Synchrony Financial (SYF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

July 21, 2020

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Consumer Finance earnings 66 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Greg Ketron

executive
#1

Thank you, operator. Good morning to all of you, and it's a pleasure to have you on our quarterly earnings conference call. We appreciate you being here. Along with the press release issued today, we've made available a presentation that addresses the subjects we intend to discuss on this call. The press release, along with comprehensive financial schedules and the presentation, can be found on our site, synchronyfinancial.com. To view this material, simply navigate to the Investor Relations portion of that site. Before we begin, please allow me to note that forward-looking statements will be part of what we say today. Such statements carry risks and uncertainty, and results in reality may vary materially. The factors that could lead to actual results differing materially are set out in our SEC filings, which you can access on our website. Throughout this call, non-GAAP financial measures will be referenced as we discuss how the company performed. A reconciliation linking those measures to GAAP financial measures appears in our materials for today's call. Last, Synchrony Financial bears no responsibility for, and neither edits nor guarantees the accuracy of, earnings teleconference transcripts supplied by third parties. Webcasts that are authorized exist solely on our website. Joining us this morning are Margaret Keane; Brian Wenzel; and Brian Doubles. I'll hand the call over to Margaret now.

Margaret Keane

executive
#2

Thanks, Greg, and good morning to all of you. The last time we spoke, a global health crisis and widespread economic turmoil were confronting the world. Unfortunately, although we observed a few positive signs and started reopening across the U.S., the COVID-19 virus has come back, which keeps disrupting our lives, our businesses, and the economy. On top of that, after even more senseless deaths in the black community, our nation is waking up to the necessity of tackling racial injustice and inequality in a meaningful way. Both of these problems are tough, emotional, and require serious effort to solve. I take pride in the way Synchrony keeps managing successfully through these exceptionally difficult times. Putting people first drives every choice we make; when it comes to COVID, our attention is on the health and safety of our employees and their families, on supporting our customers, and on helping our partners resume operations. In the struggle for equality, we are putting new measures in place to bring more diverse talent into the workforce at every level, to expand business ties with diverse and small firms, to invest in diverse markets, and to collaborate with our partners, customers, and employees to confront gender and racial inequality that is deeply entrenched. With our values leading the way, we are determined to meet these challenges and come out as a stronger company and a stronger country. Now I'll move to the second quarter results on Slide 3. Earnings came to $48 million, or $0.06 per diluted share. That figure reflected a higher provision for credit losses stemming from this year's CECL implementation, totaling $483 million, or $365 million after tax, which cut EPS by $0.63. Results for this quarter were affected by the pandemic. Brian will walk through the trends later on the call, and I'll give you a high-level summary here. On a core basis, which leaves out Walmart and the Yamaha portfolios, COVID-19's impact produced a 3% decline in loan receivables, a 7% decline in interest and fees, a 13% decline in purchase volume, and a 5% decline in average active accounts. For the quarter, the efficiency ratio stood at 36.3%. Because of our liquidity and funding strategy, taken in response to COVID-19's effect on our balance sheet, deposits fell $1.5 billion, or 2%, compared with last year. That reflects a deliberate choice to slow overall deposit growth, given the excess liquidity on hand. We have kept direct deposits flat at last year's level of $53 billion. Our direct deposit platform is still a key funding source, and we will keep directing our efforts toward making our bank appealing to depositors. While we deal with the everyday realities of this new environment we all now inhabit, we are also sharply focused on where our business is headed. During the quarter, we extended several programs and brought on new partnerships, as you can see on the slide. We also carried out a successful launch of the new Verizon program. This initiative is something we take great pride in, and we collaborate intently with Verizon to build a distinctive, sturdy rewards offering for their cardholders, one that relies on straightforward, user-friendly tools for applying, purchasing, and servicing the Verizon visa card. Contained within this card is a strong value proposition, which provides consumer wireless customers with the means to reduce their monthly Verizon bills via rewards accumulated from everyday spending, along with the liberty to direct those rewards toward Verizon purchases, such as bill payments plus the newest phones and accessories. On top of that, the Verizon visa card genuinely answers what consumers are seeking at this moment: a contactless, frictionless and digital-first experience. Our new program with Venmo also has us enthusiastic, and we keep working alongside them to roll out their new program, something we expect to happen later this year. Across the quarter, we likewise delivered $128 million in capital back through common stock dividends. The strength of our business pleases us, and we are well positioned to keep assisting our cardholders and partners as they navigate these challenging times. We stay highly focused on digital innovation, on accelerating our data analytics capability and on creating frictionless customer experiences, all of which are key to our programs succeeding and to winning new partnerships. I'm going to turn the call over to Brian Doubles to discuss some of the key highlights in this area.

Brian Doubles

executive
#3

Thanks, Margaret. As we've talked about before, the shift to digital has been going on for quite a few years. And often, the pandemic sped up changes that were already happening. It's obvious that a lot of these fresh patterns and how our consumers act are here to stay, and a new normal will emerge, particularly when it comes to shopping online and the growing desire among consumers for touch-free buying and payment choices. Research shows that people are altering how they shop, and that touch-free payments are growing more critical, as the information on the slide demonstrates. The reality that consumers want and are swiftly embracing touch-free options is driving more demand for our partners to provide secure and effective touch-free experiences. We're in a strong spot to handle these shifting behaviors. And we've moved fast to answer this need with committed teams and funding to back our partners and cardholders throughout this period of swift change. As you're aware, we've been putting money into our digital tools and skills, and we realized early on in the pandemic that we'd have to act even faster to assist our partners and help them speed up their own digital shift; we promptly went through every strategic project in the company and shifted resources and agile teams to speed up our work on crucial digital efforts. We think we're in a one-of-a-kind spot to rise to this occasion and its enduring impact. Information reveals that the large majority of consumers intend to keep up their digital habits once the pandemic ends, and we're ready to assist our partners in preparing for today's new reality and what lies ahead. Boosting digital sales penetration remains essential to our achievement with both current partners and our more recent programs. In Retail Card, digital sales penetration came to 48% in the second quarter, and digital applications made up roughly 70% of all our applications, which is 14 percentage points above the prior quarter. The mobile channel by itself rose 43% versus the same quarter a year ago, not counting Walmart. Moreover, over 60% of all payments on our cardholders' accounts happen digitally. We keep giving partners and customers more digital choices, from applying on their own devices, adding a new card to their digital wallet, using contactless cards and paying. We think customers will keep adjusting to whatever feels more comfortable for them. A lot of our partners have been with us for many years. We've been around to help them expand their operations, and now we're here to help them deal with the hurdles of the new landscape; we're stepping up our work to give our partners and their customers creative services and products they can rely on amid this disruption. Our spending on our digital tools has shown itself to be incredibly worthwhile in helping them serve their customers and boost sales. This really shows what our flexible setup makes possible, since it allows us to provide solutions in real time, and it also reflects the commitment of our teams, who never stop putting in effort to back our partners along with the customers those partners serve. So with that said, I'll now hand things over to Brian Wenzel.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#4

