Energy Vault Holdings, Inc. (NRGV) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 16, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Laurence Alexander
executiveThank you. Good afternoon, and welcome to the First Quarter 2022 Earnings Conference Call for Energy Vault. Just a reminder that Energy Vault's earnings release and a replay of today's call will be made available later today on the Investor Relations page of our website. This call is being recorded at this time. If you have any objection whatsoever, please disconnect now. Please be aware that Energy Vault's earnings release, along with this call, contains forward-looking statements that carry risks and uncertainties. Such forward-looking statements are predictions only and could differ materially from actual future events or results because of a variety of factors; we urge everyone, when analyzing Energy Vault, to be guided by referring to our 10-Q filing for a list of factors that could cause results to differ from those anticipated in any forward-looking statements. We assume no obligation to publicly update or revise any forward-looking statements, except as required by law; additionally, please be aware that we will present and discuss certain non-GAAP information. For more details, including a reconciliation to comparable GAAP measures, please refer to the Safe Harbor disclaimer and non-GAAP financial measures presented in our earnings release. With me on the call today are Robert Piconi, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, and David Hitchcock, our Interim Chief Financial Officer. At this time, I would like to hand the call over to Robert Piconi.
Robert Piconi
executiveThanks, Laurence. And hello to everybody joining us on the line today. It’s quite a milestone—our first earnings review since becoming a public company—and here we are, already halfway into the second quarter. For me personally, it feels a little like the old days, given the public-company roles I’ve held before. I’m glad to be back, supporting our customers, our investors, and the terrific people who are the foundation of Energy Vault. Today I’ll start with a review and an update on how the company has progressed since its founding—though with a tighter focus on the recent three to six months, especially strategically and operationally. After that, I’ll give an update on how well we’ve executed against the plans we first shared with all public investors in September of last year. Then I’ll hand the call to David Hitchcock, who will walk through our latest financial results in greater detail. Let’s return to where things began when we founded the company. Our mission is unchanged from 4.5 years ago: a broad focus on decarbonization—by which we mean tackling one of the planet’s most urgent problems, one that threatens the very existence of the world we inhabit. Global society must develop and store cleaner, more renewable forms of energy, thereby decarbonizing and safeguarding the planet’s health for future generations. To speed renewable energy’s adoption, you have to be able to store it, so it can become dispatchable power—or, as we put it in our early investor presentations, Clean Energy on-demand. Today, new wind and solar plants cost 50% to 75% less than the cheapest fossil fuel options. So what’s the problem? The problem is that storing those same generated electrons is genuinely difficult to do both economically and sustainably; in fact, storing it costs a minimum of five to ten times what renewable generation power costs; and today only very limited solutions exist that can sustainably solve this problem in a way that makes it competitive with existing fossil fuel plants. As an industry, I’d say we are far behind the innovation curve here, and that is not positive for any of us in this position. The fact that pumped hydroelectric dams account for over 90% of all energy storage today really says it all; and unfortunately, we really can’t build them anymore. But on the plus side, there are places like Idealab and people like Bill Gross and Andrea Pedretti, my co-founders in this project, from the very beginning. Bill also being the founder of Idealab, whose passion has been focused on renewable energy since he was a kid; it has resulted in well over a 100 companies being created since he founded Idealab. The reason I feel optimistic — and it's thanks to technology innovators such as Bill and Andrea, and folks at Energy Vault who worked tirelessly to deliver for our customers — is that I'm also excited to witness so many new storage approaches and technologies emerging. It's exciting, and I'm cheering on every one of them that can provide energy storage, both short and longer duration, in a way that's sustainable and economical. Luckily, we have an extremely favorable industry backdrop right now, with a huge long-term tailwind from investments that will urgently be required to safeguard the clean energy transition already in progress. Over the past 24 months especially, we've witnessed a dramatic change in global policy, at the government level and in the private sector alike. A number of the biggest investment managers and public companies worldwide have actually declared net carbon-neutral targets for the coming five to 15 years. Meanwhile, many nations have pledged carbon neutrality, more broadly, across the coming 20 to 30 years. Lately, the war in Ukraine has further shown why numerous countries across the globe, and truly our planet, the United States included, must move faster toward growing energy independence and away from fossil fuels; and last, and possibly with the greatest impact, investors of every size and employees at every organization are casting their checkbook and their fee as votes, insisting that the companies they invest in, and the companies where they work, enhance every facet of business sustainability — including the decisions those businesses make about supply chain partners and the carbon footprint of the infrastructure used to deliver their products and solutions. Each of these factors matters on its own, yet viewed together they show enormous backing for the shift to renewables, and that can no longer be ignored. Hence the founding of our company, Energy Vault; we develop and are now deploying turnkey sustainable energy storage solutions built to close the enormous market gap today for utility-scale energy storage, which is needed for de — carbonization to preserve grid resiliency as more intermittent and unpredictable wind and solar power comes online to the grid. A crucial element in making this economical is the use of sophisticated software, which explains why we announced last October the formation of our Energy Vault solutions group, along with the addition of former Greensmith Energy leaders John Zhang and <<inaudible>>. The EBS team is spearheading the effort and bringing to market, in record time, our proprietary energy management system and optimization software suite — technology and hardware agnostic — which harnesses sophisticated algorithms to orchestrate and optimize energy generation and storage resources alike, helping utilities, independent power producers, and large industrial energy users substantially cut their levelized cost of energy while preserving power quality and grid reliability; much like how telecommunications networks evolved. And in a similar manner, our grid infrastructure is undergoing that same evolution. Also, like in telecom, software is going to be central when it comes to optimizing and distributing electrons down the road. Our EBX gravity-based energy storage system — I'll say more about it shortly — was built to use environmentally friendly materials, among them waste materials that can be put to beneficial reuse when they're available for the large composite bricks; and that connects back to our de-carbonization mission. For us, that involves not just advanced technology and favorable economics, but also considering ourselves and the goods we make through a more circular economic lens. Because of the materials science collaboration with Pemex labs and <<inaudible>>, the party directing Pemex's worldwide R & D plus its Swiss lab, our standard approach is to take soil from the local extubation and use it for more than 98% of the composite bricks. That's less expensive and more sustainable than concrete. Yet we don't end there, and neither did Pemex nor our group of collaborators and scientists. We're also able to use coal ash, fiberglass from decommissioned wind blades, and tailings left over from mining. Every one of those was historically headed to landfill at an extremely high cost financially and environmentally.
