Mirrabooka Investments Limited (MIR) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
July 30, 2026
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood day, everyone. Good afternoon, and thanks for joining us for the Mirrabooka Full Year Financial Results Briefing. <<operator_script>> At this point, I'll turn the presentation over to Alison Gibson, who is Managing Director of Mirrabooka. Thank you. Over to you.
Alison Gibson
executiveThanks, and good afternoon everyone. Glad to have you at this briefing on our full year results. My name is Alison Gibson, and I serve as CEO and Managing Director of Mirrabooka Investments. I returned to the team quite recently, after 5 years at HESTA working as a portfolio manager, where I helped build up the Australian equities team. I use the word returned because I worked as a portfolio manager for this company between 2011 and 2021. Being back with the team is genuinely exciting for me. Serving our shareholders in this capacity is an honor and a privilege, and I'm eager to meet and talk with shareholders in the months ahead. To start, I want to acknowledge the traditional owners and custodians of all the lands on which we've gathered today, and to pay my respects to their elders, past and present. With me on today's webinar are Kieran Kennedy, Portfolio Manager for Mirrabooka; Stuart Low, Assistant Portfolio Manager for Mirrabooka; Andrew Porter, our CFO; Matthew Rowe, our Company Secretary; Geoffrey Driver, General Manager, Business Development; Claire Aitchison, Head of Business Development and Investor Relations; and Suzanne Harding, Business Development Manager. This briefing draws on material available on the company's website. The presentation slides will advance automatically through the webcast.
Alison Gibson
executiveLet me move to slide 1, our disclaimer, which notes that our purpose here is discussing the company rather than giving any individual investment advice. Slide 3 sets out who will be presenting this afternoon. Kieran will go through Mirrabooka's key features, after which Andrew will discuss the results. Following that, Kieran and Stuart will address markets, the portfolio, and the outlook. Once the formal presentation wraps up, we'll return to questions and answers. As noted earlier, questions can be submitted through the webcast using the tab located at the bottom of the screen. I'll now pass things to Kieran Kennedy on the following slide.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveThanks, Alison, and good to be back. I'll begin my portion of the presentation on Slide 5, and I'll start with how we invest. For anyone who has tracked the company for some time, this is the identical slide we have used for several years, and it captures the steady investment philosophy we have applied throughout Mirrabooka's 27 years of investing. At the heart of it, I suppose, our starting point is that we take a long-term view, as we do across the four listed investment companies this group manages. What we are essentially seeking to do is acquire companies we believe we can hold across cycles over the long term, and the businesses we acquire are then able to produce appealing returns as a foundation for the portfolio. In pursuing that, the first thing we examine is business quality, since that is the most crucial characteristic required for consistent returns over the long term and can assist in weathering the volatility that arises to a greater extent at this end of the market. We tend to place a lot of emphasis on the people. They matter especially in smaller companies when it comes to management.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveThose factors carry more weight with these businesses. And in situations where things break down and go wrong, one of the first places you tend to look back on is people, saying that in that instance we backed the wrong individuals. So judging the people, what motivates them and what their incentives are, is a crucial point right from the start. A strong financial position matters a great deal too. Once more, when you examine the businesses that fail in this segment of the market, the pattern that keeps appearing is some mix of people and balance sheet. Therefore, what we truly want is companies whose balance sheets are strong, that generate solid cash flows, and that have good resilience on the balance sheet, enabling them to ride out cycles and meet their return targets over the long run. As for how we run the portfolio, this part of the market is naturally inclined to be more active. The everyday running of these businesses involves greater volatility. Their results show greater volatility as well. On top of that, the valuation placed on these businesses also tends to swing more. So, in order to manage risk and ensure we produce the right returns for investors in a risk-controlled manner, being mindful of valuation is essential, including where extremes show up in either direction.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveNow turning to how this strategy has performed and what it has delivered over the long term. One appeal of putting money into smaller companies, I suppose, is our belief that better returns are available. There are a couple of reasons behind that. First, if you are identifying strong businesses in the early phases of their development, they are usually somewhat less discovered. That gives you the capacity to locate companies with returns on offer that other participants in the market have not yet spotted. What we especially favor is that when you pick them well, you subsequently enjoy a longer stretch of ownership during which they are producing their faster growth, and you can compound that over an extended period, which can produce genuinely strong returns over the long term. As with all things in financial markets, nothing comes without a cost. So, where better returns are available, there can be — and in this instance, there is — greater short-term volatility, and we have lately seen some of that in the Mirrabooka portfolio, which will be a major focus of what we discuss later. But crucially, at the start, returning to the strategy and what Mirrabooka stands for, if we examine the since inception figures, Mirrabooka has shown that this theory — that higher returns can be generated — has been borne out in the portfolio in practice relative to both its benchmark, the mid- and small cap indices, and the broader ASX 200.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveBefore we leave this slide, we do receive a few questions regarding growth in the share price. If your focus is solely on the share price and the returns you see coming from it, then increasingly with Mirrabooka, I believe you're overlooking total returns, given the bigger part dividends now play in the Mirrabooka return profile. Andrew will go into this further. Since our first special dividend was paid back in 2013, we have paid $0.57 in fully franked special dividends. That really stems from realized gains making up a growing share of returns, which ties back to the point I made earlier regarding valuation extremes and ensuring we lock in some of those returns when they arise. So again, with an additional $0.03 special dividend this year, it matters that these are reflected in returns. And investors clearly can reinvest those and achieve compound long-term returns by participating in the DRP and growing their share count over time. So with that, I'll pass things to Andrew to cover the latest financial results.
