Kaltura, Inc. (KLTR) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 22, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Erica Mannion
executiveThanks so much, and welcome everyone to this morning's session. Joining us on behalf of Kaltura are Ron Yekutiel, who serves as Co-Founder, Chairman, and Chief Executive Officer, along with Yaron Garmazi, our Chief Financial Officer. Ron's remarks will open with a recap of how we performed during the fourth quarter that closed on December 31, 2022, plus what the company intends to do and the patterns we anticipate seeing in 2023. After that, Yaron is going to walk through the specifics of our financial performance for both the fourth quarter and the entire 2022 fiscal year, and he'll follow that with our guidance for the first quarter as well as the full year of 2023. Once those remarks wrap up, we'll take your questions. I want to remind everyone that forward-looking statements, as defined under the federal securities laws, will be part of today's discussion — this covers things like projections about Kaltura's future financial outcomes and what management expects and intends for the business, though it isn't limited to those items. Such statements should not be treated as commitments or assurances, and they carry risks and uncertainties that could lead to actual outcomes differing substantially from what we describe today. You can locate the key factors that might produce results different from our forward-looking statements in the Risk Factors portion of Kaltura's quarterly report on Form 10-Q covering the quarterly period that ended September 30, 2022, along with other periodic filings with the SEC, among them the annual report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year that ended December 31, 2022, which is set to be submitted to the SEC. Everything forward-looking that gets said on this conference call, including anything said while answering your questions, reflects expectations held as of right now, and Kaltura is under no duty to update or revise any of it, whether because of new developments or for any other reason, unless the law demands otherwise. One more note: a non-GAAP financial measure, adjusted EBITDA, is something we'll be covering during this call. If you'd like a reconciliation of that non-GAAP measure against the most directly comparable GAAP metric, our earnings release has it, and you can find that release on our website at www.investors.kaltura.com. At this point, I'll hand things over to Ron.
Ron Yekutiel
executiveThanks, Erica, and I appreciate all of you being with us this morning. For the fourth quarter of 2022, total revenue came in at $44.1 million, which is a 3% increase compared with the same period a year earlier, while subscription revenue reached $39.6 million, also representing 3% growth year-over-year. Adjusted EBITDA for the quarter landed at negative $4.2 million. On the last two earnings calls, we laid out three main financial forecasts: first, that revenue growth would come back in Q4 of 2022; second, that adjusted EBITDA would improve each quarter throughout 2023, getting closer to a loss in the single-digit dollar range; and third, that cash flow would improve significantly, with a projected single-digit dollar loss in total cash flow from operations for the back half of 2022. As we shared today, all of those 2022 targets were achieved, and we're reaffirming them again for 2023. Looking at our top line for Q4 2022, both subscription and total revenue set all-time highs, and the quarter-to-quarter growth rates for each climbed to levels we hadn't reached since the first six months of 2021. That same quarter also represented the first time since that stretch in 2021 that our year-over-year quarterly growth rates rose for subscription and total revenue alike. While we expect professional services revenues to remain hard to forecast and to continue shrinking on the whole, we do expect subscription revenue growth rates on a year-over-year quarterly basis across 2023 to come in above what we posted during the final three quarters of 2022. Turning to adjusted EBITDA profitability, we posted the smallest adjusted EBITDA loss across the last 5 quarters, and despite a highly turbulent year, we have secured our original annual guidance for 2022; we keep taking proactive steps to modify our spending levels so we can return to profitable growth. Along those lines, in early January, we announced that because of the macroeconomic climate, we are reducing our workforce by 11%. Today we're restating our goal: we want to keep making progress each quarter, lowering our adjusted EBITDA loss until it reaches single digits in 2023, and then reach breakeven in 2024. Turning to cash flows: in the back half of 2022, we achieved the single-digit loss from operations we'd forecast. We're also restating our plan to significantly cut our yearly cash burn in 2023, and most of those losses will likely land in Q1 due to normal seasonality plus the fact that our January cost cuts won't do much for that quarter. We expect to hit breakeven on cash flow from operations in 2024, with enough cash on hand. In 2019 and again in 2020, the business achieved profitability on an adjusted EBITDA basis as well as in cash flow from operations, and we have strong confidence that we'll return to that position before long. Turning now to our business update: across each of our segments, we closed new business during the fourth quarter. The patterns that shaped 2022 continue to hold — communication and training for employees and partners, engagement with customers, events both internal and external, and student learning — with all of them still moving in the direction of online, video-centric experiences, and powering exactly that is what Kaltura's products were designed to do. On top of that, companies increasingly prize the ability to bring their presently fragmented video requirements together around Kaltura's one flexible, tightly integrated, engaging, enterprise-grade platform. This means they can