Nasdaq, Inc. (NDAQ) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 25, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Neil Stratton
executiveHello, everybody, and thanks for being with us as we go over Nasdaq's financial results for the fourth quarter and the entire year 2022; joining us are Adena Friedman, our Chair and Chief Executive Officer; Ann Dennison, our Chief Financial Officer; John Zecca, our Chief Legal Risk and Regulatory Officer; plus additional members of the management team. Once our prepared remarks are done, we'll take questions on the line. You can find the press release and presentation on our website; we plan to rely on that website to disclose material, non-public information and to meet our obligations under SEC Regulation FD. Please be aware that some statements made in this presentation and in response to questions may concern future events and expectations, and therefore qualify as forward-looking statements under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Results could end up differing materially from those projections. Details about factors that might lead actual results to diverge from forward-looking statements appear in our press release and in periodic reports we file with the SEC. I'll hand the call over to Adena now.
Adena Friedman
executiveThank you, Neil, and good morning to all of you. We appreciate you being here. Today, my comments will cover these topics: how Nasdaq performed financially and operationally in the fourth quarter and across all of 2022. The strides we've taken to move Nasdaq forward on our strategic path, along with our company-wide goals and priorities looking toward 2023 and past that. I'll also share a few thoughts about the market and regulatory landscape as it stands now, and then I'll hand things to Ann so she can take a closer look at our financials. We keep producing healthy growth in 2022, despite a macroeconomic picture that remains uncertain and after an exceptionally robust 2021. For Nasdaq, 2022 brought milestones, strategic firsts and innovation that led the market. I take pride in our team at Nasdaq, in how resilient our business is, and in the trusted bonds we've built with our clients. Before I get into our financial performance, I want to remind all of you about the new corporate structure we put in place during the fourth quarter. At our Investor Day in November, when we came together, we pointed out how organizing our business into three new divisions — Market Platforms, Capital Access Platforms and Anti-Financial Crime — lets us take advantage of mega trends reshaping the financial system so we can unlock fresh growth opportunities for our company. Among these trends is the modernization of markets, where we keep delivering innovation that powers economies around the world and strengthens the underlying infrastructure; the growth of the ESG ecosystem, where we assist companies and investors in successfully navigating reporting frameworks that grow ever more complex, reaching more seamless routes to capital, and meeting their net zero or sustainability objectives; and the rising demand for advanced anti-financial crime technology, where we're able to improve the integrity of the financial system via emerging technologies, cloud and AI among them. Our results today show this new divisional alignment, and we're eager to keep going on our journey as we deliver world-leading platforms that enhance the liquidity, transparency and integrity of the global economy, with our long-term aim of becoming the trusted fabric of the global financial system. Now let's look at our results. It's a real pleasure to share Nasdaq's financial performance for the fourth quarter and the full year of 2022. Starting with the fourth quarter, Nasdaq brought in $906 million in net revenues, which is a 2% rise versus the prior year period and a 5% rise on an organic basis, once you exclude the impacts of changes in FX rates and acquisitions and divestitures; during the quarter, we achieved 5% organic growth across our Solutions businesses even though our Index revenues fell 11%. We also achieved 4% organic growth in our Trading Services business during the fourth quarter, building on a very strong trading performance in the fourth quarter of 2021; for the full year of 2022, net revenues of $3.58 billion were up 5% from 2021 and up 7% on an organic basis. Despite a market landscape that shifted quickly, our Solutions segments achieved 10% organic revenue growth for the year, while Trading Services revenues rose 1%, building on an exceptionally strong 2021. We closed the year with annualized recurring revenue, or ARR, of $2 billion, which was up 8% compared with the prior year. In the fourth quarter of 2022, annualized SaaS revenues climbed 13% to $725 million, accounting for 36% of total company ARR; across the full year, non-GAAP earnings per share came in at $2.66, a 6% gain over 2021. Delivering these results in 2022 amid a difficult macroeconomic environment demonstrates how diversified our business is and how capable we are of meeting our longer-term goals. Now I'll move on to divisional highlights, which mirror the new corporate structure, with a focus mostly on fourth quarter results. Within our Capital Access Platforms division, total revenue for the fourth quarter reached $420 million, representing 2% organic growth. Our Data and Listing Services business saw revenues rise 3% from the same period a year earlier, with organic growth of 6%. That was mainly driven by higher annual listing fees and growth in proprietary data revenues from increased international demand, though it was partly offset by a decline in initial listing fee revenues. During 2022, Nasdaq held its place as the top U.S. exchange for IPOs for a 10th straight year, with 87 operating company listings and a 92% annual win rate; in Europe, our Baltic, Nordic and First North exchanges together welcomed 63 new listings in 2022, among them 38 IPOs. For a second year in a row, Nasdaq Stockholm remains Europe's most successful listing venue; in our Index business, revenues fell 11% versus the year-ago period, largely because of lower average AUM and exchange-traded products tied to Nasdaq indices, partly offset by greater revenues from futures trading linked to the NASDAQ 100 Index. Average AUM for the fourth quarter dropped 19% year-over-year. The fourth quarter brought a particularly difficult market backdrop both year-over-year and quarter-over-quarter. Ann will walk through more detail on the AUM and trading dynamics behind the fourth quarter revenue decline. Looking at full year performance, our Index revenues for all of 2022 were up 6% against 2021, thanks to higher net inflows and futures volumes. Net inflows into exchange-traded products came to $34 billion in 2022, and demand grew for our new offerings, with 44 ETPs tracking Nasdaq indexes gathering $3.5 billion in AUM over the year. In our Workflow and Insights business, which covers our Corporate Solutions and our Investment Analytics business, fourth quarter revenues grew 8% from the year-ago period, or 10% organically, reflecting deeper client engagement and strong client retention. Now turning to our Market Platforms division; total revenues for the fourth quarter were $403 million, up 3% from the prior year period, or 5% organic growth. Our Trading Services business, which includes our transactional and U.S. For our Tape Plan data segments, the combined revenue came in at $253 million during Q4. That's a 4% organic rise compared with the same period a year earlier. The main driver was stronger U.S. equity derivatives trading revenues, which reflected both improved revenue capture relative to last year's comparable period and increased industry volumes. Turning to cash equities trading revenues, those declined versus a year ago. The biggest factor there was weaker European cash equities revenue, though that was partly countered by modest expansion in the U.S. cash equities business. In Q4, we were extremely happy to share news about Nasdaq MRX — 1 of our 6 U.S. options exchanges — completing its move to the cloud alongside Amazon Web Services. This newly cloud-enabled system keeps providing ultra-resiliency for our market participants, and it also boosts latency performance by 10%. Being the first exchange to bring a major market into the cloud represents a major milestone as we work toward creating next-generation technology infrastructure for capital markets worldwide. That achievement has further strengthened how our technology clients view us. A good example is the agreement Bolsa Electronica de Chile reached earlier this month to shift their existing on-premise Nasdaq trading technology over to our cloud-based marketplace services platform. We're delighted that BEC selected us to assist with managing this next stage of their cloud journey.
