FactSet Research Systems Inc. (FDS) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
June 21, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Alexandra van Nes
executiveThanks so much, and hello everybody on this morning's session. It's great to have you with us for the FactSet earnings update covering our third fiscal quarter of 2024. Just a quick note before we dive in — those slides that we'll be walking through can be accessed via the webcast located in the Investor Relations area of our site, factset.com. You'll also be able to find a recording of this call posted on our website later. Once we've finished with our prepared comments, we'll take questions from investors. We've got 1 hour set aside for this call. <<operator_script>> Prior to getting into the numbers, I'd like to ask everyone listening to take a look at the legal notice appearing on Slide 2, which covers the risks associated with forward-looking statements as well as how non-GAAP financial measures are used. Also, we'd encourage you to check our Forms 10-K and 10-Q, where risk factors are discussed that might lead to actual results differing materially from what's contained in those forward-looking statements. Both our slide deck and the commentary during this call will feature certain non-GAAP financial measures. Reconciliations comparing those to the most directly comparable GAAP measures can be found in the appendix of the presentation as well as in the earnings release we put out earlier today. With me on the call are Phil Snow, our Chief Executive Officer, and Linda Huber, our Chief Financial Officer. Helen Shan, our Chief Revenue Officer, will also be joining us for the Q&A portion. At this point, I'll hand things over to Phil Snow.
Frederick Snow
executiveAli, thank you — and good morning, everyone. It's great to have you join us. Ahead of discussing this quarter's results, I'd like to mention that we scheduled today's call for a Friday so that everyone had the chance to mark the Juneteenth holiday earlier in the week. We finished our third quarter with 5% growth in organic ASV and professional services. For the quarter, adjusted diluted EPS rose to $4.37, while adjusted operating margin reached 39.4%. Throughout this quarter, we continued to observe the impact of tighter client budgets and cost rationalization — the same trends we highlighted last quarter and that others across the industry have also noted. Such pressures delay choices and drag out how long deals take to close. Also, as you might recall, our softest stretch of the year is typically the third quarter. Despite all this, FactSet's streak continues: 44 straight years of revenue growth and 28 straight years of adjusted EPS growth. Through those 44 years, we've weathered market conditions harsher than the ones we face now. Even while end markets remain strained, this is a thrilling time for our industry, particularly for tech firms possessing valuable data assets. We're leveraging GenAI to build advanced solutions and capture market share. Take April, for example — that's when our 11th client symposium took place in Miami. There, we put our newest offerings on display and demonstrated how much value they bring to the people who use them. Those offerings have been driving demand for hundreds of product demos, which in turn is feeding fresh leads to the sales team. Now let me turn back to Q3. We finished with 8,029 clients, along with 9 net new logos. More than 208,000 users came in on our count. Overall, ASV retention held above 95%, while client retention landed at 90%. As things stand, we expect to wrap up the fiscal year with annual organic ASV plus professional services growth somewhere between 4% and 5.5%. Linda will walk through additional guidance updates shortly. Let's move on to our regional results. In the third quarter, growth came in at a slower pace, which we attribute to persistent market headwinds along with the fallout from a cancellation related to the Credit Suisse-UBS merger — and that affected each of our regions. In total, that cancellation accounted for about 30 basis points, meaning 2/3 of the deceleration in ASV that we saw quarter over quarter. Turning to the Americas, ongoing cost rationalization among clients offset the gains we saw among asset owners and wealth managers, and organic ASV growth in that region reached 5.7%. Meanwhile, in EMEA, growth was fueled by a price increase, sales to asset owners, and a higher ASP from the Analytics product suite. In EMEA, organic ASV increased 4.4%. Meanwhile, in Asia Pacific, buy-side firms picked up the pace, driven by front office solutions and higher transactional revenues. Asia Pacific's organic ASV growth came in at 6.1%. Turning to trends across firm types: within the institutional buy side, we secured a significant win this quarter, taking business from a rival at a major U.S. asset manager. That deal was powered by our advanced fixed income analytics. We put an enterprise sales motion in place, and the client chose our performance solutions suite together with analytics capabilities. Then we landed another major win with a global asset manager; that relationship shifted into a multiyear agreement that includes middle office portfolio services; the deal supports this client's strategy of consolidating vendors while lowering total cost of ownership. Wins like these show we can deliver customized, high-value offerings to our customers. Those customers likewise see that because we continuously manage their intricate portfolio holdings, we are positioned strongly to do additional work on their behalf. Within Banking, a decrease occurred stemming from the Credit Suisse cancellation. Cautious hiring