Papa John's International, Inc. (PZZA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

August 6, 2026

NASDAQ US Consumer Discretionary Hotels, Restaurants and Leisure earnings 62 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Heather Hollander

executive
#1

Hello, everyone, and thanks for joining us for the earnings conference call covering our second quarter of 2026. We put out our earnings release earlier today, and you can find it on the investor relations section of our site, ir.papajohns.com, by going to the News & Events tab, or you can get in touch with our investor relations team. On the line with me this morning are Todd Penegor, our President and Chief Executive Officer, along with Chris Collins, Interim Chief Financial Officer and Senior Vice President, Corporate Finance and Principal Accounting Officer. During this call, we'll be making forward-looking statements as defined under the federal securities laws. Risks and uncertainties tied to these statements might lead actual results to differ materially from what is stated. You should read those forward-looking statements alongside the cautionary language in our earnings release and the risk factors laid out in our SEC filings. Also, for the required reconciliation of the non-GAAP financial measures we'll discuss today, please see our earnings release and our investor relations website. Finally, we'd appreciate it if you could keep your questions to one question and one follow-up; with that, I'll hand things over to Todd.

Todd Penegor

executive
#2

Thanks, Heather. Hello, everybody. Before we move into that, I want to take a moment to speak to the continuing press rumors about Papa John's and a possible sale of the company. Our board and management team are dedicated to delivering the greatest possible value for shareholders. In line with that dedication, we carried out an in-depth examination of our strategy across the last 18 months. We looked carefully at whether other opportunities existed, among them a possible sale of the business. We received strong guidance throughout this process from our financial and legal advisors. Based on what we've learned from this work, the chance to create value that Papa John's can genuinely put into action lies in executing our transformation plan. Of course, the board remains open to alternative ways of maximizing value; even so, any such options would need to be actionable, would need to provide certainty, and would need to be in shareholders' best interest. In our view, what serves the company and all of our shareholders best is putting 100% of our focus on the Papa John's transformation and the initiatives we're discussing today; throughout the second quarter, we continued moving that transformation forward while strengthening the groundwork for growth and value creation over the long term. We're starting to see some positive signs of movement. One is Papa Rewards — membership there is climbing and people are really engaging with it. We've also made real headway on efforts to strengthen restaurant-level economics through supply chain cost reductions and by optimizing our restaurant portfolio. On top of that, our investments in AI and digital are beginning to pay off, improving the ordering experience for customers. At the same time, a weaker consumer environment and heavy discounting across the QSR space have weighed on us, continuing to drag down our financial results. Our commitment hasn't changed, but it's clear the transformation is moving more slowly than we'd hoped. We know we need to execute at a higher level and pick up the pace. As we look ahead, adjustments are being made where needed throughout our strategic priorities and within our leadership ranks, so that outcomes get better and Papa John's is set up for 2027 and the years that follow. To steer the changes we're implementing and ensure we push for strong performance across the whole company, we shared news today of multiple key management shifts. Chris Lyn-Sue, currently Senior Vice President and General Manager of International, will step into the role of Global Chief Marketing Officer. Jenna Bromberg has decided to depart the company in pursuit of other opportunities. With Chris Lyn-Sue moving into that position, Chris Phylactou, presently Managing Director, U.K., Europe, and Canada, takes on the title of Senior Vice President, International. In this capacity, he'll take charge of steering our extremely prosperous overseas operations. Lastly, John Matter, our Senior Vice President and General Counsel, is stepping into a brand-new role as Global Chief Development Officer, in which he'll oversee worldwide growth and development strategy—covering expansion, franchise development, and strategic partnerships; these executives have already played key roles in our transformation, which leaves me deeply confident about what they'll accomplish in these new roles. To