Synchrony Financial (SYF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 29, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Kathryn Miller
executiveThanks, and good morning to all of you. It's a pleasure to have you join our quarterly earnings conference call. Along with the press release issued today, we've made available a presentation that walks through the subjects we intend to cover on this call. You can find the press release, the detailed financial schedules, and the presentation on our website, synchronyfinancial.com. To access this information, simply navigate to the Investor Relations section of the site. Before we begin, I'd like to remind everyone that forward-looking statements will be part of our comments today; such statements carry risks and uncertainty, and actual results might differ materially; the factors that could cause actual results to differ materially are listed in our SEC filings, which you can access on our website. On this call, non-GAAP financial measures will be referenced when we discuss the company's performance. A reconciliation of these measures to GAAP financial measures is included in our materials for today's call. Lastly, Synchrony Financial bears no responsibility for, does not edit, and cannot guarantee the accuracy of our earnings teleconference transcripts that third parties provide. The only authorized webcasts can be found on our website; joining us this morning are Margaret Keane, Brian Doubles and Brian Wenzel. At this point, I'll hand the call over to Margaret.
Margaret Keane
executiveThank you, Kathryn, and hello everybody on this call. The year 2020 brought many difficulties, defined by a worldwide health crisis, turmoil in the economy, and social upheaval stemming from racial injustice. This genuinely put to the test how well we could bounce back, move quickly, and stay strong as an organization. We take pride in how Synchrony navigated these hurdles. Even though important progress has been made that gives reason to believe the pandemic's severity will start to ease, we are still dealing with renewed outbreaks of the virus, the regional closures that follow, and the ongoing consequences for joblessness; and while results keep being affected by the pandemic, certain patterns that have emerged give us optimism. Further along in this call, Brian Wenzel is going to walk through how these factors shaped the quarter's performance and share his perspective on what this year could look like. I'll give a broad summary at this point. Let's begin by examining our results for the quarter, along with a few recent accomplishments, which you can find described on slides 3 and 4. We earned $738 million, which works out to $1.24 per diluted share, $0.09 higher than a year ago. Loan receivables declined 6%, landing at $81.9 billion, and the count of average active accounts fell 10% compared with the prior year, while new accounts dropped 19%. Purchase volume per account rose 10% year over year, reaching $602, and the average active balance per account grew 4%, coming in at just under $1,200. Net interest margin declined 37 basis points, settling at 14.64%. The efficiency ratio for the quarter came in at 37.1%. Net charge-offs reached a new low of 3.16%. Because of how we approached liquidity and funding in reaction to COVID-19's effects on our balance sheet, deposits shrank by $2.3 billion, or 4%, relative to a year earlier. That figure reflects a deliberate choice to decelerate overall deposit growth, since we currently hold excess liquidity. Deposits in total make up 80% of how we fund ourselves, and our direct deposit platform continues to serve as a key source of funding. Our capacity to serve customers and deliver digital tools is what makes our bank appealing to depositors, and we'll keep expanding additional capabilities. During the quarter, we gave back $128 million through dividends on common stock. In addition, we shared that the Board approved $1.6 billion for repurchasing shares in 2021, starting in the first quarter. We have a strong pipeline spanning our platforms, consisting of both new and established programs; however, we remain highly disciplined regarding risk and return, in light of the uncertainty characterizing today's environment; and as this return environment evolves, we think comparable opportunities will keep arising, as demonstrated by deals we've recently won. I'll mention a handful of notable items. We shared that we are set to take on the role of issuer for the Walgreens cobranded credit card program within the U.S., marking the first credit program of its kind in the retail health space. With this card, customers can accumulate rewards on purchases wherever MasterCard is accepted. We anticipate rolling out the new program during the second half of 2021. This fresh agreement extends the company's current strategic partnership. CareCredit can now be used at over 9,000 Walgreens and Duane Reade locations. Our promise is to give Walgreen shoppers and patients exceptional experiences, a top-tier loyalty offering, and the means to handle their health and wellness expenses; on top of that, we have renewed our strategic alliance with Mattress Firm. We offer adaptable financing options and creative commercial resources that allow Mattress Firm to connect with their buyers at pivotal points in the buying process, which is moving more and more online. Our digital instruments and our sector-leading credit programs group, which includes retail marketing and analytics specialists, have fine-tuned each stage of the omni-channel customer path to produce a competitive user experience. We anticipate many additional years as a strategic partner of Mattress Firm. We have also secured a definitive agreement to purchase Allegro Credit, a top provider of point-of-sale consumer financing for audiology products and dental services. Allegro extends many loan choices to customers via its merchant partners, with adaptable payment terms at the point-of-sale. Such products are built to give customers options for buying the goods and services they require or desire. Bringing in Allegro Credit’s merchant network and customers supports our approach of expanding CareCredit, our foremost health and wellness financing platform. The deal should be finalized in the first quarter of 2021. In total for this quarter, we completed nine renewals and secured seven new deals in addition to the acquisition. I cannot emphasize enough how vital digital innovation is to the success of our programs. Consumers are swiftly embracing technologies that allow contactless commerce and anticipate engagement throughout their digital buying journeys. We are utilizing our digital assets and consistently investing to make sure our partners are well positioned in this fast-changing environment. Such investments encompass capabilities to equip staff and achieve seamless integration with our partners’ digital assets, allow customer choice at the point-of-sale, improve contactless experiences, support a smooth and simple application process, deliver the in-store experience to a customer's digital devices for applications and payments, and weave our financing office through the whole digital shopping experience. We also keep broadening our digital reach across every facet of our customer journey: apply, buy and service. Roughly 50% of our applications were submitted digitally in the fourth quarter and rose 18% in mobile channel application; in Retail Card 51% of our sales took place online. Lastly, roughly 65% of our payments were completed digitally. In summary, we are meeting the challenges brought by this hard period. We have bolstered the strategic positioning of our business and enlarged the opportunity set ahead of us. And we're putting money into the right strategy that will allow near term wins, while also generating significant shareholder value over the long-term. With our future in mind, as you know, a few weeks ago, we revealed some important changes to this company's leadership. Starting April 1, I will move into the role of Executive Chair of our Board of Directors and Brian Doubles will take over as Synchrony’s President and CEO. Synchrony holds a very special place for me. As CEO, one thing I wanted to accomplish was to prepare for a leadership handoff to someone capable of carrying forward everything we've established. The Board and I are convinced that nobody anywhere could handle that task better than Brian. At every stage of Synchrony's development, Brian has played a part in building it. For over 10 years, he has been a partner I trust, and that includes the period of our IPO. Back in 2014, when Synchrony got its start, our aim was to create an outstanding company with an outstanding culture that serves our partners and customers daily. Alongside our 16,500 employees, that is exactly what we're achieving; since Synchrony stands in a strong position, the moment has come to carry out this transition, which lets Brian keep pushing the remarkable progress already achieved and lead the next chapter of Synchrony's thrilling growth story. Through this transition, I'm eager to collaborate with Brian, and I'll keep championing Synchrony's expansion and future achievements as a decade chair. Having said that, I'll hand the call to Brian.