Andrew J. Porter
executiveThanks, Kieran, and good afternoon, everyone. There are a few new boxes on this slide compared with the ones you know, but I'll go through each of them quickly before we return to the portfolio. Profit rose for the year, reaching $0.058 per share, though that is in fact in line with the levels we saw in 2023 and in '24, which were themselves unusually high. This came about not just from higher dividends received, especially from companies such as ALS, which shifted the timing of its dividends. As a result, we received three dividends this year instead of last year, along with a special dividend from ARB, and also from a larger contribution from writing call options over stocks we held, with a particularly big contribution from options written over Lynas Rare Earths as its value surged. And from the trading portfolio, especially from our positions in TUI and Flight Centre, which were sold at the right time during the year to capture the gains they had made by then. The interest we earned on our cash holdings was substantially higher, since we were patient with the cash raised from the rights issue.
Andrew J. Porter
executiveWe had a decent share of that sitting in deposit accounts. As Kieran mentioned, we declared a special dividend of $0.03 this year, which brings total dividends for the year to $0.14 — that works out to a yield of 7% on the portfolio at year end, including franking. We genuinely see this as one of the draws of Mirrabooka: receiving a fully franked dividend of that size from a small to mid-cap portfolio is uncommon. Even after paying those dividends, we still hold enough franking credits to cover $0.27 worth of dividend, and I'll return to that point shortly. Now, on the bottom row, the portfolio stood at $635 million at the end of the year, and Kieran and Stuart will walk through the main drivers behind that. The Management Expense Ratio, or MER, serves as a proxy for the cost of running the company and is worked out as the cost for the year divided by the average portfolio for the year. So although costs were flat and the portfolio was lower at year end, the rights issue meant the average portfolio this year came in above last year's. As a result, the MER fell to 0.52%, or $0.52 per $100 invested.
Andrew J. Porter
executiveBut no need to stress about a pop quiz on that — I'm glad to field any questions. For this part of the market and the effort required, we believe the expenses are in fact quite competitive, though the Board and management keep them under constant review. Realized gains per share fell versus a year ago, yet when paired with the higher earnings, the Board felt comfortable declaring a special dividend. The following slide lays out the record of special dividends that Mirrabooka has distributed, as Kieran mentioned, from 2013 onward — though not, I should point out, in each and every year, nor at a steady amount. Whether Mirrabooka pays a special dividend will hinge on earnings levels, the extent of realized gains, and what is viewed as a sensible reserve of franking credits so the ordinary dividend can keep being paid during periods when we aren't receiving or generating as many franking credits as we typically do. As mentioned, this year, once the August dividends are paid out, we'll have coverage of about $0.27, which is the dotted line shown on the chart. It's worth highlighting that Mirrabooka's ordinary earnings, and in earnings per share — what it receives from dividends, options, and so forth, which I referred to earlier — come to only roughly 50% of the ordinary dividend, even in a strong year.
Andrew J. Porter
executiveThe remaining portion of that dividend has to come from realized gains. That means Mirrabooka must exercise greater caution regarding the stock of franking credits we hold, so that we can sustain that ordinary dividend during periods when gains prove difficult to obtain, more so than may be the case at other LICs. The final slide I'll walk through is the premium to discount chart. As you'll observe, Mirrabooka has, for the first time in recent years, been trading at a persistent discount—though a modest one until quite recently—which indicates the share price sits below the per-share portfolio value. The Board was aware this could have resulted in our issuing shares through the DRP or DSSP at a discount. So we have established a share buyback plan, to be used if the Board chooses to do so. That said, as we noted in the estimated NTA for close of business last Friday—shown in the box there on the screen—that discount has narrowed substantially by now. So we'll keep watching how things develop. As I mentioned, I'm very happy to take questions on this or any other topic once the presentation wraps up.
