HDFC Asset Management Company Limited (HDFCAMC) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 22, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood day, everyone, and welcome to the HDFC Asset Management Company Limited Q2 FY '21 earnings conference call, hosted by JM Financial Institutional Securities Limited. <<operator_script>> Kindly be aware that this conference is being recorded. I'll now pass the conference to Mr. Sameer Bhise of JM Financial. Thank you, and the floor is yours, sir.
Sameer Bhise
analystThanks, Nirav. Good evening, everyone, and thanks for being on today's call. We also want to extend a big thank-you to the leadership team at HDFC Asset Management Company for letting us host this call. So, without further delay, I'll pass things over to Mr. Simal Kanuga, Chief Investor Relations Officer at HDFC Asset Management Company. Simal, the floor is yours.
Simal Kanuga
executiveThanks, Sameer. Good evening, everyone, and thanks to the JM team for hosting this call. I hope all of you are doing well in these unusual times. The presentation can be found on our website as well as on the exchanges' websites. Milind and Piyush are both here with me. So I'll begin with a brief overview and then take questions, if there are any. Let's begin with an industry update. QA AUM for the quarter just ended stood at INR 27.6 trillion versus INR 25.7 trillion for the quarter ended September 2019, which is a 7.4% increase. Equity QA AUM rose by 3% over the same period. Equity QA AUM posted 14.7% growth on a Q-on-Q basis, driven by the mark-to-market effect. Regarding net new flow in the quarter, equity-oriented funds recorded outflows of INR 165 billion, debt funds brought in INR 938 billion, and liquid funds had outflows of INR 692 billion. On the total MA AUM split between T-30 and B-30, it stands at 84:16. However, for equity MA AUM, the split is 73:27. So 27% of the equity-oriented AUM comes from B-30 locations. Individual investors now represent 52% of total AUM.
Simal Kanuga
executiveSIP flows, based on what AMFI reports, have stayed resilient, totaling INR 78 billion during September. Now, turning to our own figures. For the quarter that closed in September 2020, our average mutual fund AUM came to INR 3,755 billion, roughly on par with September of 2019. Actively managed equity-oriented QA AUM reached INR 1,436 billion this quarter, compared with INR 1,610 billion in September 2019 and INR 1,293 billion for the quarter ending June 2020 — that's a Y-o-Y decline of 11% and a Q-on-Q increase of 11%. Our debt AUM has grown healthily, from INR 1,057 billion in September '19 to INR 1,212 billion in September of 2020. The June quarter figure was INR 992 billion. So year on year we've grown 15%, and quarter on quarter 22%. Liquid funds AUM fell 4% on a Y-o-Y basis and 16% on a Q-on-Q basis. Equity-oriented assets make up 39% of our QA AUM, with 61% in nonequity-oriented assets. For the industry, that split is 37.5:62.5. We now serve 9.3 million live accounts and 5.5 million unique investors, working through more than 65,000 distribution partners, 223 branches and 1,176 employees. Our customer base spans the country and reaches 98% of PIN codes in India.
Simal Kanuga
executiveBeyond our mutual fund AUM, portfolio management services and separately managed accounts together total INR 98 billion. For QA AUM market share in the quarter just ended: overall market share came in at 13.6%; actively managed equity-oriented market share was 14.1%; debt stood at 13.4%; and liquid was at 18.7%. Our individual MA AUM is 55.2% versus 52% for the industry. In individual AUM, our market share is 14.1%, the highest in the industry. 26% of the mutual fund industry's unique customers have invested with us. For us, flows driven by systematic transactions totaled INR 9 billion for the month of September 2020. As we said on the last quarterly call, the figure we report reflects actual cash flows rather than registrations. On B-30 market share, we continue to hold the second position. Details of the B-30 asset mix, et cetera, at industry level are also included in the presentation. We keep strengthening our digital platform and have now built top of the line digital infrastructure. 87% of our transactions in the current financial year have been processed electronically. That figure is somewhat higher because all transactions were processed digitally during the lockdown period.
Simal Kanuga
executiveTypically, we’re seeing 50,000 logins each day on our MF online platform, along with more than 50 fresh user registrations every hour. Now I’ll turn to the financials for the quarter that ended September 30, 2020. During the first quarter, our financial performance showed a deteriorating trend because of COVID-19’s impact on the markets. Although uncertainty remains about how the pandemic will ultimately play out, markets have stabilized, and our financial performance in this quarter has improved. That’s clear from the sequential betterment in our profit parameters and also in our operating profit margin, which rose from 34 basis in the quarter ended June 30, 2020, to 37 basis points in the September ’20 quarter. Normally, we compare figures with similar quarters from the prior year, but given the COVID-19 reset, we think sequential comparisons are just as relevant, so we have provided both. The company’s operating profit for the quarter ended September 30, 2020, was INR 3,491 million. Although that is 7% below the operating profit of INR 3,765 million for the quarter ended September 2019, it is 16% above the operating profit of INR 3,006 million for the quarter ended June 30, 2020.
Simal Kanuga
executiveFor the quarter that closed on September 30, 2020, profit before tax came in at INR 4,628 million. That's 8% above the INR 4,275 million profit before tax recorded for the quarter ended September 2019, and it's 22% above the INR 3,804 million profit before tax posted for the quarter ended June 30, 2020. Profit after tax for the quarter ended September 30, 2020, stood at INR 3,379 million. That figure is 8% below the INR 3,683 million profit after tax for the quarter ended September 30, 2019, but 12% above the PAT of INR 3,024 million for the quarter ended June 30, 2020. Because of a change in the taxation rate, during the quarter ended September 30, 2019, an approximate tax benefit of INR 343 million relating to the quarter ended June 30, 2019, was taken into account in the following quarter. As a result, normalized profit after tax for the quarter ended September 30, 2019, came to INR 3,340 million, versus INR 3,379 million for the quarter ended September 30, 2020. This is -- this produces a rise of 1%. Turning to the half yearly financials. Operating profit for the half year ended September 30, 2020, was INR 6,497 million, compared with INR 7,580 million for the half year ended September 30, 2019, which is a decline of 14%.
Simal Kanuga
executiveProfit before tax for the six months that ended September 30, 2020, came in at INR 8,432 million. That compares with INR 8,574 million for the half year ended September 30, 2019, which works out to a 2% decline. Profit after tax for the half year ended September 30, 2020, fell 3% to INR 6,403 million, against INR 6,600 million in the half year ended September 30, 2019. Before we take questions, I want to make 2 additional points. During our previous call, Milind noted that we plan to, and have been working to, cut costs even further. Total expenses across the first 6 months of the current year amounted to INR 2,180 million, versus INR 2,444 million, a decrease of INR 264 million. That figure includes INR 95 million less in fees and commissions, which stems from the fading amortization of the old upfront commission and therefore will not come back. For this quarter, total costs stood at INR 1,071 million, compared with INR 1,215 million in the quarter ended September 2019, a saving of INR 144 million. Second, you will have observed the higher other income this quarter, or for that matter across the first 6 months of the current financial year.