Thanks, Brian, and good morning to all of you. Let me take a moment to add to what Margaret mentioned earlier regarding the two-fold crisis our country is confronting. We're committed to protecting the wellbeing of our employees and assisting our partners and customers in achieving success throughout this period. Our dedication to pursuing real progress in the battle for racial equality within our organization and in the neighborhoods where we work and reside has only grown stronger. Against a background of unmatched ambiguity and market swings, I have never felt more pride in our company and our team, the principles we uphold and our dedication to inclusion that sits at the core of our identity. Now let's move to the financial results for Q2. I'll begin with Slide 5 in the deck. To start, I'd like to address several of the patterns we're observing from COVID-19's effects in terms of purchase volume, and I felt it was valuable to give an update on how accounts that got forbearance are performing. Slide 5 displays purchase volume growth versus the prior year for the entire company during the quarter, along with purchase volume broken out by sales platform going back to January. For the whole company and across each platform, purchase volume growth was robust, reaching double digits from January until the middle of March. During the latter part of March, when government restrictions escalated, travel, entertainment and event activity dropped sharply, and a large number of nonessential retail locations shut down. Elective healthcare services were also cut back considerably. Consequently, purchase volume fell dramatically, dropping by as much as 31% during the first half of April for the entire company. And when examining the complete month of April by sales platform, Retail Card was down 21%, Payment Solutions was down 41% and CareCredit was down 60%. CareCredit took the biggest hit, with a major drop in spending on elective and planned procedures across dental and medical services throughout this stretch. Retail Card fared comparatively well because of a greater mix of digital volume and because it has programs that gained from higher spending on essential goods, including grocery, supplies and home-related purchases. As consumers grew more at ease with stay-at-home orders and the initial reopening phases took place in May and June, we observed purchase volume bouncing back as the second quarter went on. During the latter half of June, total purchase volume rose 3% compared with the same period a year earlier, and all 3 sales platforms experienced a substantial rebound in purchase volume from the April low point. Now let's look at a few of the other major business metrics for the quarter. New accounts were down 36% and purchase volume per account was down 8%, which mirrors the effect of the crisis along with the underwriting measures we implemented as the pandemic's effects unfolded over the quarter. We did observe a 4% rise in the average balance per account, driven by a blend of portfolio mix from our digital and retail partners and also by lower-than-normal volume in new accounts. Although these patterns give us reason for optimism, a great deal of ambiguity remains regarding what happens once stimulus programs and sector-wide forbearance practices wind down. That said, because of how our business is composed — with a significant digital piece and a range of different segments — we are situated to gain from spending in categories like household-related purchases and animal care services, which should soften a portion of the downturn's consequences. The final outcome remains mostly unclear since how long the pandemic lasts and how severe it becomes are still largely unknown as of now. Turning to Slide 6. We show the effect on, and results of, accounts that received forbearance versus those that did not. As of June 30, forbearance had been extended to a cumulative roughly 1.7 million accounts, representing $3.2 billion in account balances at the moment forbearance was granted; close to 70% of those accounts had exited forbearance by June 30, which left about 500,000 accounts, or $1.1 billion in account balances, still in forbearance. As of mid-July, those figures had stayed fairly steady. Among accounts that entered forbearance, 92% were either current or fewer than 30 days delinquent, meaning only a comparatively small share were 30-plus days past due. If you examine certain performance traits, the patterns you observe are unsurprising. Credit line utilization is elevated while payment rates are reduced. Regarding the effect on financial results, altogether we waived $47 million in late fees and $20 million in interest through the close of the second quarter. On the trend side, we are observing a significant drop in the count of accounts entering forbearance from a high point in late March to early April, when nearly 40,000 accounts were enrolling each day. By June, that had fallen to under 10,000 daily. Turning to payment patterns for June, close to 70% of accounts that entered forbearance were making payments. 8% of those accounts paid off their balance entirely, another 61% were making payments, which left 31% of enrolled accounts making no payments. From a credit standpoint, 56% of enrollees had a FICO score of 660 or lower when they enrolled. For accounts that have left the forbearance program, their credit performance is marginally worse than other comparable accounts. Accounts that exited forbearance show a 3x rise in the rate of entering delinquency; nevertheless, because the accounts have only been off forbearance for a short period, it is not clear right now how they will ultimately perform with respect to delinquency. It should be noted that although performance is generally weaker than for similar accounts, it has not materially affected our 30-plus delinquency metrics, which got better during the second quarter. I will discuss our delinquency results later on in the presentation. We will keep monitoring closely how accounts in forbearance perform, along with those that have left forbearance, and we remain prepared to offer help to affected cardholders. Turning to Slide 7 for our second quarter financial results. Earlier today, we announced earnings for the second quarter of $48 million, equating to $0.06 per diluted share. That figure reflects a higher provision for credit losses stemming from our adoption of CECL this year. That increase totaled $483 million, or $365 million on an after-tax basis, which cut EPS by $0.63. As we show on Slide 8, COVID-19 affected our growth across multiple areas. Excluding the Walmart and Yamaha portfolios — what we call our core basis — loan receivables fell 3%, while interest and fees on loans dropped 7%. Also on a core basis, purchase volume declined 13%, and average active accounts were 5% lower than a year ago. On Slide 7, we've shown purchase volumes and loan receivable balances for dual and co-branded cards so you can see the diversification these products give us. Dual and co-branded cards represented 34% of purchase volume in the second quarter, a decline of 22% versus the prior year. Measured by loan receivables, they made up 23% of the portfolio and were down 4% from the prior year. As I mentioned earlier, COVID-19's impact picked up speed throughout March and April, though we observed some encouraging signals in these metrics during May and June.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#5

