Synchrony Financial (SYF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 21, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Greg Ketron
executiveThank you, operator. Good morning to all of you, and it's a pleasure to have you on our quarterly earnings conference call. We appreciate you being here; alongside the press release issued today, we've made available a presentation that addresses the subjects we intend to cover on this call. The press release, comprehensive financial schedules, and the presentation can be found on our site, synchronyfinancial.com. You can reach this information by navigating to the Investor Relations portion of the site. Prior to beginning, please let me remind you that forward-looking statements will be part of what we discuss today. Such statements carry risks and uncertainty, and actual results might differ materially; the factors that could lead actual results to differ materially are listed in our SEC filings, which you can access on our website. On this call, we will discuss non-GAAP financial measures when talking about the company's performance. A reconciliation of those measures to GAAP financial measures is included in our materials for today's call. Lastly, Synchrony Financial bears no responsibility for, does not edit, and cannot guarantee the accuracy of earnings teleconference transcripts from third parties. Only the webcasts hosted on our website are authorized. Joining us this morning are Margaret Keane, Brian Wenzel, and Brian Doubles. I'll now hand the call over to Margaret.
Margaret Keane
executiveThanks, Greg, and good morning to everybody. Right now, both our nation and the entire globe confront a global pandemic unlike anything we've seen before. First off, I'd like to express gratitude to everyone putting in round-the-clock effort, particularly the health care professionals and first responders stationed on the front line, along with those whose contributions happen behind the scenes, among them our devoted staff members who are serving our customers and partners. Though each of us has felt the effects in our own way, and we might experience sorrow and loss, the determination of our society to unite during this crisis gives me encouragement and inspiration. I've witnessed a great deal of kindness, altruistic behavior and backing from communities. That is definitely something I'm hopeful will persist well beyond the conclusion of this situation. I also want to promise our staff members, our partners, our customers and our communities that we'll keep doing everything within our power to back you. This worldwide health emergency is putting us to the test as people and as leaders. It's also putting companies to the test when it comes to performing in a remarkably tough setting. And let me add one more expression of gratitude here to the leaders at Synchrony who've risen to the occasion in so many remarkable manners throughout this unbelievably hard stretch. Thank you. Our business got its start back in the 1930s when we started financing refrigerators amid the Great Depression, and Synchrony has confronted numerous other tough stretches, most recently, the great financial crisis in 2009. It's the blend of our history, robust culture and our gifted team members that will let us leverage our strength to steer through these unpredictable times, safeguard our staff members and keep delivering for our cardholders, retailers, merchants and providers. Afterwards in the call, I'll go into more depth about how we're responding to the COVID-19 outbreak. But before that, allow me to walk you through our results for the first quarter. First quarter earnings came to $286 million, or $0.45 per diluted share; that figure included a rise in provision for credit losses stemming from the CECL implementation in January. The portion of the increase tied to CECL was $101 million, or $76 million after tax, which brought EPS down by $0.13; we achieved strong expansion across a number of key areas throughout the quarter. On a core basis, which leaves out Walmart and Yamaha portfolio, loan receivables expanded 4%, which fueled a 5% rise in interest and fees. Purchase volume rose 6%, and average active accounts climbed 4%. The efficiency ratio stood at 32.7% for the quarter; we boosted deposits by over $500 million, or 1%, compared with last year. And even though we decelerated deposit growth because of the excess liquidity coming from the Walmart portfolio sale, we still kept growing lower-cost direct deposits at a 3% rate compared with the prior year. Our direct deposit platform stays a crucial funding source for our expansion, and we keep putting money into our bank to help draw in new deposits and keep existing customers. We extended and added partnership; we renewed several key relationships, and we added to our growing CareCredit network. We're still enthusiastic, and we're collaborating tightly with Verizon and Venmo to roll out these new offerings at some point in 2020. The exact go-live timing for both initiatives hinges on how the curve environment unfolds, but we're looking at a midyear debut for Verizon and a second-half rollout for Venmo. Meanwhile, our attention stays squarely on digital innovation, boosting our data analytics strengths, and delivering seamless customer journeys — all of which matter greatly for our programs' success and for landing new partnerships. Pushing digital sales penetration higher remains central to winning. Within Retail Card, digital sales penetration hit 41% during the first quarter, while digital applications made up 56% of all applications. Excluding Walmart, the mobile channel by itself climbed 34% versus the equivalent quarter a year ago. Over the quarter, we bought back $1 billion of Synchrony common stock and distributed $135 million, or $0.22 per share, in common stock dividend. We're happy about how solid our business is; even so, we did see purchase volumes drop significantly because of COVID-19 in the latter half of March, which Brian will discuss afterward on this call. Pinpointing the full effect of this crisis is extremely hard at present, since how long it lasts and how big it gets remain mostly unclear. Even so, we think our position gives us an edge for getting through this unpredictable stretch. From a credit standpoint, our portfolio sits in good shape thanks to adjustments we've implemented since the great financial crisis, along with certain more targeted tweaks made over recent years. On top of that, our RSAs have proven over time to serve as a strong cushion when stress hits. Ours is a partner-centric business model, and we're more agile than we've ever been, which lets us put changes and improvements in place quickly. We've also constructed a powerful data lake that grants us business-wide information access at a level never seen before. Pair that with our analytics strengths, and we hold yet another potent instrument for helping our partners steer through this stretch. The digital tools we've developed, which have helped us secure key digital partners, represent one more vital instrument for enabling our partners throughout the business to steer through this period by assisting them in moving volume toward online and mobile channels. At this point I'd like to devote some time to highlighting what Synchrony has done for our employees, partners and communities. We've pursued these steps in the spirit of helping the communities where we live and operate to aid in curbing the global health crisis, while still serving the needs of our cardholders, retailers, merchants and providers. Every step we've taken has come with empathy and regard for each constituency, and we'll keep responding as this crisis develops. Our employees are the strength of our company. We acted fast and firmly to implement measures that uphold the health, wellness and safety of our colleagues around the world. We've put a plan in place so that everyone can work from home full-time. Here in the U.S., team members throughout the entire company—everything from support roles to the frontline associates in our contact centers—are all doing their jobs from home. That's let us keep our operations steady and keep serving customers, all while making sure our people stay safe. We're helping our associates by paying for co-pays on virtual doctor visits for any employee who wants to talk to a medical professional, and we've upgraded our benefits so they now include expanded backup emergency care benefits, giving our colleagues the childcare or eldercare support they need. On top of that, we're offering financial planning and employee assistance, as well as wellness programs. For the associates in our contact centers, we handed out a onetime special bonus as a thank-you for the essential role they play in helping our customers each and every day without missing a beat. Beyond that, an emergency fund is being set up to help our associates handle unexpected financial challenges that could hit them during this period. For consumers going through financial hardship, we're able to help these cardholders through this extremely difficult period. We'll waive fees and interest charges, or we can extend promotional financing periods. We'll also waive minimum payments on existing balances for certain qualifying accounts.