Simal Kanuga
executiveSo, as all of you know, the company owns certain nonconvertible debentures of the SL Group, and those are secured by a pledge of listed equity shares. When we fair-valued the NCDs as of September 30, 2020, the unrealized gain that was recognized in the results for the half year ended September '20 comes to INR 649.21 million, and that figure includes INR 91.21 million for the quarter ended June 30, 2020. As of September 30, 2020, the carrying value of these NCDs stood at INR 943.43 million. The collateral's value as of September 30, 2020, is INR 1,347.75 million. Let me pause there. Milind, Piyush and I would be glad to take your questions, if there are any.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Our first question comes from Saurabh Kumar, who is on the line from JPMorgan.
Saurabh Kumar
analystSir, just 2 questions. The first concerns that other income of INR 110 crores. During this quarter, you recognized INR 55 crores from the NCD fair valuation. Is that right?
Milind Barve
executiveCorrect, yes. Around INR 56 crores, that's right.
Saurabh Kumar
analystAll right, so the yield on your cash comes out to roughly 6-odd percent. I mean, that 6% is what you'll get as other income on your cash, correct?
Milind Barve
executiveRight. Looking at the whole book, if you strip out the revaluation, or strip out the gain from marking the SL exposure to market, our income comes to roughly 5.7% or 5.8% — at least after tax, yes — and that's pretty healthy.
Saurabh Kumar
analystAll right, and then the second thing, sir, relates to your market share. I mean, if you could just weigh in — we've noticed your share has slipped once more, both versus the prior quarter and even compared with a year earlier, in individual active management and in the SIP book as well. I mean, if you could just say something about what you're observing there?
Milind Barve
executiveSure, let me break it down into the 3 asset groups we operate in, which are mainly equity, debt and liquid. Within equity funds, our market share has dipped somewhat compared with a year earlier. That's partly because of fund performance — I think it isn't quite what people expect from us, and I'll get into that while answering other questions or even right now. Still, I believe we continue to be the biggest manager of actively managed equity funds, with a meaningful gap over the #2 player in actively managed equity funds. Our market share of the book relative to AUM remains fairly decent. The second area where market share matters, where the equity volume of industry AUM comes into play, is debt within the fixed income business. On the fixed income side, during the first quarter we faced a bit of a challenge on market share because — as you're aware — due to a problem at one of the fund houses, there were sizable redemptions in credit funds across the industry as well as for us. That challenge has now faded, has disappeared — it's no longer present.
Milind Barve
executiveAnd we've done a pretty — actually, we've had a really strong catch-up when it comes to market share this quarter in the debt side of the fixed income product range. So, as you will notice, on both a quarter-over-quarter basis and a year-over-year basis, our share of the market in debt products has stayed quite stable, and it's genuinely pretty high. In the third category — the liquid fund — market share has dipped slightly, but you need to remember that a year ago, our share had climbed above 20%. The explanation for that was that this came roughly 1 year after the IL&FS crisis hit the financial markets. And people had moved a great deal of money into liquid funds, with a flight toward quality and safety, and we benefited substantially from that. Now, I think more money is being allocated across different fund houses. That said, we still hold an 18%-plus market share in the liquid fund, and ours is, by far, the largest in the industry. From what I understand, it exceeds the #2 liquid fund's size by more than INR 15,000 crores.
Milind Barve
executiveWe hold a very dominant position in market share in the liquid fund industry. To summarize, yes, on the equity side there's some catch-up we need to do in terms of market share. On debt, our market share has been stable to improving over the last quarter, so we're quite okay there. In liquid funds, we're by far the largest. There might appear to be a slight decline in market share, and we're quite comfortable with that, because we remain by far the largest. I mean, you can imagine that an 18% market share isn't something easy to -- or a 20% market share isn't easy to retain or maintain. So it has just slipped to 18%, and we don't see much of an issue there. So coming to the first question, yes, we do have some challenge when it comes to market share on equity products. We think equity fund performances, like cycles in the market, do go through certain cycles where fund performances lag behind not just the benchmark or sometimes the peer. I think we're in that phase where equity performances in some of our large products are a little soft. Having said that, we understand this and are very confident that over a period of time, this -- we will see a return.
Milind Barve
executiveWe’ve been through this kind of situation before — in 2007, in 2000, and in 2013 — when a number of the key calls we made didn’t work out. So we are — we believe that with what we’re working on, and I’ll get to that right up front and will probably address some of the questions we can anticipate. A couple of things to address regarding the investment performance of our equity fund. First, we have set out, together with our investment team, a very clearly understood road map to build a product range that has diversification of style. I mentioned that on my call last quarter as well. What I mean by diversification of style is that for a large fund house like ours, if you have 7 or 8 or 9 different investment styles, apart from products like mid-caps and small caps, which carry their own distinctive styles and their own distinctive mandates, then it matters that we have at least 4 or 5 or 6 differentiated approaches across our fund products. The idea is that we hedge ourselves so that at any point in time, we could have 2 or 3 that will do well, 2 or 3 that might be in the middle of the pack, and indeed, 1 or 2 that might be lagging.
Milind Barve
executiveThe core concept here is that across a span of time, we build a distinctive method for equity investing across the various investment products offered to our customers. With those goals in mind, this isn't merely talk — just words in the air or something written on paper. We've brought on board 2 new fund managers who joined our fund house bringing a clearly distinct investment style. Among our current funds as well, one fund is currently in the midst of being carved out substantially over a span of time, and another 2 funds that look quite alike will likewise have their investment styles separated over the coming 1 or 2 quarters. We also have other funds that are, naturally, category-specific, handling either mid-cap or small cap, so each carries a particular mandate that must be adhered to. That said, we think that with this, over the medium to longer term — it might not occur by the next quarter, but over the medium to longer term — we will correct the situation we're in where our funds may hold certain views or certain kinds of positions that appeared to overlap.
Milind Barve
executiveWe're also focused on how much stock overlap exists among our funds. On that front too, we're tracking it and pushing fund managers toward holding differentiated positions in different funds. So I'd say we're on this path of diversifying by style. For a large fund house like ours, we believe that's the most suitable approach. We've brought in new fund managers. They're introducing different kinds of perspectives into how they build portfolios. And yes — we may be considering adding more people to the team. So this process is underway. Getting there will take us a few quarters, but we stay confident that this fund performance will come back, will bounce back. And over a period of time, we should be able to regain our market share. I'm not trying to suggest or promise it will happen in 1 quarter or 2 quarters, but over the medium term, we remain optimistic about regaining the share we hold in the equities — in the actively managed equity fund. Another point is that a lot of the industry — some portion of the industry flows have also come from new fund offerings.
