Frontline plc (FRO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 20, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Robert Macleod
executiveMany thanks. Good morning, and good afternoon to everybody. To begin with, I apologize that we began this call late, something caused by technical problems. So, at the outset, I want to say thank you to the people working ashore and the members of our crews for what they have done, which goes well beyond the ordinary, and for their commitment. Those people are plainly among the key reasons our results are so strong. In the first three months of 2020, Frontline posted its best showing since 2008, and for the second quarter we already have firm bookings. It has been a remarkable period, quite a wild ride, yet tanker earnings stayed extremely robust in the middle of a global situation unlike anything seen before. Let us begin by turning to slide three, if you would, and take a fast look at the Q1 highlights. We earned net income of $165.3 million, equal to $0.84 per share — definitely a strong quarter. Once non-cash items are excluded, net income came to $179.3 million; the $7.1 million of profit tied to better results at Suezmaxes is left out of those numbers. Frontline's board declared a dividend of $0.70. The previous payout was $0.40, declared for Q4 of 2019. VLCCs earned roughly $75,000 during Q1, and for Q2 we have fixed 75% of the days at $92,500. Suezmaxes earned $57,800 in Q1, and for Q2 we have booked a bit more than 60%, at slightly below $72,000. LR2s earned a little above $30,000 in Q1 and are a bit more than 50% covered for Q2 at approximately $50,000. Turning to finance, we completed the $544 million ICBC credit facility covering the 10 Suezmaxes. Now, before we get into the tanker markets, I would like to pass the call to Inger. Please walk us through the financials.
Inger Klemp
executiveRobert, thank you. Greetings, everyone, and good afternoon as well as good morning. Turning to slide four, we can take a look at the income statement. During the first quarter, our total operating revenues, net of voyage expenses, came to $289 million, and EBITDA, after adjustments for certain non-cash items, reached $234 million. Net income at Frontline was $165.3 million, equivalent to $0.84 per share, while net income adjusted for certain non-cash items stood at $179.3 million, or $0.91 per share, in that same first quarter. When we look at net income for Q1, it does not include the $7.1 million in net cash received plus accrued profit share connected to the five charter-in and charter-out agreements with Trafigura — those were instead recorded as a reduction of the acquisition cost of the vessels. In this quarter, non-cash items added up to a net total of $14 million, which consisted of a $5.4 million unrealized loss on marketable securities, a $15.8 million loss on derivatives, a $1.2 million gain from our equity method investments, $1.8 million on settlement of claim, and a $4.2 million gain on termination of the lease from Front Takata <<inaudible>>. Looking at the first quarter against the fourth quarter of 2019, adjusted EBITDA came in $17 million higher, while adjusted net income was up by $72 million. That $72 million gain in net income for Q1 largely comes down to a stronger time charter result, driven by the higher TCE rates we reported this quarter compared with the one before. Turning now to slide five, let's go through the balance sheet. When you look at how the balance sheet shifted between the close of March 2020 and December 31st, 2019, the main driver is a $54 million rise in cash and cash equivalents. That figure nets out several things: CapEx payments, debt repayment, debt drawdown, cash flow from operations, and dividend payment. Beyond that, newbuilding went up by $21 million, which comes from installments paid during the quarter. We also saw vessels increase by $278 million, tied to the five vessels on TCL <<inaudible>> to Trafigura, which we put on the balance sheet when the acquisition closed on March 16 this year. Additionally, our short- and long-term debt went up by $484 million, which came from drawing on the $544 million facility with ICBCL, though repayments during the quarter partially offset that. Our short- and long-term obligations under finance leases declined by $298 million, largely because the five Trafigura vessels became owned vessels when the deal closed on March 16, 2020. Equity also rose by $94 million, driven mostly by net income for the quarter, with cash dividends providing an offset. Frontline ended the first quarter of 2020 with $392 million in cash and cash equivalents as of March 31st. That figure takes into account the amounts we haven't drawn yet from our unsecured loan facility, along with marketable securities and the minimum cash we're required to hold. When March wrapped up, we still owed $282 million for newbuilding capital expenditures. That remaining amount is tied to one Suezmax tanker, which was handed over to us on May 19, and a VLCC that should arrive in June 2020. On top of those two vessels, we have four LR2 tankers on order, scheduled for delivery in January, March, and October of 2021, and then January 2022, following that sequence. For these newbuildings, we figure debt capacity of roughly $239 million; against that, in May we drew $42 million from the term loan facility with Credit Suisse that was entered into in November 2019, funding the Suezmax tanker delivery from <<inaudible>>. Within short-term or long-term debt, there are maturities of about $310 million tied to the $500 million facility maturing in December 2020, along with roughly $40 million maturing under the $60.6 million facility that comes due in March 2021. Refinancing of the $500 million facility is underway, and in May of this year we signed a term loan facility with Nordea totaling $50 million, aimed at refinancing the $40 million due in March 2021. As Robert mentioned, during March 2020 we entered into an arrangement to sell and lease back assets for $544 million with ICBCL. After that, in April 2020, we paid down $60 million of the $275 million senior unsecured facility agreement we hold with a Hemen affiliate, which left up to $215 million still accessible under that facility once the repayment was made. Then, in May, we executed a senior secured term loan facility with Crédit Agricole worth as much as $62.5 million, which helped fund a portion of the VLCC being built at Hyundai. Let's now turn to slide six for a closer examination of cash breakeven rates and OpEx. Looking at 2020, our projected cash cost breakeven comes to roughly $22,000 each day for VLCCs, $18,600 per day for Suezmax tankers, and $15,000 daily for LR2 tankers, while the fleet-wide average works out to approximately $18,600 per day. Those figures represent the all-in daily rates our ships must bring in to handle budgeted operating costs along with dry dock estimated interest expenses, time charter and bareboat hire installments on loans, and G&A expenses. The graph on the right-hand portion of this slide displays incremental cash flow after debt service on both a yearly and per-share basis, assuming achieved rates of $10,000 per day, $20,000, $30,000, and $40,000 per day above our cash breakeven rates, respectively. Those numbers include ships that are out on time charter, and the window we're looking at runs 365 days beginning April 1, 2020. To give you an example, if the fleet's average cash cost breakeven comes to $18,600 a day and we add $30,000 on top of that, the average fleet TCE rate works out to $48,600 a day, and under those conditions Frontline would generate cash flow per share after debt service of $3.65; with that, I'll turn it back over to Robert.
Robert Macleod
executiveOkay, thanks so much, Inger. Let's go to slide 7, if we could. Q1 was definitely a turbulent stretch. When the coronavirus outbreak moved around the world, old metrics such as ton miles and refinery runs got pushed aside because a fresh, potent force appeared. When imports of crude into China started falling, the market swung up hard, since the anticipated output reductions never happened and instead Saudi Arabia, Russia, and the UAE pushed volumes higher. In shipping, we saw the most active chartering stretch of my professional life, with charterers racing to secure vessels. Because worldwide oil use fell quickly owing to lockdowns everywhere, output quickly exceeded what was needed. Usually, weaker demand could push freight rates down, but this time it caused a spike, since storing oil on ships became one answer. Conditions were far from typical, and the pace and depth of the decline had the reverse effect on tanker rates, as an unprecedented rise in oil and water caused freight rates to strengthen considerably. On the slide's chart, we can see demand falling away faster than supply cutbacks, which meant inventories piled up at a record pace, onshore and offshore. These shifts in worldwide oil commerce occurred extremely fast. How trade evolves from here depends on the speed of demand recovery, its extent, and how rapidly output changes. Obviously, that's extremely difficult to forecast. I'll return to that on the last slide, but first let's examine worldwide fleet capacity. Now slide 8, please. Capacity growth for the worldwide fleet is decelerating. Growth in the global tanker fleet is a major factor behind long-term earnings, and the order book sits at a level last observed in 1997. Several elements underpin our view that order books will stay depressed through the next 24 months. Besides the record-low order book, note that 24% of VLCC fleets exceed 15 years of age during this year. The gap between customers and modern tonnage keeps