Synchrony Financial (SYF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 24, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Greg Ketron
executiveOperator, thank you. Good morning, all, and welcome to our quarterly Earnings Conference Call. We appreciate you being here. Along with today's press release, we've made available a presentation that addresses the subjects we intend to cover on this call. The press release, comprehensive financial schedules, and the presentation can be found on our site, synchronyfinancial.com; you can reach this material by navigating to the Investor Relations portion of the site. Prior to beginning, I'd like to note that our remarks today will contain forward-looking statements. Such statements carry risks and uncertainty, and actual results may differ materially. The factors that could lead to actual results differing materially are listed in our SEC filings, which can be accessed on our website. On this call, we'll reference non-GAAP financial measures when discussing the company's performance. A reconciliation of those measures to GAAP financial measures is included in our materials for today's call. Lastly, Synchrony Financial bears no responsibility for, does not edit, and cannot guarantee the accuracy of our earnings teleconference transcripts supplied by third parties. The sole authorized webcast can be found on our website. At this point, I'm happy to hand the call over to Margaret.
Margaret Keane
executiveThank you, Greg. Hello, everybody, and I appreciate you being with us this morning. For Synchrony, 2019 represented yet one more year of meaningful change. Through every one of our sales platforms, we extended over 50 partnerships that were already in place, and in addition we closed 30 fresh business agreements. Our CareCredit card network grew, along with our auto and home networks. We made considerable improvements to the digital experience offered to cardholders and achieved substantial expansion of our direct-to-consumer deposit platform. Over the 5 years since we became a public company, we've invested heavily in our people and in technology, and that has driven the company ahead and made it possible to develop innovative offerings for our partners while upgrading our capabilities and the experiences our cardholders have with us. For the fourth quarter, earnings came to $731 million, or $1.15 per diluted share, and that figure reflected the leftover reserve decrease tied to the October sale of the Walmart consumer portfolio. That decrease came to $38 million, or $28 million aftertax, and gave the quarter an EPS boost of $0.05, as laid out on Slide 3 of the presentation. Loan receivables declined 6%. But looking at a core basis, which leaves out Walmart plus the Yamaha portfolio that we shifted into loans held for sale during the fourth quarter, loan receivables climbed 5%. On that core basis, the rise in loan receivables produced 5% growth in interest and fees. Purchase volume rose 7%, and average active accounts were up 3%. The efficiency ratio stood at 34.8%, and that includes a $21 million restructuring charge tied to employee costs, which affected the efficiency ratio by 60 basis points this quarter, as we keep pushing for cost efficiency across the company. Deposits grew $1.1 billion, or 2%, compared with last year, and a large share of that growth arrived via direct deposits, which were up 10%. Our direct deposit platform continues to serve as a key funding source for our growth, and we keep putting money into our bank to help bring in new deposits and keep the customers we already have. Organic growth still offers us our biggest opportunity, and we've shown we can do more than just expand the programs we already have — we can also start new programs alongside fast-growing partners in new markets. Within our Retail Card sales platform, we revealed a new partnership with Verizon, under which we'll serve as the exclusive issuer of Verizon's co-branded consumer credit card. Together we're bringing out the first credit card built specifically for Verizon's customers. We're delighted to be working with Verizon, since they keep delivering innovation to their customers, and this represents a terrific growth opportunity for us as we keep diversifying our portfolio. The new Verizon credit card should launch sometime in the first half of this year. We formed fresh payment solution alliances with Mor Furniture for Less, Grand Home Furnishings, Travis Industries and Leisure Pro; we also extended important ties with Rooms To Go, BuyMax Alliance, CFMOTO and Continental Tires; our attention stays on expanding our network so our cards gain wider acceptance and usefulness, and we've achieved plenty of recent wins in that area within our CareCredit network. In Q4, CareCredit forged a fresh tie with Kaiser Permanente. Our efforts have centered on bringing health systems into our CareCredit network, and thanks to adding Kaiser Permanente, we currently have 5 health systems signed up. Over the quarter, we additionally extended a crucial CareCredit tie with Demant, a worldwide market frontrunner in hearing health; our focus remains strong on digital innovation, speeding up our data analytics skills and building seamless customer experiences, which prove essential for our programs' success and for securing fresh partnerships. Boosting digital sales penetration is essential for our success. Within Retail Card, digital sales penetration hit 39% during the fourth quarter. We're glad to share that we've achieved a fresh peak in digital applications, which made up 52% of all our applications in Q4. The mobile channel by itself expanded more than 40% versus the same quarter a year ago, leaving out Walmart. Our approach to allocating capital fuels robust growth at appealing risk-adjusted returns, all while keeping a solid balance sheet and the capacity to give capital back to shareholders. Over the quarter, we bought back $1.4 billion of Synchrony Financial common stock and distributed $141 million in dividends. We wrapped up 2019 having achieved major strides in our capabilities and secured crucial partnerships set to create long-term value for the company; we possess a distinct vision for our future and what must be done to arrive there. Further into the call, Brian Doubles will lay out our strategic priorities as we head into 2020. I'll pause briefly to spotlight our platform results on Slide 4. Within Retail Card, loans fell 12%, yet rose 4% on a core basis, with steady growth fueled by our digital partners. Other metrics declined because of the Walmart portfolio sale. We're thrilled about our fresh partnership with Verizon, alongside the other partnerships unveiled in 2019, and can't wait to roll out these new programs this year. Payment Solutions turned in a robust quarter with wide-ranging growth throughout the sales platform, and notable strength in home furnishings and home specialty, producing loan receivables growth of 4% or 7% on a core basis. Interest and fees on loans climbed 4%, largely pushed by the loan receivables growth. Purchase volume rose 6%, and average active accounts went up 3%. We inked several new programs and renewed crucial partnerships this quarter. We kept fueling growth organically via our partnerships and card networks. Those networks, plus efforts like pushing for greater card reuse—now around 31% of purchase volume once you strip out oil and gas—have contributed to producing strong results and have put the Payment Solutions platform in a good spot for growth ahead. CareCredit turned in yet another robust quarter. An 8% rise in receivables was spearheaded by our dental and veterinary specialties. Interest and fees on loans climbed 9%, largely due to the growth in loan receivables. Purchase volume rose 12%, while average active accounts were up 5%. We kept broadening our network and enhancing what our card can do, most recently via the Kaiser Permanente partnership, which assisted in pushing the reuse rate to 54% of purchase volume during the fourth quarter. All year long, we generated robust growth throughout our sales platforms. We extended and expanded relationships, inked exciting new partnerships, rolled out new programs, boosted the usefulness of our cards and networks, and grew our Payment Solutions platform past $20 billion and our CareCredit network beyond $10 billion in receivables. What we've done and achieved lays a solid foundation going forward. Having said that, I'll hand the call to Brian Wenzel, who will go over our financial performance for the quarter and the year as well as our outlook for 2020.