and a wait-and-see stance regarding overall capital market conditions in Wealth Management continue to weigh on this segment, and while growth during this quarter was modest, the sector still represents a tremendous opportunity for FactSet, thanks to our active pipeline. We remain dedicated to improving what we offer so we can seize future growth and bring compelling value to wealth advisers along with the people they serve. A strong illustration of that is the investment we recently made in Aidentified, which we announced last week. When Aidentified's relationship management data gets incorporated into FactSet's intelligent prospecting solution, we can speed up new client acquisitions for wealth advisers. So that brings us to the fast-moving world of technology, and FactSet is well placed to take the lead there. We have more than 40 years of data that we've carefully built and linked together. Institutional asset managers and retail wealth advisers put their trust in us — 16 million portfolios sit on our system, and those represent over $30 trillion in assets. On the sell side, meanwhile, FactSet has a firm foothold as the go-to platform for fundamental research workflows. Whether someone is on the buy side or the sell side, we give them a distinctive range of data shaped around their specific use cases. That rich data ecosystem of ours is a uniquely strong and secure base for putting generative AI to work. To put a finer point on it, when clients bring together our data, their workflow knowledge that we understand, and the generative AI capabilities we've just introduced, the result is unique insight and efficiency gains. Everyone at FactSet is genuinely excited about assisting customers in finding new approaches to revealing insights that set them apart from competitors. How are we delivering on that? By showing off our newly launched products in live demos — these are things clients can get their hands on today. That's why FactSet has become the go-to trusted partner: getting things right requires experienced judgment alongside data sources you can trace. We offer both. Take Portfolio Commentary, which came out last month — it's a great example, producing full, in-depth summaries of investment performance in roughly 60 seconds. By combining our extensive data with deep sector knowledge, Portfolio Commentary produces outputs that are customized and extremely efficient. We also rolled out Portfolio Manager Hub, a complete solution connecting every part of a portfolio manager's workflow, covering everything from news and research through to analysis and trade simulation. Within PM Hub sits a GenAI-powered chatbot named Portfolio Assistant, which draws on our data to deliver accurate, traceable responses, all while keeping users inside the platform. Customer reaction to Portfolio Commentary and PM Hub has been strongly favorable, which gives us confidence to expand our buy-side middle office presence toward front office users. Over on the sell side, meanwhile, junior bankers at companies get a streamlined research workflow thanks to FactSet Mercury. We're working toward a point where pitch books and charts can be produced on demand through a single, trusted conversational interface. Users previously reported that FactSet saved them 5 to 10 hours each week before Mercury launched, and we expect this tool will free up another 10 hours weekly on top of that. As banking conditions improve, we believe bankers will increasingly rely on FactSet Mercury for greater speed, accuracy and efficiency. Looking ahead, our multiyear strategic investment plan is built on 3 key pillars. The first is expanding our market data across deep sector, private markets, alternatives and real-time applications. Consider real-time market data: our goal is to compete for market share by moving toward cloud-based solutions. By enhancing the cloud capacity of our ticker plant and expanding the content we cover, we can provide data services that are more scalable, dependable, and economical; we are positioned strongly to gain market share as clients seek out contemporary, cloud-based infrastructure. Second, client workflow. Beyond our middle office operations, we are making substantial investments in front office capabilities, covering both fundamental and quantitative research. Our sell-side products, particularly in banking automation, are building momentum with leading global banks and boutique firms. Our wealth business likewise continues to expand, with meaningful new opportunities in the pipeline. Third, generative AI. This core strategic effort, we believe, will start contributing incremental ASV in fiscal 2025. As we noted, our new portfolio commentary in FactSet Mercury is already generating demand. Also, during the prior week, we unveiled off-platform AI offerings aimed at technical professionals. Those consist of a fresh generative AI data bundle, a conversational API driven by FactSet Mercury, plus a new AI partner initiative designed to welcome fintech companies and AI startups into FactSet's ecosystem. Taken as a whole, we anticipate ASV expansion stemming from financially sophisticated businesses and hedge funds. To wrap up, my enthusiasm about our competitive opening is enormous. With appetite rising for auditable, high-quality data — especially where financial choices are concerned — we keep introducing essential AI capabilities that create tangible benefits for our customers. Because we emphasize collaboration, FactSet has become a go-to provider, and that leaves us positioned to achieve still stronger results once market conditions turn more favorable. Linda will now take you through a closer look at how we performed in Q2.
