Synchrony Financial (SYF) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

April 19, 2023

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Consumer Finance earnings 60 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Kathryn Miller

executive
#1

Thanks, and good morning to all of you. We're glad to have you join our quarterly earnings conference call. Along with the press release issued today, we've made a presentation available that addresses the subjects we intend to cover on this call. You can find the press release, the detailed financial schedules, and the presentation on our website, synchronyfinancial.com. To access this information, simply navigate to the Investor Relations section of the site. Before we begin, I'd like to remind everyone that forward-looking statements will be part of what we say today. Such statements carry risks and uncertainty, and actual results might differ materially; the factors that could cause actual results to differ materially are listed in our SEC filings, which you can access on our website. Throughout this call, we'll reference non-GAAP financial measures when discussing how the company performed. A reconciliation of these measures to GAAP financial measures is included in our materials for today's call. Lastly, Synchrony Financial bears no responsibility for, and does not edit or guarantee the accuracy of, earnings teleconference transcripts furnished by third parties. Only the webcasts posted on our website are authorized. Joining us this morning are Brian Doubles, Synchrony's President and Chief Executive Officer, and Brian Wenzel, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. I'll now hand the call over to Brian Doubles.

Brian Doubles

executive
#2

Kathryn, thanks. Morning, everybody. Synchrony posted robust results for the first quarter today, with net earnings hitting $601 million, which works out to $1.35 per diluted share, alongside a 2.3% return on average assets and a 23.2% return on tangible common equity. Yet again, the strength of Synchrony's distinctive business model, combined with ongoing consumer health among those we serve, produced steady expansion throughout our varied lineup of partners and products. Looking at core figures, we added 5.2 million new accounts, boosted average active accounts by 8%, and generated $42 billion in purchase volume — a first-quarter record. That achievement came from performance in all 5 of Synchrony's platforms, underscoring how strong our diversified approach is. Purchase volume in health and wellness rose 19% versus a year ago, driven by widespread gains in active accounts and more spending per active account. Within diversified and value, purchase volume climbed 16%, powered by solid out-of-partner spending, robust retailer results, and greater penetration. Digital purchase volume's 10% gain was widespread, mirroring growth in active accounts and vigorous customer engagement. Over in lifestyle, purchase volume went up 9%, thanks to larger transaction values, mainly in outdoor and luxury; for home and auto, purchase volume rose 6% from momentum in our commercial products plus bigger transaction values in furniture and home specialty. Dual and co-branded cards made up 41% of total purchase volume and rose 22% on a core basis, showing sustained strong uptake of multiple new value propositions. This record first-quarter purchase volume growth at Synchrony demonstrates how useful our adaptable financing options are, how appealing the value propositions we provide are, and how our customers keep proving resilient as they deal with inflation's effects and elevated interest rates; through our billions of real-time transaction data points, we routinely track what our customers need and how financially healthy they are. What we find keeps indicating just small differences in average transaction value and frequency spanning spend categories. Broadly speaking, average transaction values and frequency both rose this quarter for in-store as well as out-of-partner spending, mirroring the ongoing consequences of inflationary pressure. That said, average transaction value growth decelerated during March, perhaps signaling an early effect from smaller tax refunds. Taking a wider view, the data indicates our customers are carefully managing their budgets while the macro picture shifts. We're also still noticing a few small seasonal category movements in our out-of-partner spending, even though the proportional split between discretionary and non-discretionary spending is basically the same. At the same time, among all the credit segments we cater to, borrowers in our top credit grade keep shopping more often and spending more on each occasion. As evidence of their comparative strength, transaction frequency among super prime customers on certain platforms rose at levels not witnessed since the summer of 2022. Those with lower credit grades are shopping a bit less frequently. This pattern has stayed fairly consistent since the fourth quarter and tracks the payment behavior of that credit segment, which shifted back toward pre-pandemic norms during last year's second half. On the payment side, we're still observing that payment rates are normalizing across both age groups and credit bands. That's what you'd anticipate as people work through the savings they built up and start carrying balances that revolve. Looking at the outside deposit information we track, savings levels for consumers kept falling all the way to March 31, but the decline was slower than what we experienced for the bulk of 2022. This quarter, average deposit balances for consumers were down 2%, and they're still 10% higher than they were in 2020. As those accumulated savings keep shrinking at this moderate rate, we anticipate that borrower payment and revolve patterns will normalize even more. That will in turn produce ongoing expansion in our interest-bearing loan balances, bring delinquency and credit loss metrics back to where they stood before the pandemic, and allow us to better optimize risk-adjusted margins for the business. Synchrony's business model was built to help our customers and partners navigate shifting macro conditions, and especially an operating environment that's more normalized than anything we've encountered since the pandemic began. As this return toward historical levels keeps unfolding, we're running the business prudently for the long haul while keeping an eye on trends. With that perspective, and because labor markets are stable and the consumer's balance sheet is relatively strong, we stay positive about the consumer's situation right now. Our confidence stems from the decades we've spent managing through economic cycles. That experience yields a model that serves all of our stakeholders in a sustainable way. At the heart of everything is our diversified partner portfolio and product suite, which equip us to deliver consistent, high-quality products and results across a range of environments. We kept building on those strengths during the first quarter, as shown by the product launch we announced recently and by adding or renewing over 15 partners. Specifically, we introduced the Synchrony Outdoors card, which came as a direct answer to demand from customers and partners in our powersports business. It stands as an illustration of how our platform realignment lets Synchrony rethink the way we deliver for partners and customers. For a long time, Synchrony has offered valuable installment lending solutions for powersports equipment. In this market, which is projected to reach $131 billion by 2028, there are significant purchases that happen after the initial purchase — things like accessories, parts, garments, fuel, service, and warranties — that the installment lending model we've traditionally provided in powersports didn't serve. Our dedicated platform team, whose combined experience spans partners and products, spotted this opportunity to satisfy our customers' demand and generate even stronger loyalty for dealers. Now turning to our health and wellness platform, Synchrony extended relationships this quarter with the largest and second largest dental associations, cementing CareCredit as the dental financing solution of choice. To be more specific, we announced a 10-year partnership extension with the American Dental Association, setting CareCredit apart as the only ADA-endorsed patient financing solution; this endorsement, which goes back to 2001, includes special features and offers for over 159,000 dentist members and their patients. We've also renewed our two-decade partnership with the Academy of General Dentistry, and we stay the only patient financing option for that academy's benefits program, which serves over 35,000 member dentists. These ongoing long-term alliances highlight the distinctive worth that our integrated CareCredit product brings to the providers and patients we serve. And last, this quarter we shared news of renewals with a range of partners on our home and auto platform, among them Havertys and Lovesac. Synchrony's capacity to expand and secure new partners, plus to diversify our products, programs, and markets, lets us deliver more flexibility, utility, and value for our customers and partners, while strengthening how resilient our business is. To wrap up, I take pride in all the ways Synchrony keeps meeting our customer wherever they want to make a purchase, a payment, or a deposit. As what they need and prioritize keeps shifting, Synchrony is prepared. Prepared to provide flexibility, value, and seamless experiences via additional solutions and in additional locations together with our industry-leading partners. With that, I'll hand the call over to Brian.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#3