Andrew J. Porter
executiveThat said, I'll now return the floor to Kieran.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveThank you, Andrew. For anyone tracking along, I'm moving to Slide 12 now. As I said earlier, the possibility of stronger returns over the longer term at Mirrabooka does carry with it additional volatility. We need to be upfront that during this stretch we've felt both challenged and disappointed by how the 1-year returns have come in, and that's plainly visible on this slide. We recognize that a negative 10.8% for the year, against a benchmark that delivered positive 7.8%, will probably prompt questions from investors — which we're happy to take later — and the weight of that underperformance has pulled our longer-term figures down, and over a 10-year horizon we had previously enjoyed an untarnished record of beating the benchmark. So our central purpose in this session is to give you reassurance that the portfolio's settings and the strategy remain consistently in place, and that we hold full confidence in generating strong returns for Mirrabooka over the long-term future. Over the next few slides, I think it's important to lay out some of the main drivers behind this underperformance, looking both at what we haven't held that has done especially well and at what we have held that hasn't. After that I'll hand over to Stuart, who will give you a snapshot of the portfolio as it stands today along with some of the recent buying and selling activity.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveAlright, let's turn to Slide 13 and take a closer look at the holdings we don't own that have done especially well. In terms of how concentrated the returns have been, this has been a rather unusual year for the market. As I noted, our benchmark came in at a positive 7.8% over the one year. Within that figure, though, the mid-cap resources indices gained positive 68% for the year, while the small-cap resources index rose positive 31%. If you look at all the remaining companies in the benchmark — the ones referred to as industrials and non-resources — they actually posted modest negative returns. So the strength in the resources part of the market is really what drove that 8% benchmark return. The obvious question that raises, I suppose, is how Mirrabooka approaches investing in mid- and small-cap miners. What we've said consistently is that we apply the same investment approach to these companies as we do to any other company. That said, we recognize that with commodity and resource companies, they tend to be price takers — they don't influence or control what their products sell for — and their competitive advantage tends to be more limited. What that really means is that when we decide to buy a company we intend to hold through cycles over the long term, we find it harder with most mid- and small-cap miners to make that call and truly back them when the commodity price is moving against them and to hold them through those more difficult periods.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveThose kinds of companies also bring greater swings in their profits and in the share prices tied to them as those cyclical conditions unfold. Still, it's worth pointing out that whenever they satisfy our requirements, we've held them. We are not an investor that avoids mining. During this stretch by itself, we've held Lynas, which came up earlier. For the portfolio, that has been a genuinely strong investment. It's one we've exited — Stuart will go through that — since it moved up into the 50 Leaders index. What we're truly focused on there, though, is the competitive edge we believe that company possesses. The reason is that, being the sole significant producer of rare earths beyond China, we saw a strategic quality in their asset base. So, in cases where that holds, or where a business has genuinely powerful market positions, a cost position that is highly appealing within its industry, and where we can support returns across the cycle, we'll put money into them. Yet when you scan the index, and especially right now when roughly 25% of the benchmark sits in mining companies, given how we invest with a long-term perspective and, I suppose, the returns we've managed to produce from that, it is difficult for us to genuinely match that benchmark.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveSo we're probably going to stay underweight in that area. It's worth pointing out that this isn't the first occasion on which we've witnessed weak results coming out of the mining part of the market. If you turn to the chart on Slide 13, what it shows is the way resource companies have performed relative to industrials within the benchmark over a rolling one-year period going back to 2002. In that chart, whenever the orange bar sits above the line, those are stretches when industrial companies are beating resources. And where it sits below the line, that's when resource companies are beating them. So as you'll see from the chart, this latest episode has been the strongest stretch of outperformance by resource companies against industrials across Mirrabooka's history of investing in markets. Turning then to what we've held, which has been dragging on our numbers. If you look at the main drivers of relative portfolio performance, I'll begin in the right-hand box with the negative contributors. Over the year, we've owned a number of stocks that we backed as sound long-term investments in the portfolio, and those have run into earnings disruption and downgrades. We'll get to this later, but what we're finding is that the way market structure works these days, the penalty for downgrading profits has never been bigger, and the volatility on the downside has never been bigger.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveWith businesses such as Gentrack, Temple & Webster and ARB, we have gone through that over the course of this stretch. Let me briefly address each one and the way we view them with a long-term lens. First, for those listening, a quick reminder that Gentrack is a utilities billing software firm that also runs an airports operation. That, in our view, is an appealing area. A great deal is shifting in the energy sector, and that is altering how customers get billed. Our take is that Gentrack ranks among the handful of firms worldwide holding solid intellectual property positioned to gain from this, yet it is currently in a stage where it earns both project revenue and high-value recurring software revenue. During this stretch, it faces lengthy sales cycles and there was a gap when it came to signing new customers, and that has caused a very rapid shift from market darling status to a business now under pressure, with many investors having left the register. As for Temple & Webster and ARB, what they share is that we regard both as businesses with genuinely strong long-term records of gaining market share within their sectors, though lately we are observing greater pressure on consumers. Temple & Webster has reflected that in a sales slowdown, and so has ARB, which likewise has experienced deratings in those stocks.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveStuart will go into more detail on this later, but the long-term track record for these companies is worth examining. We've held these businesses for many years, purchased them at attractive levels, and sold at significantly higher prices. Over a one-year horizon, they've weighed on performance, yet viewed over a longer period they've benefited the portfolio. Equity Trustees is another name that has affected our numbers. Anyone who follows markets would know it has exposure to Shield and First Guardian, which ASIC is currently prosecuting. There are court cases underway there. Its role is that of the trustee that had some of these products on menus, and the question being put to it is whether it should have kept that off the investment menu for those participants further down the line. That will play out. The share price has understandably been hit. There's potential exposure to having to foot the bill for some of the losses suffered, though much of that is now reflected in the share price. So we'll keep holding that position while watching it very closely from here. The one we especially want to discuss is Corporate Travel Management.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveLike I said before, we describe our investment approach as quality first, and that is the very first thing we examine. Honestly, we're really attempting to steer clear of blowups. So having a business like this in the portfolio is especially disappointing. It was a small position, yet honestly it's still one that has prompted considerable reflection about how our quality assessment went wrong in this case. There were warning signs, I suppose, regarding parts of the margin profile, particularly in the European business, that we had been monitoring. But they have, I suppose, come to pass, with some accounting irregularities having occurred, and it appears this business will not make it through that. So that is something we think about deeply and will make sure we are reflecting those warning signs in how we handle these positions going forward. Just to finish on those on the right-hand side, companies we don't own, Pilbara and Mineral Resources operate in the lithium mining space. That has been especially strong with commodity prices, and that ties to what I was bringing up earlier. It's important to keep this balanced — there have been some good positive contributors. Stuart will again mention some of them among the top 20 investments shortly.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveQuite a few of these are companies we've acquired more recently, since we found better value in them, and some strong performers have come through in the portfolio. But I'll let Stuart go through those on the slides that follow. So with that, I'll turn things over to Stuart.