We should also point out that although these metrics are trending positively, how long the pandemic lasts and how big its impact will be are still mostly unclear, so giving a more exact estimate of the effects right now remains hard. RSAs fell by $86 million, a 10% drop compared with last year. For the quarter, RSAs represented 4.0% of average receivables, which is beginning to show how COVID-19 is affecting program performance. Our provision for credit losses rose $475 million, or 40%, versus last year. That rise comes mainly from a bigger reserve for the expected effect of COVID-19-related losses, plus the prior-year reserve cut tied to Walmart that came to $247 million. The reserve build in the second quarter reached $627 million, mostly because of the projected impact of COVID-19-related losses. Other income went up by $5 million. Other expense declined $73 million, or 7%, chiefly because of cost cuts stemming from the Walmart sale, the lower purchase volume and average active accounts seen during the quarter, and decreases in certain discretionary spending; those declines were partly offset by higher operational losses, costs tied to our COVID-19 response, and charitable contributions. Turning to our platform results on Slide 9. As I mentioned earlier, the sales platform was affected to differing degrees by COVID-19. In Retail Card, core loan receivables dropped 4%, with strong growth in our digital programs partly offsetting the COVID-19 impact. Other metrics declined, pushed down by the Walmart portfolio sale and the effect of COVID-19. Even though Payment Solutions felt the impact of COVID-19, strength in powersports produced a 1% increase in core loan receivables. Interest and fees on loans fell 8%, mainly because of lower late fees. Purchase volume dropped 19%, and average active accounts fell 3%; during this quarter we signed several new programs and renewed key partnerships, as shown on Slide 3. We keep generating growth organically through our partnerships and networks, and we added nearly 4,000 new merchants in the quarter. These networks, together with other efforts such as encouraging greater card reuse, which now accounts for roughly 30% of purchase volume excluding oil and gas, keep building a strong foundation of business for the future. CareCredit took the biggest hit from COVID-19 in the second quarter. But as I said earlier, we did see some encouraging signs in the trends as the quarter went on, as providers started offering discretionary and planned services. Receivables fell 5%, and we did see growth in veterinary specialties that partly offset the negative effect of COVID-19. Interest and fees on loans dropped 4%, mainly because of lower merchant discount resulting from the decline in purchase volume, which was down 31%. Average active accounts fell 2%. We continue to grow our CareCredit network and the usefulness of our card, as we added more than 2,000 new provider locations to our network during this quarter. Our network build-out contributed to pushing the reuse rate up to 60% of purchase volume during Q2. Turning to Slide 10, I'll walk through net interest income and margin trends. Net interest income came in 18% lower versus a year ago, mainly because interest and fees on loan receivables fell 18%, which reflects the Walmart portfolio sale, COVID-19's impact, and lower benchmark rates. On a core basis, interest and fees on loan receivables were down 7%. Net interest margin stood at 13.53% versus 15.75% a year ago, largely attributable to COVID-19's effect on receivables plus higher liquidity, fee and interest waivers, and lower benchmark rates. Loan receivables as a share of total earning assets dropped from 83.9% to 78%, reflecting greater liquidity during the quarter; that shift drove 113 basis points of the net interest margin decline. Fee and interest waivers tied to forbearance, which I mentioned earlier, drove 24 basis points of the net interest margin decline. A drop in loan receivables yield, chiefly from lower benchmark rates and the Walmart portfolio sale, drove 101 basis points of the reduction in net interest margin. Investment securities yield fell because of lower benchmark rates and drove 32 basis points of net interest margin decline. These pressures were partly offset by total interest-bearing liabilities cost falling 58 basis points to 2.15%, mostly from lower benchmark rates and reduced deposit pricing; that gave a 48 basis point lift to net interest margin. Now I'll discuss key credit trends on Slide 11; regarding specific dynamics this quarter, I'll begin with delinquency trends. The 30-plus delinquency rate came in at 3.13% versus 4.43% a year ago. And the 90-plus delinquency rate was 1.77% versus 2.16% a year ago. Excluding the Walmart portfolio's impact, the 30-plus delinquency rate dropped roughly 90 basis points, while the 90-plus delinquency rate fell roughly 10 basis points versus a year ago. Turning to net charge-off trends. The net charge-off rate was 5.35% versus 6.01% a year ago. The decline in net charge-off rate stemmed mainly from the Walmart sale and better credit trends. Excluding the Walmart portfolio's impact, the net charge-off rate was about 20 basis points below a year ago. Allowance for credit losses as a percent of loan receivables was 12.52% post-CECL implementation. Excluding CECL's effects, the allowance under the ALLL method would have been 7.91%. Reserve build in Q2 was $627 million under CECL and $144 million under the ALLL method. Overall reserve provisioning exceeded expectations because of COVID-19's impact, which drove most of the reserve build in Q2. To sum up, Q2 trends remained solid, with forbearance delivering some benefit to delinquency trends. Looking ahead, we anticipate that COVID-19 is going to have an effect on general credit patterns. Now on Slide 12. I'll go through this quarter's expenses. On the whole, our expenses declined $73 million, which is 7% compared with a year ago, landing at just under $1 billion for the quarter. The decrease came primarily from the cost cuts tied to Walmart, the reduced purchase volume and average active accounts we saw during the quarter, along with decreases in some discretionary spending. That was partly offset by greater expenses from operational losses and certain outlays connected to how we responded to COVID-19. For the second quarter, the efficiency ratio came in at 36.3%, compared with 31.3% a year earlier. Higher expenses from operational losses, certain costs tied to our COVID-19 response, and charitable contributions weighed on that ratio. If you set aside those effects, the efficiency ratio would have been lower by 260 basis points, or roughly 33.7%. Turning to Slide 13. With our loan receivables having declined and the strength of our deposit platform, we kept building liquidity through the second quarter. Although we believe holding higher liquidity is wise given how much uncertainty and volatility there is, we are actively managing our funding profile so that excess liquidity is mitigated.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#6

