why don't you come in?
Mark Mason
executiveCorrect — the one point I would tack on is this: given how far we've come in carrying out the strategy, you've surely picked up on the fact that our earnings stream has become steadier and more predictable, and beyond that, it's expanding. Part of the evidence for that shows up in the stress capital buffer cut we've now recorded 2 years running; at this stage we need clarity regarding the way that will be applied, including whether averaging comes into play. I bring it up because we intend to keep at the work and keep running the franchise the way we do so we can get better, and as a result keep shrinking what comes out of a CCAR stressed analysis. Another item worth flagging: other dimensions of the regulatory picture remain unsettled, even though they appear set to be beneficial — G-SIB, the Basel III end game, and so forth. We're hoping that by May we'll have clarity there, which would then shape how we plan for what's ahead. On the management buffer, you've heard me say time and again that we review it continuously, and we're always examining everything from the certainty we're getting on regulatory capital requirements — which, as we said earlier, is getting better — to how we view internal stress analysis and and the volatility in RWA and similar items. So we'll keep watching it and keep hunting for chances where trimming it makes sense, and we'll pass that along if and when we reach that conclusion.
Ebrahim Poonawala
analystA brief one for you, Mark. You mentioned credit reserves along with the unemployment rate figure you're carrying. But give us your thoughts on — and I believe Jane referenced a bit of softness in the economy. Regarding what we should expect for the consumer cards book, are there any warning signs, red or yellow, that have caught your eye? If you could also touch on it — I'm seeing the nonaccrual loans, and there's a fairly sizable sequential uptick in corporate nonaccruals. Was that a one-time event? Do you anticipate that as some of the, I suppose, banking book normalizes? Some insight on that would be great.
Mark Mason
executiveAbsolutely. I'll take that first, then we can turn to the consumer side. We did observe a modest rise in NALs during the third quarter. What drove the linked-quarter growth was really 2 idiosyncratic downgrades. I'd characterize NALs as a fairly modest share of the loans we've funded. Looking at that percentage, which you can find on the page, it's a low figure; we hold solid reserves against it — from a coverage standpoint, so NAL reserve coverage is still adequate, sitting above 2x, and frequently there's ample collateral plus a few upgrades we expect. So while the magnitude of the increase looks big, we can genuinely attribute it to 2 idiosyncratic names as the primary cause, and take some reassurance that NALs as a share of funded loans stayed low this quarter. Naturally, we're monitoring this intently; yet once more, since many of these are still making payments, we're feeling positive about our exposure right now. Turning to consumer, I'd highlight a few points. First, the losses recorded this quarter fall within the ranges we provided for both the branded card portfolio and the retail services portfolio. My sense is consumers are spending quite selectively. The growth in spend we've observed is mostly in branded, and it's skewed toward higher income consumers; and importantly, when I review delinquency trends, those trends are behaving quite normally when it comes to the early buckets. I see no indication of any shift in that pattern or that normalcy. So when I examine our book, I'm quite at ease with our exposure. I'm quite at ease with the reserves we hold. I'm quite at ease, honestly, with certain moves we made more than a year back when we considered how we wanted to underwrite consumers. And I believe that has given us some of what we're witnessing here. I remain quite cautious. Our operations are being run in a recession-ready mode; we're tracking NIM payments to catch any early signals of stress. Still, when I review our pipeline, I'm at ease with our current position and the direction our customers are heading. Jane, would you like to weigh in on that?
Jane Fraser
executiveYeah. One point I always make to people is that our strategy gives us an edge. Take our consumer customers — 85% of them are prime. Take our corporate customers — we hold a pretty pristine blue-chip portfolio. And we went from serving millions of clients internationally down to a few tens of thousands. That lets us zero in on them, truly know them, and do deep diligence on them, which pays off enormously. We stay very disciplined when it comes to credit assessments, client selection, concentrations, hedging, and sell-downs. So when I look at an environment where the market has run up considerably despite tariff and other headwinds, a correction could well arrive at some point. Still, I feel very good about where we'll stand when that happens. Plus, our consumer base is very fiscally disciplined and, as I said, very prime. So whatever the environment brings, we're ready and well positioned.
