Synchrony Financial (SYF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 19, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Kathryn Miller
executiveThanks, and good morning to all of you. It's a pleasure to have you join our conference call covering this quarter's earnings. Along with the press release issued today, we've also made available a presentation that goes over the subjects we intend to discuss on today's call. You can find the press release, the detailed financial schedules, and the presentation on our site, synchronyfinancial.com; to view this material, simply navigate to the Investor Relations portion of the site. Prior to beginning, I'd like to note that forward-looking statements will be part of what we say today. Such statements carry risks and uncertainty, and actual results might differ materially. The factors that could lead actual results to differ materially are listed in our SEC filings, which you can access on our website. On this call, non-GAAP financial measures will be referenced when we discuss how the Company performed. A reconciliation of those measures to GAAP financial measures appears in the materials for today's call. Lastly, Synchrony Financial bears no responsibility for, and neither edits nor guarantees the accuracy of, earnings teleconference transcripts that third parties provide. The only authorized webcasts can be found on our website; joining us this morning are Brian Doubles, Synchrony's President and Chief Executive Officer, and Brian Wenzel, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. I'll hand the call over now to Brian Doubles.
Brian Doubles
executiveThank you, Kathryn, and good morning to all of you. Our third quarter financial results once again demonstrate the strength of Synchrony's business model. We keep expanding our reach and providing service to a growing number of partners and customers. We opened 17% more new accounts, totaling 6.2 million, while average active accounts rose 5% to 67.2 million for the period. A major driver of this was the potent blend of our insights powered by data, our frictionless customer experiences, and our best-in-class product offerings, all of which connect strongly with customers. Synchrony's omnichannel abilities let our partners and customers engage at any place and any time they wish to be served, and the range of financing choices and value propositions we provide gives them the power of selection. By continuously foreseeing and fulfilling what our partners and customers need, we generate additional value and higher utilization. This yielded an 11% gain in purchase volume per active account for the third quarter, along with 16% growth in total purchase volume versus a year ago. Naturally, this purchase volume strength was mostly counterbalanced by payment rate trends that stayed elevated because of government stimulus and forbearance actions across the industry, producing a 2% rise in loans, including loans held for sale. Net interest margin came in at 15.45%, which was 165 basis points above the prior year, mainly driven by less excess liquidity. Operating expenses declined 10% from a year earlier and fell 7% year-to-date, as our cost efficiency programs proceed according to plan. We are still set to take out roughly 210 million from our expense base by the end of the year, while we keep investing in our business. The efficiency ratio reached 38.7% this quarter, essentially unchanged from last year. Credit quality remains very strong. Net charge-offs totaled 2.18% in the third quarter, a drop of 224 basis points versus last year. Net earnings came to 1.1 billion, or $2 per diluted share, and that figure included a $0.33 benefit tied to the reserve release stemming from reclassifying the GAAP portfolio to held-for-sale. Now looking at our balance sheet, deposits fell 3 billion, or 5%, compared with last year, which mirrors the retail deposit rate moves we made to control our excess liquidity. At quarter end, deposits made up 82% of our funding mix, a modest uptick from last year thanks to debt retirement. Over the quarter, we gave back 1.4 billion in capital, consisting of 1.3 billion in share repurchases plus 124 million in common stock dividends; we also keep putting money back into our business. As we pointed out at our recent Investor Day, our capacity to stay agile and adjust to the constantly evolving consumer finance environment stems from our ongoing investment in our product lineup and our cutting-edge digital tools. Actually, when you look at just the past 10 years, things like digital wallets arriving, point-of-sale financing, and a wider range of installment options — to give just a few examples — have shown how much diversity, accessibility, and utility matter in products and in experience; that's why Synchrony has kept evolving, layering in fresh financing choices, upgrading our technology platform, and growing our channels and distribution networks so we can reach and serve additional partners and customers in sustainable ways that create more value for everyone. Beyond rolling out new products and partner programs, we're staying focused on innovative approaches to achieving scaled distribution for our product suite. Last week, we unveiled a broader strategic partnership with FiServ, and through it small businesses can now get Synchrony products and services and take private-label credit card payments using the Clover point of sale and business management platform from FiServ. That makes faster growth possible for small businesses, giving merchants the power to draw in more customers and bring in more revenue by providing our customers more flexibility and choice in how they make purchases. We'll also look into further chances to cross-sell Synchrony products to merchants already on Clover. Crucially, this strategic partnership additionally strengthens Synchrony's ecosystem and backs our growth strategy of expanding and speeding up innovative product offerings via extra distribution channels; it extends our momentum toward getting products to merchants more quickly and draws on Synchrony's leadership along with financing, analytics, and services. We're eager to use the point of sale innovations Clover drives to keep reshaping how people buy while assisting merchants in growing. What's more, as our partners and we work to give customers more comprehensive access to financial products and resources, we're eager to broaden our partnership with PayPal. As was announced in late September, Synchrony, we'll be launching PayPal savings, a brand-new savings account under the PayPal brand. This distinctive opportunity lets us widen distribution of our savings product to a distinctive set of customers, with features and functionality within the PayPal App providing an improved customer experience, while further diversifying our deposit base at an appealingly low cost to acquire. Alongside our continued work to grow both our product suite and distribution network, we also aim to boost partner and customer engagement via tailored value