avoid fragmented processes and isolated pools of content, all while reducing the technical and operational headaches and expenses that come with them. Now, on the media and telecom side, in Q4 we closed an upsell deal with a major telecom client of ours — one that depends on Kaltura's cloud platform to power its multi-country TV operations across Europe. Looking at forecasted usage, our yearly revenue from this account should grow by over $2 million in 2023 compared with 2022. Also during the quarter, we wrapped up cloud PV deliveries for two other sizable telecom clients, and subscription revenue from those projects will start being recognized. Our partnership continues to deepen with a major global brokerage firm, which has now brought Kaltura on board to handle its outbound marketing as well. In the pharmaceutical space, we achieved notable wins with 2 of the 10 biggest drug makers worldwide. The first of these is a brand-new client that has adopted Kaltura to support its internal video applications, while the second — already a Kaltura customer — has begun using it to run both internal and external events. Additionally, we are broadening the range of use cases delivered through our event platform at one of the biggest technology organizations on the planet, which was among the earliest to embrace our offering. There's rising interest in what we offer for Events from numerous sectors — as I noted, financial services, pharma and tech, plus health care, manufacturing, market research and education. On the subject of events, our second annual Virtually Live! took place last November, drawing registrations from more than 5,000 professionals in events, marketing leadership and digital experience creation, who tuned in for speakers from Accenture, Lenovo, AWS, SAP, Salesforce, Oracle, Adobe, Microsoft, Google, Cisco, IBM, Airbnb, VMware and plenty of others. Through that gathering, we were also able to put our event platform in front of a broad set of prospective customers, which produced over 1,000 qualified leads that are now feeding our pipeline. When it comes to product development, we continued advancing both our Events platform and our new webinars product throughout this quarter. With our offerings, any organization, regardless of sector or size, can put on all kinds of branded events — anything from a basic webinar up to multi-day, multi-track gatherings held online or in hybrid form with full branding. Over the quarter, our investments went toward stronger user authentication and management capabilities, a better mobile user experience, our new virtual meeting room and chat experiences, and more sophisticated analytics. We also continued building deeper ties with other companies, including a renewed integration with Webex App Hub that gives customers a simple way to have a Webex meeting recording moved into our platform automatically — something they can already do with recordings made in Zoom and Teams. Finally, we introduced the latest iteration of our Player along with Player Studio, bringing better features, a redesigned interface, and more integrations from other providers. Even though these offerings are extremely component-based, they keep requiring fewer Kaltura offerings in order to get started and tailor them; plus fresh launches such as our webinars offerings already come entirely self-service. To support our push to move beyond intensive sales toward lighter-touch and self-service driven product-led growth, in January we added a fresh face to our Board of Directors, Eyal Manor. He serves as Chief Product Officer at Twilio, overseeing product and engineering there. Earlier in his career, he worked 14 years at Google, holding the role of General Manager at Google Cloud. Even earlier, he served as Vice President of Engineering at YouTube. And prior to his time at Google, he started a voice and video SaaS streaming company. We feel lucky to gain from Mr. Manor's deep product and business expertise. Looking ahead toward 2023, we feel enthusiasm regarding our widening product lineup, our market expansion, and our solid standing as a horizontal platform provider tackling numerous use cases within our sector. Conversely, we continue to observe how the macroeconomic environment affects our clients and potential customers via extended sales cycles and tighter budgets. We're additionally facing greater pricing pressure from rivals. To gauge anticipated future demand, we keep a close watch on forward-looking metrics like the count of RFP requests and the count of meetings arranged by our SBR team. On that note, although those figures declined during the latter half of 2022, they began rising once more early this year, when, for instance, our fee submissions exceeded those of either of the previous 2 years. Though we're hopeful this pattern persists, we remain cautious and practical, which is particularly necessary during periods like this. To sum up, we closed out a challenging year with a robust post-COVID currency exchange and recession in growth headwinds that sharply decelerated our growth well beneath our historic rates. The final quarter brought a resumption of growth, and we're hopeful this pattern carries into this year. Although we think we possess the correct products and market positioning to enable considerably quicker growth, given macroeconomic circumstances and taking into account last year's results, we remain deliberate regarding our revenue guidance. No matter how much our revenue increases, our dedication to getting back in the black hasn't changed at all. That requires hitting the adjusted EBITDA guidance in the single digits, plus achieving profitability on both adjusted EBITDA and cash flow from operations during 2024. During our first 2 years as a public company, we achieved our profitability targets even with everything going on in the markets, and we plan to achieve them across the coming 2 years too. Having said that, I'll hand things over to Yaron, our CFO, so he can walk through our financial results in greater detail. Yaron?