Ebrahim Poonawala
analystThat helps. I guess there's just one other item — Jane, could you provide a mark-to-market for the wealth division? When I look at operating leverage year over year — solid revenue gains versus expense increases — a lot of that, again, stems from NII. I just want to know if the simple gains tied to what Andy is doing in that business have already been realized. And how should we think about what's ahead, in terms of both operating leverage and ROTC improving?
Jane Fraser
executiveYes. Thank you. No, I'd say this was another strong quarter for Wealth, with revenue up 8%, better ROTC, and positive operating leverage for a sixth quarter in a row. And what made us particularly pleased, I think, was net new investment assets hitting a record $18.6 billion. That flows straight out of the strategy we've been running for the past couple of years, and you should expect it to keep going. It's all about becoming the lead investment adviser for our clients. That sits at the core of the strategy. So what we've been doing is strengthening the CIO research product, and we've been reworking important pieces of the investment product platform. You've noticed that we're committed to open architecture as a fundamental way we operate. Our alliances with elite third-party asset management organizations have grown stronger. This is assisting us in boosting investment fee income and in capitalizing on that well-known $5 trillion opportunity among our current client base; additionally, we're increasing cooperation across USPB, banking and markets. We're also observing quite robust two-way referrals between these various teams. That once again underpins our expansion in net new investment assets and revenues across wealth as a whole. Plus we're introducing new AI-driven features, which are likewise receiving excellent initial responses. AskWealth is our Gen AI-driven inquiry engine, and it's taking on thousands of client and service questions while getting updates quickly. Then there's adviser insights, which we brought out and saw really strong early adoption — it gives advisers personalized, data-driven chances to engage. Usage came in at 75% on that one. So there's a lot of demand from advisers. What this all adds up to is that it's pushing forward our long-term goals of being the top investment adviser for our clients, and there's plenty of runway in front of us as the business scales. So we'll simply keep going. Yes, we'll keep up solid expense discipline. Our attention will be on deploying the balance sheet as part of the broader relationship we have with clients. The figures show substantial progress already, yet clearly there's still plenty left to accomplish — and the potential ahead is massive as we grow, with that growth entirely within our own hands. Hopefully this gave you some insight into the various components involved.
Ken Usdin
analystOne quick item about costs, Mark. You brought up the efficiency ratio below 64% for the full year, and checking the deck, year-to-date appears to be 62%. Normally there's somewhat of a higher exit rate there. So I'd like to hear what we should expect regarding fourth-quarter expenses compared with the 13.6% posted in the third quarter, excluding the impairment charge — factoring in seasonality, the anticipated downward drift in trading you referenced earlier, plus the severance and other items.
Mark Mason
executiveA few things come to mind that I'd highlight. First is the FX effect, which is visible toward the back of the deck on Page 26 — that will add into the $53.4 billion figure we've put out there, probably by roughly $400 million; clearly, or rather, obviously, it should end up EBIT neutral, yet it's definitely a headwind worth keeping in mind when considering how much above $53.4 billion the total could land. Then there's performance to consider. What we've baked in regarding how far above the $84.4 billion — counting FX — that figure could rise is the remaining driver pushing expenses beyond $53.8 billion, correct? I've already given guidance that NII ex markets rises about 5.5%, and that clearly feeds into whatever amount sits above the $85 billion shown on the page. On the market side, as I said, I've provided some historical context. Still, with such a strong quarter, you need to assume some sequential decline in the fourth quarter. So those, in my view, are the puts and takes — the extent by which we exceed $53.4 billion results from FX plus top-line outperformance. On everything else, we've stayed quite disciplined regarding the expense targets we established.
Gerard Cassidy
analystCould you walk us through something? In your Q2, as I remember, you provided the balance sheet's interest sensitivity, and clearly we'll get the Q3 figure too. My recollection is that with an instantaneous 100-basis-point move in rates, your guidance was for NII to possibly fall by roughly $1.7 billion. But suppose we simply watch the Fed — say the curve's long end remains pinned near 4% to 4.5%, and the Fed delivers an additional 60 — sorry, 50 basis points within roughly the coming 3 months. What would that do to your net interest income across approximately the next 6 months?