Stuart Low
executiveThank you so much, Kieran, and good afternoon, everyone. Let's now turn to a discussion of the Mirrabooka portfolio. If you go to Page 16 in the slide deck, you'll see the top 20 holdings as of the 30th of June, together with how long we've owned each one. We like to keep this slide in the deck because I believe it demonstrates that we truly are a long-term investor. The reason we see that as increasingly important, I suppose, is that it gives our companies the time to grow, to compound their cash flows, and then our returns in those companies. It also means unnecessary transaction costs are reduced, and it gives us time to build confidence in the management of these companies. As Kieran pointed out, a few years ago, we reflected that there was some pretty high growth and top 20. So, we did move down a couple of defensive businesses like Cuscal, Region, Channel Infrastructure. Some of the more recent entries into the top 20 are there. We purchased those businesses in smaller size, but they have performed very well over the last couple of years and have earned their way into the top 20. The one of note that you'll notice with a shorter holding period is ASX.
Stuart Low
executiveThat's something we added recently, within the past 2 months, and we'll get into it in a bit more depth on the following slide. As ever, we're glad to discuss any of the businesses in our top 20, and any stocks in the portfolio more generally, during Q&A. If we turn to Page 17, the significant transactions over the financial year, beginning with acquisitions. ASX, as I mentioned, entered the portfolio following a genuinely difficult stretch that involved several downgrades tied to costs, mostly connected to the CHESS replacement problem, which has been well covered publicly. ASX then dropped out of the top 50 companies — a place it had held for several years — and came back into our investable universe. In our view, ASX has long been essential, unique market infrastructure. It continues to carry a good balance sheet and strong revenue growth. And with the shares having underperformed, it now trades, in our assessment, on an undemanding earnings multiple, with a solid dividend yield. A new CEO has been announced, someone highly regarded, and we look forward to meeting them once they start in September. CAR Group, as the prior slide showed, we have held for many years.
Stuart Low
executiveAfter tech stocks got hit hard in the second half of the year, we increased that position. What draws us is its leading industry position in automotive classifieds across several international markets. It has a very strong balance sheet and highly capable management. Vista Group is probably less familiar to the audience. This business makes software that powers nearly 50% of the cinema industry. Over the last three years, they've been transitioning from an older on-premise software business to a fully cloud-based, largely subscription business. And again, that was a business we added to during the technology sell-off in the second half of the year, as we see it as a very hard to replicate piece of infrastructure software. Web Travel. This is another business we've owned before, one of the major global bed bank hotel wholesaling businesses, and understandably it was sold down quite heavily when the Middle East war broke out earlier this year. Despite having exposure to that region, Web announced earlier this week that their operating performance continues to be really strong. And because of the subsequent share price weakness following the war, combined with a very strong balance sheet, they've announced a $9 million on-market buyback.
Stuart Low
executiveAnd it's pleasing that, despite the brief time we've held it, the stock has done really well over the past week. On the disposal side, as Kieran said, Lynas, the rare earths miner, proved a very successful investment for us during the year, but it got promoted to the ASX 50 and therefore left our index. That's usually a natural trigger for us to revisit whether we should keep owning it, and we've since exited that position. Cobram, the big olive oil producer, and Peet, a residential land developer — we still own both of these businesses. And in each case, the companies did very well during the year. Both are businesses we'd been buying over the last couple of years, but after material share price moves, their position sizes in the portfolio became quite large relative to what we'd consider quite full valuations for both. We took advantage of the subsequent strong share prices to trim both positions, but we do still hold them in the portfolio. Infomedia was a successful takeover in the first half of the year. The next box contains three companies we still own in the portfolio. These are examples of stocks where we sold material amounts earlier in the year, when valuations became stretched and positions had grown quite large in the portfolio.