Robert Piconi
executiveOur system also helps create jobs for the local community, since most of our EBS systems are engineered to be built using materials and construction partners sourced locally. That lets us lower supply chain risk, and it works hand in hand with our brick composite manufacturing process, which is also carried out locally at the site. Local also means less transportation, and that translates into lower overall GHG from the transportation sector. And that benefits everyone. We completely recognize and take on the responsibility our company has to support the move to a circular economy and to accelerate the clean energy transition for our customers, and we think we've developed a truly distinctive way of designing products and handling the supply chain. Although we're still a long way from our goal, we're achieving meaningful progress by leveraging materials science along with creative structural and civil engineering to help us reach it; and I'm encouraged by how far we've come on that front. Let's continue a bit further. Back in 2018, we got a quarter-scale prototype built successfully, and that validated the core technology along with the key economic parameters. Then, in 2019, we moved on to a commercial-scale demonstration of our first energy storage system. That one was meant to confirm the technology's fundamental elements using a full five-megawatt system, which was hooked up to the Swiss electrical grid in the middle of 2020. We verified and tested each core technology component at commercial scale with 35 metric ton composite blocks — that covers the gravity-based charging and discharging cycles to and from the grid. We managed to reach a number of important milestones and accomplish some first-time development. This encompassed, first, a round trip efficiency validated by a third party that exceeded 75% — a first for mechanical storage systems and considerably higher than any thermodynamic energy storage process currently available on the market. We demonstrated the software automation and orchestration using computerized control with machine vision, and we further brought in CEMEX's innovative material science, developed at their Swiss-based laboratories, to reduce concrete usage and allow beneficial reuse of soil sourced locally, along with numerous other waste materials, as I mentioned earlier. By doing so, we could substitute local soil from that foundation excavation for concrete, so that it accounted for over 95% of the materials in the first-generation composite bricks. Through our work with CEMEX, additional waste streams that would otherwise end up in landfills can now be put to beneficial reuse. Among these are coal ash, fiberglass taken from retired wind blades, tailings left over from mining operations, and even ordinary concrete rubble — materials that carry steep environmental and financial costs and that contribute extra greenhouse gases simply through their transport. This approach created a compelling circular-economy value proposition for customers pursuing the clean energy transition, while also addressing sizable environmental liabilities tied to disposal expenses on their balance sheets. After hearing from customers who wanted a more modular system built for shorter-duration, higher-power applications in the two-hour to four-hour range — something that could serve as an alternative to lithium-ion while still scaling seamlessly to longer-duration needs with zero storage degradation — we were excited to launch the new EBX platform in April 2021, coinciding with the investment from Saudi Aramco Energy Ventures. EBX draws on the key technology elements we demonstrated at scale in Switzerland, and it comes in a new form factor that is modular, enclosed, and scalable. Our EBX solution lets us provide a system built for greater power and shorter duration requirements, and it also addresses longer-duration needs spanning eight to twelve-plus hours. Since EBX's proprietary lifting systems rely on a more streamlined vertical motion, gains in round trip efficiency ought to produce performance in the 80% to 85% range, which brings substantial economic advantages both to our customers and to the worldwide community. Given what we have accomplished in the value we offer, we have been lucky enough to draw in numerous of the biggest companies as strategic investors or customers, among them Saudi Aramco, BHP, and TPC — recently announced in India — Enel Green Power, Korea's Inc., Pickering Energy, CEMEX and Atlas Renewable, to name a few of the larger names. Speaking for the whole organization, we feel humbled, and we appreciate the backing of these worldwide firms, each a leader in its own market segment. We wouldn't be standing here now without that backing. Now let's turn to what we accomplished during the quarter. On the whole, I'm quite happy with our results in Q1. We recorded total revenue of $42.9 million tied to recognizing revenue from the IP licensing and royalty deal with Atlas Renewable that we made public in February. In the first quarter, we collected $20 million in cash from Atlas Renewable under that licensing and royalty agreement. We also got the second installment, which was scheduled, of $25 million during Q2, so $45 million out of the full $50 million 2022 license is now in hand. I can't overstate how strong the commitment and partnership with Atlas, China Tianying, and Chairman Yen, who leads China Tianying, are becoming, and I'll go into more detail on that later. Because licensing and royalty revenue carries such strong margin flow-through, we posted substantial positive adjusted EBITDA of $31.2 million in Q1. As all of you know, we likewise finished our pipe investment in d. We completed a SPAC deal in mid-February that brought $191 million in net proceeds onto our balance sheet. That gives us the funding we need to carry out our plan, and we ended the quarter holding roughly $304 million in cash. As we noted earlier, two strategic customers — <<inaudible>> Inc. and Outlets Renewable — each put $50 million into our pipe alongside our go-public transaction, which leaves us with a very strong balance sheet today and no long-term debt. I'd like to spend a moment walking through several of the key highlights and accomplishments from Q1 in more detail. We achieved meaningful strides alongside our strategic partners, grew our world-class leadership group, and welcomed new board members as well as a strategic advisory board. To add a bit more detail on that, back in January we announced the strategic partnership with Korea Zinc and its subsidiaries concerning metals — an Australia-based zinc refinery. <> Group ranks as the biggest non-ferrous metals producer globally and also encompasses wholly-owned subsidiaries, Arc Energy, which recently came about through the announced closing of the acquisition of more than nine gigawatts of wind and solar generation projects in Australia. Kathy Danner, Vice Chairwoman of Arc Energy, likewise joined Energy Vault's Strategic Advisory Board, and I'll go into that further shortly. This collaboration supports Korea Zinc’s plan to cut carbon from its refining and smelting activities, and the first project rollouts should occur during the latter six months of 2022. I genuinely want to thank Korea Zinc for teaming up with us so quickly after November and December, when storage was under discussion, and for setting a genuinely leading example among businesses that commit to bold goals.
