Nasdaq, Inc. (NDAQ) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 29, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Ed Ditmire
executiveHello, everyone, and welcome. We appreciate you being here as we go over Nasdaq's results for the fourth quarter and the entire 2019 fiscal year. Joining us are Adena Friedman, our CEO; Michael Ptasznik, our CFO; John Zecca, our Chief Legal and Regulatory Officer; along with additional members of the management team. Once we finish our prepared remarks, we'll move into the Q&A portion. You can find the press release and presentation on our website. We plan to use the website to disclose material, nonpublic information and to meet our disclosure obligations under Regulation FD. Please be aware that some statements made in this presentation and in the Q&A may pertain to future events and expectations, and therefore qualify as forward-looking statements under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Actual results could differ materially from those projections. Details about factors that might cause actual results to deviate from forward-looking statements appear in our press release and in periodic reports filed with the SEC. I'll now hand the call over to Adena.
Adena Friedman
executiveThanks, Ed, and hello everybody. I appreciate you being here. Today I’ll cover three things: how Nasdaq performed financially and operationally in 2019; what we’ve done to move the company ahead in line with our strategy; and what we’re aiming for in 2020 and afterward. Now to the numbers. It’s a pleasure to share that Nasdaq delivered robust financial results in both the fourth quarter and the entire year of 2019. Net revenues for Q4 2019 came to $646 million, and non-GAAP earnings per share reached $1.29, up 4% from the fourth quarter of 2018, even though the U.S. market environment saw much less volume and volatility than during the same stretch a year earlier. For the whole of 2019, net revenue totaled $2.54 billion, which included 8% organic growth in our nontrading businesses, offset partly by a 3% decrease in our trading businesses, producing overall organic revenue growth of 3% for the year. Nasdaq executed well again in 2019, surpassing our longer-term revenue growth targets in the nontrading businesses, and we also became more efficient, reaching a multiyear high of 49% for our non-GAAP operating margin, despite an operating leverage headwind caused by moderated trading revenues. All through 2019, we kept investing both organically and inorganically to enhance what we offer, guided by our strategic pivot toward capturing the biggest opportunities as a technology and analytics provider, while still putting money into maintaining the strong competitive position of our core marketplace franchise. It has now been three years since we announced the new vision for Nasdaq. Our 2019 results show how Nasdaq can execute on that technology-led strategy, and even more importantly, how our disciplined, client-centric approach is generating value not only for our clients but also for every one of our shareholders. We came into 2020 with solid momentum after a strong close to 2019. Market technology and new order intake both picked up speed as the year went on; with that investment, close to 40% of our new sales went to clients we hadn’t served before, and existing clients spent more on average as they used more products. Our ETP assets under management sit at record levels, and our pipeline for new listings looks very healthy. Now for some specific business highlights from the fourth quarter and across the year: our market technology segment posted 12% organic growth in Q4 and 11% organic growth for 2019 as it moved forward with building and deploying our next-gen technology platform. Total revenue growth for 2019 was 25%, which includes the favorable effect of buying Cinnober. New order intake for the fourth quarter came to $204 million, while annualized recurring revenue, or ARR, reached $260 million, which is 17% higher than a year earlier. The fourth quarter brought several especially encouraging wins. Under our updated market approach, we shared recently that a fresh partnership has been agreed with Skytra, an Airbus subsidiary, through which we committed to supplying the complete range of marketplace solutions so the air travel sector can set prices and handle revenue risks tied to ticket price swings. Within our sell-side operations, 2 new Tier 1 global banks joined our execution platform during the fourth quarter, lifting our count to 6 banks and brokers as we head into 2020. We additionally finalized extension and expansion deals with 5 marketplace clients already on board in the fourth quarter, among them Japan Exchange Group for derivatives trading and surveillance, plus FINRA for its multiproduct trading and data platform services. Now, I want to bring you up to speed on how our next-generation market technology offering, the Nasdaq Financial Framework, is being developed and deployed. Progress on the NFF core platform has moved into advanced stages; and although our work on application solutions built atop the core platform carries on, we regard both as on target relative to our product planning schedule. With 2020 underway, additional phases of this lengthy undertaking grow more and more significant. To illustrate, a major focus will be placed on our go-to-market approach across both managed services and SaaS-based solutions; and we have implemented recent organizational changes aimed at optimizing efficient client delivery and support. We take encouragement from the growth and momentum across this segment of our business, now aiming to keep scaling the business and to deliver improved profitability in 2020 and 2021. Switching to our Information Services segment. We generated $194 million in net revenue in the fourth quarter, up 4% versus the prior year period, aided by index licensing along with investment data and analytics revenues. Across the entire year in 2019, Information Services climbed 9%, overwhelmingly powered by organic growth, with the faster-growing index and investment data and analytics businesses, as well as the more mature market data businesses, all performing consistent with their respective long-term organic growth objectives. The fourth quarter represented a notable milestone for Information Services. For the first time, more than 50% of revenue came from our higher growth index and investment analytics businesses. It is exciting to witness this progress in areas holding clear secular growth opportunities that emerged from our strategic pivot now in action; and although quarterly figures can fluctuate, I anticipate this trend will persist over time. As we move into 2020, we are making investments to ensure these growth engines have the fuel to keep performing in the long term. For instance, we are working to bring eVestment capabilities and insights into the rapidly expanding private market space. In addition, our new eVestment products, Research Management and Market Lens, give us new capabilities for our existing clientele and can provide new growth engines in 2020. Moving to our foundational marketplace businesses. In the fourth quarter, revenue from our Corporate Services segment came in at $129 million, which was up 5%, driven by especially robust results in our listings business as well as greater demand for the intelligence products we offer in Investor Relations. Organic revenue growth for Corporate Services across the full year stood at 3%. For a seventh year in a row, Nasdaq was the top U.S. exchange for IPOs in 2019, posting a 78% U.S. win rate and welcoming 188 IPOs; during the fourth quarter by itself, we brought in 50 IPOs and reached an 82% U.S. win rate for that period; across 2019, 10 of the 15 largest IPOs by dollars raised chose to list with us. Altogether, U.S. Nasdaq IPOs brought in $34.5 billion during 2019, far surpassing the amount of dollars our competitor exchange raised. It makes us very happy to see our listing clients showing that they trust us as a genuine partner while they step into and move through the public markets. At the same time, new companies from all over Europe keep coming to our Nordic, Baltic and First North exchanges, which added 53 new listings, among them 34 IPOs in 2019. I'm also delighted to share that 16 new companies moved their corporate listings to Nasdaq from either the New York Stock Exchange or IEX in 2019, among them Exelon and the newly formed Viacom CBS. Sanofi and TCF Financial likewise shifted the U.S. components of their listings over to Nasdaq, and together with those 16 new switches, this brought an aggregate of $230 billion in global equity market capitalization to Nasdaq last year.