illustrate, Chris Lyn-Sue and Chris Phylactou were key forces behind significant change and standout results in our overseas operations. John has played a pivotal role as a leader in our very successful global development and transformation initiatives, and he has also headed up our development team in North America, our portfolio optimization efforts, and negotiations for strategic partnerships. Now let's move on to how we performed in the second quarter. Comparable sales for our international business rose 1.5% during the quarter, which represents our seventh straight quarter of positive comps and shows the ongoing gains from our transformation work. The U.K. One area delivered particularly impressive results, with same-store sales up 10%. That came from steady operational execution, a better customer experience, and heavier media investment — including a 20% bump in PSAs over the course of the transformation, which is lifting brand awareness in that market. Korea likewise posted solid numbers, with comparable sales up 9%, supported by new product development, key partnerships, and holiday shopping demand. In the Middle East, comparable sales were basically level, since ongoing conflict in the region held back results. In North America, comparable sales dropped 8.3%, driven by fewer orders and continued strain from softer customer acquisition. Once again, loyalty stood out as a clear highlight in the quarter. Sales at comparable locations coming from loyalty members outperformed those from customers outside the program by 12 percentage points, and during Q2 our Papa Rewards program passed 42 million members. We consider these loyalty members our most valuable customers — their tickets run 6% higher per order, and they place orders about twice as often as customers who aren't in the program. Within our core pizza segment, orders with more than one pizza showed further improvement, as pies per order climbed 6%, which provided a favorable boost to our overall system ticket, and that number came in flat compared with a year ago. That gain was offset by pizza mix moving toward smaller, non-specialty pizzas, which led to mid-single-digit drops in overall pizza sales. Beyond pizza, comparable sales faced pressure from weaker sides and desserts, though sales of our new sandwiches nearly canceled out the elimination of Papadias and created a completely new food category for us without adding complexity to our make line and operations. Considering our results and the challenging consumer environment, which we anticipate will persist for the rest of the year, we have updated our outlook for 2026. Chris will go into more detail during his remarks, but broadly speaking, we now anticipate global system-wide sales will fall somewhere between 2% and 4% versus last year, with adjusted EBITDA landing between $180 million to $190 million, which now incorporates an additional $18 million of investment aimed at supporting our franchisees and speeding up our transformation. Although our financial performance is not where we want it to be, we have a firm grasp of what needs to be done to better our results and capture market share. These priority areas operate alongside our continuing strategic transformation efforts. As we've mentioned before, we still see two distinct opportunities to capture share: first, further strengthening how customers perceive our value through more focused, personalized offers and a consistently elevated customer experience; and second, drawing in new customers via a more sharpened aggregator strategy, expanding our total addressable market, our rebuilt innovation pipeline, and a revitalized local presence through reestablished co-ops. When we consider what we bring to customers, it's clear that in this tough climate we have to reach people wherever they happen to be. That's why our emphasis was on giving diners the menu items they love most at attractive prices, all while keeping store-level profitability in balance. During this quarter, we highlighted the Papa Pairings promotion along with carryout deals available locally. Sandwiches became part of Papa Pairings, which broadened the selection in our mix and match; in addition, our barbell approach was put to use when we promoted the Epic Stuffed Crust Pizza priced at $13.99. Going forward, instead of running continuous, deep national discounts the way some rivals have done, we're pursuing a more focused method of strengthening what we offer. Over the back half of the year, a more conventional barbell tactic will be rolled out, centered on our top fan-favorite items, with brief, well-targeted periods of aggressive value. Additionally, phase I is underway for bringing our new personalization engine into our CRM platform. This engine is a refined, multi-channel, AI-driven instrument that draws on a blend of national and local deals and provides a greater level of personalization.