Milind Barve
executiveDuring today's Board meeting, along with earlier sessions we've held with the Board, we've requested approvals for several new product launches. It would be too early for me to lay out what those are. So we will have a pipeline of new product launches. Getting SEBI approval and so on takes a couple of months. So we have a pipeline, a very strong pipeline of product launches, roughly 1 every month or every alternate month over the next -- maybe after a gap of 2 or 3 months, once we receive the required approval from SEBI. So we will be launching a slew of new product ranges, which will include both thematic products as well as some product gaps that will get filled. So a lot of work is being done to address the market share on equity. We are very mindful of the fact that our investors have high expectations from us. And I feel very optimistic that we are -- we will -- with the steps that we are taking, we will be able to address the concern on equity market share.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Ajox at B&K Securities.
Ajox Frederick H.
analystMy question is a bit more basic, then. Aside from fund size, what factors drive TER on a sequential basis, say?
Milind Barve
executiveAre you referring to TER, or do you mean the margin we get on the product?
Ajox Frederick H.
analystYes, let’s talk about the product’s margin.
Milind Barve
executiveLook, SEBI’s formula defines TER purely by product size. That’s it — nothing else. So the operations department essentially calculates the TER using the prescribed SEBI formula, which depends on how large the product is. Now...
Ajox Frederick H.
analystMargin — got it.
Milind Barve
executiveYes. So what we do with retained margins is essentially this: starting from the TER, costs fall into 2 categories. One of them, the bigger portion, is distribution or customer acquisition cost — put simply, the commission paid out to distributors. Then there are other fund running expenses, such as R&T costs, custody costs, and so forth. So once you take those 2 out of the TER, you arrive at what we call retained margins. So obviously, retained margin does depend on the TER, which in turn hinges on fund size, along with how efficiently we — how much exactly we pay distributors in commission and how well we handle fund operating cost, things like R&T cost, custody and trustee fees, and that sort of thing.
Ajox Frederick H.
analystOkay, okay, thank you. And I have another question regarding other expenses. This quarter showed a nice sequential improvement as well. So what was behind that?
Milind Barve
executiveSince the lockdown began, we've been cutting costs across virtually every expense category. And I don't think any single line item is what's delivering the savings. Starting with all the rent we pay — roughly 38 branches have had their leases renegotiated. Further down the list, there are 220 more. There's still plenty of ground to cover. We'll keep renegotiating leases. And we'll watch each cost category like a hawk, which is essentially the zero-based budgeting method we're applying. That's how we've managed to get costs down. As we said on our first quarter call, we're pushing hard on that effort, and results are starting to show. So we'll hold the line on cost. I must say — I don't want to provide guidance. But as more branches reopen through additional unlock phases, I think overall we'll finish the year with a meaningful cost saving. So matching that same savings amount quarter over quarter may be somewhat tough, since more branches are opening and so forth. And we don't want to impose unnecessary restrictions.
Milind Barve
executiveThat said, if you examine our company's cost structure relative to the amount of AUM we oversee, we rank among the fund managers with the lowest operating costs in the country, and we intend to hold on to that standing. So when it comes to cost, we will keep running an extremely tight ship.
Ajox Frederick H.
analystUnderstood, sir. Sir, regarding the SIPs, what kind of sense are you picking up from folks on the ground, more at a broader level?
Milind Barve
executiveI think what's going on in the industry — and this is a trend we've witnessed before — is that when markets are highly volatile or when they rise. And when you look now at 1-year returns, 2-year returns, even for the index, they aren't very strong, not like double digit. If you, of course, put money in during the month of March, then you're seeing a 30% return. But apart from that, returns are a little soft. So what happens — and this is unfortunate, actually — is that at the time when people should be adding to their SIPs or raising the size of the SIPs, people tend to sort of move away from SIPs or cancel SIPs. And that is happening in the industry. And that is why the result — while there are new people adding their — to SIPs and signing up or registering new SIPs, there is a number which is either reducing or canceling SIPs, which is, therefore, the total run rate of monthly SIPs that we are seeing in the industry is coming down marginally. But we've seen this trend in the past when markets remain flat or the markets have some — and clearly, there is an overhang about the pandemic, which people might be a little concerned about, and the fact that markets have rallied a lot.
Milind Barve
executiveI'd say this is a temporary stretch, and folks will return to purchasing additional SIPs on a net basis. So I don't interpret — and if you look at the figures both for the industry and for us, there isn't — it's not an especially earth-shattering figure. Seeing numbers decline isn't pleasant, yet it isn't a case of a very substantial count of people just halting SIPs.
Operator
operatorOur next speaker is Madhukar Ladha with HDFC Securities.
Madhukar Ladha
analystI have just a couple of quick questions. First, I believe you covered the market share loss from the mark-to-market angle. Could you give us some qualitative commentary on how flows have been? And are we experiencing any loss in incremental flows, or additional outflows relative to other industry participants? A bit of detail there would be helpful.
Milind Barve
executiveI don’t believe we would disclose flows at any point during the quarter or at any point during the year. That said, it would be reasonable to state that AUM movements, both for the industry and for us, depend mainly on 2 factors. The first is mark-to-market movements; the second is flows as well. Let me now give some context on flows. For instance, if you take financial year ’19/’20 — that is last year — the industry had net flows and people were happy, people were actually buying a mutual fund. However, total flows for that year came to about INR 67,000 crore. So INR 67,000 crore was against a book of roughly INR 10.5 lakh crores of equity AUM for the industry. I’m referring to actively managed equity AUM. Thus the flows — the entire flow for a given year — represented roughly 6% of the book. So, as you know, in our industry there is a book and then there is a flow. The flow was therefore around 6%, let’s say 6.5%, of the book. Market movement, by contrast, can be materially higher and, of course, as you saw in the month of March, was sharply down.
Milind Barve
executiveSo here's what happens now, given how big this industry is — take, for instance, a lot gets made on a month-on-month basis, especially in media or electronic media, because when people notice negative or, rather, net outflows from equity funds month-on-month, and we've witnessed that across this entire quarter for the industry. Now here's the thing: when you talk about a INR 5,000-crore bond or, say, in this quarter, as my colleague just mentioned, the industry saw INR 16,000 crores of net outflow, let's say INR 5,000 crores a month. Now INR 5,000 crores a month works out to under 0.5% of the industry's book. So I'm not trying to claim inflows don't matter — they do matter, and we must keep attracting and growing this industry with new customers. A flow figure of 1%, 2%, 3% coming in or going out during the month doesn't materially alter the size of the book. What matters more for this industry, and for us, of course, is that markets stay healthy and keep, sort of, trending positively upwards, so that people get a good outcome on investment performance and remain invested and raise their amounts as we bring in new customers.
Milind Barve
executiveYou need to grasp, or weigh, how flows and market movement both affect the AUM book. So — and don't let flows sweep you away when they turn somewhat negative, or because INR 16,000 crores equals 1.5% of the industry's AUM book, which fails to move the needle when it comes to revenues or profitability for the industry. Once more, I have to say, I'm not — one takes no pleasure in seeing outflows, neither for the industry nor for us, but it doesn't move the needle.