Linda Huber
executivePhil, thank you, and greetings to all of you. You'll have noticed in the press release we issued this morning that although ASV growth was slower during Q3, our margins and EPS both strengthened, and for the fiscal year we're raising guidance on each of those. More on that in a bit. Let's begin with what we delivered this quarter. As Ali mentioned, the customary bridge from our adjusted metrics over to the comparable GAAP numbers appears at the close of the press release. During Q3, organic ASV was up 5%, adjusted operating margin came in at 39.4%, a gain of 340 basis points, and adjusted diluted EPS climbed 15% to $4.37; GAAP revenue for the quarter rose 4% to $553 million, coming from sales to institutional asset managers, asset owners, partners and corporates; within our geographic segments, organic revenue was up 5.5% in the Americas, 2.4% in EMEA and 3% in Asia Pacific. Now on to expenses. GAAP operating expenses came down 2% versus a year ago, landing at $350 million; the driver was reduced compensation expense, chiefly an $8 million cut to our annual bonus accrual plus lower salary expenses and payroll taxes, partly offset by greater intangible amortization and cloud-related costs. Against the prior year, GAAP operating margin climbed roughly 420 basis points, reaching 36.6%. Higher revenues together with lower operating expenses stemming from reduced compensation expense explain that move. Adjusted operating expenses were down 1.2%. Let's walk through each of our 4 major cost buckets, starting with technology, which, as we've often said, remains our biggest source of expense growth. To be specific, technology costs rose 26% versus a year ago. Technology now accounts for roughly 9.5% of revenue. Second, moving the other direction, employee expenses dropped 8.6% compared with last year, pulled down by lower compensation costs thanks to earlier cost reduction efforts and the smaller bonus accrual. Third, third-party content costs were up 9% because of the timing of changes in variable fee expenses. And last, real estate and related expenses declined 14% year-over-year, reflecting the payoff from the early and significant steps we took to shrink this expense bucket. Thoughtful expense management, as we've said before, is setting the company up for future growth while letting us keep investing in technology and strategic initiatives. Let's turn to margin. Adjusted operating margin was 39.4%, an improvement of 340 basis points. That came mostly from an adjustment to the bonus accrual, a onetime payroll tax adjustment and lower salary expense. Given our lower ASV achievement, the bonus accrual was cut by roughly $8 million for the fiscal year. In the quarter, this change contributed about 160 basis points to adjusted operating margin. On top of that, earlier cost rationalization efforts delivered another 130 basis points of the 340 basis point improvement in adjusted operating margin. And as ever, an expense walk from revenue to adjusted operating income can be found in the appendix of today's earnings presentation. When you look at cost of services relative to revenue, on a GAAP basis it came down 90 basis points compared with a year earlier. On an adjusted basis, cost of services ran about 40 basis points lower. What drove that reduction was mostly reduced compensation expense, though it was partly offset by more intangible amortization and higher cloud-related costs. Now for SG&A: measured against revenue, it dropped 320 basis points versus a year ago on a GAAP basis. Adjusted SG&A came in roughly 300 basis points lower. That decline came mainly from reduced compensation expense, along with a decrease in bad debt expense and reduced facilities costs. Let me shift to tax. The rate we recorded for the quarter stood at 17%, against 16.9% in the same period a year ago. That modest uptick stemmed largely from greater pretax income, partly offset by more use of foreign tax credits and extra tax benefits tied to stock-based compensation. Moving to EPS. GAAP EPS rose 18.2%, reaching $4.09 for the quarter, compared with $3.46 a year earlier. Higher revenues, margin expansion and a smaller share count drove that, partly offset by greater interest expense. Adjusted EPS climbed 15.3% to $4.37, again helped by revenue growth and margin expansion along with a reduced share count, partly offset by greater interest expense. EBITDA rose to $240 million, a 16.9% year-over-year gain, on the strength of higher net income. Free cash flow — which we define as cash generated from operations less capital spending — came to $217 million for the quarter, up 13% from the comparable period a year ago. The main drivers there were higher net cash from operating activities and less spending on property, equipment and leasehold improvements. FactSet remains a strong generator of free cash flow. Now, on to share repurchases for the quarter: we bought back 135,150 shares for roughly $60 million, at an average price of $442.12 per share. Our fiscal 2024 share repurchase plan calls for $250 million of repurchases. As of May 31, 2024, $128.1 million was still available for repurchases in fiscal 2024. In addition, yesterday we paid a quarterly dividend of $1.04 per share, which amounted to a 6% rise in the regular quarterly dividend versus the prior quarter. That makes 25 consecutive years of dividend increases on a stock split adjusted basis. We stay disciplined with our buyback program and remain committed to delivering long-term value to our shareholders. Taken together, dividends and share repurchases meant we returned $430.1 million to shareholders across the last 12 months. And in the third quarter, we repaid $62.5 million of our term loan, bringing gross leverage down to 1.7x; that aligns with our plan to fully repay the term loan by the second quarter of fiscal 2025. Like Phil said before, because our end markets are recovering more slowly, our guidance now calls for incremental organic ASV plus professional services growth of $85 million to $120 million for the fiscal year, which works out to 4.8% growth at the midpoint, compared with our recent guide of approximately 5%. Revenue for the year is now projected to land between $2.18 billion and $2.19 billion; conversely, what we expect for margin and EPS growth this year has risen. To be specific, GAAP operating margin should come in between 33.7% and 34%, roughly 100 basis points above our prior guidance. Adjusted operating margin, meanwhile, should fall between 37% and 37.5%, which is 70 to 80 basis points above prior guidance. Where adjusted EPS is concerned, we now expect it to be $0.40 higher than prior guidance, within a range of $16 to $16.40. Our effective tax rate guidance is unchanged, staying between 16.5% and 17.5%; to wrap up, we keep managing our cost base prudently so we can deliver value to shareholders while still investing in GenAI and other strategic initiatives. As the markets improve, we think we are well positioned for growth; with that, we're ready for your questions. Operator?