Brian Doubles
executiveTo begin, I'd like to express my gratitude to Margaret for everything she has contributed to Synchrony and to me on a personal level throughout the past 10 years. Without her guidance, we genuinely would not be in our current position or be the company we are now, and it is a genuine privilege to follow in her footsteps and steer Synchrony forward. I'm also thankful that we will keep gaining from Margaret's knowledge and direction as Executive Chair. I'm eager to work alongside her, the Board, our leadership group, and above all our associates as we keep building on our positive trajectory. There is plenty to look forward to as Synchrony's path continues. Our company is robust, our culture is successful, and we have an enormous chance to expand upon a solid base. In my new role as CEO, I will keep executing the plans we have crafted across the past 3 years, which have generated the momentum our company enjoys at present; we will keep drawing on our competitive advantages, strengthen our position as market leader, and put resources into digital capabilities, data analytics, and fresh product lines to deliver a smooth customer experience. We will keep expanding our operations and generating value for every stakeholder — our investors, our staff, our partners, and our customers. With that said, I'd like to change topics and move to Slide 5 to discuss a single illustration of a plan we put in place to boost the usefulness and worth of what we provide, and which has grown into a key component of our company now: equal payment financing. At the core of our company is our aim to deliver a complete range of offerings that can be customized to meet the changing requirements of our customers and partners while generating suitable economic returns. What our partners need most critically revolves around their capacity to present a product that integrates smoothly with their digital infrastructure and systems, achieves greater average order sizes and sales, lifts conversion rates, and strengthens customer allegiance. In the same way, customers possess their own distinct requirements, such as financing options that align with their budget, are clear and simple and practical to utilize, and which give them adaptability in their purchasing and financing choices. We bring substantial expertise and installment lending, which has shaped how we approach equal payment financing. We classify these offerings into 2 groups. First, evolving products. We provide mid and long-term equal payment plans, featuring promotional periods ranging from 12 to 152 months, varying by product category. We also provide short-term equal payment plans, with promotional periods spanning 3 to 12 months. Second, closed end products; we provide collateralized installment offerings for larger ticket purchases, with promotional periods from 12 to 180 months. Additionally, we provide short and long-term installment loans via our SetPay product. These offerings extend anywhere from 3 to 36 months. Every one of these offerings carries a suitable price point so that both our partners' goals and our customers' goals are satisfied, with APR beginning at 0%, and every one of them delivers its own set of advantages while tackling the particular aims our partners and customers hold. Take revolving equal pay offerings: they can be placed within a revolving account that already exists, which removes the requirement that a customer start up a brand new account. Because of how they work, they also bring us repeat purchases, plus stronger engagement and greater loyalty toward the partner's plan. Closed end offerings, on the other hand, usually attract customers who like steady, foreseeable payments. To frame our broader equal payment financing approach, at present we hold $15 billion in equal payment balances, and 56% of that carries 0% APR financing. Roughly 74,000 partners or locations make our payment plan offerings available; our overall repeat purchase rate comes to about 30% within 24 months of the initial purchase. What has powered Synchrony's achievements here and in our remaining core strategies is our dedication to innovation grounded in data, a thorough grasp of what our partners aim for and what customers require, and our capacity to adjust as competition and market circumstances have changed across time. Our company is structured to be agile, quick to respond and focused on results; we draw on our decades of underwriting know-how, our proprietary data analytics and our sector knowledge to craft and roll out tailored solutions that serve our partners' needs and simultaneously produce suitable economic results. That is the force behind Symphony's long-established record of performance and the strengthening of our market leadership through the years; we look forward to carrying this momentum ahead in 2021 just by keeping on improving the value we deliver to everyone we serve. Having said that, I'll hand the call to Brian Wenzel.
