Synchrony Financial (SYF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 28, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Kathryn Miller
executiveThank you, and good morning, everyone. I'd like to welcome you to our conference call covering quarterly earnings. Along with the press release issued today, we've made available a presentation that addresses the subjects we intend to discuss on this call. You can find the press release, comprehensive financial schedules, and the presentation on our website, synchronyfinancial.com; to reach this material, simply visit the Investor Relations section of that site. Before we begin, I'd like to remind everyone that forward-looking statements will be part of what we say today. Such statements carry risks and uncertainty, and actual results might differ materially; the factors that could cause actual results to differ materially are listed in our SEC filings, which you can access on our website. Throughout the call, we'll reference non-GAAP financial measures when discussing how the company performed. A reconciliation of these measures to GAAP financial measures appears in our materials for today's call. Lastly, Synchrony Financial bears no responsibility for, and neither edits nor guarantees the accuracy of, the earnings teleconference transcripts that third parties provide. The only authorized webcasts can be found on our website. Joining us this morning are Brian Doubles, Synchrony's President and Chief Executive Officer, and Brian Wenzel, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. I'll now hand the call over to Brian Doubles.
Brian Doubles
executiveThank you, Kathryn, and good morning to everyone. Our Synchrony team makes us genuinely proud, and the high quality of execution they delivered is what let us finish the year with results this strong, among them a number of company records. Sustainable growth at appealing risk-adjusted returns is what our core strategy targets, and it rests on three main objectives. The first is to expand the partner programs we already run while bringing new partners on board. The second is to broaden our programs, products and markets; and the third is to provide customer experiences that rank as best-in-class. Over the course of 2021, we brought in 36 partners and renewed 38 more. We see exciting prospects both in the portfolio we hold today and in the pipeline of new partners, which will fuel innovative financing experiences and meet our customers' constantly shifting needs. As you're aware, we are always looking for ways to extend our leadership position, and a great deal of that will keep coming from the ongoing diversification and expansion of our distribution channels. With that in mind, we acquired Allegro Credit early in the year, a top provider of point of sale consumer audiology products. That deal let us strengthen our foothold in health and wellness, reach more providers and customers, and give them a broader suite of financing products and services. We likewise revealed a strategic alliance with Clover, enabling us to deliver our novel goods and experiences to more merchants and customers. To reiterate, via our connection with Clover, smaller companies can tap Synchrony lending offerings and solutions and take private label credit card payments through the Clover point-of-sale and business management platform; furthermore, Synchrony continued expanding our two primary consumer-oriented marketplaces, mysynchrony.com and carecredit.com, across the year. Such marketplaces are extensive and profound networks offering consumers a single destination for locating and purchasing from merchant partners and providers, and for sending in applications and managing their accounts. Synchrony is seeing robust repeat business, which stems from how broadly these networks reach, how readily people can access them, and how much practical value they deliver. Across those networks combined, annual visits had topped $300 million by the time the year closed, and through carecredit.com we produced about 1 million referrals while providers logged close to 19 million views. Repeat sales across our networks reached 52% during the fourth quarter of 2021. Sales per active account is another metric we're working to drive, and in our CareCredit and home and auto networks it runs at roughly double the level of the average buy now pay later products available in the market. That reflects the strong customer relationships our network products build. Our ability to tap into our networks — attracting new customers and generating repeat purchases for partners at greater spending levels — has served as a strong competitive edge and an essential engine of growth, and it will continue to do so. Another piece of how we've kept diversifying and expanding during the past year is the health system initiative, which allowed us to sign seven additional systems, lifting the total to 20. By linking up with health systems through technology platforms like Epic, Synchrony can reach far more customers and providers, and the CareCredit card becomes more valuable as well. Consider Epic MyChart's user base, for example: it spans about 150 million patients. And by offering our patient financing app inside the Epic App Orchard, we give those patients wider access to financing choices wherever the provider or health system belongs to the CareCredit network — across a wide range of needs, from elective care to routine medical expenses and non-elective care needs. In a setting where insurance coverage keeps getting more limited while health and wellness needs keep coming up, we are giving more patients and providers greater choice, flexibility and utility as we grow our networks and integrate with additional health systems. So all in all, 2021 was the year we sped up our business strategy. Strategic partnerships such as Clover let us reach tens of thousands of new merchants. When we grow our digital networks, we can connect with hundreds of millions of consumers. And if you add it up, the health systems where CareCredit has launched, along with some capacity, represent over 40 million patient visits. No matter how you slice it, Synchrony occupies the middle of a broad slice of U.S. commerce, regardless of whether a purchase takes place in a store or online. Through smooth omnichannel experiences, we connect close to 70 million average active accounts to almost 450,000 locations. And we support their routine buying — everything from furniture and home improvement to health care products and services, car care needs, clothing, jewelry and powersports — using tailored financing choices that maximize value and results for our customers and partners alike. As Synchrony connects with a growing base of consumers, merchants, providers, and partners, demand for our products, services, and value propositions grows more varied. That's why throughout 2021 we continued broadening our offerings and programs—launching our industry-first program with Walgreens and introducing our SetPay Pay-in-4 product. Beyond that, we're continuing to build momentum for our Synchrony Mastercard, which stands as a key opportunity in our product strategy for driving highly scalable growth and above-average returns for our business over the long term. In the year's second half, we widened our Synchrony Mastercard acquisition efforts to include new digital channels, extending our reach and speeding our time to market. By combining real-time activity and data capture with our advanced dApply features—things like sophisticated pre-fill and credit decisioning insights—we made the application process smoother and improved how customers experience it. Because of that, active accounts rose 11% in the second half versus the first half of the year. And on that same basis, sales per active account were up 18%, reflecting the strong value propositions we provide. Of course, as our share of wallet continues to expand, Synchrony is able to reach and serve more customers, which gives them extra choices and greater value. And since we aim to offer simple, all-encompassing access to a wider range of financial products and services, we're eager to introduce PayPal Savings during the first quarter. With this bigger partnership alongside PayPal, we'll extend how widely our savings offering is distributed, reaching a distinct group of customers through important capabilities and features—among them immediate transfers of funds between PayPal balances, no limits on withdrawals, and a savings goal feature that helps customers establish and achieve their financial targets. Current PayPal customers will be able to open a PayPal Savings account swiftly and effortlessly within the new PayPal Super App. We take pride in being part of this transformative effort and stay sharply focused on further raising the customer experiences we deliver through every one of our partnerships. It's hardly a shock that Synchrony's steady spending on digital innovation has made possible the success of each product and partner throughout our journey. We keep improving how we provide straightforward, frictionless customer experiences, since the results are considerably better for every one of our stakeholders.