Brian Wenzel
executiveThanks, Margaret, and hello everyone. I'll start on Slide 5. Earlier today we announced Q4 earnings of $731 million, which works out to $1.15 per diluted share. That figure reflects the last piece of the reserve decrease tied to the October sale of the Walmart consumer portfolio. As Margaret mentioned, that decrease came to $38 million, or $28 million after taxes, and it added $0.05 of EPS in the quarter. We saw strong growth compared to last year in a number of areas, which Slide 6 lays out. If you set aside Walmart and the Yamaha portfolio — which we shifted into loans held for sale during Q4 — core loan receivables climbed 5%. We also saw a 5% core year-over-year rise in interest and fees tied to loan receivables, which came from receivables growth. Purchase volume on a core basis grew 7%, while average active accounts were up 3% versus a year ago. On the whole, we feel good about the growth we achieved beneath the surface throughout the business, and about the risk-adjusted returns that growth produced. RSAs rose $174 million, or 20%, compared with last year. The gain was mainly the result of stronger program performance and growth. It also reflected the RSA effect of the $17 million reserve release tied to reclassifying loan receivables as held for sale for Yamaha. For the quarter, RSAs equaled 4.8% of average receivables. The sale of the Walmart portfolio played a role in the RSA percent, since that portfolio ran below the company average for RSA percent, and it combined with the other things pushing RSAs higher. Compared with a year earlier, the provision for loan losses fell by $348 million, or 24%. That decline came primarily from a smaller core reserve build along with fewer net charge-offs. During the fourth quarter, the core reserve build totaled $50 million. Other income rose $40 million versus the prior year, largely because loyalty costs came down following the Walmart program conversion. Other expenses came in roughly level with last year, though they did include a $21 million restructuring charge within employee costs. All in all, we kept up a strong performance during Q4. Turning to Slide 7, I'll walk through how net interest income and margin moved. Net interest income came in 7% lower than a year ago, largely because interest and fees on loan receivables fell 6% owing to the Walmart portfolio sale; excluding that, interest and fees on loan receivables rose 5% on a core basis. Net interest margin landed at 15.01%, versus 16.06% in the prior year. Several factors influenced where margin ended up. First, loan receivables as a share of total earning assets fell, going from 83.5% down to 80.2%, which came from keeping roughly $3 billion of extra liquidity on hand after the Walmart portfolio sales generated proceeds. Second, loan receivables yield dropped 33 basis points to 20.87%, mostly because of that Walmart portfolio sale. Third, the cost of total interest-bearing liabilities rose 10 basis points to 2.58%, largely reflecting higher benchmark rates. I'll share more detail later in this call about where net interest margin is headed for 2020, including how the Walmart portfolio sale factors in. Now let's turn to key credit trends, which are on Slide 8. Regarding what happened specifically this quarter, I'll begin with delinquency trends. Looking at our delinquency metrics, the 30-plus rate was 4.44%, down from 4.76% in the prior-year period. The 90-plus rate stood at 2.15%, compared with 2.29% a year ago. If you exclude the effects from both the Walmart portfolio and the PayPal Credit program, neither the 30-plus nor the 90-plus delinquency rate moved relative to last year, indicating that credit trends are holding steady. Now on to net charge-offs. We posted a net charge-off rate of 5.15%, which compares to 5.54% a year ago. The improvement in that net charge-off rate was driven primarily by Walmart along with better credit trends. Acting as a partial offset was the 2018 purchase accounting impact associated with the PayPal Credit program. When you exclude the impacts from both the PayPal Credit program and the Walmart portfolio, our net charge-off rate came in roughly 15 basis points lower than it was a year ago. As for the allowance for loan losses, it represented 6.42% of loan receivables. We built up $50 million in core reserves during the fourth quarter. That figure leaves out the final reduction in reserves associated with the Walmart portfolio, which came to $38 million, and also excludes a $17 million release tied to the Yamaha portfolio, which was moved into held for sale during the fourth quarter. That Yamaha release had zero impact on net earnings, because of the RSA offset I brought up earlier. Bottom line: core credit trends have leveled off and are slightly stronger than what we had anticipated. Assuming economic conditions stay stable, we look for core trends to remain steady going forward. We still see solid opportunities to grow at appealing risk-adjusted returns. Later on, I'll give an outlook for credit expectations this year, including what adopting CECL will mean. Shifting to Slide 9, I'll go over our expenses for the quarter. Total expenses were $1.1 billion, essentially unchanged from a year ago. That figure includes a $21 million restructuring charge, which sits in employee cost for the fourth quarter. Although growth pushed expenses higher, Walmart cost reductions offset that. We hit our Walmart cost reduction target, and those reductions will be baked into the 2020 expense run rate. In the fourth quarter, our efficiency ratio rose to 34.8%. Several factors mainly drove that rise: Walmart ran at an efficiency ratio below the company average; RSAS came in higher, which takes in the effect of the Yamaha portfolio; and the restructuring charge was also part of it. Let's turn to Slide 10. Deposits have grown by $1.1 billion, or 2%, over the past year. That means deposits now represent 77% of our funding, versus 73% a year ago. We deliberately eased the pace of overall deposit growth during the second half of 2019, expecting the proceeds from the Walmart sale, yet lower-cost direct deposits kept expanding at a robust 10% rate in the fourth quarter. Now on capital and liquidity. We closed the quarter at 14.1% CET1 under the fully phased-in Basel III rules, a modest gain versus last year. In November, we finished our inaugural preferred stock issuance, which totaled $750 million at a fixed rate of 5.625%. Demand for that issuance was strong and it was heavily oversubscribed. Throughout the quarter, we kept carrying out the capital plan we announced in May. We distributed a common stock dividend of $0.22 per share and bought back $1.4 billion, or 38.4 million shares, of common stock in the fourth quarter. As the fourth quarter ended, roughly $1.3 billion of share repurchase capacity remained under the $4 billion plan our board authorized, which expires June 30, 2020. Total liquidity, counting undrawn credit facilities, stood at $23.4 billion, equal to 22.3% of our total assets. That's higher than 18% a year ago, and it reflects the roughly $3 billion in excess liquidity we hold from the proceeds of the Walmart portfolio sale.