propositions and omnichannel capabilities; we recently introduced 2 industry first, retail health and wellness credit cards: the myWalgreens MasterCard and myWalgreens private-label credit card, which give customers savings on future health and wellness purchases. Holders of the myWalgreens credit card can earn 10% Walgreens cash rewards on eligible Walgreens branded products and 5% Walgreens cash rewards on other eligible brands and pharmacy purchases. Holders of the myWalgreens MasterCard can also earn 3% Walgreens cash rewards on eligible grocery and health and wellness purchases everywhere else, including healthcare providers and 1% Walgreens cash rewards on eligible purchases anywhere MasterCard credit cards are accepted. As consumers shoulder a larger share of their healthcare expenses, we think these value propositions will create substantial value, offer more flexible financing for health needs, and strengthen loyalty as time goes on. On top of that, Synchrony's digital tools let us connect effortlessly with customers no matter where they happen to be. Across Walgreens' web, mobile, and native app channels, we have deep digital integration, so customers can apply instantly by means of any of those channels. We've rolled out frictionless customer experiences, drawing on technology such as QR codes and quick screen — a real-time pre-screen combined into one — along with customer-initiated pre-qualification, a directed device in-store application process, card servicing woven seamlessly into the Walgreens app, and an API integration with the myWalgreens loyalty program. Although it remains early, the first data we're seeing suggests that both the value prop and the dynamic customer experience we've built with Walgreens are landing very well with card holders, driving spend both inside and outside Walgreens in categories like grocery, health, and wellness. By giving our partners and customers best-in-class wallet optionality along with compelling outcomes, Synchrony is ever more well-positioned as the partner of choice. Boasting over 65 million active accounts, Synchrony enjoys market-leading reach and deep, diverse lending insights that let us anticipate customer needs more effectively, and thus determine which financing options will optimize utilization and drive lifetime value. So whether it arrives through our dual, co-branded, and private-label credit cards, our various SEP pay installment products, or our Synchrony MasterCard, we understand deeply when, why, and how customers view financing solutions for their everyday purchases; we're especially enthusiastic about the opportunity we see for our Synchrony MasterCard, which lets us tap into the 500 billion general purpose credit card market. Our approach to growth is measured. Even so, by leveraging our scale and underwriting expertise, we've managed to identify better performing customer segments, acquire more customers at lower CPAs, and fine-tuned our channel strategy across the last two years. These days Synchrony MasterCard provides a range of value propositions that we pair with our pricing strategy to broaden our customer reach and optimize conversion. And we have excellent digital utility through dApply and integration in Apple wallet, plus our mobile app; this lets customers reach their various bank products, their money market, and high-yield savings accounts, as well as our credit card balances and transaction data. This value proposition and seamless digital experience lands very well with our customer, leading to purchase volume growth of 36% versus the same period in 2019. We're also witnessing higher levels of engagement around the product and brand, since spend per active account is up 40% versus 2019. So we're very excited about our Synchrony MasterCard. This is a key part of our product lineup approach that we expect will let us win a bigger share of customers' top-of-wallet spending, which should fuel highly scalable expansion and returns that beat average for our business across the long term. With that said, I'll now hand the call to Brian.
Brian Wenzel
executiveThank you, Brian, and good morning to all of you. Our financial results for the third quarter at Synchrony show strength that is broad-based throughout the business, marked by a purchase volume increase in the double digits along with ongoing growth in loans, a substantial gain in our net interest margin, losses and delinquencies at historically low levels, and ongoing discipline on costs. These results, taken together, produced $1.1 billion in net earnings, or $2 per diluted share, a return on average assets of 4.9%, and a return on tangible common equity of 40.1%. What these results truly demonstrate is the strength of Synchrony's distinctive business model, which is built on our deep expertise in the consumer lending domain and makes use of dynamic digital capabilities, delivered via our comprehensive suite of multiple products, to reach and serve a deep and diverse universe of partners and customers. When we look more closely at how we performed in the third quarter, starting with purchase volume, it rose 16% versus last year and 16% versus 2019, with Walmart excluded, which clearly shows broad-based consumer demand strength. Our purchase volume per account also reflects this, rising 11% versus last year. Dual card and co-branded cards represent 40% of third quarter purchase volume and rose 29% from the prior year; measured on a loan receivable basis, and excluding the effect of the reclassification to GAAP portfolio to held-for-sale, dual and co-branded cards made up 24% of the portfolio and grew 4% from the prior year. Average active accounts rose 5% versus last year, and new accounts rose 17%, amounting to more than 6 million new accounts during the third quarter, and over 17.5 million new accounts year-to-date. In late August, we agreed to sell the GAAP portfolio, which caused $3.5 billion of loan receivables to be reclassified to held-for-sale and consequently lowered our ending loan receivables balance. If you set aside the reclassification's impact, loan receivables would have risen by 2% versus the prior year, since strong purchase volume growth during the period was largely offset by a payment rate that remained persistently elevated. The payment rate in the third quarter was roughly 200 basis points higher than last year. Interest and fees on loans rose 2% versus last year, mirroring similar growth in average loan receivables. Net interest income came in 6% above last year, mainly due to a decrease in interest expense from lower benchmark rates. RSAs totaled $1.3 billion in the third quarter, which is 6.38% of average receivables. The $367 million year-over-year increase chiefly reflected the effect of the lower provision for credit losses along with continued strong program performance, including growth and improvement in net interest income. To put this in context, keep in mind that our RSAs are structured to align interests between us and each of our partners. That means driving growth at attractive