Toni Kaplan
analystGreat. I'd like to ask about ASV. That range in the guidance looked quite wide. Could a broad set of outcomes really occur? My sense is the midpoint basically presumes things perhaps hold steady quarter over quarter, which would then maybe be somewhat stronger than what we saw across recent quarters. So I just hoped to understand — since you mentioned the tough backdrop, whether there are any positive signals emerging and what our thinking should be.
Frederick Snow
executiveThank you, Toni. This is Phil. Let me begin, and I believe Helen will add some further specifics. Yes, our visibility into Q4 has clearly improved, with 4.75% now sitting at the middle of the range we've just provided. Our aim was to remove risk from the bottom end. The bottom end therefore sits at 4%, and we have strong confidence in this range as well as in its midpoint. That said — this is, after all, our largest quarter, and it contains numerous deals that could swing either way, along with many opportunities worth 7 figures. So whether every one of those comes through isn't truly known until the quarter closes. Still, I believe there are grounds for optimism. As I noted in my remarks, Q3 brought us some excellent strategic wins, new categories of wins for us spanning the portfolio life cycle, and these genuinely assist clients with total cost of ownership. So my confidence keeps growing in our capacity to go out and help clients cut costs using the current portfolio life cycle product set, plus the generative AI tools we're currently developing.
Helen Shan
executiveYeah. No. As Phil mentioned, we secured several strong wins earlier in Q3. So looking ahead to Q4, we've also seen quite a few deals with longer decision cycles, and that has shifted things somewhat for us too. But when I look at the weighted pipeline for Q4, it aligns with last year. And we've managed to sell at the same pace — it's really the end market that has been affecting us when it comes to erosion and cost decisions. That's the reason we chose a wider range to account for that; yet at this point we feel very confident that we've taken the risk out of it.
Alex Kramm
analystPhil, you mentioned — I believe — 3 investment areas that excite you, or that you're concentrating on, I should say. Looking back several years, I think we were in a comparable spot. Growth had perhaps declined due to the environment, and you believed additional spending was necessary to restart that growth. So regarding these investments, when you consider the coming couple of years, do you believe the company requires yet another injection of investment? Or do you feel you can handle things within the existing cost structure you currently have?
Frederick Snow
executiveThat's a reasonable question. Thanks, Alex; so my basis for optimism is that many multiyear initiatives remain underway and are still being developed, and we anticipate fueling growth going forward. Those would be deep sector, private markets, and more lately real time. So somewhat of an earlier vintage; so those efforts continue progressing well and show promise; and over the past 18 months or so, we've truly succeeded in unlocking extra dollars to put toward generative AI and the data platform. And honestly, I think we've triggered yet another surge of innovation within the company, in terms of how we tackle this; so I remain hopeful. Still, it's a reasonable question. So as Q4 unfolds and we work through our rolling 3-year plan, I believe we will assess whether there might be certain areas deserving additional investment, though we can't offer any genuine guidance on that before the September call. Still, it's a good question.
Kelsey Zhu
analystThe data we monitor for the industry points to a few initial indications that capital markets activity is coming back. So I'm just wondering, what are your sell side customers telling you? And at what point do you anticipate sell side ASV growth picking up again?
Frederick Snow
executiveWell, Kelsey, thank you; I believe we're definitely observing additional activity when it comes to M&A among the bankers. I believe we're seeing somewhat improved hiring compared with what we had, and Helen may want to add a bit more about that. And I believe that when you examine how things have trended over time, when banking fees rise, banking hiring has tended to follow suit. And after that, FactSet's ASV on the sell side has tended to follow that. So assuming those historical patterns hold, though there's no assurance, and I believe there are a few grounds for optimism there.
Helen Shan
executiveSure, let me expand on that a bit. From what we can observe among the big investment banks and the universal banks, recruiting activity has stayed fairly subdued, so they themselves are behaving more cautiously. At the middle market banks and the boutiques, we're seeing stronger figures. So I'd say that at this point, seasonal hiring for the quarter — meaning the first quarter of this year — is, for the first time this year, above where it was a year earlier. That said, we aren't really treating that as a major rebound when it comes to our Q4 numbers.