Brian Wenzel
executiveThank you, Brian, and good morning to all of you. First off, I'd like to offer my congratulations to Margaret and Brian regarding their new positions, and express my appreciation for everything they've contributed to Synchrony and to me on a personal level. I believe I can speak on behalf of the entire company in saying that we're eager to collaborate closely with them as Synchrony moves into its next chapter. With 2021 now underway, the progress being made against the pandemic gives us encouragement, and we remain inspired by those serving on the frontlines. For our part, we stay committed to protecting the safety of our employees, and to assisting our partners, customers and communities through this challenging time, guided by our values and principles and with the partner centric focus, we are working to help our constituents navigate this environment with an eye towards the future and the opportunities ahead of us as we begin to overcome the pandemic. Throughout the fourth quarter, the pandemic kept weighing on our growth across multiple areas, as shown on Slide 7. That said, our business mix, which features a sizable digital component along with certain industries that have benefited from people staying at home — things like home related products and services, veterinary services, and electronics and appliances — has offset a portion of the downturn's impact. Purchase volume came in essentially flat, falling 1% compared with a year ago and matching what we had expected for the quarter, even with some strain from fresh shutdowns and restrictions as the pandemic wore on during the quarter. That persistent strain drove our average active accounts down 10% and brought a 6% reduction in loan receivables. Payment rates remain above what we'd consider normalized levels. Interest and fees on loans dropped 11% versus a year ago, in line with the core decrease we saw in the previous quarter. Dual and co-branded cards represent 38% of our purchase line during the fourth quarter and were down 4% from the prior year. Measured on a loan receivable basis, they make up 24% of the portfolio and fell 10% from the prior year. Although our growth metric has been trending positively as we enter the quarter, the pandemic's acceleration brought regional shutdowns and a fading effect from the CARES Act stimulus that put a brake on that early momentum. Even though our sales are holding steady, recent developments give us encouragement, among them the recently enacted stimulus, the proposed stimulus, a new administration and national rollout of a vaccine. Our belief is that these factors will deliver a positive impact. It should generate momentum as we move through 2021. I'll share a fuller picture of 2021 in a moment. RSAs rose $18 million, or 2%, from a year ago. For the quarter, RSAs as a percentage of average receivables came to 5.2%. That figure was above the historical average, largely because of the substantial improvement in net charge-offs and the elimination of Walmart, which ran at an RSA percentage below the company average. The betterment in net charge-offs produced a $354 million reduction in the provision for credit losses, or 32% from a year ago. A reserve build of $119 million in Q4 partly counteracted that. The figure for other income fell by $22 million, largely as a result of increased loyalty costs. Other expense came down by $79 million, a 7% drop versus a year ago, driven by reduced purchase volume and fewer average active accounts, along with decreased employee costs, since we've started putting our strategic plan into action to cut operating expenses. Turning to platform results on Slide 8. COVID-19 keeps hitting our sales platforms to differing degrees, and how each has moved through this stretch varies depending on things like business and partner mix, digital concentration, provider access, and whether hardline goods are available. At Retail Card, loan receivables fell 8%, though strong expansion in digital programs partly counterbalanced the COVID-19 effect; that resilience shows up in purchase line growth, which rose 1% compared with a year ago. COVID-19 dragged down the other performance metrics. We're thrilled to roll out our new value prop with Sam's Club; they're a key and cherished partner, and the updates to this program for Sam's Club members have us excited. In Payment Solutions, ongoing momentum in Power Sports and Home Specialty helped counterbalance a portion of the COVID-19 hit. Loan receivables dropped 2%. Average active account along with interest and fees on loans each declined 9%, mostly because of reduced yield on loan receivables. Purchase line was 7% lower this quarter. This quarter we inked a number of new programs and renewed a number of crucial partnerships. We keep generating organic growth via our partnerships and networks, bringing on more than 2,800 new merchants in the quarter. We're also continuing to push greater card reuse, which today accounts for roughly 34% of purchase volume, excluding oil and gas. What we've done and achieved is enlarging a base for growth that was already strong as we come out of the pandemic. Even though CareCredit took the hardest COVID-19 blow earlier in the year, improvement started appearing as the year went on, since providers keep ramping up elective and planned services after the low point in the second quarter; even so, climbing infection rates and tightening stay at home restrictions did hold back part of that progress. Loan receivables fell 7%, while interest and fees on loans dropped 4%, chiefly because of reduced merchant discount revenue stemming from a decline in purchase volume, which was down 6%. Average active accounts fell 10%. As Margaret mentioned before, our partner activity in this platform has us excited, including the Allegro Credit acquisition, our Aspen Dental renewal and expansion, and our new partnership with Community Veterinary Partners. Over the quarter, we also kept expanding our CareCredit network and improving how useful our card is. Our acceptance and network build-out has contributed to pushing the reuse rate up to 59% of purchase line during Q4; these results make us proud, and we're especially enthusiastic about the possibilities for future expansion on this platform once the pandemic's effects fade. Turning to Slide 9, I'll walk through net interest income and margin trends. Net interest income fell 9% versus a year ago, mainly because interest and fees on loan receivables dropped 11% due to COVID-19's impact. Net interest margin came in at 14.64%, versus 15.01% a year earlier, mostly from COVID-19's effect on loan receivables, more liquidity, and lower benchmark rates. To be specific, loan receivables as a share of total earning assets slipped roughly 30 basis points, from 80.2% to 79.9%, because of higher liquidity carried during the quarter; that represented 5 basis points of the net interest margin decline. The loan receivables yield was 19.93%, a drop of 94 basis points from a year ago, and it drove a 75 basis point decrease in our net interest margin. Liquidity yield fell because benchmark rates were lower, which accounted for a 30 basis point decline in our net interest margin.
Brian Wenzel
executiveA portion of those effects got counterbalanced by a decline of 89 basis points in what our total interest-bearing liabilities cost, which came to 1.69%, largely because benchmark rates moved lower and deposit funding made up a bigger share. That yields a 73 basis point gain in net interest margin. Now I'll walk through the main credit trends, found on Slide 10. Regarding the particular dynamics this quarter, delinquency trends come first. At 30-plus days, the delinquency rate stood at 3.07%, versus 4.44% a year ago. At 90-plus days, that rate came in at 1.40%, versus 2.15% a year ago. Stronger payment activity contributed to pushing delinquency rates lower. Turning to net charge-off trends. The net charge-off rate reached 3.16%, versus 5.15% a year ago. What mainly drove that lower net charge-off rate was delinquency trends getting better as customer payment behavior improved across 2020. Allowance for credit losses, measured as a percent of loan receivables, came to 12.54%, and the rise relative to a year ago was mostly caused by adopting CECL during 2020 along with the effect of COVID-19. Shifting to Slide 11, expenses for the quarter are what I'll cover. All told, expenses came to $1 billion for the quarter, which is $79 million lower, or 7%, versus a year ago. Driving that decline were reduced purchase volume and a lower count of average active accounts, along with cuts in employee costs and operational losses. Our efficiency ratio in the fourth quarter came to 37.1%, versus 34.8% a year