Adena Friedman
executiveAnd finally, in Marketplace Technology, we brought in $150 million of revenue in Q4, which was up 5% compared with the same period a year earlier. The revenue growth mainly came from greater demand for connectivity, which drove a record year for our Trade Management Services business, along with higher revenues from SaaS-based market technology. Order intake for our Market Technology business came to $106 million in the quarter and $264 million for the whole year, versus a record $304 million in 2021. We saw strong order intake among both existing and new clients, with more than 90% of new clients opting for SaaS solutions — an encouraging sign that growth is returning to the technology business after the pandemic. In 2022, we signed 12 new technology clients and finished five implementations in our Market Technology business. We're still making solid progress on our post-trade implementations, having brought two of our biggest clients into live operation during the year. Over the last 18 months, demand for our technology solutions has risen, with lots of conversations with current and new clients centered on market modernization efforts that include both cloud delivery and SaaS. Before I wrap up my comments on our Market Platforms division, I'd like to say a few brief things about the SEC's equity market structure proposals, which the commission released in December of 2022. It's encouraging to us that the proposals took up many of the recommendations from a paper we put out last year on optimizing markets. Although we think equity markets are functioning well at present, we recognize there are always chances to improve. As such, we back the SEC's work to modernize and enhance equity market structure so trading is more efficient, competition is stronger, market transparency is greater, best obligations are reinforced and, in the end, investors get better outcomes; when proposing major changes to markets that are already very complex and interconnected, we believe it's essential that the commission try to steer clear of unintended consequences by moving ahead incrementally, methodically and collaboratively. There are also some areas where our view differs from the SEC's approach, and we intend to put forward improvements, modifications and/or alternatives during the comment period. Last, turning to our Anti-Financial Crime division; we generated $82 million in total revenue in the fourth quarter, a 21% organic rise from the same period a year earlier and 14% after adjusting for the deferred revenue write-down's impact. That revenue increase was fueled by robust demand for our fraud detection and anti-money laundering solutions, which we refer to as our FRAML solutions, plus modest growth in our surveillance solutions. On our FRAML solutions in particular, revenue was up 23% after adjusting for the deferred revenue impact in the prior-year period. The business continued to add new clients across small to medium banks, with 98 new SMB clients signed in the quarter. The business also signed its first two clients to its crypto anti-financial crime platform in 2022. This is an exciting thing we're bringing forward, one that gives crypto firms the ability to spot criminal activity, stay in line with regulations, and head off losses. On top of that, momentum keeps building after a handful of proofs of concept with quite a few Tier 1 and Tier 2 banks, and in Q4 we even signed up a Tier 2 bank for the enterprise fraud product we offer. The response to how those proofs of concept turned out has been extremely favorable, and we expect to bring more clients on board during 2023. Let me pause for a moment to recognize a leadership change that happened this month within our Anti-Financial Crime unit. Brendan Brothers, who helped found Verafin and serves as Head of Strategy for that division, is now interim Head of our AFC division. He takes over from Jamie King, who is stepping away from Nasdaq as he retires. We deeply appreciate everything Jamie has given to Verafin, and we send him our very best wishes for whatever comes next. At the same time, we're thrilled that Brendan is taking on this position as we keep pushing forward on our AFC road map. As I noted when I began my comments today, Nasdaq has achieved meaningful strides along our wider strategic path. Now that the coming year is coming into view, I'd like to walk through our enterprise priorities for 2023 and what lies beyond. Number one, we'll work hard to capture the advantages of the fresh alignment of our divisions. Our goal is to open up the growth possibilities this new structure makes available. We plan to provide a better client experience by bringing more unified solutions to our clients through a One Nasdaq approach; we'll follow a disciplined capital allocation strategy spanning our three divisions, and we'll boost our go-to-market nimbleness by folding related software development and marketing talent into each division, which should help us make decisions more efficiently. Number two, we intend to stay set up for success in a market environment that keeps shifting. Since macroeconomic uncertainty will probably remain as we move through 2023, we want to show how valuable our mission-critical solutions are at a time when companies understand they must keep spending but are paying more and more attention to getting value quickly and earning a solid return on invested capital. And number three, we want to keep pushing our long-term cloud and AI strategy forward throughout the Nasdaq franchise by making our agile development as efficient as possible and applying machine intelligence across our solutions so we can unlock further chances to bring innovation to our clients. Within market platforms, as we roll out our new data-centric system architecture, together with the scalability and the analytics engines that cloud infrastructure makes possible, we're confident we'll be able to build new AI-based order types and provide more advanced capabilities to the market participants plugged into our ecosystem. Those capabilities will likewise become accessible to our exchange technology clients as we collaborate with them to roll out cloud-based market infrastructures in the markets where they operate. Outside of market platforms, we already hold a strong position thanks to our cloud-based SaaS solutions across many of our solutions businesses, and we're on a path toward moving more of our solutions into the cloud. During 2023, we are in the process of shifting our customers over to our next-generation governance platform, which runs in the cloud, along with our trade surveillance platform. Our anti-financial crime offerings show how a cloud-based data lake opens up tremendous possibilities for deploying sophisticated AI algorithms and self-reinforcement learning engines within our products. Plus, with fresh step function enhancements in AI now reaching