widening, which leaves Frontline's fleet well positioned. We also anticipate that vessel off-hire will keep having a significant effect on fleet capacity during this year, since many ships are scheduled for periodic dry dock, and a fair number have lately received short extensions, yet that's merely a temporary delay; the servicing still has to be done. Right now everyone is focused on inventory draws. Vessel supply might deliver a major surprise in the latter half of 2020 and into 2021; we're monitoring it closely. Turning to the current market and some outlook. Oil demand has been called destroyed in recent months; we believe suppressed fits the situation better, since we think the fall in oil demand is only temporary. Those production curtailments we've seen lately hit right away and they're genuine, there's simply no question about that, and they've pushed freight rates down. Turning to oil consumption, the past few weeks have brought some unexpected developments. Gasoline demand out of China has come in higher than what we saw in 2019, and fresh data from India likewise points to a strong bounce back in gasoline sales. It comes as little shock that Asia is out front when it comes to demand rebounding, while the U.S. will probably bounce back more quickly than Europe will. As for floating storage, our current estimate sits at roughly 200 million barrels afloat, and we may be nearing the top. We anticipate an unwinding of floating storage over the remainder of 2020. Aframaxes sitting in Europe will probably be the first to discharge; a number of them already have, whereas VLCCs will likely stay tied up under a longer-dated structure. This is entirely guesswork; naturally, given the demand-side headlines we've had lately, it's possible the production cuts get reversed as soon as the second half of 2020. One thing that must be said: volatility is going to keep going forward — going forward, pardon me, much the same as what we've experienced this year. So to wrap up, Frontline has the youngest fleet and the lowest breakeven level in the company's entire history; and 2020 is looking like a terrific year for Frontline and for its shareholders. With that, operator, let's open it up to questions, please.
Jon Chappell
analystThanks. Morning Rob — or good afternoon, and good afternoon to you too, Inger. I've got three questions today. With any luck, each one will be fairly brief. Rob, you folks did an excellent job walking through how the accounting works on a quarter-to-date basis and sort of how that shakes out; so with the 75% you've completed at over $90,000 a day, could you just help us frame what we ought to be considering for the remaining 25%? Clearly, the markets have declined, but those ballast days always show up. And looking at 1Q, if we take what you had to-date and then fold it back into the $74,800, it appears it was actually negative across the last 17% of the days. So I'm not requesting guidance or an exact figure, but is it nearer to what's key to this today, nearer to zero, or somewhere in the middle, just so we can frame how the second quarter will sort of take shape?
Inger Klemp
executiveClearly, that's hard to forecast, but there will be certain ballast days toward the end of the quarter, which will bring it down. It will also be brought down somewhat by — but the rates right now are softer than what has contracted so far for the 25%. So — but providing you an exact figure or anything along those lines is tough or very, very — that isn't doable in a sense, so I apologize for that.
Jon Chappell
analystAll right. Perhaps I could put it differently — regarding the ballast days you expect over the remainder of the second quarter, would they look like those of a typical quarter-end, would there be a greater number, a smaller number, or just — ?
Inger Klemp
executiveIt fluctuates. From one quarter to another, the count of ballast days shifts; however, during this particular quarter, the figure was in fact rather elevated; take the VLCCs, for instance, where it reached 319 ballast days, which represented an increase over the quarter before.
Jon Chappell
analystAll right, that helps. Rob, regarding the fleet, this is clearly a matter we're monitoring quite closely and we're really hoping it brings about the next genuine lasting upturn, rather than just temporary spikes. Earlier this week I was told the Korean yards are getting desperate. Right now, our hope is that they'd get filled up with LNG carriers from Qatar. Yet we hear things are turning somewhat more desperate on the VLCC side — can you say whether or not you're getting word from the yards? And beyond that, Frontline and your biggest shareholder in particular were somewhat early in placing orders at appealing prices. So, if the Koreans truly are getting aggressive on pricing, what's your appetite for ordering vessels at present?