So because of that approach, the way our funding is mixed shifted during the quarter. Deposits were down $1.5 billion from a year earlier. We also shrank our securitized funding sources by $3.9 billion and our unsecured funding sources by $1.3 billion. That leaves deposits making up 80% of our funding versus 75% a year ago, while securitized and unsecured funding each accounted for 10% of our funding sources when the quarter ended. Even though we curbed deposit growth overall in the second quarter because we had excess liquidity, we kept direct deposit flat at last year's $53 billion. Total liquidity, which includes undrawn credit facilities, came to $28.0 billion, equal to 29% of our assets. That's higher than 22% a year ago. Before I get into our capital position, I should note that we chose to take the benefit of the transition rules put out by the joint federal banking agencies in March, and that comes with 2 primary benefits: first, it pushes back the effects of the transition adjustment by an incremental 2 years; and second, it lets the portion of the current period provisioning under CECL be deferred and amortized along with the transition adjustment. Under this framework, we finished the first quarter at 15.3% CET1 under the CECL transition rules, 100 basis points higher than last year's 14.3%. The Tier 1 capital ratio came in at 16.3% under the CECL transition rules versus 14.3% a year ago, which reflects the preferred stock issuance last November. The total capital ratio also rose 200 basis points, to 17.6%, again reflecting the preferred issuance. And the Tier 1 capital ratio plus reserves ratio, on a fully phased-in basis, climbed to 26.5% from 20.8% a year ago, reflecting the higher reserves from implementing CECL and the preferred stock issuance. During the quarter, we paid a common stock dividend of $0.22 per share. Last quarter, we announced that because of current economic uncertainty and wanting to be as prudent as possible, we decided to stop further share repurchases, so that we have greater visibility into how big the impact of COVID-19 will ultimately be on the economic environment; we'll keep evaluating this going forward. On the whole, we're still executing the strategy we laid out earlier. We're committed to keeping a strong balance sheet with diversified funding sources and to operating with strong capital and liquidity levels. To wrap up, given how many uncertainties exist around how severe and how long the COVID-19 pandemic will be, and the impacts that actions such as the CARES Act, payment assistance for consumers and other government and regulatory actions may have, it remains very difficult to assess the ultimate impact right now and to give specifics around key outlook drivers. Like we did last quarter, I want to offer a framework to help you think about the impacts on our key outlook drivers. On the topic of growth in loan receivables, the pandemic hit purchase volume hard, especially toward the end of Q1 and heading into Q2. Then, once businesses started reopening, purchase volume began trending positively and improving. If businesses stay open, we anticipate that pattern to hold. That said, the rising COVID-19 infection counts we're observing across the country, along with how people respond, will shape whether the recovery keeps going and could bring about additional volatility down the road. What keeps supporting our trends and our resiliency is growth in digital, the diversity within our platforms, and financing in essential categories like home and health care. We'll keep drawing on our capabilities and expertise to assist our partners and providers through this challenging time. The overall trajectory of purchase volume will play a major role in shaping our receivable growth rate. A number of factors have weighed on our net interest margin, among them the liquidity that has built up on our balance sheet and the smaller size of our receivables; lower benchmark rates stemming from the Fed's rate cuts, affecting our receivables and investment security yields; and the effect of forbearance in the form of interest and fee waivers for a temporary stretch. Looking ahead, we'll keep exploring ways to put our excess liquidity to work, and the impact of forbearance ought to diminish; we do anticipate a boost to net interest margin from greater interest income and fees tied to a growing number of accounts in our loan receivable portfolio, plus continued lower interest expense. Lastly, it's worth noting that we also share the effect on revenues and funding costs via the RSA. When it comes to RSAs, beyond sharing the net interest income effects, we also see an effect from elevated credit costs. How large the credit cost impact ultimately is, and its timing, will be shaped in part by the anticipated deterioration in credit as stimulus measures and industry-wide forbearance assistance fade. Although we expect the net charge-off rate to climb as the year goes on, it's worth noting that overall portfolio quality and credit trends were strong when we entered this pandemic and kept improving during the second quarter. In addition, the tools and capabilities we've previously highlighted will help us better steer through the economic effects of COVID-19. Lastly, we also believe higher recoveries will eventually come to pass, partly offsetting the effect of greater losses. Although we continue to expect reserve builds to stay elevated going forward, we can't offer more specific guidance until we get more visibility into how long and how severe the current pandemic turns out to be, along with the effects of stimulus and industry-wide forbearance. Once we have better visibility, we'll be better positioned to lay out expected net charge-off and reserve build expectations for the periods ahead. On the efficiency ratio, activity levels will affect both revenue and expense levels, and we would seek to offset some of that effect through chances to cut expenses. A thorough examination of the cost structure we operate under has been completed, and on account of a decrease in the mix within our portfolio of loans receivable, we are putting together a series of steps aimed at bringing those operating expenses to the appropriate size. At its core, the business continues to be solid and able to withstand pressure, and we are navigating this circumstance from a position of strength when it comes to our balance sheet, capital, and liquidity; having said that, I will now hand the call back to Margaret.

Margaret Keane

executive
#7

Appreciate that, Brian. I'll do a brief closing summary, and after that we'll take questions from participants. Like we've mentioned, how much this crisis ultimately affects us is still hard to pin down at this point. Therefore, let me repeat that in our view, we hold a favorable position for getting through this pandemic unlike anything we've seen. From a credit standpoint, we sit in a strong place thanks to adjustments implemented since the financial crisis, along with certain more targeted tweaks we've carried out over recent years — and which we keep carrying out given how the business environment currently looks; our model puts partners at the center, and we take a nimble approach across every operation and investment we make. The strength of our digital tools and holdings has allowed us to secure key digital partnerships, and it also plays a crucial role in assisting our partners as they move sales toward online and mobile channels. Right now our attention is on getting things done while keeping the future in mind, putting money into investments, developing skills, rolling out initiatives and implementing the essential transformations needed so that we come out of this pandemic standing stronger. I'm grateful that you joined the call today, and I wish good health and safety to you and your loved ones. At this point I'll hand things back to Greg so we can begin the Q&A.