Robert Piconi
executiveThey've established ambitious goals—80% of generation powering their operations to be renewable by 2030—and they're backing that up with capital, as shown by the recent acquisitions they've disclosed, including nine gigawatts of wind and solar. We're extremely enthusiastic about collaborating with them, and we anticipate expanding this partnership over the years ahead. Beyond the IP licensing and royalty agreement I referenced earlier, we made meaningful progress in the first quarter by commencing construction in China on the previously announced 100-megawatt hour EBX facility alongside our partners Atlas Renewable and the China-based recycling and environmental services firm China Tianying. The CBX gravity-based system, at 100 megawatt-hours, is being built beside a wind farm and a national grid site in Rudong, Jiangsu province, outside Shanghai. Its purpose is to supplement and stabilize China's national energy grid as renewable power gets delivered to the State Grid Corporation of China, the largest utility company in the world. I'd also like to recognize Chairman Yan of China Tianying for his leadership in shaping this announcement and the organization we've now assembled to deliver not just the first 100 megawatt-hour gravity system but also the additional deployments we're planning following that demonstration. As a further note, it's essential to restate that Atlas and Korea Zinc each put $50 million into Energy Vault. That $100 million infusion—along with proceeds from our GOP public transaction and our Series C, which wrapped up in September 2021 at $107 million—bolsters a balance sheet that was already strong and adds further flexibility, so we're in good shape to execute our growth strategy. The investments made by these two entities are a clear demonstration of the value our technology offers, and we're delighted to have them on board as partners. We also announced in February that two new directors, Mary Beth Mandanas and Thomas Ertel, are joining the Energy Vault board; they bring strategic know-how in energy solutions and global corporate governance, respectively. Ms. Right now, Mandanas is the Chief Executive Officer at Onyx Renewable Partners — a platform for renewable and distributed energy solutions that serves commercial, industrial, and municipal sectors throughout North America. Mr. Ertel currently holds the Chief Accounting Officer role at Strada Education Network, and he brings more than 30 years of leadership experience guiding audit committees and CEC executives on global corporate governance and financial matters. These two accomplished executives joining our Board is something we're delighted about; on top of that, we managed to bring their talent and experience onto our executive bench, which was already strong. This morning, we were excited to share that Josh McMorrow is coming aboard as Energy Vault's new Chief Legal Officer. Josh has joined our executive leadership team, which is now fully staffed and concentrated on carrying out our worldwide growth initiatives to roll out our groundbreaking energy storage technologies. We remain proud of our ongoing ability to attract elite leadership talent across all areas of our operations. Moving on to our Energy Vault Solutions businesses, or EVS. We made significant progress in executing our software development strategy for the new energy management platform. As a reminder, in the fourth quarter of 2021 we announced the formation of EVS, which is led by energy storage veteran John Jung together with Akshay Ladwa. Both of them bring deep experience and expertise in grid-scale energy storage and technology integration. Looking ahead to the remainder of 2022, our position is strong for beginning customer service this year using this proprietary technology. A key point is that our platform, because of a hardware agnostic approach, will handle integration of energy generation along with storage infrastructure across any energy storage technology, and will optimize for numerous revenue-generating grid services. Also, in the prior week we announced jointly with DG fuels that our earlier-announced project would have its size doubled and its scope expanded. Originally, we said we'd provide 1.6 gigawatt hours—equal to 1,600 megawatt hours—of energy storage to back DG fuels at three sustainable aviation fuel, or SAF, projects; the first of those, in Louisiana, was initially planned at 500 megawatt hours. Back in October 2021, we put money in alongside Black & Veatch and Hydrogen Pro through financing rounds for DG fuel, helping it keep advancing that initial Louisiana SAF project. With the agreement now enlarged, that SAF project is being built to deliver as much as 73 megawatts over 16 hours, which works out to 1,168 megawatt hours of total storage capacity. DG Fuels and its partners plan to add projects in British Columbia and Ohio after the Louisiana one, as previously announced, with potential total storage capacity reaching 2.2 gigawatt hours across all of them. Potential project revenue across the three projects could reach up to $737 million. We're also continuing to strengthen our relationship with Enel Green Power after the strategic collaboration we announced in June 2021. Once phase one wrapped up successfully — that was the wind blade recycling and feasibility study report for the first gravity energy storage system deployment — we signed an MOU to advance to phase two, which involves construction now of a gravity energy storage system in Snyder, Texas. We've got a two-hour system rated at 18 megawatts and 36 megawatt hours, and we expect to break ground this September. We're genuinely thrilled to demonstrate this technology in Texas alongside a partner as significant as Enel Green Power. I'd like to express real gratitude to Nicola Rossi, Chief Innovation Officer at Enel Green Power, and to Salvatore Bernabei, the CEO of Enel Green Power — both have been familiar with Energy Vault for the past two and a half years and have backed our technology's development and diligence. Last, in February we introduced the strategic advisory board, which supports me and my leadership team as we sharpen our energy storage solution focus and pursue our longer-term strategic evolution. The Advisory Board is made up of respected industry leaders drawn from Energy Vault's current investors and customers, and every one of them contributes relevant domain experience, in-depth familiarity with the changing technology landscape, and, individually, a demonstrated history of creating shareholder value. Among them are executives from CEMEX, BHP Ventures, Saudi Aramco Energy Venture, Ark Energy, Pickering Energy, PlusVolta and Enel Green Power. I very much anticipate receiving their counsel regarding these customers and these investors as we keep prioritizing innovation and maintaining our attention on the longer-term strategic roadmap. Turning to the remainder of the year, here is a summary of our expectations. To begin, we will keep achieving substantial milestones in building the Atlas Renewable project in Rudong, which is our first EBX facility in China. The pace and effectiveness of construction locally will let us trial and roll out fresh, innovative cost-reduction efforts while drawing on the Chinese supply chain locally for those builds and also for later optimization of our global deployments beyond China, for certain power electronic components, for instance. Next, beyond China, our emphasis this year will be on execution together with our strategic investors and customers in two highly significant, fast-growing markets: Australia and the United States.