the market, we are very eager to bring those technologies into additional solutions during 2023 and afterward. We anticipate sharing updates with you regarding our advancement on these priorities over the upcoming quarters. Prior to finishing, I want to discuss the present market conditions. Unsteadiness continues to affect the worldwide economy and headwinds driven by the markets. Should those conditions last through the year, that might affect our near-term growth outlook for listings and index in 2023; we are additionally observing a slight lengthening of sales cycles for some of our solutions, especially our IR solutions and our asset owner solutions, which belong to our Analytics business. Our IR and asset owner clients regard us as a dependable partner who assists them in navigating the difficulties the markets have created; however, we are discovering, particularly within sectors hit harder than others, that clients must pass through additional internal gates before approving investments in IR and portfolio management solutions.
Adena Friedman
executiveTaking a wider view, throughout the rest of our Nasdaq platform, demand from clients is still robust. Even with uncertainty around the macro picture, our expectation is that how effectively companies keep adjusting to the economy's digital transformation via tech spending will define 2023. That digital shift works in Nasdaq's favor, thanks to the breadth of our technology and analytics offerings. With a base of dependable client retention, wins against competitors and stronger ties to clients, we're confident that spending by our clients on technology and cloud-based SaaS solutions will stay a priority. So we hold firm in our belief regarding the investments we are making to bring modern, world-class solutions to our clients; our value proposition is highly resilient and diversified, and we're well positioned to steer our clients and our companies through this dynamic environment. We begin the year still concentrated on hitting our medium-term revenue growth outlook while steering through a complicated 2023, and our confidence is unchanged that our longer-term investments spanning market modernization, ESG solutions and anti-financial crime technology will generate value for our clients and shareholders alike. To close, let me sum up by noting that Nasdaq's fourth quarter delivered solid results, capping a highly successful 2022 for our company. As we look forward to 2023, we start the year centered on capturing the advantages of our new corporate structure to boost growth across our core pillars of liquidity, transparency and integrity as we aim to move toward our objective of becoming the trusted fabric of the global financial system. With that said, I'll hand the call over to Ann now for a review of the financial details.
Ann Dennison
executiveThanks, Adena, and hello everybody on this call. My remarks will mainly address our non-GAAP figures, and unless I say otherwise, every comparison is against the same period a year ago. You can find reconciliations from U.S. GAAP to non-GAAP in our press release, and also in the document posted under the Financials section of our Investor Relations site at ir.nasdaq.com. Just a note that Slide 4 shows how our financial reporting now mirrors the new corporate structure we told you about last quarter. Also, to line up our financial reporting more closely with how we manage the business internally, we have reclassified U.S. cash equity and options tape plan revenues out of the Data and Listing Services business within the Capital Access Platforms division and into the Trading Services business within the Market Platforms division. An updated supplement covering historical periods that reflects this change is available for investors on the IR website. I'll begin with a look at how we performed in the fourth quarter of 2022, starting on Slide 11. Reported net revenue rose 2% to $906 million, which nets out to organic growth of 5%, made up of a 5% organic gain in the Solutions businesses and a 4% organic gain in Trading Services, partly offset by a 3% negative effect from FX rate movements plus the net effect of an acquisition and divestitures. Now on to operating profit and margins. Non-GAAP operating income fell 1%, and our non-GAAP operating margin came in at 49%, lower than the 51% recorded in the same period a year ago. Across all of 2022, the non-GAAP operating margin reached 52%, which is 1 percentage point below 2021. Non-GAAP net income attributable to Nasdaq was $317 million, or $0.64 per diluted share, versus $328 million, or $0.64 per diluted share, in the comparable period last year. Over on Slide 12. As Adena noted earlier, ARR came to $2 billion, up 8% from the same period a year ago, and annualized SaaS revenues reached $725 million, a gain of 13%. Now I'll walk through the quarterly division results on Slides 13 through 15, beginning with Market Platforms. Revenues were up $10 million, or 3%. Organic growth was 5%, and FX rate movements had a 2% negative effect. Trading Services posted organic growth of 4%, with the gain mainly driven by higher U.S. equity derivatives and U.S. cash equity revenues thanks to higher capture and higher industry volumes, partly offset by lower European cash equity revenues stemming from lower industry volumes. In marketplace technology, our Trade Management Services business performed strongly, and we delivered yet another quarter of organic growth in the Market Technology business, fueled by higher SaaS revenues and robust order intake during the period. This follows the positive organic revenue growth we saw in the third quarter of 2022, and it's one more encouraging piece of evidence that the programs and initiatives the leadership team has put in place are pushing the business ahead. ARR came to $503 million, up 5% versus the same period a year ago. For the fourth quarter of 2022, the division's operating margin came in at 52%, and for the full year of 2022 it was 54% — each of those figures represents a drop of 2 percentage points versus the equivalent prior-year period. What's driving that change is mainly higher expenses tied to our ongoing investments in people and in our businesses, and that includes our digital asset strategy. On the Capital Access Platform side, revenues held flat, and that reflects organic growth of $7 million, or 2%, along with a 2% drag from movements in FX rates. The organic growth we saw in the period came from positive contributions in the Workflow, Insights, and Data and Listing Services businesses, though that was partly offset by an organic decrease in Index revenues. Let me take a moment on Index. All told, Index revenue fell 11% versus the fourth quarter of 2022. If you look at the main drivers behind the financial performance, asset-based licensing revenues were down 21% against the prior-year period, partly offset by a 25% rise in