Yaron Garmazi
executiveThank you, Ron, and good morning to all of you. As I walk through our results for the fourth quarter and the full fiscal year today, I want to flag that I'll be discussing a non-GAAP measure, adjusted EBITDA. You can find a reconciliation of GAAP to non-GAAP figures in today's earnings release, which is posted on our website at www.investors.kaltura.com. One more thing before I get into the numbers. We had said previously that we planned to combine our EE&T and M&T segments and report them as one segment beginning in the fourth quarter of 2022. During this call, just like our press release indicated, we've decided against making any changes to how our segments are presented at this time, meaning two segments will continue to be the basis for our reporting. Now let's get into the figures. For the fourth quarter, which wrapped up on December 31, 2022, total revenue was $44.1 million, marking a 3% increase compared to the same period last year. Subscription revenue hit $39.6 million, also rising 3% year-over-year, and professional services revenue generated $4.5 million, which reflects a 6% gain versus a year ago. Our remaining performance obligation came to $171.7 million, a 7% decline year-over-year, and 60% of that amount is expected to be recognized as revenue within the next 12 months. Annual recurring revenue totaled $159.2 million, up 6% compared with last year. For the fourth quarter, our net dollar retention rate was 96%, matching what we saw in Q3 2022. During Q4, our EE&T division brought in $30 million overall, representing a 3% decline compared to the same period last year. Subscription revenue there came to $29 million, which was 2% lower year-over-year, and professional services added $1 million, marking a 19% drop from the prior year. Over in media and telecom, Q4 total revenue reached $14.1 million, a 20% increase year-over-year. Subscription revenue for that segment was $10.6 million, up 21% from a year earlier, while professional services contributed $3.5 million, which grew 16% year-over-year. Then on January 3, we implemented a reorganization that reduced our workforce by 11%. We expect to save $16 million in unrealized terms as a result of this move, and we took on pretax charges of roughly $1 million — mostly severance and costs tied to it — every bit of which hit our expenses during the first quarter of 2023. The plan's goal was getting our spending in line with what the market looks like right now, so we can keep moving toward profitability. For the quarter, GAAP gross profit came to $27.6 million, which works out to a 63% gross margin — matching what we saw in Q4 2021. Looking at our EE&T segment, fourth-quarter gross profit reached $21.1 million, a 70% gross margin, which is lower than the 71% gross margin recorded in Q4 2021. Looking at our M&T segment, we posted $6.5 million in gross profit during Q4, which works out to a 46% gross margin — an improvement over the 39% we saw in Q4 2021. For the quarter, GAAP net loss came to $14.8 million, or $0.11 per diluted share. Adjusted EBITDA landed at negative $4.2 million for the quarter, which is better than the negative $7.7 million recorded in Q4 2021. Turning now to results for the entire fiscal year: revenue totaled $168.8 million for the twelve months ending December 31, 2022, a 2% increase compared with the prior year. Subscription revenue reached $152.5 million, rising 5% year-over-year, and professional services brought in $16.3 million, which represents a 19% decline year-over-year. Looking at our EE&T segment, revenue overall came to $120.2 million for 2022, which was a 1% increase compared to the prior year. Subscription revenue reached $113.6 million, marking 4% growth year-over-year, and professional services brought in $6.6 million, which declined 34% from the previous year. Over in our M&T segment, total revenue hit $48.6 million in 2022, representing 6% growth year-over-year. Subscription revenue there was $38.9 million, rising 8% year-over-year, and professional services added $9 million, which was down 3% year-over-year. Our net dollar retention rate came in at 100% for 2022, versus 118% for 2021. On a GAAP basis, gross profit for 2022 totaled $106.9 million, a 63% gross margin, improving from the 62% margin recorded in 2021. On subscription gross margin, we landed at 74%, which is up two points from 72% in 2021. Turning to EE&T, gross profit reached $83.8 million in 2022, working out to a 70% gross margin — that's down from 71% a year earlier. Within that segment, subscription gross margin came in at 78%, matching the 2021 figure. Over in M&T, gross profit was $23.1 million for 2022, a 48% gross margin, an increase over the 40% recorded in 2021. Subscription gross margin in M&T reached 63%, up from 56% in 2021. GAAP net loss for 2022 totaled $68.5 million, which is $0.53 per diluted share. And adjusted EBITDA finished 2022 at negative $28.3 million, down from negative $12.2 million in 2021. Let's turn to the balance sheet and cash flow. We closed out the quarter holding $86 million across cash and marketable securities. For the quarter, operating activities consumed $5.8 million net, which compares with a negative $10.7 million in the fourth quarter of 2021, and against negative $22.5 million and positive $1.1 million in Q2 2022 and Q3 2022, respectively. Looking at the whole year, net cash used in operating activities totaled negative $46.8 million, versus negative $22.1 million of net cash used in operating activities during 2021. Now let's turn to what we expect for Q1 2023 and for the fiscal year that wraps up on December 31, 2023. In Q1, subscription revenue should be up 5% to 7%, which puts it at $38.9 million to $39.6 million, and total revenue is seen climbing 1.5% to 3.5%, or $42.3 million to $43.2 million. Adjusted EBITDA, we believe, will be negative — in the range of $3 million to $4 million. Looking at the whole year, subscription revenue is projected to increase 4% to 6%, reaching $158.6 million to $161.7 million, while total revenue is expected to rise 0% to 2%, landing at $168.8 million to $172.2 million. We expect adjusted EBITDA for the full year to be negative, between $5 million and $8 million. To sum up, given the macro conditions, we wrapped up a year whose growth was much slower than typical, yet we returned to growth during the last quarter and hope this trend continues, though we remain thoughtful with our guidance. Even though professional services revenue is projected to keep shrinking, we anticipate that subscription revenue growth on a year-over-year basis in 2023 will exceed what we reported across the last 3 quarters of 2022. Most importantly, despite that top line growth, our commitment to getting back to profitability remains firm, which requires hitting this year's forecast of a single-digit adjusted EBITDA loss and bringing down our annual cash bearing substantially in 2023, with the majority of those losses landing in the first quarter of the year. Our expectation is to reach breakeven on cash flow from operations at some point during 2024, with cash reserves that are sufficient. With that said, we'll now take questions. Operator?
George Iwanyc
analystRon, perhaps we could begin with the broader economic picture. Could you provide additional detail regarding what you are observing, both in terms of activity from new customers in your guidance and also your MDR assumptions?