Brian Wenzel
executiveBroadly speaking, we're still carrying out the plan we laid out before. Keeping a very solid balance sheet is a priority for us, with funding drawn from a range of sources alongside robust capital and liquidity positions. Through growth and continued execution of our capital plan—dividends and share buybacks—we anticipate deploying more capital. Moving on, Slide 11 covers how 2019 turned out versus the guidance we gave last January. Beginning with loan receivables, core growth of 5% matched our 5% to 7% guidance range. Solid results were driven mainly by organic growth. Our cards' compelling value propositions, successful marketing approaches, and ongoing spending on technology, digital assets, and data analytics capabilities are strengthening our capacity to generate organic growth and land new programs. Within our Payment Solutions and CareCredit sales platforms, we keep seeing robust growth of 7% to 8%. For the year, net interest margin reached 15.78%, within the 15.75% to 16% range we had anticipated. The Walmart portfolio sale did create a margin effect during the fourth quarter, and that effect will carry into 2020, something I'll address in our 2020 outlook. RSAs as a share of average receivables landed above the guidance we gave last January. For the year, RSAs stood at 4.4%, versus guidance of 4.0% to 4.2%. Better program and credit performance during 2019 mainly drove that higher RSA percentage, and it also reflected the RSA effect from releasing reserves tied to Yamaha. At 5.6%, our net charge-off rate came in under our 5.7% to 5.9% guidance range for the year. Credit trends improved modestly in 2019, a touch better than we had anticipated. The Walmart portfolio sale likewise helped the net charge-off rate in the fourth quarter, and that benefit will persist into 2020. The efficiency ratio reached 31.9% for the year, a bit above what we expected. This stemmed largely from higher RSAs tied to better program and credit performance during 2019, and it also reflected the restructuring charge recognized in the fourth quarter. Lastly, setting aside the effect of the Walmart reserve reductions, our return on assets came to 2.7% against expectations of roughly 2.5%; Slide 12 recaps the projected effect of adopting CECL. CECL took effect on January 1. As a result, there was no effect on 2019. The initial adjustment goes to retained earnings and has no effect on net earnings or EPS. On January 1, adopting CECL initially raised the allowance for loan losses by roughly $3 billion, or 54% of the year-end balance, matching what we expected. When it comes to the after-tax effect, the hit to retained earnings comes to roughly $2.3 billion, and we also establish a deferred tax asset of about $700 million. From a regulatory standpoint, we chose to phase in that roughly $2.3 billion capital impact at 25% each year, covering 2020 through 2023. Measured on a CET1 transition basis, that translates into a hit to the ratio of about 60 basis points annually across the phase-in window. We keep wanting to stress our position that CECL represents a change in accounting rather than in economics. The cash flows the company produces, the way we think about an account's lifetime value, and the IRR on marketing investments are all untouched by CECL. We're giving the 2020 outlook, and it incorporates the expected CECL effect. We've also called out those particular measures where we anticipate CECL will show up, so you can compare how our expectations line up against 2019. Starting in the first quarter, we plan to offer similar visibility to aid comparison with the prior year, when the historical loss method was in use. Now turning to our 2020 outlook on Slide 13. Our macro assumptions for 2020 include key benchmark and unemployment rates that stay stable across the year. For receivables growth, our outlook falls in the 5% to 7% range. As Margaret mentioned, we have new programs, including Venmo and Verizon, that will roll out over the course of the year. Because of that, we expect receivables growth to pick up speed in the year's second half. Purchase volume, we expect, will run at our historical rate of 2 to 3x broader retail sales. And online and mobile should keep up their strong growth; we believe our net interest margin will come in between 15.25% and 15.50% for the year, which is below where margin has historically run, and with the normal seasonality we observe from quarter to quarter. One thing pushing the margin expectation lower is the roughly $3 billion in excess liquidity we'll be holding on our balance sheet from the Walmart sale proceeds. We expect that excess liquidity to be put to work through growth as the year moves along. Even so, it will hit our margin by an estimated 20 basis points in 2020. The second factor is the effect of losing the higher yields that the Walmart portfolio brought in. As for how net interest margin performs over the year, we expect it nearer 15% in the first half, then drifting back toward 15.50% in the second half as we put the excess liquidity to work. RSAs as a percent of average receivables, we expect, will land in the 4.3% to 4.5% range for 2020. The biggest single reason behind the expected rise in the RSA outlook is the sale of the Walmart portfolio, which ran at a lower RSA percent than our overall rate. The outlook sits more in line with our historical run rate and mirrors the continued strong performance of our programs. On the initial CECL adjustment to reserves, there won't be any RSA offset, but CECL's continuing effect is going to be part of the RSA, and that gives us a partial offset against the higher reserves. During the first half of 2020 that offset