Nasdaq, Inc. (NDAQ) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

January 31, 2024

NASDAQ US Financials Capital Markets earnings 67 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Ato Garrett

executive
#1

Hello, everyone, and thanks for being with us this morning as we go over Nasdaq's financial results for the fourth quarter and the entire 2023 fiscal year. Joining us are Adena Friedman, who serves as our Chair and Chief Executive Officer; our Chief Financial Officer, Sarah Youngwood; John Zecca, our Chief Legal Risk and Regulatory Officer; along with additional members of the management team. Once the prepared remarks are finished, we'll take your questions on the line. You can find the press release and the earnings presentation on our website. Our intention is to use that website to disclose material nonpublic information and to satisfy our disclosure obligations under Regulation FD. I want to remind everyone that some statements made in this presentation and in response to questions may concern future events and expectations, and those constitute forward-looking statements as defined by the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. There could be material differences between actual results and these projections. Details about factors that might lead actual results to diverge from forward-looking statements appear in our press release and in periodic reports we file with the SEC. Additionally, whenever we refer to organic growth, that figure leaves out the effects of changes in FX rates as well as the impact of acquisitions and divestitures — for this quarter, that impact is substantially all tied to the 2 months of Adenza performance that fall within the fourth quarter and in the year. Adenza's results sit inside Solutions revenue and inside the Financial Technology division. Please note that starting this quarter, we are reporting results under our new divisional structure. For your reference, a reconciliation to the previous divisional structure is available in the appendix of our earnings presentation. You can locate reconciliations of U.S. GAAP to non-GAAP results in our press release and in a file in the financials section of our Investor Relations website at ir.nasdaq.com. With all of that said, I'll hand the call over to Adena now.

Adena Friedman

executive
#2

Thanks, Ato, and good morning to all of you. We appreciate you being here. Ahead of getting started today, I want to formally welcome Sarah Youngwood to Nasdaq. During her first 2 months as CFO, Sarah has already hit the ground running, and going forward we're thrilled to keep benefiting from Sarah's extensive expertise. Now, on to my comments. I'll address the following topics today: the outside environment and how Nasdaq is set up for ongoing growth; key points from our Q4 and full year financial and operational results; and our priorities as a company for 2024. After that, I'll hand the call to Sarah so she can walk through our financial results. Let me begin with what we anticipate from the external environment in 2024. For the last several years, heightened complexity and unpredictability have weighed on the worldwide economy and markets, driven by a dynamic and difficult geopolitical landscape. We anticipate that geopolitical conditions will remain and keep affecting global markets in 2024. That said, encouraging signals are emerging that the economic picture, especially in the U.S., is normalizing. Inflation is moving lower while the economy has stayed resilient, which may give central bankers confidence to start cutting rates later in the year so that the cost of capital is calibrated with an inflationary environment that is normalizing. Against that backdrop, and drawing on the data we've observed so far, we're cautiously optimistic about a better business environment for Nasdaq in 2024. Our pipeline of companies that have filed to go public on Nasdaq is healthy. On top of that, during 2023 we gained $31 billion in net inflows within our index business, which gives us a strong starting point for 2024. In Q4, we also observed early indications of normalization in our sales cycles for our IR and asset owner solutions. Finally, market volumes have begun the new year solidly, and client interest in our comprehensive suite of technology solutions remains very strong. Now to our financial results. In Q4, Nasdaq surpassed the $1 billion mark in net revenues for the first time in a single quarter, reaching revenues of $1.1 billion. That's a 23% rise versus the prior year period and a 7% rise on an organic basis; we achieved 9% organic growth across our Solutions businesses in the quarter while Market Services was flat. For the full year, net revenues of $3.9 billion rose 9% from 2022, or 5% on an organic basis. Solutions produced 7% organic — annual organic revenue growth, which aligns with our overall Solutions revenue outlook despite a dynamic market environment. Our Market Services revenue was flat year-over-year, mainly because of continued muted volumes in Europe following strong performance in 2022. Our annualized recurring revenue, or ARR, finished the year at $2.6 billion, an organic rise of 6% year-over-year. A sluggish market for IPOs, combined with reduced corporate spending on our IR offerings, led to softer ARR expansion during 2023. By the fourth quarter of 2023, annualized SaaS revenues had climbed to $910 million. Setting Adenza aside, that figure amounted to growth of 12% and accounted for 38% of ARR for the whole company. Companywide, we delivered top-line growth and expanded our business while holding our operating margin at 52% on both a quarterly and a full-year basis, again excluding Adenza. How well we did in 2023 speaks to the resilience of our diversified operations and our capacity to hit our longer-range targets even when conditions are unpredictable. All of this happened as we took a major strategic step in Nasdaq's evolution; on November 1, we were pleased to complete the Adenza acquisition, and we are now working as one team to further our clients' goals for risk management and regulatory reporting excellence. Looking back over the last year, I take enormous pride in what Nasdaq's team has achieved. With our divisional structure now in place and Adenza acquired, 2023 stood out as a year of transformation for our business. Over those months, we reached a number of significant milestones that deepened ties with clients and pushed forward our vision to be the trusted fabric of the world's financial system. Let's now walk through the operational and client highlights by division, beginning with Capital Access Platforms. At Nasdaq, as you know, our exchanges are our foundation. We held on to our standing as the top U.S. exchange for IPOs, posting an 81% U.S. operating company win rate in 2023. All told, we welcomed 103 operating company IPOs that brought in over $11 billion in proceeds, which made Nasdaq the leading U.S. listing exchange for a fifth straight year measured by both the number of IPOs and the proceeds raised. On top of that, 18 companies representing $377 billion in market value moved their listings over to Nasdaq during the year. In Index, net inflows for the year came to $31 billion, with $10 billion of that arriving in the fourth quarter. Our clients want — our clients brought 83 new products tied to Nasdaq indices to market during the year, delivering robust solutions that match investor demand. Beyond our leadership in exchanges and indices, we serve the buy side as a leading source of institutional intelligence through eVestment and have kept expanding our offering into alternatives and ESG. We carried on broadening our ESG solutions in 2023, rolling out multiple new offerings to help corporates and investors navigate an evolving ESG ecosystem, including Nasdaq Metrio and eVestment ESG Analytics. We also brought out a suite of new solutions built to help corporate clients drive governance excellence and speed up their ESG strategies, including Sustainable Lens through IR Insight. Now to the Fintech division. With the Adenza acquisition now closed, we have built a financial technology powerhouse spanning anti-financial crime, surveillance, market technology and risk and regulatory reporting solutions, which establishes us as a key risk management partner to the global financial system. Through our Calypso offering, banks and other financial firms can steer through many different market environments, gaining an up-to-the-minute picture of exposure spanning both their own and customer trading books, backed by in-depth analytics that inform risk decisions made in real time. In much the same way, as global regulation grows more intricate and split apart — with threats needing to be handled over tighter timeframes and at a fine-grained level — our AxiomSL product lets customers take advantage of Nasdaq's worldwide reach and know-how. By assisting them in optimizing their liquidity via top-tier capital markets and risk management technology, and by strengthening integrity throughout the banking system with our regulatory reporting plus anti-financial crime solutions, we are now able to serve as a full partner to banks, brokers, financial market infrastructure providers and investment managers everywhere. Following the completion of the Adenza deal, our entire attention is on connecting with customers and newly joined staff so that the transition and integration go smoothly and succeed. Over recent months, Tal Cohen — Nasdaq's Co-President and the head of our Fintech division — along with me, have held direct conversations with our customers, and enthusiasm is high regarding what may now be possible with Adenza inside Nasdaq. Adenza wrapped up the year posting robust sales and upsells throughout its offerings. To be specific, across the past 2 months, we brought on 6 new clients, 2 of which are central banks. On top of that, we deepened ties with 35 clients we already had.