Manav Patnaik
analystI suppose what I have is a question about run rate, and it comes in two pieces. First, regarding the top line, has the UBS-CS effect been completely absorbed into the run rate at this point, or do you expect further effects? Then, specifically on expenses, along with all the head count initiatives and similar actions taken so far, is there additional flow-through still to come? I'm simply trying to understand how those two things work.
Helen Shan
executiveOf course. Manav, this is Helen. I'll address the first portion. What I'd say is that most of the effect stemming from that transaction shows up in this quarter. A small amount remains for Q4, though it is considerably less.
Linda Huber
executiveAbsolutely. So Manav, when it comes to the margin gain, I'd like to walk through the specifics here so it's clear to everybody which pieces are one-time and which ones carry forward. On the positive side for margin improvement — and this is adjusted operating margin — the total came to roughly 540 basis points, while the negative items totaled around 200 basis points. Let me walk through each of them. The reduced bonus accrual of $8 million, which was needed to align our annual bonus accrual, was responsible for about 160 basis points of the benefit in the third quarter, and that won't happen again; put differently, that adjustment was required. Reduced salaries contributed roughly 130 basis points, and that will carry on. Lower payroll taxes contributed around 120, and that's a one-time item. It comes from the Cares Act. It's a refundable tax credit tied to keeping employees on payroll through COVID. Reduced facilities costs contributed 60 basis points, and that will carry on. Increased capitalization contributed 40, which will also carry on. And reduced stock-based comp amortization contributed 20 — that one has now been caught up and won't carry on. So of those 540 basis points, roughly 280 are one-timers. Then on the negative side, we saw increased technology costs of 170 basis points, plus increased third-party data and other expenses of 30 basis points. That gives us 340 basis points of overall improvement. And on the positive side, roughly half of that will carry on as we progress through the year. I hope that's useful.
Faiza Alwy
analystI'd like to inquire about how the competition looks right now. What are you observing from your rivals? Over the past 2 years or so, it appears competitors have been putting in investment as well, compared with how things used to be. You've mentioned pricing battles for new business, so please help us understand your read on where competitive dynamics stand today.
Frederick Snow
executiveThanks, Faiza. When it comes to the institutional buy side, there are, I'd say, 2 main competitors for us; and what matters most is really total cost of ownership. With the portfolio analytics we offer on FactSet, we feel our position is very strong, and it's even stronger now following our investments in front office tools. As I noted, we rolled out PM Hub, and that does a great job linking our middle office solutions together with the front office. So regarding our competitive standing on the buy side, I feel quite good. The firms, in my view, under the heaviest cost pressure are the ones cutting expenses. In my view, the companies that offer portfolio analytics solutions are the ones with the right to compete on the buy side; and I believe we're well placed there; in wealth, in the same way, we have the portfolios on the system. Our wealth adviser product and adviser dashboard work has been outstanding; and you heard me discuss another workflow today, which is the CRM workflow, in a sense. So our heavy focus right now is on developing more workflows for the wealth space, yet in the wealth space our positioning couldn't be better. Within banking, private equity, corporates, the hedge funds, that area, admittedly, is becoming somewhat more crowded; so many of us are present there with fundamental analyst products. The work we've done with deep sector, with private markets, the tools we're creating with generative AI, all of those, I believe, give us a very strong position on the competitive front.
Helen Shan
executiveRegarding what you said about pricing, let me address that. We've noted previously that new logos do face a certain amount of price pressure, though it isn't broad-based. Typically it arises when we're taking business from rivals and might have to lower our price so budgets line up, for instance. The favorable part, though, is that nearly all of our agreements run for multiple years, which means we regain that price and boost our price realization as the contract moves toward maturity.
Surinder Thind
analystWhen it comes to GenAI, plus how these tools get integrated and what features are offered — as customers start picking them up and relying on them more heavily, what does that do to your technology expenses? Any insight on that would be useful.
Frederick Snow
executiveThat's a wonderful thing to ask. I appreciate it; right now, there's a fair amount we simply don't know. Linda has discussed how our tech spending is climbing, and that's justified since we're putting money into this area; however, yes, the more customers make use of these tools, the more compute costs will rise; naturally, then, we're giving that serious thought; at FactSet we have excellent engineers who are essentially keeping an eye on it, and whatever we find will get factored into the pricing model we ultimately land on for these offerings. So this is a puzzle that's going to need solving as time goes on. That said, provided we create sufficient value by helping clients save time — which is genuinely our central aim — that ought to exceed the extra cost we'd only take on because of compute.