Thank you, Brian, and good morning to all of you. During Synchrony's first quarter, the results made clear that consumers remain strong, and that strength was combined with the benefits of our varied sales platforms, attractive value propositions, and a careful financial stance. People keep engaging more deeply with what we offer. On a core basis, loan receivables at period end grew 16%, and that growth came from purchase volume that was 11% stronger, plus spend per active account that was 3% higher. Net interest income rose 7%, reaching $4.1 billion, since growth in loan receivables and a rise in loan receivable yields pushed interest and fees up 15%. Partly offsetting this was the effect of the portfolio that was sold in the second quarter of 2022. On a core basis, interest and fees were up 23%, which shows the effect of credit normalization as payment behavior moves back toward levels seen before the pandemic. When you adjust for last year's portfolio sales, the pay rate for the first quarter stood at 16.7%, roughly 85 basis points below last year and roughly 150 basis points above our 5-year pre-pandemic historical average. Net interest margin for the first quarter came in at 15.22%, a decline of 58 basis points, mostly because interest rates had a larger effect on what we pay for funding, though better yield trends partly offset that. Loan receivables yield rose 97 basis points and added 83 basis points to net interest margin. Yield from the incremental liquidity portfolio also added another 54 basis points; those gains were more than outweighed by higher costs on interest-bearing liabilities, which rose 219 basis points to 3.43% and lowered net interest margin by 179 basis points. The composition of our interest-earning assets cut net interest margin by about 16 basis points, since we built up liquidity to support the growth we expect. RSAs came to $917 million in the first quarter, equal to 4.10% of average loan receivables. The $187 million drop versus the prior year came from the portfolios sold in the second quarter of 2022 and from higher net charge-offs, partly offset by greater net interest income. RSAs keep us closely aligned with our partners and continue to work as intended, cushioning the company's financial results and helping deliver more stability in our returns. The first quarter demonstrated this, as RSA cushioned the effect of rising net charge-offs and higher funding costs. Provision for credit losses totaled $1.3 billion for the quarter, reflecting larger net charge-offs and a $285 million reserve build. That build took into account possible macroeconomic effects from industry credit contraction and what that might mean for consumers, even though we see no such effects in our delinquency performance at present. Other income fell $43 million, mainly because of higher loyalty costs and the impact from investment gains and losses, partly offset by greater debt cancellation income. Other expenses were up 8%, to $1.1 billion, largely due to higher employee costs, operational losses, and technology investments. Our efficiency ratio for the first quarter was 35%, versus 37.2% last year. All told, Synchrony posted $601 million in net earnings for the first quarter, equal to $1.35 per diluted share, which works out to a 2.3% return on average assets and a 23.2% return on tangible common equity. On slide 8, I'll walk through the key credit trends; credit metrics keep coming in at or above how they performed in 2019, since normalization is proceeding at a deliberate pace. Delinquency rates are still roughly 80% of where they stood before the pandemic, and newer vintages keep outperforming the 2018 or 2019 ones. Consumers' accumulated savings continue to taper off, which is driving a gradual shift in payment behavior back toward pre-pandemic norms. As we mentioned last quarter, this normalization trend has slowly moved into higher credit rates, where balances are typically bigger. Consequently, payment rates fell about 30 basis points from the prior quarter, while delinquencies and losses rose as we had expected. At 30-plus days, our delinquency rate came in at 3.81%, versus 2.78% a year ago or 4.92% in the first quarter of 2019. At 90-plus days, our delinquency rate was 1.87%, compared with 1.30% in the prior year or 2.51% in the first quarter of 2019. Net charge-offs rose to 4.49% from 2.73% last year, which is still roughly 100 basis points under our 5.5%-6% underwriting target. As a percent of loan receivables, our allowance for credit losses was 10.44%, up 14 basis points from 10.30% in the fourth quarter. The quarter-over-quarter rise in the reserve rate mainly came from the effect of the extra reserve we discussed earlier plus seasonally lower receivables. The allowance also captures a $294 million reduction, announced previously, in reserves for troubled debt restructurings, recorded through equity when we adopted updated accounting guidance. That guidance lowered our reserve coverage rate by about 30 basis points for the quarter. During the quarter, Synchrony's handling of funding, capital, and liquidity continued to be a strength. We establish and keep suitable target levels for common equity, liquidity, and reserves; our funding strategy is generally run to be interest rate neutral and to keep duration risk to a minimum. Cash and short-term U.S. Treasuries make up the overwhelming majority of our liquidity portfolio, mostly maturing in under 1 year. As depositors nationwide dealt with the uncertainty of several bank failures and significant deposit flows in mid-March, Synchrony Bank stood in a strong position as a dependable source of stability for our customers and our business alike. Our steady direct-to-consumer deposit base is mostly insured, with no concentrations by geography or in high-balance accounts. The typical depositor has been with us for about 5 years, and close to 80% of our deposit balance is over 3 years old. Underpinning that loyalty are Synchrony Bank's award-winning platform and customer satisfaction scores that lead the industry. People come to us because of how easy and digital our service feels, plus the rates we offer are appealing. During the final three weeks of March, as customers tried to balance how much they had at their banks or shift funds around to use whatever FDIC insurance room they had, Synchrony Bank brought in close to $700 million in net deposits, and we posted sequential account growth in the double digits. That helped drive deposit growth of 17% in the first quarter compared with a year earlier, along with $2.7 billion sequentially, bringing the total to $74.4 billion. When the quarter closed, more than 91% of Synchrony Bank direct deposits carried full insurance. Looking at how April is shaping up, activity at Synchrony Bank is back to patterns that look more seasonal, with new accounts and deposits still rising. Our deposit base gives the business a solid foundation, making up 83% of total funding, and securitized and unsecured debt round it out, accounting for 7% and 10% of funding respectively, with a $1.7 billion increase over the prior year. That growth involved issuing 10-year subordinated debt, a key milestone as we keep building out our capital stack and moving toward target capital levels. Total liquidity, which counts undrawn credit facilities, came to $21.7 billion, or 20.2% of total assets, a rise of 148 basis points from a year ago, driven by deposit growth and pre-funding of the loan receivables growth we expect. Now let's turn to Synchrony's capital position. We had already chosen to use the CECL transition rules put out by the joint banking agencies, and in January Synchrony applied its annual transitional adjustment of roughly 60 basis points to our regulatory capital metrics.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#4