Robert Macleod
executiveWell, at the yards, whatever the timing may have been, I'd describe it as desperate, yet pricing has declined and we've observed that there's been almost no ordering as of late. As for Frontline and our interest, we hold a constructive view of the tanker markets in 2020 and 2021. So, all our interest lies further out in 2022, when resources are available and other opportunities exist, and in that case I think I'd say the primary focus is there, and ordering newbuildings isn't something on our radar.
Jon Chappell
analystAll right. Thank you. So, moving to the final item. Given how you work with European banks, I doubt anyone questions whether Frontline can secure credit facilities. Right now the world is quite unpredictable and everything is strained, so $310 million is a fairly substantial amount. Regarding when that refinancing will happen before December 2020, what ought we to keep in mind? How are you framing those talks? Also, that $100 million ATM mentioned in the press release — clearly you noted you were new to today's prices. But are you considering setting it up simply as a precaution, in case the financing market turns very tough during this uncertain period?
Robert Macleod
executiveBacking the company, I believe, is quite straightforward — regarding Mr. Fredriksen and the access to finance, our confidence is completely full, and in no way whatsoever is the ATM connected to this. The ATM is more or less housekeeping; it's an instrument we've had before, and as we plainly said, at the current share price it isn't something we would even consider using.
Inger Klemp
executiveNo, but also, to address what you asked — like I mentioned, we recently completed a few financings in the market, and we refinanced that Nordea facility. So we're not really worried about being unable to refinance the $500 million facility either; it's just about attempting to, say, get the best terms possible, maximize or improve them if that can be done. But the financing is available, so there's no issue.
Jon Chappell
analystAll right. Inger, thank you. And thanks to you, Rob.
Randy Giveans
analystHello there, Rob and Inger. How are you doing?
Inger Klemp
executiveWe're doing fine. And how are things with you?
Randy Giveans
analystThings are going well, thanks. Alright, I've got a couple of quick items. In Q4, you declared a $0.40 dividend, and with EPS at $0.60, that works out to roughly 66%. Then in Q1, the dividend came in at $0.70 against EPS of, say, $0.91, which is around 75%. Is there a set dividend policy you can point to from here on out? I'm just wondering about 2Q and further out.
Inger Klemp
executiveIn a sense, our approach to dividends hasn't been altered. There's a statement posted on our site that essentially describes us as being there to distribute, in a broad sense, the excess cash flow — either matching it or coming near to it. And naturally, the Board, of course, also retains the ability to make choices that reduce risk, so to speak, and what we've factored in is, naturally, whatever CapEx program is underway at a given moment, plus any other modifications that must be weighed, such as non-cash items. So I suppose that's essentially it — that's the way things stand.
Randy Giveans
analystWhen it comes to the second quarter of 2020, ought we to anticipate roughly the same EPS, at a minimum somewhere around 50% or 60% of that figure?
Inger Klemp
executiveMy apologies, I'm not sure I quite caught what you were asking.
Randy Giveans
analystWhen it comes to Q2, should we reasonably anticipate yet another payout at 50% or more — perhaps 60% of EPS?
Robert Macleod
executiveRandy, regarding the second quarter, my sense is that we'll find out whatever the Board decides and puts forward during August. If you look at what this company has done over time, we've now paid out considerably more than $6 billion since listing in the U.S., and my belief is that neither the company nor the Board intends to deviate from that pattern and record. Our aim is to continue expanding on it — examining the business, examining our position regarding cash breakevens, examining our recent performance on time charters, and, combined with our positive outlook on the markets, plus a fleet whose average age sits at slightly above 4 years. My view is that we have all the potential needed to deliver strong results moving forward. And when it comes to your question, I believe the track record speaks for itself as the finest response.
Randy Giveans
analystAll right. Next, regarding your Aframax and LR2 vessels: throughout the majority of Q1, Aframax crude tanker rates beat LR2s. Yet during April, crude rates dropped somewhat, while LR2s reached record peaks. So at present, roughly how many of your LR2 product tankers are deployed in crude or dirty trade? Also, could you discuss that market a bit — what drove that surge in rates, followed by the subsequent drop back to around $40,000 per day?