Todd Penegor

executive
#3

Our expectation is that after this technology is completely rolled out, it will let us do a better job of customizing messages and deals for our diners, generate additional orders from customers who are new as well as those who have drifted away, and protect restaurant margins while still giving guests strong value at important moments; lessons learned during this first stage will guide how we fine-tune the wider rollout across multiple channels that is scheduled for Q4. Moving on to operations, we recognize that value means more than just price. With that in mind, we keep working to lift the customer experience so Papa John's stands apart in the market and generates additional transactions. Over the past 2 years, we have achieved meaningful progress, making execution stronger throughout the system. At the start of our transformation, our operations support team and field support structure were smaller and scattered across the U.S., which meant less oversight at the market level and fewer touchpoints inside restaurants than we required. Since that time, we have assembled a brand standards coaching team of pizza experts who have launched in-person training, workshops, coaching sessions, and restaurant evaluations; even so, additional work remains because some restaurants and operators continue to trail. As an illustration, during Q2, a 400 basis point gap existed in comparable sales, comparable orders, and restaurant margin performance when comparing restaurants in the top quintile of operation scores with those in the bottom quintile. Lifting the standard for the bottom quintile of operators ranks among the single most important efforts we are undertaking to make our customer experience, brand perception, and top-line performance more consistent. To assist underperforming restaurants in lifting their execution, we are offering dedicated coaching, earned financial incentives, which raise the bar on operational performance, and a regional franchise business director model built to deliver closer in-market support and stronger accountability; that covers more frequent restaurant visits, regular business reviews, documented follow-up, and standardized scorecards to produce measurable improvement. Past better execution, we are also drawing on consumer insights to lift and fine-tune our core product, setting Papa John's further apart on quality in a fiercely competitive marketplace. This effort begins with a sharp grasp of what our customers care about most: better ingredients, craveable flavor, consistent execution, and value they can see and taste. We are using those insights throughout the menu to sharpen the fundamentals of the pizza experience, ranging from dough optimization and bake consistency to toppings, cheese, sauce, and overall product presentation. Our aim is refinements that improve the customer experience while staying operationally simple and scalable across the system. We expect these moves to bolster brand preference, boost repeat purchase behavior, and strengthen Papa John's long-standing quality positioning. Shifting to new customer acquisition, we see a substantial chance to speed up trial through a more concentrated aggregator strategy. Such platforms keep playing a key role in bringing new customers to the brand, and we see room to enhance both our visibility and effectiveness. To accomplish this, we're refining how we promote — blending value-focused deals with our signature items, while also adjusting where our national and local third-party marketing dollars go so returns are maximized. As we extend our footprint via aggregators, we're simultaneously working to lift brand awareness and generate consideration on a bigger scale. To back that, we're shifting our media mix in the back half. Innovation likewise underpins a brand promise that fuels new customer acquisition; we're drawing on a refreshed innovation pipeline, having rolled out pan pizza, oven-toasted sandwiches, a cheesy garlic bread side, and our newest menu item, personal pizzas, ideally sized for one person. Together, these launches are lifting our pizza mix and widening our total addressable market past core pizza. Though innovation stays a key lever, during this quarter we found that innovation on its own didn't produce the new customer trials we'd anticipated. Moving ahead, we're combining innovation with a more focused aggregator strategy and our new first-party CRM platform to boost reach, trial, and conversion. Internationally, our innovation keeps raising the bar, with promising results from launching our artisanal sourdough pizza in the U.K. — a lighter, thinner, more premium pizza aimed at growing our addressable market; this item stands apart with scaled TSR pizza and brings in new customers, yields a higher profit margin, and further lifts the Papa John's brand in that market; beyond new menu items, we're also honing our marketing message to create more meaningful impact with customers. First, we're shifting our media mix toward more mass exposure and higher TRPs. In such a competitive landscape, we understand how vital it is to safeguard share of voice on mass channels while continuing to support a balanced channel mix so we reach customers where they engage most. Getting the most from our marketing investment means balancing wide national awareness with local relevance. As we mentioned on our prior earnings call, we brought back advertising co-ops throughout the U.S. to sharpen market-level targeting, boost relevance, and connect better with customers in local communities. Currently, roughly 50% of our U.S. restaurant system is backed by local co-ops, and the early results give us encouragement. Markets backed by co-ops and significant supplemental local spend are beating other markets by 200 basis points. To keep that momentum, we're building a field marketing team that will collaborate directly with local operators to align on effective coordinated market strategies, make sure local spend complements our national spend, and drive stronger market level performance. We're dedicated to aligning our system on the right amount of national and local spending to support the brand and restore co-ops for most of the system by the close of this year. Naturally, our marketing strategy goes past media and market optimization. We're putting money into experiences and partnerships that deepen engagement, strengthen brand affinity, and draw in new customers. Back in June, we rolled out 4 Pizza Planet pop-ups in major markets across the globe, marking the big-screen debut of Disney and Pixar's "Toy Story 5." These pizza arcades, inspired by retro style, gave fans a chance to walk right into the Toy Story world, complete with beloved characters, experiences, and themes from that cherished franchise, all while cementing Papa John's standing as a brand that connects with culture. The activations drove powerful worldwide response, racking up roughly 4 billion total earned media impressions plus thousands of organic social posts from excited fans. At our 4 immersive retro arcade pop-up spots in L. A, London, Seoul, and Madrid, interest ran exceptionally high, and reservation slots for every event were snapped up within minutes. Putting money into technology matters if we want a seamless customer experience and deeper engagement, and it also gives operators stronger tools for running their operations. We keep expanding our AI capabilities as a way to bring in customers, open up fresh demand channels, and boost how relevant the brand feels. Toward that goal, we're pushing forward with our technology transformation by rolling out Lou AI, our next generation AI-powered pizza assistant, which we built alongside Google Cloud and which you can find on our app. Lou AI works as an always-on digital concierge, tailored for Papa John's and built to make ordering simpler, address customer needs in real time, and pave a smoother route to purchase.