Margaret Keane
executiveFor those looking to increase their credit line for essential purchases, we'll review credit limits provided they satisfy our credit standards. A large number of our partners have been alongside us for many years, and we've supported them as their businesses expanded. Now we're here to help them safeguard it. We've adopted a forceful strategy to make sure we keep delivering dependable products and service to our partners and their customers that remain usable throughout this period of disruption. The money we've put into making every one of our digital assets quick and simple to use is assisting them in serving their customers. Additionally, our relationship managers are actively assisting them, and their availability to our partners has not been disrupted. Our agile structure is helping generate solutions in real time, and our committed teams are working relentlessly to back our partners and their customers. The communities in which we live and work form such a central piece of Synchrony's cultural fabric. That's the reason we've pledged $5 million to assist local and national organizations in helping those parts of the country hit hardest by COVID-19. We'll be backing organizations such as Feeding America and Meals On Wheels within the U.S., along with groups in Puerto Rico, India and the Philippines. Furthermore, our employees have given countless hours to Synchrony's Gear Up initiative. Staff members have participated in our communities to help produce certain protective devices, including face shields, via 3D printing, and to sell gowns and masks through our network of cardholders who are deeply involved in the sewing community, where we have numerous partners selling sewing machines. We've also utilized our CareCredit network, and Synchrony acts as a site within our communities where individuals can give PPE items, and we're involved in moving needed items to different medical facilities. We're confronting an extraordinary and unprecedented moment, yet Synchrony possesses the strength, the resources and the resolve to combat this global health crisis on behalf of our employees, partners, customers and communities. Having operated for almost 100 years, we've steered through multiple periods of economic uncertainty by keeping our attention on supporting our associates, partners and their customers, while still investing in our businesses for the long haul. I take pride in the actions we've taken for our constituents, and I'm confident that through the strength of our business model and balance sheet, we'll keep steering through this crisis successfully while keeping our attention on the substantial opportunities in our business, our long-term objective and strategic initiatives; with that, I'll hand the call over to Brian Wenzel to go over some of the key business trends we're observing, the financial performance for the quarter and views on a framework to help consider the impact of COVID-19 on our key outlook drivers.
Brian Wenzel
executiveThank you, Margaret, and hello everybody on this call. To begin, I'd like to repeat Margaret's appreciation for all those helping to protect our communities, including health care staff, first responders, and people in grocery stores or involved with vaccines. Their selflessness and commitment is truly inspiring and we are deeply grateful. I also want to express gratitude to our team members worldwide who are adapting to different ways of working so they can keep serving our partners and customers. Thank you. Now let's discuss the financial results for Q1. I'll begin on Slide 4. Before getting into Q1 numbers, I want to address certain early patterns we are observing due to COVID-19's effect on purchase volume, plus some key elements of our business worth noting given the circumstances we currently confront. Slide 4 presents purchase volume growth compared to last year, both for the entire company and for world sales from our dual and co-branded cards, covering January, February, and March. March is divided into the first portion and the latter portion, when COVID-19's impact rose substantially. Purchase volume growth remained robust until mid-March, with double-digit increases for both the entire company and world sales volumes; during March's second half, as federal and state mandates grew, travel, entertainment, and event activity dropped sharply, and many stores considered nonessential shut down. Consequently, purchase volume for the entire company and world sales fell considerably, dropping 26% and 27%, respectively, during March's latter half. These patterns persist into April. Examining year-over-year growth rates of world sales by category during the period before travel restrictions, which is January, and then growth after travel restrictions through the end of Q1. We saw shifts in spending categories comparable to broader industry patterns. Grocery, discount, and drug store spending rose considerably after January, whereas restaurants, entertainment, gas, and specialty travel fell considerably over that same timeframe. Although restaurants, entertainment, gas, and travel were hit hard, just 27% of 2019 world sales came from these categories. Clearly, these patterns will affect our purchase volume and loan receivable growth moving forward. The final effect remains unclear since the length and scale of this pandemic is still mostly unknown right now. Turning to Slide 5. We emphasize the stronger quality asset base now compared with our 2008 asset base before the great financial crisis. This stems directly from our strategy to enhance asset quality via disciplined underwriting and improvements in our underwriting processes that have proven highly effective in managing overall credit quality. I want to point out several elements of our credit management program. To start, our credit team is highly experienced, and our underwriting approach is very disciplined. Next, every underwriting and credit choice made within our programs—and throughout all our sales platforms—sits under our control. The credit approaches we use are built around whichever partner industry we happen to serve, and they differ from one channel to the next for both origination and account management. On the left-hand portion of this page, if you look at FICO as a benchmark for comparison, you'll see that 73% of the portfolio carries a FICO score higher than 660, whereas back in 2008 that figure stood at 61%. Even more significant is what happened in the FICO band of 600 or below, where losses tend to run higher: we've brought our exposure down to 9% of the portfolio, versus 19% in 2008, which represents a major gain in portfolio quality. We moved 12% of the portfolio out of balances at or under 660 FICO and into the above-660 FICO category, and balances with FICOs of 721 or greater grew by 4%. When we came out of the great financial crisis, we made a deliberate strategic call to raise the credit quality of our portfolio, and you can see that reflected in how our new account origination mix has looked since 2010. More than 80% of accounts originated since 2010 carry FICOs above 660, and 45% of those accounts have FICO 721 or higher. Under 1% of what we originated had FICOs of 600 or lower; beyond that, we also apply sophisticated underwriting methods when managing the portfolio. A few illustrations of this: on the account acquisition side, we draw on as many as 16 distinct data sources along with over 4,000 attributes in order to assess creditworthiness and verify who the customer is; we take a multi-algorithmic approach aimed at specific outcomes—covering credit, fraud, synthetic IDs and other malicious behavior—and we also tap client-specific data so that customer engagement with our partners helps us set more effective credit lines. On the account management side, we keep using internal triggers and credit bureau triggers to reassess a customer's creditworthiness on a dynamic basis so we can manage credit exposure, and we also apply the newest technology to passively authenticate customers and to target at-risk behavior more selectively. You can see this in the better purchase volume mix since we put those underwriting techniques in place during 2016. The chart over on the right-hand portion of the page illustrates how the purchase volume mix improved from first quarter '16, showing 65% of that mix sitting at a 721-plus FICO for the first quarter, up against 61% during the first quarter of 2016. Last, it's worth pointing out that our portfolio is nicely diversified across industries, we've been expanding Payment Solutions and CareCredit at a quicker pace than Retail Card, and we hold no meaningful geographic concentrations. To wrap up, we've dramatically strengthened the asset quality of our portfolio relative to what we held through the great financial crisis. The tools and capabilities we've built are better, and we can roll out underwriting changes faster and more effectively than at any point in the past. Slide 6 gives you a longer-term picture of how we do on the loss side, going all the way back to the great financial crisis, when the loss rate for card issuers hit its peak in 2009. A common belief holds that when credit losses rise, private label cards tend to do a bit worse than general purpose ones. Yet the top chart shows our credit results during 2009, on a managed basis, landed fairly close to what general purpose card issuers saw, in that 10% to 11% loss range. What helps explain why our loss experience looks similar is that our loss severity runs lower, since the typical balance we carry is smaller than what general purpose cards have. During the first quarter, the average balance for each active account came to $1,171, unchanged from a year earlier. Viewed through a risk-adjusted yield lens, we beat the general purpose card peers by a wide margin throughout the crisis, with risk-adjusted yield coming in more than 700 basis points above that peer group. Once we got past the cycle and losses fell, our risk-adjusted yield advantage versus general purpose card issuers stayed above 600 basis points after the crisis. RSAs give us a cushion as well.