Robert Macleod
executiveThat's an excellent and pertinent question. What you're describing actually also occurred during the latter half of 2019. Aframaxes were beating LR2s, and there were certainly moments when I regretted not having put more LR2s into dirty trade. Still, across the two segments, we clearly have 18 LR2s altogether. We're running 11 clean and seven dirty, and luckily in recent months, LR2s have somewhat recovered in earnings — we haven't checked the precise figures, but they're likely to end up not far from matching what's occurred lately. As for the LR2 market, I find it extremely hard even to say how it's performed during the past couple of months. It's been — I've never witnessed anything comparable. I'd characterize the LR2 surge as more extreme in relative terms than the VLCC surge was. There are many delays in our segments. Regarding LR2 count, the fleet is just 23%, 24% of VLCCs by number. So the moment many vessels are delayed or stuck on storage or full storage, you get these massive spikes. Thus, I believe the extremely high rates we also saw on VLCCs occur on just a few fixtures. But during the last month or two, it's been remarkable. So it's stabilizing now, yet it remains at a quite healthy level. Still, it's extremely hard to forecast how this will continue. But it appears that although there are indications, as I mentioned earlier, that demand is returning, particularly in — in Asia, then Europe and the U.S. will continue to struggle. So, you'll essentially be compelled to store for quite some time.
Randy Giveans
analystAll right, and how do your Aframaxes and LR2s break down between crude and clean?
Robert Macleod
executiveWe have eleven LR2s and seven Afras.
Randy Giveans
analystEleven LR2s and seven Afras — that's great. Then one last short thing about Hemen: it appears you've reduced half of it, bringing $120 million down to around $60 million — do you intend to pay off what's left in Q2?
Robert Macleod
executiveCorrect. So that has been — we're moving from $120 million to $60 million. Additional repayments haven't been settled yet, but once that situation arises, we'll update you.
Randy Giveans
analystRight, that covers everything from my side. I appreciate it very much.
Greg Lewis
analystThanks, and a good morning or good afternoon to everyone. Rob, you brought up certain newbuildings currently taking shape at yards. Obviously, a portion of those belong to parties with stronger balance sheets, while others are held by weaker ones. Describing the opening stretch of 2020 has made for quite a fascinating exercise. So what does demand look like from possible tonnage sellers? Has it shifted at all, or has it moved during recent weeks, given that we seem to have now landed in a steady, robust market sitting near $50,000 per day? The splashy $200,000 figures aren't showing up anymore, yet it remains an appealing market. Has this relaxed things, or generated greater curiosity, or a rise in — perhaps not completed physical transactions — but in activity, or buyers asking questions, or interest within the S&P space?
Robert Macleod
executiveGreg, I believe you've hit on a genuinely intriguing point. Honestly, I have never witnessed a situation like this one. Regarding S&P, what has unfolded during this year has truly astonished me. A straightforward illustration: typically, when the freight market climbs to a point where you can depreciate a purchase by over $10 million — indeed, even $15 million or $20 million within a brief window — there were stretches, for instance, when 12-month charters would depreciate a ship by over $20 million. Even then, we didn't observe a large number of deals. Vessels were put up for sale; we examined a handful, yet the market has been extremely, extremely peculiar, with almost no transactions taking place; and once the rate adjustment arrived, which likewise reduces the depreciation potential at the front end, we find ourselves at quite robust levels still, just as you put it. However, we're witnessing minimal activity, and I hold the view that even should yard prices decline, deal volume will remain thin there too, since we can't overlook that obtaining financing — as we covered in the prior question, and I'd say Frontline's financing access is better than most, never really an issue or obstacle for us; yet for the industry overall, it's tougher, and that has an impact. So — and likewise, as you noted, a fair number of strong players are waiting and likely content to keep waiting, provided they hold the same optimistic outlook we do.