ago. Lower revenue, stemming from reduced receivables plus a smaller interest and fee yield, weighed on that ratio, though cuts in employee costs and operational losses partly counterbalanced it. Shifting to Slide 12. Because our loan receivables shrank and our deposit platform remains strong, we keep holding a greater amount of liquidity. Although we consider it wise to keep liquidity elevated amid this volatile and uncertain stretch, we are actively steering our funding profile so that surplus liquidity gets mitigated where it makes sense. This strategy produced a change in how our funding is mixed during the quarter. Deposits fell $2.3 billion versus a year ago. Our securitized funding sources dropped $2.6 billion, while unsecured funding sources dropped $1.5 billion. Consequently, deposits represented 80% of our funding, versus 77% a year ago, while securitized and unsecured funding each accounted for 10% of our funding sources when the quarter ended. Total liquidity, which includes undrawn credit facilities, stood at $23.7 billion, equal to 24.7% of our total assets, which is up from 22% a year ago. Before I give details about our capital position, it's worth noting that we chose to take advantage of transition rules that the joint federal banking agencies issued in March, which carried 2 primary benefits. To start, it pushes out the impact of the CECL transition adjustment by another 2 years; and next, it permits part of the provisioning from the current period to be postponed and amortized along with the transition adjustment; using this approach, we closed the quarter at 15.9% CET1 under the CECL transition rules, which is 180 basis points higher than the 14.1% we had a year ago. Under those same CECL transition rules, the Tier 1 capital ratio came in at 16.8%, versus 15.0% the prior year. The total capital ratio also rose 180 basis points, reaching 18.1%. And on a fully phased-in basis, the Tier 1 capital plus reserves ratio climbed to 27.0%, up from 21.4% a year earlier, which mirrors the growth in reserves from adopting CECL. In the quarter, we distributed a common stock dividend of $0.22 per share. Across the entire year, we gave back roughly $1.5 billion to shareholders through share repurchases and common stock dividends. As 2020 wraps up and we move into 2021, we've kept evaluating the company's capital and liquidity strength along with how steady our business is at this stage of the pandemic; given that picture, the Board has approved $1.6 billion for share repurchases in 2021, starting in the first quarter. Buybacks depend on our capital plan, regulatory limits, and broader market conditions, including any possible worsening from the continuing pandemic. Now, turning to Slide 13, we're laying out a framework on the main drivers for 2021. Obviously, the present situation will include stretches of uncertainty and volatility until the pandemic is contained and the resulting effect on the economy is understood more completely. Although what we can see is limited, we're offering this framework for how we think the year could play out, based on our best judgment as of today. These assumptions hold that during the first half of the year, pandemic pressure persists and the economic recovery stays slow; in the second half, we assume the pandemic is mostly contained and the economic recovery speeds up. Purchase volume in the first quarter should align with the trends that emerged late in 2020. Second quarter comparisons will clearly mirror the economic trough felt in second quarter '20. In the back half of the year, we expect growth trends to improve as pandemic effects ease and macroeconomic growth picks up. On loan receivable growth: during the first half, we expect continued elevated payment rates stemming from stimulus actions to weigh on loan growth. In the latter half of the year, we think payment rates will decline as stimulus fades, and we go back to more normal payment behavior patterns, paired with the anticipated rise in purchase volume from a better macroeconomic environment; these factors will help drive accelerating asset growth. For net interest margin, on the whole, we expect further improvement as we head into 2021. As for the first-half improvement, we anticipate that higher payment rates will lead to continued excess liquidity affecting asset mix. During the latter six months, we bring down surplus liquidity by growing assets and slowing payment rates, and that combination pushes normalized interest and fee yields higher, which lifts NIM. Turning to how we see credit across the year, we anticipate delinquencies will rise, with the highest point arriving in the third quarter of 2021, producing quarter-over-quarter growth in net charge-offs; reserves, in our view, would mostly be shaped by asset growth along with whatever effects come from shifts in the credit macroeconomic scenario. We expect a reserve release at some point in 2021 as the credit macroeconomic environment evolves. RSAs should stay elevated through the first six months, mainly a reflection of the program's strong performance, which includes revenue and net charge-offs. Over the back half, we look for RSAs to come down, largely because net charge-offs are higher, with that partly offset by greater revenue. As noted earlier, we have put cost reductions in place throughout the company; our belief is that this yields roughly $210 million of expense savings over the course of the year. Working against those cost reductions will be higher expenses tied to growth, plus the expected rise in delinquent accounts; we intend to keep watching closely how the pandemic evolves and what it does to the macroeconomic environment, making adjustments as the landscape changes. Going into 2021, we stay optimistic about the strength and strategic position of our business, and about meeting the challenges and coming out of the pandemic period stronger than we were when it began.
Brian Wenzel
executiveWe're going to keep putting money into our workforce, our offerings, our tech, and our platforms so we can create value over the long term and keep our employees safe, all while serving what our partners, merchants, providers, and cardholders need. At this point, I'll hand things over to the operator so we can start the Q&A part of today's call.
Ryan Nash
analystMargaret, to start off, I just wanted to tell you that working alongside you for these past 7 years has truly been a pleasure. Getting the chance to learn from you is something I've genuinely appreciated, and I wish you the very best as you move into your next position as Executive Chair.
Margaret Keane
executiveRyan, thank you so much.
Ryan Nash
analystI'll start things off with something for Brian Wenzel. Brian, this quarter's RSA to loans came in above 5%, which reflects credit performing better than we'd anticipated. Could you perhaps lay out a framework for how we should think about the RSA for 2021? Assuming your base case from the slide comes to pass, should we anticipate that it stays around this 5% RSA to loans level and then declines at some point later in the year?
Brian Wenzel
executiveThank you, Ryan. Clearly, the higher level we saw coming into 2021 was largely a function of credit, which came in 200 basis points better on net charge-offs. That was partly offset by — or offset by — a portion of the interest expense and NIM; yet it's plainly elevated. So I believe as we move into 2021, what you'll observe is that with NIM continuing to climb as we expect, there will be a gain that flows back through the RSA to the retailers, driving it higher; however, once credit returns to normal, that will bring it down; therefore, our expectation is that it stays somewhat elevated; we wouldn't anticipate that degree of elevation as we close out 2021; and I think once you're in 2022 and past that, it ought to return to the typical range we ran in before the pandemic.
Ryan Nash
analystUnderstood. And Brian Doubles, I appreciate all the detail regarding the equal payment approach. Could you perhaps elaborate a bit on what you offer and how you see that developing as time goes on? So looking at it, your offerings typically began with roughly 3 months of financing. That made me curious whether there might be an opportunity for certain of these shorter-term offerings to develop into a buy now pay later product of your own? And next, since a number of the newer competitors in this area charge merchants fairly substantial fees for such offerings, could you discuss the pricing around merchant discount rates for some of your equal pay offerings? And is it possible to leverage pricing to push volumes toward what you offer and perhaps steer them away from certain of these more recent market participants?