risk-adjusted returns, which enhances program profitability. This lets each partner share in the progress and performance. So when profitability expands, our partners take part in that upside. Turning to the combined $1.4 billion year-over-year gain across net interest income, net losses, and the reserve change — through the RSA, $367 million of that was shared with investors. On credit performance, our provision for losses came in at $25 million. This quarter's provision included a reserve release of $407 million, which captured continued strength in credit performance, an optimistic macroeconomic backdrop, and the effect of reclassifying our GAAP portfolio loan receivables to held-for-sale. That produced a reserve reduction of roughly $247 million. Other income fell $37 million, largely mirroring higher loyalty program costs tied to greater purchase volume in the quarter. Compared with a year earlier, other expense was down $106 million. As you'll remember, we booked an $89 million restructuring charge last year, and we keep seeing favorability from lower operational losses. On Slide 8, our platform results. Broad-based purchase volume growth showed up across all 5 platforms, signaling strong consumer demand. Each of our HOME and auto, diversified and value, digital, and health and wellness platforms posted double-digit year-over-year purchase volume growth. The 10% year-over-year rise in home and auto was mostly the result of strong retailer performance across nearly every vertical, while purchase volume in diversified value climbed 25%, reflecting the ongoing return to in-person retail experiences. Within digital, the 21% gain came from broad-based growth among our partners, paired with growth in our new programs with Verizon and Venmo. In health and wellness, the 10% purchase volume growth mainly reflected consumers feeling more at ease with the environment and moving forward with planned procedures. Purchase volume in Lifestyle, meanwhile, grew a more modest 2%, reflecting broad-based growth across the platform, though it faced a tough comparable against last year's strong growth in power sports. Loan receivable growth trends by platform largely mirrored modest growth rates versus the prior year, since higher purchase volume was mostly offset by elevated payment rates. The sole exception was our diversified and value platform, which store closures in 2020 affected. Average active accounts trends varied by platform, rising by as much as 10% in diversified value and 7% in digital, while average active accounts in home and auto and health and wellness were generally flat. The active account growth in diversified value largely reflected the return to in-store retail experiences. Digital active accounts rose versus the prior year on greater engagement across our existing customer base, plus the impact of recent program launches. Interest and fee trends generally improved across the platform, except for diversified value, which is down due to lower receivables. I'll turn to Slide 9 to discuss net interest income and margin trends. Cumulative savings by consumers from stimulus, forbearance, and lower discretionary spending kept weighing on payment rates during the third quarter. Paying rates ran approximately 260 basis points above our five-year store average. Even so, in some cohorts we've started noticing a bit of easing, since the payment rate came in roughly 200 basis points above where it stood a year earlier, versus a comparison of nearly 300 basis points higher year over year in the second quarter. Our expectation is that the pay rate will steadily return to normal, given that consumer spending is still strong, excess savings have already topped out, and broad-based forbearance is fading away. Interest and fees rose about 2% during the third quarter, which mirrors growth in average loan receivables. Net interest income climbed 6% versus a year ago, mirroring the year-over-year gain in interest and fees along with reduced interest expense during the period. Net interest margin came to 15.45%, against last year's 13.8%, which works out to a 165 basis point year-over-year gain, powered by the composition of interest earning assets and a favorable cost on interest-bearing liabilities. To put it more precisely, loan receivables as a share of total earning assets rose 550 basis points, moving from 78.3% to 83.8%, which stemmed from less liquidity being held over the quarter. That contributed 106 basis points of increase to our net interest margin. Costs on interest-bearing liabilities stood at 1.31%, a 59 basis point improvement from a year earlier, largely because of lower benchmark rates and the funding mix. That gave us a 51 basis point lift in our net interest margin. The yield on loan receivables reached 19.59%, a 10 basis point gain year over year; that translated into an eight basis point boost to our net interest margin.
Brian Wenzel
executiveNow I'll go over the main credit developments, which you'll find on Slide 10. To begin, let's talk about how our delinquency patterns, along with higher payment patterns, have kept producing improvements when compared with a year ago. At 2.42%, our 30+ delinquency rate came in versus 2.67% during the same period a year earlier. The 90+ delinquency rate stood at 1.05%, against 1.24% a year ago. Worth noting: if you strip out the effect of the GAAP program in the third quarter of both this year and last year, the 30+ delinquency figure would have fallen roughly 40 basis points rather than 25 basis points; and the 90+ figure would have dropped about 25 basis points rather than 19 basis points; and when it comes to how our portfolio's losses performed, our net charge-off rate registered 2.18%, versus 4.42% a year earlier. The improvement against the prior year came mainly from the robust delinquency pattern we've seen. As a percentage of loan receivables, our allowance for credit losses stood at 11.28%. Let's turn to slide 11 to talk about expenses. On the whole, expenses fell $106 million, or 10%, from a year ago, landing at $961 million, largely because of the prior year's restructuring charge of $89 million and reduced operational losses. During the third quarter, the efficiency ratio came in at 38.7%, versus 39.7% a year earlier. That metric is still elevated compared with our historical average, a result of lower revenue stemming from the effect of a higher payment rate and lower average receivables; we keep up our disciplined emphasis on containing costs, even as we make strategic investments in our business aimed at deepening our competitive advantage and generating long-term value for shareholders. On to Slide 12. Because loan receivables shrank in 2020 and early 2021, combined with the strength of our deposit platform, we keep carrying a greater amount of liquidity. Although we consider it prudent to hold a greater liquidity level through uncertain and volatile stretches, we keep actively managing our funding profile in order to mitigate excess liquidity and optimize that profile. Thanks to this