We're going to keep doing this annually through January 2025. CECL's effects are already reflected on both our income statement and our balance sheet. The reduction in TDR reserves I referenced earlier came through net of tax and equity, contributing roughly 25 basis points to our capital ratios; under the CECL transition rules we closed the first quarter at 12.5% CET1, which is 250 basis points below the 15% we recorded a year ago. Under those same CECL transition rules, the Tier 1 capital ratio stood at 13.3%, versus 15.9% the prior year. Our total capital ratio fell 180 basis points, landing at 15.4%. On a fully phased-in basis, Tier 1 capital plus reserves declined to 22.5%, down from 24.5% a year earlier. Synchrony carried forward its strong record of returning capital during the first quarter; altogether, shareholders received $500 million from us, split between $400 million of share purchases and $100 million of common stock dividends. At quarter end, the amount still available under our share repurchase authorization for the period running through June 2023 was $300 million. Synchrony is well positioned to keep returning capital to shareholders, guided by how our business performs, market conditions, regulatory restrictions, and subject to our capital plan. We will also keep looking for chances to finish building out our capital structure by issuing more preferred stock. For additional detail on our full year 2023 outlook, please turn to slide 12 of our presentation. Broadly speaking, first quarter purchase volume exceeded what we had expected, and that, combined with payment rate normalization that came a bit faster than anticipated, produced better receivables growth for the quarter. Consequently, we now project that receivables will grow by 10% or more by the time the year ends. That said, we expect payment rates to finish the year considerably above where they stood before the pandemic. Our expectation for net interest margin stays at 15%-15.25%; this view incorporates the gain from favorable deposit beta and payment rate trends during the first quarter, offset by the impacts we anticipate from wider market uncertainty. Among those potential impacts are carrying more liquidity in preparation for funding growth needs, plus industry competitive dynamics that might push betas higher. In the meantime, credit normalization is proceeding as expected when it comes to both our delinquency and loss trends. As a reminder, we expect delinquencies to keep climbing and to near pre-pandemic levels by the middle of the year. Net charge-offs ought to track a comparable but delayed path relative to how delinquencies normalize. Loss dollars will climb throughout 2023, yet won't hit fully normalized levels until roughly six months after delinquencies peak. Because of that, our expectation for the full year 2023 net charge-off rate remains 4.75% to 5%, and our portfolio won't reach the annual underwriting loss target range of 5.5% to 6% until 2024. Since our outlook for net interest margin and net charge-offs hasn't changed, the RSA stays where it was, between 4% and 4.25% of average loan receivables. Our commitment to hitting operating efficiency for the whole year hasn't changed — we're aiming at roughly $1.125 billion in operating expenses each quarter. All told, Synchrony's model is designed to produce durable results with solid risk-adjusted returns as we expand to serve what our customers, our partners, and our shareholders need. With conditions returning to normal, we're still on course to reach our long-term financial operating targets. At this point I'll hand the call back to Brian so he can share his closing thoughts.

Brian Doubles

executive
#5

Appreciate that, Brian. The way Synchrony has consistently performed shows how we take a different tack when it comes to supporting both our customers and our partners, and the steadiness that creates for everyone with a stake in the business. Across many decades, spanning downturns and periods of rapid change, we favor approaches that produce durable growth over the long haul with appealing returns once risk is factored in. Looking toward what's next, I have every confidence in our capacity to keep evolving and performing whatever conditions we face, and I'm eager about the chances we have to hit our targets over the coming year; so with that, I'll hand things back to Kathryn and begin the Q&A.