futures-related revenues tied to the NASDAQ 100 Index. Average AUM for the period — the figure we use each quarter to calculate asset-based revenues — fell 19% versus the prior-year period, while trading volumes in futures linked to the NASDAQ 100 index rose 21% compared with the prior-year quarter. To help analysts and investors going forward, we're updating our public disclosures so that average AUM is provided every quarter in addition to the end-of-period figure, which will — which will do a better job of aligning our key disclosures with the key revenue drivers for the business. One more thing as we look ahead to the first quarter of 2023. Trading activity in instruments tied to our indexes hit certain annual thresholds during the second quarter of '22, and that produced an increase in licensing economics for the rest of the year. As 2023 gets underway, the economics of certain agreements reset for the new year; we estimate this will mean roughly $9 million less revenue in the first quarter of 2023 than in the fourth quarter of 2022, assuming trading activity and product mix are similar across the two periods. ARR for Capital Access Platforms came to $1.19 billion, which is up 7% versus the prior-year period. The division operating margin of 50% in the fourth quarter decreased — in the fourth quarter of 2022 decreased 3 percentage points from the prior-year period. For the full year 2022, the operating margin was 54.4%, which is up 60 basis points from 53.8% in 2021. Anti-Financial Crime revenue rose $14 million, or 21%, and $4 million of that increase came from the impact of the deferred revenue write-down on Verafin in 4Q '21. Organic growth was 21% for the period, or 14% once you exclude the deferred revenue impact, which reflects healthy demand for fraud detection and anti-money laundering solutions as well as SaaS-based surveillance solutions. Revenues from fraud detection and AML solutions grew 23% versus 4Q '21, excluding the effect of the deferred revenue write-down. Anti-Financial Crime ARR came to $312 million, which is up 16% from the same period a year earlier. Signed ARR — that figure also takes in ARR from new contracts that have been signed but haven't started yet — reached $338 million, a 17% rise compared with the prior year period. In the fourth quarter of '22, the operating margin for the Anti-Financial Crime division stood at 32%, and for the full year of '22 it was 26%. If you turn to Page 16, we'll go through both expenses and guidance. Non-GAAP operating expenses rose $26 million, landing at $460 million. That gain comes from a $45 million organic increase, partly offset by a $20 million reduction tied to the impact of changes in FX rates, along with a $1 million decrease from the net impact of an acquisition and divestitures. The organic expense growth is mainly the result of higher compensation and benefits expense as well as general and administrative expense. The compensation increase reflects our ongoing investment in new employees to drive growth — our team grew 10% over the past 12 months — plus annual merit increases, which came in above prior years because of inflationary pressures on compensation. The rise in general and administrative expense largely reflects higher travel than in the prior year period, as we returned to a more normalized level of travel in 2022.
Ann Dennison
executiveIn Q4 of 2022, we kicked off a divisional alignment program, aimed at unlocking the complete potential of our newly established corporate structure. As you'll recall, the reason behind this was to sharpen our business focus onto three megatrends: market modernization, ESG, and anti-financial crime. This structural shift doesn't just sharpen our focus — it will also draw commercial teams nearer to one another, move technology and marketing resources closer to what we offer, and reshape the way we engage, attract, and keep clients across our products. Consequently, we anticipate pretax charges between $115 million and $145 million, with roughly 40% of that amount being non-cash. This initiative will run for two years and consists of three primary elements: first, asset impairments along with contract terminations; second, costs tied to employees to facilitate the divisional realignment; and third, one-time consulting and other expenditures meant to help us unlock revenue synergies; we aim for benefits combining annual run rate operating efficiencies and revenue synergies of no less than $30 million by 2025. Expenses tied to the divisional alignment program will be booked as restructuring expense. We're setting our 2023 non-GAAP operating expense guidance at a range of $1.77 billion to $1.85 billion. The midpoint of that expense guidance range represents a rise of slightly more than 5%, which includes a 1% increase linked to our digital asset strategy, and mainly mirrors our ongoing investments aimed at driving growth in ESG, anti-financial crime, and market modernization. We anticipate the 2023 non-GAAP tax rate will land between 24% and 26%. Now to Slide 17. Debt rose by $27 million compared with 3Q '22, largely because of net issuances of $465 million in commercial paper plus a $164 million bump in Eurobond book values driven by a stronger euro, partly offset by repayment of $600 million of 0.445% senior unsecured notes at maturity. Our total debt to trailing 12 months non-GAAP EBITDA ratio holds at 2.7 times, same as in the third quarter of 2022. Thanks to record free cash flow, excluding Section 31 fees, of $1.5 billion in 2022, our weighted average cash cost of debt at 2.2%, and no long-term debt maturities before 2026, we've positioned the company to limit the effects of rising rates and to give us flexibility in supporting our growth strategy. In the fourth quarter of 2022, the company distributed common stock dividends totaling $98 million. As of December 31, 2022, an aggregate $650 million was left available under the Board-authorized share repurchase program, which reflects an authorization increase the Board approved in December. Now to Page 18 of the presentation. I want to call out some of the notable strides we've taken in carrying out our sustainable strategy. For a seventh straight year, we earned a spot on the Dow Jones Sustainability North America Index, among the most respected environmental, social, and governance ranking benchmarks. Nasdaq stood as 1 of 8 diversified financial services companies picked for inclusion in the 2022 index. On top of that, just 1 of 283 businesses among 15,000 that were assessed earned a spot on CDP's 2022 Climate Change A list, and we were among them. To wrap up today, what Nasdaq delivered in the fourth quarter of 2022 shows the company carrying on its knack for reliably doing well no matter what kind of operating conditions it faces. I appreciate you spending this time with us, and now I'll hand things back to the operator so we can take your questions.