Stuart Low
executiveEach of the three businesses went on to experience significant declines in their share prices. Since we held a favorable view of all of them, we bought back shares at prices we considered considerably more reasonable. Sadly, in every instance the stock has dropped beyond what we expected and is still trading under the levels where we most recently purchased. Kieran will address this shortly, and we have already referenced it during the presentation, but this is a matter we are taking into account in our buying. As a lot of listeners will have observed, share price swings are far wider now than they have been for many years. To illustrate, across the past 18 months, Temple & Webster moved between $13 and $28 before returning to $5. Life360 went from $22 to $55 and then back down to $18. Fortunately, we managed to turn this turbulence to our benefit, selling during the rallies and generating substantial capital gains that have contributed to funding our dividend, yet it has prompted us to reconsider how we approach purchasing companies whose momentum has shifted negative and whose share prices are declining. I will now pass things back to Kieran so he can go into this subject in a bit more depth, cover the latest market observations, and share the outlook for Mirrabooka.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveThank you, Stu. I'm on Slide 19 now. We've discussed this quite a bit throughout the presentation, but clearly the market we're operating in today is more volatile. So we thought it would be worthwhile to pause and consider why that's the case. We believe it's fair to say that equity market structure has shifted, and it's difficult to envision a return to how things were before. The reason we think that is there's been greater flow into passive funds, which has been well documented, I think, and most people understand. What that means is that a larger share of buying and selling activity in the market is now driven by index weighting and often the operating momentum of those businesses, rather than fundamental bottom-up stock picking. With that force at work, active managers are now highly conscious of these technical drivers of share prices and of their positions versus the benchmark in their stocks, because the penalty for underperformance has never been larger as more of that money goes passive. If you then consider the super fund industry and the performance tests that apply to it, that also means a great deal of money today tracks the index very closely, far more than was ever the case.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveWhat this has really done is make share prices swing around more, since whenever a business hits a rough patch, the volume of selling we see now is greater than at any point in the past, and that raises the question of just how steeply prices are able to drop. So let's turn to Slide 20. What are we doing in response to these shifts, and how does our investment process take them into account? The key takeaway, I'd say, is the first one: none of this alters the kind of companies we're looking to purchase, the ones we believe suit our strategy. Our conviction that quality is the factor with the greatest persistence, that earnings growth compounds over the long run, and that such growth is the strongest driver of where share prices head over time — all of that stays the same. Where we see scope to adapt is on the tactical side, not in the strategy itself. That means focusing on when we invest, plus our sensitivity to volatility and to how prices track the direction and operating momentum and earnings momentum of businesses, along with index weighting — factors we believe can help us get better prices, especially when buying, than what we've seen over the recent period.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveThen there's the sector weighting piece. Shifts across sectors have been bigger than ever, and it's worth thinking about how that has unfolded during the past few years. As we've mentioned during this presentation, we've been through a stretch of unusually elevated turnover and selling in Mirrabooka across the last three or four years, since we recognized that the quality companies we favor have frequently carried richer ratings and higher valuations than previously. That has meant more selling and more generation of capital gains. Looking at it now, we consider the kinds of high-returning businesses available in sectors such as technology and healthcare and where those stand today, and the situation has actually reversed. In our view, if you look at the sectors that are currently most out of favor, that is in fact where the portfolio has good representation, which has been one of the underlying headwinds to the portfolio's performance. The last slide, Slide 22, turning to outlook. As we said, we are not altering our approach to investing. We believe the LIC structure gives us a unique capacity to see through cycles and act as a genuine long-term investor.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveAnd we believe Mirrabooka's track record over the long term gives us the confidence to keep doing that. When we look at the portfolio, we feel good about the businesses we hold. We think our portfolio of stocks carries extra competitive advantage compared with the universe. We see attractive returns over the long term. And the valuation backdrop for these businesses is now less demanding. Returns since inception give us really strong confidence over the long term. But as always, the near-term direction of markets and economies is always hard to predict. Right now there are any number of things — White House policy, Middle Eastern conflict, I guess the tax changes we've seen in Australia, and the consumer pressure we're seeing in Australia — that do create some caution in the short term, but we have strong belief in the portfolio and in our strategy for the long term. So with that, I'll hand over to Claire, and she'll queue some questions.
Executive
executiveAppreciate it, Kieran, and thank you for the questions. <<operator_script>> This one might be for Kieran or for Stu. Would either of you be able to share some perspective regarding the average return on equity and the earnings growth within the Mirrabooka portfolio?
Kieran Kennedy
executiveYes. Look, it's clearly spread across a portfolio of 60 stocks, each sitting at a different point in its maturity. There's a lot going on when you try to quote a return on equity number, and I think citing a figure can be misleading. But when we consider what we're looking to invest in and how we identify quality, obviously, companies that have a spread over their cost of capital — the mature companies in the portfolio — that's absolutely a factor we look at, and we see that well represented across the portfolio. So, we're confident our portfolio of stocks has a higher return than the average in the indices, but there's a lot of noise in terms of short-term earnings that influences those return on equity figures in our benchmark.
Executive
executiveThis listener noted that AFIC has put money into overseas equities. Would Mirrabooka think about taking the same step?
Kieran Kennedy
executiveOf course, we'd never rule anything out completely. It's a topic we've considered before. We actually make trips to look at certain companies held in the portfolio. In the past, we've frequently noted that some of the high-quality Australian businesses carry pretty steep valuations compared with what you find in other global markets. Still, right now we genuinely believe we've witnessed some recent ups and downs within the portfolio. What we're strongly driven to do at present is go out and search for the next companies listed on the ASX that can truly power our returns and bring us back to producing those solid long-term results in the portfolio. So that, I'd say, is where our attention sits for the near term. Over the medium to long term, though, we wouldn't dismiss it.
Executive
executiveAll right. During the presentation, you mentioned the investment in the Corporate Travel Group. Has this investment been written down?
Kieran Kennedy
executiveWe actually went beyond that point—we sold that investment. Clearly, the price we got for it was a modest sum. But in this case, we had substantial capital gains during the year. So the greatest value that stock could deliver to the portfolio going forward was to realize that loss and offset a portion of those gains. And it's worth noting that after this activity we still had net capital gains, which has funded the dividend, but corporate travel is no longer something we own.