Mark Mason
executiveThe easy way to frame it, I believe, is that what I gave you in Q2 covered both U.S. and non-U.S. dollars. For a 100-basis-point decrease spanning every currency and the whole curve, the hit was roughly $1.8 billion. Breaking that apart, Gerard, the U.S. dollar piece is only around $400 million, correct? And once more, that assumes a parallel shift along the curve of 100 basis points. We've been trying to lower that figure even more. So in the Q3 we'll give a number, and you'll observe it declining. I'd rather not reveal it right now, but it is falling from that negative $400 million. So you can roughly calculate it yourself. To repeat, that's a parallel shift; things aren't much different if you considered only the overnight rate move, since most of our short-term exposure sits in non-U.S. dollar. So I hope that's useful. Still, you can tell the number is fairly modest and shrinking, given the 100 basis points.
Gerard Cassidy
analystThen moving to my next question — there's been quite a bit of talk on other calls today, and among investors too, regarding lending to non-depository financial institutions, particularly given that, across the industry, it has more than doubled over roughly 5 years, and fast loan growth is always something worth watching closely. Could you — and per the regulatory filings as of the close of the second quarter, you have roughly $104 billion in this area. Could you share some color or perspective on the various lines you lend into, and how at ease you are with this credit?
Mark Mason
executiveSure. First, I want to point out that when banks report NBFI exposure on the Y-9C, that disclosure spans a really broad set of exposures. Private credit falls under that umbrella, but the category itself is very wide. Second, a big chunk of it consists of securitization exposures backed by diversified collateral pools. That means you'll find consumer-linked pieces such as mortgage, credit card and audit exposure, along with corporate-linked pieces that take in private credit or broadly syndicated loans. Commercial real estate shows up there too. Everything I just mentioned gets folded into this NBFI bucket. Broadly speaking, most of the NBFI exposure sits at investment grade. That's something we've always done as a company, and you can see it clearly in what we're sharing here. In practice, this means we partner with first-rate asset managers who back private credit deals or with well-known consumer lending platforms. Our collateral pools stay broadly spread out, and we cap how much can sit with any one borrower. We also build in safeguards at the deal level, such as plenty of subordination, which is what gets us to that strong investment-grade attachment point. On top of that, we keep an eye on every piece of collateral underneath, with visibility all the way down to each individual loan. If I pull back and consider the bigger picture, we are quite choosy about risk when it comes to operating in each of those subcategories, and especially where private credit is concerned. What I would emphasize most is that this particular category covers a tremendous amount of ground.
Rob Siefers
analystMark, could you go into more detail about what we should expect from the card portfolio strategy? With the Strata Card, it seemed like you suggested Citi is turning into a more prominent player at the higher end. So should we anticipate a deliberate shift in the overall makeup of the card portfolio that will unfold across the coming years? Or is it simply that you're adding a product where there had been somewhat of a hole before? How should we best frame this?
Jane Fraser
executiveThe main thing to focus on first, I'd say, is that we already rank top 3 in U.S. card balances and are a leader in both payments and lending. We're expanding that position through the introduction of competitive innovations and new capabilities. As you've seen, our branded cards product and offering suite underwent a considerable expansion this year — for instance, we returned to the Premium Rewards segment with the Citi Strata Elite, which the market has received very strongly. In the Costco portfolio, we refreshed the value proposition. Thanks to our partnership with American Airlines, we've started rolling out new and quite unique, pretty exciting capabilities, such as the Points Transfer with our branded card portfolio and our own proprietary cards. And as I've hinted, the team will soon be announcing additional new offerings, especially as we broaden our partnership with American Airlines. I think more growth should be expected in the co-brand space rather than the private label space. We're also putting significant investment into AI capabilities, which helps us serve our customers better, manage risk better, and drive efficiencies. Across all of this, you're seeing us very much on the front foot, building out the ecosystems around our COGS capabilities, being at the forefront of a lot of the innovation in AI and the like, and applying it for our clients' benefit and for the shareholders' benefit. So what we've got coming up excites me. We'll also have the acquisition of the Barclays portfolio in the second quarter next year, which will be a nice boost to the scale of the franchise as well. Lots of good stuff going on.