Rich Repetto
analystYes, hello, Adena, and hello, Ann. I didn't really grasp those restructuring charges, but I believe I'd prefer to make my question wider. Adena, you spoke right at the end of your prepared remarks regarding, sort of, the outlook for '23. And I think we all understand if the markets are down, the index business, the listing business, and so on. But I'm attempting to determine which businesses could thrive, or are there any businesses that could advance if we get — with this macroeconomic uncertainty? Because investors view exchanges as being somewhat countercyclical. And right tied to that, that this sort of outlook, I know it's early, but the Reg NMS changes, just on balance, they won't occur this year; but if they — the entire balance, whether the fee — cap fees versus the higher volumes, how do you view the balance from the proposed changes.
Adena Friedman
executiveSure. Okay. So that was a good long and multi-pronged question, Rich.
Rich Repetto
analystFeel free to go ahead. My apologies. Go right ahead.
Adena Friedman
executiveNo problem. No, no, that came through fine. All right. So when it comes to how we see 2023 shaping up, the prevailing sentiment among us at Nasdaq at this moment is that we keep enjoying very robust engagement with clients throughout every one of the segments making up our annualized recurring revenue. That covers our Anti-Financial Crime operation, the part we refer to as Corporate Solutions, our investment analytics offerings — especially within analytics and data — plus our Marketplace Technology division. We continue to observe genuinely healthy demand from clients, strong interaction with them, and momentum on executing our plan. Our ESG services, in my view, achieved double-digit expansion, and we keep identifying excellent capabilities and possibilities in that space. The technology we provide for anti-financial crime keeps delivering very impressive growth. And I'd say market modernization initiatives are genuinely making a difference — they're producing a favorable impact on how we engage with market tech customers as those clients consider upgrading their infrastructure; so what I'd tell you is that the long-term trends we're pursuing feel solid as we head into 2023, and our level of client engagement feels excellent. Turning to the broader market environment — clearly, none of us is shielded from it. That's true of every company. Still, I'd concur that exchanges possess remarkable resilience — ours is a resilient platform, given that we rest on a foundation of trading, on a foundation of listings and the fees those generate. We also rest on a foundation of data, all of which helps keep us robust and fairly resilient through every kind of market condition. That said, a few spots do carry market beta for us. For instance, listing revenues can't expand as quickly when no listings reach the market. We currently have 200 companies on file aiming to list on the NASDAQ, and ideally the markets will open up during the course of the year. Yet, as everyone knows, it takes 2 to tango. So the supply is there, while demand really hinges on investors gaining confidence to underwrite fresh deals; and my sense is that if interest rates can peak and we get some clarity on where they settle, if inflation keeps declining and the economic ground beneath us becomes more stable, activity could genuinely rebound, especially during the back half of the year; that's what we're hoping for. Such a pickup would of course support growth in '23 while also supporting '24. Regarding the Index business, it clearly carries market beta tied to our AUM. We managed to endure substantial swings in market values during the prior year; however, as you could observe, the fourth quarter packed a major punch. Consequently, AUM fell sharply. Inflows during the fourth quarter weren't strong enough to offset that decline. Even so, heading into 2023, we've gotten off to an improved start. We're going to need to observe how that develops, and that's a space where market data will come in throughout the year. So we'll just have to watch how it plays out. If I had to boil it down, however, in the places where revenue repeats and where our SaaS revenue sits, we feel quite good about the way we're working with clients. Sales cycles have stretched somewhat in IR and analytics. Still, broadly speaking, demand is very strong. The trends we're basing our underwriting on give us real confidence, as do the investments we're putting into them; and markets will do what markets do, but I believe we've shown very solid results through a range of market cycles. Finally, you raised a question about Reg NMS along with the fees and volumes. It's very early, Rich. What the SEC has put forward is an initial proposal. There will be comment periods, and there will likely be changes to the proposals. So it's going to take several years before we sort of witness that impact. But you're pursuing the same playbook we're attempting, which is that we see a greater opportunity to move more retail volume onto lit venues, and that clearly stands to help us; yet we also see a shift in tick sizes and the associated access fees, and that's the part we have to sort of examine, the sort of what I'd refer to as the differing dynamics that will come out of it. And so on balance, net-net, we're broadly favorable toward what the SEC has proposed. But naturally we want to be sure we're adjusting the tick sizes and access fees in the right way for what they're aiming to accomplish there.
Rich Repetto
analystThanks.
Michael Cyprys
analystMorning, and I appreciate you taking my question. I'd like to go a bit deeper on Verafin. Could you give us an update on how the sales environment and pipeline are shaping up? You referenced some proof of concepts currently underway. Could you expand on how many involve Tier 1 banks, and what the historical time to conversion has looked like when those past clients signed on and started paying? Thanks.