Brian Doubles
executiveTo give you an example, over the last year we moved nearly 11 million accounts with 14 partners onto the alerts platform we launched, and that platform provides customizable e-mail, text messages and push alerts featuring real-time, rich transaction data and notifications. We also introduced certain upgrades to our SyPI platform, among them several new features such as digital wallet provisioning plus improvements to push notifications and e-bill. Taken together, having these features available helped drive a 40% rise in unique visitors during 2021 and 56% growth in the count of payments we received in SyPI. Thanks to the launch of enhanced native acquisition capabilities through SyPI and our client mobile apps, new accounts for that channel are up 67% year-over-year. To be more specific, letting cardholders provision their Synchrony account into their digital wallet meant fourth quarter wallet providence was up 32% year-over-year while wallet sales volume rose 63%. So, all of this combined — our deep lending expertise, the most complete product set in the industry and our advanced digital capabilities — has let Synchrony become a leading financial ecosystem that produces compelling outcomes for both our partners and our customers. No other industry provider today offers the full breadth and depth of digitally powered financing products, services and value propositions that Synchrony offers, and this capacity to link our partners and customers via best-in-class omnichannel experiences resonates strongly and is producing record results for Synchrony and our stakeholders; over this past year we reached almost 25 million new account originations along with record purchase volume of $166 billion and a 19% rise in spend per active account. Those milestones, together with strong credit performance and our ongoing discipline around risk-adjusted returns and expense management, allowed Synchrony to post record financial results for the full year, among them $4.2 billion of net earnings, or $7.34 per diluted share, a 4.5% return on assets and a 39% return on tangible common equity. Because of that, we could return $3.4 billion of capital to shareholders, which included $2.9 billion of share repurchases and $500 million of regular dividends. With that said, I'll hand the call to Brian so he can discuss fourth quarter performance, which showed broad-based momentum throughout our business.
Brian Wenzel
executiveThanks, Brian, and good morning to you all. Synchrony has delivered another quarter of strong financial performance. Those results reflect both our differentiated business model and the attractive value propositions we offer to partners and customers, which we're able to provide as we execute on our strategic priorities. Net earnings were $813 million, equal to $1.48 per diluted share. Our return on average assets was 3.4%, and return on tangible common equity reached 28.7%. These solid net earnings and returns demonstrate the power and efficiency of our digitally enabled model, along with the compelling value of the financial products and services we deliver through our ecosystem. We managed to back the robust seasonal customer spending with our wide product lineup, and we accomplished that while maintaining cost discipline and solid risk-adjusted returns. In the fourth quarter we reached a record $47 million in purchase volume, which was 18% higher than both last year and 2019, excluding Walmart. Four of our five platforms posted double-digit gains in purchase volume, which shows clear strength across the board through the varied industry verticals we serve. Purchase volume per account likewise increased in the quarter, rising 13% versus last year and 22% versus the fourth quarter of 2019, excluding Walmart. During Q4, dual and co-branded cards accounted for 42% of purchase volume, up 30% year over year. Measured by loan receivables, including those held for sale, these cards represented 25% of the portfolio, a 10% increase from the prior year. Average active accounts grew 5% versus last year, while new accounts climbed 20%, amounting to over 7 million in the fourth quarter and roughly 25 million originated across the full year. As you may remember, we agreed to sell our GAAP portfolio, which at year-end comprised $3.9 billion of loan receivables in the held-for-sale portfolio. As part of our ongoing focus on delivering suitable risk-adjusted returns, we're ending the BPAY partnership, and that led us to move roughly $500 million in loan receivables into held-for-sale status in December. If you set aside the held-for-sale portfolios, loan receivables would be up 4% from a year earlier, since strong purchase volume growth during the period was mostly offset by payment rates that stayed persistently high. RSCs came to $1.3 billion in the fourth quarter, equal to 6.15% of average receivables. The $220 million increase compared with last year mainly came from a lower provision for credit losses and continued strong program performance, including growth in receivables and purchase volume along with improvement in net interest income. Turning to credit performance, our provision for credit losses came in at $561 million. This quarter's provision included a reserve build of $72 million, net of $98 million in reserve reductions from our held-for-sale portfolios. Excluding the impact of those held-for-sale portfolios, the $170 million reserve build reflected growth in loan receivables, set against macroeconomic assumptions that are unchanged and a credit normalization outlook that is also unchanged — an outlook that includes peak loss in the first half of 2023. Other income increased by $85 million, driven by a $93 million gain on a venture investment. I’ll cover this in greater depth later during our discussion, but I want to note that the bulk of the fourth quarter EPS benefit from that gain was offset by unrelated asset impairments and some opportunistic marketing investments we made in Q4. Moving to Slide 8 and our platform results, purchase volume across our home and auto, diversified and value, digital, and health and wellness platforms continues to grow at a double-digit rate year over year, reflecting strong diversified demand. Our lifestyle platform also experienced robust demand, with purchase volume rising 6% year over year, although it was up against a tough comparison to last year’s strength in powersports volume. Across our platforms, loan receivable growth generally followed the same pattern of more restrained expansion compared with the previous year, since increased purchase volume was partially counterbalanced by payment rates that are still running high. Average active account trends differ from platform to platform, climbing by as much as 9% in both diversified and value in digital. In Home & Auto, Lifestyle and Health & Wellness, average active accounts increased by low single digits or stayed roughly level. The rise in average active accounts for diversified value largely tracked the stronger results from retailers. Digital active accounts increased over the prior year, driven by deeper engagement among our current customers and by new programs. On fee trends, things have generally gotten better across the platforms, though elevated payment rate continues to weigh on them. Turning to Slide 9, I'll go over net interest income and margin trends. During the fourth quarter, payment rate was shaped by the savings consumers have built up along with the usual seasonal pickup in holiday transactor activity. As the period went on, payment rate came down