Brian Wenzel
executiveYou could see this pattern back in 2009, and then once more from the start of 2016 all the way through 2018, when credit costs rose, which is illustrated by the chart in the bottom right area of Slide 6. Although credit-related factors are what drive the countercyclical behavior of RSAs, additional things also affect them, including program revenue, expenses, and mix. Back in 2009, RSAs measured as a share of average receivables fell to 1.6%, which is 64% lower than the more typical RSA average of 4.43% seen across 2013 through 2016. The robust risk-adjusted yield, together with the countercyclical behavior of RSAs, played a big part in letting us stay profitable during the great financial crisis, since both of those things underscore how resilient our business model's earnings are. At the worst point of the crisis in 2009, the company produced a return on assets of roughly 1%. Considering what I mentioned above, even though we don't anticipate charge-offs stemming from the present circumstances reaching levels like those in the great financial crisis, we believed it mattered to offer some historical background regarding the main elements that distinguish our business from others in the industry. Now turning to the first quarter financial results, which are on Slide 7. This morning, we announced first quarter earnings of $286 million, or $0.45 per diluted share. That figure included a rise in the provision for credit losses stemming from the adoption of CECL in January. That increase came to $101 million, or $76 million after tax, which cut EPS by $0.13. We achieved strong growth compared with a year earlier in a number of areas, as Slide 8 shows. On a core basis, which leaves out the Walmart and Yamaha portfolios, loan receivables rose 4%, and interest and fees on loan receivables rose 5%, both driven by receivables growth. On that same core basis, purchase volume came in at 6%, and average active accounts climbed 4% versus last year. On Slide 8, we've provided dual and co-branded card purchase volumes along with loan receivable balances so you can see how diversified we are across these products. Dual and co-branded cards represent 38% of total purchase volume in the first quarter and rose 8% compared with the prior year. They made up 24% of the total loan receivables portfolio and increased 6% versus the prior year. All in all, we're happy with the underlying growth we delivered throughout the business. As I said before, the effect of COVID-19 picked up speed as the quarter went on, with the bulk of that effect landing late in the quarter. We expect a bigger effect this quarter, but since how long it lasts and how large it will be remain mostly uncertain right now, offering a more precise forecast of the effect is difficult. RSAs fell $28 million, or 3%, compared with last year. As a percentage of average receivables, RSAs were 4.4% for the quarter, which sits at the low end of the range we had anticipated for the first quarter because of a larger credit loss reserve build. The provision for credit losses climbed to $818 million, or 95%, compared with last year. The main reason for the rise was last year's $522 million reduction in the Walmart credit loss reserve. A bigger reserve build in the first quarter, partly offset by lower net charge-offs, made up the rest of the increase. That first-quarter reserve build came to $552 million, mostly reflecting the anticipated effect of losses tied to COVID-19. Other income rose $5 million. Other expense fell $41 million, or 4%, because of cost cuts from Walmart, partly offset by greater operational losses and costs connected to the COVID-19 response. So on the whole, apart from the COVID-19 impacts, the company kept producing solid results in the first quarter. Let me take a moment to go over our platform results on Slide 9. In Retail Card, core loan receivable growth came in at 3%, with solid growth driven mainly by our digital partners. Other metrics declined because of the Walmart portfolio sale. Payment Solutions had a strong quarter with broad-based growth across the sales platform and strength in home furnishings and home specialty, producing core loan receivable growth of 7%. Interest and fees on loans were up 3%, mainly because of the loan receivable growth. Purchase volume and average active accounts each rose 2%. We signed a number of new partners and renewed key partnerships this quarter. We keep driving growth organically through our partnerships and card networks; those networks, together with other initiatives such as driving higher card reuse, which now stands at approximately 30% of purchase volume excluding oil and gas, help us drive solid results. CareCredit also had another strong quarter. Receivable growth of 7% was led by our dental and veterinary specialties. Interest and fees on loans rose 9%, mainly because of the loan receivable growth. Purchase volume was up 2%, and average active accounts rose 5%. We keep expanding our network and the utility of our card, having added over 2,000 new provider locations to our network during the quarter. That network expansion has helped drive the reuse rate to 56% of purchase volume in the first quarter. We did begin to see COVID-19's effects on the platform results as the quarter went on. In Retail Card, while store closing impacted results, we also saw strong growth in digital purchase volume that helped offset some of the COVID-19 impact; in Payment Solutions, while store closings had a less pronounced impact, promotional offerings and growth in areas such as home specialty helped mitigate some of this impact. For CareCredit, we continue to see good performance in areas such as veterinary, partly offset by reductions in elective procedures. We do expect these effects will carry into the next quarter and be more pronounced, since many of the store closings happened during the latter part of March. I'll move to Slide 10 and cover our net interest income and margin trends. Net interest income fell 8% versus a year ago, largely because interest and fees on loan receivables dropped 7% following the sale of the Walmart portfolio. Looking at the core figures, interest and fees on loans rose 5%. Our net interest margin came in at 15.15%, while last year's margin stood at 16.08%. Several main items drove this margin result: loan receivables mix, as a percentage of total earning assets, slipped, moving from 84.4% down to 81.7%, which came from greater liquidity in the quarter tied mostly to proceeds from the Walmart portfolio sale in October of last year; loan receivables yield declined 47 basis points to 20.67%, chiefly because of the Walmart portfolio sale; and this was partly offset by total interest-bearing liabilities cost dropping 14 basis points to 2.50%, mainly on lower benchmark rates. Turning next to our key credit trends, which I'll cover on Slide 11. Regarding specific dynamics this quarter, let me begin with delinquency trends. The 30-plus delinquency rate was 4.24%, versus 4.92% a year ago, and the 90-plus delinquency rate was 2.10%, versus 2.51% a year ago. When you strip out the Walmart portfolio's impact, the 30-plus delinquency rate declined roughly 15 basis points and the 90-plus delinquency rate declined roughly 5 basis points relative to last year.