strategy, a shift occurred in our < > mix during the third quarter. Our deposits dropped by $3.2 billion from a year earlier, while our securitize and unsecured funding sources fell by $3 billion. As a result, deposits made up 82% of our funding, versus 80% a year earlier, with securitized and unsecured funding each accounting for 9% of our funding sources at quarter-end. Total liquidity, undrawn credit facilities included, came to 18.4 billion, equal to 20% of our total assets, down from 28% a year earlier. Before I give you details on our capital position, note that we chose to take the benefit of the transition rules issued by the joint federal banking agencies, which offers two main benefits. First, it postpones the effect of the CECL transition adjustment by an incremental two years. And second, it permits a portion of the current period provisioning to be deferred and amortized along with the transition adjustment. So using this framework, we finished the quarter with a CET1 ratio of 17.1% under the CECL transition rules, which is 130 basis points higher than the 15.8% we had a year ago. On those same CECL transition rules, the tier 1 capital ratio came in at 18%, versus 16.7% last year. Our total capital ratio rose 120 basis points, reaching 19.3%. Meanwhile, the ratio of Tier 1 capital plus reserves, on a fully phased-in basis, fell to 26.6%, down from 27.3% a year earlier. Over the quarter, we gave back $1.4 billion to shareholders — that figure includes $1.3 billion of share repurchases along with $124 million paid out as common stock dividends. Strong returns and substantial capital are produced by our business, thanks to our dedication to generating growth at suitable risk-adjusted returns, the scalability of our technology platform, and the cost discipline we maintain. As business performance and market conditions permit, and subject to our capital plan and any regulatory restrictions, we'll keep taking an opportunistic approach when it comes to returning excess capital to shareholders. Now let me turn to our outlook for the fourth quarter, which you can find summarized on Slide 13 of our presentation. Although several external variables are hard to forecast precisely, we broadly anticipate that the key operating trends from the third quarter will hold steady in the fourth quarter. A stable and improving macroeconomic environment, along with the pandemic remaining largely under control, forms the foundation of our forecast. We anticipate robust consumer demand throughout the holiday season, which should sustain continued strength in purchase volume. That strength, partly offset by payment rates that remain elevated, ought to produce modest growth in receivables. Our net interest margin will likely be in line with 3Q '21. The impact of asset growth, credit performance, and macroeconomic factors will keep shaping our provision for credit losses, along with continued reserve reductions tied to the GAAP portfolio. As credit losses start to normalize, we expect the RSA as a percent of average loan receivables to begin moderating. Finally, on operating expense, we anticipate that the acceleration in purchase volume will drive a slight sequential rise in absolute dollars for the fourth quarter. Even so, we still expect full-year operating expenses to be lower than they were in 2020. As we wrap up the year and look ahead, we're enthusiastic about the opportunities before us to keep delivering strong financial results and shareholder value. The strategy we presented during our Investor Day leaves us well-positioned to execute and to drive sustainable growth at attractive risk-adjusted returns, simply by continuing to leverage the core strengths we already have. Those include the breadth and depth of our business model, the scalability of our innovative digital capabilities, and the customer lifetime value expansion we generate through our diversified product suite and powerful value propositions. I'll now hand the call back to Brian for his closing remarks.
Brian Doubles
executiveThanks, Brian. The results our team keeps producing for Synchrony's partners, customers, and stakeholders make me genuinely proud. We possess an understanding that is truly one of a kind when it comes to the broad spectrum of needs our partners and customers are looking to meet at any moment. And because we tackle those needs differently than others, we're able to provide solutions and experiences that strike a deep chord. Be it the optionality built into our varied product suite and tailored value propositions, or the numerous ways we fuel the link between our partners and customers, Synchrony keeps reaching, engaging, and serving additional customers while generating bigger, more lasting outcomes for our stakeholders. Having said that, I'll hand the call back to Kathryn so she can kick off the Q&A.
Kathryn Miller
executiveAlright, that wraps up the remarks we had prepared. At this point, we're going to move into the Q&A portion. In order to get to as many of you as we can, I'd ask those joining to keep it to 1 main question and 1 follow-up. Should anything else come up, our Investor Relations team will be around once the call ends. Operator, go ahead and open the Q&A.
Betsy Graseck
analystHey, good morning.
Brian Doubles
executiveGood morning, Betsy.
Brian Wenzel
executiveGood morning, Betsy.
Betsy Graseck
analystI have two things I'd like to ask about. First, I'm hoping you can share your perspective on the purchase volume and the spend volume you've generated up to this point. It's clearly been picking up speed. At the same time, some of the general purpose card activity we're seeing in the market strikes me as somewhat soft, and I'd like your take on that.
Brian Wenzel
executiveSure. I'll kick things off, and Brian is welcome to add anything if he has further thoughts, Betsy. Here's my take: relative to general-purpose cards, their decline was steeper, and they carried bigger exposure to certain T&E categories and other types of purchases, so our results didn't fall by as much as theirs did in the prior year. On purchase volume, the first thing I'd note is that it's coming from across the board on every one of our platforms, and the performance we've seen has been quite strong. Lifestyle is the one exception, and that's because it faced a really tough comparison against last year in power sports and outdoor power equipment; even so, looking at it week by week across the quarter, it held remarkably steady from the quarter's opening week all the way through, and that pattern has carried into the first couple of weeks of October. So the activity level on the card makes us quite happy. It spans a wide range of categories. Even with the modest travel and entertainment exposure we carry, we watched that pick up, with travel rising 75% on either our co-branded card or the Synchrony MasterCard. Restaurants climbed 44%. So that growth is showing up. Still, our business has been highly consistent, and we view that as a genuine strength as we head into the fourth quarter.