Greg Lewis
analystAlright, excellent. Then one final item from my side. You sort of — and I think this appeared in the prepared remarks, possibly during Jonathan's — one of his questions, but you mentioned ships traveling somewhat more slowly, and that factors into why you chose to push back certain scrubber installations. I'm just curious how we ought to frame that? Obviously fuel prices are currently cheap. So it isn't elevated fuel costs causing slow steaming. And rates are solid, so just — any sort of insight you can offer regarding why slow steaming persists and perhaps what's behind it?
Robert Macleod
executiveI'd say slow steaming, congestion, plus ordinary delays. It's all — if you examine it, part comes from contango, part comes from insufficient space onshore, and all these elements combine and produce this oil on water figure, which has risen nearly 20% this year in terms of how much oil sits on the global tanker fleet. So, breaking down each individual one, I believe it's quite hard to determine how they impacted the overall market, yet this oil on water, which captures all the factors, I find pretty helpful. Regarding the scrubber, in reality, everything we've done is decide to leave the scrubber at our factory and only prepare — while in dry dock only prepare the vessel's underwater portion. So, a modest investment under $100,000. And afterward, when or if the fuel spread comes back, we can move alongside, install the scrubber, and begin using it. So, this spread clearly correlates strongly with the crude flat price, and once that rises, the spread will rise too. So time will tell, but we judged it wise given where rates stood when we made the call, since this also cuts dry dock time by two weeks. So we felt it was the correct choice. We can undo it, but it appears to be right — as you noted, we're still at a fairly good level in terms of earnings.
Greg Lewis
analystAll right, that's helpful. And to piggyback on that really quickly, do we have any way of knowing — and I get that this is a moving target. I'm not certain how you — how Frontline monitors what the typical speed of its fleet is; but I don't know whether we consider it on a month-over-month basis, weekly, daily — is there any way to tell how that typical fleet speed has been trending, however you happen to think about it?
Robert Macleod
executiveBroadly speaking, fleet speed has declined ever since we introduced eco speed. So that's the pace at which — the speed flexibility of the fleets has decreased because of the more economical engine with reduced power. The latent speed, meaning the speed at which we've contracted to carry out voyages, hasn't really shifted. So it's the ballast speed that's the one changing; and beyond that, it's quite straightforward. When the market's slow, you reduce speed to conserve some fuel, and when it's high, as it has been lately, then you rev the engine up to reach load ports as quickly as possible. But in reality, across a year, it doesn't make all that much of a difference. It's a knot or two, but then you consider how many are in ballast. And then you consider how many days the ship is laid up and/or in port; so it's a meaningful factor, though not an enormous one.
Greg Lewis
analystAll right, excellent. I appreciate it, Inger. Thank you, Rob, for making the time.
Omar Nokta
analystThanks. Hello, Robert and Inger. Robert, near the conclusion of your prepared comments, you brought up floating storage and the fact that a number of Aframaxes have exited that storage, though VLCCs are probably going to remain somewhat longer. Looking at it from a market color angle, presumably a portion of the VLCC charters you signed included options for floating storage. Could you describe the shift you're seeing on those charters — whether they're presently sitting in floating storage, or whether the option to do so has been exercised.
Robert Macleod
executiveThat's a fair question. Thanks for that, Omar. Let's start with the Aframaxes. At the high point in Europe, we saw about 35 million barrels. Some of that has since been released — released — and as for the VLCCs, we've completed charters, roughly five or six of them, lasting somewhere between six and 12 months, and these are time charters. So they're not — under these charters, the vessels can trade however they like; they aren't strictly storage charters. As things stand, I think we currently have — one Suez vessel has moved into storage, and one of ours is just about to begin storing, but those are the only two. Beyond that, we have a good number of vessels tied up in what you might call involuntary floating storage, driven by missing cargo origins and similar issues. It remains to be seen where this goes, though word on the street is that a few Aframaxes have come in at three, while on the VLCC side certain cargoes look set to be held through the second and third quarters. And keep in mind that when it comes to risk, traders typically aren't in the business of carrying flat price exposure. The situation is that certain cargoes were offloaded at extremely steep markdowns, and given how robust the container market has been, my guess is that a number of participants have locked in positions on the near end of the forward curves covering the coming two to three months. On top of that, you may have folks who are betting on demand genuinely rebounding as Brent strengthens from here. So it's possible you'll see people holding back and waiting for this upward momentum to carry into later periods, since the scheduling around crude buying over the past few weeks was unusual.