Brian Doubles
executiveYes, Ryan, excellent question. I believe you truly need to step back and say, well, what we're doing is essentially aimed at delivering a complete range of offerings that suit what our partners are seeking, as well as what shoppers are seeking; and clearly, buy now pay later is a trend that isn't disappearing. Installment loans, a trend that isn't disappearing. If you step back and consider our company, we have such a wide array of partners that a single approach that works for everyone simply isn't possible. So as you're aware, Ryan, we meet with every one of our partners, we meet and ask, alright, what are you aiming to accomplish? In what ways can we assist you in generating sales, in what ways can we assist you in conveying life cycle market to your customers? And that means they're going to want a range of offerings; sometimes, a revolving product will be the more logical choice. Sometimes, an installment product suits better. When you consider larger ticket items, that leans toward longer-term installment, which can be structured as a revolving product or closed end. And then for smaller ticket, what we've observed lately is, that tends to lean toward shorter-term and more shorter-term installment; and so once more, ultimately it returns to what the partner is seeking. Now you raise a very valid point. Clearly, merchant discount pricing is a factor here. The shorter the term and if you aren't charging interest on the account, then clearly, you apply a larger merchant discount. And so once more, ultimately it boils down to what the partner is seeking and what the consumer is seeking. Look, I feel very good about the range of offerings we have. The one thing I wouldn't underestimate, though, is that the product itself is only a single component of the equation. What we've been focused on and what truly matters is, in what way do you embed the product into the shopping journey. And because of that, how we bring things together matters more now than it ever has. What really matters, then, is the features and the capabilities, and those count for even more than the products themselves. When you get right down to it, these products aren't all that complicated. The real question is how we integrate, and how we embed the financing offer across the whole shopping journey.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystCongratulations to everyone from my side too. I suppose it feels somewhat odd since such strong credit quality is impacting you folks a bit more, given that you share a portion of that upside with the retailers. I'm simply wondering, since we have the stimulus benefit, how much is that stimulus benefit contributing to credit quality? And do you anticipate it fading away at some point? Did you begin to notice it fade a bit during the fourth quarter? I'm just attempting to determine sort of how stimulus — how long do you believe credit sort of stays this favorable right now, given your understanding of your forecast that things could revert to the mean?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. Thanks, Sanjay. So stimulus has clearly helped. We've observed that across 2020, definitely, we saw a surge of payments, correct, when the latest stimulus package arrived. So payment rates actually climbed back up higher in early January; so clearly, stimulus is active, and you do observe it fade; now what's intriguing, more intriguing regarding this newest stimulus is it isn't as surgical. It's going out to a broad-based population. So the effectiveness as we keep moving forward even with additional stimulus, our portfolio changed. We previously were 27% subprime, at present we're 23% subprime. So the impacts of that won't persist; so we do presume that once the stimulus burns off here, definitely from the one in December, but if another stimulus does get enacted in the first quarter, that will burn off, and you'll see payment rates climb back up, and then you'll see delinquencies return into the portfolio. Well, certainly, we're anticipating, given the elevated level of unemployment that delinquencies will accumulate fairly quickly here as we move out. But again, we haven't witnessed that so far in the credit metrics that you have seen. So there's a possibility, though, that with upcoming stimulus and if you get the pandemic under control, with the vaccine that you might flatten the ultimate loss curve here and have a bridge, which is what we would hope for.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystUnderstood; and perhaps one for Brian Doubles, just regarding — and Margaret, the Verizon and Venmo Card. I'm just wondering, kind of — I realize these are a key element of the growth narrative, at minimum through the intermediate stretch while we wait for offline to bounce back. I'm just wondering whether you're observing advancement and how they're performing compared with what you expected?
Margaret Keane
executiveYes. I'd say the two are performing quite well. Verizon, we introduced it back during the summer, and once more, it was our initial launch amid the pandemic. I think as we began more through online channels and as the stores have started opening, we're certainly witnessing genuine favorable momentum there. Consumers are enjoying the value proposition. So we feel quite favorable regarding our Verizon partnership and what its potential could be. On Venmo, we did the soft launch during the fall, that has also gone extremely well, and customers are truly enjoying how the product functions inside the Venmo app. I think there's plenty of technology that both sides developed to make that a genuinely integrated experience for customers, and we are receiving a great deal of favorable momentum there. As we roll out to the wider population shortly, we anticipate that will keep being a major element of our growth narrative as we move forward with the company; so 2 truly thrilling programs, 2 programs where technology and our investments have truly delivered returns, and we look forward to continuing to push forward our investments in technology as we keep integrating even further.
Brian Doubles
executiveCorrect. The one point I'd tack on there is that Walgreens deserves more than a passing mention. That partnership has us genuinely enthusiastic, and for us I'd rank it right alongside Venmo and Verizon when it comes to the size of the opportunity. Sanjay, 90 million Walgreen loyalty customers — we're truly thrilled about what that tie-up can deliver for us too.
Moshe Orenbuch
analystThanks, and well done to Margaret and Brian. I'll stay on that same topic with one more question. Obviously, every one of these partnerships brings a sizable customer base and a sizable chance on its own. Still, could you talk about how pairing the sort of customer who feels devoted to that specific brand with the value proposition ends up turning into a credit product? And could you perhaps look at all 3 together and maybe even put them in order based on how much you expect each to drive growth at Synchrony?