Madhukar Ladha
analystGot it. Sir, just a quick follow-up on that. From a qualitative standpoint, are we seeing improved yields on both equity and debt — that one's for Piyush? Based on my calculation, it looks like equity yields have improved somewhat on a sequential basis.
Piyush Surana
executiveMadhukar, looking at the larger picture, equity yields don't differ much. On the debt side, naturally, yields have come down somewhat, and that's because the credit risk fund — which previously earned us higher management fees — now makes up a smaller share of debt AUM.
Operator
operatorOur following questioner is Kunal Thanvi with Banyan Tree Advisors.
Kunal Thanvi
analystSo my question again was — I get that flows aren't, in the big picture, a particularly important function — but what we've historically observed is that once the market recovers to where it stood before the crash, say, in our case, in this context, at a NIFTY level of 12000, we've seen retail investors heading for the exits at that moment. So do we have any read on that front, whether from our past experience or what we're seeing currently — does it make sense — would it be right to conclude that outflows might speed up as the market tests those pre-COVID, pre-crash levels?
Milind Barve
executiveThere’s no real basis to expect that it’ll get worse. Honestly, whether another few thousand crores comes in over the course of a month may or may not happen, and it’s really hard to project. But you have to remember that the pandemic has left a certain overhang. So people might be worried about their incomes; their wealth in terms of equity value and book value may have been restored. Still, they may have concerns about their incomes and their future cash flows, and they might have grown somewhat more risk averse. For instance, just consider this: even as we’re seeing bank deposit rates at historically low levels, bank deposit growth is at a 4-year or 5-year high. I mean, it’s 9.5% to 10% even when rates are among the lowest. So I think there’s probably an aversion to risk, or to risk assets, for some time, because we’re dealing with a once-a-century kind of event. So I think there could be an overhang of risk — a bit of risk aversion toward equity as an asset class. I think we believe this will be a transitory period.
Milind Barve
executiveIt's hard to predict how long this stretch will go on. I don't believe — take, for instance, what counts for us and within our company and how we see it, we remain guided by the reality that ownership of equity funds or equity products in India, whether held via mutual funds or directly, is extremely low. Still, there may be a stretch when people aren't purchasing new right now. They could hold off until some clouds clear, and then they'll return. So when I add up all these figures, it doesn't shock me to observe an unusual rise in bank deposits at low interest rates while consumer inflation remains elevated. Equity fund results might be the — I mean markets might have bounced back to pre-COVID level. So there's a bit more risk aversion before committing money to the equity asset. Thus the engine of this business will keep being the underpenetration of fund products broadly and equity products specifically. I mean, if you look at it as we stated, as we've consistently said, we hold under 5%, 6% of India's market cap. So that's likely the lowest institutional mutual fund ownership anywhere, as one among emerging markets.
Milind Barve
executiveSo that stays the same. What I mean is that this stretch—or this stage of reduced purchasing, some worries, or people putting in more money—could go on for a while longer.
Kunal Thanvi
analystOkay, that's clear, and it helps. For my second question, it's essentially about how few channels are accepting it. What we've been noticing, since many distributors are — first with the TER cut and now with weaker performance likely — for a fairly long stretch. The distribution channel isn't very happy, and they appear to be pushing other products ahead of, say, HDFC, and I realize this is a transitional phase where performance is concerned. In what way are the management team and the marketing team handling the distribution channel — to ensure they stay with us through this transitionary period?
Milind Barve
executiveNo. So we're deeply dedicated to a lasting partnership with the distribution channel, and we aim to develop that partnership in a way that benefits both sides. We're incredibly dedicated since nearly 80% of our equity business arrives through our different distribution channels, which are IFAs, banks and national distributors. So we are very dedicated. As a matter of fact, they form the foundation upon which our distribution and marketing model rests. From what I understand, it's crucial that we provide what customers desire regarding investor experience on performance, beyond merely paying money to distributors. Let me phrase it this way: I've observed a stronger correlation between flows and fund performance than between flows and distribution payout. So you simply cannot push a fund that isn't delivering good investment performance merely by paying IPs, and it's wrong for the customer to even purchase it. So that doesn't mean you just keep handing more money to distributors to get them to buy — I think you get customers to buy. So my sense is we'll always strike that balance. And I think, for instance, we've just announced a festival-style promotional campaign in which we've raised commission payouts for a certain set of selected products.
Milind Barve
executiveSo we'll keep at this in order to stay connected with our distribution fraternity. For instance, one aim behind rolling out new products is likewise to keep the HDFC fund brand prominent in people's minds — introducing fresh product ideas where commissions might be somewhat more attractive, higher than what we pay on our older products. The point, then, is to sustain the distribution community's interest both in our products and in our relationship, and we're confident that as a team we will get there.
Operator
operatorVinod Rajamani from HSBC is on the line with the next question.
Vinod Rajamani
analystI had a few questions. You mentioned that you're bringing on a small number of new fund managers. In terms of your overall equity AUM — total equity AUM — what share will those managers be responsible for? Also, regarding the new products you plan to launch, will they mostly be equity funds? Or will they be hybrid, or mostly debt? Any detail on that would help. And my third question: as people return to work, there's a view that some DIY investors who bought equity directly might come back to buying funds. Are you seeing any early signs of that as the unlock takes shape?
Milind Barve
executiveYes. So, if I recall correctly, your initial question was about how much money the new fund managers are managing. That's a reasonable question. At present, there are 2 fund managers. Market feedback on both of them has been positive. We might look to hire at least 1 or 2. The more important criterion, as we seek to strengthen our team, is that they bring a differentiated investment approach compared with what we already have. And I think ultimately, the allocation of funds will settle over a period of time regarding how much we will manage. So at this moment, it's not that we take a new manager and immediately hand him an INR 20,000 crore fund to manage — that may or may not happen. And it also depends on the person, what type of skill sets he brings to the table. So I think the eventual allocation of money between new and old — and we are not really looking at new and old necessarily in terms of how much they manage, that's not how we look at it. We are looking at the different fund product range that we have, and we are trying to manage the skill of that person, the individual who is coming — who is joining us — and see where he fits in.
Milind Barve
executiveTo give an example, when a person specializes in a particular approach or a particular market-cap category, we'll do our best to place that individual in that category. To us, that matters more than just splitting total AUM across the number of fund managers. So I don't believe we hold a view of that kind. On the second question, if I'm not — could you bring that back up?
Vinod Rajamani
analystRight, so this relates to those product launches. Could you share any detail on the kinds of products you intend to roll out? Would it mostly be equity? Would it be a blend of equity and debt? Would it be debt? Would it be liquid?