Omar Nokta
analystOkay, that is quite intriguing. That is a valid observation. You are referring to the reductions offered by the Saudis and similar parties. Therefore, one should not only examine the near portion of the curve and the far portion, or the half-year, since a $5 or $10 reduction exists at the outset too.
Robert Macleod
executiveIndeed, precisely. That is when one truly needed to grasp just how constrained the shipping sector had become. There were cargoes in distress, and all at once somebody could secure a vessel, able to meet the dates in West Africa during roughly the following 5 days, and reductions of, let us say, $5 to $10 per barrel would disappear. Then, if you factor in the latest surge in the flat price, it becomes apparent that certain parties hold oil sitting offshore that is extremely, extremely profitable. And a number of them may be prepared to gamble on going even further.
Omar Nokta
analystRight. So, say the contango actually flips and they decide they want a shorter position — how would that play out? If they choose to release the floating storage, does that affect the charter agreement we have with them in any way?
Robert Macleod
executiveNo. Until the earliest redelivery dates arrive, they'd remain obligated to keep that vessel on hire and continue paying us the higher rate. So in a scenario like that, what you'd observe is them attempting to trade the ship in the spot market instead. That said, a lot of the parties who've placed ships into storage know the spot market well, since they own vessels themselves. As a result, they'd shift from being in storage mode to operating as regular spot participants.
Omar Nokta
analystOkay.
Robert Macleod
executiveAs I said before during the presentation, at that point our thinking was that the peak would take us — if you go back a month, our expectation was that the high point for oil stored on vessels would sit at a considerably greater level. What we're being told at present is that we may be near that point, with 200 million barrels afloat. So the downside of that is we aren't getting the extended freight surge we had anticipated. Our expectation is that crude prices stay low and contango remains strong for a longer stretch than it did; yet looking at the other side, it means the crude inventory draw that everyone has discussed over the last month or two, the one seen as the big animal that would wreck the entire market — that volume will be smaller. So there's another side to this recent drop. And because it's smaller than that, it means our return to a more normal freight market will come sooner.
Omar Nokta
analystYes, thank you. Appreciate that context, Robert. Another thing I wanted to ask about is what you mentioned before regarding the LR2s — 11 of them are trading clean, while seven are dirty. What's your view on how that mix will shift moving forward? Last year there was significant pressure to move toward dirty, and now there's plenty of discussion about possibly dirtied LR2s reverting back to clean. How are you evaluating those vessels from this point, say as we look ahead over the next six months?
Robert Macleod
executiveIt's still early, and it really hinges on where the market goes. Broadly speaking, though, for the dirty ships, whenever we find chances to clean them up inexpensively — that would involve condensate cargos and similar things — we'd probably seize those chances. So my sense is there won't be a major shift. That 11/7 split has been in place for a good while. If I had to speculate, I'd say it's more probable that one goes clean and another goes dirty. But that all depends on market conditions. As for how the market has moved so far this year, it's genuinely been a wild roller coaster, and some of the mechanics at play are quite extraordinary. And those 35 million barrels floating in the North Sea or on the continent, on Afras, will ultimately get unwound. So we simply need to watch things very carefully, and we have no issue making swift choices regarding our chartering strategy.
Omar Nokta
analystUnderstood. Okay, that's great. Thank you, Robert, for that. I appreciate it.
Robert Macleod
executiveYou're welcome.
George Burmann
analystHello there, and thanks for letting me join the call. Congrats on a fantastic quarter.
Inger Klemp
executiveThank you.