Brian Doubles
executiveThe one point I'd tack on is that we're seeing genuinely strong expansion in new accounts as well. That's really laying the groundwork for what we expect will be robust purchase growth as we head into '22. New accounts rose 17%, and once you strip out Walmart, they climbed 37%. So that's quite solid momentum in new accounts, and in my view it's a favorable signal for the quarters ahead.
Betsy Graseck
analystYeah. No, I understood that. That was really impressive, for sure. And then, looking at the guidance you gave, I realize there's a ton of language about modest increases and decreases, that kind of thing. I just wanted to focus on the RSI and figure out how we ought to be approaching it. I see that program profitability rose this quarter, thanks to the NIM strength and the credit strength, so I suppose my question is, if I look ahead, how do I think about where that RSA is heading? Because the pace of change in those 2 areas clearly begins to decline, and credit begins to accumulate. Yet at the same time, marketing and other sorts of costs flow into that RSA. And I'm trying to figure out how to reason through how much < > What's the new normal we should be aiming for.
Brian Doubles
executiveBetsy, let me just step back and keep reinforcing the point that the RSAs function exactly as they were built to, correct — as the Company's profitability grows, we'll share a larger amount on the RSA. So that's how it's designed. It's the cushion we all want when things go bad, though we'd rather have the good times. So at this moment, we're simply going to — we're going to pay out more. I think you ought to think about
Brian Wenzel
executiveGoing forward, how that metric develops will align more closely with the NIM of the business as well as net charge-offs. So at this point, we'd anticipate charge-offs sitting at a trough, with only a slight increase. Once charge-offs start climbing, that flows straight through — with the RSA, there really isn't a delayed impact from charge-offs. And I believe — if you consider the business's margin together with its revenue side, as delinquencies start to climb, revenue rises, so that gets passed along. Then, when write-offs begin to appear, the NIM will decline somewhat; so my sense is it will hopefully track in parallel. A delay exists solely where reserve changes are concerned, though it ought to track alongside the business. And once more, our view is that delinquencies have likely hit their trough right now, but we'll watch how things unfold; still, we're happy with the performance and happy with the way the RSA actually behaved, since it tracked alongside the business results.
Betsy Graseck
analystYeah. Thanks.
Brian Doubles
executiveThank you, Betsy.
John Hecht
analystMorning everyone, and thanks for letting me ask. With new accounts climbing 17%, I'd like to know how much of that growth is driven by newer channels such as Verizon and Venmo, and how much simply reflects deeper reach within our longer-standing partnerships.
Brian Wenzel
executiveSure, John. Here's how I'd put it: are the new programs delivering in line with what we expected on account performance? Given our scale, they simply aren't big enough to move the business much. What we're actually seeing is strength among certain traditional retailers that have reopened and brought back that in-store shopping experience, plus ongoing growth within our digital programs and platforms—so it's pretty broad-based. No area is falling behind, in our view. I think once people began engaging again after the pandemic, so to speak, in shopping, it comes down to the multiple products we offer and the strong value propositions behind them, and it's spread across the board. We look for that to carry through the fourth quarter and the holiday season.
Brian Doubles
executiveSure, John — I'd say it's clearly a mix of factors, with Venmo, Verizon, Walgreens and that appealing new value profit Sam's Club all in play. Still, I'd credit a big share of it to the digital investments we've been making, since we've made applying so much simpler whether you're in a store, on your phone, or online. These days you can complete it within seconds. You simply fill in a few fields, do it straight from your phone, or even scan a QR code while you're inside a store. So it's really about making the application easier. In terms of what the business is going through, I believe all the macro tailwinds are definitely present. Yet this is the point where the digital investments we've made across the last five years are truly beginning to pay off.
John Hecht
analystAll right, that's useful, thank you. Then for my second question, could you tell us how much reserve release is still left on the GAAP side?
Brian Wenzel
executiveSure, John. I'd put the total provision at roughly $400 million, and there's approximately $150 million still to flow through across the next couple of quarters. When exactly that lands and at what pace really hinges on how the portfolio performs as we work through it. That said, the initial portion is, of course, the largest under held-for-sale accounting.
John Hecht
analystOkay. Great. Thanks, guys.
Brian Doubles
executiveThanks, John.
Brian Wenzel
executiveThank you, John.
Rick Shane
analystGood morning, everyone, and thanks. I want to spend a moment on that online sales figure you gave, the 40%. What I'm wondering is how you see that stacking up against the peer average for general purpose, and also how it looks next to your own general purpose, because when we think about spending picking back up as the economy reopens, I'm curious whether there's leverage to be had there, given that you do more in person than a number of your peers.
Brian Wenzel
executiveWell, that's a number where we clearly believe we've over-indexed when it comes to sales done online and through mobile. You only have to look at our partners, at Amazon, PayPal, Verizon, and others. There's definitely leverage in that, I'd say. When you look at the portfolio mix — and we laid some of this out at Investor Day, in terms of where we expect a great deal of the growth to come from over the longer term within the Company — it's plainly going to be over-indexed when it comes to online sales. That speaks especially to our digital partners as they take a bigger share of the business overall; though I'd add that with some of the more traditional partners we work with, we've been, I believe, instrumental in assisting them as they transform their footprints to be more digital; so that's been a major piece of what we've attempted to do, especially across the last couple of years, in response to the pandemic. A lot of our partners were forced to shut stores, they shifted a great deal of their sales online; and we played a big role in how they managed to meet that need and transform their businesses. So there's certainly leverage ahead, that's for sure.