is muted, and then it gets more fully realized across the second half of the year, consistent with how the RSA and our program agreements are calculated. Turning to credit, our expectation is that the 2020 net charge-off rate lands somewhere between 5.4% and 5.6%, compared with 5.6% in 2019. Selling the Walmart portfolio helps the net charge-off rate. As for loan loss reserve builds, we anticipate that the total reserve build for the year under CECL falls in the $800 million to $900 million range, against $500 million to $600 million had we kept reserving using the same methodology as 2019. That works out to roughly a $300 million increase in reserve provisioning stemming from CECL's implementation. Certain factors could move these ranges, including shifts in economic trends, consumer behavior, portfolio and product mix and the underlying assumptions used in determining the allowance for loan losses; we expect to run the business at an efficiency ratio of approximately 32%, in line with 2019. The technology and people investments needed to launch the new programs we have noted will also have an impact on the efficiency ratio.
Brian Wenzel
executiveWe have to make these upfront investments in order to expand what we can do and construct the infrastructure surrounding the programs before they actually go live. Launching these programs is estimated to have a total impact on 2020 EPS of roughly $0.20 of dilution, and that figure covers investments made ahead of launch, operating costs, and reserves tied to growing these new programs. Although getting these programs started dilutes EPS in 2020, we're enthusiastic about the potential they offer down the road. Dividends on the preferred stock will begin this year, paid quarterly, with the first payment in mid-February. Across the full year, those dividends will come to $42 million, or a $0.07 hit to EPS. Lastly, in line with our history, and setting aside the effect of CECL, we anticipate a return on assets of about 2.5% in 2020, and that figure factors in the dilution from launching the new programs. Within this outlook, I'd like to offer a view on a few key earnings drivers for the first quarter. Because of the factors I mentioned earlier, we expect the net interest margin to stay close to 15% in the first quarter. Seasonally, the net charge-off rate tends to run higher in the first quarter than in the fourth quarter, reflecting the seasonal drop in receivables. That increase has historically fallen in the range of 50 basis points, and we anticipate a similar trend in the first quarter. We expect RSAs as a percent of average receivables to land in the 4.4% to 4.6% range, both with and without the CECL impact. As for reserve builds, we expect $75 million to $100 million with CECL, and $50 million to $75 million if CECL's impact is excluded. For the first quarter, we expect the efficiency ratio to come in at approximately 33%, after which it should trend downward as the year goes on. With that, I'll hand things over to Brian Doubles to walk through the strategies that will help drive future results.
Brian Doubles
executiveThanks, Brian. To wrap up, I’d like to summarize where we’re focused strategically — priorities aimed at creating value over the long term while also diversifying for what’s ahead. As it always has been, one of the biggest priorities is expanding our core partnerships. Any chance to grow will keep being assessed based on the risk-adjusted returns it generates. To deepen those relationships, we’ll aim to keep rolling out new products and capabilities that are innovative and that bring value to cardholders and the programs, while increasing card usage and brand loyalty. We’ll also keep starting up new programs in cases where we think a partnership can offer growth potential at attractive risk-adjusted returns. Beyond that, we're going to diversify by way of focused efforts across Payment Solutions, CareCredit, and the products carrying the Synchrony name. Doing so lets us create a revenue mix that's broader, thanks to faster expansion in smaller programs and newly introduced offerings. Within Payment Solutions, the emphasis is on expanding through better point-of-sale functionality and fresh, inventive products. Over at CareCredit, we'll continue pushing for wider acceptance and further network growth, concentrating on health systems — a good example being the Kaiser Permanente partnership we announced not long ago. That's a space where we believe there's a major opportunity. We'll also carry on putting money into our Synchrony-branded offerings, the auto and home networks, and the Synchrony Mastercard. To wrap up, our latest acquisitions will serve as building blocks for creating and scaling fresh income streams in the e-gifting and pets spaces. Staying centered on technology and data analytics remains essential as we strive to deliver top-tier experiences for our customers; we're confident that putting customers first will become a progressively vital engine of growth. Our efforts will continue toward broadening sophisticated data analytics, capitalizing on performance dynamics at the individual customer level, and strengthening our abilities to create seamless customer interactions. Beyond that, we're directing attention to alternative data and machine learning as means to push innovation further, along with enhanced underwriting and authentication. Making these investments matters greatly for fueling expansion across our current programs, and equally for locking in renewals and capturing new ones such as Venmo and Verizon. Keeping our balance sheet and overall financial standing in a solid place is something we stay focused on. We've shown we can do that, and it's going to stay a leading priority going forward. Our plan is to hold capital and liquidity at healthy levels so we can back our operations, expand the business and meet the expectations of credit rating agencies and regulators. On top of that, we'll keep putting our robust capital base to work fueling growth, rolling out new programs, making investments in products and capabilities, and giving money back to shareholders via dividends and buybacks. We feel our position sets us up well to grow over the long term, and we're eager to deliver results for our partners, cardholders and shareholders throughout 2020 and afterward. I'll hand things off to Greg now so we can move into the question-and-answer segment of this call.