somewhat compared with third quarter levels, but it rose with the seasonal holiday spending we typically see in December. For the period, payment rate ran roughly 180 basis points above last year and 290 basis points above our five-year historical average. Looking at how account payment behavior shifted between the third and fourth quarters, there's a modest movement away from payments covering the full statement balance or more, toward minimum payments and amounts below the minimum. To break that down: the share of account balances paying the full statement balance fell by roughly 20 basis points quarter over quarter, while the share of accounts paying somewhere between the minimum and the full statement balance dropped about 70 basis points sequentially. Meanwhile, accounts paying only the minimum, or less than the minimum, rose by approximately 90 basis points from the prior quarter. Our expectation remains that payment rates will normalize gradually, given that customer spending is still strong, the consumer savings figure is coming down, and forbearance across the industry is running out. It's difficult to predict high levels of consumer spending, but reduced savings, inflationary pressure, and the return of full financial obligations have begun to weigh on the savings consumers have built up, and we believe this will lead to a moderation in the payment rate. Interest and fees increased about 2% in the fourth quarter, driven by growth in average loan receivables. Net interest income rose 5% compared with last year, driven by the year-over-year improvement in interest and fees as well as lower interest expense during the period. Our net interest margin was 15.77%, compared with 14.64% in the prior year — that's 113 basis points better year over year, and it came from the composition of interest-earning assets along with favorable costs on interest-bearing liabilities. Putting a finer point on it, loan receivables as a share of total earning assets increased 500 basis points, moving from 79.9% to 84.9%, which reflected average receivables growth and less liquidity carried during the quarter. That contributed 96 basis points of the rise in our net interest margin. Costs on interest-bearing liabilities stood at 1.18%, an improvement of 51 basis points versus a year ago, mainly from lower benchmark rates; this added 42 basis points to our net interest margin. Loan receivable yield came in at 19.61%, down 32 basis points from a year earlier, and that cut our net interest margin by 26 basis points. Now I'll walk through key credit trends on Slide 10. Higher payment rates are still pushing our delinquency metrics to improve compared with last year.
Brian Wenzel
executiveOur delinquency rate for 30-plus days was 2.62%, compared with 3.07% in the prior-year period, and the 90-plus delinquency rate was 1.17% versus 1.40% last year. When you exclude the impact that held-for-sale portfolios had on our delinquency measures in the fourth quarter of both this year and last year, the 30-plus delinquency figure would have shown a decline of about 60 basis points instead of 45, and the 90-plus figure would have been roughly 30 basis points lower rather than 23. These favorable delinquency trends in our portfolio continue to drive the strong year-over-year improvement in our net charge-off rate, which was 2.37% compared with 3.16% a year ago — an improvement of 79 basis points. Our credit-loss allowance, measured against loan receivables, came in at 10.76% — down 52 basis points from 11.28% in Q3. Moving to Slide 11, we'll review expenses. Other expenses totaled $1.1 billion, which included $46 million in asset impairments plus $29 million tied to specific added marketing investments. Strip those out and other expenses were up 5% year over year. On employee compensation, two main things shaped the fourth quarter: first, hourly wages went up because we raised the minimum wage to $20 in the third quarter; and second, incentive compensation was higher, since 2020 levels had been hurt by the pandemic. In Q4, the efficiency ratio came in at 41.1%, versus 37.1% a year earlier. If you strip out the venture investment gain, the asset impairments and the extra marketing spending, that ratio would be 39.7%. Even with those adjustments, the efficiency ratio remains above our historical average, driven by reduced revenue resulting from the higher paying rate and lower average receivables. We will continue managing expenses with discipline while maintaining the pace of strategic investments in the business; this continues to be a clear differentiator for Synchrony. As we showed at our Investor Day, Symphony draws on our legacy of operating smaller dollar balances to acquire, originate and service our accounts more efficiently than other general purpose issuers. Our cost to acquire is half that of private label peers and 1/4 of the broader industry's average. It's also important to keep in mind that throughout the course of the pandemic, we've maintained a relatively steady level of marketing spend to stay engaged with our customers, much of which is largely contemplated within the RSA. As a result, Synchrony generally doesn't ramp up our marketing expenses in order to compete for new customers. In the same way, we consistently prioritize investment in our business and technological innovation. What makes it possible for us to provide these digital products and services and that smooth omnichannel experience that ranks among the world's most advanced technology partners is our relentless commitment to and consistent funding of innovation, year in and year out. So getting our operating efficiency ratio back to about 32% will come primarily from payment rate normalization along with the revenue recovery that follows, though we're confident we can continue producing top-tier operating leverage as loans continue to grow. Turning now to Slide 12, let's discuss another fundamental strength here at Synchrony: our funding, capital and liquidity. Because loan receivables were lower during 2020 and the first part of 2021, and given how firmly our deposit base holds, we've typically maintained a larger liquidity cushion throughout the year. In our view, carrying extra liquidity makes sense when conditions are uncertain, though we've been actively working on our funding profile to bring down surplus liquidity and make it more efficient. As a result of that approach, our funding mix moved a bit compared with a year ago. Deposits were down $512 million year over year, while our securitized and unsecured funding sources declined by $1.3 billion. At quarter end, that put deposits at 81% of our funding against 80% a year earlier, with securitized funding accounting for 10% of our funding sources and unsecured funding at 9%. When you factor in credit lines we haven't drawn on, total liquidity reached $15.7 billion — that's 16.4% of total assets, compared with 24.7% a year earlier. Before I go into the capital position, I want to point out that we decided to use the transition rules that the joint federal banking agencies issued, and those rules give us two key advantages. The first is that the impact of the CECL transition adjustment was delayed by an additional two years. The second is that it permits some of the provisioning for the current period to be deferred and amortized together with the transition adjustment. Under that framework, we closed the quarter at 15.6% CET1 on a CECL transition basis, which is 30 basis points under last year's 15.9%. Under CECL transition rules, the Tier 1 capital ratio came in at 16.5%, compared