Executive
executiveThis question ties back to your earlier point about realized gains forming a component of the dividend. When did Mirrabooka last record earnings per share above its dividend per share?
Andrew J. Porter
executiveHonestly, I can't recall an instance — definitely not over the past 15 to 20 years. Ever since we raised the dividend to $0.10 and higher, it has remained a central element. Realized gains have consistently provided the funding for it.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveYes. Look, I get the reasoning behind that question. My guess is it's about how sustainable this is — whether that dividend policy can hold up. But I think it's worth reflecting on this part of the market. The average dividend yield among mid- and small-cap companies sits in the low 2%. So that's roughly the running yield you'd get buying the average stock in the market. I guess when you're a listed investment company, with the kind of volatility we deal with, the extreme valuation, being prudent as we are, and I guess the way businesses change, you get businesses taken over. There's just a natural level of turnover you're going to have in a portfolio. When we have that turnover and we've had a successful investment, we pay tax as a company. And that takes away some of the value out of the portfolio because you paid the tax. We get a franking credit from that. We've got to communicate that value back to shareholders because it's important that a franking credit on our balance sheet is worth nothing. But when it goes back to shareholders, that's where the value is transmitted. So, it is important that we pay out those realized gains.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveTurning to your question, though, I'd say the key thing is that we approach this sustainably. What has pleased us most about Mirrabooka's dividend policy is that we came through both the GFC and the COVID pandemic, periods when dividends across the market were reduced substantially. And even in a portfolio such as this one, which operates at the small and mid-cap end of the market, we did not reduce the ordinary dividend during that stretch. So we believe that is worth pointing out.
Andrew J. Porter
executiveAnd I'd point out that this is exactly why our franking credit reserve balance sits higher than what you'd find elsewhere.
Executive
executiveThanks a lot. So this question concerns shifts across sectors. You mentioned portfolio turnover, and I'd like to ask whether we've seen any significant sector-level changes within the portfolio.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveNot really, no. I mean, we’re bottom-up investors, and that’s still true. We assess every stock on its own merits. I think when we mentioned some of the sector volatility earlier, part of our thinking is that when we were dealing with some of the very high valuations in the portfolio over the past three or four years, as I said, that resulted in more turnover, which is benefiting the dividends now. Going through those conditions, our lesson from that stretch is probably to look more at sectors then and ask where the unloved sectors are and which best-quality businesses you could hold for the long term in those sectors, while the higher-growth sectors we invest in are flying high. So that’s the lesson we’ll apply over the next cycle. But I think we’re now in a position where it has flipped. And I guess the sectors where we have strong representation in the portfolio are the ones out of favor now, which gives us some confidence from a valuation standpoint going forward.
Executive
executiveOkay. Andrew, will the DRP be active when it comes to the final dividend?
Andrew J. Porter
executiveCorrect. The DSP will as well — that's the bonus share plan. So for this dividend, the Board has chosen to leave those in place.
Executive
executiveThere's a question that's come in regarding Objective Corp, where the share price has moved around somewhat recently. What's management's take on the news that the Department of Defense chose not to renew its agreement? Perhaps you could offer some reflection on that announcement, and then share your own views on it as well.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveYes, I’ll handle that question, Claire. Yes, you caught that well. And clearly, this development surprised us as well. For some context for everyone listening, Objective makes software for local government, federal government, and many government agencies. The specific contract was with the Department of Defense, and it was not renewed; essentially, they had been with the Department of Defense for several years, and this involved the support and maintenance revenue tied to that contract. It was fairly significant to the business—around 7% of revenues—and it was a considerable surprise both to us and to the company. We have obviously talked with the company since then, and they were taken aback. As part of our ongoing work, we are trying to determine what drove that outcome—whether it relates specifically to Objective’s software or whether pricing played a role. We feel reasonably confident that it was specific to the Department of Defense. They are using an older on-premises product, which differs substantially from Objective’s current subscription software stack. But when you look at software companies, they tend to have very low churn and very high returns.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveIf they do end up losing a contract, that's a moment when we need to step back from the investment case and truly dig into the reasons behind it, and that work is ongoing. That said, right now our sense is that this is isolated, though clearly we will reconnect with the company around its results period, speak with them in greater depth, review the complete financials, and form our judgment from there.
Stuart Low
executiveTo build on that point, isn't it rather uncommon to have a case like this, where support hasn't been renewed yet the product is still in use? That tells us there's a great deal of work ahead to figure out precisely what is happening.
Executive
executiveThanks, guys. So this question concerns share repurchases. Are there particular companies you believe are executing buybacks in a way that genuinely adds value?
Kieran Kennedy
executiveIt's a fair question, and I'll respond in broad terms. What we tend to favor is businesses sitting on hidden value in their balance sheets—ones with genuinely robust financial footing. Over the past 6 to 12 months, we've observed a clear increase in the count of portfolio holdings running active on-market buybacks, and that's a positive sign for us. It signals confidence, though it isn't always a reliable one—we've seen buybacks previously that came ahead of significant declines in share price. Still, it's an effective way to put a latent balance sheet to work. Webjet strikes me as a strong recent illustration, where they seem to feel that if the market isn't willing to bid for it, then deploying our capital there makes sense at this point.