Greg Ketron
executiveThat wraps up what we wanted to say about the quarter. At this point we're going to move into the Q&A portion. <<operator_script>> Operator, please go ahead and open the Q&A.
Ryan Nash
analystI'd like to kick things off by asking about the net interest margin. Since your IPO, when you put all that liquidity to work, it's been sitting around 15.75% to 16%. Now, looking at how things are shifting, you're guiding to 15% in Q1, which implies you'd need 15.5% or better over the remaining three quarters to hit the midpoint of your guidance. I realize forecasting that far ahead is tough with so many variables in play, but once this liquidity drag passes, should we treat 15.50% plus as a more typical margin level? And secondly, are there additional levers, especially around funding, that you could pull to push this back toward that historical range?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYeah, thanks Ryan. So we are moving in the direction of that 15% figure during the first six months, mainly because we're still working our way through the $3 billion in extra liquidity that came in from Walmart once the fourth quarter wrapped up. Naturally, our aim is to structure the funding profile and handle it so that we can put that liquidity to work as quickly as we can, which includes pursuing organic growth, particularly during the opening couple of quarters in 2020. As our guidance indicated, the latter half of the year ought to be heading toward that 15.5%. So if you look at it on a year-over-year basis, there are really two big factors at play, correct? The initial one involves using up this surplus liquidity. Next, there's what the Walmart book of business does to the mix — it runs at better margins than both the overall company and our other books. Naturally, Walmart was absent for a stretch of Q4. Given factors like that, we ought to move back toward that 15.5% later in the year.
Ryan Nash
analystAll right, understood. And perhaps to fit in one question regarding expenses; I believe I heard you mention that every one of the Walmart cost savings had been realized in the run rate. I simply wanted to verify whether that was true? And could you perhaps assist us in grasping the components behind expense growth moving forward. I'm aware Brian Doubles spoke about a few of them. But Margaret, perhaps you might elaborate on which major strategic investments you are currently making? And would you consider this a period of quicker cost growth, and might we possibly return to something reduced past this year?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes; so I'll handle the initial portion and then pass it along to Margaret. So when you consider the cost, once more, our guidance is roughly 32%, which is merely 20 basis points above the full year average of 31.8%. Yes, we did obtain the cost reductions we expected for Walmart out and they will be completely incorporated into the run rate as we proceed. The effect slightly on the efficiency ratio, once more, is Walmart-related due to the high revenue that came off of that portfolio and what it has produced, it operated at a considerably lower efficiency ratio as a portfolio than the company average. So that's the minor uptick that you will observe there.
Margaret Keane
executiveYeah. Ryan, regarding where the money's going, there are a few pieces to it. The first piece is what we're putting into Venmo and Verizon. For both programs, the experience will be entirely digital and inside the app, so we brought on quite a few agile teams whose job is building out a bunch of APIs to serve those partners. The launch is underway. There are additional people we still have to bring aboard, so those 2 programs represent a significant chunk of the strategic push. On a wider level, we keep putting money into a few important places. We touched on CareCredit earlier. We're bringing in more people and upgrading the technology behind it, especially as we move into health systems, which strikes us as a genuinely strong place to invest and one that should pay off well down the road. And speaking generally, on the technology side, we remain on this path of pushing digitization forward and making customer experiences seamless. The other thing we're paying close attention to is what I'd describe as the customer journey. I believe our front end work has been quite strong — that means how someone applies, makes a purchase, and uses mobile features — yet we're now examining ways to squeeze more efficiency from our back office, applying digitization to make that customer experience shine. So there is some investment involved. Still, the largest addition this year, I'd argue, is the money going toward Verizon and Venmo. To our thinking, those are 2 excellent chances for growth ahead. And we believe that spending is genuinely the correct investment for this company to make.
Ryan Nash
analystUnderstood. And I appreciate all the detail regarding CECL.
Moshe Orenbuch
analystI was hoping — and I really dislike posing this sort of highly specific question, but during the fourth quarter you generated $4.03 billion in net interest income. Typically, there's a modest seasonal dip in Q1, after which growth resumes. Considering that you anticipate a higher margin and expanding assets, and Walmart was essentially absent from Q4, is it fair to assume that aside from typical seasonal effects, we ought to see NII increase beyond the Q4 figure?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. Thank you, Moshe. Yes, when you consider the fourth quarter, Walmart was present for roughly, let's say, 15, 20 days. So that effect, looking at the quarter, will create a slight dilution tied to it. And beyond that, it's really the surplus liquidity that we're holding which is having an impact, together with ordinary seasonality, on a sequential quarter-over-quarter basis.
Moshe Orenbuch
analystUnderstood. However, that surplus liquidity isn't really moving net interest income dollars in any meaningful manner, correct?
Brian Wenzel
executiveIndeed, it also has an effect — yes, it does have an impact on dollars.
Moshe Orenbuch
analystAlright. For my second question, I want to focus on costs. You mentioned a charge — that happened in Q4 — plus some investments. Since you indicated there would eventually be an improvement on the efficiency front, could you perhaps discuss the strategy you're pursuing with those investments? What timeframe would you expect for them to pay off? And how ought we to frame that in our thinking?