Milind Barve
executiveNo, it’s — no, no, no, I’d say it’s mostly, I think, not on their all-equity side. And a few of them are plain-vanilla funds that fill a gap, such as dividend-yield offerings, and at present there are quite a few stocks delivering unusually high dividend yields. So we think that could be one approach that works. There are other options that differ — either thematic, or most of them, in my view, are thematic; all of them are equity funds. To be clear, they aren’t debt funds, and I don’t believe they’re hybrid funds either.
Vinod Rajamani
analystAnd third, regarding employees heading back to work, are you noticing any indications that folks are returning to funds? Just because either direct investors might have gone through a rough patch with active manage — active fund management, and also, they may not have sufficient time available to sort of play the market. So are you picking up any early signals that people are shifting toward mutual funds at this point?
Milind Barve
executiveLet me frame this properly. At one point the market suffered an extremely steep decline during March. Then in April, the widespread assumption was that this epidemic, or pandemic, would be over within just a few months. People were confined to their homes with nothing to do, and they either couldn't or perhaps simply didn't — they couldn't reach a mutual fund, a distributor, or an adviser. So they shifted into a mode of attempting to bias with the number — purchasing on their own. As a result, DMAT account openings rose, and even trading accounts at broking firms went up, along with various other things. I don't mean to diminish anyone's skill or capacity for buying stocks. But when you consider the huge segment of the Indian population with no equity exposure, I'd say those enlightened enough to purchase equity directly represent just a fraction of that share. Most people need to hold diversified products, which is what mutual funds provide. Some may indeed understand, analyze, or receive sound advice sufficient to go buy stocks directly.
Milind Barve
executiveI'm not going to dispute that. But if you consider who we're going after over the medium to long term — well, as we've mentioned, and I recall making this point during our IPO road shows — what drives us is the dream that every Indian ought to own a mutual fund product, and one of those should be ours. And looking at that, I see that 95% of people, or perhaps more, aren't equipped to purchase equity shares directly in the market on their own. And at times people let themselves get carried away. Take an example: had you bought — stayed at home and purchased something during the month of April, at the bottom of the market, you'd consider yourself a great fund manager, since the market is so good — it has run up so much. But if you purchased later in the markets, whether you will — whether you'll consistently get returns of this kind, nobody knows. So having said that, this isn't to undermine, as I said, people's ability and skill when it comes to selecting stocks and buying them directly, and they may well do so. But I believe there's a far larger multiple of people who would prefer an approach to the equity markets that involves somebody like a distributor, an adviser-driven mutual fund approach.
Milind Barve
executiveAnd we’re there to serve that segment.
Operator
operatorMoving on, the next question comes from Rahul Nandwani at Centrum Broking.
Rahul Nandwani
analystSir, in the prior quarter you said a search had been launched to identify your successor. So is there any update on that front?
Milind Barve
executiveSo yes, giving any color or details wouldn't be appropriate on my part. You see, there's a nomination and remuneration committee, which effectively doubles as the search committee for whoever takes over from me. That committee is fully engaged in evaluating candidates, both internal and external. When they land on the right person, they will, of course, bring it to the Board for discussion, and an announcement will be made once that process has wrapped up. So I'd say we're right in the middle of it. And whenever the Board — the committee and the Board — is ready, I think an announcement will come from the Board. That said, I just want to assure you that I've spent roughly 20 years in this business. I don't own the company, but I won't — I've been its founder CEO from day 1. And across this period, I have been truly blessed with an incredibly strong and outstanding group of people who today head all our functions. I don't want to name any particular individual or function. But we have people who have been manning these functions for — some of them for 15, 18, 20 years, and some are even day 1 employees who remain with us still.
Milind Barve
executiveI feel really confident that we've got an extremely well-established group of professionals — very committed and dedicated people who have, in a way, been part of this journey with me across all these 20 years. And I think — or for a majority of this 20 years. So as a team, we're very well-established in terms of where we stand. They're very motivated. What we want to achieve, what we've achieved so far, and the desire to build on it further — that's what drives them. So of course, leadership matters. I'm not saying leadership doesn't matter. I'm very sure and confident that the remuneration or nomination committee, together with the Board, will find a suitable candidate. And once that process is complete, they will announce it.
Rahul Nandwani
analystJust one more question here. Given that the quarterly average is now holding steady at... what is your view on equity yields?
Operator
operatorApologies for cutting in, but we're not getting your audio clearly.
Rahul Nandwani
analystWith NIFTY sitting above 11000, would you expect equity yields to go up on the back of mark-to-market gains? And probably your equity contribution...
Milind Barve
executiveYes. Look, projecting where an index will sit over a very short horizon is extremely hard. But, as I mentioned when responding to an earlier question, my sense is that an asset-allocation mindset will be what drives people. And even though they are planning with a gold-based asset-allocation approach, an enormous number of individuals remain underallocated and underinvested when it comes to equities. So they will discover — equity will discover, or will need to — they certainly need to discover a position within their allocation. In that sense, when it comes to interest in equity as an asset class, we are still only scratching the surface. What I mean is there is a huge — a long way to go before people will say that — so we differ greatly from developed markets, where every household, whether through their 401(k) plan or through some government program, has some exposure to equity. Some are — they are probably 10, 15 years away from that. So I think there is — the appetite for equity will remain. We may go through phases when that appetite is a little high or low, but that fundamental ownership of a person's wealth or allocation — in his personal portfolio is very low, and we will continue to find interest.
Rahul Nandwani
analystAlright, one final follow-up question here. Structurally speaking, since your ETF share is among the lowest, does that give us an advantage on the margin side? But looking at your long-term pricing, do you see ETF growing as a portion of overall AUM? Maybe more so through making some acquisition?
Milind Barve
executiveNo, an ETF could be launched, but as you can see, the bulk of the AUM — and my colleague will go into this in a bit more detail — but most of the equity AUM sits only in NIFTY or SENSEX ETFs, that's point one. Point two, most of the money that's come in has come from EPFO, where the mandate is to invest only in — directly or indirectly — directly owned — government-owned asset management companies. So it's unfortunate, but it's a reality that private sector asset managers such as us won't get any share even if we run a very efficient ETF. So that's the reality — it's only a large portion from institutional EPFO money. And then some disinvestments have happened through ETFs like Bharat 22 and so on, where the margins were very low. So I think the ETF business still hasn't found the same kind of acceptance among retail Indian investors who are long-term investors. So my sense is — and maybe my friend will add — my colleague can add a bit more color on these ETF numbers. But my sense is that — secondly, we are such an underpenetrated population looking to invest in different things apart from bank deposits, which will remain popular.