Chris McGratty
analystTo follow up on what Ebrahim asked regarding Slide 4, about operating leverage—you mentioned wealth, Jane, and that was useful. Could you address how sustainable that is, or maybe where the improvement in operating leverage is coming from, broken out by segment, as you get close to that 10% to 11% ROE target for next year?
Jane Fraser
executiveSure. When we examine it, services is pretty straightforward, as we've said. Fee revenues keep growing for us. Volume keeps growing too, through both new and existing clients. And on the market side, we've been quite disciplined, focusing on where revenue growth potential exists, especially in prime. You're seeing financing and securitization contribute as well. Wealth, we already covered. At USPB, growth will come in part from the Barclays portfolio, plus product innovations, and really pushing customer engagement and new customers—and drawing new customers in. Then there are synergies spanning the businesses, such as the Alpha trades we see between markets and banking, leading to the referrals we discussed between wealth and other businesses, and so on. And then Mark set out, quite succinctly I thought, the efficiencies we'll keep pursuing on the operational efficiency front. So I'd say you have a story combining revenue growth, investment in the businesses, and, as Mark put it, ongoing productivity gains. And those will be shared across the board.
Mark Mason
executiveYeah, I think what you should anticipate is that we're clearly aiming for positive operating leverage across the entire company in 2026. That's something you ought to see in the majority of the segments. Whenever a segment doesn't show it, the reason is probably that we're pushing harder on investments in that area. Still, on the whole, for the full year, positive operating leverage is what we'd expect, and we should keep seeing solid momentum on that front. So we'll provide additional detail about how we're thinking about it when we get to the Investor Day. But given that all of these businesses are generating better returns in 2026, that's probably the way it shakes out. I would be cautious about viewing it quarter by quarter. Take a markets business, for instance, in Q4, when there's downward pressure on the top line — you could get a dynamic specific to that quarter. That said, I'd direct you to a year-to-date that's really strong in each one of these segments, and as this chart shows, quarters in a row of positive operating leverage. And let me just remind everyone that we definitely expect top line momentum to keep going, but it's the need to invest that will produce those better returns past '26.
Mike Mayo
analystAnother one for Jane. In what way do you strike a balance between honoring achievements while making sure your staff maintains their drive for all the challenging tasks that lie ahead? I suppose I came across a story about folks marking the occasion when the share price reached $100, something I can grasp since you hit your latest goals, advanced on the transformation, and have a fresh team assembled. Yet for those who have stuck around for quite some time, we wouldn't want you to overlook the bigger picture. Returns remain below 10%, efficiency is still above 60%, and the stock has continued to lag throughout this decade. So it seemed to me that kind of festivity might have been hasty, though you do want to acknowledge the accomplishment. So what steps are you taking to make sure that drive stays strong at Citi?
Jane Fraser
executiveAlright; that was a landmark occasion for us and a significant one for everybody as we proceed along this path. From my perspective, there are always stopping points and there are end goals. The end goal is what gets us thrilled. And like I mentioned at the beginning of this call, enormous potential lies before us. Consequently, we feel highly driven by the possibilities waiting for us. We have an extensive roster of them across the various businesses. We are eager to share that narrative on Investor Day through each business and for the company as a whole since all these pieces fit together. However, I believe there is not one individual within our organization who thinks we are claiming success. We still have a considerable distance to cover. Having that momentum with us is wonderful; the journey won't follow a straight line, yet we are genuinely thrilled to stay sharply concentrated on the possibilities and the remaining potential, and unyielding in how we carry them out.
Jen Landis
executiveWe appreciate you being here with us. Should anything else come to mind afterward, don't hesitate to get in touch. Thanks so much.
Operator
operatorThis concludes the Citi's Third Quarter 2025 Earnings Call. You may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Citigroup Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Citigroup Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Citigroup Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.