Todd Penegor

executive
#4

Our agentic ordering takes care of applying whatever deals are best available, automatically, and it now lets Papa Rewards members reorder quickly and without friction. The early signs look good. When we compare against orders that don't have AI assistance, customers who use Lou AI convert at a rate that's 18% higher and finish their orders in roughly three minutes less; on top of that, our move to a new POS platform keeps moving forward steadily after we successfully launched our first restaurant pilot in April, with more restaurants joining before this year wraps up, and we expect full deployment across every U.S. corporate and franchise location by the end of 2027. Operators will gain better visibility into important restaurant performance metrics from this modern AI-native platform, which will sharpen operational decision-making and deliver a more connected experience throughout our digital ecosystem. In the end, these investments make us better able to serve customers and back operators. Across every demand channel, we keep setting our customer experience apart to fuel top-line growth; our new e-commerce platform is being used to deliver distinctive, optimized customer experiences spanning app, mobile web, desktop, call center, and aggregators. Thanks to our robust CRM platform, we reach customers more often, relying on targeted, personalized communications through email, push, and SMS to generate incremental visits and strengthen engagement. For Papa John's, our extensive data and digital insights represent key advantages, and we're using them more and more to spot chances to enhance the guest experience and generate incremental sales by innovating continuously across our brand. Since digital channels, aggregators included, account for more than 85% of our sales, delivering an outstanding digital experience is imperative. We're also putting our new e-commerce gaming platform to work to drive trial and repeat visits by weaving CRM and loyalty into the user experience and by fully capitalizing on our partnerships. To connect with customers around "Toy Story 5," we introduced Operation Pizza, our first ever in-app game, which unlocked perks for Papa Rewards members. Last, we keep partnering with and evolving our franchisee base. Our push to optimize our North American supply chain keeps moving us along the path toward unlocking the full potential of our commissary business. During the second quarter, we captured an additional $7 million of benefits and remain on track to realize at least $25 million of savings this year. We believe we will achieve at least $60 million of North American system-wide supply chain productivity opportunities, which equates to at least 160 basis points of full wall EBITDA improvement by 2028 at both our company-owned and franchise restaurants. As part of evolving our franchisee base, we're optimizing our North American system so restaurants end up in the hands of great operators focused on the long term, with capital structures in place that properly support the transformation of the business. In the second quarter, we made further progress optimizing our restaurant portfolio and have closed 101 of the planned 300 North American restaurants identified in our strategic closure program. To remind everyone, this initiative centers on shutting down sites that fail to satisfy brand requirements, don't show a viable route toward lasting enhancement, post AUVs under 600,000, and mostly produce negative EBITDA. Initial outcomes have been positive, with robust sales moving over to nearby locations. Alongside the demonstrated achievements of our overseas overhaul—where prioritizing key markets alongside deliberate closures boost franchisee wellbeing and market results—these outcomes give us assurance that our portfolio optimization approach will reinforce franchisee fiscal health, sharpen our competitive edge, and underpin forthcoming market share gains across North America. All told, we anticipate delivering no less than 200 basis points of full wall EBITDA enhancement for company and franchise restaurants alike across the medium term, factoring in the supply chain savings, restaurant portfolio optimization efforts, and operational efficiency programs already covered. Now shifting to our capital allocation priorities. Our board alongside management adopt a disciplined stance on capital allocation, putting investment in the business first, preserving a robust balance sheet, and giving capital back to shareholders via share repurchases and dividends. Steering by this framework and our dedication to directing capital toward the highest return opportunities, our board plans to pause our quarterly dividend starting in August. This move will boost flexibility to make the investments we see as necessary to fulfill our strategic transformation and produce the greatest value for shareholders. A key investment area is our franchisee base. We're broadening financial incentives linked to operational excellence and restaurant image upgrades, while simultaneously revising our national marketing fund agreement to achieve a better balance between national and local investment. Setting up local co-ops across the vast majority of our markets. Taken together, these moves will speed up our transformation, lift the customer experience, and yield solid returns for franchisees and franchisors alike. Additional investment areas encompass fueling new customer acquisition via a sharper aggregator strategy, enlarging our total addressable market, product innovation, and core menu enhancement, pushing forward our technology roadmap, such as our AI capabilities, new CRM platform, and next generation POS system to deepen customer engagement, deliver personalization at scale, and drive incremental purchases, further refining our supply chain to enhance cost leverage and drive higher wall EBITDA, and putting money into our international business to build on our momentum and support long-term growth. We've clearly set success criteria, are rigorously monitoring returns, and are already witnessing encouraging early indicators of progress. As we capture the benefits of our transformation over time, we plan to revisit how best to return capital to shareholders through share buybacks and dividends. To sum up, we're executing with discipline, investing for the long term, and positioning the business for improved comparable sales trends in 2027. In the end, our aim is to reengage customers with what is new, better, and distinct about Papa John's. Thanks to the six simple ingredients we use, we enjoy a real quality edge, and we can turn out pizzas that come across much like what you'd get from a neighborhood pizza place — priced within reach and far more convenient. That bolsters how sure we are about the brand's strength and about our capacity to fight for share and win it as time goes on. Our transformation is stretching out beyond what we expected, yet we're putting in place the operational and financial groundwork for growth that lasts. As I described today, the way we get there is by battling on value through offers that are more focused and tailored plus a steady, improved experience for customers, through well-chosen spending on winning customers and lifting the brand, and through careful portfolio trimming and supply chain upgrades that make unit economics stronger. This approach mirrors the transformation playbook already shown to work abroad, and we're sure it will let us fight harder and come out on top across North America. Now I'd like to bring Chris Collins onto the call. Chris has taken on the interim Chief Financial Officer position and carries deep financial expertise regarding Papa John's. The board and I are grateful that Chris is filling this extra role as we run a thorough search to find Papa John's next CFO. Chris, the floor is yours.