Kathryn Miller

executive
#6

Alright, that wraps up the remarks we had ready. At this point we're going to move into the Q&A portion. So that we're able to fit in as many of you as we can, I'd ask those joining to kindly keep it to one main question plus a single follow-up. Should you have more questions beyond that, our investor relations team will be around once the call ends. Operator, go ahead and open the Q&A.

Moshe Orenbuch

analyst
#7

Great. Thanks to both Brian and Brian. So I suppose what I want to ask first is this: now that you're seeing profitability come back to a more typical pattern as this process plays out where losses return to normal levels, and given the economic picture right now along with all the uncertainty surrounding it, could you say a bit about how you view growth in new accounts and what those conversations with your partners look like — regarding your capacity to keep expanding, and regarding how they view the RSA they get?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#8

Good morning, Moshe. When it comes to those talks with partners, they definitely expect us to deliver new customers for them and boost their sales. For them, the retail landscape is extremely tough at the moment. I believe our capacity to offer them a multiproduct dimension is quite appealing; we keep collaborating with them on the proper placement of products. As for profitability, we are getting back to typical levels. Funding cost is definitely elevated compared with what we've historically observed, and they get that. On the RSA discussions, they acknowledge that over the past couple of years they gained from the market's downturn, and they're ready to take part; that's the economic deal we've had, and none of them are truly resisting; they are certainly careful and want clarity on how credit is trending, and whether at some point we might take steps that could affect their sales. By and large, they've been supportive and really want us to keep generating volume and new customers for them. I don't know, Brian, is there anything you'd like to add?

Brian Doubles

executive
#9

Sure, I'd just like to chime in here, Moshe Orenbuch — as you know, this subject has come up between us before. In my view, whenever things feel unsettled — and it's fair to say that conditions are somewhat unsettled at the moment — that's exactly the moment when our partners lean further into the card programs, and that works in our favor. The degree of involvement, I'd argue, spanning both our larger and our smaller partners, has reached an all-time high as we speak. They're deeply involved. They're collaborating with us to genuinely grasp what the consumer is up to and how that behavior will unfold across the coming 12 and 24 months. We're also witnessing terrific involvement with our multi-product strategy. That's an area we made a focal point a couple of years back. There's a lot of momentum around it throughout the business. I believe that as partners sort of step back and attempt to make sense of the macroeconomic backdrop and consumer patterns, they're simultaneously reconsidering which financial products to provide and sort of streamlining their point of sale. That, I believe, unquestionably aligns with our strengths.

Moshe Orenbuch

analyst
#10

Thanks a lot. Brian Wenzel, you mentioned that your outlook for margins took into account a sector backdrop that might result in larger betas. From what you and others have done, plus the deposit inflows, it appears the reverse is taking place, I suppose. Could you elaborate a bit more on what you're truly observing and what would be needed for conditions to improve or deteriorate regarding deposit beta going forward?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#11

Thank you, Moshe. When we started the year, we expected our betas would increase compared to the prior year. There was a change late last year when competition became intense, especially among certain regional banks. If you looked at our betas at the close of last year, they stood at approximately the low to mid 70s for high yield savings and roughly 80% for CDs. Upon entering 2023, we expected around a 10 to 15 point increase in beta for high yield savings and roughly 20 basis points, or basically 100% or greater beta, for CDs, correct? That's how we began the year. I would say the market largely from the third week of December until the close of the first quarter remained quite rational, and betas did better than we had forecast, correct? If you check betas today, they are approximately mid-70s for savings and about 90 for CDs. However, Moshe, our outlook, which is incorporated into the NIM guidance, is that we will return to those initial levels where you'll see mid-80s for high yield savings and above 100 for CDs, simply because other banks that have experienced deposit outflows might become more aggressive. Once more, we haven't observed that so far, but that is what the outlook includes. Ideally, that won't happen, which would provide us with some possible upside.

Moshe Orenbuch

analyst
#12

Excellent, many thanks.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#13

Thank you, Moshe. Enjoy your day.

Ryan Nash

analyst
#14

Hey, good morning, guys.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#15

Hey, Ryan.

Brian Doubles

executive
#16

Morning, Ryan.

Ryan Nash

analyst
#17

Brian, with the accounting change in mind, perhaps begin with the allowance. Could you remind everyone what the macro side captures? Also, you mentioned that normalization remains 20% below, and you provided helpful detail on how charge-offs are progressing. Given the environment and the expansion you expect, how are you viewing delinquencies and charge-offs flattening out against the danger of going too far, considering growth math and the weakening macro picture? Thanks.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#18

Yes. Let me work through that, Ryan. Good to speak with you today. To begin, regarding the TDR accounting change, we, along with numerous others, opted for retroactive application. A decrease to the reserve occurred, net of tax, through equity on January first. Entering the quarter, the reserve really comes down to two factors. First, seasonal paydown came in below what we expected, purchase volume exceeded our expectations, leaving us with a larger asset position at quarter end, which produced the growth-driven reserve provision. Considering the elements inside the reserve from a macro view, essentially, when examining the entire baseline model plus the qualitative reserves, unemployment sits at effectively 6%; across this reasonable, forecastable horizon, should unemployment remain under 6%, rate-driven reserve provisions ought not occur. Once more, this quarter, because of the banking turmoil and possible credit contraction, we increased the macroeconomic overlay to address potential filter effects on consumers. Looking ahead, what I would say is we anticipate mainly growth-driven reserves. That is, provision increases, and that ought to match our prior thinking. Even so, we continue to believe we will move lower over time as we progress toward the end of this year and into the next, reaching that adjusted CECL day one reserve post.