Adena Friedman
executiveNow turning to private capital: our Nasdaq private market unit posted record yearly volume for 2019, handling $4.8 billion in transaction value tied to private company liquidity programs. Growth in the Corporate Solutions subsegment came from demand for our IR intelligence product. During the fourth quarter we recorded a 6% gain. The momentum building in this business makes me proud. It reflects years of behind-the-scenes effort by our team to sharpen and create offerings that fit our clients best — meeting our corporate clients' needs, such as our new ESG offerings, and widening the ways we assist them in tackling the sharpest challenges facing our public issuers. Last, our market services business posted fourth quarter net revenue of $225 million, an 8% organic drop from the same period a year earlier, driven largely by the comparison of lower volume and volatility against a highly active prior-year stretch. Across the full year, the organic decrease came to 3%, once more chiefly because industry volumes moderated in our biggest equity derivatives and cash equities products. Considering the elements we control most, our competitive position, shown through our market share and capture trends, we perform reliably in our larger revenue categories, U.S; and European cash equities and equity derivatives. Our smaller FIC area remains a work in progress, and there we are striving to improve our offerings so we can achieve the performance we seek moving ahead. Within the U.S., The Nasdaq Stock Market is still the biggest single venue of liquidity for traded listed cash equities, and in options we kept the largest combined market share from multiple-listed options, with capture and share developments staying fairly steady. In Europe, Nasdaq's Nordic LIFFE equity market share climbed to 71% in 2019, up from 67% in 2018. As part of our wider dedication to connecting with our clients, I want to call attention to one regulatory development. Last April, Nasdaq rolled out our total markets reform agenda, which lays out our concepts and proposals meant to make capital markets work more efficiently for investors and, alongside our renewed efforts, also appealing to small and medium growth companies. That blueprint further set out our thinking on places where we might help clients operate more effectively in the market; on that point, we are glad the SEC has proposed merging the Consolidated Tape facilities and proposing — and proposing governance changes that give customers a greater role in the SIP plans. While we examine the SEC's proposal closely during the comment period, our comments and recommendations will center on safeguarding the market's best interest and keeping the plan's goals intact down the road. Changing topics, I now want to discuss our push to strengthen our corporate sustainability practices, both inside our own operations and as we help clients solve intricate challenges. Back in 2019, Nasdaq introduced a number of ESG-oriented commercial products, responding to what our clients needed throughout the different parts of our business. Those include an ESG advisory service aimed at corporate clients, plus the Nasdaq Sustainable Bond Network and the Nasdaq Center for Corporate Governance, along with the release of our worldwide ESG reporting guide. Then only a week ago — actually within these past 7 days — we unveiled a new ESG workflow technology designed to make ESG reporting easier for publicly traded companies. This product answers the call from corporates who want greater efficiency in a process that all too frequently suffers from difficulties managing data and from survey fatigue. It's exciting for us to act as a strategic partner to our clients in this fast-expanding segment of the market. We take great pride as well in having shared that Nasdaq reached carbon neutrality throughout our operations, switching our energy sources to renewables wherever feasible and buying renewable energy certificates that neutralize the emissions footprint from our offices, our data centers, business travel and staff commuting. Beyond that, Nasdaq is aggressively looking at additional ways to cut both the resources we consume and the emissions that follow. As mentioned, 2019 was a significant year when it came to moving forward on our strategic journey. With that journey continuing, I want to outline our main goals for the coming years. The first is to turn into the most trusted and most successful partner in market technology and regtech for trading companies, financial marketplaces and emerging nonfinancial markets around the globe. The second is to grow into a strategic market operator and a specialized analytics partner for the investment management sector spanning index, active and alternative management. The third is to act as the destination exchange and partner for businesses everywhere, bringing unmatched know-how in equity markets, investor relations and governance. The fourth is to reinforce our standing as a leading market operator across North America and Europe, improving the client experience throughout the trading, data and connectivity elements of our exchange complex; and the fifth is to be the dependable supplier of liquidity solutions for private asset classes, covering private company shares, private equity funds and other traditional and digital assets. Our plan is to pursue these goals by drawing on the exceptionally talented, client-focused Nasdaq team, by grasping the obvious requirements of our customers as we collaborate, and finally, by putting money into and adopting the power of today's leading technologies — specifically cloud and machine intelligence — notably via rolling out the Nasdaq Financial Framework to speed up what we deliver to clients; we're eager to bring you updates on how we're doing with these goals over the upcoming quarters. To close, let me sum things up by noting that our fourth quarter delivered strong results for Nasdaq, capping off a successful 2019 for the company. As we head into 2020, we stay relentlessly committed to pushing our strategic pivot forward to capture the most opportunities as a technology and data analytics provider, all while keeping segment leadership in our foundational marketplace businesses in the U.S. and Europe. My confidence hasn't changed that Nasdaq is headed the right way in 2020, since we're making the most of the powerful momentum we built during 2019. With that said, I'll hand things over to Michael so he can walk through the financial specifics.