Brian Wenzel
executiveSure. So when you consider those investments — as Margaret pointed out — with regard to what's being spent on Verizon and Venmo, there are separate components, correct? People have to be pre-staged, right? That means teams have been assembled and put in place here so these programs can be made ready. There will be certain launch costs, such as when you consider consumer research, the value proposition, and so on, which come in gradually. As Margaret mentioned, we're subsequently building out the IT and infrastructure. These represent substantial opportunities, and we must be operating at full scale in connection with the launches — Verizon during the first half and Venmo during the second half. And because of what these 2 opportunities involve, there are particular elements concerning the data lake, concerning how digital servicing gets done, as Margaret mentioned, API. So those expenses accumulate, right, as the year progresses. That component, then, is the incremental part. Meanwhile, we operate with, ideally, really solid cost discipline throughout the business. We achieved the cost reduction we were after from Walmart. We keep attempting to eliminate waste and generate efficiencies within the business and its processes, whether that's on the enterprise operations side or throughout all our core functions. And we examine the business through many different lenses in terms of how expenses get managed, and we intend to stay fairly disciplined as 2020 unfolds.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystThanks for the details on CECL. When we consider what you expect for loan growth in 2020, along with the expansion we experienced this year — please tell me if I have this wrong — it appears the core portfolio is expanding at a mid-single-digit pace, which is below the levels we've observed previously. Could you discuss how that might shift as time goes on? Since you now hold a group of merchants that are growing more quickly within the portfolio. And then perhaps — yes, I suppose the question is how it would move upward across the coming several years?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. Thanks, Sanjay. On the growth side, we've guided to between 5% and 7% for this year. Last year we finished at 5%. When you look back at that 17% to 19% stretch, leaving out the PayPal deal, we averaged somewhere between 4% and 7%, so what we're seeing now falls right in line with that. As for Verizon and Venmo, those will ramp up gradually. They're both brand-new programs — one starts in the first half, the other in the second half. We aren't giving any long-range guidance on the growth rate at this point, but clearly these are startup efforts, and that path — we'll share guidance once we get into 2021. So we're sitting within our historical range. When you examine what's in the portfolio, you'll find components that shift over time. Sure, certain parts of our business are expanding quickly, yet there are also areas where growth is slower, which I'm confident you can see, and these elements function together; so once more, we feel good about the 5% to 7% range for this year. That falls inside our guidance. And obviously, we'll be watching how the new programs we're rolling out this year develop.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystAll right; and I suppose, two follow-ups tied to data points. Regarding the preferred stock issuance, what was the reason behind it? Was it simply about broadening where our funding comes from? And then on the charge-off rate, how does that relative charge-off rate compare with this year's guidance — if Walmart were excluded in 2019, do we have that metric, meaning what would that charge-off rate have been?
Brian Doubles
executiveYes; as for your first question, we've discussed over the long term our capital strategy and truly shifting our capital levels, CET1, and so forth, to align with peers. Throughout this journey, we began with an 18% CET1, and now we're at 14%. A piece of that long-term capital strategy has involved diversification so we match our peers. Thus it was always a component of the strategy, it was incorporated in our capital plan that we submitted to the regulators, and our Board approved it earlier this year. So it formed part of our diversification efforts, really, to bring down the overall cost of equity. So getting it done mattered to us. As for the timing — the market was quite attractive. We received a 5.625% rate on the preferred, with a substantial number of institutional and retail investors. So it was heavily oversubscribed. Naturally, we wanted to tap the market and wanted to complete it before 2020 and any possible disruptions that unforeseen events might bring to the market. So that's essentially the rationale for why we pursued it. So — and your second question concerned — just remind me.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystYeah. What about that charge-off rate? For instance, is there a figure comparable to it, excluding Walmart, for 2019?
Brian Doubles
executiveSure; Sanjay, we won't be giving that ex Walmart number; however, here's what I can tell you — roughly 18 months back, we provided some indication of what that rate looked like. Since that point, clearly, the portfolio has worsened, going from $10 billion down to about $8.2 billion, which is where we sold it. Plus, the credit refinements we implemented several years earlier genuinely contributed to beginning to bring that down. So the effect this year wasn't as large, correct, as the one we'd outlined 18 months ago.
Don Fandetti
analystCould you elaborate a bit further on how CECL and the RSA affect each other? On the face of it, the provision increase looks fairly substantial, though I take it there's something offsetting that. Would you mind expanding on that? I realize you mentioned it before.
Brian Wenzel
executiveSure. Thanks, Don. Sure. When you consider the RSA, clearly, for a number of months now we've been in discussions with our partners regarding that shift and what it means for the RSAs. Let me be clear on one point: for those RSAs that take part in reserves, the RSA will capture the entire CECL amount. None of our agreements were modified so as to remove or lower the reserve provisioning tied to those agreements; that point deserves emphasis. When you think about CECL and what it does to the RSA, grounding the discussion strikes me as important. The Retail Card platform is the main one where RSAs come into play. Because of its products and the way it interacts, that platform carries a smaller provisioning figure under CECL. In the Payment Solutions and CareCredit business, the longer-duration promotional activity taking place there means a bigger CECL increase shows up as you progress. One more factor: a minor lag occurs in how the calculations operate as they flow through; so once more, you'll observe that in the year's full run rate, especially during the back half of the year, going forward.
Don Fandetti
analystAll right, and a quick follow-up regarding underwriting. At this moment, are any adjustments being made to how you underwrite? Or would you describe things as basically stable? Also, with the somewhat improved economic picture, have you noticed any rivals easing their standards?