Robert Piconi
executiveWe have our gravity-based storage offerings along with the new Energy Vault software solutions, EVX, which delivers a seamless software platform that integrates and optimizes energy generation as well as storage systems, helping customers handle the complexity of network transitions more effectively. Next, we'll keep expanding our global supply chain and other infrastructure capabilities as we start executing on our first projects — sourcing and qualifying critical materials, for instance, and building key supplier relationships around the world. We're very focused on diversifying our supply chain base to help remove as much potential disruption as possible, like what's being seen in the current operating landscape across many sectors, and the fact that between 50% and 75% of our solution is produced locally within the region already gives us an edge in this sector. Lastly, we keep bringing on the best talent so we can deliver on our mission. Our people are the foundation of this company. And that talent, along with their passion to deliver and execute for our customers with courage, integrity, and above all humility, is what drives our culture and makes Energy Vault the place where the industry's best talent wants to work. All in all, I'm very pleased with what we achieved during the last quarter and energized about what the future holds for us at Energy Vault. I'll now hand the call over to David Hitchcock, Energy Vault interim Chief Financial Officer, to cover our financial results in more detail.
David Hitchcock
executiveThanks, Rob. It's great to be here with you today, and I'm eager to get to know many of our investors and analysts over the coming months. I'll walk through the quarter's results. Before that, though, I'd like to offer some first impressions from my time at Energy Vault since I came aboard in mid-April. That puts me at 4 weeks in, and I've been very glad to work alongside and watch the team operate as we closed the quarter and pulled the 10-Q together; it's obvious to me that the finance team has a solid talent base, along with a strong foundation of finance systems infrastructure and internal controls; near-term, my plan is to folk — to keep collaborating with colleagues throughout the organization to pinpoint where we can further strengthen our capabilities as we mature as a public company and deliver a best-in-class finance function, with emphasis on bringing in the resources needed to reinforce and solidify the team, and on continuing to implement and shore up key systems and processes so we gain better visibility into the business. Now let's look at the numbers for Q1 2022. We posted $42.9 million in revenue for the quarter, which reflects the licensing deal with Atlas Renewable. Licensing revenue is generally booked when the IP gets handed over to the customer, and we got part of that transfer done during the first quarter. About $7 million relates to other services, and we've deferred that until we actually provide them later on. From a cash standpoint, we received the initial $20 million payment for the IP transfer in Q1, and as Rob mentioned earlier, the second payment of $25 million, which was scheduled, arrived during this quarter. Gross profit for the first quarter of 2022 came to $42.9 million, thanks to the Atlas licensing revenue I just walked through. The development expenses for the intellectual property we handed over are included in our past R&D spending. For the first quarter of 2022, sales and marketing costs came to $2.6 million, compared with $0.1 million a year earlier, reflecting greater marketing outlays — among them expenses tied to our IPO — plus a larger workforce and higher stock-based compensation. Research and development spending in Q1 2022 reached $9.7 million, against $1 million in the same period last year, pushed up by growth in personnel-related costs such as stock-based compensation and depreciation, as well as engineering and development expenses. General and administrative costs for the first quarter were $9.8 million, versus $1.9 million in the prior-year period. Those increases came primarily from more staff, stock-based compensation costs, legal fees, insurance, consultants, and various other expenses. In line with our business plans, we anticipate that operating expenses will continue climbing for the foreseeable future as we broaden our global footprint and put more into growing the business overall. First-quarter 2022 operating income reached $20.9 million, better than the $3 million loss recorded a year earlier. That improvement was again attributable to recognizing the high-margin licensing revenue. It's worth noting that operating income includes a $9.2 million charge related to non-cash stock-based compensation expense. Adjusted EBITDA for the first quarter of 2022 was 31.2 million. That compares with a negative 3 million during the same period a year earlier, and our earnings release along with the 10Q we filed this afternoon contains a bridge running from net income to adjusted EBITDA. The main non-cash or non-recurring items we added back consist of 9.2 million of stock-based compensation, 20.2 million from the change in fair value of our warrant liability tied to our public and private warrants, plus 20.6 million of transaction costs. At March 31st, 2022, we held roughly 304 million in cash and cash equivalents, which leaves us well-positioned to keep making progress on our growth objectives in 2022 and beyond. Financially speaking, we got off to a really solid start this year in Q1, a period that saw both the <<inaudible>> and the pipe close. Taken together with the commercial efforts Rob outlined plus the others we're still working on, we now have decent visibility into hitting our top-line plan for 2022. Looking ahead, our attention is on execution for our strategic partners and customers, and on meeting the commitments in our business plan. With that, I'll turn things back to Rob.
Robert Piconi
executiveDavid, thanks. And I’d also like to compliment you on being four weeks in and getting up to speed on the business here so quickly. David is someone I’ve known from about 20 years ago. And our paths crossed together in the telecommunications industry, and I was able to convince him to come out of retirement to join us here on our mission. I want to thank you, David, for doing that.