Ashish Sabadra
analystI'd like some clarification regarding that CS-UBS headwind — is what we're seeing purely the net figure? Or should we consider possible cross-selling upside? Did any cross-selling chance exist that reduced the size of that hit? Then a fast follow-up to make things clear about Q4 revenue growth compared with ASV growth. Assuming my calculations are correct, at the midpoint of the revenue guidance I arrive at under 2% revenue growth for the second — for the fourth quarter, and that's roughly 3 points beneath the ASV growth at the midpoint. What accounts for that gap? Also, how should we view the exit revenue run rate as we head into next year?
Helen Shan
executiveOf course; Helen here. I'll take the first portion, after which I'll hand things over to Linda. Regarding the merger between Credit Suisse and UBS, our discussion concerns the net figure. We managed to recover a portion of that cancellation by selling into UBS. From where we sit, that counts as a positive.
Linda Huber
executiveAbsolutely. And Ashish, that's a fair point. This is Linda. Typically, ASV moves ahead of revenue. During Q3 of last year, we saw an atypical one-time bump in CUSIP revenues. That drove up the revenue figure tied to Q3 of '23, and since that makes for a difficult comparison, Q3 '24 appears weaker as a result, so timing plays a role here. And I'd say it's reasonable to point out that while CUSIP isn't broken out separately given how central it is to what we do, during the third quarter that business delivered very strong results, on both growth and margins. So we're quite happy with the way that business is performing. That said — you've got it right, though what's driving this is the lapping effect.
Ashish Sabadra
analystPardon me, I wanted to ask whether you might also share some thoughts regarding Q4; what you said about Q3 was useful context.
Linda Huber
executiveThanks. As for where we exit at a run rate in the fourth quarter, Ashish, guidance on that isn't something we'll provide. So once we arrive there, we'll find out how it turns out. We'll talk with you about it in September.
George Tong
analystI was hoping you could give us a bit more detail on what's driving the revised ASV guidance. Is the thinking essentially that deals are taking longer to close, so it comes down to when they land? Or are we seeing more client losses, meaning the business is genuinely gone for structural reasons? Then, second, could you address international pricing? Our understanding is that fiscal 3Q is normally when you implement pricing changes, so how did this year's pricing stack up against last year?
Helen Shan
executiveOf course. George, this is Helen. I'll take a shot at that. Let me start with pricing. International pricing did go up. You're correct that we do this annually in Q3. It came in at 16 versus 16.8 a year ago. So as you can tell, we managed to achieve essentially the same level as the prior year. That also shows more clients were captured. So we're quite pleased with that, and it matches what we had expected. So we think our pricing realization, along with the value delivered to clients, is holding steady. Turning to Q4, the reason we shifted part of this when we look at the pipeline is that deals keep slipping, particularly in analytics, and on the buy side especially. They aren't dropping out, to use our phrase. They aren't gone; however, because they've slid by several quarters — the bigger the deal, the more clients need confidence about end markets, and at times our own capacity is, frankly, tighter — we keep seeing that push. So that factors in. I also want to restate one thing I said before. Looking at what we anticipate for the year, underlying demand for our products is still stable. On a gross basis, we match last year. So we're selling the same amount as a year ago. So demand isn't the issue. That said, we've had several onetime cancellations that we've discussed. So the effect has shown up as greater erosion, which we think is partly, clearly, market-driven.
Andrew Nicholas
analystSo I believe you said that AI is going to produce incremental ASV during 2025. Thanks for all that detail. But what I want to know is about the flip side, perhaps regarding savings on internal costs. Would you also anticipate that showing up at some stage in 2025? Or ought we to keep viewing this mostly as an effort that breaks even when it comes to expenses?
Frederick Snow
executiveYes. Thank you, Andrew. Excellent question. So as you might imagine, similar to a lot of companies, this is something we've been examining. And we believe there are solid chances for efficiency along with client service, quality assurance, content collection, and even simply engineer — just editing code, writing code. So we're looking at that carefully. I think efficiencies will come to us. What really matters is whether we put those back into products, which sort of returns to the earlier question from Alex; so efficiencies definitely are things we will obtain; we're noticing that. It simply comes down to what we ultimately decide to do with them.
Shlomo Rosenbaum
analystTo start, I just want a bit of clarification regarding those earlier questions about CS and UBS. The guidance for the fourth quarter suggests revenue will decline, and that stands out. On a sequential basis, I don't believe we've witnessed that in roughly 5 years. So I'd like to know: if you set aside the situation where the UBS-CS license is disappearing, would revenue grow sequentially once we normalize for that? I'm trying to figure out whether this reflects the environment or whether that factor is weighing on you too heavily. More broadly, revenue growth has been slowing, and Linda, I've raised this with you previously, but you've pulled many levers on the expense side, and the environment keeps drifting. What remains available to you if we don't get a pickup? We were somewhat hoping for more, I think, from those green shoots we flagged last quarter; but should they fail to appear soon, which other levers would you use?