Ron Yekutiel
executiveAbsolutely, George. I appreciate the question, and hello everyone. So first, up to this point, the patterns we noticed during the previous quarter that are impacting us. Bookings during Q4 came in somewhat below Q3. That mirrors the prior Q4. Looking at the breakdown, it was as it always is, predominantly enterprise along with EDU and M&T, mostly upsells rather than new logos. Geographically, as is typical, EE&T was mostly from North America, followed by EMEA and then APAC. Channel business came in slightly above normal, yet it remains in that sort of low double-digit territory. And the proportion of services keeps declining somewhat, though it is still within the high teens for EE&T. For M&T it exceeds 50%, but the overall direction continues downward. Regarding tailwinds, the things that keep supporting us are the familiar, standard motivations for purchasing Kaltura: changing how customers engage, training employees, reskilling, students learning, video-centric experiences — these are now realities; therefore, even though other post-COVID matters have diminished, this remains something people continue to desire. There is still an ongoing move toward online work streams, plus this year it serves as a means to cut costs, and we encounter many people telling us about lowering travel expenses and finding our solution applicable to them. Along those lines, customers are likewise seeking better budget efficiency and vendor consolidation to spend less while also gaining efficiency. And Kaltura stands out uniquely in our capacity to handle content management as well as events of any size, which makes consolidation possible. And when we discuss events, they have grown into a larger portion of our bookings. Currently they represent roughly 30% or more of total bookings, which has expanded across the years. It is entering numerous new verticals. At first, we were primarily in tech, as you are aware, and now it has spread further into sectors such as banking, business services, market research, pharma, EDU, and retail. And regarding financial services, that remains a very robust market for us. We recently talked about how we introduced solutions for wealth management at one of the biggest, biggest banks; in EDU, we are incorporating our event platform, and we are expanding our efforts with K-12. And in Europe especially, we are observing growth from consortiums. In M&T, we keep seeing expansion within our current Pay TV customer base; that is fueled by both subscriber growth and price rises, in fact, that we have succeeded in implementing. We have also rolled out several new projects. So those are some positive developments taking place. Second part, a few of the macroeconomic challenges. What we're observing is that customers are pulling back on what they spend, becoming somewhat more cautious about risk, and spending more time on valuation. When you look at it through the lens of budget limits, that's weighing on demand. On top of that, many of our rivals are cutting their pricing, and their aim is to retain their own customers, since our positioning generally reflects a superior product. So in order to stop people from moving over to us, they're attempting to bring costs down. Last time we discussed the count of qualified leads and RFPs; those began climbing again; thus the start of the year brought an improvement. Looking at Q4, it remained below where it stood earlier in the year. Broadly speaking, then, the back half of last year saw the SDR's meeting set drop roughly 30% relative to the first half. Yet that came back up in January and now in early February. As such, it's difficult to predict how this year will unfold. We're watching it carefully. And up to now, organic usage across enterprise and education has eased somewhat; and within M&T, fresh deals are scarce. Things are still dragging on; so it's roughly a balanced picture, with headwinds on one side and tailwinds on the other; as for how that bears on NDR, to address your question, well, NDR has looked flat this year — this quarter versus the one before. And we continue to hold the view that NDR will begin rising at the start of the year. It's too soon for us to say how far it will climb. And broadly, we're cautious regarding any forecast reaching further out into 2023. Still, we do think it will outperform the present situation in Q4. Yaron, would you like to add anything?
Yaron Garmazi
executiveAbsolutely. There’s one key thing I want to add regarding NDR: as Ron said, it came in flat versus Q3, and what we’re seeing is that it’s beginning to build as we head into Q1. That said, the biggest takeaway is that gross churn figures were really low this quarter—in fact, the smallest we’ve seen since Q3 2021. So we remain hopeful that things are starting to improve, though clearly we have to stay careful as we look ahead to this year.
Ron Yekutiel
executiveAbsolutely. Regarding gross retention along with churn, that figure has consistently been solid, and we have consistently pointed out that, in contrast to certain other video providers selling into the SMB space, our focus leaned toward large enterprise. Moreover, thanks to the nature of the integrations we provide, our offering tends to stick; that has consistently held true for Kaltura on a year-over-year basis, and on a gross retention rate basis we keep sustaining very robust retention levels.
George Iwanyc
analystAnd perhaps to build on what we discussed regarding the pipeline. As more customers start engaging with the platform, would you say your conversion rates have remained fairly steady while new customer activity has picked up somewhat?
Ron Yekutiel
executiveCorrect. Our win rates haven't declined, and neither have conversion rates. On the M&T side, we're noticing extra pipeline pointing toward additional deals on the horizon. And when it comes to EE&T, we're in advanced talks with one of the biggest aerospace and defense conglomerates; we also have a major European bank. There's a sizable Indian IT service provider. Several of the world's largest software companies are discussing projects for Q1; we have universities across the globe; so things remain quite active. As I mentioned, given all the other things I've noted, it may not look like the strongest year, but for Kaltura the market out there is certainly bustling.
Jacob Titleman
analystThis is Jake, filling in for Gabriela. Considering the steps you all took during January, why not move the profitability and breakeven targets earlier instead of merely repeating what has been stated across the past couple of quarters?
Ron Yekutiel
executiveSure, Yaron, please go ahead.
Yaron Garmazi
executiveYeah. Clearly, we made that move at the start of this year. With part of it, the effect will show up as we go along — chiefly during the latter half of the year. Yet you likewise saw the figures we posted for this quarter, and those came in above guidance when it comes to profitability. Plus, incidentally, when it comes to cash flow; so we're going to figure out how to speed things up, and we think the outcome will be solid, though the bulk of the effect will appear in the back half of the year. As for cash flow, Q1 is — has always been, seasonally, a weaker quarter; however, as we stated in our script, we think this pattern will reverse entirely across the coming 3 quarters of the year.