Greg Ketron

executive
#8

Those are all the remarks we have about the quarter. At this point we're going to move into Q&A. <<operator_script>> Operator, kindly open up the Q&A session.

Sanjay Sakhrani

analyst
#9

My first question, I suppose, concerns pre-provision earnings. There are many items that you, Brian Wenzel, set out. Yet when we consider loan growth, recognizing it shifts around a bit, the purchase volume figures are heartening. What should our view be on pre-provision earnings moving ahead? Did the second quarter mark the lowest point? Or might additional pressure lie in wait?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#10

To begin, taking volume first, once more we observed favorable movement during the quarter, going from a bottom in early April to a rise of 3% by late June. Come July, I'd estimate we're roughly at negative 2%, which somewhat captures certain uncertainty and volatility. Still, at present it's broadly within plus or minus 2% to 3%; and our thinking on that pattern is genuinely somewhat unclear as the quarter progresses and as the pandemic and its economic consequences unfold. The payment rate has remained robust; yet clearly, when viewed through a seamless lens and an industry-wide forbearance lens, those may diminish here, which ideally will eventually lower the payment rate. Thus when we consider receivable growth, it's somewhat unclear, since numerous factors are pulling in different directions. Regarding the business's margin, honestly, we believe this is likely a bottom, given receivables fell by close to $5 billion from one quarter to the next, and we attempt to eliminate as much of that liquidity as possible. We'll keep trying to eliminate it. Consequently the effect felt in the quarter, which came purely from greater liquidity, the 113 basis points, ought to start diminishing here in the third quarter. And once more, as we progress into the fourth quarter and then early next year, the 24 basis points from forbearance should, largely, be diminished here in the third quarter by now. So from a margin standpoint, I believe we've essentially reached that floor and will move upward from there; concerning credit, clearly, we've performed well on credit. Delinquencies are 90 basis points improved excluding Walmart. They truly haven't been affected by forbearance, and we can discuss that afterward. Yet forbearance hasn't produced that effect. It's genuinely once we begin seeing those patterns flow through. So from a charge-off standpoint, we don't anticipate charge-offs actually climbing here, perhaps in the later portion of '20, but more so in the first half of '21. On expenses, we will keep taking a truly proactive stance to control certain discretionary costs. Like I mentioned during the prepared remarks, we are conducting a thorough examination of our costs and genuinely examining more structural items so that we can remove additional expense, truly to mirror the shift in the share our platforms represent within the overall mix of our portfolio. Therefore, we anticipate returning with a set of measures that we can genuinely implement during the later portion of '20 and on into '21, in order to bring expenses down and return that efficiency ratio to the level at which it would typically operate. So once more, I believe there are certain favorable developments emerging here, yet without question, the ambiguity surrounding purchase volume and, indeed, payment behavior patterns is what matters most to us during the second half of the year.

Sanjay Sakhrani

analyst
#11

Understood. My next question concerns the reserve builds. Brian, I believe you mentioned that credit quality migration remains somewhat of a moving target going forward. Still, when we consider reserve builds based on the macro assumption you applied, do you feel at ease with the build you have completed, assuming nothing shifts in that macro assumption? You would not anticipate additional reserve builds. Perhaps you could also address that macro assumption.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#12

Certainly. Certainly. Sanjay, allow me to begin with the macro assumption. We run several economic scenarios, and we truly developed a base case, plus we have a few downside scenarios and, I would describe, one upside scenario. To orient ourselves, for the first quarter, we applied a model that basically had unemployment reaching its peak during the second quarter, near 10%. Yet once more, as I mentioned, what matters most is really where you finish '20, 21 and '22, where unemployment stood at the close of '20 at 7%, then 4.5% in '22. Clearly, looking at assumptions now, they have worsened since that March 31 date. Therefore, what we did was step away, and we adopted the Moody's baseline model as our point of departure, despite the fact that they released revisions during June and July that were somewhat favorable, we remain with the Moody's baseline; and then basically, we modeled onto that unemployment. We effectively reallocated unemployment to account for forbearance, to account for stimulus. Thus, at year-end, considering our unemployment exiting 2020, it stands at 11.5%, 9.3% in 2021 and 6.4% in '22. And we truly do not return to an unemployment rate below 5% until 2023. So I believe, considering how we approached the macroeconomic environment, we envisioned a slower recovery with possibly a larger effect on unemployment. What will be crucial for us is how that unemployment actually evolves and whether you observe a greater, what I would term, higher income, unemployment entering the picture later in the year as you perhaps shift out some lower income individuals. So that will be one variable. When you consider the reserve build, then, for us it truly boils down to a platform mix, since clearly, we have platforms that draw a higher CECL reserve, CareCredit and Payment Solutions. So a portion of this will be mix-related. Under CECL, we anticipate reserves to be elevated on a typical basis; so once more, I think, we have taken the best estimate of the macroeconomic environment as it currently stands, but it will truly revert to delinquency formation and loss formation as we exit '20.

Moshe Orenbuch

analyst
#13

To kick things off, I was hoping you might be able to spend a moment on something — Margaret, you brought up the partner-centric strategy, and how it could shape the back half of the year? The Verizon card is out there now. You also have Venmo in the mix. How should we frame what Brian was referring to regarding the current volume levels, given that partner-centric activity in the back half?