Brian Wenzel
executiveNow let's look at net charge-off trends. Our net charge-off rate came in at 5.36%, versus 6.06% a year ago. The decline in that net charge-off rate was mainly a result of Walmart along with better credit trends. If you set aside the Walmart portfolio's impact, the net charge-off rate ran roughly 15 basis points below the prior year. That came in ahead of what we anticipated, which was roughly a 50 basis point rise from the fourth quarter's 5.15% net charge-off rate. Following CECL implementation, the allowance for credit losses as a percentage of loan receivables stood at 11.13%, and that figure included a day 1 transition adjustment of $3.02 billion. Had CECL not been applied, the allowance under the ALLL method would have come to 7.34%. During the first quarter, the reserve build reached $552 million under CECL and $451 million under the ALLL method. Overall reserve provisioning exceeded our expectations because of COVID-19's impact, and that accounted for the bulk of the first quarter's reserve build. To sum up, first quarter credit trends came in a bit ahead of what we expected once COVID-19's impact is excluded; going forward, we anticipate credit trends will feel the effects of this. Gauging how big that impact will be is tough right now, since there's uncertainty about how long the pandemic lasts and how severe it becomes, plus possible effects from the CARES Act and our own efforts tied to cardholders hurt by COVID-19. Let's turn to Slide 12. I'll walk through the quarter's expenses. Total expenses reached $1 billion, which is $41 million lower, or 4% below, the prior year. Cost cuts from Walmart drove that decrease. Higher expenses from operational losses and certain spending tied to our COVID-19 response partly offset it. The efficiency ratio this quarter was 32.7%, against 31% a year ago. Once you exclude operational losses and the COVID-19-related expenses, the efficiency ratio was unchanged from the prior year. Let's move to Slide 13. Over the past year, deposits grew by more than $500 million, or 1%. That brings deposits to 79% of our funding, up from 75% a year ago. We did slow overall deposit growth during the first quarter, since we had excess liquidity from the Walmart portfolio sale in last year's fourth quarter, yet we kept growing our lower-cost direct deposits, which rose at a slightly faster 3% pace versus the prior year. Total liquidity, undrawn credit facilities included, came to $24.8 billion, equal to more than 25% of our total assets. That's up from 22% a year ago. Before I get into the details of our capital liquidity position, I should note that we're choosing to take the benefit of transition rules issued in March by the joint federal banking agencies, and those rules had 2 main benefits. First, it postpones the transition adjustment's effects by an additional 2 years; and second, it lets a portion of current period provisioning under CECL be deferred and amortized along with the transition adjustment. Under this framework, we finished Q1 with a CET1 ratio of 14.3% under CECL transition rules, which is close to where we were a year ago. The Tier 1 capital ratio came in at 15.2% under the CECL transition rules, versus 14.5% in the prior year, and that reflects the preferred stock issuance we completed last November. The total capital ratio also rose 70 basis points, reaching 16.5%, again reflecting the preferred issuance. In addition, the Tier 1 capital ratio plus reserves ratio, on a fully phased-in basis, grew to 24.1%, which is a 280 basis point increase from the prior year, driven by higher reserves from implementing CECL and the preferred stock issuance. Throughout the quarter, we kept executing the capital plan we announced last May. We distributed a common stock dividend of $0.22 per share and bought back $1 billion, or 33.6 million shares, of common stock in Q1. As of the end of the first quarter, we had $366 million left in share repurchase capacity out of the $4 billion authorized plan for the current capital plan cycle. Because of the present economic uncertainty and taking the most prudent approach possible, we've decided to stop any additional share repurchases under this plan until we gain better visibility into how deep and how large the current situation becomes. On the whole, we're still carrying out the strategy we laid out earlier. We remain dedicated to keeping a very strong balance sheet, with funding sources that are diversified, and to running the company with solid capital and liquidity levels. To wrap up, we typically give updates on our outlook. With so many unknowns about how severe and how long the COVID-19 pandemic will be, along with the offsetting effects of things like the CARES Act, payment assistance for our customers, and any government and regulatory actions that might come, it's extremely hard to gauge the final impact right now. Consequently, our expectations differ from the outlook we gave in January, and that guidance should not be trusted any longer. Because the length and scale of the current environment remain unclear, we cannot offer any ranges for the key outlook drivers for 2020, but I do want to give you a framework to help think through the effects on those key outlook drivers. When it comes to loan receivable growth, COVID-19 has hit purchase volume hard, especially toward the end of the first quarter. We expect purchase volume to keep deteriorating on a year-over-year basis until things get better, presumably later in 2020. One thing that might offset some of this is growth in digital, and we're in a strong position for that thanks to our digital partners and by using our expertise to assist other partners and providers. The net deterioration in purchase volume overall will eventually affect our receivable growth rate. If we turn to net interest margin, a couple of things are going to weigh on it. The Fed's rate cuts bring prime rates down, which affects us, and we'll also see less investment income coming from our liquidity portfolio, plus there's the possible effect of forbearance — interest and fee waivers over a temporary window. Working partly against that margin squeeze: we expect more interest income because more accounts in the loan receivable portfolio should revolve, and interest expense should be lower since benchmark rates have fallen. One last point — through the RSA, we share in both the revenue impact and the funding cost impact. On the RSAs specifically, beyond sharing the net interest income effects, higher credit costs will hit us more noticeably as the year goes on; and, as we mentioned back in January, CECL's effect on RSAs will be felt more completely during the second half of the year. We do anticipate net charge-offs rising over the course of the year, but keep in mind that portfolio quality overall and credit trends were strong when we went into this pandemic, and our tools and capabilities are more advanced than they were in the great financial crisis — that came up earlier on this call. And lastly, we think higher recoveries will eventually come through, which offsets some of the hit from bigger losses. Just like with revenue, we also laid out how higher credit costs flow through the RSA.
Brian Wenzel
executiveAlthough we anticipate that the reserve builds will come in above what we initially expected, we are unable to offer more detailed guidance at this point, given that we still lack sufficient visibility regarding how long the current pandemic will last and how severe it will be. When our visibility improves, we will be better positioned to set out what we expect for charge-offs and reserve builds moving forward. Turning to the efficiency ratio, revenue and expense levels will be affected by activity levels, and we will seek to offset a portion of that effect by pursuing opportunities to reduce expenses. We will keep evaluating the situation and offer guidance once we have more clarity about how the current environment is affecting us. At its core, the business is still solid and resilient, and we are entering this situation with a strong balance sheet, along with strong capital and liquidity positions. With that, I will hand the call back to Margaret.
Margaret Keane
executiveAppreciate that, Brian. Let me give you a brief closing summary, and after that we'll move into the question-and-answer portion. Our belief remains unchanged that the power of our business model, along with how resilient our associates are, is going to carry us through this worldwide health emergency. Our attention stays on delivering for the retailers, merchants and providers we serve, and on standing behind our cardholders with understanding throughout this challenging time. Execution is where our focus lies right now, yet we're equally committed to keeping up strategic investments in the business so we can build on our strengths and bring customers the products and services they'll be looking for once this period has passed. I'm grateful that all of you joined the call today. And I'd like to wish each of you, and your families, nothing but the best as we keep confronting this extremely tough circumstances. At this point I'll hand the call back over to Greg so he can kick off the Q&A.