Adena Friedman

executive
#3

Across the entire year, Adenza brought in 23 new customers while deepening ties with 142 that were already on board, and that figure includes 3 cross-sells. As we move into 2024 with Adenza now a piece of Nasdaq, we couldn't be more enthusiastic, and we're eager to push the business and its solutions toward new heights in the coming years. Now shifting to Market Technology: during 2023, we strengthened our presence with clients worldwide by bringing on 7 of them, 4 of which came during the fourth quarter. On top of that, we grew existing relationships with 4 customers in Q4 and over 10 across the whole year. Significantly, we secured important technology client agreements in both APAC and LatAm. We take pride in building a fresh technology alliance with nuam exchange, formed by combining marketplaces in Peru, Chile and Colombia. Beyond that, we deepened our work with Chile's central securities depository, adding the ability to handle digitized assets, and with B3 in Brazil to build a new clearing solution, plus with BMV in Mexico to overhaul its full post-trade technology platform. These expanding customer ties underscore how vital the financial technology we deliver has become, since it keeps markets around the globe resilient and liquid. Within our anti-financial crime offerings, we combine world-leading technology with consortium data drawn from 2,500 banks to combat the escalating danger of financial crime throughout the global financial system. Our first-ever Global Financial Crime Report, produced alongside outside experts, projects that more than $3 trillion in illicit funds moves through the worldwide financial system, with $500 billion lost to fraud — a massive problem demanding collective effort from the banking sector, the public sector and the adoption of cutting-edge technology. We're extremely proud of the part we play in the fight against financial crime, and we see enormous opportunity to keep growing what we can do across banking. During 2023, we hit a major milestone in our strategy for growing anti-financial crime. Over the course of the year, Verafin, our fraud and AML offering, brought aboard its first three Tier 1 banks along with four Tier 2 banks, among them one Tier 1 client and one Tier 2 client signed in the fourth quarter; we also teamed up with an expanding roster of small and medium-sized financial institutions, reaching a total of 237 new clients for the year and 100 in Q4 by itself. In addition, we built our first proprietary Verafin Gen AI copilot, which has entered beta with our customers. Our Gen AI tools cut down on the time and resources devoted to manual tasks and processes, like alert reviews, research and documentation. By boosting their operational efficiency, Verafin lets our clients put money into resilient growth at an appealing ROI; over in Surveillance, we brought on 27 new clients during 2023, 6 of them in the fourth quarter. We achieved meaningful progress in updating our solutions, rolling out a new cloud-based architecture and new capabilities in surveillance user interfaces. Thanks to these innovations, our clients can calibrate their surveillance setup with greater efficiency and effectiveness. At present, half of the customers using Nasdaq Trade Surveillance take advantage of our cloud-hosted offerings, and those offerings enable reaching 200 advanced alerts spanning over 160 markets worldwide. As we keep strengthening what our surveillance can do, the early uptake of our next-generation cloud architecture along with new user interfaces gives us reason for optimism. Now to Market Services. During Q4, we held onto a solid 72% share of the market for our cash equities markets in the Nordics, even as volumes proved difficult throughout European markets. We have likewise kept showing a top-tier market position when it comes to U.S. equities and options markets. In Q4, strong closing cross volumes tied to the S&P, MSCI and our own Nasdaq rebalance events worked in our favor, and adoption of our NDX index options product keeps expanding. On top of that, we keep pushing forward with modernizing markets, having successfully moved our second U.S. options market onto AWS cloud infrastructure, and having secured SEC approval for Dynamic M-ELO, the first AI-driven order type, which should go live during the first quarter of 2024. All things considered, we are acting quickly while still generating revenue growth and an appealing margin profile that will create shareholder value. Now that the coming year is squarely in view, I want to walk through our enterprise priorities for 2024. Priority one is carrying on with a successful integration of Adenza. The early stage of that integration has gone very well, and we stay confident about hitting the targets we set out when the deal was struck. Priority two is speeding up the impact of our divisional structure so we can activate and open up fresh opportunities that push our business forward. Throughout the last year, we made meaningful strides within every one of our business divisions, and in 2024 we will keep capturing the advantages this structure provides. Priority three is embedding client listening throughout the whole company so we can unlock revenue growth via a One Nasdaq approach to how we engage clients. During 2024, we have a dedicated program aimed at arranging our client data, upgrading our CRM and other connected systems, and improving our processes company-wide so we gain a complete picture of our clients, all with the aim of fueling partnerships and cross-selling opportunities down the road; and priority four is that we will further magnify how AI affects the business and our products. Nasdaq relies on a number of essential elements to make certain AI gets deployed in a safe, secure and fair manner. Thanks to our emphasis on AI, combined with the enormous proprietary data sets built up over decades in our markets and in our solutions spanning investment analytics, investor relations and anti-financial crime, we feel sure we can broaden Nasdaq's competitive edge in the years to come. We are eager to bring you updates on how these priorities are progressing at Investor Day and over the quarters ahead. In closing, 2023 stood out once more as a year marked by major strategic and operational milestones and by strong execution. Looking toward 2024, we're in a strong position to meet our clients' needs in a more holistic way as we grow into the trusted fabric of the global financial system. With that said, I'll hand things over now to Sarah, who will walk through our financial details.