Adena Friedman
executiveOf course. Thanks, Michael. Broadly speaking, across all of AFC — that's anti-financial crime — you have the FRAML business, which represents the Verafin capabilities, plus trade surveillance, the surveillance technology we provide to trading firms, and market surveillance, the surveillance technology we provide to markets. Within Verafin, as I noted, demand remains very strong, and with small and medium banks in particular, conversion has stayed quite consistent — moving a lead through to becoming a paying client. I believe we added 98 new clients during the quarter, and the dynamics there were really strong. I have to say, what we provide is an excellent product, and that comes through in the sales. Moving upmarket is where we, as Verafin, are entering somewhat uncharted territory, correct? We're reaching the very top of the banking universe. What we're observing is that with Tier 2 banks, we're getting them signed and lined up gradually but steadily. The proof of concepts demonstrate a meaningful drop in false positives along with improved capability to spot actual fraud. So those proof points are genuinely useful in converting a client. With Tier 2 banks, the sales cycle runs more like, I'd say, somewhere between 6 and 12 months. Then you reach the large Tier 1 banks. There, once again, we have multiple proofs of concept now finished, and I think we're seeing very strong results when it comes to fewer false positives and better fraud detection. However, contracting cycles at that level are extremely long, since they conduct a very thorough internal review. We obviously go through cyber review. We go through numerous other steps. Those sales cycles can run anywhere from, I'd say, roughly 9 to 15 to 18 months. So we're quite hopeful that, because we finished some of those proofs of concept during the first half of last year, we ought to be able to convert them this year. Michael, what I can tell you is that while we aren't sharing exact figures, we've wrapped up a solid quantity of proof of concepts. That opens the door for us to demonstrate our ability to break into the Tier 1 banks throughout '23. So as the year unfolds, we're confident those proof points will become visible.
Michael Cyprys
analystThanks.
Alex Kramm
analystYeah, morning, everybody. This might come across as a tad testy, yet I'll pose it regardless. It concerns the recast. Clearly, back in November you resegmented and introduced fresh targets for solutions 7 to 10; yet now, clearly, you've recast something today essentially to shift a business that's flat or contracting into the non-solution segment. If my calculations are correct, that's roughly 60 basis points of beneficial effect on organic growth for Solutions during Q4; so my question, I suppose, is whether we ought to hold you to higher targets at this point? Was it 7.5% to 10.5%? Or what's the right way for us to think about this? Since, once more, you did a solid job recasting and genuinely shifting Solutions to be non-trading, and now you're altering that yet again? Thanks.
Adena Friedman
executiveYeah. So Alex, I appreciate the question and it isn't testy. So — though here's what I'd say. That change was in fact ours, so here's what occurred: the options tape revenue previously sat within the Market Services business, while the equities tape revenue sat within Market Data; and — yet what the realignment accomplished was that we truly shifted management of the equities tape over to the Markets team, given that the revenues tied to the equity tape tend to — they rise and fall alongside market share and other market dynamics rather than purely reflecting client demand; and so we concluded, and so at the outset when we redid — entered the new divisional alignment, we truly shifted the options tape into data rather than shifting the equity tape into the markets. And we — while working through Q4 and genuinely considering how to align the business alongside the management, we truly concluded to make a switch. So we've essentially shifted the options and equities tapes into market platforms at this point, since that's where the team supporting them is heading into the Market Platforms division, being run by the Market Platforms team. So we didn't do this deliberately in order to recast targets or anything of that sort; we aren't altering our medium to long-term outlook throughout our Solutions businesses. 7% to 10% is the target and the outlook we anticipate being able to hit across the medium to long term. Yet we did wish to shift those products simply into the group that runs them; that's genuinely the sole catalyst.
Owen Lau
analystMorning, and thanks for taking my question. Turning to the expense outlook, would you mind discussing where you plan to put money into ESG and Anti-Fin Crime? Could you share any concrete examples? Also, how should we view the upcoming product rollouts, or perhaps the additional revenue these investments could generate? Thanks.
Ann Dennison
executiveOf course. I'll kick things off. Hi Owen. When we consider — well, going back to the guidance, the midpoint sits at 5%, and given our 4% to 7% medium-term outlook, that puts us slightly under the midpoint, which would be 5.5%. As for what makes up that 5%, nearly all of our increase goes toward supporting, as you mentioned, our growth initiatives spanning ESG, AFC and market modernization. I'd describe these as the spending required to keep developing the long-term opportunities for those businesses, so they can back the revenue growth built into our medium-term outlook; so really, it comes down to that 18% to 23% medium-term outlook for AFC, plus our capital access platform's medium-term outlook to fuel growth there, with ESG being the largest or a high — expanding from a small base yet a fast-growing piece of the Workflow and Insights segment.
Adena Friedman
executiveYes, and Owen, I think there's one point we made clear: within that 5% yearly increase in expenses, roughly 1 percentage point comes from the ongoing investment we're putting into our digital assets business. We're getting nearer to getting that business off the ground, ideally during the first half of this year. That's a single, concentrated investment we singled out when we walked through and talked about the outlook. Beyond that, I think, looking at the other 4% of growth, as Ann mentioned, most of it really stems from ensuring we make the proper investments throughout the three key pillars. We aren't quantifying the investments in any one of those pillars. But all of them — here's how you should think about it. If one of those businesses has a higher growth outlook, then odds are we're directing more investment dollars there, or at minimum, on a percentage basis, putting more investment into those businesses; take our AFC business, for example. If our medium to long-term growth outlook is 18% to 23%, we're putting money into R&D and the go-to-market and sales capabilities so we can support that growth; and so that would carry a higher level of investment than something growing 5%, let's say. But I also think that — generally speaking, we feel we're making the right choices about where to invest our capital so we can sustain our growth and make sure we achieve this on the medium to long-term outlook.