Margaret Keane
executiveSure. Ranking them isn't really possible at this point, since we're still early in the process. Still, from what we've seen, people are able to keep these things separate in their minds. Take Venmo — my sense is it'll evolve into a card people reach for daily, especially those who are on that app constantly. Once it's woven into that payment flow, you get the capacity to divide charges and genuinely feel that give-and-take in how individuals spend. Yet the real upside for Venmo, in my view, comes down to this: that card is now accepted at a much wider range of merchants. I mean, QR codes are increasingly becoming a default kind of technology. It's not yet where it should be, but we see that as the other major opportunity for Venmo. You've got the in-app side, where folks team up to make purchases; then in physical stores, or through QR codes, you get a completely different — a distinct range of experiences, I'd say, and possibly a wider customer base for us. So that's something we're enthusiastic about. Regarding the other two, the value proposition is genuinely what creates another significant difference, because with Walgreens, what we do know — and we've learned this via CareCredit — is that individuals separate out their healthcare spending. Since people are shouldering more of what medical care costs, we see this card as an excellent entry point into the wider healthcare market. As you're aware, that fits within the plan we've been pursuing. It's also worth noting this expands on the ties we've built with Walgreens, since the CareCredit card was already taken there; what's new is linking our card to what they offer, joining the two, and letting shoppers with medical or wellness requirements take full advantage of it and earn rewards. Beyond that, our aim is to move all of this into digital form. The consumer ends up with something truly smooth, with no friction at all. And Verizon, truthfully — once you examine just what that value proposition gives people and the way they genuinely make use of it, things become interesting there. Here's a joke I tell often: because I'm getting up in years and my children are adults now, they're still listed on my account. The reality is those kids simply never exit the plan. Being able to draw on that value proposition and put it toward what you owe — that, in my opinion, is additional positive momentum we're seeing. So as we see it, all 3 of these initiatives have real space to expand. And I think it shows clearly how capable we are of staying nimble amid extremely tough conditions — launching while the pandemic was going on, and truly addressing what I'd call very compelling value propositions, powered by technology.
Moshe Orenbuch
analystUnderstood. I definitely get your point regarding the phone plan. Moving on to my next question there. Brian Wenzel, considering everything you mentioned regarding capital positioning and just how solid it is. To put it plainly, you folks made more than $1 billion during the last year while the balance sheet got smaller. So how does the $1.6 billion buyback authorization connect to that? It seems like it might grow stronger as time goes on, so could you just discuss how that figure came together?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. Thank you, Moshe; it's key to understand that what we announced and what the Board approved differs somewhat from our past practice. This covers a calendar year. Of course, the Fed imposed certain limits during the first quarter, but we will follow our own procedure. From a governance standpoint, we've been running a quarterly process, examining loss stresses and examining how our balance sheet is likely to perform. I believe if you look back one quarter, we weren't certain we'd be able to begin the year in this position; our thinking leaned toward the latter half of the year; however, I think when we spoke with the Board, we saw the capital and liquidity strength of the company, we saw how stable the company was as we moved through the latter half of 2020. Looking ahead to 2021, we — once more, it's uncertain. Volatility will be present, but we're hopeful that the pandemic gets brought under control during the first half and that the macroeconomic side improves. So we felt it was wise to begin. We'll follow a process and file our formal capital plan with the Fed at the end of March, beginning of April. After that we'll come back with what that amount is. We believe that's a sensible amount, right, since this is a transitional year, right, in terms of visibility and uncertainty; so clearly, our long-term view concerning capital and where we aim to reach hasn't changed. It's really just the pace. And so we're at ease that this is a solid place to begin, and we can always revisit it as we move through the year.
Mihir Bhatia
analystAnd I'd like to congratulate Margaret and Brian as well. Perhaps we can — I wanted to begin with — perhaps simply returning to what you said regarding Walgreens, I suppose my initial question is really just for clarification: will it be placed within CareCredit, or will it fall under your Retail Card segment? Since it appeared from your release that it was under CareCredit. And then my follow-up would simply be, are there — does that carry any implications? Because as I recall, historically your CareCredit has had no RSA or a significantly lower RSA. And regarding the program, is there anything we ought to be considering that's specific to Walgreens, which sets it apart from a standard co-brand or Retail Card program?
Margaret Keane
executiveWell, I'll begin and then Brian can address the RSA; but look, I think one thing we've stated for some time now is that we feel we possess a unique insight into the entire healthcare wellness space thanks to our CareCredit platform. We've grown that platform throughout all of last year as we've moved into hospital network through simply our acquisition of Allegra Credit. We believe that consumers — and incidentally, it does sit in CareCredit. So I should make that clear. It does sit in CareCredit. We believe that everyday spend surrounding wellness is a space where consumers are seeking rewards. We believe Walgreens is an excellent partner because we were already there accepting the Walgreen — the CareCredit card. So we believe this space is a genuinely ripe opportunity because of our distinctive knowledge and experience in this space for over 30 years, and we truly see Walgreens as a means for us to keep expanding and distinguishing ourselves in the healthcare business. I don't know, Brian, if you'd bring up the RSA.
Brian Doubles
executiveAbsolutely. The sole point I would tack onto what Margaret said is this: regarding the capabilities, a CareCredit dual card is already up and running in that space. And we will definitely — even though we are a sizable operation, our capacity to genuinely bring the tools, the technology, and the talent that reside in that business, which handles the co-band relationships within the Retail Card, is going to partner with those people, merging the healthcare side with that expertise. We have that in other platforms, so within the payment solutions platform, we do have a certain amount of limited RSA. So some RSA would show up here, but once again, for us that platform is $10 billion. So in the early stage especially, I would not view it as material. So — but over time you will see some development there.
Mihir Bhatia
analystGot it. Then my second thing was about capital — returning to what you said regarding putting money to work and moving your capital ratios nearer to where your peers are. It seems to me you've had surplus liquidity for as long as you've been a public company. So is there a chance, or a desire, to put some of that capital to work through buying portfolios or via other non-organic expansion, be it M&A or whatever else, that we ought to be considering? Or is your sense that you already have plenty to handle with Walgreens, Venmo, Verizon, and the economy reopening, so in the near term that's likely where our attention should be?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. Excellent question. In terms of how we rank uses of capital at the company, organic growth comes first for us; so consider a few of the programs that have been around longer, like an Amazon or PayPal or TJX, Sam's, Lowe's — there's a great deal of room to keep pushing our penetration there. With the newer programs, Verizon, Venmo, Walgreens, we would definitely want to put capital into those. So growing that piece is our top priority; yet we'll have capital past what's needed to grow the book. If you consider how much capital the business generates, consider the resiliency and the return, consider how resilient the RSA is, we're going to have extra capital, and our following priority is keeping the dividend and giving that back to shareholders. Past that, we think there will be a surplus, and that will go first toward share repurchase, and if we come across an acquisition that makes sense — a portfolio or businesses — we'll pursue it.
Margaret Keane
executiveThe Allegro acquisition, I believe, served as proof of that during this quarter. So should a suitable opportunity present itself, one aligning with our strategy over the long term and offering us the appropriate return, then without question we are examining such opportunities if they were to appear.