Ron Yekutiel
executiveYeah, I'd like to emphasize once more how the yearly figures differ from what we report each quarter — and for the entire year, Q1 represents a sizable loss relative to the aggregate figures we anticipate for this year. So my sense is that as we move through Q2, Q3, and Q4, the business will appear fairly strong; and again, we've been quite deliberate regarding the numbers for the year; we examined last year, and clearly, we reached our even original adjusted EBITDA figures, which is something we managed to accomplish; yet last year brought a good number of surprises, and we'd rather go into this one holding the proper expectations and then, with luck, be in a position to over-deliver instead of overpromising.
Jacob Titleman
analystThat helps. For my follow-up, Ron, I suppose this is more of a longer-term question. You clearly brought up momentum around the self-serve products. I'm just interested in an update, now that those capabilities have rolled out completely. Which product cycles are coming next that buyers are requesting, and that investors ought to be watching?
Ron Yekutiel
executiveYeah. So, as you remember, during the prior quarter we announced we were adding our webinars product, and that's a completely self-serve offering. It joins the broader low-touch push. Our event platform, as I've said, has sales and pipeline improving and is turning into a sizable share of what we offer. And although that particular one isn't completely self-serve but rather low touch — self-operated, you could say, since it doesn't need event services — it fits within the overall path we're taking. Regarding webinars, that was only the initial launch, and we've begun signing early deals and refining it; it provides a single session event rather than the multi-track events of our EP, and it will keep getting better over the coming quarters. We anticipate it beginning to move the needle during this year, though gradually. From our own internal forecasting standpoint, it's upside, not because we lack belief in it. It's simply a new product and a new market entry. To be clear, the target there isn't SMBs, but rather SMEs — we move into medium-sized enterprises, departmental sales, selling more easily into bigger companies through a product-led growth approach, where we want people to begin experimenting with our products before they hold advanced discussions with us. And during the most recent quarter, we introduced a number of feature sets, which we flagged in our script. New player and capabilities, new integrations such as Webex, and particularly into webinars and events. Our overflow room, mobile activity, plus additional authentication and user management. So we're pushing hard on that. I believe it's fair to say that if you view it not quarter by quarter but year over year, it will turn into a meaningful growth driver for Kaltura over the next 3 years.
Yaron Garmazi
executiveAs Ron pointed out, though, what really matters is that our approach when projecting it for this year's guidance leans quite cautious.
DJ Hynes
analystRon, when it comes to the Events platform, where exactly are you gaining momentum? Are the people buying this using event technology for the very first time, or are they replacing something already in place? And if it's the second one, what typically gets swapped out, and for what reason?
Ron Yekutiel
executiveThanks, DJ. We're seeing both. Initially we got going by focusing on huge flagship gatherings that came with heavy service components during COVID — situations where there was an urgent requirement for a massive event, ones that in the past had been held in person but had shifted to a virtual format. But quite soon after, we began building out our Events platform, and that platform handles a wide range of mid-sized and smaller gatherings that lots of individuals inside a company could use for their own digital meetups. That EE&T offering — the Events platform product — doesn't need event services at all, it runs on its own, and it's steadily moving toward being more self-service. It came out during the back half of last year. Regarding who's actually using it, I'd put it at roughly a 50/50 split between replacements and first-timers. Plenty of people now recognize they want these kinds of activities delivered online, whether the purpose is learning or marketing. We handle both from one platform — internal and external use cases inside organizations. That's one of the advantages: someone can use a single platform to cover both, and on top of that, link it up with their content management. Others are replacing it — swapping out either older webinar tools or older event tools. Typically the greatest benefit they see from Kaltura is how powerful the experience layer we provide is. The interactivity, the branding an organization can apply; it's sort of a fantastic Netflix-like experience, if you will, rather than those fairly clunky earlier products where it didn't really feel like you could interact, get something personalized, and enjoy a really high-quality experience when people come together for these gatherings. So the ease of use and the level of engagement we deliver matter enormously. Part of what we're working to catch up on, adding more and more capabilities, is on the back-end side of these events — things like quantum management and registration, plus items involving payments and that sort of thing, where we keep adding capabilities as we move forward. That's more the back-end piece rather than the front end; but the front end represents a very, very strong differentiator for this company.
DJ Hynes
analystYeah. Yeah. That's really useful context; and to follow up, Yaron, regarding you, what's the way we ought to think about gross margins during '23? I mean it appears as though right now, the bulk of your expansion is originating from the M&T segment, which has lower margins. So I'm just wondering what effect that has on how you see '23?
Yaron Garmazi
executiveYeah, I'd say that right now, we likely ought to anticipate the same margin level as 2023, if we prefer to be somewhat conservative. You're correct that the majority of the gain is coming out of M&T, and our belief is that this pattern will keep going. So as we enter the latter half of the year and certainly into 2024. Additionally, owing to a few of the reductions we made or the downsizing, we think we'll witness ongoing enhancement; so in short, you probably ought to remain at the level we currently have; yet our belief is that it will keep rising toward the high 60s as we head into the following year.