Greg Ketron
executiveThat wraps up what we had to say about the quarter. Now we're going to move into the Q&A portion. <<operator_script>> Should any further questions come up, the Investor Relations team will be around once the call ends. Operator, go ahead and open the Q&A session.
John Hecht
analystI've got a question here. Brian, you mentioned that during the latter portion of March, your volumes and sales dropped roughly 25% to 26%. I'm just attempting to work through how to model the upcoming few quarters. Is that the kind of shrinkage you're observing so far in April? And what's our framework for thinking about what you've been seeing in April up to now?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYeah. Appreciate it, John. During the second half of March, which was down, once more, around 26%, it picked up a bit. So through the early part of April, we've been consistently running in a range that's 30% to 35% lower. Again, if you consider the world spend categories, the ones we called out in the earnings chart, they look quite similar in terms of declines across travel, gas and entertainment, somewhat better in grocery, drug store, and so on; but once more, that's only on the dual card, yet with the power of the digital assets, we do have certain retailers considered essential that remain open. And obviously, digital and e-commerce keeps fueling it. So it's fairly stable at that net 30% year-over-year decrease.
John Hecht
analystAll right. Excellent. That's quite useful. Then for my second question, I'm just attempting to consider how this compares with the Great Recession. Where — I suppose what — within the economic models you've used to set your — the allowance levels, what sort of unemployment figure are you currently assuming? Or how should we frame the economic assumptions against the 2009 timeframe?
Brian Wenzel
executiveAbsolutely, John. Let me walk through our thinking, or rather how we approached this quarter when establishing the ACL reserve. As you're aware, economic assumptions differ quite a bit among the many institutions that publish them; we don't generate our own, we rely on external ones. So because of the dispersion we observed among many institutions, we ran multiple scenarios and examined multiple scenarios for how they'd behave against our book; after that we landed on a set of assumptions from one source that essentially assumed an unemployment rate nearing 10% during the second quarter as roughly the peak; followed by a second half recovery, in which unemployment falls to approximately 7% and then a much more gradual decrease in '21 and returns to roughly about a 4.5% unemployment when you consider it in '22. Alongside that, bankruptcies climbing roughly 15% and remaining elevated over the next couple of years was another very important assumption there. And then a substantial GDP contraction in the second quarter, again, with the second half recovery, though clearly negative for the entire year. So that's roughly our approach. Now when you take that and compare it with the great financial crisis, a very, very different set of scenarios, where the consumer was stressed, unemployment lagged, and you didn't have the timing or the magnitude of stimulus reaching the consumer. So it's quite a different scenario to try to benchmark against. And then if you truly look back and examine the portfolio, John, it's fundamentally different. Clearly, Walmart's gone. The quantity of assets we hold above 660 has moved significantly. The amount — the amount we've put into our advanced underwriting, the tools and technology, is very, very different. So we're comfortable as we sit here today that the portfolio has very good credit quality. Until mid-March, we actually observed our credit quality improving, or continuing to improve, year-over-year, which was encouraging to us. So the consumer entered in great strength. We have this sort of economic situation really emerging from the pandemic, and then we have a kind of stimulus moving through; so very, very different from where we stand.
Moshe Orenbuch
analystI was hoping you might be able to provide a bit more of a sense of what you're aiming to accomplish with the deferments and how that would operate? Any sort of granularity regarding what customers are requesting? What are you providing? And what proportion of a portfolio do you expect will fall into that category at some future points, let's say, the end of the second quarter?
Brian Wenzel
executiveSure. Allow me to walk through the forbearance we're extending to our customers; the first thing we do is if a customer calls in and has been impacted, if they request a waiver of a late fee or interest charges, those are being waived. For qualifying accounts, the min payment is also waived. So if the min payment on the account is actually deferred for as long as 3 months and they're kind of held in their due stage of their current, brought back if they're too due to current. So really giving them the chance to kind of get their situation a little bit more — we're — in the promotional book as well, we are extending for periods as long as 90 days the deferral of the expiration of the promo. So those are the main forms of relief being provided to those people; so if you look at how many people have taken advantage of that, for us, it's roughly 800,000 accounts to date and approximately $1.6 billion in balances. So if you think about it, a small percentage yet have taken advantage of the program, and we have not seen a tremendous amount of people needing that min pay deferral at this point. But again, that will continue to be offered to help our cardholders through this time.
Moshe Orenbuch
analystUnderstood; and could you possibly speak a bit, whether it's Brian or Margaret, regarding the conversations you're currently having with your retail partners and what they're requesting from you? And what requests are you making of them?
Margaret Keane
executiveRight. So I'd say immediately, the most significant item was truly getting the operation stabilized. Clearly, something we put a lot of effort into, and it was quite extraordinary honestly, was getting every one of our staff members set up to work from home, our call center included. So at present we're at nearly a 100% work from home situation. So on the servicing side, we are hitting and ensuring we surpass the service standards for our customers. And I believe that mattered a great deal; we have a bit of everything here since we have retailers who are open and taking care of customers. We have very large online partners taking care of their customers. And then we have retailers who are in fact shut; so I'd say every one of our teams is extremely focused on both our retail partners and our providers, with relationship managers reaching out to them. Clearly, they're — they want to be certain we're responding the proper way for their end consumer and doing the right things both regarding forbearance and also regarding credit. And we're talking with them every day. I'd say we feel fairly confident about our position. We received a quite pleasant note from one of our partners, who was genuinely delighted to see how we've managed to serve their customers throughout this. So very engaged, we aren't taking it easy, we're holding those conversations and ensuring we maintain clear dialogue the entire time.
Don Fandetti
analystBrian, I'd like to ask you something. You brought up that your unemployment forecast sits near 10%. My guess is that figure is greater for April. Could you expand on that a bit? Also, looking at your allowance near 11%, my sense is it will need to rise. Could you address the reserve build — for instance, Q2 compared with Q1? That would really help.
Brian Wenzel
executiveWhen you think it through, under CECL and ACL, we clearly rely on a group of assumptions at that moment, which form the basis for our reserve estimate. Once we got into April, there's still quite a broad divergence among folks regarding the peak jobless rate that will occur during the second quarter; yet much of it — a key element is the shape of the recovery phase. And starting from that peak, as it comes down, how fast does that happen? And in what manner? So without question, how the retail picture evolves, and how consumers and the stimulus carry people across this stretch of time, will be essential. If you carry that logic forward and conclude that yes, assumptions worsen regarding the unemployment peak during that recovery phase along with the stimulus impact, then larger reserve entries would arrive in the second quarter — however, we're merely 20 days into the quarter right now, Don. So honestly, I can't provide you, with precision, the specific reserve entry we'd record. We must observe how those assumptions actually unfold here in the second quarter as we progress through it. Once more, that recovery phase and the stimulus effects are truly significant factors.