Chris Collins

executive
#5

Thanks, Todd. Morning, everybody. I'm glad to be on today's call in the role of Papa John's interim Chief Financial Officer, and I'm looking forward to collaborating with you and the rest of our team as we push our transformation forward. First, I'll walk through our second quarter results in more depth. After that, I'll go over our revised 2026 outlook. Just a note that unless I say otherwise, every comparison and growth rate I mention today is measured against the same period a year ago. In the second quarter, global system-wide restaurant sales came to $1.2 billion, a decline of 5% in constant currency, since stronger international comparable sales were outweighed by weaker comparable sales in North America plus strategic closures aimed at making our system stronger. As Todd mentioned, our international business keeps outperforming, with comparable sales up 1.5%, even with pressure in the markets hit directly by the Middle East conflict. Total consolidated revenue in the second quarter was $482 million, down 9%, as declines in revenue from our domestic company-owned restaurants, North America commissaries, North America Franchising, and all other business units were partly offset by growth in international revenues. Domestic company-owned restaurant revenues fell $37 million, mainly because of the refranchising of 85 corporate restaurants in the fourth quarter of 2025, along with weaker comparable sales. Revenues for our North America commissaries segment dropped $12 million, mainly on lower volumes, partly offset by higher pricing. Revenues for our North America Franchising segment fell $3 million, mainly because of weaker comparable sales at our franchise restaurants. Revenues for all other business units declined $8 million, driven by lower advertising fund revenue and digital fees resulting from lower system sales. Partly offsetting those declines was a $1 million rise in international revenue. Consolidated adjusted EBITDA was $53 million, up slightly even with top-line pressure, mainly because of lower overall G&A spend thanks to strong cost management and reduced supplemental advertising spend, lower cost of sales from lower volumes in last year's refranchising transaction, and better performance in our international markets. Those gains were partly offset by lower sales flow-through and softer QCC volumes in North America; we captured roughly $7 million in system-wide supply chain benefits in the second quarter by increasing efficiency and reducing cost to serve at our North America commissaries. Through Q2, we've captured roughly $16 million in supply chain savings, which works out to 43 basis points of restaurant margin benefit. North America commissaries segment adjusted EBITDA margins came in at 8.7%, an improvement of about 140 basis points, mainly reflecting supply chain cost savings benefits and higher pricing, partly offset by lower volumes during the quarter. Domestic company-owned restaurants posted EBITDA of $15.6 million and margins of 11.2%, a decline of 130 basis points, mainly driven by lower transactions and higher food cost, partly offset by the benefits of our transformation initiatives, including restaurant, labor productivity, and re-franchising activity. Now let's turn to our balance sheet. When the quarter closed, we had roughly $500 million in total liquidity available, and our leverage ratio on covenants stood at 3.3 x, reflecting the very strong balance sheet we keep, which gives us room to back our transformation efforts. Moving on to cash flows: net cash from operating activities for the second quarter came to $36 million. Through the first half, free cash flow was $9 million versus $37 million a year earlier, largely driven by lower net income, the timing of marketing spend inside our advertising fund, more normalized incentive payments, and investments tied to the company's enterprise transformation plan, partly offset by lower first-half cash taxes stemming from new tax legislation enacted in July last year. Shifting to our 2026 outlook: as we discussed, we are updating that outlook to reflect year-to-date results in a difficult environment, one we anticipate will persist through the remainder of the year. For 2026, global system-wide sales are now projected to decline somewhere between 2% and 4%. In North America, comparable sales are expected to fall 6%-8%. July North America comparable sales tracked with Q2 on a year-over-year basis but slowed on a three-year stack. We anticipate North America comp sales improving sequentially in the back half of the year, aided by our marketing co-op activations, a stronger aggregator marketing strategy, our new CRM program, and prior year comparisons. Taking into account geopolitical and consumer conditions, international comparable sales are now expected to rise between 1% and 3%. We signed an asset purchase agreement to re-franchise 28 company restaurants located in Orlando, Florida, and anticipate completing that deal in the third quarter. Because the closing timeline has shifted to the end of the third quarter, we now anticipate the transaction lowering 2026 consolidated revenues by about $4 million, including the effect of eliminations, and benefit-adjusted EBITDA by about $500,000, all of which is baked into our 2026 financial guidance. As we move toward an asset-light model, we remain on track to bring company restaurant ownership down to a mid-single-digit percentage of our North America system. We are actively reviewing several additional North America markets for re-franchising while also weighing opportunities internationally; we expect these moves to support incremental growth opportunities and strengthen our franchise network by transitioning select restaurants to high-performing franchise partners, and we look forward to sharing updates as these transactions progress. For 2026, consolidated adjusted EBITDA is now expected to land between $180 million and $190 million. We now intend to invest roughly $35 million in total supplemental marketing and franchisee subsidies, including the incremental $18 million added for the back half of this year to accelerate our transformation, as Todd described. We expect that elevated investment to carry into 2027. Our 2026 consolidated adjusted EBITDA outlook reflects continued disciplined cost management and includes $13 million of G&A savings, excluding marketing. Looking ahead, we have line of sight to generate at least $30 million of cumulative cost savings by the end of 2027. Additionally, we anticipate that stock-based compensation will come to roughly $5 million each quarter. In line with what we previously told you regarding non-operating expense items, our expectation is net interest in the $35 million to $40 million span, adjusted D&A in the $70 million to $75 million span, and capital expenditures in the $70 million to $80 million span. Our 2026 GAAP effective tax rate should land somewhere in the 30%-34% range. Last, we anticipate diluted shares outstanding of about 33 million. Shifting to restaurant development, we remain on track to open 40 to 50 gross new restaurants across North America during 2026, with 17 restaurants opened through the second quarter. Our 2026 North America restaurant closures are now expected to fall between 200 and 250, since portfolio optimization work alongside our franchisees is moving ahead faster than anticipated; when it comes to our international business, we continue to expect 180 to 220 gross restaurant openings in 2026, and we anticipate closures in the 5%-6% range of our international system. We are likewise looking into new formats and distribution channels, including non-traditional locations, as a way to grow our footprint and bring new customers to the Papa John's brand. While we invest in speeding up our transformation, our commitment stands to keep our balance sheet strong and to position the business for more robust cash flow generation. Refranchising is how we are building a more asset-light model. With disciplined cost reduction and operating model optimization, we will create a more efficient, profitable system. On the whole, our attention remains on carrying out our transformation strategy to improve the customer experience, drive sales growth, enhance profitability, and deliver value for our stakeholders; having said that, we would like to begin the question-and-answer portion of the call. Operator?

Andrew Strelzik

analyst
#6

Hi there, good morning, and thanks for taking my question. Clearly there's a lot happening, and many strategies that you're putting into place and working through. I suppose, stepping back, from your perspective, where have the turnaround strategies broadly delivered the impact you wanted, or had the greatest effect, in the way you intended? And where would you say you're falling furthest behind your expectations as you try to close the gap, recognizing, of course, that this is a tough operating environment.