Margaret Keane

executive
#14

Sure. I'd frame it as really 3 pieces, correct? Retail Card, Payment Solutions and CareCredit. In every one of those, I'd say each platform is performing pretty well. Looking back at everything we've been through, we've really tried hard to stay deeply involved and keep a tight relationship with our partners. As you were saying, we were able to get Verizon up and running — something I like to call our first pandemic-era launch when I talk about it with the team — and from an execution standpoint, it went incredibly well. Obviously, Verizon is still working out how to get every one of their locations reopened, so what Brian brought up before about our ability to operate in a fully digital way — I see that as a major positive for us, since we pulled off a launch that succeeded, and we feel great about the program along with where its growth is headed, considering the circumstances we're facing today. Regarding Venmo, there's quite a bit happening right now. Of course, we've needed to move everything over to an agile, virtual setup. That transition has truly been remarkable, and our teams are carrying out that plan. As you're aware, with both of these, our goal is to give the consumer a completely digital, integrated experience, which I believe reduces pressure on physical locations given how things keep shifting between being open and shut. So our outlook there is optimistic. We've focused heavily on the front end of our business regarding fraud, since that's an area where I believe everyone is feeling significant pressure, to make sure we're bringing in the right accounts. We're pleased with the tools and techniques we've managed to implement in order to genuinely get this program off the ground. That applies mainly to the Retail Card side. When it comes to Payment Solutions and CareCredit, I'd mention a few things. We're collaborating very closely with these partners; in fact, we conducted several seminars in health, especially within our CareCredit business, to assist the offices as they reopened. We laid out our plans. There are people assigned to the effort around getting our workplaces open again — though none have actually opened so far — and the measures we've established, the processes. What we're aiming for is to bring things together in a way where we assist them in handling the strain they're facing when they come back up, and at the same time make certain we're giving them the digital capabilities they'll require as they move away from being purely brick-and-mortar toward more online operations, especially within our Payment Solutions platform. There's a committed team working on creating a brand-new digital POS for that platform, and we believe it will deliver substantial returns by the end of this year as well as heading into the beginning of next year. So one action we took involved stepping back deliberately and taking a real, honest look at the initiatives we had in progress. We've also sharpened our emphasis considerably throughout the whole digital portion of our operations, so that in terms of both digital capabilities and data, we're backing those partners as they continue reopening and work through all the difficulties involved in closing down and restarting, while ensuring we're able to serve their customers digitally. So it's tightly integrated, with plenty of discussions, and we feel quite positive about what we've achieved up to now.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#15

Absolutely. Moshe, one more item worth mentioning regarding CareCredit: we're thrilled to share news about AdventHealth. As far as the health systems side goes, we now count Kaiser Permanente, Cleveland Clinic, and Advent among our partners, and having the chance to enter that channel and genuinely assist our customers while they deal with medical expenses right now is fantastic. In that business, we're assembling a network of a truly distinct kind, collaborating tightly with them to bring it online alongside several other strong health systems nationwide.

Margaret Keane

executive
#16

What I would say is really impressive is that our teams managed to get these transactions done while the pandemic was going on, at a time when plenty of these organizations are facing significant difficulties of their own. That really demonstrates the ties we have established, and how much trust we've earned in this sector up to now, in terms of our capacity to work with them at that kind of level throughout this stretch.

Moshe Orenbuch

analyst
#17

All right. It seems your significance to them has grown. Brian, I just want to ask a brief follow-up regarding that reserving question you addressed earlier. At 12.5% — I mean, the typical duration of your portfolio sits somewhere around — I'm not sure whether it got shorter during this stretch, but previously you figured it was roughly 1.7 to 1.8 years. Given that 12.5% reserve, can we draw any conclusion about where peak loss rates might land in 2021?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#18

Yeah. Moshe, I'd say drawing that conclusion is quite hard, since none of the trended data has truly emerged yet. And that will really determine where we observe certain pressures accumulating. Certainly, if you consider our CareCredit and Payment Solutions, those assets have longer durations and involve promotional financing. Clearly, on the front end we're able to manage origination there, yet that book is going to require a longer stretch of time. The encouraging aspect, I believe, is that looking at the Retail Card book, clearly we've left the Walmart portfolio behind, which carries greater loss content, and have truly shifted into what I would describe as portfolios that grow faster and are more stable; and I think if you examine the FICO mix, our FICO mix for the first quarter on a sub-660 basis is now 300 basis points stronger than just 24% of the total. So we're pleased with our position. I think, ideally, the macroeconomic assumptions we're using are the worst case; but once more, we'll keep watching those going forward; so before we witness some of that trended data and delinquency formation occurring, providing you that guidance for '21 is somewhat difficult right now.

John Hecht

analyst
#19

To begin with, Brian, I believe you said — correct me if that's not accurate — that in Q2, the real purchase volume through the digital channel rose compared to the same period last year. So first, did I get that right? And secondly, regarding that channel, could you discuss what the main driving factors are? In other words, does most of it originate from e-commerce sites such as Amazon and PayPal, or is it spread more widely? Some detail on that would help.

Brian Doubles

executive
#20

Absolutely, happy to. Brian Doubles here. Let me take that first. In Retail Card, the online sales penetration rate came to 48%. To offer some historical context, only a couple of years back, that figure was sitting in the mid-20% range. So we're quite pleased with that expansion. For e-commerce sales nationally, the typical figure has generally fallen in that 15% to 20% range. That should give you a solid point of comparison. So I certainly believe we are over-indexing in that channel. This year, I think it's broader than only Amazon and PayPal, for sure. Thinking about the pandemic, truly, it has simply sped up a digital transformation that was already in progress. So, as Margaret more or less pointed out, what we did very early on was go through each strategic project in the business, and we asked, alright, how can we best assist our partners by helping them speed up their digital transformation? So we proceeded project by project; we reassigned agile teams; we collaborated with all of our partners — big partners, small partners, providers and CareCredit — to help determine how we could best assist them. So we allocated more resources, more investment, reallocated things toward items like Digital Apply, Digital Buy, speeding up many projects that were already underway. So it's broader-based than merely the fact that we've been attempting to engage more and win more programs in the digital-only space. We're genuinely helping our omnichannel partners transform their business and determine how we can best assist them in that transmission.