Executive
executiveThere's a question I have about Clover Corporation. Has this company ever come up in your considerations? Or have you had a chance to meet its management team?
Stuart Low
executiveWe never actually engaged with that business as a company — we haven't sat down with its management team. That was several years back at this point, and it never passed the screen for the criteria we seek, meaning, I suppose, the free cash generation along with a continuing growth narrative. And I suppose Clover falls into that category. My guess is the market cap sits around $150 million at present. One thing we're considering more widely is possibly lifting the threshold on market caps and, I suppose, the scale and maturity of the businesses we put money into. What we've observed, I think, is that certain liquidity constraints among micro caps and small caps — and beyond that, the outlook following these budget changes as to whether we'll receive the proper reward or whether they'll be priced correctly in that segment of the market — make it potentially an area where we shift somewhat further up, I suppose, the food chain when it comes to market caps and the size of companies.
Executive
executiveThanks, Stu. This one's regarding PWR Holdings, and the portfolio holds a modest position there. Would you say their shift toward cooling systems for drones and aerospace turns them into a more appealing investment?
Kieran Kennedy
executiveYes. Look, that's a really sharp question, and we do hold a modest position in the portfolio. I think the straightforward answer is yes. I mean, it took us some time to get comfortable. These are new markets — large new markets they're moving into. We have some hesitation regarding the margins they'll generate in those markets compared with the core Formula 1 pedigree of the business. But what we admire about the company is that a business which has built fantastic, unique IP on the Gold Coast, with a genuinely charismatic founder, has been willing to back itself, put capital in overseas, and take that expertise into bigger markets such as aerospace and defense. I actually caught up with them recently in the U.K. within the last month or two. And simply observing the progress there since they opened that facility, I came away really encouraged that they're gaining traction on that bold choice to double down and reinvest in the business. And that's, I suppose, part of the buzz you get from investing in smaller companies. One thing I'd mention, and the reason it's a small position, is that it's a fairly popular stock and the valuation has jumped up again.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveWe would really like that stock to get a valuation that feels fairer, I suppose, so that we could go ahead and build the position, but on that we will be patient.
Executive
executiveAnd did you think about participating in the Vista cap raise? Sorry if I got that wrong.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveNo, look, that isn't something that's really been front of mind for us recently.
Executive
executiveOne question I have concerns how long the LIC model can last, especially regarding how popular it is with younger investors.
Andrew J. Porter
executiveYes. Brit, we still believe there's a great deal going for the LIC model. We've discussed at some length today the capacity to build reserves and distribute dividends. And I think that's going to be essential. What we haven't witnessed yet is a prolonged market decline when that kind of strength truly proves its worth. So let's wait and see how things unfold, and whether that does increase interest in LICs. But certainly, I can say that as a group, we have been stepping up our marketing efforts. And in fact, the fact that Claire and Suzanne are here is evidence of that. We recognize that we do need to — we can't simply wait for them to approach us. We do need to reach out to shareholders and explain those advantages. Geoffrey, I'm not sure whether there's anything else you'd like to add.
Geoffrey Driver
executiveWell, Andrew, I think there's clearly growth in ETFs, and that's where people are being drawn. But as investors progress through their investment journey, especially once they begin considering the LIC model and dividend sustainability, that's an area where they start coming back to listed investment companies. As Kieran said, we still believe it's a great model for taking a long-term investment view. And referring to your earlier point about downturns, that's actually when the LIC model proves itself. In the past, when we've been through a downturn in investment cycles and interest rates have also fallen, LICs have returned to favor quite dramatically. So there's cyclicality around the discounts, but there may also be some longer-term structural issues, and we are addressing those. Given the nature of the market and the growth of self-managed super funds, we remain confident that the LSE model is very effective for those particular investments.
Executive
executiveThanks. This question concerns Magellan and the fact that they think, or seem to recall, that it was in the portfolio previously. And they're simply asking whether the merger or takeover with Barrenjoey will make them a candidate for the portfolio going forward.
Stuart Low
executiveNo, that hasn't happened in Mirrabooka, and at the moment it isn't really something we've formed a very active view on. So I'd probably just let that one pass through.
Executive
executiveThere's a question about resources. So do you make a distinction between mining services businesses and those that actually own or extract the resources?
Kieran Kennedy
executiveWell, I think it comes back to what we mentioned before — we begin from that same philosophy. The whole question is whether you can hold onto this business over the long haul across various cycles, and why you'd believe that's possible. The most obvious business element there is a durable competitive edge. So, I mean, ALS is the portfolio's second-largest stock. In a sense it's a mining services business, since it tests samples in its labs taken from mines. We've held it for more than 20 years across different cycles, including when mining was under pressure and their earnings fell — but that has often handed you a genuinely good chance to buy back in, because they run a network of laboratories worldwide. They possess competitive advantages. Very few scaled competitors exist in that industry. And if you look across the cycle and take the average earnings they generate over it, it's really appealing relative to the capital they put to work. So that's the method. I think a few of the difficulties — and it's probably worth flagging, I guess, flagging once more when you think about mining companies at this end of the market compared with the large end of the market.