with 16.8% a year earlier. The total capital ratio declined 30 basis points to 17.8%, while the Tier 1 capital plus reserves ratio, on a fully phased-in basis, fell to 24.4% from 27% last year. During the first quarter of 2022, we will recognize the initial portion of the CECL transition adjustment, which reduced our CET1 ratio by roughly 60 basis points. As a reminder, CECL's impact is already reflected in our income statement and balance sheet. This transitional adjustment is strictly tied to the metrics we use for regulatory capital. Meanwhile, we keep delivering on our commitment to return capital to shareholders in a strong way—during the fourth quarter, we returned $1.1 billion to shareholders, made up of $982 million in share repurchases and $120 million in common stock dividends. Across the full year, we returned $3.4 billion, which included $2.9 billion in share repurchases and $500 million in common stock dividends. In light of how strongly our business performed over the year, our Board approved raising our share repurchase authorization through June 2022 by an additional $1 billion. As of December 31, the authorization remaining for share purchases was $1.2 billion. We've kicked off the customary capital planning effort, and once it's approved, we'll share an update on the capital actions we intend to take. Strong returns and substantial capital come out of this business, which speaks to how dedicated we are to producing steady growth along with appealing risk-adjusted returns, the scalability of our technology platform, and the cost discipline we keep applying; we hold a sizable amount of excess capital on the balance sheet that can be put to work either by growing the business or by returning it to shareholders. So we'll keep pursuing an aggressive yet prudent strategy when it comes to giving capital back to shareholders, shaped by how the business performs, conditions in the market, and subject to our capital plan along with any regulatory factors. Last, I want to turn to the outlook, which appears in summary form on Slide 13 of the presentation, and which assumes a macroeconomic backdrop that is stable to improving as well as a pandemic that stays well controlled. Over the coming year, we anticipate consumer demand will stay robust, which supports broad-based growth in purchase volume throughout the industries and markets we serve. Once consumer savings start to shrink and the payment rate eases, we would anticipate purchase volume growth to ease to some degree; we expect our net interest margin to mirror the trends seen in the second half of 2021 and to track historical seasonality.
Brian Wenzel
executiveWith our held-for-sale portfolios progressing in late Q2, we anticipate some excess liquidity, and that will pose a modest NIM headwind during both the second and third quarters. As in the past, we'll move quickly to reduce that excess liquidity. With payment rates easing and credit trends normalizing via a gradual uptick in delinquency and loss, we expect elevated interest and fee yields to be countered by elevated reversals. Delinquency, per our present expectation, will reach its peak in the fourth quarter. With the reserve levels we had at year-end, our expectation is that 2022 reserve builds will largely be driven by assets and partly offset by roughly $130 million of final reserve reductions tied to our held-for-sale portfolios. RSA expense will keep reflecting how strongly our program is performing and the growth in purchase volume, though it should start to moderate as net charge-offs go up. On operating expense, we generally expect the quarterly figure to come in around the fourth quarter 2021 levels, apart from the effect of asset impairments and certain marketing items we discussed earlier; and finally, regarding our held-for-sale portfolios, we expect conveyance to take place in the second quarter, which would generate a nonrecurring gain on sale of about $130 million. We plan to put that gain back into the business through incremental investment that fully offsets it, so EPS stays neutral for the full year. Taking everything together, Synchrony's differentiated model is driving strong growth with attractive risk-adjusted returns as market conditions shift, and we're coming out of the pandemic with substantial momentum. We'll keep building on our core strengths: our diversified portfolio, which delivers resiliency and sustainable growth; our deep industry expertise, advanced data analytics and digitally enabled product suite, whose combination produces strong risk-adjusted returns; and our scalable technology platform, which enables efficient customer acquisition and servicing along with swift partner integrations. Synchrony is going to keep bringing in additional customers, boost lifetime value further, and produce sustainable growth with risk-adjusted returns that lead the peer group. Therefore, with operating conditions continuing to return to normal, we have confidence in our capacity to hit the long-term operating metrics we presented at Investor Day, and to keep generating substantial value for every one of our stakeholders. At this point I'll hand the call back to Brian so he can share his closing remarks.
Brian Doubles
executiveThanks, Brian. I honestly couldn't feel more pride in the Synchrony team and everything we've accomplished this year on behalf of our partners, customers and stakeholders. Through putting money into our digital innovations, integrating strategic partners, moving into new distribution channels, and adding new product offerings, Synchrony has kept evolving and improving how we link our partners and customers through our financial ecosystem; that has made us a leader in the digital commerce revolution, with really exciting opportunities lying ahead of us; we'll keep winning new partners and renewing the ones we already have. At the same time, we'll diversify our programs, our products and the markets where we operate even further. And naturally, underlying all of it is our laser-like concentration on our integrated product set and on delivering that best-in-class customer experience, which drives value, loyalty and superior outcomes for our partners and customers. Synchrony will keep outperforming over the long term, as we give our partners and customers the power of choice. As we execute on our key strategic priorities, we'll keep generating consistent growth at attractive returns and unlock still greater value for our stakeholders. With that, I'll hand the call back to Kathryn to open the Q&A.
Kathryn Miller
executiveThat brings our prepared comments to a close. We're moving into the Q&A portion now, which lets us get to as many of you as we can. I'd ask everyone on the line to keep it to one main question plus one follow-up. Should anything further come to mind, the Investor Relations team will be around once the call ends. Operator, would you go ahead and open the Q&A?
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystThanks. Good morning.
Brian Doubles
executiveHi, Sanjay.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystSo I’ve got a question for the two of you. Hey, how are things? For both of you, Brian, regarding loan growth. I realize payment rates are kind of working against the underlying expectations for loan growth. But your long-term targets sit around high single digits to low double digits. A number of your peers are at their average, if not above it. Could you perhaps discuss what’s causing the softness compared with your long-term expectations? And — or do you think 2022 will get there? Thanks.