Michael Ptasznik
executiveAppreciate that, Adena, and a warm good morning to everyone. Today I'll focus primarily on our non-GAAP figures, and if I don't note otherwise, all comparisons are being made to the equivalent period one year earlier. Reconciliations bridging U.S. GAAP and non-GAAP can be located in the attachments accompanying our press release, and also within the presentation available on our website at ir.nasdaq.com. To start, I'd like to walk through how revenue performed in the fourth quarter, which you'll find on Page 3 of the presentation, with organic revenue growth shown on Pages 4 and 14. On the top line, we posted net revenue of $646 million. That's up by $1 million, which works out to 6% organic growth in our nontrading segments, plus a $5 million net benefit from acquisitions and divestitures. Those gains were mostly canceled out by an 8% organic drop in market services, measured against a strong Q4 a year ago, along with a $5 million negative impact from currency fluctuations. Let me now take you through the quarterly highlights segment by segment, starting with Information Services, which you'll find on Pages 5 and 14. There, revenue was up $7 million, or 4%. Organic growth for the quarter also came in at 4%, powered by our investment data, analytics and index businesses. Taking out the deferred revenue adjustment tied to the investment purchase price in the fourth quarter of 2018, you'd be looking at organic growth of 3%. Across all of 2019, Information Services delivered 9% organic revenue growth, or 6% once you set aside that investment purchase price adjustment, and most of that expansion came from sources outside the regulated category. Turning to market technology revenue, which you can see on Pages 6 and 14, the figure climbed $22 million, a 29% gain, and that included $9 million of organic growth, equal to 12%. The organic improvement in the period mainly came from higher change request revenues and Software as a Service surveillance revenues, plus growth in both the size and the number of software delivery projects. On the call, we reported annualized recurring revenue of $260 million. That's a 17% increase compared with the prior year, and it made up 66% of annualized fourth quarter segment revenues. In Q3 '19, that share was 76%, and the decline was mainly because change request and software deliveries revenues rose during the fourth quarter. For the full year 2019, organic revenue growth in market technology came to 11%, while the operating income margin was 16%. As we've noted before, we expect 2020 to bring the start of year-over-year margin improvement in this segment. The reason is that we'll be leveraging our Nasdaq Financial Framework investments across a bigger recurring revenue base, and we'll also see the advantages of the run rate synergies that came from the Cinnober acquisition. Now let's move to Corporate Services, on Pages 7 and 14. We saw a $6 million, or 5%, rise in revenues, driven by organic growth, which came from more listed companies and stronger revenues in our IR intelligence offerings. Over on Pages 8 and 14, market services net revenues declined by $24 million, or 10%. If you set aside the $3 million negative hit from unfavorable foreign exchange moves, the organic revenue decline was $21 million, or 8%. This quarter's organic revenue drop stems from lower cash equities, equity derivatives, and FIC trading revenues, mainly because industry trading volumes came in below the exceptionally busy stretch of Q4 '18. Turning now to expenses on Pages 9 and 14: non-GAAP operating expenses climbed $5 million to $335 million. Even though costs came in at the high end of what we'd projected, looking at it year over year, that's only about 2% growth on an organic basis, which equals $8 million. Beyond that, we saw a net $1 million lift from acquisitions and divestitures, and that was partially counterbalanced by a $4 million positive impact from currency fluctuations. When you look at the full 2019 year, our organic expense increase was 2%. Turning to Slide 10, we're introducing our guidance for 2020 non-GAAP operating expenses, which spans $1.31 billion to $1.36 billion. After accounting for foreign exchange rate adjustments, the midpoint of that range implies an organic increase of approximately 3% versus last year, which matches our medium-term target of 3%. Let's move on now to operating profit and margins. During Q4 of 2019, non-GAAP operating income increased by $4 million, and our non-GAAP operating margin came in at 48%. Across all of 2019, that non-GAAP operating margin climbed 1 percentage point, reaching 49% versus 48% the prior year. One factor behind the improved annual margin is the benefit of a business model that becomes more scalable as we continue to evolve. We executed a strategic pivot aimed at shifting our product and business portfolio toward a greater emphasis on SaaS offerings, and we continue putting money into our technology platform, which we believe will produce even stronger operating leverage in the future. During Q4 of 2019, net interest expense totaled $26 million, which represents a $9 million decline versus the same period a year earlier. This improvement reflected reduced debt levels as well as replacing the USD 600 million bond carrying a 5.55% rate with EUR 600 million in new notes at 1.75%. For the fourth quarter of 2019, our non-GAAP effective tax rate stood at 25%, while for all of 2019 it was 26%. That 2019 rate came in at the bottom end of our full-year guidance, largely driven by lower U.S. taxes associated with specific foreign-derived income. Looking ahead to full year 2020, we anticipate the non-GAAP tax rate will fall somewhere in the range of 25.5% to 27.5%. Turning to our results: for the fourth quarter of 2019, non-GAAP net income attributable to Nasdaq came in at $215 million, equal to $1.29 per diluted share. That compares with $207 million, or $1.24 per diluted share, during the same period a year earlier. Moving on to capital, which is on Slide 11: debt declined by $91 million compared with Q3 '19. The main driver was a net payment of $148 million on commercial paper, which was partly offset by a $56 million increase in Eurobonds book value resulting from the stronger euro. When the period ended, our total debt-to-EBITDA ratio stood at 2.6x, unchanged from the third quarter of 2019. During the fourth quarter of 2019, the company distributed a dividend of $77 million in total. Also, throughout 2019, we gave back $505 million to shareholders by way of dividends along with our share buyback initiative, and that buyback met its goal of holding our diluted share count level; with that said, I appreciate everyone's time, and now I'll hand things back to the operator so we can move into the Q&A.
Rich Repetto
analystI suppose the initial — my inquiry — the first thing I want to ask about is market structure. There appears to be quite a bit happening, and you shared a few remarks regarding the SIP, the proposals over at the SEC, plus the recent green light for the CBOE market on close — market close order. So I suppose, Adena, what I'd ask is, starting with, I guess, the SIP. What — it leaves you to come up with a plan if the proposal is approved. I guess how would you respond to that? Will you come up — perhaps is there going to be any — what's your thinking on — will you simply adhere to that plan? And do you believe the changes will benefit Nasdaq?