Todd Penegor

executive
#7

Yes. Appreciate that, Andrew. Regarding the transformation, I'd point to some of the efforts we've made across the past couple of years to truly rebuild our technology platform, reduce friction in how customers order via our app and our website, plus the AI work we've done to tap the data and forge a stronger connection with the consumer through our CRM program. Each of those represents a solid foundational piece that we've kept developing; we rebuilt our innovation pipeline. We put some news in front of customers. We aren't attracting as many new consumers through innovation as we'd anticipated. Still, I feel good that we've performed well on those fronts, and we've lifted the bar when it comes to operational excellence, even though we recognize there are inconsistencies and chances to keep improving there. The area where we've likely struggled most is that we haven't managed to get the local co-ops fully reestablished throughout the whole system. We're gaining ground there, but we've now brought in our field marketing team to give those co-ops better support and ensure we have a genuinely balanced, thoughtful strategy for what national messaging accomplishes, along with local messaging, so we can truly compete and win and have a powerful barbell at both the national and local levels. What matters most is that we get aligned on finding the proper balance between generating transactions and safeguarding margin. We understand we must meet the consumer where they are. We can't simply rely on the quality and the messaging around better ingredients and better pizza. We'll keep doing that with our fan favorites at affordable price points and keep delivering through the remainder of this year. We recognize we'll need to pulse in suitable discounting to keep driving frequency and hold our current customers' engagement, while we attempt to bring in some new customers along the way. We'll be smart with the discounting. We'll pulse it the right way, and we'll use the tools available to us, particularly CRM, together with some of the optimized AI engine work we've completed, to genuinely target those investments.

Andrew Strelzik

analyst
#8

All right, that helps. I'd like to follow up on the franchisee incentives you mentioned earlier today. Could you give us a clearer picture of how those factor into the outlook and what effect they'll have on the P&L? Some additional detail there would be useful. Thank you.

Todd Penegor

executive
#9

Sure. Under the guidance range of $180 million — $190 million, as we noted during the prepared remarks, the total investment coming out of our P&L during 2026 comes to roughly $35 million. Around $10 million of that has been set aside to back the formation of local co-ops, where we've put money in alongside franchisees who've set up those co-ops and are putting capital to work at the local level. Then there's roughly $13 million for supplemental marketing, which we've put in place so we have the proper pressure behind telling our story across both the premium and the value ends of the barbell. Another approximately $5 million goes to operational incentives, letting franchisees keep earning rewards tied to strong overall customer satisfaction scores, strong restaurant inspection scores, and Good out-the-door times. That's a solid motivator for continuing to raise the bar. Finally, about $7 million falls into what I'd describe as subsidies, where we assist the system in co-investing and in driving some of the promotional activity we've run so far this year and intend to run for the remainder of this year. We'd anticipate that spending level carrying over into 2027, depending on certain discussions we're having with our franchise community to get aligned on how we'll co-invest together in order to compete.

Andrew Strelzik

analyst
#10

Great. Okay. That's really useful. Thank you.

Mike Tamas

analyst
#11

Hi. Thanks. Good morning. Michael Tamas here, filling in for Brian. Todd, you rolled out quite a few new initiatives, and I would have expected you'd be seeing some business improvement by this point. Do you figure there's a category headwind you're up against? Perhaps looking at the second quarter specifically, what do you think category sales trends looked like during the quarter compared with the negative 8% that you saw? Thank you.

Todd Penegor

executive
#12

No, that's a great question. I really do believe that all of QSR has engaged in a lot of aggressive discounting. Pizza QSR has been aggressive to an even greater degree, and we probably didn't reach the consumer as much as we ought to have during the second quarter, since we protected margin a bit more. The way we see it, we'd say the QSR pizza category declined slightly in the quarter. The pizza category is very broad. A lot of other players are now competing in pizza when you consider convenience stores, gas stations, and so on. There's still an appetite for pizza more broadly; we really need to think about how we compete, where we show up, and how we give access to the brand. All of those are things we're tackling through accelerating the transformation efforts tied to the investment we talked about today.

Mike Tamas

analyst
#13

Thanks.

Tyler Prause

analyst
#14

Hello, Tyler Prause here. I'm calling in for Jim. Thank you for fielding our question. We're grateful for all the detail on the internal initiatives, and as we look ahead to 2027, assuming nothing significant shifts in the operating environment, is it more probable than not that comps will once again be negative for the full year?

Todd Penegor

executive
#15

Yes. It's a bit soon to offer guidance. With the investments we're putting in, we would clearly anticipate sequential improvement in our same-restaurant sales comps as we move into 2027. We recognize that we're at a point where we'll need to keep co-investing alongside our franchise community to lift the standard on operational excellence, engage the consumer wherever they are, and keep communicating why we're better, unique, and different from the competitive set. We'll be methodical about where we put our money; we'll be very smart in ensuring we achieve a solid return, with part of it offensive and part defensive. Our real aim is to use that co-investment so the whole system is pulling in one direction. Whatever initiatives and whatever focus we bring into 2027, we carry them out with excellence as a single system going forward. That's the reason we'll keep investing together. We truly want to position this brand for long-term success, rather than merely pursuing short-term sales. Through technology, we're making every foundational move, lifting the standard on operational excellence, and continuing to communicate our story about why we're unique, better, and different via the marketing messaging we've had. Those elements are foundational to building this brand over the long haul.

Tyler Prause

analyst
#16

Excellent. That's really useful. Can you identify any regions that outpaced the overall system?

Todd Penegor

executive
#17

Sure. When you look at how the second quarter wrapped up, the Northeast was likely somewhat weaker compared to other parts of the country. That mainly happened because they had a stronger showing last year. Looking at our results in the Midwest and Southeast, those were likely our strongest regions. The West fell somewhere in the middle. On a two-year basis, nothing stood out as significantly larger than the rest.