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. Sanjay, perhaps I’ll begin and then invite Brian to weigh in. What I’d say is, look, overall, we feel quite good about the operating environment at present; we feel quite good about the consumer’s position. Last year set a record for purchase volume on our products. And looking at that, something that’s really encouraging is that when you break it out by demographic, much of it is actually coming from Millennials and Gen Z. Sales on our accounts with Millennials and Gen Z rose 42% versus 2019; and for Baby Boomers, that grew only 6%; so when you consider that mix shift, our products are clearly very appealing to that younger demographic; we also brought in 25 million new accounts for the full year. So we genuinely feel quite good about the growth prospects; and as you mentioned, what’s somewhat hard to predict at this point is the payment rate; but I think if payment rates simply normalize somewhat, they don’t have to return entirely to pre-pandemic levels. If they just normalize a little here in 2022, we could certainly see loan growth in the high single digits for the full year. I don’t know, Brian, whether you’d like to add anything to that?
Brian Doubles
executiveYes. What I would — the point I'd make, Sanjay, is that if you examine purchase volume throughout every one of our segments, every platform is showing strength. That diversification is therefore coming through. And I believe when people compare us with some of our competitors, the thing that gets overlooked is how resilient our business is, correct? We had less volume decline than others, and less asset decline than others, last year; so on that front we're staying more consistent. And listen, I completely agree. Coming into 2022, we were exiting a record purchase volume. Thinking about the quarter's first month, we're seeing solid mid-teens growth in purchase volume as that carries on; and we do see — and I'm certain we'll discuss payment rates later on this call — we are seeing some moderation. So I do think that high single digits is visible. And under certain scenarios, we have one that indicates loan growth can reach double digits. So the model and our position entering 2022 feel really good to us.
Brian Wenzel
executiveOne final point, Sanjay: if you look across the platforms, it's fairly broad-based. Digital purchase volume rose 22%. D&V <<inaudible>> climbed 26%. There's plenty of room for growth in health and wellness, where sales increased 14% in the fourth quarter. So again, growth was fairly broad-based, and it's good to have turned the corner, with every one of our platforms showing positive receivable growth year-over-year in the fourth quarter.
Sanjay Sakhrani
analystAll right, that sounds great. There may be one more revenue driver you folks tend to mention, the NIM, Brian Wenzel. And I realize there's plenty of liquidity and all these other factors that play into that metric. Still, when we consider the yield, I notice the final bullet mentions higher interest and fees offset by higher reversals. Is that a one-for-one trade? Or should we expect the yield to get better as this year progresses?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYeah. The way I'd frame it, Sanjay, is that as the payment rate falls, you're going to see the yield rise on the book, correct? The reversals that ultimately arrive will come alongside the charge-offs, which lag behind that, and it isn't one for one. It never has been. As for the NIM impact this year, it does gain from reversals, but that isn't necessarily the main force driving it; so it lags and it won't be one for one.
Moshe Orenbuch
analystGreat. Thanks. Brian Wenzel, I suppose you mentioned how the efficiency ratio would normalize. Given the current conditions, investors are focusing far more on expenses and costs; and you said the driver would be revenue that's been kind of deferred, lost, suppressed. Could you discuss how you size up how big that is and the timeframe over which it returns?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. Excellent question, Moshe. To begin, let me start with expenses. Ours are up — once you exclude the impairment and discrete items we chose to act on because of certain gains in the quarter, our expenses rose 5% year-over-year. And when you consider that, to begin with, much of it stems from employees, right; we raised the hourly wage for employees; we also made some onetime adjustments tied to certain critical roles in the organization, such as data scientists, technology, et cetera. So the base in the run rate, as we look ahead, is fairly stable. And as I noted in my prepared remarks, to begin with, we don't need to put much money into this to drive our growth. So the expense base, as we move through each quarter, should stay relatively consistent. When you consider the efficiency ratio, clearly, revenue and yield are below what we expected. So I believe across that period, call it the revenue normalization between 2022 and 2023, you'll see it return and we see a path back to that 32%, 33%. But at present, we're managing, hopefully tightly, to the dollar amount as we move along. Again, it's mostly volume driven now, with more active accounts and greater volume passing through the associations or networks.
Moshe Orenbuch
analystSo just to make sure I understand, as volume grows your cost structure will lean more toward fixed, and perhaps credit normalization means the RSA actually gains on revenue across the coming several quarters — is that the right way to think about it?
Brian Wenzel
executiveOn a dollar basis, I'd say that's broadly accurate. What we're going to drive is that the variable components of that will increase, but we'll drive productivity to offset it and hold the expense base roughly flat. So I wouldn't characterize it as a shift to fixed. It's that we're going to drive productivity and get operating leverage.
Moshe Orenbuch
analystRight. We're treating it as fixed and fixed, yes. Understood. Okay. Thanks a lot.
Brian Wenzel
executiveThank you, Moshe. Have a good day.
Ryan Nash
analystHey there, good morning everyone. Morning to you, Kathryn.
Brian Wenzel
executiveHello, Ryan.
Brian Doubles
executiveMorning, Ryan.
Ryan Nash
analystBrian, perhaps following up on what Moshe asked. When I look at the expense guidance and adjust for that $75 million, it seems to indicate roughly 7% to 8% expense growth; so I wanted to clarify whether, for 2022, the expectation is that you'll produce positive operating leverage. Could you give some parameters for how we should think about expenses against the revenue backdrop? And then, more specifically, the slides mention reinvesting the $130 million from the gain — is that included in the expense outlook? And should we treat that as a onetime step up? Or will it stay in the run rate? And I have a follow-up.
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. Thanks for the question, Ryan. Let me address the latter part of what you asked. The $130 million and any potential offsets we have will not be in the run rate. They will be onetime. So when we actually make those decisions, and that could have a wide ranging effect. That could address some of our fixed costs and again, continuing to adjust for the way in which we work. There could be some investments in marketing programs, and we'll highlight those, but it should not go into the run rate of the business and would be additive to what we have here on the page. I think generally, when you think about the expense base, we are going to generate positive operating leverage, and that's the way the model was set up. So that as we think about the expenses this year, our view would be that we would have greater growth relative to the assets and the revenue. So we do believe we're going to get operating leverage; we're going to manage the positive operating leverage throughout as we step through 2022.