Ryan Cary
analystWith everything that's in flux, I'm hoping you might shed a bit more light on the trajectory you foresee for charge-offs as they build. I realize that pinning down the size is tough to do when forbearance plans and government support programs are all on equal footing, but can we reasonably expect charge-offs to be delayed beyond what they'd be otherwise? And what's your view on the possible effect if unemployment stays high for a couple of quarters rather than a couple of months?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes, Ryan, and thanks for your good wishes. When we look at it right now, clearly, forbearance — which hasn't amounted to much in our case — might push out possible net charge-offs. Once more, I believe the stimulus package is going to assist in carrying some consumers through for a stretch of time. Our expectation would start to be that charge-offs would truly start rising in the later portion of the third quarter, likely the fourth quarter and on into 2021. Once more, regarding the size of that, we believe we've addressed it in our ACL reserve as of the close of the first quarter. Yet the timing of it will genuinely hinge, again, on this peak and on how the recovery starts to take shape as we progress here in the second quarter, to be candid with you.
Ryan Cary
analystAlright. I was hoping you might take a bit of time to talk about the conversations you're having with retailers regarding signing new programs or renewing partnerships. I know you mentioned a couple during the quarter. But how does the current environment affect the prospect pipeline? And could you talk about how the pace of new business deals is impacting things, both in 2020 and beyond?
Margaret Keane
executiveYeah. Whether you believe it or not, deals do exist in the pipeline, and we're having conversations and bidding on deals. I'd say that things — conversations have perhaps slowed slightly, just as folks have been attempting to handle all the challenges they're facing. But we feel fairly good about the pipeline that's out there; we've been able to be, I think, and will be very selective about the things we do examine to make sure they suit where we want the business to go. But I'd say, across all 3 platforms, we've seen good activity; and we will, I think, keep seeing that good activity. We'll have to wait and see how the rest of the year unfolds, but at this moment, we do have a decent pipeline.
Brian Wenzel
executiveTo build on that, Ryan, when we consider these partnerships — and Margaret made a point of emphasizing this when you aim for them, when we start evaluating the financials involved with them, obviously, a downturn has always been factored into our pricing. When you're looking at a deal spanning 7 years or one spanning 10 years, we, as a company, approach it with the full cycle in mind. Naturally, in examining this particular situation, that cycle sits at the outset of what could be a relationship and how deep it might go. Consequently, we're likely somewhat more cautious. And truly, we'll only proceed with such a deal if it delivers what we regard as a risk-adjusted return that strikes us as conservative right now.
Betsy Graseck
analystA couple of things. First, regarding RSA. Brian, I believe you said during your prepared comments that the RSA effect — tied to CECL day 2 — would show up in the latter half of the year. Could you walk us through some of the pluses and minuses there, and how big we should expect that to be?
Brian Wenzel
executiveSure. Thanks. When you look at it, the situation has shifted somewhat since January. First, I want to be sure — Betty — that we share a view on the reserve provision this quarter and how CECL differs from the ALLL. If you consider the overall reserve build this quarter at $551 million, 515 — sorry, $511 million of that is essentially tied to COVID-19. And $40 million, which is below what we had anticipated coming into the quarter, basically arose from the core book, reflecting the stronger credit quality we saw across most of the quarter. When you look at it, the entire $551 million is CECL; so we pointed out, under ALLL it would be $451 million. Under CECL, it's $551 million. But when you consider that $551 million, that is ultimately what will flow through. To the degree it's subject to the RSA, it will flow through the RSA; so we'd anticipate, I'd say, a sequential dollar — declining dollars of the RSA as we move through the year and clearly as a percentage of ALR. So you'll observe that in the second quarter and then really more in the back half of the year.
Betsy Graseck
analystAll right. So the shift into the back half of the year happens because of how revenue recognition works on your retail clients' end, that's my guess.
Brian Wenzel
executiveNo. Betsy, what happened is that when CECL came in and through the RSAs, we didn't alter how the economics get shared. It's really just the way it flows from us via the RSA, and that carried a small timing delay; so nothing differs, when you look at it through the RSA in 2020, whether you're talking CECL or ALLL. The reserve simply arrives with a bit of a lag. So you'll start to sense that more during the back half. And it goes beyond simply the mechanics of how it operates through the program agreements with our retail partners and then their revenue recognition or whatever other type alters the economics; it was really more about mechanics in how it functions within the program agreement. But once more, we anticipate a sequential gain as the year progresses.
Betsy Graseck
analystAll right, understood. Then, as a second question, Margaret, considering the shifts we've seen during these past 2 months, what's your view on chances to broaden your capabilities or what you're able to provide to your retail partners or your CareCredit partners? I'm curious whether there are openings to acquire technology or other kinds of systems or capabilities that might improve what you offer.
Margaret Keane
executiveYeah. There are 2 points I'd make. First, prior to the pandemic even, certain possibilities were beginning to emerge that caught our attention somewhat; we have not let those go cold. At this moment, I believe you truly need to hold back and observe how valuations shake out, so we won't rush into anything. Yet there are items available that definitely interest us. Regarding the second point, I think another step we've taken is that we genuinely — we reviewed our strategic initiatives for 2020 and shifted our teams around somewhat so they could concentrate on and speed up certain digital efforts we had underway or intended to pursue. We halted a few items that we believe can wait until 2021 and took those agile teams and are directing them once more toward greater digital capability for the company. And I believe that will assist us as we emerge from the — or move through this, and we provide our partners and the end consumers with more digital capability. Clearly, we are certainly succeeding on the digital front when it comes to our online penetration and the volume flowing through there. So we recognize this is an absolutely essential matter. Thus, beyond the external possibilities, I think we possess and have already launched the teams and set it in motion and are pushing it ahead. I don't know, Brian Doubles, whether you'd like to add something there?
Brian Doubles
executiveRight. The one point I might tack on is that, like Margaret mentioned, our pace was really fast, and we genuinely reviewed each strategic project across the company. Some of those were clear-cut items our partners wanted us to speed up so we could assist them in weathering this tough stretch, so we shifted agile resources over there. Beyond that, there were certain efforts we undertook involving special promotions for partners that continue to operate stores and remain quite active online. Then, as Margaret noted, a few items we halted simply didn't make sense given these circumstances. That covers things such as certain card reissues and dual card upgrades, which we either repositioned or pushed back, shifting them toward the latter half of the year, once conditions grow somewhat more settled.
David Scharf
analystI appreciate you giving us as much detail as could fairly be anticipated under these conditions. I just want to ask a quick follow-up about what you mentioned earlier regarding forbearance — that fairly small figure for accounts and balances. I'm simply wondering: has the majority of people gone through a billing cycle yet? What I mean is, do you have a sense that they know about the relief options open to them? I'm only trying to understand how we ought to frame the count of accounts and balances that might eventually, perhaps 1 month from now, make use of these programs.