Ryan Nash

analyst
#19

Understood. Thanks for that explanation. Turning to capital, Brian — you mentioned that you're in a solid position to keep giving money back to shareholders. At 12.5, it's clear you're getting near that 11% goal. Could you walk through how you'd handle capital in a setting like this, considering the fairly strong asset growth, but also a possible downturn looming and the fact that you're moving closer to your target? Perhaps just discuss a few of the pluses and minuses and how you plan to oversee the capital base across a medium-term horizon.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#20

Yes. Ryan, what I always attempt to communicate is that whenever you apply your loss stress testing models amid these harsh and idiosyncratic scenarios, with unemployment reaching 10%. In principle, you work through and apply those stresses; we examine the situation even if some type of downturn emerged over the short to medium term, in principle, our capital provision and our buffers could handle it. We don't really view that as a situation where we'd step back and claim that we ought to halt or scale back certain buybacks or the amount of buybacks is safe. The economic event is genuinely incorporated into our capital forecast and our capital plan. When we consider the priorities, you nailed it. What we think about first is the company's organic growth, next is dividends, and third relates to whether we have inorganic opportunities and/or share repurchases. Regarding some of the cadence that could emerge across the coming couple of years, are there assets that become available that we'd like to put capital into? At present, once more, we'll keep giving capital back to shareholders consistent with what we've done historically and aim down toward the 11%. Once again, I pointed out in my prepared remarks that we still need to complete development of our preferred stack, though that isn't something we must do right now.

Ryan Nash

analyst
#21

Ryan Nash, thanks for that added detail.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#22

Appreciate it, Ryan, and enjoy the rest of your day.

Erika Najarian

analyst
#23

Hi there, good morning. I'd like to start with a question about the RSA. At 4.1% for the quarter, my sense is that this came in roughly 20 basis points below what consensus had expected. When we consider how credit normalizes over the remainder of the year, Brian, should we anticipate that the rest of the year lands at the bottom end of the range you provided?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#24

Morning, Erika. To repeat, the range we provided was 4%-4.25%. What really matters is how net interest margin unfolds, correct? Consider the funding cost side of the business. Losses, once again, sit within that very same band of 4.75%-5%. The outcome truly hinges on the way deposit betas come through and how benchmark interest rates pass along to our partners. Our expectation is that it falls within 4%-4.25%.

Erika Najarian

analyst
#25

Understood. I really don't want to bring up 2024, but plenty of investors right now are focused on credit sensitive financials and trough earnings during a recession, and they expect those trough earnings to show up in 2024. When we consider how things play out with your net charge-off dollars getting back to pre-pandemic levels in 2024, plus the possibility of Fed cuts possibly giving your margin support as deposit costs get repriced lower — how should people who might invest with you, and those already holding the stock, think about the RSA in that kind of setting? I think that when investors look at that step function higher in net charge-offs, is there a simple way for them to say, "All right, here's a step function lower on RSA during a recessionary year that only applies to your stock?"

Brian Wenzel

executive
#26

Yeah. Appreciate the question. First, let me address credit briefly. We closed out the quarter, and if you go back and look at historical delinquency rates, we'd been running roughly 10 basis points per quarter higher along the normalization curve. We finished Q4 of 2022 at approximately 80%. We finished Q1 of 2023 at approximately somewhere between 75% and 77%. Credit is normalizing just as we anticipated, and we expect it to remain on that path. As you move into 2024, we anticipate the loss rate returning to our underwriting target of 5.5%-6%. The other dynamics at play — you're correct. If you think we return to that sort of environment, one with a somewhat normal or elevated or more normalized unemployment rate, then you're going to see your payment rate revert back in line, and that ought to provide a tailwind when it comes to interest and fees. We also anticipate the prime rate and the cost of interest-bearing liabilities declining. All of those roughly work together. You've got two effective tailwinds, and a headwind from net charge-offs. Everything flows back through the RSA. When you consider that, there are pluses and minuses. There might be a stretch where we dip below 4%, for a quarter or two, and after that you should return to what I'd consider the longer-term financial framework, the one we provided, which sits in that 4%-4.25%.

Erika Najarian

analyst
#27

That's useful. Thank you.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#28

Appreciate it, Erika. Enjoy your day.

John Hecht

analyst
#29

Hello, everyone, and I appreciate you giving us the chance to ask a few questions.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#30

Hi there, John.

John Hecht

analyst
#31

Morning, and thanks. What I'm really picking up on is that you've made solid progress shifting toward greater reliance on co-brand and dual cards. Brian, earlier during this call you mentioned product expansion in some form. Given that shift, I'm curious what you're actually observing. Are there any shifts in how customers behave that stand out, and does product expansion account for them, or do they come from somewhere else?

Brian Doubles

executive
#32

Yes, John, I'll take that first, then I'll have Brian share a few more details. The approach built around dual cards and co-branding is something we've depended on a great deal across the past 10 years. What appeals to us most is the chance to move our strongest customers, along with our partners' strongest customers, onto a product capable of handling spending worldwide. The way earnings work on such a card usually creates an incentive for them to return to the partner's location. Those synergies appeal to us, and we're experiencing growth above the average in dual card and world sales, which benefits us and benefits our partners too. Stepping back for a moment, when we consider the multi-product approach, it's genuinely something you could picture beginning at the lower end of the range with a secured card, a buy now, pay later option, or a shorter-term installment loan, then moving into a revolving product PLCC, and finally reaching a dual card or co-brand card. That approach strikes us as a successful one. From an economic standpoint, when we weigh risk against return, it lets us serve an extremely broad cross-section of our partners' customers. That's where I believe we've witnessed genuine change within just the past 2 or 3 years, as we've worked with our partners on the multi-product approach. There's substantial involvement and substantial momentum, and I believe that over time this approach wins for us. Brian, perhaps you could add a few details regarding whether anything has shifted in terms of.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#33

Yeah.