Ron Yekutiel
executiveThe point I'd like to emphasize in that response is that, looking ahead to next year, both businesses will likely see comparable rates of subscription growth. Therefore, between M&T and EE&T, we don't anticipate any meaningful lift in top line growth; and in all likelihood, the decline in professional services, measured year over year, will be the same for each. When you combine those two factors, it's likely that EE&T — given that it carries less professional services — will actually end up expanding more quickly than M&T under our current view. So the fact that M&T provided something of a lift this quarter shouldn't be read as meaning our outlook for 2023 has the larger pool coming from M&T. On a top line basis, then, the portion of the business likely to expand faster year over year is the portion with a higher blended gross margin, and that would help deliver a stronger overall gross margin. This doesn't contradict what Yaron noted — namely that, division by division, comparing M&T with EE&T, the per unit gains have been and will keep being greater on the media side; and we could anticipate stronger unit economic gains as that gross margin keeps rising. And we've demonstrated across the last 2 years that it has kept getting better and better. So taken together, we're optimistic about gross margin continuing to grow; but as was said, and as is more or less the general direction for this year, we're remaining thoughtful and don't wish to set the bar too high. Even if we assume a gross margin that's similar, that's fine, but our hope is that we will keep picking up.
Austin Williams
analystAustin Williams here, filling in for Michael Turrin. I'd like to ask about the restructuring — how it's going so far. And is there any effect you'd highlight when it comes to sales productivity or efficiency, plus sales coverage?
Ron Yekutiel
executiveRon, is it Austin? I wasn't sure. Right, Austin sitting in for Mike. Appreciate the question. So indeed, we went through one more restructuring round as the year began. As we told everyone, that was 11% of our headcount and roughly $16 million in savings. Like always, these moves get put together somewhat in advance, and we keep watching how things develop. Late in the year, we got hit, as most companies did, by a couple of waves. Wave one was the post COVID wave. A lot of people were asking themselves whether this year would come in above 2019 or below 2019. Then once that post COVID kind of wave arrived, folks started behaving more like pre-COVID times. The second wave that struck everyone, I think, is the question of, oh my God, is a recession coming? And if it is, then maybe 2019 isn't the correct comparison. Maybe we ought to be thinking in terms of the 2008 or 2000 world, which led many companies to rethink their direction, exactly as we did in the latter portion of the year, and we cut back. I'd say we removed people from different parts of the company. Part of what worked in our favor regarding our capacity to cut is that we had pulled off something like a quantum leap, this electronic jump involving what we built over the last 3 years around Events and the shift into RTC, real-time conferencing. So once 2022 ended, we were able to scale back some of the work there without hurting the products, since they had already launched; they're already available. And clearly, we want to keep developing quickly. But if we have to slow down somewhat, it doesn't change the fact that we've already landed and we're now in this new market, and we could manage to spend somewhat less on engineering. Then on the go-to-market side, we've materially grown how many people we have in recent years. In particular, during 2021, we expanded the count of RAM salespeople by roughly 40%, and by roughly 7% the last year. So now we're coming back down by about 13%. So if you do all that math, it essentially means we're not far off from 2021 numbers. And it's still roughly 30% more ramp salespeople than 2020. So we have sufficient people and gun powder to handle the growth we're expecting. Is it enough to support a 30%, 40%, 50%? Of course, not. Given the current expansion of the business, the state of the world today, and the level of demand that exists, I'd say our position is solid, and our workforce is being used effectively. Spirits are strong. We haven't experienced any notable voluntary attrition. Actually, it's lower than in prior stretches; and I can tell you that staff members feel quite positive about our achievements and about how we're looking after the organization. Both those within and beyond the organization know full well that we turned a profit in 2019 and 2020. Back then, the top question was, what makes you profitable? Why aren't you expanding more quickly? And our response was, take us to court for holding the belief that a company must earn a profit before entering a fresh investment cycle; so that stance remains. We're attempting to handle matters prudently. We've got the appropriate number of sales personnel to meet present demand, and we believe our balance is right.
Austin Williams
analystYeah, that helps. I've got just one more question. Regarding how you're handling guidance — it seems like professional services revenue is dropping quite a bit this year. And the conservatism you've built into the guide — does your outlook factor in any macro improvement or worsening? Or does it presume market conditions will remain roughly unchanged?
Ron Yekutiel
executiveYeah, I'm assuming things will remain roughly unchanged; the figure we've provided for professional services is certainly a carefully considered one. Nothing proves with 100% certainty that this will be the extent of the decline, and that it is — will keep falling, but we'll have to wait and see. But no, this isn't — there's no optimism baked into it. That said, there's no underlying conviction that something catastrophic is coming either; we're simply looking at last year. We're noticing how a great many people spent less on professional services, and we've made this shift toward recurring, and we'd prefer to set the bar lower so we aren't chasing every dollar available, instead focusing on building a healthy business — a SaaS business; and we're mostly keeping our attention on the subscription recurring revenue, which is the sticky portion; clearly, the fact that we can customize and let companies tightly integrate our offering into their workflows is a major advantage. And nobody should confuse the fact that we're lowering revenue from professional services with the idea that our customers can't integrate, customize, and accomplish a great deal. They simply don't always have to pay us for that. So it remains a very significant differentiator and one that keeps our gross retention figures high, as I mentioned before. But we're lowering the expectation for how much money we'll recover and hopefully exceed that.
Michael Funk
analystFirst off, during your prepared remarks you mentioned that pricing pressure is building throughout the market. Can you quantify it for me — are we talking about 5% pricing pressure, or 10%? And as part two of the same question, are there current customers approaching you to request a lower price? And do you grant them one so that you can retain that very strong GR?