David Hitchcock
executiveThanks.
Robert Piconi
executiveI'm happy with how the first quarter of 2022 went, since we moved a long way toward our objectives. We're in a really solid position at this point given the balance, with several things working in our favor. Those include, first, a strong Q1 financial showing, as David just walked through, on both our income statement and our cash flow — but maybe even more significant, strong commercial validation from customers, including some of the biggest ones, in the most important renewable and energy storage markets worldwide. We have a rising count of signed LOIs and executed agreements amounting to roughly 2500 megawatt hours, or 2.5 gigawatt hours, within our gravity energy storage system portfolio by itself. To me, these signals genuinely provide a great deal of confidence and a great deal of visibility as we now look ahead at the business, with our deployments this year and in the years to come. We've also established strong differentiation and sustainability. That runs from beneficial reuse of waste materials to relying on a localized supply chain that cuts greenhouse gases from the transportation sector and supports local job growth; and I believe this sustainability dimension matters so much to our customers, and it matters to our investors and our employees. That's part of why I joined this company — our focus isn't just on what we make and the way we make it; it really comes down to us being the sole energy storage business with this beneficial reuse of waste materials dimension. Throughout this development we've had a strong partnership with CEMEX, and we continue to expand on it around the world. And last, we complete the picture with a world-class management team and employee base. Globally diverse, with deep domain expertise, extensive project development and construction experience, and nearly all of us bringing solid prior public company experience along with a track record of delivering results. Yet a common dedication to wider adoption of clean energy—and to rolling out the storage that enables it—is what unites us. Last, as we end this call, I'd like to express gratitude to every one of our team members for their effort and commitment, particularly during the past six to nine months, a stretch when we moved into the IPO and stock markets, made our deal public, and still had to keep our attention squarely on customers. Throughout the shift into the pre-IPO market that helped us go public, and then as a public company executing on that path, their attention to what customers receive never wavered. Without the dedication, resolve, and enthusiasm they bring to decarbonizing the planet, none of this could have happened. I view our employees in three categories. The first illustrates how this company was built: they endured the extremely hard COVID stretch—a time of uncertainty for everyone—and accepted salary reductions of as much as 50%. During that period, we didn't lose a single person, which shows just how dedicated and enthusiastic the team is about what we're trying to accomplish, and how they kept their eyes on the objective throughout a stretch that was extremely difficult and full of uncertainty. Then you've got a second group of employees: our headcount grew by a factor of three across the past 12 to 14 months, and those individuals joined us from other businesses—much larger ones, much more predictable ones, with revenue, that weren't in the middle of going public and weren't exposed to the SPAC market, which came in for a lot of criticism in the second half of last year. I really want to express my gratitude to those employees for having faith in us, for joining the team, and for staying committed to their desire to advance decarbonization alongside a company that now serves customers on a global scale, giving them something concrete to execute against. As one illustration, let me highlight the recent additions we've publicly announced. I've already referenced David Hitchcock, who built a highly successful career across both public and private companies, serving as a CFO and also working for a large private equity firm. Kevin Keough is another, whom we announced at the same time as David. I had the opportunity to work with Kevin Keough at Danaher. Most of you know Danaher has been the most successful public company for roughly 25 years, averaging between 19% and 20% return on equity. There we have a genuine recipe for delivering results. I spent time there, and Laurence Alexander, who's next to me here, our Chief Investor Officer. We bring that experience to this company, and these are people who chose to join us along with our mission. And then this morning we announced Josh McMorrow, based out of Germany and a very seasoned Legal Officer across various industries. Some of them the energy sector, a few IPOs under his belt, and a lot of strategic transactions. I'd like to give a formal welcome to everyone who's new, express appreciation to each of our team members across the company, and give all of you the credit for our being here today and for starting this journey as a publicly traded business with our inaugural quarterly results. With that said, Operator, we're ready to take questions now.
Stephen Gengaro
analystHi, gentlemen. Nice work on a solid beginning.
Robert Piconi
executiveHey. Thanks a lot.
Stephen Gengaro
analystWell, thank you for making the time to — appreciate you taking my question. So there are two things I'd like to cover. First, it's clear that the royalty payments gave a significant boost during the quarter. As we begin considering what the year will look like — and we're not after specific guidance figures — but as you start thinking about revenue recognition on projects and how '22 and '23 might play out, perhaps even compared with the management forecast you issued during the process of I think $150-ish million for this year and $530-ish million for next year, how is progress on that front, and how should we think about the way the year develops from here?
Robert Piconi
executiveGreat, thank you, Steven. Well, regarding the first point on license revenue, that clearly is more of a onetime item. We're very pleased to have. Beyond merely being acknowledged, $45 million of that $50 million is genuinely deposited. Those proceeds will clearly be deployed to fund our development through the rest of the year, which I take to be the heart of what you're asking — specifically, how the remaining months shape up regarding the areas you raised: revenue, rack and execution. We therefore have the projects covered earlier in this commentary, which will sit in the United States and in Australia, along with constructing the 100 Megawatt-hour project in China. From a regional perspective, I'd say those areas will be where we concentrate; demand is abundant in numerous other locations as well. We've made announcements about Stephen and TPC in India, and we're now working toward a collaboration with them to thoroughly study their transition into renewables at over 60 gigawatts. Certain of these players simply won't be reachable by us this year, but regarding the main ones I named in those locales, expect that revenue recognition for gravity projects will start in our third quarter of this year and then continue through the second half. As you know, we use the percentage-of-completion method for revenue recognition, which falls under U.S. GAAP. As we construct these systems and advance them toward progress milestones that trigger customer payments along the way, we're permitted to recognize that revenue; we'll align our cost spending with progress and book revenue in step with those projects. We discussed Enel Green Power in Texas in the release — we fully expect to begin that work in earnest during the second half — and we also mentioned Korea Zinc and BHP in Australia. Since these partners put money in and buy from us too, that matters a lot to us; we also brought up the 100 megawatt hour project in Rudong, China, which will keep moving forward after construction started in March of the prior quarter.