Craig Siegenthaler
analystMorning, everybody. My question concerns those pretax charges tied to the divisional alignment. Could you walk us through more of the specifics regarding the costs connected to employees? And in plain terms, what does that actually involve? Does it mean cutting jobs, bringing people in? And which areas see headcount going up versus where might it come down?
Ann Dennison
executiveSure, Craig, thanks. Let me take a first pass at answering. If we step back and consider the realignment initiative as a whole that we've kicked off, its purpose is tightly linked to how we are restructuring — and realigning — the divisions themselves. So regarding those employee-related expenses sitting inside the $115 million to $145 million band, they support our divisional realignment rather than being spread across the board. This isn't something we're viewing from an enterprise-wide standpoint; instead it reflects examining where we operate and how functions are organized as the divisions get aligned. On top of that, we're shifting certain technology to maximize the strength of the merged divisions. Those costs should land across the coming 2 years, and we anticipate they'll deliver an annualized run rate savings plus revenue synergies of roughly $30 million a year, essentially fully realized by 2025. As for that $30 million figure, at present, most of it falls on the expense side.
Dan Fannon
analystThanks, good morning. I'd like to ask a follow-up about Anti-Fin Crime. This quarter showed 14% growth excluding deferred revenue, and I'm trying to connect that figure to your 3 to 5-year outlook of 18% to 23%. You've obviously described a lot of momentum. But given the — with these long sales cycles, do you need — ought we to view 2023 as falling inside that range, at the upper end? Or will it build gradually as we sort of reach and perhaps leave that — leave '23 behind or later, in order to hit those larger figures?
Adena Friedman
executiveSure. Well, when we consider our sort of medium- to long-term outlook, that 18% to 23%, we believe it's well supported by the sales opportunities, the pipeline, and the ongoing investment we keep making in the products themselves, so that we can keep broadening our capabilities. I thought I would offer a bit more detail on how we see the dynamics; and I noted — as I said earlier, we have our FRAML solutions. And clearly, that's our Verafin asset, and it was delivering more than 20% growth in the quarter and still has truly strong growth potential even while it keeps scaling. And so there, Dan, we certainly believe that the Tier 1, Tier 2 — we aren't reliant on Tier 2 and Tier 1 banks to prop up that growth rate near term; but as we keep — as we move upmarket and can draw in these Tier 1 and Tier 2 banks, the ticket sizes are far, far larger. So across the longer term, demonstrating momentum on that front will matter for sustaining the strong growth trends we're showing in that business. The other two parts of the business, trade surveillance, that keeps having sort of high single-digit, low double-digit growth, and it has for quite a while. That's providing surveillance solutions to trading firms. And there, we keep driving that growth by widening the types of modules we offer, such as our crypto modules as well as more — bringing additional asset classes onto the platform and really continuing to globalize the clientele there; we have reached the point where we've become an enterprise provider of surveillance across large banks, and that remains a good growth opportunity to support that sort of high single digit, low double digits. The one area that actually has a low — I would say flat to low growth profile is our market surveillance business, where it's the smallest part of the division. But it's a tougher one to grow a lot because the overall base of client opportunities is smaller. That's where we provide surveillance to markets and regulators. And over there, that unit was mostly unchanged across the year and still has a low growth profile; so that's — I think definitely in 2022, that has produced somewhat of a kind of a lower growth view. And as we move into '23 and '25 or '23 to '24, '25, '26, we hope to discover new ways to spark some growth there, but we will expect that to be a low grower in the years to come. So hopefully, that just gives you a bit more context.
Brian Bedell
analystMorning, and thanks for taking my question. First, a point of clarification regarding the divisional alignment program and that $115 million to $145 million figure. I simply want to confirm those costs are excluded from the non-GAAP guidance, so a clarification there; and then on a wider level, concerning Solutions growth for this year, I understand 7% to 10% is still your longer-term target. Yet considering the headwinds you mention for this year — the elongated sales cycles and, naturally, the pressure on index licensing — ought we to view 2023 near term as somewhat below that? And then the initiatives you are investing in could perhaps lift it in '24? So in a sense a deceleration followed by a reacceleration of that Solutions revenue.
Ann Dennison
executiveSure, Brian. Regarding the first portion of your question, the divisional alignment program — the cost tied to those will be recorded on the restructuring line, and they will not be counted as part of — they are not included within our non-GAAP expense guidance that we issued for 2023, yes.
Adena Friedman
executiveRight, and turning to how the whole business is shaping up, Brian, here's how I'd frame it: broadly speaking, we're quite pleased with the growth we're achieving in our Solutions segments — that covers AFC, as we've said, plus investment analytics, meaning insights and workflows for corporates, and I know market tech as well. Demand from clients remains quite strong, in our view. Sales cycles have stretched out somewhat, and that might shave a bit off growth for the year. The one place where we do rely somewhat on the market backdrop, though, is our listings business together with our Index business. In those areas, we're hoping to see some gains in index values and market values, which would in turn support bringing additional companies to market, and that would help us navigate the year and stay in line with how we view our targets. Should the broader market environment fail to improve this year, however, those areas could pose a bigger challenge. That's precisely why we prefer to frame those targets as medium to long term, looking at an average across multiple years — simply because some years bring a tougher market backdrop. Even so, I'd note that despite the difficult market backdrop in 2022, we still managed to deliver 10% organic growth throughout our Solutions businesses. On top of that, we saw an 8% improvement — an increase — in our ARR, and a 13% increase in our SaaS. So even against a really challenging market environment last year, we were able to present a consistent story across Nasdaq.