Ron Yekutiel
executiveYeah. Yeah. I appreciate the question, Michael. As for quantifying it, that's obviously tough, because we aren't in a business with hundreds or thousands of small and medium customers. We're in the larger business. So for that reason, you won't find a million negotiations happening simultaneously. In most cases, these aren't really the kind of traditional price-matching arrangements. That said, we do see it pop up in particular tenders and particular scenarios. When it does show up, the discount can go as high as 10%, maybe even 15%. A 5% cut is always a possibility. That's not even a case of some broader economic force at work, yet we're seeing situations where competitive pressure pushes things beyond 10% at times. As for our approach, once again, we're generally regarded as the top-tier offering in the market, and customers appreciate the extra value they get. In most cases, both in the past and right now, we come out on top in deals despite charging more, and that's because the value we bring is bigger. So when a prospect is staring at cheaper options from our rivals, what often happens is we're able to make up that gap by delivering extra value instead of having to cut our cost or price. That's why we have such a broad lineup of products. You know the figure — the majority of our customers rely on three or more Kaltura products — and with the new ones we've rolled out, we're in a position to say: you're getting more for the same, or more for slightly higher, instead of getting the same for a lower amount. And we can back that up with added value. Yet once more, this varies per situation—it's not happening across the board. Are there current clients of ours who've asked for specific price cuts? A few here and there. This isn't a universal phenomenon, not in the slightest. Still, such instances do exist, and as I said before, we're in talks with those customers: ought that to be recovered through value, or should it come as a discount? If a discount, which service should we trim to match, so our margins stay intact and the outcome is equitable? Sometimes we can determine that they simply require less of one thing so they can spend less overall. That said, this doesn't describe most of our business. Once more, take a look at the gross retention figures. Regarding those figures Yaron mentioned before, plus the fact that our gross churn figure for the quarter was the smallest we've seen on a quarterly basis across 5 quarters — those figures take into account every kind of lost recurring revenue, whether that comes from complete churn or from any sort of reduced amount; so if we're sitting at the smallest churn level recorded over 5 quarters, that tells you we haven't experienced any meaningful reduction spreading through our customer base.
Yaron Garmazi
executiveAdditionally, Michael, as we discussed earlier, regarding what we're seeing with NDR patterns — to begin with, during the prior quarter, we indicated it might decline by 1 or 2 points. At present it has held steady at that same figure; and like we stated, we're observing the direction shift. We also expect it will begin climbing again commencing in Q1 2023.
Michael Funk
analystYeah, that would be a pleasant trend, and definitely stronger than what we'd anticipated for 4Q. Along those same lines, regarding what you said about premium offerings, how should we consider the necessary R&D investment needed to preserve that differentiation, or the share of revenue tied to premium product status? What level of R&D spending is appropriate to hold onto that positioning?
Ron Yekutiel
executiveThat's a fair question. As I said earlier, we've taken what amounts to a quantum leap, which is what got us to our current position. Right now, our feeling is that achieving the growth figures we've targeted — and beyond that — doesn't require us to spend more on R&D. What we have is more than sufficient to push ahead and deliver significantly greater growth. Could we now further trim R&D and bring those numbers down? That isn't what we intend to do; we see no need for it. Certainly, the figures indicate that reaching profitability doesn't demand it, and we firmly expect growth figures to rebound. Relative to what this company consistently achieved before COVID, we aren't sitting at historical lows for growth. And our belief is that once the macro picture changes, the company is capable of growing more quickly. That said, is it possible for those percentages to keep declining substantially? Yes, that's possible. To reiterate, over the past 3 years, we've taken a very bold leap from the content management space into events and real time. As I've noted before, that was a 7-level jump: beginning with a fresh technology stack built for real time, then progressing to a fresh product lineup covering events, webinars and virtual classroom, then reaching a fresh set of buyers — the CMOs — along with use cases involving marketing, plus a fresh approach to selling that leans more on low touch and self-serve, and even more heavily on channel-based sales as a result. That's an enormous amount of change, and step by step we've shifted the whole company to accommodate it, and performed well in terms of securing new accounts, landing big names and executing effectively, earning solid NPS scores and considerable backing, all while keeping churn low. So we're headed the right way. With that transition behind us, it's as though we took on this huge chunk of stake, and now we're steadily moving forward. On a percentage basis, what we require is far, far lower than it used to be.
Ryan Koontz
analystI'd like to return to the shift toward self-service. You may have addressed this in an earlier question. Perhaps I can frame it a bit differently. I certainly grasp the reasons behind it—lowering what customers pay and making onboarding smoother. But where do you think the product lineup stands right now relative to where you'd like it to be? That's my first question. And second, what are you noticing in terms of business patterns on the self-service front showing up in your bookings lately?
Ron Yekutiel
executiveYes. Thank you, Ryan. We're still in the early stages, correct? And we made that clear from the outset—when you're venturing into so many new areas. On the revenue side, whatever was anticipated to arrive is entirely incremental; so as far as usage goes, we began running this operation, releasing it, and starting to engage with our initial customers to confirm they receive what they're looking for. The feedback has been excellent. There's considerable enthusiasm surrounding the product. I'm not sure whether you've given it a try personally, but we strongly suggest it; so our perspective is that across the coming quarters, it will shift from early adoption into logo count and eventually into meaningful revenue. At present, we've also restructured our cost base on the go-to-market side to be quite constrained. That means we haven't allocated substantial marketing spend or substantial resource spend toward inside sales or commercial sales to support this model. The reason is that, from where we stand, we want to confirm—regarding product market fit and the initial users—that this is functioning precisely as it should. There remain several feature sets we intend to add, including integrations with other CRMs, things along those lines, over the next couple of quarters. So no, this isn't something we can yet revisit and say, let's provide you with all the math on revenue growth and how self-serve has propelled it forward. Still, I'd say that, once again, through 2023, it will begin gaining momentum, and it will certainly become a major contributor to 2024 and beyond on the growth side.