Adena Friedman
executiveWell, I believe that, as every one of you is aware, the manner in which the SEC process operates is that they issue a proposal for rulemaking. And in fact there genuinely was a pre-proposal prior to the proposal for rulemaking. So that marks the beginning of a rather lengthy and thorough process to weigh changes in the governance and composition of the securities information process or plans; and thus there will be plenty of opportunity for us together with all of our clients and peers to comment and offer recommendations to the SEC in line with their proposals; and I believe that will in the end set off most likely a multiyear process for deciding the future of that portion of the market structure; and I — we are fairly encouraged by certain things that they have included in their proposal and other things that we certainly will have a view on as we consider what is best for the markets. How do you leverage the securities information process in the correct manner? If you consider it, it is a regulated, in our view, sort of monopoly component to the industry. So how do you ensure that you're governing it the proper way? And how do you ensure that you also are providing our clients suitable choice and alternatives with proprietary products in the market? So we have a great deal to consider as we move forward. But we are pleased that the SEC is taking it on and considering it; we do think there are some elements that need to be modernized. And as we had laid out in total — the total market's proposal.
Rich Repetto
analystThen for my related follow-up — you got there before I could on laying out your plan for where you're headed after carrying out the strategic pivot across the last 2 to 3 years. What I suppose I'm attempting to get my head around is that the approach — the strategic pivot, plus shedding assets that weren't delivering a solid return — appears to have gone over well. So my question concerns what you laid out, those 5 things: could you simply point to the differences — or what would you call out as the differences versus what you've spent the past 3 years doing?
Adena Friedman
executiveWell, that's a fair question, Rich. What I'd say is that the 5 goals we've set for the coming several years align with the pivot we've already put in place. But we're advancing further along that path. So when we initially announced this strategic pivot, our focus was really on what we believe are the long-term trends our clients are navigating. And by long term, I mean across a span of the next 10 years — when — back in 2017, essentially, what are we observing over the next 10 years that might genuinely affect our clients, and as a result, how ought we to be positioning ourselves. And so we're roughly 3 years into a long-term journey. The ambitions we've set out for the coming several years aren't a change, but instead a matter of continuing along the road. And I believe the difference is that we've kept building confidence in our capacity to actually deliver on some of those ambitions — that is, to be the most trusted market tech and regtech provider to the industry, we genuinely feel that our Nasdaq Financial Framework and technology implementations, our cloud-based services, the way we're delivering against SaaS now, all of those give us far more confidence that we can keep expanding and accelerating the business. Meanwhile, within our data analytics business, we've truly come to understand the investment management industry in a manner that frankly we didn't have when we entered the strategic pivot. eVestment, I think, has genuinely provided us a level of insight and expertise there, and it lets us keep thinking through how we expand our offerings to be even more of a strategic partner to them. So those are a couple of examples of where we simply feel more and more confident that we're heading down the right road. And then also having that — I set out 5 different ambitions, but the fifth one being private markets. It remains a very small business for us, but the momentum in the private asset space when it comes to liquidity solutions is really building. We're getting really good feedback on the private equity fund offering as well as our core private shares offering and how we can keep expanding that. As a result, we have raised that so it now stands among our main ambitions.
James Steele
analystIt's James Steele here, sitting in for Dan. I'd like to ask about the info services segment, specifically regarding the quarter-over-quarter decline in market data revenue. I believe you said FX contributed to that, but I was wondering whether you could expand on whether any other factors played a role in that drop from one quarter to the next.
Michael Ptasznik
executiveLooking at it quarter over quarter, another significant element was a decline in the — within reported revenue from — unreported revenue usage. That figure came to $9 million during Q3, while for this quarter it stood at roughly $5 million. So that represented one of the additional main contributors on a quarter-to-quarter basis.
James Steele
analystAll right; and for my next question, I'll stay on that same segment. Operating margins fell 400 basis points from one quarter to the next. Did that $9 million also play a role in that?
Michael Ptasznik
executiveYeah, so that contributed to it; beyond that, we saw somewhat higher spending, on infrastructure and on the new initiatives Adena mentioned before, and on top of that, some of the compensation had timing effects as well. Those were among the main reasons expenses came in higher during the quarter.
Ari Ghosh
analystTurning to market tech — that was yet another robust quarter, even once you factor in certain seasonal patterns. So, Adena, might you share an update regarding the customer mix and the revenue contribution you observe coming from nonfinancial players, plus perhaps some of the more recent markets where traction is building? Also tied to that, if possible, an update on how competition looks in this segment — whether from in-house efforts by clients or perhaps fresh fintech players entering — particularly as your TAM keeps shifting within this business?
Adena Friedman
executiveAbsolutely, happy to. In my view, we assess this business by how revenue success and growth get measured across 4 primary areas. The first is what we refer to as our core marketplaces operation — exchanges, financial markets; that represents 1 key revenue stream and opportunity. The second sits within regtech — specifically our smart surveillance product and the way we bring it to banks and brokers. The third involves banks and brokers, where we sell them trading solutions, trading technology offerings. The fourth concerns this newer market segment; and indeed, the bulk of our revenue still originates from the initial 2 — our core marketplace operations and regtech. Both showed robust growth traits, and we are renewing contracts with clients, broadening those agreements and bringing aboard additional customers, especially around post-trade; that is where most marketplace demand originates, alongside ongoing expansion of SMARTS. What we aimed to highlight in my comments is that we moved from having 1 in-place banks and broker client entering 2019 to 6 by the time 2019 ended. Those represent genuinely compelling opportunities since they tend to be — not always, but frequently — provided either as a managed service or via SaaS, making it a different delivery method; it's a richer offering than merely handing over software. For certain clients, we additionally supply hosting and surveillance. That makes for a truly compelling space, and it's unquestionably among the major growth prospects before us. Finally, as you noted, there's a new market, still quite tiny. What occupies our attention heading into 2020 is that we've kept growing the roster of clients within sports betting and gaming; we brought on 2 additional clients in horse racing, one in Australia and one in Sweden, during this year. We have the football index, which relates to soccer — or rather, European football — within that space. And insurance as well. Through the Cinnober acquisition, they possess a genuinely compelling risk modeling instrument that has been rolled out to insurance. That opens a door for us in insurance. And then on the transportation side, as we said, through the Airbus partnership. So growth opportunities are clearly there for us, though it's starting from a pretty tiny base and moving toward something where, as we deepen our involvement in each of those industry verticals, we see a TAM that keeps getting bigger. From a competition standpoint, I'd say this is a business that, in my view, depends heavily on scale, especially in the core market tech and trading solutions business. Scale matters here, and we think we're the scaled player that has had the most success delivering these comprehensive end-to-end trade life cycle solutions to the marketplace industry as well as to banks and brokers. Then when it comes to surveillance, you'll always find small niche players attempting to introduce new things. But honestly, in that business we've been putting real money into machine intelligence. We've rolled out the Nasdaq Data Discovery platform for surveillance. And so we've kept innovating so we remain ahead of those niche players entering the market. That was a long answer, but it's a major area of opportunity for us. And the TAM is expanding as we move into the banks and brokers and into the new markets.