Margaret Keane
executiveCorrect. Easing is not something we've done. What I'd say is our approach to underwriting has remained quite steady. Naturally, small tweaks happen all the time. One point we've mentioned previously is that we've invested heavily in building our models and in the data we rely on, whether sourced outside or inside the company. Because of that, our approach to underwriting is far more strategic. That, I believe, has genuinely assisted us in sustaining the solid results we keep posting on delinquencies and charge-offs. So consistency is what we're maintaining. Given where we sit in the cycle, now strikes me as the moment when you'd want to stay as steady as you can.
Ryan Cary
analystWhen people talk about why loan growth could speed up in 2020, most of it traces back to fresh programs such as Venmo and Verizon. That said, is there anything to gain on the PayPal side now that the conversion sits behind you? Have you also discussed shifting toward a deeper integration stage? Or does the payoff here lean toward a longer runway — meaning it might need somewhat more time before it ramps?
Margaret Keane
executiveNo. Here's how I see it — PayPal is a portfolio of ours that's expanding quickly. It's delivering exactly as we expected it to deliver. What we described a year ago was completing the conversion of that portfolio, and that wrapped up in June. It was a pretty large and complex conversion. At this point, what the PayPal team and we are truly zeroed in on is figuring out ways to speed up growth. Venmo strikes me as somewhat different, given that it's a start-up. That means getting its growth moving will require somewhat more time from us. Still, on the whole, I'd tell you we feel quite good about the growth we're witnessing. It's the sort of growth we're after. And my sense is that as we bring on certain of these newer partners that lean more on digital, you'll see that keep feeding into our portfolio. One thing I do want to flag: even though a number of retailers may be having a tougher time, among the areas where I believe we're clearly coming out ahead is mobile, and growth in mobile is plainly showing up for us. My sense is that during the holiday period, that represented a major piece of our success, I think, alongside our partners, and those partners keep counting on us to genuinely hand them the capability to genuinely fuel digital growth. So my sense is that's another area we'll keep our attention on as well.
Brian Wenzel
executiveYeah, I'll try to clarify just one thing. When you're looking at where most of this year's growth comes from — that 5% to 7% — it's being generated by the book we already have. So even though Verizon and Venmo are launching, because of when that happens across the first half and the second half, if you're considering growth at end of period, it won't represent a significant shift this year. Down the road, when we look at years ahead, that's what will act as an accelerator. So I want to be sure we're all clear: it's the current portfolio that's producing that growth.
Ryan Cary
analystAll right, all right. I also wanted to touch on the GPR card. My understanding is that you mentioned several direct mail campaigns during the quarter. What I'd like to know is how adoption and uptake turned out, and whether that matched what you had anticipated? Should we expect more aggressive direct marketing for the GPR card in the coming year?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYeah. Well, the trends we keep observing on that card are quite favorable. Relative to what we had projected, I'd say results from both campaigns we ran have come in stronger. Activation looks solid, usage is healthy, and balances are being retained nicely. That said, as I mentioned during the prior quarter, we remain highly disciplined when it comes to profitability and returns. Near term, our growth outlook is modest; we're proceeding carefully. We understand this is an intensely competitive marketplace, and our aim is to go after accounts that are profitable; so we genuinely like this space and are pleased with what we've seen up to now, but we will stay disciplined in our approach.
Betsy Graseck
analystI was hoping to get a bit more detail on RSA, just so I'm clear. I realize you provided the range for the entire year, 4.3 to 4.5, but after that you mentioned that at the start of the year it would come in lower, and by the time the year ends it would be higher. Does that fall inside the range you're pointing to? Or does this range represent the average across the full year, meaning the quarterly figures might land outside it?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. That 4.3 to 4.5 represents the average across the entire year, Betsy. So once more, we provided a few projections for the first half. What's really driving the movement here, clearly, is the CECL impact, which comes through somewhat more subdued given how the contractual calculations function; that subsequently normalizes during the back half of the year. So — but 4.3 to 4.5 is the estimate for the full year.
Betsy Graseck
analystAll right. So the quarterly figures might land on either side of that range? Or inside it — you're not actually giving us a firm answer, correct? I just want to be certain.
Brian Wenzel
executiveRight. To repeat, the average will come out at 4.3 to 4.5, and it might sit at the bottom of that or it might sit at the top. Clearly, that will move around depending on how the program performs and how the portfolio's credit performs; so movement is possible. But once more, I believe over the entire year, it will recover.
Betsy Graseck
analystAll right. Moving on to a different topic, Verizon is a fascinating new collaborator. Margaret, perhaps you could elaborate a bit on the range of offerings and goods you'll provide to them that made you appealing, and why they selected your company? Also, might you expand a bit more on the size of the market possibility you see ahead, considering what Verizon brings to the table?
Margaret Keane
executiveSure. To begin, we'll be handling their co-branded card; the branding on it will be Verizon. We are collaborating quite closely with them to ensure this card is truly cutting-edge and powered by digital technology. Some of the developments we're pursuing have us quite thrilled. We won't be disclosing the value proposition and similar details, since that will come at the time of a launch. Now, they possess roughly 119 retail phone connections; therefore, this represents a sizable chance for our company, and the partnership has us enthusiastic. Their level of involvement is high. In my view, we secured this deal thanks to certain investments we've been making. I believe I've moved past the uncertainty I once had regarding whether we are digitally savvy. And judging by the winners that we — the programs we captured this year, I believe our success stems from these investments we've made and those we will keep making. So we're extremely thrilled about Verizon.
Betsy Graseck
analyst119 million customers — is that the figure you mean?
Margaret Keane
executiveNope, we mean something like phone connections. Really, it's phone lines.
Betsy Graseck
analystGot it. Okay.
Margaret Keane
executiveSomebody calculate it.