Ryan Nash
analystGot it, thank you. Let me follow up with something else: on credit, losses are obviously extremely, extremely low right now. We've seen some slight increases in delinquencies and charge-offs. So I'm curious — could you talk about any patterns worth noting that you're seeing across the portfolio? Are you seeing more normalization in near prime relative to prime? And second, Brian, just to be clear, the allowance stands at 10.76 versus 10% Day 1 CECL, though I understand 4Q is seasonally low. You described it as asset driven. So is Day 1 CECL still where we ultimately land? And could you perhaps share some perspective on how we ought to think about the reserve's trajectory over time? Thank you.
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. So let me — my answer on credit will probably run longer, Ryan, since I genuinely believe setting that context matters. To address your question straight on, nothing noticeable has emerged in our results, and I'll walk you through where we land. But we see nothing suggesting performance is worse than what we anticipated. I think we understand there's substantial anxiety about what the phrase credit normalization means, how soon it shows up, and the extent of the damage. I'd like to give you a framework. First, we discussed, earlier in the call, in my prepared remarks, that delinquency is 60 basis points better and 30 basis points better than prior periods once you exclude the held for sale. So the delinquency formation of how that will give you lost content for the first half of the year is in great shape. I think, Ryan, when we examine the vintage performances, both on a cumulative basis and a coincident basis and view it from 2018 forward in these six-month kind of tranche views, each of the vintages from 2018 through 2020 have improved. And we see no deterioration in those vintages as we sit here at the end of 2021. If you look at 2021, both 2020 and 2021 are significantly better than all of the pre-pandemic vintages, significantly better. When we look at 2021 specifically, that is a little bit worse than 2020 because we took some credit refinements. We don't believe we have added incremental risk in, but slightly worse performance; but again, significantly better than pre pandemic. I then think you have to consider three other factors, Ryan, as you think about credit. The first is our credit strategy and multiproduct strategy. Our credit strategy is we have a tighter loan grow line strategy. We have tighter account management strategies, which gives you lower severity as you head into this normalization period. We believe our results will show reduced volatility, and that pattern has been evident when you examine the loss curves from the GFC, prior recessions, and the pandemic period. Then, considering the capabilities we presented on Investor Day — expansion in data analytics, our unique data sources, and the ability to act more surgically — we can manage credit throughout 2022. And the last element is the RSA, right? In the end, those charge-offs will be absorbed by the RSA, with our partners offsetting them. When you combine that with revenue generation, you get a resilient risk-adjusted margin throughout the period. That, then, is how I think about credit. Brian, I, and the rest of the leadership group are quite optimistic regarding how credit is likely to unfold across 2022 and into 2023. Regarding your follow-up on the allowance, we aren't taking a contrary stance suggesting we'll never get back to Day one CECL. The key issue is your assumption about the target loss rate and the mean loss rate — and on that, we don't hold a firm fundamental position. Portfolio mix will play some role in this; but ultimately, in my view, we can transition back to that, provided that's the position we take — the real question is timing. And broadly speaking, if you adopt that position, there may be offsets to provisioning driven by assets as we progress through 2022. So I apologize for the lengthy answer, but I think that gives a framework for how you think about it and talk to your customers.
Arren Cyganovich
analystThanks. Turning to the NIM outlook, I had a question about the guidance around those two each levels — roughly $15.60, I believe — since I would have thought that figure would climb a bit further given the rate hikes we're seeing. How many rate increases are you anticipating for the year? And what else is holding that number somewhat below where I'd expect?
Brian Wenzel
executiveSure. As for our expectations on rate increases, our present view calls for three. Of course, the market may see things differently depending on the day, I think. But keep in mind that under 50% of the receivables in our portfolio carry a variable rate. And once you factor in the transactors, that figure is, I believe, under 30%. So we won't be heavily exposed to, shall I say, NIM movements. There could be 20, 30 basis points potentially when it comes to NIM. Honestly, though, that isn't a significant driver. Ultimately, we plan to run our book on a rate neutral basis; we're slightly asset sensitive, but not by much.
Arren Cyganovich
analystOkay, got it. And that conversation about where our costs sit is helpful—but there's a revenue-related item working the other way: the loyalty program expense climbed quite a bit during Q4, which I'd guess is likely tied to the sales volume you saw. Still, how do you see loyalty program reductions shaping up from here?
Brian Doubles
executiveYeah. Great question. Brian and I look at this closely. It's not really a negative; it actually shows customers are engaging with what we sell and pushing volume. So you're right that volume is the driver, first of all—and you can see that in our dual card volume and our co-branded volume. Some of that increase is coming from our new programs. Lastly, the value proposition obviously shifts as we update those offers to help drive volume. Another key point that often gets missed: this is a program expense, and about 80% of it comes back to us through the RSA, so we aren't carrying that burden. Again, with our unique model, we don't need to put much into marketing to generate growth, and we don't need to put much into loyalty either—our partners share in both the marketing costs and the loyalty costs. There is, of course, an inherent cushion within RSA. Much of that impact gets counterbalanced there once more, and when usage climbs it typically reflects customers interacting with what we offer, which on the whole is a positive.
Betsy Graseck
analystHi, thank you very much. I have a couple of questions. First, just on expenses, to close that out a bit. I know from your Investor Day last year you’ve got the longer-term guidance out there on expense ratio, 32%, 33%. Should we be expecting that you’d be aiming for that over the next one year or two? Or is that more of a 2024, 2025 kind of timeframe?
Brian Doubles
executiveYes. First of all, good morning, Betsy, I wouldn’t treat that as a 2022 metric. Relative to revenue, we’re in a transitory year. So I think you start looking at that once you get into 2023 and see how revenue actually develops. Again, we’re going to control the expense dollars. That we can control. The actual output of that has a denominator that’s somewhat less controlled, given the payment rate — elevation and payment rate.