Ari Ghosh
analystThat's quite useful. As a fast related follow-up, I wanted to ask about the business's margins. Once more, similar to what happens after that period of significant spending, things have strengthened considerably across the past few quarters. I realize this can be uneven; however, ought we to anticipate that certain of those margin gains within the business will materialize more during 2020, or should we view it as a more persistent situation occurring in 2021? Once more, framing it as an improvement compared with the prior year.
Adena Friedman
executiveYes. And that is how we examine it — comparing against the prior year. So as you mentioned, on a quarterly basis, results may be somewhat uneven. Yet when viewed on an annualized basis, we anticipate beginning to show that our margins can expand together with top line growth as we move through 2020 and — during 2020 and 2021; so that's what we've consistently stated, and we anticipate achieving it.
Jeremy Campbell
analystRegarding Airbus — and I know I'll mangle the name here — the Skytra deal...
Adena Friedman
executiveCorrect, Skytra. You nailed it.
Jeremy Campbell
analystI was hoping we could dig a bit deeper into what this opportunity actually looks like. Maybe start with this: what would air travel price derivatives actually be? And can we get any sense of how big that potential market could be?
Adena Friedman
executiveSure. Okay, so this was actually pretty fascinating — Airbus came to us, just so you know; they're the ones who genuinely came up with this rather inventive idea, and the idea is basically about finding ways to give airlines and travel agencies more stability in their revenue, so that — airlines in particular get to a point where they can look further out when they're doing their planning and feel more secure about the money they can bring in, which means they're clearly in a position to put more capital into bigger things down the road, new aircraft included; so you can kind of see how the interests line up naturally, given that Airbus is the one supplying that. But they — this really started with a team over at Airbus; they basically said, "Alright, let's do this." The plan is to set up a brand-new subsidiary and get it off the ground as a start-up from scratch, to be named Skytra." What they're really doing is making use of a huge amount of data. That covers most ticket pricing, not just for tickets that get purchased, but also for tickets that are actually settled — in other words, selling a ticket to a customer is one matter, while that customer truly boarding the plane and taking the flight is something else entirely. They've got two kinds of data, basically. One is pre-trade pricing info that comes from the airlines, and the other is post-trade execution — meaning tickets that were actually sold and actually used. On top of that, they pull data from a few industry sources. What they do with all of it is build an index, and that index tracks various routes. A route might be something like New York to London, or it might be broader, like Eastern U.S. to Europe. So across these different routes, they're able to spot pricing trends. And once you've got an index that lets you identify those trends, the next step is that you can build a future tied to that index. This lets the sector employ it for hedging purposes. Airlines and travel agencies, then, are the obvious participants here, reaching the market via broker dealers. Since this is a professional broker-dealer system, those firms can hedge their revenue exposure and thereby adopt a longer-term outlook. It's genuinely inventive. As for what we bring, we supply the trading platform, we supply the surveillance layer, and beyond that, additional offerings exist that we're hopeful we can keep delivering to them through our trade life cycle solutions and operations. This comes as a SaaS offering, and they're making use of our next-generation tech—so that's something we're genuinely thrilled about.
Jeremy Campbell
analystThat's quite interesting. Now, as a quick follow-up — and this resembles what you told Ari on the previous question — could you remind us, when it comes to market tech wins, what the usual ramp timeline looks like, going from signature to some sort of P&L contribution? That could apply to something like this in nonfinancial markets, or to something more conventional, such as the 2 new sell-side execution venues you signed in 4Q.
Adena Friedman
executiveSure. Starting with signing — honestly, the biggest — when it comes to trading solutions, getting a signature on a page takes the most time, meaning the stretch from the first meeting all the way to signing. After that, going from signing to the actual launch normally takes — for a very simple system, we can typically manage it in 6 months, while a more comprehensive system runs 9 to 12 months, based on how complex the client is. And then, naturally, they frequently also have to ensure they're integrating it within their own systems. So I'd put it this way: 9 to 12 months is the more typical span from signing to production. Then, when you look at post-trade systems, which are far more complicated, delivering a complete end-to-end post-trade solution — clearing and settlement — for some of these larger scale clients can take anywhere from 18 months to 2 years, and we currently have several of those in progress.
Michael Ptasznik
executiveHowever, when looking at it through the lens of revenue recognition, as we begin constructing those platforms across the 6 to 9 to 12-month timeframe that Adena outlined, revenue is going to be recorded while the platform is being built. Usually, there's a greater expense tied to that delivery phase. As we shift increasingly toward SaaS, costs will decline down the road. At present, though, expenses run somewhat higher. And afterward, you observe a larger portion of run rate revenues once that 12-month window has passed, or following completion of the implementation.
Adena Friedman
executiveAlso, a few years back, the rules for recognizing revenue were modified. As a result, we record revenue immediately once a deal is signed through to deployment, while expenses run higher during the period between signing and deployment, after which it shifts toward a cost structure that is more about service and maintenance.
Jeremy Campbell
analystSo when you reach that finalized implementation stage of 6, 9, 12, is that where your revenue and margins hit their full run rate?