Rick Shane
analystGreat. Thank you.
Don Fandetti
analystBrian, I was just wondering if you might speak a bit about — I mean, it appears that 30-day plus day delinquencies have hit a trough here, and looking ahead, we're going to normalize. When do you believe they will begin turning positive on a year-over-year basis? Is that a mid next year type event, or could you discuss that normalization process?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYeah. Don, good morning. Let me walk you through two scenarios regarding delinquency. The first one leans a bit more cautious. In that scenario, delinquencies climb more steeply, beginning in Q4 of this year, hitting their highest point in Q3 of next year, and then driving a peak in charge-offs during Q1 of 2023. That's the more conservative scenario. What drives it is this: consumers exit forbearance programs, government aid, and renter forbearance without having built up enough savings to stay current, which produces that steeper, more conservative outcome. If things go better than expected, delinquency increases would be gentler from 2022 through 2023, and then losses would return to normal—by which I mean the average, roughly 5.5%—as we move from late 2023 into 2024. That's a far more moderate climb. This scenario assumes consumers saved enough that, once their financial obligations resume, they can keep paying their bills and handle them. Those are the two extremes I'd keep in mind.
Don Fandetti
analystThat's genuinely useful. Thanks, Brian. Is there anything regarding acquisitions—maybe add-on fintech companies or portfolios—that you're evaluating as potentially strong options?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. What I'd say is, we've got a really busy M&A pipeline. Our teams are screening opportunities daily. One item I can mention is that during the pandemic, we'd been hoping valuations would return closer to reasonable levels. Instead, what happened was the reverse. So pricing remains quite high out there, whether you're talking about capabilities or businesses. We are definitely reviewing quite a few possibilities—I'd describe them as current businesses where our scale can be used to help them expand. Allegro Credits stands out as an excellent illustration of this. That's a prime instance of it, since we can apply our scaling in Care Credit plus health and wellness, acquire those businesses, and truly help them grow effectively, something we discussed briefly at Investor Day regarding our approach. However, we will remain disciplined. What we want are acquisitions that are strategic as well as accretive, so we've kept pretty strict on that front, though the team remains highly engaged with that product.
Don Fandetti
analystThank you. Okay.
Brian Wenzel
executiveYeah.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystThank you, and good morning. There are just 2 things I'd like to ask — 1 for Brian Wenzel and 1 for Brian Doubles. Brian Wenzel, regarding the guidance, when we consider what's expected for the net interest margin, my sense is that you're building in a pickup in loan growth, and delinquency ought to be higher. Wouldn't that be a positive for the NIM? So as we head into the coming quarter, shouldn't the NIM really come in stronger, or is something else holding it back?
Brian Wenzel
executiveWell, good morning to you first of all, Sanjay. There are a couple of things — that loan growth you'll see, which clearly sits in the denominator, actually drives the NIM lower. And then, thinking it through, you do get — a bit of an offset will come as charge-offs and delinquency move higher, since you'll see some reversal of write-offs flow back through. So I'd say that isn't really inconsistent with, I believe, prior years, if you go back a couple of years; it ought to line up with that. That said, once more, we're quite happy that the NIM is up in the 15+% range, which I'm aware many people zeroed in on back when we stood 165 basis points beneath where we are now. So clearly this performance pleases us.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystDefinitely. That was clearly a solid move quarter over quarter. And then Brian Doubles, you folks have obviously completed several initiatives, or perhaps several, just during the past three months: the Pay in 4 launch, that embedded finance tie-up with PayPal, plus the Clover partnership, and in the press release you mentioned positioning for a varied set of partners. I was just wondering how we ought to view other things, such as the product pipeline ahead. Are there additional arrangements similar to that, where you'll serve as an embedded partner from a financial perspective for other tech companies? And then how does that factor into the business model, such as the revenues and expenses looking forward? Does the makeup of those revenues shift, or how should we be thinking about that? Thanks.
Brian Doubles
executiveI wouldn't, Sanjay. I'd pull back a bit and consider our strategy in essentially two major parts. First, one is heavily centered on products. We devoted considerable time to this at Investor Day. We think we offer the most comprehensive product suite available, whether that's private label, dual co-brand cards, buy now, pay later, short and long-term installment. And so, we believe that is, clearly, quite important, given how varied our partners' situations are and what they seek from us. The other truly key element of the strategy is essentially about distribution of those financial products. So this is — consider integration into the merchants and providers, making it simpler to apply for those products and truly achieving that scale. So having the products is one matter, but you must have the distribution channels too. And so if you look back over time, we do plenty when it comes to direct partner integrations. So that's utilizing our APIs Synchrony plug-in, and so on; but in certain instances, we're aiming to broaden distribution via practice management systems such as Aptec. Whenever we can create a solution once and reach thousands of merchants, we definitely want to do so, and that's really what Clover provides for us. With the creation of a single app, we can reach thousands of merchants; we can access their, approximately, 180 billion of GPV. So we consider this a major opportunity and it lets us do something once and gain immediate scale. And so, if there — We're examining — we're actively reviewing other opportunities to do that for our products. But this is really, think of it as truly a two-pronged approach. You must have the product set, but then you must have a distribution channel or a setting distribution channels that let you scale rapidly and get those products made available to our merchants and their customers.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystOkay. Great. Thank you.
Brian Doubles
executiveThanks Sanjay.