Sarah Youngwood

executive
#4

Thanks, Adena, and good morning to all of you. It's a real pleasure for me to be on my first earnings call here at Nasdaq. Joining this company during such a transformative period has me incredibly enthusiastic, and I'm eager to connect with many of you at Investor Day. Let me now move on to the financials. I'll be speaking about non-GAAP figures, and the year-over-year growth percentages I cite will be on an organic basis. In the same way, operating margins will be addressed excluding Adenza so comparisons are consistent. I'll get into the Adenza standalone numbers once the Fintech portion wraps up. Before diving into the quarter, I want to share highlights for the entirety of 2023, and I'll begin on Slide 12 of the earnings presentation; despite an environment full of uncertainty, we achieved solid financial performance along with robust cash flow generation. Revenue came in at $3.9 billion, rising 5%, while Solutions revenue reached $2.9 billion, climbing 7%; non-GAAP expense was $1.8 billion, an increase of 5%, matching our guidance; this produced a 52% operating margin, which was unchanged from the previous year. All of this translated into diluted EPS of $2.82, which reflects 6% organic growth. Free cash flow ex-Adenza was $1.6 billion, representing growth of 11%. Now let's look at the fourth quarter on Slide 13; revenue was $1.1 billion, an increase of 7%, and Solutions revenue was $860 million, up 9%. Non-GAAP expense came to $504 million, a rise of 2%, and the operating margin was 52%, an increase of 3 percentage points. On the whole, diluted EPS was $0.72, reflecting 11% organic growth. Now on to Slide 14. ARR came to $2.6 billion, which is 6% higher organically. Annualized SaaS revenue reached $910 million, which represents 12% organic growth. If you exclude Adenza, SaaS accounted for 38% of ARR, an improvement of 2 percentage points. When Adenza is included, that figure stands at 35%, and it will rise as the cloud share of their revenue grows. As a reminder, we count only the cloud share of their revenue as SaaS. Let's go through the division results for the quarter, beginning on Slide 15; for Capital Access Platforms, revenue was $461 million, an increase of 10%, fueled by outstanding performance in Index. Within Data and Listing Services, growth was 3%; on the Data side, we've continued to see proprietary data revenues rise, mainly because of stronger international demand. On the Listings side, the favorable effect of pricing was partly counterbalanced by delistings, a subdued IPO environment and the roll-off of initial listings revenue from the prior year, all combined. Workflow and Insights revenue rose 3%. Analytics posted high single-digit growth, which shows our capacity to monetize the value of our data for the buy side through new business and higher pricing across traditional and alternative asset managers. The strength in Analytics was partly offset by a softer capital raising market and the effect of a drawn-out sales cycle in Corporate Solutions. Index revenue rose 26%, and overall AUM grew 34%. During the past dozen months, our net inflows reached $31 billion, with $10 billion coming in the fourth quarter. Revenue from licensing for futures contracts tied to the Nasdaq 100 Index also rose, fueled by greater capture, though this was partly offset by lower trading volumes. Keep in mind that our capture steps up after passing a volume threshold, then resets when each new year begins. Though smaller, Index revenue additionally gained from growth in Index data revenue. ARR for Capital Access Platforms came to $1.2 billion, a 3% rise. Growth in ARR was mainly powered by Analytics, and to a lesser degree by Data and Listings. The subdued IPO backdrop weighed on ARR growth; even so, we hold cautious optimism about a possible IPO rebound, together with sales cycles that are more normalized, as 2024 moves forward. Remember that nearly all Index revenue sits outside ARR. This division's operating margin reached 54% in the quarter, climbing 4 percentage points thanks to higher revenues. Across the full year, the figure was 55%, up approximately 50 basis points. Higher revenues fueled that gain, partly offset by inflation, revenue-related expense and investments, especially in Data and Index. Turning to Financial Technology on Slide 16. This division posted $399 million in revenue for the quarter, an 8% increase. Regulatory technologies rose 17%, with Verafin at 25%. Verafin brought on 100 new clients during the quarter, among them our third Tier 1 bank. Though these additions excite us, as noted before, contracting and implementation with such larger, more complex institutions takes longer. Subscription revenue recognition will begin in 2024, yet we think regtech will accelerate further as we deepen ties with these clients. Verafin's robust showing, plus 6% growth in Surveillance, produced that 17% growth for Regulatory Technology. For Surveillance, fourth quarter growth felt the effect of booking timing in 2023 relative to 2022; nonetheless fundamentals stayed solid across the year, with 6 new clients in the fourth quarter and 27 for the full year. We also gained ground with the Tier 3 broker client cohort, showing progress that goes beyond our leadership position among large banks. Cloud for Trade Surveillance now exceeds 50% deployment, a key driver of client stickiness via the speed and efficiency we can deliver. Now on to Capital Markets Technology. We recorded 3% growth, powered by demand for data center connectivity. We signed new Market Tech contracts in Latin America and with one of our U.S. Tier 1 clients. Those contracts should begin accruing in 2024. As Adena noted, we keep expanding our market technology footprint in Latin America and play a leading part in modernizing markets across that region. ARR for Fintech reached $1.35 billion, a 10% increase, thanks to ongoing customer wins at Verafin plus growth in trade management services and market technology. During Q4, the division posted a 40% operating margin, which is a rise of 4 percentage points. This organic improvement comes from healthy top line expansion along with disciplined cost management, even as revenue-linked expenses went up overall, balanced out by gains in efficiency and reduced professional fees. We're making headway in our effort to boost efficiency within Market Technology, all while still backing the expansion of Verafin and Surveillance. Across the entire year, operating margin reached 40%, an increase of 5 percentage points, and the narrative here is similar to what we saw in the quarter, encompassing robust operating leverage as well as investments. Before we wrap up on Fintech, just a few more comments regarding Adenza. During November and December, Adenza brought in $149 million of revenue; $458 million in ARR, with $98 million of that from SaaS; plus $35 million in non-GAAP operating expense. A powerful close to the year produced a 77% operating margin throughout our 2-month period of ownership. Looking at the whole year, Adenza's adjusted EBITDA margin came to 59%, surpassing our original 58% guidance for the year. Now let me discuss Adenza's revenue and ARR for the full year. Revenue totaled $583 million in 2023, marking a 14% increase. ARR hit $458 million, rising 16%, or 14% when you exclude a major bankruptcy that took place during the year. Both of these figures are reported on a constant currency basis.