Adena Friedman
executiveThat's right — once we've finished the development phase and move into production, the margins do get better.
Alex Kramm
analystI'd like to keep discussing market tech, but let's return to the figures briefly. Mike, you walked us through the growth figures, and I believe you mentioned that the organic growth came mostly from the nonrecurring part. So could you also share what organic looked like on the recurring side, since that's the metric we're meant to judge you by? And on a related note, perhaps give us some sense of how we ought to view the nonrecurring piece, because clearly it rose over 50% this quarter. So will things become more even? Does Cinnober make it more even? Or when we consider 2020, how should I think about the path of those more one-off-type items or multi items?
Michael Ptasznik
executiveYes. So as you're aware, the fourth quarter usually carries more when it comes to certain change requests, and other factors also come into play. If you check the annualized recurring revenue slide, you'll notice that ARR rose from $255 million to $260 million during the quarter; so I think that shows the kind of growth you're seeing in more of the — on the recurring revenue side of the business. And you can review that regularly to see what's occurring from a recurring standpoint versus more of the change requests, et cetera.
Adena Friedman
executiveAnd I wouldn't claim that Cinnober really alters what that's made up of. No. What we're seeing, I think, is that the revenue they brought in lined up pretty well with how we view it, covering both the recurring and the nonrecurring portions, and that's what's on Slide 19. You can sort of observe how it went up from one quarter to the next.
Alex Kramm
analystAnd so, circling back to what Rich said, I believe near the start of this call, you brought up the CBOE closing cross, but I don't think anyone actually asked about it afterward. So let me revisit that for a moment. Since we're now a bit nearer to this happening — I realize you shared your views a few years back, when the idea was still new — do you have any fresh perspective on, say, the size of the opportunity there? Obviously, a portion of this pre-cross activity is already happening within the brokerage industry. So what's the actual opportunity we're talking about? Could you perhaps break it down a bit further? And it would be helpful if you might share some of the economics you expect to gain from that potentially at-risk piece of the closing auction.
Adena Friedman
executiveSure. Well, to start, we don't break out the individual pieces of our U.S. equities trading operation. That said, generally speaking, we don't anticipate this will meaningfully affect our financials, in terms of the way we plan to handle it. What we've really been concentrated on these past few years, Alex, is improving what the close can do. We've implemented some modifications and collaborated quite closely with both the buy side and the sell side on changes aimed at keeping the close, I'd say, as workable and as valuable as it can be when it comes to producing an accurate picture of supply and demand at the close. Consider this: multiple trillions of dollars in assets under management track that price. So it's essential that it serves as a genuinely thorough supply-and-demand price discovery event. We felt quite let down when the SEC ended up approving that rule filing — not for financial reasons, but honestly, from a market standpoint and an investor standpoint. We had issuers send letters. Indexers sent letters too. Investors voiced worries, and still the SEC didn't really tackle many of their concerns in the approval order; instead, it simply concluded that exchange competition matters more, in our view, than the quality of the closing price. So that left us fairly disappointed. That said, we've spent the last few years working alongside our clients. We believe we can resolve whatever concerns they may have about this new competitor and ensure the close stays very vibrant; and we foresee no material effect on that, or on our financials, as a result.
Chris Allen
analystI'd like to explore the fresh order intake and market tech a bit further. Clearly, that's a huge figure. I'm curious whether it was concentrated — thinking about concentration in terms of not particular requirements, did merely 1 or 2 deals account for it? Also, what kinds of deals were they, so we can consider how revenue will be realized.
Adena Friedman
executiveRight. We had — the figure — we felt quite good about it. These new contracts have been in the works for a lot of months. So they all sort of landed in Q4. A few major current customers, as we referenced, such as the Japan Exchange Group and FINRA; those are big, multiyear agreements we were developing to ensure we broaden and prolong our arrangements with those current customers. Those matter a lot. The — as we noted, the 2 additional banks that joined plus a few of these others — and a few lesser fresh deals that arrived in Q4 all sort of reached completion simultaneously; so we've consistently stated that order intake is rather uneven; this year is especially uneven, yet it's truly setting us up nicely going forward — regarding locking in our revenue, expanding our revenue within our current client base and also bringing on some fresh customers. So I don't — I mean there were certainly additional names in Q4 compared with earlier quarters, but a number of the larger names showed up that quarter.
Chris Allen
analystRegarding the change request — I think during the prior quarter you said you'd pulled forward $2 million to $3 million. So, to circle back somewhat to what Alex asked: is this simply growing in overall size? It appears somewhat larger than what we've typically observed before.
Michael Ptasznik
executiveYes. A few additional deals came in — particular requests, particular transactions, both involving the change request and involving certain software deliveries, that ran higher this quarter than what we normally see in Q4. So across both the previous quarter and this one, we keep witnessing growth in that business. So you're correct — there were a few other particular situations where extra requests came through. And because we're just — let me return to Alex's question, and regarding the recurring side, I want to ensure this is clear, Alex, when I referenced the $255 million to $260 million. That applied to Q3 through Q4. So progress has kept happening on the annualized recurring revenue rate. So that's — returning to last year's $222 million, Cinnober would be included in that, but there, as Adena noted, the composition of their business would look quite similar. So we're observing the benefit of recurring revenue continuing to expand, on top of the change request we just discussed.
Brian Bedell
analystPerhaps we could return to the topic of how market technology is ramping up. Adena, could you give us a picture of the client count — specifically, how many nonfinancial clients do you currently serve? I recall that number was merely a small group back when this initiative first began, and I'd also like to know how significant that contribution has become. You listed the 4 distinct components of market tech, and this is the fourth one. I'm just trying to gauge the scale of it. Also, regarding those new air travel price derivatives — do you believe that product could potentially be introduced across a large number of carriers? Then, turning to how this business is growing, it reached 12% during the fourth quarter. That's higher than the 8% to 11% guidance you've provided. If you pair that with solid expansion in your other segments, might you be looking at surpassing, yet again, the 5% to 7% target for 2020 when it comes to recurring revenue growth?