Helen Shan
executiveSure. I'll address part of that first, then hand things to Linda. Regarding CS, let me walk through it, especially since we referenced the impact in our script. If we remove that as a onetime impact, it would be roughly 30-plus basis points. That won't hit revenue immediately. It plays out across a period of time. Looking at some other onetime items we've discussed previously, I believe it was last quarter, that single large cancel, that helps account for the delta. But yes, from my perspective — again, let me return to this. What we're selling aligns with how we've observed it previously. Certain onetime items are driving the erosion, so I don't see this as a problem with our underlying business, but instead more market-related or, again, some matters somewhat beyond our control, Shlomo.
Linda Huber
executiveShlomo, I appreciate you pointing out that in spite of this wandering market — which is a fitting word for it, we like that — our attention has stayed...
Frederick Snow
executiveOne second operator, I believe Window was done yet.
Linda Huber
executiveOn the cost side, our personnel expenses declined 10% compared to a year ago during Q3, while real estate costs fell 14%. Those savings counterbalance a 26% rise in technology spending, plus third-party data, which ticked up somewhat unexpectedly in Q3. So we believe every one of our expense categories is fairly firmly in hand. What made the margin look especially favorable in Q3 was a lower bonus accrual. Naturally, that accrual will track how we perform against our ASV completion. That leaves a handful of additional levers available to us. I'd say we've been managing things extremely diligently. Still, I don't anticipate any significant cost reduction initiatives on the horizon. We're quite content with our current position. And we mapped all of this out to align with what Helen is projecting on the revenue side for Q4, so we consider ourselves to be in a solid spot. As you observed, our outlook for adjusted operating margin has risen 70 to 80 basis points across the remainder of the year. So our confidence in these moves is high. And my apologies for the audio problems here.
Craig Huber
analystLet me ask something fairly wide-ranging. What's your current take on the customers on both the sell side and the buy side that you're dealing with in the market — do you get the sense you're simply drifting along at the lowest point, that the worst has already passed? Speaking generally, how would you characterize the situation you're in at the moment? Put another way, do you believe you've hit rock bottom and it's only a question of when things pick back up again?
Frederick Snow
executiveThat's a tough thing to forecast, Craig. I'll kick things off, and I suspect Helen might want to add something. For many businesses, 2024 was essentially framed as the period for trimming expenses. So a great number of budgets were basically locked in toward the close of last year, and plenty of organizations across many sectors, ours included, had people removing costs. There is a sense that matters are becoming more positive with our clients. From what I hear when talking with our sales force and customers, it appears those efforts that had been put on hold are starting to revive; however, I wouldn't count on any genuine favorable momentum from the end markets until possibly the following calendar year. As for what we see at present — I'd say I was limited in what I could do for the remainder of the calendar year. Helen?
Helen Shan
executiveAbsolutely, I see your point. Forecasting is clearly tough given how markets move. Still, what stands out is the weakness in banking, the heavy attrition driven by clients merging their costs, and naturally the pushback on certain bigger initiatives. At this point, our assumption is that this pattern holds for the remainder of the year, which echoes what Phil said. As I mentioned earlier, this marks the first quarter where net seasonal hiring in banking has come in above the prior year, though I wouldn't necessarily treat that as a signal that we've hit the floor.
Craig Huber
analystLinda, I've got a quick administrative item to ask you about. Regarding your bonus accruals, what figure did each of the initial 3 quarters of this year show? My recollection is that it ran $24 million to $25 million per quarter during the prior year. What did the first 3 quarters of this year come in at? Apologies for the bookkeeping inquiry.
Linda Huber
executiveNo problem at all, Craig. My microphone has just been swapped out. I'm feeling somewhat like Taylor Swift right now. With any luck, it functions properly. The accrual for bonuses in our first quarter totaled $30 million. Within that was a $3 million addition meant to partially make up ground relative to 2023. Craig, the second quarter came to $20 million. For the third quarter, the figure is $18 million. As for the fourth quarter, our expectation is a figure somewhere between $15 million and $16 million, contingent on where ASV lands when we close out; that adds up to approximately $83 million in bonus across the entire year. During the previous year, the bonus total for the whole year came to roughly $105 million. The regrettable pattern we're seeing is that adjustments to bonus are forced by ASV results, which make up around 2/3 of the bonus formula, with margin accounting for the remaining 1/3. I trust that provides the specifics you were after, Craig.
Russell Quelch
analystI'd like to dig a bit deeper into the private market segment. Many of your rivals are likewise aiming at this space for expansion. So would you mind doing us a kindness and spelling out your product goals in this area, how you plan to prevail over these other players pursuing growth; and the second part of my question is, word recently circulated that a major established player in this space is up for sale; so might that be something you'd consider to speed up your standing and expansion here?