Milind Barve
executiveSo how do you actually get a product in front of this investor? One of the biggest challenges we face as an industry — perhaps the largest — is getting our product to the customer, and in that process the distributor is the most important leg. We simply cannot reach the population we're targeting just by opening offices. Think about it: we're among the largest players, and we have 223 offices, whereas State Bank of India has 25,000 branches. We have 225, and we're talking about capturing a share of bank deposit money. That's not possible. We need distributors. And here's what happens: today's distribution community doesn't sell ETFs. Whatever the reason, the commercials of an ETF don't give any distributor any incentive to sell ETFs. So the reality is that a simple average investor might buy a simple product, might buy a hybrid product, might buy a debt product. But most likely he comes through a distributor or an adviser. An ETF has its obvious advantage: you don't take fund manager risk, and your costs are among the lowest.
Milind Barve
executiveSure, that's something you could do. But to address what you're asking, take ETFs as an example — that's the lens we'd use. If it turns out there's sufficient room, and you're able to build ETFs whose impact costs stay low, or perhaps we need to offer thematic ETFs, which carry a particular theme, then we'd request — in those cases we collaborate with the companies that provide indexes to construct a thematic index, and afterward we introduce ETFs built on it.
Simal Kanuga
executiveTo build on what Milind said, I’ll give a few data points on what we’ve done. For instance, gold ETFs stand at roughly INR 13,600 crores in industry AUM. We hold INR 2,000 crores of that. Banking ETFs are INR 13,600 crores as well. We launched our banking ETF recently — during the quarter, we launched the banking ETF. We already have the SENSEX and the NIFTY ETF, which is very much in place. So if you exclude that EPFO money, only about INR 6,000 crores, INR 7,000 crores sits in that space. We already have a product there. So that is just — we are already present. Whenever the market really gains traction, we’re happy to expand further in that space.
Operator
operatorOur next participant is Piran Engineer, who joins us from Motilal Oswal.
Piran Engineer
analystI just have a couple of particular questions. First, with the hybrid funds, across the last 4, 5 quarters, the AUM has kept falling consistently, and it's now down 25%, 30% from the last year, so...
Operator
operatorI apologize for cutting in, but the audio on your end is coming through distorted.
Piran Engineer
analystAlright, is that improved at this point?
Operator
operatorYeah, a bit better, sir. Yes.
Piran Engineer
analystYeah, so my first question concerns hybrid funds. Across the last 4 or 5 quarters, the AUM we hold in hybrid funds has declined steadily and in a fairly consistent way. So has there been some kind of reclassification? And if there hasn't, then what's driving that decline?
Milind Barve
executiveIf I got your question right, then yes, that's correct. When you look at the asset base of hybrid funds, even across the industry, there appears to be a gradual shrinking in that asset base industry-wide. In one of our own hybrid funds, we were distributing dividends — monthly ones, as I recall. And with the tax law change introduced in the last budget, those dividends now get taxed at your marginal rate, or whatever rate applies to the individual, instead of the earlier favorable rate of roughly 10% plus surcharge plus cess. Because of that, dividends have become less appealing for any mutual fund, really — and for any equity fund too, for that matter. So that has likely had an effect on certain balanced funds, both industry-wide and for us as well. That's my guess. But yes, I would agree that hybrid funds on the whole are somehow losing a bit of their connection with investors. They're saying they would rather do their own split between equity and debt than pick a hybrid product.
Piran Engineer
analystAll right, that's fair. Sir, for my second question — and I may not have caught everything you all said properly — but was it stated that you're going to raise the distribution commission for certain distributors?
Milind Barve
executiveNo, no, no. What we've said is that we launched something like a festival-style program in which, for certain select mutual fund products of ours, we're offering a higher commission — higher trade fees, that is. We're paying more than what we normally don't really pay. On those few products, we've raised the trade fees for the new business they bring in during this — I think it's a festival offer or something of that sort. It isn't select distributors. It's on select products of ours.
Piran Engineer
analystAll right, all right, that's fair. Sir, for my final question: when I look at your top line yield — essentially revenue from operations divided by quarterly average AUM — before COVID it was nearer the 55 bps mark, and this quarter it has fallen to 49 bps. And if I even adjust for a smaller equity share and a larger debt share, that 49 would probably have been 51, 52. Yet even after adjusting for the shift in product mix, our top line yields have still been somewhat weak.
Milind Barve
executiveNo, no—no, no, that's not correct. The reason is purely the product mix. Also, one factor is equity within the total, which was 44% and now stands at 38% in the averages. That has a pretty big effect, because the difference—look, I don't know how—there's no way to work it out without knowing the precise yield on our equity and the precise yield on our debt and liquid funds. Unless you have that, you can't figure out your revenue income yourself or work out the decline. Our equity products, in fact, generate quite a healthy retail margin. So any drop in equity and the product mix does hit the top line—that's point one. Point two, there's also been a bit of a decline in the debt margin, mainly because at one stage we had this credit risk fund, which was roughly, if my memory is right, INR 13,500 crores, and today it has fallen to approximately INR 6,000 crores, INR 6,500 crores. So we had a massive INR 7,000 crore sitting in a higher-margin debt fund, and that exited during the course of May following certain events at a particular fund house.
Milind Barve
executiveThat, too, nudged the overall yield in the debt business down somewhat. So those are the 2 factors that have had an effect, though my colleague can add a bit more detail, but Piyush, is there anything more behind that decline?
Piyush Surana
executiveNo, you've hit on it, Milind — those really come down to 2 factors. And Piran, as Milind mentioned, it's somewhat more involved, since even inside the debt side there are various schemes that contribute differently, and the same holds for equity. So suppose a specific asset category rises or falls, and you're receiving a different contribution from that kind of scheme — that too would influence the mix.
Piran Engineer
analystAll right, all right, that's fair. So it comes down purely to product mix — no other factor.
Piyush Surana
executiveYes, definitely.
Milind Barve
executiveThat's exactly right.
Operator
operatorHiral Desai from Anived Portfolio Management Service is our next participant. Hiral Desai, could you please unmute your line on your end and proceed with your question? Hiral Desai, are you able to hear us? There's no response from you. We'll move on to the following participant. Our next question comes from Manjeet of Solidarity Advisors.
Manjeet Buaria
analystI've got 2 questions. First, when you look at the mutual fund industry landscape as it stands today, what lead indicators would you be watching that would point to a shift toward index funds happening on a much broader basis incrementally? So could you shed some light on which lead drivers you track? And the second thing I wanted to understand is, I just want to get a sense of when we open branch offices across multiple cities, how that differs from, say, outsourcing to an agent like CAMS, since they also appear to have branches in multiple cities. So what's the overlap in functionality, or perhaps the nonoverlap, between these branches? Those are my 2 questions.