Stephen Gengaro
analystAlright, that's encouraging news, Rob. The other thing I wanted to ask about is this: at what point do you expect to have your first commercial operational facility up and running?
Robert Piconi
executiveWell, throughout the investor discussions we've consistently stated that construction would happen this year and turnover would come in 2023. I genuinely think that because we got moving so fast in China, even that China unit — from the February announcement to breaking ground in mid-March — has progressed and continues to progress at quite a pace, as I believe you've partly heard through how the license payments have reached us, with the majority now sitting on the balance sheet. And beyond the fact that they've already broken ground, China Tianying also announced last week the agreement with the local grid operator covering integration of the grid into the State Grid. So my view is that if any unit is going to be first to turnover, the one in China just outside of Shanghai would probably be the first unit we turn over, judging by how I see them moving and by the fact that we're already in the ground there. And also the tremendous support we've received from the local company, from Atlas renewable, and frankly from the local and regional municipal authorities in really speeding up a lot of the approvals — to have something announced and then break ground within 6 weeks with all permitting and everything in place. So I'm fairly convinced that's likely where we'll see our first unit turned over.
Stephen Gengaro
analystGreat. Well, I appreciate the additional detail.
Robert Piconi
executiveThanks, Steven.
Thomas Boyes
analystAppreciate you taking my questions. To start, I'd really like to get a clearer picture of what the CapEx expectations look like for the year. My guess is that a sizable chunk would be set aside for building the mobile mass machines, so any detail on that would be useful, and then maybe as a follow-up, what do the <<inaudible>> machining cost, and how should that move over time?
Robert Piconi
executiveSure. Yes. What our capital mostly goes toward is our brick machines, as you know, so those really are the heart of our CapEx. Thomas, in the original five-year plan we allocated significant capital — I believe it exceeded $300 million across three years — to back a great deal of on-balance sheet financing and co-equity investments so that projects could be constructed. Compared with what we expected over a year ago, that has shifted considerably, since our customers genuinely want to purchase and own these assets; that doesn't mean we won't deploy capital strategically on chosen projects where we believe it's appropriate. For example, as we mentioned regarding the DG fuels, we put a modest amount into that project. On the whole, though, the bulk of the CapEx will be directed toward these brick machines. Also, to some degree, these first projects aim at elevating our EPC and construction management capabilities overall. As you probably know, many firms that are heavily engaged in building and construction face a tough environment right now, particularly given certain supply chain difficulties. That has created strain within the system, and we aim to relieve some of it by putting additional investment into our own resources. That, incidentally, includes the software team whose addition we announced in October. From a CapEx planning standpoint, I would say there are mainly no surprises regarding these brick machines. You asked approximately how much they cost? The brick machines are built in a modular fashion, meaning that for smaller jobs they can be produced at a cost anywhere between $2 million and $4 million. When it comes to bigger projects, we have the option to expand them or set up several production lines, which costs more. Keep in mind that although a single project may require greater spending, the cost of these units gets amortized across a great many projects and over a great many years; since we own them, they'll be relocated locally within the region — we won't be sending them across oceans. They'll be manufactured regionally, delivered regionally, and we'll keep reusing them from one site to the next at the country and regional level.
Thomas Boyes
analystGreat — and thanks for that detail. Maybe if we jump over to licensing for a moment: what should we expect there beyond China? Are there other spots where you figure that model fits a particular market or geography?
Robert Piconi
executiveYes. We had put some licensing into our plan. We didn't put as much in so early in the five-year plan, though. So this was a — this agreement. And as you're probably aware, we had budgeted volume in China. Internally, we've always carried a separate line item in our budgets for licensing. But this one was somewhat bigger on the earlier side. When it comes to other places and regions, there are additional regions where this could work, and we're looking into those; we really like this model, Thomas, since it lets us team up with the right local partners who have a design that already exists and is proven for them — they simply go execute, and we back them on road maps and on whatever technical support they require, as needed, and then they just go execute so that model succeeds; and I'd say what we've done in China, even though it's unique in the sense of bringing a new U.S.-disruptive technology into China at the same time; so a U.S.-disruptive technology launched in China first and concurrently with other continents — across a 30-year career, I can't remember new U.S. technology beginning in China. So that was meaningful in itself. But the fact that this company has now put more than $95 million of $100 million into Energy Vault. So consider that. They've invested in a manner that shows they're committed, that they'll safeguard our IP, and that they intend to build a large business to address a huge problem in China. As you likely know, China intends to raise greenhouse gases for the coming nine years through 2030, and only then reach net carbon-neutral status in 2060, and that's something the entire world will pay for. In terms of us evaluating these licensing opportunities, I'd say it's a strong model that begins with the right partner, where you can move fast, and it strikes the right balance between the partner using their local network to execute and build while we simply support and hold an ongoing royalty stream tied to that volume deployment. The way we've structured China, I think, is an excellent model, and we'll look to replicate it in suitable locations.
Thomas Boyes
analystFor sure. That insight is much appreciated. I'll get back in the queue.
Robert Piconi
executiveThank you, Thomas.
Joseph Osha
analystHey, everyone. Apologies if I'm asking something that's already been covered. I got disconnected and had to reconnect. In the past, you were open to giving out aggregate megawatt backlog or commitment figures. Can you do that today, or did you maybe share it while I was off the call?