Adena Friedman
executiveThere's quite a bit to address in that question. Let's begin with the nonfinancial markets. We — I believe we were attempting to tally it up mentally. My estimate is that we currently have roughly 15 clients among the nonfinancials. That figure isn't precise, though it falls within that vicinity; of those, at minimum 5 to 7 were new clients we brought on board during this year. So there — this is unquestionably an area of growth for us; and as I noted, we added new clients within the sports sector; we added new clients within this transportation sector, and we added various other new clients throughout the year that operate in nonfinancial markets. So — yet it remains — as I stated, it's unquestionably a modest yet expanding area, and the TAM continues to grow there; regarding our total growth rate in market tech, we are — we still hold the view that 8% to 11% is the appropriate lens through which to assess the business going forward. And we'll keep assessing that as we proceed. But we're quite happy to observe that the business's growth characteristics align with that sort of growth rate. And we want to ensure we keep delivering on that, which explains why we keep investing in the business. But our — as I said earlier, the expansion of our investment ought to be surpassed by the expansion of the revenue; so we should begin to show some margin expansion as we head into 2020 and 2021. And you also brought up the overall growth rate across the nontrading businesses. That — we are — once more, that 5% to 7% is what we consider the appropriate lens for our longer term — mid- to longer-term outlook. And so we remain confident that's the appropriate lens for assessing our business.
Ken Hill
analystI'd like to ask about the ESG business. I realize this has mattered to you folks for quite a while, and maybe especially so in your European operations, yet I was hoping you might expand a bit further on what you provide, how it stands apart from certain rivals, especially among exchanges, which we've been seeing more of lately, and how you're gauging, or planning to gauge, the size of this segment down the road.
Adena Friedman
executiveOf course. So it's really quite an early-stage commercial space. There are 2 things we're concentrating on. The first covers investable products, which might be sustainable bonds — we run our sustainable bond market in Europe. And at present — we've only just rolled out the Sustainable Bond Network in the United States alongside our European team, which is genuinely taking the lead on that too, plus any ETFs or indexes tied to ESG. Those are what I'd describe as investable products. The second piece involves backing our corporate customers. That makes us unlike many of our competitors, since our true emphasis is on figuring out how to serve as the ideal partner for all these firms that now face mounting pressure from investors around handling and disclosing ESG. It's an extremely complex landscape to help navigate. You've got all these various standard setters and metrics makers out there, and these companies truly require our assistance. So we've decided to become the ideal partner for them, whether that means pushing them to disclose on ESG — especially across our European markets — or handing them tools, guidance, and consulting services to bolster this expanding field. That's proven to be a genuinely compelling commercial space for us. So, as I'd put it, you'll be hearing more on this as we move into 2020, since we're adding some technology offerings on top of our consulting services too. Still, I should note it remains quite tiny right now. This strikes me as a fresh area for everybody.
Alex Blostein
analystI just wanted to check in regarding where capital is being directed as all of you think ahead toward 2020; I noticed that during Q4, a modest amount of commercial paper got repaid. It seems as though the leverage level is roughly at the point you'd like it to be. So perhaps some refreshed thinking specifically about the buyback as all of you plan for 2020.
Michael Ptasznik
executiveYes. Thanks for asking that. We intend to keep moving forward with the capital plan we've laid out. In line with that, again, seek out strong opportunities for investment and keep expanding the business — that's priority #1. Beyond that, we aim to increase the dividend as our earnings and cash flow increase. Then when it comes to buybacks, we're relying on them to counter the dilution that would arise from any of our equity programs. After all of that, should extra cash exist — regarding debt, you're correct. The debt leverage targets we set have been reached, and therefore we're at ease keeping our investment-grade status. Thus if extra cash remains once we've factored in all those items, examining — if nothing particular exists with — that we intend to put money into within the horizon, then eventually, we'll weigh pursuing further buybacks past that stage. However, that truly isn't a quarter-to-quarter matter. It will be something we examine across a longer stretch of time. So capital filing is very much in line with what we've expressed previously.
Owen Lau
analystOnce more, I'd like to revisit the Skytra transaction. It had never crossed my mind that Nasdaq — that Nasdaq could engage in business with an aircraft maker. So Adena, you said Airbus approached Nasdaq regarding this partnership. But did a competitive bidding process take place? Also, would you mind discussing what else Nasdaq is undertaking to boost the likelihood of inbound opportunities such as this one, and how Nasdaq stepped up its outreach efforts to spot new markets and new industries?
Adena Friedman
executiveCertainly. Regarding the process itself, that's something you'd need to ask Airbus about, rather than Nasdaq, when it comes to how we ultimately became their partner. That said, broadly speaking, we aim to ensure that people are aware of what we're doing alongside companies such as Airbus, so that we attract more inbound interest. Yet simultaneously, we've genuinely been expanding our sales team in the new market space. That has been among our investment areas in market tech. We keep ensuring we possess the appropriate expertise to bring into the industries where — where we're seeing the greatest interest in considering a market's economy-like approach; so be it transportation, insurance, or the sports space, all of these are sectors where we've been putting money into sales, along with ensuring our technology stays relevant. We've also been building modules inside our technology that let us demonstrate our capabilities to these new nonfinancial markets, where a bit more education is needed. And beyond that, we're examining additional partners we can bring in to make deploying these technologies to customers simpler and quicker; so all of those efforts are what we're doing to expand and grow that portion of the business. We appreciate inbound interest, but being able to uncover opportunities ourselves matters greatly to us as well. So the sales push has certainly been a scaling-up effort on our part.
Owen Lau
analystThat's quite useful. A follow-up on that — I'd like to return to Slide 19. I'm attempting to get a clearer handle on those figures. So you said new order intake for the third quarter came in at $62 million, and 4Q was $204 million, roughly 3x more. Yet ARR stayed more or less level. How are we supposed to adjust for that? Would it be reasonable to anticipate that ARR in 1Q 2020 or the second quarter of 2020 would come in higher? What's the proper approach to make these 2 figures line up?