Sarah Youngwood

executive
#5

This year, cloud accounted for close to 50% of new ACV. Our clients' robust adoption of cloud underpins both our expansion and our efficiency gains. A substantial share of ARR that was eligible for renewal during the quarter and across the year gave a boost to revenue growth. Looking ahead, we anticipate Adenza's revenue growth landing in the low to mid-teens, which aligns with the medium- to long-term outlook we shared at the time we announced the acquisition. The timing of contract renewals, together with how much revenue comes from cloud versus on-premise delivery, determines how much we grow in any given quarter or year. That's exactly why we focus on ARR growth—it's less sensitive to renewals that happen within the year and to the delivery method. At Investor Day, we'll provide more specifics about the revenue dynamics in our Fintech division. That wraps up our divisional overview along with Market Services. For the quarter, net revenue was $247 million, about flat, since gains in U.S. cash equities were canceled out by drops in U.S. options. The increase in U.S. cash equities resulted from higher capture, which was partly offset by lower share; in a fiercely competitive U.S. Within the options space, we're safeguarding both our commanding position in the market and the appealing economics we capture. At the same time, over in Europe, a $7 million one-time payment and gains from spreading activity across fixed income and equities helped counterbalance weak trading volumes. The money we've put into using our tech and data so European market clients gain transparency and can generate alpha has let us assist those clients in raising their execution quality, and it was essential to winning back our 72% market share — that's up 2 percentage points. For the division, operating margin came in at 57% during Q4 2023, down from 60% a year earlier. The decline came from increased compensation expenses tied to our continued investment in employees, along with greater technology spending stemming from ongoing work on capacity and shifting U.S. markets onto the cloud. For the entire year, the division's operating margin reached 59%, driven by the same factors behind the quarterly result. Moving to Slide 19. Non-GAAP operating expense for the quarter was $504 million, which on an organic basis rose $8 million, or 2%, while organic revenue grew 7%. That aligned with what was happening across the businesses, and it also shows we kept a tight grip on costs along with how the timing fell for marketing and professional fees. Taking it all together, that works out to a 52% operating margin, which is 3 percentage points higher. Looking at the whole year, non-GAAP operating expense came to $1.83 billion, matching what we had guided; that was a 5% increase, which tracks with revenue growth and leaves operating margin flat at 52%. The rise stems from putting money into key growth areas, inflation, and expenses tied to higher revenue. We also found efficiencies over the year as we kept refining our location footprint and merged the divisions through our divisional realignment. When Adenza is counted for the entire year, operating expense came to $2.05 billion. Now let's talk about our guidance. We're setting our initial non-GAAP operating expense outlook for 2024 at a range of $2.105 billion to $2.185 billion, with the midpoint representing pro forma growth of 5%. This projection includes a full year of Adenza and applies the in-year expense method for net synergies. On an organic basis, excluding Adenza, the expense growth for Nasdaq would be slightly below 4.5%. We'll cover synergies in more detail at Investor today, but we are reaffirming our target of $80 million in net synergies by the end of 2025, along with $80 million in costs to achieve, as outlined in the restructuring program we recently launched. Looking past that, our guidance for the whole year on a non-GAAP basis puts the tax rate between 24.5% and 26.5%. That's a bit above what we saw in 2023, driven by our expectation of a smaller tax benefit tied to equity awards. Now let's turn to Slide 20. Nasdaq's signature trait continues to be strong free cash flow. Across the year, we brought in $1.6 billion in free cash flow excluding Adenza, while Adenza itself delivered $306 million in unlevered pretax free cash flow. At the time the deal closed, we expected our gross leverage ratio to land at 4.7, so we're pleased to share that we ended the year at 4.3, and that's despite a 0.1 headwind caused by euro strength. Let's go through what the chart shows in detail. At the end of Q3, our adjusted leverage ratio came in at 2.4. The Adenza acquisition is what added that leverage. During the first part of December, we stopped buying back shares and made a $260 million payment on our term loans. The ratio improved thanks to extra EBITDA from a full year of Adenza plus growth at Nasdaq. We expect to keep bringing leverage down through Q1 of 2024. Wrapping up on how we used free cash flow: repurchases of our common stock total $269 million for the year, with $110 million of that coming in Q4. We also distributed a quarterly dividend of $0.22 per share, which works out to a 35% annualized payout ratio. In wrapping up, what we achieved both in this quarter and across the full year shows Nasdaq can generate steady growth, margins, and free cash flow no matter what conditions we face. We stay committed to running the business with discipline and continuing to innovate. The money we've put into our resilience, our technology, and our data over the years—along with the breadth of our business and our history of results—means we're set up to grow in a lasting way while helping our clients win. I appreciate your attention, and now I'll turn things over to the operator so we can take your questions.