John Hecht

analyst
#21

That's quite useful. Brian Wenzel, I think I have another follow-up about provisioning. I'm just trying to get a sense of how you're thinking about the different risk factors for people who requested deferrals versus those who didn't; and on that note, could you discuss the provision this quarter — maybe what piece was a specific provision tied to the deferral group, and what piece was a general provision tied purely to uncertainty and risk in the broader environment?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#22

Yes. Great, great, John. Let me start with how forbearance played through. I think we try to give you some detail on the accounts that went into forbearance. Among the accounts that came in, only 8% were delinquent at the time they entered forbearance. And while they had higher credit line utilization and payment rates, what we've seen is that after they leave forbearance, their performance was a bit weaker than comparable groups in the portfolio, though not materially weaker. So their entry into delinquency is about 3x. But when you look at the accounts coming out of forbearance and factor in what's already in our delinquency, less than 6 basis points is currently in delinquency for accounts that had been in forbearance. And if you took that whole 8% and pushed it all the way through, it's less than 20 basis points. So for the $2 billion that has rolled out so far, forbearance has had no impact. Of course, we'll need to monitor how that develops. These accounts are early in really performing after exiting the program; but we're encouraged by the number of people — the 8% who have paid in full and the 61% who continue making payments. So in our case, forbearance has clearly been a benefit to our cardholders. What we can't know is the total forbearance they're receiving from participants across the industry. That will have an effect, then. So when you think about the reserve provisioning in 2022's quarter, the overwhelming majority reflects deterioration in the macroeconomic assumptions fed into our model. We did include some qualitative amount for forbearance, but that's only a small share of the reserve build.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#23

I've got a question about RSA. When we look at the second half of the year, I believe you previously shared some expectations regarding how RSA should be viewed across the second half compared with the first half. Could you talk a bit about what you see as the drivers there as we head into 2H?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#24

Absolutely, Betsy. Clearly, no specific guidance has been given by us, largely since a portion of what's unknown ties directly to credit; however, when I consider our framework and how RSA ought to be viewed for the back half of this year and really going into 2021, program performance comes first. That means how the loan receivables actually evolve here, and even more significantly, how the net interest margin returns and how it progresses once you start seeing delinquency emerge — clearly, our partner share on that revenue side of things. Credit costs, clearly, will play a bigger role more likely in '21. So from a net credit write-off standpoint, you'll likely observe a continued increased benefit through the RSA during the back half of the year. When you consider reserve provisioning, which is, sadly, perhaps the biggest wildcard in this situation, what you find is — first off, a platform mix problem, correct? Thus, up to now, we've probably recorded more of the CECL benefit actually residing in CareCredit and Payment Solutions, since those draw a higher CECL reserve provisioning because of the duration and character of those assets. Within the Retail Card portfolio, everything ultimately depends on which partners flow in there. As we're aware, certain partners share in the reserve, certain partners do not share in the reserve; and sadly, as things stand today, we're only making estimates concerning how delinquency formation occurs and how that feeds into loss content as we build toward 2021; so variable pieces exist here. So I believe there's a bit of a timing element where RSA's impact could be delayed. Still, we truly need to see where those 2 land from a reserve standpoint. Yet again, we're hoping to advance on a NIM basis, and charge-offs might create slight upward pressure on the RSA from a performance angle alone, before you even factor in reserves.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#25

All right, understood. And then, Margaret, near the close of May you participated in a genuinely fascinating podcast with ICE, and it contains quite a bit of information about your thinking on this topic. So I was curious — at a certain moment, someone asked what effect the pandemic has on Synchrony. And within your response, you mention becoming a smaller organization. But I'm wondering whether there was additional nuance on that point that you might share, or whether your perspective has shifted since perhaps conditions between now and the end of May aren't quite so harsh.

Margaret Keane

executive
#26

Yes. I believe what I was actually getting at is that our assets have clearly contracted somewhat. And because of that, as Brian mentioned, we will need to undertake a reset of expenses and get ourselves aligned so that we preserve the return of the business in the range we prefer. I think it resembles any challenging circumstance. I think people step up when called upon, and we can genuinely pause and ask, all right, as we emerge from this, how do we want to ensure we're prepared for what lies ahead. And I think the reality that we've existed for 90 years, weathered a great deal, means we're situated that way. But I think, especially as we become more digital, we must ensure our resources line up with that digital transformation we keep pursuing. And so I think we're truly examining every lever within our business to guarantee things don't slip away from us and that we emerge from this in a manner where we have the right partners, the right program, the right digital experience and capabilities, building out our data that we've kept doing. And then ensuring that the returns in our business keep delivering for our shareholders.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#27

Absolutely, Betsy — one more point I want to make sure doesn't get overlooked here. If you look at how average loan receivables fell from one period to the next, that drop comes to just over $5.7 billion. So obviously, our focus is on getting a handle on just how deep that could go and making sure we respond. And then, turning to the efficiency ratio for the quarter, once you take out a chunk of the operational losses tied to the COVID-19 response, I believe we land at 33.6% on the efficiency ratio. Getting that back to a level where we can keep running a business with a higher ROA is what we're after, so that, in my view, is the real driver; and ideally, from here, it's a matter of waiting to see how sales unfold as we go through the second half of the year.

Don Fandetti

analyst
#28

So Margaret, I suppose, would it be reasonable to state that you keep on seeing credit performing above expectations? The consumer's resilience caught me off guard, and I realize we shouldn't read too much into your reserve. Yet should NCOs reach their high point during the first half of '21, that would imply an NCO loss rate not much greater than your current level, and definitely far below what happened in the credit crisis. In your view, is stimulus really the driving factor? And what do you expect in the near term?