George Burmann
analystI have a few brief things to ask about the joint ventures you're involved in. There's the one alongside Clean Marine, and then back in January you formed another together with Golden Ocean and Trafigura, I believe regarding fuel supplies. From what I can see, both of them contributed roughly $600,000 each as your portion of the profits. What do you intend to do with these two investments going forward for the company? Is either of them considering an IPO, or else — what sort of returns are you generating from them?
Robert Macleod
executiveAppreciate the question. Starting with the first, Clean Marine, our stake is roughly one-sixth of that business. They build scrubbers, and right now scrubbers aren't selling. That's the reason we installed our own at the factory rather than putting it on a vessel, since everything hinges on the fuel spread. So the business is exploring other options, and we have a completely new plant capable of making a wide range of different products. That's something being examined. For Frontline this is a quite minor investment, and since we're only a passive shareholder, there aren't really any near-term plans there. The Trafigura joint venture is a fuel JV, and it has gotten off to a very strong start. It obtains fuel at the correct price, quality, and timing for our vessels as well as for others across the industry. Our company has therefore seen enormous growth. I'd say the smartest IMO 2020 move we made was definitely teaming up with Trafigura and Golden Ocean to create that business. So we're quite optimistic about it, and I think exciting times could lie ahead for our company; what matters most for the company and for us is staying focused on delivering. Then, as growth arrives, we can make additional plans. That said, neither of these two investments currently has anything in the pipeline.
George Burmann
analystAll right. So, turning to how the market currently values you, it appears many crude transportation businesses, shipping firms, and tanker operators are given very low valuations instead of buying newbuildings or secondhand vessels available in the market. Do you see any chances, perhaps, to combine with other companies whose valuations are even less appealing than yours? I know you —
Robert Macleod
executiveWe definitely keep an eye out for those opportunities. If any company is in a position to consolidate, I believe it's Frontline. So we'll watch for whatever comes along, but the key thing for us is continuing to work hard with our modern fleet. We have the big size, and the Q1 results show that we deliver pretty hefty returns to our shareholders here, and I think that will keep our focus, and in Q2 we made solid bookings. So I think we're in a very good standing; but broadly, I agree with you. Looking at the tanker companies, in general, it doesn't seem to be valued in relation to the earnings.
George Burmann
analystYeah, it feels as though we've got to determine some method for moving the oil through the cloud.
Robert Macleod
executivePrecisely, yes.
George Burmann
analystAll right, thanks a lot, and I’m eager to see what comes next for you.
Robert Macleod
executiveI appreciate that.
Analyst
analystGood afternoon, Robert and Inger. That recent rise in demand coming out of China, and now India as well — did it catch you off guard? Would you say they were perhaps catching up after running inventories down, or do you believe that the appetite they're showing right now is going to continue into the future?
Robert Macleod
executiveJohn, thank you; that's a really, really solid question. It's highly pertinent. Sadly, I don't possess the answer, though I'll offer a guess. What I'd guess is that the demand structures that got described weren't as steep as what the analysts had been forecasting. And I believe the comeback is arriving fast; so, it's possible — plus, the data in this case, the U.S. data, tends to be more accurate; yet it's a trend, and we're picking it up from a number of sources. And it appears Asia is rebounding swiftly, and the Chinese sale on gasoline is encouraging. So, that might suggest the drop in demand wasn't as low and the pickup really is a V, but let's say, the oil market has definitely been hard to forecast as of late.
Analyst
analystAll right. And before we finish, Inger, I noticed from what you said that your throat sounds sore. Might I recommend some hot tea with lemon? In my view, that should help you get better. We need an Inger who's healthy out here.
Inger Klemp
executiveThanks so much.
Robert Macleod
executiveThanks, Irma. With that final remark, I'd say, you know, that's a really nice way to wrap things up, and once more I want to say sorry for the late start; you may also have picked up that the audio quality on this call wasn't what it typically is. So we'll see to it that this doesn't occur again. Thanks to all of you for joining. Wishing you all the very best.
Operator
operatorThanks a lot. Everyone, that wraps up today's call. We appreciate your joining us. You're free to hang up at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Frontline plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Frontline plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Frontline plc or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.