Betsy Graseck
analystAll right. Then the second thing about expenses relates to what you're putting into investment. There's the $130 million gain, and that's going to get invested. From what you've described, it sounds as though those investments would be made in, say, the second, third and fourth quarter of next year. Would that be a reasonable interpretation of your comments?
Brian Doubles
executiveYes; my expectation would be that the investment lands mainly in the second and third quarter; we'd prefer to have it there so we capture the leverage effect. Naturally, it will hinge on which actions are taken. And once more, I believe there will be a mix of actions aimed both at lowering the fixed cost base of the business and at incremental investments intended really to fuel the growth side of the business. So Brian and I will go through that with the team and lay out our plans, and hopefully we can update you on our first quarter earnings call in April.
Brian Wenzel
executiveIt's reasonable to say that any investments we make will need to offer a genuinely strong payback or a genuinely strong return on those dollars.
Betsy Graseck
analystDo you mean more along the lines of marketing, or spending on the programs rather than on technology? Is that...
Brian Doubles
executiveIt'll be a mix of several things; it will be, and potentially might be — we'll examine some of the fixed costs we carry in the business related to facilities. It might involve refreshes of particular programs where we perhaps reissue cards and run things along those lines, campaigns of that kind; it might be on the technology side, where we may attempt to speed up and keep accelerating our digital capability. So it's a mix, but Brian touched on it. We're going to conduct a review, and ultimately the best projects with the best payback and IRs will come out on top.
Brian Wenzel
executiveTypically, Betsy, there are two levers we consider. One involves generating efficiency over the long term within the business, while the other involves generating growth, correct? Both should deliver strong paybacks. We follow a highly disciplined approach when assessing those investments, and clearly we will apply that same approach this year.
Don Fandetti
analystMorning, and thanks for taking the question. It appears the CFPB has been discussing cards a bit more lately. Could you share your latest view on the regulatory landscape? And as a follow-up, what does the pipeline look like for new partners and portfolios?
Brian Doubles
executiveSure. Don, I'd characterize the regulatory climate as pretty steady. Clearly, there was the CFPB's request for information on fees. To start, I'd simply note that we always aim to be highly transparent about what we disclose to our consumers; apart from late fees, we truly don't carry many fees. As you're aware, late fees are already regulated and computed by the CFPB; we are fully compliant today with that and with their guidance on late fees. So we'll certainly keep a close eye on it, but there's really nothing further to share at this point.
Brian Wenzel
executiveAnd then I'd say that, broadly speaking, we've got a solid pipeline across each of the five platforms. There are plenty of promising new program opportunities in that pipeline that we're reviewing, plus quite a few chances to partner on new distribution channels that have us excited — so the pipeline looks pretty strong. What I'd note is that not many large existing programs are available at the moment. Most of them are already locked up, but there are some genuinely exciting new program opportunities out there. So that's something we're excited about.
Don Fandetti
analystThanks Brian.
Brian Wenzel
executiveThanks.
Kevin Barker
analystThanks, and I just want to follow up on that earlier question. Your late fees are relatively high compared to the industry, though that's naturally the case given how many accounts you have. If the CFPB were to take some action, or if any regulatory changes occurred, do you feel you'd have the flexibility to adjust your model so you could keep generating similar type revenue trends, particularly given your relationships with other merchants?
Brian Wenzel
executiveWell, the first thing I'd say is that we don't disclose the aggregate amount of late fees, but the late fee dollar amount we charge on accounts is, again, regulated by the CFPB and very consistent across all of the general purpose card players out there; and look, if something were to change on that front, we could price for it in other ways and protect our revenue and our margin. But look, I think we just have to stay close to this, as I said. And I don't know, Brian, if you'd add anything.
Brian Doubles
executiveYeah. The way I think about it, Kevin, is that when we look at the average late fee per incident, and given that we're in the safe harbor with the CFPB, there really shouldn't be much difference between us and, I'd say, other industry participants. I think if you go back in history, under the CARD Act, our revenue when the CARD Act changes took effect essentially stayed the same; we went back to partners and we worked through that; so I think historically, we've had and run the play where, if the environment shifts in terms of how revenue may or may not be affected, we'll work with our partners to, again, deliver the value to our customers for them and their appropriate risk-adjusted return.
Kevin Barker
analystOkay. Thank you for taking my question.
Brian Doubles
executiveThanks.
John Hecht
analystHi there, good morning, and many thanks for taking my questions.
Brian Doubles
executiveJohn, how are you doing?
John Hecht
analystHey, how's everybody doing? You brought up the RSA, and I was just wondering — with the RSA, how does that relate to delinquencies or charge-offs going up, and what's the timing on that? Is it essentially a basis point for basis point match? And then as well, how have loyalty program costs affected the RSA? I'm just trying to get my head around those moving pieces inside it.
Brian Doubles
executiveSure. So John, if you think about delinquency, higher delinquency ought to produce more revolve and more late fees, and that generally passes through the RSA right away. Charge-offs work the same way; when they occur, it goes to media. There is no lag and no delay. Loyalty behaves in exactly that same manner — it passes through during the period in which it's been counted. So if you're seeing higher interest and fee yield, that will pass through and create an upward bias on the RSA; charge-offs will create a downward bias; and then either marketing or loyalty, depending on which program expense line it lands in, will likewise create an immediate downward bias through the RSA.
John Hecht
analystAll right. So during that identical stretch, ought we to factor in the variability?
Brian Doubles
executiveRight. The sole item that genuinely operates more with a delay would be reserves, John.
John Hecht
analystAll right, and as a follow-up — my second question covers a separate subject. Last year you brought Clover into the picture, you built out SetPay, and there were new partners — Venmo, Verizon — so could you perhaps speak to how much those new partners and products are contributing this year?