Owen Lau

analyst
#6

I realize Sarah said you might cover this at Investor Day, but would you mind giving us additional detail regarding how things are going so far with folding Adenza in and hitting those revenue and cost synergy targets?

Adena Friedman

executive
#7

Of course. Right, so — like you mentioned, the deal closed on November 1. Right away we set up the operating model for how things would run moving forward, which means the teams got merged. There's now a leadership structure combining folks from both Adenza and Nasdaq reporting up through Tal. We've been putting in a lot of effort to unite the sales groups, the client delivery success side, the operating teams, and the technology teams. So Owen, it's really only been a couple of months, but we are absolutely functioning as a single team. We've got a synergy plan that's very specific and well defined. Our line of sight toward hitting that plan is quite clear; we'll share further specifics about it. That said, Owen, throughout the whole of Nasdaq, we're combining our efforts to generate efficiencies among the team, exactly the way you'd expect from a typical acquisition integration, and beyond that a location-based approach that lets us position ourselves alongside our clients down the road and takes advantage of what Adenza brings in certain really important centers of excellence globally. So I'd say we've got a solid plan. More specifics will come at Investor Day. Then the final point I'd make regarding revenue synergies is that it's clearly quite early, and getting new deals signed takes time. Building those relationships takes time; however, the initial discussions I've been part of, along with ones Tal and Valerie, our Chief Revenue Officer, have had, have been incredibly encouraging. There's a genuine desire among people to work with us. They now view us as a partner who can help them tackle their biggest challenges; whether that's in reg tech, or in anti-fincrime and risk management. I believe they get that we get them. We're a regulated entity. Our ties with regulators are strong. And I think they likewise recognize that we're able to deliver a great deal of cutting-edge technology and push forward cloud capabilities inside Adenza. So honestly, those early conversations have been fantastic; though as we've consistently said, realizing those revenue synergies in the actual financials is going to take time. And once more, we'll give you further detail on all of this at Investor Day.

Owen Lau

analyst
#8

Understood. Regarding Verafin, you released a report and discussed both the scale of fraud and the potential opportunity. Could you share your 2024 strategy for Verafin? In which segment do you believe you can secure more Tier 1 and Tier 2 customers? Is it primarily payments, or does it extend to other areas?

Adena Friedman

executive
#9

Absolutely. Thanks for bringing that up, Owen. We put together a study — collaborating with two external firms. So it involved those two outside organizations alongside our own team. We spoke with numerous key people at banks who handle anti-financial crime to grasp, first, the magnitude of the issue. $3 trillion laundered via the system, $0.5 trillion in fraud losses. Then, how substantial is the challenge when it comes to actually resolving it? And what obstacles exist? First, various criminal groups operate in distinct ways. That means you need diverse categories of analytics to uncover differing unlawful activities, firstly. Secondly, as we've consistently stated, wrongdoers don't confine themselves to a single bank. Therefore one institution alone can't review its entire transaction dataset and truly fix the issue. That makes Verafin a genuinely distinctive offering, since we have 2,500 banks accounting for $6 trillion in assets, all part of a consortium data lake, enabling us to identify highly specific typologies and more effectively eliminate criminal activity; as a result we observe reduced false positives, increased fraud detection, greater AML identification, and we can demonstrate this convincingly. That's how we've managed to bring on board the Tier 1s and Tier 2s, with an additional Tier 1 signed during the fourth quarter. As for where our emphasis lies, I'd mention a couple of areas, Owen. First, maintaining that momentum with SMBs. In that context, our main push is toward real-time payments, ensuring smaller and mid-sized banks possess top-tier AFC capabilities for their real-time payments; that represents a significant growth avenue for us in '24. Among bigger banks, we've been — clearly the most straightforward ROI to demonstrate is fraud. Thus payment fraud such as wire fraud, ACH fraud, check fraud, every payment-related fraud we detect delivers enormous value and unmistakable ROI. AML presents a tougher challenge to address, yet we have indeed signed one of the major Tier 2s, actually I believe two of the major Tier 2s, with a strong emphasis on AML; and while we address the fraud issue, what we're discovering is that once we enter these large banks, demonstrate our fraud value, they begin engaging with us about AML. So that's the land-and-expand prospect before us, and we certainly anticipate expansion possibilities in '24 with the institutions you've already signed. Also, one final point: our attention is now heavily on the United Kingdom. Brendan actually has meetings scheduled with banks this week, aimed at gaining a real understanding of our capabilities there — especially when it comes to payments fraud. Because of upcoming legal changes, more data sharing will be permitted, which means our pooling approach can do a far better job of addressing the issue they face and let us deliver a solution in that market. That represents the following phase of expansion for us as we move through '24 and into '25.

Michael Cho

analyst
#10

I wanted to ask about Adenza for a moment. You've mentioned ARR growth, which has remained healthy in the mid-teens, and you've been clear about your medium-term goals for it. Still, because the sales cycle there tends to run long, I was hoping you might share what you expect for Adenza's revenue growth this year, perhaps framed against your long-term targets; and it would also help to get any detail you can offer on Axiom versus Calypso.

Adena Friedman

executive
#11

Of course. On the ARR growth side, we gave you that mid-teens figure, and the dynamics of the business keep backing it up. So our expectation is that the medium-term outlook for Adenza will keep supporting growth in the mid-teens. As you know, revenue growth gets shaped by when bookings land, when renewals occur, and whether the arrangement is on-prem or cloud. That's why we'll break this down at Investor Day, so you can see how ARR converts into revenue and how the revenue mechanics shift; and while we acknowledge revenues will move around more from quarter to quarter, the broad takeaway is that ARR growth is absolutely the key metric for judging the progress of Adenza, Calypso, and Axiom. At the same time, we want you to grasp how the revenue mechanics function. The more cloud deals we sign, the more those contracts are recognized ratably across the contract term. In contrast, with on-prem deals, half the license fees are recognized upfront at signing. So there's plenty to break down. Still, we feel terrific about the underlying demand drivers. Another factor with Axiom and Calypso is that renewal timing can also affect revenue recognition. That said, demand cycles for both Axiom and Calypso look really strong, so we feel quite good about that, even though revenue timing may differ between them depending on when renewal cycles fall in a particular year; so, once again, that's something we'll walk through. Overall, the foundation is very solid and stays in line with what we anticipated.