Brian Wenzel
executiveThat is the main takeaway. Even now, at this stage in the cycle, I doubt prices have corrected sufficiently for us to pursue anything major. That said, should they reach that point and a chance present itself, we would be happy to put that money to work toward building value over the long term.
Don Fandetti
analystBrian, there are additional inquiries coming in regarding regulation, and I simply wanted to kind of hear your take on how you view that particular risk? Also, are there any segments of your operation that might draw greater attention, primarily from the CFPB and so forth?
Margaret Keane
executiveSure, Don, I'll handle that one. It's — we are — my guess is this pertains to the fresh administration. What I'd say is we've existed for quite an extended period. Every administration has been something we've operated under; we're confident that regardless of the new administration, we could navigate whatever modifications they might introduce. I believe we consider ourselves to be in a strong position. And honestly, I think oversight and the attention really always centers on this entire concept of treating consumers fairly and transparently, and I believe that's what we do; therefore, the infrastructure exists on our end, the personnel exist on our end. We're striving to make certain we're performing all the correct actions from a consumer standpoint and additionally collaborating with our partners on this too. So we aren't excessively worried. I mean, honestly, there will likely be additional developments emerging, but we will adapt however necessary.
Betsy Graseck
analystMargaret, working alongside you has truly been a joy. I realize that in your new position, you'll continue to wield incredible influence at Synchrony. Still, I'm very grateful for all the hours you've devoted to us throughout the years. And Brian, I'm eager to collaborate with you even more closely.
Brian Doubles
executiveThank you, Betsy.
Margaret Keane
executiveThanks so much.
Betsy Graseck
analystAll right. A few things about SetPay. I was hoping you might share some detail on how many of your partners' customers are actually signing up, and, say, what share of them have already gone live? How far do you figure you can drive that during 2021, a stretch when I believe you'll watch some of the standalone players fighting really aggressively to win merchants? So I'd like to hear your read on that? Also, can the partners you already work with — one more being a PL platform — layer SetPay on top? Or must you sit tight until their programs come up for RFP a few years down the road? A bit of detail on that would help.
Brian Doubles
executiveYeah, absolutely, Betsy. Everything hinges on the specific partner and the goals they've set. And clearly this draws a lot of attention; that's the reason a slide went into today's deck, simply to spell out more thoroughly the amount of this business we handle right now. It isn't widely understood, I think, that $15 billion of balances sit on equal pay products, spanning both short and long-term. And I'd say it truly comes down to what the partner chooses. So like I mentioned, we meet with every one of our partners, and sometimes they're enthusiastic about an equal pay product since that's what the consumer wants; that's what their customer wants, yet they'd rather place it on a revolving product; partly because that delivers a continuing relationship with the customer, correct? It lets them encourage repeat usage. It lets them handle life cycle marketing. Every one of those elements matters greatly to our partners and, honestly, they've spent the last 5 or 6 years chasing exactly that; we constantly tell you how much reuse we get on the card. And building that enduring relationship with their customer ranks as a major priority for our partners. Then we also serve certain customers who, based on their customer base and the kinds of products they sell, actually prefer more of a short-term closed end installment product; so through SetPay we can offer that too, and we're able to do it very short-term, we're able to do it longer term; yet it genuinely gets tailored to each partner in terms of what they hope to accomplish. One thing I can share is that we're observing somewhat higher growth rates on those installment products than we're observing on the remaining products in the portfolio, which strikes me as good news. I mean, we definitely must keep ahead of that curve; it's rapidly evolving. But the product is merely one piece of the equation. I mentioned this before — what our partners truly need to be certain we're capable of. And depending on which kinds of partners we're talking about, it varies a great deal: the question is how we plug into their digital point of sale. If I consider all the investments we're making across the company, that one ranks among the largest. So simply having the product isn't sufficient — in many instances, actually having the product is the simpler piece. The real challenge is how you integrate smoothly within every one of our partners' digital assets; so how do you accomplish that online? How do you accomplish it inside their mobile app? And as you can imagine, because our partner base is so broad, we need solutions tailored to each of those individual partners; so ultimately it really comes down to the experience rather than the actual product. Did that answer your question?
Betsy Graseck
analystYeah, so I suppose what I'm really asking is this — do you expect — I get that right now you've got a pretty big amount of balances sitting on that equal pay offering. SetPay carries a somewhat different feel from that one, and it's a somewhat different thing you're providing; so what I'm curious about is whether, in your view, 2021 will be a year in which adoption from your partners blows up, or is this just business as usual for you? And then — should we truly not anticipate much of a gap in the way your partners deal with you when it comes to the equal pay offering?
Brian Doubles
executiveI believe you will without a doubt witness stronger growth rates in SetPay than what you witness, broadly speaking, in other products. That being said, I wouldn't call that explosive growth, since ultimately it boils down to what the partner is attempting to accomplish when everything is said and done. And there are certain partners we have that are quite concentrated on a strategy in which they favor the equal pay offering, yet they would prefer that we keep them on a revolving account so they can keep pushing repeat usage and keep that relationship going over time.
Margaret Keane
executiveAlso, what matters there is giving customers options, correct? What is it that customers are actually looking for?
Brian Doubles
executiveYes, and for certain…
Margaret Keane
executiveWhat we need to do is genuinely provide the offerings and place them appropriately for the customer, so they’re able to make their own selection. And one area we’re highly concentrated on is ensuring that this is embedded within our digital properties. Therefore, it becomes an option for a client.
Brian Doubles
executiveYeah. Ultimately, it boils down to what our partners are looking for and what consumers are looking for. And again, because our partners are so varied, we need to offer a really comprehensive product suite that revolves around short-term and long-term installment, and we'll be capable of doing that. But ultimately, it depends on the partner and on what the customer is looking for.
Bill Carcache
analystLet me also say congratulations to the two of you, Margaret and Brian. As you prepare for new and active accounts to start growing again after all this, you've got a number of excellent new programs you're putting money into. Could you share a little more detail on how you determine the appropriate amount to invest? Your operating expense guidance anticipates greater investment, but perhaps you could offer additional context, maybe framed around an efficiency ratio?