Gautam Sawant
analystMorning, Adena and Ann. I'd like to take a moment to focus on Puro.earth and what it could mean over the long haul. Puro.earth did a presentation at COP 27, as I understand it, and trading certificates were up 250% in 2022. Could you discuss how much this business might contribute to earnings down the road? Also, is there a chance to market Puro.earth straight to your corporate customers spanning U.S. and Nordic operations?
Adena Friedman
executiveAbsolutely. In fact, we do; so — I enjoy discussing Puro.earth; to recap, Puro.earth is a carbon removal marketplace in which we hold a minority stake alongside a partner, Fortum, based in Finland. We're genuinely enthusiastic about what Puro.earth can offer us and, honestly, our customers; so we already reach out to our corporate customers as customers. They arrive directly and purchase carbon removal credits via the Puro.earth platform, and we use our corporate ties to keep expanding demand for those credits. What I believe is restraining that market right now — and it's quite small, so I want to emphasize to everybody that this is a small business at present. It did expand, as you mentioned, in fact, I believe roughly 250% to 300% year-over-year, though off a tiny base; it resides within our Market Platforms business. It backs our ESG strategy and that mega trend. Yet the real thing constraining that platform — that entire marketplace — is supply; so we're highly focused on top-quality industrial carbon removals; we vet every supplier we bring onto the platform. We have — we collaborate with an advisory committee to decide which scientific methods we're prepared even to place on the platform. We're extremely selective about how we add supply to the platform. And since it remains a fairly nascent industry, we're severely limited by scarce supply at present. So across the coming three to five years, we in fact anticipate considerable investment flowing into carbon removal. We believe that will genuinely strengthen supply. We're rebuilding Puro.earth to feature a highly sophisticated blockchain based registry that we can then use across various trading venues. And we're collaborating with several market makers to help establish — they will purchase from removals and begin building a secondary market, enabling trading activity to start growing on the platform too; but let me add this. In my view, Puro.earth is sort of a 5 to 10-year strategy. It's a quite modest investment for us right now. It's a small yet formidable team. But we're truly, truly thrilled about its potential, though just keep in mind it's a long-term strategy.
Alex Blostein
analystMorning, and thanks for taking the question. What I wanted to do was explore a bit how the legacy listings side of things interacts with the Corporate Solutions side. On one hand, I was wondering whether you could give us a sense of how much revenue might be exposed if stocks delist during this year. Then on the other hand, what opportunities do you see arising as the discounts you gave on Corporate Solutions offerings to companies that IPO'd across the past couple of years roll off, and how likely is it that those firms begin paying for the service?
Adena Friedman
executiveGreat. Yes. Thanks, Alex. SPAC revenue accounts for a bit more than roughly 1% of Nasdaq's total revenue, so it's a modest piece of what we bring in. We are seeing SPAC combinations happening, yet we're also watching quite a few SPACs choose to return capital to their shareholders. So it remains a modest piece of our revenue. And — but we're — but we also acknowledge that conditions for SPACs have shifted considerably, so we'd expect some decline in revenue stemming from SPACs eventually failing to find combinations. So I think that will likely matter more in 2024 than in 2023, though we're monitoring it quite carefully. But as I mentioned, to put it in perspective, it's slightly above just 1% of revenue. On Corporate Services and Solutions, meaning our IR and ESG offerings that support corporates, you're correct. Many clients join our platform. Through the IPO package, we've been supporting them for the past two years; and so once we get especially into 2024, we'll have the chance to turn them and convert them into paying clients. And so that's clearly — that portion of our outlook for that business hinges on how we convert those clients into paying customers. We've additionally upsold those clients even while they were in the IPO package period, where we might sell them into certain ESG packaged solutions and into a deeper set of IR solutions. So some of them are already paying clients today. And I think that clearly, it even strengthens our view that they'll keep wanting to use our services past the IPO period; but I want to note, I think that's more of a '24 opportunity than '23, though we're quite optimistic about it. Retention of clients is strong as we convert them.
Kyle Voigt
analystMorning. Perhaps I could ask about the BEC shift away from your installed on-premise product toward the cloud-hosted one. Would you mind walking us again through what this sort of move from on-premise to cloud means for Nasdaq's revenue and margin? What I'm after is some figures around that effect, so we can grasp the bigger opportunity better should we get additional announcements of a similar kind across the next one or two years?
Adena Friedman
executiveRight. My sense is we likely have to return to this with you and provide a bit more of that perspective. Using a single client and applying it across the entire business isn't something I can do. That said, whenever we bring a client onto a market tech contract that leans more toward SaaS, two advantages arise. First, it turns into annualized recurring revenue rather than implementation revenue, and that carries considerably thinner margins, after which comes a service and maintenance and license agreement, which carries a fatter margin. Consequently you get revenue that's steadier and a margin that's steadier across the contract's duration; however, my impression is we haven't yet provided you with any view of, say, how large the margin difference is. So my feeling is we probably should return and offer somewhat deeper insight on that point in particular as we build more momentum in persuading our clients to sign up for cloud-based offerings, cloud-based ones especially; so we'll get back to you about it, though what I really don't want is to hand you something incorrect at this moment.
Adena Friedman
executiveOkay, thanks so much. So, to wrap up the call today, let me say again that the folks leading this company stay really locked in on carrying out our plan so we can come through for every one of our stakeholders. And we’re eager to keep talking over the course of this year about how far we expect to move on the things that matter most in our strategy. So, thanks a lot, and enjoy the rest of your day.
Operator
operatorThanks. That wraps up the call for today. We appreciate everyone joining in. You're free to hang up now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Nasdaq, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Nasdaq, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Nasdaq, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.