Kieran Kennedy
executiveWhen you look at companies like BHP and Rio, they enjoy advantages on cost, they've got scale, and their operations are diversified. So if one of the miners isn't producing particularly well — and mining is a hard business — that structure gives you some protection and greater consistency in cash flows. Right now, 26 gold companies sit within our index of 250 companies, and many of those hold far fewer assets than that. Quite a few of the jurisdictions are difficult. So it does become harder, I suppose, to achieve a strong representation where the portfolio carries competitive advantage. But the key point is that nothing is ruled in or out. We assess every business on its merits, through the same lens.
Executive
executiveThanks. I just have a question about Macquarie Technology, and I want to note that it's the biggest position, and there's been some trading in it. Could you explain what makes you so confident in that company?
Stuart Low
executiveYes. That's a fair question. To be clear, it's a big stake and our number one holding. We've been trimming it. It's remained a fairly sizable position, actually, because it has outperformed during the past year. Understandably, I suppose, when the sell-off hit software and technology companies, anything tied to the AI theme went up in tandem, and that includes data centers. So it's outperformed, and that's why, even after our trimming, it still occupies a pretty large place. We're mindful of that. It's a very big holding. I'd say we have a great deal of confidence in management. They've been operating these businesses for 25 years. very heavily invested. They hold, I believe, roughly 43% of the shares on issue. And across our 8 years of ownership of this business, we've observed that as owners they make decisions that are very deliberate and long-term. So we place a lot of weight on that. They've maintained a very modest balance sheet the whole way through and are probably the least geared among the data center businesses, which again provides us some reassurance. It does have two other divisions generating a significant amount of cash flow, their cloud business and their telco business, and those have helped fund some of their data center development.
Stuart Low
executiveSo it isn't purely a data center play. That gives us exposure across cloud, telco and data centers, and that's a help. And I suppose in the nearer term, they've put up their Super West facility right in the middle of Macquarie Park, which is, I guess, the most desirable precinct, and we're constructing a data center there at the moment. It's probably 2 months out from going live. So construction risk on that has been largely taken out. And we're hoping, ideally, to hear a contract announcement at any point soon. But I guess, yes, the size of the portfolio is something we're conscious of. It's probably bigger than we would have expected it to be, given that it has outperformed and grown to that point. It's something we'll keep watching, but we have a great deal of confidence in management and in the business.
Executive
executiveThanks, Stu. Andrew, during the AFI results presentation, you discussed how the altered capital gains tax settings have had an effect. Could you explain what the potential impact on LICs might be, please?
Andrew J. Porter
executiveAbsolutely, glad to address that. You have a good memory. As Kieran walked everyone through, we pay 30% across all our games, and that stays the same. The thing is, as a company we're unable to pay capital gains to shareholders, since it comes through as a dividend. That's why, when the CGT discount came in, separate legislation was introduced covering shareholders and LICs, so that when a dividend is received from those capital gains, shareholders can effectively access that 50% discount. In fact, every bit of the dividend we're paying this year is derived from realized gains. That means the LIC gain remains available for shareholders. What we have to do is make sure that 50% discount — on gains through to the end of June next year — stays available to LIC shareholders just as it is for other investors. Then there's the separate matter of what should happen with indexation, which we also need to discuss with the Treasurer. So those are the two key issues on that front.
Executive
executiveThanks, Andrew. There's a specific question here about our efforts regarding the discount and moving the share price nearer to NTA. With luck, the team has already covered that question. And it's pleasing to note that, as of Friday, the discount has closed.
Andrew J. Porter
executiveThat's right. I should also mention that Mirrabooka went ex-dividend today, so that would have caused the share price to drop today.
Executive
executiveYes, thank you, Andrew. It seems we've reached the end of the questions. So with that, I'll return the call to Alison for a few closing remarks.
Alison Gibson
executiveThanks, Claire, and thank you everyone for joining today's presentation. So, I just want to wrap up with one last remark. Some of you have asked what might be different, if anything, now that I'm stepping in as the new CEO. And what I'd say is, look, we're only at the beginning. But at the core, I'd echo what Kieran mentioned before — our basic philosophy of investing for the long term in quality companies is not going to shift. It has served our shareholders extremely well over the long term. You can see that clearly in how Mirrabooka has performed. Across the long term, we've produced some truly outstanding returns for shareholders. That's a tribute to the team, and that's the other thing that won't be changing — the team. I'm really thrilled to be back alongside this quality team. So obviously, we'll be looking at reviewing our processes. We're taking things on board. I hope you've picked up today on the learnings and lessons from what has been a tough period to invest in over the short term. But I've spent 25 years in markets, and I've witnessed quite a few cycles where particular sectors and stocks become overhyped. And that happens for a brief stretch, and we've definitely seen it in gold, this year in resources, as Kieran noted.
Alison Gibson
executiveYet our core conviction remains that quality wins out across extended periods. And honestly, I see a substantial opening for a vehicle built this way — a closed-end fund — to move into that turbulence and adopt that longer-horizon perspective. The chance that lies before us excites me enormously, and I anticipate reconnecting with shareholders at the AGMs in October. So thanks very much, and good afternoon.
Operator
operatorWe appreciate everyone joining. Your lines can be disconnected at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Mirrabooka Investments Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Mirrabooka Investments Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Mirrabooka Investments Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.