Brian Wenzel
executiveSure. Thank you, Bill. Even through a pandemic, unlike many of our competitors, we never pulled back on any of those investments — whether that meant technology or the people and resources assigned to these growth initiatives — and within that, we shifted priorities toward certain items offering better near-term opportunities. That approach has stayed in place, so from our standpoint, investing will continue. Consider that 2020 was a significant year for us with the spending required to establish a Venmo and Verizon; and once more, we're eager for a complete Venmo launch in 2021. So our investment has been substantial. Walgreens follows closely after this. We keep pushing core productivity, and within that we're maintaining the investment. And once more, Bill, the way we're setting up the company for the longer haul is to ask — looking ahead to 2025, what counts as an above-average ROA — and we intend to push that efficiency ratio back down to a level closer to where it sat historically, while genuinely delivering that ROA given the revenue mix and loss content present in that portfolio mix. That said, we will identify methods either to boost the margin on the portfolios or to remove incremental costs so we can sustain and possibly grow that technology investment. That's something we want to accomplish and believe we must accomplish for the medium and long term.
Bill Carcache
analystThat's really useful. On a different note, regarding capital, could you provide some additional detail about how you're approaching the CECL and CARES Act phase-ins in terms of your capacity to give back surplus capital? And also, is it possible that we might see you raise that $1.6 billion authorization if the macro backdrop turns favorable and you wind up freeing up a meaningful level of reserves as 2021 goes on?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. Let me break that down. The first component, in every model we've run as we go through '20 and truly '21, we have consistently incorporated the transition adjustment tied to CECL, and without question, that would be drawn from — we look at capital generation during those years as we move forward; it's approximately, I believe, 60 basis points if the rules remain unchanged. Honestly, we keep having conversations with our stakeholders regarding some form of permanent capital relief, since we clearly think that when you consider our Tier 1 plus reserves at 27%, that's quite elevated, given where we stand, and we think there ought to be credit, whether it's in Tier 2 or Tier 1, in relation to CECL. So that has always been a consideration within our plans and really shouldn't have an effect on it. As for the second portion of what you asked, the better macroeconomic outlook, certainly, we aren't locked into the $1.6 billion; that's simply how we see it at present. We'll work through our capital planning process here during the first quarter, obtain Board approval for our capital plan in March, and file it in April. And then ideally, we'll return to you during the second quarter with a more complete picture. But there's a scenario in which we can plainly give back potentially additional capital. I think at this moment, $1.6 billion is — we're at January 29 and transitioning into a year that's somewhat uncertain isn't a terrible spot to begin the year. So we'll keep watching things the same way each quarter. We had believed we wouldn't take any action until the latter half of this year. So we'll keep assessing it, Bill.
Kathryn Miller
executiveVanessa, there are 5 additional individuals waiting in line, yet we only have room for 1 further question.
John Hecht
analystCongrats to Margaret and Brian, plus a warm welcome to Kathryn. One more thing about the RSA. I'm curious, since we're able to review past typical figures and recognize that it could be inflated owing to the charge-off cycle. First, does anything stand out as unusual, such as a level where our typical RSA ought to land across time? I'm not focused on its prior position, and it seems a slight shift could occur from the Walmart transition; yet is there any other factor that might alter the longer-term typical RSA figures?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYeah. Appreciate it, John. The straightforward response would be no. Clearly, Walmart, if you remove it, will drive the RSA upward since it ran at an RSA below what the company averages. Aside from that, nothing basic is going on. What I believe is tripping people up, and I get how that looks from the outside, is that CECL has hugely reshaped how profitable this company is. And that's really tough. We're behind on CECL, yet when delinquencies aren't showing up at a retail partner, it's tough to approach them and claim, fine, despite no delinquencies appearing, they will arrive eventually, so here's $100 million, $200 million. Regrettably, that's what drives the RSA up at this point. Then, considering credit truly beating the loss within NIM, our RSA sits at its highest. Over the long run, I believe, combining '20 and '21, it will return to the average. And definitely, once the pandemic ends, nothing in the structure means they ought to run at a separate level, aside from the Walmart effect.
John Hecht
analystMy final question concerns the new offerings you mentioned, and I completely understand how much they center on the customer. But when does the shifting combination of those new offerings begin to affect, say, the financial workings of your company? Take the closed end product, for example — it could carry a larger merchant discount that would move through what I'd guess is a separate line item on your P&L. So when should we expect shifts in that mix? And what would that look like — what shape could it take?
Brian Doubles
executiveSure. Appreciate it, John. Let me take that one. Look, as you're aware, our approach to pricing is quite disciplined. We aim to keep pricing that delivers a solid, appealing return for whichever program or product we're underwriting. That won't change. There are definitely trade-offs, no question; and the way you make money on these products differs somewhat. Clearly, with shorter-dated promotions, perhaps you capture a higher merchant discount, while taking less from the APR or from the consumer. Still, I wouldn't expect a meaningful effect on our total profitability return over the longer term — you'd likely just see the pieces shift, and as you know, both of those flow through net interest income. So I doubt you'd observe any significant impact there. Brian, I'm not sure if you'd like to add anything.
Brian Wenzel
executiveThat's right. John, our asset base stands at 81 billion dollars. So for any metric to shift meaningfully, whatever we did would need to be enormous in scale. Sure, you'll notice faster growth percentages coming from rivals that are far smaller. Still, with 81 billion dollars behind us, the impact shouldn't be significant, at least over the near and medium term, given how favorably our P&L is positioned.
Brian Doubles
executiveMy view is that over the longer term, these will represent genuinely appealing growth paths for us. When it comes to this overall product strategy, we actually handle far more of this kind of business than most people would guess. Clearly, revolving credit is what we're known for, but installment is a big part of what we do too. Underwriting it is something we're quite at ease with. Pricing is another area where we're quite at ease; and as I mentioned, growth there looks slightly stronger than what we're seeing in our other products; so ultimately, I find that encouraging. Once again, it boils down to what partners and customers choose, and we're able to deliver whatever solution our partners are looking for.
Operator
operatorAnd thanks. That wraps up the Q&A portion. Thank you, ladies and gentlemen. That brings our conference call to a close. We appreciate everyone for joining. You're welcome to disconnect at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Synchrony Financial transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Synchrony Financial earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Synchrony Financial or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.