Michael Ptasznik
executiveYes. So regarding new order intake, once again, part of that is temporary — or rather, not temporary, but a portion of it falls inside the quarter and will be recognized there; however with ARR, a substantial share of that $204 million is going to convert into ARR on a continuing basis. It hinges to some degree on — regarding certain contracts recognized within that $204 million alongside ARR — renewals of contracts we've already recognized; so suppose we have a client already counted in ARR and then we renew a contract and extend it for, say, an additional 5-year period, then there might be the — if the amount they pay us goes up, then that will be reflected to some degree in ARR. But — so that represents a continuation of it. It's — yet the new contracts for new clients, that's the piece that will keep pushing it higher; and new order intake isn't an annualized figure. It's a multiyear one. So the $204 million might cover a 5-year span, or it varies with the contract's size. So it captures the entire order intake amount across the whole contract duration being signed.
Adena Friedman
executiveYeah, and the way I'd think about it from an ARR standpoint too is that we honestly believe the quarter-over-quarter improvement in ARR through 2019 has been quite solid. And Michael's point is accurate — out of that $204 million, most of it is going to convert into either continued or expanded ARR. That said, I'd note that combining those 2 figures involves a great deal — plenty of factors feed into it. And since ARR is something new we've started reporting, we're still adjusting to providing it, so we'll keep working to refine how we explain it, which should help you all better grasp how to read it alongside order intake down the road.
Mike Carrier
analystThis is Sameer Murukutla here, calling in for Michael Carrier. I've got a question about the expense guidance, and I believe you announced that NFX is being divested to EEX, if I'm not mistaken; so when do you expect that deal to close? And how much of the benefit from that divestment shows up in the 2020 expense guide? Also, on the R&D guide, I think it's up roughly 20% versus a year ago. Could you give us some details about what's going into the R&D guidance for 2020?
Adena Friedman
executiveYes. So there are a couple of things. First, regarding NFX, we expect it to keep migrating over to EEX throughout the first quarter of 2020 and to begin coming out of our financials as we move through the second quarter; however, it was an R&D initiative. So it has been reflected in our R&D numbers. And so therefore, what we're essentially saying with the change — with our R&D numbers is that we are redirecting the money we would otherwise be spending on NFX toward some of these opportunities with higher growth and higher potential. And we're truly focusing our R&D on those areas that we believe have a very large total market opportunity and genuine growth potential. The reason the investments in ARR — I mean in R&D are rising is that the revenues are rising as well. A good example would be banks and brokers. That's actually viewed as an R&D initiative when it comes to building out and supplying our trading solutions to the banks and brokers; but we have a very significant increase in our clients, so the revenue from that business is going up, but so are the investments in that business to supply — to support those revenues. So the — we're only showing you one side of the ledger when we show you our cost guidance and the R&D spend, but the revenues are rising along the line as well. So the net cost of that program is roughly the same year-over-year.
Chris Harris
analystFor Nasdaq, does strategic M&A remain a priority, or would you say that in 2020 the emphasis will lean more toward your organic growth possibilities?
Adena Friedman
executiveHonestly, we are constantly assessing acquisitions. That's simply one element of what we examine. And our consistent approach to thinking about acquisitions is whether they can speed up our capacity to fulfill our strategy within a specific segment — so either we're growing our client base or growing our capabilities to serve our clients in fresh ways inside a segment, with particular attention on technology along with the data and analytics; yet honestly, we've also completed — we made a small acquisition in corporate services during the prior year. And we consistently consider — we will consider acquisitions in market services too, provided it delivers the proper financial framework. So I'd say we always examine them. The current environment is that they are quite expensive. Therefore we are — we're absolutely very focused on ensuring we possess genuine conviction regarding the financial model, alongside obviously the strategic advantage, prior to deciding to proceed with an M&A initiative; and that has certainly established a discipline within Nasdaq, where we clearly review a great deal, yet we have only acted on a handful.
Michael Ptasznik
executiveWhen I consider the priorities and strategic ambitions Adena laid out in her remarks, along with those 5 items we discussed before, what we're doing there is organic. Should chances arise to speed things up through M&A, we will certainly explore that, provided it clearly satisfies the strategic and financial standards we apply. Still, those ambitions are being chased organically.
Kyle Voigt
analystPerhaps I could ask something that builds on an earlier inquiry regarding the Consolidated Tape idea. Clearly, we're at a very early stage here; however, the SEC appears to be interested in setting up a new governance committee that would establish fees that are fair and reasonable for the new SIP. Do you have any sense of what the SEC might consider fair and reasonable? Could it be a specific maximum operating margin, or perhaps some other measure? And should that wording end up in the final rule, do you perceive any danger to the SIP revenue pool overall, or do you think it would remain steady throughout the transition?
Adena Friedman
executiveThe initial point I'd make is that the fees associated with the SIP have — they've consistently been subject to a fairly strict regulatory procedure from the time the SIP committees came into existence a very long time back; therefore, there's already substantial regulatory supervision and scrutiny any time a fee — a proposed change to a fee arises. And what constitutes fair and reasonable has not been spelled out by them. Our perspective, I believe, is that the governance structure of the SIP and how it gets organized will assist in ensuring that clients are involved in those kinds of choices while also acknowledging that the products being developed generate considerable value. Beyond that, these — the fees don't merely cover the cost of building the product; they also cover the regulatory supervision that exchanges must provide to maintain a fair market environment; thus, every one of those factors gets weighed. In my view, though, the SEC hasn't laid out its intentions in a clear way; and we'll need to watch what happens — how things progress during the comment period.
Adena Friedman
executiveAlright, thank you. To wrap up, Nasdaq delivered a robust showing for both the fourth quarter and the entire 2019 year, and we're entering 2020 carrying significant momentum. The team I lead stays committed to carrying out our strategy, which is driven by technology, so we can produce results for those we serve, and I'm eager to keep talking with all of you across this year about how we're advancing on the goals we've set as strategic priorities. I appreciate you spending your time with us today.
Operator
operatorEveryone, that wraps up the call for today. We appreciate you joining us. You're free to hang up at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Nasdaq, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Nasdaq, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Nasdaq, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.