Brian Doubles

executive
#34

Same trends.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#35

As you know, John, whenever we discuss this, the people who come looking for our cards are the ones most devoted to our partners, correct? They're involved with that brand and they want rewards returned to it. If we examine the spending categories we observe, especially with the dual card, the way they're ordered stays quite steady, and they stick around. For instance, the top category for spending worldwide, at number 1, is bill pay. If you consider the top 5, groceries appear, restaurants appear. Those are everyday sorts of things that remain sticky and keep happening. When they get benefits back into a brand they're fond of, they'll keep doing that. Looking at how much transactions are worth and how often they occur, it has stayed fairly steady, which brings us back to what we always say regarding the dual card. Then, if you think about certain other brands present that might not be dual card but offer wide usefulness among some of our digital partners, a large portion of this business spans multiple categories.

John Hecht

analyst
#36

All right, that's really useful context. Brian Wenzel, I'm sorry if you already touched on part of this during your prepared comments, but I realize you left your NIM guidance unchanged, and the same goes for RSAs — still, are there seasonal factors we ought to keep in mind across the coming two quarters?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#37

Yes, seasonal patterns will be there. Take charge-offs, for example — typically you see them rise on a seasonal basis during the second quarter when you look at things through an interest margin lens. Some seasonality also shows up as we fund ahead of the growth planned for the latter part of the year, pulling it into the first quarter within the liquidity profile. Those balances might dip and then climb again, and charge-offs could run somewhat higher in the second quarter. Regarding charge-offs, one point worth stressing: the speed of the pickup I mentioned only a few minutes back — we remain at 80% of historical delinquency levels. If you examine how delinquencies moved from the third quarter into the fourth quarter, and then from the fourth quarter into the first quarter, the increases have decelerated. On a dollar basis once more, since volume is higher, you'll notice it in receivables hitting a seasonal low during the second quarter; after that, receivables should expand while the loss rate roughly levels off, possibly declining in the back half of the year.

John Hecht

analyst
#38

And as far as NIM fluctuations go — just as a piece of that same question.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#39

I attempted to address NIM. My apologies, John; on that point, what you'll notice is some slight downward pressure during the second quarter, after which it recovers, largely because of pre-funding for growth in the back half.

John Hecht

analyst
#40

I probably ought to have done that. I appreciate it. Yes. Thanks so much.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#41

The one item I reflect on and mention as a possible tailwind would be this: if the betas we have assumed turn out differently than what we expect — meaning they land in a more favorable spot, so our funding costs rise by a smaller amount — then that might work in our favor.

John Hecht

analyst
#42

Okay. Thanks very much, guys.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#43

Thanks, John.

Brian Doubles

executive
#44

Thank you, John.

Sanjay Sakhrani

analyst
#45

Good morning, and thanks. I'd like to build on what Moshe asked earlier. Clearly, this particular cycle stands apart from the ones before it. I'm wondering whether the upheaval in regional banking, along with the effects of that playing out across the economy, could be prompting you to reconsider your approach to underwriting. You brought up, Brian Doubles, that spending slowed during March and tax refunds came in lower. Could you walk us through those various forces and how they're shaping the way you think about underwriting?

Brian Doubles

executive
#46

Yes, absolutely. I'll take that one, Sanjay. What matters here, and it comes up often in our discussions, is that during what amounted to the strongest credit backdrop ever seen in financial services across the past 2 years, we chose not to go much deeper in our underwriting. That matters to us, since our partners depend heavily on consistency. Especially during periods as favorable as the one we just experienced over those last couple of years.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#47

Our underwriting doesn't go much deeper than it does, and the reason for that is we hope that whenever conditions become somewhat uncertain or somewhat worse, we won't need to make a dramatic retreat. That consistency matters to our partners, and it matters to us. At this point, we aren't expecting any major underwriting changes. You know, the way we're underwriting today is something we like. The consumer remains healthy. You know, we expect charge-offs to normalize back into our target range next year. In terms of consumer trends, what we're seeing right now is still fairly comfortable. Nothing significant is anticipated at this point.

Sanjay Sakhrani

analyst
#48

All right. One more thing: it seems like a partner you used to work with may be seeking some kind of change. I'm just wondering about your willingness to absorb big portfolios, including that particular one. Clearly the share price remains quite appealing at this point. I'm just, you know, weighing the trade-offs involved and how you folks are viewing, you know, what's ahead for buying portfolios and similar moves. Thanks.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#49

Yeah. Look, there's nothing I can share about that specific matter. I simply don't wish to engage in speculation there. We aren't, you know, we aren't involved in that, clearly. What I'd say is we have an excellent relationship with Sam's Club, stretching back more than 25 years. Strong alignment, strong engagement and momentum behind that program. There's nothing really to speculate about past that. I'd say, just speaking more broadly, we are constantly seeking out large portfolio acquisitions and startup opportunities; we run a highly active B&E process, with a sizable team dedicated to it, and that's always something of interest to us. What matters most there, though, as we've discussed before, is that you need genuinely strong alignment. You need the proper balance between risk and return. I believe that's crucial, you know, especially in a climate like the current one where you're kind of moving into a stretch of uncertainty; we will keep remaining very disciplined when it comes to risk and return.