Robert Piconi
executiveYes. We actually put some of the talking points together here. We had shared that, so that same figure, Joe — the one you recall from earlier, from our investment reviews back in Q4 — we referenced that number too, and it's roughly 2.5 gigawatt hours across LOIs, MOUs, and agreements. That matters because there are instances where we sign something after being chosen as the technology and even as the company, and we keep working toward a notice to proceed, which then leads to a final announcement. It's similar in nature to what we've already talked about on this call — for instance, the Enel Green Power projects, where we actually specified the location and the sizing. So yes, that's the number I think serves as the reference point right now, in terms of what we've executed at various stages of agreements that we're going to be building toward, as things move to notice to proceed and as we continue through the rest of this year and into next year.
Joseph Osha
analystAll right, thanks — that helps. I figure pinning a specific duration on it is a bit tough, so we should probably just think about it in gigawatt-hour terms.
Robert Piconi
executiveYeah, at this point I'd frame it in megawatt hours, or gigawatt hours. Once we're at the individual projects where the customer gives us the go-ahead, we might be able to state the power explicitly. So, for instance, what have we already shared? China — 25 megawatts, 100 megawatt hours, which makes it a four-hour system. For Enel Green Power we gave both the power and the duration: 18 megawatts, 36 megawatt hours. Interesting, Joe — that's a two-hour system for gravity, correct? And that's with the biggest global IPP in the world. I'd say these are meaningful, and they also show why our approach with EBX was the correct one. It was driven by the market, shaped by what our customers tell us, and that's the reason we adjusted and moved to the EBX architecture. That way we could play in this higher end of shorter duration and offer something flexible, modular, and customizable — because that's what our customers were requesting.
Joseph Osha
analystThat makes sense, thank you. I also wanted to ask — you mentioned turning units over, and from your discussion I gathered this would be China. What kinds of tests do you rely on for performance or customer acceptance? And are there any worries or obstacles we should keep in mind once a project is turned over, regarding being able to recognize revenue?
Robert Piconi
executiveYes. So, on the first question — what do we have to measure when turning something over? Usually there's a set number of days during which we must run the system after commissioning, and that operation is what enables us to receive a final last payment from the customer. And usually our contracts are built around power availability, so first of all we need a certain percentage — say, of being able to supply and discharge power. Beyond that, I'd say the main other performance metric is probably efficiency — or round-trip efficiency. That's another key aspect, which ties into your second question: do I have any concerns? The reason we spent the capital and did a large Series B with SoftBank was to build out a commercial scale system — and not just build it, but interconnect it, not to diesel gens or other local infrastructure, but to a live grid. So that investment, all that testing, and all the optimization we did let us optimize the overall solution, and all those learnings went into the development and design of EVX. So on concerns — we've done this before, we've done it at scale; it's gravity, it's not an idea, it's a law, right, for centuries, for lifetime. So I'd say that for the core piece of the technology, we're using, as you know, motors and power electronics from the likes of GE, Nitec, Siemens, AVB — all companies that have been around forever making these things for pump, hydroelectric dams, and a lot of other systems. So from a technology risk standpoint — throwing in the software, which obviously is pretty sophisticated, but we also proved that out. And we're building a building — we are building a 20-story building as far as that goes — so I don't really see a lot of risks there. That doesn't mean that on first systems it might take a little longer to commission some of them — it might. But that's just a when question, not an if. And as I said, the main confidence we have is the fact that we already have integrated these things together in a new system called the EV1 tower that's still in Switzerland, which we're going to actually be taking down here over the next few quarters. Either way, though, we're feeling fairly confident about the technical feasibility, about there being no technology-side risks, and about our capacity to get these things turned over efficiently no matter what.
Joseph Osha
analystAlright, thank you very much.
Robert Piconi
executiveGreat. Thanks, Joe.
Brian Lee
analystHi everyone. Good afternoon. Appreciate you taking the questions. I joined a little bit late.
Robert Piconi
executiveHey, how's it going?
Brian Lee
analystI may have overlooked this, but could you put an actual figure on your revenue guidance for '22? From what I recall, the most recent forecast you issued was for $148 million of revenue in 2022, and after that you announced the $50 million licensing agreement with Atlas, which sounds encouraging since you're getting those funds. If I'm calculating correctly, that suggests something in the neighborhood of $200 million in top-line recognized revenue for 2022. During the prepared remarks you mentioned feeling pretty comfortable about the guidance. Is that the figure we should be using in our models — are you reconfirming roughly $200 million on the top line for 2022?
David Hitchcock
executiveYes; it's David here. I don't believe we're reconfirming that 200 number. Given the strong start in the first quarter and the projects Rob outlined as we walked through all of our commercial progress, we're focused and we have good line-of-sight on delivering approximately $148 million for the year.
Brian Lee
analystAll right, licensing included — got it, that's reasonable. Then let me ask a couple of more pointed questions as we work on calibrating the model. First, you brought up Enel, Korea Zinc, and Atlas. I'm aware you mentioned DG Fuels too, so could you update us on how things stand with that big customer, and also whether you expect shipments and revenue recognition from them during this year? Second, regarding Atlas, apart from the $50 million in licensing revenue you'll receive, can you help us understand the revenue range for the 100-megawatt hour deployment? Since it's the first one, it sounds like it will be fully online and, from what it sounds like, could be in 2022 once everything is wrapped up. Thank you.