Tyler Prause

analyst
#18

Great; that's all from us. Thank you.

Todd Penegor

executive
#19

Thanks.

Todd Brooks

analyst
#20

Thank you, and good morning to everybody. Near the close of the year, I believe we received an incomplete figure from your team regarding profitability at the franchisee unit level. There was, I believe, a data point indicating that the top 75% of franchisees were earning roughly $125,000 for each unit. Do you have a final figure covering the entire system? And are certain moves we're observing you make — on incentives, or on marketing spending beyond what franchisees put in — somewhat indicative that little room remains to boost franchisee profitability across the coming couple of years, as you strive to enhance profitability from the supply chain and generate momentum in the business?

Todd Penegor

executive
#21

Yes, Todd, I'd say our largest opportunity at present is this: we've handled labor in the restaurants quite well; the four walls are wired pretty tight. For every additional transaction we can bring through a restaurant, the variable profit margin runs quite high. The same holds for the supply chain. With each case unit we move through our supply chain. We're able to deliver solid cost efficiencies to the system. Our greatest opportunity at this point is to keep driving transactions. What we're attempting to do is motivate the system to raise the bar on operational excellence. We don't simply want to discount in order to drive transactions; we want the consumer to grasp that the total experience justifies what you pay. An excellent experience with a high-quality pizza that brings customers back repeatedly. What we're attempting to do is ensure we motivate the system to put ourselves in position to compete better, get all the co-ops reestablished so we can have a strong, coordinated national and local message, keep working to ensure the bottom quintile of our restaurants keeps raising the bar on operational excellence, so we don't carry the Achilles heel of inconsistency as a perception across the U.S. For our consumer base. I do believe there's substantial opportunity for our system to keep working together to accelerate profitability from where we stand today; we'll be part of the solution through some co-investment, but the system knows they'll also have to fight at the local level and partner with us nationally to bring that to reality.

Todd Brooks

analyst
#22

All right, that's helpful. For my second question, Todd — product innovation was something that drove results for you, and really it's been more of a strategic shift as you entered this year, rather than simply battling it out on price. You mentioned that sandwiches are nearly making up for the revenue you lost from Papadias and Papa Bites. Since we aren't really seeing that show up in same-store sales, I'd like to know how each of these new items is doing compared with what you planned. Or is it simply that this is a hard climate in which to persuade a shopper who cares so much about deals to branch out and try a new item instead of sticking with the familiar option at a cheaper price? Thanks.

Todd Penegor

executive
#23

My sense is that the consumer is being quite careful when spending money they worked hard to earn. When circumstances push you to want each of your dollars to stretch as far as it can, you return to the familiar standbys — the ones you're confident will come through on the experience and won't let you down. Under those conditions, innovation has a somewhat harder job getting noticed. Consider our pan launch. It blended nicely with the customers we already had, yet it failed to draw the volume of first-time buyers we'd likely have anticipated. Same story with Toy Story. It generated plenty of buzz that kept the brand cool, hip, and part of the conversation. It paired well with the customers we already had, but it didn't attract as many new ones as we'd have liked. Sandwiches, I'd view as more of a longer-horizon chance to grow our TAM, since we genuinely see them as a substitute for Papadias and as a way to remove the Rhythm Breakers from the restaurant. You're correct. Innovation by itself finds it somewhat harder to win over new customers in conditions like these. I believe we can improve at conveying our story through the third-party aggregator channel — showing what's new, distinctive, and different that we offer, which gives fresh access to innovation — and we're tweaking some of our plans going forward to accomplish that. I see that as a chance for us; we'll keep working hard to strike the proper balance between innovation, promoting our familiar standbys on the higher-end portion of the menu at prices people can afford, and being a bit sharper while sending out a bit more value messaging, so that we have a genuinely strong barbell driving awareness. Those innovations are solid; they'll serve a useful purpose on our calendar. Eventually, I do believe they'll attract new customers. It's just that we aren't witnessing that in today's climate.

Todd Brooks

analyst
#24

All right. Thanks, Todd.

Jim Sanderson

analyst
#25

Hey, I appreciate the question. Let's revisit Q2 — can you split out same-store sales or the sales patterns for carryout against first-party and third-party delivery?

Todd Penegor

executive
#26

Yeah. When you look at our second quarter, North America came in down 8.3%; that decline was nearly all from transactions, since check was flat. Across carryout, first-party, and third-party, our carryout operation declined but held up reasonably well. I'd put that at down mid-single-digit. Our third-party aggregator operation was down low-single-digit, and our first-party delivery operation was down double digits. There's a chance for us to keep working at optimizing the mix across every one of our delivery channels and the carryout channel. More recently, you can see we've rebalanced our calendar a bit further with Epic Stuffed Pepperoni at an attractive $14.99 price point, alongside a 50% carryout offer delivering strong value to our consumers; we've already made those adjustments to rebuild our barbell a little stronger so we compete better through the back half of the year.

Jim Sanderson

analyst
#27

Following up on that point. When you push further into third-party delivery as a way to sell, what's your plan for bringing in new customers through that route, using the marketing money you intend to commit?