Margaret Keane

executive
#29

Yes, I believe — look, I believe, something all of us recognize is that the consumer entered this period in a fairly strong position, correct? So — and I believe what we are observing, and we even observe it in deposits, correct, consumers hold more cash, they are stockpiling more cash, and they are settling their bills. Now I believe the major caveat here, Don, is truly what takes place once the stimulus finishes, which will occur soon should they fail to devise a new plan, what does that new stimulus look like, and then how fast do individuals return to work? And I believe that is the point where I must admit I have spent 4 years around the business. None of us, I believe, would have anticipated witnessing what is occurring, occurring when it comes to delinquencies. I believe we are somewhat taken aback and assumed there would certainly be additional pressure there; so I believe we truly need to observe the third and fourth quarter to genuinely grasp how — what the next phase of stimulus is, how does that unfold? And I do believe we are expecting additional job loss. I believe what we have witnessed thus far involves the things tied to travel, entertainment, restaurants, things of that nature. But I believe each company is pulling back and examining its own cost structures and how that factors in. So I believe we are attempting to remain cautious regarding this. Because if you simply took — how we are performing today, we ought to be patting ourselves on the back and saying, "Oh, things look great." But I believe the truth is there is more ahead, and we simply must be prepared for that. And that is genuinely what we are attempting to guarantee. We are accomplishing both from an underwriting standpoint, guaranteeing we reserve appropriately, and then the third area of genuinely examining expenses closely to ensure we are positioned correctly as we emerge from this. I don't know Brian, if you would like to add anything.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#30

Yeah. The one point I would make, Don, is that the book looks completely different from what it did 12 months ago — no question, especially if you trace it backwards. With Walmart having come out the way it has, and when you look at the portfolio, the fact that today only 24% of the book sits below 660, which is 300 basis points lower than the first quarter — clearly stimulus and forbearance, forbearance across the industry, have pushed our payment rate up. For the quarter, our payment rate came in at 15.60%, 83 basis points higher year-over-year, so people are paying down their debt. The encouraging part is that since we've migrated credit, performance is improving. And ultimately, as Margaret said, the point is that as unemployment plays out — so once you return to whatever our estimate is near the end of the year — is there a fundamental rotation in there that produces a different outcome? We expect that. I think we're executing our credit enhancements with that in mind. But again, we'll need to watch how it unfolds. Still, I think it speaks to how we've reshaped the book since the GFC, and then really the tools and data elements we're using to manage the book today, to hopefully drive credit in a fundamentally positive way as we head into this recession.

Rick Shane

analyst
#31

Okay, I'd like to build on something we've already dug into a bit. When comparing the bump in reserves against how the economic picture has shifted, it feels as though that link is somewhat weaker than what we've seen in past periods. Once more, I believe you've all mentioned a few of the drivers behind that — forbearance-related policy efforts, which have softened that connection. I'm wondering whether you feel the ultimate danger lies in how long this cycle runs, which might pull that relationship back toward its typical historical level.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#32

Rick, when you consider it, that typical historical level does include Walmart, plus a few additional elements; therefore, you essentially need to make adjustments right at the beginning for consumer strength and for how the underlying portfolio shifts going forward. So without question, we're highly attuned to how long these effects last, or if things stretch out further than our assumptions, then without question that would matter. Yet when we examine our stress outcomes, even looking back at what we shared during 2018, those results look stronger once Walmart is excluded. So I believe that's factored in. And regarding this quarter, given that our receivables dropped by such a substantial amount, there's a fairly significant volume offset at play. Consequently, the rate component of the provision has risen considerably this quarter. So — but once more, it comes down to — you nailed it. It really depends on how that curve shapes up and whether there's an underlying mix change within unemployment that we're anticipating.

Rick Shane

analyst
#33

Understood. And I value that point — you're correct, there's a fairly meaningful idiosyncratic movement in the portfolio excluding Walmart that also needs to be factored in.

Mihir Bhatia

analyst
#34

I wanted to briefly follow up regarding the reserve build conversation. On this call, you've mentioned the possibility that the unemployment pool could shift somewhat, with perhaps certain higher income consumers losing their jobs down the road. And I just wanted to get clarity: does the reserve build already reflect this change? Or is this something you're monitoring and concerned might occur, after which you would need to build reserves for it? I realize the magnitude could differ, but I'm simply trying to grasp what has already been reserved for versus what hasn't been?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#35

Yes. That's an excellent question. And I believe we've attempted to model a portion of that; yet in the end, since we are observing credit strengthening as we go forward and truly credit strengthening even within the credit grades, it's hard to ultimately forecast that; so we've made some degree of investment in; it's simply exposed to considerable uncertainty right now. As we all read, there are many signals that a substantial number of layoffs are coming, including some of these higher income positions. But until we truly witness that and what accumulates in our portfolio, it is rather difficult. Still, we've included some estimate for how we believe the portfolio will perform as we move forward, though that's merely a risk factor, in the end, how it unfolds.

Mihir Bhatia

analyst
#36

And then just one final item. Could you perhaps talk a bit about a few of the more recent offerings you've rolled out? Here I have in mind the Synchrony HOME program, CarCare, or possibly the GP card as well. What kind of results have they delivered during the crisis, and as far as you're comfortable disclosing regarding volume or credit trends? And how does that stack up against the remaining portfolio or even what you had anticipated? Does it shift your willingness to expand those? I'm just attempting to get a sense of your thinking on those offerings, now that a crisis has occurred.

Margaret Keane

executive
#37

Yes. No. What I'd probably say is every one of them is doing well. We — their performance is no different from the book as a whole. I'd note, especially, that we're witnessing considerable strength in HOME. I'm certain lots of you have observed that HOME appears to be the area where consumers are directing their spending. And so we're clearly seeing solid uptake and customers purchasing furniture, home improvement and similar items. So both our HOME, card and our partners involved in the HOME space are certainly experiencing a great deal of strength. CarCare differs somewhat in that regard. The car portion itself is doing fine, but when — gas has declined, though that's beginning to recover as consumers resume more driving; but it remains below the level of driving seen before the pandemic. Still, I'd say, on the whole, from a credit standpoint and an origination standpoint and a utilization standpoint, we feel quite positive about every one of those offerings, and we'll keep seeking to grow them.

Greg Ketron

executive
#38

We appreciate you being with us today. Should you have any additional questions, our Investor Relations team will be on hand to address them, and we wish you a wonderful day.

Operator

operator
#39

Everyone, that wraps up the call for today. We appreciate your participation. At this point, you're free to hang up.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Synchrony Financial transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Synchrony Financial earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Synchrony Financial or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.