Robert Piconi
executiveYeah, thanks Brian. This is Rob, and I'll handle those. First, on DG Fuel — as you'd have seen, we just announced the up-scopes to that initial contract, which amounted to more than doubling it. As for that project's timing, it will be up to DG Fuels to finalize things, since we now have a bigger up-scope, and a great deal of the work involved in assembling it relates to when we actually reach a notice to proceed. All right; we haven't necessarily baked any of that revenue into this year. All right. So, as David said, to repeat the point, our public guidance has consistently been $148 million. If we announce something later, that doesn't mean it sits on top of the 148 — it means it's simply a component of what we're announcing toward our figure for the year, which hasn't changed. And as David said, we're feeling good about where we stand with this start and the projects in motion. Beyond Korea Zinc, which you mentioned, I'd add their wholly-owned companies, ARC Energy and Sun Metals BHP to Australia. So, as you know, they're both an investor and someone we're collaborating with on storage. For the 100-megawatt hour in China, we are — and have already begun — building it, and I think on our next call we'll give some guidance on the approximate timing of that; it has clearly gotten underway already, and we're working with them to support a lot of the development now that they're in the ground with their — the piling activity and such; it was pretty amazing, Brian. As I said on the call, I don't know whether you caught it since you mentioned you joined a little later, but they — from the announcement's timing, February I believe, it was actually February 1st when we announced it, the pipe investment of $50 million and then the license and royalty deal — they were in the ground in six weeks. China never ceases to amaze me. My experience spans 3 industries during the past 30 years, so I will never underestimate how quickly and efficiently they are able to move around infrastructure, which is exactly what this is. So regarding your question about whether that is going to fit into our plan, it is already in the ground. My expectation is that it will form a part of our plan, and next time around we will provide some updates on what that will be relative to the second half of this year.
Brian Lee
analystOkay, many thanks. That's much appreciated.
Robert Piconi
executiveYes. Yes.
Noel Parks
analystHi. Good afternoon.
Robert Piconi
executiveNoel, how are you?
Noel Parks
analystThanks, that's really helpful. Could you spend a little time on total cost of ownership, and obviously some of the geopolitical events we've seen have come on top of a big surge in lithium pricing. I know you originally discussed the gap between your total cost of ownership and a lithium storage solution. I'm curious — have you run any updated numbers, or do you have a sense of what that delta looks like now at current prices?
Robert Piconi
executiveYeah. Well, here's what I can say on that, because unfortunately that kind of question always comes down to — it depends. And let me be very clear about what I mean. You've got the power component and the storage duration, plus the power needed to actually deliver it. Take the two projects we cited — we gave specifics on those. With Enel, it's an 18-megawatt, 36-megawatt hour setup — a two-hour system — and its cost profile will reflect what must be invested to deliver that power across just two hours, right? Then consider the China system at 25 megawatts over four hours, which comes to 100 megawatt hours. That one will carry a different kind of profile. There's going to be a spread of costs depending on the power rating you specify and on the duration. That said, let me break down your question regarding what makes up those costs. What you refer to as total cost of ownership, we think of as levelized cost of energy — or for storage, the levelized cost of energy it contributes to. Generally speaking, there's a CapEx piece. You mentioned Lithium, so let's use Lithium as the comparison: both of us carry CapEx that must be invested up front to construct the system. That's the first item. Second, Lithium has something we don't, which is called augmentation CapEx. So what that means is, when their battery cells wear down — and as you're aware, cells wear down just like the ones in your phone, your laptop, or your EV — those cells need swapping out after a set number of years. And the more cycling you put them through, the faster they drain. Then there's a second piece of the levelized cost, which we call augmentation CapEx — that applies to technologies that degrade, and if you were asking, Lithium-ion would be one of them. Operating expense makes up the third component. Right, and this one matters a great deal, since it's what hits the P&L annually for customers; they're extremely sensitive about it. When you look at lithium-ion, for instance, those sites require air conditioning. In hot climates, that pushes OPEX above what we provide. We do rely on power electronics, but our solution is essentially an enclosed structure that operates across virtually any ambient temperature without dedicated cooling or heating. That, I'd argue, gives us an advantage when it comes to operating expenses for these systems. Beyond that, we're pure infrastructure and we don't degrade — so nothing on our system requires replacement apart from routine servicing of certain motors and the power electronics, under a standard maintenance plan covering things like bearings and cables. Those get replaced, but you're never replacing entire battery cells. Because we also don't degrade, that brings another major gain on augmentation CapEx, which, as I mentioned, we simply don't incur. It carries through to that operating expense as well, and then there's end of life. Hopefully technology advances so that more and more of what makes up a Lithium Ion battery today gets recycled. That point hasn't arrived yet. So for us it's a modest liability sitting on balance sheets; we're only a building, and our infrastructure can be constructed. Finally, we cite a technical life of 30-plus years. It's a building, and much like pumped hydro electric dams, which have run for nearly a 100 years — many of those are 40 to 50 years old and nobody, I think, intends to tear them down — we enjoy quite a long technical life. Does that at least help frame the comparison?
Noel Parks
analystIt really does, and what's fascinating is that past the raw materials expenses tied to lithium storage, the operating and augmentation costs in particular come in handy, so thank you.
Robert Piconi
executiveYes. Okay.
Robert Piconi
executiveAlright, thank you very much, Operator. I'd also like to express my appreciation to everyone who has spent some time listening in with us today, because hopefully you've picked up a sense from us that we're genuinely thrilled about the beginning we have right now. Yet even more significant, we're enthusiastic about the market validation along with the commercial and customer progress — items that aren't visible in last quarter and might not show up in the next quarter either. But take these announcements we've issued with the biggest companies in their respective countries for power and TPC, for instance: the biggest power provider in India, together with large industrial giants such as Korea, Zinc, and BHP; with organizations that distribute and develop renewables and that sign long-term agreements with utilities like Enel, Green Power. So that's the biggest global IPP on earth. This matters a great deal and gives us considerable confidence as we keep building those relationships, some of which are fairly new; so both Korea, Zinc and Atlas are somewhat new, but we're simply seeing enormous focus from them, and especially in China, as you heard, the pace at which we're advancing there is truly unprecedented compared with anywhere else on earth. So, fairly, I want to thank all of you here for tuning in, and once again, thank our employees for backing our development and for continuing to back our development up to this point. Thank you very much.
Operator
operatorThanks. That brings today’s teleconference to an end. At this point you’re welcome to disconnect your lines, and we appreciate you taking part.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Energy Vault Holdings, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Energy Vault Holdings, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Energy Vault Holdings, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.