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. Great. I appreciate that question. We've leveraged our assets — our digital assets, social media channels, and so on — to communicate to our cardholders the benefits they can access if COVID-19 has affected them. So we do have this outreach effort. Of course, we're still fielding a substantial volume of calls at our call center. That means we're speaking with consumers about when they require it. In part, if you consider the dollar figure, it differs from several of our other competitors — our typical balance is far lower than theirs, because of the private label share. Yet even so, our retail Dual Cards are likewise more oriented toward a growth strategy at the lower end. So once more, 2% of the balances strikes us as fairly sensible; but everybody has gone through a billing cycle; and once more, I believe part of this is that as they move through it — we implemented this plan, I believe, on March 11 — we'll start seeing the impact. Clearly, some individuals have kept working for a stretch or perhaps are on a furlough arrangement; but they might only now be beginning to recognize that they need help, and we'll keep offering that help going forward; so that figure is going to rise. Still, once again, we're deploying our assets to ensure that customers who truly need forbearance are getting our support.
David Scharf
analystUnderstood. Understood. And then one more question regarding the retail partner side — I do appreciate the detail about how purchase volumes have trended in April so far. Setting aside for now the reality that digital is acting as something of an offset, I'd like to know, specifically in Retail Card and in, well, really in all 3 product segments, could you give something like a percentage for how many partners are actually shut down physically? Clearly, you've gained from exposure to discount clubs, home improvement, and locations that remain open and are considered essential services. I'm just trying to get a bit of a...
Margaret Keane
executiveYeah. We've been keeping track of that. That said, I'd say on the Retail Card side, most of them, even if they might be closed in person, still have some kind of digital channel. So that's part of what we're observing. It becomes somewhat more complex when it comes to Payment Solutions, since we have more than — nearly 200,000 merchants, so figuring out which ones are entirely shut or doing some business online is tough. Of course, there are certain situations where, I think, some of our partners lack online capability; and then clearly, with CareCredit, what we're really observing comes down to 2 things: emergency dental is continuing. Emergency care, that's still going on. Whether you believe it or not, there's been a modest uptick. For any of you with little ones at home, we've noticed a small rise in orthopedics. So folks are getting hurt while they're stuck at home and riding their bikes and such. So providing you with a figure is a bit difficult. What I'd say is that we're attempting, wherever digital capability exists, to work closely with those partners to ensure we're delivering. But — and it differs by region too, as you're aware. Some states remain open, with stores operating. So giving you a percentage or a number is a bit tough, given how much of a mix it is.
Vincent Caintic
analystJust a couple of quick items. So in terms of thinking through and understanding that drop in purchase volume, perhaps assets begin to contract. When it comes to the funding aspect of that, what's your approach regarding deposits and how you price them? And I suppose what I'm getting at is how far down would you be prepared to go on deposit pricing to get the right size if there's a surge?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. Appreciate that question, Vincent. So regarding how we view the funding side of the stack, obviously, given the economic climate we find ourselves in, we believe that tapping either the unsecured or secured market isn't as efficient from a cost standpoint. That means deposits, which made up 79% of the debt stack as of the end of the first quarter, will keep expanding, likely as a share of the total funding stack; so we'll aim to tilt somewhat more toward that. As far as we're concerned, it'll be — there are a few main rivals of ours in that space, and we intend to remain competitive there. That approach means we don't need to spend as heavily on marketing and similar efforts; so when it comes to rates, we've actually reduced them this year. On the subject of high yield savings, we've cut 30 basis points from the high yield savings. We also reduced at least 30 on our certificate deposit changes, on top of what we'd already lowered back in 2019. So we'll keep assessing that market, but that would be among our main sources in relation to that. So our expectation is that hopefully we can bring that down, or keep bringing it down, over the course of 2020.
Vincent Caintic
analystAll right. Then one more thing, a quick one, about RSAs. Looking at Slide 6 in your presentation, where it shows — let's say the net charge-off ratio stood at 11% back in 2009 while your RSAs were 1.5%. Does that link still hold up? Or is there a different way we should be looking at it?
Brian Wenzel
executiveRight. What I would say to you, Vincent, is plainly this: the RSAs are going to shift and act as that buffer against the cycle. So when charge-offs show up, you'll observe the RSA percentages coming down. As for the precise relationship between that percentage and the charge-off rate — once again, like I mentioned before on this call, given that Walmart isn't in the picture, and given that the economic circumstances differ greatly from the great financial crisis to today, I'd rather not make that direct connection, but the curve's shape will look comparable once the benefit flows through.
Dominick Gabriele
analystI truly appreciate all the specifics you laid out as well. When you consider the reserve builds driven by CECL as opposed to growth — for expansion versus shifts in your unemployment assumptions, with the drop in year-over-year purchase volume and the loan book possibly shrinking, wouldn't that give you a cushion when it comes to releasing reserves and lead to some very large quarter-over-quarter swings? So how do you think about — what's your approach to those 2 components? And do you consider them across the entire year rather than quarter by quarter? And it appears to me that maybe the reserve build might essentially be 0 for the whole year, given the possible decrease in the actual loans?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. First off, thanks for your question. I believe we need to be somewhat cautious here regarding data points, correct? We provided a snapshot to be transparent about what occurred between March 15 and March 31, with purchase volume falling 26%, and then during the first couple of weeks of April, dropping roughly 30% to 35%. What remains very unclear is when the mandates lift, right, and retail comes back online, what that retail landscape will look like and the shape of that curve; so I'm not necessarily certain. If I were in your position, I would be considering that we're going to see a 30% decline in retail purchase volume or purchase volume for the company for the rest of the year. So that's number one. Number two, you also need to keep in mind, during this period, when you're navigating an economic environment like the one we are, you are going to observe the payment rate decline; so you'll see an upward bias theoretically on the asset rate. So you have those 2 things moving against each other; it will then really depend on what for us, from a reserving standpoint, will be — as we think about the portfolio at that point in time, what is the economic assumption. So I'm not necessarily certain. I'd say, okay, your portfolio is going to decline, and therefore, you'll be at 0. There are several factors moving in different directions within that. Again, if you see a deterioration in the macroeconomic assumptions that we've used for March, you do see retail come back online, then I do believe you're going to see provisions for credit losses as we move forward.
Dominick Gabriele
analystGood. Thanks for clearing that up. Then I noticed your yields on consumer installment loans picked up quite a bit. Where do you see those yields heading over — is it that you expect more risk, so you raise the yield? Or how are you looking at that trajectory going forward? And can that hold up?
Brian Wenzel
executiveWhat's really behind that is the Yamaha disposition in the first quarter.