Tom Blakey
analystThis is Tom Blakey from KeyBanc. Here's what I want to ask — actually, a few things. The main one concerns the guidance. I believe plenty of my colleagues have already pressed on this, so let me try approaching it from another angle, and Ron, if you don't mind, about visibility. I'm attempting to square all the shifting parts — we're all on this call, and there's that solid ARR figure for the quarter, yet the back half appears to have decelerated when it comes to RFPs, plus there's some careful guidance in there. I'd like to revisit how much visibility there is on the '23 guide, particularly since in one of your responses just a couple back, you came across as fairly assured about it. Ron, I've got a follow-up for you.
Ron Yekutiel
executiveRight. Once more, it comes down to balance. What you have in front of you is, at one extreme, several elements that are going our way. Product usage, the start of expansion in Q4; at the other extreme, all of us recognize the market conditions we're operating in; and it isn't a robust market. We aren't experiencing an enormous draw from customers that greatly exceeds a normal year; it's below a normal year. Regarding how long sales cycles last and regarding how many meetings get scheduled, those things are now getting better, yet it remains a year with smaller budgets for a great many companies. So, we're approaching this carefully, conservatively, and with thought. Looking ahead across the year, our visibility into Q1 is strong, as anticipated. And you might notice those figures compared with prior expectations are moving favorably. Yet when you look at the remaining portion of the year — even though we anticipate growth rates on a year-over-year basis for recurring to exceed the recent quarters, as we've mentioned — we aren't incorporating a major upward pull into the present guidance. We're choosing caution since we simply lack knowledge of what lies beyond the curtain in Q2, Q3 and Q4. It's early. These cycles won't provide us with sufficient visibility until considerably later in the year. So it's — we're simply handling it 1 day at a time; and we're establishing a very clear base for the first quarter according to what we know, and we're putting a careful, middle-of-the-road, good-and-bad perspective on what might occur afterward, from where I sit. Yaron, please go ahead.
Yaron Garmazi
executiveYeah. Clearly, one key point is that during the prior quarter, we indicated Q4 would bring a quite significant sequential improvement, and what we actually achieved surpassed even that forecast. Also, as Ron pointed out, our visibility for Q1 is really solid, which is why we issued guidance in that manner for Q1. However, as we move toward the latter half of the year, given all the developments around us, our approach right now is to stay quite cautious and handle things one quarter at a time.
Tom Blakey
analystThat's quite useful. So Yaron, perhaps I'll stay with you on this. You mentioned breakeven guidance heading into '24, plus those single-digit figures you projected for the bottom line in '23. I've been speaking with plenty of businesses during this stretch of post-pandemic reductions, downturns, and broader economic strain. There's a great deal coming at you folks. Meanwhile, Ron keeps bringing up fresh offerings and additional distribution avenues, and so on. My blunt question is this — in something like a flat-demand situation, how sure are you that these objectives can be reached?
Yaron Garmazi
executiveSure of it. Take the figures we posted for Q4 — as you can tell, they beat our earlier projection. My sense is that we hold really solid command over this, and we're approaching it quite carefully. The steps taken during this year, along with those from early — well, late last year, plus how we're currently handling our budget, give me the view that regarding profitability/adjusted EBITDA and cash flow, our visibility and command over those figures is really strong. We also have faith in those figures, even under circumstances where things dip somewhat — something we aren't anticipating right now. So to put it briefly, the bottom line and cash flow figures leave me quite at ease. With luck, we can surpass them.
Ron Yekutiel
executiveTom, in the script I noted that over the past 2 years — as a public company, though this also applied while we were private — we've delivered on the bottom line. And even with unexpected developments on the top line, and all of us are aware that last year wasn't a good one for us, for the industry, for the world. So, we have the flexibility to shift things around and take the actions that are required. Chasing the biggest possible resolutions isn't necessarily our aim. So a year ago, we didn't just hack everything off right at the start of the year, because with that 7-degree shift we made, we would have been shortchanging ourselves after a multiyear effort if we hadn't stuck the landing and finished the kinds of products we wanted to bring into this new market that gives our shares far more growth options. And so, we ensured that we finished that, and after that unwound whatever needed unwinding. And in my view, that was the smart, wise, cautious approach to take. So at this point we're moving into this phase with more assets in hand, and we've managed to bring our costs down while still keeping the right amount of cash and being able to balance the company back; so that's what we're focused on. We have a lot of confidence in how we manage cash and in our capacity to tackle and deliver on the bottom line. And simultaneously, to hold a genuine option to keep growing this company or, put briefly, return to profitable growth, which is exactly what we committed to.
Tom Blakey
analystNice improvements there, and I'm eager to see what '23 brings. Best of luck, everyone.
Ron Yekutiel
executiveRight. I want to express my gratitude to each of you for sticking with us and for the excellent questions. Here's to a very healthy 2023 for all of us; 2022 has been quite a year for the globe; at Kaltura, a company of ours that genuinely champions openness, adaptability, and working together, we are strong advocates of pluralism, and our hope is that this year will prove pluralistic for the world overall and a prosperous one for our sector and particularly for Kaltura. I truly appreciate the time you've given us today. Enjoy a wonderful day.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of today's teleconference. At this point, you're free to drop off the lines. We appreciate everyone for joining in.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Kaltura, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Kaltura, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Kaltura, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.