Brian Doubles
executiveYeah. I'd say there are plenty of genuinely exciting growth opportunities ahead of us in 2022, John. You named several of them. In my view, Venmo and Verizon are performing remarkably well, on both the quantitative and the qualitative side. The response I hear regarding the Venmo experience is simply outstanding, and so is what we hear about the Verizon value proposition and the amount you're able to save; plus the fact that this card is clearly behaving like a top-of-wallet card, which is precisely what we were aiming for; we're as pleased as we could possibly be with how both are performing. As you know, we also introduced Walgreens, and it's still quite early days there, but I believe we have a customer experience that is very well integrated — in-store, online, mobile, and so forth. And then there's Pay-in-4, which obviously is also still quite early, but we have a genuinely strong pipeline of partners that we'll be bringing on board this year. Beyond integrating partners one at a time, we're likewise exploring wider distribution possibilities in health and wellness; we plan to switch this on in dermatology during the first quarter. Given the ticket size in that space, we believe it's a product that will truly connect with people. The providers are enthusiastic about it; so there's plenty for the team to concentrate on, and this is unquestionably a year of execution. I believe we now have the product set we were after. We've made considerable headway on distribution channels, and at this point it's simply a matter of getting those products out there to the greatest extent we can. So they're accessible to consumers, and we're sharply focused on the customer experience. After all, that's what ultimately wins in the market, and you can never invest too much in making sure applying for our products is truly simple, servicing them is truly simple, and buying them is truly simple. So that's our focus, and there's a great deal that's exciting about 2022.
Mark DeVries
analystThanks. I've got a question about the credit guidance — investors have been paying a lot of attention to how fast and how big the normalization will be. With that in mind, I just want to make sure: when you say the peak is expected in Q4, are you only referring to your seasonal peak for 2022? You're not saying that's when you assume normalization happens; and if so, how are you thinking about the speed and size of the normalization we'll see?
Brian Wenzel
executiveGood morning, Mark. On the normalization of delinquencies — that really happens after the peak of losses, and we've said the peak of charge-offs will come in the first quarter, possibly early second quarter of 2023; so it would occur — normalization of delinquencies happens after that. We expect it to rise. I think you have to begin with where we start the year and how that builds; we're at low levels. We haven't seen anything yet, but it will start to rise as we move through 2022, which again we believe will be closely tied to how the payment rate begins to change. If the payment rate stays elevated for a longer period, delinquencies will rise more slowly. So I think that — it all hinges on that payment rate behavior pattern. And I laid out a bit in our prepared remarks how we see some movement there. And I think as the payment rate has changed, one thing we started noticing in some of our cohorts is that on a unit basis, we see some cohorts of accounts migrating back to 2019 levels. What's happening is that we have another cohort of accounts that have increased spending and increased payments. And so on a dollar basis at the top of the house, it looks like the payment rate isn't slowing down for certain pieces. For some pieces of our portfolio, it is clearly migrating back to 2018. When that happens more broadly across the portfolio, I think you'll see delinquency trends move along with it.
Mark DeVries
analystAlright, thanks. Turning to how fast normalization might happen — given the macro picture you assumed, with stability to improvement and the pandemic included, how do you figure delinquencies would normalize, assuming no economic stress?
Brian Wenzel
executiveTypically, it takes roughly 18 months for vintages to start seasoning when you look at it from a delinquency standpoint. So since we began some credit refinements in Q1 of this year, you'd start seeing part of that come through later in the year — so Q3 or Q4, mostly Q4. So you'll start seeing that, assuming nothing shifts in the macro environment. Simply because we've been unwinding things and have started to generate what we'd term smart growth when it comes to certain CLIs and upgrade efforts within our dual cards and private label book.
Bill Carcache
analystGood morning. Brian Doubles, I think you mentioned that even a slight easing in payment rates could lead to high single-digit growth in loans. Could you elaborate a bit on what "a little bit" means? Might that be 50% of 2019 levels? And Brian Wenzel, you mentioned a scenario in which loan growth might reach double digits. Could you say a bit more about what that scenario would look like?
Brian Doubles
executiveYes; so look, Bill, what I'd say is we definitely don't require payment rates to return fully to pre-pandemic levels in order to deliver high-single-digit loan growth. I mean a modest improvement and only a slight reversion to the mean; and I won't give you basis points here, but that would put us in that high-single-digits for the full year, I don't know, Brian, whether you'd like to add anything to that?
Brian Wenzel
executiveYes. Bill, what I would mention is that during this year's planning cycle, we examined several different scenarios, and we tested them against differing levels of how the payment rate develops. So one scenario has the payment rate decelerating more rapidly; and under that scenario, because of the timing lag on purchase line, you could potentially observe a greater growth rate in loan receivables; so it really depends on — I think the key piece is what the payment rate is doing and how the payment rate trends across the whole portfolio as we move through 2022, which will give you the range of outcomes; but again, when we're reporting purchase volume growth in the mid-teens type range, it doesn't take much movement on the payment rate to affect the sequential loan growth that we're seeing.
Brian Doubles
executiveBrian brought this up before, and I’d add that we’re seeing encouraging signs on the payment rate side, with fewer customers paying their balance in full. That suggests to me there could be some reversion to the mean during 2022; pinning down the exact timing and magnitude is difficult; still, when you look at purchase volume across the platforms, we feel quite good about wrapping up a record year last year, and across all platforms we’re seeing purchase volume growth that is broad-based. And in the fourth quarter, every single one of our platforms posted positive receivables growth; so as you look ahead to 2022, it’s a fairly solid setup.
Bill Carcache
analystYes, that really does help. So, building on a few of the points you made earlier, and thinking about how that normalization in payment rates interacts with credit — do you have any concern at all about credit normalizing more quickly than payment rates? Or, on the flip side, given what you're seeing in credit, could there actually be the reverse situation, where growth in receivables leads credit when it comes to normalization?
Brian Doubles
executiveAbsolutely, on the second part — loan growth could outpace credit normalization. It may be possible to say that. More likely than not, the two will move in sync. Generally, we don't see a scenario in which credit normalization occurs while payment rates stay elevated the way ours have. That would be highly unusual and probably something we've never seen before.
Operator
operatorThanks. And that brings today’s call to a close, everyone. We appreciate your participation. You’re welcome to hang up now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Synchrony Financial transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Synchrony Financial earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Synchrony Financial or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.