Greg Ketron
executiveWe have time for one more question.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystI'm hoping all of you are keeping well and safe. Margaret, I believe you said that the launches for Venmo and the Verizon product are still on schedule. When we consider — and you noted these are somewhat contingent on the shifting macro picture. When we consider whatever commitments you'd undertaken to expand the portfolio, how ought we to think about that? Then perhaps I'll follow with my second question tied to it. When we consider certain investment spending that you had — that your team was starting on, plus other wide-ranging investment outlays, how might we think about how adaptable those costs are given this backdrop?
Margaret Keane
executiveCertainly. Let me take the first one; so obviously, we felt tremendous excitement when we secured both Verizon and Venmo. And in my view, those represent 2 highly strategic programs for us as we keep working to truly expand our digital capabilities. So the agile teams dedicated to getting those 2 programs launched are moving at full speed, and we have not cut back on any emphasis. If anything, we might even be speeding up certain efforts there. So we're genuinely thrilled to be able to get them launched. Naturally, the launches will hinge on conditions, we believe midyear for Verizon and the second half for Venmo. So thrilled about those, and the teams are truly putting in hard work; regarding the remaining investments, it's somewhat like what Brian Doubles mentioned; we actually paused to reassess. And let me step back yet one more step. What we did as a leadership team, I mean in spite of all the negative developments occurring around pandemic, there are opportunities too, correct? And so what we genuinely attempted to do is step back and ask, how do we assign part of our leadership team to concentrate on the operation and get operations stabilized? We have a separate group working on what we'll look like as we emerge from this and how fast we emerge, and what initiatives we must have ready to emerge. And then third, what are the long-term opportunities and implications for the company? And so we've more or less arranged ourselves in that manner. And we have 7 work streams that Brian is heading to really kind of position us for the future. So Brian, I'm not sure if you'd like to add a bit more about our flexibility in some of the things we've been doing.
Brian Doubles
executiveRight, I believe that's accurate. So, like I mentioned before, we examined each strategic initiative across the company, and we evaluated them in light of the circumstances we're currently dealing with. Then we concluded, fine, certain ones require us to accelerate, given what our partners aim to accomplish while navigating this crisis. Meanwhile, a few others honestly simply aren't logical to pursue at this moment; those we'll defer, hold off on, put on hold, and so forth. And then a handful we'll merely keep going; Verizon and Venmo being instances of those we'll keep going, as Margaret noted, with a bit of unpredictability. But beyond that, we also concluded, fine, we must consider what comes after 2020. We must consider, once we get through this, what's the best way to set ourselves up going forward? And we concluded, look, there exist — we developed 7 or 8 separate work streams that truly span everything. And we concluded, never mind if this turns out V or U-shaped, we recognize that each facet of our operations will transform, to some extent, once we get past this. Consequently, our customers will engage with what we offer in new ways; we recognize they'll buy in new ways. Their spending habits will shift. Their payment methods will shift. We recognize our partners will emerge from this appearing different, and they'll adopt different approaches that we must adapt to. Plus we recognize the manner in which we collaborate as one team will shift too. So we examined those 3 wide categories, and we concluded, fine, we must establish a truly solid strategic plan and a vision for every single one of them so that we come out of this in the strongest possible position; and I believe as we progress through that effort, we'll clearly disclose more down the road.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystAnd so, as a bit of a follow-up to that point: are we to conclude that perhaps the cost base doesn't need as much downward realignment, in light of certain difficulties your retailers could be facing?
Margaret Keane
executiveNo. A realignment of our cost base is absolutely going to be necessary. I'd say we're simply — we're attempting to determine what this — we'd like to gain somewhat more insight into how it plays out; yet one matter that we — and we merely — when Walmart left, that's what we did; adjusting the cost base is something we understand well. Hiring has been frozen, meaning nobody is being brought on at present. All those sorts of measures were already taken right from the start. Naturally, we're achieving savings elsewhere, for instance on travel and similar items. However, we — should a reset of the business's cost base become necessary as we emerge from this, since we're smaller, that's what we'll do, and that remains our focus. That's part of what's among the work streams Brian has on his list as well.
Brian Wenzel
executiveBrian here, Sanjay. I suppose I should pick up right where you left off and wrap things up, correct? Now, regarding your initial inquiry about Verizon and Venmo, the schedule hasn't actually moved all that much if you consider what those two will cost — and I realize we're pointing to $0.20 a share across the year. There's the marketing research expense, the launch expense, the development expense needed to build out all the in-app features for, say, Venmo, which likewise has to happen, correct? The reallocation of the programs along with the reserves, which formed part of that expense, isn't all that substantial at this point. Like Margaret mentioned, we'll observe how the present situation unfolds — and whether a more meaningful change occurs there. And clearly we'll offer visibility once we reach our July call. So as far as where we began, there's essentially no deviation from, I believe, the guidance we gave earlier in the year. Next, simply to underscore what Margaret noted. Clearly, the evolution of the retail landscape and the evolution of the consumer — once we gain greater visibility into that, clearly, we'll aim to preserve the same kind of efficiency, and we'll navigate that since, clearly, substantial chunks are variable. Yet clearly, we might act on the fixed cost portion of the business so as to rightsize it. So that's my way of thinking about it.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystThat's great. My apologies. One final item, since I keep getting this one a lot. How are you approaching capital ratios and whether the dividend can be sustained? Clearly, Brian Wenzel, you mentioned the balance sheet getting smaller — how should we think about capital being freed up if that actually happens? Would that count as a form of excess capital, and so give you a buffer? Or perhaps you could just take us through what you're discussing with the regulators?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. Absolutely. On the capital side, capital is one thing that has been a strength since we separated from GE; we emerged with a CET1 capital ratio that was higher than we likely required; but we had to show we could function as a standalone public company and endure events such as this. So our end objective was genuinely to bring our capital ratios down toward those of our peers. That hasn't shifted because of this; we feel that as we enter this economic stretch, we have a substantial amount of capital to get through the storm. Clearly, the CECL transition is a help too. But over time we'll keep bringing that capital down toward peer levels. On your second point about the dividend, clearly, the dividend matters to us. When we consider the business and really the PPNR and how resilient the business is, we think we can keep generating capital. When we consider our priorities for deploying capital, growth of our existing programs comes first. The second is really the dividend; and as we stand here today, we believe we will keep paying that dividend given the current environment and given our forecast that we have the financial strength in capital and liquidity to keep doing so. And that is a top priority for us. And then as you go further, clearly, next would come share repurchases and then later on, whether it's portfolio acquisitions or M&A. But from the dividend standpoint, again, with the current environment and our assessment, we're committed to paying that dividend.
Greg Ketron
executiveWe appreciate all of you being with us today. Should you have any additional questions, our Investor Relations team will be on hand to address them.
Operator
operatorThanks a lot, everyone. That wraps up the call for today. We appreciate your joining us. You're free to hang up now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Synchrony Financial transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Synchrony Financial earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Synchrony Financial or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.