Rick Shane
analystMargaret and Brian, each of you brought up the data analytics and machine learning you're putting money into; you also noted that you've begun using those insights in a strategic way already. What I'd like to know is what you're observing at this moment when it comes to consumer behavior. Bifurcation among consumers gets discussed a lot. And with the breadth your portfolio has, I'm curious what the two of you are seeing and how that's being applied strategically?
Margaret Keane
executiveBifurcation isn't a term I'm certain I follow — do you mean good customers versus bad customers when it comes to credit? Or...
Rick Shane
analystWell, no, to put it more economically, the economy is showing that kind of divergence. And I'm wondering whether you're finding more opportunity or less, especially among middle and lower income groups.
Margaret Keane
executiveNo, I don't believe we — the way we underwrite is rooted in whether the consumer can pay for the credit card. That's fundamental to our underwriting approach. What I think we're aiming to do is further improve by using data from our partners. For example, I'd say it's more about how we establish a credit line at the outset. So if a partner tells us that a given consumer shops very heavily, we might extend a larger credit line than we typically would, drawing on that information. I think one key thing about our business that sets it apart from maybe the general purpose credit card space is that you can apply and purchase immediately. So from a line size standpoint, we have to be extremely disciplined when providing an initial line; and that's where I think we're truly learning and truly creating a strong customer experience, since we're sharing data between ourselves and the partner. I think another area is assisting us with fraud and true name and using identity and similar things, which are genuinely helping us. So for example, we've used Payphone as an illustration, where now on our mobile app, you only need to fill out 3 lines. And that's genuinely helping us do a better job at identifying that customer; and again, much of this is due to the fact that since we're an apply-and-buy company, we must be very diligent in identifying that as the right customer who's applying.
Brian Doubles
executiveAbsolutely. Rick, there's one more point I'd like to make here. What we've observed up to this point is that, with our partners now providing data such as spending amounts, how often customers come into the store, typical basket value, and how they pay, those measures — which together form what we refer to as an engagement index — actually span all income brackets. As a result, we're discovering it serves as a highly effective indicator of how those accounts will perform, how they'll act when it comes to spending, and likewise when it comes to losses and fraud. So it's delivering benefits for us across several different areas.
Ryan Cary
analystGreat. Okay, that's really useful information.
Bill Carcache
analystMargaret and Brian Doubles, I'd like to ask whether you can help us understand how interested you'd be in Synchrony's exposure to possible merchant receivables — basically extending credit to merchants that's secured by their sales. Could there be a growth opportunity in that area for Synchrony? Is this something you've barely looked at but might explore? Whatever insight you can offer would be appreciated.
Margaret Keane
executiveYes; I'd describe that as an area we are thinking about. As Brian highlighted, I believe our strategy is already clear: we'll stay with what we genuinely understand and expand from there. I'm not sure whether you...
Brian Doubles
executiveYeah. I mean, when you look at it, we're a consumer lender. That's our area of expertise. We're going to keep our focus right there. And in the business we already have, we see a huge number of excellent growth chances, which we laid out; so I'd say never say never, but at this moment it isn't part of our strategic map. I think across all 3 of our platforms we have a huge amount of great growth opportunity; what we're seeing in the direct-to-consumer space is something we like; so in those areas we're going full throttle, and at some point down the road we'll revisit it; but at present, plenty of growth opportunity exists in the core.
Bill Carcache
analystGot it. So, staying on the consumer side, would there ever be any appetite for exploring international consumer down the road? Or, once more, is the U.S. growth potential sufficient that you'd likely rule that out for the near term? Any additional detail on this would be useful too.
Brian Doubles
executiveYeah. Bill, listen, this is a topic we've looked at; it's been discussed with the leadership team and with the Board. As I said, the opportunity we currently see in our U.S. market feels large enough that going international doesn't seem necessary, though I'd never say never. In certain overseas markets, the business does work; that's something we've observed. We'll keep evaluating it, but nothing near term.
Greg Ketron
executiveVanessa, we have time for one more question.
John Hecht
analystI suppose the last thing I'd ask is if you could perhaps discuss what sorts of possibilities are coming down the line. From a wide-angle view, it looks like the partner agreements you've landed lately lean more toward technology — Verizon, PayPal, Venmo, that sort of thing? Has anything shifted regarding the kinds of companies you target? And has anything shifted when it comes to the level of competition?
Margaret Keane
executiveSure, I'll take the second half first. In my view, the competitive landscape is fairly — it's remained fairly steady. Nobody out there seems to be doing anything wildly out of the ordinary. So we feel fairly confident about our position within that competitive landscape. Look, we still aim to capture core retail agreements. So this — and when you look at our Payment Solutions business, much of what we brought in was the heart of that operation. I'd say these chances that have emerged, or that have existed, are, I'd argue, rather distinctive in how they've entered the market. Right now there simply aren't many large retail agreements available, when it comes to portfolios that already exist. We keep seeing a good number of smaller, mid-sized agreements sitting in our pipeline. I'd say each of the 3 platforms has a solid pipeline of possibilities, and that's something we're highly focused on. So I believe you'll see us — later on, you'll see additional retail agreements. It isn't as though we're abandoning that area. I just believe this reflects what the market offered and our chance to, in certain instances, set our portfolio apart a bit.
Greg Ketron
executiveAlright. We appreciate all of you being here with us today. If anything else comes up that you'd like to ask, the Investor Relations team is around to help. And we hope the rest of your day goes well.
Margaret Keane
executiveThank you.
Operator
operatorThanks very much, everyone. That brings today's conference call to a close. We appreciate your joining us, and you're welcome to hang up now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Synchrony Financial transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Synchrony Financial earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Synchrony Financial or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.