Dan Fannon

analyst
#12

I was hoping you could go into a bit more detail on that, and perhaps also address pricing — specifically, how much pricing added to revenue growth and/or ARR growth during 2023, and how you're thinking about that for the Adenza business going forward.

Adena Friedman

executive
#13

Sure. Honestly, we won't be extremely granular about that specific year. But speaking generally, when it comes to ARR growth, roughly half of it we attribute to upsells, in fact. We did upsell a large number of clients, and I believe I can share that figure. We upsold close to 150 clients — I think 120 clients in 2023. The remaining half stems from a mix of price increases and new bookings; we don't disclose those separately at that stage, but I'd simply say it's a blend of the two. And here's how it functions: clearly, we deliver a great deal of value across the products throughout the year, so when we move into both the annualized increases that are contractually specified and renewal cycles, we clearly demonstrate that the value we're delivering to them aligns with an increase; and/or their assets are growing, which means they're using this across a bigger portion of their operations, and that too justifies an increase. But those are — that pattern holds steady.

Dan Fannon

analyst
#14

Got it. Now, for a second question: given what was said about the drivers behind listings revenue in Q4, when you look at the opening six months of this year and/or the entire year — with initial fees from earlier years rolling off, plus a hoped-for rebound in new listings — what's the right way to frame the revenue trends for 2024?

Adena Friedman

executive
#15

Yes, absolutely. First, though, one point of precision: in 2023 we recorded 142 upsells, and that figure includes 3 cross-sells in Adenza. I want those facts on the record. On the listings side, though, the environment has clearly been tougher; and as you say, and as you highlight, amortization tied to the initial listing component is a key factor shaping listings revenues. The benefit works like this: in a very strong listings year, such as 2020 and 2021, not all of the initial listing fees get recognized in that same year. That creates something of a boost in later years, since those fees amortize across 2 to 4 years, based on how large the listing is. The flip side is that after two tougher years, it takes a while for that effect to work its way through. As a result, we'll see something of a lingering effect from these weaker years in 2024 and 2025, as initial listing fees from the stronger years roll off and — as you've observed — we had a net decline in listings during 2023. So our expectation is that 2024 will be a difficult year for listings. That said, inside the Data and Listings business, our position is essentially that it grows at a low single-digit rate. And we believe we can still hit that even with the softer listing revenue we're anticipating in 2024.

Kyle Voigt

analyst
#16

Okay, so perhaps I'll start with a question about sales cycles. You mentioned seeing initial indicators that sales cycles are normalizing for your IR and asset owner offerings. Could you elaborate on those initial indicators and provide a few examples? And regarding what that implies for revenue growth, should we anticipate that organic growth for Workflow and Insights might be close to a floor-level figure of 5% organic in Q4 and then steadily improve from there? Or is there any other perspective you could offer on the timing and what that enhancement signifies regarding sales cycles.

Adena Friedman

executive
#17

Absolutely. Every one of the offerings under Workflow and Insights is a SaaS offering. Therefore, the way you conclude the year truly shapes a great deal about the next year. And so we certainly encountered a tougher landscape with corporates in the prior year. The listing landscape was quieter, yet additionally they simply weren't as concentrated on putting money into IR amid a tougher market setting. That got better in Q4, and so we did begin to experience a more — I'd describe it as a more typical setting for discussions and contract signings with corporate customers for our IR offerings in Q4, though it occurred against the context of a tougher year in general. So it's going to require time for that better setting to truly make its way through and appear in the actual SaaS revenues since we clearly must keep witnessing that, and it will sort of accumulate on its own; however, I'd anticipate that 2024 will keep having some drag from the weaker climate in '23 even with a more typical selling climate; when it comes to Analytics, what's actually intriguing is this. Our total Analytics growth was pretty robust in Q4, reaching 9%. And I believe that genuinely mirrors appetite for our data throughout the buy side and the analytics offerings we provide that cater to the buy side. However, our asset owner offerings, this is a quite particular software functionality that we provide to endowments and pensions and others, that in fact saw a rise in demand and signings in Q4, though it was a difficult year on the whole. So that, once more, I believe will generate a headwind as we move through 2024 with the expectation that we can begin to demonstrate some improvement as we progress through the year.

Kyle Voigt

analyst
#18

Got it. And perhaps a quick additional question about Adenza. You brought up how strongly cloud adoption has been going. I don't want to get ahead of the Investor Day, but could you simply remind everyone what cloud adoption will mean for EBITDA margins over the long run, at least in terms of direction? And since these contracts run so long, and since you're seeing that level of cloud uptake when renewals come around, is there an approximate timeframe for how fast that shift to cloud could occur across the coming years?

Adena Friedman

executive
#19

That's — I'd say we'll give at least additional detail on that during Investor Day. Yet when we consider it, I believe, Sarah, it's roughly 14% of total revenue?

Sarah Youngwood

executive
#20

14% of revenue is currently cloud and 50% of new ACV bookings.

Adena Friedman

executive
#21

And then in ARR, it's 21%?

Sarah Youngwood

executive
#22

21%.

Adena Friedman

executive
#23

Yeah, cloud accounts for 21% of ARR, which means there's plenty of runway ahead. As we renew customers, we shift them onto cloud modules; as we bring on new customers, we sign them up for new modules — though we should note a client can sign up for just one new module in the cloud. It isn't necessary that they buy Calypso and then layer on extra functionality. That additional functionality alone can be delivered via cloud. That's the level of flexibility the platform offers. There's no requirement for them to redo their entire platform implementation in the cloud. That said, it also means that when we handle renewals and changes with clients, each will have its own timeline for adopting those cloud capabilities. Certain banks are moving toward cloud very quickly, with what amounts to top-down mandates to make the shift. For us, that can clearly be a tremendous catalyst. Yet other banks are moving toward it fairly slowly. So flexibility is what we want. As we've said, we anticipate this being very much a multiyear transition, starting from 21% of ARR and climbing and climbing. Still, I should say it will be a slow-moving train. Economically speaking, it's an opportunity for us to become a true managed service provider, which brings us more revenue opportunity, and it also delivers a very attractive margin for both them and us. So there's upside to capture, but once again, a slow-moving train. We'll therefore want to give you a bit more color on this at Investor Day.