Milind Barve
executiveYes. So the first lead indicator I’d look at is whether people’s more recent experience with equity products has been positive. And unfortunately, what happens is that when markets are a little flattish or down, people actually don’t invest, and when markets are in the momentum upwards, people want to buy, which is exactly opposite of what they should be doing. So one of the things we look for is whether the fund performances or what is delivered by the industry in terms of fund performance is reasonably attractive in absolute terms, not necessarily benchmark. You have to remember that the real benchmark in the Indian investors’ mind is neither the NIFTY nor the SENSEX, but it is a comparable bank deposit interest rate, or let us say, some other alternative product that you may have in mind. But to my mind, for the average small Indian who is the first time investor investing through an SIP, this benchmark is neither NIFTY nor anything complicated that the industry does. His real benchmark is bank deposit rate. As long as we have delivered returns in absolute terms of a bank deposit, we will continue to believe that and rightly so that he’s better off in an equity mutual funds, apart from the fact that — because in addition, the capital gain that you get on a equity mutual fund, for example, has attracted a much lower tax rate if it is long term.
Milind Barve
executiveAnd short-term gains are taxed at a lower rate too. So the main lead indicator I'd watch is whether our industry is generating absolute returns that compete with or beat bank deposit returns. And the answer is yes. Over a stretch of 1, 2 or 3 years. We can't claim 10 years. So if the answer stays yes, people will return to equity funds. That's my response to your first question. On your second question about branches. The main purpose of a branch isn't customer servicing. Essentially, our branch combines servicing walk-in customers with something equally important and at times more important — servicing the distribution community in that region. We do collaborate very closely with CAMS Offices across all their branches where they may handle physical transactions and so forth. And actually — I should mention that beyond our own branches, our products are sold through CAMS branches in more than 223 of our branches.
Milind Barve
executiveHowever, CAMS doesn't handle servicing for our distributors. What I mean is, when a distributor wishes to talk about a product, or wants to sit down with a sales executive to grasp what the new offering is, what fresh positioning exists, or to get some insight into our product strategy, that distributor has to speak with one of our salespeople. So the staff in our branches really consist of a blend of individuals who deliver client services. Above all, these are the sales and marketing personnel who assist in delivering services to distributors. Therefore, I'd say that function isn't the same — CAMS is able to perform just one of those two roles, whereas our branch performs both.
Manjeet Buaria
analystThat was quite useful. May I ask one more thing related to the first question?
Milind Barve
executiveMy apologies — could you repeat that?
Manjeet Buaria
analystSir, may I ask a follow-up regarding the first question about index funds?
Milind Barve
executiveMy apologies regarding the index funds. Could you repeat your question about those index funds? I’m sorry—I may have missed it.
Manjeet Buaria
analystNo, no. So let me follow up on that. There's a lot of published literature now about how large stock funds in India really don't deliver much over index. And while the broader market may not look at index in terms of an SP or anything, right? They are reading literature around how the index fund would have a lower expense ratio while delivering similar returns to any actively managed equity funds over a 3-year period or 4-year period. So is that something which worries you? Or do you think it's still too small to be worried about?
Milind Barve
executiveNo, I won't describe it as worried. And I'm not suggesting that an index fund or an ETF is a bad product in any way. If you're looking for a fund that simply — and you're content having it track the market as efficiently as possible at low cost — then an ETF or an index fund serves you well. But if your goal is to produce returns superior to the index, well, the selection of indices available for that through ETFs and index funds is only, as I said, the NIFTY and the SENSEX, or perhaps someone offers a fund named the Next50, and so forth; there's no index fund covering the mid-cap fund, and no index on a small-cap fund. So if you want a flavor of a product within that category, you simply cannot go and purchase any index or ETF. So many funds out there are thematic. For instance, hybrid funds exist. There are funds that are long and — sorry, large and mid-cap, there are multi-cap funds. Dynamic funds exist. Hybrid funds exist. But no indices exist on that, and there are no, as you'd call them, ETFs or index funds on that.
Milind Barve
executiveSo yes, if your interest lies solely in large cap and you're comfortable tracking something like a NIFTY or the SENSEX, then there's nothing wrong with entering an index fund or purchasing a low-cost ETF. But if you're after alpha over the long run, then you may — though I'm not at all attempting to argue that ETFs are bad or unsuitable for people. It is — it can be just as appealing to those who simply want to track the index. My sense is that at present, people are more concerned with absolute returns rather than a comparison with the benchmark. That's my sort of simple understanding of how a small, average, retail Indian investor thinks about his investment.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Hiral Desai, who is calling in from Anived Portfolio Management Service.
Hiral Desai
analystCan you hear me at this point?
Milind Barve
executiveCorrect — that's right.
Hiral Desai
analystYes. So I just wanted to ask — with the weak results we've been seeing on a few of the big equity schemes, the popular ones — has the typical length of time money remains invested in your equity scheme gone down over the past 3 to 4 years?
Milind Barve
executiveNot really. I mean, yes, I'd frame it the opposite way — look, you can't get around the fact that how much a particular product grows is tied very tightly to how the fund performs. Take some of these large funds: we've built them up to the point where mark-to-market gains over the last 2 or 3 years have done a lot, but flows will add a much smaller amount of growth. As I keep saying, AUM size comes down to two things: mark-to-market and flows. The book equals flows plus mark-to-market. So in certain cases where fund performance isn't very strong, or competitive — I'd say that's the better word — then flows may be somewhat lower, though sometimes you'll see small redemptions. But — and — but mark-to-market will keep making it grow. So let's take our INR 20,000 crore fund. If the market grows by 10%, it grows by INR 2,000 crores. So the large size works in our favour. I mean, let's just take a INR 145,000 crore size of our equity AUM. If the market flows — where the market grows by 10%, we will grow by INR 15,000 crores if we are close to the market.
Milind Barve
executiveThat isn't even the whole industry's flow. So what I was getting at in our earlier question is this: how the market performs matters just as much as flows do.
Hiral Desai
analystAlso, given that our share of small- and mid-cap AUM is disproportionate relative to total equity AUM, what difficulties arise when trying to launch a small-cap index fund in India?
Milind Barve
executiveNo. I’d say...
Hiral Desai
analystRight now, a lot of investors who genuinely want that exposure don't really have any real options available to them — it's just not there.
Milind Barve
executiveThat's exactly right, since building an index in small and mid-cap is nearly impossible — the impact cost is simply off the charts. I mean, even with 150 stocks, the impact cost of constructing a mid-cap index is a serious challenge. And in small cap, it's genuinely very, very difficult. So when it comes to creating an index — this is precisely the point I made a little earlier — if someone wants to buy small or mid, they don't have the option of an index fund or an ETF. They necessarily have to come into actively managed mid-cap or small cap, whichever they prefer. I'm mindful of what you asked: we have a significantly large mid-cap fund, close to about INR 19,000 crore, INR 20,000 crore. And a reasonable size small-cap fund as well, which is INR 6,000 crore, INR 7,000 crores. And we will always be very careful not to increase or take new funds into these flows. Whenever the fund manager signals that I'm running out of ideas to invest in this category, we will stop new flows into both — either the mid-cap or the small cap, either both or either of them.
Milind Barve
executiveI get the difficulty these funds face: they need to expand in line with what the market offers, not according to — and that call isn't made just because we want to keep selling these products.