Bill Carcache
analystThanks. Morning. I'd like to follow up regarding credit. When we think about NCO rates moving back up to more typical levels from where they sit now, people have worried this might create headwinds when it comes to building reserves. That said, given that your reserve rate remains significantly above the day 1 figure of slightly less than 10%, does it make sense to think the reserve rate will keep trending downward from here, even while NCO rates rise toward normal, meaning that the process of credit normalizing wouldn't automatically result in reserve-building headwinds? Just some big-picture thoughts on that. Those dynamics would be really useful.
Brian Wenzel
executiveYeah. Thanks, and good morning, Bill. How I view charge-offs and reserve build is that our reserve build is really still going to be shaped by asset growth and the macroeconomic assumptions. You're right that right now we're running at 11 — a bit below 11.3%. Our CSO day 1 stood at 10%, and we anticipate that migration occurring over time. Again, CSO day one was 10%. We never truly had a normal quarter under CSO; but if you take that as a reference point, that's the direction we'd expect to head back toward. So you're correct, there will be some rate movement, but once more, asset builds will be the dominant factor; so as for reserve provisioning, there could be reserve builds that arise and are partly offset by more typical rate decreases as you get closer, depending on, again, how credit performs and what the macroeconomic picture looks like; but reserve builds won't be avoided if you're in a setting where assets are increasing.
Bill Carcache
analystGot it. That helps a lot. If there's room, one final question about buy now, pay later: have Pay in 4 and your other longer-term installment offerings been made available to all of your merchants? I realize it's early days, but do you see any sign of cannibalization among existing Synchrony customers who hold traditional Synchrony revolving credit products and who have enrolled in or are paying for Pay in 4? Or is it usually the case that someone choosing Pay in 4 wouldn't have been approved for credit at all and is simply using it to convert a debit card into a credit card? I'd welcome your perspective on that.
Brian Wenzel
executiveLet's perhaps step back for a moment, since I believe — and I'll split buy now, pay later into a few groups, because at present everything seems to be grouped under buy now, pay later. As we've said before, we handle roughly 15 billion in installment, short and long term combined. Those products are available at approximately 70 thousand locations now; and I truly think of it as two buckets. First is what we refer to as closed-end installment, or buy-now-pay-later. That's expanding quite nicely for us. It's simply a closed-end loan, quite straightforward, with various durations. And looking at the last 3 years, from 2017 to 2020,
Brian Doubles
executiveOn those closed-end offerings, the amount purchased has been increasing roughly 46% annually, so it's clear we're getting quite strong traction; buy now, pay later is already live with partners including Tula (ph), American Signature, Electronics Express. Under the brand < >. Then during Investor Day we mentioned that come October, our paying-for-product option will be offered to partners. So discussions are happening with them as we speak, covering integration plans and how to bring it to market. To your point, I'll say they're concentrating on precisely what you described, namely, in what way does this offering stack up against what they already provide? And we spent a lot of time at Investor Day discussing the economic equation for our partners. That, I can tell you, is something they weren't especially focused on, I'd say, 6 to 9 months back, though at present they are very
Brian Wenzel
executiveThey're really zeroing in on this. They're weighing the trade-offs of a conventional offering, where they could be earning in RSA, against what a short or long-term installment option like Pay in 4 looks like, where a merchant discount is what they're paying. And the way I see this unfolding is that there's going to be a great deal of testing and learning, watching how these offerings interact, what kind of customer uptake there is, and then, when all is said and done, what the economic equation back to the partner turns out to be. So that's one large bucket of what we refer to as installment, closed in, buy now, pay later. Another subject we covered is the option to pay over time — what we call buy now, pay later — which we extend to cardholders, meaning those with a revolving account. And this is an area where our partners continue to show an enormous level of genuine enthusiasm. What draws them in partly is the fact that a person can take on several installment plans, or buy-now-pay-later loans, without undergoing any additional credit review or filling out another application. On top of that, it lets the customer, at any moment they prefer, just go ahead with an ordinary purchase that isn't structured as an installment and still enjoy the value proposition — for example, saving 5% at Amazon. And from what we've seen, customers genuinely appreciate having that flexibility. When people make specific buys, they might prefer to split the cost into six or twelve equal installments through a buy-now-pay-later option, and occasionally they're looking to get the benefit that value proposition offers. The nice thing about this offering is that it supports either approach, ultimately giving the customer the power to decide. As for the partners, this works well for them since it enables richer lifecycle marketing—they're able to push out deals and promotions tied to holidays and similar moments. That ongoing lifecycle connection they maintain with the customer is something they value. To wrap up, every one of our partners seems to be approaching this somewhat uniquely—they're weighing how these offerings interact and running the numbers on the economics. The encouraging part, I'd say, is that when you take a step back and consider where we stand, our lineup of products is quite broad. A partner can come sit with us and essentially choose off a menu whatever they'd like to provide. Then we're able to show them the economics involved, along with our projections for what it'll mean for their sales, and so forth. That leaves me feeling we're in a strong position, since we have that product lineup. Our partners can be brought on board fast. And in the long run, we believe a strategy built around multiple products is the one coming out ahead.
Bill Carcache
analystThat is really useful. I appreciate you fielding my questions.
Brian Wenzel
executiveThank you, Bill.
Brian Doubles
executiveThanks, Bill.
John Pancari
analystMorning. Could you expand a bit further regarding what you anticipate for the payment rate? I understand your expectation is that labor rates will steadily return to normal. Perhaps you can help quantify that. Does it resemble what we saw drop in Q3, and are there any additional signs of accounts that usually revolve beginning to hold balances once more, if you could provide some detail on that. Thanks.