Sanjay Sakhrani

analyst
#50

Thank you.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#51

Yep.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#52

Hello there. I'd like to explore the NIM topic a bit further. I realize the outlook going forward means it will fluctuate, and I recognize that NIM currently sits at the top of its range. I was hoping to clarify, first, which interest rate assumptions underlie your NIM guidance? Second, whether the mix shift will shift meaningfully across this year compared with what we saw in 1Q. Thanks.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#53

Morning, Betsy. Regarding the first portion of what you asked, our peak Fed funds rate sits at 5.25%. That leaves one more effective move from this point. We do anticipate certain reductions, once more, tracking the forward curve as we head into the later portion of the year; that carries, I would characterize it, a very small to inconsequential impact on net interest margin across the full year; on your second item, when you sort of consider the business mix, I don't believe you'll encounter problems necessarily during this year when it comes to mix affecting the net interest margin. Certainly as time passes, I think if you consider where the geography stands, should health and wellness keep expanding at a rapid pace, and you observe a number of the businesses that lean more toward promotional financing getting bigger, you might witness a shift in the revenue. Profitability, precisely the same, but perhaps a shift away from NIM in how it flows through our merchant discount, merchant discount pricing. That won't be a 2023 issue.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#54

All right. To build on that, you mentioned loan growth a bit, and you did lift the guidance from 8 to 10 to 10-plus. Meanwhile, in the reserving conversation, there's the possibility of tighter lending standards across the industry. Could you speak to how you're approaching lending standards? And does that higher loan growth you're targeting — I'd imagine it stays inside the credit box you have — maybe you could explain what's behind that pickup in loan growth and how your lending standards factor into the outlook. Thanks.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#55

Yes. When it comes to our underwriting right now, once again, we continually make a certain amount of tweaks, particularly involving how the partner channel performs and whether the risk-adjusted returns we're getting are the right ones. We keep examining that at all times, you know, and every single day our credit team stays focused on it. We aren't making any moves across the board, since we observe nothing at that level in terms of vintage performance. The vintages, you know, from when the pandemic began onward, are doing better than 2018 and 2019, and they're doing well. Once more, Brian mentioned how consistent our underwriting is; we didn't really step on and off the gas the way a lot of other issuers do. When we examine the accounts we brought on recently, they're performing at or above what we saw before the pandemic. The pre-pandemic book is performing in line with how it kind of went into the pandemic. We truly don't observe any deterioration across the board when we examine entry rates and flows. This isn't a situation where we're doing what I'd call across-the-board moves, opening the box or closing the box. Once again, we don't really use that as a growth lever the way a number of issuers do. For us, it's going to be far more consistent. As for how you think about, you know, loan growth coming in higher, there are two factors. First, we are seeing consumers utilize our cards more, and we are seeing a payment rate that's slightly favorable. Those two factors are what's driving the growth in the first quarter. We expect that to keep going somewhat through the back half of or for the rest of 2023. That's my way of thinking about loan growth being up. Once more, what you might see if the economy slows more quickly, what you should see or you might see is payment rates slowing more quickly, and then you can see purchase volume taper down somewhat. Once again, I think you have to look at dollars here because I think last year you're going to begin comping the post-Omnicom period, which is a harder comp for all of us. Once again, I think of that as being more adoption and utilization of our cards and then 2, payment rate driving the growth, not underwriting.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#56

All right, thanks.

John Pancari

analyst
#57

Morning, everyone.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#58

Morning to you.

John Pancari

analyst
#59

Regarding what you're projecting for charge-offs, I realize you left that figure at 4.75%-5%. You don't anticipate hitting the more typical level until 2024. Could you provide a bit more detail about where exactly you're observing rising pressure, and which specific products and vintages? Are the newer vintages still the ones affected? Is growth still continuing across different income groups? I think you said that before, but I just wanted a bit more clarity there. Thanks.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#60

I wouldn't call it pressure. We aren't really witnessing pressure there. What we are observing, I believe, is a shift back toward levels that existed before the pandemic. What you're beginning to notice among prime and super-prime customers is that their credit grades sat far under historical averages. That's largely due to the fact that they gained during the pandemic, whether through stimulus, reduced spending, or less capacity to spend, and now they're drawing down a portion of those built-up savings. They're going back to what I would call pre-pandemic performance levels. This applies to payment rate performance, spending performance, and performance related to entering delinquency and moving through it. I wouldn't describe it as pressure. I'd simply say these consumers are shifting back toward earlier behaviors, and that's happening throughout the portfolio. It isn't limited to a particular group of vintages. That's roughly how I view the credit development in that respect. As for how delinquency is performing, once again, what you're currently seeing is a highly favorable rate of entry into delinquency. You're seeing reasonably solid front-end collections. The back-end collections are rather soft since you don't yet have the usual flows moving through delinquency. What you would anticipate is entry rates climbing somewhat. Your front-end Cs might weaken a bit, and the back end Cs would climb as more volume moves through the collection channels. We haven't yet observed that in our performance, and that's what we expect to show up over the rest of 2023 and into 2024.

John Pancari

analyst
#61

Understood. All right, thanks. To revisit what Ryan Nash asked regarding the reserve — I just want to verify once more that the increase during this quarter stemmed primarily from growth and from the attainment rate. When you consider the outlook, assuming unemployment stays where you anticipate, specifically under that 6% mark, then a decline in the reserve ratio from this point would be what you'd anticipate. Is my understanding right?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#62

To clarify once more how this works: most of this quarter's reserve came from growth. We did add to the macroeconomic overlay, which essentially said, "Look, with banking turmoil, these institutions might pull back on credit, and that would feed through into the economy and reach the consumer." We set aside for that. Once again, growth accounted for the bulk of it, since assets arrived higher than we had projected. I believe that provided we keep making progress against the macroeconomic assumptions, those qualitative reserves release and partially counterbalance the growth-driven provisions we will incur. To repeat, if we stay in line with our macroeconomic assumptions, provisioning ought not to be rate-driven in the future — only growth driven.