Hiral Desai
analystUnderstood. And one final thing—those roughly 5.5 million unique customers you have at present, they're the active ones who hold an HDFC fund today, correct?
Simal Kanuga
executiveThat is correct. Yes.
Milind Barve
executiveThat is correct.
Hiral Desai
analystRight, so what would the total customer base look like — meaning the people who had previously put money into an HDFC fund but at present hold none of the HDFC funds?
Simal Kanuga
executiveWe don’t examine the data that way, since our focus is on active customers, and these unique customers are essentially identified by PAN numbers.
Hiral Desai
analystRight. Right. Have you fellows carried out any research on clients who departed HDFC AMC over the past 3, 4 years? Aside from performance, were there other grounds for their leaving the fund?
Milind Barve
executiveNo, I really don’t see any other explanation. And I also don’t believe people exit the fund purely due to how it has performed. What we’re really discussing here is market share. Sometimes investors simply won’t add more capital to a fund. When performance disappoints them, they’ll search for an alternative. Because I still believe — look, we continue to hold the biggest market share in equity AUM among actively managed AUM across the industry. Even now, we still have the highest share of our individual investors’ wallet in equity funds. So despite the relative underperformance we’ve had recently, we remain the top manager of equity — of actively managed equity funds. So we still have — and not all of these people are going to walk away from us. Yes, naturally, that doesn’t mean we should just relax and take no action. That’s not true at all. We’re working hard, front and back, to bring the right formula for the funds back to us. And as I mentioned earlier, we stay optimistic about being able to get there.
Operator
operatorAditya Jain from Citigroup is our next participant.
Aditya Jain
analystRegarding costs—I hope I haven't overlooked this—during 1Q, you mentioned removing INR 35 crores to INR 40 crores in costs across 12 months. Does that target still stand? Or, given the market's appreciation and perhaps stronger equity performance, has there been any shift in how you're thinking about this?
Milind Barve
executiveNo, no, I think — look, what we're discussing here is the fixed cost side of operating expenses. I think our focus is very clear. All I said was that we've achieved, if I'm not mistaken, INR 26 crores of savings in the first 6 months. That may or may not translate into INR 52 crores for the whole year. That's the only guidance I'm giving. It could be INR 35 crores, or INR 40 crores, or INR 32 crores, or INR 37 crores. So — but we will keep maintaining an absolute hawks eye on cost, and that's something we will not let go of. So one thing I definitely want to mention here, and I think my colleagues have mentioned it. The important thing to look at when you look at this quarter's performance — one way to look at it is what people often do, quarter-on-quarter, which is year-on-year. And there is some fall in that, obviously, because our equity AUM has not reached that, has not reached last year's level. But having said that, it's more important to look at our operating profit sequentially. And as my colleague just mentioned, the June quarter operating profit was INR 301 crores, INR 302 crores.
Milind Barve
executivePiyush, please correct me if I get anything wrong here. For the second quarter, operating profit stands at INR 349 crores. That means it's up by nearly INR 48 crores compared with the prior quarter. So what I believe we're seeing is this: taking operating profit after accounting for all of it — the market gain, the market share gain, selling and expenses, the shift in product mix with lesser equity — despite all of that, operating profit has risen from INR 301 crores to INR 349 crores. And as I said, to answer your question directly, the short answer is yes, we will keep costs under control. But we'll do so in a way that still supports growth in the business.
Aditya Jain
analystUnderstood, sir. And regarding the equity yield — a question came up earlier about the longer term. But looking at equity yield over a longer horizon, there are 2 pressures, correct? First, schemes growing in size, which brings the TER cap down, and possibly movement caused by a higher trail commission on new assets compared with the old ones. So, all else being equal, if you imagined something like 15% appreciation per year in equity AUM over the longer term, would you then see a steady decline of roughly 1 to 2 basis points in equity yield from that factor alone, setting mix and everything else aside?
Milind Barve
executiveYes. But the way I'd see it, this is a nice problem to have, since we may need to give up 1 or 2 basis points, yet the absolute revenue from the equity business — which is so healthy today — will help the bottom line, because costs won't rise in the same proportion. Look, this business is largely about very high operating leverage. So if you can generate more revenue from the equity business at higher AUM, in basis points it might be 1 or 2 basis point lower, but in absolute terms, that's a materially good number to get. So it's a good problem to have that we have 1 or 2 basis point lower yield, but the size of the equity AUM has grown because not — because costs won't increase in the same proportion.
Aditya Jain
analystUnderstood. And finally, sir, regarding the dividend payout, it came in lower this year. Over the longer term, on a more normalized basis, could it be something like 70%?
Milind Barve
executiveHonestly, I don’t want to get ahead of the Board, but there’s just one point I can make: we held a meeting this year — on the 8th or 9th of May, if I’m not mistaken — and some of the discussions surrounding it took place during the last week of April or the first week of May. At that time, we were likely at the start or the height of the harshest lockdown, before any easing had begun. Our aim was to err on the side of caution. We considered a kind of worst-case scenario regarding what might unfold if we stayed under a very strict lockdown. Thankfully, a series of unlocks has since occurred. And many leading indicators for the economy, as well as — beyond the recovery in the market, the economy’s lead indicators are looking favorable. Naturally, we still lack a vaccine, which would resolve our health issues. But I believe we made this call on the large dividend at what was probably the peak of the pandemic’s worst period, when uncertainty regarding the future was at its maximum. I think when the decision is taken regarding the next dividend, conditions will be a bit better than the mindset we had in the last week of April and first week of May.
Milind Barve
executiveAnd that, I hope, will help inform the Board's decision regarding what the upcoming dividend should be.
Operator
operatorLadies and gentlemen, the final question will come from Prayesh Jain of Yes Securities.
Prayesh Jain
analystI think we've covered most of what was asked. One thing that came up for me not long ago — I saw an announcement, or at least the possibility being raised, that subscriptions into mutual funds, or inflows into mutual funds, might also fall under the 0.1% TCS. Do you have any color on that? And what would the impact be for the industry?
Milind Barve
executiveI'm aware that our industry body, MC, has submitted a representation seeking clarification that the TCS shouldn't apply. I can't foresee how that will turn out. So I don't know whether — I don't think I can offer you a satisfactory answer on that point, but I do know the industry body has filed a representation arguing it shouldn't be made applicable.
Operator
operatorThanks a lot. At this point I'll pass things over to Mr. Sameer Bhise for some closing comments.
Sameer Bhise
analystAppreciate all of you being on this call, and many thanks to HDFC AMC's management for giving us the chance to host it. Thank you, HDFC.
Milind Barve
executiveWe appreciate your interest. Please stay safe. Thanks.
Operator
operatorThank you so much. That brings this conference to a close on behalf of JM Financial Institution Securities Limited. We appreciate you being with us. You can go ahead and disconnect your lines now. Thank you.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete HDFC Asset Management Company Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to HDFC Asset Management Company Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in HDFC Asset Management Company Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.