Todd Penegor

executive
#28

As you're aware, we moved early in 3P. Five or six years back, we were able to benefit from that trend. These days, the space has far more players in it. What I believe we truly need to accomplish is to ensure that when we deploy the funds — and I think we are deploying a sufficient amount in that channel — we have a chance to get more out of those funds by way of the promotions we've got running, so they land better. Those tweaks will come in the back half of the year. It's clear to us that we'll need to battle within the 3P channel, both on a national level and in a way that's tightly aligned locally — which is exactly why establishing the co-ops matters so much. There are a few smaller moves available to us regarding how our brand appears, in terms of visibility within 3P, yet we have solid insight into what must be done to monitor and tweak so we can compete with even more strength in that channel. In our view, it's an excellent channel for generating some visibility and a chance to showcase our innovation and get the consumer to give us a try.

Jim Sanderson

analyst
#29

All right, I'll wrap up with one final item here. When it comes to the overhaul of advertising for both the national and local co-ops, in what fundamental way does that alter what franchisees contribute, and what kind of budget are you able to build as gross sales grow over time?

Todd Penegor

executive
#30

Sure. As things stand right now, we're structured with a 6% contribution at the national level. Anything at the local level is completely voluntary. When we consider what the system is currently doing — both through the co-ops that have been brought back and through operators simply investing locally — the figure we're likely at is somewhere between 1.5% and 2%. All told, somewhere around 7.5% to 8%, nearly 8%, is what's going into the marketplace. What we're certain of is that a rebalancing is probably necessary. It's likely we could dial back slightly on what's contributed nationally while making sure a set amount is required at the local level. Even more critical is having that required amount in place so we can establish the co-ops, guaranteeing we have a seat at the table and that we're partnering with franchisees in the communities where they do battle, delivering one consistent message locally that works alongside what we say nationally — coordination like that simply hasn't existed. Progress is being made. Getting the entire system on board is what we need. Securing a vote will require collaborating with the wider system so the proper national and local levels can be put in place, since the previous such vote happened back in 2023. Those conversations with the franchise community are happening right now.

Jim Sanderson

analyst
#31

Okay, thanks.

Analyst

analyst
#32

Hello, and good morning. I appreciate you taking my question. Grace here, filling in for Sara. You pointed to a weaker consumer backdrop as the cause of the soft U.S. comps, yet a number of other restaurant chains posted better numbers this quarter. What, in your view, accounts for that gap? Is it about who the customer is, given that Papa John's has a lower-income skew than other QSRs? Is it rivalry in the pizza segment, including independents listed on the aggregators, or perhaps pressure from non-pizza players, such as other QSRs and convenience stores as well? I have one more question after this. Thanks.

Todd Penegor

executive
#33

My take is that the pizza segment has changed, and not only regarding who is competing on the third party aggregator side — it's no longer just pizza we're up against, it's all of QSR. Good-quality pizza can now be found in all sorts of places. Think about the major C store chains and the gas station down the street; pizza is on their menus too. Going forward, we need to be set up to battle on both price and quality in a wider landscape. Looking at the QSR pizza segment, as I mentioned before, it would be down a bit. What's taken place in our segment is that price competition has gotten intense; our two biggest rivals ran deep discounting for most of at least half the quarter in one case, and for the entire quarter in the other case. We failed to respond as forcefully as we ought to have; our own deep discounting lasted just one week during the quarter. Papa Pairings was running the whole time. We had sharp price points on our everyday favorites on the premium side of the menu. We've got to rebalance the barbell so we can compete more effectively in the competitive consumer landscape we face today.

Analyst

analyst
#34

All right. Thanks. I appreciate that. In the 10-Q, you also brought up the chance of additional strategic closures, and you just noted that the Northeast is somewhat weaker. Which particular regions are not performing well? Earlier store shutdowns apparently haven't helped same-store sales across the rest of the system. Where did those sales go? Thanks.

Todd Penegor

executive
#35

Yes; it's still fairly early. When you consider our position on closures, roughly 100 have been shut so far, and those have only recently been occurring, so the complete effect on recapture isn't visible yet. At a lot of those locations, recapture is looking solid. Over the remainder of this year, we've already signaled that through the efforts we're making alongside the franchise community, out of the 300 closures we anticipated for 2026 and 2027, roughly 200 to 250 might now take place during this calendar year. That truly represents robust portfolio optimization, and we're confident we can achieve decent recapture at many of those shuttered locations to reinforce not just the restaurant economic model and the current restaurants but also strengthen the balance sheet for our franchise community. We believe we're moving some of those closures forward into this year. I'd say we're still roughly on track for 300 across this year and the next; we feel fairly good about it, particularly given some of the co-investment incentives and the investment we'll be deploying into the system to help it compete more effectively going forward.

Analyst

analyst
#36

Alright. Many thanks. I truly appreciate it.

Todd Penegor

executive
#37

Looks like that wrapped up the final inquiry. Let me just add, hi, I'd like to thank each of you for joining us on this call. I realize we shared quite a bit during the earnings call to keep pushing our transformation ahead and speed it up going forward. I'm genuinely grateful to our teams and all they do each and every day to help back and champion this brand, driving our success over the long term, along with the partnership we have with the franchise community to invest side by side, so the brand keeps advancing. Thanks for listening in. We have tremendous confidence that the steps we're taking are the right ones to reach our objectives and deliver sustainable growth as well as value creation for every one of our stakeholders; we're eager to keep you informed about how we're progressing. Everyone, have a wonderful day.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Papa John's International, Inc. transcript — plus 131,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Papa John's International, Inc. earnings transcripts and 131,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Papa John's International, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.