John Pancari

analyst
#63

Okay, Brian, thanks.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#64

Brian, thanks. You too.

Dominick Gabriele

analyst
#65

Hello, and thank you very much for fielding my questions. So, regarding how net charge-offs will be timed, based on everything you've described, plus what you're assuming for the reserve — if you consider when your loss rate is likely to top out and the possibility of releasing reserves — I realize you've already addressed this, but could there be a stretch where you conclude, "Look, conditions remain uncertain, so we can't let reserves go right now, and charge-offs are still climbing"? Or do you believe you'd be freeing up reserves throughout the whole period that charge-offs are increasing? I understand that's a difficult question. I have one more after this. Thank you.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#66

Yes. Good morning, Dom. Here's the thing that makes CECL interesting — in principle, it's signaling that when your worst losses fall within the reasonable and supportable window, you'd theoretically be able to start freeing up reserves before those losses actually crest. For this industry, I believe that's quite unusual, yet it's something CECL produces as a side effect. It's possible to imagine a scenario in which reserves get released before peak losses arrive, simply because the forecast period captures the climb to the top and the subsequent decline. That hasn't shown up so far, and it isn't something we factor into our 2023 view. As far as 2024 goes, and how delinquencies will trend over the rest of this year, we'll need to follow up with you on that.

Dominick Gabriele

analyst
#67

Thanks a lot. So, on this call, the efficiency ratio hasn't come up yet, and clearly you're posting some really substantial and impressive core efficiency ratio improvements compared with a year ago. What I'd like to know is, when you look further out, you've established certain targets. Do the shifts in today's macro backdrop that you've baked into some of your reserves alter the direction that efficiency ratio could take?

David Scharf

analyst
#68

Any chance?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#69

Yes, no, that's a terrific question. In our view, today's conditions don't alter our longer-term framework, starting down at that 32%-33%, which I'd say is best in class for efficiency ratio. One thing Brian and Margaret accomplished is that through the pandemic, they pushed us to pursue digital efficiencies in collections and to insource other functions, which boosted productivity. The efficiency ratio took a negative hit from the drop in interest and fee yield. As we generate those efficiencies and achieve operating leverage — and Brian and I are dedicated to delivering operating leverage as we move through the periods — that ought to return us to that longer-term framework. Once more, should the macro backdrop worsen, the investments we've made digitally in our collections activities, but throughout our whole business, should help support that wherever expenses are within our control. This would be a very different approach from what occurred back in the Great Financial Crisis, when you added a lot of bodies and simply had them calling people all day. That isn't what would occur even under any type of recession.

David Scharf

analyst
#70

Thanks so much.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#71

Thanks. Have a good day.

David Scharf

analyst
#72

Thanks. Morning, and I appreciate you fitting me in. The first thing is for Brian Doubles, and it might just be a point of clarification. About the status of the capital plan you filed last month, I don't think I came across anything in your releases, whether I heard it or read it. Could you give us any update on where things stand, the timing, and maybe some directional sense of the magnitude?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#73

Appreciate it, David. Let me handle that one. Our capital plan has been submitted. It moved through the very same process we always use; because of certain things that happened during the first quarter, we actually built some extra stresses into it; our board gave its approval, and we sent it along to our regulators, you know, right on schedule compared with prior years. So they review it and then give what we expect will be a non-objection. Depending on their schedule and how long the review takes, that non-objection could arrive any time from later this month through May; based on the plan and what we included, we don't expect anyone to read anything into it beyond the fact that they are simply moving through their process. Probably in later April and May we'll come back, and the moment we have it, we'll make it known. As for how large it is, sadly, I'm not in a position to say anything until our regulators give us that non-objection.

David Scharf

analyst
#74

Yep, got it. As a quick follow-up, I was curious whether you could shed any light on how you see the competitive landscape at this moment. Do you get the sense that there's been a pullback larger than anticipated, and perhaps in direct mail marketing, from some of the companies you'd normally consider your main rivals? Whether that's in general purpose or in point of sale. I suppose related to that, you mentioned that your higher quality credits were transacting more often at bigger average purchase sizes. Given everything being said about macro uncertainty, does anything ever signal to you that this is the moment to gain ground in different FICO bands? If you're watching competitors pull back in various ways, is the current climate fairly steady compared with the past few quarters?

Brian Wenzel

executive
#75

Yeah. Look, I'd say the environment remains quite competitive out there. I think it's somewhat bifurcated. The more established players, in my view, remain competitive in our space. Let me set direct to consumer to one side for a moment. I think we continue to see it as a fairly competitive environment. One encouraging thing, though, is that given the uncertainty ahead, there's solid discipline among the more traditional competitors. That tends to be true whenever you go into a period like this. No one is pricing in a credit environment like what we've gone through over the last couple of years. I find that encouraging. Solid discipline. I do believe you've seen some fintech players and some of the newer entrants ease back somewhat. I do think, you know, direct to consumer, direct mail, some of that will ease back a little. Generally, in our core, in our core space, it remains quite competitive out there, but with solid discipline.

David Scharf

analyst
#76

Got it. Thank you very much.

Brian Wenzel

executive
#77

Yep. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#78

Appreciate it; that brings Synchrony's earnings conference call for today to a close. At this point you're free to hang up, and we hope your day is a great one.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Synchrony Financial transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Synchrony Financial earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Synchrony Financial or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.