Frederick Snow
executiveYes. Thank you, Russell. So indeed, we haven't hesitated to discuss this. And we've been putting money in consistently since 2019 in private markets. We've expanded, I think, our coverage from roughly $4 million to $8 million or $9 million. So that's a doubling. The quality keeps improving. We bought Cobalt, as you'll recall. And we're simply carrying on working with numerous partners across the ecosystem; so I believe this is a significant area. Private credit, clearly, matters and is something we're examining; and clearly, we cannot discuss any deals that might or might not exist at present.
Heather Balsky
analystFirst, on ASV growth, could you give some detail on what you're currently observing regarding price compared with volume, and how that lines up against what you'd anticipated for the year? Then the second, broader question — and I realize you've just mentioned the possibility that this sluggishness carries on through year-end. I know it's been extremely difficult to gain visibility in this kind of environment, but when you consider the rebound, given what you've observed, how do you expect things to come back? Or might we get a U- or V-shaped recovery? Do you have the impression that your clients will proceed very slowly, simply because of all the uncertainty you've faced? Any perspective you can offer would be useful.
Helen Shan
executiveCertainly. I'll take that one first, Heather. This is Helen. I appreciate the question. Broadly speaking, one factor behind certain deals slipping is their magnitude. So regarding volume and pricing, in fact, interestingly enough, our volume — that is, the count of transactions — is significantly greater this year compared with last year. And I'd say the strongest increase is in the low to mid figures, possibly reaching 20% greater by the time we reach the end of the year. What that implies is that on average, volume is lower when it comes to transaction size; so, as you can imagine, growing that requires bigger deals. So these larger transactions, which carry a very large number of opportunities, but when they aren't converted within that quarter, that's the situation we're facing at the moment. So I believe it all connects: greater volume at a lower average price right now, in terms of opportunity size alone. As for where we ultimately bottom out, that's quite difficult to predict. I think it differs depending on firm type. Historically, we've observed banking responding fastest. We had believed that would improve during the latter half of this year. That isn't happening, so we'll need to watch how it develops. As Phil said earlier, it depends on where we land if capital markets recover. But technology is really the primary force at present. And so, as clients seek to upgrade and as we witnessed after COVID, once they're prepared to spend, choices tend to be made faster; so I believe it will depend heavily on market conditions.
Frederick Snow
executiveWhat I'd like to do is jump in here and make the point that creating our own tailwinds is something we're responsible for. So no matter what happens with end markets, our total addressable market sits at $28 billion, as it's historically been defined. A portion of that — 1/8 — is now starting to become available to us thanks to the feed products we're developing; and picking up on Helen's point, my sense is that as companies choose to outsource more when it comes to technology and even managed services, that addressable market expands. Honestly, then, there's no lack of addressable market; and my belief is that businesses positioned strongly going into this can generate some tailwinds of their own even with what the market is handing us.
Guru Sidaarth
analystThis is Guru filling in for Owen. I'd like to ask about the deep sector product. I believe the most recent significant news came in Q1, when it assisted in pushing out a rival in banking. So is there anything new to share? Since this genuinely looks like it might be a strong catalyst sitting right behind AI; so any fresh details or observations on that front?
Frederick Snow
executiveJust a bit, Guru. Appreciate the question. So indeed, we're definitely making gradual progress here. As I understand it, we currently cover 8 sectors reasonably well, plus more than 80 reports are available in the workstation. And I think we're also putting together some feed agreements. So we have an active pipeline, and this is a key thing that most banks are looking for these days when renewals come around; so honestly, I'd say only 1 or 2 of us in the market actually offer this in banking.
Scott Wurtzel
analystLet me return to the wealth segment for a moment. Could you perhaps give some sense of how overall demand on the wealth side stacks up against what you're seeing from institutional buy side and sell side? I know you mentioned modest growth this quarter, but I'd really like to hear a characterization of overall demand and how it compares with some of the other end markets you serve.
Frederick Snow
executiveHonestly, Scott, I'd call it the healthiest one for us. Thanks for asking. We've got a very active pipeline there, with deals across a range of sizes. We're beginning to develop some compelling workflows that extend past what we've offered in recent years, and now that certain AI tools have been rolled out, I believe our position is quite strong, which makes me quite hopeful regarding wealth and regarding our capacity to speed up going forward. To wrap up, we feel our strategy and product portfolio leave us favorably situated to take advantage of the industry megatrends that continue unfolding and to benefit once end markets turn more favorable. I appreciate all the excellent questions you've asked today. We look forward to seeing everyone in September. Operator, that concludes today's call.
Operator
operatorWe appreciate everyone joining us on today's call. That brings the program to an end. You're welcome to hang up at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete FactSet Research Systems Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to FactSet Research Systems Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in FactSet Research Systems Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.