Chris Allen

analyst
#24

I'd like your help thinking through what the client wins at Adenza mean in terms of contract value. Perhaps you can give us some sense of how a new client — and you had 6 this quarter — translates from a new contract standpoint; and when you deepen ties with clients you already have, is it a 10% bump, a 15% bump? Any detail on that would be useful.

Adena Friedman

executive
#25

We don't really disclose particular contract values for any individual client or anything along those lines. If it's all right with you, I believe we'll hold that question and consider the best way to offer greater transparency on it. That said, here's what I'd note: it's always land and expand; and in fact, as we climb into Tier 2s and Tier 1s in AFC, it's land and expand. So to land, we might sign a client at, say, the mid- to high 6 figures or the low 7 figures. Then, as we expand, we're able to double or triple, or in certain instances reach 5x the amount over time. And I do believe we have a few illustrations of that from when we initially signed the deal, and on our third quarter results, we shared some examples of how contracts have grown over time; but at the moment we aren't giving specifics such as what the new contract values were for the new clients.

Patrick Moley

analyst
#26

I had just one question regarding Adenza's retention ratios; for the full year, on both a gross and net basis, they came in somewhat below what you had anticipated at the time the deal was first announced, even after factoring in the effect of those bankruptcies. So I was hoping you might offer a bit more insight into what you believe caused that shortfall. And then any insight on the retention ratios, or what your target retention ratios would be moving forward.

Adena Friedman

executive
#27

Yes. So I believe we did observe certain declines in gross and net retention during the later portion of the year; and I think a great deal of that truly came from the bankruptcy we referenced. And that really did begin to affect us in the fourth quarter. And then we had — I would simply describe it as the events of 2023 throughout the banking system, which did generate some degree of difficulty in a few very particular areas of retention. But it's not — I would say there was nothing systemic regarding the concern. There was nothing we observed that was more of a trend in any manner at all. It was more the encapsulation of many of the events that took place over the year, both in terms of examining the retention as well as some of the acquisitions that took place. But again, these are extremely, extremely specific and nothing trend-related. But I don't know, Sarah, whether you would like to add anything to that?

Sarah Youngwood

executive
#28

Right, so if we take out that bankruptcy, gross retention really didn't move at all — it held at 97%. So from a longer-term trend perspective, we see that as quite solid.

Michael Cyprys

analyst
#29

I'd like to ask about capital allocation — specifically, how are you approaching where the money goes now that Adenza has closed? What's your thinking on how quickly debt gets paid down, and on buybacks too? I believe you said something about halting buybacks. Does that halt remain? And what circumstances would cause you to start buybacks up again?

Sarah Youngwood

executive
#30

Mike, good to keep talking; Sarah here. The plan we've laid out remains in place; we take a balanced approach to deploying capital, to restate it, spanning the dividend, repurchasing shares and bringing down leverage. As I noted, you've observed the halt, and throughout the first quarter that halt will stay; continuing to reduce leverage matters greatly to us and — yet this is a near-term tactical move within an overall strategy that has not shifted. So our commitment to a growing dividend stands, and you've witnessed the advancement on that front. And in time, using buybacks to counter dilution also matters. That's the backdrop; and naturally, this is something we'll revisit at Investor Day.

Adena Friedman

executive
#31

There's something we feel good about, Michael, which is that, yes, as we exit 2023, like Sarah said, our leverage sits at 4.3x. That puts us ahead of where we thought we'd be when the deal closed. And really, that reflects both how strong the business is and some quite deliberate tactical choices we made to bring down the term loan as we're sort of beginning to head into 2024 with a really solid plan for deleveraging. At the same time, though, the emphasis is going to be on that balanced approach over the long run.

Michael Cyprys

analyst
#32

Thanks. And a quick follow-up regarding the cost guidance. On that cost guidance, could you go into more detail about the 5% pro forma expense increase for this year in '24 — what factors would push you to the top end rather than the bottom end of that range, and any components you could break down?

Adena Friedman

executive
#33

Absolutely. Yes. So first off, I'd say we've remained very focused on ensuring we operate as efficiently as we can throughout the business on a run rate basis; while also continuing to invest in advancing our products, our growth, and automation as well, adding more of it into the organization; and simultaneously starting to realize synergies from the Adenza deal. And the midpoint essentially captures all of that. What would push costs higher than that would be stronger growth. So if we can expand more quickly and expand more, there could be some expenses tied to revenue that arise, simply to support achieving that revenue. But I believe it also relates more to whether we can keep accelerating certain investments if we're seeing stronger revenue growth as the year goes on. That's why we always provide a range covering the mid- to long-term outlook for our solutions business growth, revenue growth, and expense growth, so you can see how we calibrate it. But we do believe it's been a solid mix at the midpoint of cost discipline, Adenza's synergies, and targeted investments in our business.

Andrew Bond

analyst
#34

Since you pulled the plug on the custody product, could you bring us up to speed on whatever fresh initiatives or approaches Nasdaq is looking into within digital assets? There are clear tailwinds now that spot ETFs have won approval, plus plenty of big institutional names you know well are getting more involved in this area — so where does Nasdaq see itself fitting in today?