Brian Wenzel
executiveAbsolutely. Thank you; and good morning, John. Clearly, within the deck we presented the elevated figure we observed during the third quarter, and as we transition into Q4, once more, that level will stay elevated. I would direct you toward a few items when we consider the payment rate along with the patterns; we have performed considerable analysis attempting to confirm that, when we examine it, we think it will revert back to the mean, all that we have observed continues to bring us to that same judgment that a reversion back to the mean occurs. There are a few, what I'd term underlying data points I would attempt to direct you toward. First, when we examine savings rates among consumers, they are drifting downward toward a more normalized, pre-pandemic level. And we consider that both at the large money center banks and the digitally focused banks compared with what we observe concerning activity within our savings accounts; so one, savings is declining — the savings rate is declining, which once more, part of that will stem from the high purchase volume. Second, we begin examining cohorts within our portfolio; we do observe very modest downward shifts; so for example, if you examined at a product level, our dual card pride from Q2 to Q3 sequentially had a small decrease in the payment rate at a product level, that's a higher FICO customer starting to migrate back down. When you consider it concerning accounts that either pay full-pay, between full-pay, or statement balance, and min-pay, and then statement balance or below statement balances, throughout every one of those categories, we have witnessed a small reduction in that paying rate. So if you think about the individuals who paid stated balances, that is marginally lower in Q3 versus Q2. The individuals paying between statement balance and min-balance, that is lower during the third quarter than the second quarter, and then the min-pay is somewhat higher in Q3 versus Q2, and then the individuals paying under the min pay is somewhat higher, so I think as we begin seeing a very modest movement, those are movements that would indicate to us that the payment rate will shift back toward the mean that we experienced pre-pandemic or we are beginning to see a few signs there.
John Pancari
analystUnderstood, got it. Thanks, Brian, that's useful. Moving on to the second point about NIM — I appreciate the detail you provided earlier regarding a few of the dynamics behind the linked-quarter outlook. Is there any added chance on the funding side to keep refining the funding stack in a way that supports the NIM further out — something we might be able to factor in? Thanks.
Brian Wenzel
executiveLooking at our funding stack right now, retail deposits make up 82% of it. We haven't been an active issuer in the market, whether in '19 — sorry, in 20 or 21. My expectation is that we will tap the market. To start, I believe it benefits the Company's liquidity. So we'd anticipate seeing a modest amount of activity, since we haven't replaced a portion of that debt as it matures, though I'd guess our deposit funding rate stays elevated compared with the 70%, 75% we've guided to historically. I also see a chance with our PayPal savings product to keep widening our reach among retail customers. That's something we're excited about as it launches in the months ahead. So we'll keep concentrating on optimizing costs, while also preserving our access to the deep markets, both secured and unsecured. As we start to sequence the capital stack, we'd likely bring in additional funds to build out the Company's capital stack and reach our target level. So over time we plan to be an active issuer, doing so in a manner that keeps costs optimized.
John Pancari
analystUnderstood. Thanks, Brian. I appreciate your willingness to field my questions.
Brian Wenzel
executiveThanks.
Kathryn Miller
executiveThank you, Operator. I think we have time for one more question.
Mark DeVries
analystYes, thank you. We saw significant movement this quarter regarding your repurchase authorization. Could you talk about how buybacks might be paced moving forward, and should we anticipate any additional activity tied to the sale of the GAAP portfolio?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes, thanks Mark. Regarding GAAP — the manner in which GAAP capital gets released, clearly a smaller piece of the reserve release has flowed back through capital during this quarter, while the majority of that reserve release is set to occur in Q2 of next year, when we plan to transfer that portfolio; so that will likely be part of our following capital plan. Entering this quarter, $1.2 billion is left under the authorization we currently have. So we're happy with the share repurchases made in Q3. As previously stated, we'll be aggressive yet prudent going forward. And as always, we'll keep running our internal stress test model, assess business performance and the income profile, and if we judge it prudent, we'll talk with our board about possibly raising the authorization. But at this moment, $1.2 billion remains in front of us. And again, we aim to be aggressive yet prudent as we keep bringing Company's capital level down toward our longer-term target.
Mark DeVries
analystUnderstood, that helps. Now on a different topic, can you share what we should expect for OpEx going forward, given the push and pull between the cost-cutting efforts you already have underway, the winding down of the GAAP partnership, and the ongoing need to keep putting money into the platform?
Brian Wenzel
executiveBrian, Margaret, and the board have made it our top priority to keep funding the long-term bets we've made in the business through our strategic initiatives. We'll do just about anything to safeguard that spending, since it serves our shareholders' best interests and protects that long-term value. Beyond that, we've kept up our cost discipline and taken out a great deal of expense; we're on track to hit our $210 million this year. That said, we've made some decisions to put money back into certain parts of the business. That covers moving to $20 an hour for our non-exempt workforce and reinvesting in the business. When you get to the fourth quarter, I'd expect a modest bump, given some marketing and other items landing in that period; even so, looking ahead, once revenue recovers, we'd anticipate moving back toward an efficiency level in the low 30s, and staying disciplined on a dollar basis as we progress quarter by quarter through '22.
Mark DeVries
analystOkay. Great. Thank you.
Brian Doubles
executiveThanks, Mark.
Operator
operatorAppreciate it. That wraps up today’s earnings call, everyone. Thanks for joining us. You’re free to hang up now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Synchrony Financial transcript — plus 133,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Synchrony Financial earnings transcripts and 133,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Synchrony Financial or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.