Adena Friedman

executive
#35

Absolutely. Appreciate it, Andrew. So partnering with BlackRock and Valkyrie as they listed their Bitcoin ETFs on Nasdaq is something we're genuinely proud of, and it truly offers investors a way to take a position on how Bitcoin is trending — inside a tightly regulated venue, and without needing to go out and purchase Bitcoin directly. So our thinking is that this opens up greater accessibility for retail investors who want exposure to Bitcoin. When it comes to the wider digital asset landscape, though, as you're aware, we serve the industry as a technology provider; we keep supplying technology to cryptocurrency exchanges — trading, clearing, and surveillance as well. And in fact, through our work with certain traditional exchanges, they're eager to ensure they're future-proofed, so to speak. Take one of the CSD clients we sold to this year — a central priority for them was ensuring they could shift toward digital assets within their settlement system; and so we are — every piece of our technology is capable of supporting digital assets across trading, clearing, settlement, and surveillance, which gives us an opening to collaborate with traditional exchanges and crypto exchanges alike; as for our dedicated crypto custody solution, we've built it; we stand ready to deliver it to exchanges, providers, and custodians globally. So that's now a technology offering we can put in front of clients worldwide. That said, we've deliberately chosen not to roll out a custody solution, meaning we won't act as a custodian ourselves. Our sense is that multiple such providers already exist and are performing well, yet it's also a highly capital-intensive line of business; and we believe we're better positioned as a market operator for ETFs and similar instruments, along with being a technology supplier to the industry.

Alex Blostein

analyst
#36

So I'll just jump in with one more quick question about Adenza. During the past 2 years, it seemed as though they made a fairly substantial upgrade to their tech stack, and there's likely some CapEx tied to that. Looking ahead, would you say that work is mostly finished? Or are there still some areas that could involve heavier lifting and still need to be put in place, that aren't yet part of Nasdaq? And maybe you could also speak to what you expect overall for CapEx in 2024.

Adena Friedman

executive
#37

Sure. What I'd do is — let's handle Calypso and AxiomSL one at a time. AxiomSL did a major technology rewrite several years back; so we feel quite confident about where they stand; but — and then Calypso, in fact the one — they're extremely flexible and highly modular. So they essentially have an ongoing, continuous investment in Calypso. And they've managed to — because of that, they've actually been far better able to — or both companies are centered on introducing new modules extremely fast and continually refining their technology. So we feel very good about the tech foundation, and I believe we mentioned that when we signed; now that the deal has closed and we've had a chance to look under the hood, it's excellent technology, and it's highly modular and essentially platform-based. I think the place where we can genuinely help sharpen their focus is figuring out how to truly optimize the cloud implementation so that it becomes as efficient as possible for them and for their clients. And so we possess a great deal of expertise in that area; we have a lengthy track record with cloud-deployed solutions. And so we genuinely believe that's somewhere we can assist them in investing so that it can be delivered even more effectively and efficiently. But that isn't a major capital outlay so much as it is simply us carrying on with innovation. They've been putting money into R&D; so that's been a defining feature of their business, and so we're very happy to see that. And we'll keep that going, but that isn't something requiring a large CapEx commitment at this moment. We truly view it as an ongoing continuum of innovation. As for our CapEx over the course of the year, I think — I'm not sure whether you have anything particular you'd want to bring up there.

Sarah Youngwood

executive
#38

Nope, there isn't really any specific pattern here, so nothing like a distinct speed-up or anything worth flagging is going to show up. Investment in the business keeps going, and at Investor Day we'll return with plenty of detail regarding the kinds of returns and the kinds of breakdowns of what we're putting money into. Also, we hold a strongly cash-on-cash perspective on what that delivers for us, plus, naturally, the spending that is foundational to the business.

Brian Bedell

analyst
#39

The majority of things have already been covered, though I have a few additional items. First, regarding Verafin — Sarah, I believe you said, assuming I caught it correctly, that Verafin's year-over-year expansion this quarter was 25%, compared with 17% for the legacy Regulatory Tech segment. And then I — there was a remark you made concerning the Surveillance portion that I didn't catch. So I simply wanted to get clarity on that 25% figure at Verafin and whether some offset occurred in the Surveillance business; and then when you consider that legacy business moving ahead, do you still — is Verafin in your view a grower in the core 20%-ish category?

Sarah Youngwood

executive
#40

What I stated is that 25% is in fact the growth rate for Verafin; and when Surveillance is included, the result is 17%. That works out to 6% for Surveillance. The reason is the timing of bookings during 2022, which affected the year-on-year growth in the fourth quarter. So it comes down purely to timing in the comparable period a year earlier.

Adena Friedman

executive
#41

For Surveillance.

Sarah Youngwood

executive
#42

For Surveillance.

Adena Friedman

executive
#43

Brian, my response would be affirmative, since you're aware that throughout FT we generally anticipate a range of 18% to 23%. As we shift toward reg tech and bring it together with AxiomSL, we'll be offering a sort of perspective; and in my view — I've consistently regarded it as 10% to 14% for Fintech overall. That figure will encompass Verafin and Surveillance, plus Market Tech and the Adenza products.

Brian Bedell

analyst
#44

Alright. Fantastic. Fantastic; and now, finally, one more question regarding operating leverage, in light of the expense guidance you provided. I suppose I'm asking about how confident you are in that operating leverage. It genuinely appears to be a solid 3 percentage points or perhaps lower than your Solutions revenue guidance of 8% to 11%. Yet, in what way do you consider Adenza's revenue movements relative to Adenza's ARR as affecting that? I suppose the key question I have is whether you are still handling that operating leverage based on reported revenue. Or might you view that ARR as a superior indicator for that operating leverage situation?

Sarah Youngwood

executive
#45

Thus, we keep our attention on our operating margin and on achieving operating leverage while we make investments on a GAAP basis; yet we will at all times provide you with the specifics on the ARR basis, which truly represents the superior economic perspective of what we are doing.

Adena Friedman

executive
#46

Alright, thanks. As we head into what should be another thrilling year here at Nasdaq, our attention stays fixed on activating and unlocking fresh opportunities that will carry this business forward. Before wrapping up, I'd like to remind all of you, in case it slipped your mind, that our 2024 Investor Day is set for Tuesday, March 5; we're hoping each of you can make it, whether you attend in person or virtually, and we're eager to lay out our vision for you. Thanks for being with us, and enjoy the rest of your day.

Operator

operator
#47

Thanks. That wraps up the conference call for today. We appreciate everyone joining in. You're free to disconnect at this point.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Nasdaq, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Nasdaq, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Nasdaq, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.